►
From YouTube: City Council Meeting - May 9, 2017
Description
May 9, 2017
Asheville City Council Meeting
A
A
A
Nine
years
ago
the
asheville
city
council
envisions
a
new
program
that
would
place
students
with
meaningful
summer
internships
with
city
departments
and
partnering
organizations
throughout
asheville.
This
program
would
empower
its
students
to
get
involved
in
our
communities,
support
them
in
their
quest
for
college
and
reward
them
with
the
generous
scholarship
after
a
rigorous
application
process,
each
spring
25
kayla.
A
Students
are
placed
in
prestigious
summer
internships
that
allow
them
to
explore
careers
and
learn
from
caring,
adult
professionals,
members
of
the
kayla
class
of
2017
interns
with
valuable
community
partners,
including
habitat
for
humanity,
care
partners
and
the
omni
grove
park
in
each
friday.
During
the
summer,
the
students
attended,
day-long
leadership
workshops
that
focus
on
social
entrepreneurship.
Students
learned
about
the
triple
bottom
line
that
considered
the
company's
social,
economic
and
environmental
impact.
A
A
The
kayla
students
began
planning
in-depth
social
justice
projects.
They
organized
the
sixth
annual
mlk
youth
summit,
which
brought
together
more
than
60
teenagers
from
all
of
us
and
county
high
school
to
discuss
issues
of
importance
to
use
the
kayla
students
also
taught
a
class
each
week
for
the
asheville
city,
schools,
foundations,
irl
after-school
program.
Over
the
years,
kayla
students
have
given
more
than
3600
volunteer
hours
to
our
communities
in
recognition
of
their
accomplishments
and
the
critical
role
they
play
in
asheville
future.
A
D
A
A
B
A
L
L
L
K
These
are
the
folks
that
go
in
when
everybody
else
is
fleeing
the
scene,
reflecting
fire
clips,
have
to
have
these
skills,
and
this
was
pointed
out
at
911
that
your
system
has
to
work.
We
are
now
fully
equipped
and
up
to
the
homeland
security
standard.
Thanks
to
the
folks
that
are
here
today,
I
think
they,
this
is
the
highest
service.
K
K
K
K
K
N
A
Motorcycle
awareness
and
rider
training
programs,
the
cva
works
with
communities
across
the
state
to
expand
safety
and
awareness
for
the
motorcycle
rider
and
for
the
motorist
and
whereas
the
cba
educates
citizens,
elected
officials,
law
enforcement
agencies
and
motorcyclists
about
the
importance
of
motorcycle
safety
and
awareness
and
whereas
cba
members
are
available
to
give
presentations
in
high
schools
and
community
groups
and
organizations
to
educate
everyone
about
sharing
the
road
with
motorcycles.
Now,
therefore,
I
esther
man,
homer
mara,
the
city
of
asheville,
do
hereby
proclaim.
May
2017
as
motorcycle.
A
O
A
N
I
just
want
to
give
it
a
little
bit
of
an
introduction
most
of
you
in
this
room
live
here.
So
you
probably
know
this,
but
I'm
astonished
at
how
many
people
don't
so
western
north
carolina
is
one
of
the
most
biodiverse
places
in
the
entire
world,
not
just
in
the
country,
not
just
in
the
on
the
continent,
in
the
entire.
N
N
And
endangered
species
we
have
here
in
western
north
carolina
at
least
13
species
on
the
endangered
list
and
seven
on
the
threatened
list,
and
I'm
just
going
to
read
some
of
these,
partly
because
I
think
it's
important
for
people
that
actually
associate
animals
with
these
numbers,
not
just
the
numbers,
also
because
some
of
them
have
some
really
fun
names.
So
we
have
a
bunch
of
that.
We
have
the
great
bat
begin,
the
enof
at
the
virginia
big
eared,
that
we
have
the
spruce-fir
mosque
spider.
The.
N
N
N
Here
so
they're
not
on
those
lists
on
the
endangered
list,
but
they
live
nowhere
else
on
earth.
So
again
we
have
we
need
to
protect
them
and
we
have
by
sometimes
close
to
300
of
those
plant
and
animal
species
that
are
endemic
to
this
region
that
again
live
nowhere
else,
so
again
pretty
special
place.
N
H
Here-
and
I
just
just
like
to
thank
the
mayor
and
the
city
council
very
much
for
recognizing
the
importance
of
endangered
species,
everything
on
this
planet
has
purpose
and
we
need
to
do
what
we
can
to
sustain
it
and
just
a
couple
of
very
short
quotes
that
are
favorites
of
mine,
one
from
john
muir.
When
we
try
to
pick
out
anything
by
itself,
we
find
it
hitched
to
everything
else.
In
the
universe
and
teddy
roosevelt
once
said,
wildlife
and
its
habitat
cannot
speak
so.
H
Q
Q
Q
Q
T
T
V
A
A
A
A
W
Determine
revenue
neutral,
but
to
evaluate
where
revenue
neutral
was
and
then
look
at
what
we
needed
in
the
budget.
So
as
we're
all
aware,
the
citywide
valuation
of
property
tax
has
increased
tremendously,
nearly
30
percent
for
the
whole
city
as
an
average.
Our
revenue
neutral
estimate
and
the
revenue
neutral
that
is
published
in
the
budget
document
was
thirty,
nine
point
five
cents.
My
latest
estimate
for
that
is.
W
W
W
W
W
W
W
W
Have
staffing
within
sourced
labor
and
we
have
transit
improvements,
and
these
are
all
things
we've
been
over
in
the
work
sessions,
but
I
just
want
to
kind
of
remind
you
all
without
going
into
detail
and
then
efficiencies
and
cuts
that
we've
made
to
make
all
these
things
were
a
lot
of
budget
cuts
in
the
general
fund
departments.
Departments
went
through
their
budgets
and
really
cut
more,
and
we.
W
W
W
W
Moving
on
to
the
capital
budget-
and
I
probably
need
to
actually
catch
up
with
my
pages-
we've
gone
over
a
bit
of
what
to
expect
in
the
existing
cip
and
then
in
the
geo
bonds,
and
just
to
kind
of
talk
about
that.
A
little
bit.
The
existing
capital
improvement
program
was
started
in
2013-14
and
it's
approximately
a
hundred
and
ten
million
dollars
in
projects
under
ten
million
dollars.
That
willie
should
get
for
more
than
that.
W
W
W
W
W
Residents
who
don't
necessarily
know
how
that
works?
So
I
think
we
all
know
the
business
accounting
structure.
You
have
sort
of
your
business
conglomerate
and
then
you
might
have
little
areas
that
they
do
like
kraft
owns
philip
morris
or
you
know
something
like
that,
and
then
they
have
divisions
under
them.
It's
basically
a
pyramid
structure
of
business
government,
on
the
other
hand,
is.
W
W
W
W
A
W
W
W
A
Q
Q
W
A
A
K
A
A
A
V
V
Because
we
have,
we
do
have
the
bond
issue
for
affordable
housing,
which
is
a
big
chunk
of
change.
I
mean
that
might
be
one
place.
We
could
squeeze
it
a
little
bit
that
occurred
and
it's
not
that
I'm
against
affordable
housing,
but
we
have
approved
a
huge
fund
for
affordable
housing
because
I
wouldn't
get.
I
agree.
N
N
Hearing
all
right,
then
I
do
want
to
so.
I
do
want
to
take
a
couple
things
then.
So
I'm
gonna,
I
think,
I'm
well
on
record,
is
you
know,
definitely
wanting
the
transit
increases
and
I'm
still
willing
to
do
a
tax
increase.
If
that's
what
it
takes,
we're
the
cities
that
do
transit
well
have
to
pay
for
it
themselves,
and
that
continues
to
be
true
and
we'll
only
get
more
true
and
we're
just
going
to
have
to
figure
it
out
the
as
to
the.
N
Affordable
housing
trust
fund.
I
think
this
may
not
have
necessarily
come
back
to
council
yet,
but
one
of
the
things
that
we
have
discovered
in
terms
of
implementing
the
energy
innovation
task
force
recommendations
around
the
low
income
weatherization
program
is
that
we
can't
use
bond
button
for
that.
So,
if
we're
going
to
use,
if
there
is
an
existing
pot
of
money
that
we're
going
to
use
its
our
general
fund
allocation
to
the
affordable
housing,
trust
fund
and
julie,
you
know.
A
A
N
Question
for
cathy
or
ken,
and
I'm
not
sure
if
either
one
of
them
is
here,
but
the
thing
that
struck
me
about
this
reading.
This
was
the
caught.
This
is
the
first
time
we
have
seen
a
dollar
figure
associated
with
the
cost
of
the
new
structure
of
the
transit
management
company,
so
that
the
new
structure.
N
N
N
N
K
K
K
Y
A
N
Am
examine
600,
so
so
what
what
was
shown
in
our
budget
document
was
a
an
overall
increase
in
transit
funding.
That
would
that,
if
it's
about
three
million
dollars
right-
because
that's
it's
the
lost
federal
funding,
it's
the
630-
it
said
management
contract,
it's
the
it's
the
full
year
of
services
that
we
implemented
this
year.
It's
a
big
big
chunk
of
change,
and
the
analysis
of
it
was
that
it
equates
to
about
three
cent
on
the
military.
I
to
believe
that
we.
N
N
Q
Subsidy
to
transit
and
having
that
kind
of
resolution
around
tying
it
to
a
certain
number
in
the
way
that
we
have
our
cip
when
we
did
the
tax
increase
last
time,
that
is
a
certain
number
of
cents
of
the
property
tax
that
allows
us
to
continue
to
make
investments
in
our
infrastructure.
In
the
same
way,
this
would
allow
us
to
continue
to
make
investments
in
our
transit
in
a
growing.
Q
W
N
Q
Q
Q
Don't
think
that
the
folks
who
came
in
and
voted
for
that
we're
saying
hey,
would
you
please
raid
the
rest
of
the
trust
fund
and
just
use
this?
I
think
that
this
was
a
general
awareness
that
the
affordable
housing
crisis
is
real
and
we
need
to
go
over
and
above
to
make
this
happen.
So
I
won't
be
in
favor
of
raiding
the
trust
fund
to
make
up
in.
Q
Q
M
N
Think
it
was
public
works
staff,
I'm
not
sure,
and
safety
recommend
seconded
that
recommendation
that
there'd
be
a
new
position
in
public
works,
specifically
around
waste
and
waste
management,
recycling
and
composting,
and
things
like
that.
I
didn't
see
that
position
in
here
and
I
just
want
to
make
sure
that
I'm
right
that
I
didn't
see
it
is
that
correct.
That's
correct,
okay,.
K
C
C
C
C
C
Relating
to
our
position
on
this
and
some
of
the
trains
in
law
enforcement,
it's
important
to
note
the
value
of
body-worn
cameras
related
to
police
interactions,
particularly
related
to
obtaining
consent
to
search
mother.
One
came
cameras
are
a
step
forward
in
ensuring
that
the
drivers
are
being
treated
in
a
fair
and
constitutional
manner.
In
most
cases,
we
acknowledge
that.
C
C
C
C
C
C
B
B
N
N
Commit
to
this
so
I'll
frame
that,
in
the
same
way
that
that
gwenda,
that
I
put
this
on
the
table
for
discussion,
I
think
you
know
we.
Everyone
in
this
community
has
an
interest
in
seeing
chief
hoover
succeed
and
in
seeing
our
entire
police
force
succeed
in
addressing
these
issues
and
one
of
the
key
ways
that
we
know
to
do.
That
is
that
you
you
can.
N
N
Information
we
can
know
where
we
are,
we
can
know
where
we
have
to
go,
and
I
think
very
importantly,
for
this
particular
topic.
I
would
love
for
this
community
to
get
around
the
table
in
trying
to
solve
this
problem
instead
of
where
it
feels
to
me
like.
We
are
right
now,
which
is
on
opposite
sides
of
the
table
and-
and
I
think,
regular
frequent
reporting
and.
N
B
V
V
Y
That
report
it
is
online
under
the
agenda,
so
you
can
go
to
that.
I'm
going
to
dig
in
a
little
bit.
You
know
it's
often
said
that
no
other
profession
demands
a
higher
ethical
standard
in
that
of
law
enforcement
and
regardless
of
whether
or
not
there
are
other
careers
that
require
a
similar
dedication
to
doing
the
right
thing,
it.
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
I
would
hope
that
in
the
future
that
we
could
look
and
make
sure
that,
when
we're
doing
some
sort
of
audits
that
we're
doing
the
monthly,
some
sort
of
monthly
checks
sbi
to
make
sure
that
these
things
are
being
reported,
we
can't
regulate
what
the
state
does
on
their
side,
but
we
can
definitely
write
their
tale
a
little
bit
to
make
sure
that
things
are
syncing
up.
One
of
my
concerns
would
be
that
why
it
was
at
a.
Y
Y
All
that
says
it
sucks
to
be
poor
in
asheville,
and
then
on
top
of
that
it
says
it
sucks
to
be
poor
and
asking
to
be
black.
My
concern
is
if
this
is
the
case,
let's
say
I
accept
that
premise.
If
this
is
the
case
where
the
poor
white
drivers
that
drive
in
asheville,
because
african
americans
only
make
up
a
small
percentage
of
individuals
in
the
city
and
consider
that
being
the
premise
to.
Y
A
Y
C
C
A
Can
be,
it
could
mean
that
10
black
motorists
were
stopped
and
100
white
motors
for
stop,
but
of
the
ten
black
motors
that
were
stopped.
40
percent
were
stopped
for
equipment
violations
of
the
hundred
white
motorists
stopped
32
were
stopped,
32
percent
were
sought
for
equipment
violations.
It's
not
giving
you
a
total
number.
It
says
regulatory
stops.
A
A
Y
Y
Y
Y
Audits
and
continue
to
do
that,
but
also
look
at
in
charge,
find
out
what's
going
on
with
the
espe
hasta
in
those
two
months
and
make
sure
that
that
doesn't
happen
as
far
as
the
mandate
of
regulatory
stops
and
they're
trying
to
make
that
less
of
a
priority,
it
seems
like
we're
already
doing
that
as
far
as
the
warrant
into
things
when
made
a
good
point
asking
if
those
were
being
documented,
that's
pretty
much
just
where
I'm
at
with
all
of
this.
What
way
do
you
think.
A
N
N
Would
we
would
look
at
something
and
adding
another
layer
on
that?
I'm
I'm
kind
of
willing
to
I
mean
I
could
go
either
way.
I
could.
I
would
be
perfectly
happy
if
there,
if
there
were
a
written
consent
process
implemented.
I
would
also
be
perfectly
happy
with
a
commitment
of
reviewing
the
that
the
body
worn
cameras.
N
Y
Y
Y
Q
Wanted
to
see
if
there
was
a
will
among
council,
I
know
that
there
was
a
need
for
revision
to
make
sure
that
those
legally
confidential
pieces
were
withdrawn
from
that
prior
to
making
it
public,
but
just
wanted
to
know
if
there
was
so
will
among
council
to
just
go
ahead
and
add
that
layer.
This
is
on
the
consent,
search.
Z
V
Mane's
will
address
this
during
public
comment,
but
in
the
document
it
asserts
that
mr.
mane's
did
not
provide
the
list
of
citations
to
the
police
department
and
in
fact
he
did,
but
the
police
department
missed
the
email
they
discovered
that
later
so
just
like
to
make
sure
people
that
are
reading.
That
document
know
that
there
was
a
correction
made
there.
I'm
still
not
aware
that
okay.
A
A
A
A
A
I
know
that
we
are
working
to
make
sure
our
consent
search
numbers
are
lower.
We
want
to
keep
those
on
the
lower
end
and
you
know
not
having
expertise
and
policing.
I've
got
to
defer
to
the
police
department
if
they
feel
the
camera
consent
is
better
than
the
written
consent.
You
know
I'm
going
to
go
with.
A
That
recommendation,
I
do
think
it
would
be
helpful
for
this
council
to
kind
of
have
a
six-month
follow-up,
maybe
to
look
at
the
number
of
consent,
searches
versus
the
number
of
probable
cause,
searches
and
how
those
consent,
searches
were
documented,
and
you
know
I
don't
know
what
kind
of
data
you
collect
around
that.
But
you
know
were
there
issues
with
it?
Is
it
working
or
you
know,
are
we.
A
Getting
complaints
to
the
police
department
about
you
know,
forced
consent,
searches
or.
However,
you
want
to
refer
to
that,
and
so
some
way
for
us
to
kind
of
be
able
to
get
our
arms
around.
How
frequently
that's
happening,
what
the
numbers
are
and
whether
that
systems
working
or
not.
So
that
would
be
helpful
to
me
to
understand
a
little
bit
about
that.
I.
Y
Just
want
to
be
strongly
on
record
saying
that
written
consent
searches
benefit
the
individual
that
is
being
pulled
over
to
know
for
a
fact
that
the
officer
cannot
search
their
car
without
their
consent.
And
if
you
come
to
me
and
you
pull
me
over-
and
you
say
mr.
young
man
search
your
car
and
you
don't
have
probable
cause
and
say
mr.
young,
which
assignments
we
need
to
search
your
vehicle
and
I
say
metal.
That's
it
that.
Y
Lets
me
know,
as
opposed
to
someone
being
asked
four
or
five
times
hanging
outside
other
officers,
showing
up
I'm
just
being
anecdotal
here.
Can
I
search?
Can
I
search
kind
of
search?
Cannot
search,
cannot
search,
cannot
search.
Can
I
search
and
finally
go
they're,
not
gonna.
Let
me
go,
I
don't
want
to
do
that.
You
say
yeah
so
anyway,
that's
section.
Eight
well
and
I.
A
N
Y
C
C
Think
for
the
issue
we're
talking
about
here
relates
back
to
the
traffic
stop
report.
That
goes
to
the
point
that
I
made
that
we
want
to
look
at
address
from
that
to
be
able
to
collect
more
detailed
information,
as
other
agencies
have
done,
because
the
report
itself
doesn't
give
you
the
full
picture
of
what
is
occurring
either.
If
I
may
ask
someone
for
consent,
even
though
I
have
probable
cause,
it
doesn't
mean,
I
don't.
C
C
C
N
N
N
K
K
AB
AB
AB
Have
those
three
locations
identified
on
the
website?
We
got
some
feedback
today
that
we
probably
could
goes
out
a
little
bit
better
so
that
people
could
see
where
they
were
specifically
so
that
they
could
go.
Take
a
look
at
them
under
each
of
these.
Those
applications
on
how
communities
can
set
up
these
gardens
and
sponsor
them,
and
what's
required
to
do
that,
and
then
thirdly,
establish
urban
agriculture
releases
for
three
or
more
years.
So
it
gives
people
an
opportunity
under
more.
AB
AB
V
AB
AB
Community,
the
community
that
agrees
to
do
it
would
decide
what
to
do,
and
then
they
would
go
into
actual
agreement
with
the
city
on
how
it
would
be
maintained.
Thank
you
and
I'm
stepping
in
for
amber
weaver
who
did
all
the
work
on
there.
The
one
lost
a
partner,
so
I'm
the
poor
substitute
may
not
be
able
to
answer
all
the
questions.
I
just.
Q
Everyone
who
has
participated
in
the
asheville
park
of
food
policy
council
is
responsible
for
seeing
these
programs
happen.
This
is
a
community
led
effort,
and
if
it's
going
to
be
successful,
it's
going
to
be
a
people
powered
effort
city
government's
not
going
to
go
out
there
and
plant
the
gardens,
we're
not
going
to
grow.
The
food
actually
have
been
told
by
our
community
that
there
was
more
opportunity
desired
to
be
able
to
use.
Q
Q
AA
AA
The
htd
committee
knows
this
is
it
also
means
that
1.3
million
dollars
in
direct
assistance
to
those
transitioning
out
of
homelessness
also
remains
intact
and
will
be
coming
into
our
communities
for
1718?
So
good
news
are
on
budget,
that's
different
from
what
is
in
the
staff
report.
So
that
means
that
these
recommendations
should
be
able
to
move
forward.
Assuming
you
approve
them
with
funding
that
is
listed,
compare
additions.
AA
AA
Q
Passed
their
question
was:
might
they
qualify
for
some
of
that
bond
funding
rather
than
having
it
come
out
of
the
community
development
block
grant?
And
so,
when
we're
having
our
housing
and
community
development
committee
meeting,
what
happens
every
year?
Is
that
there's
more
people
applying
for
more
funds
than
we
have?
What
happened
this
year
was
the.
Q
Folks,
the
housing
authority
for
kind
of
moving
that
forward,
and
you
should
have
seen
the
jaws
drop
in
that
room
when
everybody
got
fully
funded.
People
have
been
doing
this.
Their
whole
careers
have
never
seen
it.
So
it
was
a
really
a
special
moment
that
day.
So,
hopefully
that
clarifies
where
that
piece
is
tonight
and
it
will
require
council.
Q
N
AA
AA
Those
things
or
your
decisions
upon
those
things,
but
because
hud
puts
a
percentage
cap
and
has
a
particular
formula
about
how
that
percentage
is
done,
and
so
the
additional
funds
from
the
section
108
pay
off
that
gave
us
the
additional
dollars
do
not
count
toward
that
15%
caps.
That
does
not
move
it.
So.
AA
When
we
do
has
use
additional,
if
you
move
tonight-
and
we
have
this
additional
money
to
do
another
round
of
cdbg
funding,
there
will
be
no
public
service
activities
eligible
for
that
for
those
dollars.
And
so
you
have
funded
all
the
applications
other
than
those
to
their
full
amount.
But
you
couldn't
move
the
interest
and
again.
AB
AB
AB
A
Sure,
though,
that
you
know
I
feel
like
every
several
months,
we
circulate
emails
and
say:
where
are
we
only
walker?
Do
we
still
all
have
the
money
set
aside
for
lee
walker?
So
I
would
want
to
make
sure
that
we
had
in
the
minutes
that
we
are
directing
a
path
to
find
a
replacement
for
the
money,
so
we're
offsetting
here
tonight,
which
is,
I
think,
a
good
idea,
and
I
support
it.
I
just
want
to
make
sure
that
we
don't
drop
the
ball
and
forget
that
we
made
the
commitment
so
that.
AA
Q
There
was
another
project
that
was
initially
funded
down
in
transylvania,
county
that
fell
through
and
that
the
lion's
share
of
that
was
reallocated
into
the
mountain
housing
project
in
an
effort
to
make
their
application
for
low-income
housing,
tax
credits
more
competitive
in
profits
wise.
So
you
make.
AA
N
A
A
A
AC
AC
Look
from
the
sky
at
the
southern
tip
of
this
peninsula
is
where
the
hump,
where
the
french
broad
river
greenway,
starts,
the
hominy
creek
cream
way
ends
at
shelburne
road.
It
gets
a
little
confusing
because
how
many
creeks
mentions
a
lot,
but
basically
we
have
two
existing
greenways
on
either
end
of
these
roads.
AC
AC
AC
AC
AC
AC
AC
Those
54
trees
kind
of
on
the
side
of
the
site,
so
it
won't
be
on
top
of
the
landfill,
but
it
will
be
between
the
greenway
in
the
new
building
which
will
help
screening
further.
It
will
be
on
their
land.
It
won't
be
on
our
use
mint,
so
we
won't
be
maintaining
those
trees,
that'll
be
broken
county
property.
AC
AC
AC
AC
AC
D
AC
AC
With
mccray
codes,
we
think
that
maybe
it
could
cross
before
the
second
driveway,
but
we
also
want
to
work
with
our
traffic
engineer
to
make
sure
that
we're
not
putting
pedestrians
at
risk
because
the
crossing
would
be
longer
it
would
be
diagonal.
We've
got
several
different
drainage
structures
here
in
the
street,
so
it's
not
a
simple
straight
90-degree.
AC
AC
AC
AC
AC
N
AC
AC
That
would
connect
that
end
of
how
many
creek
greenway
at
shelbourne
down
to
the
park.
So
you
have
to
get
across
that
creek
at
some
point
either
you're
crossing
at
the
top
or
down
closer
and
then,
of
course
there
is
a-
and
I
should
have
said
this
before
there
is
a
proposed
greenway
that
would
come
over
from
the
farmers
market
across
that
creek.
So
it's
this
convergence
of
three
green
wave's
really
so
alright.
So
that
concludes
my
opus.
AC
AD
AD
AD
AD
It
from
there
there
was
also
discussion
about
from
the
parking
area
down
the
park.
Could
you
see
the
facility?
Basically,
you've
got
a
bearing
the
era.
When
did
they
have
to
look
up
through
from
where
the
parking
area
is
and
you're
really
looking
over
towards
the
garage?
You
can't
see
the
existing
transfer
station
because
it's
basically
over
over
to
your
right
more
so
it's
it's
not
visible
from
there
when.
AD
AD
A
X
X
X
X
X
Q
Approve
the
conditional
zoning
request
from
institutional
district
to
industrial
industrial
conditional
zone,
with
the
requested
condition
for
the
reduced
landscaping.
And
finally,
the
request
is
reasonable,
as
in
the
public
interest
and
is
consistent
with
the
comprehensive
plan
and
the
other
adopt
plan
and
that
one,
the
site
has
historically
been
an
industrial
use
to
additional
landscaping
and
the
location
serves
to
largely
conceal
the
facility.
Q
A
Z
Y
Motion
I
moved
at
the
asheville
city
council
going
to
closed
session
for
the
following
reasons:
one
to
prevent
disclosure
of
information
that
is
privileged
and
confidential.
Pursuant
to
the
laws
of
north
carolina,
we're
not
considered
a
public
record
within
the
meaning
of
chapter
132
of
the
general
statutes.
The
law
that
makes
this
information
privileged
and
confidential
is
north
carolina
general
statute,
143.
Y
A
B
B
A
A
A
A
A
AE
AE
Can't
just
use
this
year's
budget
in
isolation.
Second,
there's
not
enough
information
in
this
budget
about
how
the
25
million
dollars
in
bond
proceeds
to
the
affordable
housing
bond
will
be
spent
before
before
this
month
and
start
paying
interest
on.
We
need
to
have
a
specific
plan
for
its
use
and
with
our.
AE
Not
sufficient
at
all
for
an
expenditure
of
sighs.
Twenty
five
million
dollars
is
more
than
what
the
city
spends
annually
on
our
parks
and
rec
public
works,
transportation
and
city
manager,
departments
combined.
I
would
be
clear
that
I
don't
disagree
with
the
goal
or
the
intent
of
the
bond,
but
from
a
budget
perspective,
this
lack
of
information
on
specific
projects
is
a
red
flag
and
even.
AE
AE
P
P
P
P
Though
depends
what
what
problems
are
I'm
not
going
to
go
into
a
litany
of
items
and
read
verbatim
from
what
I've
written
down
the
notes
that
I
have,
but
I
do
want
to
say
that
our
duty
with
the
n
double
acp
criminal
justice
communities
to
make
our
community
a
place
where
all
people
can
live.
I
had
a
good
look
at
those
young
people.
Those
were
nice-looking
young
people
when
we
started
this
meeting,
often
looking
at.
P
P
P
P
Yard
talk
about
race,
and
all
of
that,
that's
not
the
point.
The
point
is
to
talk
about
common
data
points,
things
that
we
can
agree
on
that
are
pertinent,
that
are
there
tools
that
we
can
use,
and
then
we
want
to
talk
about
using
these
data
points
to
pick
benchmarks,
to
bring
these
disparities
down
to
look
at
best
practices.
We
can
do
this,
we
can
do
it.
P
AF
AF
The
room
tops
was
released
publicly,
so
citizens
like
myself
could
look
at
that
to
know
how
that's
conducted
and
really
I'm
looking
just
for
more
transparency,
a
more
complete
view
of
the
methodology
behind
that
I
do
think
moving
forward.
It
would
be
a
great
set
for
apd
to
release
reports,
as
was
discussed
here,
not
only.
AF
AF
These
efforts
move
forth
because
I
enjoy
working
with
public
data.
I
think
this
is
a
very
important
issue
in
our
community
and
I
think
we
need
to
continue
to
look
at
this
and
see
it
through
not
just
to
look
at
where
we
stand
now,
but
just
to
provide
an
insurance
to
the
public
that
moving
forward
we
can
catch.
Any
issues
that
come
up
early
on
is
not
something
that
we
have
to
look
back
at
five
years
and
say:
how
did
we
miss
that?
AF
A
J
J
J
Presented
the
last
meeting-
and
I
did
that
and
after
the
call
I
emailed
asus
reports
of
some
of
the
traffic
stops
that
we
had
run
through
the
database
to
illustrate
how
we'd
arrived
with
the
conclusion
that
the
stops
weren't
being
reported.
Although
I
did
learn
this
morning
as
councilman
bothell
said
that
that
nina
was
not
seen.
J
J
J
That
would
give
the
appearance
give
every
appearance
of
a
traffic
stop.
That
should
be
reported
that,
but
for
reasons
that
wouldn't
be
evident
on
the
face
of
the
ticket
might
be
exempt
from
the
reporting
requirement.
But
I
would
really
dispute
this
idea
that
there's
not
any
evidence
to
support
these
concerns
about
under
reporting.
The
fact
that
reported
searches
could
drop
so
dramatically
from
more
than
1,200
to
less
than
200
and
the.
J
J
Wasn't
an
issue
of
the
monthly
report
not
being
submitted
all
there's.
Never,
as
far
as
I
can
tell
has
never
been
a
month
where
the
department
reported
zero
traffic
stops
to
the
sbi,
but
there
have
been
times
where
not
all
the
stops
that
occurred
during
that
period
were
reported
and
so
moving
forward.
I
think
that
making
a
similar
sort
of
harrison
on
a
day-by-day
basis
might
be
helpful
and
it
might
be
a
better
way
of
thinking
about
and
in
evaluating
this
underreporting
issue.
The
report
says.
J
The
department
reported
81
traffic
stops,
but
on
january
12
on
january
7th
that
same
month
it
reported
for
the
entire
department
and
that's
a
very
significant
day-to-day
difference
within
the
same
month.
We
know
that
in
north
carolina
the
majority
of
police
citizen
interactions
occur
in
the
course
of
traffic.
Stop
so
two
stops
in
a
city
of
80,000.
People
does
seem
low.
The
previous
january
there.
J
J
J
Only
account
for
traffic
stops
that
individual
officers
themselves
report
to
the
department,
so
when
the
report
says
102
percent
compliant,
what
is
what
it
means
is
that
of
all
the
traffic
stops
that
police
management
who
are
responsible
for
putting
together.
These
reports
are
aware
of
102
percent
or
100.
J
One
who
got
off
without
a
ticket
took
the
time
to
call
and
tell
them
about
that.
The
reporting
system
is
very
much
an
honor
system,
so
I
would
question
whether,
on
days
when
the
department
is
reporting
zero
or
one
or
two
or
three
stops
for
the
entire
department,
I
would
question
whether
that
is
an
accurate
reflection
of
the
entirety
of
police
activity
in
that
day,
and
I
do
think
it
bears
further
review,
particularly
when
the
department
has
admitted
there
was
some
pretty
significant
under
reporting
issues
in
the
fairly
recent
past.
I
also.
J
Had
a
few
just
a
brief
thing
to
say
about
written
consent,
which
is
that,
while
the
department
is
right
that
the
video
is
a
better
account
of
what
transpires
in
the
police
encounter
than
a
written
form,
can
I
don't
think
that
that
is
a
reason
not
to
adopt
a
written
hunt,
a
search
policy?
The
issue
is
really
about
whether
people
who
grant
consent
to
search
adequately
understand
as
the
choice
that
theirs
to
make
giving
them.
J
J
Watch
some
of
these
videos
of
these
traffic
stop
shows
sometimes
the
officers
say
things
use
double
negatives
and
say
things
like
you
don't
mind.
Do
you
if
I
take
a
look
in
your
car
and
then
the
person
will
say
yes
and
it's
not
entirely
clear,
did
they
mean?
Yes,
I
do
mine
or
yes,
you
may
look
in
my
car
and
a
written
consent
form
can
help
clarify
that
there's
also
the
issue
of
the
new
body,
camera
law
that
some
of
you
have
discussed
that
governor
mccrory
signed
that
makes
difficult,
video
more.
J
Difficult
to
obtain-
and
I've
talked
to
a
few
public
defenders
in
the
last
week
or
two
not
here
in
buncombe
but
in
another
county
who
told
me
that
they've
had
to
clear
more
hurdles
already
just
to
get
a
copy
of
the
footage,
and
then
it's
not
always
available
to
them
at
their
first
appearance
and
I'll
wrap
up.
I
did
want.
J
To
say
that
the
news
in
the
report
that
the
department
is
shifting
away
from
citations
for
regulatory
stops
and
towards
morning
think
is
really
encouraging
and
it's
not
exactly
what
we
had
recommended,
but
I
do
thinks
that
this
department
deserves
credit
for
moving
in
that
direction
and
for
being
responsive
to
concerns
the
people
of
the
community
of
raised,
and
I'm
also
very
encouraged
to
hear
that
they're
going
to
start
collecting
locational
data
and
I
think
that
it'll
take
a
while,
but
that
will
give
us
a
really
valuable
additional
piece
of
information.
Thank
you.
Thank
you.
AG
AG
AG
AG
AG
AG
AG
AG
What
you
laugh
is
community
policing,
honest,
genuine
attempts
at
rebuilding
trust,
a
nurturing
relationship
chief
hooper
talks
about
nurturing
relationships
as
part
of
our
21st
policing
plank
21st
century
policing
plan.
There
are
no
nurturing
relationships
that
I
could
find
at
asheville,
nc
gov.
She
did
mention
a.
AG
Community
police
policy
work
group
couldn't
find
it
anywhere.
I
have
no
idea
what
that
is,
but
the
only
genuine
attempt
was
a
six-week
plan
back
in
january,
where
a
police
officer
would
go
to
south
side
for
an
hour
and
break
bread
and
talk
and
have
a
great
time
and
rebuilt
that
trust,
and
it
was
a
great
plan,
and
there
were
some
success
in
his
response
to
sir
charles
gardner,
when
he.
AG
AH
No
debt
service
fund.
There
is
not
at
this
time
that
what
there
is
it's
commingled
or
it's
placed
into
b
city
general
fund,
and
so
I
addressed
the
question
to
all
of
you,
which
was
as
follows.
As
to
those
taxes
specifically
whether
even
collected
to
service
its
bond
indebtedness,
does
the
city
of
asheville
maintain
in
its
accounting
system
a
debt
service
fund
into
which.
AH
AH
AH
AH
I
I
Efficient
way-
and
I
hope
that
we
can
move
towards
doing
that-
so
I
appreciate
what
one
member
of
council
said
only
said.
Their
written
consent
doesn't
mean
that
everyone
isn't
bullied,
and
I
further
ask
that
we
actually
make
this
mandatory.
So
this
during
this
making
written
consent,
searches
mandatory,
would
clear
up
individuals
between
google
cause
and
officers
discretion
at
discretionary
suspicions.
I
I
personally
applaud
the
asheville
baby
for
adopting
body
cameras,
but
to
mention
them
is
a
measure
that
is
potentially
invalidate
or
dilute.
The
need
for
written
consent
is
perplexing
to
me.
The
body
cameras
have
not
been
fully
rolled
out
yet,
although
which
means
that
we
can't
use
their
eventual
deployment
as
a
resilient
reason
to
wait
for
making
a
decision
about
mandating
written
consent
for
searches
the
equipment
can
malfunction
and
video
can
be
lost.
I
I
That
they
said
I
say
in
court,
isn't
dating
to
everyday
people.
Likewise,
likewise
reviewing
videos
as
when
she's
alone,
I
believe
it
makes
no
sense
to
instigate
a
best
practice
based
on
the
precautionary
principle
approach
to
renovate
mitten
consent,
searches
to
be
used
in
tandem
with
body
cameras.
So
I
ask
that
you
all
support
that.
I
asked
the
city
council
director
city
manager
to
director
works
at
the
police
department
I'll
see
immediately,
and
we
also
mentioned
that
the
written
consent.
I
The
policies
of
path,
94
other
cities
in
north
carolina
specifically
derma-
would
be
the
most
similar
to
asheville
anyways.
They
actually
sent
a
hit
both
with
that
pulling
them
over,
and
so
that
would
be
done.
I
sure
if
I
could
be
done
with
mornings,
I
don't
know
what
the
morning
require
that
people
be
pulled
over,
but
I
would
just
like
to
mention
that
that
could
be
another
thing
in
that
area,
so
that
was
all
it
was
asking
all
the
police
fully
consider
and
support
these
policies
again
and
no
pop.
So
I
thank
you.
A
G
G
G
City
is
that
we
outsource
everything
the
consultant
to
hire
the
equity
and
including
manager
that
that's
a
california
firm
doing
that
hiring
that
there
aren't
people.
It
just
makes
me
wonder:
do
you
have
the
relationships
and
the
understanding
of
the
brilliance
that
it
isn't
in
this
community,
the
people
that
are
on
the
ground
spending
day
the
day
dealing
with
these
inequities
are
geniuses.
There
are
strategic
thinkers.
G
G
Williams
mentioned
the
inspiration
seeing
the
kayla
folks
up
here
today,
and
I've
worked
with
those
kayla
students
and
when
they
had
to
identify
the
seven
top
issues
that
needs
focus.
Police
profiling
was
one
of
their
issues.
They
have
extreme
solutions.
I've
listened
to
middle
schoolers,
come
with
ideas
about
what
they're
facing
from
their
black
middle
school
students
their
experience
living
in
asheville
in
their
skin
talking
to
cpac
meetings.
I
don't
I
just.
G
G
Making
more
of
what's
happening
transparently,
available
shows
that
there's
an
investment
and
building
the
relationships
with
those
who
are
on
the
ground
doing
the
work,
but
doing
everything
behind
closed
doors
and
yeah
there's
going
to
be
money,
and
we
can
show
you
the
things
that
we're
spending
money
on
spending
money
doesn't
cause
two
changes
in
communities.
So
if
we're
meeting
data
ask
the
communities
that
are
impacted,
what
is
the
data
that
they
think
should
be
collected
and
then
start
collecting
that
data?
How
are
we
measuring
great
and
implicit
biases
happening
in
the
escalation?
G
AI
Thank
you
mayor
members
of
council.
First,
I'm
kind
of
aggravated
because
I
left
went
to
pacs
and
I
hear
whether
they
came
to
the
roof
and
on
the
roof
come
here
for
so
long
and
how
many
people
here
to
speak.
You
know
the
sudden
the
last
minute
he
changed
the
roofs,
and
so
I
think
she
can
come
running
over.
They
changed
the
rules
and
so,
as
I
kind
of
feel
like
the
dissipation.
AI
AI
It's
no
wonder
that
the
detective
office
is
down
now,
50%
that
they
they
are
not
longer
work
in
all
cases
that
mr.
meditations
going
to
the
officers
on
controls.
I
don't
have
enough
people
inside
in
this
book,
10
20
in
this
week
I
was
going
to
help,
but
they
said
we
can't
have
trended.
We
don't
have
the
men
and
women
to
work
the
street
we're
so
short.
AI
I
don't
blame
them.
Why
would
anybody
want
to
come
and
work
for
a
police
department?
That's
as
bad
as
it
is,
as
you've
heard
denial.
Why
would
anybody
I
would
encourage
him?
I
do
not
come
work
for
dodge
police
department
stay
away
and
the
officers
that
have
worked
in
the
street
and
I've
had
surgeons.
Tell
me
this.
These
officers
are
pulling
in
a
parking
lots
it
and
not
doing
anything.
I
don't
blame
you.
Do
it
park
just
going
to
get
a
call,
come
back
and
talk.
That's
since
1993
we
have
been
mandated.
We
have.
AI
AI
Spend
time
in
the
housing
complexes
you
have
officers
or
totally
every
spend
an
hour
a
day
inside
a
housing
complex,
we've
been
told
since
93
by
the
housing
starting
to
spend
time
in
these
neighborhoods.
A
human
saying,
surely,
is
kansas
93,
but
I
said
cpac
north
their
complaint
was
what
the
police
gonna
do
right.
The
shootings
are
up
in
the
housing
call
like
just
drug
overdoses.
Up
in
owsley
tom
takes
the
last
three
days.
We
had
a
shoot.
We
had
three
old
days
last
year,
then
she.
AI
Prime
was
downtown
number
two
kids
give
you
with
hillcrest
to
be
review
in
walmart.
So
tell
me
what
we're
doing
wrong.
I
think
community
you're
doing
wrong.
He
council
you're
doing
wrong
somebody's
being
these
neighborhoods
polyphasic,
mike
you're,
putting
a
bail
or
less
they're,
still
shooting
they're
still
doing
those
they're
still
all
binion,
and
you
want
to
bring
the
whole
esport
these
men.
Women
are
out
there.
AI
AI
Doesn't
do
nothing
something
to
pay
for
to
seeing
it.
I
can
pour
jim
all
day
long
be
realistic.
You
go
sit
and
talk
with
people.
It's
been
out
here
on
the
streets,
it's
being
here
in
each
housing
complex
since
93,
I've
been
told
to
be
there
and
write
tickets
and
stop
cars
or
you're
not
going
to
work.
Thank
you.
Is
there
anyone
else
pushing.