►
From YouTube: Human Rights Commission | April 12th, 2021
Description
No description was provided for this meeting.
If this is YOUR meeting, an easy way to fix this is to add a description to your video, wherever mtngs.io found it (probably YouTube).
C
C
C
C
C
A
D
D
E
D
D
A
A
Food,
we
love
zoom
and
then
we
love
them
when
it
works
right.
F
C
I
know
my
internet
box,
but
I'll
put
this
on
with
no
just
in
case,
because
again
it's
been
going
in
and
out.
A
A
G
Okay,
commissioner
andrade
president
commissioner
flood
president,
commissioner
romeron
commissioner
shepard.
A
Okay,
excellent
well.
First
item
is
the
mission
statement.
Two
would
like
to
just
read
the
first
paragraph
of
the
mission
statement
today,
who
have
we
not
had
for
a
while
edwin.
Thank
you
for.
D
A
A
Yes,
I
did
thank
you,
but
we've
got
a
full
house
right,
correct.
Okay,
now
we're
on
to
item
five
on
the
agenda,
which
is
public
comment.
This
time
has
been
set
aside
for
members
of
the
public
to
address
the
human
rights
commission
on
agenda
items
and
items
of
general
interest
within
the
subject
matter.
Jurisdiction
of
the
commission
three
minutes
is
allowed
for
each
speaker.
Although
the
commission
values
all
comments
pursuant
to
the
brown
act,
it
generally
cannot
take
any
action
on
items
not
listed
on
the
posted
agenda.
A
Jay,
do
we
have
folks
submitted
for
public
comment.
G
C
A
Right,
so,
if
folks
would
like
to
raise
their
hand
jay,
do
you
see
any
hands.
A
Who's
that
he
is
jenny,
folk,
jenny,
you've
got
three
minutes.
Jenny
for
public.
H
Okay
can
do
I
do
that
now.
Yes,
perfect,
okay,
so
and
then
first
of
all
thank
the
human
rights
commission
for
taking
on
the
important
issue
of
racism
in
our
city,
history
and
recognizing
that
our
past
is
not
all
glamour
and
hollywood
stories.
H
H
H
Yes,
our
city
grew
from
the
playground
of
the
stars
during
his
tenure,
but
the
horrors
that
were
perpetrated
on
the
mostly
minority
working
poor
of
our
city.
To
get
us,
there
were
unfavorable
under
bogart's
leadership.
Hundreds
of
families
lost
everything
as
he
and
the
city
councils
oversaw
the
burning
of
their
homes
and
their
possessions,
to
quote
clear
out
the
squalor,
which
was
his
term
for
the
justifying
the
burning
of
section
14.
H
compensation
help
with
relocation
or
any
other
minor
assistance.
Much
less
an
apology
was
never
provided
to
the
families
as
they
watched
their
homes
and
personal
belongings
go
up
in
flames.
As
a
city,
council
member,
I
had
the
opportunity
to
request
that
the
statute
removed
that
request
was
sent
to
the
public
art
commission
where
it
died
because
of
what
seems
to
be.
Finally,
an
awareness
of
the
racism
that
has
existed.
H
H
Both
of
those
investigation
concluded
that,
among
other
things,
it
was
an
egregious
act
of
racism.
It's
time
to
remove
the
symbol
of
hate
from
in
front
of
the
people's
building.
It
will
not
make
up
for
all
the
pain
and
harm
that
was
caused
to
many
of
the
families
that
still
live
in
palm
springs.
Nor
will
it
raise
the
racism
that
extended
then
and
still
permeates
our
present,
but
what
it
will
acknowledge
is
that
we
as
a
city
recognize
the
racism
and
we
recognize
the
pain
and
are
willing
to
act
upon
it.
H
H
We,
most
importantly,
can
never
give
back
their
dignity,
their
homes
or
their
possessions,
but
by
acknowledging
these
wrongs,
we
in
some
small
way
protect
the
future
from
these
atrocities
from
ever
being
perpetrated
again.
So
I
I
really
think
that
the
the
resolution
you're
about
to
discuss
is
well
written
and
includes
many
of
the
parts
of
history
that
are
covered
by
this
part
of
our
terrible
time.
A
G
I
I
Bit
of
background
for
those
of
you
who
are
joining
us
here
this
evening
and
thank
you
for
giving
us
an
opportunity
to
speak,
however,
you
know
my
family
there's
a
lot
of
families
within
the
desert,
highlander
gateway
states
area
who
came
from
texas
and
yes,
they
came
from
texas
and
migrated
and
they
moved
to
section
14
on
section
14,
a
lot
of
their
homes
or
personal
properties
or
belongings
were
ripped
away
with
some
with
no
prior
knowledge.
You
know
to
come
home.
I
want
you
to
think
about.
I
If
you
were
to
come
home
one
day
and
not
see
your
house
standing
here,
what
would
you
do?
What
would
you
do?
You're
going
to
be
angry,
you're,
going
to
be
sad,
you're
going
to
be
hurt
and
not
not
to
mention
people
had
kids,
kids
that
were
affected
by
it
and
then
within
the
attorney
agenda
report.
Once
they
involved
frank
once
they
involved
attorney
general
attorney
general,
it
was
cited
that
bogart
said
they
were
poor,
blacks.
I
He
added
that
they
come
from
texas
or
wherever,
and
they
settled
in
section
14,
indian
land,
where
they
could
live.
Rent
free
some
of
the
hotels
in
the
center
of
the
town
thought
it
was
a
bad
image
for
the
center
for
the
center
of
palm
springs
without
any
regard,
houses
were
just
demolished,
people
had
to
uproot
and
go
wherever
they
could.
Some
were
able
to
mike
to
go
to
crosley
crossy
tracks.
Some
were
able
to
go
to
india.
I
My
granny
was
one
of
the
people
that
was
able
to
buy
a
house
during
that
process.
I
moved
to
the
old
side
of
the
desert,
where
the
opposite
side
of
the
desert
highlight
the
states
area.
But,
however,
how
can
the
city,
if
you
say
you
are
here
for
all
people,
all
people
that
includes
my
ancestors,
my
family
members
that
were
uprooted
from
section
14.?
I
That's
a
whole
neighborhood
out
here
that
you're
saying
basically
you're
saying
you
know
what
we
have
no
regard
for
whatever
happened
to
your
family
by
letting
that
statute
stay,
there
move
it
someplace
else,
but
if
that
is
that
is
a
city
building
and
you're
telling
us
that
that
is
representing.
That
is
a
representation
of
all
people
of
all
people
feeling
like
they're,
welcome.
No,
it's.
L
Hello
citizens,
I
come
to
present
a
view
for,
or
in
favor
of
frank
bogart,
his
family
tribal
members
who
oppose
this
council
culture
movement,
it's
our
mayor
and
city
council
or
former
council
who
spin
the
narrative.
Once
again,
we
all
know
that
several
hundred
whites
leased
on
section
14
with
substantially
fewer
squatters
of
color.
L
L
His
widow
bernadine
siva,
has
spoken
to
this
fact
and
she
is
absolutely
against
council
culture,
where
the
city
leads
wrongful
conduct
to
take
this
bogart
memorial
away.
It's
time
to
stop
this
absurdity,
our
city
leads
have
duty
to
focus
on
many
other
situations,
for
example,
under
their
example
of
this
absurdity
is
human
rights
issue.
Why
keep
allowing
homeless
to
rogue
downtown
do
drugs
there
or
in
our
parks?
L
Why
allow
abandoned
building
projects?
Why
allow
parolees
released
in
our
downtown
areas,
who
end
up
night
crawling
to
steal?
Trespass
break
into
cars:
why
not
see
to
hiring
more
police
officers
that
we
need
focus
on
issues
needed
situations
to
protect
health
and
safety
of
citizenry,
not
political
rhetoric
based
on
a
few
absurd,
squeaking
wheel,
council
culturists
again
this
this
needs
to
stop
it's
a
it's.
A
frank
boger
was
a
pioneer
of
palm
springs.
L
He
was
here
in
the
stagecoach
era
greeting
and
welcoming
the
kaufman
family
and
all
of
the
early
pioneers.
He
was
helpful
to
the
tribe
and
he
was
helpful
to
all
citizens
of
every
color,
black
white,
yellow
and
red.
I
mean
again
it's
absurd
you're,
taking
away
our
culture
of
palm
springs.
L
We
need
not
cancel
our
pioneers,
we
need
to
respect
them
and
to
allow
them
to
remain
and
to
me,
it's
just
a
plot
for
our
current
mayor
to
take
down
his
statue
to
put
up
her
own
as
as
some
sort
of
a
landmark
culturist
who
is
lgbtaq
the
first
woman
mayor
of
palm
springs.
It's
just
it's
gotten
so
absurd
and
it's
time
to
just
put
this
to
rest
and
really
focus
on
improving
our
city
and
getting
things
accomplished.
L
B
Hi
good
evening,
good
evening,
human
rights
commission,
thank
you
for
having
this
forum
for
us
to
speak
on.
My
name
is
jody
diaz.
I
am
a
third,
almost
30-year
resident
of
palm
springs
and
since
coming
here
and
being
involved
in
numerous
community
activities
and
learning
the
history
of
palm
springs
from
both
sides.
B
I'm
here
to
speak
on
the
same
topic.
That's
been
spoken
on.
I
feel
that,
just
as
other
people
have
stated,
when
I
first
came
here
to
palm
springs,
I
wondered
who
is
this
cowboy
in
front
of
city
hall
like
what
is
this
about
and
now
having
spent
all
of
this
time
here
and,
like
I
said,
being
highly
involved
in
the
community
and
community
activities,
come
to
find
out
the
history
and
it's
not
absurd.
B
B
I
feel
that
the
removal
of
that
statue
would
show
and
express
to
all
of
the
communities,
and
especially
our
minority
communities,
that
we
will
not
tolerate
racism
as
as
a
city
of
any
kind
sexism
racism.
None
of
it
should
be
tolerated
here
in
palm
springs,
and
so
I
just
wanted
to
really
urge
urge
the
commission
to
vote
in
favor
of
removal.
You
can
honor
him
in
other
ways,
but
I
don't
feel
that
you
know.
B
I
feel
that
taking
down
that
statue
would
would
really
set
a
precedence
and
and
express
to
the
city
and
the
community
at
large
what
we
stand
for
here
in
palm
springs.
Thank
you.
A
B
Myself
now
that
wasn't
a
hand
that
was
just
a
that
was
a
reaction
to
something
that
I've
heard
being
in
palm
springs
as
long
as
I
have
not
the
90s,
not
the
80s,
not
the
70s,
but
the
60s,
and
I
I
would
encourage
all
of
you
to
look
at
the
history.
B
Look
at
the
history
and
thank
you.
Thank
you,
susan,
for
your
very
intuitive
and
heartfelt
caring
expose
to
this.
B
Hi,
so
I
don't
because
I'm
like
okay,
so
I'm
a
freshman
student
in
high
school.
So
I
don't
know
too
much
of
extensive
research
research
on
the
history
of
the
city,
even
though
I've
lived
here
my
whole
life,
but
I
did
do
a
lot
of
research
on
sex
section
14
when
I
was
in
about
the
sixth
grade
and
obviously
it
is
a
terrible
thing
that
happened
to
those
people
that
lived
there.
B
And
I
I
am
a
kind
of
person
that
likes
to
stay
in
the
middle
of
situations
or
in
the
middle
of
conflicts,
not
really
on
sides,
and
I'm
sure
there
are
many
people
in
this
call
and
in
the
city
that
think
that
that
statute
needs
to
be
removed.
B
B
But
personally,
I
feel
that
I
just
wanted
to
put
the
idea
of
maybe
a
sort
of
compromise
of
instead
of
exactly
completely
getting
rid
of
the
statue,
maybe
moving
it
to
a
more
ideal
spot
in
the
city,
maybe
somewhere.
B
That
would
make
more
sense
for
it
to
be
in
whether
it
pertains
to
the
history
of
that
man
better
because,
since
there
is
obviously
dark
history
behind
that
that
that
person
behind
him,
I
feel
it
would
be
a
lot
easier
to
maybe
not
put
so
much
public
light
on
it
as
in
front
of
the
city
hall,
but
more
so
just
move
it
to
a
place
that
that
way
he
could
still
be
recognized
and
the
history
that
he
brought
to
our
city
is
still
understood
and
and
and
brought
to
the
attention
of
our
member
of
other,
like
citizens,
but
not
necessarily
completely
hidden
to
the
point
where
nobody
learns
it
at
all,
but
that
that's
I
just
wanted
to
fill
it
in.
C
Good
evening,
congratulations,
my
name
is
tom
kiley
and
I
was
born
in
the
el
mirador
hotel
and
I've
lived
my
whole
life
here,
my
family's,
been
here
since
1911.,
and
it's
interesting
to
hear
folks
talk
about
their
long
history
of
palm
springs.
Having
been
here
20
or
15
years,
I
bring
to
you
tonight
a
perspective
of
someone
who
lived
through
that
era,
who
knew
that
section
very
well
who
was
at
that
section
walked
those
grounds
at
least
once
a
week,
all
through
my
growing
up
years.
C
C
Tracy
conrad,
who
is
the
president
of
the
palm
springs
historical
society,
wrote
a
very
good
letter
to
city
council
several
months
ago
and
urging
the
council
to
carefully
look
at
the
true
history
of
that
area,
offered
the
resources
of
the
of
the
historical
society,
not
only
the
archives
but
of
those
members
of
the
society
which
represent
native
americans,
blacks,
hispanics
and
those
of
of
all
racism
genders
that
have
been
in
this
city.
Most
of
whom
have
been
here
all
their
lives.
C
C
So
I
would
urge
you
if
you
really
want
to
do
your
job
and
you
want
to
serve
your
community.
Well,
there's
no
rush
on
this.
Take
your
time
engage
the
the
palm
springs.
Historical
society
accept
their
offer
to
sit
with
them
and
to
see
their
archives
and
to
review
the
actual
data
of
what
happened.
Who
was
there?
C
C
You
really
need
to
know
what
that
whole
process
was
including
some
residents
who
had
three
years
to
relocate
and
chose
not
to
so
again,
I
would
ask
you
you
all
have
a
perception
that
you
think
you
know
the
history,
you
think
you
know
what
the
situation
is,
but
I
will
tell
you
that
there's
a
completely
different
side
that
needs
to
be
also
heard
and
that
you
need
and
have
available
to
you
the
resources
of
things
like
the
historical
society
and
pioneer
members
of
of
your
community
who
would
love
to
tell
you
their
perspective
and
hopefully
get
you
to
understand
what
the
truth
of
this
whole
situation
is.
I
G
Hey
sorry
about
that,
hello,
commissioners
and
everybody
in
this
room,
some
city,
council,
people
that
I
know
has
city
council
people,
you
guys,
I'm
speaking
extra
ramenously
off
the
cuff,
because
I
just
it's
been
a
crazy
spring
for
me,
but
I
wanted
to
address
some
of
the
comments
that
have
been
made
and
you
know
for
all
the
people
that
are
talking
about
cancel
culture.
G
What
a
great
guy
frank
was
things
like
that?
None
of
us
are
saying
that
he
doesn't
have
certain
aspects,
that
of
his
time
that
were
good
for
certain
parts
of
this
community.
G
But
what
we
are
saying
is
we
also
have
a
lot
of
documentation
from
articles
at
the
time
in
the
desert
sun
from
articles
more,
you
know
a
little
bit
after
in
in
the
early
times
in
usa.
Today
from
the
california
attorney's
generals
reported,
I
don't
care
if
the
you
know,
representative
from
the
ag's
office,
spent
15
minutes
here
or
15
weeks
here.
He
still
had
a
chance
to
sit
and
talk
to
people
and
see
what
happened.
G
We
have
people
that
are
affected
by
these
policies
in
our
community.
One
of
them.
You
know
ms
cora
just
passed
away,
and
you
know
her
family
is
still
involved,
active
and
had
been
relocated
from
section
14..
We're
not
we're
not
trying
to
cancel
out
the
history
we're
just
you
know.
I'm
saying
I
think
the
people
that
worked
on
this
before
me,
because
I
am
not
the
first
person
to
work
on
this
idea,
a
lot
of
people
put
in
a
lot
of
effort
and
time
and
jenny.
G
Thank
you
so
much
because
you
you
got
this
ball
rolling
before
I
even
knew
about
it.
We're
saying
for
somebody
that
helped
to
shape
policies
that
evicted
people
from
their
homes
or
might
have
subjected
them
to
you
know
being
forced
to
the
outskirts
of
town.
G
G
The
statue,
I
think,
is
what
we're
saying
and
have
a
historical
display
about
what
happened
in
section
14
and
why
we,
as
the
citizens
of
palm
springs,
are
really
wanting
that
history
to
get
out
both
as
far
as
educating
people
about
what
happened
to
counter
potential
racism
and
to
as
our
own
way
apologize
for
what
has
happened
by
people
that
lived
in
this
town
before
us.
G
We
owe
an
apology
to
the
citizens
that
were
uprooted
and
relocated,
and
I
think
part
of
that
apology
includes
moving
this
statue
to
a
different
part
of
town
and
I'm
sorry
for
my
puppy.
I'm
gonna
go
mute
right
now,
because
she's
very
talkative.
I
think
she
has
her
own
ideas
in
favor
of
moving
the
statue.
A
All
right,
david
weiner,
thank
you
very
much.
I
don't
see
anybody
else
from
the
q
j.
Oh,
I
see
a
doug
evans
waving
his
hand
doug.
We
will
go
to
you.
A
After
you
unmute,
we
you've
got
three
minutes.
J
Thank
you
very
much.
I'm
done
no!
My
name's
doug
evans.
Mr
chairman
members
of
the
commission
council
member
of
chief
reyes,
I
have
the
the
honor
and
privilege
of
working
for
the
city
of
palm
springs
for
26
years.
J
J
J
J
J
J
People
were
given
notices,
it
wasn't
a
surprise
actually
mayor
bogart
at
the
time
asked
for
stays
of
demolition
permits,
so
people
would
have
more
time
he
worked
closely
with
lawrence
crossley,
who
was
a
conservator
of
indian
land,
just
as
frank
bogart
was
to
try
to
come
up
with
ways
to
create
housing.
J
The
city
didn't
have
redevelopment
tools,
it
didn't
have
state
monies
for
affordable
housing
back
then
there
was
no
help
the
tribe
couldn't
get
out.
Mr
chair
three
minutes
has
elapsed.
Thank
you
very
much.
I
appreciate
your
time.
I
am
disappointed
that
there's
been
reference
to
a
resolution
and
that's
not
in
the
agenda
packet.
There's
just
newspaper
articles
and
something
about
tobacco
in
cannabis
is
attached
to
the
agenda.
J
I
can't
give
you
meaningful
comment,
because
that
information
is
not
made
available
to
the
public.
I
apologize
for
the
extra
time.
Thank
you
very
much.
You
have
a
difficult
decision
to
make.
Thank.
L
A
L
I
do
I
I
meant
to
say
that
susan.
A
L
Don't
think
I
fulfilled
my
three
minutes.
However,
so
I'd
like
I'd
like
to
just
say
one
thing
that
when
my
family
bought
a
home
in
palm
springs
on
via
miralestra
a
block
from
the
desert
regional
hospital,
I
was
it,
it
was
1957.
I
was
10
years
old
and
I
remember
section
14.
I
had
schoolmates
who
lived
on
section
14..
I
have
schoolmates
who
would
come
forward
and
like
to
see
the
city.
L
It's
all
political
spin
and
we
really
need
to
get
to
the
bottom
of
this
and
maybe
correct
history
once
and
for
all
correct,
correct.
The
publications
that
are
have
incorrectly
been
spun
and-
and
we
need
to
make
this
right
but
removing.
A
Any
other
first
time,
folks,
who
would
like
to
make
comments
publicly
during
public
comments.
A
Jay,
I
don't
see
any
other
new
people
so
with
that
we
will
close
public
comments
for
our
meeting
today
and
move
on
to
item
six.
A
Janelle,
if
you
have
like
a
one
minute
comment
that
you
would
like
to
make
susan
smith
was
correct.
She
didn't
use
the
full
three
minutes
when
she
was
on
the
first
time,
so
we
extended
that
courtesy
and
would
do
the
same
for
you
if
you've
got
a
minute
comment
that
you
would
like
to
make
quickly.
I
You
know
people
talk
about
that.
This
is
what's
written
in
books
or
newspapers
articles.
There
are
first-hand
accounts
that
I
listened
to
you
from
my
granny.
Claudia
crawford
taught
kylie,
I
didn't
know
you
know
her.
You
knew
her
because
she
worked
for
me,
but
firsthand
accounts
of
numbers
of
family
members
that
lived
on
section
14.
It
was
not
anything
that
was
just
written
written
it
down
to,
according
according
to
attorney
general
report.
I
These
are
first-hand
accounts
stories,
memories
that
were
shared
not
one
time
not
two
times,
but
every
every
opportunity
where
a
cookie
bar
came
about.
So
I
have
tons
of
stories.
Yes,
that
might
ready
to
share
so
this
I
mean
for
you
to
sit
there
and
say
that
families.
Yes,
this
is
what
took
place
yes
and
we
know
that
it
wasn't
just
frankfort's
doing,
but
we
have
a
man.
We
have
a
statue
of
a
man
that
we
are
that's
a
symbol.
That's
of
who
city
city
of
palm
springs
is
that's
not
right.
A
F
Thank
you
ron,
it's
with
sadness
and
deep
respect
that
the
palm
springs.
Human
rights
commission
acknowledges
the
passing
of
a
former
commissioner
friend
and
upstanding
member
of
our
community.
Jim
gross
lost
his
battle
with
stomach
cancer.
On
april
the
1st
he
was
born
just
up
the
road
in
redlands
attending
local
schools
and
later
earning
a
bachelor's
and
master's
degree
in
theater
arts
from
usc,
while
jim's
professional
career
was
notable.
F
F
Recently
he
served
as
chair
of
the
1ps
organization,
bringing
together
a
consortium
of
neighborhoods
in
the
palm
springs,
jim
practiced
buddhism
for
45
years,
and
he
was
especially
proud
of
his
time
as
a
volunteer
dharma
teacher
at
ironwood
state
prison
where
he
changed.
Many
many
lives
for
the
better.
F
A
I
would
also
like
to
just
calm
the
nerves
of
the
rest
of
our
commissioners
about
the
vacant
seats
on
the
commission.
We
do
have
two
new
commissioners
joining
us.
We
believe
starting
july
1,
if
not
sooner
so,
we're
we're
excited
to
almost
have
a
full
house
and
we're
going
to
be
talking
about
another
member.
When
the
youth
committee
gives
us
an
update
today.
A
So
now
we
are
moving
into
item
seven
and
specifically
seven
a
a-
and
this
is
an
item
out
of
committee,
and
it
is
an
opportunity
for
us
to
discuss
and
bring
forward
the
subject
that
this
body
first
addressed
55
years
ago.
This
isn't
an
overnight
conversation.
This
is
a
conversation
that
started
55
years
ago,
the
human,
the
original
body,
the
human
relations
commission,
was
led
by
rabbi
hurwitz
and
the
conversation
started
with
civic
leaders,
and
it
was
the
first
item
of
action
for
the
human
relations
commission
in
1966.
A
The
conversation
today
is
is
going
to
center
on
the
monument
to
frank
bogart.
It
was
installed
on
the
palm
springs
city
hall
lawn
on
march.
31St
1990
and
it
was
intended
and
it
did
honor
and
does
honor
and
recognize
decades
of
service
to
the
community.
A
So
we
will
read
the
entire
resolution
for
discussion
today,
but
before
we
can
get
to
that
point,
the
executive
committee
is
comprised
of
vice
chair
chapelle,
commissioner
shepard
and
myself
chair
de
hart.
We
bring
this
motion
out
of
committee
to
discuss
a
proposed
resolution
on
the
frank
bogart
monument.
May
I
have
a
second.
A
J
A
All
right
so
before
we
read
the
discussion
or
read
the
draft
resolution,
I
would
specifically
like
to
ask
the
commissioners
if
they
have
any
comments
on
the
item
before
us
prior
to
us
reading
the
full
full
draft
proposal.
A
With
none
right
now,
I'm
inviting
jeff
coors
who's
our
guest
to
today's
meeting.
To
give
us
a
few
comments
to
to
start
our
conversation
off
so
council
member
coors.
You
have
the
floor.
C
Great
thank
you
chairman
to
heart
and
commissioners,
and
thank
you
for
that
warm
remembrance
of
jim
gross.
He
was
a
true
match,
as
my
people
would
would
say,
and
will
certainly
be
missed.
C
So
what
I
really
want
to
first
acknowledge
former
council
member
fo
and
claire
lucas,
who,
along
with
chairman
to
heart
and
myself,
have
done
a
great
deal
of
research.
There
are
over
20
footnotes
in
this
resolution
and
three
pages,
so
everything
would
be
well
documented.
C
I
also
want
to
thank
the
commission
last
month
for
us
working
together
on
the
apology
and
now
working
together
on
this
and
invite
the
commission
to
join
a
special
meeting.
The
council
member
garner-
and
I
requested
on
may
20th
at
5
30
a
thursday
night,
to
focus
entirely
on
section
14,
to
do
a
joint
presentation
on
the
history
of
section
14
and
for
counsel
with
the
human
rights
commission
together
to
make
final
decisions
on
these
and
any
other
matters
related
to
section
14..
C
This
will
also
give
the
public,
as
some
people
requested,
an
opportunity
to
weigh
in
and
well
more
than
a
month
notice
more
than
the
three
days
state
law
requires
on
this
and
to
do
the
outreach
to
the
public.
So
we
make
sure
we
get
all
that
information.
I
do
want
to
make
just
a
few
comments.
First
of
all,
to
those
who
say
this
is
cancel
culture,
we're
not
canceling
what
happened.
C
C
It
is
taking
into
account
the
incredible
pain
that
so
many
of
our
residents
feel
every
time
they
come
to
city
hall
to
see
him
celebrated.
Given
the
well-documented
history
that
is
included
in
this,
I
know
the
pain
it
causes
me
and
councilmember
vote
as
we
talked
about
it
regularly
when
we're
on
council
together-
and
I
can
only
imagine
pain
and
causes
to
the
families
that
were
impacted
directly
by
these
actions
on
section
14.
C
to
celebrate.
One
person
who
was
involved
in
this
atrocity
does
not
belong
in
front
of
our
city
hall.
That
says,
the
city
is
the
people,
so
I
really
want
to
thank
chairman
de
hart
and
the
commission
and
those
who
are
involved
in
doing
this
research,
including
finding.
Finally,
thank
you,
chair
to
heart,
the
attorney
the
interior
department's,
extensive
report
on
this,
that
we
all
had
a
lot
trouble
finding
for
many
years.
C
C
What
happened
to
their
belongings
where
they
went
not
one
and
so
to
think
that
would
happen
today.
We
know
it
wouldn't
and
it
shouldn't
have
happened
then.
So
thank
you,
chair
for
giving
me
the
time
to
make
those
comments.
A
Thank
you,
council.
Member
of
course,
I'd
like
to
make
a
few
comments
before
we
move
forward
on
the
draft.
You
know
the
our
our
commission
report
is
is
based
on
hundreds
and
hundreds
of
documents.
A
The
report
alone
is
309
pages,
and
we
have
hundreds
of
documents
that
we've
sorted
through,
including
the
comments
that
have
made
have
been
made
in
our
community
through
since
2015,
when
this
discussion
has
come
up
on
a
number
of
occasions.
Over
and
over
again,
the
comments
that
were
made
today
have
definitely
been
considered
because
they've
been
made
before
and
we've
you
know,
included
them
in
our
consideration,
and
you
know
they.
A
A
So,
let's
move
forward
we're
gonna
to
give
the
other
commissioners
fair
warning
I'll
call
on
you
to
help
us
read
the
resolution,
but
to
start
us
off
council
member
coors
is
going
to
do
the
first
three
paragraphs
for
us
and
to
get
you
prepared.
How
about
commissioner
andrade?
C
C
The
successful
implementation
of
this
plan
resulted
in
the
removal
of
the
city's
people
of
color
and
restructured
the
race
and
class
configuration
of
the
city
and,
whereas
under
frank,
bogart's
leadership
in
1964,
the
city
of
palm
springs
approached
the
conservators
appointed
by
judge
hilton
mccabe.
The
plan
to
raise
section
14..
C
E
I
Whereas
defending
the
city's
actions,
bogart
said
they
were
poor
blacks,
he
added
they
began
to
come
from
texas
or
wherever
and
settled
in
the
section
14
indian
land,
where
they
could
live.
Rent
free.
Some
of
the
hotels
in
the
center
of
town
thought
this
was
a
bad
image
to
the
center
of
palm
springs
and
whereas,
while
he
was
leading
the
section
14
demolition
profiting
as
a
conservator
and
championing
development
in
palm
springs,
frank
bogart
incorporated
cal
a
nev
as
a
california
corporation
for
real
estate
development
in
arizona,
california
and
nevada.
I
With
no
city
planned
for
relocation.
The
displaced
residents
were
forced
to
disperse
to
the
north
part
of
town
veterans
tracked
on
the
eastern
edge
of
the
city
banning
beaumont,
west
garnet,
san
bernardino,
riverside
and
other
cities.
The
1968
investigation
by
the
state
attorney
general's
office
said
city
crews,
acted
without
observing
proper
eviction
procedures
and.
H
This,
as
well
as
other
similar
instances
is
improper
under
california
law
and
whereas
the
frank
bogart
monument
which
stands
in
front
of
city
hall
is
a
hurtful
symbol
of
systemic
racism
and
the
significance
of
being
the
only
monument
in
city
hall
makes
the
symbolism
even
more
hurtful.
The
current
prom
palm
springs
city
council
has
declared
systemic
racism.
B
With
the
understanding
that
good
and
just
just
actions
of
an
individual
can't
be
considered
apart
from
actions
of
racism,
segregation
and
terror
brought
on
the
community,
the
city
of
palm
springs
desires
to
remove
the
frank
program
monument
from
in
front
of
city
hall.
Now,
therefore,
be
it
resolved.
We,
the
undersigned
members
of
the
palm
springs
city
council
order.
The
immediate
removal
of
the
frank
berger
monument
located
in
front
of
palm
springs
city
hall
said.
Removal
is
to
be
completed
within
90
days
from
the
date
of
full
adoption
of
this
resolution.
A
All
right,
thank
you
very
much
and
and
just
as
a
a
precursor
to
conversation.
This
is
just
a
draft
resolution
that
would
be
a
recommendation
to
city
council
if
it
is
endorsed
today
at
the
human
rights
commission
meeting.
So
we
are
open
for
discussion.
Commissioners.
Anybody
have
discussion
on
the
item.
H
E
E
I
my
family
has
been
in
veterans
track
since
the
60s,
I'm
glad
to
hear
about
the
context
that's
put
in
there
as
well,
that
we
know
the
history
of
the
different
neighborhoods
that
that
were
formed
in
this
city
because
of
what
had
happened
in
the
60s
and
I
and
it's
really
important.
You
know
that
we
really
find
you
know.
I
think
this
document
this
document
is
very
much
a
level
how
we're
going
to
build
upon
our
moral
compass.
E
We
have
a
social
responsibility
to
our
communities,
especially
those
who
have
been
affected
for
so
many
decades,
and-
and
I
think
I
think
this
is
a
great
it's
a
we're
at
a
moment
of
reckoning.
This
city
is
at
a
real
moment
of
reckoning.
I
think
we've
seen
that
we've
we've
been
part
of
a
lot
of
discussions
around
racial
and
social
equity,
and
I
think
this
is
this
is
a
great
document,
and
I
applaud
the
authors
of
this.
Thank
you.
F
Thank
you
well,
first
of
all,
I
don't
think
there's
any
denying
the
harm
that
was
done
with
the
handling
of
section
14.,
that's
a
given,
but
the
issue
of
whether
to
keep
or
remove
a
statue
seems
to
have
paled
a
little
bit
for
me
with
the
language
in
the
resolution.
F
And
I
feel
that
there's
a
one-sided
judgment
of
character
and
motivation,
and
is
that
as
much
of
a
violation
of
mr
bogart's
human
rights
as
it
is
an
attempt
to
correct
another
situation.
So
those
are
my
thoughts.
I'd
like
to
see
the
resolution
reworked
in
a
way
that
is
less
judgmental
more
factual,
less
anecdotal,
and
I'm
I'm
thinking
that
the
people
again
that
spoke
earlier.
Both
ways
need
to
be
heard
before
we
actually
vote
on
something.
As
being
fact.
B
As
a
personal
aside,
I
moved
here
nine
years
ago
and
I
tried
to
get
in
touch.
I
spoke
to
a
lot
of
the
african-american
people
who
lived
here
and,
of
course,
the
population
is
very
low,
but
one
of
the
things
several
of
them
pointed
out
to
me
was
that
statue
and
I
was
born
and
raised
in
virginia.
D
Agreement
to
have
the
statue.
D
Relocated,
I
do
believe
that
it
is
important
to
be
t
teachers
of
atrocities
that
that
have
happened.
I
do
understand
that
there
are
two
sides
to
every
ever.
Every
is
a
story,
but
I
have
had
the
opportunity
to
to
wow
work
and
be
friends
with
people
who
had
endured
what
that
decision
did
to
their
families,
and
I
I
am.
D
I
also
fully
understand
our
responsibility
here
on
the
palm
springs
human
rights
com
mission
and
that
it
is
a
very
careful
walk
because
we
are
here
to
represent
everybody
from
every
culture
from
every
walk
that
lives
here
and
we
have
to
be
sensitive,
but
we
also
have
to
teach
so
that
those
types
of
of
of
of
atrocities
don't
occur
again
to
anybody,
because
they
could.
A
And
I'm
sorry
representative
cash.
I
should
have
called
on
you
before
vice
chair.
Please
make
any
comments
you
might
have.
I
I'm
also
in
support
of
the
resolution,
and
I
I
think
it's
kind
of
preposterous
how
people
would
think
that
removing
this
statue
is
trying
to
you
know,
censor
anybody
or
remove
history.
I
just
feel
like
it
would
be
more
so
not
celebrating
you
know
awful
actions
than
trying
to
erase
history
or
anything
like
that.
A
Excellent
well,
thank
you
and-
and
thank
you
you
know
for
all
the
comments
from
the
commissioners
you
know
in
in
my
thoughts.
Are
you
know
the
the
the
discussion
is
is
really
about
a
person's
leadership
and
the
ability
that
that
individual
had
to
stop
the
atrocities
that
were
happening
and
to
make
a
difference
in
the
lives
of
hundreds
of
families
that
were
residents
that
were
tax,
paying
members
of
our
community
that
were
the
working
class
of
our
community
and
the
backbone.
A
The
leadership
had
the
ability
to
not
just
stay
the
demolition
six
months,
but
to
stop
the
demolition
until
housing
was
provided
and
relocation
assistance
plan.
A
plan
was
well
thought
out
and
instituted
for
all
individuals
to
take
part,
not
just
the
white
residents,
not
just
the
mexican
residents,
but
all
residents
to
be
able
to
have
that
assistance
and
support.
A
We're
talking
about
a
very
short
time
span
when
he
served
his
first
two
terms
as
mayor
of
the
city
and
we're
we're
not
talking
about
99
years
of
his
life
and
the
monument
should
recognize
an
individual
and
his
contributions
to
the
community.
It
just
shouldn't
be
the
only
monument
in
front
of
city
hall,
and
I
fully
endorse
the
the
thought
of
relocating
the
monument
to
another
place
in
the
city.
A
Another
place
of
honor
that
we
can
tell
both
sides
of
the
story
has
been
has
been
discussed
tonight
and-
and
maybe
you
know,
there's
a
a
a
large
you
know
plaque
is
installed.
That
tells
tells
both
sides
of
the
story
and
in
a
way
that
individuals
who
spoke
today
and
and
others
who've
commented
in
in
the
past,
would
agree
on,
so
that
history
can
be
told
in
in
a
positive
fashion
or
truthful
fashion
that
everybody
agrees
to
so,
commissioner,
ramran,
I
see
your
hand
up
is
that
from
previous.
E
Actually,
it
was
just
is
this
where
we
can
discuss,
I
didn't
mean
to
interrupt
you
chair
to
heart.
I
apologize.
E
I
didn't
mean
to
cut
off
where
you
were
with
your
flow
flower.
E
Thank
you
chair,
and
you
know,
and
this
is
one
thing
you
know
we
can
talk
about
the
removal
of
the
the
sculpture
itself,
but
we
have
to
also
realize,
as
a
body
that
you
know
we
could
talk
about
yeah.
We
could
talk
about
both
sides
of
the
story,
but
you
know
what
the
reality
is.
That
statue
has
been
there
telling
one
story
so
this
whole
time.
So
we
can't
just
say
you
know:
okay,
let's
talk
about
both
stories,
but
the
reality
is
the
suppression
of
one
side
this
whole
time,
so
I
just
want
to.
E
I
want
to
find
a
way
to
really
reconcile
that
part,
because
it's
not
about
just
telling
both
stories,
because
this
is
actually
a
longer
longer
conversation
that
deals
with
the
history
of
how
the
formation
where
we're
at
here.
Why
are
we
here
in
in
this
place,
known
as
sekhee
now
palm
springs?
Why
you
know
what
you
know?
There's
a
lot
of
discussions
around
that
that
I
want.
I
think
this
is
really
much
part
of.
I
must
I'm
a
student
of
our
art
history
too.
E
So
like
I
actually
like
to
be
able
to
speak
about
art,
history
too,
and
it's
sort
of
its
relationship
to
sort
of
building
monuments
as
well,
and
I
think
this
ordinance
very
much
speaks
in
in
in
alignment
with
where
we're
going.
You
know
this
is
where
we
talk
about
community
reparations
on
so
many
levels
that
we
do
speak
about
the
trauma
that
that
art
can
have
on
folks.
You
know
this
is
real.
This
is
not
trauma
that
you
know
someone
just
had
today.
E
E
It's
not
just
about
saying
we
have
both
sides
of
story,
and
but
I
totally
endorse
this
ordinance
as
it's
written
right
now,
but
I
believe
it's
a
larger
systemic
discussion,
which
is
definitely
addressed
in
this
ordinance,
and
I
appreciate
the
you
know,
resolution
and
I
appreciate
that
language,
because
I
think
it
really
needs
to
be
discussed
that
this
is
about
structural
racism.
This
is
about
white
supremacy
and
its
role
in
the
building
of
this
city,
so
I
believe
we're
on
on
the
real
right
track.
I
appreciate
this.
This
is
really
an
exciting
moment.
A
F
H
F
A
So,
by
the
time
it
came
forward
to
the
human
relations
commission
in
1966,
the
the
the
clearing
had
already
occurred.
So
the
conversation
was
about.
You
know
what
what
was
done
to
people
that
were
forced
off
their
property.
What
were
the
truths
at
that
time
and
and
how
were
citizens
in
our
community
disregarded?
A
A
I
don't
I
don't
know
what
the
continued
conversation
was
with
the
human
relations
commission,
the
documentation
that
we
do
have
clearly
documents
the
conversation
and
the
fact
that
this
was
you
know
was
widely
covered
in
the
media.
A
The
first
action
of
discussion
for
the
commission
when
it
assembled
in
august
of
66.
A
Okay,
if
we
have
no
further
conversation
or
comments
discussion,
we
will
move
forward
to
the
motion
on
the
floor
and
the
motion
on
the
floor
is
supposed
to
make
it
harder
for
police
to
identify
them
all
right.
A
A
Four
five
oppose.
A
So
any
opposition-
I
think
that
takes
everybody
so
jay
that
was
five
in
favor,
commissioner
andrade
opposed,
so
the
motion
carries.
We
will
send
our
draft
forward
to
this,
the
city
council
and
as
council
member
coors
mentioned
at
the
beginning
of
the
meeting.
This
conversation
can
will
continue
at
the
special
meeting.
A
A
Okay,
excellent,
thank
you
for
that,
and
a
lot
of
really
good
input
and
conversation,
not
just
from
the
commission,
but
from
folks
that
were
participating
online.
The
chat,
room
and
public
comment.
You
know
it.
We.
We
appreciate
everybody's
input
there.
Next
up
is
item
7,
a
b
recognition
of
world
health
day
april
7th
of
each
year
marks
the
celebration
of
world
health
day
from
its
inception
at
the
first
health
assembly
in
1948,
at
the
u.n
and
since
taking
effect
in
1950.
A
A
A
One
was
on
march
9
at
eisenhower
medical
center,
and
there
was
a
report
with
an
assault
of
a
deadly
weapon.
Officers
responded
to
the
investigation
and
after
conversations
back
and
forth
with
the
patient
and
a
visitor,
the
technician
went
and
found
the
visitor
who
was
sitting
in
her
car
at
the
time
and
as
the
technician
approached
the
visitor
who
was
in
their
car,
the
visitor
attempted
to
run
over
the
technician.
A
The
other
such
incident
that
was
reported
was
on
the
following
day
march
10th,
the
palm
the
police
department
was.
Our
officers
were
dispatched
to
the
police
department
to
meet
with
a
party
who
was
reporting
on
an
ongoing
hate
incident
from
the
600
block
of
cottonwood
officers.
A
Responded
met
with
the
reporting
partying
determined
that
the
the
reporting
party
actually
works
as
a
manager.
At
one
of
the
complexes
it
was
revealed
that
a
tenant
at
a
location
had
been
sending
unsolicited
text
messages
to
the
manager
in
which
the
tenant
made
derogatory
statements
about
the
manager's
race
period.
The
reporting
party
declined
prosecution
and
is
working
with
the
property
owner
to
to
to
evict
the
tenant
and
obtain
a
restraining
order.
So
that's
what
we
have
for
hate
crimes
report
update
for
march
and
next
up.
We've
got
item
b,
commissioner
romeron
on
the
calendar.
E
Thank
you,
chair
to
heart,
some
highlights
for
our
calendar
this
month
in
terms
of
u.n
observations,
for
instance,
were
april
2nd
world
autism
awareness
day
april.
7Th
was
united
nations
world
health
day.
As
we've
noted
april,
22nd
is
earth
day
april.
28Th
is
world
a
a
world
day
for
safety
and
health
at
work.
E
E
This
year
we
commemorated
the
holocaust
remembrance
day
on
april,
8th
2021
and
the
museum
held
a
virtual
ceremony
featuring
remarks
by
the
secretary
of
state
anthony
j
blinken,
who
spoke
on
the
importance
of
holocaust
remembrance
and
the
personal
impact
of
his
family's
experience.
This
is
work.
This
is
an
observance
you
could
watch
online
at
state.gov.
E
Sexual
assault
awareness
month
is
also
in
april.
It
is
an
annual
campaign
to
raise
public
awareness
about
sexual
assault
and
educate
communities
and
individuals
on
how
to
prevent
sexual
violence.
I
wanted
to
highlight
one
item.
I've
been
very
happy
that
denise
schoolsby
with
1ps
has
been
for
hoarding
me.
A
lot
of
calendar
items,
and
I
wanted
to
highlight
one.
The
next
1ps
talk
of
the
town
event
will
feature
kate,
anderson,
the
director
of
public
relations
for
the
agua
caliente
band
of
korea.
Indians,
ms
anderson,
is
an
enrolled
tribal
member
of
citizen.
E
Nation,
a
federally
recognized
tribe,
with
the
reservation
in
shawnee
oklahoma.
She
has
had
three
decades
of
experience
in
journalism,
photography,
public
relations,
marketing
and
film.
So
I
I
definitely
encourage
folks.
Palm
springs
has
been
home
to
the
agua,
culinary
band
of
korea.
Indians
since
time
immemorial,
learn
about
the
tribe's
history,
culture
and
modern
times,
as
well
as
the
tribe's
economic
impact
on
the
community
through
new
development,
cultural
tourism
and
philanthropy.
That's
going
to
be
happening
on
tuesday
april
20th
at
5,
30
p.m,
and
that's
there's
a
zoom
link.
I
think
folks
can
get
that.
A
B
I
have
nothing
at
this
time.
A
I
would
just
like
to,
I
don't
know
if
we
formally
made
it
official,
but
commissioner
shepard
is
added
to
this
committee
as
one
of
our
representatives.
A
B
Open
according
to
the
status
where
now
congressman.
A
Okay,
thank
you.
Next
is
the
youth
education
affairs
committee
and
we
have
student
representative
cash
and
vice
chair
chappelle
for
that
update.
D
Yes,
so
this
is
student
rep,
cash
and
and
I
were
provided
an
an
application
from
lily
had
hannah
who
is
participating
on
our
call
this
evening.
Lilly,
I
is
a
resident
of
palm,
is.
D
D
She
is
interested
in
participating
in
the
palm
springs:
human
rights
commission.
She
is
a
member
of
her
gsa
and
is
a
youth
for
eq
quality.
She
is
working
to
ensure
the
human
rights
of
of
all
gir.
D
D
D
Join
our
commission.
A
Okay,
thank
you.
So
that's
we
have
that
motion
out
of
committee
from
vice
chair
chappelle.
Do
we
have
a
second
on
that
motion
seconded
by
commissioner
shepard,
all
in
favor.
A
A
Lily,
do
you
have?
Would
you
like
to
share
with
us
why
you
want
to
be
on
the
human
rights
commission.
B
To
be
honest,
when
I
filled
out
my
application,
I
thought
that
about
a
year
ago,
so
I
was
at
a
different
school
at
the
time
because
I
just
got
into
high
school.
So
just
a
few
comments
of
what
my
application
was
at
the
time.
At
the
time
I
was
at,
I
was
in
my
school's
gsa
program.
I
still
technically
do
participate
in
that
program
when
I
feel
needed
to
be
within
those
meetings.
B
But
since
that
was
a
past
school
of
mine,
I
don't
participate
like
now
other
than
that
I
just
I
I
heard
of
I
was
super.
I
don't
put
on
spot
here,
but
I,
when
I
I'm
not
ready
to
speak
out
loud.
B
So
basically
I
came
to
the
realization
that
I
was
a
part
of
the
lgbtq
community
in
about
the
sixth
grade
and
from
then
I
wanted
to
educate
myself
and
push
the
narrative
forward
that
people
like
me
or
other
people,
like
my
friends
and
my
family,
are
just
as
normal
as
any
straight
person
or
or
you
know
just
anyone
here,
especially
in
our
inner
town,
which
is
very
open-minded
about
things
like
that,
but
they're.
B
Obviously,
people
who
still
aren't
people
that
I
personally
know
or
have
come
into
contact
with
in
my
life,
and
I
felt
that
when
I
was
presented
the
opportunity
or
pushed
to
apply
for
a
a
position
here
by
vice
chair
chappelle,
who
was
a
close
friend
of
my
families,
I
decided
that
it
would
be
a
good
opportunity
for
me
and
a
place
where
I
could
make
a
difference,
even
though
personally
I
have
never
felt
like
I
could
being
as
young
as
I
am.
B
So
I
thought
that
this
of
all
places
somewhere,
where
I
don't
really
ever
want
to
leave.
Besides
for
obviously
education,
I
thought
that
if
I
was
going
to
want
to
put
my
foot
in
the
door
and
to
push
a
more
open-minded
community
and
mindset
on
our
community
as
a
whole,
that
this
would
be
the
best
place
that
I
could
do
that
and
I
decided
to
take
my
shot.
So
here
I
am.
A
D
D
Chair,
I
I
will
get
in
touch
with
lily,
as
I
work
with
ella
and
I'll,
get
them
to
together
and
virtually
and
and
and
go
go
over.
The
human
right.
A
All
right,
thank
you
for
doing
that,
and
I
just
would
like
to
bring
some
clarification
to
something.
Lilly
said
that
vice
church
chappelle
is
a
good
member
of
the
family
for
those
listening
vice
chair
had
no
idea
that
lilly's
application
had
come
forward.
I
actually
brought
the
application
forward
from
council
member
woods
and
council
member
pro
tem
littleton,
who
had
the
application
through
the
formal
application
process
so
again
welcome
lilly.
We
look
forward
to
having
you
be
a
part
of
the
commission.
F
Yes,
yes,
they
do
have
an
update
commissioner,
ramron
and
flood
and
myself
we
finished
our
formal
classroom
curriculum
about
a
week
ago,
I
guess,
or
two
close
to
two
weeks
ago
now
we
submitted
our
final
exams
I'll.
Let
them
tell
you
about
their
experience
at
this
point.
We
can
receive
a
certificate
of
completion
or
we
can
move
on
toward
the
state
mediator
certification.
F
You
have
a
choice
there
which
you'd
like
to
do,
and
if
you
go
that
far,
you
will
be
completing
a
series
of
courtroom,
observations
assigned
courtroom,
observations
and
mediations,
and
then
you
also
need
to.
F
We
will
also
need
to
conduct
a
series
of
co-mediations
where
we're
actually
co-mediating
with
another
another
state-certified
mediator.
So
that's
where
we're
at
right
now,
personally,
I
plan
on
moving
forward.
F
Part
of
the
issue
is
going
to
be
when
the
courts
are
back
in
session,
because
we
won't
be
able
to
do
our
observations
until
that
time,
but
the
county
riverside
will
will
keep
us
posted
as
to
when
they
return
to
session.
So
I'd
like
to
have
both
commissioner
ramron
and
and
commissioner
fled
talk
about
their
experience
as
well.
If
that's
okay,.
A
Yes,
so
that's
great
news
and
congratulations
for
everyone
making
it
to
this
point
so
yeah,
commissioner
ramiran
or
flood
you
would
you
have
anything
you'd
like
to
share
on.
B
Commissioner,
I
think
I
think
the
commissioner
covered
mostly
everything
I
too
plan
to
go
ahead
with
the
next
part
of
the
program.
I
found
the
the
classroom
so
to
speak.
Work
was
quite
intense
and
very
interesting
and
I
got
a
lot
out
of
it
and
I
I
just
felt
personally.
I
would
like
to
continue
to
see
what
it
brings.
E
The
same
here
we
got
this
wonderful
book,
the
community
action
partnership.
You
know
we
got,
we
got
some
nice
swag,
but
we
I
want
to
thank
you,
know
dr
yan
and
professor
edmundson
and
and
olga
sanchez
at
community
action
partnership.
It
was
it
was
great
and
I
know
that
commissioner
andrade
totally
covered
it.
I
apologize
about
that,
but
I
I'm
definitely
gonna
look
forward
to
also
continuing
and
getting
certified.
E
I
think
this
is
really
really
exciting,
and
I
know
that
I
realized
that
the
one
of
the
new
incoming
commissioners
is
also
a
mediator,
so
I
think
that's
really
exciting
to
see.
A
Okay,
excellent,
thank
you
for
that
update
and
we
appreciate
everybody
taking
the
time
to
go
through
that
training
and
and
for
those
that
are
continuing.
That
is
really
good
news.
So
good
luck
to
you
all!
A
Next
up,
we
have
item
b
committee
assignments
and
coming
out
of
committee
is
a
report
back
on
the
clean
air,
clean
indoor,
air
health
protection
draft
ordinance.
That
was
a
collaboration
with
the
sustainability
commission
and
commissioner
ramron.
You
are
the
point
on
that.
Would
you
like
to
give
us
an
update.
E
Sure
I'll
give
a
quick
update.
I
also
want
to
welcome
lily
hanner
to
the
commission.
As
as
a
a
gay
kid
growing
up
through
the
palm
springs
unified
school
district,
it
was
tough
and
you
know
there
was
a
lot
of
times.
You
know
you
felt
really
alone,
so
I'm
so
excited
to
have
you
know
to
have
you
coming
on
board
it's
so
inspiring
personally,
and-
and
I
can't
wait
to
share
stories.
A
Excellent,
you
can
sink
our
praise
on
item
d
when
we
have
commissioner
and
staff
comments.
So
the
update
on
the
ordinance.
E
I
have
the
I
believe
everyone
should
have
received
the
attachment
and
the.
Let
me
get
this
out
here.
Sorry
about
that.
E
But
the
main
one,
the
main
thing
is:
I've,
been
in
contact
with
commissioner
carl
baker
through
sustainability,
and
this
is
where
the
draft
is
currently
so
you'll
see
the
red
line,
information,
sort
of
changes
that
are
suggested
for
now.
It
hasn't
gone
forward
yet
to
city
council
as
that's
why
it's
coming
back
to
us.
So
that's
the
main
update.
I
want
to
make
sure
that
everyone
gets
a
chance
to
read
it.
E
We
have
we,
we
don't
have
a
strict
timeline
in
terms
of
like
making
sure
it
gets
to
back
to
sustainability,
but
I
would
love
to
get
more
feedback
from
the
commission
and,
if
there's
anything
in
particular,
I
know
that
we
had
one
public
comment
that
was
forwarded
to
us
earlier
before
our
meeting
today.
So
I'll
definitely
read
that,
but
that's
the
quick
update
from
the
the
discussion
with
the
ordinance
right
right
now.
It
did
not
pass
too
clearly
to
city
council.
E
E
We
have
to
read
it
and
then
provide
any
comment
like
just
as
we
did
last
year
with
some
of
the
other
documents
that
we
worked
on.
It
would
be
great
to
get
any
notes
and
then
we
could,
if
there
are
any
particular
notes,
I
could
compile
them
and
then
we
could
get
them
to
carl
baker.
Our
commissioner
on
sustainability,.
A
A
Commissioner
ramirez,
I
I
have
a
question
on:
have
the
stakeholders
been
invited
to
speak
to
this
resolution,
that's
being
considered
like
the
restaurant
bar
owners,
the
downtown
merchants?
It's
been
so
long
since
this
started.
I
I
don't
remember
what
conversations
have
taken
place.
I
know
we
weren't
involved
in
inviting
folks
to
the
table
to
share
their
thoughts
and
opinions,
but
has
sustainability
done
that.
E
A
And
then
so
next
step
is
there
a
timeline
on
when
these
comments
are
to
come
back?
Are
we
going
to
address
the
comments
in
the
april
meeting
and
then
you're
going
to
compile
them
and
work
with
sustainability
on
our
input.
A
Okay,
excellent-
that
is
that's
a
great
progress
to
see
this
coming
forward
and
not
sure
how
long
it's
really
it's
been
worked
on,
but
I
know
it's
been
a
long
time
so.
E
And
I
appreciate
that
share
because
I
think
I'm
because
it's
new
to
me
as
well,
so
I
think
this
is
a
really
great
opportunity
to
really
provide
a
lot
of
input
from
from
both
commissions
and
and
as
like
as
you
can.
As
you
said,
stakeholders
there
are
real
issues
related
to
civil
liberties
that
are
that
are
that
are
addressed
in
the
or
of
the
ordinance.
If
everyone
could
have
spend
the
time
reading
it
yeah.
Okay,.
A
K
A
I'm
looking
at
you
during
this
entire
meeting
and
I
say:
oh,
what
isn't
this
great?
The
chief
is
joining
us
today
and
now
I'm
looking
at
the
agenda
item-
and
I
realize
why
why
you're
here.
So
I'm
sorry
that
we,
I
didn't
realize
that
earlier
we
could
have
moved
this
forward.
But
thank
you
for
being
part
of
our
meeting
and
we
appreciate
getting
an
an
update
from
you
on
the
homelessness.
K
Sure
thank
you
for
having
me
and
no
need
to
be
sorry.
Actually,
I
kind
of
enjoyed
this
overall
I'm
reading.
So
far,
it's
been
a
long
time
since
I
presented
in
front
of
an
entire
commission-
and
I
see
some
things
have
not
changed
in
regards
to
the
depth
that
you
all
put
into
your
work.
K
So
I
thank
you
all
for
your
continued
efforts
on
this
commission,
as
it
relates
to
homelessness
that
continues
to
be
a
hurdle
for
for
the
entire
city
of
palm
springs
and,
more
specifically,
the
resources
that
we
are
devoting
to
this
effort.
K
The
quality
inn
and
the
downtown
area
of
palm
springs
has
been
a
hot
topic
that
was
a
designated
hotel
by
the
county
for
project
room
key
that
has
been
brought
up
in
the
past.
They
we've
reached
out
to
the
county
that
have
had
ongoing
communication
with
the
county
to
help
adjust
some
of
these
locations.
K
K
It
simply
was
not
a
good
location.
It's
too
close
to
downtown.
We
have
a
different
audience,
obviously
being
a
tremendous
resort
destination.
We
have
a
different
audience
every
72-96
hours
that
tend
to
give
a
lot
of
cash
money
to
the
homeless.
K
So
that
became
a
location
where
there
was
a
lot
of
hanging
around
resulted
in
some
drug
dealing
on
site,
in
which
we
had
to
activate
a
drug
task
force
to
go
deal
with
that
drug
dealer.
So
the
good
news
it
stopped,
there's
no
more
clients
at
that
location.
However,
we
still
continue
to
get
a
lot
of
hanging
around
that
property
and
it's
it's
fairly
significant
to
include
the
barista
park,
just
east
of
that
hotel.
K
That
appears
to
be
the
one
of
the
hottest
locations
as
of
right
now
we
do
have
spot
checks
nightly
at
least
three
times
every
night,
where
we
move
the
homeless
out
of
the
park,
because
there's
curfew
ordinance
where
they
can't
be
at
the
park.
Anybody
can't
be
at
the
park
actually
between
10
p.m.
I
believe
six
or
seven
in
the
morning,
so
they
just
relocate
to
other
close
areas
and
then
reposition
once
the
park
is
open.
K
So
that
is
what
we're
dealing
with
right
now
we're
trying
our
best
to
to
get
these
people
some
help,
but
simply
some
people
just
simply
do
not
want
help.
So
our
focus
is
on
that
park
right
now
to
try
to
get
it
in
a
position
where
kids
can
actually
enjoy
it
again.
G
Mr
chair,
I
would
just
add
this
is
an
item.
The
commission
requested
an
update
on
homelessness,
so
if,
if
chief
reyes
has
provided
input
for
you,
that's
great.
I'm
also
happy
to
help
try
and
answer
questions
on
the
efforts
that
the
city
has
been
engaged
in
to
assist
individuals
that
are
suffering
from.
A
Homelessness,
I'm
not
sure
who
who
brought
this
forward,
but
is
there
any
other
discussion
or
questions
for
the
chief
or.
A
Jay
chief,
we
appreciate
it.
Thank
you
for
providing
the
update
and
we
appreciate
it.
F
Just
real
quick,
I
know
we're
running
late,
there's
a
meeting
on
the
23rd
that
well
in
the
desert
is
hosting,
I
believe,
and
maybe
even
martha's,
on
some
new
proposed
housing.
Are
you
familiar
with
that.
K
I
am
personally
not
familiar
with
that,
meaning
that
scheduling
j
may
be,
but
I
will
comment
that,
as
I
stated
earlier,
the
communication
with
the
county
has
increased
it's
much
more
steady
in
fact,
jay.
I
a
couple
council
members,
our
new
city
manager
and
a
couple
other
county
employees
did
a
tour
today,
so
they
everybody
can
see
firsthand
some
of
the
areas
that
are
impacted
throughout
our
city.
So
I
think
everybody
on
that
tour
today
has
a
greater
appreciation
and
understanding
of
the
homelessness
in,
in
the
impacts
that
our
city
is
facing.
G
Commissioner,
andrade
hot
purple,
energy
will
be
hosting
a
display
of
pallet
homes
on
the
23rd.
I
believe
that
begins
at
4
30
p.m.
This
is
one
possible
option
for
providing
housing
at
an
affordable
cost.
C
L
I
have
a
question
for
chief
reyes
years
back:
we
had
subscription
to
spot
crime
and
I'm
wondering
if
we
can
bring
that
back,
so
that
citizenry
can
be
more
informed
on
more
or
less
a
daily
basis
of
crime
incidents
in
the
palm
springs
area.
It
would
be
a
great
gift
for
the
palm
springs
police
department
to
subscribe
to
that.
K
You
know
that
that
that
program
is,
you
know,
actually
very
much
outdated.
We
actually
provide
information
in
almost
real
time
now
to
the
media
and
to
our
to
our
our
community,
in
which
it's
it
refreshes.
There
will
be
so
many
seconds
you
can
see
what's
going
on
throughout
the
city,
with
the
100
block
in
the
type
of
crime,
so
I
will
see
what
that
an
email
gets
over
to
your
chair
to
share
where
that's
actually
posted
on
websites.
L
A
C
Yes,
if
I
could-
and
thank
you
chief,
I
thought
our
tour
with
supervisor
perez
was
really
helpful
today,
so
he
first
hand
knew
when
we
were
having
discussions
with
him.
The
demons
the
demonstration
on
the
23rd
is
from
well
in
the
desert.
Martha's
village.
C
There
are
also
a
number
of
other
projects
being
considered,
including
we
are
in
the
process
of
seeking
the
new
community
project
grant
from
the
federal
government
congressman
ruiz
can
recommend,
10
of
which
then
will
go
to
the
committee
to
buy
the
boxing
club
and
land
next
to
it
for
a
project,
and
we
also-
and
we
looked
at
that
today
and
we
also
went
to
the
gene
autry
property,
which
is
about
five
acres
for
possible,
affordable
housing
with
wrap-around
services
and
potentially
navigation
center
there.
C
A
Nope,
okay:
well,
we
appreciate
that
and
thanks
again,
chief
and
council
member
coors.
Thank
you
for
sharing
a
little
more
information
with
us.
Let's
see,
I
oh
go
back
to
commit
committee
assignments,
commissioner
ramran
any
update
on
the
street,
naming
in
your
committee
with
somebody
else
who
who
else
is
on
that.
E
E
I
want
to
thank
jay
for
guiding
me
through
some
of
my
questions
related
to
how
our
updates
our
committees
work
as
well,
but
we
will
be
following
up
it's
very
new,
so
I
appreciate
everyone
and
if
anyone
else
would
like
to
be
in
the
discussion
around
street,
naming
renaming
in
the
city
of
palm
springs,
please
let
us
know
it's
it's
a
it's
an
opportunity
to
look
at
the
you
know
planning
too
on
a
level
of
being
a
human
rights.
Commissioner,.
A
Okay,
thank
you.
It
was
brought
to
my
attention
that
we
needed
another
resolution
coming
out
of
our
first
item
today.
7Aa
and
that's
acceptance
of
the
309-page
report
with
the
pending
or
for
review
and
adoption
with
a
28-day
28
business
day
review
for
the
commission,
so
I'll
entertain
a
motion
that
we
accept
the
report
with
the
28
business
day
review
and
then
it
will
be
voted
on
at
the
commission
for
acceptance.
A
Commissioner,
andrade
first
and
second
shepard.
Second
on
the
motion,
any
any
question
or
discussion
on
this
motion.
A
All
right,
no
discussion,
all
in
favor
of
accepting
the
report
as
presented
for
a
28
business
day
review.
Please
say:
aye.
B
A
A
A
Is
there
consensus
that
we
would
like
to
cancel
our
originally
scheduled
may
10
meeting
and
in
favor
of
the
may
20
special
meeting
with
city
council
nod
your
heads
up
and
down
I've
seen
thumbs
up
nods,
beautiful,
okay
jay.
Then
we've
got
consensus
on
that
for
the
special
meeting
and
thank
you,
councilmember
coors,
for
extending
the
invitation
to
the
commission
to
take
part
next.
We've
got,
commissioner
updates.
We'll
go
around
the
table,
starting
with
commissioner
romeron,
who
had
a
lot
of
kudos
for
our
new
student
rep.
E
I
think
you
all
heard
it
already
so,
but
I
wanna
yeah,
I
think
thank
you
everyone.
This
is
actually
a
very
exciting
meeting.
As
you
can
see,
I
mean
that
was
the
most
we've
had
in
our
zoom
call.
So
I
think
this
is
really
an
exciting
moment
for
the
history
of
the
palm
springs
so,
but
welcome
lily.
H
I
also
want
to
welcome
lily
tickle
to
death
that
you've
decided
to
join
us
and
ella.
It's
good
to
see
you
continuing
to
participate
and
edwin.
I
haven't
responded
to
your
email
yet,
but
I
got
it.
I
fully
intend
to
do
so
and
help.
However,
I
can
with
the
street
naming
project
and
agree
that
this
was
it's
a
tough
subject,
but
that
we
covered
today,
but
it's
so
important
and
I'm
so
glad
to
see
everybody
taking
a
stand.
So
thank
you
for
that.
I
A
Wonderful
commissioner,
andrade.
F
Ditto
welcome
welcome
to
lily
it's
it's
so
nice
to
have
have
the
young
perspective
on
our
city
and
the
issues
that
are
affecting
our
city
and,
and
it
was.
I
agree
that
it
was
great
to
have
the
attendance
that
we
had
today
and
it
is
a
tough
subject
and
it
it
does
bear
a
deep
looking
at
and
not
just
a
it's
been.
It's
been
probably
overlooked
and
not
looked
at
deep
enough
for
a
long
long
time.
So
I'm
really
happy
that
that
we're
looking
deeply
at
the
subject.
Thank
you.
D
Lily,
actually
I
I
am
had
not
even
recogn.
D
Nice,
the
application
is
yours,
because
I
I
I
didn't
think
that
you
had
today.
I
intended
hi
hi.
D
Welcome-
and
I
do
think
that
this
is
probably
one
of
the
the
deepest
conversations
that
we
have
had
in
in
a
very
long
time.
I
think
that
this
is
what
we
continue
to
look
to
have,
because
this
is
how
human.
D
Rights
are
are,
are
our
ri
in
short,
and
as
as,
as
I
pre
pair
to
wind
down,
I
I
I
just.
I
hope
that
they
can
com.
D
Mission
continues
to
push
forward
like
this.
G
Yes,
mr
chair,
if
he's
available
to
say
hello,
I'd
like
to
introduce
you
and
the
commission
to
our
new
city
manager,
justin
clifton,.
E
C
You
I
am
here
and.
B
Boy,
what
what
a
fun
meeting
to
watch,
important,
serious
and
and
some
somber
all
at
the
same
time,
I
just
want
to
say
it's
great
to
be
in
palm
springs.
I
come
by
way,
most
recently
of
sedona
arizona.
I
managed
two
communities
in
colorado
before
that.
B
A
Rest
assured
we'll
reach
out
and
happy
honeymoon
for
the
next
few
months
and
then
then
it
will
hit
hard
we'll.
A
A
All
right,
excellent,
thank
you
anything
else,
jay,
that's
it,
mr
chair,
thank
you
and,
and-
and
I
too
you
know,
two
things
are
several
things.
I
really
appreciate
the
the
commission's
feedback
and
comments
to
the
resolution
today.
Regarding
the
monument
you
know,
we
will
continue
having
that
conversation,
you
know
on
on
the
the
20th
of
may,
with
city,
council
and
and
and
also
a
big,
welcome
to
lilly.
We're
excited
to
have
you
here,
so
we
will.
A
In
the
next
couple
months
also
introduce
our
next
two
commissioners,
and
I
would
like
to
congratulate
commissioner
shepard,
who
has
kind
of
been
in
limbo
for
a
couple
meetings
but
you're
official.
I
don't
know
if
you've
been
told
that
you
are.
You
are
official
and
you've
been
reappointed.
So
congratulations
and
thank
you
for
being
a
pivotal
member
of
the
commission.
A
A
A
Yeah,
okay,
commissioner
ramron
does
that's
timing
still
work.
A
Okay,
all
right
excellent.
So
if
we
don't
have
any
other
agenda
items
jay
you
didn't
have
any.
E
I
have
I
have
one
chair.
Oh
yes,
go
ahead,
I
would
like
I
noticed
in
last
week's
city
council
meeting.
There
was
a
discussion
around
inclusionary
housing
and
I
think,
since
we
as
the
human
rights
commission,
look
at
you
know
one
of
our
missions
to
look
at
the
fair
employment
and
housing
act.
I
think
that
that
might
be
an
interesting
discussion
for
us
as
a
body.
I'm
not
sure.
E
I
just
wanted
to
propose
that,
and
I
I
think,
it'll
be
kind
of
nice
to
see
how
we
as
a
body
as
a
commission,
would
also
have
a
real
stance
on
affordable
housing
in
the
city
of
palm
springs.
A
C
And
suggestions
in
terms
of
policy
for
affordable
housing.
B
L
A
Be
the
the
liaison
jay
will,
let
us
know
who
the
city
council
liaison
is,
and
you
can
carry
that
conversation
forward
and
see
how
we
might
be
able
to
serve
city
council.
You
know
on
that
topic,
specifically.
Okay,
great.
A
The
things
we
learn
when
we
watch
the
city
council
meetings-
I
don't
know,
I
don't
know
how
they
do
it
and
it
was
close
midnight
or
close
to
it.
This
last
thursday.
Okay,
I
think
that's
it
there's
no
other
announcements,
so
we
will
adjourn.
The
commission
will
adjourn
to
a
special
meeting
on.
A
I
don't
know
what
day
of
the
week
may
20th
is
at
5,
30
joint
meeting
with
city
council.
Thank
you
all
again
appreciate.