►
From YouTube: Historic Preservation Commission - Aug. 30, 2021
Description
Work Session & Hearing
A
A
A
A
A
A
Item
number
four:
we
will
be
hearing
this
is
a
proposal
to
take
the
sighting
off
of
a
house
and
to
install
lp
smartside
with
diamond
coat,
which
is
not
something
we
typically
is
typically
allowed
in
the
historic
districts.
So
that
came
to
the
commission
for
your
review,
so
that
one
is
proposed
to
be
heard.
A
B
E
Good
evening
nice
to
see
everyone,
this
is
my
last
visit
with
the
three
of
the
planning
and
development
services
department
commissions.
I
had
a
chance
to
present
to
the
planning
and
zoning
commission
and
then
design
review
committee
last
month.
So
I'm
glad
to
be
here
with
you
all
tonight,
just
to
give
a
brief
overview
of
the
city's
climate
action
roadmap
as
part
of
our
outreach
processes
follow
following
the
adoption
of
the
road
map
in
june
by
city
council.
E
So
start
quickly,
with
just
some
background
around
why
the
city
developed
a
climate
action
roadmap,
we're
seeing
a
number
of
climate-related
impacts
in
our
region,
some
of
which
are
described
here
on
the
slide
in
the
bottom
right
hand,
corner
you
can
see
the
drought
severity
index
maps
for
both
idaho
and
the
west
and
the
darker,
the
red,
the
more
severe
the
drought.
So
certainly
some
areas
in
the
west
dealing
with
what
they
describe
as
an
exceptional
level,
drought
and
then
the
other
pictures.
E
What
impacts
would
be
from
climate
change
here
in
boise
and
the
region
looking
at
various
climate
models
and
seeing
what
would
happen
out
into
the
future,
with
some
of
the
changes
that
we're
anticipating
to
see?
And
you
can
see
some
of
the
projected
impacts
there
in
terms
of
hotter
days,
drought,
frequency
and
then
other
impacts
related
to
water.
E
E
And
boise
is
not
new
to
the
climate
action
journey
when
you
think
about
it.
We've
been
doing
clean
energy-
our
geothermal
system
since
before
1900,
so
for
well
over
100
years,
a
clean,
locally
produced
source
of
energy
to
eat
buildings
in
areas
close
to
downtown
more
recently,
more
significant
work
around
energy,
specifically
in
a
number
of
city
facilities.
E
That's
the
20
miles
south
farm
administration
building.
If
you
all
are
not
aware,
the
city
owns
a
farm
south
of
town
where
we
land
apply
biosolids
from
the
wastewater
treatment
process,
and
that
is
the
first
net:
zero
energy
commercial
building
in
idaho.
The
solar
panels
that
you
see
on
the
roof
there
on
average
across
the
year,
produce
more
energy
than
we
use
in
the
building
and
then
and
then
the
green
building
award
there
in
the
bottom
right.
Noting
significant
work
amongst
the
the
private
land
development
community
in
this
area
as
well.
E
What
we're
doing
now
with
the
road
map
and
the
work
that
we're
doing,
is
really
rolling
them
up
together
and
emphasizing
the
discussion
and
prioritization
of
climate
action.
The
mayor
formed
my
team,
the
climate
action
division
last
summer,
consolidating
myself
and
then
three
other
existing
staff
who
had
previously
been
working
on
these
issues
together
and
then
adding
a
fifth
person
earlier
this
year.
E
E
Another
key
purpose
of
the
document
is
to
help
the
city,
identify
climate
action
goals
and
prioritize
opportunities
across
many
different
areas,
and
finally,
we've
set
it
up
to
be
a
living
evolving
document.
Obviously,
things
are
changing
in
this
space
very
rapidly
almost
daily,
and
we
anticipate
this
document
kind
of
evolving
as
technology
changes
as
community
needs
change
and,
as
other
issues
arise,.
E
We've
identified
some
guiding
principles
around
those
goals
to
support
them,
and
that
goes
back
to
the
people,
health
and
jobs
slide.
So
these
think
of
these
as
sort
of
the
key
principles
as
we
work
through
our
implementation,
bringing
in
co-benefits
and
adjacent
activities
that
can
support
the
principles
here.
E
With
that,
we've
identified
seven
priorities.
Some
of
these
line
up
with
the
slides
that
I
shared
a
few
minutes
ago,
kind
of
talking
about
the
journey
to
get
to
this
point,
and
then
we've
mapped
them
on
a
spectrum
from
those
on
the
left
where
we're
focused
on
reducing
emissions
like
in
our
energy
system
or
our
transportation
system,
and
then
those
on
the
right
like
the
natural
environment
and
water,
where
we're
focused
on
resilience
essentially
preparing
for
the
city
that
for
changes
that
may
come
regardless
of
what
we
are
able
to
accomplish
with
mitigation.
E
E
E
Our
greenhouse
gas
emissions
primarily
come
from
two
sources:
the
energy
that
we
use
in
our
transportation
system
and
then
also
the
energy
that
we
use
in
our
residential
and
commercial
buildings.
That's
primarily
comes
from
the
use
of
electricity
and
natural
gas,
and
then
our
approach
to
getting
to
carbon
neutral
is
first
to
reduce
emissions.
So
we
want
to
take
that
pie.
E
Chart
that
you
see
there
down
as
close
to
zero
as
possible
once
that's
occurred,
we'll
look
to
either
sequester
or
offset
emissions
as
our
sort
of
secondary
priorities,
and
then
I
think
the
most
important
element
of
this
slide
is
that
community
in
action.
This
is
a
community
goal.
The
city
can
certainly
do
its
part
in
terms
of
the
facilities
that
we
operate,
but
ultimately
the
success
of
this
will
need
to
be
made
by
all
of
us,
as
residents
and
businesses.
E
Some
of
you
all
may
be
aware
that
the
city
set
clean
energy
goals
a
couple
years
ago
and
those
have
not
gone
away.
They
essentially
integrate
into
the
new
climate
goals
and
become
interim
milestones
or
targets
on
that
path.
So
you
can
see
how
those
lay
out
here,
starting
with
clean
electricity
and
carbon
neutral
for
city
government
and
then
for
the
community.
E
I'll
just
finish
up
here
with
we're
often
asked
what
does
this
mean
to
the
individual
resident?
What
does
this
mean
to
the
individual
business
and
that
is
often
difficult
to
quantify
with
an
issue
as
complex
as
climate
change
or
climate
action,
but
the
intent
of
this
slide
is
to
depict
some
of
the
potential
outcomes
that
would
happen
in
a
carbon
neutral
future,
starting
on
the
top
right.
B
B
D
E
Chair,
commissioner,
thanks
for
the
question,
I
think
in
the
broad
sense
we're
currently
engaged
with
the
planning
and
development
services
department,
as
well
as
other
city
staff,
to
support
the
update,
that's
happening
to
the
development
review
ordinances
with
the
city
and,
where
appropriate,
integrate
more
recommendations
or
requirements
related
to
climate
action.
A
tangible
example
I
could
give
would
be
charging
infrastructure
for
electric
vehicles
that
would
come
along
with
parking
requirements
for
new
development
or
redevelopment,
so
in
the
broad
sense
that
work
to
support
the
regulatory
platform
or
design
guidance.
E
I
think
with
specifics
to
the
historic
preservation
commission.
Certainly
one
thing
that
comes
to
mind
would
be
any
enabling
or
support
for
for
solar
for
rooftop
solar
applications
in
the
historic
district.
Certainly
I
understand
you
all
have
guidelines
that
you
have
to
work
with,
but
there
are
some
challenges
to
rooftop
solar
in
our
state,
given
other
regulatory
constraints,
so
where
there's
an
opportunity
to
support
and
enable
that,
I
think
that
would
be
certainly
one
tangible
outcome
that
would
come
to
mind.
B
B
B
H
A
Thank
you,
madam
chair
good
evening,
and
welcome
to
the
his
boise
historic
preservation
commission
meeting
a
few
things
to
start
out
for
tonight's
proceedings.
Everyone
from
the
public
entering
the
hearing
has
been
automatically
muted
and
cannot
speak.
As
the
item
you're
interested
in
comes
up
for
discussion.
You
will
be
called
upon
and
unmuted
you
will
be
promoted
to
panelists
and
will
rejoin
the
meeting
after
a
slight
delay.
A
A
After
that,
we
proceed
to
public
testimony,
starting
with
those
who
signed
up
on
the
online
sign
up
sheet
in
advance
and
then
anyone
else
who
raises
their
hand
virtually.
If
you
are
attending
through
your
telephone,
you
can
type
star
9.
To
raise
your
hand,
each
member
of
the
public
is
allowed
up
to
3
minutes
for
testimony.
A
A
B
F
E
B
F
B
A
B
Seeing
none
and
based
on
the
representation
of
the
applicant
and
lack
of
opposition
item
drh21-00305
will
be
placed
on
the
consent
agenda.
I
move
that
the
consent
agenda
in
all
items
on
the
consent
agenda
be
approved,
subject
to
all
the
findings
and
conclusions
and
conditions
of
approval
agreed
upon
for
each
application.
Do
I
have
a
second
last
second,
thank
you,
commissioner.
Moroney
victoria.
Would
you
please
call
the
roll
maroney.
A
A
It
is
a
two-story
house,
the
bottom
half
of
the
house
is
clad
largely
in
stucco,
with
the
upper
half
with
shingles
siding
that
was
apparently
according
the
applicant.
That
sighting
was
installed
in
1960,
so
with
that
it
would
not
be
considered
the
original
sighting
the
sighting
beneath
the
structure.
This
is
a
close-up
of
the
existing
sighting.
A
A
A
I
I
So
we've
been
looking
for
a
material
that
we
can
use
to
reside
the
entire
top
floor,
because
we've
not
found
a
shingle
on
the
market
that
matches
the
quality
of
the
shingles
that
were
put
on
in
the
late
60s
and
and
our
repair
work
shows
that
the
shingles
that
we
put
on
the
new
construction
on
the
garage
four
or
five
years
ago.
We
were
not
able
to
match
that
that
solid
flank
look
other
of
the
of
the
original
house
or
the
house
that
was
remodeled
in
the
late
60s.
I
So
the
diamond
coat
has
three
advantages
to
it
that
we
felt
when
compared
with
the
fiber
cement
board.
We
we
liked
it
as
a
better
product,
and
we
thought
it
would
be
a
better
product
for
the
house.
The
first
reason
is
because
the
the
lp
diamond
coat
is
a
is
a
greener
product
than
fiber
cement.
So
it's
more.
I
It's
got
a
lower
carb
carbon
footprint
to
produce
and
to
ship,
and
both
products
are
being
shipped
from
from
the
south
from
louisiana,
so
in
texas,
so
there's
quite
a
distance
that
they're
being
carried,
and
so
just
the
the
cost
of
of
carrying
a
light
product
versus
a
heavy
product
and
then
the
the
process.
The
manufacturing
process
itself
of
the
smart
side
is
a
greener
process
than
than
fiber
cement
and
with
the
added
bonus
that
it
is
renewable
materials
that
is
going
into
the
construction
of
the
of
the
smart
side.
I
So
that
was
reason
number
one.
Is
it's
a
greener
product
reason
number
two
is
from
a
durability
product,
and
I
know
that
there
have
been
issues
with
lp
siding
in
the
past.
However,
with
the
the
diamond
coat
coating,
it
adds
a
very
durable
finish
onto
the
the
manufactured
wood
that
prevents
and
mitigates
against
the
issues
that
have
been
seen
in
the
past
with
particle
board.
I
So
it's
not
your
traditional
lap,
siding
that
we're
putting
on
if
the
diamond
coat
does
give
it
a
very
solid,
very
durable,
protective
finish,
and
you
can
see
that
in
the
application
we've
we've
attached.
Some
photos
of
the
impact
tests
that
have
been
done,
comparing
the
smart
side
with
diamond
coat
against
fiber
cement,
and
you
can
see
the
impact
resistance
there
in
those
photos
to
show
the
durability
of
the
the
smart
side
against
the
fiber
cement.
I
The
third
reason
is
to
in
an
attempt
to
maintain
congruence
with
the
current
look
of
the
house.
So,
if
you
look,
you
know
at
the
the
one
photo
in
particular
of
the
north
side,
where
it's
the
least
damaged
there
is
this
very.
It
looks
like
solid
wood,
siding
on
the
side
of
the
house
and
when
we,
when
we
went
out
and
we're
looking
at
what
kind
of
shingles
could
we
get
to
replace
that
we
simply
are
not
able
to
find
the
quality
of
shingles.
I
That
will
let
us
replicate
that
the
the
depth,
the
height
of
the
of
the
siding
and
also
the
the
the
smooth
bottom
finish.
That
being
said,
the
siding
does
have
a
texture
to
it
and
this
the
fiber
cement.
As
you
know,
it's
a
smooth
siding.
So
we
would
not
be
able
to
maintain
the
texture
of
the
siding
with
with
the
smooth
fiber
cement,
with
the
diamond
coat
that
the
siding
is
textured.
I
B
A
B
I
So
one
other
comment
that
I
almost
forgot
about
sorry
about
that
this
is
tracy.
Speaking
again,
we
do
have
or
know
of
several
other
historic
districts
across
the
us
that
have
approved
this
product
in
in
their
zones,
one
in
indiana
for
sure,
and
we
believe
one
in
louisiana,
we're
still
trying
to
sort
that
that
one
out,
but
I
can
send
the
reference
for
indiana
if
that
would
be
of
interest
to
to
the
committee
and
and
then.
B
C
C
C
I
think
I
mean,
if
you
can't
find
it,
I
think
you
should
be
looking
for
something
that
is
the
same
material
and
as
close
as
you
can
get
to
it,
you
shouldn't
be
doing
a
wholesale
replacement
of
your
siding.
You
should
be
repairing
it
where,
where
possible,
so
that's
my
first
recommendation
would
be
to
repair
it
and
then
replace
sections
that
you
need
to
replace
and
they
put
cedars
there's.
G
B
Yeah,
I
just
my
thoughts.
It
sounds
like
from
from
the
applicant's
mouths
that
this
has
been
a
process.
They've
been
working
on
for
quite
some
time
and
given
the
fact
that
we
are
in
a
very
interesting
global
situation,
materials
are
near
impossible
to
come
by
and
when
they
are
available,
they're
incredibly
expensive.
And
so
I.
B
D
Consider
emotion-
and
I
have
just
one
comment
and
if,
if
I'm
understanding
everything
quickly
that
we're
looking
at
a
house
that
has
the
sighting
was
put
on
in
the
60s,
but
we
don't
really
know
what
was
originally
there
and
it
and
it's
my
understanding
that
we're
trying
to
the
desire
would
be
to
have
the
same.
Look
on
the
house.
D
That's
here
now
that
was
put
in
the
60s,
rather
than
putting
it
back
to
what
it
might
have
looked
like
in
1912
when
it
was
originally
built,
and
I
would
suspect
that
some
of
the
siding
options
that
don't
quite
match
this
might
match
more
of
what
was
originally
on
the
house.
And
potentially
you
know.
I
can
understand
that
this
look.
B
C
I
mean
I
agree
with
commissioner
weaver
that
would
be
nice
to
have
a
little
bit
more
research
done
on
what
would
have
been
there
and
then
another
route.
Is
that
not
all
the
sides
of
the
house
need
replace,
so
I'm
replacing
the
ones
that
need
needed
that
are
in
the
sun
all
the
time.
So
that's
another
possibility,
because
if
we're
talking
about
what's
green,
what
green
but
screen
would
be
leaving
the
sides
that
don't
need
replaced.
D
And
then
I
guess,
if
the
homeowners
want
to
look
at
a
couple
of
these
options
of
either
partially
replacing
the
siding
or
doing
additional
research
into
you
know,
maybe
what
what
was
originally
there.
If
we
are
looking
at
still
reciting
the
whole
house,
then
you
know,
then
they
could
come
back
with
staff
and
and
discuss
that
with
them
rather
than
having
to
come
back
here.
But
that
would
be
fine.