►
Description
City of Boston Licensing Board - Violation Hearing - 01/18/2022
A
A
As
a
reminder,
when
you
are
joining,
please
mute
yourself
unless
you
are
appearing
or
testifying
before
the
board
good
morning.
This
is
a
hearing
before
the
licensing
board
for
the
city
of
boston.
Today
is
tuesday
january
18th
2022.
Today's
hearing
is
being
held
to
pursuant
to
temporary
amendments
to
the
open
meeting
law.
That
is
what
allows
us
to
meet.
Virtually
today's
hearing
will
be
recorded
and
posted
to
the
city
of
boston
website.
A
Thank
you
please
ensure
that
your
audio
and
visuals
are
working
properly.
I
will
call
each
item
in
the
order
it
appears
on
the
agenda.
I
will
then
ask
who
is
president
on
behalf
of
the
licensee
and
who
is
on
behalf
of
the
boston
police
department
and
whether
there
are
any
other
individuals
with
knowledge
of
the
alleged
incident.
A
Again,
all
testimony
will
be
limited
only
to
individuals
with
personal
knowledge
of
the
alleged
incident
now
calling
item
number
one
955
llc
doing
business
as
dylan's,
located
at
951
boylston
street
date
of
the
incident
october,
31st
2021
patron
on
patron
assault
in
violation
of
mass
general
law,
chapter
138,
section
64.,
ed
chapter
265,
section
13,
a
an
expired
assembly
permit
in
violation
of
mass
general
laws,
chapter
138,
section
64.
and
boards
rule
1.02
b,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
D
Mr
green,
madam
chair
members,
the
board
dennis
quilty
attorney
representing
the
licensee
with
me
this
morning,
anthony
chuba
and
joe
hicks
of
both
management
personnel
for
the
licensee
morning.
A
Okay,
can
you
all
please
raise
your
right
hand.
A
E
E
Officers
observed
the
physical
altercation
involving
the
bouncers
from
game
on
and
victim
number
one
later
identified.
As
gary
wilgus
officers
observed
the
witness
later
identified
as
sean
mckenna,
attempting
to
separate
victim
juan
willgas
from
the
altercation
with
the
bouncers
as
officers
approached
victim
number,
two
miriam
rathfeld
also
was
observed.
Attempting
to
separate
victim
number
one
wilgus
from
the
bounces
officers
observed
as
victim
number
two
rafael
was
struck
in
the
face
by
victim
number
one's
wigas
elbow
victim
number.
Two
rathfield
immediately
started
bleeding
from
the
nose
as
a
result
of
the
accidental
contact.
E
Once
the
individuals
were
separated
officer
keegan
spoke
to
victim
number.
One
willgus
and
officer
larosa
spoke
with
victim
number
two
raphael
victim
number.
One
wilgus
stated
that
he
was
utilizing
the
restroom
inside
of
game
on
when
he
was
struck
in
the
side
of
the
head
with
a
glass
bottle
victim
number.
One
wilga
stated
that
he
did
not
know
the
suspects
officers
observed
swelling
in
the
area
where
victim
number
one
wilga
stated
he
was
struck.
E
Officers
requested
the
assistance
of
boston
ems
ambulance,
3,
alpha
1-6,
joyce
and
schneider
arrived
on
scene,
boston,
ems
ambulance,
3a16,
joyce
schneider
offered
medical
attention
to
both
victim
number
one
willgus
and
victim
number
two
raffled,
as
both
individuals
denied
needing
medical
attention,
the
witness
mckenna
provided
a
photo
of
the
suspect
to
officers
officers
searched
the
area
and
were
unable
to
locate
anyone
matching
the
suspect's
description.
Misogyn
disease,
the
delta
910,
was
notified
of
the
above
mentioned
incident
and
responded
on
scene
to
conduct
code.
E
35
licensed
premise:
investigation,
license
premise:
violation,
citation
zero
four
four
six
four
two
was
issued
as
a
result
of
a
patron
on
patron
assault.
In
addition
to
patron
unemployee
assault
officers
were
equipped
with
boston
police
issued
axon
body
warn
cameras
during
the
incident.
That
is
the
conclusion
of
the
boston
police
report.
D
Yes,
if
I
may,
is
it
detective
wallace,
yes,
sir,
and
were
you
present
on
the
night
of
the
incident?
I
was
not
sure,
okay,
so
you're
reading
from
a
that
night
by
the
officers
on
scene,
that's
correct,
sir,
and
with
regard
to
the
inspection
notice,
it
indicates
that
management
was
cooperative
with
the
police.
Is
that
correct?
D
Yes,
that
is
correct.
Sir,
thank
you
and
just
reading
the
details
of
the
narrative.
The
narrative
indicates
that
staff
from
the
bar
indicated
that
assistance
was
needed.
E
D
Right
and
do
you
know
again,
I
know
you
weren't
there
that
night,
but
subsequently
I'm
informed
that
the
cooperation
included
mr
chu
anthony
providing
video
to
the
bpd
of
the
incident.
Is
that
correct?
That's
correct,
sir.
Yes,
all
right!
Thank
you.
Thank
you.
Detective
brother.
I
know
you
have
no
personal
knowledge
but
appreciate
your
testimony.
Thank
you
very
much.
E
I,
mr.
D
Green
go
ahead.
Thank
you.
So
we
have
mr
kuga
who's.
Anthony
you've.
Just
heard
of
is
here
he's
the
one
who
was
outside,
who
you
know
ask
for
the
police
assistance
the
occurrence,
as
you'll
hear.
This
incident
between
two
people
apparently
happened
in
the
bathroom,
and
nobody
on
the
premise
was
aware
of
it
until
these
two
individuals
saw
each
other
out
in
the
street.
D
D
There
were
people
gathered
outside
waiting
for
rides
in
the
lake,
and
apparently
these
two
individuals
who
got
into
a
scuffle
in
the
bathroom
saw
each
other
and
went
at
it
again.
That's
really
all
that
we
know
mr
chuba
did
supply
the
bpd
with
the
video
of
the
entire
incident.
D
We
think
the
the
staff
did
everything
they
could,
in
the
circumstances,
to
keep
people
from
becoming
involved
in
this
fight
and
again
this
individual,
whoever
it
is
that
was
identified,
was
unable
to
be
found
in
the
area
and
the
staff
had
no
no
knowledge
again
as
to
what
happened
inside
the
bathroom.
Mr
you've
been
sworn.
Would
you
just
state
your
name
for
the
record.
D
And
with
regard
to
the
incident
itself,
this
was
at
closing
time.
Is
that
correct.
G
I
was
outside
one
of
my
one
of
my
employees
had
been
struck
and
I
advised
both
of
them
to
get
inside,
and
I
was
outside
trying
to
just
de-escalate
the
situation.
It
didn't
take
long
for
the
police
to
show
up
as
soon
as
they
did.
I
kind
of
stepped
to
the
side
and
asked,
and
I
told
them
that
we
have
a
situation
going
on
and
that
I
could
use
their
help
and
immediately
they
stepped
in
and
when
they
stepped
in.
I
don't
know
the
guy's
name,
but
the
tallest
one
there.
G
He
he
was
the
one
with
the
problem
and
he
started.
He
was
even
screaming
with
the
officers
pushing
them
back,
and
this
was
this
was
after
I
had
like
this
person
was,
they
were.
Everyone
was
out
the
building.
The
doors
were
locked
and,
like
you
said,
we
were
closing.
H
D
So
at
that
point,
did
you
do
you
and
the
staff
stood
by
and
just
let
the
let
the
bpd
handle
the.
G
Yeah
I
had
already
put
in
I
had
already
pulled
in
after
my
employee
was
struck.
I
told
him
to
go
back
inside
that
I'd
handle
the
front
door
for
any
further
issues,
and
it
was
just
me
outside
with
the
police.
G
G
D
C
Ask
who
sean
mckenna
is
in
the
police
report
is
that
a
patron
or
a
staff
member.
C
He's
not
okay,
I
don't
have
any
questions
for
the
for
any
of
them
today.
D
I'm
sure
members
again
dennis
quilty
attorney,
representing
the
licensing
with
me
this
morning
is
nelson
burns,
who
is
the
gm
and
jamal
schaffner?
Who
was
one
of
the
security
staff
on
duty
on
the
night
in
question?.
J
Officer
burke
should
be
present.
I
saw
his
name
on
there
and
detective
swain.
A
A
Yes,
sir,
can
you
not
see
me
at
all
hear
me
yeah,
I
can
we
can
see
you
and
hear
you
now.
Thank
you.
Okay.
Are
there
any
other
individuals
with
not
personal
knowledge
of
the
incident
who
would
like
to
testify
as
well.
A
L
Good
morning,
everyone,
my
name,
is
detective
terence
burke,
I'm
with
the
wasson
police
department
currently
assigned
to
area
c
to
triple
11,
which
is
in
dorchester
on
saturday
october
23rd
2021.
L
I
was
doing
a
patrol
shift
in
south
boston
at
about
10
27
hours.
I
was
dispatched
to
the
massachusetts
general
hospital
in
regards
to
a
a
victim
that
had
suffered
injuries
from
the
early
morning
of
the
same
day,
october
23rd.
L
Initially,
when
I
arrived,
I
met
with
the
mass
general
hospital
police
who
escorted
me.
She
emerged
through
the
emergency
department,
where
eventually
I
met
up
with
the
victim
mr
jack
caban
or
cabin,
and
mr
giovanni
abril,
mr
giovanni
abril,
was
the
reporting
party
and
the
victim
was
mr
jack
caban.
L
Due
to
the
nature
of
mr
caban's
injuries,
his
jaw
was
wired
very
complicated.
He
had
other
medical
therapy
going
on
and
to
the
fact
that
we
were
in
a
hallway,
and
I
had
asked
to
have
that
moved,
but
it
was
declined.
L
I
decided
mr
giovanni
abril,
his
cousin,
the
reporting
party,
initially
establishing
timeline
for
what
had
happened.
What
transpired
mr
grill
explained
that
he
counted
and
repeated
some
of
the
local
businesses
in
the
seaport
area?
They
were
from
out
of
town
and
then
eventually
around
midnight.
They
proceeded
to
lucky's
launch
at
355
congress
street
in
south
boston.
L
Mr
obviously,
giovanni
abril
had
departed
to
go,
collect
their
vehicle,
leaving
mr
mr
there
and
when
he
returned
discovered,
a
group
was
acting
violent,
tumultuous
and
afraid,
with
mr
jack
obama
being
the
victim
in
the
matter.
Eventually,
I
spoke
with
mr
jack
bond,
corroborated
all
the
timeline
of
the
events
and
that
he
had
explained
that
his
cousin
had
left
to
go,
collect
the
vehicle
he
was.
L
He
had
lit
up
a
cigarette
as
he
was
exiting
prior
to
exiting
luckies
when
words
were
exchanged
with
the
security
staff
or,
as
he
noted,
the
bouncers
words
were
exchanged
and
a
specific
gentleman,
an
african-american
male
about
five
nine
must
go,
build,
became
physically
aggressive
and
then
other
security
staff
joined
in
and
he
was
afraid
this
was
witnessed.
As
mr
was
coming
back.
L
D
Yes,
if
I
may
detect
as
a
detective.
D
Thank
you,
sir
you're.
From
from
the
report
it
would.
It
would
appear
that
you,
you
responded
to
the
hospital,
so
this
was
after
the
incident
had
occurred.
You
have
no
personal
knowledge
of
the
incident
itself.
I
do
not,
sir
all
right,
and
I
know
the
the
other
officer.
Swain
is
here
or
detective
swain,
and
that
is
the
violation
notice
or
the
inspection
notice
was
delivered.
The
later,
I
guess
the
same
day.
D
Is
that
correct?
Yes,
that's
correct,
and
at
that
time
you
indicate
that
the
establishment
the
licensee
cooperated
with
you.
Is
that
correct?
Yes,
the
sir
detective,
I'm
sorry
detective
burke,
the
statement
that
you
received
was
from
mr
abril
and
mr
caban
correct,
and
you
had
no
no
no
statement
or
explanation
from
the
establishment
or
the
staff
or
anybody
like
that.
L
The
investigation
would
be
from
the
respective
districts
detectives,
okay,.
D
Thank
you,
sir
sorry
and
detective
swain.
If
I
may
did
the
cooperation
with
you
to
your
knowledge,
did
the
cooperation
include
mr
nelson
burns
who's
with
us
this
morning,
providing
video
of
any
any
video
they
had
of
that
night
to
the
police?
Yes,
and
was
mr
burns,
the
person
who
you
interfaced
with
yes
and
was
he
cooperative
to
you
personally?
Yes,
did
he
explain
to
you
what
had
occurred
that
night?
Yes,
did
he
suggest
to
you
or
explain
to
you
that
mr
caban
was
the
aggressor
here.
K
D
Did
he
explain
to
you
that
mr
cabron
had
called
the
door
staff
for
lack
of
a
better
description?
The
n
word
yes,
and
did
he
tell
you
that
they
then
spit
in
this
gentleman's
face?
Yes,
is
it
did
he
then
tell
you
that
the
spitting
in
the
face
and
the
calling
of
the
n-word
caused
the
the
person
to
basically
defend
himself?
D
Yes,
and
did
you
were
you
given
the
name
of
that
individual
I
was
and
was,
is
that
I
don't
even
have
it's
elijah
I
don't
have
his
last
name.
Is
that
the
first
name
franklin?
Yes,
yes,
so
he's.
K
D
Thank
you
detective.
I
don't
have
any
further
questions,
but
I
would
like
to
have
mr
burns
and
witness
jamal
shafner
speak
they've
both
been
sworn.
May
I,
madam
chair.
D
M
I
was
on
duty,
but
I
was
inside
dealing
with
the
inside
nightly
stuff
at
the
end
of
the
night
like
getting
getting
ready
to
close
the
restaurant.
So
I
did
not
witness
the
incident.
You
were
there.
M
The
next
day,
I
discovered
what
happened
when
when
the
police
came
into
the
restaurant-
and
I
said
there
was
an
assault
that
occurred
and
I
immediately
took
them
up
to
the
office
to
watch
the
cameras
because
I
wanted
to
get
to
the
bottom
of
whatever
didn't
happen.
Okay,.
D
D
In
fact,
on
the
night
in
question,
it's
just
a
minor
matter,
but
he
had
not
clocked
in.
He
was
there
speaking
to
his
friends.
Is
that
correct.
M
Yes,
he
works
at
another
restaurant
down
the
street
and
he
usually
shows
up
when
he
gets
cut
and
if
they
need
help
at
the
end
of
the
night
he'll,
he
works
full
time,
some
full
ships
or
he
did
work
full
ship
sometimes,
but
he
would
come
after
his
ship
and
asked
him
if
they
were
okay,
if
they
needed
help
and
he'd
either
clock
in
for
the
last
two
hours
of
the
night
or
he
would
go
home.
And
at
this
point
they
said
it
wasn't
very
busy
inside
and
they
said
we're
not
going
to
need
you.
D
M
Yeah
there
was
two
separate
camera
systems
and
then
we
had
within
a
short
period
of
time
I
had
rit
guy
come
in
and
download
all
the
footage
onto
a
zip
drive
for
them
from
both
systems,
and
I
called
them
back
and
delivered
that
to
them.
D
Thank
you,
sir
board
may
have
some
questions,
madam
sharon,
whether
you
want
me
to
go
through
the
other,
witness
first
and
then
or
whatever
you
choose.
D
Okay,
thank
you,
sir.
Is
that
jamal
shafner
are
you
present
with
us
today?
Yes,
good
morning,
all
right?
Thank
you
very
much.
Just
having
been
sworn
to
just
identify
yourself,
please,
mr
schaffner.
D
And
at
some
point
at
that
evening,
were
you
talking
with
elijah
franklin
and
other
other
personnel
in
the
vestibule
entryway.
N
Yes,
towards
the
end
of
the
night
we're
about
to
close,
and
he
was
just
hanging
out
by
the
door.
You
know
chatting
up
with
us.
N
Yeah
I
I
identified
the
patron
coming
out
of
the
the
restaurant
and
he
appeared
to
be
very
inebriated
and
he's
stumbling
up.
The
steps
you
know
with
the
cigarette
in
his
mouth
and
we
asked
him
not
to
light
up
the
cigarette
in
the
vestibule
and
he
instead
of
engaging
me,
he
engaged
elijah
and
he
asked
him
who
he
was.
You
know
and
immediately
started
swearing
and
from
there
he
called
them
the
n-word
several
times,
and
that
is
what
started
the
escalation.
Then
they
spilled
out
onto
the
sidewalk.
N
You
know,
and
we
witnessed
also
the
the
friend
he
the
patron
had
a
friend
that
was
trying
to
come
up
behind
elijah
and,
and
so
the
security
staff
stepped
out
into
the
sidewalk
to
prevent
anything.
N
You
know
any
further
like
escalation
of
the
the
violence,
because
at
that
point
they
were
just
shoving
each
other
and
then
the
patron
spit
on
elijah
at
the
column
there,
where
several
times
and
that's
when
you
know
it's
a
one-on-one
fight-
and
you
know
the
security
staff
did
their
best
to
break
up
any
other
individuals
trying
to
get
involved
and
yeah.
That
was
it.
N
N
Oh,
absolutely,
I
I
don't
know
any
human
being.
That
would
not
defend
themselves
under
those
circumstances,
he's
a
pretty
evenly
temporary
person,
but
after
somebody's
calling
you
the
n-word
several
times
and
then
spit
in
your
face,
you
know
at
that
point.
You
know
as
like
I
said
it.
I
don't
know
anybody
that
wouldn't
defend
themselves
under
those
circumstances.
D
O
Good
morning,
members
of
the
ward
attorney
seamus
o'kelly
on
behalf
of
the
licensee,
and
I
have
present
with
me
three
witnesses
who
should
be
present:
dana
roy
arthur
madeiras
and
john
karen,
the
licensee.
J
A
A
Okay,
could
everyone
please
raise
your
right
hand.
P
A
Q
J
J
Officers
walked
over
to
the
victim,
mr
kuru,
laying
on
the
ground.
Mr
crew
was
incoherent
and
could
barely
speak
or
keep
his
eyes
open.
He
fell
forward
on
several
occasions
attempting
to
stand
up
while
attempting
attempting
to
assist
mr
crow.
He
began
swearing
at
the
officers
and
became
physically
aggressive.
Mr
crew
was
placed
in
handcuffs
for
officer,
safety
and
boston.
Ems
were,
and
a
patrol
supervisor
was
were
summoned,
so
sergeant
downey
arrived
on
scene
and
issued
a
license
premise:
citation
to
to
west
end
johnny's
and
the
victim.
J
Mr
crew
was
transported
by
an
ambulance
to
to
mass
general
hospital.
Let's
see
one
and.
J
And
then
the
second
one
ordered
by
sergeant
paul
downey
relative
to
the
licensed
promise
inspection
on
saturday
morning
august
28th
sergeant
jack
downey
conducted
a
licensed
premise:
inspection
west
end
johnny's
138
portland
street.
As
a
result
of
a
radio
call
for
a
disturbance
outside
the
front
entrance
district.
One
officers
found
staff
members
from
the
bar
club,
interacting
with
a
highly
intoxicated
male,
who
was
served,
alcoholic
beverages
as
a
patron
inside
the
establishment.
J
J
Mr
arthur
maduro's
manager,
was
cooperative
throughout
the
inspection
and
held
had
all
the
required
license.
Permits
prominently
displayed
on
the
wall
near
the
bar
license,
inspection
notice,
number
60604
was
issued
to
the
establishment
for
serving
patron
excessively
excessive
alcoholic
beverages.
That's
the
extent
of
the
incident
reports.
A
O
Thank
you,
council,
lieutenant
detective,
troy
you.
You
were
not
present
that
that
early
morning
on
the
day
of
this
incident,
correct,
no,
it
was
not,
and
you
in
fact
have
read
from
the
reports
of
sergeant
downey,
I
believe
and
also
officer,
christina
gate.
Is
that
correct?
That's
correct!
Are
you
aware
of
this
individual?
J
From
reading
from
the
police
report,
he
was
not
placed
under
arrest.
He
was
transported
by
boston
ems
to
mass
general
hospital
for
treatment.
Okay,.
O
And
you,
you
would
agree
with
me
from
reading
the
reports
that
the
the
manager,
mr
arthur
madeiras,
was
fully
cooperative
with
the
boston
police
department.
That
evening.
R
O
All
right,
you've
already
been
sworn
mr
roy
correct,
correct.
Yes,
could
you
please
identify
yourself
to
members
of
the
board?
Please.
O
And
you've
heard
the
recitation
by
lieutenant
detective
troy
of
the
events
of
august,
the
28th
2021,
yes
correct
correct,
were
you
present
in
west
end
johnny's
on
august
28
2021
I
was
and
and
and
you
are,
the
the
the
general
manager
of
west
end
johnny's,
correct,
correct
and-
and
that
was
that
was
your
position
on
on
that
on
that
date,
august
28
2021,
correct,
correct!
Okay,
could
you
please
tell
me
your
your
recollection
of
the
events
of
that
early
morning.
R
Yes,
so
either
I
forget
who
it
was
either
author,
I
called
9-1-1
about
the
fights
or
disturbance,
and
that
was
happening
in
the
street.
While
that
was
happening,
I
observed
the
oversearched
patron
come
outside.
I
could
see
that
he
was
stumbling
a
little
bit
and
then
I
so
I
went
over
tried
to
engage
him,
make
sure
he
was
okay.
R
While
I
was
talking
to
him,
I
had
him
sit
down
on
the
windowsill
and
while
I
was
talking
to
him,
he
was
he
was
speaking
to
me
in
what
I
would
describe
tongues.
He
was
telling
me
that
the
devil
was
coming
to
get
me
and
that
the
world
is
coming
to
an
end.
You
know
just
really
bizarre
things,
so
I
was
like
this.
You
know
my
opinion.
This
isn't
alcohol.
I
I
thought
he
was
on
some
sort
of
drug.
At
that
time.
R
I
waved
over
the
female
officer-
and
I
was
like
this-
this
man
needs
help.
There's
there's
something
wrong
with
him.
She
agreed
with
me
at
that
time.
She
said:
what
did
she
kept
on
asking
him?
What
did
you
take?
What
did
you
take?
He
was,
you
know,
unprecautive
unresponsive.
R
At
that
time,
the
mail
officer
came
in
started,
asking
him
for
an
id
asking
him
also
what
he
took
and
then
he
that
he
swung
and
punched
the
officer
at
that
time.
I
I
backed
away
the
ambulance.
Came
he
I
believe
he
kicked
the
paramedic
and
then
they
put
him
on
the
gurney
and
strapped
him
down
and
and
took
him
away.
It
was
a
very
bizarre
incident.
O
O
And
just
to
be
clear,
your
interaction
with
this
individual,
mr
karu
occurred
outside
the
licensed
premises
on
the
street.
Correct,
yes,
correct
and
mr
crew
was
was
taken
away
in
an
ambulance
to
a
local
hospital,
correct,
correct.
Yes,
I
have
no
further
questions
unless
members
of
the
board
have
questions
of
this
witness.
C
Are
you
aware
of
how
long
this
patron
was
inside
your
premise.
R
No,
I
was
outside
when
what
he
was
I
was
outside
when
I
saw
him
come
outside,
so
I
I
wasn't
sure.
C
Do
you
know
how
many
drinks
he
consumed
or
purchased
that
night
at
west
end
johnny's?
I
do
not
know
the
license.
Premise
was
written
up
for
over
service
of
a
patron.
Did
you
have
an
opportunity
to
review
any
credit
card
receipts
to
see
if
he
had
any
credit
cards
that
were
used
to
purchase
drinks?
That
night.
C
Okay,
I
don't
have
any
questions
any
more
questions
for
mr
roy.
R
Yeah,
I
asked
people
about
him,
but
nobody
had
any
recollection
of
one
in
particular
person
that
was
over
served.
I
remember
him
solely
because
of
the
interaction
that
I
had
with
him.
R
Yeah
I
can
yeah
they're
all
digital.
I
can
look
them
up,
but
that's
only
if
I
can
get
the
last
four
digits
of
his
credit
card.
O
Have
one
for
the
witness,
arthur
madeiras.
O
Good
good
morning,
mr
madeiros,
you
have
been
sworn
previously
yes
correct,
and
you
heard
the
the
testimony
of
lieutenant
detective
troy
in
this
matter
earlier.
Is
that
correct?
I
did.
K
O
S
Yeah
I
was
present.
I
do
recollect
the
recall
the
incident.
Rather
there
was
some
sort
of
disturbance
outside
in
the
street
on
the
sidewalk
across
from
from
the
premise
from
west
to
johnny's,
so
I
called
9-1-1.
S
The
officers
arrived
promptly
and
the
incident
was
was
was
taken
care
of
and
meanwhile
I
walked
over
to
the
door,
and
I
saw
dana
roy
talking
to
a
gentleman
who
was
sitting
on
the
ground
with
his
back
against
the
the
wall,
the
building
and
asked
dana
what
was
going
on
and
he
told
me
the
gentleman
had
just
come
out
and
something
was
wrong
with
him.
So
we
attempted
to
get
some
information
out
of
the
gentleman
to
find
out
what
happened.
S
What
was
wrong
with
him
if
he
had
friends
inside
and
he
was
conscious,
but
he
didn't
really
offer
much
information.
He
was
somewhat
like
dana
said
babbling
and
making
no
sense
at
all.
So
we
called
the
officers
over
and
said
you
know
something's
wrong
with
this
gentleman.
I
think
we
need
to
call
an
ambulance
and
from
there
on
it
just
you
know
he
he
attacked
the
officer
and
it
just
sort
of
went
downhill
from
there.
O
Did
you
witness,
did
you
witness
what
you
described
as
an
attack
on
the
officer?
I
do
not
witness
it
now.
Okay,
so
what's
your
position
with
west
ham,
johnny's.
S
Like
the
nightlife
manager.
O
Okay,
do
you
recall
seeing
mr
carew
who's
only
identified
as
karu
in
the
report?
Do
you
recall
seeing
this
gentleman
been
served
alcohol
on
the
premises
of
west
ham
johnnies
at
night
I
don't
know
and
who
called
the
police?
O
I
believe
I
called
okay
and,
and
are
you
the
same,
arthur
madeiras
that
the
police
officer
described
as
being
was
totally
cooperative
with
the
police
department
that
evening
correct?
That
would
be
me.
Yes,
you
you
showed
the
licenses
and
all
other
appropriate
documentation.
I
did
yeah
correct.
I
did
yes,
I
have
no
further
questions.
The
board
may
have
some
questions
of
you,
mr
medeiros.
Okay,.
A
Great
antonio
kelly
is
that
all
that.
O
Is
all
I
have
one
other
witness
present,
but
I
just
I
I
haven't
present
because
he
is
the
the
licensee
john
karen,
but
I'm
not
intending
to
to
call
mr
karen,
as
a
witness
we
just
just
haven't.
Have
him
present
for
the
purpose
of
the
hearing.
A
Thank
you
attorney
kelly.
There
are
no
further
questions
from
the
board.
Then
the
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement.
Thank
you.
Thank
you
now
calling
item
number
five
gsth
investment
group
llc
doing
business
as
bijoux
and
rock
and
rye
located
at
51,
stuart
street
date
of
the
incident
november;
5th
2021
persons
under
21
in
possession
of
alcohol
on
premise,
in
violation
of
mass
general
laws,
chapter
138,
section
34a,
34c
and
64-64a,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
U
Good
morning,
mr
secretary,
madam
chairman,
boyd
stephen
miller,
mcdermott,
quilty
and
miller
also
with
me
this
morning,
mate
aslan
who's,
the
general
manager
and
joe
ghanam,
who
was
one
of
the
managers
at
the
premises
that
evening.
V
W
A
F
Good
morning
I'll
be
reading
a
from
a
police
report
which
I
wrote
on
friday
november,
5
2021
shiny,
detective,
william
gallagher,
detective
hernandez
assigned
to
the
bpd
licensed
permission
and
conducted
a
license:
premise:
inspection,
a
b2
located
at
5153
stewart
street
in
boston.
While
detectives
were
walking
past
sabaria
detectives
are
three
female:
patrons
standing
at
the
barrier
with
alcoholic
drinks,
detectives
notice,
these
females
look
young
detective,
asked
them
to
produce
identification
to
confirm
their
ages.
Three
female
patrons
say
they
were
over
21
years
of
age
and
produced
driver's
license.
F
That
initially
appeared
as
though
they
were
all
over
21
years
of
age.
Detectives
used
the
license
verification
program,
which
confirmed
that
that
the
driver's
license
were
indeed
fraudulent.
The
frauds
and
drivers
licenses
contain
the
person's
name
but
display
the
date
of
birth
made.
It
appear,
so
they
were
over
21
years
of
age.
The
frauds
and
drivers
licenses
were
confiscated
by
detectives.
F
After
a
further
investigation.
Next
we
were
able
to
confirm
the
underage
identities
of
alexis,
weldner,
arula,
saminus
and
brook
film.
These
patrons
would
be
summoned
to
corporate
persons
under
21
personnel
and
possession
of
fraudulent
identification.
Detectives
brought
this
to
the
attention
of
the
person
in
charge.
Mr
joe
gaiman,
as
a
result
of
what
detectives
are
sergeant
detective
gallagher
issued
a
license.
Private
inspection
note
was
zero.
Six
zero,
three
zero
zero
persons
under
twenty
one
thousand.
U
Yes,
please
detective
was
mr
gannom
and
the
staff
cooperative
with
you
and
and
sergeant
gallagher.
Yes,.
U
U
F
Well,
they
didn't
they.
I
believe
they
have
one
now,
I'm
not
sure
if
they
had
one
that
night.
Okay,.
U
I
have.
I
have
a
video
which
I
apologize.
I
I
didn't
get
to
the
board
before
the
hearing,
but
I
can
have
it
delivered
over
this
morning,
showing
the
not
only
these
three
girls
and
the
exterior
of
the
premise
that,
with
having
their
ids
scanned
by
the
by
the
staff,
but
also
the
video,
goes
a
little
bit
longer
and
it
shows
other
members
of
the
public
trying
to
get
in
and
being
turned
away,
but
it
clearly
it
also
shows
the
three
women
in
the
in
the
premises
too.
U
Okay,
so
mr
aslan
you're,
there.
U
Okay,
oh
there
you
are
okay,
mr
aslan
or
mr
gannon.
Either
one
you've
been
sworn
you've
both
been
sworn
and
and
were
you
both
there
that
evening.
U
Y
He
asks
a
couple
questions
to
see
if
we
can
get
them
off
off
guard
the
holograms.
U
So
you
broke
up,
I
don't
know
if
the
board
heard
it,
but
you
you
basically
did
you
say
that
he
scans
the
id
and
he
also
asks
them
questions
and
he
also
checks
with
black
life,
a
hologram
before
he
scans.
It
is
that
correct.
U
U
Y
U
So
this
new
system-
you
refer
to
it
as
hid.
U
In
in
that
system
was
presented
to
you
for
consideration
that
at
least
I
I
shouldn't
say,
was
recommended
to
you
by
sergeant
gallagher
and
detective
hernandez
is
a
system?
That's
probably
the
most
most
reliable
is.
U
U
Besides
having
the
scanner
at
the
front
door,
you
can
also
have
a
scanner
at
each
bar
in
in
the
premises,
so
any
bartender
that
had,
even
though
everyone
was
scanned
to
get
into
the
premises.
If
any
bartender
had
concerns
as
to
the
age
of
the
person,
they
could
also
have
ask
them
for
their
ids
and
have
it
scanned.
U
Is
that
correct,
correct,
I
have
no
further
questions
of
of
either
either
person.
Does
the
board
have
any
would
like
to
ask
him
any
questions.
C
Just
so
I
know
you're
gonna
send
the
video
over.
So
the
testimony
today
is
that
these
three
individuals
were
scanned
at
the
door.
C
And
I
just
I'm
just
curious:
were
these
three
individuals
known
to
anyone
at
this
premise?
Were
they
familiar?
Were
they
regulars.
Y
C
So
it
sounds
like
the
video
that
you'll
send
over
today
will
demonstrate
that
all
ids
were
scanned
I'll,
take
a
look
at
it
myself.
Some
were
scanned
and
turned
away
so
you're.
I
think
you're
leading
us
to
believe
that
the
id
scanning
device
you
had
picked
up
on
some
fake
ids
but
may
not
have
picked
up
on
these
three.
Is
that
what
you're
saying.
U
Everybody
you
can
see.
You
can
see,
madam
chair,
that
when
the
people
walk
up
to
the
man
at
the
door,
he
has
a
black
light
which
he
takes
the
id
he
he
looks
at
their
face.
He
hits
the
black
light
to
check
for
the
holograms
and
then
he
turns
around
and
scans
the
id
in
the
machine,
and
then
he
decides
whether
they
they're
allowed
to
enter
the
premises
or
not.
I
These
fake
massachusetts,
ids
licenses.
I
Now,
and
did
the
to
the
addresses
on
the
licenses,
were
they
actually
the
addresses
of
the
individuals?
Do
you
know.
H
F
U
So
mate
or
you're
you're,
the
guy
checking
the
ids
with
familia
with
the
features
of
each
of
those
ids
to
make
sure
that
they
were
accurate,
well
accurate
other
than
the
fact
that
they
were
fraudulent
but
consistent
with
ids
from
those
jurisdictions
from
those
various
states.
Y
Yeah
consistent
with
the
imaging
yes.
U
A
U
U
You
know,
as
as
sergeant
gallagher
and
detective
hernandez,
have
informed
not
only
this
this
premise,
but
other
premises
that,
as
fast
as
these
scanning
devices
upgrade
their
systems
to
deal
with
fraudulent
that
the
fraudulent
ids
change.
So
the
the
the
system
that
they're
going
with
is
much
more
expensive.
But
it's
highly
recommended
by
the
not
only
the
boston
police
but
the
abcc.
A
U
A
Yep,
the
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement.
Thank
you
now
calling
item
number
six
fuente
cleaning
services
inc,
doing
business
as
belarus,
columbia
located
at
28
bennington
street
in
east
boston
date
of
the
incident
november.
6
2021
failure
to
adhere
to
licensing
board
guidelines
regarding
window
covering
in
violation
of
mass
general
law,
chapter
138,
section
64.,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
A
A
If
needed
great,
thank
you.
Can
you
please
all
raise
your
right
hand?
A
V
Yes,
on
11
6,
20
21
at
23,
20
hours,
massage
detective,
william
gallagher,
detective
eddie,
hernandez
assigned
to
the
licensed
premise
unit
conducted
a
licensed
premise:
inspection
in
belarus,
colombia
at
28
bennington
street
detectives,
were
aware
that
there
had
been
an
agreement
between
the
boston
licensing
board
in
belarus,
colombia
that
there
would
be
no
signs
of
coverings
of
premises,
front
windows,
an
id
scanner
and
security
plan
on
file.
This
agreement
allowed
belarus
and
several
other
licensed
premises
in
the
area
to
resume
normal
hours.
For
closing.
V
On
this
evening,
detectives
observed
the
front
windows
of
polaris
colombia
to
be
covered
with
an
adhesive
that
prevented
the
officers
from
looking
in
while
on
patrol.
As
a
result,
what
detectives
had
observed
assad
detective
gallagher?
Is
your
licensed
premise:
inspection
notice,
number,
zero,
four,
four
six
five
one
to
belarus,
colombia
for
failure
to
adhere
to
licensing
board
guidelines
regarding
window
covering
mr
fermi
restrepo,
signed
for
and
accepted
the
notice
attached
to
the
report.
V
AA
How
are
you
good
morning
so
when
the
officer
came,
I
asked
him
that
she
wanted
me
to
remove
him,
but
I
want
to
tell
the
board
why
we
have
them
up.
What
happened
was
back
in
2020
when
we
the
covet
hit
us,
we
had
to
close
down,
we
had
to
shut
down,
so
what
we
we
did
was
we
covered
the
windows
with
the
signs
saying
beginners
colombia
and
there
was
a
pool
so
that
people
could
remember
us
because
we
were
shut
down
for
13
months.
AA
So
we
just
wanted
to
put
a
picture
of
people.
Oh
that's
they're.
Still,
there
they're
still
there
because
we
were
shut
down.
We
couldn't
open
because
of
the
covert,
but
then
when
the
covert
came,
it
was
good
that
that
I
asked
the
officer
and
we
spoke
to
one
of
the
captains
which
I
don't
remember
his
name
but
he's
not
there,
and
we
told
him.
Do
you
mind
having
the
windows
like
this
and
he
advised
us
that?
No,
he
didn't
have
a
problem.
AA
He
had
a
problem
before
because
we
had
too
many
incidents,
but
now
he
didn't
have
a
problem
and
we
let
it
and
now
what
I'm
seeing
is
the
the
second
thing
that
I
wanted
to
address
the
board
is
that
when
people
they
say
they
don't
want
people
outside
outside
the
street.
They
want
everybody
to
clear
the
street
right
away
and
the
officer
sean,
which
is
one
of
the
officers
that
helps
us
at
night
time.
He
knows
that
people
go
and
they
just
peek.
They
look
inside
and
see
who's
there
and
they'll
wait
outside.
AA
So
that's
why
that's
another
thing
that
we
don't
want.
We
don't
want
people
to
pick
it
inside
and
they're.
Just
gonna
sit
outside
and
wait
for
people
to
come
out
the
club
to
see
where
they're
gonna
go.
They're
gonna
go
to
an
after
party,
but
if
the
board
wants
me
to
take
them
down,
I'm
more
than
happy
to
take
them
down.
But
to
to
my,
I
just
wanted
to
say
that
I
think
it's
better
like
that.
We
never
have
a
problem
with
the
police
they
can
come
in.
AA
The
officer
can
say
we
are
very
cooperative
with
them.
We
always
try
to
do
whatever
is
best
for
the
community
for
everybody
for
the
cops
for
us.
So
if
you
guys
want
me
to
take
it
down,
I
don't
have
a
problem
with
it,
but
I
think
the
the
way
it
is
is
that
that
people
are
not
outside
gathering
outside
and
waiting
for
other
people
to
come,
because
there's
actually
three
bars
right
next
to
each
other.
C
Have
questions
I
have
the
picture
in
front
of
me
here:
it's
attached
to
the
license
premise:
violation,
and
maybe
it's
for
detective
gallagher
sergeant
gallagher,
the
windows
I'm
looking
out
at
fro
on
the
front
where
it
says
the
bottom
lock
window
is
completely
covered
and
then
it
looks
like
I
don't
know
a
disco
ball
or
something
are
those
totally
opaque.
V
You
can't
see,
really,
you
can
probably
just
see
shadows
through
them
on
the
right
side
door.
There
were
some
political
signs,
it
was
an
election
year,
but
in
the
front
it
was
like
a
laminate
that
you
really
couldn't
look
in,
and
I
mean
this
goes
back
several
years
ago.
There
were
a
lot
of
incidents
down
there,
and
that
was
the
agreement.
They
rolled
back
the
premises,
hours
or
three
places,
and
this
was
one
of
them
and
in
order
for
these
guys
to
reopen,
they
had
to
adhere
to
that.
V
So
I
think
you
really
can't
see
in
it.
They've
changed.
We
haven't
had
any
problems
down
there,
which
is
good,
but
we
just
remember
what
the
old
rulings
were,
and
you
know
we
just
walked
in
and
talked
about
it
and
figured
the
board,
maybe
want
to
rehash
it.
C
V
Yes,
we
have,
we
have
had
to
talk
to
others
about
the
blinds
right
down
into
listen,
they
got
to
be
up,
and
sometimes
they
forget
sometimes
it
depends.
Who
opens.
You
know
right.
C
C
C
Okay,
well,
can
you
hear
me
now,
I'm
gonna,
let
the
other
commissioners
ask
some
questions,
but
in
general
I
would.
I
would
urge
you
not
to
make
any
changes
that
go
against
your
security
and
operations
plan
without
written
permission
of
the
board.
C
Them
down
we're
going
to
vote
on
thursday,
if
you
don't
mind
holding
on
I'm
going
to
let
commissioner
saxon
and
commissioner
curran
ask
you
some
questions:
should
they
have
any.
I
More
of
a
comment
just
that,
I
think
that
the
solution
to
people
may
be
peeking
in
and
hanging
outside,
really
lies
within
your
existing
duty
to
you
know:
police,
the
the
adjacent
area
of
your
of
your
place.
So,
if
that's
going
on,
I
think
you
have
to
work
that
out
with
your
staff
and
your
door
staff
not
cover
up
the
windows.
I
don't
know
covering
up
the
windows
whether
or
not
it's
going
to
be
voted
as
being
a
problem.
Still,
I
don't
think
covering
the
windows
is
a
solution
to
that
problem.
T
A
A
V
Yes,
on
11
8,
20
21
at
10,
20
p.m.
Sergeant,
william
gallagher,
detective
eddie,
hernandez,
signed
the
license
premise
unit
conducted
a
licensed
premise:
inspection
of
applebee's
restaurant
at
11a
all-state.
Road
aside,
the
premise
detectives
observed
two
young
looking
females
sitting
at
the
far
end
of
the
bar
with
two
cloud
glasses
of
what
detectives
discovered
to
be
doubled.
Shots
of
patron
tequila
detectives
approached
the
two
identified
themselves
as
bpd
offices
and
requested
ids
to
confirm
their
ages.
V
V
V
Mr
dude
stated
that
miss
mendes
is
his
baby's
mother,
and
he
knows
ms
pena
mr
dude
stated
he
didn't
ask
for
ids
because
he
knew
both
of
them
detectives
informed,
mr
dude,
that
persons
under
21
should
not
be
sitting
at
the
bar
with
alcohol
directly
in
front
of
them
all
young.
Looking
patients
must
display
an
actual
id,
not
a
picture
in
one's
phone
detectives
sought
out
the
manager,
ronnie
belzea
and
relayed
their
findings
to
him,
showing
him
what
they
had
discovered.
V
V
T
Yes,
thank
you,
members
of
the
board
and
thank
you
sergeant,
detective
gallagher
and
detective
hernandez,
two
things
that
I'd
like
to
bring
up
and
address.
If
I
could,
the
expired
entertainment
license
that
was
hanging
goes
underneath
the
current
in
the
permit
box,
which
was
taken
down
to
send
for
somebody
within
our
organization,
and
it
wasn't
put
back
correctly
so
the
next
day
the
current
was
posted
as
it
should
be.
T
So
we
are
also
up
to
date
through
the
end
of
2022
with
the
license,
but
I
think
it
was
a
matter
of
posting
taking
it
down
to
send
in
for
verification
within
our
organization,
and
then
we
forgot
to
simply
put
it
back
up
this.
C
Isn't
even
an
entertainment
violation
hearing
so
we're
just
focused
on
the
alcohol
violations.
T
Okay,
thank
you,
but
I
just
wanted
to
kind
of
explain
what
that
problem
was,
and
as
far
as
the
the
serving
of
the
minor
a
couple
of
things
that
I'd
like
to
just
bring
to
the
board's
attention.
First,
at
the
direction
of
sergeant
detective
gallagher
and
sergeant
hernandez,
we
did
implement
the
hid,
verification
intellicheck,
it's
a
great
tool
when
used
properly.
T
I
do
have
over
70
fake
ids
that
we've
confiscated,
so
we're
trying
to
do
our
due
diligence
by
taking
and
and
taking
ids
and
trying
to
prevent
you
know
miners
from
drinking.
T
As
far
as
our
employee
training
goes,
we
do
every
year
go
through
a
responsible
service
of
alcohol
training,
that's
a
combination
of
videos
as
well
as
tests,
so
we
try
to
hire
properly
trained
properly
and
and
make
sure
that
we
hold
them
accountable
to
standards
of
serving
proper
alcohol
and
responsive
responsible
service
of
alcohol.
T
I
think
what
we
have
here
is
a
situation
where
the
bartender
was
very
familiar
with.
The
patrons
unfortunately
chose
to
do
the
wrong
thing,
despite
having
the
knowledge
of
what
should
be
done,
broke
protocol
for
not
checking
the
identifications
certainly
broke
protocol
for
serving
a
minor,
and
for
that
he
was
terminated
immediately
upon
investigation
of
what
we
found
out.
So
I
don't
believe
that
there's
any
other
facts
that
I
could
bring
for
a
conversation,
but
I'd
certainly
open
up
for
any
questions
that
you
have.
C
Thank
you,
mr
gill,
so
you
now
have
a
scanner
system
in
place.
It.
T
Has
been
in
place
all
along,
unfortunately,
this
bartender
honestly.
I
believe
that
he
knew
the
patrons
and
chose
to
do
the
wrong
thing.
He
was
trying
to
do
it
and
in
the
moment,
because
he
I
believe
one
of
the
woman
was
the
mother
of
his
child.
They
came
in
for
takeout
that
night
they
weren't
even
into
the
bar.
They
might
have
recognized
him
as
the
bartender
came
in
and
that's
when
it
happened.
C
Okay
and
your
testimony
is
that
he
made
the
he
was
properly
trained,
but
he
made
the
wrong
decision
and
he
broke
protocol.
T
C
So
in
the
police
report
sergeant,
maybe
you
can
provide
a
little
more
color
to
this.
It
says
that
this
someone
apologized
for
the
way
the
other
staff
had
interjected
themselves
with.
It
sounds
like
a
fight
occurred
when
you
guys
are
iding
them
or
something.
V
Correct
they,
you
know
a
lot
of
times.
Deflection
is
probably
the
best
defense
and
they
started
you're
picking
on
us
and
some
of
the
staff
members
I
you
know,
I
feel
that
the
general
manager
here
is
correct.
This
was
sabotage
from
within
and
I
think
a
lot
of
the
employees
also
probably
knew
these
females
from
the
relationship
they
had
with
the
bartender
and
they
came
to
their
defense.
Okay,.
V
Manager,
we
talked
to
apologized
for
the
behavior,
he
noticed
what
was
going
on.
We
told
him
what
was
going
on
and
you
know
he
just
had
them
all
quiet
down
and
let
us
do
our
job,
but
we
were
outnumbered
at
first,
but
we
don't
take
it
personal.
C
A
Calling
item
number
eight
russian
benevolent
society
doing
business
as
crystal
restaurant
garage
room
located
at
14
to
20
linden
street
in
allston
date
of
the
incident
november;
15
2021
assault
and
battery
with
a
dangerous
weapon
and
gun
in
violation
of
mass
general
laws;
chapter
138,
section
64
and
chapter
265,
section
15a
assault
and
battery
patron
on
patron
in
violation
of
mass
general
laws:
chapter
138,
section
64.
in
chapter
265,
section;
13;
a
assault
and
battery
patron
employee
in
violation
of
mass
general
laws;
chapter
138,
section
64.
A
in
chapter
265,
section
13a;
failure
to
call
9-1-1
in
violation
of
mass
general
laws;
chapter
138,
section,
64
and
boards
rule
1.14
b;
and
failure
to
cooperate
with
police
in
violation
of
mass
general
laws.
Chapter
138,
section
64.
and
boards
rule
1.10
a
and
b,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
Z
Good
morning,
madam
chair
members
of
the
board
attorney
kurt
bledson
for
the
russian
benevolent
society.
I
also
have
with
me
alex
mattov,
who
is
the
manager
of
record
alex
shapiro,
who
was
a
manager
on
duty
that
night
and
jesse
omar?
Who
was
the
head
of
the
security
group
that
evening.
A
Thank
you
detective,
and
are
there
any
other
individuals
with
first-hand
knowledge
of
the
incident
who
wish
to
testify
on
this
matter
today?.
A
A
P
About
zero
zero:
three
five:
on
november
15,
2021
d14
officers
responded
to
20
linden
street
the
garage
for
a
report
of
a
person
shot
officers
in
ems
arrived
and
found
the
victim
suffering
from
a
gunshot
wound
to
the
face.
In
the
parking
lot,
the
victim
was
transported
to
the
mass
general
hospital
where
he
was
treated
for
his
injuries.
V
Bp
records
show
no
9-1-1
calls
were
placed
from
the
premise
to
bpd,
alerting
them
of
the
incident
and
staff
members
refused
to
identify
themselves
or
cooperate
in
the
first
stages
of
the
investigation
on
the
night
of
the
18th
bpd
officers
waited
at
20
linden
street
for
about
15
minutes
and
were
informed
that
the
manager
alex
mattov
would
not
be
showing
up.
Furthermore,
detectives
were
advised
to
contact
council
attorney
fred
blesser.
Should
there
be
any
further
questions.
V
Bpd
officers
were
also
made
aware
that
the
garage
would
be
closed
for
the
next
two
weeks.
As
a
result
of
this
incident.
In
what
detectives
had
learned
sergeant,
detective
gallagher
issued
a
license
premise:
inspection
notice,
number,
zero,
zero,
five,
three
two
four,
the
garage,
slash
wrestling
benevolent
society
for
assault
and
battery
dangerous
weapon
times
two
assault
and
battery
patron
on
assault
and
battery
patron
or
employee,
and
failure
to
call
9-1-1
failure
to
cooperate
with
police.
This
inspection
notice
will
be
mailed
to
mr
alex
matov
manager
of
russian
benevolent
society.
20
linden
street
austin
mass
02134.
Z
V
Z
But
there
was,
there
were
cell
phone
calls
made
to
the
bpd
that
evening
correct,
I
believe
they
were
were
you.
Do
you
have
a
log
of
the
diamond
one
calls
that
were
made
to
the
station
out
onto
9-1-1?
I
do
not
have
that.
Sir
okay.
X
X
Mcafee
here
I
do
have
a
log
and
I
I
call
just
about
every
911
caller
on
that
catchy.
X
I
have
to
go
back
and
check
my
my
records,
I'm
not
in
the
office
today,
I'm
actually
on
vacation.
Z
I
do
have
for
the
board.
I
do
have
a
log
which
I
will
send
in
from
alex
shapiro,
who
was
the
manager
on
duty
that
night,
with
a
9-1-1
call
at
12
30
a.m
and
the
police
report.
The
police
responded
to
a
radio
call
at
12
35.
I've
just
been
able
to
obtain
that.
So
I
will
scan
that
and
send
that
into
the
board.
Z
And
detective
gallagher
was
there
any
other
follow-up
with
the
establishment
after
the
appointment
on
11
18?
Do
you
have
knowledge,
not.
Z
Detective,
mccarthy,
you
yeah
you
did
you
respond
that
evening?
You
responded
that
evening.
Correct.
Z
You
do
not
respond
to
the
establishment
nope
and
after
the
incident
the
next
day
you
had
conversations
with
the
manager
alex
shapiro,
correct
right
and
you
went
to
the
establishment
the
next
day
and
went
through
and
he
took
you
through
and
went
over
the
incident
that
day
correct.
Z
Z
Yes,
sir,
and
you
were
also
given
joe
sweeney's
information,
who
is
the
I.t
guy
for
the
for
the
establishment,
correct,
that's
right
and
mr
sweeney
provided
you
with
a
videotape,
and
he
also
provided
you
with
the
actual
recorder
for
the
establishment,
correct.
X
We
had
to
seize
the
recorder
because
the
video
that
mr
sweeney
had
provided
lacked
what
I
believe
to
be
key
moments
in
the
incident.
It
was,
it
was
incomplete
and
not
all
the
footage
I
had
asked
for.
Z
Z
Z
X
That
is
still
being
analyzed
by
our
department
specialists.
X
X
X
X
Z
X
Okay,
because
he
didn't
get
me
what
I
needed-
and
I
contacted
him
well
over
a
month
ago
about
a
list
of
his
employees
and
he
seemed
kind
of
dismissive.
X
Yeah,
but
I
would
think
that
mr
ormata,
you
know
being
a
business
owner,
would
realize
the
gravity
of
the
situation
and
would
think
as
soon
as
I
get
back
to
boston,
I
think
would
be
important
to
reach
out
to
this
detective
to
to
get
him
what
he
needs
to
conduct.
This
investigation.
Z
After
that
phone
call.
Z
Okay,
if
I
may
have
mr
omad
testified.
K
AB
Hello,
excuse
me:
I'm
the
owner
of
the
contractor
for
garage
boss.
Z
And
were
you
there
on
the
night
of
the
incident
that
this
violation
hearing
is
for
november
15th,
the
night.
Z
And
what
happened
inside?
That
was
the
cause
of
the
initial
incident
inside.
AB
AB
That's
when
they
got
a
little
abrasive
and
got
physical
between
some
groups.
We
dispersed
the
groups
which
we
left
one
half
of
the
problem
inside
and
escorted
the
other
half
out.
We
don't
send
both
parties
out
because
then
that
causes
problems
within
the
outside.
So
as
we
kept
one
in
the
other
half,
we
made
sure
that
they
left.
AB
Well,
at
that
point
in
time,
like
I
said,
we
escorted
the
other
side
away
from
the
premises
and
kept
the
other
side
in
at
that
point
in
time,
people
were
still
upset.
So
that's
when
we
decided
to
end
the
night
before
anything,
escalated.
Z
All
right
did:
did
the
lights
go
on
and
close
close
the
establishment
at
that
point.
AB
AB
Oh
yes,
in
and
outside
we
have
security
at
the
door
outside
and
inside.
AB
Outside
I
guess
another
argument
had
dispersed
from
some
of
the
people
that
were
talking
stated
that
some
guys
came
from
out
of
the
parking
lot
and
came
back
down
the
walkway
and
shortly
after
maybe
some
words,
a
blow
was
thrown
and
then
a
shot
required.
AB
AB
We
tried
to
give
medical
attention
to
the
person
that
was
actually
shot
and
get
everybody
else
off.
The
premises.
AB
I
believe
it
was
two
from
what
I
heard
it
went
through.
One
patron
shoulder
and
hit
the
second
person
in
the
mouth.
AB
Well,
the
person
I
got
shot
in
the
shoulder,
I
believe
they
took
this
out
to
the
hospital,
so
we
tried
to
help
the
the
second
patron
that
actually
got
hit
in
the
mouth
he
was
kind
of
out
of
it.
You
know
he
was
running
around
and
moving
we're
trying
to
get
him
to
sit
down
which,
eventually
you
know
he
kind
of
collapsed
and
stayed
in
one
place.
AB
AB
When
they
first
got
there,
I
approached
them.
I
let
them
know
who
I
was
and
what
they
needed
from
me.
They
asked
me
a
few
questions,
which
was:
where
did
it
happen?
I
showed
them
the
area
where
it
happened.
They
asked
me
questions
as
far
as
did
anyone
see
the
firearm,
what
it
looked
like
and
then
we
pretty
much
was
just
searching
the
area
for
shelves
at
that
point
in
time
I
asked
the
rest
of
my
security
to
continue
to
disperse
the
area.
Z
Okay
and
did
the
did
the
area
disperse
at
that
point,
did
all
the
pain.
AB
For
the
most
part,
yes,
I
would
say
over
90
of
everyone
was
gone
at
that
point
in
time
there
were
still
a
few
lingering,
like
I
said
they
were
the
ones
taking
the
videos,
but,
as
bpd
was
trying
to
get
rid
of
them,
we
also
helped
them
get
rid
of
those.
Last
few
stragglers,
okay,.
Z
And
then
at
some
point
were
all
the
patrons
dispersed.
AB
Yes,
there
really
wasn't
any
patrons
left,
it
was
more
just
the
employees
and
maybe
a
couple
promoters,
but
for
the
most
part
everyone
was
gone.
Okay,.
AB
Z
And
did
anybody
take
any
witness
statements
of
any
of
any
of
the
of
the
patrons
prior
to
dispersing
them.
AB
Not
of
my
knowledge,
like
I
say,
stated,
they
were
more
concerned
with
finding
a
shell
casing
and
getting
people
out
of
the
area
which,
like
I
stated
we
we
helped
them
do
so
well.
I.
Z
Okay,
and
was
the
person
that
got
shot
able
to
identify
who
the
shooter
was.
AB
Well,
my
knowledge,
no,
he
wasn't
necessarily
coherent
enough
to
really
speak.
He
was
kind
of
like
in
and
out
and
he
was
bleeding
profusely
from
the
mouth.
AB
Not
to
my
knowledge
like
there
were
so
many
things
going
on
like
I
said,
we
were
more
focused
on
clearing
the
area
and
getting
the
emt
emt
to
be
able
to
come
in
and
help
him.
So
there
wasn't
much
talking
as
far
as
asking.
I
don't
know
if
they
asked
him,
but
that
wasn't
something
that
was
to
my
knowledge.
AB
Z
And
how
many
staff
members
did
you
have
on
duty
that
night.
Z
Okay
and
then
at
some
point,
did
the
yellow
tape
go
up.
As
you
said,.
AB
AB
Z
And
did
your,
did
your
employees
give
you
their
information.
AB
They
did,
it
did
take
a
few
minutes
because
there
was
a
another.
I
don't
know
if
he
was
a
patron
or
a
promoter,
but
they
were
having
an
altercation
with
him,
so
they
kind
of
put
us
to
the
side
because
they
were
arguing
with
that.
Other
person.
AB
AB
Well,
the
the
issue
is,
he
asked,
was
you
know
he
suspected
of
committed
a
crime?
Is
he
being
detained?
They
told
him?
No,
so
he
said
well,
if
that's
the
case,
then
I
don't
need
to
identify
myself.
So
that's
where
the
standoff
came
in
here.
AB
I
want
to
say
it
lasted
over
half
an
hour,
45
minutes,
because
I
stood
there
and
waited
in
the
rain
just
to
kind
of
help.
With
the
situation,
I
was
actually
even
telling
him.
You
know
just
give
your
information
and
he
was
just
adamant
on
not
giving
it
so
I
was
actually
talking
to
him
because
I
known
him
from
around
the
area,
and
he
just
didn't
want
to
do
so.
So
I
know
I
eventually
I
had
to
leave,
and
I
was
there
for
at
least
half
an
hour
during
that
standoff.
AB
Z
Okay,
did
you
have
follow-up
conversations
with
detective
mccarthy.
Z
AB
I
had
that
one
conversation
with
him
in
texas
and
that's
what
I
wanted
to
clear
up
that
that
I
felt
was
something
incorrect
when
I
told
him
that
I
was
in
texas
and
I
gave
him
one
of
he
asked
me
some
questions
the
same
things
that
you're
asking
me.
I
gave
him
all
that
information.
He
did
state
that
he
wanted
to
get
the
names
of
the
people
that
were
working,
but
he
stated
since
I
was
out
of
town.
When
was
I
coming
back?
AB
I
told
him
then,
when
I
was
coming
back
in
a
few
days
and
he
stated
that
he
would
reach
back
out
to
me
when
I
was
back
in
town
so
that
I
can
get
that
information.
I
never
received
any
follow-up
calls,
so
I
wasn't
supposed
to
contact
him.
He
said
he
was
going
to
contact
me
because
I
gave
him
the
date
that
I
was
coming
back
and
he
said
that
we'll
go
further
from
there.
AB
Z
All
right,
thank
you,
alex
shapiro.
If
I
may,
it
was
avoid
asked
alex
shapiro
a
couple
questions
alex
you're
there.
AC
AC
Z
Z
And
that's
the
that's
the
sheet
that
you
were
able
to
get
this
morning,
which
shows
in
your
phone
maybe
that
your
phone
made
a
12
30
a.m,
call
at
11
15
to
911.,
correct!
Yes,
okay
and
you
had
a
two
minute
conversation
with
the
operator
correct.
AC
Z
Z
And
you
went
through
what
had
happened
that
evening
and
took
him
for
a
tour
through
the
through
the
establishment,
correct.
AC
Z
AC
Admittedly,
I
got
tied
up
in
a
family
emergency.
I
then
texted
him
and
asked
him
to
contact
my
attorney
to
set
up
another
meeting
to
which
she
responded
so
you're
not
coming
tonight.
I
said
no,
I'm
sorry.
I
was
really
tied
up
and
I
never
heard
anything
else.
Although
I
was
cooperative
and
still
am.
Z
And
you
you
were
aware
that
joe
sweeney
who's
rit
guy
was
going
to
give
the
vcr
machine
to
the
boston
police,
correct,
correct.
All
right.
You
guys
did
that
at
their
request,
correct.
AC
AC
Z
Thank
you
again.
The
I
will
send
in
to
the
board
the
911
caller
was
made
from
alex's
phone.
I
will
represent
that.
That
is
his
number.
I
didn't
ask
him
that,
but
I
have
called
that
number
many
times.
The
number
that
I'm
going
to
send
you
in
the
610
number
is
his
telephone
number
and
it
shows
a
12
30
call
to
call
to
the
individuals
all
all
cooperated
that
evening.
There
was
an
incident
that
occurred
that
escalated
outside
whether
the
individual
that
did
the
shooting
was
in
the
bar.
Z
We
aren't
sure
we
can't
tell
from
the
video,
although
I'm
sure
the
detectives
will
be
able
to
determine
that
there
was
a
subsequent
video
that
I
gave
to
detective
gallagher.
That
shows
actually
shows
the
shooting
the
videotape
was
given
to
the
boston
police.
The
establishment
cooperated
with
the
police
that
night
and
continues
to
cooperate
today.
Whatever
else
they
need
we're
happy
to
happy
to
give
to
them.
Z
Z
How
this
happened
obviously
is
depending
on
the
people
that
came
in
there
that
evening,
it's
an
unfortunate
incident
that
happened
and
we
will
continue
to
to
cooperate
with
the
police.
Whatever
else
we
need
to
do
at
this
point,.
P
I
missed
a
paragraph
from
the
police
report
where
the
second
victim
self-applied
to
brigham
women's
hospital
with
the
gunshot
wound
that
was
mr
jermaine
cohen,
six,
eight
ninety-one
and
that
evening,
when
we
responded
there,
we
weren't
aware
of
a
second
victim,
and
it
seems
at
this
time
that
that
security
gentleman
was
aware
that
there
was
a
second
victim
and
we
we
were
not
made
aware
of
that
until
at
least
an
hour
after
the
incident,
when
this
gentleman
self-applied
and
called
the
police
and
detective
mccarthy
went
from
mass
general
to
the
brigham
to
interview
the
second
victim
and
the
gentleman
also
said
that
we
asked
him
to
escort
everybody
out
without
we
were
getting
everybody's
names
and
identification
as
witnesses.
P
That's
where
the
incident
happened
with
the
promoter
where
he
would
not
give
his
name
and
wouldn't
give
us,
wouldn't
help
us
out
as
a
witness.
That's
why
he
held
the
whole
crowd
up,
so
we
weren't
asking
them
to
get
rid
of
the
whole
crowd.
We
wanted
to
get
everybody's
name
every
possible,
witness
there
so,
and
he
mentioned
that
they
were
there
filming
social
media
stuff
and,
if
he's
aware
of
any
social
media,
stuff
it'd
be
nice.
P
If
we
could
hand
that
over
to
us,
because
we're
not
aware
of
any
social
media
stuff
besides
the
stuff
that
attorney
blessing
gave
us
like
two
days
ago,
but
which
shows
the
actual
shooting.
Z
Yeah,
that's
that's
the
only
video
that
we've
been
able
to
obtain
that
somebody
ended
up
sending
to
to
us
through
one
of
the
promoters,
but
they
were
when
we.
P
Say:
social
media?
Your
security,
gentlemen,
is
aware
of
more.
L
Z
P
Videos
he's
aware
of
he,
it
seems
like
he
knows
a
lot
of
those
people
there
and
he
can
reach
up
with
people
that
he
knows
and
provide
us
with
the
videos
you
know,
because
he
he
knew
everybody
there.
He
knew
the
general
the
promoter
who
wouldn't
give
us
his
name.
P
Z
AB
K
AB
Z
P
You
have
any,
you
can
just
share
with
us.
That's
fine!
Another
thing
in
the
were
there
two
fights
in
the
club
before
the
shooting.
P
P
What
was
in
front
of
like
the
dj
booth
and
one
was
up
in
the
private
section
right.
AB
P
AB
AB
AB
Z
Z
AB
Z
Z
X
And
one
more
question
for
mr
omad
and
and
I'll
ask
you
attorney
blitzer
since
you're
representing
mr
shapiro,
based
on
witness
interviews
I
conducted
it
seems
to
be
that
each
promoter
had
brought
in
their
own
kind
of
security
detail.
Is
that
true.
Z
The
promoter
had
a
couple
of
guys
at
the
door
with
them.
Yes,.
X
Okay,
so
there
were
two
separate
security:
there
was
mr
omad
security
company,
and
then
they
were,
there
were
others
with
the
promoter
that
were
assigned
to
security
as
well.
Z
C
P
I
want
them
to
share
whatever
they
can
share
with
us
if
they
get
any
social
media
video
or
they
cannot
identify
anybody.
P
P
Z
We
I
I
did
speak
to
joe
sweeney
about
that.
Joe
sweeney
has
no
idea
what
the
issue
was.
That
was
why
he
gave
the
machine
over
to
the
bpd
to
see
if
they
can
figure
out
why
there
are
gaps
in
it
because
there
are
gaps.
I
don't
he
doesn't
know
why
and
he's
the
only
person
that
deals
with
the
video
nobody
else
in
the
place
really
knows
how
to
use
it.
Z
It's
it's
locked
upstairs
in
the
in
the
building
and
runs
all
the
security
throughout
the
whole
building,
because
there
are
other
other
tenants
in
the
building.
There's
a
daycare
in
there
and
some
other
some
other
people
that
are
in
there.
So
no
idea
on
the
video
issue,
but
whatever
other
video
we
have
we'll
certainly
give
to
the
dpd.
C
Thank
you.
I
want
to
jump
in
and
like
leave
it
open
for
anyone
from
boston
police
to
jump
into
if
any
other
questions
arise
during
the
commissioner's
questioning.
So
just
so,
I'm
clear,
alex
shapiro
was
the
manager
on
duty
that
night.
Z
No,
I
think
they
would.
They
had
been
talking
to
alex
shapiro
they're,
actually
talking
they
were
talking
to
alex
shapiro.
I
think
I
think
they
thought
it
was
alex.
Mattov.
C
Okay,
mr
matavir,
here
on
the
hearing.
Q
C
Okay,
I
just
want
to
reiterate
your
responsibility
as
the
manager
of
record
for
this
license
premise:
you
need
to
be
familiar
with
the
rules
and
regulations
of
this
board,
the
abcc
and
the
laws
of
the
commonwealth.
You
also
need
to
cooperate
with
boston
police
on
any
investigation
or
any
boston
police
agent.
You
need
to
tell
your
in
advise
and
train
your
employees
to
cooperate
with
boston
police.
C
Q
Yeah
everybody
who's
been
hired
by
the
company,
been
gone
through
the
process
of
getting
to
know
the
police
getting
all
the
policies
what
they
need
to
do.
We've
been
in
business
for
quite
a
while
and
done.
I
think
everybody
has
has
gone
through
the
through
the
process.
Q
And
we
have-
and
we
always
done
it-
our
security
camera
has
been
used
by
district
14
for
several
times
for
several
occasions
throughout
the
years
on,
under
related
incidences
to
to
our
establishment.
So
we've
been
always
cooperating
with
police.
C
Okay
in
district
14,
you
know
this
license.
Premise
has
been
a
focal
point.
It
seems
I
don't
have
all
the
the
call
logs
in
front
of
me,
but
it
seems
that
this
has
resulted
in
extra
police
attention
at
this
location,
especially
since,
especially
you
know,
last
fall
winter
during
this
time.
What
are
you
doing,
mr
matov,
to
not
make
this
a
central
local
focus
point
of
boston,
police
attention.
Q
Well,
we
we've
been
diligently
working
to
make
sure
that
we're
not
we're
not
taking
police
in
this
14th
time,
precious
time
that
they
have.
We
have
decided
to
shut
down
the
facility
for
until
further
notice
until
we
figure
out
v
and
potentially
change
some
of
the
staff
members
and
returning
to
policies.
C
Q
We
don't
have
this
plan
at
this
point
at
this
point,
we're
concentrating
on
hiring
good
staff
members
and
revisiting
our
policies.
C
Okay-
and
I
want
to
thank
detective
mccarthy
for
taking
time
on
his
vacation
for
to
join
us,
because
it
was
very
difficult
for
us
to
get
this
hearing
scheduled.
I
just
want
to
ask
sergeant
detective
gallagher
or
detective
hernandez.
Do
you
have
anything
you'd
like
to
add
before
we
move
on
to
the
other
commissioners
for
any
questions
they
might
have.
V
That
night
in
question,
we
made
time
to
go
out
there
to
to
assist
district
14,
and
it
was
only
after
that
they
thought
that
they
weren't
getting
their
fair,
shake
and
getting
the
information
they
needed,
and
everyone
was
there
and
you
know
they
just
they
failed
to
show.
We
had
to
issue
the
lpv
via
mail,
which
we've
never
really
done
before
you
know
things
could
have
worked
better.
I
think
district
14
is
still
looking
for
information
and
this
happened
quite
a
while
ago.
V
So
I
think
the
facts
basically
speak
for
themselves.
F
I
apologize
no,
no,
I
mean,
I
think
it
does
speak
for
itself.
It's
been
a
very
uncooperative.
Let's
see,
it
appears.
C
Okay,
before
I
move
on
to
the
other
commissioners
attorney
bletzer
would
you
I
know
you
have
been
working
with
boston
police,
but
if
there's
anything
else,
you
or
your
client
or
their
contractors
can
do
to
help
with
this
investigation.
I
know
you
will.
I
hope,
you'll
continue
to
do
so,
but
I'm
going
to
move
to
commissioner
saxon
and
commissioner
curran
to
see
if
they
have
any
questions
about
about
the
licensed
premise.
Inspection.
That's
before
us
today,.
I
Z
We
do
we
had,
and
we've
had
conversations
with
jsg
security
and
they've
actually
been
pretty
good.
I
thought
they
did
a
pretty
good
job
with
cooperating
that
night
and.
I
I
think
I'm
more
concerned
with
the
this
promoter
or
tj.
I
don't
know
what
he
was,
but
he
clearly
wasn't
following
our
expectations
and
in
the
language
you're
telling
me
that
it
would
have
been
in
an
agreement
when
you
hired
him.
Z
Nor
hours,
and
obviously,
as
we've,
had
conversations
with
the
board
and
I've
had
with
all
of
the
establishments.
I
represent
the
promoters
because
cause
a
big
problem
for
all
of
us
because
they
do
what
they
want
to
do,
and
we
make
it
clear
to
these
people
that
they
have
to
listen
to
us
and
cooperate
with
us.
Z
We're
not
really
sure
the
guy
blew
who
he
was.
I
think
he
was
with
the
promoter
we're
still
trying
to
get
to
the
bottom
of
that
part,
but
I
think
the
police
ended
up
knowing
who
he
was
from
something
else
that
had
happened.
I
think
he's
actually
a
boston
school
teacher,
but
he
was
a
real
problem.
That
night
really
gave
up
gave
a
hard
time.
I
think
decided
to
detective.
Salute
you
that
night,
which
was
totally
unwarranted.
I
Well,
thank
you,
I'm
sorry.
My
recollection
is
and
I'm
looking
at
the
our
docket
this
this
premises
had
a
shooting
in
the
parking
lot
in
2018.
You
recall
that.
Z
I
Z
Yeah
we
screened
them
the
way
this
this
person,
my
understanding
from
this
particular
incident,
was
this.
Guy
came
back
down,
came
back
down
the
driveway
with
the
weapon,
we're
not
really
sure
how
or
why
or
you
know.
If
somebody
was
coming
to
pick
somebody
up
but
yeah,
they
they
pat
down
at
the
door.
Our
security
does
all
that
to
make
sure
nobody
has
weapons,
we
don't
have
a
metal
detector,
but
we
do
have.
We
do
have
steps
in
place
to
pat
pat
frisk
people
for
weapons.
I
Can
you
describe
to
me
one
of
like
the
details
that
lead
you
to
believe
that
that
was
what
happened
here?
It
was
a
video
was
a
witness
testimony.
Z
Z
I
think
it
was
just
somebody
believing
or
surmising
that's
what
must
have
happened.
We
don't
know
for
a
fact
we're
not
really
sure
where
it
comes
from
the
most
recent
video
that
we
just
gave
to
I
just
gave
to
detective.
Gallagher
was
just
a
quick
10.
Second
cell
phone
video,
which
shows
the
shooter
go
out
of
the
picture
and
come
back
in
with
a
gun
and
take
a
shot.
Z
And
trust
me,
nobody
touched
the
video,
but
there
was
nothing
in
it
for
us
to
touch
the
video
after
the
establishment,
the
video
guy
joe
sweeney's,
the
only
guy
that
touches
it
has
anything
to
do
with
it.
He
has
no
idea
as
to
why
things
cut
out
when
they
cut
out.
We've
had
trouble,
we've
had
trouble
in
the
past,
but
we've
got
good
video
all
throughout
the
place
inside
and
outside.
Z
Well,
I
think
we
can
tell
I
think,
with
the
latest
video
I
think
the
detective's
in
a
better
position
to
be
able
to
identify
the
guy.
That's
ultimately
the
shooter,
because
you
can
see,
I
think
you
can
see
who
the
person
wants
to
do
the
shooting.
So
it
should
be
easy
to
see
him
whether
he
comes
out
of
the
club
or
comes
down
the
driveway
from
the
prior,
the
just
for
some
reason,
the
there's
a
period
right
before
the
shooting
and
during
the
shooting
that's
blank
for
a
period
of
time.
X
That
video,
it
skips
intermittently
throughout
playback
a.
B
So
this
this
is
a
problem
that
has
occurred
with
the
video
equipment
before.
Z
It
had
before
we've,
we
thought
we
had
it
fixed.
We
thought
it
was
all
fixed
and
we
put
more
cameras
in.
We
actually
put
more
cameras
in
at
the
request
of
district
14
to
get
this
whole
area
down
our
driveway
and
get
all
the
entire
parking
lot.
And
then
we
also
have
the
fault.
We've
got
a
street
scene
too,
to
get
more
of
the
street,
because
there's
been
incidents
that
have
come
through
there
not
related
to
our
place.
I
And
getting
back
to
the
timeline
once
again
for
whoever
can
answer
the
the
altercation
that
happened
inside
was
what
was
the
timing
versus
the
shootings
like?
Was
there
minutes
gap
in
between
no
gap,
or
was
it
overlapped?
What
is
the
time?
Because
I
don't
I-
it
was.
Z
I
X
It
in
detective
mcgann
I'd
like
to
point
out
that
the
video
footage
from
the
the
best
footage
we
have
from
the
outside
that
does
show
people
walking
out
with
drinks
people
in
the
crowd
still
with
drinks
in
their
hands.
Y
X
I
Z
It
was
it
was
what
happened
was
when,
when
we
took
the
when
we
took
the
individual
off
of
the
table,
he
pushed
one
of
our
security
guys
who
fell
and
hid
and
cut
himself
when
he
felt
that
spilled
over
into
the
group
next
door.
There
was
some
pushing
and
shoving
some
some
punches
thrown.
They
were
separated.
That's
when
we
turned
the
lights
on
and
closed
the
place
down
and
cleared
the
place
out.
At
that
point,.
I
All
right,
so
you
had
an
incident
where
one
of
your
employees
was
assaulted
and
cut.
There
were
punches,
thrown
and
and
from
getting
back
to
the
point
the
detective
made.
There
was
at
least
five
minutes
between
that
incident
and
a
shooting
where
there
was
ample
opportunity
to
call
9-1-1,
because
that
incident
sounds
serious
enough
to
me.
Call
9-1-1
and
it
wasn't
so
the
police
weren't
there
and
or
on
their
way.
And
then
we
had
a
shooting,
correct.
I
Z
B
B
Jesse,
okay,
sorry
so
jesse
can
you
describe
the
person
who
told
you
that
you
could
clear?
Was
it
a?
Was
it
a
police
officer?
Would
you
just.
AB
As
I
was
police
officer
like
I
stated
so,
we
were
clearing
the
area.
Everybody
was
going
home
as
the
police
were
coming
up,
the
driveway,
I
greeted
them
and
told
them.
I
am
the
head
of
security.
This
is
where
the
situation
happened.
Whatever
you
need
we're
here.
AB
I
pointed
out
even
a
couple
of
my
other
guys
that
were
there
and
he
asked
for
us
to
clear
the
area
we
continued
cleaning,
the
area,
one
or
two
of
them
went
over
and
they
assisted
the
the
gunshot
victim
and
the
rest
of
us
were
clearing
out
the
area.
I
even
took
a
minute
or
two
to
help
them
find
the
showcases.
AB
A
few
moments
later,
one
of
the
officers
said
the
captain's
coming
on
here
or
the
sergeant.
I
can't
remember
what
he
said.
He
said
whatever's
left
here
when
a
yellow
tape
goes
up,
he's
going
to
be
scared,
so
me
and
him
actually,
since
there's
so
many
cameras,
you'll,
probably
even
see
me
and
the
officer
go
in
the
building
and
get
people
out
of
the
building.
AB
One
or
two
of
those
officers
walked
in
the
building
with
me
and
told
me
that
we
need
to
get
everybody
out
so
when
the
altercation
happened,
but
the
verbal
match
happened
with
blue
and
the
other
captains
that
were
there,
everybody
was
pretty
much
gone
at
that
time.
It
was
only
a
few
workers
there.
There
wasn't
any
group
for
anyone
to
get
any
witness
statements
or
anything
of
that
nature.
It
was
only
the
few
handful
of
people
there
left
and
he
had
the
problem
with
them
because
he
wanted
to
go
home.
AB
P
W
AB
P
AB
Most
most
of
mostly
everybody
was
kind
of
already
feathered
out
and
gone
like
I
stated,
there
was
mostly
a
handful
of
people
that
was
still
there.
A
couple
of
them
were
trying
to
take
videos
and
we
moved
them
away
from
the
area
so
that
emt's
mayweather
come
in
and
assist
us
the
gunshot
victim,
mostly.
AB
Like
I
stated
when
we
kicked
everybody
out
of
the
club
after
the
first
altercation,
what
happened
is,
is
everybody
was
feathering
out?
It
wasn't
like
we
were
out
there
kicking
all
these
witnesses
out.
People
were
still
running,
people
were
leaving
the
few
that
stayed.
There
were
the
ones
trying
to
take
the
videos,
and
there
was
only
that
one
person
that
was
still
on
the
ground.
The
officers
were
pulling
up.
No
one
stopped
anybody
from
leaving
out
the
walkway.
The
officers
walked
through
the
group
and
came
into
the
gate.
P
To
work
on
that
on
our
spot,
but
I'm
having.
AB
AD
AB
P
I
know,
but
is
your
recollection,
like
five
minutes
before
the
shooting
was
the
fighting
on
the
floor?
P
AB
That's
what
I'm
saying
to
you.
I
don't
know
the
accuracy
of
that,
but
there
were
still
people
in
the
building
dealing
with
they
were
dealing
with.
That's
why
me
and
the
officer
went
in
the
building
and
he
told
me
to
get
everyone
that
that
that
doesn't
need
to
be
here
out
of
the
building,
there's
still
people
in
there,
but
the
the
majority
of
the
crowd
was
gone
and
the
officers
were
pulling
up.
No
one
stopped
nobody
put
out
in
tape.
No
one
stopped
anybody
for
walking
this
walkway.
AB
The
first
thing
I
did
was
announce
myself
to
the
first
officer
that
I
ran
into
and
I
helped
them
look
for
the
showcases
they
asked
me
do.
Can
I
can
I
identify
with
the
gun?
Look
like
I
told
them.
No,
I
wasn't
out
here
for
the
shot.
I
don't
know.
If
he's
a
revolver,
I
don't
know
if
it
was
a
semi-automatic,
they
asked
them
what
shots.
I
said
I
heard.
P
Did
you
tell
anybody,
did
you
tell
any
of
those
officers
that
the
gentleman
was
shot
in
the
shoulder
before,
because
I
wasn't
aware
of
that
that
night?
Oh.
P
AB
AB
P
AB
P
C
Q
C
Q
I
believe,
then
I'll
give
you
the
phone
number.
I
believe
you
do
have
my
phone
numbered,
but
just
in
case
617.
C
Q
I
have
been
contacted
before
so
that
gives
me
that
as
I'm
thinking-
but
I
just
gave
it
to
you
again.
C
A
C
Q
One
of
our
associates
she's.
Currently
she
is
a
human
resource.
Q
A
A
We
will
now
take
a
second
call
for
item
number,
one
on
the
agenda
now
calling
955
llc
doing
business
as
dylan's,
located
at
951
boylston
street
date
of
the
incident
october.
31St
2021
patron
patron
assault
and
violation
of
mass
general
chapter
138,
section
64
chapter
265,
section
13,
a
an
expired
assembly
permit
in
violation
of
mass
general
laws,
chapter
138,
section
64
and
boards
rule
1.02
b,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee
william.
A
W
A
I
do
great
thank
you,
and
could
you
please
proceed
with
the
police
report.
A
E
Upon
arrival
officer,
marshall
delta
499
alpha
was
on
scene
speaking
to
victims
victim
number
one
later
identified.
As
zachary
jordan
stated,
he
was
involved
in
a
verbal
dispute
in
the
bar,
which
led
to
a
fight
outside
victim
number.
One
jordan
stated
that
the
unknown
suspect
hit
him
two
times
to
the
left
side
of
the
face.
With
his
palm
officers
observed
no
visible
injuries.
Victim
number
one
declined
boston,
ems
victim.
E
No
one
stated
that
the
suspect
identified
himself
as
bouncer
for
the
bar
and
an
off-duty
police
officer
pick
number
two
later
identified
as
sophia,
typically
that
she
was
trying
to
figure
out
why
the
unknown
suspect
was
fighting
with
her
boyfriend,
jordan
from
the
suspect
shoving
her
causing
over
her
head
on
the
light
pole
officers
observed
no
visible
injuries.
Picker
number
two
declined
boston
ems
victor
number,
three
later
identified,
as
ernie
veni
stated
that
the
suspect
shoved
her
victim
number
three
stated
that
he
did
not
fall
down.
E
She
did
not
fall
down
and
was
not
injured
victim
before
later
identified,
as
james
griffin
stated
he
consumed
a
lot
of
alcohol
does
not
remember
what
happened.
All
parties
refused
medical
attention
officer.
Marshall
spoke
to
the
manager
later
identified,
a
geo
vega,
who
stated
that
victim
number
one
jordan
had
a
verbal
dispute
with
his
bartender
when
another
patron
suspect
got
involved
and
both
parties
went
outside
to
fight
the
manager.
Vega
stated
that
the
suspect
was
not
a
bouncer
with
the
bar
and
does
not
know
who
he
is.
A
Thank
you
attorney
burke.
Would
you
like
to
address
the
alleged
incident.
H
Yes,
I
would
please
first
of
all
let
me
state
that
mr
vega
is
for
reasons
beyond
my
control
not
available
to
us
this
morning,
but
I'm
prepared
to
put
together
a
statement
from
him
and
submit
it
to
the
board
before
before
thursday.
For
you,
mr
mr
wilson,
who's
the
operations
manager
is
here
and
did
conduct
an
investigation.
So
let
me
if
I
may
direct
some
questions
to
him.
AD
Video
outside
the
premises,
there
was
no
for
where
the
incident
happened.
It
was
not
within
the
scope
of
the
video
from
our
premises.
H
W
AD
We
discovered
that
they
had
been
partaking
in
a
bar
crawl
for
halloween
around
the
back
bay
area
and
had
ended
up
in
dillon's.
We
were
not
part
of
the
said
barkwal
and
they
were
looking
for
discounted
drinks
that
they
had
received
at
other
establishments
and
that
were
participating
in
the
bark
wall.
We
let
them
know
that
we
were
not
part
of
it.
There
were
no
discounted
drinks
available
and
they
started
giving
the
bartender
a
hard
time
about
us.
AD
A
patron
who
was
at
the
bar
had
asked
them
to
lay
it
off
and
don't
be
abusing
the
bartender.
At
that
point
they
seemed
to
go
outside.
There
was
a
slight
scuffle
and
and
before
we
knew
it,
the
police
were
outside.
H
Okay
and
with
respect
to
after
the
police
arrived,
did
your
people
fully
cooperate
with
them
and
and
give
the
usual
cooperation
that's
required
of
the
boston
police
department.
I
believe.
AD
H
Is
okay
and
it's
true
that
mr
vega
told
him
that
he
did
not
know
who
this
individual
was
and
in
fact,
were
you
able
to
determine
that
the
individual
who
was
involved
was
described
only
as
a
very
tall
well-dressed
black
male?
Are
you
able
to
tell
us
whether
or
not
he's
on
your
staff
either.
H
He's
not
on
our
staff,
though,
and
is
it
fair
to
say
that
nobody
knows
who
this
individual
is?
That
is
correct.
Okay,
I
don't
have
any
further
questions
I'll
leave
it
to
the
board.
Let
me
just
address,
if
I
may,
I'm
sorry
the
expired
assembly
permit.
Mr
wilson,
had
you
in
fact
made
reapplication
and
made
the
payments
necessary,
but
not
yet
received
the.
AD
New
permit,
at
that
time
we
had
made
payment
for
it
and
we
had
neglected
to
post
a
copy
of
the
cash
check
from
the
lice
are
from
the
inspectional
services
to
post
it,
but
that
was
submitted
with
their
license
application
and-
and
we
did
receive
our
new
license
this
year-.
H
Thank
you
I'll,
submit
that
statement
from
mr
vega
directly
to
the
board.
A
Thank
you
and
the
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement.
Thank
you.
Those
are.
Those
are
all
the
items
before
the
board
today.
So
thank
you.
Everybody.