►
Description
Coverage of the May 2, 2023 Cupertino City Council Meeting.
(Live Streamed Version)
A
A
B
D
E
Thank
you
mayor
way,
so
the
the
council
heard
two
items
in
closed
session
today
and
took
an
action
to
authorize
the
City
attorney
to
file
a
cross-complaint
in
the
action
Sharma
versus
city
of
Cupertino.
B
Thank
you,
CT
attorney,
and
so
we
are
going
to
move
to
ceremonial
items
on
number
three.
B
F
Thank
you
on
behalf
of
Silicon
Valley
at
home.
I
would
like
to
thank
the
city
of
Cupertino
for
this
Proclamation
for
affordable
housing
month.
This
year's
theme
is
building
communities
and
by
building
communities.
We
are
finding
ways
to
make
sure
that
our
members
and
our
our
neighbors
and
our
longtime
community
members
and
new
friendly
new
neighbors
are
able
to
come
and
stay
in
the
cities
that
we
love
and
work
hard
for.
So
thank
you
so
much
for
this
Proclamation
and
thank
you
for
your
leadership
in
recognizing
this.
B
B
As
part
of
tonight's
ceremonial
matters,
we
have
two
proclamations
that
have
been
issued
but
are
not
being
presented
here.
So
we'd
like
to
I
would
like
to
acknowledge
them.
First
I'd
like
to
take
a
minute
to
recognize
the
month
of
May
is
Asian
American
and
Pacific
Islander,
otherwise
known
as
aapi
Heritage
Month.
So
many
Asian
Americans
in
Pacific
Islanders
have
contributed
to
our
country
and
our
City's
economy
and
supplement
a
unique
character
of
our
nation.
B
The
aapi
community
has
produced
leaders,
scientists,
teachers
and
so
many
more
people
who
have
also
campaigned
and
fought
for
a
fairer
and
more
just
Society
for
all
Americans.
We
recognize
and
celebrate
the
contributions
that
Asian,
Americans
and
Pacific
Islanders
have
made
to
our
city
state
and
Nation.
B
In
addition,
I
would
also
like
to
recognize
National
Public
Works
week,
which
is
May
21st
to
27th
this
year.
Public
Works
professionals
focus
on
infrastructure
facilities
and
services
that
are
vital
to
the
public
health
quality
of
life
and
well-being
of
our
residence
in
the
city
of
Cupertino
and
Beyond
I'd
like
to
recognize
and
thank
our
Public
Works
employees
here
in
Cupertino,
for
all
of
their
hard
work
in
maintaining
improving
and
protecting
our
City's
Parks
public
facilities
and
much
more
for
our
community.
So
thank
you
very
much
for
our
Public
Works
employees.
B
So
any
postmodern
from
the
council
I
actually
like
to
see
if
my
fellow
council
members
I
like
to
make
a
recommendation,
a
motion
to
postpone
consent,
number
11.
and
the
reasons
I
like
to
postpone
and
table.
It
are
twofold.
First,
you
know
we
are
in
the
process
of
doing
housing,
elements
and
I
do
believe.
B
We
need
to
have
a
holistic
view
of
the
city,
what
are
the
same
rural
streets
and
have
an
overview
of
the
semi
Rural
Street
so
that
we
can
decide
which
ones
can
move
forward
and
which
ones
we
need
to
reconsider
in
the
housing
element.
The
second
one
is
I
am
I
would
like
to
know
the
impact
from
a
potential
common
Bridge
Project
with
this
semi
rural
destination,
so
I'm
going
to
move
that
we
tabled
number
11
for
a
future
date
until
we
have
a
little
bit
more
information
and
where
our
housing
element
is
moving
forward.
B
G
G
E
B
I
I'd
like
to
have
a
substitute
motion
that
we
do
if
I
need
to
do
this,
that
we
hear
the
item
and
not
postpone
it
because
we
have
already
had
this
item
come
to
the
city
council
before
and
they've
already
pulled
the
entire
neighborhood
to
see
what
their
opinions
are
on
the
matter.
G
B
The
request
yeah,
we
have
a
substitute
motion
motion
by
council
member
Moore
and
second
because
remember
ciao,
and
if
there's
no
more
discussion,
that's
vote
on
it
by
light.
B
I,
actually,
okay
with
the
suction
motion,
so
okay,
so
we'll
keep
it
on
the
so
we're
going
to
move
to
oral
Communications.
This
portion
of
the
meeting
is
reserved
for
persons.
B
C
Mayor
we
have
three
speaker
cards
in
Community,
Hall
and
I
see
one
hand
raised
on
Zoom.
So
we'll
start
with
the
the
speakers
in
Community
Hall
Sandy
James,
followed
by
Brooke
as
it
followed
by
Jennifer
Griffin,
okay,.
J
Good
evening
Madame
mayor
vice
mayor
city,
council,
city
manager,
my
name
is
Sandy
James
and
I
am
a
former
mayor
as
well
as
a
long
time
resident
of
Cupertino
and
I'm
here
tonight
to
acknowledge
and
praise
our
public
works
department
I've
been
involved
in
many
ways
in
this
city
and
all
of
us
that
live
here
see
the
work
that
the
public
works
department
does
every
single
day.
Wherever
we
go
in
the
city,
they
are
absolutely
outstanding.
J
I
just
like
to
give
you
two
personal
examples
that
that
I
am
really
touched
by
the
first
one
is
the
Veterans
Memorial.
You
know
that
I
was
the
the
co-founder
of
the
Veterans
Memorial,
the
city
staff,
from
the
very
beginning,
when
we
dedicated
that
in
2007
has
been
they
sort
of
adopted
that
Memorial
they
take
very
good
care
of
it.
The
tiles
are
always
nice
and
clean.
The
lawn
looks
beautiful
around
it.
J
J
I
could
tell
you
all
kinds
of
wonderful
stories
around
that
Memorial,
but
tonight
I
want
to
acknowledge
the
staff
that
has
really
helped
us
in
every
way
whenever
we
need
any
help
with
a
new
Boulder
being
installed
or
in
any
way
they're
there.
They
they
help
us
in
numerous
ways
and,
more
importantly,
to
me,
they
take
great
pride
in
it
and
they
take
personal
care
of
it
and
that's
an
example.
In
addition
to
that,
the
former
public
works
director,
Roger
Lee.
J
Some
of
you
knew
Roger
he
retired
about
two
years
ago,
at
the
same
time
that
my
project
manager,
passed
and
so
I
took
Roger
to
lunch
and
I
asked
him
if
he
would
be
willing
in
retirement
to
be
a
project
manager
for
any
and
any
additions
or
or
any
changes
and
improvements
that
needed
to
be
made,
and
he
very
willingly
said
yes
and
so
he's
doing
that
now
working
with
the
staff.
Obviously
they
work
very
well
together.
J
J
I
see
him
every
day
and
it
is
astounding
the
amount
of
pride
he
takes
in
his
work,
how
much
time
he
spends
on
it
and
we
all
enjoy
it
every
time
I
go
to
the
library
we
go
to
City
Hall
or
we
just
walk
in
the
city
hall,
City,
Center
area,
so
he's
just
another
example
of
the
outstanding
service
that
all
of
our
Public
Works
employees
give
us
as
well
as
the
management
team,
so
I'm
just
here
to
say
thank
you
to
all
of
them
from
myself
and
probably
from
the
rest
of
the
community.
Thank.
C
K
Brooke,
thank
you
good
evening.
I
would
like
to
address
the
majority
of
this
Council
about
focusing
all
of
one's
resources
on
persecuting
people
whose
only
behavioral
pattern
involves
reading.
Thinking
and
being
honest,
do
you
know
what
happens
when
you
persecute
people
doing
the
work
and
continue
to
do
so
exclusively
when
you
become
tasked
with
doing
the
work?
Well,
things
stop
working
because
no
matter
how
much
those
doing
the
persecuting
and
only
the
persecuting,
pretend
understand
the
problem
and
not
working
for
a
solution
but
pretend
to
work
for
a
solution.
This
does
not
create
Solutions.
K
This,
in
fact
creates
more
problems
case
in
point.
Housing
is
expensive
around
here
we
need
better
Transit
and
we
need
inclusionary
zoning.
We
have
to
deliver
temporary
housing
for
unhoused
people,
because
people
are
dying
out
there.
These
are
not
easy
things
to
do,
but
there
are
real
solutions.
Yes,
they
require
work
and
thought
they
require
real
conversations
with
the
development
Community,
some
really
difficult
conversations.
What
is
not
a
solution
is
taking
money
from
development
interest
and
then
saying
whatever
it
is.
K
They
want
you
to
say
or
whatever
it
is
that
you
think
they
want
you
to
say.
Why
is
this
problematic?
Why
does
reading
thinking
and
being
honest,
actually
yield
better
results?
That's
an
interesting
question,
reading,
thinking
and
being
honest,
you'll,
better
results,
because
that's
how
you
arrive
at
Solutions,
rather
than
schemes
and
cover-ups,
that's
how
you
talk
to
anyone
with
care
and
Effectiveness,
whether
you
call
them
a
friend,
a
relative,
neighbor
or
stakeholder.
K
That's
how
you
work
effectively
through
any
issue.
If
there's
a
disagreement,
then
share
the
perspective,
appreciate
the
thinking,
don't
smother
it,
that's
how
you
earn
and
build
respect.
If
you
instead
adopt
tactics
of
smear
and
not
doing
the
work,
then
maybe
you
feel
some
surge
of
Victory
if
the
tactics
work
for
a
cycle,
but
really
what
really
happens.
The
quality
of
thinking
erodes
to
the
point
of
being
absent
economies
fail
people
who
do
the
work
get
attacked
for
doing
the
work.
Our
problems
get
worse.
K
Does
that
sound
familiar,
please
start
doing
the
work
and,
honestly,
what
was
the
point
of
removing
the
two-thirds
majority
required
to
call
a
question?
Do
you
realize
that
is
about
building
consensus?
It
literally
has
never
been
a
problem,
and
the
majority
of
the
council
eliminated
that
that
was
incredibly
disappointing.
Please
do
your
work.
Thank
you.
L
Good
evening
city
council,
hi,
I'm,
Jennifer,
Griffin
and
I
wanted
to
speak
tonight
on
one
or
two
items,
I'm
very,
very
concerned
with
how
the
housing
element
is
rolling
out
in
California,
as
I
had
stated
in
the
Planning
Commission
last
Tuesday.
It
has
become
aware
that
50
percent
of
the
cities
in
southern
California
have
not
been
certified
by
hcd
for
their
housing
element,
and
this
is
for
the
last
two
years.
L
Hcd
has
been
running
the
cities
in
Northern
California
ragged
in
a
hamster
wheel
cycle
with
no
way
off
we're
being
threatened
with
Builders
remedy
edicts
from
the
state.
The
governor
and
Rob
Banta
are
going
after
a
suburb
of
Sacramento
for
some
reason,
just
as
they
are
going
after
Huntington
Beach,
they
appear
to
not
like
cities,
which
is
very
strange.
L
Since
Gavin
came
out
of
San
Francisco
I
am
still
trying
to
figure
that
one
out
I'm
going
to
talk
for
a
minute
about
SB,
423
I,
believe
personally,
that
the
housing
element
is
something
that
is
supposed
to
keep
the
cities
busy
so
that
they
don't
watch
to
see
what
housing
bills
are
being
churned
out
at
the
sacramental
level
by
Senator.
Weiner
and
some
other
folks
I've
been
dubious
about
the
housing
element.
Since
the
beginning,
I
said
it
was
a
dog
and
pony
show
two
years
ago.
It
is
still
a
complete
circus.
L
L
Sb
423
is
one
of
the
worst
bills
to
have
been
introduced.
Mr
weiner
has
about
four
more
years
of
his
11
years.
That
he's
allowed
to
be
in
the
legislature.
I
understand
that
he
wants
to
run
for
I
believe
he
wants
to
have
to
go
to
the
state
to
the
federal
level,
but
423
is
the
coffin.
L
Is
the
lid
on
the
coffin,
our
complete
Liberty,
to
have
local
control
and
to
live
in
our
cities
is
going
under
with
this
horrendous
Bill
I'm
bringing
it
up,
because
the
main
concern
is
that
the
coastal
areas
are
going
to
be
inundated
with
housing.
It
leaves
us
open
and
vulnerable
to
builders.
Remedy
and
hcd.
I
predict
will
not
certify
us,
they
will
not
certify
Cupertino.
Thank
you
Jennifer.
It
is
a
hamster.
M
Hi
I
have
an
overhead
this
evening.
First
I'd
like
to
follow
in
Sandy
James's
footsteps
here
shout
out
to
Public.
Works
I
was
lucky
enough
to
attend
the
audit
committee
and
there
was
an
audit
of
how
the
building
project
was
handled,
but
the
library
and
Susan
Michael
did
an
absolute
Stellar
over-the-top
job.
M
You
know
the
Auditors
could
only
find
a
little
couple
of
little
nitpicks,
which
and-
and
you
know
we
learned
from
having
that
audit.
We
know
now
that
the
city
is
doing
a
great
job,
so
shout
out
to
Susan
Michael.
The
other
thing
I
learned
at
the
audit
committee
was
that
we
have
a
150
million
dollars
or
so
in
long-term
savings,
and
now
the
city
intends
to
move
toward
liquidating,
that
and
and
and
with
respect
to
the
cdtfa.
M
M
We
didn't
used
to
see
that
and
I'm
so
appreciative,
and
no
wonder
that
why
Kitty
was
has
been
voted
by
her
peers
to
have
had
leadership
positions
on
the
VTA
previously
anyway,
what's
going
on
with
the
budget,
so
the
first
slide
here
this
is
showing
per
capita
income
for
sales
tax
in
this
in
comparing
other
cities.
So
this
is
Cupertino.
You
can
see
that
cupertino's
pretty
much
gone
much
higher
than
our
peers
in
San,
Jose,
Los,
Altos,
Mountain,
View,
I.
M
Think
I've
shown
you
this
slide
before
and
and
so
I
really
want
to
see
how
we
can
live
within
our
means.
I
know
that
on
April
13
y'all
were
talking
at
potential
about
potentially
selling
our
water.
Our
water
rights
I
want
you
to
know
that.
M
That's
something
that
we
voted
for
in
1960
for
those
of
you
who
were
around
to
vote
or
even
living
here
and
and
and
it's
it's
troubling
that
that
would
be
considered
to
be
sold,
because
it's
a
publicly
traded
company
that
it
would
go
to,
we
would
have
no
control.
M
The
other
thing
is,
please,
don't
consider
selling
our
open
space
Blackberry
Farm
again.
This
is
something
that
we
voted
for.
It's
interesting
any
of
you
guys
who
pay
or
rare
the
utility
users
tax.
That
is,
that
that
was
initiated
through
the
purchase
of
Blackberry
Farm
in
1990,
and
very
clear
in
the
vote:
the
acquisition
and
preservation
of
Blackberry
Farm
as
open
space
I.
For
me,
that's
a
third
rail
issue.
M
The
other
one
is
with
respect
to
Bloomberg
News.
There's
another
article
out
there
I'd
really
like
to
see
more
transparency
coming
out
of
the
city
with
respect
to
what's
comes
worse
with
clawback
and.
C
N
And
City
Council
Members
I
would
like
to
acknowledge
the
great
work
done
recently
by
the
Cupertino
sister
cities
organization
and
specifically
the
Cupertino
sintures.
Is
the
cities
Association
after
a
height
of
four
or
four
years,
chsca
is
successfully
planned
and
executed
a
fantastic
delegation
from
Cupertino
to
the
sister
city
of
sinchu
Taiwan.
N
These
events
form
the
history
of
our
city.
To
understand
this
one
would
have
seen
the
photos
of
sister
city
with
a
dating
back
to
the
1980s
during
the
recently
conducted
Terry
Blossom
Festival,
the
sister
city
program
is
unique
to
our
city.
It
is
Meaningful
and
builds
bonds
that
last
a
lifetime
between
the
Youth
of
Cupertino
and
our
city
and
make
them
realize
the
value
of
participating
in
the
Civic
process
and
giving
back.
N
It
is
a
special
and
unique
different
shade
of
a
Cupertino
compared
to
the
neighboring
cities
in
Santa
Clara
County.
None
of
this
would
have
been
possible
without
the
effort
of
the
leads
for
the
visit
this
year
to
sinchu.
I
would
like
to
explicitly
call
out
and
give
a
shout
out
to
the
contributions
of
the
following
people:
Mr
Angelo
neguera,
a
teacher
from
Kennedy
Middle
School
Miss
Janice
sung,
president
of
chsca.
N
Each
of
the
above
members
are
tirelessly
for
weeks
and
months,
alternating
in
10
days
of
long
hard
work
for
them,
but
giving
lifetime
memories
to
the
students
that
travel
for
that
school,
kids,
the
travel
and
their
families
that
experience
the
program
will
be
forever
grateful.
I
encourage
the
city
to
similarly
revive
the
program
for
other
sister
cities
and
ensure
funding
is
maintained
and
expanded
for
the
sister
city
visit
I
request
the
city
to
expand
the
sister
city
programs
to
be
symmetric
in
their
eligibility
for
high
school
students.
N
As
you
may
be
aware,
the
property
is
not
eligible
for
high
school
students.
Kindly
expand
the
program
to
be
insured,
who
you
know
high
school
students
are
eligible.
Finally,
I
want
to
thank
me
RV
for
our
travel.
It
makes
a
difference
and
I
hope
to
see
vice
mayor,
Mohan
and
other
council
members
join
in
future
trips
in
the
near
future.
Thank
you
very
much.
O
Good
evening,
mayor
way,
vice
mayor,
Mohan,
council
members
and
staff
I
want
to
address
the
budget
survey
that
was
posted
on
the
City
website.
It
closes
on
May
31st,
but
the
city
is
going
to
present
the
results
on
May
17th.
O
O
Also,
the
survey
is
lopsided
and
narrow
when
reducing
expenditures.
Everyone
goes
for
the
for
the
big
first
items:
hiring
freeze
eliminate
any
project,
that's
not
necessary,
such
as
some
of
the
CIP
projects.
Don't
start
new
ones,
reduce
maintenance
costs
by
maybe
going
to
70
percent
instead
of
80
on
the
street
code.
O
O
P
P
The
the
small
City-
and
we
have
actually
the
case
right
here-
is
a
city
actually
through
their
own
residence
if
they
with
the
ones
without
the
knowledge
the
buildings
suits,
sometimes
the
ones
that
I
study
foundation
for
the
the
Imports
at
the
wall
and
everywhere,
actually
it's
open
to
the
space,
and
it
still
comes
out
only
a
few
centimeters
and
also
these
people
for
the
table
from
less
than
five
feet
and
big
shells
become
a
story
or
because
it
will
hire
their
neighborhood,
they
add
another
they
could
put
behind
the
neighborhood
before
he
becoming
it
before.
P
So,
that's,
that's.
The
overage
action
is
capping
the
city
alone.
They
don't
need
to
solve
itself,
and
you
know
you
can
talk
about
how
the
state
and
the
other
agents
trying
to
do
that
too
or
small
cities
and
all
the
people.
Whoever
made
that
decision.
It
comes
for
it
and
also
whoever
don't
have
the
building
background
and
try
to
make
that
decision
quickly
and
all
the
ones
thoughts,
not
don't
need
it.
There
was
The
Beauty,
Department
and
later
on,
we
actually
get
from
it.
B
B
Eight,
so
we
have
eight
and
eleven
that's
being
called
okay,
so
I
like
to
open
public
comment
for
items
number
four,
five,
six,
seven,
nine
and
ten.
These
are
for
public
comments
not
for
eight
or
eleven,
but
for
the
rest
of
the
consent
calendar,
that's
not
being
pulled
so
do
we
have
any
cards.
O
Good
evening,
mayor
way,
vice
mayor,
Mohan,
council,
members
and
staff
I
want
to
speak
to
the
I
I
mean
this
is
a
lot
of
money
and
I
understand
that
a
lot
of
this
money
is
coming
from
already
designated
Bots.
But
item
number
10,
curves,
gutters
and
ramps
is
one
and
a
half
million
dollars.
O
Then,
to
me
it
seems
like
I
I
know
in
a
normal
year
you
could
just
go
as
as
planned,
but
it's
not
a
normal
year
and
it
won't
be
for
another
10
years.
So
reducing
only
doing
higher
priority,
curbs
ramps
and
gutters
would
be
The
Prudent
way
to
go
cut
the
cut
the
budget
by
20
percent
have
them
in
the
report.
They
didn't
even
list
which
ones
they
were
going
to
do.
I
know
vice
mayor
Mohan
asked
and
they
have
a
list
and
they're
probably
prioritized
so
cut
the
cut.
O
The
lowest
20.,
the
lowest
25
reduce
the
cost.
Also,
the
garbage
and
construction
item
number
2012
you're
increasing
our
costs,
not
yours
and
right
now
people
are
being
laid
off.
B
Excuse
me
we're
not
talking
about
12
right
12
is
not
on
consent.
So
when
12s
come
out
action,
please
raise
your
hand
and
speak
to
12..
Thank
you.
C
B
L
Know
I
think
I'm
starting
to
get
this
after
six
months,
but
I
still
get
really
confused.
Okay,
yeah
eight
I
had
asked
I
had
I
think
sent
several
emails,
asking
it
to
be
pulled.
It
has
been
so
I'm
still
confused
about
what
we're
doing.
I
understand.
You
know:
I've
been
coming
here,
23
years,
so
I
believe
me.
I,
know
this
agenda
by
heart.
So
I,
don't
know
why
we're
discussing
number
seven,
but
that's
what
you
guys
want
to
do
we'll
do
that.
L
So
I
want
to
make
sure
on
seven
that
Cupertino
is
not
having
to
shoulder
more
of
the
cost
burden.
Santa
Clara
is
bigger
than
Cupertino.
They
have
more
money
than
Cupertino.
They
are
probably
not
going
through
a
budget
issue
like
we
are
and
I
I
just
want
to
make
sure
that
Cupertino
is
not
going
to
get
dragged
through
the
weeds
like
they
are
by
everyone
and
I
am
really
getting
tired
of
having
Mr,
Banta
and
the
governor
say
bad
things
about
my
city.
L
L
I
want
to
make
sure
that
in
this
situation
that
we
are
getting
our
bang
for
the
buck,
I
I
think
there
was
a
problem.
The
last
time
that
this
came
up,
that
it
seemed
like
Cupertino
was
having
to
give
out
a
lot
more
money.
You
know
I
like
Santa
Clara,
but
fair
is
fair.
We
have
got
to
fight
for
our
individual
cities
and
it's
nice
to
have
the
Via
shuttle,
but
we
do
have
buses
we
do
have
you
can
call
cabs,
you
can
have
a
lift
you
can
have
relatives.
L
Take
you
places
believe
me.
I
spend
a
lot
of
my
time
taking
people
places
and
it's
my
pride
and
joy
to
do
that.
But
I
really
do
not
want
Cupertino
to
get
reamed
I
don't
want
to
find
out
five
years
from
now
that
we
were
paying
the
bulk
of
this
and
Santa
Clara
has
gotten
a
free
ride
now
how's
that
for
a
Segway,
if
you
guys
can
make
sure
that
we're
not
getting
taken
to
town
in
a
town
car,
then
I
will
be
very
happy
about
this.
L
C
Thank
you
Jennifer
and
thank
you
mayor
for
catching
that
so
so,
seeing
as
eight
was
move
it
moved
to
after
the
the
action
calendar,
we
have
no
more
speaker
cards
in
Community
Hall.
However,
we
have
one
hand
raised
on
Zoom
by
San
r
welcome
San.
N
Hello
mayor,
we
and
city
council
I'd
like
to
make
a
clarifying
question
or
comment
on
consent.
Calendar
item
number
I
believe
it
is
item
number
six
on
the
hazardous
waste
collection
program.
It's
not
clear
to
me
from
the
staff
report.
If
the
cost
is
going
to
be
passed
on
to
the
residence
of
Cupertino.
I
would
like
to
request
that
if
these
costs
are
going
to
be
passed
on
to
the
residents
of
Cupertino
that
will
not
be
approved,
we
have
seen
a
continuous
rise
in
our
utility
bill
and
Recology
has
continued
to
rise.
N
Our
prices
and
I
want
to
make
sure
that
this
is
not
another
increase
that
we're
going
to
get
nickel
and
timed
on
so
I
request
the
city
council
to
please
take
a
look
at
item
number
six
and
understand
what
exactly
it
means
to
augment
the
funding
by
an
additional
ninety,
Thousand,
Seven
or
five.
The
staff
report
I
could
not
make
out
from
that
if
those
costs
will
be
passed
on
in
the
form
of
additional
fees
on
restaurants,
and
so
I
want
to
bring
that
to
your
attention.
Thank
you.
B
Thank
you,
medicity
clerk
Can,
the
staff
answer
the
question,
or
should
we
can
we
have
a
staff
get
back
to
the
resident
about
the
the
number
six
we.
B
The
residents,
thank
you
very
much,
so
we
have
consent,
calendar,
8
and
11
Port.
It
is
customary
it's
going
to
become
a
separate
action
item,
so
we
have
to
take
public
comments
when
it
comes
up,
they
will
be
placed
after
the
action
item.
So
right
now
we
have
consent
number
four,
five:
six,
seven,
nine
and
ten
I'd
like
to
have
a
motion
to
approve
the
consent
calendar
please
except
number.
Eight
and
eleven.
B
Eleven
thank
you.
May
I
have
a
second
please.
Second,
so
it's
being
moved
and
seconded
that's
vote
by
light.
B
Unanimously,
thank
you.
Now
we're
gonna
move
to
action
item
which
is
number
12.,
consider
a
request
for
proposals
for
garbage
and
construction
and
demolition
debris
disposition
services,
including
solicitation
of
options
to
process
garbage
for
Recovery
of
organic
and
other
recyclables,
and
do
we
have
a.
H
S
Thank
you
city
council,
mayor
Chad,
Mosley
interim
director
of
Public
Works
Ursula
is
going
to
present
this
item
for
all
of
you
and
I
met
with
most
of
you
before
this
meeting.
I
appreciate
your
time,
and
hopefully,
we've
done
a
good
job
of
answering
your
questions
and
hopefully
Ursula's
presentation
will
provide
relevant
information
to
to
the
public
today
so
or
so.
If
you'd
like
to
start
yeah.
T
T
T
Second,
agreement
is
with
a
landfill
for
disposal
of
the
city's
garbage
and
for
processing
and
disposal
of
construction
and
demolition
debris.
The
cost
for
both
agreements
is
factored
into
the
garbage
rates
paid
by
residents
and
businesses,
while
Recology
does
collect
all
the
materials
they
also
through
sub-agreements
arranged
for
processing
of
the
green
and
blue
cart
materials
after
Recology
collects
those
materials.
The
green
cart
Organics
are
taken
to
recology's
facility
in
San,
Jose
Consolidated
and
then
are
transferred
to
one
of
two
facilities
to
be
composted.
T
Recyclables,
like
paper
and
containers
placed
in
the
blue,
cart,
are
taken
to
green
waste
in
San
Jose,
where
they
are
sorted
and
processed
for
sale.
These
arrangements
are
all
managed
by
Recology,
as
noted
in
our
franchise
agreement.
They
will
continue
unchanged
and
they
are
not
the
topic
of
today's
item.
T
What
is
before
us
today
is
the
material
in
the
gray,
carts
and
bins,
currently
that
material
in
the
carts
and
bins,
the
gray
ones
is
collected
by
Recology
and
then
taken
to
newbie
Island
landfill
near
Milpitas
for
direct
disposal.
Recology
also
takes
construction
and
demolition
debris
to
newbie
Island,
where
it
is
sorted
for
Recovery
of
usable
materials
and
then
anything
left
over
is
disposed
into
the
landfill.
T
T
As
noted
on
the
previous
Slide,
the
city's
garbage
goes
directly
to
the
landfill,
while
material
and
construction
and
demolition
Debris
Boxes
undergo
some
processing
to
remove
recyclable
materials,
and
then
the
leftovers
are
landfilled,
as
we
think
about
the
construction,
demolition
debris
and
contemplate
new
agreements.
We
are
interested
in
what
kinds
of
diversion
rates
different
facilities
can
achieve
as
they
each
have
different
technology
and
Recovery
rates.
T
T
T
Some
people
will
willingly
do
a
good
job,
sorting
the
Organics
and
recyclables
out,
but
other
people
will
not,
as
we
come
to
the
end
of
our
current
agreement,
with
Republic
to
dispose
of
materials
at
newbie,
Island
Landfill,
which
has
been
in
place
since
1989.
One
of
the
big
questions
we
can
now
ask
ourselves
is
whether
or
not
we
want
to
send
collected
garbage
to
a
material
recovery
facility
or
Murph.
T
A
Murph
can
divert
up
to
half
or
even
more
of
incoming
garbage,
depending
on
the
technology
and
processes,
because,
as
we
saw
in
the
previous
slide,
a
lot
of
the
material
in
our
garbage
is
organic,
such
as
food
scraps
and
food.
Soiled
paper.
Routing
garbage
through
a
Murph
for
processing
is
a
recommended
climate
change
mitigation
strategy
identified
in
the
city's
adopted
climate
action
plan,
cap
2.0
and
would
in
fact
accomplish
action
item
W
1.2.
T
If
Cupertino
decided
to
send
garbage
to
a
material
recovery
facility,
it
would
not
remove
or
replace
the
green
and
blue
carts
and
bins
yard
waste.
Food
scraps
and
food
soiled
paper
could
still
go
into
the
green
carts
where
people
are
willing
and
able
and
encouraged
to
do
so,
and
recyclable
containers
and
clean
paper
would
still
go
into
blue
carts.
T
T
The
cost
of
disposal
is
just
one
part
of
the
overall
equation
in
determining
the
garbage
service
rates,
but
a
preliminary
evaluation
of
cost
for
sending
garbage
to
a
Murph
could
result
in
single-family
residents
with
32
gallon
garbage
service,
which
is
the
most
common,
paying
an
additional
five
to
eight
dollars
a
month
or
about
seven
to
fifteen
percent
more
than
they
would.
If
the
garbage
was
sent
directly
to
landfill
without
processing
in
2020,
a
survey
was
conducted
of
residence
on
topics
relating
to
garbage,
Organics
and
recyclables.
T
T
T
So
what
service
providers
are
nearby
here
is
a
map
of
the
service
providers
in
our
general
area.
Newbie
Island
Landfill,
where
our
garbage
currently
goes,
is
next
to
Milpitas,
and
then
we
can
see
that
there
are
two
other
landfills
in
the
South
San
Jose
area,
as
well
as
to
material
recovery
facilities.
T
T
The
conceptual
timeline
for
this
project
is
shown
here.
The
launch
of
the
RFP
is
expected
in
May
or
June,
and
then
we
anticipate
three
months
for
proposers
to
develop
responses.
These
proposals
would
be
reviewed
and
evaluated
in
negotiations
with
the
recommended
providers
will
begin
after
that,
as
noted
in
the
staff
report.
Communications
during
this
time
of
RFP
can
present
challenges
and
perhaps
invite
unwanted
requests.
T
It
is
recommended
that
if
any
proposer
approach
you
directly
that
you
direct
their
questions
and
inquiries
to
staff,
as
noted
in
the
RFP,
our
next
steps
are
to
issue
the
RFP
evaluate
proposals
and
make
recommendations
the
city's
goals,
as
stated
in
the
zero
waste
policy
from
2017
and
our
climate
action
plan,
support
ongoing
efforts
to
minimize
waste
going
to
landfill,
including
routing
garbage,
to
be
processed.
But
we
are
looking
for
guidance
from
Council
on
that
point,
in
particular,
as
we
head
into
that
process,
and
that
concludes
my
slides
and
I'm
happy
to
answer
any
questions.
R
Ursula
I
had
a
question.
We,
you
are
fairly
certain
that
the
rate
per
household
is
will
increase
by
what
eight
dollars
to
ten
dollars
per
month.
If
the
garbage
is
redirected
to
an
mrf.
H
R
Okay,
so
we
would
really
only
know
it
could
be
more,
it
could
be
less
depending
on
the
rfps
right,
correct,
okay,
so
this
is
something
that
we
could
consider
again
after
we
receive
the
RFP
responses.
S
You
wouldn't
mind:
Council
will
be
seeing
any
negotiated
contracts
prior
to
approval,
so
with
those
negotiations
we'll
be
we'll
be
back
with
numbers
at
that
point
in
time
you
can
decide
based
on
the
cost,
to
the
residents
today
we're
just
looking
for
kind
of
general
direction
as
to
you
know,
policy
direction,
as
it
should
be
kind
of
go
out
and
look
at
the
material
recycling
facility
as
an
additional
option,
above
and
beyond
the
services
that
we
already
provide.
Cupertino.
B
I
D
There
was
a
slide
that
you
had
with
respect
to
they
survey
as
to
whether
or
not
residents
would
be
willing
to
pay
more
or
pay
less
and
I
didn't
notice
at
the
time
and
did
today
that
it
was
taken
in
2020.
Do
you
recall
considering
that
2020
was
a
rather
unusual
year
when
in
2020
that
might
have
happened.
G
G
Thank
you,
yeah
I,
thank
you
for
considering
this
I
think
it's
always
it's
more
price
to
pay
to
improve
on
how
we
process
our
garbage.
My
question
is
so
with
this,
but
then,
besides
the
five
to
eight
dollars,
we
also
expect
the
the
garbage
fee.
You
say
to
increase
ant
in
addition
to
the
five
to
eight
right.
T
Right,
so
this
is
kind
of
a
big,
complicated
ball
of
things,
but
all
else
being
equal
that
one
piece
of
sending
to
a
material
recovery
facility
or
not
would
be
that
additional
amount.
The
five
to
eight
estimated
we
are
going
into
a
fourth
year,
cost-based
adjustment
with
Recology,
where
we're
going
to
review
the
rates
and
bring
those
before
Council
for
approval,
that's
built
into
the
franchise
agreement,
so.
G
I
from
what
I
read,
even
with
the
the
amount
of
recyclables
that
we
produce
on
in
general,
only
five
percent
actually
gets
recycled
and
cut
capacity
of
of
this.
A
lot
of
this
recycle
processors
are
very
limited,
so
a
lot
of
them
couldn't
get
processed
and
still
went
to
the
landfill,
so
I'm
just
curious.
It's
always
good.
To
with
this
program
we
will
be
able
to
produce
more
recyclables,
but
the
product
cost
of
processing,
recyclable
globals
is
increasing
because
of
the
capacity
challenges
and
many
of
them
don't
even
get
processed
so
I'm
curious.
T
T
G
So
they
are
getting
recycled
because
I
read
multiple
sources
that
they
say
on.
There
are
a
lot
of
challenges
with
separating
the
different
kind
of
plastic
and
if
they
cannot
be,
many
of
them
are
not
cleaned
that,
if
not
separated
properly
it's.
There
are
a
lot
of
challenges
to
actually
recycle
them.
That's.
T
T
S
If
I
may,
one
of
the
biggest
things
that
we're
looking
at
with
this
with
the
internal
recycling
facilities
is
Organics
we're
trying
to
pull.
S
A
I
I
I
was
shocked,
yeah,
so
yes
and
I
was
watching
a
video
on
on
one
of
the
murphs,
and
it
was.
I
It
was
interesting,
so
I'm
wondering
in
terms
of
the
landfills
are
these:
are
they
all
created
equally,
what
we're
looking
at
and
if,
if
they,
if
there
are
some
differences
for
how
they
are,
are
constructed,
if
some
of
them
are
doing
a
better
methane
recapture
doing
a
better
job
with
the
with
the
the
leachate
anything
like
that,
if
we
could
come
back
and
let
us
know-
or
if
you
already
know
about
that
I'm
curious
about
it,
we
did
in
this
course
look
at
look
at
all
the
landfills
in
the
Santa
Clara
County.
I
So
but
they
didn't
really
talk
about
the
actual
construction
being
different
for
them
or
yeah
things
of
that
nature.
I
If
you've
got
some
information
on
that,
that
would
help
and
then,
with
regards
to
the
murf
facilities,
if
if
we
could
have
a
little
bit
information
about
the
what's
distinguishing
one
from
another,
that
that
would
be
helpful
and
I
think
you
know,
while
we
have
that
the
the
green
bin,
maybe
you
have
some
thoughts
about
what
is
kind
of
keeping
people
from
actually
doing
that
separating
because
and
then
the
other
part
is
what
happens
when
people
don't
separate
their
Organics
when
it
goes
to
the
landfill?
T
So
the
Organics
going
to
the
landfill
today,
what
happens
to
them
so
the
the
main
difference
I
think
of
with
that
is
composting,
Organics
versus
Organics,
going
to
the
landfill
and
the
landfill
environment
is
anaerobic
and
just
that
situation
that
environment
generates
methane
as
opposed
to
a
composting
process
which
generates
more
carbon
dioxide
and
methane
is
84
times
more
potent
than
carbon
dioxide,
so
they're
both
generating
some
greenhouse
gases.
But
it's
much
worse
in
the
landfill
environment.
T
And
to
the
other
questions,
I
I
mean
we
could
ask
Peter
if
he
knows
a
bit
about
I
know
land.
All
landfills
are
not
created.
Equal.
Some
are
newer.
Some
are
older,
different
technology.
Different
lining,
I,
just
don't
know
those
answers
off
the
top
of
my
head
for
the
specific
ones
in
our
area,
but
we
could
include
that
you
know
request
in
the
RFP.
I
would
think
to
describe
their
the
makeup
of
their
facility.
X
Y
Mayor
council
vice
mayor
just
a
quick
comment:
yes,
we
will,
as
part
of
the
RFP,
be
looking
at
the
regulatory
status,
which
is
really
the
key.
The
key
issue
for
the
landfills
and
checking
in
terms
of
their
permits
and
status
of
of
all
that.
B
By
the
way
from
HSN,
thank
you
Peter,
so
councilman
Memorial.
Are
you
okay
with
your
questions?
Okay,
so
my
question
is
this
agenda
is
ask
the
council
to
approve
for
you
to
go
out
to
get
estimates
and
you
can
come
back
with
reports
on
different
proposals,
so
we
can
at
that
time
can
decide
what
to
do
right,
which
one
to
pick
with
price
or
materials
or
how
they're
going
to
process
and
how
much
we
have
those
detailed
information
mayor.
Q
If
I
could
interject
here,
yeah
thank
you
so
I
want
to
be
clear
on
on
the
recommendation
from
staff,
so
we're
we're
looking
at
a
an
increased
focus
on
recycling.
So
with
that,
we
wanted
to
be
clear
that
that
increases
the
cost
to
to
the
to
the
to
the
residents
and
the
businesses,
as
as
we're
doing
that,
it's
still
in
alignment
with
our
cap.
But
we
thought
because
there
was
a
significant
decision
point
and
a
cost
increase.
We
wanted
to
check
in
with
you
to
make
sure
that
we're
still
in
alignment
in
that
direction.
Q
So
our
recommendation
is
to
pursue
the
direct
the
previous
Direction
lined
out
in
the
in
the
climate
action
plan,
and
we
would
structure
the
RFP
and
the
evaluation
of
the
rfps
in
alignment
with
that.
So
we
would
be
emphasizing
the
ability
to
recycle
and
with
that,
we
would
sort
of
book
a
little
bit
less
at
the
cost
associated
with
that,
because
we
know
there's
going
to
be
an
increased
cost.
So
that's
what
we're
asking
for
here
to
make
sure
that
we're
in
alignment
as
we
go
forward
with
that.
Okay.
B
C
Yes,
we
have
two
speaker
cards
in-house
and
we
have
I
see
two
hands
raised
on
Zoom
Jennifer
Griffin
is
first
followed
by
Rhoda
Frye.
L
L
Etc
I
was
just
curious
whether
this
would
be
come
if
you,
if
you
all
I'm
assuming,
would
contract
once
you
get
your
bids
in
ETC.
If
you
would
be
contracting
with
one
of
these
vendors
and
do
are
they?
How
is
the
contract
with
Recology
and
the
new
vendor
set
up?
Would
we
be
billed
through
Recology
would
would
a
home
in
Cupertino
receive
two
different
bills?
Would
they
be
bundled
together
and
how
does
that
affect
the
cost
increase
to
the
customer?
L
I
I
think
that
I
I'm
a
little
bit
curious
about
how
that
goes
because
I
understand
that
garbage
contracts
I
mean
coming
here.
23
years
we've
had
Recology
I
think
it
was
Los
Altos
garbage
for
a
while,
but
we've
had
various
times
that
they've
had
to
come
in
and
rebid
the
contracts
and
I'm
just
curious.
How
that
would
be
set
up
with
this
extended
environmental
setup
here
Etc?
L
It's
good
for
the
public
to
understand
how
the
contracts
are
set
up,
because
then
they
understand
more
of
what's
going
on
in
the
bidding
process,
especially
when
you
have
a
long
time
vendor
like
Recology
Cupertino
has
dealt
with
them
for
many
years.
That
way,
then
the
public
is
clued
in
on
what
to
expect,
and
there
are
no
surprises.
So
if
you
could
talk
about
after
the
bidding's
done,
how
do
they
award
the
contracts?
L
C
M
M
Z
Z
I
heard
this
being
discussed
on
my
way
in
and
I
did
hear
councilmember
chao's
questions
with
regard
to
Plastics,
and
it
made
me
really
want
to
put
in
a
plug
for
awareness
of
the
fact
that
we
really
do
have
a
very
serious
plastic
contaminants
issue
worldwide
and
if
you'll
recall
back
when
I
was
on
Council.
Last
year
and
mayor,
we
held
a
mayor
scope
challenge.
It
was
an
inaugural
challenge,
talking
about
the
issue
of
microplastics,
and
these
are
not
questions.
Z
I
think
that
are
immaterial
to
the
situation
that
you're
looking
at
here
and
a
lot
of
the
discussion
that
we
had
last
year
was
about
the
various
influences
on
the
reality
of
what's
happening
right,
because
petroleum
usage
in
vehicles
is
projected
to
go
down
for
obvious
reasons,
but
at
the
same
time,
the
industry
right
fueled
by
a
lot
of
motivational
dollars,
is
wanting
to
Output
more
of
these
materials.
And
how
do
they
do
that?
Well,
unbeknownst
to
a
good
portion
of
people.
Z
So
as
pertains
to
something
like
this,
if
we're
focusing
upon
the
various
things
that
we
can
do,
even
though
most
of
these,
perhaps
by
weight
or
Organics,
this
is
also
an
accumulative
problem
right,
because
what
doesn't
end
up
getting
recycled
often
gets
you
know.
Decomposed-
and
you
know,
we
wouldn't
have
thought
it
30
years
ago,
when
we
thought
we
had
these
brand
new
shoes
or
whatever
they
were
little
covers
on
DVDs,
but
right
now,
they're
degrading
and
a
lot
of
these
things
go
out
into
our
environment.
Z
C
O
Good
evening,
mayor
boy,
vice
mayor,
Mohan,
council,
members
and
staff
I'm
concerned
with
the
increase
eight
dollars
per
month
for
12
months
is
72
dollars
a
year
and
that's
only
one
utility
we've
got
electricity,
gas,
water,
sewer
and
now
garbage
you
can't
look
at
this
in
a
vacuum.
You're
impacting
us
all
across
the
board.
Please
the
survey
taken
in
2019
since
then,
we've
had
layoffs,
all
utilities
have
been
increasing,
we're
going
into
another
recession,
we're
impacted
and
it's
not
getting
any
better
right.
O
Now
the
presentation
stressed
Organics,
not
all
the
other
recyclables
50
going
in
landfills
are
Organics
and
that's
that's
bad
I
understand
that
punishing
everyone
for
actions
by
a
selected
group
of
people
out
of
either
ignorance
or
just
not
caring,
doesn't
make
sense
rewarding
people
for
getting
it
right,
educating
so
that
you
can
train
them.
O
I
think
that
gets
more
benefit
than
charging
us
to
do
this.
My
husband
and
I,
encouraged
by
our
son
and
daughter-in-law,
we
focused
on
Organics
and
the
city,
had
had
set
a
orange
juice
container
and
expected
everybody
to
use
it
for
the
Organics
and
it
didn't
work
it
leaked.
It
was
just
ugly,
but
we
found
something
that
hangs
on
a
cabinet,
a
bottom
kitchen
cabinet,
and
there
are
bags
that
are
compostable,
that
that
line
this
little
tub.
O
It's
like
a
little
bucket
and
it's
very
convenient
and
we've
done
it
and
it
and
we've
reduced
our
trash,
buy
a
whole
bag
and
we
have
one
of
those
small
gray
trash
cans.
So
that's
significant,
but
it
took
somebody
saying:
oh,
you
can
use
this
and
there
are
bags
to
line
it.
Educate
us
show
us
what
we
can
do
to
improve.
Don't
punish
us
with
additional
costs.
O
My
ask
is
that
you
not
increase
the
cost
of
the
residents
at
this
time.
Educate
reward
us
have
fun
games
where
it's
difficult
to
recycle,
see
how
many
people
can
get
it
right
anyway.
N
N
Furthermore,
you're
not
considering
the
lower
income
strata
of
Cupertino.
On
the
one
hand,
we
talk
about
affordable
housing,
concessional
housing,
homeless,
housing
and
all
of
these
initiatives
that
are
intended
for
equity.
On
the
other
hand,
we
talk
about
projects
that
go
after
higher
utility
prices.
Solving
upper
class
problem
ignoring
the
day-to-day
challenges
that
people
face,
26.7
percent
of
Cupertino
is
Indian
American.
N
It
is
hard
for
me
to
understand
how
City
staff
makes
these
recommendations.
Perhaps
they
don't
live
in
the
city
and
they
don't
have
to
pay
for
this.
I.
Don't
understand
how
the
council
makes
these
suggestions
that
are
completely
out
of
touch
with
your
residence
and
I'm
disappointed
that
our
ex-mayor
is
also
making
the
same
suggestions.
I
agree
with
Peggy.
N
B
Thank
you,
mother,
CD
clerk
I'd
like
to
thank
all
the
public
comments.
Ella
especially
recognize
our
immediate
former
mayor,
Darcy
Paul.
Thank
you
for
coming
and
so
we're
going
to
close
the
public
comment
and
go
back
to
the
council
for
a
discussion.
I
Hands
sure
thank
you
Mary
mayor
way.
Do
we
have
any
financial
assistance
at
all
for
garbage
pickup?
We.
T
Do
Recology
offers
a
low-income
discount
that
is
available
and
to
the
previous
question,
it
will
all
be
on
the
garbage
bill.
There
will
not
be
separate
bills,
so
it
will
all
be
folded
in
okay,
the
same
way
it
is
now
seamlessly
with
you
know,
even
though
we
have
an
agreement
with
a
separate
landfill.
That's
all
on
the
on
the
garbage
bill.
Okay,.
I
And
then,
when
I'm
looking
over
at
San
Jose
area,
I've
noticed
that
all
of
their
yard
waste
goes
out
into
the
street
and
they
do
a
pickup
right
from
the
street,
but
they
don't
separate
the
their
their
Solid
Waste
out
so
that
all
of
the
the
kitchen
scraps
and
everything's
going
in
there.
And
then
you
have
a
recycle
bin
for
to
pull
out
your
paper
and
plastic
and
all
like
that.
So
have
you
looked
at
the
what
they're
charging
as
a
comparison
for
what
we
have
for
rates
here
for
a
comparison.
T
I
Okay,
just
quickly
so
I
I,
really
like
the
idea
of
individuals
separating
it
out
themselves
and
that
saves
on
cost.
But
if
we're,
if
we
have
a
situation
where
people
just
actually
are
not
doing
it,
then
one
way
is
to
have
some
kind
of
enforcement.
And
are
you
anticipating
that
happening.
T
Sb
1383
actually
requires
us
to
enforce
proper
separation
beginning
in
2024.,
so
we
will
be
going
out
and
trying
to
do.
Enforcement
I
mean
you
know.
There
are
60
000
residents,
so
you
know
we're
not
going
to
be
at
every
14
000
single
family
homes
every
week,
but
we're
going
to
try
to
do
our
best
to
you
know:
do
Outreach
education,
flip
Lids,
offer
friendly
feedback
and
encouragement
we're
not
going
to
lead
with
citations
or
anything.
We
always
want
to
lead
with
education,
but
the
state
law
does
require
us
to
enforce
beginning
2024.
I
Okay,
so
that's
that's!
Coming
up,
that's
wow!
Okay!
So
with
regards
to
that,
do
you
anticipate
there
will
be
a
citation
like
a
like
a
parking
ticket
type
of
thing
coming
at
some
point,
it's.
T
T
Sunnyvale
Mountain
View,
obviously
San
Jose
channels
through
I'm,
not
sure
about
the
West
Valley
Cities
Peter
may
know.
If
we
want
to
have
him
join
us
again,.
T
G
G
What
I
find
is
I
put
my
Organics
in
this
little
bin,
which
has
a
lid
that
the
city
provide.
It
works
great.
However,
I
don't
have
yard
waste
every
week
since
I
don't
have
a
long,
so
certainly
for
the
weeks
I
don't
have
any
yard
wasted.
There
is
no
place
for
me
to
put
my
Organics
so
I.
Would
then
this
kind
of
program
offer
place?
We
can
drop
off
Organics
because.
T
T
T
S
G
Q
T
G
Q
Intent
is
to
bring
back
a
staff
recommendation
and
that's
why
we're
here
tonight.
We
want
to
get
your
guidance
early
on,
so
that
we
can
do
the
evaluation
and
bring
back
a
solid
recommendation
that
aligns
with
what
we
think
is
correct:
the
cap,
the
climate
action
plan
and
we're
hoping
that
you
can
provide
that
direction
tonight,
so
that
we
can
bring
a
solid
recommendation
to
you
for
a
contract
award.
When
we
come
back.
G
Really
appreciate
that
you
bring
this
to
the
council
early
on
to
get
direction
and
I'm
just
wondering
in
Inc.
There
might
be
multiple
providers
and
degrees
of
sustainability.
Maybe
the
cost
difference
will
be
five
dollars
a
month
ten
dollars
a
month
and
so
that,
if
there
is
option
we
always
want
to
do
good.
But
then
we
need
to
balance
and
need
the
cost.
G
Q
D
T
So
so
far
with
SB
1383,
you
know:
we've
we've
made
sure
everyone
has
their
service
available
to
them,
which
luckily
we
we
mostly
had
in
place.
We
had
some
stragglers
that
we
picked
up
and
everyone
has
service.
We
do
focus
more
on
Commercial
generators
because
obviously
they're
going
to
have
a
larger
amount
for
a
single
generator.
T
So
far,
we've
had
good
luck
just
well.
You
know
we
we
go
out
and
educate,
we
look,
educate
and
work
with
them
and
and
we've
had
good
success
with
bringing
folks
into
compliance.
It's
an
ongoing
effort,
so
we
between
Recology
staff
and
our
own
staff
we're
out
looking
in
bins
every
week,
it's
especially
with
San
Jose.
You
know
wanting
everyone
to
put
it
in
the
garbage,
and
you
have
people
commuting
here
to
work.
B
So
I
like
to
make
some
comments.
We
just
had
our
Earth
day
and
then
all
five
high
schools
in
our
Fremont
Union
High
School
District,
had
their
separate
Earth,
Day
and
I
was
fortunate
to
attend.
One
of
them
and
the
speech
I
made
is
cupacino
is
taking
meaningful
action
to
reduce
greenhouse
gas
emission
and
mitigate
climate
action
change
impacts.
The
city
adopted
climate
action
2.0
in
August
of
last
year.
B
This
plan
outlines
the
next
generation
of
strategies
to
achieve
a
carbon-free
city
by
2040
and
is
comprehensive
of
all
sectors
of
our
local
economy,
including
clean
energy,
Transportation,
zero
waste,
adapting
to
climate
change
and
working
with
nature.
I
do
think
our
city
needs
to
take
a
lead
and
walk
the
talk
and
really
work
on
our
cap
2.0
and
move
forward
in
reducing
waste.
It's
I've
seen
you
know,
I
know
like
as
a
family.
We
try
to
separate
the
ways
councilmember
ciao
I,
my
Gardener
only
come
every
other
week.
B
So
one
week
my
guard,
my
green
bean
will
be
empty,
so
what
I
do
is
I
put
them
in
in
a
shopping
in
grocery
shopping
bags,
which
are
paper
so
that
contains
the
you
know
the
way,
so
it
doesn't
contaminate
the
the
the
green
thing
and
I
do
it
on
Monday
on
the
day
that
they're
going
to
pick
a
garbage.
So
that's
my
solution,
because
you
know
you
don't
want
it.
The
the
beans
to
be
really
dirty
smell
of
food,
so
I
think
we
can
make
an
effort
to
really
do
it.
B
Ourselves
and
I
am
very
pleased
that
the
city
staff
is
recommending
that
we
go
forward
and
really
be
a
leader
in
this
area.
So
that's
my
comment
and
do
we
have
any
other
more
comments?
If
councilmember
Moore,
you
have
about
a
minute
and
45
seconds,
okay,.
I
I
So
if
there,
if
there's
there's
like
an
optimal
solution
for
the
for
the
best,
we
can
do
with
the
technology
that
we
have
right
now.
I
I'd
be
interested
in
hearing
that
and
whether
or
not
there's
some
trade-off
for
different
Murph
facilities,
which
have
a
more
advanced
technology
and
also
with
regards
to
the
landfill.
I
If
there's
some
landfills,
which
are
actually
doing
a
better
job
than
others,
I
I,
don't
know
what
the
answer
is
to
that,
but
I
I'm
interested
in
in
hearing
about
it
and
while
you
know
I
mentioned
I,
was
taking
this
class
I,
remember
being
a
kid
going
to
the
the
dump
and
back
then
it
was
a.
It
was
an
open.
It
was
opened
up,
no
liner,
nothing
and
that's
where
most
of
them
are
like.
So
I'm
I'm
really
glad
to
see
that
this
has
improved
so
much
over
the
past
30
and
40
years.
R
R
T
Probably
not
likely,
and
even
as
it
is
now,
the
the
market
rate
for
landfill,
just
direct
disposal
to
landfill
is
a
bit
higher
than
what
we're
paying
under
our
current
agreement.
So
even
if
we
kept
disposing
direct
to
landfill,
we'd
likely
see
a
little
bit
of
an
increase
just
to
come
up
to
Market
and
that.
But
if
are
you
asking.
A
T
For
pulling
more
out
exactly
yeah,
that's
an
interesting
question:
I
I
think,
with
the
increased
expense
of
going
through
the
processing.
I,
don't
know
if
there
would
be
a
cost
benefit,
but
that's
something
hfh
will
help
us
evaluate.
B
B
So
I
think
if
we
might
want
to
encourage
our
students
to
propose
to
the
district
and
follow
the
Cupertino
City's
lead,
so
they
are
separates
all
like
Fremont
Union,
High,
School,
Districts,
USD
and
40
audience
that
they
all
have
separate
agreements.
T
B
B
B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
I
Like
to
recuse
on
this
item,
if
I
may
make
my
statement,
okay,
thank
you
before
we
begin
this
item.
I
need
to
make
a
statement.
I
I
believe
that
the
council
is
making
a
quasi-judicial
decision
here
today,
whether
to
release
an
attorney-client
privileged
confidential
attorney,
work
product
report,
the
14th
Amendment
of
the
U.S
Constitution
guarantees
all
people
the
right
to
due
process.
The
U.S
Supreme
Court
determined
the
following
rights
and
protections
for
quasi-judicial
decisions.
I
I
I
I
This
is
how
I
was
able,
for
instance,
to
determine
that
Cupertino
had
not
been
properly
reporting
its
financial
information
on
a
regular
basis
to
the
public
as
a
result
of
that
work,
I
discussed
this
fact
with
the
Civil
grand
jury.
During
my
interview
with
them.
That
discussion
is
what
led
to
the
Civil
Grand
jury's
prior
report
entitled
show
me
the
money,
but
the
problem
with
the
current
activities
is
that
they
fail
to
reflect
upon
the
various
parts
of
the
discussion
and
the
work
process.
I
Part
of
that
job
is
to
ensure
that
there
is
transparency
in
government
processes
and
a
great
deal
of
the
work
of
the
public
is
ensuring
that
people
understand
where
monetary
and
lobbying-based
influences
arise
and
what
their
effects
are.
I
see
this
current
exercise
as
a
pure
sham
and
I
think
it's
a
shameful
statement
as
to
the
protections
that
we
are
supposed
to
provide
to
the
public.
We
owe
it
to
ourselves
to
comport
ourselves
with
integrity
and
not
be
unduly
influenced
here.
I
I
do
not
believe
this
is
an
impartial
Council
that
should
be
making
what
appears
to
be
a
quasi-judicial
decision
that
will
adversely
and
falsely
impact
individual
interests
and
the
community.
In
the
absence
of
due
process,
we
have
had
bright,
inquisitive
and
hard-working
colleagues
on
this
Council
and
what
I
see
now
is
political
gamesmanship
in
the
form
of
leveraging
mechanisms
of
accountability
in
the
name
of
discriminatory
gains.
I
E
So
I
think
this
would
be
a
good
time
for
me
to
give
a
brief
presentation.
So
so
what
we're
here
today
is
to
discuss
whether
whether
a
report
of
an
independent
investigation
conducted
into
the
conduct
of
City
officials
as
directed
by
this
Council,
should
be
publicly
released
or
whether
it
should
continue
to
remain
confidential
in
attorney
client
privileged.
E
There
are
no
no
rights
of
any
individual
affected
by
this
report,
so
there
is
there's,
certainly
no
due
process
obligations,
at
least
not
at
this
time,
and-
and
certainly
you
know,
council
member
Moore
was
not
advised
to
recuse
herself.
Nor
is
she
required
to
at
really
any
stage
of
this
process,
including
today,
but
if
she
chooses
not
to
participate
in
the
deliberation,
that's
her
right
to
do
so.
E
E
The
city
council
directed
the
city
attorney's
office
to
investigate
and
report
back
on
violations
of
the
municipal
code
with
respect
to
council
staff
and
commissioner
staff
relations.
The
city
attorney's
office
retained
Linda
Davi
to
conduct
an
independent
investigation,
and
the
council
has
been
provided
with
a
confidential
attorney-client
privilege
report
prepared
by
Miss
Dobby.
E
E
E
If
Council
does
not
need
to
see
the
need
to
discuss
this
report
further
or
discuss
this
report
in
public,
no
action
is
required
today
and
I
point
out
that
that
Miss
Dobby
is
available
on
Zoom.
If
there
are
any
process
related
questions
that
the
council
has.
However,
at
this
point
the
substance
of
the
report
remains
confidential
and
so
we're
not
prepared
to
discuss
it
and
as
well
as
you
know,
Miss
Dobby's
thought,
processes
and,
and
and
and
and
and
and
and
deliberations,
and
prepare
the
report.
E
B
Thank
you
to
the
attorney
so
I
understand.
Miss,
Linda
Dobby
is
online
to
answer
procedures.
Questions,
that's
correct,
okay,
so
I'm
opening
up
for
Council
questions.
So
please
remember
our
city
attorney's
advice
that
this
is
still
under
a
client
attorney,
client
privilege.
So
no
content
and
confidential
information
is
to
be
revealed.
So
do
we
have
any
questions
or
yes,
please,
council,
member
yeah.
G
G
And
there
was
no,
so
we
can
discuss
the
process
of
preparing
the
report
and
there
is
no
cross-examination
so
that
any
of
the
statement
provided
to
me
stop
is
able
to
be
verified
and
cross-examined
by
anyone
who
are
accused
right.
G
This
kind
of
and
I
have
asked
for
even
for
the
part
that
I
was
interviewed,
I
requested
a
transcript
of
my
interview,
because
I
feel
the
the
report
report
is
extremely
biased
and
accurate
and
I
requested
a
transcript
of
the
interview
and
I
was
told.
The
transcript
itself
is
confidential.
Therefore,
the
transcript
of
every
interview
is
confidential.
The
only
thing
that
will
be
made
available
to
the
public
would
be
opinions
written
by
me
step.
However,
you
can
say
it's
neutral,
but
it's
an
opinion.
E
E
E
So
there
so
so
there
is
no
transcript
available
for
your
discussion
with
Miss
Dobb
Dobby,
I,
I,
I,
I,
I
I.
Believe
the
advice
would
remain
that
that
the
report
is
final
and
that
you
know
any
attempt
by
council
members
to
influence
the
opinion
of
an
independent.
The
independent
investigation
would
raise
pretty
serious
ethical
concerns.
G
G
E
G
G
You
mean,
at
least
for
me
now
no
attempt
has
been
no
material
has
been
given
to
me
anything
that
I
that
I
read
in
the
report
and
then
I
didn't
see
those
until
I
read
and
then
the
report
did
not
provide
any
effects.
So
I
would
have
like
to
have
a
conversation
on
the
accuracy
of
those
accusation,
but
I
was
not
able
to
bring
that
up
in
the
interview,
because
I
was
not
aware
of
those.
G
G
Okay,
20
seconds
left
so
I
did
not
receive
the
report
until
3
pm
yesterday
and
I
didn't
have
time
to
really
read
through
them.
I
only
had
maybe
about
10
minutes
to
glance
through
them
today
at
work,
and
so
I
would
request
that.
Please
postpone
this
item.
If
you
want
to
make
any
action,
because
I
need
to
go
through
the
report
to
respond.
X
Oh
good
evening,
mayor
of
way
and
council
members.
D
Good
evening,
just
a
a
few
questions
to
lay
the
groundwork
for
what
your
background
is.
Could
you
tell
us,
for
example,
how
long
you've
been
practicing
law?
What
sort
of
law
you've
practiced
what
your
experience
is
in
producing
reports
of
this
character.
X
Yes,
I've
been
a
public
lawyer
for
approximately
in
excess
of
30
years.
I
worked
for
the
City
of
Long
Beach
for
10
years.
I
was,
with
a
fairly
large
law
firm
in
Los
Angeles
for
another
eight
I
matriculated
My
Way
North
to
Sonoma
County
I
served
as
a
contract,
City
attorney
for
a
city
in
Contra,
Costa
County
for
another
eight
years
and
then
I've
been
I,
ran
my
own
Law
Firm.
For
the
remainder
of
that,
and
that's
what
I'm
doing
now,
I've
done
a
lot
of
litigation.
X
X
But
no,
no,
the
it
was.
The
thing
that
stood
out
was
the
cons.
You
know
which
what
you
do
is
look
for
credibility
and-
and
you
know,
I
basically
don't
have
a
dog
in
this
hunt
so
to
speak,
and
so
what
you're
doing
is
looking
to
see.
You
know
what
are
the
factors
that
are
most
important
and
I.
Think
I've
listed
some
of
those
in
the
report,
but
but
what
you
do
then,
is
you
interview?
X
You
know
you
know:
I've
interviewed
16
people
in
here
current
and
former
employees.
You
then
because
of
the
numerous
emails
which
I
went
through,
which
is
about
oh
probably
up
to
800
I,
don't
know
my
eyes
are
going
a
little
bit,
but
I
went
through
and
I
compared
what
the
statements
were
with
the
email
exchanges.
X
I
also
asked
each
of
the
witnesses
to
you
know
if
you
had
documents
and
so
forth
that
supported
your
case,
then
I
was
able
to
look
at
that.
I
looked
for
discrepancies
in
the
statement.
X
You
know
that
it's
basically
the
you
know,
can
you
verify
the
fact
and
in
this
particular
report
there
was
an
inordinate
amount
of
consistency
in
in
everything
that
was
said
at
that
point,
then
I
I
talked
to
other
people
to
find
out.
If
there's
another
side
of
the
story.
R
Did
the
people
were
the
people
who
were
mentioned
in
the
report?
Did
you
in
your
in
your
line
of
work?
Did
they
get
sufficient
opportunities
to
explain
themselves
or
yeah,
maybe
explain
themselves,
and
did
they
get
an
opportunity
to
make
sure
that
whatever
the
accusations
or
the
incidents
that
were
mentioned
were
handled
from
from
their
side
as
as
well?
And
it
wasn't
just
one-sided.
X
As
far
as
I
could
tell
because
there
it
was
more
not
so
much
consistent
or
individual
incidents,
but
collectively
there
were
just
a
couple
of
things
that
you
know
when
I
had
very
good
conversations
with
the
people
mentioned
in
the
report,
though,
as
far
as
I
was
concerned,
the
the
issues
where
there
was
the
other
side
of
that
story.
Those
are
the
things
that
have
been
included
in
the
report.
X
I
think
one
of
the
things
and
if
I
may
comment
one
of
one
of
the
issues
that
you
saw
in
the
Civil
grand
jury
report
and
I
did
watch
that
council
meeting
that
there
were
some
some
some
issues
raised
about
some
of
the
findings
there.
So
one
of
the
things
that
I
wanted
to
do,
which
was
sort
of
a
carry-on,
was
to
to
to
ask
questions
regarding
you
know
what
the
what
the
issues
were
with
the
report.
So.
B
Okay,
thank
you.
So
thank
you.
I
have
a
question
a
couple
questions.
Thank
you
Miss
Dobby.
Can
you
wait
a
little
bit
what
I
asked
RC
attorney
one
questions?
First,
so
Jensen
when,
when
the
council
instructed
you
to
find
a
an
investigator,
did
you
do
due
diligence
and
find
a
professional?
You
feel
that
would
give
the
council
an
unbiased
professional
investigation.
E
Yeah,
yes,
Miss
Miss
Debbie
has
experienced
a
municipal
attorney,
and
this
is
her.
Current
practice
is
doing
this
kind
of
investing
Personnel
investigations
as
well
as
this
kind
of
investigation,
and
so
so
she
has
extensive
experience
and
again,
the
purpose
of
retaining
her
was
was
to
prepare
an
independent
report.
Thank.
B
You
Miss
Dobby
can
I
ask
you
a
couple
questions
procedure,
questions
as
in
your
profession,
in
your
professional
opinion,
this
particular
case
you
have
applied
the
customary
and
professional
procedures
to
come
up
with
an
independent
report.
Well,
you
think
that's
accurate,
or
can
you
elaborate
on
it.
X
Yes,
you
know:
I
I
am
a
frequent
speaker
in
terms
of
processes.
I
am
asked
by
several
I
represent.
Currently
I
go
all
over
the
state,
because
I
came
from
Southern
California
and
so
I'm
frequently
asked
to
go
back
there,
and
you
know
I'm
asked
by
city
attorney's
offices
and
by
the
county
council's
offices
to
evaluate
other
investigative
report
and
and
to
me
you
know,
one
of
the
things
that
I
forgot
to
mention
is
that
I
I
started
out.
X
I
do
a
lot
of
work
with
police
departments
and
fire
departments
and
so
forth,
where
you
really
have
a
focus
on
The
credibility
of
of
you
know.
Whatever
the
report
is
that's
generated
because
these
things,
you
know
you
have
to
base
on
facts,
you
cannot
base
on
opinions,
you
have
to
verify
and
so
forth.
So
yeah
I
this
one.
You
know
I'm
I'm
a
stickler
on
that
because
again
from
my
Approach,
the
you
know,
I'm
not
here
to
to
say-
or
you
know,
I,
don't
approach
these
things
like
well,
you're,
the
bad
person
and
you're.
X
You
know
the
good
person
and
you
know
I,
don't
do
that.
My
Approach
is
problem.
Solving
if
you've
got
issues
and
concerns,
let's
just
lay
them
out
and
see
if
we
can
move
on
and
that's
always
been,
my
Approach
and
I
will
tell
you.
There
are
some
clients
that
don't
like
that,
because
you
know
there
are
some
people
out
there
that
do
investigations
that
simply
say
well.
I've
got
to
do
this
and
I've
got
to
find
always
for
the
person
that
hired
me
or
whatever,
because
otherwise
I'm
not
gonna,
you
know
be
retained.
X
I'm
at
a
stage
in
my
career,
where,
what's
important
to
me,
is
truth,
veracity
and
and
the
whole
thing,
because
one
of
the
reasons
I'm
still
one
of
the
things-
that's
really
always
important
to
me-
is
to
see
if
we
can
make
local
governments
much
better,
so
yeah
I
would
I
would
go
to
the
bank
on
this
one
and
and
would
testify
it
and
have
testified
in
terms
of
you
know
the
the
quality
of
a
report.
B
So,
thank
you.
Miss
Dobby,
so
I'm
gonna
further
pursue
this.
You
would
say
that
this
report
that
you
produce
is
independent
and
and
verified
by
facts,
even
though
you're
interviewing
people,
but
you
do
go
over
factual
materials
that
you
get
to
verify
the
words
of
people.
Would
that
be
a
fair
statement
that.
X
Is
a
very
fair
statement:
yeah
yeah!
Absolutely
absolutely
because
you
know,
if
you
do
these
things,
the
ultimate
goal
is
to
do
these
things
is
to
address
the
situation
and
and
to
say,
okay,
if
we've
got
issues,
you
know
what
what
do
we
need
to
address
and
fix
those
kinds
of
things?
So
yeah,
that's
really
important
to
me
personally
and
in
terms
of
my
professional
reputation
so.
B
Thank
you,
Miss
Dobby
I
have
no
more
questions.
Any
questions
from
the
floor.
I
will
open
up
to
public
comment.
Miss.
Do
we
have
any.
C
Yes
mayor,
we
have
I,
have
four
speaker
cards
for
Community
Hall,
starting
with
Jennifer
Griffin,
followed
by
Brooke.
Is
it
and
Lisa
Warren
and
Darcy
Paul
and
I
see
one
hand
raised
on
Zoom
welcome,
Jennifer.
L
Yes,
it's
Mike,
yes
and
Mike
is
working.
I
would
just
say
that
no
one
introduced
the
nice
lady
that
was
on
the
camera
that
you
were
speaking
to
so
I
I,
didn't
know
who
she
was.
She
was
not
introduced.
That
I
saw
I
would
have
preferred
that
she
was
here
I
thought,
reading
this
staff
report
that
this
was
just
going
to
be
something
about
we're
going
to
make
this
Grand
Jury
report
public
okay.
So
it
turns
out
that
it's
a
Witch
Hunt
we
are
going
after
three
elected
City,
Council
Members.
L
Okay,
you
have
to
understand
the
frame
of
reference
that
a
lot
of
the
public
are
coming
from.
I'm
coming
from
I
belong
to
three
groups
in
California
that
are
fighting
the
housing
laws.
Okay,
let's,
let's
get!
Let's
understand
that!
I
feel
that
my
state
is
threatened,
that
every
democracy,
every
democratic.
L
Law
that
my
ancestors
died
for,
we
had
five
people
killed
before
the
Revolutionary
War
in
South
Carolina
by
machete.
So
you
can
understand
the
toll
that
the
last
years
have
taken
on
everything
that
I
believe
in
I.
Never
thought
that
my
state
would
reach
this
point
that
we
were
removing
sitting
elected
city
council
members
that
disagree
with
the
yin
be
ethic
and
all
of
the
money
that
is
being
pumped
in
by
Google
and
Facebook.
Let's
get
it
all
out
there.
L
This
is
a
Witch
Hunt,
and
this
is
what
we're
going
to
become
if
these
housing
laws
are
approved
and
the
governor
is
involved.
Okay,
yeah
Jerry,
Brown,
I
I
said
before
that
I
have
little
faith
in
anyone
that
is
an
elected
at
the
state
level.
I
have
faith
in
certain
members
of
my
city
council,
because
I
have
been
down
in
the
trenches
when
we
were
fighting
the
urban.
Whatever
those
things
was
that
San
Jose
was
trying
to
do
where
they
were
putting
in
300
foot
high
Urban
Villages.
L
Okay,
I
was
in
the
trenches
with
these
people
five
years
ago
and
that's
why
they're
elected
on
your
city,
council,
yes,
I,
think
this
is
a
Witch,
Hunt
and
they're
I.
Don't
know:
okay,
I've
seen
a
lot
of
stuff
in
here
in
23
years
and
five
years
in
the
county
before
when
we
were
trying
to
Annex
but
I,
don't
care
what
you
do
with
that
grand
jury.
You
need
to
make
sure
that
the
public
knows
because
to
me,
I,
don't
see
this.
It's
a
Witch
Hunt
thank.
C
E
Point
of
order,
so
the
the
rules
procedure
provide
that
if,
if
a
speaker
representing
Fiverr
members
of
the
public
in
attendance
and
wishing
to
comment
on
an
item
but
electing
us
to
speak,
the
speaker
may
have
up
to
10
minutes
to
address
the
council.
Consolidation
of
time.
Among
speakers
does
not
otherwise
allowed.
If
Council
wishes
to
do
something
different,
it
does
have
the
ability
to
vote
to
suspend
the
rules.
I.
B
Would
be
much
pressure?
What's
my
fellow
council
members,
preference
I'd.
Z
Hi
I'm
Darcy
Paul
I
find
this
course
of
action
taken
by
the
new
Council
majority
in
investigating
the
prior
Council
extremely
disappointing.
When
a
political
majority
asks
for
an
investigation
like
this,
it
is
not
only
without
precedence
and
the
City
of
Cupertino.
It
is
also,
in
my
opinion,
requested
by
the
very
group
that
should
be
investigated.
Z
Overwhelming
amounts
of
special
interest
dollars
have,
over
the
years
attempted
to
wield
grossly
disproportionate
amounts
of
financial
influence
over
our
elections.
Unfortunately,
as
a
result
of
these
activities,
rather
than
focusing
upon
the
work,
the
focus
has
been
upon
discrimination,
fueled
persecution
of
those
doing
the
work
of
reading,
objective
thinking
and
the
sharing
of
opinions
and
perspectives
without
fear
of
undue
political
or
monetarily
based
reprisal.
Z
Unfortunately,
the
truth
of
the
matter
is
that
such
reprisal
does
indeed
exist
and
it
exists
in
full
forces
reflected
by
actions
of
a
new
and
narrow
political
majority.
I
do
welcome
the
opportunity
to
have
a
meaningful
and
fair
dialogue.
That
approach
was
what
I
worked
and
sacrificed
for
during
my
time
in
public
office.
Z
I
think
that,
as
a
result,
our
community
did
very
well
because
people
and
entities
who
engage
with
this
approach
realize
that
this
was
not
about
short-term
superficial
gains
by
sacrificing
substance,
but
about
the
intrinsic
value
of
ensuring
Integrity
of
process,
consideration
and
delivery
of
implementation.
My
concerns
are
that
now
the
work
of
the
public
has
been
attacked,
not
for
legitimate
reasons
related
to
the
details
and
challenges
of
democratic
governance,
but
for
political
purposes,
grounded
in
superficial,
Optics
and
maneuvering,
devoid
of
any
real
redeeming
thoughts.
Z
I
question
this
process
in
a
backdrop
of
the
corruption
of
our
institutions
that
are
supposed
to
be
protecting
the
electorate
from
a
lack
of
transparency
and
greedy
influences.
I
question
the
nature
of
the
anonymous
complaint
that
motivated
this
investigation
and
I
believe
that
you
have
placed
yourself
in
an
untenable
position
of
pursuing
bad
politics
and
bad
policy.
I,
don't
think
anything
will
get
done
with
these
methods
of
not
doing
the
work,
inviting
a
slew
of
special
interest
dollars
and
then
blaming
decent
smart
people
for
the
problems
of
the
people.
Z
You
are,
in
effect
using
to
advance
yourselves
while
things
will
get
done,
just
not
very
palatable
things.
In
the
final
analysis,
we
can
start
by
asking
ourselves.
How
can
you
have
due
process
preserved
when
you
go
directly
from
a
report
which
was
apparently
being
researched
last
week,
I
asked
the
investigator
to
send
me
written
questions
last
week
and
received
none
to
one
that
is
now
being
put
up
the
following
Tuesday
for
consideration
of
public
disclosure.
Z
This
majority
voted
for
the
report.
Has
it
conducted
any
fact
checking
and
diligence
Beyond,
political
and
monetary
biases
and
influences
does
anything
Drive
the
process
here
as
controlled
by
this
majority?
If
so,
it
does
not
appear
evident
since
I
left
office,
I
have
done
my
best
to
respect
the
space
of
a
new
composition
of
the
council.
Z
I
wish
and
hope
that
people
tasked
with
doing
the
work
of
the
public
and
who
have
been
given
the
substantial
responsibility
of
representing
our
electorate
take
this
role
seriously
study
the
issues
with
humility
and
act
accordingly
with
the
realization
that
the
work
of
public
office
in
our
society
is
neither
glorious
nor
fun.
It
is
certainly
not
vindictive
when
we
lose
sight
of
the
fact
that
the
elected
job
is
grounded
in
self-sacrifice,
listening
and
thoughtful
engagement.
Z
Then
we
are
implementing
a
very
different
system
than
the
one
we
aspire
to
deliver
in
my
first
three
years
on
Council
I
didn't
go
on
a
single
City,
related
trip,
I
stayed
here
and
I
did
the
job
and
that
effort
generated
workable
policies
and
those
policies
led
to
real,
affordable
housing
projects
that
led
to
community
discussions
on
the
Innovative
and
the
challenging.
And
while
we
had
differences,
we
also
had
discussions
and
we
did
things,
do
the
job
so
stop.
C
AA
Thank
you
so
I'm,
going
to
start
with
months
ago,
I
asked
for
a
definition,
a
true
definition.
That's
used
by
this
city
and
in
the
documents
that
use
the
phrase
of
undue
influence
and
I
later
asked
just
a
small
number
of
people.
Actually,
one
person
to
add
to
that
request.
A
definition
of
due
diligence,
I
haven't
gotten
either
and
I
still
am
requesting
that.
AA
AA
C
M
Good
evening
again,
it's
it's
hard
to
follow
these
speakers
and
I'm
a
little
weak
in
the
knees
after
hearing
that,
and
these
reports
on
the
Deus
y'all
ran
your
campaigns
on
transparency.
M
Kitty
Moore,
Leong
Chao
have
been
champions
of
trans
transparency.
I
could
talk
all
night
if
not
for
Kitty
Cupertino
would
have
been
out
of
compliance
financially
and
I'm
grateful
to
her,
and
we
all
should
be
that
we're
not
building
on
toxic
soil
at
velco.
Thanks
to
Liang,
we
can
read
presentations
before
Council
meetings.
M
Kitty
is
a
civil
engineer
and
has
become
a
Secret
expert.
More
Liang
is
a
brilliant
problem.
Solving
has
brilliant
problems
so
solver
with
a
PhD
in
computer
science
hung
you're
a
long
time,
public
servant
and
Sheila.
You
come
with
so
much
Finance
expertise
and
Jr.
You
passed
the
bar
exam,
so
you
know
this
really
looks
like
further
dividing
our
Council.
We
have
important
work
to
do
you
all
need
to
work
together.
M
M
C
AB
Good
evening,
mayor
Wade
and
council
members,
I'm
speaking
on
behalf
of
myself
only
this
evening,
so
I
am
a
Parks
and
Rec.
Commissioner
I
urge
you
tonight
to
release
the
confidential
report.
We,
as
residents
have
voted
for
our
city
council
members,
who
then
appointed
Commissioners.
These
are
public
officials
and
their
actions
affect
every
city
resident
I
myself
was
sworn
in
just
a
few
months
ago,
and
I
knew
at
that
time.
I
was
taking
on
a
duty
that
had
specific
requirements
every
other
commissioner
and
council.
Member
knows
that
too.
AB
We
as
residents
deserve
to
know
whether
all
our
Cupertino
elected
officials
are
fulfilling
their
duties,
including
whether
they
are
interfering
with
day-to-day
operations
of
the
city,
whether
they
are
respectful
towards
our
paid
City
staff
and
whether
they
are
violating
our
Cupertino
municipal
code.
This
is
just
common
sense.
It's
also
clearly
part
of
being
a
transparent,
City,
the
transparent
city
government,
who
represents
and
respects
its
citizens
and
staff.
AB
C
N
Me
and
ASC
members
for
the
council,
during
your
film
I,
have
on
multiple
locations
plead
with
you
all
to
please
work
together.
This
is
not
Washington
DC.
This
is
not
a
two-party.
City
Council
election
campaigns
and
elections
are
over
and
we
request
the
council
to
work
together
and
tackle
the
big
issues
that
are
in
front
of
the
city
to
continue
to
spend
time
on
this
topic
and
not
provide
the
decency
and
privacy
that
it
deserves
is
only
reflecting
on
the
vicious
politics
that
have
continued
after
the
elections.
N
N
The
respect
that
we
provide
our
city
staff
in
performance
reviews
is
not
the
respect,
we're
providing
our
elected
officials,
a
mere
442
votes,
separated
a
council
member
sitting
on
the
tires
from
one
that
could
have
been
there.
A
mere
442
votes
separated
the
entire
Destiny
of
how
Cupertino
could
have
shaped
up
in
four
years.
N
N
This
should
be
A,
Private,
Matter
not
exposed
to
the
public
and
let
Council
move
forward
with
issues
that
the
public
can
actually
measure
your
impact
on.
May
we,
one-third
of
your
term,
is
over
what
impact
will
you
have
that
people
will
look
back
on
10
years
from
now
to
say
this
is
what
may
have
we
accomplished?
N
N
C
O
O
The
workshop
the
Dave
Styx
provided
might
as
well
not
have
been
done
because
you're
not
doing
it
you're,
not
even
trying
you've
had
a
tax
accusations.
All
for
political
gain.
You've
talked
about
building
Community
cooperation
collaboration.
Yet
all
your
actions
over
the
last
five
months
have
been
contradictory
to
those
polls.
O
O
Liang
Chao
has
worked
diligently
to
make
sure
that
transparency
and
public
input
and
public
involvement
was
critical
to
their
regime,
but
not
you.
You
have
eliminated
this,
you
have
eliminated
participation,
the
the
council
meetings
are
shorter
because
nobody
gets
information.
In
fact,
some
of
the
items
don't
even
get
mentioned.
They
just
appear
on
paper,
so
I'm
asking
you
and
I
agree
that
maybe
you
should
look
at
yet
anatomy
of
Feasts
and
stop
dividing
find
ways
to
unite.
O
AC
Hi
this
is
Luisa
Daddy.
Thank
you
to
Mayor
Wade
vice
mayor
Mohan,
council
members,
city
manager,
Wu
City,
lawyer,
Denson
and
City
staff
be
transparent,
show
us
the
report.
I
agree
with
item
13..
This
is
about
transparency.
The
Civil
grand
jury
found
some
very
alarming
findings,
which
cannot
be
ignored
or
dismissed.
AC
AC
AC
The
City
waving
attorney
client
privilege
would
allow
for
the
public
release
of
the
report.
This
would
enable
the
details
of
the
grand
jury
report
to
the
open,
City
and
public
review.
The
city,
the
Cupertino,
Council
City
staff
and
residents
can
then
consider
early
responses
to
the
finding
the
grand
jury
findings
were
serious
and
Cupertino
is
legally
required
to
address
his
findings.
AC
Having
me
having
the
results
of
the
the
details
of
the
result,
made
available
to
all
of
us
would
help
bring
the
details
to
light
and
for
good
governance
for
all
to
proceed.
Any
council
member
can
defend
themselves
in
an
open
discussion
following
a
open,
full
public
report.
It
is
transparency
to
have
the
report
details
made
available
to
everyone.
Political
gamersmanship
is
usually
called
out
by
those
who
participate
most
in
political
game.
Gamesmanship
show
us.
The
report
show
us
the
details
to
the
one
council.
Member
do
not
allege
count
gamesmanship.
AC
Why
you
yourself
display
aimsmanship,
be
transparent.
Wave
a
training
crime
rivet
show
us
the
report
detail.
Any
council
member
can
defend
themselves
by
giving
details.
This
is
any
Council
member's
time
to
speak
a
council
member
can
say
they
did
not
have
the
opportunity
to
give
their
sign,
but
they
were
interviewed
by
the
Civil
grand
jury.
Then
the
same
council
member
recusing
herself
is
not
backing
their
statement
that
they
weren't
given
a
chance
to
give
their
side.
This
is
her
chance
to
present
her
case
who's,
accusing
herself
in
place.
AC
She
cannot
defend
her
previous
actions
when
given
an
opportunity
to
any
of
the
versions
of
the
issues
at
hand
with
off
topics.
Not
Central
to
the
issues
brought
up
by
the
grand
jury
is
obvious,
obfuscation,
do
not
make
allegations,
including
Financial
or
whatever,
without
proof,
don't
attack
the
messenger
as
one
councilman.
Thank.
AD
Good
evening,
thank
you
for
the
opportunity.
I
am
just
going
to
mention
things.
I've
noticed
since
since
I've
been
involved,
and
that
is
when
I
first
got
involved
right
before
Liang
and
councilmember,
Chao
and
council
member
kidney
got
elected,
they
were
heavily
supported
by
the
residents
of
Cupertino
and
the
sitting
counts.
The
other
three,
the
that
are
now
pushing.
AD
This
have
always
been
known
through
next
door,
posts
and
whatnot
to
be
heavily
supported
and
funded
by
developers
and
special
interest
groups,
and
whether
or
not
they
were
directly
and
whether
or
not
it
was
a
pact
that
was
funded
by
them.
It
was
known
so
I
would
like
everyone
here,
including
the
attorney.
That's
investigating
to
keep
that
in
mind
if
there's
any
bearing
in
that
judgment.
Also,
the
question
I
have
for
the
attorney.
AD
Dobby
is
if
there
were
within
City,
corrupt
city
staff
or
otherwise
I
hate
to
say
staff,
but
if
there
was
any
conspiracy
towards
or
leniency
towards
a
certain
group,
are
there
any
measures
in
place
to
reveal
those
and
the
reason
I
ask
that
is
because,
when
councilmember
Tau
and
council
member
Moore
were
elected,
there
were
staff
that
left
immediately
before
ever
giving
them
a
chance
to
work
with
them.
AD
It
was
very
obvious
and
when
I
spoke
to
them
at
the
time
before
they
left,
they
were
very
almost
rude
to
the
residents
that
were
trying
to
get
some
answers.
So
I
I'm
I'm
really
questioning
the
individuals
that
made
these
accusations
and
the
legitimacy,
because
I
I've
had
the
chance
and
privilege
to
work
with
both
council
member
chow
and
council
member
Moore
and
I've
never
met
some
more
honest,
incredible
individuals
that
really
had
the
residence
interested
heart.
So
please
keep
in
mind
some
of
the
developers.
AD
What's
going
on
a
four
billion
dollar
project
with
possibly
International
money
coming
in
heavily
heavily
pushed
I
think
the
plan
was
always
to
get
them
elected
and
has
always
I
mean
it
just
seemed.
It
was
like
bang
bang
getting
them
as
soon
as
they
came
in,
they
had
a
plan
and
they
started
to
they'd
elected
mayor
way
before
the
election
Council
and
the
meeting
ever
happened-
and
it's
just
been
very
obvious
to
me
that
this
was
on
the
agenda
and
the
plan,
so
I
beg
everyone
here
to
please
keep
in
mind.
B
You,
madam
CD
Clerk,
and
thanks
for
all
the
public
comments
I'm
going
to
bring
back
this
to
council.
Please
keep
in
mind
that
we
have
not
voted
to
waive
the
attorney
client
privilege.
So
no
content
of
the
report
is
going
to
be
discussed,
I'm
bringing
back
to
council
discussion.
Anybody
would
like
to
make
comments.
G
G
E
G
Report
at
this
point,
many
residents
appreciate
the
fact
that
council
members
are
responsive
to
their
concerns
and
they
appreciate
the
questions.
I
ask
have
any
of
the
residents
being
interviewed,
none
of
them.
This
is
why
this
report
is
biased.
It
didn't
interview
the
most
important
people
in
this
room.
The
residents
who
elected
us
it
didn't
interview
any
of
the
residents
whom
all
the
city
staff
is
hired
to
serve.
G
I
was
interviewed.
I
cannot
talk
about
the
content,
but
glancing
at
the
report.
Only
on
the
pushing
related
to
myself.
This
is
the
most
biased
report.
I
have
ever
read.
I
asked
the
transcript
as
City
attorney
alluded.
Two
cannot
be
released
because
that's
a
concerning
client
privilege.
However,
the
council
is
asked
to
waive
privilege
only
on
this
report,
which
is
a
collection
of
never
I,
find
that
the
the
preparer
of
the
report
took
things
didn't
even
talk.
G
G
It's
a
collection
of
hearsay
because
there
is
no
cross-examination,
no
swearing
truths
say
the
fact
and
no
way
to
even
verify
what
the
report
is
derived
from,
because
all
the
supporting
material
is
still
a
client
is
still
privileged,
so
the
public
will
be
able
to
Only
See
a
report
similar
to
Grant's
devotion
report,
which
As
We
Know
is
a
collection
of
hearsay
with
no
fact-
and
so
I
must
ask
that
my
fellow
council
members,
what
are
you
trying
to
achieve?
Are
you
trying
to
Advance
your
political
goal
by
revealing
it
in
this?
G
If
we
are
trying,
if
the
goal
is
to
improve
the
process
of
the
council
meeting,
we
are
already
on
our
way
of
doing
that.
We
exposing
this
very
biased
report,
and
only
the
report,
not
any
of
the
supporting
material,
will
only
tear
the
city
apart
and
it
does
not
really
achieve
any
of
the
goals
that
we
should
be
working
on
better
working
relationship.
If
there
is
anything
we
can
improve,
we
can
continue
to
work
on
that.
We
have
a
council
Workshop
coming
up.
We
are
going
to
review
our
Council
procedure.
G
D
So,
when
I
originally
moved
for
this
investigation
as
part
of
our
response
to
the
Civil
grand
jury,
my
intention
was
twofold:
one:
to
demonstrate
to
the
Civil
grand
jury
that
we
took
their
report
seriously
as
we
should
have
and
that
we
were
actively
seeking
to
improve
our
city
governance
if
the
allegations
could
be
substantiated
and
then
second
to
determine
whether
the
Civil
Grand
jury's
findings
were
accurate
and
if
so,
to
what
extent
so
that
we
could
address
the
matter.
However,
this
body
can.
D
B
Thank
you,
councilmember
film.
Do
we
have
any
Vice
Maya
Mohan.
R
R
So
during
this
process,
there
was
an
independent
attorney,
an
investigator
who
looked
at
all
the
incidents
mentioned
in
the
grand
jury
report
and
Beyond,
and
this
was
the
the
opportunity
that
the
council
members
had
to
make
their
case
and
correct
all
the
incidents
which
they
felt
were
inaccurate
in
the
grand
jury
report.
R
So
in
the
interests
of
transparency,
we
all
talk
about
transparency
all
the
time,
so
in
the
interests
of
transparency,
I,
don't
see
why
this
should
not
be
made
public
so
that
the
pub
the
public
can
get
a
chance
to
look
at
it
and
we
we
can
move
forward
from
that
point,
thank
you.
B
So
I
know
my
name's
been
throwing
around
because
I'm
the
mayor,
yes
I.
B
We
want
to
work
together,
but
on
the
premises
of
being
honest
having
integrity
and
this
report,
as
stated
by
council
member
froon
and
vice
Mohan,
it
is
to
verify
that
civil
grand
jury,
because
when
that
report
came
out,
there
were
statements
that
they
were
not
true.
This
is
really
not
what
happened.
It
was
just
a
one-sided
story
from
staff
so
to
further.
B
This
report
is
to
really
verify
whether
you
know
our
council
members
being
planned
wrongly
and
I'm,
hoping
that
it
that
you
know
so-
and
the
second
thing
is
I-
want
to
call
all
for
respect.
We
have
a
professional
Miss,
Linda
Dobby.
She
is
a
professional.
She
produces
unbiased
reports,
she's
not
connected
to
any
one
of
us
she's
not
connected
to
special
interest
and
I
trust.
Our
CEO
attorney
has
secured
us
a
professional
to
give
us
unbiased
report
in
that
respect.
B
This
is
paid
by
public
fund
and
this
is
to
verify
the
grand
jury
report.
They
could
be
both.
It
could
go
both
ways
so
for
transparency.
I
do
believe
our
public
has
the
right
to
know
what's
in
this
report.
As
for
working
together,
how
can
we
work
together
if
we
don't
ourselves,
are
not
honest
with
us
ourselves
and
are
not
transparent,
are
not
willing
to
work
together?
B
That
is
my
motion
and
I
like
to
ask
for
a
second.
Please.
D
B
H
We
do
not
have
staff
report,
but
we
do
have
Public
Works
staff
available
to
answer
any
questions.
I
believe
the
item
was
pulled
by
council
member
Chow
council
member
Chow.
Do
you
have
any
specific
questions
for
a
staff.
G
The
reason
I
pour
this
item
is
because
this
is
a
location
of
amount
budget
amount
over
three
hundred
thousand
dollars.
I
think
I
have
requested
it
before,
but
never
acknowledge
that
this
kind
of
item
should
not
be
on
consent.
This
is
the
kind
of
item
that
the
public
would
want
to
know
and
I
have
other
questions.
Do
I
ask
them
now,
or
is
there
a
staff
representation,
there's
no
step
presentation?
Okay?
So
how
much
do
we
have
in
the
art
in
movie
right
now.
S
Foreign
Council
Chad
Mosley
interim
director
of
Public
Works
I'm,
currently
in
the
art
and
Luffy,
we
have
I
think
as
it's
indicating
the
staff
report.
I
believe
it's
338
thousand
dollars
is
that.
A
G
So
this
item
will
exhaust
all
of
the
art
in
Luffy.
S
Our
intent
is
to
provide
our
art
amenities,
public
art
amenities
for
this
project
that
would
probably
probably
come
close
to
exhausting
Nets.
Any
funds
not
utilized
would
be
placed
back
in.
G
G
S
G
So
we
already
have
4.5
million
dollars
spent
on
this
location
and
this
project
and
this
art
English
fee
I-
think
it's
meant
to
provide
art
in
Cupertino,
which
is
much
much
needed.
I
think
we
we
need
all
we
do
need
more
art
in
Cupertino,
and
this
item
has
not
been
through.
The
final
commission
I
understand
that
it
will
go
through
to
the
Fine
Art
Commission,
when
the
items
are
proposed
to
be
selected.
H
H
Just
point
of
clarification,
so
what's
being
asked
of
council
tonight,
is
that
this
is
a
restricted
art
in
Luffy
fund,
we're
asking
Council
to
allocate
the
funding
for
the
artwork
at
jollyman
Park,
and
this
is
not
for
equipment
and
once
the
artist
is
selected
and
the
art
pieces
are
confirmed,
it
will
go
through
the
Fine
Arts
commission.
For
final
confirmation.
I
Thank
you,
so
I
noticed
that
there
had
been
a
contract
with
netzel
Grigsby
for
playground
fundraising,
and
we
had
spent
33
000
a
little
bit
over
that
on
this
to
to
try
to
have
a
fundraising
effort.
Does.
Does
anyone
from
staff
know
what
happened
with
that.
I
Okay,
so,
but
we're
looking
at
the
funding
for
these
extra
amenities
for
this
particular
playground,
and
also
when
I
was
looking
at
the
budget.
You
have
the
library
extended
hours
over.
Six
hundred
thousand
dollars
has
been
allocated
for
that
and
it
hasn't
been
spent
because
we
haven't
had
to
spend
the
money
for
the
extra
hours
since
well.
I
The
last
check
was
468
000
in
2019,
so
I
was
wondering
if
perhaps
staff
could
come
back
and
let
us
know
if
there
is
a
way
that
that
600
000,
because
it's
already
in
the
budget,
if
it
could
be
reallocated
for
this
project
and
it
actually
would
could
cover
another
one
that
was
in
here
I
I'm,
curious
about
how
that
money
could
be
moved
around,
because
we
are
not
needing
to
spend
the
600
000
for
the
extra
Library
hours.
H
This
is
not
the
subject
for
tonight,
but
if
you
would
like
to
add
that
to
a
future
agenda
item,
that
is
the
council's
discretion
and
point
of
clarification.
The
ask
before
council
is
to
allocate
the
money
that
has
been
restricted
for
art.
It
is
not
to
provide
for
additional
amenities
to
the
playground.
This
is
purely
for.
I
Public
Arts:
well,
you
can
consider
the
art
to
be
an
amenity
to
the
playground,
because
it
pretty
much
is
so
also
so
this
policy,
if
I'm
understanding
correctly
it
arose
from
staff
and
not
Council,
who
are
the
policy
makers,
so
I
was
wondering
if
there
was
some
discussion
about
whether
or
not
to
bring
the
concept
to
a
council
to
see
what
we
thought
about
it.
First,
before
having
these
kind
of
absolutes
about,
you
know
you,
you
will
take
this
money,
you
are.
You
are
going
to
do
this.
H
There
is
no
absolute
asking
of
the
council
tonight.
This
is
staff's
recommendation.
Our
professional
opinion
is
how
the
money
should
be
spent.
It's
completely
up
to
council
and
your
full
discretion
to
decide.
Staff
will
not
have
our
feelings
heard
if
you
counsel
to
collectively
decide
that
this
is
not
the
right
place
for
the
public
guards
to
be
implemented.
H
I
Thank
you
and
and
I
want
to
point
out
that
those
are
restricted
funds
and
there
was
an
expectation
for
for
where
what
would
be
purchased
with
it,
and
the
city
has
multiple
properties
where
the
the
public
art
could
be
placed,
and
also
I,
going
back
to
the
600
000,
which
is
going
to
be
again
this
year.
Unspent
funds
for
the
library
extended
hours
I,
what's
troubling
me,
is
that
we're
being
kind
of
pushed
into
just
looking
at
these
restricted
funds.
I
Rather
than
opening
the
discussion
up
about
the
six
hundred
thousand
dollars
from
the
the
unspent
library
extended
hours
of
funding,
so
I
I
wish
there
was
a
little
more
flexibility
on
on
the
part
of
staff
to
look
into
that
budget
item
and
where
it
can
be
reallocated.
Thank
you.
H
Student
mayor
I
just
want
a
point
of
clarification
that
I
believe
councilmember
Moore
was
referring
to
other
budget,
but
this
is
a
restricted
art
in
loot
fee
for
public
Arts
implementation.
Again
this
is
Staff
recommendation
to
be
implemented
at
Jolly
met.
Council
has
full
discretion
to
decide.
If
this
is
the
right
location,
I
believe
Public
Works
staff
will
not
have
their
feelings
heard.
If,
if
Council
collectively
believe
that
there's
a
better
place.
B
Thank
you,
I
would
turn
on
to
other
council
members.
You
have
any
questions.
If
not
I
do
have
a
couple.
Questions
go
ahead.
Council
vice
mayor
Mohan,.
R
I
had
a
couple
of
questions
and
I
staff
did
answer
my
questions,
but
let
me
reiterate
it
once
more
for
the
public,
my
one.
My
question
was:
what
makes
jollyman
part
the
most
appropriate
place
for
this
in
Liu
fee
revenue
and
were
there
other
locations
considered.
S
At
this
excuse
me
again
interim
director,
Chad
Mosley
at
this
point
in
time.
Jollyman
is
an
appropriate
location
because
we
have
an
existing
project
that
we
believe
would
benefit
from
public
art
features.
We
believe
that
this
is
going
to
be
kind
of
a
an
area-wide
location
for
people
to
come
because
of
the
you
know
the
inclusivity
of
this
project.
S
S
You
know
with
that
stated,
as
a
city
manager,
Wu
had
had
indicated
we're
offering
this
opportunity
for
Council
to
consider
the
addition
of
these
funds
for
our
facilities
at
this
project.
But
again,
if
Council
chooses
not
to
do
so,
that's
your
prerogative,
we're
just
providing
this
as
an
opportunity
for
you
to
provide
those
funds
at
this
location.
R
S
S
The
only
time
constraint
at
this
point
in
time
is
for
the
project
we
need
to
get
this
project
started
in
relatively
short
order
in
order
to
take
advantage
of
other
Grant
funds
that
we've
secured
for
this
project.
So
we've
brought
this
to
you
to
provide
this
opportunity.
If
you
decide
not
to
move
forward
with
this
tonight,
we
will
just
move
on
from
this
and
continue
with
the
existing
project
so
that
we
can
be
sure
to
hit
those
timelines
for
the
other
Grant
funds.
E
A
very
based
membrane,
just
just
to
clarify
so
I,
so
there's
no
immediate
requirement
to
spend
the
funds.
If
Council
chooses
to
put
them
to
a
different
use,
it
would
become
an
issue
if,
if
the
city
were
to
to
keep
the
fees
you
know
in
over
and
indefinitely
Or
over
a
very
long
period
of
time,
and
so
so
there
would.
We
would
want
to
start
working
on
an
alternative
plan
to
spend
the
money
if,
if
Council
decide
to
go
in
a
different
direction,.
X
G
S
At
this
point
in
time,
we
have
the
funds
and
we're
looking
to
just
utilize
those
funds
for
this
project
again,
depending
on
the
features
and
the
art
features
that
are
chosen.
If
we
don't
utilize
all
of
the
funds,
they
will
go
back
into
that
restricted.
So.
G
S
G
But
maybe
those
can
be
installed
in
other
parks.
Those
I
mean
that's
really
nice
amenities
that
you
have
suggested
in
the
staff
report,
but
I
would
love
to
see
those
in
other
Parks,
not
just
jollyman,
because
jollyman
is
already
going
to
get
a
really
cool
amazing,
inclusive
playground.
So
if
other
Parks
could
get
the
musical
branch
and
some
of
these
other
interesting,
interactive,
Mosaic
bench
and
and
their
mural,
those
could
go
in
any
park
right.
H
So
through
the
mayor,
if
I
may
so
staff's
recommendation
is
to
use
the
to
utilize
the
current
fund
to
implement
at
jollyman
again,
if
Council
feels
otherwise
Council
has
full
discretion.
I
would
necessarily
labor
my
staff
to
do
the
design
on
the
diets
at
this
point,
to
figure
out
what
bench
or
which
art
elements
should
go
somewhere
else.
G
B
B
H
Detail
in
the
staff
report,
a
project
of
certain
size
with
expansion
or
whatnot
is
required
to
provide
public
Arts
per
our
Municipal
Code.
Given
the
location
and
sensitivity
and
the
nature
of
the
public
storage
project,
it
was
decided
that
a
in-lu
fee
is
more
beneficial
to
the
city
than
having
a
public
arts
on
site.
For
instance,
I
believe
the
beta
Brother
Project
will
have
a
public
art
component,
so
is
the
marina
Plaza
project,
typically
Community
Development
and
staff
at
work
with
Public
Works
staff
and
also
potentially
Parks
and
Rec
staff.
H
To
arrive
at
that
professional
opinion
to
decide
whether
or
not
an
on-site
public
art
or
a
park
in
Luffy
is
the
best
solution
for
the
city.
In
this
scenario,
the
public
storage
facility
project
inadvertently
volunteered
to
have
the
art
in
Luffy.
Therefore,
the
total
amount
that
has
been
take
taken
from
the
public
storage
project
is
being
used
or
being
proposed
at
the
jollyman.
B
Park,
thank
you.
That's
what
I
would
like
the
public
to
know,
because
this
English
fee
is
because,
if
you
put
a
public
art
in
the
public
storage
area,
it's
really
not
a
beneficial
to
our
city,
so
I'm
very
appreciative
of
staff's
professional
opinion
to
arrive
this.
We
have
this
much
money,
I'd
like
to
follow
up
with
council
member
Moore's
continued
mentioned
about
the
six
hundred
thousand
dollars.
That's
another
part
of
money
that
cannot
be
mixed
with
this
project,
I
mean
we
have
funds
everywhere.
We
have
funds
in
general
fund.
B
H
And
to
respond
to
council
member
Moore
I
am
not
aware
of
the
600
000
Library
fund
that
you're,
referring
to
I'll,
be
more
happy
to
talk
to
assistant
city
manager
to
locate
but
mere
way,
you're.
Absolutely
right.
What
is
being
proposed
is
to
out
is
for
Council
to
allocate
what
has
been
prior
allocated
for
are
in
lieu
and
and
point
of
clarification
and
point
out
by
council.
Member
fluent
that
this
is
the
first
time
the
city
has
ever
received
a
r
in
Luffy
and
also
detailed
in
staff
report.
H
We
currently
don't
have
a
policy
staff
is
working
on
a
policy
that
will
be
brought
back
to
council
for
final
consideration,
so
oftentimes
council
is
used
to
seeing
a
public
art
being
dedicated
and
offered
on
site,
and
this
is
the
first
time
we're
taking
Project
X
and
put
it
on
on
a
city
facility,
so
assistant
city
manager,
Morley.
If
you
have
the
information
to
answer
council
member
Moore's
question,
we.
Q
Need
to
do
research
on
the
600
000,
but
assuming
that
it's
for,
if
they're,
assuming
there
is
600
000
for
Library
extended
hours,
that
would
be
general
fund
dollars
and
just
like
any
other
general
fund
dollar
that
could
be
appropriated
by
Council
on
on
any
any
given
Tuesday.
The
the
goal
here
is:
we've
collected
funds
from
from
a
developer
for
the
use
on
public
art,
and
so
the
goal
is
to
follow,
through
with
the
commitment
to
use
those
funds
for
public
art,
and
that's
why
our
recommendation
is
before
you
thank.
B
I
Yes,
so
I
was
looking
at
Palo,
alto's,
public
art
and
their
ordinance.
They
do
have
a
public
art
fund
and
the
the
money
will
stay
in
there
until
it's
designated
by
their
their
their
version
of
our
fine
arts
and
culture
commission.
So
it's
not
having
to
be
pulled
out.
I
did
a
turn
in
for
for
written
Communications.
The
the
library
Services
account
the
budget
unit
160-636
and
have
confirmed
with
the
jpa
Santa
Clara
County
Library
District.
I
The
last
check
that
we
sent
them
was
in
2019
for
468
thousand
dollars,
but
we
have
continued
to
allocate
money
for
the
extended
hours,
even
though
there's
plenty
of
taxes
there.
So
I
would
like
to
know
because
it
doesn't
sound
like
it
is
such
a
difficult
matter
for
Council
to
do
to
reallocate
the
money
and
retain
the
300
and
something
thousand
dollars
in
that
in
the
in
the
restricted
fund
and
and
with
regards
to
the
restricted
funds.
I
I've
been
asking
for
this
for
some
time
to
to
see
what
the
actual
restricted
funds
are.
I
think
there
are
a
number
of
them.
So
if
we
can
get
to
that
later,
but
I'd
like
to
have
a
a
report
on
all
the
restricted
funds
which
have
been
allocated
from
various
projects.
Thank
you.
So
thank.
B
C
Yes,
mayor
so
I
have
two
speaker
cards
in
Community
Hall,
one
from
Jennifer
Griffin,
one
from
Lisa
Warren
I
have
handouts
from
Rhoda,
but
I
did
you
want
to
speak
okay
and
so
we'll
start
with
Jennifer
welcome
Jennifer.
L
Good
evening
city
council
I
have
worked
in
public
sector
and
private
sector
and
for
two
three
startup
companies
in
Tech
I'm.
Believe
me,
when
I
say,
I
have
been
coming
here.
23
years,
I
am
very
familiar
with
the
art
fund.
It
is
not
you
don't
have
to
use
it
up
at
one
time.
L
You
know
we
went
through
the
whole
Main
Street
drama
which
took
I
think
that
was
10
years
ago,
but
it
was
every
bit
as
big
as
Valco
and
we
spent
hours
looking
at
maps
and
graphs
and
dialogues
Etc
and
they
discussed
the
in
Luffy
for
art
and
I.
Think
it's
set
it.
What
is
it
seven
percent
three
percent
and
it's
it's
a
flat
amount.
L
Okay,
remember
the
people
in
the
public
in
the
audience
know
these
things:
okay,
we're
not
newbies
I've
spent
millions
of
hours
sitting
here
so
I
know
this
stuff
by
heart,
the
the
art,
the
funds
and
the
art
are
not
normally
spent
on
one
project
now,
I'm
very
familiar
with
the
magical
bridge.
This
has
been
going
on
for
four
years
now.
I
think
it's
a
wonderful
Project
A
lot
of
it
was
paid
for
by
grants
from
various
people.
L
Two
years
ago
we
were
up
against
having
to
get
a
park
selected
because
we
were
going
to
lose
the
grant.
Then
I
think
we
ran
into
covid
things
slowed
down,
but
I
I
don't
know.
L
I
have
great
respect
for
staff.
Believe
me,
I
have
been
through
so
many
city
councils
and
Mayors
we've
had
staff
members
come
and
go.
Some
people
are
still
here.
Some
people
come
back
again,
but
I'm
not
really
exactly
sure
why
we
have
to
have
three
hundred
thousand
dollars
of
art
on
the
magical
bridge.
Is
it
becoming
the
big
black
hole?
Bridge?
L
Are
we
putting
in
a
chiculi
twenty
thousand
dollar
Glass
Project
like
they
have
at
I
I,
understand
I
know
we
have
one
at
Palo
Alto
Medical
Clinic
at
Highway
85
in
El
Camino,
but
then
my
friend
claimed
that
there's
another
one
in
Palo
Alto.
So
we
are,
we
just
going
to
put
a
chacouli
out
there
for
twenty
thousand
dollars
and
stick
it
in
the
park
where
it
might
break
I,
don't
understand,
okay,
if
if
they
want
to
take,
you
know
fifty
thousand
and
do
artwork
with
it
or
something.
L
But
at
this
point
we
need
to
explain
to
the
audience
and
yes,
it
may
be
in
the
staff
report,
but
there
are
people
in
the
public
who
need
to
know
what
is
going
on,
because
it's
our
money,
the
developers,
don't
normally
the
developers,
are
required
by
law
to
give
a
certain
percentage
to
the
art
fund.
That
is
it.
It's
never
been
any
different.
So
why
are-
and
we've
never
spent
it
all
at
one
and
think
if
velco
ever
builds
out
we're
going
to
have
40
million
dollars
of
art,
but.
L
AA
AA
I
would
I
attended
by
Zoom
the
meeting
close
to
a
year
and
a
half
ago
where
arts
and
culture
had
this
come
before
them.
Staff
explained
because
arts
and
culture
is
who
makes
the
decision
of
whether
dollars
that
are
meant
to
be
on
site,
are
deferred
and
made
into
in-loop
fees
to
go
somewhere
else.
That's
who
makes
that
decision?
That's
how
the
city's
rules
are
written
yet
for
some
reason,
there's
never
been
a
rule
on
how
that
money
gets
distributed
somewhere
and
at
that
meeting
I
spoke.
AA
The
minutes,
don't
reflect
it
because
the
minutes
don't
say
anything
other
than
I.
Was
there
and
spoke
I
asked
staff
and
I
suggested
to
the
Commissioners
at
the
time
you're
the
people
that
are
deciding
this
money
is
not
going
to
need
to
go
at
Public,
Storage
I
think
it's
important
if
you
understand
where
the
money's
going
to
go
and
what's
going
to
be
done
with
it
and
I
believe
that
you
should
have
the
ability
to
decide
where
that
money
goes.
AA
Since
you
decided
it
wasn't
going
here
and
that's
your
job
staff
was
unable
to
answer
the
question
because
there
was
no
procedure,
so
I
find
it
very
uncomfortable
to
have
something
come
with
one
plan:
I,
don't
know
if
it's
a
good
plan
or
not
I,
just
don't
think
it's
being
done
properly,
I,
don't
think,
and
and
I
applaud
public
iPod
public
works
for
being
creative
and
trying
to
think
of
a
way
to
put
something
else
there.
If
they
really
think
it's
needed
I
personally,
don't
think
it's
needed,
but
that's
neither
here
nor
there.
AA
The
problem
is,
there's
not
a
procedure
and
I.
Don't
think
it's
right
for
you
to
be
asked
to
make
a
decision
on.
One
idea
and
one
question
I
asked
was:
was
this
project
site
considered,
meaning
the
Tory
Avenue
or
any
other
or
any
other
projects
considered
any
other
sites?
And
the
staff
answer
was
opportunities
for
art
at
other
City
Field
facilities
have
not
been
evaluated.
This
is
a
One-Shot
thing.
There
should
be
choices
and
that
arts
and
culture
commission
should
be
making
the
primary
recommendation.
AA
AA
It
will
go
to
arts
and
culture
for
confirmation,
not
not
for
a
yes
or
a
no
for
confirmation.
I'm,
not
sure
what
that
means,
but
it
doesn't
sound
like
they're,
making
a
decision
and
I
think
that
is
the
main
thrust
of
the
problem
here,
not
that
it
wouldn't
be
great
to
have
whatever
is
being
talked
about,
not
that
staff
didn't
have
a
good.
M
Good
evening
again,
I
want
to
thank
council
member
Moore
for
their
comments.
I
also
submitted
written
comment,
which
you
probably
have
really
great,
to
see
more
explanation
in
the
packet
from
staff.
So
I
want
to
bifurcate
the
issues
here.
One
is
on
the
budget,
so
look
in
2021,
December
2021,
so
it's
almost
2022
a
year
ago
or
so.
This
project
was
going
to
cost
us
1.2
million
dollars
in
City
funds
and
then
somehow
a
ballooned
and
by
another
1.1
million.
M
So
my
at
today's
point,
we're
at
2.1
million
in
City
funds
and,
what's
being
asked
of
you
tonight,
is
to
put
in
a
16
percent
increase
for
this
project
of
340
000.
So
that
would
be
us
out
of
pocket
2.4
million.
The
total
budget
is
at
4.6
million
right
now.
Do
we
really
need
another
0.3
million?
That
would
take
it
close
to
5
million?
M
M
So
I
want
to
go
on
to
what
about
the
issue
of
the
art
piece.
So
that's
a
separate
issue.
You
know
I
started
looking
at
the
Cupertino
municipal
code
and
and
all
the
so.
The
overall
goals
are
to
enhance
Community
character
and
identity,
provide
attractive
public
Arts
to
Residents
and
visitors
alike,
and
then
it'd
be
visible
from
the
street.
You
know
something
about
what
would
that
mean?
You
know
maybe
some
sculptures
at
Quinlan
or
sculptures,
even
at
other
Parks,
if
they're
just
packing
an
awful
lot
of
stuff
in
here.
M
Thankfully,
staff
also
provided
some
more
information
about
the
ideas
of
what
would
go
in
and
so
create
a
presentation
for
3
500.
That
is
not
art.
Okay,
that
shouldn't
you
know
to
me.
This
looks
like
I
hate
to
say
it,
but
I'm
going
to
say
it
because
it's
been
eating
at
me.
Misappropriation
of
funds,
colloidal
scope,
installation
for
83
000.
You
know
that
kind
of
looks
like
more
like
a
landscaping
or
garden
feature.
M
That's
also
ineligible
colorful,
peaking
Windows
is
this
art
and
by
the
way,
all
art
has
to
have
an
eight
by
eight
inch
plaque
on
it
to
for
the
artist
viewing
binoculars
seriously
a
musical
bench,
bird
scavenger
hunt,
a
multi-lingual
tactile
sign
the
CMC
explicitly
says
no
to
signs
stair,
murals
and
a
contingency
of
50k,
not
okay.
Just
please
say
no.
Thank
you.
C
O
Good
evening,
mayor
way,
vice
mayor,
Mohan,
council
members
and
staff
I.
Second,
everything
that
Rhoda
fry
has
said,
but
I
want
you
to
think
about
it
in
a
different
way.
You
have
the
opportunity
to
do
a
win-win
this
project.
The
current
plan
has
the
construction
doc
documents
being
ready
in
August
2023.
That's
in
what
two
three
months,
the
deadline
is
June
24th
2024..
O
If
we
don't
make
that
deadline,
a
grant
is
at
risk.
The
staff
has
said
that
the
schedule
is
on
schedule
to
meet
this
deadline
and
it
is
within
budget.
That's
very
unusual.
O
O
If
you
don't
do,
if
you
vote,
no
everything
will
go
as
planned
and
we
will
get
this
design
done
on
budget
on
time.
You
also
have
the
opportunity
for
the
funds
to
be
addressed
in
artwork
at
another
location
or
multiple
locations.
O
So
I
want
you
to
think
about
that.
The
staff
has
done
a
great
job
and
you
know
it
I.
You
know
I
I,
you
always
want
more,
but
I
I
looked
at
these
items
and
peaking
windows,
not
art,
viewing
binoculars,
not
art,
multi-tactical
sign,
not
in
the
code.
O
The
bird
scavenger
hunt
questionable
a
very
large
contingency.
Think
about
this.
You
have
a
successful
project.
O
C
M
AB
You
Kristen
good
evening
again
mayor
way
and
council
members
I'm
again
speaking
on
behalf
of
only
myself
this
evening
and
not
on
behalf
of
the
parks
and
recognition.
This
city
council
has
already
approved
this
great
amenity
of
an
all-inclusive
playground
for
our
City's
youngest
residents.
I'm,
really
glad
that
that's
not
up
for
debate
tonight.
AB
The
issue
tonight
is
whether
adding
art
creatures
to
the
playground
is
considered
public
art,
an
in-loo
public
art
piece,
whether
or
not
they
should
be
used
to
add
art
features
to
the
playground.
I
say
that
art
has
no
age.
Many
adults
are
conditioned
to
look
at
art
as
something
static
like
a
painting
or
a
statue,
that's
kind
of
what
I
think
of
when
I
think
of
Art
kids.
Don't
have
these
limits.
In
fact
our
Municipal
Code
chapter,
19,
Section
148,
says
any
other
form
of
artwork
determined
by
the
arts
and
culture.
AB
Commission
is
permitted
public
art
allowing
us
to
consider
unique
types
of
art,
whether
it's
hearing
the
first
two
and
they
make
themselves
on
the
musical
bench
or
climbing
a
stair
mural
or
all
the
colors
they
see
in
the
decorative
Sun
Kaleidoscope.
Our
children
will
be
interacting
with
art
and
gaining
an
appreciation
for
it.
This
is
the
first
time
that
the
city
is
using
art
in
Luffy's
this
way,
and
it
will
give
us
some
great
experience
to
create
a
forward-looking
policy
in
the
future.
C
Thank
you,
Jennifer
and
our
final
two
speakers
that
had
their
hands
raised
within
the
nine
minute
time
limit
are
lyanna
Crabtree
and
Louise.
Sadati
welcome
lyanna.
P
U
You
good
evening,
Council
and
staff
I
really
appreciate
the
comments
of
so
many
residents.
Who've
spoken
this
evening,
giving
context
and
offering
I
think
very
helpful
suggestions
for
how
to
move
forward
with
this
project.
I
I
really
appreciate
them.
U
What
Lisa
Warren
was
saying
about
how
it
seems
that
we
really
haven't
involved
the
Fine
Arts
and
your
commission
in
making
decisions
about
what
to
do
with
with
these
windfall
funds
from
the
public
storage
project,
and
that
that
seems
like
a
a
really
unfortunate
miss
that
you
have
an
opportunity,
as
others
have
stated,
to
bring
more
people
in
to
improving
our
our
public
spaces
and
people
who
generously
volunteered
their
time
on
the
Fine
Arts
and
cultures.
Commission,
and
it
seems
that
we're
we're
really
not
giving
that
that
resource.
U
It's
due
that
it
that
we
would
benefit
if
we
had
I
think
maybe
more
people
thinking
about
how
we
could
best
utilize,
These
funds
and
and
I
do
agree
with
what
Peggy
Griffin
said,
especially
that
the
project
will
move
forward
and
we'll
have
a
wonderful
new
playground
for
the
community,
and
it
doesn't
need
to
have
the
art
it
could
have.
Art
and
the
art
could
come
later,
but
it's
still
a
great
project
that
has
a
much
better
chance
of
being
on
time
and
on
budget.
U
If
it
doesn't
have
these
other
things
added
and
to
the
other
point
that
galliman
Park
is,
it's
got
a
lot
going
on
and
we
have
other
perks,
other
public
spaces
that
have
far
fewer
amenities.
It
would
be
nice
if,
again,
the
Fine
Arts
commission,
Fine
Arts
cultural
commission
could
be
looking
at
other
spaces
where
we
might
sort
of
share
that
that
wealth
of
resource
of
art.
U
So
thank
you
and
and
I
I,
really
hope
that
you
will
consider
not
moving
forward
with
the
art
at
this
location
and
consider
bringing
in
the
fine
arts
and
culture
commission
to
really
interrogate
what
would
be
a
great
choice.
Thank
you.
AC
So
I'm
thank
you.
I
am
speaking
to
support
the
city
staff
recommendation
of
item
8.
using
cupertino's.
First
in
the
art,
the
gentleman
on
crucial
play
directory
approval
of
eight
will
optimize
the
jollyman
on
the
play
structures,
planning
and
include
art
in
an
optimal
usage
serving
the
community,
especially
the
children.
AC
Children
and
adults
will
come
from
all
over
the
city
to
the
central
location
in
jollyman
and
art
can
indeed,
children
can
enjoy
an
interactive
art
feature,
including
a
decorative
Sun,
Kaleidoscope,
interactive
musical
bench,
nature
related
art,
a
multilingual
technical
sign,
dear
Miro,
artists
are
capable
of
doing
incredible
things,
and
this
would
leave
a
huge
opening
for
children
to
be
introduced
to
art
as
an
interactive
feature.
AC
This
would
be
an
excellent
and
efficient
merging
of
interactive
art
within
the
time
constraints
of
jollyman's
play
structure
and
incorporate
the
art
feature,
while
construction
is
occurring
for
the
play
structure.
I
think
this
is
a
I
commend
the
city
staff
they're,
coming
up
with
an
efficient
and
clever
way
to
get
the
artist
dog
in
the
middle
of
jollyman
being
under
construction.
This
will
probably
result
in
more
efficiency
and
less
cost.
AC
This
is
a
creative
and
efficient
solution
for
our
city
in
the
middle
of
the
City
versus
Lawrence
midi
on
the
far
edge
of
the
city,
Memorial
Park,
which
will
require
three
to
four
more
years
of
planning
versus
Darwin
that
can
be
done
by
the
middle
of
next
year.
So
for
the
present
the
time
deadlines
on
Jellyman
structure
and
are
limited,
valuable
staff
time,
we
need
to
proceed
with
this
win-win
solution
and
approve
item
8
smoothly
and
promptly.
AC
We
should
not
ignore
the
jollyman
deadline
with
further
wandering
around
investigating.
We
have
a
a
very
professional
staff.
They
have
City
staff.
They
have
come
up
with
a
very
clever
efficient
solution
and
children
and
adults
will
be
drawn
from
all
across
the
city
to
enjoy
this
all-inclusive
structure
and
for
it
to
include
art
elements
that
will
involve
the
children
in
interactive
art
play
will
be
fabulous,
they
so
kudos
to
the
city
staff.
Please
vote
Yes.
B
You
medicity
clerk
I'm,
bringing
it
back,
I'm
close
to
public
comment,
bringing
back
for
Council
for
comments.
First,
I'd
like
to
take
a
couple
minutes
to
ask
two
questions
to
verify
a
couple
of
things:
I
heard
a
few
comments
about
staff.
Are
you
going
to
be
able
to
do
this
on
time?
If
we
add
any
art
to
it
to
not
lose
our
grants.
S
B
H
The
mayor,
this
allocation
of
the
money
has
been
in
a
restricted
fund,
so
this
will
not
be
coming
from
the
general
fund.
Okay,
thank.
G
Oh
here,
okay,
yeah
I,
think
the
features
mentioned
in
the
staff
report
that
sound
very
interesting
and
I
will
not
object
to
having
those
artistic
features
in
a
playground,
and
it's
good
to
know
that
in
whatever
our
decision
tonight
would
not
affect
the
schedule
of
the
project,
but
I
do
want
to
make
sure
that
we
follow
existing
city
code,
so
Municipal
Code,
19.148040
has
ineligible
artwork
and
before
that
it
has
permitted
artwork
I
think
here,
it's
very
clear.
Art
means
original
art.
G
If
something
that's
really
nice
artistic,
but
if
it's
commercially
produced
and
available
in
multiple
locations,
it's
not
art.
The
the
idea
of
public
art
is
not
only
to
provide
art
to
the
city,
but
also
to
support
artists
who
create
original
work.
I
thought
that's
the
intent.
That's
why
here
ineligible
work
is
reproduction
of
original
art
is
not
eligible
unless
it's
produced
in
limited
edition
and
directional
functional
elements
is
not
eligible.
Art
object,
that's
mass
produced,
not
eligible
landscaping
and
garden
features
are
not
eligible.
G
W
If
I
may
Susan
Michael's
CIP
manager,
we
are
aware
of
the
code
and
the
requirement
that
the
art
be
original
and
custom
there'll
be
no
standard
pieces
uses.
If
it's
also
of
any
comfort,
The
Next
Step
would
be
that
we
will
return
to
the
arts
and
culture
commission
with
a
proposal
and
they
will
review
the
art
itself
against
those
standards.
W
G
I
Okay,
thank
you
so
going
back
to
the
the
funding
that
I
mentioned,
so
I
am
disappointed
that
we
spent
the
thirty
three
thousand
dollars
for
fundraising,
which
was
originally
supposed
to
bring
in
hopefully
two
million
dollars,
and
then
it
was
lowered
to
1
million
and
then
in
the
end,
we
we
didn't
have
any
fundraising
money
from
that.
But
I
did
notice,
though,
that
the
website
has
a
donate
button
and
I
was
wondering
I
mean
for
this
specific
project.
I
It's
a
little
PayPal
donate
button
on
there
and
I
was
wondering
if
any
money
has
been
collected
for
that
and
maybe
offline,
you
could
provide
an
answer
and
what
would
a
donor
get
in
return
for
using
that,
and
and
is
it
a
tax,
deductible
donation
as
well
I'm
glad
to
hear
the
fine
arts
and
culture
commission
will
get
a
chance
to
see
the
objects?
I
I'm
I'm
not
opposed
to
the
the
art
objects
going
at
this
location,
but
overall
I
would
like
to
see
Equity
throughout
the
community
when
we're
having
these
special
installations,
provided
so
that
it's
not
just
in
in
one
concentrated
area
so
that
we
can
look
to
that
moving
forward
and,
as
you
know,
I
would
would
have
preferred.
I
The
policy
been
floated
by
the
council
to
have
a
discussion,
so
I
I
think
we
better
find
a
way
to
open
that
up
and
Palo
Alto
seemed
rather
simple
to
follow
and
it
was
structured,
pretty
close
to
two
hours
and
so
I'm
glad
to
see.
This
is
moving
forward
with
with
a
few
caveats
that
I've
mentioned
and
I
do
hope
that
and
I'll
bring
it
up.
I
Like
I
mentioned
that
the
that
other
funds
that
we
can
look
into
that
and
and
I
I
think
it's
great
for
the
public
to
also
understand
and
for
myself
to
understand
how
the
money
can
be
moved
throughout
the
budget.
I
think
that's
an
important
bit
of
information
and
and
we're
going
to
need
it
in
the
next
few
weeks.
Okay,
so
thank
you.
B
R
Since
this
is
these
are
restricted
funds
and
I
I've
asked
these
questions
of
staff
and
I'm
satisfied
that
that
are
certain
efficiencies
that
will
that
will
be
generated
as
a
result
of
placing
this
art
in
in
jollyman
park,
as
opposed
to
anywhere
else,
and
that
there
are
Grant
fundings
which
which
could
grant
funding
which
could
be
in
Jeopardy.
If
we
don't
proceed
now
or
today,
I
am
convinced
that
that
this
is
the
way
to
go
and
I
I
would
like
to
proceed
with
the
with
the
staff
recommendation.
D
All
the
way
over
on
the
end
here,
I
I,
think
these
are
a
really
good
use
of
of
restricted
funds.
I
think
it's
a
great
way
to
leverage
those
funds
so
that
we
can
use
a
project
that
is
already
in
the
works
to
try
to
figure
out
how
we're
going
to
use
in
Luffy,
since
we
apparently
haven't
ever
had
to
do
that
before
I'm
also
elated,
that
the
arts
and
culture
commission
will
have
something
substantive
to
do
for
a
change.
D
I've
looked
at
a
number
of
of
their
agendas
and
they
frequently
consist
of
ratifying
the
minutes
and
looking
at
the
work
plan,
and
we
have
some
really
talented
people
in
the
arts
and
culture,
commission
and
I'd
love
to
see
them.
Do
something
really
good.
I
think
that
they'll
enjoy
looking
at
this
I'd
also
encourage
everyone
to
review
our
municipal
code
with
respect
to
what
is
and
isn't
considered
public
art
I
think
there's
a
lot
of
misstatements
that
have
been
made
with
respect
to
what
is
excluded
and
what
isn't
and
that's
it.
B
So
that
actually
brings
me
to
another
question:
the
Fine
Arts,
no,
the
Arts
and
Cultural
commit
commissioner
are
going
to
decide
on
what
kind
of
Arts
that's
going
to
be
put
put
into
the
jarment
park.
Is
that
the
procedure.
W
Our
next
step
is
to
return
to
the
arts
and
culture
commission
with
a
proposal
we'll
be
coming
with
a
specific
proposal
about
how
we
would
propose
to
install
art
in
within
the
pellet
ground
area
specifically
and
we'll
need
to
have
some
conceptual
designs
to
share
with
the
commission.
Yeah.
B
B
W
G
So
you
mentioned
some
conceptual
art
will
be
presented
to
the
Fine
Arts
commission
with
multiple
pieces
here
and
we
need
original
art.
Shooting
the
art
commission
be
engaged
the
ways
reaching
out
to
artists
to
help
design
these
elements,
rather
than
the
public
work,
doing
their
job.
That
I
think
Fine.
Art
commission
likely
have
connections
in
the
art
community
and
many
people
probably
would
really
like
to
see
their
work
being
displayed
in
a
public
park.
W
If
I
may,
the
designers
for
this
project
Mig
have
done
amazing
custom
installations
at
other
playgrounds.
If
you
look
at
their
website,
you
might
see
some
examples.
Our
plan
is
to
work
with
them
and
artists
that
they
know
and
that's
part
of
our
staying
on
schedule
and
budget
to
develop
the
custom
pieces.
So
that
will
be
part
of
what
we
will
be
presenting.
The
specifics
of
the
commission.
G
Could
we
possibly
engage
our
local
artists
I?
Think
a
lot
of
our
local
artists
if
we
can
engage
them
to
present,
maybe
Cupertino
or
Santa
Clara
County
arrested
are
resident.
Artists
Can
can
Mig
especially
reach
out
to
them,
but
they
can
also
connect
with
Fine
Arts
commission
for
this
Outreach
right.
Thank.
G
B
G
My
suggestion
that
we
prioritize
reaching
out
to
local
artists
for
for
the
original
art
and.
B
I
B
I
But
go
ahead
when
I,
when
I
think
about
these.
These
playgrounds
with
regards
to
I
I
appreciate
the
the
idea
to
reaching
out
to
the
local
artists,
but
it
becomes
really
complicated
because
of
all
the
colors
that
you're
that
you're
looking
at
colors
and
textures
and
you've
got
a
lot
of
design
elements
that
they're
going
to
need
to
tie
in
so
I
don't
want
to
complicate
their
their
their
work.
I
So
that's
my
only
comment.
I
have
there.
B
E
Yeah,
so
we
can
start
the
item
before
10
30
and
we'll
have
to
be.
We
will
have
to
be
finished
by
11
absent
to
vote
the
council
to
extend
the
meeting
beyond
that
time.
Okay,
do
I
need
a
motion
too.
B
B
B
H
Mere
way
we
do
not
have
a
staff
report,
we
do
have
interim
Public
Works
director
chat
mostly
here.
To
answer
any
questions.
The
ask
is
for
Council
to
consider
approving
the
semi-rule
destination
for
the
allocation
and
just
a
point
of
clarification
that
this
is
not
a
staff
recommendation.
Rather,
this
is
a
proposal
provided
by
the
property
owner
in
an
also
neighborhood,
so
staff
is
taking
the
property
owners
request
to
council
for
consideration.
B
Well,
thank
you
so
so
I
think
it's
I'm
going
to
open
up
for
Council
questions
before
public
comment.
Council
members.
Do
you
have
questions?
I
do
have
a
couple
questions
I'm
going
to
start
with
my
questions
so
it
in
the
report.
It
says
the
city
has
the
city
can
received
the
semi-rural
designation
anytime.
S
Council
yeah,
yes,
that
can
be
done
as
part
of
these
development
projects.
The
city
is
still
requiring
Dedication.
That
would
facilitate
our
ability
to
install
sidewalks
at
a
future
date.
So
if
we
did
deem
this
area
a
semi-world
designation,
we
had
a
couple
of
projects
redeveloped
and
they
did
not
install
those
sidewalks.
The
city
would
have
the
ability
to
rescind
the
semi-world
designation
and
we
would
have
the
ability
if
we
wanted
to
to
proceed
with
installation
of
sidewalk,
as
we
would
have
the
necessary
right-of-way
for
that.
B
S
At
that
point
in
time,
if
the
city
was
interested
in
progressing
a
project
quickly
to
have
sidewalk
installed,
it
would
be
the
city's
responsibility.
So.
S
Like
if
we
wanted
to
initiate
a
project
that
extended
sidewalk,
immediately
sort
of
like
what
was
done
for
Orange
Avenue
and
Byrne
Avenue
in
the
Monte
Vista
area,.
G
I'm
confused
because
the
staff
report
here
reads
with
the
findings
presented
above
and
the
petition
the
property
owner.
Having
shown
their
support
for
the
proposed,
the
semi-rural
designation,
the
city
staff
recommends
approval
to
forego
the
future
installation
of
sidewalks
along
the
east
side
of
Carmen
Road
between
Scenic
Boulevard
and
Stevens
Creek
Boulevard.
The
semi-rural
designation
does
not
waive
the
requirement
for
curb
garter
or
straight
light
installation.
So
it
is
the
city's
staff
recommendation
for
the
item
to
approve.
H
I'll
answer
that
so
it
is
a
request
coming
from
the
property
owners,
after
staff,
evaluation
and
staff
recommending
what
the
applicant
is
proposing.
Yeah.
G
And
in
that
area,
I
remember:
I
visited
the
many
areas,
don't
have
sidewalk.
So
even
if
it's
going
to
be
a
property
owner
cost
and
it
will
likely
be
no
sidewalk
or
maybe
this
can
disconnected
sidewalk
for
many
years
to
come.
Even
if
even
if
one
property
owner
maybe
have
did
a
renovation
and
have
to
install,
but
there
will
be
their
neighbors
might
not
move
for
another
30
years
through
the
mayor.
So
the.
H
H
G
H
Q
The
city
manager
is
correct,
as
as
projects
have
larger
remodel
projects
on
the
on
the
site,
they're
required
to
install
sidewalk
and
and
related
improvements.
It
does
lead
in
to
a
situation
where
we
have
sort
of
properties
that
are
adjacent
to
other
properties,
who
don't
have
the
improvements
and
the
intent
is
that
it
catches
up
over
time
and
we've
been
successful
with
that
in
some
locations
in
other
locations,
you'll
see
the
odd
house
that
doesn't
have
sidewalk,
where
the
adjacent
do
and
eventually
we'll
catch
up
with
all
of
them.
G
Q
We
have
a
standard
for
sidewalk,
so
when
we
make
a
requirement
for
sidewalks
it
would
meet
the
city
standard
and
that
that's
what
you
would
see
in
a
you
know
normal
City
Block.
If
you
walked
outside
the
door
here
in
terms
of
a
wider
Street,
the
streets
have
evolved
over
time.
Sometimes
there's
there's
a
an
area
off
the
side
of
the
of
the
of
the
street.
That
is
paved
most
of
the
time.
B
B
So
the
the
proposed
Jolly
sorry,
the
proposed
Carmen
Bridge-
that's
going
to
go
through
that
street
right.
That's
going
to
go
into
that
street.
S
B
Is
that
I'm
going
to
come
down
to
that
question?
Why
are
we
requesting
west
side
and
not
East
Side.
S
With
respect
to
the
West
Side,
there's
already
sidewalk
installed
along
those
sides,
so
once
we've
kind
of
started
a
policy
of
an
installation
of
sidewalks,
we
typically
progress
with
ensuring
that
so.
S
In
certain
areas
where
there
is
no
sidewalk,
we
would
evaluate.
Is
this
an
area
that
is
need
of
sidewalk,
or
could
it
be
more
of
a
semi-rural
approach.
B
B
West
Side,
okay,
understand
and
one
more
question
is:
there
are
two
homes
that
don't
didn't
sign
it
do
they
disagree
with
it
or
they
they're,
okay,
with
sidewalks
I'm,
just
curious.
S
I
Okay,
Chad
I
just
want
to
make
sure
that
I
have
the
right
area.
I
So
this
is
the
end
of
Carmen
Road
and
now
we're
I
just
want
people
to
get
a
get
a
good
sense
of
what
the
Street
looks
like.
Okay.
Can
anyone
from
staff
verify
okay.
I
S
When
the
road
is
fully
built
out,
it
will
be
40
feet
wide.
Okay,.
S
Beyond
this
end
here,
that's
where,
if
Carmen
Road
Bridge
is
ever
constructed,
it
would
be
at
that
fence
in
the
North
End,
okay,.
I
C
AE
Thank
you
good
evening.
Madam
mayor
and
city
council
and
City
staff.
State
managers
hi,
my
name
is
Patrick
Clark
here
I've
been
living
at
the
1022
common
for
the
past
24
years,
I'm,
the
one
who
circulated
all
the
petitions
to
all
the
neighborhoods
17
of
those
one
of
those
is
a
rental.
So
the
landlord
Mr
Baron
directly
sent
in
the
petition
supporting
the
semi
rule
as
it
is
right
now
we
have
about
65
houses
all
together
on
common
and
Scenic
of
the
east
side,
every
houses
on
this
common
and
Scenic.
AE
They
are
also
my
rule
except
the
11th
one
that
are
asking
the
petition,
all
the
houses
on
the
west
side
coming
in
from
Stevens
Creek
into
Janus
and
upcoming.
They
all
have
sidewalk
except
the
last
three
that
are
very
old.
So
when
they,
if
it
Remains
the
Same,
they
will
have
to
put
sidewalk
to
continuity,
to
finish
everything
on
the
West
Side
web
sidewalk.
If
these
three
houses
were
remodeled
so
far,
the
petitions
at
16
out
of
17
support
the
sidewalk
all
the
five
on
the
West
Side.
AE
They
supported
it
on
the
East
Side
10
out
of
11.
AE
They
all
supported
the
sidewalk
and
it
is
very
consistent
with
all
the
houses
on
the
east
side
from
common
to
scenic
because
they
all
are
semi-rural
destination,
so
I
represented
the
residents
because
I
I
circulated
the
petition
and
they
all
feel
that,
as
it
is
now
to
remain
semi's
rural,
it
will
be
very
safe
because
the
street
is
wide
enough
for
the
people,
for
the
restaurants
to
bike
and
walk
and
skate,
and
everything
in
here
and
your
questions
that
were
raised
was
that
if
carbon
breaches
is
to
be
built,
a
city
can
rescind
the
destination
on
the
east
side.
AE
But
as
far
as
the
west
side
is
concerned,
it
will
have
sidewalk
all
the
way
through
from
Foothill
from
a
service
Creek
up
Janus
and
into
our
common.
There
are
fire
houses
on
the
West
Side
three
of
those
already
have
sidewalk
the
other
three.
If
they
were
to
do
the
remodeling,
they
would
have
sidewalk.
So
a
good
continuation.
Also
I
walk
on
one
side
on
the
west
side
of
city
and
by
this
partition.
You
know
it's
very
consistent
with
the
neighborhood
on
the
east
side,
Scenic
and
common.
C
And
next
we
have
rotify,
followed
by
Jennifer
Griffin,
welcome
murder.
M
Hi
again
and
I
just
wanted
to
get
up
and
support
Patrick
crock's
petition.
M
Many
of
as
many
of
you
know
he
served
on
our
city
council
for
many
years
highly
decorated
he's
he
knows
Cupertino
and
he
obviously
knows
his
own
neighborhood
and
I.
Think
it's
a
no-brainer
to
go
with
semi
rural
I
I
live
in
Monte
Vista,
where
we
had
sidewalk
no
sidewalk
sidewalk,
no
sidewalk.
It's
been
a
mess
and
I
just
go
with
Patrick
and
and
I
I
can't
resist
to
make
the
pun,
but
with
respect
to
the
Harmon
Avenue
Bridge,
why
don't
we
cross
that
bridge
when
we
get
to
it?
L
Okay,
segue
from
magical
Bridge,
it
was
interesting,
seeing
the
actual
street
views
I'm
glad
that
Ms
Moore
brought
those
up
because
I
I
remember
that
area
so
well
from
growing
up.
We
call
that
huhu
Hill,
which
was
from
an
elderly
lady
from
many
many
years
ago,
used
to
call
it
that
the
who
who
house
was
up
there
and
Carmen.
Actually
there
was
I,
think
it
actually
you
if
I
remember
correctly
years
ago,
you
could
actually
use
that
road.
On
the
other
side,
it
wasn't
blocked
off.
L
I
may
have
the
wrong
road
there,
but
it
is
an.
It
is
a
unique
area.
I
think
it
was
part
of
inspiration
Heights
from
the
1920s
when
it
was
subdivided
Etc,
but
there
is
a
point
in
terms
of
having
some
continuity
in
the
area.
My
brother
owned
a
house
in
the
airport
District
of
Modesto
years
ago,
and
it's
a
very
poor
section
and
he
actually,
when
he
remodeled
the
house
he
had
a
sidewalk
put
in,
but
I
will
tell
you.
There
were
no
sidewalks
anywhere
else
in
the
entire
neighborhood.
It
was
gang-ridden.
L
It
still
is
it's
a
very
poor
area
and
when
he
finally,
he
kept
the
house
as
a
rental
and
he
moved
to
a
different
home
with
my
sister-in-law
that
still
that
house
still
is
the
only
one
after
probably
30
years,
that
had
a
sidewalk,
so
he
was
trying,
but
but
all
in
all,
it's
probably
better
to
just
have
some
continuity
for
the
neighborhood
down
the
road.
Eventually
Public
Works
will
be
able
to
put
in
the
sidewalk
someday,
but
it's
probably
better
to
try
to
keep
the
neighbors
happy
with
consistency.
L
I'm
also
wondering
if
you're
going
to
be
putting
in
the
Carmen
Bridge
there
well
you're
going
to
have.
Obviously
cars
aren't
going
to
be
going
over
it,
but
we'll
you're
going
to
have
a
lot
of
foot
traffic
bicycles,
skateboards,
electric
vehicles,
Etc
going
down
that
street
to
go
over
the
Footbridge,
I
I!
Guess
it's
a
you'd
call
it
a
footbedge
because
it
doesn't
have
cars
on
it.
How
how
does
not
having
a
sidewalk
versus
having
a
sidewalk
effect?
L
This
speed
of
vehicles
going
down
there,
because
when
you
have
these
electric
bicycles,
they
can
be
going
through.
I
mean
I've
been
passed
by
them
in
cars,
I
mean
I,
mean
I've
been
in
the
car
and
they've
passed
me
in
the
bike.
Lane
they're,
probably
clipping
along
35
or
40
miles
an
hour.
Is
that
by
having
a
similar
semi-rural
designation?
L
C
AB
Good
evening,
mayor
way
and
council
members
I'm
again
speaking
on
behalf
of
myself,
I
asked
something
different,
I
think
than
what
most
people
are
saying.
I
ask
that
you
postponed
voting
on
this
item.
The
reason
for
this
is
that
it's
likely
for
the
proposed
staff
work
plan
for
the
next
few
years
that
the
council
will
be
voting
on,
whether
to
build
the
Kerman
Bridge,
which
would
connect
the
neighborhoods
to
the
south
and
north
of
Stevens
Creek.
The
bridge
will
change
the
amount
and
then
I
think
a
couple.
AB
AB
One
note
is
that
bikes
do
use
sidewalks
all
kids
under
age,
13,
plus
their
parents,
with
them
bike
on
the
sidewalk
so
and
and
let's
face
facts,
sometimes
people
order
that
do
too.
There's
no
rush
to
do
this
at
this
time
and
no
sidewalk
projects
are
planned
on
that
street
by
the
city.
So
please
just
postpone
the
decision
until
it
seems
like
the
appropriate
time
and
then
once
we
know
all
the
facts,
the
real
decision
can
be
made
with
all
the
facts.
N
Good
evening,
city,
council
and
maybe
I
would
agree
with
Jennifer
I
think
it
is
important
to
assess
safety
conditions
for
pedestrians
at
all
times
of
the
day
and
all
through
the
year
I'm
concerned.
The
staff
report
has
no
photographs
of
the
area
and
I'm
concerned.
There's
no
photographs
taken
at
dusk,
where
people
go
out
for
walks
in
the
neighborhood
and
no
photographs
at
winter
time.
N
N
We
have
school
kids
that
walk
down
some
of
these
roads,
I
see
them
all
the
time
on,
headed
towards
Stevens,
Creek
and
then
headed
up
towards
the
towards
the
shortcut
to
Modern,
Vista
and
so
on
and
I'd
be
concerned
about
visibility
come
evening
hours
and
why
don't
we
have
photographs
where
we
made
to
look
at
street
maps
and
not
look
at
actual
photographs
from
a
assessment
of
the
site.
I'm
also
concerned
that
the
cost
and
sidewalk
would
then
be
transferred
to
the
city
as
opposed
to
the
homeowners.
O
Good
evening,
mayor
way,
vice
mayor,
Mohan,
council,
members
and
staff,
I
support
Mr
kwok's
petition
for
semi-rural
designation
and
the
reason
is
consistency.
O
They
have
different,
looks
and
I've
been
on
Carmen
Road
and
it
is
a
semi-rural
place
and
if,
at
some
other
time
you
decide
that
you
need
sidewalks
there,
you
have
the
ability
to
do
that,
but
until
then
preserve
the
look
of
the
neighborhood
by
allowing
all
the
people
on
the
east
side
who
want
to
be
semi-girl
to
stay
that
way.
It
has
a
soft,
it's
a
very
relaxing
feel
and
in
that
neighborhood
I
have
not
seen
people
the
the
street
is
narrow
and
I
did
not
see
people
racing
through.
O
Of
course,
I
haven't
been
there
all
times
a
day,
but
I
think
you
need
to
also
preserve
the
ability
for
different
neighborhoods
to
be
unique.
We
aren't
all
the
same.
Just
like
people
aren't
the
same,
allow
them
to
be
unique
so
that
we
can
walk
through
our
city
and
experience
these
different
neighborhoods.
B
I
Thank
you
Mary
way.
I
have
a
quick
question
again
for
Chad.
You
mentioned
I
believe
40
feet
was
that
curb
to
curb.
I
Okay,
so
40
feet
curb
to
curb:
will
you
have
a
four
to
five
foot
Parkway
strip
and
then
a
four
or
five
four
or
five
foot
sidewalk.
S
Typically,
yeah
you'd
have
about
a
four
and
a
half
foot
park
strip
and
about
a
four
and
a
half
foot
sidewalk.
If,
if
that
were
to
be
the
constructed.
I
Okay
and
to
the
residents
in
that
area
know
what
that's
going
to
look
like
Dimension
wise,
compared
to
what
what
they
have
there
now
have
has
that
been
presented
to
them.
S
I
mean
there
are
other
side
other
areas
in
the
city
that
have
that
same
layout.
We
are
requiring
dedication
of
any
developer,
so
we're
you
know
that
land
is
being
provided.
I
Okay
and
I
was
wondering
if
we
could
hear
from
Patrick
Kwok
about
this
if,
if
you've
noticed
any
speeding
in
that
area,
what
I'm
seeing
is
that
there's
a
very
there's
a
lot
of
turns
in
and
between
Carmen
and
Bellevue
and
I'm
just
wondering
if
it's
been
your
experience
that
people
speed
through
their.
AE
The
way
it
is
now
is
that
it
runs
into
that
end
straight
so
people
people
who
live
around
in
here
they
are
residents.
They
know.
Safety
is
a
concern,
so
they
would
not
risk
to
speed
the
car
all
the
way
Express
you're
going
down.
Quinterra
is
a
very
narrow
Street
if
they
speed.
You
know
this
morning.
I
saw
a
garbage
pickup,
you
know
it
was
so
steep
down
in
Quintana
is
of
a
common.
AE
They
have
to
back
the
car,
the
garbage
truck
all
the
way
they
will
not
because
there's
no
way
to
to
use
to
answer
your
question
it
is
people
will
not
speak
because
number
one
they
live
in
the
neighborhood.
They
are
not
people
who
who
are
lost
looking
for
something
they
are
familiar
with
it.
They
are
know
that
the
people
are
running
here.
They
know
that
they
are
safe.
They
are
kids
in
here.
I
Would
believe
that
okay,
so
maybe
this
question
is
for
Chad
also,
it
seems
as
though
the
configuration
of
the
roads
actually
is
going
to
have
a
traffic
calming
effect,
because
they're
they're
pretty
narrow
and
there's
a
lot
of
twists
and
turns
and
sounds
like
Hills
there
as
well.
S
You
know
the
neighborhood
doesn't
have
a
lot
of
twists.
It
is
along
a
hillside.
It
should
be
noted
that
this
section
of
Carmen
Road
is
on
a
no
Outlet
area
there
for
vehicle
traffic.
That
is
it's
kind
of
a
dead
end
stretch.
It
goes
in
serves
around
20
properties
and
that's
those
are
the
only
properties
that
are
served
by
this
section
of
Road.
Okay,.
G
Okay,
so
first
I'd
like
to
thank
the
staff
for
a
very
detailed
staff
report.
It
answered
on
every
one
of
my
questions
that
I
would
have
asked,
so
it
could
consider
idea
compliance
and
the
possibility
of
considering
Common
Road,
and
you
answered
that
this
designation
can
be
rescinded
by
the
city
at
the
time
and
the
street
light
got
her.
Every
question
is
answered
really
appreciate
a
thorough
report.
G
It
would
have
been
nice
if
there
were
photographs
of
the
area
and
the
areas
where
it's
always
outside
work,
but
it's
just
very
thorough
report
and
it
says
that
the
proposed
the
seminal
area
is
similar
in
character
to
the
surrounding
neighborhood
and
I.
Looked
up
the
Google
map
again,
although
I
visited
the
area
before
that,
is
a
dead
end
street.
G
So
I
understand
the
San
Ras
concerned
that,
if
especially
around
school,
when
cars
passing
through,
but
this
is
an
area-
that's
a
dead
end
and
even
if
a
common
bridge
is
built
in
the
future,
it's
going
to
be
a
pedestrian
bicycle
Bridge.
There
won't
be
any
through
traffic,
so
there
won't
be
car
zooming
by
there
might
be
bicycles,
but
I
think
the
40
feet
is
wide
enough
for
pedestrian
and
bicycle
English
trees.
That's
real!
That
has
relatively
little
car
traffic
except
the
neighbors
who
live
there.
So
it
sounds
like
then,
even
with
common
Bridge.
G
There
may
or
may
not
be
need
for
a
sidewalk
and
at
this
point
I
would
think
it
makes
sense
to
approved
semi,
semi-rural
designation
and
when
we
do
need
to
consider
Common
Road,
we
may
or
may
not
need
the
sidewalk
at
that
time
on
I
do
agree
that
we
should
allow
Cupertino
to
have
different
neighborhoods
to
have
different
characters.
We
should
not
expect
every
neighborhood
to
have
sidewalk
in
all
of
Cupertino.
That's
simply
unrealistic
and
would
not
allow
different
areas
of
Cupertino
to
have
its
own
neighborhood
character.
G
B
You
councilmember
child
any
more
questions.
Oh
no
discussions,
council
member.
R
R
Although
there
was
I,
think
kids
were
still
going
to
Crossing,
Stevens
Creek,
so
I
didn't
have
any
concerns
about
traffic
staff
was
able
to
in
their
staff
report
as
well
as
in
my
conversations
with
them,
did
confirm
that
there
would
not
be
it
would
not
interfere
with
garbage
pickup
or
fire
hydrants
or
or
even
the
future
construction
of
the
Common
Road
Bridge.
So
I'm
good
with
this
recommendation,
also
with
the
understanding
that
it
could
be
rescinded
anytime,
there's
a
another
event
that
does
not
make
this
convenient
any
longer.
G
B
B
B
Okay,
so
it's
10
52
and
we
are
moving
to
excuse
me
we're
moving
to
a.
E
Council
member
reports
so
that
so
this
meet
the.
T
AC
B
A
A
A
A
A
AF
AF
V
AG
AG
For
sister
city,
I
am
the
first
vice
president,
and
my
main
focus
is
with
the
student
delegation,
where
I
plan
in
getting
students
to
go
to
Japan
and
and
having
our
of
the
kids
from
Japan
coming
to
us
for
visiting
as
an
exchange
and
working
very
closely
with
my
counterpart
in
toyakawa.
My
daughter
was
interested
in
going
to
Japan
and
there
was
an
opportunity
to
be
part
of
the
exchange.
She
had
a
wonderful
time.
AG
I
had
a
blast
when
the
girls
came
to
stay
with
us,
and
so
I
wanted
a
way
to
give
back
to
the
community
because
it
was
so
worthwhile
for
us
as
a
family.
My
youngest
daughter
also
was
able
to
participate,
another
wonderful
experience,
and
so
essentially,
I
landed
up
besides
just
two
daughters
here,
I
also
have
like
six
other
daughters
in
Japan
as
host
daughters
and
then
I
had
an
opportunity
to
be
a
chaperone
in
2016..
AG
Just
makes
me
proud
to
see
these
kids
grow
into
these
wonderful
adults
with
girl,
scouting
Since
I
no
longer
have
any
girls
in
girl
scouting.
My
focus
has
been
running
a
annual
Day
Camp
up
in
our
Sanborn
Park
area
and
besides
student
delegation,
I
do
help
out
with
the
Cherry
Blossom
Festival
as
well.
AH
When
you
have
someone,
as
invested
as
shared,
is
in
your
community,
the
community
benefits
so
much.
She
is
tireless
and
just
up
for
anything
and
I
love
that
in
a
volunteer,
she's
endlessly
creative
and
positive
and
has
just
an
overwhelmingly
amazing
attitude.
It's
citizens
like
Sharon
that
make
a
community
and
that
Inspire
other
people
to
become
involved.
Thank
you.
AG
I
swear
to
God
you're,
so
awesome
you
never
know,
because
you
could
find
that
you
really
enjoy
doing
it
and
there
are
times
when
you
do
have
to
say
no,
because
your
Plate's
full,
but
if
there
is
a
chance
that
you
might
find
something
that
you
really
enjoy
so
I
do
suggest
that
people
really
try
to
just
just
go
out
there.
Try
it
once
you
never
know,
and
you
know
that
that's
a
great
way
to
just
get
to
volunteer.
AG
AI
AI
Good
afternoon
and
welcome
to
today's
Wellness
presentation,
my
name
is
Claire
varesio
and
I.
Am
the
community
librarian
at
Cupertino,
Library
and
I'm
very
pleased
to
have
you
all
join
us
for
today's
program.
The
root
causes
of
pain,
Cupertino
libraries,
Wellness
series
brings
you
what
we
are
calling
the
other
half
of
Health
topics
that
many
of
you
may
wish
to
know
more
about,
or
that
may
not
be
covered
during
your
regular
visits
with
your
doctor.
Today's
presentation
is
being
filmed
by
the
city
of
Cupertino
and
we
thank
them
for
their
support
of
this
series.
AI
We
are
able
to
bring
you
these
wellness
events
through
the
generous
support
of
Cupertino
Library
foundation
and
I
would
like
to
introduce
Henry
sang,
Cupertino,
Library
Foundation
president,
who
will
say
a
few
words
about
the
foundation
and
also
introduce
this
afternoon
speaker.
Thank
you
all
very
much.
AJ
Good
afternoon
yes,
I'm
with
the
Cupertino
Library
foundation
and
where
that
organization,
that's
in
the
background-
and
we
do
a
couple
of
different
things
for
you.
We
work
with
our
library
and
in
fact
you
could
think
of
us
in
a
very
Silicon
Valley
way
as
we're
an
incubator
for
new
types
of
programs.
So
when
we
saw
that
there
what
we
saw
was
a
missing
thing
about
health
and
what
the
doctors
don't
have
us
don't
tell
us
with,
but
we
have
to
do
on
our
own.
AJ
That's
when
we
started
this
thing
and
we
incubate
that
we
try
it
out.
We
do
different
things,
they're
going
to
be
doing
some
other
things.
The
library
is
putting
together
this
follow-on
program.
So
after
we
do
Dr
Young
stock
and
we're
going
to
look
at
some
some
smaller
group
sessions
to
what
you
would
look
at,
you
know
try
to
do
the
next
step.
Now
we're
not
able
to
do
everything
for
you,
but
we
start
these
things.
AJ
So
my
organization
is
say
you
know
we
can
kick
in
a
few
thousand
dollars
here
and
do
some
time
there
and
try
to
help
things
out.
But
that's
that's
kind
of
what
we
do
we're
like
the
that
we
do
the
experimental
programs
with
our
library.
Now
you
may
not
know
it,
but
her
organization
put
on
656
programs
last
year.
AJ
You
know
that's
several
a
day
right.
It's
amazing!
Now
the
the
funny
thing
is:
our
community
loves
our
library.
You
know
we
come
here
a
lot.
You
can't
find
a
parking
spot
right,
I
mean
do
you
know
we're
the
only
library
that
has
that
problem
right
and
actually,
if
you
find
a
parking
spot,
sometimes
go
across
there
right
now.
Good
luck,
finding
a
chair
because
not
only
don't
have
enough
spots,
but
the
people
who
found
a
spot.
They
can't
find
a
seat
because
it's
people
attend
our
library.
AJ
They
use
our
library
that
is
good,
most
celebrities,
United
States.
Aren't
that
way.
Well,
what
we're
trying
to
also
do
is
our
organizations
we're
an
advocacy
organization
we
fight
for
them.
You
know,
quite
frankly,
as
County
employees
are
not
allowed
to
say
certain
things
weekend.
You
got
it
right
yeah,
so
you
know
not
25
years
ago
when
we
started.
AJ
If
you
remember,
if
you
were
resident
time,
we
had
the
old
library
and
a
budget
thing
hit
and
the
number
of
hours
went
down
to
very
few
hours
a
week.
I
think
it
was
like
16
to
20
hours
a
week.
The
foundation
was
formed
and
we
went
out
and
raised
money
to
open
the
library,
because
our
community
needs
our
library.
We
then
advocated
with
the
governments
and
we
got
more
funding,
and
you
know
we
have.
AJ
We
have
a
probably
the
most
number
of
hours
in
any
library
in
the
district
right
now,
and
we
still
have
some
amazing
use
well,
because
we
have
all
these
programs
and
you
like
to
have
them
and
I
think
you
know
the
reason
we're
continuing
with
this
is
because
of
the
interest.
We
know
that
we
need
to
do
more
programs,
we
need
to
have
more
space
for
it,
the
bit
the
the
limiting
thing
right.
AJ
We
don't
have
room
right,
so
we're
trying
to
actually
build
on
to
the
library
and
so
we're
starting
an
advocacy
campaign
to
try
to
educate
you
and
show
what
we're
trying
to
do
so
filling
out
that
that
that
form
at
the
end,
saying
yeah
I,
want
to
see
more
on
this
or
I
have
an
idea.
Our
next
speaker
in
May
is
going
to
be
on
on
mindfulness,
which
is
like
take
meditation
and
go
to
the
next
level.
How
do
you
actually
use
it
to
change
it?
AJ
It's
a
great
topic
we're
going
to
have
follow-on
sessions
that
guess
what
we
need
space.
So
that's
what
we
do
now,
that's
enough
for
the
the
you
know
the
stump
and
trying
to
get
you
aware
of
what
we
do.
The
the
great
thing
right
now
is
Dr
Yang
is
our
speaker.
Now
she
was
the
very
first
Speaker
two
years
ago
when
we
started
this
program
and
it's
because
of
her
excellent
talks
that
we've
decided.
You
know,
let's
keep
doing
this,
it's
a
little
bit's
good.
AJ
Let's
try
some
other
things
who
went
to
the
Alzheimer's
thing
right
or
how
about
cholesterol
or
skin
care
right.
You
know,
we've
got
some
really
great
topics
that
once
again
our
doctors
don't
help
us
with
we
need
to.
We
need
to
actually
learn
from
people
like
driana.
By
the
way
she
is
a
retiree
Tech
retiree,
who
then
created
a
second
career
in
pain,
management,
acupuncture
and
acupressure.
AJ
Today,
we're
going
to
be
talking
about
acupressure
since
I've
seen
her
last
she's
told
me:
she's
been
in
five
different
countries,
she's
been
in
Taiwan
in
China,
Myanmar,
Swaziland
and
in
Honduras
Honduras
right.
So
this
woman
has
been
out
taking
her
Med
the
medical
training
she
has
and
has
been
out
offering
it
as
a
medical
missionary
across
the
world.
Now
the
amazing
thing
is
this:
is
our
home
and
so
she's
here
today
to
help
us
Dr
Young,
please.
AK
Love
can
you
hear
me?
Well,
okay,
hi
everybody.
My
name
is
Lian.
Today,
it's
a
part
of
the
pain
relief,
Workshop
series.
We
have
a
series
of
them
and
we
are
going
to
have
two
more
sessions
coming
up.
AK
Okay,
today
we
are
going
to
focus
on
the
root
causes
of
pain,
but
in
the
same
time,
we're
also
going
to
use
we're
going
to
use
the
neck
and
shoulder
pain
as
a
sample
to
show
how
the
three
simple
steps
to
pain,
relief,
okay,
so
other
than
that
at
the
end
of
the
session,
we're
going
to
have
a
little
quiz
and
as
you
already
have,
you
have
souvenir
to
bring
home
the
the
one
page
summary
summary
sheet
and
also
there's
a
lot
of
tennis
ball
here,
donated
by
Cupertino,
Sports
Center.
AK
They
are
used
tennis
ball,
so
Chris
drop
it
and
pick
it
up.
They
are
very
good
pain,
relief
tool
and
I
will
show
you
how
okay.
So,
let's
start.
AK
AK
Okay
in
the
story
of
a
whiz
of
Arts,
that's
an
interesting
character.
Tingman
one
day,
tingman
was
a
chopping
Woods
in
a
forest
and
and
it
started
raining
so
his
joint
got
rusted
in
the
rain,
water
and
Frozen
and
could
not
move
so.
Do
you
feel
that
Kim
is
sometimes
especially
when
you
wake
up
in
the
morning
that
the
joy
got
all
stiff
and
not
able
to
move
okay,
yeah
I
see
that
nothing
hits
okay,
30
Americans
are
handling
their
pain
issues
in
the
width
of
Arts.
AK
AK
You
can
break,
you
can
conceal
the
pain,
but
it
does
not
really
solve
the
fundamental
problems.
Let
me
show
you.
Let
me
share
with
you
one
story
from
last
week
when
I
was
at
Honduras.
One
of
our
members
is
a
pharmacist.
AK
AK
Okay,
that's
why
I
have
so
much
pain
and
I
I.
Look
at
her
knee!
It's
not
swelling!
It's
not
deformed
and
I,
set
her
down
and
start
to
palpate
the
areas
for
the
knee,
there's,
no
pain
and
so
I
asked
her.
Where
exactly
is
the
pen
point
to
here?
This
is
the
the
tibial
bone,
the
media
epicondyle
of
the
the
tibial
bone
like
if
you
trace
your
your
teeth,
your
bone
up
and
when
it
starts
to
turn
a
little
bit
and
back
a
little
bit
then
here.
AK
AK
I
also
have
my
own.
The
other
picture
is
my
own.
Mri
I
also
have
my
own
story.
Over
10
years
ago,
I
have
back
pain,
I
went
to
the
doctor,
doctor
MRI
and
say:
oh
you
have
compression
fracture.
This
is
not
reversible.
You
are
going
to
live
with
the
pain,
and
this
is
the
prescription
for
the
painkiller
and
please
don't
do
outdoor
activities
anymore.
Okay,
do
I
look
like
the
kind
of
person
who
don't
do
outdoor
activities
so.
AK
Since
pain
is
such
a
common
human
suffering
I
feel
like
they
got
to
be
a
better
way
to
handle
it
so
I
started
learning
Chinese
medicine
I
get
my
acupuncture
license.
I
quit
my
high-tech
job
and
go
on
Mission
around
the
world
around
the
world.
This
is
those
beautiful,
beautiful
pictures.
Are
the
pictures
I
took
last
November
at
the
Mema?
Okay,
it's
totally
isolated
from
the
world
because
it
was
a
territory
for
the
rebel
Army
over
there.
AK
The
people
have
very
different
lifestyle,
as
you
can
see
on
the
pictures,
and
they
have
a
different
set
of
paint
this.
This
guy
I
call
him
Mr
thousand.
AK
He
have
a
pen
on
the
right
shoulder
and
the
LED
back
and
a
lot
of
people
in
that
Village
have
the
same
problem.
So
I
try
to
figure
out
why
this
is
their
pen
area,
okay,
I
figure
out,
because
November
is
a
rubber
tree
potashi
season
at
the
night
they
go
to
the
rubber
tree
forest
and
cut
the
back
of
tree
with
Falls
like
this
in
that
position.
AK
AK
AK
What
it
does
is,
allow
you
to
rotate
your
leg
bone
like
this
Okay.
So
after
a
while
I
figure
out,
the
reason
is
the
way
they
sit
on
the
floor.
You
see
this
is
their
Sunday
school
for
Buddha
descent
and
all
the
all.
The
students
are
sitting
like
this,
so
I
work
with
the
school
I
work
with
the
patients
to
make
sure
they
don't
rotate
their
leg
to
one
side
all
the
time.
That's
why
they
cause
the
trouble
okay.
AK
So
when
this
is
a
Africa
in
February
in
Swaziland,
but
just
looking
at
the
picture,
can
you
see
there?
They
are
having
a
lot
of
back
pain,
Tennessee
elbow
pain
when
I
go
from
country
to
Country.
There
are
different
lifestyle
have
a
different
epidemic
of
pain.
When
I
come
back
home,
we
have
another
set
of
pain.
AK
Okay,
so
we
with
our
Advanced
Medical
system
and
the
technology
we
are,
we
are,
we
don't
have
less
pain
than
other
people,
so
they
made
me
think
I
learned
acupuncture
to
help
people
relieve
the
pain,
it's
very
effective,
but
the
problem
is
the
pain,
keep
coming
back.
Okay.
So
if
we
don't
dress
the
root
cause,
the
the
treatment
of
symptom
is
just
temporary.
It's
going
to
keep
coming
back
and
I'm
not
going
to
stay
in
those
Village
or
villages
with
them
all
the
time.
Okay.
AK
AK
What
we
learn,
what
what
I'm
going
to
show
you
in
one
hour
is
not
what
you
learn
in
eight
years
in
medical
school.
Okay,
what
I'm
learning
is
just
some
simple
rules
that
you
can
handle
most
of
the
problem.
Okay,
I
have
to
admit
there
are
problems
that
cannot
be
addressed
here
and
there
are
even
problems.
I
cannot
address
myself.
AK
AK
Okay,
sorry,
the
what
now
now
we're
talking
about
the
root
cause
and
the
pain
relief.
Now,
let's
talk
about
the
root
cause.
First,
there
are
many
reasons.
There
are
many
root
causes
of
pain,
nutrition,
exercise
and
many
things,
but
this
this
one
no
hanging
fruit,
which
is
a
posture.
So
that's
what
we're
going
to
talk
about
today,
because
that's
totally
under
your
control,
not
only
is
under
you
can
not
totally
under
your
control.
You
are
the
only
one
who
can
control
it.
AK
Okay,
I
met
with
a
person
like
that
she
complained
to
me.
She
have
so
much
pain
on
her
neck
and
shoulder
she
couldn't
sleep
at
night
for
years.
She
goes
from.
She
went
from
Doctor
to
doctor
should
take
many
different
medications
and
she
still
had
pain.
So
I
asked
her.
Do
you
always
sit
like
that?
She
said
yes,
so
I
asked
her.
Do
you
have
pain
right
now?
She
said
yes,
really
bad,
so
I
told
her
I
have
a
good
news
and
bad
news
for
you
bad
news.
AK
First,
there's
no
doctor
can
fix
your
problem.
The
good
news
is
but
I
know
somebody
who
can
fix
your
problem
for
sure,
and
that's
you,
okay,
so
I
help
her
to
adjust
her
posture.
I
will
show
you
how
to
do
that
later
and
then
she
she
said,
oh
I,
feel
much
better
and
I
say
you
still
have
pain,
yeah,
she
said.
I
still
have
some
pain,
then
I
I
told
her
how
to
do
the
pain
relief
technique
and
she
happily
walk
away
without
any
treatment.
AK
AK
Okay,
as
a
result,
we
affect
all
the
muscles
in
the
front
back
and
all
the
way
to
your
stomach.
Okay.
The
first
thing
is
the
shadow
breathing
okay,
because
you
can
press
your
your
on
your
lung
capacity.
Shadow
breathing
sounds
an
easy
problem
if
it's
not
hurting
or
whatever,
but
Shadow
breathing
can
affect
your
can
affect
your
health,
a
lot
if
you
don't
pay
attention
to
that,
because
it
affect
your
sympathetic
system.
So
this
is
another
topic,
but
make
sure
you
can
breathe.
Easy
is
important.
AK
AK
AK
Reason
is
when
you,
when
your
hair
go
when
you,
when
you
bend
down
this
muscle,
can
stretch
and
you
pull
on
your
on
this
bone,
and
it
puts
stress
on
the
joint,
sometimes
as
a
result.
It
can
also
cause
dental
problems
like
over
10
years
ago.
My
dentist
look
at
my
teeth:
I
grind
the
teeth:
really
bad,
okay,
after
35
years
of
a
high-tech
engineer,
and
she
she
said
I,
don't
understand
why
all
the
high
tech
Engineers
grind
their
teeth.
AK
Okay
and
then
I
later
figured
out.
That's
because
we
do
our
work
like
this.
Okay,
so
posture
can
cause
a
series
of
health
problems,
including
the
muscle
problems.
The
second
problem
is
the
forward
head.
Okay,
when
you
have
a
wrong
shoulder
and
the
screen
is
in
front
of
you,
you
have
a
tendency
to
forward
head.
AK
Good
guess
the:
how
much
does
a
head
weight?
Okay,
15
pounds?
Well,
you
have
a
big
head,
but
okay,
according
to
the
book,
actually
I
never
tried.
My
head
and
weighted
okay
according
to
the
documentation,
is
10
to
12
pounds.
Okay,
but
that
the
reason
that
when
we
look
down
how
come
our
head
don't
drop
on
the
floor,
it's
because
the
muscle
in
the
back
is
pulling
it
back.
AK
Okay,
just
like
fishing
pot,
putting
it
back
the
more
you
bend
down
the
the
more
that
burden
to
those
muscles
are
okay,
they
have
a
actually
they
come
out
with
a
turn.
This
is
a
new
term.
Okay,
it
didn't
This.
This
term
does
not
exist
50
years
ago
called
text
neck.
Okay,
when
you
example
that
when
you
do
a
text,
your
nickel
45
degree,
which
is
common
right,
we
do
all
do
that.
Your
head
to
the
to
the
muscle,
the
stress
is
49
pounds,
which
is
about
half
of
my
body
weight.