►
From YouTube: Chattanooga City Council Meeting — 05-10-22
Description
Chattanooga City Council Meeting — 05-10-22
A
C
D
Reading
from
isaiah
chapter
30,
verse
21,
whether
you
turn
to
the
right
or
to
the
left,
your
ears
will
hear
a
voice
behind
you
saying
this
is
the
way
walk
in
it.
Would
you
bow
with
me
for
prayer
god?
We
thank
you
that
you
are
with
us
that
you
do
speak
to
us
and
let
us
know
the
way,
help
us
to
be
attentive
to
your
word,
so
that
we
do
your
will
tonight
in
your
name.
We
pray,
amen.
C
E
C
E
D
Thank
you,
sir.
I
do
have
one
condition,
and
I
just
spoke
to
the
attorney
for
the
applicant
if
he
wouldn't
mind
coming
up
for
just
a
minute
and
I
may
have
to
get
miss
renek
involved
as
well
tom
we
had
talked
earlier
about
this
project
and
y'all
did
agree
to
grant
public
access
to
the
river
and
donate
a
certain
portion
of
land
that
we
might
be
able
to
build.
Little
parks
similar
to
blue
grooves,
blue
blue
goose
hollow
and
have
a
river
walk
connection
there.
D
It's
not
in
the
conditions
and
I've
learned
through
the
years
that,
if
it's
not
in
writing
many
times,
it
does
not
happen.
So
I
would
like
to
figure
out
a
way
karen
to
somehow
add
this
as
a
condition
and-
and
I
apologize
to
the
council
that
I
hadn't
been
able
to
talk
to
tom
before
about
this
well
about
the
condition.
But
do
you
have
any
problem
with
that?
As
as
we
had
agreed.
G
No,
it's
been
our
expectation
that
the
riverwalk
would
eventually
be
developed
across
the
shoreline
of
this
property,
headed
headed
to
moccasin
bend,
and
we
think
it's
kind
of
fruitful
to
the
project
to
have
some
kind
of
river
access.
Obviously,
a
public
access,
rather
we've
not
worked
out
the
details
of
exactly
what
that
looks
like,
and
maybe
we
should
just
work
with
either
rpa
or
parks
and
rec
on
that.
But,
generally
speaking,
the
notion
of
public
access
as
part
of
the
intention
of
the
project.
H
We
can
draft
some
language
based
on
what
we've
used
in
other
zoning
cases
and
we'll
work
with
the
applicant,
the
city,
attorney's
office
and
parks,
just
to
make
sure
we've
got
the
language
correct
on
that.
But,
yes,
it'll
be
a
condition:
granting
public
access
to
the
river
on
that
through
the
site
or
adjacent
to
the
site.
D
D
C
C
E
C
C
E
In
order
to
admit
chattanooga
city
code
part
two
chapter,
38
zoning
ordinance
so
as
to
lift
conditions
number
one
number
two
and
number
three
from
ordinance:
number:
eight,
nine,
six,
nine
from
previous
case
number,
nineteen,
eighty
eight
zero
one;
six,
eight,
I'm
probably
located
at
twenty.
Sixty
seven
crescent
club
dry,
drive
sub,
subject
to
certain
conditions.
I
C
E
C
E
In
order
to
mention
city
code
part
2,
chapter
38,
zoning
ordinance,
so
let's
deliver
conditions
number
one
through
six,
eight
and
nine
awards
number
one.
One.
Eight
two
seven
from
previous
case
number,
two
thousand
six:
zero
zero;
two
eight
for
the
properties
located
at
5867,
5871
and
5893
highway
153.
C
E
In
ordinance
to
admit
chattanooga
city
code
part
2,
chapter
38,
zoning
ordinance.
So
that's
the
reason
properties
located
at
66
20
66,
24,
66,
28,
66,
32,
66,
36,
66,
40
and
66
44
sand
switch
row
from
r1
residential
zone
to
rtz
residential
townhouses.
There
are
lot
lines
on
subject
certain
conditions.
C
H
H
H
The
hixson
north
river
plan
recommends
low
density
residential,
which
is
classified
as
detached
single
family
dwellings.
Being
the
dominant
use,
some
exceptions
made
for
townhouses
patio
homes
and
two
family
dwellings
of
density
is
compatible.
The
requested
single
family
dwellings
are
compatible
with
the
planned
goals,
but
the
average
density
in
the
area
is
three
dwelling
units
an
acre.
The
requested
rtz
zoning
allowed
allows
eight
dwelling
units
an
acre,
so
staff
recommended.
Oh
I'm
sorry,
I've
gone
way
too
far.
H
Staff
recommended
that
limiting
the
uses
to
single
family
and
limiting
the
number
of
residential
lots
to
keep
the
density
more
compatible.
Excuse
me,
I
apologize.
I
will
get
there
here.
We
go
sorry
about
that,
so
because
they
found
that
the
the
project
is
compatible
with
the
use,
but
not
the
density
goals.
H
There
was
quite
a
bit
of
opposition
planning.
Commission
planning,
commission
found
the
request
is
compatible
with
adopted
plan,
the
development
form
and
adjacent
land
uses
and
approved
with
the
following
conditions,
including
d-chat
single-family
residential
use,
only
no
more
than
32
residential
lots.
Just
the
applicant
originally
proposed
32.
So
this
brings
the
number
to
32
a
20-foot
undisturbed
buffer
provided
along
the
dalemont
lane,
property
line
and
no
access
to
delmont
lane
and
those
dale
mount
lane.
H
C
I
J
Well,
good
evening,
council,
my
name
is
alan
jones,
with
asa
engineering
at
714
cherry
street.
Before
planning
commission,
we
did
have
a
meeting
with
the
residents
in
the
community.
This
is
back
on
april
4th
at
the
time.
It
was
clearly
stated
that
the
residents
did
not
want
us
to
provide
access
to
delmont
lane.
J
The
original
application
was
39
units
that
fell
in
line
with
the
rtz
zoning
rpa
recommendation
was
24
and
so
working
with
the
developer.
You
know
we
looked
at
trying
to
find
ways.
We
could
reduce
the
number
of
units
to
kind
of
try
to
find
a
balance
or
or
a
medium
between
what
the
developer
is
trying
to
achieve
with
the
rtz
and
what
the
regional
planning
agency's
recommendation
was.
J
So
we
looked
at
finding
the
average
we
took
39
to
24
and
averaged
out
at
32.,
with
this
plan,
we're
going
to
be
building
the
same
amount
of
road
regardless.
So
really
where
the
discussion
comes.
Do
we
need
you
know,
or
you
know,
the
discussion
is:
is
eight
additional
residential
single-family
detached
units
that
much
of
a
stress
and
a
concern
over
the
24,
because
the
same
amount
of
infrastructure
is
going
to
have
to
be
built
for
this
project?
No
matter
what
the
project
is.
J
You
know
the
site
is
zoned
r1
right
now,
so
today
we
could
go
and-
and
you
know,
and
develop,
24
single-family
lots,
but
with
the
current,
the
site
we'd
probably
end
up
having
to
tap
into
delmont,
which
I
know
the
neighborhood
does
not
want.
So
for
us.
I
really
do
see
this
as
a
good
compromise
from
rezoning.
Yes,
we're
adding
a
few
extra
units,
then
24,
but
it
builds
in
some
protections
that
the
neighborhoods
have
voiced
concern
over
I'll
leave
it
at
that.
Thank.
K
My
name
is
neil
hoff
and
I'm
one
of
the
residents
of
the
hillbrook
area.
Yeah.
As
we
said,
we
spoke
before
we
had
a
group
of
people
that
sort
of
signed
a
petition.
You
know
expressing
our
concerns
and
all
my
primary
concern
here
today
was
that
they
stood
by
the
agreement
of
not
using
delmont
lane,
providing
what
I
thought
was
supposed
to
be
a
30-foot
buffer,
but
he
said
20-foot
buffer.
K
L
J
At
the
neighborhood
meeting
in
april,
we
did
throw
out
the
idea
of
having
a
30-foot
buffer
when
we
got
them.
We
revised
the
plans.
After
we
went
back
to
the
office
after
the
neighborhood
meeting.
We
could
really
only
make
it
work
with
a
20-foot
undisturbed
buffer
and
that's
what
we
presented
to
planning
commission
and
I
believe
the
the
same
gentleman
was
at
planning
commission
and
heard
that
same
20-foot.
D
D
J
J
M
C
C
L
C
C
Is
the
applicant
present
I
do
have
an
applicant?
Is
it
any
opposition
present
seeing
no
opposition
councilman
smith?
I
have
a
motion
for
approval.
I
do
have
a
second
questions
comments.
All
those
in
favor,
say
aye.
Those
opposed
motion
carries
madame
clerk
item.
I
would
you
please
read
the
alternate
version
and
karen,
if
you'll
be
on
standby,
to
read
conditions.
Thank
you.
E
C
H
H
The
maximum
building
height
shall
be
limited
to
two
stories
for
this
development
and
the
required
10-foot
perimeter
landscape
buffer
along
the
southern
property
line
of
this
development
that
abuts
the
preston
circle
subdivision
the
trees
species
planted
along
the
shared
boundary
shall
be
selected
by
the
joining
property
owners.
In
this,
the
development
shall
install
a
5
foot
tall,
black
or
green
vinyl
coated
chain
link
fence
installed
along
the
southern
property
of
the
development
and
extending
a
minimum
of
100
feet
and
distance
north
along
the
eastern
and
western
boundaries
of
the
development.
C
C
C
H
This
is
a
request
to
rezone
from
r1
to
r3
residential
zone
for
proposed
use
of
multi-family
independent
senior
housing.
This
property
is
a
law
is
in
the
north
brainerd
area.
We
have
both
support
and
opposition
for
this
case
the
it
is
on
northmoor
road
next
to
tucker
baptist
church.
This
is
a
zoning
map
on
the
screen.
Both
the
site
and
the
church
are
zoned
r1
residential
zone.
There
is
r2
zoning
south
of
bella
vista
shown
in
orange
and
an
rt1
zone
to
the
northeast
shown
in
brown
on
the
zoning
map.
H
The
applicant
proposed
79
units
on
about
three
acres
of
property.
Just
to
help
or
excuse
me
to
help
orient
further.
The
site
is
across
from
brainerd
high
school.
In
the
salvation
salvation
army
is
across
belle
vista
drive
to
the
south.
The
neighborhood
of
hanoi
drive
is
located
just
to
the
west
of
the
site.
H
H
The
site
is
located
in
the
north
brainerd
area
plan,
which
recommends
low
density
residential
for
the
site.
Low-Density
residential
is
described
as
dominated
by
single-family
dwellings,
with
some
exceptions
for
townhomes
patio
homes
and
two
family
dwellings.
The
request
for
arthur
residential
zone
would
allow
for
an
increased
density
in
a
type
of
residential
in
any
type
residential
form
of
multi-family
housing,
not
typically
found
along
the
section
of
northmoor
road.
H
One
of
the
planned
goals
is
to
maintain
residential
integrity
by
supporting
appropriate
residential
and
commercial
development.
The
plan
encourages
the
preservation
of
existing
single-family
neighborhoods
by
recommending
the
majority
of
the
study.
Air
remains
single-family
residential,
while
the
low-density
residential
mix,
which
includes
large
tracts
of
undeveloped
property
along
northmoor
road,
allows
for
townhomes
patio
homes
and
two
family
dwellings.
The
intention
of
this
area
is
to
remain
predominantly
single-family
residential.
H
The
plan
acknowledges
the
proximity
to
those
institutional
uses
along
northmoor
road,
which
could
support
higher
density
development,
but
states.
The
development
should
reflect
the
density
and
character
appropriate
to
the
surrounding
area.
The
proposed
summoning
this
is
from
the
staff
recommendation
again
that
proposed
79-unit
multi-family
development
does
not
meet
all
the
plan.
Goals
stated
above,
but
staff
acknowledges
this
location
could
be
developed
with
a
multi-family
development
that
serves
the
community
needs.
H
H
The
site
is
approximately
500
feet
from
existing
town
homes
along
northmoor
road.
The
proposed
multi-residential
development
is
not
compatible
with
existing
single-family
residential
adjacent
land
uses,
but
the
multi-family
development
could
serve
the
adjacent
institutional
uses
for
providing
housing
for
residents
that
attend
the
neighboring
church
or
school.
So
staff
had
recommended
deferring
the
proposed
rezoning
staff
acknowledges
the
proposed
multi-family
independent
senior
housing
would
provide
a
residential
form
that
the
community
may
need
and
the
location
is
appropriate.
Based
on
the
adjacency
to
northmoor
road
and
large
institutional
uses
neighboring
the
site
on
three
sides.
H
The
proposed
development
could
be
compatible
with
appropriate
site
design,
building
scale
and
screening,
although
it
doesn't
meet
the
goals
of
the
plan.
However,
the
proposed
development
could
provide
a
desired
housing
type
that
may
fulfill
a
need
for
the
community.
The
plan
was
adopted
in
2004
and
the
desire
to
maintain
low
density,
residential
zoning
and
single
family
dwellings
at
this
location
may
have
changed
since
within
the
community.
H
H
C
N
Evening
to
mr
chairman
and
the
council
members,
my
name
is
gary
hathaway.
I
am
pastor
greater
tucker
missionary
baptist
church
and
also
I
am
a
member
of
our
community
development
corporation
today.
I
have
with
me
miss
donald
williams,
she's,
a
consultant
on
the
proposal
and
also
I
have
hayman
mark
martin
who's.
Vice
president
with
penrose
developers,
our
mission,
really
as
a
church,
is
to
minister
to
the
needs
of
the
community
and
our
congregation.
N
We
know
everybody
knows
one
of
the
greatest
needs
in
chattanooga
today
is
affordable
housing
and,
let
me
say,
as
a
pastor,
I
see
it
every
day
I
get
calls
every
day
of
people
looking
for
a
place
to
live
because
their
rents
are
going
through
the
roof.
In
many
cases,
unfortunately,
landlords
are
not
attending
to
their
needs.
N
A
lot
of
the
properties
are
inefficient
when
it
comes
to
energy.
So
let
me
say
we
want
to
be
part
of
the
solution.
We
have
vacant
land
we're
blessed
with
vacant
land.
We
have
three
acres
that
we
want
to
use
for,
affordable
senior
housing,
and
you
know
it
is
our
plan
to
partner
with
the
community
we've
already
reached
out
like
to
brainerd
high
school.
They
love
the
idea.
Their
kids
could
come
over
and
get
and
get
service
hours.
N
N
Just
in
the
past
two
weeks,
I've
talked
with
one
of
the
leaders
because
I
was
told
by
councilman
hester
and
commissioner
jita
to
reach
out
and
have
a
conversation,
and
we
did
and
the
thinking
and
the
feeling
was
that
you
know
we
really
didn't
need
to
meet
again
we're
open.
We
are
open,
but
that's
what
we
were
advised
we
understand
change
is
not
easy,
there's
always
opposition,
but
we
believe
the
need
for
affordable
housing
is
greater
than
doing
nothing
or
standing.
Still.
N
Change
is
happening
all
over
chattanooga,
but
not
fast
enough
for
those
who
are
less
fortunate,
especially
seniors.
We've
seen
this
before
saint
elmo,
a
former
councilman
told
me
that
he
served
when
affordable
housing
was
made
available
in
saint
elmore
and
he
said
the
same
complaints.
If
people
complain
about
the
crime
rate
going
up,
they
complain
about
property
values
decreasing.
N
They
can
prank
complain
about
the
height,
and
none
of
that
has
been
an
issue
and
he
said
actually
what
happened
about
three
years
later
after
they
got
it
built
lady
called
him
and
says
you
know
I
want
to
thank
you.
She
says,
because
I
actually
live
in
the
property
now
and
I
think
it's
very
very
nice
again
some
of
our
counterparts
will
be
our
counterparts.
Orchard
knob,
baptist
church
has
a
four-story
housing
senior
housing
facility,
there's
eastwood,
which
is
close
to
us.
It's
on
one
level.
They
have
98
homes
because
they
have
land.
N
N
Two
of
three
of
the
neighborhood
associations
endorse
the
project
so
with
that
being
said,
we're
asking
that
you
will
strongly
consider
approving
our
proposal.
I
again
I
have
these
two
consultants
as
well
as
for
well
donna
and
eamon
for
any
technical
questions
per
se.
We
also
have
some
people
in
the
audience
if
time
provides
yeah.
C
O
I
worked
32
years
across
from
the
site
that
they're
speaking
of
and
I
know
we
all
have
apprehensions
about
change
and
it
is
a
big
change,
but
we
also
have
to
have
a
heart
for
those
that
are
less
fortunate
than
we
are
and
it
is
such
a
problem
to
find
affordable
housing.
And
I
would
experience
that
last
summer,
when
one
of
my
relatives
had
lived
at
a
rainbow
creek
and
they
redid
that
situation
and
when
they
went
up
on
the
rent.
O
But
in
my
heart
I
know
that
we
do
need
to
do
what
we
can
to
help
when
we
can-
and
this
is
something
that
is
much
needed,
and
my
heart
goes
out
to
all
the
homeless
people
and
like
we
know,
we
see
tent
cities
and
we
see
all
of
these
things
and
if
something
doesn't
happen
soon,
we
just
may
never
get
to
the
end
of
this.
Thank
you.
Thank
you.
N
P
I've
got
walter
williams
and
I
have
a
device,
and
so
you
may
have
difficulty
hearing
from
me,
but
I
own
the
largest
residential
property
in
whitmore
on
three
acres,
so
they
could
put
the
property
proposed
on
my
lane,
but
neither
you
know
that
I'm
just
supportive
of
the
property
from
middle
pike
to
share
of
a
road.
That's
going
to
be
commercial,
we
can
talk
all
you
know
to
talk
the
only
two
two
developments,
that's
between
midland
pike
and
charlottesville.
P
P
C
C
Q
Afternoon
my
name
is
richard
reynolds
and
I
live
at
1102.
Benoit
drive
been
there
about
40
years
and
that
field
is
not
fit
for
what
they
want
to
put
there.
It's
always
flooded
cranes,
herons,
all
that
always
gathered
in
the
field
in
the
70s
it
it
flooded.
So
bad.
If
you
remember,
maryland
lloyd
bucar,
she
had
the
levy
built
because
all
that
land
over
there
is
always
flooded
very
bad.
That's
what
that
is
marshland!
That's
why
the
herons
and
the
cranes,
if
you
guys,
know
anything
about
biology,
that's
why
they
gather
in
that
field.
Q
It's
just
marshland!
I
live
right
adjacent
to
it.
It
also
has
only
one
dream:
it
comes
from
the
brainerd
high
school
side.
It
runs
under
the
street
to
tucker
baptist
right
there.
They
had
it
developed
and
they
put
a
drain
in
the
middle
of
the
field.
This
year
in
january,
it
still
floods
and
I
have
documentation.
I
sent
it
in
with
the
videos
where
the
water
just
sits
there,
and
it's
going
to
run
off
on
the
back
side
to
the
venous
vanilla
street
drive.
They
also
did
not
provide
a
perk
test
to
test
the
water.
Q
The
soil
to
see
if
it
absorbs
and
they
have
not,
they
have
not
also
produced
any
traffic
study
to
any
of
us,
and
I
might
add
also
these
guys-
do
not
live
on
my
street.
I
live
on.
Vernor
drive
these
guys
that
just
spoke
who
the
applicants
they
do
not
live
in
my
neighborhood,
I
live
there
and
I
know
them,
but
these
guys
do.
Thank
you
so
much
for
your
time.
Thank
you,
sir.
R
Good
evening,
I
didn't
want
to
speak
because
I
get
emotional
about
this
they're
saying
they're,
going
to
put
a
50-foot
radius
between
the
building
and
your
property.
Now
I've
seen
those
stakes
they
put,
my
wife
had
them
remove
it.
It
was
less
than
10
feet
from
my
property.
I
happened
to
live
in
belleville
about
the
church,
the
former
church
sanctuary
the
land.
R
They
want
to
build
on
all
my
water
lines
run
across
them
because
the
church,
when
they
built
a
church,
they
built
the
home,
the
subdivision,
and
when
I
bought
the
home
I
asked
them
about.
They
said:
do
not
worry
about
it.
The
land
will
never
be
developed.
Your
your
water
lines
and
property
are
safe.
R
Now
we
get
flooded
over
there
every
time
it
rang
hard.
I
don't
know
if
there's
any
engineers
or
not,
but
you
put
a
three-story
building.
Not
only
is
it
taken
away
from
the
neighborhood,
but
it's
gonna
run
flood
water
back
to
my
home
again,
and
this
is
something
I
basically
cannot
target
now.
I
know
none
of
you
would
like
to
have
a
three-story
building
built
next
to
your
house,
taking
away
everything
that
you
work
for
just
like
most
of
these
people,
this
in
my
neighborhood,
this
gentleman
don't
live
in
my
neighborhood.
R
R
S
Good
afternoon
city
council,
my
name
is
gregory
owens
and
I
stay
on
11,
1116
anita
drive
one
street
over
from
venar,
and
I
just
have
a
couple
questions
on
making
real
quick
the
applicant.
Mr
gary
hathaway
pastor
gary
hathaway.
He
said
there
was
no
problems
with
the
opposed
the
people
who
support
the
project.
There's
plenty
of
opposition.
Here
today,
mr
hathaway
always
said
there
was
hundreds
of
letters
that
were
sent
to
him
opposing
I
mean
not
opposing
this
project.
That's
going
on.
S
Did
he
produce
those
letters
we'd
like
to
see
those
letters
and
the
people
that
actually
sent
in
those
letters
so
we'll
know
exactly
who
actually
did
not
oppose
the
project
in
our
community
number?
Three,
the
neighborhood
associations
that
say
that
they
were
on
record
that
they
approved
the
project.
S
Can
we
also
get
the
names
of
the
neighborhood
association
leaders
that
approved
the
project
and
also
the
people
that
on
anita
and
venoit,
that
also
approved
the
project,
and
we
was
hoping
that
we
can
get
the
information
at
the
last
meeting,
but
we
didn't
get
it
last
week,
so
we're
asking
for
it
now,
so
we
can
move
on.
Thank
you.
F
Hello,
my
name
is
keisha
sales
and
I
actually
don't
stay
on
anita
or
manoa.
I
actually
stay
on
collins,
which
is
not
a
part
of
this,
but
my
concern
is
the
safety
that
s
curve
in
there
right
before
you
get
to
talk
about
this.
It's
a
very
dangerous
s-curve.
We've
asked
for
traffic
studies
on
this.
I
know
myself
knowing
each
and
every
other
weekend.
There
is
an
accident
over
there.
Every
time
you
turn
around.
I'm
thinking
about
this
kids
that
are
going
to
school.
F
I'm
also
thinking
about
the
seniors
that
are
going
to
be
proposed
to
go
there.
This
is
not
on
a
main
bus
route.
So
how
are
these
people
going
to
get
from
one
location
to
the
next?
I
didn't
hear
any
type
of
suggestion
as
to
how
they're
going
to
get
for
transportation
we're
also
sitting
in
a
food
desert.
We
lost
our
walk.
The
neighborhood
walmart
there's
no
way
to
get
food.
F
We
are
actually
traveling
to
another
zip
code,
giving
out
money
to
another
zip
code
in
order
for
us
for
us
to
sustain
I'm,
not
understanding
how
a
three-story
building
bringing
it
to
our
neighborhood
is
going
to
make
a
difference.
How
is
it
going
to
make
this
better
for
us?
It's
not
making
it
better
for
us
and
it's
actually
putting
those
people
that
you're
bringing
to
the
neighborhood
at
a
bigger
disadvantage.
F
I
would
hope
that
the
council
would
definitely
consider
this
information.
Look
at
this
information
and
at
least
defer
this,
so
we
can
have
more
time
to
look
at
this
and
get
some
information
as
far
as
the
purchase,
the
soil
test,
the
sewer
issues
we've
know
all
these
are
things
we
know
because
we
live
in
the
neighborhood.
This
is
stuff
we've
dealt
with
on
a
regular
basis.
I
understand
the
affordable
housing
issue.
I
totally
understand
it.
I
see
it
every
day.
F
U
U
We
were
not
given
an
opportunity
to
have
dialogue
with
the
church
so
that
we
can
be
a
part
of
what
comes
into
our
community.
So
that's
the
first
piece.
The
next
piece
that
I
kind
of
mentioned
in
that
letter
is
that
this
would
be
president
changing
the
precedent
that
we
currently
have
two
miles
away.
Well,
less
than
two
miles
away,
two
minutes
away:
we
have
eastwood,
which
is
also
a
senior
living
facility,
that
is
a
single
family.
U
We
already
mentioned
that
we
have
all
of
the
flooding
concerns
the
traffic
concerns
the
food
desert
and
then
also
what
I
presented
was
some
amendments
to
those
conditions
and
reducing
the
density.
We
do
feel
like
60
units
is
quite
a
lot
for
that
small
area
and
then
all
of
that
traffic
trying
to
come
out
into
the
s-curve.
So
we
ask
that
this
is
deferred,
that
we
get
additional
information.
C
C
T
T
T
N
N
N
I
Thank
you
ma'am
again,
ayman,
martin,
regional.
Vice
president
for
penrose
yeah.
We
are
their
co-development
partner
in
this,
so
we
are
going
providing
the
tag.
The
tax
credit
development
experience
for
this,
and
let
me
back
up
and
say
the
main
financing
source
for
this
project
and
for
the
majority
of
affordable
housing
today
is
what's
called
low-income
housing
tax
credits
and
these
are
allocated
by
the
tennessee
housing
and
development
authority,
and
so
as
a
applicant,
the
church
and
the
cdc
need
an
experienced
developer
with
that
to
qualify.
I
So
we
will
provide
that
development
experience
as
well
as
all
of
the
technical
development
through
the
process
of
developing
this
project,
and
then
we
will
also
provide
all
of
the
guarantees
financial
guarantees
for
the
project.
The
cdc
will,
the
church
cdc
will
be
the
100
owner
throughout
the
entire
tax,
credit
or
affordability
period
and
penrose
will
maintain
all
of
the
guarantees
for
that
project.
Okay,.
V
Okay,
that
is
my
concern.
I
lea,
of
course,
I'm
district
7,
so
I
do
have
the
austin
park
area
penrose
has
currently
or
in
the
past,
managed
the
villages
alton
park
and
has
done
a
very
poor
job
from
not
maintaining
the
from
not
maintaining
of
the
apartments
they
live
in.
The
residence
currently
live
in.
I
get
complaints
all
the
time
from
the
villages
at
alton
park,
so
my
primary
concern,
of
course,
I'm
always
here
for
the
community,
but
my
concern
is
the
current
community
that
you
are
serving
you're,
not
serving
well.
V
So
I
would
really
want
you
to
talk
to
the
community
members
and
see
what
is
going
on.
Also,
I
do
encourage
you
to
come
out
and
look
at
the
villages
and
talk
to
some
of
those
members
of
that
community
as
well
to
see
that
some
of
them
don't
have
plumbing
that's
working.
They
don't
have
stoves.
That's
working
they're
holes
in
the
walls,
they're
they're
the
maintenance
not
up
kept
like
it
should
be.
So
I
am
concerned
highly
very
concerned
that
penrose
would
be
managing
this.
I
V
C
V
You
chair
and
thank
you
guys
for
presenting,
thank
you,
pastor,
holloway
and
just
earlier
today
we
had
a
presentation-
and
it
was
mentioned
that
you
know
47
of
our
areas
are
renters
and
it's
higher
than
nationally
and
the
state
of
tennessee,
so
we're
at
47
percent
majority
of
our
people
are
housing,
burden
and
housing.
Insecure
and
our
mayor
took
a
bold
ask
and
said:
we
need
for
our
faith-based
organizations
to
step
up
and
create
housing
opportunities.
V
You
know
all
kind
of
housing
opportunities
and
often
when
we
get
into
these
discussions,
the
things
that
we
hear
repeatedly
are
safety
crime
flood.
You
know
things
of
that
nature
and
when
we
particularly
look
at
our
neighborhoods,
which
is
this
is
a
majority
black
community,
we
instantly
think
the
negative
aspect
of
it
when
crime
is
more
rampant
outside
of
our
community.
So
first
we
got
to
get
that
understood.
We're
talk.
V
We
can't
even
compare
the
villages
to
this,
because
it's
a
different
target
group
of
people
who
live
in
that
community,
we're
talking
about
seniors,
55
and
up,
and
if
we
want
to
be
honest
on
council
half
of
us,
that's
in
that
age
group.
If
we
were
only
living
on
council
salary,
we
would
qualify
to
live
at
this
development
and
not
to
mention
some
of
the
comments.
That's
done
been
said.
V
We,
it
was
mentioned
that
we're
in
the
food
desert
we're
in
the
food
apart
time
actually
and
these
people
and
those
people,
let's
humanize.
The
target
group
of
people
were
talking
about
they're
humans,
they're,
our
mothers
they're
our
grandmothers
they're,
our
aunties
nephews,
grandpas,
whatever
you
want
to
call
them.
Meanwhile,
papa
humanize
them
not
to
mention
this
age
group
has
worked
extremely
hard,
so
yeah
right
now
we
it's
our
duty
as
a
city
to
make
sure
that
they're
able
to
have
a
place
to
live
now.
V
I'ma
share
this
story
with
you
as
a
lady
that
was
that's
a
widow.
She
owned
a
home
in
the
community
that
I
reside
in
called
isdale
lived
there,
all
her
life
first
african-american
woman
to
work
at
the
glass
company
and
so
on
and
so
forth.
If
you
all
know
about
that
area
for
people
to
be
there
because
of
one
thing
that
shifted
in
her
life,
she
had
to,
she
lost
her
home.
The
community
that
you're
talking
about
eastwood
manor
that
you
thinking
and
picturing
this
negative
image
about
she
had
to
move
into
that
development
right.
V
It
gave
her
somewhere
affordable
to
live.
Everybody
in
that
community
are
working
class
people
or
either
to
serve
this
country
or
something
that
happened
in
their
life
to
change
their
trajectory
for
their
life
to
have
them
live
and
we're
not
talking
about
a
harriet
tubman,
a
spencer
j
mccollough
we're
not
talking
about
that,
that's
equivalent
to
the
villages.
Right
now
I
grew
up
in
harry
tubman
as
well,
but
the
very
lady
that
I'm
talking
about
who
make
every
country's
effort
to
serve
her
commit
community.
V
In
spite
of
her
falls
sitting
in
the
audience
now
miss
jesse
ago,
I
have
watched
this
a
senior
who's
over
55,
who
I've
heard
being
dehumanized
by
saying
these
people
and
those
people,
but
she
the
very
first
person
who
would
take
her
shirt
off
her
back,
that
I'll
walk
watch.
Her
walk
daily
up
and
down
the
street,
knocking
on
the
doors
of
other
scenes
to
make
sure
that
they
that
they're
eating
we
need
to
humanize
them
now:
crime
and
safety.
V
All
those
are
great
issues,
issues
of
concern,
but
if
we're
not
making
sure
that
we're
doing
something
about
it,
also,
it
just
can't
be
on
the
wheel
of
the
city,
because
you
got
to
have
an
active
role
in
it
to
reduce
the
crime.
If
it's
happening
in
your
neighborhood
and
not
to
mention
when
we
say
it
put
those
people
these
people
in
a
situation
where
they
already
in
a
worse
situation.
V
Why
would
we
think
that
they're
in
the
worst
situation,
because
they
need
to
have
low-income
housing,
that's
affordable
for
them
for
their
income?
We're
talking
about
people?
That's
getting
social
security
checks,
that's
getting
widow,
pension
checks
from
their
husbands
that
served
in
the
military,
but
we're
saying
they're
in
a
worse
situation,
because
they
can't
afford
twelve
hundred
dollars
a
month
that
they
can
get
somewhere
actually
affordable.
Six
seven
hundred
dollars
is
that
supposed
to
be
something
that's
seen
in
a
negative
way.
V
Yet
I'm
very
offended
about
what
has
happened
here
in
transparent
tonight,
because
we
have
a
group
of
people
which
is
a
church,
that's
stepping
up
to
the
plate
and
saying
we
want
to
create
an
opportunity.
This
should
be
something
that
should
be
workable.
Why?
Because
it's
seniors
we
didn't
come,
they
didn't
say
we
gonna
put
this
group
of
people,
this
age
group
we
said
55
and
up
now
the
difference
with
saying
we
don't
have
grocery
stores.
That's
what
we've
had
four
in
the
area.
That's
done
closed
for
now.
V
Technology
has
advanced,
so
every
senior
that
occupies
63
units
guess
what
they
can
do,
pull
up
a
phone.
It's
alps,
they
train
you.
They
show
you
every
day.
You
can
put
your
order
in
in
any
grocery
store
that
delivered
and
guess
what
they'll
deliver
it
to
your
house,
not
just
that
you
got
people
that
will
deliver
it
for
you,
people
access
it
here
all
the
time.
I
still
do
because
I'd
rather
order
it
and
it's
delivered
to
my
step
that
saved
me
gas.
They
saved
me
time
so
anything
that
they
need.
V
V
V
Ain't
a
day
they
go
back
that
I
don't
check
on
the
seniors
in
my
community,
not
just
in
my
community,
but
every
community,
I'm
that
councilwoman
that
sitting
behind
this
diet.
None
of
that
matters
to
me
what
matters
to
me
is
serving
the
people
that
I
love
and
when
anybody
give
me
a
call,
I'm
leaving
work
I'm
getting
up
on
my
bed,
I'm
leaving
meetings
whatever
it
is
that
I
need
to
do
to
make
sure
that
their
need
is
being
addressed
in
my
district
or
not
I'm
showing
up
I'm
coming
now.
V
I
have
a
personal
relationship
with
mr
jesse.
I
go
so
anything
she
can
re.
Let
her
not
answer
that
phone.
She
know
I'm
coming
to
a
doorstep:
pastor,
hathaway!
No!
I'm
calling
him
saying
she
ain't
answering
the
door.
She
I'm
calling
mr
ellsworth
harris,
whoever
it
is
and
not
just
for
her,
but
I
do
that
for
every
senior
that's
in
my
district
or
not
so
people
we
gotta
be
careful
about
the
things
and
the
labels
that
we're
putting
on
people
right-
and
I
know
sometimes
change-
is
hard.
V
But-
and
I
apologize
I'm
passionate
about
this-
we
need
housing.
It
may
not
look
like
how
you
want
it
to
look,
but
it'll
be
a
workable
situation
chair.
I
don't
agree
with
us
deferring
it.
I
think
they've
done
and
met
everything
that
they
needed
to
do
with
the
with
you
know
with
the
community,
but
I
do
also
know
that
it
takes
to
re
property
to
get
rezoned,
so
they
can
see
if
they
qualify
for
the
additional
funding
that
they
need
through
thda.
V
C
D
N
Great
question:
I'm
glad
I'm
so
glad
you
asked
that
question.
So
we
can
clear
it
up.
We
are
leasing
the
land,
it's
a
ground
lease,
so
we
we
maintain
the
land
okay.
Now
we
view
it
as
ministry.
But
let
me
say
this:
we've
had
the
land
for
over
25
years.
We've
done
nothing
with
it,
nothing
it's
just
sitting
there.
You
know,
I
mean
you
know,
I'm
a
man
of
the
of
the
word.
D
D
So
what
I
heard
was
some
concerns
with
the
height
of
these
units
being
three-story.
The
reason
I
was
asking
if
it
was
a
ministry
or
a
money
maker,
if
it's
a
ministry,
can
you
get
by
with
two
stories?
Is
if
it's
a
money
maker
pro
former,
probably
won't.
Let
you
do
that.
So
I
guess
that's
kind
of
you
know.
D
The
burning
question
here
is
that
when
it
becomes
a
ministry
or
a
money
maker,
I
don't
know
if
if
the
residents
would
be
more
accepting
of
two-story
units
because
thinking
about
the
area
and
what
surrounds
it,
I
believe
most
of
these
residential
units
are
single
story
and-
and
I
think
I
can
understand
how
a
three
story
might
look
so
towering
over
the
rest
of
their
units.
So
you
know
this
is
one
of
those
questions.
D
I
think
you
know
what
does
yes
look
like,
because
I
certainly
you
know
I
I
know
when
I
first
saw
this.
I
thought
man.
This
is
a
great
opportunity,
but
I
hear
the
the
passion
in
which
these
residents
have
spoken
in
opposition
and
and
their
concern.
Now
I
don't
you
know
personally,
I
I
question
any
kind
of
concerns
about
safety
with
the
50
and
above
I
mean
you
know
I'm
in
bed
by
about
nine
o'clock
at
night.
D
So
you
know
I
I
don't
suppose,
there's
a
whole
lot
of
concern
for
for
crime
or
issues
there
and-
and
I
don't
understand
a
perk
test,
because
a
perk
test
is
for
your
own
septic
tank.
These
will
be
on
sewer,
correct,
correct.
I
mean
I
can't
imagine
them
being
on
anything
else.
So
I'm
not
sure
what
a
perk
test
would
do,
but
but
I'm
trying
to
understand
and
get
an
idea
of
the
concerns
of
the
residents
and
see
if
we
can't
address
some
of
those.
D
W
Councilman
henderson,
if
I
may
you
more
than
most
understand
how
construction
and
development
works
so
as
as
is
evident
by
your
remark
about
pert
test
being
irrelevant
to
the
conversation,
so
this
project,
the
only
reason
the
main
reason
this
project.
Well,
the
only
reasons
this
project
has
any
potential
of
moving
forward
is
because
the
church
owns
the
land
and
anybody
that's
been
following
development
or
housing.
Construction
et
cetera,
et
cetera,
fully
understands
the
value
of
land,
so
the
the
the
church,
the
cdc
and
its
partner,
does
not
have
to
buy
that
land.
W
Okay,
if
if
they
had
to
do
that
acquire
land,
the
project
may
be
undoable.
That's
number
one
number
two
in
order
to
deliver
housing,
quality
housing,
as
I've
said
before
many
of
you
have
heard
me
say
this
before
that
those
are
you
that
were
here,
a
house
costs
what
it
cost.
It
doesn't
care
who
lives
in
it.
It
doesn't
know
who
lives
in
it.
W
It
costs
the
same,
and
so
in
order
for
this
partnership
to
develop
housing
for
folks
who
are
55
or
older,
whose
income
is
anywhere
from
50
to
60
percent
of
the
area
median
income,
we
need
subsidy,
it's
a
third.
This
is
approximately
1600
development
that
number
changes
every
day,
because
construction,
the
price
of
construction,
is
changing
every
day
this
church
and
this
partner
wants
to
provide
63,
high
quality
housing
units
for
folks
whose
incomes
are
anywhere
from
half
60
percent
of
the
area
median
income,
and
I
totally
understand
some
of
the
concerns
of
the
neighborhood.
W
It
has
to
go
everywhere,
because
we
have
that
many
people
in
need
of
affordable
housing.
I
I
see
our
friends
here,
my
former
city
colleagues,
who
are
wearing
shirts
for
15
an
hour
correct
that
these
folks
are
working
every
day.
I
would
love
any
of
them
to
be
my
neighbor.
They
qualify
for
low
to
moderate
income
housing
and
there
are
other
people
that
are
doing
good
work.
Good
people
going
to
work
every
day,
they're,
not
criminals,
they're,
not
hoodlums,
they
cut
their
grass,
they
take
their
garbage
out.
W
W
Okay,
okay,
people's
rents
are
going
up,
just
a
phone
call,
landlord
saying
guess
what
I'm
so
glad
you've
been
a
good
tenant,
but
from
this
point
forward
your
rent's
going
up
400
300
200
a
month,
and
so
I
understand
that
some
that
we
all
have
sacrifices
to
make.
I
know
people
ask
me,
would
you
want
to
live?
Yes,
I,
yes,
I
would,
and
yes,
I
do
live
near
low
and
moderate
income
people
not
a
problem
with
for
me,
but
we
are
more
than
happy
to
have
a
fourth
meeting.
W
We've
had
three
more
than
happy
to
have
a
fourth
meeting,
but
this
could
this
city
small
c
big
c
either
is
going
to
be
committed
to
providing
affordable
housing
to
the
47
of
people
who
need
it
or
we're
not,
and
it's
not
going
to
be
effortless
and
comfortable
in
every
regard.
So
we
are
here
to
technical
questions.
You
have
any
questions
about
financing.
How
is
finance
or
whatever,
and
I
believe
it's
been
requested-
that
there
is
a
meeting
thursday
and
anybody
can
come
to
that
because
we'd
be
yeah.
D
W
X
X
W
W
So
and
eamonn
will
take
a
look
into.
He
will
look
into
that,
even
though
they
don't
currently
manage
the
property,
but
he'll
take
a
look
he'll.
Look
into
that
because
it's
your
concerns
are
valid.
So
I
just
want
to
say
that
for
the
record,
the
if,
if
all
goes
well
on
june
3rd,
we
will
be
submitting
an
application
to
thda
for
low-income
housing,
tax
credits
and
also
application
to
the
city
for
art
funds.
So
june
3rd
is
our
deadline
to
do
both
of
those
things.
L
W
The
very
likely
so
that
I
don't
want
to
go
into
it,
but
the
villages
yeah,
the
villages
is
home
ownership
and
public
housing
and
low-income
housing.
It's
a
mix.
It
doesn't
look
like
it
just
driving
by
it's
a
mix
of
different
type
of
housing,
all
of
which
has
federal
money
in
it.
But
to
your
question
I
think
to
answer
it.
I.
Z
So,
therefore,
my
motion
is
to
defer
this
for
two
weeks
and
let
it
be
known
on
the
record
that
you
must
sit
down
at
the
tablehood
a
table
of
brotherhood
where
we
can
air
out
our
differences,
I'm
here
to
build
community
not
to
divide
a
community.
I
said
so
it
this
is.
I
see
this
bigger
than
just
the
community
because
spiritually
we
look
at
this.
Z
E
E
C
C
E
C
Y
C
C
Is
the
applicant
present,
do
you
see
an
applicant?
Is
there
any
opposition
present
councilwoman
noel?
I
have
an
applicant
with
no
opposition.
What
is
your
desire
move
to
approve?
I
do
hear
a
motion
for
approval.
I
did
hear
a
second
questions
comments.
All
those
in
favor,
say
aye
opposed
motion
carries
item
o
madam
clerk.
C
E
C
C
H
This
is
a
rezoning
from
r1
to
r2
residential
zone
for
a
two
family.
Excuse
me,
sorry,
for
two
family
dwelling
at
a
property:
that's
about
0.17
acres,
there's
a
mix
of
single-family
residential
in
the
area,
but
we
do
note
that
the
surrounding
land
uses
our
mix
of
existing
duplexes,
single
family
dwellings
and
vacant
lots.
H
The
existing
site.
Excuse
me,
the
store.
The
area.
Three
historic
river
to
ridge
plan
recommends
urban
residential
place
type
for
the
site,
which
is
described
as
having
a
development
plat
pattern
that
includes
a
range
of
housing
types,
including
single
family,
detached
single
family
attached
accessory
dwelling
units,
two
to
four
dwelling
units
per
lot
and
cottage
quartz.
H
Lots
within
the
urban
residential
place
type
are
generally
50
feet
wide,
but
lot
widths
and
patterns
can
change
within
each
block.
The
proposed
r2
zone
with
the
duplex
use
meets
the
urban
residential
place
type
goals
and
both
staff
and
planning
commission
recommend
approval
and
there
was
no
opposition
for
the
proposed
duplex
and
the
rezoning
to
r2.
C
AB
Good
evening
council,
my
name
is
carrie
thornhill,
and
yet
this
property
here
on
arlington
avenue
we
acquired
it
years
ago.
We
actually
had
acquired
the
total
street
there
on
the
800
block
of
arlington
in
2009,
did
a
full
renovation
of
several
dilapidated
properties
there
and
when
we
sold
it
around
2016.
We
maintained
that
one
lot.
So
our
goal
here
was
to
essentially
build.
AB
We
know
there
was
a
need
for
affordable
housing
and
we
thought
it
would
have
kind
of
matched
the
aesthetics
of
the
current
housing
type
that
all
the
properties
that
are
contiguous
to
that.
That
lot
are
duplexes,
so
we
just
wanted
to
kind
of
maintain
that
look
and
the
usage
and
rent
it
out
to
folks
in
the
community.
AC
AC
This
particular
project
will
add
to
that.
I
hadn't
talked
to
the
developer
the
builder
on
it.
I
didn't
get
a
chance
to
look
at
his
plans
for
it,
but
in
that
area,
if
he's
trying
to
bring
back
the
similar
type
of
duplexes,
we
would
prefer
that
it
did
not
continue
along
that
format.
We
were
looking
more
in
the
river
ridge
plan
to
look
for
more
single-family
housing.
AC
AC
I
don't
want
to
give
it
a
bad
name,
but
an
area
where
it
does
need
to
have
more
single-family
housing
in
it.
It
is
pretty
close
to
where
some
of
our
multi-family
developments
and
some
of
the
activities
that
are
going
on
there
continue
to
cause
us
a
problem
so
we're.
If,
for
those
reasons,
we
hope
that
you
denied
the
r2
zoning
and
maintain
these
hard
ones
only.
AB
Yeah,
it's
important
to
note.
I
don't
know
if
mr
smith
is
familiar
with
what
we've
done
in
that
area,
but
we've
been
one
of
the
probably
the
biggest
development
groups
there
in
that
east
chattanooga
avondale
area
we've
over
the
years
have
done
maybe
a
thousand
doors
in
that
whole
area,
a
lot
of
the
properties
that
he's
actually
referenced,
the
dilapidated
duplex
and
so
on.
We've
converted
them
throughout
that
community.
So
on
several
of
the
streets,
almost
each
one
of
them,
that's
named
there.
AB
We've
done
several
conversion,
conversions,
a
matter
of
fact,
just
to
add
some
context.
Here
we
have
property
one
street
over
on
wheeler
avenue,
we're
building
a
new
new
construction
there,
because
we
thought
it
kind
of
mirrored
what
was
in
that
area.
I
think
this
one
particularly
just
because
it's
only
duplexes
on
that
street,
essentially
outside
of
the
one
across
the
street
which
we
actually
own
and
we
we
updated
it
as
well
just
recently
at
869.
AB
there
we
just
thought
it
kind
of
match.
It
would
have
created
some
level
of
maybe
just
kind
of
an
eyesore
of
some
sort,
just
having
a
single-family
new
bill
right.
Alongside
of
the
duplexes,
so
kind
of
marrying
that
look
that
consistency
and
obviously
being
able
to
help
with
affordable
housing
by
providing
a
two
bed,
one
bath,
opposed
to
maybe
a
three
or
four
bedroom
to
make
the
numbers
work.
C
Y
C
V
C
V
It
it
gives
it
a
different
flavor
because
there's
some
in
our
communities,
we
say
duplexes
and
we
instantly
think
about
the
negative
stuff.
But
when
I
take
a
ride
out
to
east
brainerd
or
I
go
to
hixson
or
I
go
out
the
north
shore,
it
they
look
the
same
as
what
we
call
a
duplex,
but
they
they
call
them
townhouses.
But
when
you
say
townhouse,
they
give
you
a
different
image
right.
AC
AC
D
V
A
AC
C
E
E
C
A
E
C
V
C
E
C
E
In
order
to
amend
chattanooga
38
zoning
ordinance,
so
it's
reasonable
properties
located
at
6,
16,
19,
dodge
avenue,
1922
south
watkins
street
2270,
east
21st
street
in
1803
and
21
11,
south
flower
street,
from
c2
convenience,
commercial
zone,
m1,
manufacturing
zone
and
r3
residential
zone
to
c2
central
business
on
subject.
Certain
conditions.
C
H
Mr
chair,
I
think
you're
referencing
the
fact
that
there
was
a
address
on
there.
That
was
since
a
recent
replying
no
longer
applies
to
the
zoning
case,
and
that
was
a
kelly
street
which
I
don't,
I
believe,
was
removed
by
the
city
attorney's
office
from
the
caption,
and
I'm
just
going
to
make
sure
I've
got
the
right
address,
dapplings
against
giving
me
the
thumbs
up
so
that
has
been
removed
from
the
caption.
C
E
An
ordinance
to
a
manchester
city
code,
part
2,
chapter
38,
zoning
ordinance
so
as
to
deviate
to
the
max
to
the
maximum
building
height
within
the
c3
central
business
zone,
for
the
properties
located
at
2318,
east
main
street
1506,
south
lowry,
street
1500
and
1700
south
watkins
street
1619.
Dodge
avenue
and
2513
east
19th
street.
C
D
Thank
you,
mr
chair.
In
the
absence
of
our
planning
and
zoning
chair
one
earlier
today,
we
did
talk
about
some
changes
that
we
possibly
need
to
make
to
this
ordinance,
and
in
that
I
would
like
to
ask
that
we
defer,
or
I'm
gonna,
make
a
motion
that
we
defer
this
until
may,
the
24th.
That
would
be
two
weeks
from
now.
C
C
E
Item
w
an
ordinance
closing
and
abandoning
an
unopened
alley
in
the
2100
block
of
east
26th
street
is
detailed
on
the
attached
maps
of
the
certain
conditions,
item
x
and
ordnance
closing
and
abandoning
an
unopened
alley
along
the
800
block
of
dallas
avenue
in
the
2700
block
of
curry,
kirby
avenue,
that's
detailed
on
the
attachments
of
certain
conditions,
item
y,
an
ordinance
closing
and
abandoning
multiple
alleyways
in
the
1800
block
of
vance
avenue
in
the
800
block
of
south
orchard.
Knob
avenue
is
detailed
on
the
attachment.
Subject:
conditions.
C
C
Y
C
C
E
Item
f,
a
resolution
authorizing
the
appointment
of
ariel
soriano
as
special
police
officer
unarmed,
for
the
land
development
office
to
do
special
duty,
as
prescribed
here
in
certain
conditions,
item
g,
a
resolution
authorizing
the
appointment
of
jamie
evers
as
special
police
officer
unarmed,
for
the
land
development
office.
To
do
special
duty
has
prescribed
here
in
subject
certain
conditions.
C
C
E
Number
one:
final:
with
wright,
brothers,
construction,
company,
inc,
charleston
tennessee
for
contract
number,
s1801201,
brandon,
avenue,
drainage
improvements
for
a
decrease
of
eighty
four
thousand;
seven
hundred
ninety
dollars
and
seven
cents
for
reconciliation
of
unit
items
to
release
a
contingency
of
seventy
six
thousand
nine
hundred
fifty
dollars
for
a
total
contract
amount
of
six
hundred.
Eighty
four
thousand
seven
hundred
fifteen
dollars
and
ninety
three
cents
item
k.
A
resolution
of
many
resolution
number
three
one.
E
Oh
two:
six
to
increase
the
estimate
amount
of
eight
eight
hundred
thousand
dollars
to
do
to
additional
contract
utilization
for
the
on-call
design
and
plan
production
services,
contract
number
s2004100
with
the
following
firms:
w
k,
dixon
volker
bars,
design,
snme,
r
k
and
k,
geosyntec,
cti,
crore,
jason
brown
and
caldwell
and
arcadis
for
revised
estimate
amount
of
one
million.
Five
hundred
thousand
dollars
item.
E
C
B
I
will
try
to
be
the
fastest
that
I
have
ever
been.
We
have
seven
purchases
this
evening
recommended
for
approval.
The
first
is
from
the
city-wide
services.
Division
of
public
works,
the
renewal
of
a
contract
for
traffic
safety,
materials,
flashers
and
barricades
for
rental
and
or
purchase
from
a1
barricades.
B
B
These
will
be
four-year
agreements
with
a
combined
annual
amount
not
to
exceed
two
hundred
thousand
dollars.
The
fourth
purchase
is
from
the
waste
resources
division
of
public
works.
This
is
a
new
four-year
agreement
for
joy,
air
compressor
parts
and
services.
Two
bids
were
received
and
the
award
goes
to
ingersoll
rand
co
as
the
best
bid
meeting
specifications.
B
The
other
bidder
took
exception
to
the
city's
standard
terms
and
conditions.
The
annual
amount
is
not
to
exceed
185
000,
the
fifth
purchase
from
the
waste
resources.
Division
of
public
works,
renewal,
contract
for
mixer
gear,
reducer,
repair
services,
sfx
flow
technology
submitted
a
price
increase
of
16
at
the
time
of
renewal,
with
an
annual
amount
not
to
exceed
150
000
the
six
purchases
from
the
fleet
management
division
of
public
works.
This
is
the
second
and
final
final
renewal
of
contract
for
single
axle
dump
trucks.
B
Nine
thousand
six
hundred.
Ninety
three
dollars:
apologies,
the
seventh
and
final
purchases
from
information
technology.
This
new
five-year
blanket
agreement
with
application
software
technologies
ast
for
testing
as
a
service.
This
is
a
sole
source
procurement
with
an
annual
amount
not
to
exceed
one
hundred.
Twelve
thousand
five
hundred
dollars.
C
D
L
V
X
Budget
for
fiscal
year
2023
presented
today,
we
all
received
copies
of
the
budget.
The
budget
went
online
tonight
for
you
all
to
look
at
critique
whatever.
Let
your
council
representatives
know
about
it.
We
start
our
education
sessions
next
week
from
10
to
3,
30
they're
open
to
the
public,
we'll
be
holding
him
in
here.
I
assume
council.
X
X
You'll,
like
it
better,
okay,
all
right,
we'll
have
them
in
here-
we'll
have
them
in
here
and
we'll
be
in
here
from
10
to
3,
30
and
we'll
be
going
over
every
bit
of
the
budget,
and
this
is
these-
are
education
sessions
for
us
right
we're
going
to
have
two
weeks
of
education
sessions;
love
it.
If
you
all
would
be
part
of
these
again.
These
are
questions
we'll
have
the
public
input
session.
X
C
Thank
you
and
thank
you
for
your
hard
work
and
thank
you
for
the
budget
team,
the
work
they
put
into
this
and
mr
goldberg.
We
appreciate
the
mayor
stopping
by
today
to
introduce
the
budget
to
us.
Madam
vice
chair,
do
you
have
anything
in
committees
all
right,
no
report
very
good.
We
will
move
on
to
other
business.
Madam
attorney,
we
have
two
announcements
for
two
items
in
business.
C
C
R
C
A
AD
Now
this
bait,
these
faces
are
very
rare.
I
mean
they
would
know
if
they're
stolen,
so
why
would
they
keep
buying
them?
I
don't
know,
but
it's
a
hardship
on
the
families
when
they
go
out
there
and
put
flowers
and
the
vases
are
gone,
and
I
just
like
for
y'all
to
think
about
some
kind
of
limit
to
put
on
the
scrap
doors.
Thank
you
thank.
AE
AE
AE
AE
AE
AF
I
work
as
a
family
service
assistant
there
and
I
see
firsthand
every
day
how
it's
important
that
head
start
early
learning
program
is
here
to
help
our
community.
I
also
see
many
needs
of
my
families
here
in
chattanooga
from
affordable
housing,
access
to
affordable
healthcare
and
access
to
education.
AF
AF
AF
These
are
all
city
of
chattanooga
employees
and
all
my
co-workers
greatly
appreciate
the
efforts.
Last
year,
the
mayor
and
the
city
council
had
to
bring
our
wages
up
to
a
more
competitive
level
and
many
above
a
competitive
level,
but
there
are
still
those
of
us
who
aren't
there,
yet
there
is
still
much
to
be
done
and
the
cost
of
living
is
at
a
historical
high.
AF
I'm
here
to
ask
that
those
ideas
and
others
as
well
that
we
share
tonight
and
throughout
the
weeks
to
come,
are
included
and
that
you
include
the
comments
of
myself
and
my
co-workers
here
in
chattanooga,
not
just
in
head
start,
but
in
every
department.
We
too
are
a
part
of
chattanooga
one
chattanooga.
Thank.
AF
M
Hello,
joshua
pelish
here
I'm
an
advocate
for
the
unsheltered
citizens
here
in
chattanooga.
I
think
you
know
some
people
are
trying
to
adjust
address.
Is
the
possibility
of
you
know
becoming
homeless,
and
you
know
that
definition
by
law
and
in
other
ways
can
vary.
You
know
based
on
your
geographical
location,
the
size
of
your
house
and
zoning,
particularly
everyone's
looking
at
long-term
development,
but
in
the
short
term
rapid
response.
M
M
M
But
I
got
a
litter
letter
from
the
city
attorney
saying
I
can't
even
go
over
there
to
check
on
my
friends
so
like
tuesday,
I
come
down
here
to
check
on
my
friends,
see
how
they're
doing
make
a
little
speech
and
go
down
there
to
you
know
serve
the
lord
in
my
community,
and
I
can't
even
do
that.
So
if
this
is
america
right
america,
the
land
of
the
free
home
of
the
brave,
the
pursuit
of
happiness,
liberty
and
justice
yeah,
this
is
the
volunteer
state,
tennessee,
correct
and
known
as
the
bible
belt.
M
You
put
all
that
together.
Why
aren't
there
more
people
out
there?
Okay?
Why
am
I
not
the
only
one
by
the
way,
I'm
just
one
dude?
Okay,
I
created
a
non-profit
company.
A
legitimate
non-profit
company
sent
the
paperwork
off
to
the
state
in
january.
Still
haven't
heard
anything
back,
that's
the
state
okay,
so
I
can't
even
legally
apply
for
the
rfp
that
I've
downloaded
and
submitted
and
all
that
sort
of
stuff.
M
So
we
have
to
look
at
bureaucracy
in
terms
of
how
long
it
takes
to
approve
housing,
63
unit
for
elderly,
folks,
55
and
older,
that
comes
out
to
254
000
per
person
and
we're
getting
grant
money
for
that.
Why
can't
we
approve
that?
Hey,
not
in
my
backyard
or
yes
in
my
backyard,
I
got
a
book
from
someone
who
really
cares
about
what's
important
in
life
and
thank
you,
but
you
know
yes
in
my
backyard,
this
is
our
country.
This
is
our
land.
M
Okay,
we
kicked
out
the
indians
a
long
time
ago
and
I'm
sure
there
are
people
before
that,
but
we've
got
to
find
a
way
to
work
together.
Okay,
this
is
america,
there's
more
people
dying
here
in
chattanooga
than
in
afghanistan.
Now
you
know
what
I'm
saying
as
far
as
americans
right.
How
can
we?
How
can
we
let
that
happen?
How
can
we
let
people
suffer
on
the
streets?
How
can
we
say
no
to
something
when
a
church
gets
together
with
a
company
who
hopefully
can
make
profit
and
pay
their
bills?
M
AG
Good
evening,
good
evening,
how
are
y'all
doing
my
name
is
sharon
pryor
I've
been
with
the
city
of
chattanooga
almost
26
years,
I'm
in
community
development,
and
I
want
to
give
the
mayor
a
round
of
applause.
I
really
do
because
he's
done
something
no
other
mayor
has
done.
He
put
his
employees
first,
that's
the
first
thing
he
did
when
he
gave
us
that
raise,
but
in
that
same
process
I
want
to
know
how
is
it
I
can
be
here
almost
26
years
since
somebody's
been
here
15
years,
making
the
same
thing
as
me.
AG
Can
y'all
explain
that
to
me.
I
know
you
probably
can't
right
now,
but
that's
just
part
of
what
I'm
talking
about
the
pay
plan
needs
to
be
fixed.
If
you
don't
know
it,
I'm
I'm
here
to
tell
you
it.
It
needs
to
be
fixed
because
I
feel
like
after
26
years
of
service
and
somebody's
been
here
15
years,
what
I've
given
they
they
can't,
but
all
I'm
here
to
say,
is
when
y'all
look
over
the
budget
please
put
in,
implement
and
think
about
the
pay
plan.
AG
AA
AH
He
talked
about
double
consciousness,
trying
to
be
two
things
in
one
body,
which
is
impossible
in
2013.
We
had
a
city
council
representative.
I
don't
want
to
point
him
out
to
my
right
that
you
all
gave
a
tremendous
amount
of
time
too.
In
fact,
you
gave
him
so
much
time
because
he
was
the
first
homosexual
city
council
representative
to
go
public.
We
camped
outside
of
the
city
council
and
then
I'd
moved
my
encampment
up
to
the
court
grounds.
AH
The
100
million
dollars
that
mayor
kelly
talked
about
in
the
paper.
I
read
recently
that
125
million
dollars
has
been
denied
to
help
people
obtain
affordable
housing.
What
is
affordable
housing,
I'm
monty
bell.
The
homeless
journalist
is
great
here
at
fox.
I've
never
had
any
of
the
criminal
councilman
byrd
to
come
out
and
engage
in
a
contract
with
me
that
nearly
got
me
killed
and
we're
going
to
discuss
that
in
length.
You
don't
have
someone
come
to
my
homeless
encampment
and
seek
me
out
a
man
interested
in
another
man.
AH
I've
had
this
problem
throughout
my
entire
career
and
I've
asked
you
to
stop
him
and
I
had
to
call
the
office
of
the
city
attorney
to
inform
them.
I'm
getting
involved
in
citizen
policing
and
getting
rid
of
this
person,
which
I
had
to
do.
We've
since
had
a
young
lady
shot.
We've
had
a
lady
pushed
off
of
the
bridge
which
you've
moved
all
of
my
homeless
and
campers
off
the
sidewalk.
AH
Turning
me
into
a
white
boy,
I've
been
so
sick
of
that
my
entire
life
two
cases
one
black
man's
case,
one
white
man's
case
the
same
case,
and
you
refuse
to
give
me
the
media
attention
jerry
summers.
How
can
he
be
the
same
attorney
for
the
city
in
the
county?
We're
not
bipartisan
here,
democrats
and
republicans
don't
get
along
when
I
read
ran
for
the
office
of
the
mayor,
the
democratic
party
told
me
that
we
were
bipartisan.
Thank
you,
mr
bell.
C
AI
Yes,
been
here
before
I
represent
the
the
high-rise
people.
On
the
west
side,
I've
been
trying
to
get
some
speed
humps
in
there
for
the
last
25
or
30
years.
Since
I've
been
there-
and
I
talked
to
the
fellow
at
the
city
works,
and
he
told
me
those
crosswalks
the
same
things
as
speed
hunt,
but
he
lied
because
from
where,
from
ml
king.
AI
AI
AI
That's
one
of
the
dangerous
cut
through
in
the
world.
If
you
leave
a
riverfront
parkway
and
go
to
come
up
through
there
by
grove
street
and
past
the
daycare
center,
you
get
once
you
got
one
crosswalk
school
bus
and
everything
else
go
through
the.
I
know
they're
trying
to
get
rid
of
the
west
side,
but
let
us
move
by
don't
carry
us
out.
AI
AI
I
sat
up
there
the
other
day
on
on
the
election
date,
two
hours
watching
people
scuffle
to
come
across
the
street
and
they
lit
dune
buggers
and
walkers,
and
things
of
this
sort
doesn't
make
any
kind
of
sense.
It
took
me.
I
don't
know
how
many
years
to
try
to
get
the
election
place
out
there
and
the
folks
downtown
have
been
trying
to
get
the
election
back
downtown
to
make
an
election.
AI
It
doesn't
make
sense,
we
got
a
place
out
there.
We
got
a,
we
got
a
community
center
out
there,
it's
not
worth
a
quarter
and
we've
got
a
health
center
out
there
that
don't
even
open
up
and
they
spent
the
housing
authority
and
the
thing
it
opens
at
12
hour
for
lunch
and
close
at
one
that
doesn't
make
any
sense.
Everybody
all
the
folks
had
to
get
the
shots
they
had
to
go
to
amaco,
highway
and
everywhere
else
to
get
this
shot.
This
doesn't
make
any
kind
of
sense.
C
AJ
I
think
what
the
mayor
did
last
year
was
great
and
you
remember
ken.
I
told
you
I
agree
with
it,
but
it's
a
lot
of
of
it.
I
didn't
agree
with
because
the
problem
is
I've
been
here
over
30
years,
and
I
got
some
people
doing
my
same
job
that
they
moved
up.
I
only
made
two
thousand
dollars
more
than
them.
It
took
me
30.
I
AJ
AJ
AJ
I
X
X
X
X
X
AC
X
Z
X
Okay,
I
just
because
I
realized
that
you
thought
you
wouldn't
be
heard.
The
sessions
earlier
in
the
day
are
the
sessions
for
council
for
education
sessions,
but
I
made
sure
that
they
would
be
public
so
that
anybody
that
wanted
to
hear
about
how
the
library
works
or
what
the
budget
is
so
but
anything
time,
there's
input.
Those
are
scheduled
for
six
o'clock
and
later
does
that
meet
your
need?
That.