►
From YouTube: Boston Licensing Board Violation Hearing - 02/14/23
Description
Date: 14 February, 2023
A
A
A
C
A
Thank
you
please
ensure
that
your
audio
and
visuals
are
working
properly.
I
will
call
each
item
in
the
order.
It
appears
on
this
morning's
agenda.
I
will
then
ask
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee,
who
is
president
on
behalf
of
the
Boston
Police
Department,
and
whether
there
are
any
other
individuals
with
first-hand
knowledge
of
the
alleged
incident
who
wish
to
testify.
A
A
Again,
all
testimony
will
be
limited
only
to
those
individuals
with
first-hand
personal
knowledge
of
the
alleged
incident
begin
with
item
number
one
on
this
morning's
agenda,
calling
JJ
Donovan
Inc
doing
business
as
Donovan's
Tavern,
located
at
27,
Clinton,
Street
date
of
the
incident,
December
4th
2022
assault
and
battery
Patron
and
Patron
in
violation
of
mass
generalize
chapter
138,
section
64
and
chapter
265,
section:
13
a
and
failure
to
notify
police
in
violation
of
mass
generalize,
chapter
138,
section,
64
and
Boards
rule
1.14
B,
who
is
present.
On
behalf
of
the
licensing.
B
Sorry
morning,
chairman
Joyce
Commissioners,
Saxon
and
Karen
attorney
Stephen
Miller
also
was
Muse
attorney.
Michael
Ford
and
also
I
have
Chris
Peterson.
Who
was
the
doorman
on
that
evening
and
Chris
hickey?
Who
is
the
bartender
manager
on
the
evening
in
the
incident.
E
A
A
Do
you
sort
of
tell
the
truth,
the
whole
truth
and
nothing
but
the
truth,
nope
I
do.
Thank
you
very
much
who
will
be
reading
the
police
reporting
to
the
record.
E
About
12
50
a.m:
on
Sunday
December,
4th
of
intuoso
Rooney
assigned
to
the
alpha
102
Alpha
responded
to
radio
call
for
a
fight
at
27,
Clinton,
Street,
JJ,
Donovan's,
also
notified
two
people
were
fighting
outside
of
the
above
location.
Dispatch
later
stated
that
one
of
the
Mills
was
now
on
the
ground
unresponsive.
E
The
following
units
responded:
Sergeant,
Hernandez,
Karen,
Murray
offices
scanned
the
length
of
this
Clinton
Street
to
no
avail.
Shortly
after
officer
Bulger
located
the
victim
Gary
Steele
215-54
inside
Faneuil
Hall
outside
of
J.J
Donovan's,
laying
on
the
ground
suffering
from
what
appeared
to
be
a
large
laceration
to
his
forehead
officer.
Safety
arrived
on
scene
and
assisted
Steele's
family
who
were
shaken
up
from
the
incident.
E
E
Number
one
was
a
white
male
with
a
long
white
long-sleeve
shirt,
blue
jeans
and
a
red
underwear
protruding
from
the
rear
of
its
waistband
suspect
number
two
was
light:
colored
hair
shoulder
length,
blue
gray,
suit
and
security
guards
directed
officers
to
the
area
of
Congress
street,
where
the
suspect's
fled
officer
scanned
the
area
to
no
avail.
E
Gomez
and
brown
stated
they
observed
the
victim
laying
on
the
ground.
Gomez
Browns
observed
the
two
suspects
walking
towards
Congress
Street
and
attempted
to
stop
them
as
they
approached
they
tried
to
gain
a
control.
Both
suspects
pushed
off
and
I
ran
towards
Congress
Street
after
scanning
the
area
officer
and
twistle
and
Masha
and
returned
to
the
victim
and
assists
directing
pressure
on
Steel's
lacerations
Boston
EMS
arrived
on
scene
at
transport,
steel
to
Mass
General
after
EMS
arrived
and
transported
seal.
E
The
hospital
off
the
entire
whistle
spoke
with
Steele's
daughter's
boyfriend,
Thomas
Regan,
who
stated
he
was
inside
JJ
Donovan's,
located
around
the
corner
from
the
assault
reconcated.
He
observed.
Both
the
suspects
get
kicked
out
of
the
bar
Reagan
say
that
he
and
his
family
left
the
bar
and
began
walking
towards
Congress
Street.
To
get
a
ride
home
as
they
walked
by
the
two
suspects,
he
observed
them
yelling
and
started
a
verbal
altercation
with
them.
Reagan
stated
both
males
came
out
of
nowhere
and
threw
Gary
to
the
ground.
E
Reagan
stated
both
males
fled
and
they
fled
the
area
and
towards
Congress
Street
Reagan
stated
he
ran
after
them,
punched
one
of
them
in
the
back
of
the
head
as
hot
as
he
could
observed,
small
laceration
to
Regan's
right
hand,
Reagan
pointed
towards
Faneuil
Hall
security,
who
attempted
to
stop
the
males
but
were
unsuccessful.
Regan
proceeded
to
State.
The
second
male
was,
with
the
suspect,
was
wearing
a
gray
suit.
E
Navy
gray
suit
with
a
shoulder
length,
they
have
sudden
hand
is
spoke
with
the
bartender
at
JJ,
Donovan's,
Chris
hickey,
and
the
doorman
Christopher
Peterson.
Both
who
stated
the
ball
was
getting
too
rowdy
around
midnight
and
an
altercation
inside
the
established
from
The
Cure
Peterson
stayed
at
around
midnight.
He
turned
on
the
lights
in
the
bar
and
kicked
everyone
out.
E
Vicki
stated
the
two
suspects
involved
in
the
assault
on
Gary
Steele
were
not
involved
in
the
altercation
inside
of
proceeded
to
play
scrime
scene
around
the
area
where
the
victim
was
until
they
were
notified
by
the
the
hospital
that
the
his
injuries
were.
Non-Life-Threatening
I
was
just
broke
down
the
crime
scene
and
continued
the
search.
E
The
area
for
the
suspects
officers
stopped
two
males
National
description
on
Atlantic
Avenue,
High,
Street
in
front
of
Rose
wolf,
Hotel
offices
conducted
a
bring
back
and
both
suspects
were
identified
as
the
combatants
who
assaulted,
Mr
Steele.
A
E
On
the
fourth
myself
and
detective,
McDonough
responded
to
JJ
Donovan's
most
issued
them
a
licensed
license
premise:
violation
for
some
battery
on
Apprentice.
A
Thank
you
very
much
attorney
Miller
attorney
Ford.
Would
you
like
to
address
the
incident.
B
You
know
Sergeant,
you
didn't
witness.
The
incident
is
that
correct.
B
And
when
you
went
back
to
back
to
the
to
the
bar,
did,
did
you
ask
for
a
copy
of
a
video.
E
I
did
they
gave
us
a
video
of
the
evening
in
question.
B
Have
you
reviewed
that
video
I.
B
And
and
sergeant
in
fact,
the
video
shows
that
this
whole
incident
took
place
about
50
yards
down,
North
Market
Street
from
from
JJ
Donovan's.
Is
that
correct.
E
The
incident
in
the
one
one
did
happen
outside
of
the
establishment.
B
B
All
right:
well,
we've
provided
the
video
to
the
board,
so
we
I
can
go
over.
That.
Has
there
been
any
follow-up
on
on
this
investigation.
E
It
has
that
we
started
a
grand
jury
up
at
self-experia
Court.
The
victim
is
still
in
the
hospital.
He
is
supposedly
only
going
to
get
back.
65
percent
of
this
mobility
in
his
head
he's
got
a
bad
neck,
injury
yeah.
It's
it's
an
ongoing
investigation.
B
And
so
on
on
that
evening,
Sergeant
one
of
the
people
involved
in
this
incident,
this
assault
on
Mr
Steele,
Mr
Buckley,
was
arrested.
He.
E
B
And
then
Minister
Fleming
who's
also
involved
was.
B
Was
not
arrested,
he
was
not
arrested,
and
that
was
because
was
stated
that
he
did
not
strike
Mr
Steele.
E
B
So
only
Mr
Buckley
was
arrested.
Correct.
Do
you
have
any
other
knowledge
of
this
incident
that
you'd
like
to
tell
the
board
not.
B
Thank
you
for
your
cooperation
Sergeant,
so
Madam,
chair,
I,
have
with
me
Chris
hickey,
who
was
the
bartender
and
I
also
have
Chris
Peterson.
Who
was
the
doorman
that
evening?
We
did
provide
you
video.
Unfortunately,
we
didn't
get
it
to
you
until
last
night.
B
I
would
ask
that
before
the
board
makes
any
decisions
that
they
review
the
video
there
there's
a
video
of
the
exterior,
which
shows
the
what
was
leading
up
to
this
and
also
the
event
itself,
and
you
could
start
at
on
the
exterior
video
at
22
minutes
and
there's
also
a
video
of
the
interior,
which
shows
what
was
going
on
that
evening
inside
the
bar,
and
that
would
be
from
the
point
in
times
or
approximately
10
minutes
to
21
minutes.
B
So
if
the
board
could
could
review
that
I
just
like
to
just
walk
you
past
quickly
and
then
ask
some
questions
of
Mr
hickey
and
Mr
Peterson,
the
video
for
the
exterior
will
show
Mr
and
Mrs
Steele
their
daughter
and
their
daughter's
boyfriend.
Mr
Reagan
inside
the
premises.
They're
sitting
in
the
far
side
of
the
bar
from
the
camera
on
also
will
show
Mr,
Fleming
and
Mr
Buckley,
who
were
obviously
friendly
and
have
numerous
friends
inside
from
the
video
of
the
entire
evening.
B
There
is
nothing
that
we
see
with
any
interaction
whatsoever
between
Mr,
Fleming
and
Buckley
and
and
the
Steels
still
is
pretty
much
kept
to
themselves.
I
saw
Mrs.
Steele
I've
obviously
watched
this
video
numerous
times
so
Mrs
Steele
speaking
with
a
woman
next
to
her
at
one
time,
but
they're
pretty
much
stay
to
themselves.
B
We
didn't
see
nor
well
as
Mr
Peterson
and
Mr
hickey
will
testify.
They
didn't
see
any
sort
of
interaction
or
any
reason
to
say
that
this
event
might
be
foreseeable.
Based
on
what
happened
inside
the
bar
in
the
the
video
for
the
exterior,
it
was
I'm,
sorry,
the
video
and
the
interior.
You
will
see
a
small
Skirmish
that
breaks
out
between
Mr
Fleming
and
one
of
his
friends.
It
seems
like
all
these
people
knew
each
other
Mr
Peterson
got
them
immediately
outside
it
wasn't
Mr
Buckley
and
Mr
Fleming
fighting.
B
It
was
Mr
Fleming
and
another
one
of
his
his
friends.
They
got
him
immediately
outside
at
that
point.
Mr
hickey
Who's,
the
bartender
manager,
said
Mike's,
Oliver
turned
up
the
lights
and
told
everyone.
You
know
finish
your
drinks
and
and
the
evenings
over
the
exterior,
video
and
I
and
I
know
the
stales
are
here,
so
they
can
solve
one
of
the
issues,
but
from
the
exterior
video
you'll
see
people
dispersing
you'll,
see
Mr
Peterson
on
the
exterior
of
the
premises.
Has
people
dispersing
talking
to
people?
B
It's
obvious
that
a
majority
of
these
people
all
knew
each
other.
At
some
point
we
see
some
maybe
comment
between
this
Mr
Fleming
who's,
the
blue
suit,
long
hair
guy
in
the
video,
and
maybe
some
comment
to
Mrs
Steele.
B
Since
we
don't
have
video,
we
don't
don't
know
what
happened.
If
you
watch
a
little
bit
further
you'll
see
that
Mrs,
Steele
and
Mr
Steele
are
discussing
something
at
that
point.
Their
daughter
comes
over
and
also
Mr
Reagan
who's,
the
boyfriend
they
discussed
something
they're
pointing
down
towards
Miha
and
that
Mr
Fleming
is,
is
standing
down
there
and
you
see.
Mr
Reagan
walked
down
towards
Mr
Fleming
shortly
thereafter,
Mrs
Mrs,
Steele
and
Mr
Steele
start
walking
in
that
direction.
B
Mr
Reagan
is
discussing
whatever,
with
with
Mr
Fleming
Mrs
Steele
stands
back.
Mr
Steele
goes
up
to
be
part
of
the
conversation
the
we've
had.
We
couldn't
see
any
any
physical
contact
at
that
point,
but
if
you
watch
Mr
Buckley
leaves
the
front
of
the
premises.
He
was
wearing
his
white
shirt,
but
he
also
at
that
time,
has
a
black
jacket
on
and
walks
down.
North
Market
Street
towards
the
three
of
them
that
are
in
this
discussion.
B
As
he
gets
to
Mr
Steele.
His
arm
comes
out
and
Yanks
Mr
steal
from
behind
violently
to
the
ground.
He
wasn't
part
of
the
altar.
You
know
the
discussion
he's
just
walking
by.
He
obviously
is
a
friend
of
Mr
Fleming,
no
idea
what
would
have
prompted
him
to
take
such
a
violent
action,
but
that
you'll
see
that
from
the
video.
This
all
happened
down
approximately
50
some
odd
yards
from
the
front
of
the
J.J
Donovan,
so
I'd
just
like
to
proceed
now
and
bring
Mr
hickey
on
Madam
chair.
B
If
that's
okay,
so
Chris
hickey,
can
you
just
identify
yourself
to
the
board.
B
Hickey
and
you
were
working
the
evening
of
this
incident-
yes.
B
And-
and
you
were
working
that
evening
the
evening
of
the
incident
where
Mr
Steele
got
attacked.
B
And
so
would
you
describe
it
as
any
other
than
a
the
Skirmish
that
occurred
between
Mr
Fleming
and
some
other
one
of
his
friends?
Were
there
any
other
incidents
or
any
problems
that
evening?
No,
there
were
no.
So
once
did
you
see
the
skirmish.
G
I
did
not
see
what
took
place
inside
the
doors
I
observed
a
bit
of
a
I,
wouldn't
call
it
a
skirmish
a
bit
of
a
episode
taking
place
outside
our
windows,
which
is
when
I
said
enough,
is
enough
for
tonight
and
put
the
lights
up.
That
was
probably
around
12
15.
B
And
when
you
saw
that
Mr
Peterson
was
outside
dealing
with
it,
is
that
correct
that.
B
And
so
the
at
that
point
you
put
the
lights
on.
Tell
people
to
leave.
People
dispersed
correct,
correct,
yes,
sir,
so
did
you
see
anything
I
know
you
reviewed
the
video
and
I
know
you
know
who
Mr
Buckley
is,
but
so
you
were
able
to
figure
out
who
Mr
Fleming
is
and
then
and
who,
who
the
steals
were?
Did
you
see
anything
that
evening
between
Mr
Fleming,
Mr,
Buckley
and
the
Steels
that
would
have
given
you
cause
for
concern
that
an
incident
like
this
could
happen?
B
No
I
did
not
so
you
didn't
see
this
in
any
way
foreseeable.
Absolutely
not!
B
So
let
me
just
go
quickly
to
the
exterior
and
and
I
know
you
weren't,
as
involved
as
Mr
Peterson,
but
so
you're
inside
you
saw
Mr
Peterson,
either
running
or
yelling
towards
how
did
you?
How
did
you
know
something
happened
on
the
exterior
of
the
premises.
G
Right
I
figured
something
was
amiss,
so
I
went
to
make
sure
that
he
was
okay
and
that
there
was,
you
know,
went
to
assist
him
if
he
was
in
need
of
said
assistance.
B
And
so
when,
where
Mr
Peterson
was-
and
you
were,
then
that
was
down
a
little
bit
past,
the
the
beginning
of
the
building
where
Miha
is,
is.
B
Okay,
I
have
nothing
further
for
Mr
Mr
hickey.
If
the
board
wants
to
ask
him
any
questions
or
wants
to
wait
until
we're
finished,
then
whatever
the
pleasure
of
the
board
is.
D
I
just
have
a
couple
questions
just
to
clarify
some
of
the
testimony.
If
you
don't
mind:
Mr
hickey,
how
long
have
you
worked
at
JJ,
Donovan's.
D
And
have
you
worked
with
any
other
establishments
in
Boston.
G
I've
worked
for
Legal
Seafoods
at
that
was
at
Logan,
Airport
and
I.
Currently,
work
for
Summer's
pubs.
G
I
saw
some
I
observed
enough
of
a
of
an
episode
to
warrant
saying
we
don't
need
any
more
type
of
this
behavior
in
or
around
the
establishment
tonight
and
in
so
doing
I
closed
the
bar
for
the
evening
again,
that
was
around
12
15,
12,
20
I
believe.
D
I
D
G
G
The
Blazer
guy,
with
the
long
hair,
okay
and
I,
don't
know
who
the
other
one
was
I
was
inside.
I
observed
this
through
the
window.
This
episode
took
place
outside
the
bar,
but
all.
D
Right
so
just
to
clarify
you
were
inside
the
bar
for
five
years:
I'm,
sorry
Mr.
I
J
E
Video
that
was
provided
by
the
JJ
Donovan
suas
and
Mr
Fleming
was
escalated
out
after
he
put
the
other
kid
in
a
headlock,
and
it
was
a
small
altercation
at
the
bar.
D
Okay,
thank
you
very
much.
D
Years
of
experience
working
here,
five
years
of
experience
and
also
at
Summers,
pubs
and
I,
think
he
said
in
total,
he's
been
in
the
bar
industry
since
1998
when
he
sees
what
he's
describing
as
an
episode
outside
from
a
window,
people
raising
voices.
G
There
was
nothing
to
the
level
that
warranted
contacting
the
police
at
that
time.
G
In
a
violent
situation
that
was
not
a
situation
of
violence,
it
was
it
hadn't
risen
to
the
level
of
problem.
D
Was
there
anything
inside
the
bar
that
you
observed
that
made
you
feel
as
if
it
could
have
been
an
altercation
outside.
H
H
D
Okay,
so
you
only
call
the
police,
when
what
did
you
say
when
it's
violence.
D
D
Level
it
wasn't
foreseeable
that
the
two
guys
outside
raising
their
voices
might
turn
the
raised
voices
to
something
violent.
D
Okay,
commissioner,
commissioner
Saxon
do
you
have
any
questions?
I
know
we
haven't
had
a
chance
to
review
the
video,
but
based
upon
the
testimony
so
far,.
K
I
have
a
couple
questions
for
for
the
bartender
here
the
so
you
said
that
when
you
observed
the
the
incident,
we'll
call
it,
you
decided
that
that
was
enough
and
that
you
were
gonna
close
the
bar
for
the
night
correct,
that's
right!
Okay,
and
you
did
that
by
and
you
indicated,
the
bar
was
closing
by
flashing
the
lights,
correct.
G
No,
that's
not
correct.
Okay
I
indicated
that
if
the
bar
was
closing
by
turning
up
the
lights,
turning
off
the
lights,
okay,
flashing,
the
lights
would
indicate
that
it
was
last
call
okay,
so
I
turn
the
lights
up
entirely
and
tell
everyone
to.
G
K
B
Think
that
was
a
problem
with
the
video
commissioner
Curran,
not
not
the
lights
flashing.
K
Okay,
I'll
I'll
take
another
look
at
that:
yeah.
K
That's
all
I
have
for
right
now.
Thank
you.
L
Mean
I
guess
I'll
have
to
watch
the
video,
but
what
is
the
the
time
difference
between
when
the
incident
happened
inside
and
when
the
incident
happened
outside
the?
What
is
the
the
length
of
time.
B
B
He
has
a
far
greater
knowledge
of
of
what
happened.
If
you,
when
you,
when
you
see
the
video
the
Skirmish
inside
when
I
say,
lasted
10
to
15
seconds.
B
Maybe
if
that
Mr
Fleming
something
happened,
something
his
friend
said
something
to
him,
and
he
violently
I
mean
he
reacted
immediately,
grabbed
him
in
a
headlock
at
that
point,
Mr
Peterson
he
started
moving
him
in
then
you
go
to
the
exterior
video
and
you
see
Mr
Peterson
outside
with
the
two
of
them
and
Mr
Peterson
will
testify
that
he
felt
the
incident
and
the
the
only
individual,
That
Was
Then
involved
again
with
the
later
on
with
these
steals
is
Mr
Fleming.
B
B
We
don't
know
specifically
other
than
other
than
you
see
them
chatting
it
up
and-
and
you
see
that
this
other
individual
getting
his
phone
and
showing
Mr
Fleming
and
Mr
Buckley
some
stuff
from
his
phone,
and
they
seem
to
when
you,
commissioner,
Kern.
When
you
see
a
lot
of
these
people
dispersing
at
the
end,
they
all
seem
to
know
each
other.
B
So
you
know
they.
They
are
friends,
they
could
be
bar
friends
as
opposed
to
yeah.
K
K
B
Okay,
Mr
Peterson
you're
there.
N
I
B
And
so
you've
heard
some
of
what
has
gone
on
and
the
questions
Mr
Peterson.
How
long
have
you
worked
as
a
doorman.
N
B
And
so
I'll
ask
the
question
before
Madam
chair
asks
you
the
question
where,
where
else
have
you
worked.
N
In
the
city
of
Boston,
I've
worked
as
a
concessions
manager
for
Aramark
assembly.
Park
I've
worked
as
a
sous
chef
at
the
TD
Garden
I,
currently
work
as
a
food
and
beverage
manager
for
Boston,
Harbor,
City
cruises
and
other
places
in
Somerville
Cambridge
as
well.
B
Yeah,
and
so
you
got
involved
with
Mr
Fleming
and
this
other
individual
once
Mr
Fleming,
you
know
grabbed
him
and
tried
to
put
them
in
a
headlock
and
you
got
them
outside.
N
Yes,
as
soon
as
I
seen
it
out
of
the
corner
of
my
eye
that
happened,
they
were
already,
their
momentum,
was
bringing
them
in
my
direction
at
the
door
and
I
we
got
I
got
them
out
and
then
I
attempted
to
separate
them
at
the
time.
I
actually
had
fallen
to
the
ground,
but
it
it
was
more
of
a
like
a
grappling
match,
I
wouldn't
say
I
think
there
were
some,
maybe
sort
of
my
best
recollection
I
there
may
have
been
it
was.
It
was
just
a
grappling
match
in
there.
N
D
N
B
B
And
then
it
wasn't
too
much
you've
dealt
with
them
outside
and
at
that
point
you
separated
them
and
tell
them
that
the
evening
was
over
for
them
and
to
leave.
Yes.
Is
that
correct?
Why
didn't
you
call
the
police.
C
N
B
Okay,
did
you
see
any
other
problems
or
whatever
that
evening,
other
than
that
incident.
B
In
so,
I
won't
go
through
what
I
went
through
with
Mr
hickey
on
on
the
interior
lead,
but
so
Mr
hickey
decides
that
the
evenings
over
turns
the
lights
up
early
and
people
start
dispersing
for
the
most
part.
Were
you
on
the
exterior
of
the
premises.
N
At
that
point,
I
was
about
that
original
incident
when
the
momentum
brought
them
towards
me.
I
was
directly
at
the
doorway.
B
All
right
so
when,
when
the
lights
went
up-
and
it
was
time
for
people
to
leave,
you
stayed
mostly
on
the
exterior
of
the
premises
while
people
were
leaving.
Is
that
correct,
I.
N
B
And
and
you
you
stayed
out
there
for
quite
a
while.
Is
that
correct.
N
Yes,
just
popping
back
in
from
time
to
time
right
in
the
doorway.
Basically.
B
And
and
so
another
video
I'll
show
this
Madam
chair
and
Commissioners.
So
if
you
were
at
some
point,
looking
down
towards
mija
and-
and
you
saw
miss
this
deal,
get
yanked
to
the
ground.
Is
that
correct.
N
N
I
immediately
ran
down
that.
B
Pretty
much
full
speed,
correct,
yes
and
Mr.
Steele
is
on
the
ground.
I
N
At
that
point,
I
believe
there
was
a
bystander
already
on
on
the
line
with
the
police.
I
did
have
my
phone
out,
I
believe
Mr
Hagee
did
as
well,
and
one
of
the
victims
I
think
Reagan
was
his
name
was
already
on
the
line.
I
I
at
that
point,
I
didn't
think
in
my
opinion,
that
it
was
needed
to
flood
the
lines
of
the
police
so.
B
You
can
call
the
police,
because
either
one
of
two
people
were
already
either
speaking
to
the
police
or
trying
to
reach
the
police.
Is
that
correct,
correct?
And
so
now
did
you
assist
the
police
in
any
way
in
finding
the
way
to
to
Mr
Steele
I.
N
Did
I
I
went
back
to
the
bar
because
they
were
the
police.
Cruisers
were
passing
on
the
on
the
Clinton
Street
side
in
the
opposite
direction
of
traffic,
so
I
went
through
the
bug
to
the
back
door
and
I
had
my
phone
out
flashlight
on
to
waved
them
down
in
the
first
officer
in
the
first
officers
that
arrived,
we
ran
through
the
the
tunnel
in
between
the
bar
and
I
think
the
gift
shop
there
back
towards
the
scene.
B
B
Did
you
do?
Did
you
assist
for
the
EMTs
also.
N
B
Did-
and
they
were,
they
were
also
on
Clinton,
Street
and.
N
We
I
I
me
and
Mr
hickey
allowed
them
to
pass
through
the
bar,
as
it
was
easier
access
to
them
and
it
was
faster
for
them
to
get
to
Mr
Steele.
Instead
of
having
to
go
around
around
the
entire
Daniel
Hall
area.
B
Okay,
so
while
your
patrons
were
dispersing-
and
you
were
on
the
exterior
of
the
premises,
did
you
have
any
indication
that
there
was
going
to
be
a
confrontation
between
Mr
Fleming
and
then
Mr,
Reagan
and
Mr
Steele.
B
Not
do
you
have
any
indication
that
Mr
Buckley
somehow
was
going
to
insert
himself
into
this
group.
N
B
You
were
standing
on
the
exterior
and
you
watched
Mr
rake
and
walk
down
towards
Miha,
slowly
towards
Mr,
Fleming,
yes
and
then
so
Mr
and
Mrs
Buckley
kind
of
follow
him
slowly
where
I'm,
I'm,
sorry,
Mr,
Mrs,
Steele,
slowly,
walk
down
towards
Mr,
Fleming
and
then
Mr
Steele
joining
the
conversation
with
Mr,
Reagan
and
Mr
Buckley.
Is
that
correct
yeah?
B
They
oh
Mr,
Fleming,
I'm,
sorry,
Mr,
Fleming,
Mr,
Reagan
and
Mr
Steele,
the
conversation
yeah
and
and
you
witness
then
Mr
Buckley
coming
up
from
behind
walking
from
the
front
of
the
bar
walking
come
from
behind
and
that's
when
you,
you
saw
Mr
Steele,
get
yanked
to
the
ground
and
that's
when
you
took
action.
M
B
I
mean
I
I
have
nothing
else.
Once
again,
you.
I
B
I
need
to
use
the
term
but
a
picture's
worth
a
thousand
words
and
I,
and
it
suggest
that
the
boy
review
the
videos
that
we
provided.
A
Thank
you
attorney,
Miller,
chairman
Joyce.
Do
you
have
any
questions
for
this
witness
before
we
move
on
to
the
victim
who's?
Also
with
us
this
morning,
I.
D
Do
unfortunately,
I
didn't
have
a
chance
to
review
the
videos
we
received
innocently
tonight
last
night,
so
unfortunately,
I
am
not
informed
as
I
chair
this
hearing
today,
so
Mr
Peterson.
There
was
what
you
called
a
wrestling
match
outside
we
broke
them
up.
They
dispersed
again
not
being
familiar
with
the
video
and
just
reading
through
the
police
report
repeatedly
and
trying
to
understand
who
the
parties
are.
When
you
broke
up
the
wrestling
match,
you
went
out
inside
a
couple
of
times
just
to
check
on
things.
D
O
N
Were
right
there,
they
were
out
there
for
about
maybe
four
or
five
minutes.
There
was
a
shouting
match.
They
both
actually
seemed
apologetic
that
had
happened.
I
then
told
Mr
Fleming
that
the
male
and
the
for
the
length
there
I
told
him
he's
he
has
to
leave.
He
attempted
to
come
back
in
I,
told
him
he
had
to
leave
because
the
incident
and
they
were
out
there.
My
the
friends
of
who
was
involved
with
Mr
Fleming
I,
explained
to
him.
You
need
to
leave
I
told
them.
N
They
both
need
to
leave
one
once
towards
the
the
friend
went
towards
well
Mr
Fleming
once
was
mija
and
the
other
friend
went
in
the
opposite
direction.
D
K
K
Of
them,
okay,
all
right,
so
my
next
question
is
they
get
into
that
you
know
Skirmish
or
whatever
you
you
you're
drawn
outside
with
them
and
I
see
all
that
you
stumbled.
Did
you
fall
all
the
way
down?
I'm
sorry,
I
can't
I.
K
And
then
you
you
got
them
apart.
Mr
Fleming
comes
back
in
the
bar
momentarily,
like
you
testified,
and
then
you
get
him
back
out
right
that
moment.
Mr
Fleming
goes
back
after
that.
Guy
again
right.
N
P
K
N
K
K
Yeah
he
he
gets
the
first
time
he
tries
to
headlock
and
they
go
outside
right.
He
comes
back
in
and
you
put
you
put
him
back
out
on
the
street
and
he
goes
after
him
with
a
with
a
flying
chick
right.
That's
the
second
time,
third
time
he
goes
after
him
again
he's
throwing
his
cigarette
at
him
and
then
the
fourth
time
he
chases
him
off.
Camera,
correct,
yes,
okay
and
we
still
haven't
called
the
police.
Yet.
N
No
I
it
was,
it
was
all
relatively
quick
in
the
in
the
moment.
I
I.
K
I
think
the
video
clearly
shows
it's
more
than
a
well
more
than
a
minute,
so
I
mean
I'll
rely
on
the
counter
on
on
the
video
here,
but
the
next
thing
I
wanted
to
get
to
is
when
I'm
watching
the
video
when
Fleming
is
down
by
mija,
he
appears
to
be
drawing
some
attention.
K
N
N
He
wasn't
alone
at
the
the
corner
of
the
miha's
patio
and.
P
K
G
K
N
So
Mr
Reagan
I
believe
I
believe
his
name
is
I,
I,
think
I
I
I'm,
not
too
sure,
but
I
think
there
was
something
said
from
Mr
Fleming
to
either
the
stales
or
Mr
Reagan
and
Mr.
Reagan
then
said:
I'm,
not
gonna.
Let
him
get
away
with
that
and
he
walked
towards
Mr
Fleming.
K
Okay,
because
I'm
watching
the
video
I'm
I'm,
not
I'm,
not
seeing
it
so
yeah,
I'm
gonna,
wait
until
I
hear
from
the
I
guess
the
victims
group
here
so
I
think
that's
all
I
have
at
the
moment.
Thank
you.
I.
L
I
mean
I
think
after
the
the
victims
speaks,
there
may
be
some
more
questions,
but
for
now
for
attorney,
Miller
I
just
make
sure
we
address.
If
there
are
any
changes
going
forward
in
your
practices,
policies
procedures
as
far
as
dispersal
and
keeping
Patron
safe.
L
Changes
in
policies
and
procedures
I
was
asking
if,
if
after
the
victim
has
had
enough,
speak,
whether
you
can
speak
to
any
changes
in
the
policies,
practices
or
procedures.
As
far
as
dispersal
and
keeping
patrons
safe.
B
B
The
thought
of
the
fact
of,
rather
than
them,
dealing
with
issues
like
this
that
just
call
the
police
rather
than
just
while
they
you
know,
realize
that
all
these
people
seem
to
be
friendly.
That
night,
rather
than
dealing
with
Mr,
Fleming
and
and
the
unknown
person
that
they
should
should
should
just
call
the
police
and
not
deal
with
it
themselves.
She
just
reinterated
that
I
do
have
a
copy
of
the
of
their
rules,
which
I
can
provide
to
the
board.
D
Do
I
have
some
more
questions,
Mr
hickey?
What
was
how
many
people
were
in
there
that
night
was
it
a
busy
night?
Was
it
crowded,
What's,
Your
Capacity,
and
how
full
were
you.
D
What's
your
capacity
45.,
okay,
so
Mr,
hickey
or
Mr
Peterson
was
Mr
Fleming
a
regular.
G
N
D
G
D
Okay,
those
are
all
my
questions.
A
A
Q
With
the
fight
I,
I
didn't
see,
it
happen
in
the
bar,
because
we
were
on
the
other
side.
Maybe
it
was
on
the
other
side,
but
I
do
do
remember,
seeing
quite
clearly
Mr
Fleming
beating
somebody
up
in
a
sweatshirt
outside
the
box.
I
was
near
the
window
side
of
the
bar
and
that
and
then
Mr
Fleming
came
back
into
the
bar.
The
person
who
was
beating
up
bran
and
slug
down
his
shrink
and
the
bartender.
Q
In
this
statement
it
it
had
said
that
the
officers
were
responding
to
two
people.
Fighting
outside
Gary
was
never
fighting
so
I,
don't
know
why
that
was
written
in
there
and
his
birthday
is
also
wrong.
It's
3,
15
54.
A
Thank
you
for
that.
Those
points
of
clarification
and
thank
you
again
for
being
with
us
turn
it
back
to
the
board
to
see
if
there
are
any
remaining
questions
for
the
licensee
for
the
victim
or
family.
Q
A
I
think
I
see
Ashley
on
here.
Ms
Steele
was
there
any
testimony
you
wish
to
provide
the
board
as
well
about
the
incident
and
first
have
you
been
sworn
in
I.
A
A
Thank
you,
and
is
there
any
conditional
testimony
about
the
incident
you
would
like
to
provide
to
help
inform
the
board.
P
A
You
Miss
deal
so
commissioner
Krishna
Saxon.
Do
you
have
any
further
questions
for
any
of
the
witnesses
who
testified
this
morning.
I
L
Saxon
anything
further
I
wish
you
the
best
in
your
in
your
healing
process,
but
but
were
there
any
words
exchanged?
Did
you
talk.
K
I
Q
Miss
Mr
Buckley
after
the
incident
and
I
was
my
daughter,
was
holding
her
dad's
neck
and
I
was
trying
to
put
my
hand
on
his
wound,
came
up
to
me
and
took
off
his
coat.
He
had
a
black
coat
on
and
put
it
underneath
his
head
and
said:
I'm
sorry
I
didn't
mean
to
do
that.
I
thought
he
was
going
to
fight
my
friend.
K
Yeah
I
mean
you:
can
you
can
clearly
see
what
he
does
on
the
video
I'm?
Really
sorry
that
happened
to
you,
I
I,
don't
know
if
I've
made
any
more
sense,
I
watched
the
video
earlier
and
I
don't
know
if
I
made
much
more
sense
of
it
right
now
than
I
did
when
I
first
watched
it
so
I'm.
Sorry
about
that,
but
thank
you
for
joining
us.
B
Excuse
me,
Madam,
chair,
could
attorney
Floyd
asked
Mr
Mrs
Steele
a
question.
I
B
M
Good
morning
Mr
Steele,
my
name
is
Michael
Floyd,
one
of
the
attorneys
for
the
for
J.J
Donovan's,
it's
fair
to
say
he
had
no
interaction
with
Mr,
Fleming
or
Mr
Buckley
inside
the
bar
correct,
correct.
I
M
This
these
questions,
if
you
Mr
Mr
Steele
and
when
you
came
outside,
you
were
sort
of
lingering
out
front,
correct
right
exactly
and,
as
you
were
lingering
outside
at
some
point,
did
you
have
any
words
with
anyone
out
front?
No,
not
at
all.
Okay,
he
didn't
talk
to
anyone.
Then
you
know
who
Mr
Fleming
is
correct.
M
R
M
M
M
Q
P
I,
don't
know,
Tom
runs
it.
It
was
the
residence.
M
M
Okay
and
as
you
walked
up
as
you
walked
up
there,
that
was
about
50
yards
away
from
JJ
Donovan's,
correct.
Yes,
and
did
you
have
any
words
with
a
gentleman
wearing
a
blue
blazer
and
long
hair,
not.
R
M
N
M
R
I
A
A
S
Morning,
Madam
chairman
members
of
the
board
Trish
Malone
for
Oakland
Old,
Colonial
Corporation,
doing
business
as
a
bell
in
hand
with
me
today.
I
do
have
I'm
the
manager
Hector
Moretz,
who
was
actually
on
the
premises
that
evening.
A
A
Yourself,
Cliff.
A
Thank
you
all
right.
Do
you
sort
of
tell
the
truth,
the
whole
truth
and
nothing
but
the
truth
yeah?
Thank
you,
Sergeant
mccasek.
You
can
please
proceed
with
the
police
report.
T
About
0-159
hours
on
Saturday,
October,
8th,
2022
officers,
Giblin
and
Scott,
assigned
to
the
alpha
103
Alpha
responded
to
a
radio
call
for
an
assault
and
battery.
At
the
bell
in
hand,
Tavern
45,
Union,
Street
Boston
operations
delayed
that
management
reported
an
assault
and
battery
occurred
between
two
patrons
upon
arrival.
Officers
were
directed
Inside
by
an
employee
and
met
the
victim
identified
as
George
Junta.
He
stated
that
he
was
on
the
second
floor
of
the
tavern
when
he
observed
a
female
who
he
was
with
being
spoken
to
by
a
black
male.
T
He
stated
that
he
believed
that
the
male
suspect
acting
in
an
aggressive
manner
towards
his
female
friend,
and
he
stood
to
the
male
that
he
needed
to
leave
her
alone.
He
stated
that
at
that,
at
that
point
the
male
suspect
then
attacked
him
striking
him
in
the
face
causing
a
laceration
underneath
his
right
eye
and
significant
bruising
to
his
forehead
officers
observed
the
victim's
injuries
in
Boston.
Ems
was
dispatched
to
the
scene.
The
victim's
t-shirt
was
also
torn.
T
The
victim
stated
that
he
could
not
accurately
provide
description
of
the
suspect
and
did
not
know
where
he
went
after
the
employees
removed
him
from
The
Tavern
officer.
Giblin
spoke
with
the
manager
Hector
huertas
and
observed
on
the
tavern
security
camera.
The
assault
occurred
occurred
at
0-148
hours.
T
Officers
notified
the
alpha
914
Sergeant,
the
guys
that
who
arrived
and
conducted
a
1235
licensed
premise
check:
number
zero,
two:
two:
no
zero,
zero,
two
six
six
one,
seven
Boston
EMS
arrived
and
provided
initial
Medical
Aid
to
the
victim,
but
the
victims
refused
to
be
transported
to
a
hospital
stating
he
would
do
so
on
his
own.
That
is
the
end
of
the
narrative
section
of
the
police
report.
S
Yes,
Sergeant,
you
don't
have
any
direct
knowledge
of
what
happened.
Is
that
correct.
F
F
F
What
it
looked
like,
maybe
like
30
seconds
before
the
victim
walked
up
to
him
said
some
words,
not
sure
it
was
said,
and
then
the
suspect
started
striking
the
victim
multiple
times
in
the
face
security
immediately
went
to
break
it
up,
got
the
suspect
to
walk
down
the
stairs
and
then
out
the
building
as
manager.
Cliff
Anderson
was
calling
9-1-1.
Okay.
S
The
time
okay,
so
you
actually
questioned
by
any
Boston
police
officer.
F
I
S
So
is
it
fair
to
say
that
that
what
you
said
in
the
video
both
showed
the
same
exact
things
that
was
is
there
was
consistency
between
what
you
said
and
what
actually
the
video
showed?
S
Yes,
okay,
so,
in
your
mind,
was
this
something
that
the
bars
are
as
spontaneous
or
unforeseeable
incident.
F
S
Okay
and
what
time
on
the
second
floor
do
does
last
call
occur.
F
Last
call
occurs
at
140
bites
turn
on
at
145
When,
the
Music
Stops.
S
F
S
Okay,
and
do
you
recall
Weller,
not
he
was
actually
transported
by
EMS,
or
was
he
just
treated
at
the
scene.
S
Okay,
so,
and
has
he
ever
caused
any
type
of
incident
on
the
licensed
premises
previously?
No,
okay.
So
what
would?
What
is
the
boards?
What
is
the
licensees
policy
with
regard
to
a
suspect
who
is
recognized?
Let's
say
he
wants
to
come
into
Saturday
night
and
go
to
the
second
floor.
What
what
would
be
you
know
what
their
staff
is
told
with
regard
to
someone
has
who
has
already
caused
kind
of
a
previous
incident,
so
to
speak.
F
S
Okay,
I
have
no
further
questions
here.
I
know
that
there
is
a
Mr
Cliff
Anderson,
who
is
an
employee
of
the
premises.
I,
don't
think
at
this
time.
I
need
his
testimony.
S
But
but
again
that's
that's
my
opinion.
I
leave
you
to
the
board
foreign.
K
F
Generally,
yes,
we
do,
but
because
of
how
aggressive
he
was
at
that
time,
I
wouldn't
want
anyone
else
to
get
hurt
and
we
obviously
cannot
restrain
anyone.
So
if
he
wasn't
really
talking
to
us,
we
can't
try
to
force
him
to.
I
A
A
W
Okay,
I'm,
referring
to
the
Boston
police
report
about
105
a.m.
On
Sunday
November
13
2022
offices
responded
to
a
radio
call
for
an
assault
and
battery
at
Empire
one
Marina
Park
Drive
in
South
Boston.
Upon
arrival,
they
spoke
to
wanderson
Santos,
he's
a
security
person
at
Empire
who
stated
that
he
saw
a
meal.
He
knew
is
Paul
pacheo
punched,
an
unknown
female
and
attempted
to
break
it
up,
as
Santos
attempted
to
break
up
the
fight,
an
unknown
meal,
mistook
Santos
for
pacheo
and
punched
him
in
the
lift.
W
Both
men
took
off
after
the
incident.
The
manager
John
farther
Guild
placed
the
9-1-1
call.
Officers
asked
Santos
if
he
was
in
need
of
EMS.
He
declined.
Thank
you.
I
arrived
on
scene
inside
of
them
for
assault
and
battery
patreon
unemployed.
V
V
You
very
much
Madam
chair
members
of
the
board.
If
you
haven't
received
it
yet
you
will
shortly
the
video
footage.
That's
very
clear
from
this
incident
from
our
compliance
specialist
Jillian
King,
along
with
a
breakdown
of
the
seconds,
really
that
this
occurred
in
pointing
out
the
folks
that
were
involved
in
this
minor
altercation.
What
you'll
see
from
this
video
is
at
approximately
26
seconds
into
the
footage.
V
A
blonde
female
can
be
observed,
standing
behind
the
stanchions
that
are
set
up
next
to
the
main
bar
you'll,
see
from
the
video
that
she
appears
to
have
a
phone
in
her
hand.
Just
that's
a
point
to
point
out,
because
it's
easy
to
identify
or
in
the
video
she
attempts
to
walk
through
guests
and
bumps
into
a
bald
white
male
Patron
who's
later
identified
as
Paul
paccio
who's
mentioned
in
the
police
report.
V
V
Approximately
52
seconds
into
the
video
footage.
A
male
who
we
later
found
out
was
the
blonde
female's
boyfriend
pushes
Mr
pachio
security
officer,
Santos
and
immediately
steps
between
the
parties
and
gets
punched
in
the
face
by
the
boyfriend,
which
is
approximately
the
one
minute
time
Mark.
So,
as
indicated
on
the
video
time
stamp
from
start
to
finish,
this
entire
encounter
happens
without
warning
within
a
little
over
30
seconds.
It's
it
starts
and
stops.
Parties
are
escorted
out
of
the
venue.
Police
are
called
by
manager.
V
Ryan
Tobin
excuse
me,
who
also
then
called
director
of
security,
Charlie
Kane
who's
on
the
call
with
us
today.
Immediately
thereafter,
while
waiting
for
the
police
to
arrive,
Live
security
manager,
John
father
Gill
who's
mentioned
in
the
report,
spoke
with
the
female's
boyfriend.
Who
said
he
did
not
realize
the
security
officer
Santos
was
employed
by
the
licensed
premises
and
was
trying
to
help
he
was
refusing
to
provide
ID,
and
the
couple
left
before
BPD
arrived
at
approximately
1
15..
V
There
is
no
issue
with
patrons
prior
to
this
incident
that
evening
it
was
regular
Saturday
night.
They
were
not
at
capacity
there's,
no
interaction,
otherwise,
with
any
patrons
or
patrons
with
employees
leading
up
to
what
can
be
observed
on
the
video
that
would
leave
staff
to
believe
that
this
event
or
any
minor
altercation
was
foreseeable.
The
staff
did
immediately
act
appropriately
in
this
situation,
escorted
patrons
that
were
involved
outside
in
public
police.
V
With
that
being
said,
Charlie
Kane,
if
you'd
like
to
add
anything
I
know
you
showed
up
shortly
after
the
incident
occurred.
Please
feel
free
to
do
so
as
well.
V
J
Oh
I
apologize,
no
just
that
all
the
policies
were
followed
when
I
got
there.
I
talked
to
detective
sergeant
donlin
and
to
my
security
officer
who
didn't
want
to
press
charges.
The
couple
took
off
Northern
Ave
towards
Ocean
Prime,
and
we
have
a
policy
on
minor
incidents
to
not
Chase
patrons
down
the
street,
because
we'd
be
liable
if
they
were
to
get
hit
by
a
vehicle
or
something
along
those
lines.
J
So
the
door
offices,
let
them
walk
away
as
they
ran
down
towards
us
from
Prime,
and
they
were
away
from
the
area
when
Boston
got
there.
J
A
Thank
you,
Mr
King
and
I
will
note
that
I
did
receive
the
video
during
this
hearing.
I'll
share
it
with
the
Commissioners
as
soon
as
we
adjourn
anything
further
attorney
Scanlon
before
we
go
to
questions
nothing.
A
A
I
A
X
On
October,
2nd
2022
we're
both
402
am
was
a
Sunday
morning
officer
kimieo
in
the
Bravo
416,
which
is
Bravo's
Roxbury
District
responded
to
a
radio
call
for
an
EMB
report
at
34
Pontiac
Street
in
Roxbury.
Upon
arrival,
the
office
spoke
to
with
the
victim
later
identified,
as
ritish
kataya,
who
said
he
was
inside
the
soldier,
Baba
1265,
Boylston,
Street
and
I
know
males
shoved
him
inside
the
bar.
A
Headlock
and
slammed
him
into
the
ground,
the
victim
say
the
suspect
came
up
to
him
from
behind
the
officer
asked
the
victim.
If
you
like
EMS,
he
stated
no,
the
victim
is
not
able
to
provide
officer
a
description
of
the
suspect.
The
victim
stated
that
the
biohaze
video
came
as
the
incidents
should
be
recorded.
The
victim's
girlfriend
stated
that
she
observed
the
email
wearing
an
off-white
sweatshirt,
and
she
believed
that
he
was
the
suspect
and
was
attending
a
birthday
party
inside.
A
Thank
you
and
we
do
have
a
supplemental
as
well,
which
is
just
yes
on.
X
October
12th
myself
and
other
detectives
went
to
Sergey
Baba
issued
a
license
performance
violation,
026-429
for
her
assault
and
battery
Patron
on
Patron
The.
C
U
I'd
like
to
ask
a
detective
a
few
questions:
if
you
don't
mind
detective,
will
you
at
the
the
scene
of
the
accident?
No,
you
said
okay
and
when
you
arrive
to
sojaba,
was
our
staff
Cooperative?
Yes,
okay!
U
So
to
give
you
a
story
around
12
30
I
got
a
one
of
my
staff.
Members
came
up
to
me
and
told
me
about
a
incident.
Mr
mapeo
was
apparently
harassing
another
table
next
to
him
when
I
got
there,
one
of
my
staff
was
already
there
at
that
location
and
actually
has
asked
a
friend,
because
my
our
policy
made
sure
our
staff
doesn't
put
their
hands
on
any
of
the
patients
or
any
of
the
customers.
I
asked
their
friends.
U
Can
you
please
make
sure
that
Mr
Mateo
does
not
Approach
at
the
table,
because
he
was
the
person
instigating
the
argument
and
all
of
a
sudden
this
happened
within
literally
about
10
to
15
seconds.
He
decided
Mr
Potato
decide
to
grab
another
customer
next
next
to
him
by
his
shirt
or
throw,
and
then
from
that
point
on
they
were
pushing
each
other,
and
this
incident
literally
lasts
about
really
10-15
seconds.
Our
staff
and
I
we
were
able
to
split
these
two
parties
up
and
we
asked
Mr
Mateo
and
his
friends.
U
Do
me
a
favor,
please?
If
you
can
leave
the
premise
and
I
have
the
other
parties
sending
it
this
other.
You
know
in
a
restaurant,
so
I
mean
they
were.
U
They
were
asked
to
leave
they
left
and
then,
when
the
we
we
had
to
take
the
come
down
to
Soldier
bar
and
I,
see
the
footage
of
the
camera
we
showed
them.
The
gentleman
that
was
instigating
if
I
was
Mr
Mateo
is
was
walking
with
his
friends
and
he
was
trying
to
come
back
to
instigate
further
argument
and
we
were
able
to
separate
them.
They
were
outside
and
they
dispersed.
While
they
were
outside.
We
kept
the
other
party
in
to
make
sure
it
doesn't
escalate
to
be
any
bigger,
but
yeah.
U
U
D
U
We,
the
incident,
happened
around
12
30.
We
closed
at
two
o'clock,
I,
don't
know
what
happened
from
the
time
that
he
left.
U
He
left
around
12
45,
which
I
showed
the
footage
to
the
detective
of
him,
leaving
around
that
time
frame
and
then,
after
that,
from
12
45
around
one
o'clock,
I,
don't
know
what
happened
around
four,
maybe
him
and
his
girlfriend
was
upset
because
we
had
to
escort
them,
but
we
had
to
have
them
leave
the
premise:
I
I
personally,
don't
know
what
happened
from
that
point
now
from
one
o'clock
to
four
o'clock,
but
I
do
want
to
mention
I've
been
in
Fenway
for
five
years,
and
this
is
I
think
the
first
incident
that
ever
happened
with
with
any
type
of
arguments
or
patient
Patron
any
type
of
way.
H
C
U
I
I
share
the
video
with
the
detective
ready
of
the
gentleman
leaving
and
with
his
friends
and
him
trying
to
come
back
in
and
and
his
friends
are,
the
one
that
that
kind
of
pushed
them
out
say
you
need
to
go
home
and
the
friend
came
out
to
us
telling
us
he's
apologizing
for
his
friend,
and
it
was
it
was.
It
was
done
with
that.
It
was
pretty.
It
was
pretty
quick
and
pretty
fast.
D
Okay,
thank
you.
I,
don't
have
any
other
questions.
U
U
We
were
able
to
de-escalate
the
situation
really
really
fast,
and
then
we
asked
the
the
friend
and
and
him,
if
you
can,
please
leave
the
premise
then,
and
they
they
walked
out
by
themselves
and,
as
we
show
the
detective,
the
video
showing
that
the
the
gentleman
was
walking
out,
he
was
trying
to
come
back
in
to
kind
of
ask
the
decision.
If
we
were
as
his
friend,
it
was
actually
the
one
that
kind
of
pushed
them
to.
C
U
Hey,
listen
that
you
know
it
was
done.
They
walked
out.
They
were
out
there
for
probably
about
say:
I,
don't
know
five
to
ten
minutes.
They
they
dispersed,
and
then
that
was
the
time
that
you
know
we.
We
could
we
told
them
if
you
like,
to
leave
the
other
group,
and
they
said
you
know,
so
it
was
done
with
that.
U
No,
no
I
just
saw
the
police
report
so
I'm,
assuming
he's
the
person
that
that
called
the
police
reports
I'm
just
assuming
as
Mrs
Mateo.
U
Q
U
Only
people
that
was
involved
in
the
in
somewhat
of
a
someone
that
was
actually
you
know
instigating
the
argument.
K
A
Items
five
and
six
concern
the
same
licensee
on
the
same
data
they
stem
from
the
same
incident
Madam
chair.
Would
you
like
to
take
these
two
items
together?
Yes,.
D
A
Can
I
read
into
the
record
items
five
and
six
paga
Inc
doing
business
as
NYX
venue
located
at
100,
Warrington
Street
end
of
the
incident
October
28
2022
item
five
is
failure
to
ID
patrons
properly?
It
was
a
Colombian
license
in
violation
of
Master
number
was
chapter
138,
section
64
and
item
six
person
under
21
in
possession
of
alcohol
on
premise,
in
violation
of
mass
in
realize
chapter
138,
section
34A,
34C
and
64-64a,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
Y
Y
A
few
women
enjoyed
vaccine
and
current
and
executive
secretary
green
Mark
of
liotti's
for
paga
Inc
today,
I
have
with
me
through
Oak
Reza,
who
is
the
director
of
operations
there
and
Billy
Robinson?
Who
is
the
manager
of
record.
A
A
A
You
I
know
there
are
a
number
of
reports
for
these
two
items
so
sort
of
Gallagher.
Will
you
be
reading
to
begin
with
sure.
AB
Is
this
the
the
affiliate
property
ID
yeah.
AB
On
10
28
2022
at
11,
40
p.m,
Sergeant
check
the
William
Gallagher
detective
Eddie
Hernandez
signed
for
the
license
premise
unit
conducted
a
license:
premise:
inspection
club
venue
at
100,
Warrington,
Street,
side
of
the
club
detectives
conserved,
a
young
looking
female
at
the
bar
ordering
alcohol
thinking
that
the
female
was
under
21
years
of
age.
Detectives
approached
identified
themselves
as
BPD
and
ask
for
identification
being.
It
was
only
able
to
provide
a
Colombian
driver's
license
in
her
name
with
a
date
of
birth.
AB
Of
five
two
of
2000
being
the
most
identified
is
Victoria
C
Fernandez
and
she
was
from
Boston
University
and
I
asked
how
she
gained
entrance
at
the
venue
with
no
passport
Ms
Fernandez
replied
that
she
always
uses
her
Colombian
license
to
get
into
the
venue
and
never
carry
his
her
passport
detectives
and
spoke
venue
manager.
Cheryl
present
informing
him
that
all
Internationals
must
present
a
valid
gospel
to
enter
and
purchase
alcohol.
Mr
Reza
stated
that
he
would
speak
to
the
door
staff
as
a
result.
What
detectives
have
observed?
AB
A
Thank
you,
and
can
we
please
proceed
with
the
additional
reports
for
violation,
058992,
Eddie.
AA
AB
AB
11
3
20,
22,
11,
15
p.m.
Sergeant
Galaxy,
Hernandez
assigned
a
license.
Criminal
student
responded
at
the
club
menu
100
Warrington
Street
issued
licensed
premise:
inspection
notice,
number,
zero,
five,
eight,
nine
nine
two,
the
club
venue
for
persons
under
21
possession
of
alcohol
on
premise
date
of
the
offense
was
actually
10,
28
20,
22,
11
40
p.m.
The
underage
Patron
initially
told
detectives
the
club
Personnel
that
she
was
old
but
21
years
of
age,
further
investigation
showed
the
Patriots
was
identified
as
Victoria
C
Fernandez
was
20
years
of
age.
AB
Mr
shrope
has
assigned
for
and
accept
the
notice.
Miss
Fernandez
will
be
summoned
into
court
for
being
a
person,
another
21
possession
of
alcoholic
possession
at
a
fraudulent
ID.
This
piggybacks
the
first
report
we
did
our
due
diligence
detective
Hernandez
was
able
to
confirm
that
this
woman
was
actually
under
21
in
the
ID
that
she
attended
to
West
bus
projects.
A
Thank
you
and
we
we
have
a
supplemental
here
as
well
that
states
those
facts.
I,
don't
know
if
you
have
that
in
front
of
you
as
well.
AB
Yes,
I
do
look
forward
to
it.
After
further
information,
protective
was
able
to
confirm
the
true
identity
of
the
involved.
Patron
Miss
Victoria
Fernandez
used
a
fraudulent
Columbia
driver's
license
and
also
a
fraudulent
Colombian
identification
card.
That
stated
here.
Date
of
birth
was
two
five.
Two
thousand
it
was
revealed
that
a
true
date
of
birth
is
2
5
2002.
As
a
result,
what
detectives
have
discovered
Miss
Fernandez
summonsed
to
court,
like
I,
said
for
a
person
under
21
possession
develop
on
possession
of
fraudulent
ID?
That's
that's.
It.
Y
Thank
you,
Sergeant
detective
Gallagher
markets
on
the
knight
in
question.
The
you
saw
the
person
at
the
bar.
AB
AB
We
observator
at
the
bar
wasn't
that
busy
that
evening
we
we
watched
her
order
drank
from
the
bartender
who
then
made
Miss
Fernandez
a
drinking
faster
tour.
AB
No,
we
we
had
room
right
there
in
the
inside
the
venue
to
speak
with
her
and.
AB
Two
IDs
or
they're,
both
fraudulent
they're,
both
from
Colombia.
Y
AB
Y
Neither
was
the
passport
I
understand
that
so
and
then
sometimes
subsequently,
six
or
seven
days
later,
you
cited
the
pocket
Inc
for
minor
and
possession
I'm.
Assuming
that
that
time
span
took
it,
took
you
to
identify
her
true
age.
AB
We
we
wrote
the
initial
report
that
night
for
the
affiliate
of
property
idibs.
You
can't
accept
out
of
country
stuff
like
that,
then
we
realized
that
she
was
from
a
local
University.
We
contacted
the
university
with
the
the
information
that
we
had
and
they
were
able
to
provide
to
us
virtual
date
of
birth.
Y
They
had
their
license
posted
properly.
You
didn't
see
any
other
incidents
in
the
space
detective.
Thank
you
very
much.
Good
luck,
Mark
ebliadis
for
venue,
I'd
like
to
call
shirok
Reza,
who
is
the
director
of
operations
regarding
this
matter,
but
prior
to
him,
testifying
there
has
been
an
internal
investigation
done
on
this
incident
regarding
the
security
staff
member
who
allowed
the
person
into
the
club
and
what
the
policies
and
procedures
are
as
far
as
Internationals
coming
into
the
venue.
Y
That
being
said,
the
staff
member
was
Jewish
and
he
has
been
recommended
regarding
not
asking
for
a
passport
to
come
in,
and
the
security
staff
has
been
retrained
with
the
fact
that
this
particular
establishment
has
a
lot
of
Internationals
that
come
to
its
place
of
business
and
it's
my
understanding
that
the
policy
is
to
always
ask
for
a
international
passport.
If
they're
coming
from
a
different
country,
sherok
Reza.
Are
you
there?
Yes,
sir?
Are
you
working
on
the.
AC
Y
And
can
you
explain
or
tell
the
board
what
the
policy
is
regarding
iding
patrons
from
other
countries.
AC
Well
would
generally
we
we
asked
for
the
five
IDs
that
are
acceptable
by
the
by
the
boards
that
the
military
ID
the
passports,
the
Massachusetts
driver's
license
or
an
ID.
AC
The
issue,
in
particular,
is
on
on
one
or
two
nights
a
week.
Boston
is
a
very
International
City
and
we
we
have
a
lot
of
a
lot
of
customers
that
come
from
overseas,
and
you
know
we.
We
request
the
passports
and
we've
had
plenty
of
vocations
where
people
have
brought
in
passports
and
I've
lost
them.
AC
I've
actually,
I
had
sent
some
examples
of
it
to
Mr
liades,
to
show
the
board
that
we've
had
people
who
came
in
with
passport
and
and
lost
it
at
our
premises,
and
you
know
we
try
to
get
it
back
to
them
and
if
we're
not,
we
finally
send
it
to
their
Embassy
of
the
country
that
they
have,
but
that's
our
preference
of
of
the
ID
that
we
accept.
AC
There
has
been
occasions
where
we
accept
International
IDs,
where
there
is
a
large
group
of
people.
You
know
they
come
with
10
or
12
people
and
and
one
or
two
people
don't
have
their
passport,
but
they're
all
part
of
that
large
group,
and
they
have
two
three
forms
of
international
ID
that
they
present
that
shows
their
21
years
of
age.
AC
Often
they
bring
in
their
passport
on
their
phone,
where
we
don't
accept
any
IDs
over
the
phone,
but
in
addition
to
the
physical,
two
or
three
forms
of
ID
that
they
have
from
their
countries,
they
also
pull
up
their
phones
and
say:
hey
I
can't
take
my
passport
out.
I'm
gonna
lose
it
and
they'll,
be
you
know
very
difficult
to
replace
it.
Then
they
show
their
passport
over
the
phone.
AC
So
those
are
very
exceptional
times
that
we
do
accept.
International
IDs-
and
you
know
this
young
lady
was
was
20
years
old
I
think
she
was
a
few
months
a
few
months
away
from
being
21
and
I.
Don't
I
can't
really
I
don't
want
to
give
a
excuse
for
it.
There
is
no
excuse
for
it
and
we
acknowledge
it
and
I
think
Sergeant
detective.
AC
Y
Okay,
but
with
this
particular
person,
when
they
first
come
into
the
door,
you
have
security
staff
at
the
door,
correct
correct
and
when
they
present
ID
on
this
particular
evening.
With
this
particular
young
woman,
she
presented
two
forms
of
ID,
a
Columbia
driver's
license
and
a
Colombian
ID
correct.
Absolutely.
Y
AC
I
would
say
it
was
a
fairly
early
I.
My
memory
remembers
I.
Think
Sergeant
was
there
before
midnight
and
we
had
just
opened
our
doors
within
a
half
hour,
30
minutes
or
so.
Y
Accepted
just
these
two
IDs
you've
had
a
conversation
with
them.
Correct,
absolutely
and
you've
also
had
a
conversation
with
the
General
Security
members
that
do
do
the
door
allowing
patrons
in
regarding
the
forms
and
types
of
IDs
and
the
backups
that
are
required
to
allow
someone
into
the
premises.
Y
Yes,
sir,
okay,
and
is
it
fair
to
say
that
it
is
often
that
you
turn
patrons
away
because
the
door
staff
does
not
find
their
identification
up
to
Snuff
I.
AC
Y
Someone
who's
been
in
your
office
and
has
witnessed
personally
the
amount
of
IDs
credit
cards
and
passports
that
you
collect
after
the
evenings
over
or
that
staff
finds
within
the
nightclub.
How
often
does
that
happen
on
any
given
evening?
Every.
AC
Y
I'm
sure
some
of
these
patrons
are
regulars
in
your
Club.
Correct,
yes,
yeah,
it's
fair
to
say
that
for
regular
patrons
you
request
for
them,
if
you're
going
to
turn
them
away
to
bring
in
their
passport
next
time,
and
that
you
could
take
a
photocopy
and
keep
it
on
file
at
the
club
if
they
are
in
fear
of
losing
their
international
passport.
Y
Thank
you,
Mr
Reza
I
have
no
further
questions
for
this.
Witness
I
have
Billy.
Robinson
is
on
I
believe,
but
he
is
the
manager
of
record
and
I
think
that
his
testimony
would
be
identical
to
Mr
residence.
So
unless
the
board
has
any
questions
for
Mr,
Reza
I
would
ask
that
the
board
find
no
violation
here
or
if
they
do
to
just
issue
a
warning
based
on
the
fact
that
they
are
scrupulous
and
have
a
zero
tolerance
policy
of
under
21
people
coming
into
their
establishment.
Okay,.
D
Vote
on
on
Thursday,
but
Sergeant
Gallagher
or
detente
Fernandez
in
the
police
report
states
that
the
MS
Fernandez
replied.
She
always
uses
her
Colombian
license
to
get
in.
Is
that
correct.
D
And
to
the
person
from
venue
who
was
testifying
I'm
sorry,
you
stated
that
the
person
working
the
door
was
newish.
What
does
that
mean.
AC
And
I'm,
terrible
and
I
have
to
be
honest
with
you.
The
acquiring
employees
in
our
line
of
work
has
been.
G
AC
Very
difficult
and-
and
you
know
it's
almost
been
a
revolving
door
and
and
training
them
has
been
even
harder
and
we
never
trust
just
our
door,
guys
that
are
just
hired
at
the
door.
We
constantly
have
managers
and
assistant
managers
available
at
the
door
as
a
backup,
but
it's
been,
it's
been
very
difficult.
D
D
I'm,
just
gonna
make
a
statement
that
you're
putting
your
alcohol
license
at
risk
when
you're
making
exceptions
like
this
for
valid
IDs.
If
someone
looks
under
21
I
I,
you
have
to
think
seriously
about
whether
or
not
a
Colombian
license
is
acceptable.
Was
this
person
a
regular.
AC
Unfortunately,
Mr
Robertson
was
ill
that
night
and
I
was
the
manager
on
the
record
for
that
nighttime
manager.
For
that
night
and
she's,
not
a
regular
customer
to
us.
A
Great
thank
you
and
the
other
two
individuals
to
the
left
planning
on
testifying
as
well.
So
please
identify
yourselves.
Z
AD
A
Great.
Thank
you
very
much
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
Boston
Police
Department
I.
O
A
AB
A
A
AA
Good
morning,
I'll
be
reading
from
a
police
report
which
I
wrote
on
Sunday
October
16
2022,
sharing
detector,
William,
Gallagher
and
detective
Eddie
Hernandez
assigned
to
the
BPD
license
permission
conducted
licensed
reference
inspection,
LaFonda
located
at
972,
Saratoga
Street
in
East,
Boston
or
walking
through
the
establishment
detectives
observed
Peterson
sitting
at
table
with
a
bottle
of
hard
alcohol
placed
on
the
table.
The
bottle
was
left
unattended
and
made
available
for
self-service
access
to
the
beverages.
The
titles
inform
the
person
in
charge,
Mr
George,
Castaneda,
that
this
is
a
prohibitive
practice
bottle.
AA
Seven
is
not
a
condition.
A
lot
on
the
establishments
coming
rickshaw's
license.
Mr
Gessner
said
that
he
would
immediately
correct
the
situation
as
a
result
of
what
detective
observed.
His
type
of
Gallagher
issued
license.
Travel
inspection
notice,
zero,
five,
eight,
nine
six
one
for
service
riding
ball
of
service
without
approval,
the
Boston
licensing
board,
Mr
kitten
had
assigned
for
an
accepted
the
notice.
A
Thank
you
detective
with
the
licensee
like
to
address
the
alleged
incident.
A
T
AD
Hi
I'm
the
manager
I.
Wasn't
that
day
my
day
off.
Well,
my
the
owner
told
me
it's
like
a
six
people
in
the
table
and
they
wait
just
give
them.
They
don't
give
it.
The
bottle
just
show
that
label
and
they
leave
the
Barrel
in
the
table
for
a
minute.
Usually
we
never
give
the
bottle
for
the
customers
only
the
chats
and
we
barely
apologize
about
that,
because
sometimes
it's
a
new
wages
and
they
are
not
the
rules
well
and
the
manager
or
most
of
the
people
here
they
know
all
rules.
They
never
get.
A
Thank
you
anything
else.
You
would
like
to
stay
to
the
board
or
fill
me
with
the
questions.
AD
Z
So
once
again,
Andrew
Santiago
security
as
the
inspectors
officers
arrived,
that
they
were
going
to
go
check
the
licensing.
That's
when
I
know
the
girl
had
come
with
the
bottle
and
everything
I
then
also
confronted
her
once
it
was
all
day.
Everybody.
Oh
sorry,
excuse
me,
the
officers
brought
it
to
the
attention
and
went
with
the
owner.
Z
I
called
her
and
I
said
you
know
you
should
not
be
bringing
any
bottle
and
she'd
claimed
what
they
wanted
to
see
the
bottle
and
so
forth,
but
I
had
also
confronted
the
waitress,
and
so,
although
you
could
never
leave
a
bottle
and
after
the
citation
was
written
and
so
forth,
I
know
the
owner
did
also
as
well
pulled
her
to
the
side
and
corrected
probably
a
bottle
serving,
but-
and
that
is
for
my
thank
you.
Thank.
A
D
Yeah
for
Sergeant,
Gallagher
and
detective
Hernandez
was
this:
the
only
table
that
had
bottle
service.
AA
D
Okay
and
for
the
the
licensee
were
you
working
with
any
promoters
that
night.
Z
D
Okay,
thank
you.
I,
don't
have
any
other
questions.
A
A
Thank
you.
Thank
you.
We
will
now
be
calling
item
number
eight
934
Inc
doing
business
as
the
Banshee
located
at
934
Dorchester
Ave
in
Dorchester
dated
the
incident
November
27
2022
person
under
21
in
possession
of
alcohol
in
violation
of
mass
generalize
chapter
138,
section
34,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
AE
Good
morning
Madam
chair
commissioner
Saxon
and
current
Michael
brought
again
on
behalf
of
the
licensee
with
me.
Today
is
Ray
Butler,
the
manager
of
record
Aaron
Callahan
the
person
in
charge
on
the
evening
question
as
well
as
Ronald
Hughes
member
of
the
door
staff.
A
Thank
you
very
much,
who
is
president
on
behalf
of
the
Boston
Police
Department
I
am
thank
you,
detector
Mendez.
Are
there
any
other
individuals
with
firsthand
knowledge
of
the
alleged
incident
who
wish
to
testify
this
morning.
A
AA
Good
morning,
I'll
be
reading
from
a
report
that
I
wrote
on
Sunday
November
27
2022,
trying
to
detected
with
Gallagher
and
detective
Eddie
Hernandez
assigned
to
the
BPD
license
permission
that
conducted
a
licensed
permits,
inspection
of
the
Banshee
located
934
Dorchester
Avenue,
while
inside
the
establishment
detectives.
There
are
three
female
patrons
drinking
alcoholic
beverages
at
the
bar
to
take
the
notice.
These
patrons
looked
young
and
ask
them
to
produce
a
notification
to
confirm
their
ages.
AA
Two
out
of
the
individual
state
of
the
over
21
years
of
age
that
produced
driver's
license,
stating
they
were
over
20
minutes
of
age
detectives,
were
able
to
confirm
that
the
two
patrons
had
valid
drivers,
licensees
and
more
of
age.
The
third
Patron
later
identified
as
soline
Jalil
green
328
of
2002,
initially
provided
detectives
with
her
valid
Mass
driver's
license
confirming
she
was
under
21
years
of
age
door.
Staff
dated
Miss
green
had
used
a
driver's
license.
That
stated
that
she
was
over
21
years
of
age.
AA
The
screen
then
produced
a
mass
driver's
license
which
contained
her
name
but
displayed
date
of
birth.
At
the
made
appearance,
though,
she
was
over
21
years
of
age.
Detectives
used
a
license:
verification
app,
which
confirmed
that
the
driver's
license
provided
cyber
screen
was
indeed
fraudulent.
The
fraudulent
Mass
driver's
license
was
confiscated
by
detectives.
The
screen
will
be
summoned
to
quarter
person
under
21.
AA
First,
in
the
last
ball,
possession
of
fraudulent
identification
detectives
brought
the
situation
to
the
attention
the
person
in
charge,
Mr
Aaron
callanan
as
a
result
of
what
detectives
observed
tried
to
detective
Gallagher
issued
license
plans,
inspection
of
the
zero
five
nine
two,
two
five
for
persons
under
21
years
old
and
position
of
alcohol
on
premise,
Mr
kellingan,
signed
and
accepted
the
notice.
Okay.
A
Thank
you,
Hernandez
attorney
brought
again.
Would
you
like
to
address
the
elect
incident.
AE
Yes,
please
just
a
few
questions
for
sergeant
Hernandez.
If
I
may
Sergeant,
when
you
were
in
The
Establishment,
all
of
the
staff
were
Cooperative
with
you
Perry
okay,
and
would
you
say
that
the
identification
that
was
the
second
form
that
was
produced?
That
was
the
fraudulent
one?
You
say
that
was
a
high
quality
ID
high
quality,
fake
ID.
Well,.
AE
And
Miss
green
originally
informed
you
that
she
had
she
produced
a
ID.
That
said,
she
was
over
21,
correct.
AA
No,
she
gave
us
her
ID.
The
screen
gave
us
the
idea.
That
said,
she
was
on
a
21
years
of
age.
The
door
staff
told
explained
to
us
that
she
had
definitely
had
an
ID.
That
said,
she
was
over
21
when
she
came
in.
She
finally
did
show
us.
She
finally
did
produce
the
idea
that
she
came
in
there
with
the
fraudulent
idea
that
he
confirmed
that
that
was
problem.
Yes,.
AE
I'm,
sorry,
so
the
the
initial
one
that
she
provided
to
you
showed
that
she
was
under
21
and
she
her
story
to
you,
was
that
she
that's
the
idea
that
she
had
produced
to
the
door
staff.
AA
AE
If
I
may
briefly,
the
Banshee
is
a
an
establishment
that
takes
a
lot
of
Pride
and
a
lot
of
diligence
with
regards
to
their
methods
relative
to
inspecting
people,
and
they
come
into
the
establishment
to
make
sure
that
they're
over
21.
this
evening
in
question
was
the
Sunday
night.
It
was
actually
a
rather
slow
night
at
The
Establishment,
despite
that
fact,
they
always
have
door
staff
at
the
door
taking
IDs
and
checking
them.
AE
On
this
particular
occasion,
Ronald
Hughes,
who
is
here
and
will
testify,
took
the
IDS
of
all
three
of
these
individuals
who
came
in
together.
They
all
produced
identifications
with
their
photos
on
them,
indicating
that
their
dates
of
birth
established
that
they
were
in
fact
of
legal
age
when
they,
when
the
police
arrived
at
the
bar
this
individual
in
question,
Miss
green
actually
tried
to
dupe
them
as
well.
AE
She
gave
them
a
Massachusetts
driver's
license
her
her
actual
driver's
license
and
indicated
to
them
that,
in
fact,
she
that's
the
license
that
she
had
produced
to
the
dormant
on
the
nighting
question,
which
in
fact
was
wrong,
and
in
that
instance,
Mr
Hughes
was
adamant
with
the
police
and
he
informed
them
that
she
had
in
fact
produced
a
fake
ID
that
insistence
in
that
cooperation
with
the
police
resulted
in
her
eventually
handing
over
this
fraudulent
ID.
AE
Since
this
occasion,
I
I
would
point
out
in
Raymond,
Butler
manager
of
record
is
here
he
can
testify
as
well.
Should
the
board
like
to
hear
it
relative
to
the
procedures
that
have
now
been
put
in
place?
The
Establishment
has
gone
to
get
a
license:
verification
scanner,
app
that
was
actually
suggested
by
the
police
on
the
night
in
question,
so
that
will
assist
them
even
further
to
to
be
able
to
identify
any
fraudulent
types
of
identification.
AE
Just
want
to
point
out
to
the
board
that
that
in
this
instance,
it
wasn't
as
if
a
a
ID
wasn't
asked
for
and
shown.
This
was
just
an
ID.
In
fact,
the
Massachusetts
ID
that
had
been
altered
by
Miss
green
and
as
I
mentioned
Mr
Hughes,
can
tell
you
that
it
was
in
fact
a
high
quality
ID.
AE
You
know
it's
it's
something
that
we
feel
as
if
we
got
duped
on
we've
taken
additional
steps
now
to
even
lessen
the
chance
of
that
occurring
in
the
future,
with
the
board
like
to
hear
from
Mr,
Hughes
and
or
Mr
Callahan
and
Mr
Butler.
O
The
board
please
Ron,
my
name
is
Ronald
Hughes
I'm,
the
doorman
for
the
banshee.
AE
And
how
long
have
you
worked
at
the
Banshee
run
just
past
the
year,
okay
and
you're
working
on
the
night
in
question?
Here?
Yes,
I
was
okay
and
do
you
do
you
remember
taking
the
idea
ID
of
these
three
females
Pride
to
them
entering
the
establishment?
AE
Yes,
I
do
and
do
you
recall
the
interaction
with
the
police
after
they
had
come
in
and
asked
about
the
IDS
yes
I
do
and
who
you're
aware
that
one
of
the
individuals
Miss
green,
had
indicated
that
she
in
fact
had
not
provided
an
ID
that
was
fraudulent.
Yes,.
O
AE
And
the
idea
that
she
had
produced
to
you
did
you
think
that
that
was
a
did?
It
looked
like
an
authentic
identification
from
Massachusetts.
It
looked.
AE
I
have
nothing
for
other.
Should
the
board
have
any
questions
for
Mr
Hughes.
AE
For
you,
I
I,
yeah
I
think
that
Mr
Callahan
would
testify
very
similar
to
Mr
Hughes
Mr
Butler
can
testify
to
what
I
told
you
about
relative
to
the
procedures
that
were
taken
subsequent
to
this
event
relative
to
purchasing
the
app,
if
you'd
like
to
hear
from
either
of
those
two
we'd
be
happy
to
do
it.
A
A
Thank
you
very
much
item
number
nine
is
being
continued,
will
be
heard
on
March
7th,
when
the
manager
of
record
and
Council
are
able
to
appear
calling
item
number
10
of
Korean
Fusion
Inc
doing
business
as
coin
located
at
16
to
18,
North
Street,
then
at
the
incident
January
14,
2023
overcrowding,
139
found
on
mechanical
count,
capacity
of
52
in
violation
of
Mass
general
laws,
chapter
138,
section
64
in
boards,
rule
1.03,
J
and
1.06
a
and
F
and
premise
conducting
bottle
service
in
violation
of
Mass
General
chapter
138,
section
64.,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
J
A
AA
Good
morning,
I'll
be
reading
again
from
a
police
report
which
I
wrote
on
a
Saturday
January
14
2023
science,
detective
William,
gallaghan,
detective,
ready,
Hernandez
assigned
to
the
BPD
license
permission
to
conduct
a
license
from
its
inspection
of
Kauai
located
16
North
Street
in
Boston,
as
detectives
walked
up
to
the
establishment
detectives
at
the
front
door
staff.
AA
How
many
patrons
they
currently
had
inside
the
staff
member
stated
they
had
a
count
of
105
patrons
or
walking
into
the
establishing
detectives
observed
Peyton
sitting
at
a
table
with
mixers
a
craft
of
unknown
liquids
and
an
ice
bucket
detectives
also
noticed
a
menu
on
the
table
for
bottles
of
hard
alcohol
for
sale.
The
spending
was
seasoned
was
brought
it
up
to
the
licensing
board.
AA
Texas
then
proceeded
to
review
the
license.
Maybe
the
licenses
and
permanently
establishment
detectives
learned
that
the
capacity
of
the
premise
is
set
at
52
persons
inside
detector,
Hernandez,
former
and
mechanical
kind
of
the
establishment
and
discovered
the
actual
number
of
persons
located
inside.
The
premise
was
139.
AA
detectors.
Also
may
note
that
bottle
service
is
not
a
condition
that
allowed
on
the
establishment.
Common
Victor
license
detectives
report.
The
person
in
charge
will
still
end
out
that
bottle
service
is
not
a
condition
allowed
at
The
Establishment
that
the
premise
was
extremely
overcrowded.
As
a
result
of
what
detectives
are
very
scientific
Gallagher
issued
a
license
permission
section
notice:
zero,
six,
zero
one,
one
six
for
premise:
conducting
bottle
service
in
Democratic,
the
style
sign
for
an
accepted
the
notes,
and
so
on
and
I
have.
AA
There
is
a
couple
of
pictures
included
in
the
packet
of
the
actual
model
service
on
the
table,
what
they
were
all
the
other
bottles
they
had
provided
in
the
kitchen
for
all
the
bottle
service,
all
the
buckets
all
the
mixers
that
were
in
the
kitchen,
getting
ready
to
go
out
and
then
I'll
show
pictures
of
the
menus
that
were
advertising
the
Gin,
Scotch
whiskeys,
Cognac
and
rum,
and
all
the
prices
for
all
the
bottles.
AA
A
AF
So,
first
and
foremost,
we
had
outsourced
the
security
team
that
we
have
since
parted
ways
with.
There
are
conflicting
numbers
on
our
capacity,
which
we
have
actually
acknowledged
and
have
begun
a
process
of
rectification
with.
We
have
hired
an
architect
who
is
actually
on
the
call
today
as
well,
and
we
are
willing
to
provide
the
new
drawings
and
everything
that
will
actually
fix
up
all
of
our
capacity
and
bring
our
standing
capacity
to
the
appropriate
number
in
terms
of
the
bottle
licensing
situation.
AF
We
acknowledge
all
these
citations
and
we're
making
steps
to
rectify
that
situation
as
well.
We
have
already
begun
flowering
our
Butters
and
are
in
contact
with
our
community
groups,
who
apply
with
the
city
of
Boston
for
a
legitimate
bottle
license
for
bottle
service.
AF
Since
then,
we
have
stopped
all
services
of
any
of
that
nature,
all
subsequent
events,
so
until
we
Rectify
everything
on
our
end
to
make
sure
that
everything
is
of
good
standing.
D
Yeah
I
do
were
you
working
with
a
promoter
that
night.
AF
AA
C
AA
D
From
police
officers,
you
heard
it
from
the
chair
of
the
board
I
think
you
should
educate
yourself
about
what
the
current
capacity
is
and
we're
not
going
to
discuss
future
capacities
until
you
get
people
working
and
finish
the
process.
This
isn't
the
first
time
overcrowding
has
come
to
my
attention.
D
Anecdotally,
I've,
had
people
call
me
on
the
weekends
to
say
it
looks
like
a
club
outside
of
koi,
so
I
I'm,
just
I,
accept
your
apology
for
the
bottle
service,
but
I'd
like
to
know
what
your
what
you
were
thinking
as
far
as
conducting
your
business.
That
way
that
night,
you
knew
it
was
against
the
rules.
You
knew
it
was
not
part
of
your
license,
and
why
did
you
decide
to
I
mean
this?
Is
this?
Is
one
not
one
table?
D
AF
Like
I
said,
we
accept
the
responsibility
of
that.
However,
what.
AF
So
we
are
moving
towards
applying
properly
and
we're
returning
to
restaurant
Services,
only
no
event
hosting
and
everything.
AF
So
there
are
three
conflicting
numbers,
but
the
one
that
we're
using
currently
is
64.,
and
where
are
you
getting
that
from
so
64
is
on
our
CV
license?
We
have
72,
that's
also
present
on
our
CV
license
and
then
another
of
I
believe
52
on
another
license.
But
the
64
is
consistent
on
multiple
licenses.
Place
of
assembly,
CV
license
inspection.
AF
What
it
says,
64,
but
then
also
72,.
AF
K
K
And
you
say
you
have
you:
have
you
have
any
kind
of
application
in
with
us
to
change
that
capacity,
you're
saying
so.
AF
So
we
have
hired
an
architect,
he
is
sending
all
the
documentation
and
I
think
that
he
has
already
been
doing
it
for
the
past
month,
so
we're
stretching.
We
can
email
all
the
documentation
over
to
everyone.
K
Okay,
where
detective
Hernandez,
where
are
we?
Where
are
we
getting
52
from
because
we
have
it
on
the
previous
violation
from
2018
that
it
was
52
as
well.
AB
It's
it
one
I'm
gonna,
say
three
out
of
the
four
licenses:
it's
that
lower
number
in
that
64
that
she's,
referring
to
that's,
including
the
patio
which
is
12
I,
believe
so
the
inside
capacity
is,
is
not
64.
But
a
majority
of
the
licenses
have
that
lower
capacity
limit
set
for.
K
AF
A
A
K
AF
K
But
that
would
that
would
be
more
in
reference
to
an
application
to
change
your
capacity.
Yes,
so
that
that's
separate,
that's
that
really
isn't
relevant
to
this
violation
right
now.
That's
for
the
future
understood.