►
Description
City of Boston Licensing Board Disciplinary Hearing 9-21-21
A
A
Okay,
good
morning,
this
is
a
hearing
before
the
mayor's
office
of
consumer
affairs
and
licensing
for
the
city
of
boston.
Today
is
september
21st
2021..
Today's
hearing
is
being
held
pursuant
to
temporary
amendments
to
the
open
meeting
law.
That
is
what
allows
us
to
meet
virtually
with
us.
Today
is
executive
director,
kathleen
joyce
myself,
rebecca
food
director
of
operations,
lieutenant
detective,
troy,
sergeant,
detective
gallagher,
detective
hernandez,
captain
ciccolo,
sergeant
moy
and
captain
ciccolo
will
introduce
other
officers
later.
A
I
will
read
the
agenda
items
in
into
the
record,
after
which
I
will
ask
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee
or
who
is
present
on
yes
and
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
police
department.
I
will
then
ask
if
there
are
any
individuals
present
who
have
personal
knowledge
of
the
alleged
incident
on
the
specific
date.
A
A
A
There
is
a
incident
report
of
two
one:
two
o
five,
two
eight
eight
five
with
the
alleged
incident
of
an
assault,
simple
and
then
instant
incident
report.
Two
one:
two,
oh
five:
two
eight,
eight
five
supplemental
report,
alleged
incident
assault
and
battery
patron
on
patron,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
B
A
C
First
officers
met
with
victim
one
mayana,
so
I
was
wearing
a
shirt
that
was
ripped
and
she
said
she
was
just
attacked.
Granum
stated
a
middle-aged
white
woman
started
being
verbally
abusive
to
her
outside
of
the
bar.
The
victim
then
said
she
was
attacked
by
the
unknown
suspect
she
remained
sorry.
I
apologize
to
the
background
noise.
I'm
in
another
courthouse.
We
continue
here,
while
officers
were
speaking
with
random
large
fight
broke
out
approximately
150
yards
further
down
the
road
on
lincoln
street.
C
We
called
for
assistance
on
the
radio
and
ran
over
to
the
fight
to
descript
the
group.
It
should
be
noted
that
there
are
several
fights
at
this
time
across
the
district,
and
several
officers
are
tied
up
on
calls
for
service
officers,
observed
an
unknown
group
fighting
and
ordered
for
the
group
to
stop
for
officers
safety
reasons.
C
Artists
decided
to
not
engage
in
the
physical
altercation,
as
officers
were
alone,
with
a
large
group
officers
were
able
to
break
up
the
the
several
verbal
commands
and
warnings
that
they
could
be
subject
to
arrest
houses
ordered
the
group
successfully
dispersion
left
the
team
officers,
not
the
victim
number
two
mary
bryant,
who
was
upset
with
police
response,
grant
yelled
at
officers
to
arrest
an
unknown
male
suspect
who
she
claimed
punched
her
in
the
face.
Bryant
refused
ems
and
was
highly
irate
with
the
scene
on
police
foster's
advisor
report
will
be
written
on
her
behalf.
C
Officers
are
speaking
with
brian
another
female
suspect,
eric
freeman
approach
officers
and
say
that
she
was
attacked
by
brian
all
right
and
then
started
yelling
and
walking
towards
freeman
officers
physically
separated
that
group
and
boarded
freeman
to
leave
freeman
was
at
this
shirtless
black
male
that
was
possibly
involved
in
the
fight
officers,
remained
on
scene
with
the
victims.
While
they
waited
for
a
ride.
C
The
victims
were
angry,
no
arrests
were
made
and
requested
officers,
badge
numbers
officers
provided
numbers
and
the
incident
report
number
to
the
victim,
which
was
granum
officers
repeated
the
incident
number
and
badge
number
two
graham
and
vice
officers
needed
to
clear
to
respond
to
another
call.
She
was
highly
upset
and
hit
the
cruiser
side
in
there
and
passed
the
doors
and
pulled
away
from
the
scene.
B
C
B
C
C
B
C
B
C
B
B
You
know
so,
and
I
would
it
be
fair
to
say
that
I
saw
one
report
and
I'm
not
I'm
just
speaking
broadly
here
officer
rooney
only
because
of
the
other
reports
that
I
read
there
are
oftentimes
fights
in
in
and
around
kingston
lincoln
street
chinatown
down
by
the.
I
guess
I
gather
as
well
down
by
south
station.
B
B
D
C
B
B
The
presumption
is
that
the
officers
ascertained
that
these
were
patrons
of
of
the
club.
Now
I
have
other
issues
about
when
people
engage
in
the
fighting,
but
that's
a
different
conversation
as
to
whether
that
should
be
a
licensed
premises,
but
that's
my
own
opinion,
but
on
the
basis
of
this,
what
we
have
to
rely
upon
is
the
evidence
that's
before
us,
and
that's
why
I
asked
if
it
wasn't
ascertained
these
people
could
have
come
from
any
place,
that's
right
and
and
and
got
in
a
fight.
B
C
F
D
D
F
G
D
F
D
G
F
D
F
Well,
people
usually
they're
standing
next
to
their
table,
they're
standing
in
front
of
the
bar
there's
no
restrictions
to
you
know
as
to
people
saying
what
they're
doing
dancing
again
like
I
said
I
don't
have
a
dance
experiment.
I
do
not
like
people
are
not
dancing
if
they're
standing
side
to
side
swaying
it's
not.
I
don't
know,
I
don't
have
like
a
dance
off
or
anything
like
that.
So.
D
F
D
Because
I
just
want
to
clarify
for
the
record,
you
know
when
you
came
back
before
the
board
in
2000.
I
think
14,
several
months
after
you
had
been
granted
a
license,
the
decision
by
the
board
at
the
time
which
pre-dated
me
specifically
said
that
requests
for
live
entertainment
are
taken
very
carefully
and
reviewed
because
of
the
impact
that
these
requests
have
on
the
neighborhood,
potentially
creating
unwanted
noise
issues
and
traffic
and
other
issues
that
come
up
late
at
night.
B
D
B
D
There's
been
a
large
number
of
calls
and
a
larger
volume
of
calls
and
incidents
occurring
at
the
license:
premise
that
have
required
boston,
police
department's
response
and
I'm
trying
to
determine,
if
perhaps
the
entertainment
license
is
contributing
to
why
bpd
has
to
be
called
down
there
and
if
it's
a
strain
on
the
resources
or
some
sort
of
threat
to
public
safety.
So
if
there's
an
assault.
B
B
A
G
A
H
A
J
H
Across
from
the
corner
pub
chin
stated
he
was
on
his
way
to
the
pub
but
had
engaged
in
an
altercation
with
a
large
group
outside
of
his
vehicle
chin
stated
a
large
group
of
black
males
and
three
females
were
giving
him
a
hard
time
about
parkin.
Where
the
group
had
been
congregating
chin
stated.
The
group
began
stating
racial
slurs
towards
chin
and
one
of
the
females
called
him.
A
chin
stated
one
of
the
females
walked
up
to
him
chest
bumped
him.
While
continuing
to
state
racial
slurs,
chin
stated
after
the
female
struck
him.
H
He
struck
back
at
multiple
people.
She,
instead
he
continued
to
strike
and
fight.
Multiple
people
then
backed
away
and
started
walking
across
lincoln
and
beach
street
towards
the
corner
pub
chin
stated.
While
he
was
disengaging
from
the
disturbance
he
observed
a
tall
black
male
about
six
foot,
four
wearing
a
red
hat
black
t-shirt
walked
to
a
white
mercedes
sedan,
reach
inside
and
grab
an
unknown
object.
H
Chin
stated
the
male
walked
towards
the
middle
of
the
intersection
and
stated
you
want
me
to
shoot.
You
shin
said
he
observed
the
male
with
the
firearm
in
his
right
hand
and
fire
the
weapon
three
to
four
times
up
lincoln
street
towards
tough
street
chin
stated.
He
observed
the
firearm
to
be
a
pistol
but
was
unable
to
make
out
the
make
and
color.
H
It
should
be
noted.
Chin
stated
the
suspect,
held
the
firearm
close
to
his
chest
and
shielded
it
with
his
left
arm.
Chin
stated
the
shots
were
not
in
his
direction
and
he
believed
they
were
warning.
Shots
chin
fled
into
the
corner
pub.
While
pedestrians
fled
the
area,
chen
stated,
the
suspect
ran
back
into
the
white
mercedes
benz
and
fled
up
lincoln
street
officers.
Aunt,
whistle
and
garcia
spoke
with
two
females
who
were
on
scene.
H
Officers
spoke
with
the
first
female
lynese
farrier
faria
was
extremely
intoxicated,
but
stated
she'd
been
hit
in
the
head
by
an
asian
male
who
ran
into
the
koana
pub
ferry
denied
any
shots
fired
and
claimed
she
had
been
attacked
for
no
reason,
officers
requested
ems
on
scene.
It
should
be
noted.
Farrier
was
not
answering
any
questions
from
police
officers.
H
Officers
spoke
with
desire,
roland,
who
stated
she
had
exited
savoir,
restaurant
and
lounge
with
farrier
roland
stated.
They
exited
the
club.
They
were
hanging
out
with
the
group
of
males
that
they
had
never
met.
Volun
stated
when
they
were
hanging
out
with
the
group
chin
and
a
chin,
and
the
group
of
black
males
started
arguing
about
race
and
chin
began
to
strike
all
the
females
in
the
group.
H
K
K
G
K
F
K
Okay,
so
instant
report,
two
one,
two
zero,
two,
six,
nine
four
one
written
by
officer,
giblin
I'll
read
it
sergeant-
will
be
reading
it
about
1357
hours.
On
monday
april,
26
2021
officer,
giblin
assigned
to
the
alpha
437
delta,
respond
to
a
radio
call
for
a
reporter
found
ballistics
located
at
the
kenny
law.
Firm
located
at
132,
lincoln
street
number
2r
in
boston
operations,
informed
the
responding
officer
that
the
reporting
party
believed
that
his
office
window
was
shot
out.
The
reporting
party
discovered
a
shadow
window
and
broken
glass.
K
K
He
said
that
he
cleaned
up
the
glass
from
the
floor
and
subsequently
notified
police,
believing
that
the
hole
in
the
window
was
from
a
gunshot
on
the
morning
of
april
25th,
around
zero
130
hours
officers
signed
to
the
a1
district,
respond
to
shots,
fired
call
at
162,
lincoln
street
referencing
incident
number
two
one:
two:
zero.
Two
six
five,
nine
great
officer
gilman.
Was
there
a
shadow
window
with
a
hold
of
both
panes
of
glass?
K
D
K
Hello
good
morning,
ma'am
sergeant
moy
again,
so
I'm
looking
at
something
like
a
one
I'll
read
that
if
you're,
when
you're
ready
is
that
okay
yeah
on
5
16
21
at
approximately
1006
pm,
detective
mcdonald
and
detective
curley
conducted
a
code
35
license
premise:
violation
at
180,
lincoln
street
civil
restaurant
detective
mcdonald,
spoke
to
the
owner
eddie
fuhrman.
Regarding
the
incident
that
took
place
on
425
21
at
zero
130.
K
K
K
G
B
Thank
you,
miss
joyce,
just
one
quick
question.
I
know
that
sergeant
boyd
didn't
do
the
supplemental
report
number
one,
but
I'm
sure
he's
familiar.
What
is
the
cd
35
license
premises?
Is
that
what
takes
space
when
I
it
says
it
conducted
a
cd
35,
license
premises,
violation
at
180.?
What
is
the
cd
35.
K
B
K
That
is
that's
one
of
the
aspects,
sir.
So
if
you
do
an
unannounced
code
35,
you
want
to
make
sure
the
licenses
are.
You
know
displayed
properly,
but,
for
example,
when
I
did
my
code
35,
I
did
not
enter
the
license
premise
establishment.
I
I
met
mr
fuhrman
at
the
door
and
I
issued
him
his
violation
there,
so
it
entails.
You
know
a
number
of
responsibilities.
B
Right:
okay,
I
know
that
on
the
supplemental
two
which
which
you
did
write
an
issue
right,
it
doesn't
indicate
a
cd
35,
but
would
it
be
customary
that
if
one
does,
if
an
officer
does
a
cd
35,
they
do
check
for
whether
the
license
that
I
know
detective,
curry
and
detective
mcdonald's
were
the
ones
on
who
did
the
supplemental
here?
I
don't
think
either
or
either
of
them
one
day
on
the
call.
B
K
B
D
She
was
hanging
out
with
a
group
of
males,
so
that's
one
of
the
issues
we
take
into
consideration
is
about
your
responsibilities
for
dispersing
the
crowd
in
front
of
your
license
premise
when
they
exit
mr
furman.
I
know
we
talked
about
this
before,
but
could
you
for
purposes
of
explaining?
Have
you
taken
any?
Have
you
made
any
changes
to
your
staffing
as
far
as
disbursement
of
crowds
outside?
D
F
Sure,
since
we
last
spoke
since
the
last
hearing,
absolutely
changes
has
been
made.
I've
submitted
a
dispersal
plan
back
to
leslie.
You
know,
after
the
hearing,
when
we
were
found,
no
violation
was
issued.
Yes,
we
do
have
up
to
10
security
staff,
who
are
normally
outside
who
are
outside
at
at
closing
time.
Who
are
you
know
they
have
flashlight,
they
are
directing
folks
in
their
cars
they're
telling
people
to
keep
it
moving
to
turn
the
music
down
to
move
away.
F
Also,
since
then,
we've
also
I've
had
to
close
the
patio.
So
it's
fully
chained-
and
I
believe
I
I
mentioned
that
to
you.
So
there
was
no
access
to
the
patio,
no
tables
no
chairs
pretty
much
is
we're
not
using
it.
It's
no
one
have
access
to
it.
I
also
want
to
point
out
that
day
just
this
just
regarding
that
event,
we've
submitted
the
videos.
Videos
prove,
you
know,
have
all
the
proofs
in
there,
so
I
don't
think
anything
else
needs
to
be
said.
F
I
E
D
G
K
K
Who
stated
that
one
of
the
bouncers,
above
from
the
above
address,
assaulted
him?
The
victim
said
that
he
was
told
by
the
bouncers
that
he
can't
enter
unless
he
removes
his
hat
and
at
the
time
the
victim
was
telling
the
bouncers
that
he
is
willing
to
bet.
There
are
people
inside
what
hats
on
the
victim
then
said
that
all
of
a
sudden
he
got
punched
and
pushed
by
one
of
the
bouncers.
He
also
stated
that
he
dropped
his
iphone
as
he
got
pushed,
which
caused
the
phone
screen
to
get
damaged.
K
The
victim
had
no
description
for
the
bouncer.
All
he
said
is
that
it
was
a
black
man.
Officer
also
spoke
with
the
owner
of
the
above,
address
eddie
fuhrman,
who
said
that
the
victim
gives
them
a
hard
time
every
time
he
shows
up.
The
owner
said
that
tonight
the
victim
was
not
willing
to
remove
his
hat
in
order
to
enter
and
because
he
couldn't
enter,
he
made
a
big
scene.
K
B
Yes,
I
like
to,
I
know
that
officer
sergeant
moy
wasn't
the
one
who
issued
the
reports.
I
can't
ask
him
this,
but
maybe
officer
giblin,
if
he's
still
on,
I
just
want
to
ask
ask
him
and,
and
if
sergeant
moy
wants
to
respond
as
well
that'd
be
great.
Is
it?
Is
it
customary
just
to
take
the
word
of
someone
that
they
said
that
they
were
assaulted
by
someone
or
is
there
further
investigation?
That's
done.
E
B
Did
you
again,
I
know
this
has
been.
This
was
august
14th
and
I
can't
remember
what
I
had
for
breakfast.
So
I'm
not
gonna,
but
I'm
gonna
ask
you
the
question.
Nonetheless.
Do
you
was
mr
ramses
lozier?
Did
he
evidence
any
since
he
said
he
was
punched
in
the
face
any
redness
or
bruises
or
battery
any
anything
that
you
observed?
B
E
Yes,
sir,
to
my
recollection,
I
mean
in
my
partner
at
the
time
officer
uca
he's
the
author
of
the
report.
I
just
I
just
pulled
up
the
report
just
now.
If,
if
he
did
not
mention
in
the
report
that
he
had
any
sort
of
visible
evidence
of
an
injury,
then
we
did
not
observe
any
and
by
looking
at
his
report
here.
It
also
doesn't
say
anything
about
an
ems
response,
so
I
imagine
that
he
declined
that.
E
B
B
F
B
A
E
Vote:
zero:
two
three:
two
hours
on
saturday
july
31st,
2021
officer,
giblin,
assigned
to
the
alpha
432,
alpha
and
officer
jones,
assigned
to
the
alpha
412
alpha
responded
to
a
radio
call
to
investigate
a
person
at
south
street
in
tough
street
boston.
Upon
arrival
officers
encountered
erica,
freeman
and
kendrick
hood
visibly
upset.
Miss
freeman
stated
that
she
was
assaulted
outside
of
180
lincoln
street
in
her
iphone
11,
her
driver's
license
and
two
debit
cards
were
stolen
from
her.
She
stated
that
she
wanted
to
file
a
police
report
on
the
incident.
E
E
Prior
to
this
incident,
officers
responded
to
the
area
of
180
lincoln
street
for
a
report
of
multiple
fights
and
progress.
Officers
were
unable
to
identify
a
suspect
that
may
have
been
involved
in
this
incident
and
no
description
was
provided.
Officers
escorted,
miss
furman
to
her
vehicle
to
her
vehicle
parked
in
the
area
where
she
was
able
to
leave
safely.
Miss
freeman
declined
ems
response.
That's
the
end
of
my
report.
D
K
Yes
ma'am
so
again
it
reads
the
same
as
the
other
ones
on
eight
27
2021
at
about
1755
hours.
In
the
evening
I
responded
at
180
lincoln
street.
I
met
mr
fuhrman
at
the
doorway
of
180
lincoln
street.
Save
a
restaurant
issued
lpv
zero
zero
zero
for
the
for
the
incident
that
occurred
outside
of
his
establishment.
D
K
B
E
B
E
B
All
right,
yes,
but
not
knowing
whether
she
was
in
the
club,
okay,
I
I
think
I've
established
you
didn't
ascertain
whether
they
at
all
were
patrons
at
civil
war,
the
other
one
that
you
said
they
were
there
again.
You
note
in
here
that
there
were
multiple
fights
in
progress
again.
It
states
that
you're
unable
to
identify
a
suspect
but
say
in
the
area
of
180
lincoln
street.
When
I
asked
once
again
do
you
have
any
knowledge
that
any
of
those
persons
involved
there
were
patrons
of
savor.
A
Next:
violation:
number:
zero;
zero;
eight
six
zero
five
date
of
incident
april;
27
2021
alleged
incident
verbal
dispute,
rear
of
180
lincoln
street
incident
report.
Two
one:
two:
zero:
two:
seven:
three:
five:
nine
alleged
incident
assault
aggravated
incident
report.
Same
number
above
supplemental
report.
A
A
A
J
So
about
10,
48
pm
p.m.
Tuesday
april
27,
2021,
myself,
officer
abrao,
along
with
officer
roca
and
officer,
brooks
responded
to
a
radio
call
for
a
fight
at
beach
in
utica.
Upon
arrival,
the
officers
located
a
male
and
female
in
the
rear
of
180
lincoln
street,
which
is
support.
Restaurant
lounge,
arguing
with
each
other
officers,
stopped
to
talk
with
the
individuals
and
the
female
became
extremely
confrontational.
Both
parties
supreme
to
be
under
the
influence
of
alcohol.
The
female
began
shouting
statements
such
as
don't
kill
him.
J
I
know
my
rights,
he
was
an
unarmed
black
man,
the
female
shouted
that
her
name
was
morgan
taylor,
but
would
not
provide
additional
information.
After
several
attempts
of
the
females
interfering
with
the
offices,
the
mail
party
agreed
to
talk
with
the
officers
the
mayor
identified
himself
as
maxwell
morgan.
He
told
the
officers
that
he
was
having
a
verbal
dispute
with
another
male
inside
of
civil
war.
Mr
morgan
stated
that
the
other
person
brandished
a
handgun,
causing
him
to
back
away.
J
J
Mr
morgan
described
the
suspect
as
a
black
male
wearing
a
play,
shirt
and
did
not
provide
further
info
due
to
the
victim's
intoxication
inability
to
cooperate
in
the
crowd
of
bystanders
beginning
to
assemble,
provoking
officers.
The
officers
instructed
the
victims
to
leave
the
area
and
return
back
to
their
vehicle.
Shortly
after
the
officers
entered
the
board
and
spoke
with
the
manager
eddie
fuhrman,
he
told
the
officer
there
was
an
argument
involving
the
victim
and
another
male.
J
He
stated
the
argument
was
about
miss
taylor.
Both
parties
were
separated
by
the
bouncers
and
escorted
out
in
different
exits.
The
staff
then
told
the
officers
that
the
victim
was
escorted
back
to
his
vehicle
for
extra
safety.
Mr
fuhrman
told
the
officer
that
a
firearm
was
not
displayed,
nor
did
anyone
allude
to
one.
J
D
K
Ma'am
sergey
moore
here,
they're
they're
not
present.
However,
I
have
a
report
in
front
of
me
so
I'll
read
that
okay,
so
at
about
10,
30,
7
p.m.
On
friday,
5
7,
21
detectives,
conley,
the
alpha,
809
and
walsh.
The
alpha
803
respond
to
save
a
restaurant
and
lounge,
which
is
located
at
180
lincoln
street
in
boston.
On
arrival,
the
detectives
were
meant
by
the
restaurant
manager
alex
vilmi,
detectives
and
foreign.
K
K
F
Sure,
thank
you,
mr
fisa,
again,
as
noted
in
the
previous
licensing
on
hearing,
so
what
we,
what
we
did
at
the
the
day.
We
observed
the
argument
between
the
young,
lady
and
another
male.
So
what
we
did
so
security
got
involved
before
anything
escalated.
So
we
decided
to
separate
the
the
two
parties,
escorted
them
in
a
different
direction,
and
especially
the
young,
the
young,
lady
and
and
her
and
the
male
friend.
F
So
we
escorted
him
outside
and
literally
we
walk
them
to
their
car,
so
we
normally
make
sure
that
they
are
safe
and-
and
we
don't
just
you
know,
just
just
have
them
go
outside
so
on
that
day,
the
same
will
follow
the
same
procedures.
So
the
second
that
security
staff
observed
anything
as
as
anything
disappointing
that
can
escalate
into
to
something.
That's
gonna
be
problematic.
They
usually
act
fast
and
they
are
very
reactive
so
that
they
follow
the
same
procedures.
F
Somebody
went
out
the
front
door
and
we
escorted
the
the
guys
to
the
back
because
he
said
his
car
was
right
right
in
the
back
on
south
street
and
that's
exactly
what
we
did
so
when
the
officer
came
in,
we
spoke
to
him.
I
smoked
him
because
I'm
always
there
and
I
clearly
stated
that
you
know
this
is
what
happened.
He
understood
and
he
asked
me
to
say
that
was
a
gun.
I
said
no,
there
was
no
gun
garnish
by
anywhere.
We
didn't
even
know
nothing
was
you
know
again.
B
F
J
D
A
D
F
F
D
F
D
G
F
D
D
B
J
D
F
Tuesday
and
again
from
the
violation
that
I'm
reading
off
of
I
I
I
don't
understand
how
it
was
a
fight,
it
was
never
a
fight
outside.
It
says
verbal
distress
because
they
were
shouting
loud.
So
that's
what
that's
what
was
said
to
me
when
the
officer
came
in.
It
was
the
fact
that
they
were
just
out
in
the
back
screaming
so.
K
F
F
F
F
D
G
G
D
A
Alleged
incident
firearm
weapon
found
or
confiscated
supplemental
report
to
that
incident.
Alleged
incident
vandalism:
supplemental
report
number
two
alleged
incident:
recovered
drugs:
supplemental
report,
number
three
alleged
incident;
assault
on
police
officer,
disturbance,
shots
fired,
lpv008606.
K
K
Okay,
so
incident
number
two
one:
two:
zero
five,
six,
eight
five,
seven
written
by
officer
sosa,
read
by
sergeant
moy
and
it
goes
about
2
20
a.m.
On
saturday,
8
14,
2021
officer
sosa
the
alpha
432
alpha
and
officer
merrick's,
the
alpha
411
alpha
we're
responding
to
a
radio
call
for
a
group
causing
a
disturbance
at
180
lincoln
street.
K
The
call
came
in
from
an
employee
at
the
corner
pub
who
stayed
there
was
about
30,
drunk
individuals
in
front
of
the
business
that
refused
to
move.
The
officers
observed
multiple
cars,
double
parked
and
groups
gathered.
The
officers
approached
the
grain
nissan
maxima
with
mass
registration,
9
mb,
as
in
mike
bravo
773.
K
There
was
a
female
in
the
driver's
seat
of
the
nissan
and
her
friends
were
trying
to
stop
her
from
driving
and
wanted
her
to
get
out
of
the
driver's
seat
officer
marx
was
standing
in
front
of
the
green
nissan
and
instructed
the
unidentified
female
to
get
out
of
the
vehicle
multiple
times.
The
female
then
put
the
vehicle
in
drive
and
attempted
to
drive
off
tapping
off
the
merricks
with
the
vehicle
officer.
Merrick
then
immediately
tapped
the
hood
of
the
vehicle
to
alert
the
female.
K
He
was
there
and
she
was
about
to
run
him
over
the
unidentified
female,
eventually
put
the
car
in
park
and
jumped
over
to
the
passenger
side
and
exited
the
vehicle
from
the
front
passenger
door.
A
male
later
identified
as
troy,
bowens
became
irate
after
observing
the
officer's
attempt
to
stop
the
vehicle
troy
bone
state
that
it
was
his
girlfriend
and
his
car
troy
bones
and
stated
verbally
started
verbally,
arguing
with
officer
merricks.
K
The
officers
instructed
all
parties
there
to
get
in
their
vehicles
and
clear
out
multiple
times,
including
the
anger,
troy
bones.
At
that
point,
the
two
males
later
identified
as
leon
edmonds
and
william
williams,
also
tried
telling
troy
bones
to
leave
and
that
anger,
troy
bones
even
more,
and
he
then
started
arguing
with
leon
edmonds
and
william
williams.
K
It
should
be
noted
that
the
incident
was
captured
on
officer
social's
body,
one
camera
at
approximately
2
44
a.m.
Troy
bones
then
gets
into
the
great
nissan
maxima,
with
math
registration,
9,
mb,
773
and
drives
off,
and
mins
and
williams
also
leave
the
scene
around
the
same
time
in
a
different
vehicle
that
was
unidentified
at
the
time,
a
short
period
of
time
after
that,
as
the
officers
were
heading
back
to
their
cruisers,
they
heard
about
eight
to
ten
shots
fired
in
the
direction
of
surface
road
near
the
chinatown
gate.
K
Both
officers
ran
down
b
tree
towards
surface
road
to
investigate
and
also
sosa
notified
channel
2
dispatcher
after
the
shot
fired
officer,
merricks
and
silsa,
crossed
over
surface
road
and
were
headed
towards
essex
street.
When
officer
merricks
observed
two
grey
sedans
driving
down
around
kingston
street
in
edinburgh
street
and
then
sped
off
down
9-3
north
officer
merrick's
relayed
this
information
to
dispatch.
K
Shortly
after
officer's
observation,
a
9-1-1
call
was
placed
for
shots
fired.
The
following
information
was
relayed
to
all
responding
units
by
the
channel
2
dispatcher.
The
911
caller
stated
that
there
was
a
male
with
a
gun
at
kingston
street
and
bedford
street.
Caller
also
stated
that
the
suspect
drove
off
in
a
gray
honda
and
went
down
9
30
north
the
caller
followed
the
suspect's
vehicle
and
gave
dispatch
a
mass
registration
of
two
mike
sierra
alpha
2
7.
G
D
B
Well,
I
first
want
to
say
I
I
feel
for
the
job
that
our
police
officers
have
to
contend
with
in
dealing
with
these
situations,
particularly
finding
these
persons
with
weapons
and
things
of
that
nature.
So,
and
I
applaud
you
for
the
work,
you
certainly
do
there
in
preventing
some
of
these
things
buddy,
but.
B
B
K
B
Said
like
states
here
and
the
report
does
not
indicate
whether
it
was
established
whether
these
individuals
were
patrons
of
savor,
at
least
what
I
can
tell
I.
I
know
you
didn't
author
it,
but
I
don't
believe
it's
in
there,
but
I'll
I'll,
just
put
on
a
record
miss
joyce.
I
don't
believe
that
it
does
state
whether
they
were
patrons
of
civil
war
and,
if
I've
wronged
a
report
will
will
indicate
that
I
was.
I
misspoke
no
further
questions.
Mr
furman,
do
you
have
anything
in
response
to
this.
F
D
G
C
B
G
B
B
B
Well,
I'm
not
sure
I
can
read
all
of
the
shorthand,
but
lots
of
cars
double
park.
Oh
call
estates,
lots
of
cars,
double
parks,
I'm
getting
pretty
good
at
this
sergeant,
moyer
learning
how
to
read.
Please
speak
but
yeah,
eight,
seven,
a
rowdy
crowd
from
the
from
the
above
about
50
people
pushing
and
shoving,
etc.
B
So
I
yeah
so
yeah
I
see
in
terms
of
the
there
are
there's
even
one
that
goes
back
to
and
goes
back
to
many,
and
this
list
consists
of
many
addresses
here,
including
one
which
talks
about
a
caller
wants
to
report.
A
guidance
across
from
above
address
seems
to
be
on
drugs,
dump
a
whole
bag
of
clothes
out
on
the
sidewalk.
B
That
was,
I
believe,
that
date
was
may
of
2021,
and
then
we
have
a
list
of
things
going
on
at
several
addresses
on
lincoln
street
80,
lincoln
street
176
lincoln
street
one
lincoln
street
179,
lincoln
street
174
lincoln
street
all
types
of
crimes
that
have
taken
place.
So
I
see
the
list
miss
joyce,
I
I
I
I
see
it,
but
it
seems
to
me
that
it
is
probably
generated,
as
we
ask
in
many
other
setting
in
terms
of
the
transparency
as
to
what
the
police
department
has
to
contend
with.
B
I
D
I
I
I
I
think
everybody's
aware
of
the
resource
constraints
that
the
police
department
is
working
on
that
are,
quite
frankly,
substantially
less
than
they
have
been
in
the
past,
and
you
know
I've
got
people
robbing
people
down
around
quincy
market.
I've
got
a
theater
district
with
you
know
a
dozen
different
clubs
to
monitor,
and
instead
they
end
up
having
to
go
over
to
this
neighborhood,
where,
quite
frankly,
not
much
happens
other
than
at
least
late
at
night
associated
with
saver.
D
I
The
space
directly
in
front
of
saver,
the
space
that
was
the
outside
dining
you
know,
would
be
a
problem
area
people
congregating
in
that
area.
I
know
mr
fur
said
that
the
space
is
locked
up,
but
that
was
not
the
case
on
the
one
occasion
that
I
went
by
and
as
well
as
the
I
forget
what
he
had.
If
you
want
to
call
it
divine
shielding
or
whatever
that
was
made,
it
made
it
difficult
and
created
a
an
attractive
nuisance
there
for
people
to
gather
outside.
D
B
B
I
am
familiar
with
what
the
entertainment,
the
office
of
consumer
affairs
and
licensing
must
consider
in
these
instances,
and
I
want
to
make
sure
I
have
a
complete
record
for
it
for
you
to
consider.
So
I
want
to
do
that.
I
won't
take
up
much
of
your
time.
I'd
say
about
five
more
minutes,
but
I
do
want
to
speak
to
the
I
know,
office
of
captain
siccolo
sicolo,
I'm
sorry
ciccolo.
I
B
Okay,
I
got
to
get
it
right
there.
I
want
to
definitely
do
that
as
I'm
looking
at
the
list
here
of
this,
you
say
in
terms
of
an
exhaustion
of
your
resources,
and
I
think
that
anything
that
the
great
men
and
women
of
the
in
blue
have
to
contend
with
is
beyond
the
pale
of
what
one
should
have
to
do.
But
it
is
the
the
job
that
one
has
undertaken,
but
in
this
particular
instance
I'm
looking
at
a
list
which,
quite
frankly,
has
six.
B
B
D
It
goes
towards
police
resources
in
this
general
area
and
he's
a
a
restaurant
owner
and
in
this
area,
so
he
he
falls
within
that
that
general
area.
So
that's
right,
just
as
we
said
in
our
hearing
notice,
it
goes
to
the
volume
of
calls
and
incidents
occurring
at
or
near
the
license
premise.
So
that's
why
we
have
the
9-1-1
call
list
so.
B
No
well,
I
understand
that,
but
in
considering
whether
my
client
has
some
way
abridged
it
the
his
the
grant,
the
granting
of
his
entertainment
license,
I
have
to
take
into
it.
I
have
to
at
least
put
on
a
record
to
you
that,
in
terms
of
it's,
whether
his,
whether
it's
direct
bearings
on
it,
his
license
says
that
and
he
has
testified
to
one
he's
allowed
to
stay
open
at
2
a.m,
and
I'd
like
for
you
to
speak
to
how
do
you?
B
A
I
I
While
officer
sosa
was
talking
to
one
of
the
females
who
later
identified
herself
as
krishna
burrito.
A
third
female
who
was
later
identified
as
chennai
hunter,
threw
her
beverage
at
officer,
sosa
and
krishna
burrito
officer
so
then
notified
the
channel
2
dispatcher
and
requested
additional
units
to
respond
to
her
location.
I
While
the
officers
were
off
with
the
two
females
that
were
arguing,
cora
jones
ward,
punched,
chris
nabrito,
in
the
face
chris
nabrito
altered
this
temp
attempted
to
fight
back,
but
officers
on
scene
stopped
her
while
they
were
doing
so.
Miss
brito
attempted
to
punch
officeroka
and
mist,
then
proceeded
to
push
officeroka
to
the
ground.
I
Cora
jones
wood
was
placed
under
arrest
for
assault
and
battery
and
disturbing
the
peace
krishna
priya
brito
was
placed
under
arrest
for
a
and
b
on
a
police
officer
and
disturbing
the
peace.
Chennai
hunter
was
placed
under
arrest
for
assault
and
battery
with
a
dangerous
weapon
in
disturbing
the
peace
they
were
transported
to.
All
of
them
were
transported
to
district
one.
I
Detective
walsh
searched
cora
during
the
booking
process
and
had
her
lift
the
left
side
of
her
shirt
to
examine
her
for
any
injuries.
She
did
not
observe
any
visible
injuries
and
asked
corey
if
she
needed
medical
attention.
She
denied
the
need
for
boston
ems
to
respond,
noted
that
there
had
been
multiple
license
premise:
violations
for
civil
those
are
the
ones
we've
just
discussed
here.
As
a
result,
I
responded,
I
told
them
to
disperse
the
outside
line.
There
was
still
a
line
there
in
place
to
enter
the
premises.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
did
I
forwarded
two
body-
camera
videos.
One
is
officer
sosa's
video
of
her
interactions
outside
from
the
time
she
exited
her
cruiser
to.
I
believe,
the
time
she
placed
a
prisoner
in
her
car
and
the
other
is,
I
forget,
which
offices
one
of
the
offices
body,
camera
video
that
entered
the
premise
with
me.
Okay,.
B
B
I'm
just
making
my
request
now
to
miss
joyce.
If
I
can
have
this,
but
mr
fuhrman,
can
you
speak
to
that
particular
night,
because
characterization
that
you
have
a
nightclub
and
folks
were
dancing
and
folks
were
leaving
with
drinks
and
etc?
And
I
guess
the
only
question
I
would
have.
I
do
have
one
for
for
the
captain
if
people
were
leaving
a
premises
with
alcohol
is
that
I
know
this
is
in
bourbon
street.
So
I
know.
Is
that
permissible?
Why
weren't
people
arrested.
I
In
you
know,
it
is
in
fact
an
arrestable
offense.
It's
drinking
in
a
public
way.
Does
depression
indicate
dictate
that
we're
going
to
try
to
lock
somebody
up
for
a
drink
in
a
plastic
cup
in
the
midst
of
trying
to
disperse
and
end
a
fight,
I
I
think
that
probably
would
not
count
as
de-escalating
okay.
F
Thank
you,
mr
pisa.
Again,
as
we
said
the
last
I
was
invited
to
to
a
neighborhood
meeting
with
the
captain
city
council,
ed
flynn
and
the
neighborhood
association
just
about
about
a
month
ago.
So
again
I
know
about
the
push
and
I
know
about
the
movement.
That's
going
in
the
neighborhood
mind
you
I've
been
there
for
about
eight
years
now
and
the
movie
that's
going
on
in
terms
of
trying
to
shut.
You
know
my
business
now,
mr.
D
F
F
Until
one
o'clock
in
the
morning
and
the
captain's
saying
there
was
no
food,
there
was
nothing
being
served
mind
you,
the
the
area
that
they
came
in.
They
came
in
for
about
five
seconds
and
and
stood
and
turned
around
and
went
back
so
people
were
eating.
I
still
have
to
have
receipts,
I
have
sales
of
food,
we
serve
food
and
we
have
takeout.
We
have
you
know.
So
if.
F
You
tell
me
today
that
you're
a
nightclub,
it's
a
restaurant
and
lounge,
though
that
promise
people
to
stand
to
for
me
to
have
music
to
have
live
music,
to
have
a
dj
to
have
tv,
so
people
are
standing
by
the
table.
People
are
sitting
in
front
of
the
bar.
People
are
standing
and
congregating.
So
therefore
they're
not
about
it
they're,
not.
I
don't
have
a
designated
dance
floor
just
like.
D
F
D
So
I
have
a
question
what
so
you
testified
earlier
today
that
you
don't
have
any
promoters
in
preparation
for
today's
hearing,
because
this
took
up
a
lot
of
time
of
of
my
time
as
executive
director,
I
did
a
little
research
online.
Okay,
what
is
saturday
vibes?
What
is
this
other
one
that
I
easily
found?
It
states
that
it
actually
rnb
brunch.
D
Through
eventbrite,
so
that
that
to
me
says
it's
a
promoter,
it
actually
says
here,
questions
that
your
patrons
might
be
asking.
Is
there
a
cover
charge?
No,
how
do
I
reserve
for
brunch
see
it's
our
first
come
first
serve.
Am
I
required
to
wear
a
mask,
no
you're
required
to
wear
a
mask
in
the
city
of
boston.
Well,.
D
D
Many
times
it's
not
necessarily
having
a
dance
floor,
you're
not
supposed
to
have
dancing
so
either
you're
understaffed.
You
don't
have
enough
people
to
tell
your
patrons
to
sit
down
and
finish
their
food
at
their
restaurant
or
you
have
an
issue.
That's
bigger
than
just
people,
swaying
at
their
tables
and
chairs.
F
F
Of
opera,
in
the
same
way,
I
feel
like
again
since,
since
this
this
push
from
the
neighborhood
and
from
the
police
has
just
started
happening
recently.
I've
been
operating
the
exact
same
way
as
I
started.
I've
not
changed
anything
mind
you.
This
is
the
same
way
as
operation
is
done
at
the
w
operation
is
done
at
lincoln
operations
done
at
other
restaurants
and
lounges
in
the
city
of
boston.
Right
now,
there's
this
this
this
pure,
I
guess,
moving
just
focusing
strictly
on
saber
about
dancing,
restaurant
and
lounges
would
have
been.
F
F
D
F
F
F
F
People
start
coming
in
late:
it's
it's
a
late
demographic.
They
come.
They
eat
ten
o'clock
on
twelve
o'clock.
People
are
eating,
so
it's
a
late
demographic
again
as
a
lounge
people
come
in,
they
eat
they
drink.
They
do
everything
all
throughout
you
know
throughout
the
evening,
so
the
typical
restaurant,
which
which
is
open
at
five
o'clock
and
have
dinner
service,
I'm
not
the
typical
restaurant
again
I
keep
referencing
other
places
because
we
have
the
same
format.
D
B
No,
the
only
thing
I
wanted
to
make
sure
that's
in
the
record
as
well,
and
I'm
sure
you
are
aware
of
this.
Mrs
joyce
is
the
the
standard
operating
procedures
that
mr
furman
has
in
place.
If
you
don't
have
that,
we
can
make
sure
that
that
becomes
a
part
of
the
record,
and
that
speaks
to
the
the
tips,
training
and
other
training
that
his
people
must
have
and
there's
a
whole
list.
B
So
if
you
do
not
have
that
in
your
records,
please
reach
out
to
me
and
we
can
make
sure
that
you
receive
that
and
as
far
as
what
I've
heard
from
from
all
of
the
officers
today,
as
well
as
what
I've
just
heard
relative
to
the
entertainment
license
each
time,
they've
done
a
I'm
just
gonna.
I
think
it
was
the
c35
or
at
least
where
they've
gone
in,
because
there's
several
reports
on
the
on
that
list
of
incidents
that
you
gave
me.
Some
of
them
were
licensed
premises.
B
The
see
the
license
checks
there's
on
here
for
180.
I
just
want
to
point
out
that
on
here
there
are
at
least
many
of
the
the
references
to
180
lincoln
street.
Are
licensed
checks
those
cd35s
and
I
can
based
upon
what
has
been
occurring
if
mr
furman
and
at
savor
restaurant
did
not
have
his
licenses,
both
entertainment
as
well
as
his
license
to
operate
as
a
restaurant,
not
visible
and
appropriate.
F
F
Totality
part
of
it
is
that
the
neighbor,
the
neighbors,
have
been
encouraged
to
call
it's
never
been
this
way
for
after
eight
years,
and
if
you
notice
the
neighbors
have
been
encouraged
to
call
their.
The
calls
have
been
coming
more,
whether
it's
true
or
not,
there's
been
time,
even
certainly,
if
it's
on
the
call
that
they
have
made
false
accusations,
they've
called
for
fights
and
then
when
people
arrived
they
said.
Oh
there
was
no
fight.
Oh,
I
thought
there
was
a
fight,
so
they've
been.
B
This
miss
joyce.
I
have
to
take
issue
with
this
characterization.
I
have
six
calls
here,
so
I
can't
see
you
know
and-
and
you
know
like
I
said
I
don't
want
to
give
my
my
opinion-
I'm
not
going
to
be
judgmental
on
whether
a
call
is
not,
but
they
have
to
be
evaluated
in
light
of
the
total
circumstances
and
to
say
that
there
is
a
a
large
volume.
That's
just
the
record
just
doesn't
demonstrate
that
and.
D
F
B
And,
as
far
as
the
violations
to
the
things
that
pertain
to
this
on
the
license,
there's
no
evidence
that
any
of
those
things.
This
is
the
neighborhood
issue
which
I
fully
appreciate,
but
as
far
as
any
violation,
if
he
had
violated
any
of
the
terms.
That's
why
I
made
it
a
point
to
say
that
if
he
advised,
when
they
did,
the
license
premises,
checks
that
if
he
had
violated
anything
including
having
the
license
that
was
out
of
date,
license
not
hung
in
a
particular
place
that
all
would
have
been
noted.
So.
D
Advertisement
on
instagram
for
your,
you
know,
bbd
thing
it
says:
no
masks
are
required.
You
are
licensed
by
the
city
of
boston,
so
you
are
subject
subject
to
our
rules
and
regulations
in
addition
to
the
state.
Is
it
one
that
trump's
over
the
other?
So
okay,
I'm
not
saying
they're
not
wearing
masks,
I'm
saying
they
need
to
be
wearing
masks
and
you
should
not
advertise
that
no
masks
are
required.