►
From YouTube: April 26, 2022 Local Board of Appeal and Equalization
Description
Additional information at:
https://lims.minneapolismn.gov
B
B
B
B
B
B
C
C
B
B
First,
we
will
call
on
the
appellant
who
will
be
given
five
minutes
to
present
the
appeal
when
your
case
is
called,
you
will
need
to
press
star
6
on
your
phone
to
activate
your
microphone
and
wait
to
hear
the
pre-recorded
message
before
speaking.
We
ask
that
you
state
your
name
and
address
for
the
record
and
then
present
your
appeal
to
the
board.
Next,
the
board
will
have
five
minutes
for
questions.
The
board
will
consider
and
take
action
at
the
end
of
each
hourly
grouping.
B
The
appeal
application
for
2943
randolph
street
northeast
case
number
22-0522,
the
applicant
is
robert
bartlett.
Is
mr
bartlett
going
to
be
joining
us.
We
have
phone
miss.
D
Madam
chair,
the
applicant,
is
on
the
line,
please
press
star,
six
to
unmute
your
phone
and
you
will
have
five
minutes
to
present
to
the
board.
E
Oh
sorry
about
that,
I
had
audio
issues
good
morning,
everyone-
I
am
robert
bartlett,
I'm
robert
bartlett,
the
property
owner
of
2943
randolph
street.
I
am
appealing
my
estimated
market
value
of
this
property.
E
I
the
assessment
here
for
six
462
000..
I
believe
this
is
an
overestimation
of
the
value
of
this
property.
I
looking
through
the
data.
I
believe
there
is
maybe
an
overestimated
overestimation
of
the
new
improvement
value
which,
according
to
the
letter,
I
received
put
it
down
as
eighty
thousand
dollars
of
new
improvements.
E
I
did
include
an
excel
spreadsheet,
sorry
for
those
who
reviewed
it
of
what
I
believe,
the
value
to
be
based
off
of
property
sales
values
of
my
neighborhood
of
duplexes
between
october
1st
2020
and
september
30th,
2021,
and
extrapolated
that
data
into
2023
and
from
that
with
the
combination
of
the
cost
of
improvements
of
roughly
32
000,
I've
estimated
the
value
to
be
approximately
405
thousand
and
generally.
I
believe
that
to
be
proper
estimate
of
what
I
could
potentially
sell
the
property
for,
if
I
were
to
sell
it
within
the
next
year.
F
F
G
Yes,
this
is
board
member
palmer.
What
was
the
scope
of
the
work
done?
The
assessor
added
eighty
thousand
dollars
for
what
was
what
did
that
all
entail.
E
Yes,
on
the
second
floor,
the
second
unit
of
the
property
there
was
there
was
a
substantial
rework,
but
most
of
the
work
was
primarily
due
to
a
replacement
of
a
boiler
and
electrical
rework.
So
it
was
bringing
the
electrical
off
the
code
replacing
a
boiler
with
a
hvac
forced
air
system
and
central
air,
and
the
remaining
work
was
mostly
just
refinishing
floors
and
essentially
replacing
dilapidated
walls.
B
Okay,
thank
you,
mr
bartlett.
We
will
make
our
decision
and
let
you
know
by
mail.
B
H
Here,
blandon
board
members,
we
did
hear
from
the
appellant
and
he
notified
us
in
his
words
that
he
is
going
to
let
the
case
go.
So
yes,
in
from
our
perspective,
yes,
we'll
just
at
the
end,
take
action
to
sustain
the
value
that
will
preserve
his
right
to
appeal
further.
If
he
wishes.
B
H
B
We
have
three
properties
under
this
with
this
appellant.
The
second
one
is
43510
morgan
avenue
north
case
number,
22-0525.
B
Deal
application
for
4139
bryant
avenue
north
case
number
to
220526
the
applicant
is
james.
Dr
dreiling
is
mr
darling
on
the
phone.
B
D
H
B
These
are
parking
spaces
right.
That
is
correct.
G
I
have
a
question
for
the
assessor.
You
mentioned
one
of
our
earlier
sessions
that
you
were
talking
to
the
one
of
these
buildings
about
all
the
spaces
is
that
this
building
seems
to
be
a
familiar
address,
or
was
it
some
other
building.
H
H
B
B
Next,
we
have
appeal
for
2809
buchanan
street
northeast
case
number,
two,
two:
zero
five,
three
zero.
The
applicant
is
hiroyuki.
B
D
I
Hi,
my
name
is
anthony
kong
and
I'm
the
owner
of
these
two
properties.
It's
a
condominium
and
a
garage
space.
I
Let
you
know
that
I
I
sent
I
sent
a
spreadsheet
that
summarized
the
documents
that
I
that
I
sent
over.
I
don't
know
if,
if
you
receive
that,
because
I
really
only
put
the
spreadsheet
together
last
night,
but
the
documents
I
pulled
basically
stated
showed,
in
my
opinion,
that
the
value
of
the
condominium
sales
doesn't
support
the
value.
That's
on
the
assessment.
I
The
assessments
don't
seem
to
take
into
account
that
there's
a
separate
value
for
the
garages,
so
when
a
comp,
a
comparable
sale
sold,
say
459
000.
That
includes
the
garage
space,
so
I'm
asserting
that
my
property,
if
I
was
to
sell
it
today,
would
sell
for
159
to
160,
including
the
garage
space,
and
I
believe
that
the
garage
space
dollar
amount
had
been
not
taken
into
account
in
the
overall
market
value.
I
H
What
would
be
included
in
your
packet
that
was
couriered
out
to
you,
where
the
inf
was
information
that
we
would
have
had
by
last
week?
We
are
doing
our
best
as
we
get
late
incoming
information
via
email
to
forward
it
on
to
you.
There
were
a
number
of
these
types
of
cases.
Last
night,
where
I
was
trying
to
forward
on
information,
I
would
have
to.
J
I
No,
that's
that's
quite
all
right.
I
I
just
I
my
my
point
also
about
the
values
was
that
I
have.
I
live
in
a
modest
condominium.
Building
that
does
not
have
high-end
finishes.
All
the
units
are
comparable.
I
have
one
that
has
641
square
feet
compared
to
the
sales
of
others
that
are
a
higher
dollar
amount.
I
K
I
J
G
This
is
board
member
palmer.
I
just
would
ask
the
appellant,
so
you
purchased
a
property
in
november
of
2019
for
159
000
and
it
doesn't
appear.
The
assessor
has
really
changed
the
value
much
in
we've
seen
other
condos
that
the
market's
kind
of
flat.
Do
you
think
the
value
has
gone
down
some
since
your
purchase,
or
is
it
remain
flat.
A
B
H
B
B
G
G
I
mean
it's
a
substantial
increase
in
value,
but
if
there
was
a
lot
of
work
done,
it
seems
plausible
and
also
his
his
estimates
are
the
trulio
and
zillow
and
that
type
of
stuff-
and
they
don't
really
hold
much
water
on
that.
So
I,
without
any
other
information
to
go
on.
I
don't
see
much
to
do
on
this.
One.
J
B
L
C
B
I'll
second,
that,
okay,
it's
been
moved
by
palmer
and
second
and
by
amba,
to
sustain
the
value
of
the
property
at
1935,
hillside
avenue.
Of
course,
would
you
please
call
the
roll
board
member
amba
board
member
bedertha.
C
C
B
L
I
this
character.
This
is
board
member,
but
earth.
It's
a
duplex,
there's
no
rent
supplied
and
not
much
else.
I
moved
to
sustain
the
value
at
375,
000.
B
G
B
Promotion
by
palmer,
second,
by
godirtha,
to
sustain
the
value
for
3510
morgan
avenue,
north
whatever
it
was.
B
C
B
G
B
It's
moved
by
palmer
and
seconded
by
amba
to
sustain
the
value
of
41
39
bryant
at
184
000
clerk.
Would
you
please
call
it
all
board
member
amba
aye
board
member
bedertha.
M
C
B
Chair
bland
hi,
sarah
four
ice
washing
carries
next
is
the
appeal
for
seven
five,
zero
south
second
street
number,
five,
a
case
number
two:
two
dash
zero,
five,
two
seven
and
there's
another
one
at
that
address
too
it's
it's
the
750
south
second
street
number
5b
case
number
22-528.
H
Chair
bland
and
board
members-
you
had
remember
palmer,
asked
a
question
about
if
this
was
in
the
same
complex
and
it
it
is
in
the
humboldt.
Lofts
you've
heard
six
other
appeals
so
far,
and
there
are
a
total
of
11
appeals
in
this
building
all
garage
sales,
okay,.
B
And
if
I
remember
correctly,
we,
except
for
one
case,
we
sustained
the
values.
I
think
they
were
going
to
be
moving
on.
What
are
people's
feelings
about
this
one.
H
I
do
not
believe
any
of
our
staff
have
worked
with
this
appellate,
yet
they
just
couldn't
make
today's
time,
and
so
they
asked
to
be
heard
as
a
write-in,
but
is
what?
Which
is
the
case
for
all
cases,
that
you're
hearing
towards
the
end
of
the
local
board
season?
Our
team
will
be
working
with
them
contacting
them
so.
G
Okay,
I
guess
yeah
there
might
be
something
there,
but
given
that
information,
our
lack
of
other
information,
I
move,
we
sustain
the
value
on
unit
number
five,
a
at
twenty
eight
thousand.
B
B
There
are
four
eyes
motion:
carries
the
next
same
applicant
750
south
second
street
number.
Five
b
is
number
two
dash
zero.
Five
two
eight.
D
Madam
chair
there's
a
typo
on
the
agenda.
This
this
case
is
for
number
six,
a
parking
stall
6a
at
that.
B
D
B
Okay,
you
want
me
to
reread
that
into
the
into
the
record.
H
B
L
C
B
Chair
planned
hi,
there
are
four
eyes
motion
carries
next.
We
have
3840
grand
avenue
south
case
number
22.0529.
G
Yeah,
so
I
this
is
a
five
unit
apartment,
just
looking
what
he
read.
First
off,
we
do
have
a
sale
which
were
it
doesn't
I
without
talking
to
him.
I
think
it
was
open
market.
It
said
it
was
marketed
with
a
real
estate
agent
with
four
months
and
the
sale
price
was
740
000.
G
That
being
said,
it's
about
187
000
a
unit,
and
I
noted
a
lot.
We
have
other
four
unit
four
and
five
unit
apartment
buildings
that
are
under
appeal
in
various
areas,
and
most
of
them
would
seem
to
be
more
like
160
000
a
unit
or
a
little
less
than
this
on
this
address,
so
he
doesn't
have
any
rents,
but
he
has
the
sale
and
and
looking
at
a
per
unit
basis.
B
C
B
Chair
bland
aye,
there
are
four
eyes
motion
carries
next,
is
2809
buchanan
street
northeast
case
number
22-0530.
G
In
looking
at
this
case,
he
had
a
lot
of
zillow
data
which,
as
we
know,
is
not
really
reliable,
and
he
said
the
mentioned.
The
high-valued
houses
are
not
similar
to
his
house
and
square
footage.
G
B
Okay,
it's
been
moved
by
the
bertha
second
by
thomas
to
sustain
the
veil
at
2809
buchanan
street
northeast
case
number,
22.0530.
L
C
J
B
Right
you're
gonna
have
to
take
this
screen
off
my
screen,
no
okay,
all
right.
Next,
we
have
and
we
have
a
unit
and
a
garage
with
this
applicant.
Mr
khan,
first
one
is
720
third
avenue
northeast
number
313
case
number
22-0531.
L
I
couldn't
tell
if
the
information
that
the
applicant
supplied
was
sales
or
just
information,
values
and
assessor
information
about
each
of
the
properties.
So
I
don't
feel
like.
I
have
any
I'm
paging
through
this
and
I
can't
see
I
see
tax
value
and
tax
summaries,
but
I
I'm
not
sure
I
see
the
unless
somebody
sees
it
different.
I
don't
see
sale
prices
unless
it's
somewhere
else
on
the
page
and
I'm
not
seeing
it.
H
Your
bland
board
member
bedroom-
this
is
the
case
where
the
property
owner
sent
a
spreadsheet
to
our
office
late
last
night.
I
have
since
forwarded
it
on
to
you
there
there
is
a
short
listing
of
comparables,
so
this
is
something
you
could
potentially
table
if
you
wanted
to
and
come
back
and
look
at
later
on
in
the
morning,
so
that
you
could
take
a
look
at
the
spreadsheet,
but
that
is
up
to
you.
G
B
Okay,
you'll
make
that
motion.
G
Yeah
I'll
motion,
we
table
the
723rd
avenue
northeast
313
case
for
later
discussion
upon
looking
at
the
spreadsheet.
Okay.
C
B
C
B
Would
someone
like
to
make
the
motion
to
table
the
second
part
of
this,
which
is
the
garage
space
I'd.
G
H
B
At
what
is
it
8
000.?
What
could
you
call
the
hole?
Madam
chair,
I
think
I
have
the
estimated
market
value
at
8
800..
B
G
We
only
see
the
pictures
that
have
the
problems
on
it.
I
don't
know
how
extensive
they
are,
but
I
think
it's
worth
maybe
that
five
thousand
dollar
reduction
for
these
minor
expenses
and
if
everything
else
is
average,
so
I'd
be
open
to
other
thoughts
on
that.
B
C
G
I
found
he
did
the
applicant
provided
some
sale
comps,
but
I
found
that
they
were.
They
were
all
over
the
place
as
far
as
location,
and
they
didn't
really
show
you
what
his
neighborhood
was
like
as
far
as
operable
sales
and
it's
a
48
increase
since
his
2017
sale,
which
in
that
neighborhood
for
four
or
five
years,
doesn't
seem
out
of
out
of
line
either
either.
So
I
would
vote
that
we
hold
the
value
at
349,
000.
J
L
B
L
B
Board
member
palmer,
I
share
blind
bye.
There
are
four
eyes
motion
series
well
way
to
move
along
guys,
we're
through
with
the
d-30
the
or
8
30
to
9
30..
Is
that
what
we
were
working
on?
I
don't
even
know
what
time
it
is
so,
and
it's
only
9
15..
So
do
we
want
to?
Is
there
anybody
else
on
the
phone?
Do
you
want
to
move
on
to
do
some
cases
from
the
next
segment?
That's
heart,
collins,.
G
G
So
I,
if
I'm
looking
the
same
thing
you
guys
are
he's,
got
four
sales
of
similar
sized
units,
but
only
two
of
them
are
in
2021.
The
other
ones
are
older,
but
they're
very
consistent,
they're,
all
in
like
150
759
000,
which
it
tells
me
this
building's
been
pretty
flat.
I
and
his
value
hasn't
increased
much,
but
if
they
all
include
the
garage
unit,
maybe
there
should
be
a
slight
deduction
to
his
unit.
G
I
isn't
most
of
the
time
they
sold
with
the
garage
space
as
part
of
the
sale.
I
mean
we
don't.
B
L
Right,
I
noticed
the
appellant
did
when,
when
he
purchased
the
property
in
in
19
or
2019,
he
did
when
he
said
he
paid
159
and
that's
what
was
listed
by
the
assessors
the
sale
price.
It
did
include
both
that's.
Why
I'm
going
to
assume
that
both
of
those
or
all
of
these
have
the
garage
listed
with
it?
Also.
G
Oh
well,
I
don't
want
to
cut
corners.
I
I
suggest
we
just
go
back
to
his
last
year's
value
and
give
them
it
was
156
000
instead
160
and
give
them
some
benefit
for
the
garage
involved.
But
I
I'll
I'll
move
that
we
reduce
the
value
to
156
thousand
I'll.
Second.
L
B
C
C
B
I
would
propose
that
we
is
there.
Anyone
on
the
line
currently.
H
Chair
bland
and
board
members,
it
doesn't
appear
that
we
have
any
callers
for
our
next
scheduled
session,
9
30
to
10
30.
So
your
options
are
to
take
a
a
brief
recess
and
then
come
back
and
start
on
the
write-in
cases.
And
then
once
we
have
callers
on
the
line
move
to
those
calls.
Okay,.
B
All
right,
I
propose,
we
take
a
10-minute
break,
come
back
at
9
25
and
we
will
continue.
L
C
B
Is
everybody
here?
Yes,
all
right?
Yes,
let
us
move
on
to
the
appeal
for
733
van
buren
street
northeast
case
number.
Two
share.
Yes,
can
we.
B
Great
board
member
amba
present
board
member
buddhista.
B
We
have
a
quorum,
so
the
next
appeal
is
733
van
buren
street
northeast.
This
is
a
write-in
case.
Let
us
just
move
on
to
the
next
one
and
we'll
consider
it
after
we
finish
here.
B
One
is
43
30,
43,
46,
44th
avenue,
south
pace
number
22-0536.
B
Next,
we
have
25
24,
34th
avenue
so
case
number,
two,
two
zero
five
three
seven
appetite
is
hope.
Solaris
is
still
allows
down
the
line.
B
The
applicants
are
lyanna,
westblum
and
ryan.
Leiden
ledden
are
either
of
them
on
the
line.
D
N
Can
you
hear
me
this
weekend?
Okay,
we
just
we
provided
some
documentation
for
what
for
why?
We
feel
that
the
valuation
of
our
home
is
is
over
what
it
should
be.
We
can
just
give
a
brief
summary
of
our
points,
so
our
home
is
a
two-story
home,
that's
2144
square
feet
with
three
bedrooms
and
two
and
a
half
baths,
and
we
have
an
unfinished
basement
as
well
as
a
two-car
detached
garage.
N
N
If
you
look
at
comparable
sales,
those
homes
are
taxed
at
lower
rates
than
our
home.
The
range
that
we
found
was
717
to
776
000
for
comparable
sales
and
their
tax
and
their
proposed,
and
their
tax
value
you're,
proposing
to
tax
our
home
at
895
000
up
from
last
year
at
800
000,
with
no
changes
to
the
specifications
of
our
home.
N
And
then
we
looked
at
homes
with
taxable
market
values
similar
to
the
proposed
taxable
market
value
of
our
home,
which
was
8.95,
and
these
homes
are
1300
square
feet
larger
than
our
home
and
have
more
bedrooms
and
more
bathrooms.
So
we
feel
that
our
home
should
remain
at
what
it
was
assessed
at
previously,
which
is
800.
G
Hi,
this
is
board
member
palmer.
Could
you
kind
of
go
over
I'm
looking
at
the
history
of
the
property
and
you
purchased
it
in
2019
for
347
000,
and
then
there
were
permits
done
in
a
large
edition.
Was
that
building
torn
down
to
the
foundation
and
then
completely
rebuilt
at
that
time?.
G
Okay
and
we're
I
looked
at
these
prairies
and
it's
hard
to
find
any
comps,
but
I
don't
think
any
comps
were
really
of
was
were
that
new
on
that
appraisal,
and
I
know
it's
hard
to
find
them.
But
it's
difficult.
N
To
find
a
comp
because
we
have
a
new
construction
without
a
finished
basement,
so
I
think
because
of
that
it
can
be
quite
difficult
to
find
comparables.
C
O
N
If
you
look
at
you
know,
if
you
look
at
comparable
homes
with
finished
basements
that
are,
you
know
in
the
3000
to
3800
range.
N
B
Programmers
any
other
questions
for
the
applicants.
Okay.
Well,
thank
you
very
much.
We
will
make
our
decision
and
you'll
be
notified
by
mail.
N
B
P
Okay,
thank
you
so
much
for
agreeing
to
granting
me
this
hearing
to
contest
the
estimated
tax
mark
estimated
market
value
for
2023
and
which
is
estimated
at
416
and
so
previously
for
2022.
P
Our
estimated
market
value
was
331k
and
the
taxable
market
value,
because
we
had
a
homestead
inclusion
with
323.550
our
bedroom.
Our
we
have
two
bedrooms:
two
bathrooms.
After
last
year
in
2021,
we
did
add
on
a
three-quarter
bathroom
into
our
unfinished
basement,
which
is
still
unfinished,
but
the
bathroom
is
of
course
finished
and
again
that
is
a
three-quarter
bathroom.
So
we
did
expand
to
now
having
two
bathrooms.
P
We
have
thirteen
and
thirty
finished
square
feet
so
in
the
materials
that
I
submitted,
I
just
included
that
I
I
realized
that
20
2016
appraisal
is
fairly
old
at
this
point,
but
just
for
the
sake
of
argument,
it
did
include
that
in
2016
our
property
was
appraised
by
an
appraisal
service
provided
by
our
bank
wells
fargo,
and
it
was
appraised
at
the
time
as
at
270
and
the
materials
I've
provided
it's
kind
of
hard
to
find
comparable
homes
with
just
two
bedrooms.
P
In
the
five
five
four
zero
nine
area
code,
two
bedrooms
and
also
we
have
an
unattached
garage
and
an
unfinished
basement,
so
the
properties
that
I
did
provide
two
of
them
were
sold
in
may
of
last
year,
one
at
37,
17
aldrich
at
373.5,
one
at
39,
41
garfield,
just
in
the
street
over
from
us,
and
that
was
at
3
45
and
then,
just
in
november
of
last
year,
37
201,
21,
colfax,
two
bedroom,
two
bath
was
sold
for
374k
and
then
3808
harriet
across
the
street,
which
is
a
bedroom
two
bath
and
has
300
more
square
feet
than
we
do
was
sold
in
december
and
late
december
at
405
k.
P
P
P
So
with
the
bathroom
and
then
we
had
some
repair
work
done
to
our
chimney.
We
were
around
35
000.
P
I
was
digging
around
to
see
on
some
realtor
websites
what
the
percentage
increase
in
home
value
would
be
of
adding
a
bathroom
and
that's
around
five
to
six
percent,
so
that
and
then
looking
at
villo's
market
report
reporting
a
typical
home
value
of
around
30
362
000
dollars,
360
sorry,
362k
of
typical
home
value
in
our
neighborhood
right.
A
P
I
just
I
feel
like
416
k,
is
a
bit
much
for
our
tiny
little
house
with
the
unfinished
basement,
and
so
I
do
think
that
it's
it's
valid
to
increase
the
value
of
our
property,
but
I
think
a
more
reasonable
figure
would
be
around
375k
again.
I
appreciate
the
time
that
you're
taking
to
have
this
hearing
and
look
forward
to
any
questions
you
have
for
me.
P
L
Yes,
this
is
board
member
bedroom.
You
mentioned
it's
unfinished
basement.
Are
we
other
than
the
bathroom
that
you
just
added?
Are
we
talking
exposed
studs,
concrete
black
walls
and
no
flooring.
P
B
Okay
hearing
none,
we
will
make
our
decision
and
notify
you
by
mail.
Thank
you
for
your
presentation.
D
Q
Q
Q
And
the
two
main
pieces
of
evidence
I
have
for
that:
fair
market
value
adjustment
are
number
one,
the
fair
market
value
for
the
recent
transaction,
which
I
have
just
stated
and
secondly,
during
my
mortgage
application,
my
mortgage
provider
commissioned
a
third-party
assessor,
which
came
out
with
the
assessed
value
of
335
dollars,
and
this
appraisal
was
completed,
completed
by
thomas
walker,
a
certified
residential
appraiser
as
of
january
7
2022,
and
he
works
for
guideline,
a
division
of
nationwide
property
and
appraisal
services,
search,
certifies
and
based
on
the
evidence
I
have
above.
Q
I
believe
your
estimated
market
value
and
taxes
taxable
market
value
is
an
overvaluation,
and
thus
I
would
like
to
appeal
the
property
taxes
proposed
for
this
year,
given
the
decrease
in
the
market
value
of
the
property
located
at
2401
harriet
avenue
as
evident
in
the
actual
transaction
value
and
also
the
third
party
assessment,
and
with
that
I
I
would
love
to
hear
if
you
have
any
questions.
L
Q
Yes,
what
I
I
I'm
actually
not
aware
of
the
definition
of
a
state
cell,
but
but
how
I
purchased.
It
was
because
my
broker
took
me
to
tour
the
property.
There
were
multiple
offers
being
presented
to
the
owner
and
that's
how
I
was
able
to
purchase
the
property.
G
Both
so
that
broker
was
was
listed,
others
like
there's
a
sign,
and
there
were
everybody
was
aware
that
was
for
sale.
Q
Yes,
so
I
believe
that
this
price
is
slightly
higher
than
than
than
the
price
I
purchased.
Just
due
to
my
confession:
on
not
doing
an
inspection
which
I
could
find
out
right
now,
I
believe
it
was
a
little
bit
closer
to
639
000.
G
Q
Right
so
this
is
a
four
unit:
rental,
a
permanent
building.
As
you're
aware
at
the
time
of
my
purchase,
there
are
two
tenants
that
are
still
within
the
building,
but
the
other
two
units
were
vacant
and
definitely
needs
a
lot
of
reparation,
which
is
something
that
I'm
going
through
with
the
inspector
as
a
new
owner.
Q
Go
ahead,
if
I
could
just
ask
so
with
the
listing
price
for
the
property
at
the
time,
was
that
699
and
900,
so
it
was
lower
than
what
was
listed
for
my
purchase
price.
Okay,.
D
Madam
chair,
yes,
we
do
have
a
caller
on
the
line
for
agenda
item
25
case
22-0544,
and
there
is
also
a
caller
that
I
do
not
recognize
the
phone
number
for
an
associated
case
ending
in
6195.
D
D
B
Okay,
let's
hear
from
this
applicant
case
number
220536
address
4346
avenue,
south
okay.
R
Thank
you,
and
essentially
our
home.
It's
just
a
situation
of
needing
a
lot
of
repair
and
several
years
ago
I
don't
remember
when
it
was.
Maybe
five
years
ago
you
had
looked
at
our
house
again
as
well
and
lowered
it
and
unfortunately,
since
then
we
have
not
been
able
to
fix
things
and
more
things
have
happened.
R
R
I
I
went
with
a
comp
of
385
for
after
repair
value,
which
is
even
more
than
what
you're
noting
our
home
valuation,
which
again
makes
sense
because
you're
already
aware
from
the
previous
appeal
we
had
done
just
in
the
state
of
our
home,
so
I
did
go
through
and
I
believe
my
husband
he's
the
one
that
set
this
up
and
emailed
in
the
appeal-
and
I
did
give
him
attachments
of
where
I
got
my
estimates
for
repair.
R
R
That's
on
the
floor
on
the
ground
near
the
ground,
so
two
springs
ago.
I
believe
it
was.
It
was
actually
submerged
in
water,
so
we
just
had
to
pull
the
power
to
the
garage
for
a
while
and
there's
damage
in
the
garage
as
well
just
from
a
different
leak
or
something
where
two
of
the
load-bearing,
I
don't
know,
you'd
call
it
joyce
or
whatever
the
support
beams,
they're,
actually
fuzzy
with
mold,
and
now
the
garage
door
is
having
a
hard
time
because
of
the
sinking.
R
So,
for
example,
there
were
several
times
where
it
actually
froze
to
the
ground
this
past
winter.
Just
because
the
way
it's
pushing
into
the
asphalt
on
that
side
and
excuse
me,
I'm
getting
through
covet
actually
and
then
there's
some
other
things
for
I'll
just
say
one
more
example.
R
So
when
I
went
through
excuse
me
the
estimated
repair,
because
it's
pretty
much
a
rehab
house
it.
I
feel
that
our
house
is
worth
259
000
and
looking
at
the
range
of
comps.
Well,
I
guess
that's
it
I'll,
say
that
and
then
I'll,
let
you
ask.
F
Thank
you,
but
I
do
have.
R
Some
experience
working
with
looking
looking
at
numbers
and
values,
and
all
of
that
so
I
feel
it's
a
pretty
accurate
representation.
Looking
at
the
numbers.
L
Yes,
you
mentioned
you,
you
came
up
with
the
numbers,
then,
for
all
these
repairs,
as
opposed
to
a
contractor.
R
Yeah
absolutely
I
did
work.
I
did
do
four
flips.
Some
years
ago
I
had
an
airbnb
and
I
actually
sold
that
one
myself
in
rochester
and
so
I've
always
been
pretty
good.
Like
I
have
my
things
that
weren't
my
strengths,
but
figuring
out,
the
numbers
are
pretty
pretty
close,
I
feel
so.
For
example,
exterior
are
siding
is
pulling
apart,
especially
in
the
corners
but
different
parts
of
our
siding,
they're
pulling
away
and
then
the
foundation
cement
area
that's
crumbling
away.
R
R
So
I
feel
that
the
6300
is
pretty
fair
estimate
and
then
the
interior
painting,
because
we
have
paint
from
I
don't
know
how.
R
Years
ago
and
old,
like
in
the
room,
I'm
in
right
now
has
wallpaper
and
it's
like
you
can
see
the
seams
and
everything
and
then
parts
of
her
ceiling,
the
plaster
starting
to
fall
off
it's
minor,
but
the
cracks
had
already
been
repaired
once,
but
for
all
of
that,
I'm
estimated
forty
seven
hundred
dollars.
So
just
so.
G
Yeah,
I
just
have
one
question
looking
at
these
costs:
whatever
be
that
as
me,
I'm
not
an
expert
on
it
and
maybe
they're
good,
but
my
point
would
be
a
lot
of
that
would
seem
to
be
deferred
maintenance
but
other
stuff
you
mentioned
after
you
did
all
this
laundry
list.
Wouldn't
your
house
be
in
better
condition
than
these
comparables
that
you're
looking
at
that
most
likely
are.
You
know
an
average
condition
and
don't
have
this
updating.
F
R
R
R
Just
mention
one
more
thing,
so
our
half
bath,
so
we
have
the
one
full
bath
and
then
the
half
bath,
it's
in
it's
a
converted,
closet
and
small
and
the
door
opens
into
another
room
and
the
door
doesn't
lock,
because
it's
like
a
when
it
has
the
slats
it's
a
door
that
just
pulls
it
doesn't
latch
or
anything.
It's
like
a
closet
door
with
those
slats
kind
of
a
cheaper
one.
So
it
doesn't
even
have
it's
very
odd
in
the
ceiling
slam.
R
F
B
We
will
make
our
decision
and
you
will
be
notified
by
mail.
B
Did
I
see
a
brief
message
about
somebody
having
trouble
clicking
in?
Can
you
help
me
on
that.
B
D
B
Since
we
have
callers
on
the
mail
we'll
skip
instead
of
taking
the
next
one
in
line
we'll
skip
to
20,
it
was
25
right
item
25.,
correct.
C
J
T
So
listen
to
what
everyone
else
said
kind
of
similar
issues,
but
this
is
a
very
small
house.
I
think
one
of
the
key
points
to
to
look
at
are.
I
provided
some
sales
information
on
four
other
homes
and
those
homes
are
all
above
700
square
feet
where
mynakoma's
property
is
472
square
feet
above
ground.
T
T
It
was
originally
my
sister-in-law's
name,
but
we
all
owned
it
together
and
then
she
passed
away
and
we
put
it
in
all
of
our
names
at
that
point
and
her
son.
So
we've
been
the
only
owners
of
that
home
and
we'll
kind
of
continue
on
it'll
stay
in
the
family,
not
a
rental,
although
we
did
lost
our
lose
our
homestead
on
that,
not
sure
what
happened
there,
but
I
can
assure
you
it's
family,
that's
that's
living
in
that
home,
but
we've
not
made
any
improvements
since
2003
nothing's
changed.
T
So
it's
the
same
house,
it's
in
a
little
bit
more
poor
condition
on
the
outside
peeling
paint
on
the
trim
and
the
roof
is
still
the
same
roof
as
when
we
bought
the
house.
So
you
know
those
are
again.
You
know
I
noticed
that
you
had
mentioned.
T
Well,
that
one's
comparable
it
has
a
foundation
size
of
480,
but
that
is
a
two
bedroom
home
and
it's
listing
at
180
000.
So.
T
B
Thank
you,
mr
johnson.
I
have
a
question.
This
is
chair,
bland.
You
said
this
is
one
bedroom,
so
there's
is
there
anything
anything
finished
in
the
basement?
Is
there
anything
above?
Is
there
a
porch?
Is
there
a
garage.
T
There's
a
garage,
the
basement,
since
you
know
we
it's
not
changed.
It's
got
a
three-quarter
bath
in
the
basement.
T
T
B
Okay,
is
that
a
a
four
season
three
season
is
it
screened?
Is
it
glassed
in
I.
T
T
T
We're
waiting
in
three
weeks,
new,
our
our
my
brother-in-law
and
sister-in-law
from
vietnam,
will
be
there.
B
Okay,
so
you
mentioned
that
you
lost
your
homestead.
This
is
a
separate
deal
from
this,
but
you
mentioned
your
last
year
homestead.
If,
if
you
have
certain
relatives
living
there,
you
might
be
able
to
reapply
from
homestead
and
get
it
back,
but
you
need
to
work
with.
T
B
Okay,
well,
there's
no
reason
that
certain
certain
relatives
qualify
for
homestead.
So
if
you
wanted
to
check
on
that
at
some
point
anyway,
board
members,
do
you
have
any
questions
for
mr
johnson.
B
F
K
Okay
hi:
this
is
asa
weston,
I'm
the
owner
of
3846
grand
avenue
south.
I
submitted
an
appeal
online
to
I
guess:
challenge
the
valuation
of
the
property.
K
Property
in
you
know,
2021
value
was
768
500
it
it
jumped
up
to
899
200
in
the
span
of
the
year.
I
I
understand,
that's
not
particularly
a
basis
for
an
appeal,
however,
when
compared,
for
instance,
the
property
directly
to
the
south,
which
is
actually
an
identical
blueprint.
I
mean
there's
three
homes
in
a
row
or
three:
these
are
four
plexes
mine
has
a
fifth
unit
that
was
added
at
some
time
in
the
basement.
K
I
don't
know
if
the
one
directly
to
the
south,
which
would
be
3852,
does
have
a
fifth
unit,
but
otherwise
it's
an
identical
building.
I
mean
there's
three
in
a
row
that
are
built
on
the
identical
floor
plan
back
in
the
20s
and
its
valuation
in
2021
was
767
000
and
it
actually
dropped
to
729
000
in
2022.
K
So
I
I
guess,
I'm
more
wondering
why
certain
properties,
particularly
an
identical
one
directly
next
door
to
mine,
is
losing
value
and
mine's
gaining
value
at
20
percent
and-
and
I
think
there
just
has
to
be
some
connection
to
what
I
could
actually
sell
the
property
for,
and
you
know
I've
talked
to
to
age,
the
listing
agents
and
I
said
sure
you
can
list
it
if
you
can
get
me
900
000
and
they
laugh
and
that's
what
the
valuation
has
placed
at
and
there
has
to
be
some
connection
to
what
I
can
actually
sell
it.
K
For
you
know,
if
someone
wanted
to
give
me
900
000
for
it,
I
would
sell
the
property
I
you
know.
That
would
be
a
great
windfall
for
me.
I
bought
it
for
just
around
670
000
in
january
of
2021.,
and
I'll
also
note
that
the
property
directly
to
the
north,
which
is
almost
identical,
it
does
have
five
units
I
know
sold
for
740
000
also
in
january
january
2021.
K
So
so
I'm
wondering
how
there
could
be
a
hundred,
and
you
know
nearly
a
two
hundred
thousand
dollar
jump
in
property
value
in
just
you
know.
Just
over
a
year-
and
I
guess
maybe
I'm
maybe
just
looking
more
for
an
answer
on
that-
rather
than
an
actual
reduction
in
the
value.
K
But
again
in
my
in
my
experience,
you
know
I
own
a
home
that
I
live
in
also
in
minneapolis
south
minneapolis,
but
you
know
the
the
assessed
value
is
often
much
less
than
you
could
actually
sell
the
property
for,
and
I
think
everyone's
aware
of
that,
and
so,
if
that
holds
true
to
a
you
know,
an
apartment
building
a
non-homesteaded
apartment
building,
then
I
should
be
able
to
sell
my
property
currently
valued
for
next
year
or
for
this
year
at
899
000.
K
I
should
be
able
to
sell
for
a
million
dollars,
which
I
know
I
couldn't
so
I
I
guess
that's
sort
of
the
basis
of
my
appeal.
It
doesn't
seem
to
have
connection
to
the
actual
value
of
the
property
and
it
certainly
doesn't
have
connection
to
the
value
of
a
property
directly
next
door.
That's
an
identical
blueprint.
There's
three
in
a
row
built
at
the
same
time
I
assume
and
they're
identical
and
the
one
directly
to
the
south
of
me
is
losing
value.
K
3852
grand
avenue
south
is
losing
value
and
mine
is
gaining
20
in
the
span
of
a
year.
So
I'm
wondering
where
that
comes
from,
particularly
so
I
I'm
happy
to
answer
any
questions
the
board
might
have
about
the
property,
so
the
rest
of
my
abilities.
G
Hi,
this
is
board
member
palmer.
First,
I
want
to
clarify
a
few
things
at
an
assessor
by
law,
and
this
has
been
in
place
for
a
number
of
years
and
it's
kind
of
a
misconception
is
supposed
to
value
all
the
properties
between
90
and
105
percent
of
market
value,
what
they
can
sell
for
that's
an
acceptable
range.
Obviously
you
don't
want
to
be
over
100,
but
somewhere
between
90
and
100
percent
is
typical,
so
we
should
be
close
to
what
they
could
sell
for.
G
K
It
wasn't,
I
knew
the
seller
and
in
fact
he
had
been
my
landlord
for
many
years
so
I
had.
Essentially,
I
had
helped
to
manage
the
property,
so
I
you
know
I'm
not.
It
could
have
been
a
good
deal.
You
know
I
I
don't
deny
that
I
certainly
had
a
personal
relationship
with
the
guy
who
owned
it
for
30
years
and
he
was
getting
older
and
he
offered
to
sell
it
to
me.
K
B
J
K
B
Bland,
I
do
have
a
question
for
you:
what
are
the
parking
accommodations
at
your
building.
K
B
What
about
the
properties
that
you
always
make
here
is
the
others
you're
excited
what
are
their
parking
accommodations.
K
3840,
which
is
directly
to
the
north,
also
has
a
three
or
four
car
garage.
I'm
not
sure
I
I
think
theirs
is
a
four-car
garage
because
they
don't
have
an
off
street
the
property
to
the
south.
3852
has
so
they
don't
have
a
garage,
but
there's
several
probably
I
don't
know
eight
off
street
parking
places.
I
would
guess.
F
B
B
Okay,
he
just
kind
of
stick
me
around.
Do
I
need
to
read
the
ones
we
skipped
into
the
record
here?
Where
are
we.
D
From
chair,
I
believe
you
can
skip
directly
to
the
decision
making
time
and
you
can
read
them
into
the
record
as
you
go
along.
There
are
no
other
callers
in
queue
at
this
time.
Wait.
B
B
So
the
first
one
then
to
decide
on
is
733
van
buren
street
northeast
case
number
22-0535.
G
I
I
chairman,
I'm
kind
of
lost
here.
I
do
we
have
a
number
left
or
I'm
missing
something
I
we
kind
of
skipped
around
for
some
reason.
I'm
at
this
case
two
two
zero
five,
four
one.
B
L
Yeah
appellant
didn't
provide,
but
I
can
see
any
good
sales
or
anything
on
this.
B
All
right:
where
could
you
please
call
the
world
cards
moved
by
bedertha
seconded
by
palmer,
to
sustain
the
value
of
733
van
buren
clerk?
Would
you
please
call
the
wall?
Okay,.
C
B
Chair
bland
hi,
there
are
four
eyes
motion
carries
next.
Is
I'm
doing
them
bringing
breakthrough
here?
Are
we
next
at
43,
46
44th.
B
This
was
a
call-in.
Am
I
right.
G
Yeah
this
is,
I
would
say,
I
mean
there
was
a
big
laundry
list,
but
my
point
would
be
to
steve's
point:
I'm
not
sure
how
good
those
estimates
are.
They
don't
look
real
bad,
but
I'm
not
a
contractor
myself,
so
they
might
be
inflated.
G
G
Is
it
really
in
that
bad
of
shape,
or
is
it
just
kind
of
minor
it's
hard
to
tell,
but
I
I
did
see,
I
thought
that
some
of
her
comps
at
least
had
ages
and
sizes
and
were
nearby,
and
there
were
some
that
385
to
400
000
seem
to
make
sense
in
good
condition.
So
I
I
think,
there's
some
problems
with
this.
I
don't
think
it's
anywhere
near
what
they
said,
but
I
would
entertain
a
slight
reduction
just
for
condition.
I
I
don't
I'm
I'm
thinking,
maybe
15
or
20
000.
L
I
think
there's
an
enough
there
with
the
the
problems
and
again
we
don't
have
the
pictures,
like
mr
palmer
said,
but
I
would
I
I
would
entertain
a
number
less
than
that,
maybe
even
towards
at
least
back
to
the
value
of
last
year,
which
was
well
it's
20,
22,
000
reduction,
but
at
least
that
amount
for
for
the
condition
of
this
property.
L
G
I
think
that
makes
sense,
okay,
I'll
move
that
will
reduce
the
value
of
the
property
to
last
year's
value.
347
000.
B
C
C
H
This
is
rebecca
the
next
item
case.
22.05
is
a
case
that
has
been
resolved
with
our
team
and
will
be
moved
to
a
board
recommendation
list
presented
to
you
tomorrow.
So
you
can
move
past
it
skip
it
for
today.
G
So
they
had
an
appraisal
from
20
late
2020
for
812,
so
that's
after
they
redid
the
house
in
the
same
condition.
I
I
didn't
see
any
age
adjustments
on
that
appraisal.
The
comps
would
make
sense
of
that
age.
So
I
think
there
should
be
some
kind
of
age
adjustment
and
then
a
time
adjustment
it
was
from
2020.
So
895
is.
It
looks
like
it's
about
an
eight
or
ten
percent
increase.
G
B
Thought
that
was
interesting
too
so
yeah
yeah
they're
thinking
775,
which
is
considerably
less
than
the
the
you
know
old
appraisal.
So
I
thought
it
was
interesting.
L
B
L
C
B
G
I
just
had
a
couple
notes.
First,
the
appraisal
doesn't
give
us
much
weight
because
it
was
from
2016.
So
I
didn't
even
really
look
at
that.
I,
the
basement
remodel,
was
didn't
sound
like
it
was
real
extensive,
but
on
a
per
square
foot
basis,
you
mentioned
some
sales,
they
weren't.
I
don't
know
how
comfortable
they
were,
but
all
the
sales
were
pretty
close
and
they,
the
last
two
I
looked
at,
were
290
and
250
dollars
a
square
foot.
G
So
I
just
if
it
was
300
a
square
foot
and
I
added
22
000
for
the
work
done.
I
I'm
coming
up
to
405.
It
isn't
a
big
difference,
but
it
just.
I
thought
it
was
a
little
high
on
the
per
square
foot
side.
L
Mike
my
comment
is
that
the
appellant
mentioned
that
there
was
no
finish
in
the
basement
and
the
assessor's
field
card
does
have
528
square
feet
of
finished
space
so
that,
for
that
reason
alone
I
know.
Probably
not.
A
lot
of
weight
is
put
on
finished
basements,
for
maybe
this
age
of
home
in
their
cama
approach,
but
I
think
that's
worthy
of
a
reduction
on
this
property.
B
B
But
reduction.
B
It's
moved
by
bedertha
and
seconded
by
amba
to
reduce
the
value
of
3821
period
to
375
000..
Or
could
you
please
call
the
roll
board
member
amba
aye
board
member
budertha.
C
C
B
Okay:
next,
we
have
2401
harriet
four.
I
guess
five
bedroom
apartment.
G
Well,
she
was
on
the
line
and
I
just
that
sale
seems
like
was
marketed
and
had
multiple
offers,
but
the
two
units
weren't
rented
to
my
mind,
that
it
seems
very
low
compared
to
the
comps
even
for
the
age.
But
it's
a
matter
of
how
much
work
really
had
to
be
done
in
those
two
units
is:
is
that
the
difference
between
these
comps
and
in
the
higher
list
price
and
what
it
actually
sold
for?
G
L
G
Yes,
she
was
in
a
state
but
apparently
listed
but
and
had
multiple
offers.
She
said
and
it
was
listed
for
6.99.
G
Yeah
yeah,
the
only
thing
I
will
mention
on
the
appraisal.
I
don't
think
there
were
enough
adjustments
made
to
get
to
that
price,
but
the
comp
won.
The
net
sale
price
was
very
similar,
very
close,
same
age,
four
unit
was
sold
in
late
21
for
759
000,
that's
just
before
making
any
adjustments,
and
so
I'm
looking
at
that
and
comparing
that
to
635
there's
a
big
gap,
but
I
I
think
it
should
be
somewhere
between
those
two
numbers
where
exactly
I'm
not
sure.
B
I
think
she
said
that
it
sounded
like
the
reason
they
took
her
off
earth
was
considerably
under
the
asking
price
was
that
she
wasn't
looking
for
an
inspection
and,
depending
on
the
the
you
know,
the
shape
of
the
building
that
could
have
added
up
to
a
lot
if
the
buyer
wanted
repairs
made
or
price
reductions
in
order
to
accommodate
for
work
that
needed
to
be
done.
G
Right
so
on
the
appraisal-
and
this
is
go
to
the
point
of
those
other
units-
he's-
got
adjustments
on
all
the
comps,
including
the
one
I
like,
the
first
one
and
the
second
one
was
775
000
at
two,
but
a
condition:
adjustment
of
a
hundred
thousand
or
a
hundred
and
twenty
five
thousand.
G
G
Well,
I
I'm
gonna,
I
like
the
first
couple:
sales
and
they're
on
25th
and
harriet
27
for
pillsbury,
and
instead
of
making
a
huge
adjustment,
maybe
something
a
little
less
than
that,
I'm
gonna
suggest
we
lower
the
the
value
to
740
000,
which
is
a
little
less
than
those
two
comparable
sales.
G
B
Okay
target
anybody.
L
I'll
second,
that
and
make
a
remark
that
we
we
note
and
as
did
this
appraisal,
that
this
property
it
needs
some
work
and
I'm
guessing
the
assessor
will
have
it
something
to
look
at
in
the
future
as
it
gets
repaired
there
hopefully
will
be
some
permits
taken
out
that
they
can
follow
up
on
this
but
I'll.
Second,
the
motion.
B
F
C
B
Share
bland
hi
there
are
four
eyes
motion:
fairies,
okay,
it's
about
20.
After
10,
there
is
actually
a
color
on
the
line
for
the
next
session.
We
have
about
six
or
eight
cases
that
we
haven't
made
decisions
on
here's,
what
I
propose
to
go
ahead
and
take
a
ten
minute
break
and
come
back
at
10
30
and
set
aside
these
cases
until
later
in
that
day
and
go
ahead
with
the
next
segment.
Everybody
on
board.
With
that.
B
B
Done
so
far
yep,
so
if
we
finish
with
2401
area,
we'll
take
up
5736
oliver
later
in
the
day,
see
you
in
10
minutes.
B
V
There's
one
caller
on
the
line
for
56
49
43rd
avenue
south.
This
is
sam
chabonsky.
D
Madam
chair,
if
the
callers
could
please
refrain
from
speaking
until
we
call
your
case,
we
actually
have
three
callers
on
the
line
at
the
present
time.
The
first
one
that
would
be
in
order
would
be
for
item
31
case
22050,
5649,
43rd
avenue,
south.
B
Again,
why
don't
we
board
members
I'm
proposing
that
we
take
up
the
cases
that
have
callers
on
the
line
and
we'll
go
back
to
the
others
after
I
know
it
gets
confusing
with
paperwork
maya's
on
my
laptop,
so
it's
even
more
confusing,
but
let's
take
care
of
the
cases
where
we
have
people
on
the
line,
so
in
that
case
the
next.
The
next
item
is.
B
E
B
All
right
go
ahead
and
present
your
case.
You
have
five
minutes.
V
All
right,
thank
you.
The
reason
that
I
am
challenging.
My
evaluation
has
to
deal
with
the
evaluations
of
properties
on
my
block.
V
If
we
look
at
a
corner
property
that
has
a
story
and
a
half
schematic
similar
to
ours
on
the
corner,
this
is
property:
five,
six,
five,
six,
forty
fourth
avenue
south,
so
kitty
corner
from
my
property,
that
is
at
310
up
from
282
the
prior
year
and
a
final
data
point
to
put
in
reference
is
a
duplex
on
my
block.
V
That
has
a
much
larger
lot.
It's
a
lot
and
a
half
that
is
address,
5609,
43rd
avenue
south
that's
at
236
up
from
208,
so
my
concern
is
based
off
of
the
jump
from
2020
to
2021
and
then
the
subsequent
jump
from
2021
to
2022
in
comparison
with
my
block,
roughly
150k
over
any
other
valuation
with
items
that
are
more
advantageous
for
some
other
properties.
Like
I
said,
a
corner
lot,
a
duplex,
a
larger
lot,
so
there's
a
disparity
there
that
I'm
looking
to
curtail.
V
V
G
Yeah
hi,
this
is
board
member
palmer.
I
just
want
to
speak
to
the
conditioner
properties.
He
was
built
in
1931,
which
is
a
good
year.
The
assessor
has
it
is
average
plus
and
I'm
looking
at
some
permits
since
you
bought
it
they're,
not
major,
but
so
it
looks
like
a
gas
install
of
a
new
fireplace,
replace
furnace,
ac,
ducting,
replace
front
steps,
reside
house
put
in
insulation.
V
So
that
has
so
that
was
done
prior
to
my
purchase,
there
was
a
foreclosure
half
of
it
was
done.
Let's
say
the
the
furnace,
the
appliances,
it
was
part
of
a
home
revitalization
project
before
I
bought
it
in
between
since
I've
owned
it,
we
did
have
a
issue
with
the
roof.
V
V
We
did
report
and
make
a
landing
for
the
front
steps
at
that
time,
but
that
has
been
several
years
since
that
repair
was
made
and
outside
of
the
the
band
that
I'm
kind
of
talking
about
here
and
that's
why
I
brought
this
up
into
question
within
the
last
few
years.
It's
been
landscaping,
adjustments
with
rock
beds
and
not
that
critical
infrastructure
that
you
described.
V
B
B
Okay,
thank
you.
Any
other
questions
board
members.
B
D
W
Name
is
gail
fleming
4808,
bryant
avenue
south
I'm
objecting
to
the
evaluation
because
excuse
me,
there's
a
property
at
4620
glendale
avenue,
which
is
in
our
neighborhood
same
configuration
three
bedrooms,
two
baths:
it's
on
the
market
for
479.
W
and
then
there's
one
more
yeah
at
55
irving
at
4,
19,
again,
three
bedrooms,
two
baths.
I
believe
our
house
is
over
evaluated
in
the
past
two
years.
W
501
and
up
to
five
580.,
that's
a
79
000
increase
in
the
past
two
years.
As
far
as
evaluation
is
concerned-
and
I
don't
believe
our
property
is
worth
that
much.
We
have
no
garage
on
on
the
property.
We
do
have
a
driveway
with
no
garage.
W
I
guess
that's
that's
what
our
our
issue
is.
B
Okay,
thank
you
board
members.
You
have
any
questions
for
the
applicant.
G
I
just
have
one
question:
this
is
board
member
palmer.
Well,
one
comment
is
your
lots
on
bryant
are
8
000
square
feet
and
your
comparables
are
all
typical
city
lots
of
52-27,
but
you
list,
your
building
area
of
your
house
is
2781
square
feet,
which
is
what
over
what
the
assessor
has.
So,
where
did
you
come
up
with
that
number.
G
W
G
W
And
I
think
what
I
did
is:
there's
a
it's
screened-in
porch
on
the
back
that
the
previous
owner
had
built,
and
I
think
I
included
that
area
in
the
square
footage
of
the
house.
W
L
This
is
a
board
member
that
it
appears
looking
at
the
field
card
that
perhaps
the
appellant
has
added
the
basement
square
footage
into
the
square
footage,
because
we
show,
or
the
assessor
shows
1700
square
feet
and
a
little
over
a
thousand
square
foot
basement.
B
I
believe
there's
one
other
applicant
on
the
line.
Is
that
correct.
D
You
are
correct,
madam
chair.
This
is
for
the
property
at
5900
pillsbury
avenue.
It's
case,
number
22056
agenda
item
40
today.
If
the
caller
could
please
press
star
six
to
unmute
your
phone
and
state
your
name
and
address
and
you'll
have
five
minutes
to
present
to
the
board.
B
N
Oh
okay,
great,
my
name
is
sandra
strothers
and
I'm
calling
about
5900
pillsbury
avenue
in
minneapolis.
So
the
reason
I
am
contesting
the
evaluated
value
I
sent
some
documentation,
but
I'll
just
go
through
it
really
quickly.
So
I
originally
purchased
this
house
for
274.9
in
2016.,
and
the
city
is
suggesting
now
that
its
current
valuation
is
431..
N
So
that's
an
increase
in
156
thousand
one
hundred
dollars
in
value.
That's
64
increase
in
six
years.
I
had
I
mean
the
main
reason
I'm
calling
is.
I
have
been
thinking
of
selling
the
house.
Last
year
I
asked
two
separate
realtors
to
give
me
an
evaluation
on
what
they
thought
the
house
would
sell
for,
and
one
suggested
3.749
and
the
other
suggested
380.,
and
then
I
went
on
to
some
real
estate
websites
and
looked
at
some
comps.
N
The
closest
comp
that
I
could
find
is
really
close
to
my
house.
It's
like
a
block
away
from
my
house.
It's
312
west
59th
street,
it
just
sold
for
355
and
it's
a
three
bedroom
two
bath
just
like
mine,
and
it
actually
had
has
2
36
square
feet
so
considerably
more
square
feet
than
mine.
There's
another
one:
that's
just
also
a
block
away:
58
20,
pleasant
avenue
that
just
sold
for
and
it's
a
three
bedroom
two
bath.
I
have
a
little
bit
more
square
footage
than
that
house.
N
There's
also
5728
wentworth
sold
for
374.9,
it's
a
three
bedroom
three
bath,
so
one
extra
bathroom
compared
to
me
and
5836
pillsbury
sold
for
378
for
and
that's
a
four
bedroom
two
bath,
so
it
has
another
bedroom.
In
addition,
and
I
in
the
documentation
I
sent,
I
sent
several
comps
in
addition
to
that,
but
redfin
estimated
the
market
value.
When
I
got
the
letter
I
just
went
on
and
they
said,
379
thousand
zillow
said
386
and
realtor.com
said
362.
N
and
then,
in
addition
to
that,
probably
relevant
information
would
be
I'm
really
confused
about
the
basement
square
footage.
Basically,
the
story
with
this
house
is
it.
It
had
been
a
foreclosure
and
the
people
who
lived
in
here
before
were
hoarders.
They
were
animal
hoarders
in
particular,
so
there
was
extensive
damage
to
the
house.
I
didn't
know
that
when
I
bought
the
house,
flippers
had
bought
it
and
they
did
a
what
I
would
say
it
would
be.
N
A
very
mediocre
flip,
so
I
had
a
lot
of
repairs
to
do
that
were
surprise,
repairs
and,
like
the
the
roof
collapsed
in
at
one
point
and
flooded
the
living
room-
and
there
have
been
a
lot
of
when
I
came
in
the
hot
water
heater,
was
broken
and
needed
to
be
replaced.
So
there
have
been
like
I
have
done
some
improvements
to
the
house,
but
a
lot
of
that
like
when
I
talked
to
the
realtors
when
they
wanted
to
evaluate
it.
N
They
said,
unfortunately,
the
improvements
that
you've
made
to
the
house
don't
actually
increase
the
house's
value
and
also
the
square
footage
in
the
basement.
It's
like
it's
there's
no
floor
in
the
basement.
It's
just
exposed
concrete
and
there's
no
ceiling
in
most
of
the
basements
and
my
realtor
was
like.
Oh
they
do
this
thing
where
they
call
it
an
industrial
look,
but
there's
like
no
heating
ducts.
There's
one
heating
duct
in
the
basement,
like
it's,
it's
not
really
finished
and
there's
a
lot
of
square
footage
in
the
basement.
N
That's
accounted
for
in
the
in
the
like
valuation
square
footage,
and
so
it's
it's
kind
of
worthless
space.
So
I
just
I
think
that
affects
the
value
and
then,
in
addition
to
that,
I,
the
heating
in
the
house,
is
really
screwed
up
there.
The
heating
vents
are
extremely
small.
N
There
was
a
period
in
the
50s
where
they
thought
it
was
state
of
the
art
and
it
actually
is
really
problematic,
like
you
have
to
use
space
heaters
in
all
the
bedrooms
and
in
order
to
replace
it,
it
would
be
incredibly
costly
because
there's
asbestos
on
all
of
those
ducts,
so
there's
just
a
lot
about
the
house
that
I
think
isn't
visible
to
the
naked
eye.
But
there's
there's
just
some
liabilities
in
the
house.
I
that
I
think
pull
down
the
value.
G
Yes,
this
is
board
member
palmer.
You,
you
talked
about
the
two
realtors.
You
got
estimates
from.
When
did
you
get
those
estimates?
What
was
it
last
year
or
what
month
was
it.
N
It
was,
it
was
last
year
it
was
in
the
summer.
I
was
looking
through
the
summer
and
the
fall
and-
and
they
gave
me
those
estimates,
then
okay.
B
B
Your
presentation
yep
bye-bye,
okay,
board
members.
You
know
a
bunch
of
cases
that
we
don't
there
are
no
more
call-ins.
Is
that
right.
B
So
I
guess
the
question
is
we
want
to
go
back
to
the
earlier
session,
where
we
did
not
finish
and
then
see
how
much
we
can
get
finished
it
is.
We
should
get
quite
a
bit
finished
before
we
get
to
the
next
session.
So
let's
go
back
to
the
9
30
to
10
30
session,
because
I
believe
we
finished
with
the
8
30
to
9
30.
Didn't
we.
B
Okay,
so
we
have
not
done
oliver
right
and
just
finished
with
harriet.
Is
that
correct?
You
are,
you
are
correct,
all
right.
Okay,
so
is
everybody
there
2
2
0
5,
4,
1,
57
36,
all
of
them.
B
G
So
this
excuse
me
this
applicant
had
an
appraisal
from
december
of
2020
that
came
up
with
700
000
and
I
I
didn't
think
the
comps
were
all
that
bad.
I
didn't
take
a
real
good,
close
look
at
them,
but
they
didn't
seem
terrible,
but
they
are
a
little
dated
they
were.
The
sales
were
from
mid
2020
to
late
2020
and
he
came
up
with
700
000,
so
I
think,
which
just
said
some
bearing
on
it.
If,
if
we
looked
at
at
you
know,
mr
bedearth
we've
looked
at
some
other.
G
These
areas
that
had
six
eight
percent
increases
in
values.
Over
the
year
from
21
to
22.,
I
was
just
looking
at
say,
an
8
increase
which
is
755
000,
so
based
on
the
appraisal
and
just
doing
some
inflation
on
that.
I
I'm
coming
up
with
around
755,
which
would
be
a.
L
B
C
C
B
Chair
bland
hi,
there
are
four
eyes
motion
carries
next,
would
be
3716
39th
avenue
south
case
number,
two,
two
zero
five,
four
two.
G
H
H
H
G
Again,
no
supporting
information,
eight
percent
increase
since
2020
purchase
seems
reasonable.
I'm
recommending
that
we
hold
the
value
at
362,
000.,
okay,.
B
Okay,
it's
been
moved
by
plumber
and
seconded
by
vedirtha
to
maintain
the
value
at
719
quincy
street
at
362.
E
C
L
G
Bedertha,
I
think
the
condition
was
average.
The
quality
was
fair
because
I
looked
at
the
same
thing
so
he's
saying
average
condition
I
stand
corrected.
Thank
you
don.
I'm
just
going
to
ask
fate.
I
mean
she.
They
have
this
green
porch,
which
is
usable
there.
No
it's
more
than
a
screen.
Poor
sound
like
three
plus
season,
but.
G
Yeah,
but
even
that's
another
100
square
feet
makes
it
bigger,
but
I
most
of
the
comps
are
six
seven
eight
hundred
square
feet.
I
mean
this
is
smallest
footprint
house.
I've
ever
seen
to
be
honest
with
you,
so.
B
Yeah
it's
hard
to
find
one
bedroom
houses
anywhere
and
then
it's
hard
to
find
comps
to
come
up
with
a
reasonable
price.
It
struck
me
that
the
amount
here
seemed
a
little
bit
high.
I
mean
it's
a
great
area,
so
that's
going
to
bring
certainly
a
better
price
for
people
who
can
can
only
afford
that
much
in
that
neighborhood,
but
it
does
seem
a
little
bit
strong.
B
G
L
I
personally
think
that's
a
little
a
little
strong
for
this
property.
So
that's
why
I'm
hesitating
on
seconding
that
I
can
second
it
so
we
can
move
along
and
I
we
can
discuss
it.
I
guess.
L
You
said
230
yep,
I'm
thinking
more
in
the
range
of
210.
Well,
last
year's
value
was
213.
I'll
recommend.
Last
year's
value
at
213,
000.
B
Okay,
it's
been
moved
by
is
that
mr
palmer.
G
Yeah
I'll
I'll
withdraw
my
my
okay
offer,
then
we'll
listen
to
entertain
steve's.
B
Had
it
been
moved
by
the
dertha
and
seconded
by
amba
to
reduce
the
value
to
213
000.,
could
you
please
call
the
wall
board
member
amba,
I'm
board
member
bedertha.
F
C
B
L
G
I
just
the
only
thing
I
saw
was
for
this
neighborhood.
I
think
it's
nice,
but
it's
it's
south
southeast
neighborhood.
So
it's
not
a
southwest
neighborhood
and
it's
on
at
323
dollars
a
square
foot
for
about
a
thousand
square
foot
house
which
most
of
the
stuff
we've
seen
is
plus
or
minus
300
or
under
300
than
the
few
comps
or
what
the
other
ones
we
talked
about.
So
I
thought,
even
though
there
was
a
lot
of
information,
I
thought
that
might
warrant
a
slight
reduction.
B
G
I'm
gonna
I'll.
How
much
should
we
reduce
the
value
to
290
000.
B
It's
been
moved
by
palmer
and
seconded
by
amba
to
reduce
the
value
for
3252
32nd
avenue
cell
to
290
thousand
clerk.
Would
you
please
call
the
roll
board
member
amba
aye
board
member
bedertha.
C
C
B
Next,
we
have
one
two
three
second
street
north
page
number
22-0546.
F
B
T
C
L
My
first
comment
on
this
one
is
that
we've
in
a
previous
discussion
earlier
today,
we
we
lowered
the
next
door
neighbor
from
935
to
850
000
that
had
a
similar
property
and
he,
the
appellant
in
this
case,
did
bring
up
the
neighboring
properties,
which
one
of
them
was
3840
grand
the
one
we've
already
acted
on,
so
I
just
want
to
make
bring
that
up
as
a
as
a
point
yeah
to
start
discussion,
I
guess.
F
L
G
And
there
I
I
I
promise
those
boilings
are
almost
identical:
there's
a
couple
of
them
in
a
row
down
there.
So
normally
I
would
say
we
let
it
go,
but
we've
reacted
on
something
that
was
almost
identical
and
there's
not
a
lot
of
data.
But
what
was
the
value
last
year?
Let
me
look
a
second
768,
so
it's
still
a
large
increase.
I
guess
I
would
look
at
going
to
850
on
this
one
as
well.
B
C
C
B
B
So
let's
proceed
to
take
care
of
some
of
these
in
the
10
30
to
11
30
session
they're,
all
with
you
there
and
if
I'm
right
our
next
one
would
be
item
number
29
case
number
220548
at
58,
41
42nd
avenue
is
that
correct.
G
L
G
L
Yeah
this
repellent
this
appellant
didn't,
provide
anything
and
didn't
even
give
us
a
not
that
they
had
to
a
suggestion
on
what
value
they
preferred.
They
left
that
blank.
So
I
I'm
just
gonna
move
that
we
hold
the
value
at
257
000
for
this
year.
F
B
Okay,
it's
been
moved
by
the
and
seconded
by
palmer
to
sustain
the
vet.
Did
we
sustain
the
value.
E
L
C
B
Chair
planned
by
there
are
four
eyes:
motion
carriers.
Okay,
so
is
our
next
item
2727
johnson.
G
L
It
could
have
been
two
sellers
tenants
and.
G
Yeah,
I
could
be
a
partnership
of
two
companies
or
llc's,
or
something
like
that.
So
I
mean
if
that,
if
that's
a
good
sales,
you
can
talk
to
the
guy
if
it's
listed
and
marketed,
and
that's
that's
that
that
would
be
a
good
indication.
But
it's
I
don't
know
it's
hard
to
say.
Is
there
any
hail
on
hair
on
that
sale
is
a
good
sale.
L
Right,
we
just
don't
have
I
I
prefer
to
ask
the
appellant
some
of
those
questions
about
the
sale,
because
we
know
there's,
there
can
be
all
kinds
of
things
that
happen
and
why
people
get
a
hold
of
properties
outside
the
market
and
that
sort
of
thing,
so
I
don't
feel
comfortable
in
reducing
it
to
that
value
and
they
always
have
a
chance
to
take
this
to
a
further
review
and
bring
up
that
information.
I
would
say
so
for
me,
I'm
going
to
propose
that
we
sustain
the
value
of
284
000.
G
B
C
C
B
Chair
planned
hi,
there
are
four
eyes:
motion
carries
okay.
Our
next
case
is
5649
43rd
avenue
south
case
number,
22-050.
G
As
I
recall,
as
mr
shibanski
was
on
the
line,
but
he
didn't
really
help
us
out
supporting
comparable
data
or
whatever
he
even
cited.
I
don't
know
if
they're
comparable
was
from
2019.
G
It
was
an
11
increase,
which
I
slightly
on
the
high
side,
but
it's
in
the
ballpark.
So
I
I
guess-
and
it
also
noticed
that
this
building
condition
was
average
plus
a
1931
building.
So
I
I
don't
see
any
data
to
really
support
any
change
in
the
value.
B
All
right,
moved
by
palmer,
is
seconded
by
amba
to
sustain
the
value
at
5649,
43rd
avenue
south
case
number
22-0550.
L
The
pillar
didn't
give
us
much
to
go
on
other
than
a
few
pictures
of
his
property
or
his
bathroom
and
some
kitchen
pictures.
He
wasn't
asking
much.
The
property
didn't
go
up
very
much
went
from
526
thousand
to
545
and
he
was
asking
for
520.,
but
without
any
comps
or
anything.
I
recommend
I
move
to
sustain
the
value.
B
L
C
B
Okay,
now
we
have,
I
think,
five
one,
two,
three,
four,
five
from
the
same
applicant
they're,
all
on
27th
and
28th
in
xerxes
I'll
begin
with
2797
xerxes
avenue
south
case
number,
two:
two:
zero:
five,
five,
nine.
G
So
I'll
just
make
a
comment
in
that
I'm
familiar
again
we're
back
on
that
27
to
20
xerxes
pay
where
there's
a
lot
of
these
buildings
in
a
row,
and
we
had
the
guy
previously,
who
bought
a
package
of
these
from
the
same
owner.
This
jerry
chester
he's
owned
those
properties
for
years.
I
don't
know
why
he
didn't
sell
these.
I
I
think
they're
very
similar,
but.
G
Yeah,
without
any
data
I
mean
I
don't
know,
are
they
dated,
or
I
mean
it's
a
great
location
but
there's
no
rents
and
I
did
the
numbers
and
signed
at
160
000
a
unit
for
these
six
units,
and
that
was
in
the
ballpark
of
what
all
those
other
ones
were
funds
for.
So
without
anything
further
information.
I
would
just
vote
that
we
hold
the
value.
L
And
I
I
I'd
like
to
comment
too,
that
he
they
mentioned
in
their
narrative
that
that
there
was
a
sale
in
january
of
2022,
but
they
don't
mention
numbers
anywhere.
They
just
talk
about
that
this
building,
they
request
a
value
adjustment
based
on
the
january
2022
sale
of
this
particular
building.
So
I
agree
with
don
that
it
was
yours,
a
move.
Did
you
moved
on
to
no.
G
But
now
that
you
mentioned
it,
he
we
were
very
confused
because
he
only
he
only
filed
on
five
of
the
six
that
were
part
of
that
sale
last
time
and
it,
and
it
was
very
hard
to
make
sense
of
all
the
numbers
and
why
they
didn't
appeal
all
six.
Maybe
this
was
the
sixth
one
I
don't
know
but,
like
you
said,
it
really
doesn't
spell
anything
out.
So
I'll
move
that
we
hold
the
value
at
963,
300.
B
It
was
moved
by
palmer
seconded
by
both
pedersa
to
sustain
the
value
at
xerxes
avenue.
South
case
number,
two:
two:
zero:
five:
five,
nine
clerk.
Would
you
please
call
the
roll
board
member
amba
aye
board
member
bedertha,
hey
board
member
palmer.
C
B
Chair
blind,
there
are
four
eyes
motion
carries
it
is
15.
After
11
we
have
four
more
xerxes
properties.
I
would
suggest
that
we
knock
those
off
take
a
break.
Come
back.
Is
everybody
with
me
on
that
because
I
think
we
can
kind
of
quickly
move
on
the
information
was
pretty
much
the
same
for
all
five
of
them.
G
G
Comment
here:
is
it
similar
this
11
unit,
building
it's
bigger
than
the
other
ones,
but
it's
on
147
000
units
he's
got
the
same
comments
before
sale
of
this
building.
I
I
don't
see
to
sell
this
building,
it's
very
confusing.
I
think
he
just
copied
the
comments
off
for
every
one
of
these
buildings,
so
I'm
gonna
suggest
we
hold
the
value
at
one
million.
Six
hundred
fifteen
thousand.
B
A
second
all
right,
moved
by
a
polymer
seconded
by
bedertha
to
sustain
the
value
at
2780,
xerxes
avenue
south
case
number,
22-0561.
J
B
Board
member
bob
chairbland
hi,
there
are
four
eyes
both
theories.
I
know
I
skipped
we
have
to
go
back
one.
I
skipped
2811
xerxes
avenue
south
case
number,
two:
two
dash
zero
six
2
2
0
5,
6
0.
G
H
H
B
B
B
C
C
B
G
This
is
very
similar
to
the
other
six
unit,
which
was
on
for
just
a
little
more
than
this
again
no
data
150
000
unit.
I
move.
We
sustain
the
value
at
900,
000.
L
C
B
Chair
bland
aye,
there
are
four
eyes
motion
carries
okay,
we
have
20.
After
when
we
come
back.
We
will.
We
have
callers
on
the
line
for
the
next
segment.
So
we'll
probably.
G
C
C
B
Chair
planned
hi,
there
are
four
eyes:
motion
carries
okay,
we
do
have
callers
on
the
line
for
the
11
30
to
12
30
segments,
so
we'll
take
a
break
until
11,
30
and
we'll
come
back
and
we'll
be
dealing
with
those
segments
we
almost
got
through
with
this.
This
I
will
come
back
to
them
later.
See
you
in
10
minutes.
D
B
B
So
tell
me:
do
we
have
colors
on
the
line?
I
believe
that
we
do.
D
U
Okay
hi,
my
name
is
matt
levitt
and
I'm
a
homeowner
at
3949,
30th
avenue
south.
I
live
there
with
my
wife
of
16
years
and
my
senior
young
daughters,
age,
2
and
10..
We
love
living
in
minneapolis.
We've
lived
at
our
current
house
for
a
little
little
over
seven
years
to
eight
years.
I
can't
really
recall
at
this
point,
but
at
any
rate
we
went
through
a
refinance
process
to
take
advantage
of
the
low
interest
rates
and,
as
part
of
that,
we
had
our
home
assessed
for
the
refinance
and
the
supporting
documentation.
U
That
was
part
of
that
is
kind
of
the
bulk
of
my
case.
The
primary
concern
being
you
know,
with
covid
and
now
high
inflation,
we're
concerned
about
the
valuation
of
the
property,
as
it
relates
to
our
independent
valuation
being
far
lower
than
the
city's
estimation
of
our
property's
worth
and
what
that
might
do
to
our
both
our
homeowner
exclusion
and
our
tax
burden.
U
But
but
more
importantly,
just
you
know
at
the
end
of
the
day
getting
a
fair
evaluation
for
the
property,
because
the
reality
is
we're
having
a
lot
of
new
home
construction
going
up
in
our
in
our
neighborhood.
Where
you
know,
people
will
buy
up
the
property
completely,
raise
the
property
and
build
a
brand
new
construction
home.
That
you'd
find
in
the
suburbs
and
are
you
know,
routinely
selling
those
for
300
plus
thousand
dollars
as
part
of
our
evaluation
from
jnr
appraisals?
U
Our
property
value
came
back
at
the
estimated
valuation
of
265,
so
that's
quite
a
bit
lower
than
the
city's
estimation
proposed,
for
I
think
320
000.,
I'm
in
my
car
at
work.
So
I
don't
have
those
numbers
directly
in
front
of
me,
but
they
did
a
comparable
valuation
of
52
properties
in
our
neighborhood
in
2021
when
the
refinance
was
completed
and
the
range
of
sale
properties
was
242
to
295.
U
So
even
that
is
well
below
where
the
city
estimates
our
current
valuation
is
so
just
want
to
be
mindful
of
that-
and
this
is
my
first
time
going
through
this
process,
but
I
thought
it
was
worthwhile
to
pursue
being
that
we
just
went
through
this
valuation
process
and
feel
like
there
was
quite
a
large
discrepancy
between
where
our
property
was
valued
by
the
credit
union's
appraisers
versus
where
the
city
values-
and
you
know
no
one
from
the
city
has
been
internally
to
walk
our
property.
U
The
independent
appraisers
did
do
a
walk
through
and
took
photos,
and
I
think
that's
all
included
there
too.
So
that's
pretty
much.
All
I
have
would
happen
to
answer
questions.
If
anybody
has
any.
G
Just
one
question
board
member
palmer:
we
did
get
the
appraisal.
I
appreciate
that
I
have
a
question
of
description
of
improvements.
10
000
for
new
bath
shower
plumbing
retiling
and
6
000
for
new
furnace
was
that
just
since
you
bought
it
or
was
that,
before
or
after
the
appraisal
was
done,.
U
The
ten
thousand
dollar
shower
was
before
the
appraisal
was
done.
The
six
thousand
new
furnace
was
since
that
appraisal.
So
really
I
mean
yeah,
so
that
appraisal
was
done
in
the
summer
of
21
and
our
new
furnace
went
in
in
the
fall
of
21.
B
B
Welcome,
who
is
our
next
caller
on
the
line.
X
Okay,
so
the
reason
that
I'm
disputing
the
valuation
is
based
solely
on
property
sold
within
the
the
past
three
months
in
the
immediate
vicinity
of
my
home,
the
square
footage,
the
the
bedrooms,
the
condition
of
the
property
all
were
considered
when
disputing
the
evaluation-
and
I
have
three
properties
listed
here-
that
I
actually
want
you
to
reference-
there
is
one
that's
listed
at
2514,
aldrich
avenue,
north
the
square
footage
is
there's
a
little
bit
more
than
mine
and
it's
the
three
bedroom
two
bath
property.
X
Although
my
property
was
fraudulently
listed
as
four
bedrooms,
four
baths,
the
equivalent
of
the
bathrooms
that
are
up
and
running
is
two.
I
believe
it's
two
and
a
half
baths.
There
is
a.
There
is
another
bathroom
that
was
attempted
to
be
built,
but
it's
functional.
I
wouldn't
put
any
real
value
on
it.
I
did
submit
photos
to
ronda
because
I
was
not
able
to
upload
them
because
of
the
size
of
the
file.
X
Okay,
so
yeah
rhonda
olsen
should
have
them.
I
was
not
able
to
upload
them,
so,
yes,
the
bathroom
again,
the
bathroom
is
functional,
but
I
wouldn't
put
any
real
value
on
it.
It
was
poorly
constructed.
Also,
the
bedroom
that
was
listed
is
again.
It
was
an
attempt
at
building
a
bedroom,
there's
no
ventilation,
it's
poorly
constructed
as
well.
So
if
we
were
going
to
place
a
value
on
the
property,
then
it
should
be,
it
should
be
placed
slowly
on
three
bedroom
two
and
two
and
a
half
bath
room.
X
And
there
are
two
other
properties
in
the
media,
definitive
that
I
took
a
look
at
as
well
approximately
same
square
footage,
bedroom
bath,
there's
a
property
that
was
sold
on
march
18th
and
it
was
again
approximately
same
square
footage
that
sold
for
about.
I
have
the
numbers
here:
I'm
just
gonna
take
a
look.
X
The
23-19
yep
206,
which
is
right
up
the
street
from
my
home,
well,
not
on
the
same
block,
so
a
couple
of
houses
down
another
comparable
property
would
be
the
one
on
twenty
percent
bryant.
X
That
was
four
bed
two
bath
more
square
footage
and
that
was
sold
for
216
216.5.
X
X
To
conclude,
just
just
you
know
just
to
three
properties
in
the
media
facility
of
my
home,
approximately
thanks
for
footage,
same
bad
bad,
so
significantly
significantly
lower
than
what
my
home
is
currently
valued
at
and
as
and
another
thing
is
that
an
assessor
has
not
been
out
here
to
to
view
the
property.
Since
I
moved
in.
X
B
Property,
thank
you
board
members.
You
have
questions
for
this
applicant.
G
Yeah
hi:
this
is
board
member
palmer.
I
just
know
you
have
the
cost
of
improvements
you
put
central
air
in
for
4100
was
that
before
was
that
after
the
sale
of
2019
after
you
purchased.
G
Okay,
okay
and
then
you
say
in
the
basement:
the
accessory
has
one
bedroom
and
a
three-quarter
bath.
Is
it
a?
Is
there
a
shower
in
that
bath
or
is
it
just
a
half
bath.
X
So
it
is
a
shower
to
bath
a
shower
in
the
bath.
However,
again
the
way
it's
constructed,
I
mean,
if
you
put
value
on
it,
I
wouldn't
put
much
value,
it's
not
something
that
I
would
use
it
is
being
used
or
has
been
used,
but
it's
not
something.
You
know
as
a
woman
that
I
would
go
down
there
and
you
know
and
consider
using
so
again
the
it's
something
that
they
just
simply
threw
up.
You
know
call
it
a
bass,
it's
rust
down
there
mold
I
mean
no.
X
I
don't
think
it's
mold
brushed
yeah.
Again,
it's
poorly
constructed,
similar
to
the
bit
the
bedroom.
Again,
I
wouldn't
call
it
a
bedroom.
There's
no
ventilation
down
there.
X
There
was
an
attempt
to
to
show
that
there
was
ventilation,
but
actually
I
was
considering
having
worked
down
there
recently
here
within
the
last
two
months
and
the
contractor
noticed
that
there
was
no
heat
or
air.
You
know
coming
to
the
basement,
and
so,
although
it
shows
that
there
are
vents,
there's
nothing
you
know
there's
nothing
coming
through
of
it.
G
G
You
bought
the
property
in
2019
was
that
listed
with
a
real
estate
broker.
X
G
X
L
X
You
know
what
that's
a
good
question
I
did
not.
I
did
not
take
that
into
consideration
when
I
was
looking
at
it,
so
that
that's
a
good
question.
That
would
be
something
that
I
mean.
I
guess
I
can
supply
in
a
later
date,
some
information.
Otherwise
you
I
mean
I
found
it
on
realtor.com,
so
the
information.
B
Okay,
miss
williams.
Thank
you
very
much
for
your
presentation.
We
will
make
a
decision
and
you'll
be
notified
by
mail.
O
Okay,
thank
you.
My
name
is
jeff
ellis,
I'm
at
4230
pleasant,
avenue
south
in
minneapolis.
I've
lived
in
indianapolis
for
over
20
years.
I
did
have
the
opportunity
in
2018,
where
connie
ferguson
did
come
out
and
appraise
my
home.
She
rated
the
home
as
average.
I
have
attached
her
appraiser
notes
from
back.
Then
there
have
been
no
updates
to
my
home
since
2018..
O
She
was
not
able
to
come
out
to
conduct
another
appraisal
of
my
home,
but
she
did
advise
me
to
go
back
and
look
at
the
sales
that
occurred
in
2021
and
to
look
at
some
of
the
comparables
and
as
that's,
what
the
2023
values
are
based
on.
So
what
I
did
was
I
did
attach
an
excel
file
and
a
couple
parameters.
Obviously
my
home
is
1152
square
feet.
It's
a
three-bedroom
one-bath
home.
O
O
As
you
can
see,
the
highest
home
value
that
I
pulled
up
was
370
000,
that
was
a
home
and
4100
blazedale.
It's
a
three-bedroom,
two-bath
home.
I
did
note
some
additional
notes
in
my
xbox
excel
spreadsheet.
O
This
particular
home
has
a
fireplace
mine
does
not.
It
obviously
has
a
two-car
garage,
two
baths
versus
one
bath.
That's
on
the
city
record,
so
I
did
go
into
the
sales
within
realtor.com
to
pull
up
the
information.
O
If
there
were
any
discrepancies
with
what
was
on
the
city
records
versus
what
was
on
the
sale
price,
you
can
see
that
there
was
another
home
at
37.07,
probably
the
most
comparable
home,
but
it
does
have
a
two-car
garage.
I
only
have
a
one-car
garage
and
that's
a
three-bedroom
one-bath
home.
That's
at
3707
blazedale.
O
There
was
a
home
at
4119,
unpleasant
that
sold
for
350
000,
slightly
more
square
footage,
1422
square
feet
versus
my
1152
square
feet,
additional
bathroom
in
that
particular
home.
It
has
two
baths
and
the
city
records
there
listed
the
home
as
eleven
hundred
and
thirty
eight
square
feet
when
in
actuality
is
fourteen
hundred
and
twenty
two.
In
addition,
there
were
major
upgrades
on
the
property
in
the
kitchen
in
the
bath
area.
O
So
in
lieu
of
this-
and
I
looked
at
so
my
home-
was
the
value
in
2022
was
326
000..
The
proposed
value
for
2023
is
375
000,
that's
an
increase
of
49
000..
O
I
looked
at
some
of
the
other
homes
in
my
neighborhood
relative
to.
If
what
the
increases
were.
There's
a
home,
that's
kitty,
corner
across
the
street.
From
me
there,
their
2023
value
is
343
000,
it's
a
three-bedroom,
two-bath
home
1700
square
feet.
O
B
E
B
A
P
P
I
have
seen
an
increase
in
the
estimated
market
value
that
far
exceeds
other
increases
throughout
hennepin
county.
The
proposed
emd
for
this
year
is
346
000
since
owning
the
property.
That
would
mean
that
it's
been
a
60
percent
increase
in
value
and
my
tax
increase,
excluding
special
assessments,
has
also
been
pretty
significant,
which
has
been
a
30
increase
since
original
ownership.
P
When
I
did
some
research
on
what
is
the
norm
in
hennepin
county,
it
looks
like
property
values
have
increased
roughly
17
percent
over
the
last
five
years,
and
I
guess
that's
concerning
to
me
with
the
increases
that
I've
seen
speaking
from
last
year
to
this
year,
the
estimated
market
value
was
301,
000
and
what's
being
proposed
on
the
property
without
any
type
of
increase
in
value,
or
I
should
say,
any
type
of
improvements
to
the
home
is
346
thousand
dollars.
P
So
that's
about
a
five
thousand
dollar
annual
increase,
which
is
far
above
what,
when
you
look
at
medium
home
sales,
it's
roughly
three
point,
two
percent,
so
what
I
did
is
I
pulled
up
recent
sales
specific
to
the
armamented
fermented
area
and
much
like
a
previous
color
on
the
line.
We
do
have
some
remodeling
being
done
where
homes
are
being
torn
down
and
rebuilt,
and
things
like
that.
P
It
is
now
a
three
bedroom
two
bath
home,
but
we
have
a
single
car
garage,
so
there
weren't
exact,
comps
but
give
and
take
type
comps
where
you
know
others
had
a
two
car
garage
where
I
have
a
single
car
garage.
Others
had
you
know
one
bath
or
and
four
bedrooms,
and
things
like
that,
so
my
biggest
concern
is
the
percentage
of
increase,
that's
being
proposed,
with
no
improvements
to
our
home
to
the
home.
There
was
a
previous
increase
that
was
very
comparable
back
in
2000.
P
P
G
Hi,
this
is
board
member
palmer.
I
just
a
comment
would
be
when
we
look
at
your
property,
we
wouldn't
look
at
the
whole
hennepin
county
area
or
whatever
it's
more
you,
the
assessor,
has
to
zone
into
what's
happening
in
your
neighborhood
or
whatever,
and
we'll
take
a
look
at
that,
but
to
cite
values
well,
all
of
hennepin
county
went
up
x
or
whatever
is
not
it's
too
broad,
too
broad
of
brush.
Let's
put
it
that
way,.
P
And
I
did
in
to
support
you
know
my
concern
with
my
neighborhood.
Specifically.
As
I
mentioned
there
are.
You
know,
remodels
happening
that
I
think
are
causing
the
home
sale
prices
to
be
skewed
some.
So
when
I
looked
at
homes
that
sold
that
were
comparable
to
my
property,
it
supports
my
concern
in
the
last
year
for
homes
that
were
comparable
to
my
property.
P
You
know,
I
think,
the
lowest
range,
one
that
I
found
was
250
000.
I
didn't
feel
that
that
was
a
fair
comparison,
but
there
were
many
that
had
sold
for
under
350
000,
which
is
where
my
property
is
being
validated.
B
Okay,
thank
you
so
much
for
your
presentation.
We
will
be
making
a
decision
and
you
will
be
notified
by
mail.
B
I
noticed
it
looks
like
we
have
another
caller
on
the
line.
Am
I
correct.
D
Yes,
madam
chair,
we
have
been
joined
by
another
caller
next
in
queue,
however,
is
the
property
at
5202
elliott,
avenue
case
number
220581,
please
press
star,
6
to
unmute
your
telephone
and
state.
Your
name
and
address
you'll
be
given
5
minutes
to
present
to
the
board.
M
Good
morning,
everyone,
my
name,
is
sam
carlson
and
I
live
at
5202
elliott.
Can
you
all
hear
me.
M
All
right:
well,
I
purchased
this
home
in
2016..
I
just
moved
back
from
the
marine
corps
and
this
is
my
first
home,
so
I
apologize
in
advance.
This
is
my
first
time
going
through
this
process,
so
I
might
be
a
little
clunky,
but
I
did
when
I
created
the
claim
here.
I
I
didn't
have
a
document
to
upload
into
the
website,
but
I
did
email
the
document,
so
I'm
hoping
people
got
that
if
not
I'll
go
through
the
list
of
comparable
multi-family
home
purchases
in
the
area
that
I
was
able
to
find.
M
M
M
M
I
bought
it
for
250
000
in
2016
october
2016..
So
since
then,
just
looking
at
the
2022
value,
valuation
estimate
is
up
to
546
thousand,
so
that's
118
percent
value
increase
since
2016.
M
M
I
I've
got
16
of
them
listed
off
here
that
I
found
that
I
thought
were
comparable
in
size,
they're
all
multi-family
homes.
They
all
have
at
least
four
bedrooms,
two
bathrooms
and
similar
and
square
footage
and
similar
as
far
as
when
they
were
built.
Many
of
them
were
actually
newer.
M
Some
of
them
are
newer.
Some
of
them
are
slightly
older,
but
but
all
you
know
my
house
was
built
in
1931.,
so
they're
all
relatively
comparable,
so
I've
got
860th
street
we've
got
4156,
19th
avenue,
6029,
portland,
avenue,
4700,
pillsbury,
avenue,
4613,
garfield,
avenue,
800
east
60th
street
might
have
already
said
that
one
5132
bloomington
avenue
4625
cedar
avenue,
3128
32nd
avenue,
4300,
cedar,
avenue,
6029,
portland,
avenue,
5801,
flysdale,
avenue,
415,
8th
avenue
and
3645
fourth
avenue
3652,
wisedell
and
3237
third
avenue.
M
So
these
are
all
you
know
within,
I
would
say,
within
a
a
less
than
five
mile
radius
of
my
house.
Most
of
these
are
are
very
close
in
in
the
hale
neighborhood
area
rock
pearl
park,
nicole,
miss
so
they're
all
local
and
all
of
these
were
at
500,
000
or
below,
and,
like
I
said
when
I
looked
at
these,
I
was
looking
at
the
you
know,
both
the
exterior
interior
of
the
home
and
what
the
condition
was.
M
Whereas
I
think
you
know
you
can
find
other
homes
that
are
the
same
square
footage
in
size
as
mine,
but
the
inside
has
been
completely
redone.
You
know,
there's
been
a
lot
of
maintenance
and
upkeep.
That's
been
done
that
hasn't
been
done
on
this,
this
house,
so
anyways.
I
I
as
someone
who
you
know
I
live
here.
This
is
my
home.
I
pay
taxes
here
in
minneapolis.
This
is
you
know
where
I
want
to
stay.
M
M
You
know
the
valuation.
The
assessment
in
2021
was
at
468
000.,
so
from
2021
to
2022
it's
a
76.
You
know
78
000
hike
in
in
value.
So
that's
a
that's
a
substantial
hike
as
well,
just
just
in
the
last
year,
let
alone
since
2016..
So
those
are
my
concerns
and
those
are
the
comparable
houses.
Recent
sales
that
I
was
able
to
find
I'm
happy
to
answer
any
questions
that
people
have.
G
G
G
Okay,
and
the
only
other
thing
I
note,
is
that
you've
gotta
your
lots,
a
little
larger
than
than
the
standard
lot
was
that
correct.
G
I'm
sorry
yeah
yours
about
8
000
square
feet.
A
typical
minute
block
here
is
about
5200
or
5500,
so
I
just
want
to
make
that
point
so.
Okay,
thank
you.
Thank.
B
Thank
you,
it
looks
like
we
have
another
caller
on
the
line.
Is
that
correct.
D
Madam
chair,
that's
one
of
the
board
members
that
had
to
call
in
who's
having
technical
difficulties.
So
we
have
one
one
remaining
caller
on
the
line
for
the
property
at
2511,
lindell
avenue
south
case
number
220570,
please
press
star,
six
to
unmute
your
phone
and
state
your
name
and
address
and
you'll
be
given
five
minutes
to
present
to
the
board.
B
D
Madam
chair,
I
did
put
in
the
chat
the
call-in
info
in
case.
That
was
the
case
for
the
other
board
member
as
well.
So
if
we
lose,
you
you'll
need
to
call
call
in
on
your
telephone,
and
I
did
have
that
information
with
your
materials
today
on
the
front
page.
B
All
right
this
indicates,
I
have
about
an
actually
have
about
an
hour
left.
J
B
Q
S
My
name
is
charles
machosek,
I'm
the
owner
of
2511
lindale
avenue
south
four,
two
bedrooms,
one
bath,
one
one
bedroom
in
the
basement.
I
do
not
believe
the
evaluation
is
right.
At
7.95
it
went
from
661.
S
S
Really
I
had
a
realtor
evaluated
from
marcus
and
milchamp
that
looked
at
the
numbers,
the
conditions,
the
market
value,
which
I
did
not
submit
because
the
assessor
said
he
would
use
his
own
stuff.
But
I
haven't
enclosed
this
letter
with
a
broker
opinion
of
value.
The
building
located
at
2511
lindeal,
based
on
market
trends,
interest
rates,
current
rental
rates
and
overall
condition
of
the
assets
is
our
estimate
that
the
building
is
valued
at
690
000.
F
S
S
We
have
one
unit
at
490
square
feet.
That's
805
includes
utilities.
S
One
bath
we're
getting
1175.
S
S
S
Remodeled
buildings
they're
getting
close
to
double
that.
G
S
Have
you
done
tonight?
We've
had
a
turnover,
it's
been
four
to
six
months
before
we
could
fill
it
again,
and
so
we
can't
really
raise
them
with
what
it
is
to
what
other
people
are
getting
in
the
area.
This
is
an
unrenovated
building,
the
last
time
that
leo
montez
looked
at
it
the
assessor.
He
lowered
the
value
that
was
about
three
years
ago.
G
S
Point
in
time,
they're
original
they
have
the
original
cabinets,
some
have
the
wall
sinks
original
all
the
tubs
are
original.
The
fixtures
on
the
thing
are
original
114
years
old.
B
B
B
G
I'd
like
to
interject
something
my
computer
also
says
it's
going
to
restart
in
says.
27
minutes
now.
Do
all
your
board
members
have
that
that
it's
gonna
restart.
D
B
Okay,
what
is
what
would
be
the
calling
number.
G
As
long
as
we
got
a
break
here,
I
would
love
to
just
restart
and
then
yeah
then,
and
then
how
long
will
that
take
a
few
minutes
for
you
to
redo
that
you
think.
D
B
When
we
see
you
back
in
the
meeting
yeah,
why
don't
we
go
ahead
and
break
we'll?
Take
15
minutes
come
back
at
11,
30.
and
restart
your
computers.
D
F
F
G
B
H
F
D
Vice
chair
bedertha,
we
only
have
two
of
the
four
members
are
in
attendance.
Currently
I'm
trying
to
reach
out
to
the
chair,
but
I've
been
unsuccessful
in
reaching
her.
Do
you
wish
me
to
continue
trying
to
get
her
into
the
meeting.
L
I
prefer
that
I'm
I
have
until
I
get
my
cataract,
I
I
can
hardly
see
much
or
to
even
follow
a
script
or
anything,
so
I
would
prefer
that.
B
Are
the
board
members
back
all
right,
chair,
bland
members
of
the
board?
The
time
is
now
12
32
and
I
will
call
the
role
to
verify
the
presence
of
a
quorum
board.
Member
amba
board
member
bedertha,
listen
board,
member
palmer
president
and
chair
bland
president.
There
are
three
members
present,
but
the
record
reflected
we
have
a
quorum.
B
Okay,
I
it
appears
we
have
at
least
one
caller
on
the
line.
Is
that
correct.
D
Madam
chair
welcome
back
to
the
meeting.
Yes,
we
have
two
callers
on
the
line.
The
first
case
would
be
the
property
is
at
605,
ramsey
street
northeast
case
number,
220584.
B
D
D
B
I'm
assuming
we're
ready
to
go
all
right,
mr
hughes
and
love.
Are
you
on
the
line.
Z
Okay,
thank
you,
madam
chair.
Thank
you
board
for
your
time
here.
So
this
is
a
single
family
home
and
there's
no
renovation
since
I
purchased
it
in
2018
the
salient
facts
I
believe
I
provided
in
the
letter
I
submitted.
So
hopefully
you
have
that
letter
and
all
the
exhibits
to
that
letter
which
which,
which
will
write
all
the
details.
But
what
I'd
like
to
highlight
for
you
on
this
call
is
that
when
I
purchased
the
house
in
2018.
Z
It
had
an
assessment
over
a
million
dollars
and
I
purchased
it
for
eight
hundred
and
nine
thousand
dollars.
So
at
that
point
in
time
it
was
overassessed
by
about
228
thousand
dollars,
and
so
I
went
to
the
tax
court
in
2019.
You
can
see
an
exhibit.
Z
I
think
and-
and
I
believe
this
year,
the
same
thing
has
happened,
although
it's
not
as
much
it's
it's
increased
since
last
year
by
98
000,
which
is
an
11.5
increase
over
last
year,
and
I
I
think
I
had
an
independent
appraiser
come
and
appraise
the
house,
and
that
appraisal
was
a
850
000,
which
I
think
is
reasonable
and
what
I
think
the
value
of
the
property
should
be
for
2023
tax
purposes.
Z
I've
provided
that
appraisal,
as
exhibit
h
to
the
letter
here,
and
I
think
the
the
assessor
does
a
good
job
of
explaining.
I
think
why
this
house
seems
to
get
continually
over
assessed,
and
it's
because
you
know
the
the
as
the
appraiser
states
at
page
six.
Z
Maybe
300
000
the
one
immediately
next
door
just
sold
last
year
for
over
four
hundred
thousand
dollars
less
than
what
the
the
city
is
currently
assessing
this
property
for
this
year,
and
so
I
think
you
know
the
this.
Ninety
eight
thousand
000
increase
from
last
year.
This
that's
more
than
11
percent
increase,
I
think,
is-
is
just
not
reasonable.
Z
Given
the
house,
given
the
history
of
over
assessment
and
given
the
the
appraisal
that
I
had
just
done
last
month,
that
that
states
that
the
house
should
is
is
more
like
850
000
of
value,
and
that's
all
I
have
to
say.
If
there
are
any
questions,
I'd
be
happy
to
answer
them.
G
Yeah
hi,
this
is
board
member
palmer.
I
guess
one
thing
I
would
comment.
I
I,
after
looking
at
pictures
of
the
house
and
location,
I
would
agree
it's
it's
a
unique
house.
It's
a
beautiful
house,
it's
built
in
2008.
I
don't
think
there's
a
lot
of
houses
around
there
built
at
the
same
time
and,
to
my
mind
it's
on
a
unique
lot:
it's
on
the
corner
of
ramsey
and
and
right
across
from
that
boom
island
park.
So
those
are
all
positives,
but
it
makes
it
hard
to.
G
You
know,
compare
to
anything
in
the
neighborhood,
so
you
did
have
an
appraisal.
The
reappraisal
done
and
I
don't
have
the
date
I
lost
the
page.
Was
it
in
2020
or
was
it
just
recently.
Z
No,
I
wanted
to
get.
I
wanted
to
really
understand
what
the
market
value,
what
what
they
think
that
I
could
sell
the
house
for,
because
I
myself
am
actually
wary
about.
You
know
getting
getting
the
value
out
of
it
that
I
actually
purchased
it
for
so
I
wanted
to
know
what
the
mark,
what
what
an
objective
value
for
the
house
was.
G
Right
so
my
only
comment
there
would
be
because
of
the
nature
of
that
house.
In
in
the
location
I
mean
the
appraiser's
got,
I'm
assuming
the
best
comps
he
has,
but
they're
just
there's
just
a
lot
of
adjustments
that
have
to
be
made
to
all
those
comps
and
when
you
want
to
praise
something,
you
want
the
least
amount
of
adjustments.
You
can
and
there's
a
ton
of
them
here,
so
it
becomes
problematic.
But
that's
just
the
only
comment
I
had.
Z
Yeah,
I
mean
that's
a
verb,
that's
a
fair
point.
I
think
that
there
are
you
know
you.
You
mentioned
the
corner
a
lot.
There
are
other
corner
lots.
In
fact,
you
know
the
my
neighbor,
the
immediate,
the
my
immediate
neighbor
right
next
to
me,
which
I
mentioned
who's
who
sold
hit
their
house
last
year,
sold
it
for,
I
believe,
535
thousand
dollars.
Z
Z
B
B
Welcome
other
applicants
on
the
line.
D
Yes,
madam
chair,
the
next
applicant
on
the
line.
A
Y
Hi,
can
you
hear
me
yeah?
Oh
sorry,
the
phone
went
unmuted.
It
did
a
strange
thing.
Hi
I'd
like
to
thank
the
board
for
hearing
our
appeal
today
for
the
property
at
4629,
35th
avenue
south.
I
am
the
property
owner
and
our
appeal
is
to
the
2023
assessed.
The
2022
assessed
value
for
the
property
at
405
000.
Y
We
provided
in
the
documentation
in
our
appeal
process
from
various
comps
obtained
through
the
realtor
who
was
supposed
to
represent
the
seller
and
buyer
in
our
home.
We
purchased
the
home
in
2016..
Y
Y
Our
property
is
currently
assessed
at
a
70
increase
over
the
comparable
sales
of
comparably
sized
homes
within
our
community.
Our
home
is
small.
It's
a
two
bedroom
one
bath.
We
presented
photos
that
demonstrate.
We
have
had
made
known
improvements
to
our
basement,
so
our
our
house
is
infected
to
the
bedroom
one
bath.
Y
We
we
have
based
on
the
location
of
our
home.
We
have
an
extensive
sump
system
that
that
appropriately
both
mitigates
the
water
management
of
our
home,
but
also
presents
some
unique
challenges
in
terms
of
the
market,
assessment
and
market
valuation,
for
the
potential
sale
of
our
property
for
renovations
to
the
basement
as
well
to
increase
square
footage,
and
you
know,
increase
any
any
opportunities
for
renovations
to
the
basement
to
to
to
make
them
palatable.
Y
You
know,
I
think,
based
on
the
comparables,
there
was
a
recent
sale
located
near
us,
that
is
within
appropriate
proximity
to
the
amenity
of
lake
hiawatha,
that
sold
in
late
the
end
of
2020,
one
that
was
also
a
two
bedroom
one
bath
comparable
of
sized
one
car
garage
that
sold
for
three
hundred
thousand
dollars.
Y
I
mean,
and
our
property
is
currently
assessed
at
405..
Also
not
noted
here
was
that
the
a
property
just
on
the
same
block
as
us
just
closed
a
couple
of
weeks
ago.
It
is
18,
000
square
feet,
a
three
bedroom
two
bath
and
it
sold
for
four
hundred
thousand
dollars,
so
a
much
larger
sized
property
with
a
two-car
garage
than
ours.
G
I
have
one
question
this
board:
member
palmer.
I
see
that
you
had
an
appraisal,
you
included,
that
was
from
early
2020
and
then
I'm
just
curious,
hey
you
had
remodeled
extensively
later
in
the
year
that
that
appraisal
did
not
reflect.
That
is
that
correct.
Y
That
is
correct.
Yes,
we
need
the
appraisal
to,
at
the
time,
take
out
equity
from
the
property
to
do
those
improvements.
G
Y
Y
We
retained
our
existing
appliances,
so
our
appliances
are
north
of
eight
years
old
still,
but
we
did
do
new,
countertops
and
cabinets
and
we
added
like
a
a
little
room
off
like
it's
a
little
nook
off
to
the
side
of
the
kitchen
that
has
two
chairs
in
it,
and
also
just
reconfigured
the
back
entry
to
the
home,
and
we
also
replaced
the
stairs
to
the
attic
and
the
stairs
the
basement
which
were
in
deteriorating
in
unsafe
conditions.
Y
At
the
time
we
added
insulation
to
the
home
and
a
new
roof
and
then
did
did
new
paint
to
match.
With
the
edition.
Y
B
Okay,
thank
you
very
much
for
your
presentation.
We
will
be
making
a
decision
and
you'll
be
notified
by
mail.
F
L
Oh,
I
was
just
gonna
say
we
do
have
that
current
appraisal,
and
it
is
a
tough.
It
is
a
tough
building,
a
newer,
newer
property
and
they're,
not
necessarily
all
old
properties
in
that
area.
They're,
maybe
a
little
older
than
theirs.
But
it
sounds
like
it's
kind
of
unique
and
it's
had
to
have
some
attention
through
tax
court
and
that
sort
of
thing
or
petitioned
into
tax
court
because
of
its
value.
L
So
I
feel
the
value
is
a
little
high
on.
This
would
be
hard
to
find
great
comps,
but
I'm
not
say
that
I
think
the
value's
too
high.
B
Great
comps
do
not
exist
for
this.
This
is
a
little
enclave.
I
call
it
an
enclave
by
boom
island,
so
this
parcel
was
developed
in
the
mid
70s,
so
the
majority
of
the
homes
in
there
are
split
entries
and
it
is
right
by
bloom,
island
and
so
you've
got
the
river
right
there.
It
is
northeast,
but
there's
nothing
else
in
northeast
that
you
can
find
to
compare
with
these.
It's
really
a
problem
so
back
in
about
2008
or
something
like
that
I
sold
one
in
there.
B
It
was
it
sold
for
345..
The
appraisal
came
back
as
bad
at
2
25.
B
I
got
that
call
from
the
loan
officer
on
friday
at
4
30,
as
we
were,
leaving
the
the
friday
before
christmas
as
we're
leaving
to
go
out
for
a
happy
hour
merry
christmas.
So
I
had
to
call
my
buyer
and
say
well
guess
what
it
only
applies
for
225
and
you're
paying
345..
B
They
came
up
with
the
cash.
That's
how
people
see
this
particular
neighborhood.
They
wanted
to
be
in
that
neighborhood
period
and
we
were
really
lucky
that
something
came
up
now.
The
605
there
was
a
mid
70s
house.
There,
like
all
the
others,
got
torn
down
and
this
place
was
built
over
it.
I
do
believe
that
at
one
time,
this
property
sold
for
a
million
dollars
back
about
the
time
that
I
sold
the
one
on
on
ramsey
circle.
B
It
is
much
different
than
anything
else
in
the
neighborhood
when
we
got
that
appraisal.
I
looked
at
the
comps
that
the
appraiser
used
and
they
were
ridiculous.
B
G
So
yeah,
like
you,
said
in
this
appraisal
too
they're,
I'm
sure
the
appraiser
looked,
but
you
can't
find
any
comps,
so
there's
adjustments
of
all
types
on
there.
One
thing
I
would
go
back
to
is
you
know
they
settled
it,
so
you
went
back
and
forth
and
he
accepted
800
000
in
2018.
G
Even
given
the
uniqueness,
there's
got
to
be
some
kind
of
appreciation
in
the
general
market,
even
in
that
area.
I
I
don't
know
that
you
go
to
948
000,
but
I
was
just
thinking.
Maybe
we
give
them
a
little,
but
if
it
goes
up
six
eight
percent,
which
isn't
much
from
2018,
but
it's
so
unique
I'd,
be
at
like
9,
15
or
920
000.
Give
them
something,
but
it's
got
to
be
higher
than
the
appraisal
was
in
the
sale
price.
B
Yeah,
I
kind
of
I
would
kind
of
agree.
I
would
give
them
something.
I
mean
it's,
it's
unusual.
You
take
that
house
and
put
it
in
a
lot
of
other
neighborhoods
and
it's
going
to
sell
for
more
it's
nice
as
unique
as
this
neighborhood
is.
But
you
know
the
things
are
around
it.
Just
don't
support
that
price.
B
L
C
B
So
our
next
one
would
be
the
owner
had
just
called
in.
That
was
our
last
call
in
4629,
35th
avenue
south.
L
This
one
I
was
about
ready
to
ask
her,
but
then
I
think
mr
palmer
did
about
the
audition
in
the
back,
because
I
was
noting
different
sizes
for
the
property.
The
appraisal
had
900
and
some
square
feet.
The
assessor
had
1100
and
the
market
analysis
at
1100.
L
So
but
that
answered
it,
I
don't
think
it
really
came
out
earlier
that
there
was
an
addition
put
on
the
property
and
until
that
question
was
asked-
and
I
don't
remember
exactly
what
the
function
was
of
the
addition,
because
it
looks
like
it's
about
looking
at
the
dimensions,
it's
about
an
extra
eight
feet
out
the
back.
So
I.
L
Right
so
I
don't
know
does
that
what
was
that?
It
was
a
family.
I
can't
remember
what
they
she
said.
It
was
a
family
room
or
I
don't.
O
G
G
But
I
there's
a
lot
of
moving
parts
in
this,
but
I
you
know
the
appraisal,
if
you
add
that
to
the
appraisal
before
that
and
again,
how
much
does
that
add
to
the
value
the
cost
of
that
doesn't
equal
value
as
we
know,
but
it's
still
at
360
bucks,
a
square
foot,
that's
what
it
is,
as
is
which
seems
higher
than
a
lot
of
other
stuff,
even
in
that
nice
neighborhood.
So
I
would
suggest
a
slight
reduction.
B
I
wouldn't
be
opposed
to
that.
I
will
say
I
just
sold
a
two-bedroom
one-bath
house,
not
in
this
neighborhood,
it's
over
on
44th
avenue
for
325
000
and
it's
a
lot
smaller
than
this
property.
B
So
you
know
she
did
mention
the
high
water
table
and
I
think
that
you
know
does
evaluate
somewhat
but
yeah
I'm
I
I'm
not.
I'm
not
quite
set
on
anything
here.
G
G
C
G
A
B
Okay,
moved
by
bodurka
and
seconded
by
palmer
to
reduce
the
value
to
380
000
for
46.29
35th
avenue.
Look
what
you
call
the
goal
board.
Member
amba
is
absent:
board
member
bedertha,
hi
board
member
palmer.
C
L
This
one
the
appellant,
mentioned
that
the
second
floor
was
not
finished
and
there
was
no
kitchen
cabinets
or
countertop.
I
believe.
L
No,
I
in
in
their
in
their
packet.
L
G
G
It
looks
like-
and
this
is
still
in
progress,
so
I'm
just
curious
when
the
pictures
are
taken.
I
was
hoping
they'd
be
on
there
to
say
what
it
was.
That
being
said,
it
still
went
up
15
and
the
assessor
added
40
000.
So,
to
my
mind,
is
it's
a
matter
of
really
was
it?
Did
they
complete
40
000
dollars
worth
of
work,
or
was
it
still
in
progress,
and
it
was
only
something
less
than
that.
B
B
When
are
you
gonna
finish
the
project
here
yeah
quite
a
bit
of
work
going
on,
but
you
know,
like
you
say,
like
I
said:
when
was
that
done,
and
was
it
still
in
that
after
three
years?
It's
still
on
that.
L
Something
must
have
gotten,
something
must
have
gotten
done
to
have
the
assessor
note
an
increase
this
year,
the
value
I
look
back
since
2017
has
been
virtually
the
same
as
515
that
went
up
to
520
for
four
years,
so
virtually
the
same
for
five
years
prior
and
that
might
have
had
something
to
do
with
the
start
of
a
you
know
and
tearing
out
things,
but
whether
the
assessor
got
to
see
it
this
year
for
permits
or
not
or
at
least
made
a
phone
call.
L
B
Well,
you
know
if
the
assessor
had
had
a
chance
to
see
this,
or
they
can
make
some
kind
of
a
judgment
about
it.
We
would
have
had
the
information,
so
they've
not
had
a
chance
to
go
out
or
talk
to
the
the
homeowner
apparently
so.
G
I
would
I'll
motion:
we
reduce
the
value
to
620
000.
G
B
Okay,
what
would
you
call
the
roll?
It
was
moved
by
palmer
and
seconded
by
podertha
who
reduced
the
value
to
six
hundred
and
twenty
thousand.
Third,
please
call
the
roll
board.
Member
amba
is
absent.
Board
member
bedertha.
C
B
Board
member
palmer
and
chair
bland
hi,
there
are
three
eyes
motion:
carries
okay
on
to
29
37
38th
avenue
south
case
number,
22-058.
L
This
this
property
had
a
realtor's
opinion
of
value,
but
I
noted
the
realtor's
name
was
the
same
name
and
last
name
as
the
owner's
name.
So
I
don't
know
what.
If
we
can,
I
don't
know
what
the
relationship
is.
It
could
be
just
that
they're
both
have
the
same
last
name
of
rose,
but
I
don't.
I
have
a
hard
time
giving
without
knowing
that
and
maybe
with
the
intention
of
the
getting
the
opinion
of
value
for
was
it
for
this.
L
Our
meeting
here
today
or
not,
I
just
have
some
reservations.
I
guess.
G
Yeah
I'll
note
that
so
the
complaints
aren't
about
her
own
property,
but
what's
around
it,
and
this
I
like
the
map
to
simba
collision.
Whatever
that
place,
is
it's
actually
not
next
door?
There's
another
house
between
her
and
that
place.
So
it's
not
an
adjacent
property.
G
And
then
the
pictures
are
all
of
this
house
next
door,
which
doesn't
say
anything
about
their
house,
which
the
essex
sessor
says
is
in
average
plus
condition.
So
the
final
thing
is
they
throw
in.
They
aren't
comps,
but
whatever
these
sales
they
threw
in
in
the
area
that
were
5,
15
5
40
5
45.
So
it
doesn't
tell
me
this
thing
is
out
of
line,
so
I
I
without
information
she
can
provide
about
other
sales
compared
to
her
house
instead
of
the
jason
stuff.
I
don't
think
we
should
change
the
value.
B
All
right,
it's
been
moved
by
and
seconded
by
palmer
to
sustain
the
value
at
29,
37,
38th
avenue,
south
clerks
want
to
call
the
rule.
Please
board.
Member
amba
is
absent
board
member
bedertha.
L
G
In
review
on
this
pack,
the
only
thing
I
saw
was
it's
a
it's,
a
double
bungalow
and
there's
work
done
over
two
family
dwelling
to
fin
and
finishing
basement
for
unit
b
in
so
now
it's
a
double
bungalow.
G
Without
talking
to
him.
I
don't
know
what
that
means.
I
don't
know
you
know
it
doesn't
show
the
units
in
the
basement
how
many
units,
or
how
many
bedrooms-
and
the
last
thing
is
all
these
sales.
He
has.
I
don't
know
if
they're
double
bungalows
and
they're
all
from
2020.,
so
all
these
sales
that
he
just
lists
are
not
necessarily
comparable
and
they're
old.
So
I
guess
I
he
hasn't
provided
enough
data
to
tell
me
that
it
should
be
changed.
B
G
So
I
I
will
motion
that
we
sustain
the
value
at
383
000.
J
B
L
C
D
Madam
chair,
it
has
now
passed
our
time
to
that
we
have
allotted
for
today's
meeting.
We
have
another
broadcast
meeting
at
1
30,
and
so
the
tech
team
will
have
to
get
prepared
for
that
as
well.
So
we'll
have
to
conclude
today's
session
and
we
will
have
to
continue
those
items
we'll
have
to
continue
those
items
to
tomorrow
that
the
board
has
not
been
able
to
decide
on
today
and
we
will
have.
We
will
need
to
read
recess
to
tomorrow
at
8
30
a.m.
B
G
I
just
want
to.
I
got
all
these
packets
all
over
the
floor.
I
show
that
we're
partially
through
the
10
30
and
we're
left
it
off
at
zero.
Five.
Six
four:
does
that
look
right
to
you
guys.
G
Right
so
that
it
looks
like
there's
only
a
few
starting
with
oh
five,
six
four
and
then
the
entire
11
30
to
12
30
packet.
We
have
to
review.
B
Okay,
all
right
do
we
need
to
talk
about
friday.
G
L
F
G
B
And
then
how
long
could
you
go
down.
G
For
friday,
I
think
I'm
pretty
clear
for
most
of
the
day,
so
I
could
go
into
early
afternoon.
If
I
had
to.
B
Okay,
so
do
we
have
ability
to
go
that
long
or
is.
G
Well,
we
need
a
quorum,
we'd
have
to
make
sure,
remember,
ambassador
online,
or
else
we
wouldn't
have
a
quorum.
L
H
Mayor
blandon
board
members.
Thank
you.
Some
of
it
is
going
to
depend
on
how
the
case
flow
goes
tomorrow,
since
we
are
looking
at
tomorrow,
already
being
backlogged.
H
We
worked
with
the
department
of
revenue
like
I
mentioned,
and
have
notified
the
109
properties
in
the
condominium
buildings
that
were
coming
to
you
with
a
recommendation
for
a
reduction
and
have
asked
if
any
of
those
people
disagree
with
that
reduction
and
wish
to
have
a
hearing.
So
we
will
know
more
around
10
a.m
tomorrow,
which
is
the
deadline
that
we
gave
them
to
notify
us.
G
G
Well,
we
have
time
to
the
does
the
board
evan
or
this
clerk
have
anything
else
to
do
after
that.
If
we
have
time
to
finish
these
cases,
we
have
like
15
or
so
left
today
that
we
have
to
decide
on
right
that
we
just
set
aside
so
after
four,
if
we
have
a
little
more
time,
I'd
like
to
you
know
to
clear
those
up
and
get
those
out
of
the
way
as
long
as
we're
there.
D
Madam
chair,
I
will
verify
with
the
tech
team,
but
I
believe
that
we
would
be
able
to
accommodate
a
little
later
in
the
day
tomorrow.
But
again,
I'd
have
to
confirm
with
the
our
tech
team.
H
To
the
clerk
and
the
chair
and
board
members,
I
have
to
make
sure
that
also
our
team
is
available
and
I'm
hoping
that,
since
we've
heard
from
a
few
cases
tomorrow
that
are
unable
to
be
with
us,
there's
a
large
group
in
the
afternoon
that
they
are
not
going
to
be
presenting
they've
submitted
just
now.
Something
in
writing
that
those
cases
will
move
faster
through
the
agenda,
and
you
can
address
these
missing
cases
from
today
tomorrow.
During
that
time
hey,
but
I
will
be
sending
you.