►
Description
Minneapolis Local Board of Appeal and Equalization Meeting
https://lims.minneapolismn.gov/
A
C
Morning,
welcome
to
this
live
broadcast
of
our
virtual
meeting.
This
meeting
includes
the
room:
the
remote
participation
of
members
as
authorized
under
minnesota
statutes,
sections
13
d,
dot
0
to
1
due
to
the
declared
local
health
pandemic.
For
the
record,
my
name
is
Neil
Anderson
and
I
am
chair
of
the
local
board
of
Appeal
in
equalization.
I
will
now
call
this
meeting
to
order.
The
open
meeting
law
requires
a
roll
call
vote
to
be
conducted
during
the
virtual
meeting,
and
a
certification
form
will
be
completed
for
each
local
board
meeting.
C
E
C
C
The
record
reflect
a
quorum
of
the
board
is
present.
We
will
proceed
to
the
agenda
copy,
which
was
posted
for
public
access
to
the
city's
legislative
information
management
system,
which
is
available
at
Li
m
dot,
minneapolis
MN,
gov
members.
The
agenda
is
before
you
for
your
consideration.
May
I
have
a
motion
to
adopt
the
agenda.
G
H
C
Motion
passes
and
the
agenda
as
printed
is
adopted.
We
have
nine
appeals
scheduled
from
9:00
a.m.
to
10:00
a.m.
we
will
proceed
in
case
order,
as
listed
on
the
agenda
when
your
case
is
called,
the
applicant
will
be
given
five
minutes
to
present
the
appeal
the
board
will
consider
and
take
action
after
hearing
these
cases
if
time
allows,
or
at
the
end
of
the
day
after
hearing
all
cases,
if
your
phone
is
muted,
plus
press
star,
six
to
unmute
property
owners
will
be
notified
of
the
final
decision
by
mail
after
the
board
has
adjourned.
C
J
Can
you
hear
me
it's
Harry
greenberg?
Yes,.
J
J
Thank
you,
no
I
I,
you
know
Phillips
Midtown
Phillips
and
what
I
wanted
to,
let
you
know
is
that
you
know
the
property
taxes
have
gone
up
in
2019.
They
were
I
believe
it
was
a
successful
one.
Eighty
seven
and
twenty
twenty
to
twenty
and
it's
gone
up.
Another
$50,000
from
two
twenty
two
to
twenty
one,
which
I
think
is
completely
unrealistic.
J
I
did
some
research
on
three
properties:
twenty
twenty-five,
seventeen,
sixteen
and
twenty
nine,
oh
nine,
thirteen
and
twenty
seven,
seventeen
twelve,
so
so
25
seventeen
sixteen
sold
for
one
hundred
and
ninety
four
thousand
dollars-
and
these
are
all
they
all
sold
I.
Think
in
the
fall.
It
was
seventeen
hundred
and
eighty
four
square
feet,
so
that
was
quite
a
bit
larger
than
and
then
then
my
house,
which
is
actually
1800
actually
so
that
was
I,
just
multiplied
that
times
one
hundred
nine,
okay,
1808.
J
J
2027
seventeen
12th
Avenue
South,
and
that
was
twenty
two
thousand
and
twenty
three
square
feet
it
sold
for
two
hundred
and
thirty
five
thousand
dollars
it
sold
in
November
of
twenty
nineteen.
So
very
recently,
when
I,
when
I
reversed
that
math
I
got
one
hundred
and
sixteen
per
square
foot
I
multiply
that
by
the
square
footage
of
my
property,
which
is
1808,
that
would
be
two
hundred
and
ten
thousand
dollars.
J
There
was
another
property,
I
believe
and,
and
that
was
lower,
that
was
3205,
3205,
18th,
Avenue
South
and
that
sold
for
two
hundred
and
five
thousand
dollars,
and
that
was
2136
square
feet.
So
that
was
quite
a
bit
larger
than
my
house
and
that
that
equaled
$96
per
square
foot-
and
that
would
put
my
house
at
one
hundred
and
seventy
three
thousand
dollars
in
all
cases.
J
Twenty-One
is
completely
unrealistic,
given
given
the
data
that
I
just
gave
you
and
that
the
houses
I
could
find
that
sold
within
my
immediate
neighborhood,
all
of
which
are
duplexes
and
all
of
which
are,
you
know,
I
think
in
somewhat
somewhat
similar
condition
when
I
bought
the
house
way
back
in
2011
I
did
I
did
spend
a
lot
of
money
remodeling
it,
but
it
hasn't
been
remodeled
since
been
so.
So
that's
all
nine
years
ago,
I
don't
know
where
my
five
minutes
are.
Does
anybody
have
any
questions
just
making
sense
for
the
board.
J
All
the
properties
I
gave
you
or
also
duplexes,
so
the
only
difference
and
I
looked
for
it.
I
look
for
duplexes
and
garages.
You
know
I
look
for
duplexes
in
town,
which
is
where
the
house
is
located.
I,
look
for
duplexes,
that's
sold,
you
know
within
the
last
three
or
four
months,
so
I
I,
just
don't
know
where
you
know
you
know
and
and
of
course,
I
know.
This
was
done
at
the
end
of
the
year
way
before
this
crisis
that
we're
sitting
than
right
now
happened.
But
I.
Imagine
that
you
know
I.
C
H
C
K
This
is
Joe
Kristoff
for
8:41
LenDale
evidence
off.
Can
everyone
hear
me?
Yes,
we
can.
Thank
you
all
right.
Thank
you
good
morning.
So
the
estimated
market
value
of
my
property
for
2021
is
481
thousand
dollars.
I
had
an
appraisal
on
the
property
from
JCM
appraisals,
on
January,
27th
2020
and
the
property
appraisal
came
back
at
four
hundred
and
fifty
nine
thousand
dollars
of
note.
This
appraisal
did
include
improvements
to
the
basement
from
2017
and
2018.
K
F
K
F
C
Seeing
none
I
think.
Thank
you
for
your
time,
sir.
Will
it
notify
even
by
writing?
Thank
you
item
number.
Five.
Three:
zero.
Two
four
Fremont
Avenue
South
case
number:
two
0bh:
zero,
zero.
Seven
six.
The
applicant
is
a
representative
of
Fremont
three
zero.
Two
four
LLC,
please
state
your
name
and
address
for
the
record
and
then
present
your
appeal
to
the
board.
You'll
have
five
minutes.
L
My
name
is
Jerry
younger
and
again
I'm
at
owner
at
thirty
twenty
four
Fremont
Avenue
South
Minneapolis
and
I'm
I'm,
a
Vietnam
era
veteran,
not
a
spring
chicken
I'm
75
will
be
this
July
and
so
I
found
it
challenging
keeping
up
with
the
tech
even
to
the
technology.
To
do
this
appeal,
I
think
I
have
about
fifty
nine
hundred
unanswered
emails
on
my
phone
and
I'm,
not
sure
how
you
keep
up
with
with
those
and
I
looked
at
that
year.
L
That
you're
doing
with
the
appeals
and-
and
these
think
and
I
appreciate,
I
appreciate
the
time
and
that
happens
to
actually
appear
and
we're
still
able
to
get
this
done
regardless
of
the
kovaydin
inaccessible
things
we've
all
experienced,
but
I've
needed
help
getting
us
done,
which
leaves
me
a
little
bit
to
the
pictures
that
I
expect
that
you've
received.
They
were
like
ten
pictures
that
I
sent
along
with
a
letter
I
addressed
to
Matthew
bye-bye
who's,
my
Assessor
from
my
area
in
Minneapolis.
So
do
you
have
that
letter
and
the
pitch
is
accessible
at
all?
L
C
L
Okay,
thank
you
and
I
just
wanted
to
add
that,
like
the
the
basement
of
that
house
on-
and
this
is
a
much
smaller
house-
but
the
basement
vent
house
is
much
worse
condition
and
what
the
pictures
can
show
I
mean
no
lighting
was
poor.
The
residents
stuff
you
know
had
been
in
in
the
way
and
I
had
to
rely
on
someone
else
to
to
take
the
pictures.
L
It's
it's
not
wash,
but
it's
poured
concrete
that
has
crumbled
and
deteriorated
so
badly.
The
basement
has
always
damp
in
the
spring
of
the
summer.
It's
always
been
that
way,
and
you
know
that
wall
should
have
like
me
ride
it
maybe
build
into
the
cement
and
then
new
new
cement
poured,
but
any
a
new
buyer
coming
in
and
I
was
going
to
see
the
definite
need
to
the
foundation.
L
The
electric
wiring
in
this
home
is
from
1960s
I've
got
the
double
hung
windows
from
when
the
house
was
built.
The
chimney
needs
a
lot
of
work.
There
are
a
lot
of
spaces
up
there,
where
the
mortar
should
be
it's
gotten,
a
detached
garage
with
the
old
swing
bar
barn
doors
on
them.
So
this
is
an
older
house
for
sure
and
not
been
updated.
Like
many
others
in
the
area.
L
There
is
a
mistake,
I
think
the
fifth
paragraph,
or
it
says
that
there
was
an
increase
of
50
24
percent
and
that
should
say
from
2016
to
2018,
and
then
there
was
a
45
thousand
dollar
increase
in
1718
and
also
then
I
did
do
some
comparisons,
but
I
found
on
Zillow
and
added
those
to
the
to
the
to
the
sheets.
I
think
that's
all
I
have
what
and
I'm
fitting
shoots.
My
presentation,
okay,.
L
It's
got
one
and
a
half
bathrooms
and
it's
it's
a
three-bedroom,
but
I
did
make
it
into
our
fourth
upstairs
sorta,
but
it's
very
it's
very
narrow
kind
of
squeezed
in
there.
I'd
include
a
picture
of
one
where
it's
got
the
bed.
You
can
see
that
the
bed
fills
the
whole
room.
So
it's
a
very
narrow
force.
L
C
L
C
C
M
N
C
I
O
I
C
F
H
Sorry
I
didn't
find
mr.
Greenberg's
house
very
helpful.
There
were
a
number
that
he
mentioned
in
his
call
that
weren't
in
his
written
material,
and
he
did
include
in
his
written
material
one
that
had
sold
and
he
did
acknowledge
that
it
wasn't
a
duplex.
So
the
information
given
isn't
particularly
helpful,
I
I
will
agree
with
them
board.
Member
havoc
that
not
having
a
garage.
It
was
definitely
a
drawback
and
might
consider
a
slight
reduction
based
on
that.
I
I
P
C
H
E
C
F
C
H
E
C
H
It's
pretty
clear:
there's
been
some
deferred
maintenance.
What
the
basement
being
poured
concrete.
My
question
about
that
without
being
able
to
know
anymore,
is
that
really
the
foundation
deteriorating
or
is
it
simply
some
spalling
which
we
find
with
properties
with
poured
concrete?
So
whether
or
not
that's
an
actual
problem,
he
did.
He
didn't
indicate
that
the
basement
is
wet
all
the
time
or
every
year
or
something
and,
as
we
know,
that's
usually
90
plus
percent
of
the
time-
that's
gutters
and
negative
drainage.
So
that,
however,
does
affect
the
value
of
the
property.
I
F
E
I
F
H
H
C
Okay,
item
number:
six:
the
caller
is
now
in
the
lobby,
so
we
will
hear
from
him.
Let
me
pull
it
up
here.
The
applicant
item
number
six
740
Portland
Avenue
ETP
519
case
number:
two
0bh
zero,
zero,
seven,
seven,
the
applicant
does
David
helper,
please
state
your
name
and
address
for
the
record
and
then
present
your
appeal
to
the
board:
go
ahead.
Mr.
Alper
press
star:
six:
have
you
been
music.
R
We're
disputing
the
amount
of
tax
increase
on
our
unit
in
2019.
The
taxes
were:
thirteen
thousand
thirty
three
dollars
and
53
cents
2020.
There
were
twenty
thousand
eighty
seven
dollars
and
eighty
two
cents
this
year
showing
twenty
two
thousand
is
the
appraised
value
it
keeps
going
up
and
it
we
don't
understand
why
such
a
I
mean
it's
a
like
a
sixty.
Seventy
percent
increase.
Q
C
R
H
H
I'm
sure
you
did
but
it
makes,
but
we
don't
have
that
information.
You
refer
to
the
amount
of
taxes
we
are
concerned
with
the
value,
not
the
taxes.
If
this
this
board
is
concerned
with
the
value.
C
C
Me
if
someone
from
the
assessor's
office
could
explain
to
miss
Benson
mr.
helper,
how
they
can
further
appeal
this
properly.
Yet
this
year.
R
S
Anderson
this
is
Rebecca
and
if
it
was
the
intention
of
the
property
owner
to
file
an
appeal
on
their
condo
unit,
instead
of
their
garage
stove,
we
can
revise
that
property
ID
number
to
reflect
the
condominium
unit.
It's
when
they
submitted
the
hearing
signup
form
the
accidentally
must
have
included
the
property
ID
number
for
the
garage
stall
instead,
so
we
can
make
that
correction
and
then
they
should
contact
Hennepin
County
to
sign
up
for
a
county
appeal
and
we
can
continue
to
work
with
them
on
their
appeal.
Okay,.
I
C
T
Q
I
C
C
C
E
C
N
H
I
C
F
I
C
H
H
E
C
C
F
E
C
D
H
F
C
U
C
S
S
This
is
also
the
same
representative
of
a
property
that
we
discussed
yesterday.
That's
an
the
addendum
for
today's
agenda.
20
BH,
zero,
zero,
six,
four
and
if
you
recall
from
yesterday,
I
had
we
had
not
submitted
to
call
an
information
to
her,
so
she
wasn't
able
to
call
in
so
I
contacted
her
yesterday
and
she
wasn't
able
to
attend
today.
So
she
just
asked
that
you
consider
what
she
had
already
provided.
You
I.
S
S
S
C
H
C
H
H
F
N
U
I
C
I
I
H
I
F
C
C
C
C
H
C
H
I
C
C
Excuse
me:
we
need
to
have
you
pause
for
a
bit
here.
Well,
while
we
get
to
you
before
we
get
to
your
case.
E
E
I
I
C
For
item
number
14
43,
just
to
recap,
when
your
case
is
called
the
applicant,
will
be
given
five
minutes
to
present
the
appeal
the
board
will
consider
and
take
action
after
these
cases
if
time
allows
or
at
the
end
of
the
day
after
hearing
all
of
the
cases,
if
your
phone
is
muted
press
star,
six
to
unmute
and
property
owners
will
be
notified
of
our
decision
by
mail.
After
the
board
has
adjourned,
we
will
go
to
item
number
14,
43
44
Colfax
out
in
the
South
case,
number
two
0bh
dash
zero,
zero.
C
V
My
name
is
Marin
genderly
and
I
live
at
43
44
Colfax,
Avenue,
South
I
have
owned
and
maintained
43-44
called
taxin
Avenue
since
1974,
in
addition
to
promptly
paying
property
taxes,
I've
also
paid
for
sidewalk
street
maintenance
and
other
levies
from
the
city.
I
have
not
upgraded
kitchen
bathrooms
and
are
built
at
garage.
I
have
no
pension.
V
C
C
A
Good
morning
my
name
is
Joshua
Campos
I'm,
the
owner
of
2228
Seabury
Avenue
I,
purchased
the
property
last
year
on
May
29,
2009
teen
I'm.
During
that
time,
I
had
the
provided
documents
as
part
of
the
appeal
and
appraisal,
the
property
which
was
performed
when
I
purchased
the
property,
the
purchased
actual
purchase
agreement
showing
the
purchase
price,
estimated
value
of
the
home
using
a
home
value
mining
mine
monitoring
service
from
USA.
A
So
the
appraisal
was
dated:
April
2015,
/,
sorry,
April,
15,
2009
teen
was
performed
by
John
Marquis
Oh
of
service
Lincoln
st.
Paul,
the
appraisal
listed
the
asking
price
of
one
hundred
and
ninety
nine
thousand
nine
hundred,
but
the
actual
asking
price
at
the
time
was
one
hundred
and
eighty
four
thousand
I
just
wanted
to
note
that
I
did
purchase
the
property
for
four
hundred
and
eighty
thousand
and
closed
on
the
property
may
29th
of
last
year.
A
A
R
A
A
H
A
Did
they
they
did
that
they
got
his
entire
kitchen.
I'll
say
that
they
gutted
the
entire
kitchen.
They
did
some
spray
foam
insulation
on
the
entire
back
wall
and
it
was
done
by
the
contractor.
It
was
professionally
done,
but
it
it
was
dated
I
would
say
most
of
the
finishes
were
catered.
Some
of
the
timing
was
dated,
but
it
was
professionally
done.
A
C
C
A
The
there
I
would
say,
there's
really
some
old
carpet
down
there,
that
I
I'm
tearing
out
as
we
speak.
My
truck
is
loaded
with
so
I'm
trying
to
get
all
that
out
and
take
it
to
the
to
the
transportation
today,
so
I
would
say
no
the
basement
is
finished.
There's
some
tile.
The
laundry
down
there
is
there's.
Okay,
it's
still
kind
of
grimy.
The
walls
are
not
finished,
it's
just
bare
and
painted
you
know
so.
Water
doesn't
get
in.
A
C
C
T
T
I
hope
everybody
has
it
in
front
of
you,
so
the
first
page
shows
an
aerial,
the
location
of
the
subject-
property
just
north
of
downtown,
and
it's
in
the
basically
the
train
yard
areas,
kind
of
a
kind
of
rail
traffic.
There
is
a
golf
course
up
to
the
north
east
of
it
and
then
a
lot
of
residential
properties
and
a
spring
along
the
tracks.
There's
a
lot
of
industrial.
So
this
is
this
is
an
industrial
building
and
it's
currently
used
by
company
that
does
like
printing
plates
in
branding
and
things
like
that.
T
So
they
you
know,
produce
plates
that
print
on
boxes
and
they're
they're
kind
of
a
wide
variety
of
services,
but
so
they
have
some
I've
included
a
picture
later.
You
know
in
the
document
that
shows
some
of
a
nicer
office
type
finish
that
they
have.
They
don't
don't
really
finish
the
ceilings
in
there.
T
It
still
looks
kind
of
like
an
industrial
building,
but
on
page
two
it
shows
my
requested
value
at
$70,
a
square
foot
and
so
what
you're?
Looking
at
on
the
aerial
that
I
included,
there
is
the
blue
box
as
the
subject
and
then
the
property
adjacent
to
the
north
sold
in
seven
2017
and
to
the
south
sold
in
2018.
And
if
you
flip
it
a
third
page,
and
this
pretty
much
tells
the
story
of
my
request.
T
You'll
see
the
subject
property
in
the
middle
of
the
page
and
then
the
some
information
on
the
property
adjacent
to
the
north
above
it
and
below
it.
Adjacent
to
the
south.
Those
details
I've
put
a
red
along
the
current
2020
values
that
the
Assessor
has
put
on.
So
the
subject
has
been
placed
at
101
dollars.
This
clerk
put
the
one
just
to
the
north
of
60,
almost
64
bucks,
this
court
foot
and
then
the
one
just
south
of
it
Jason
it
right.
A
T
$60,
a
square
foot
I'm
requesting
$70
a
square
foot
I
think
ours
is
a
little
better
than
those
I
mean
if
you
look
at
them
on
the
outside.
They
all
look
kind
of
yes,
similar
age,
they're
all
from
the
80s,
and
they
don't
look
industrial
then
those
two
also
sold
so
I
included
the
sale
prices
in
there
per
square
foot
and
at
the
top
line
of
each
of
those
sections.
T
The
fourth
page
shows
it's
all
driven
through
your
photos.
To
give
you
an
idea
of
what
the
nicer
office
area
looks
like
and
then
the
last
part
of
it
I'm
not
going
to
go
through
these,
but
I
did
provide
a
search
through
costar,
and
these
are
searched
on
industrial
flex
buildings,
which
is
what
our
I
believe.
Our
category
falls
in
so
flex
building
gives
you
more
office
space
many
times
there
are
multi
units
and
they
rent
them
out.
So
they
have
some
office
space
in
front.
Maybe
a
shop
in
the
back
like
a
carpet.
T
Cleaning
company
might
be
in
there
or
you
know
just
any
type
of
a
service
operation,
so
those
sales.
And
if
you
look
at
the
map
and
they're
just
kind
of
sprinkled
all
over
many
apples,
they
don't
sell
real
great.
The
very
high
end
of
the
range
is
70
107
and
I
was
you
know
the
one
right
close
to
us
so
anyway,
the
average
on
that
was
48
dollars,
a
square
foot
I'm
not
asking
for
that.
I
think
we're
in
good
shape.
T
C
T
C
B
And
we
believe
we
can
appeal
the
current
property
taxes
for
2020
because
of
the
current
condition
of
the
property
that
needs
some
repairs
inside
and
out
and
remodeling.
In
the
entire
house,
we
submitted
the
photos
showing
the
current
condition
of
the
property
to
the
vault
and
the
closing
documents
showing
the
amount
we
paid
for
the
house.
C
B
C
C
C
F
H
Looking
at
the
what
she
submitted,
she
claims
in
writing
that
similar
houses
near
buyers
selling
for
two
hundred
ten
thousand
I
would
buy
them
for
two
hundred
ten
thousand
all
day
in
that
neighborhood
I'm
thinking
that
whatever
analysis
was
done
included
condos,
there
have
been
some
buildings
in
the
area
that
have
been
converted
to
condominiums
in
for
plexes.
I
actually
grew
up
in
one
of
them,
so
I
know
this
neighborhood
very,
very
well.
I
F
H
F
F
U
C
I
C
C
H
Yeah,
we're
I
believe
six
cups.
Four
of
them
were
very
good.
There
were
two
that
we're
really
the
four
were
right
along
the
river.
Not
you
know
probably
had
river
views.
The
others
too
were
several
blocks
away.
I
would
come
them
is
not
very
good.
Comps
also
I
was
interested
in
the
fact
that
the
appraiser
referred
to
all
those
comes
as
bungalows.
Look
at
the
pictures
there,
those
aren't
bungalows
the
people,
buyers
who
want
that
bungalow
aren't
even
going
to
consider
something.
It
doesn't
look
like
a
bungalow,
no
matter
what
you
call
it.
H
H
C
H
Miss
her
I
thought
he
said
he
installed
white
cabinets,
okay,.
C
C
D
C
H
C
C
C
H
H
Sold
one
not
too
far
from
there
a
few
years
ago,
that
was
a
really
bad
shape
had
been
terribly
abused
and
I
know.
My
mine
fires
got
it
for
a
little
good
price,
but
that
price
was-
and
this
was
a
few
years
ago
now-
139,000
mm,
which
they
ended
up
selling
just
a
few
months
ago
for
300,000
with
a
lot
of
fix-up.
F
I
H
C
H
C
C
C
C
H
C
H
H
H
I
C
S
C
S
I
S
P
C
You
I
do
not
have
a
script
for
this
afternoon,
yet
so
we'll
wing
it
case,
number
two
0bh
zero,
one:
four,
nine
five,
six,
four
four
Thomas
Avenue
South
and.
I
C
C
C
F
I
E
C
D
Q
F
C
H
H
H
H
D
H
C
F
It
looks
to
me
like
on
this
case:
there
is
no
--ss
any
data
to
make
a
change.
Just
divert
maintenance
photos
and
the
market
value
is
the
same
as
nineteen,
so
I
would
put
a
motion
forward
to
sustain
the
value
of
710
Jackson
the
street
at
two
hundred.
Eighty
four
thousand,
thank
you.
Is
there
a
second.
D
C
C
E
I
F
P
F
E
E
P
C
H
H
H
H
H
C
H
C
C
H
I
C
I
H
I
C
C
D
H
K
U
F
E
L
C
C
H
H
C
A
I
B
A
It
stands
on
our
block.
There
is
an
abandoned
church
in
school,
which
obviously
does
not
add,
curb
appeal
to
our
block,
but
the
nearest
large
street
Lowry,
just
south
of
us,
has
extremely
poor
pedestrian
access
and
is
has
up
until
coronavirus
has
been
extremely
busy
and,
quite
honestly,
not
safe
for
pedestrians,
and
the
nearest
park
from
our
house
is
a
little
over
four
blocks
away,
which
is
about
as
far
as
you
can
get
away
from
a
park
in
Hearne.
A
True
I've
listed
out
several
current
issues
with
the
house
which
affect
the
value
in
my
eyes
and
provided
a
series
of
comps
and
the
one
note
I
wanted
to
add
about
the
comps.
Is
that
slide
6
the
houses
which
were
bought
around
March
of
18
just
thought.
Those
were
notable
because
my
wife
and
I
had
placed
offers
on
those
prior
to
actually
purchasing
that
25:34
Taylor
Street
house.
So
it
just
seemed
notable
to
me
that
those
houses
have
not
appreciated
in
the
eyes
of
the
city
of
Minneapolis.
A
C
C
Looking
on
the
agenda,
the
applicant
for
item
22
is
not
present.
We
will
go
on
to
item
number
23,
23:44
River
points
circle
case
number,
2,
0,
B,
H,
2,
0,
1,
0,
the
applicant
is
Susan
a
whiskey
or
bixi.
Please
state
your
name
and
address
for
the
record
and
present
your
appeal
to
the
bar.
You'll
have
five
minutes.
Yes,.
C
N
N
Thank
you
for
taking
the
call.
Our
valuation
appeal
is
based
upon
the
recent
sale
of
properties
and
our
townhome
development.
Our
address
is
located
within
the
Riverview
townhomes
development.
In
the
Hawthorne
neighborhood
two
blocks
north
of
Broadway.
There
are
29
townhomes
13
for
level
and
16
3
level.
Our
home
has
three
levels:
two
bedrooms,
one
full
bath,
one
3/4
bath
and
two
half
baths.
The
addresses
in
the
complex
are
River
Point
circle
and
River
Point
Lane.
N
What
I
originally
attached
were
three
recent
homes
and
our
development
that
are
the
size
of
our
home,
which
is
approximately
2,200
square
feet
that
have
either
recently
sold
or
our
for
sale.
For
example,
23:36
River
Point
Circle
sold
September
18
2019
for
277,000
23:15,
River,
Point
Lane,
so
is
for
sale
for
three
hundred
and
sixty
three
thousand
nine
hundred
and
twenty
three
twenty
three
River
Point
Lane
sold
March
5th
2020,
three
67,000
all
these
homes.
If
I
didn't
mention
before
our
three-bedroom.
N
N
Q
N
G
N
Quite
noisy
yeah,
we
feel
that,
due
to
the
recent
sales
of
properties
that
have
more
bedrooms
than
we
do
and
two
of
them
that
are
have
a
better
location,
that
our
value
is
not
the
four
hundred
and
five
thousand
that
was
sent
or
that
was
going
to
be
assessed
next
year.
And
so
we
ask
for
your
consideration.
N
I
C
C
Item
number
excuse
me:
can
I
get
some
clarification
on
from
Rebecca
or
Jackie
as
to
which
which
property
is
next
in
the
queue.
O
I
C
W
Thank
you
very
much.
My
name
is
Brad
Marcel
I
manage
the
property
at
1920,
Franklin
Avenue
southeast
I've
gone
back
and
looked
at
the
valuation
on
the
property.
For
the
last
five
years
in
2015,
the
property
was
valued
at
385
in
2016,
the
valuation
went
to
459
in
2017.
The
property
valuation
did
stay
the
same.
However,
in
2018
it
went
to
495
five
in
2019.
It
went
to
525
and
now
in
2020
it
has
been
valued
at
614.
W
W
We
keep
the
property
in
a
well
maintained.
State
we've
always
tried
to
keep
the
rents
reasonable,
provide
quality,
affordable
housing
for
our
tenants.
Our
tenants
are
mostly
students
at
the
University
of
Minnesota
or
recent
graduates.
Our
monthly
rent
we've
had
to
adjust
it
to
980
you
put
on
utilities
to
that
price,
along
with
food,
clothing
and
entertainment
for
our
tenants,
and
you
come
out
with
a
cost
of
about
one
thousand
three
hundred
eighty
dollars
per
month
for
tenants.
W
We
believe
that
the
valuation
of
the
property
and
is
not
accurate,
and
it's
really
going
to
raise
the
rents
beyond
what
our
tenants
can
afford.
At
this
point,
we
feel
that
this
building
is
really
a
working
antique,
it's
well
over
a
hundred
years
old.
The
property
is
in
need
of
capital
improvements
that
we're
addressing.
We
will
have
to
put
in
new
kitchens
new
bathrooms
update
electrical.
The
front
porches
are
going
to
be
addressed
this
year.
W
C
H
C
C
C
O
C
O
I
I
X
So
I
think
my
first
piece
is
that
I'm
actually
quite
close
to
my
neighbors
on
Franklin
Terrace,
as
well
as
the
street
behind
it
on
30th,
and
it
seems
that
possibly
at
least
six
with
my
neighbors
have
had
significant
granted
relief
from
the
proposed
text
for
2020
and
they
sort
of-
let
me
know
this-
that
maybe
in
general
there's
been
some
over
evaluation
of
these
two
streets.
X
Nine,
five
and
just
alone
in
my
wet
basement,
I
have
over
$40,000
worth
of
work
to
do,
and
that
being
said,
speaking
of
the
first
date,
I
mean
I
have
been
a
homeowner
in
Minneapolis
for
over
thirty
four
years
and
I
am
getting
finally
to
appoint.
My
life
for
I
can
maybe
invest
in
this
home,
but
if
the
taxes
continue
to
go
up,
it's
going
to
become
harder
and
harder
to
afford.
X
But
if
someone
comes
to
see
a
house
I'm
going
to
try
to
sell
it
and
there's
several
cars
parked
out
front,
you
know
selling,
marijuana
or
obviously
smoking
marijuana.
That's
going
to
deter
people
from
buying
a
house
that
literally
evaluated
at
five
hundred
thousand
there's
also
quite
a
bit
of
noise
because
were
two
houses
in
from
ninety
four
freeway.
X
Most
of
my
neighbors
have
said
that
they've
gotten
at
least,
and
it's
a
mix
of
properties.
It's
all
different
types
of
prostitutes
that
almost
everyone
is
button
somewhere
between
thirty
thousand
and
fifty
five
thousand
granted
relief,
and
so
at
that
point,
I
thought
it
might
be
appropriate
to
address
this
issue.
If
nothing
else,
to
sort
of
maintain
some
ability
to
continue
to
repair
the
home.
X
X
Well,
I
didn't
I
mean
I,
can
itemize
sort
of
concerns
with
the
home
itself,
I
mean,
obviously,
if
the
house,
that
has
the
updated
kitchen
and
the
updated
roof
and
the
professional
paint
job
and
the
brand
new
garage
and
professional
landscaping,
a
professional
fence
and
new
wood-burning
stove
is
being
sold
at
5:40
and
my
home
that
needs
that
is,
has
a
wet
basement
with
dirt.
On
the
third
floor,
I
have
to
use
space
heaters,
there's
no
electric
is
broken
up
there.
X
X
Want
to
say,
13
or
14
via
Craigslist
I
got
new
cabinets
and
counters
for
the
downstairs
kitchen
and
then
new
appliances,
but
that
was
also
six
years
ago.
So
you
know
I
think
it's.
The
home
just
needs
a
lot
of
work
and
I,
don't
actually
know
if
you
could
tell
it
the
way.
The
basement
is
right
now
if
the
basement
needs
to
be
sump
pumps
and
then
areas
of
it
needs
to
be
cemented,
so
you
know
and
pointed
and
such
I'm
not
I'm,
not
a
professional
basement,
fixer,
so
I
don't
know
exactly
the
terminology.
X
So
I
guess
you
know
the
combination
of
maybe
a
possible
over
evaluation
of
the
neighborhood.
Those
are
my
neighbors
reports
on
the
concerns
for
some
petty
crime.
Don't
do
to
it
kitty,
didn't
area,
you
know,
sort
of
defeating
the
value.
The
most
expensive
nice
as
health
on
the
block
is
only
being
his
only
you
know,
I
just
want
like
a
$40,000
difference
and
I.
Don't
even
think
for
the
answer.
I've
gotten
my
base,
yeah.
X
X
H
X
H
X
No,
it's
short
space.
My
son
lives
down
there,
we
homestead
the
house
and
we
lived
in
the
entire
home
and
we
had
six
children
there
and
we
still
had
two
of
our
six
children
in
the
home
with
us
on
so
there's
four
of
us
in
the
moment
and
then
one
room
that
we
imminently
use
on
Airbnb.
So
if
we've
lived
in
the
entire
house,
we
live
in
the
entire
house.
It's
not
separated
out,
as
in
two
you
walk
in
the
front
door
and
there's
one
set
of
stairs.
So
it's
not
like
two
doors.
X
C
C
C
P
Muting,
a
part
of
that
335
second
Street
northeast,
so
looking
at
recent
multifamily
sales
in
the
area,
I
didn't
really
find
any
support
for
the
468
thousand
dollar
valuation.
On
my
home,
the
two
most
expensive
sales
I
found
in
my
zip
code
over
one
five,
four
three
deaf
person,
Street
northeast
four
hundred
twenty
thousand
on
November
5th
in
2019
and
824
fifth
Street,
northeast
and
I-
was
four
hundred
and
fifty
four
thousand
I'm,
not
over
thirty.
First,
both
of
those
zones
appear
to
be
in
excellent
condition,
but
they're
considerably
larger
than
mine.
P
That
1534
Jefferson
comes
out
to
152
dollars
a
square
foot
where,
as
824
fist
comes
out,
161
dollars
per
square
foot,
it
also
has
the
50%
larger
lot
and
a
two-car
garage
based
on
per
square
foot
cancellations.
That
would
put
my
home
at
three
hundred
and
sixteen
thousand
or
three
hundred
and
thirty
five
thousand
for
homes
similar
in
size
to
mine,
which
is
two
thousand
and
eighty
square
feet.
P
U
P
And
then
I
listed
three
properties
that
were
almost
identical
to
my
square-foot
are
the
closest
I
could
find
and
they
range
from
260
mm
at
three
hundred
and
forty
five
thousand,
and
then
you
know
I
of
course
wanted
with
his
Laura
Williams
regarding
this,
and
she
had
mentioned
the
updates
that
were
done
so
I
just
addressed
those
below
and
I
understand.
You
know
the
assessed
value
role
is
following
the
updates,
but
it's
I'm
not
following
why?
P
Many
years
later,
my
assessments
continue
to
my
sentiment:
increases
in
Utah
outpaced,
my
neighboring
properties,
significantly
from
2015
to
2020,
my
assessed
value
rose
by
66%
or
186,000,
while
the
neighboring
property
rose
by
forty
two
point:
five
percent,
or
one
hundred
and
three
thousand
the
house
right
next
to
me
same
build
it's
the
same
house.
Essentially
they
did
add
a
add
a
gable
on
the
back,
and
so
they
do
have
a
little
bit
more
square
footage,
but
other
than
that
the
properties
they're
very
similar.
P
They
have
a
little
larger
lot
in
the
driveway
where,
if
I
haven't
use
meant
to
the
neighbors
to
access
the
driveway
in
the
back
Liz's
a
little
bit
larger.
But
essentially
they're
the
same
houses
and
there's
a
value
that
347,000
finds
at
468
now
and
it
keeps
it
just
keeps
going
up,
whereas
theirs
does
that
going
to
be
rising
at
the
same
rate.
For
some
reason
and.
I
P
Is
a
nice
home,
but
it's
not
really
not
any
different.
Besides
my
siding
than
any
of
the
neighboring
properties,
you
know,
and
they
were
done.
Those
updates
were
done
eight
years
ago,
so
I
mean
I
did
include
some
pictures
where,
where
things
have
not
held
up
real
well
and
there's
some
buckling
of
plaster
drywall
improperly
laid
concrete,
let
us
notice
yesterday
that
this
will
rot
on
the
garage.
The
doors
gonna
have
to
be
replaced.
P
P
I
P
Yeah
I
haven't
I,
haven't
permanently
rented
the
upstairs
I'm
at
permanent
tenants
up
here.
I've
had
to
move
around
quite
a
bit
to
work
over
the
past
few
years,
so
so
I
haven't
wanted
to
I
guess,
remove
the
option
to
return
for
myself
so
so
I
I
have
air
be
indeed
a
twin
when
I've
been
relocated
elsewhere
for
work
and
those
I
guess
you
could
say.
Yes,
it
probably
averages
out
to
about
that.
Some
months
there
better
stuff
month
or
worse.
E
P
C
C
Y
Z
Z
Z
Z
Y
Z
W
J
T
Z
Buildings
in
Uptown
the
values
are
running
between
100
to
120
thousand
a
unit.
Here,
suddenly
we
are
at
183
thousand
dollars
the
unit
with
the
new
pricing.
Even
the
2019
I
was
I.
Wasn't
aware
of
that,
I
feel
that
it's
high
it
to
two
million
879
a
point
from
287
93
311,
that's
over
close
to
$600,000
in
case
in
years
now.
Violette
is
absolutely
not
realistic.
I
I
feel
that
it's
a
mistake
that
somebody
made
an
error.
We
will
not
aware
because
we
would
approach
you
guys
about
it
last
year.
So
that's
for
this
building.
T
V
Z
Those
two
building-
thirty
seven
hundred
and
thirty
708
they
appraised
value-
is
much
higher
than
thirty
four
thirty
six
Lindale.
We
are
walk
able
to
increase
from
34:36
window.
We
are
not
okay,
with
the
increase
of
thirty
seven
hundred
and
thirty,
seven
or
eight
window,
as
they
said,
those
are
the
same
buildings
same
rents,
same
time
of
Units
built
at
the
same
time
by
the
same
builder,
which.
Y
Y
Y
Z
P
C
C
C
C
C
H
I
thought
they
needed
better
information,
their
sales,
comparable
sales
were
from
2017,
2018
and
2020
steal
them,
and
it
looked
to
me
like
they
were
mixing
in
multi-family
homes
and
I.
Think
this
one
is
a
single-family
if
I'm
right,
so
it
was
kind
of
confusing.
Maybe
they
have
a
case,
but
I
don't
know
that
they
presented
information
to
make
it
possible
for
us
to
make
a
determination.
H
H
25:34
Taylor
Street
is
that
right,
yep,
okay,
northeast
at
221,
pardon
me
for
never
mind.
I
got
it
four
hundred
twenty
one
thousand
five
hundred
thank.
C
H
C
H
This
property
is
located
in
Shenandoah
Terrace,
which
tends
to
really
be
popular
and
all
there's
a
small
area.
Homes
in
Shenandoah
Terrace
really
are
in
high
demand.
I
noticed
that
there
was
an
appraisal
that
was
done
a
couple
of
years
ago,
so
that
wasn't
particularly
helpful.
For
today
there
was
a
kitchen
remodel
done
in
2018,
and
some
of
the
I
realized
that
if
there
probably
weren't
a
lot
of
comps
in
Shenandoah
terrace,
because
it's
small,
so
they
went
outside
of
tension
and
or
Terrace,
but
there
was
no
adjustment
made
for
location.
H
I
C
H
C
H
H
C
F
C
H
S
I
C
H
C
H
H
I
C
H
C
H
E
H
H
S
C
C
C
Below
grade
water
intrusion,
and
was
you
know
severely
affecting
foundations,
the
property
ID
list
had
actually
had
when
it
rained
it
had
a
river
running
through
it.
It
would
come
in
one
side
and
go
out
the
other
being
that
this
is
just
two
doors
away.
I
would
imagine
they're
experiencing
something
similar,
so
I
feel
that
that
highway
work
has
detrimental
e
affected,
the
value
of
their
property.
Are
there
any
other
comments
from
other
board
members.
C
H
Well,
I
think
the
proximity
to
94
is
also
an
issue
here.
$4.99
five
does
seem
pretty
high.
To
me,
four
hundred
seems
maybe
low
it's
you
know
going
back
to
2017.
It
was
assessed
that
year
at
382,
five
in
the
following
year,
at
424,
I
think
I'd
be
more
inclined
to
say
525
reduction
instead
of
the
400
of
425.
Okay,.
F
H
H
C
C
I
C
H
C
H
C
C
New
business,
we
have
four
appeals
scheduled
from
12:00
to
12:30,
we'll
proceed
in
case
order,
as
listed
on
the
agenda
when
your
case
is
called,
the
applicant
will
be
given
five
minutes
to
present
their
appeal.
The
board
will
consider
and
take
take
action
after
hearing
these
cases
if
time
allows,
or
at
the
end
of
the
day
after
hearing
all
cases,
if
your
phone
is
muted,
please
press
pound
6
to
unmute
property
owners
will
be
notified
of
our
decision
by
mail
after
the
board
is
adjourned.
Item
number
30,
27
25.
Humble
down
of
excuse
me
mr.
I
O
C
G
My
name
is
Judith,
got
here
or
Gautier,
probably
the
right
way:
800
East,
Minnehaha
Parkway,
my
sister
and
I
bought
this
duplex
in
July
of
18
and
we're
both
living
here.
I'm
retired
she'll
be
retiring.
This
year
it
was
previously
a
rental,
so
we're
doing
kind
of
a
lot
of
maintenance.
Related
issues
like
there
was
bats
and
the
ceiling
and
the
boilers
hadn't
been
maintained.
Those
kind
of
things
other
than
that
there's
been
kind
of
no
major
upgrades
or
remodeling,
and
it
still
looks
like
the
1950s
60s
places
that
were
originally
built.
G
G
We
paid
four
hundred
ninety
five
thousand
in
July
of
eighteen,
and
that
year
it
was
valued
at
515
and
last
year
it
went
up
to
571
and
I.
Wasn't
aware
of
this
appeal
process,
even
though
I
should
read
those
sheets
that
come
out
better
and
so
I
spoke
to
a
gentleman,
Scott
I,
don't
remember
his
last
name
and
he
said
that
I
should
try
to
appeal
this
way,
because
now
it's
gone
up
to
five
five.
Ninety.
K
G
F
G
C
I
C
H
Similar
to
the
other
cases
from
this
particular
applicant,
the
may
well
have
case
we
don't
have
the
necessary
information
to
make
a
determination,
certainly
encourage
them
to
go
on
to
the
county
process
and
and
provide
more
information
there.
So,
based
on
that,
I
would
move
that
we
sustain
the
value
for
701
University
Avenue
southeast
at
1
million
two
hundred
ninety
one
thousand
dollars
for
this
year.
H
E
C
H
C
H
H
I
H
C
H
C
You
item
number
31
appeal
for
34
36,
Lyndale
Avenue
South
case
number,
2
0,
B,
H,
0,
1,
1
4.
Are
there
any
questions
or
discussions
from
board?
Members
related
to
this
property
is
my
understanding
from
our
discussion
with
the
property
owner
that
they
were
ok
with
the
value.
May
I
have
a
motion
please,
but
remember:
bland.
H
C
D
C
H
Well,
unless
I'm
mistaken,
this
is
the
one
that
they
were
comparing
to
the
previous
one
which
they
were
satisfied
with
and
would
like
this
to
be
valued
at
the
same
amount.
These
claim
it's
the
exact
same
building
unless
I'm
mistaken,
but
yes,
based
on
the
information
that
we
have
here,
I
would
vote
to
sustain
or
move
that
we
sustain
the
value
of
3708
Lyndale
Avenue
South
at
1
million
five
hundred
twenty
three
thousand
dollars.
Thank.
I
C
H
C
C
C
F
E
F
C
I
I
C
O
I
S
S
If
we
could
just
go
back
to
that
condominium
garage
case
from
the
nine
o'clock
session,
the
condominium
garage
was
case:
two
0b
h:
zero,
zero,
seven,
seven,
seven,
forty
Portland
Avenue
parking
stall,
five,
one
nine,
it
was
David
helper
and
he
had
and
meant
to
file
on
his
condominium
unit.
So
we
would
like
to
add
a
case
for
that.
So
we
would
like
you
to
add
case
to
zero
B
H
zero.
S
C
O
H
Rebecca
provided
us
with
an
item
number
she's,
adding
for
the
unit,
but
she
doesn't
have
a
unit
number.
The.
H
H
C
C
C
U
C
H
H
C
C
C
I
see
a
number
repairs
are
needed
on
the
property.
I
have
reviewed
several
other
comps
that
he
provided
for
a
market
that
they
have
done
on
another
property,
so
I'm
familiar
with
the
comparables,
even
though
he
hasn't
provided
extensive
information
on
them.
I
would
tend
to
agree
that
the
property
valuation
is
high
given,
given
the
condition.
F
H
H
H
C
H
E
D
H
I
C
H
H
C
C
C
Just
of
note,
the
property
was
purchased
in
on
February
18th
2024,
six
hundred
thousand
dollars
their
appraisal
that
the
applicant
has
provided
was
at
six
hundred
and
five
thousand
dollars.
It
is
currently
assessed
in
the
twenty
twenty
year
at
$722,000.
Are
there
any
other
comments
or
questions
from
board
members.