►
From YouTube: IETF100-TUTORIAL-NEWCOMERS-20171112-1230
Description
NEWCOMERS TUTORIAL at IETF100
2017/11/12 1230
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/100/proceedings/
A
I'm
Mike,
st.
John's
I'm
gonna
be
giving
the
newcomers
presentation.
My
claim
to
fame
in
the
IETF
is
probably
that
I've
attended
more
of
these
memes
anybody
else.
This
is
by
ninety-fifth,
so
I've
been
doing
it
since
basically
meeting
one.
Does
anybody
recognize
that
phrase
up
there
and
amazed
of
twisty
little
passages
all
alike?
This
is
from
an
old
computer
text,
game
called
Adventure
and
part
of
what
how
that's
related
to
this
is
I'm.
Trying
to
help
you
work
your
way
through
the
maze
of
what
the
IETF
is
this
meet.
A
This
is
a
slide
you'll
be
seeing
a
lot
of
you.
Don't
have
to
read
it
right
now,
but
it's
important
to
understand
that
for
you
to
understand
that
when
you're
here
you
are
generally
making
an
IETF
contribution,
so
things
that
you
say
in
working
groups,
if
you're
saying
them
in
a
working
group
or
to
someone
who
is
discussing
things
about
the
IETF
there's
an
IETF
contribution,
which
means
it's
not
something
you
can
basically
go.
Oh
keep
it
confidential,
or
things
like
that.
A
If
you
want
to
have
those
talks,
go
ahead
and
take
somebody
out
someplace
else
out
of
the
working
groups,
areas
or
often
a
corner
somewhere,
and
have
that
conversation,
but
be
aware
unless
you,
if
you're,
if
you're
working
with
people
who
you
haven't
talked
to
before
this
may
apply,
so
there's
a
bunch
of
different
on
the
things,
but
go
ahead
and
read
this
later
on.
It
will
show
up
in
every
meeting
in
every
session
you
go
to.
A
This
is
not
the
history,
the
IETF
there's
30-some
years
of
that
going
on
this
is
not
how
to
write
a
standard
there
are
for
that.
This
is
basically,
how
did
you
survive
this
week,
and
you
know
this
is
what
I
looked
like
during
several
of
the
IETF
meetings
way
back
when
we
had
the
longest
working
group
session
ever
it
started
about
8:30,
8:30
or
9:00
in
the
morning
ran
until
2
o'clock.
The
next
morning
we
sent
out
for
pizza
twice
so
pace
yourselves
through
this.
A
This
is
a
busy
busy
week
and
you
can
overextend
yourself,
especially
if
this
is
your
first
time
trying
to
do
everything.
The
IETF
by
the
way
is
not
like,
is
not
a
conference
in
where
it's
it's
designed
for
tutorials.
This
is
all
working
sessions,
so
it's
all
about
the
standards
and
standards
development.
It's
not
about
teaching
new
things,
with
the
exception
of
things
like
these
sessions
and
other
tutorial
sessions
on
Sunday
I
mean
you're
talking
about
the
IETF,
how
it
differs
from
other
standards.
A
Development
organizations
give
you
a
little
bit
on
IETF
culture
and
it's
important
because
we
are
different
than
other
standards.
Development
organizations
I'll
talk
about
what
a
working
group
is,
what
birds
of
the
feather
sessions
are
and
how
they
differ.
I'm
gonna
give
you
a
little
bit
of
guidance
on
how
to
act
in
the
working
group.
The
etiquette,
if
you
will,
and
the
meeting
etiquette
I,
know
two
different
things.
There
we're
talk
about
how
the
IETF
makes
decisions.
A
So
the
IETF
is
an
organized
activity
in
the
Internet
Society
that
wasn't
always
the
case.
The
IETF
was
part
of
those
collection
of
organizations
put
together
by
the
United
States
government
to
get
the
internet
up
and
running.
Ok.
This
was
just
one
of
those
at
when
we
got
started.
The
IETF
was
an
engineering
organization,
which
is
why
we
have
engineering
in
our
name.
It's
now
a
standards
organization.
We
never
got
to
run
this
changing
the
name.
A
The
engineering
part
was
to
put
together
the
Department
of
Defense
MILNET
and
ARPANET
NASA
science
internet
work,
the
NSF
NSFNET
and
the
do
E's,
ES,
Network
and
eventually,
to
start
transitioning
into
a
more
commercial
model.
So
that
was
probably
about
the
first
three
years
of
the
IETF
about
meeting
ten
we've
pretty
much
turned
into
a
standards
organization
and
the
engineering
stuff
moved
other
places.
A
The
meeting
here
the
IETF
consists
of
a
lot
of
working
groups
and
many
of
those
working
groups
meet
here.
They
are
organized
by
areas
and
the
areas
are
important
because
for
you,
newcomers,
if
you're
interested
in
a
particular
working
group
chances
are
the
other
working
groups
you
might
be
interested
in
are
in
the
same
area.
Now,
there's
a
couple
of
exceptions
and
I'll
talk
about
how
the
how
the
areas
are
structured
a
little
bit
later.
Most
of
our
standard
work
is
done
in
the
working
groups
and
is
part
of
the
IETF
consensus
process.
A
Working
groups
I'll
talk
about
a
little
bit
further,
but
working
groups
are
things
that
last
from
meeting
to
meeting
to
meeting
to
meeting
some
of
them
last
20
years.
Heaven
help
us
mostly
they're
supposed
to
be
shorter
than
that.
You'll
also
encounter
the
name,
the
term
internet
architecture
board,
and
that
may
actually
be
more
well
known
than
the
IHF,
because
it's
some
ways
are
publicly
facing
part
of
the
organization
and
there's
a
lot
of
details
that
I
could
get
into.
But
you
really
don't
need
them
for
this
first
week.
A
If
you
want
to
I'm
gonna,
give
you
the
tools
to
go.
Do
your
own
research.
If
you
need
to
or
to
find
somebody,
you
can
buy
them
a
beer
and
they'll
explain
more
if
you
want
it,
so
we're
all
about
developing
standards
for
the
internet
and
making
them
accessible,
making
them
maintainable,
making
them
supportable
on
a
network.
Depending
on
what
we're
doing,
we
may
be
going
as
deep
as
just
above
the
link
layer
and
all
the
way
up
to
just
below
the
application
layer.
We
don't.
A
A
One
way
I
started
security
was
not
something
we
cared
about
or
we
didn't
think
about
as
much.
It's
turned
out
to
be
the
biggest
problem
we've
had
with
your
early
internet
protocols
and
scaling.
Well,
everybody
here
is
heard
of
ipv6.
That's
because
ipv4
everybody
thought
that
2
million
some
IP
addresses
was
going
to
be
sufficient
or
whatever.
The
number
was
so
how
many
of
you
here
have
been
involved
in
other
standards,
development
organizations
on
2,
3,
4
or
5?
Oh
yeah,
that's
a
lot!
Ok,
so
you
don't
have
a
lot
to
unlearn.
A
A
Giving
your
company's
I
don't
know
what
sorry
get
old.
So
when
you
get
involved
in
our
meetings,
if
you
are
giving
us
a
topic
that
makes
no
sense
technically
we're
gonna
know
it
just
be
aware
of
that.
We
are
about
letting
the
market
decide
and
bottom
up.
The
people
bring
the
ideas,
and
then
we
create
standards
from
those
rather
than
the
organization
chartering
groups
specifically
to
deal
with
ideas
that
the
organization
wants
to
do,
standards
the
formal
standards.
Knellman
organizations
tend
to
work
a
little
bit
more
top-down
than
we
do.
B
A
Have
organizations
in
international
standards,
organizations
that
deal
with
steel
stand
standards
for
Steel's
and
bolts,
there's
actually
a
standard
for
how
to
make
a
fruitcake,
for
example,
and
it's
actually
an
ISO
standard,
so
lots
of
her
things.
We
don't
work
on
it
if
you
have
been
involved
with
the
other
standards.
Development
organizations
take
a
deep
breath
occasionally
because
we're
not
gonna
do
things
the
way
they
do
them
and
yeah
and
you'll
you'll
notice
that
a
lot
so
I
keep
repeating
this.
We're
not
a
transitional
thing,
we're
very
informal.
A
In
fact,
I
would
be
normally
wearing
shorts
here,
except
it's
Singapore
and
it's
a
little
bit
more
formal
than
I
was
prepared
for
also
it's
pretty
damn
cold
in
here,
mostly,
we
don't
have
people
showing
up
in
suits
and
suits
and
ties.
Occasionally
we
will
cut
off
the
ties
of
people
who
do
it
hasn't
happened
for
a
while,
but
it's
still
an
option.
If
the
people
here
are
smart
and
very
opinionated,
mostly
not
rude
or
don't
mean
to
be
rude,
but
sometimes
you're
gonna
perceive
them
as
such.
A
The
rule
here
is:
don't
assume,
you're
being
insulted
unless
they
tell
you
you're,
being
insulted
and
don't
and
try
not
to
be
insulting
to
other
people
in
return.
Most
of
the
people
you're
gonna
meet
are
fairly
welcoming.
They
are
here
for
a
good
discussion
or
in
some
cases
a
good
argument
about
something
you
might
have
a
knockdown
drag-out
argument
and
working
group
and
then
go
off
and
have
a
beer
with
a
guy
and
go
okay.
We
now
know
what's
going
on,
so
we
have
our
own
culture,
it's
30
years
old.
A
B
A
I've
got
this
last
statement
here
because
occasionally,
with
other
occasionally
people
coming
in
for
other
standards,
development
organizations
where
it's
all
about
voting,
we
get
bulks
of
people
coming
in,
bringing
their
idea
and
trying
to
vote
it
into
thank
boat
it
into
reality.
Bad
ideas,
fortunately,
presenters,
still
bad
ideas.
We
know
what
bad
ideas
are,
or
we
mostly
can
identify
them.
Sometimes
we
standardized
them,
but
most
we
can
identify
them
and
get
rid
of
them.
A
So
if
you
are,
if
you
were
challenged
on
the
technology
or
the
Technic,
the
technical
approach
that
you're
you're
providing
make
sure
you
have
good
technical
reason,
good
technical
statements
about
that
for
the
guy
who's
taking
photos,
there
are
slides
and
we
can
get
you
copies
of
them.
Okay,
we
meet
three
times
a
year.
We
need
all
over
the
world.
This
100th
meeting
we
used
to
meet
about
four
times
a
year
way
back
when
we
can't
do
that
anymore.
In
the
meeting
you're
going
to
encounter
a
bunch
of
organized
activities.
A
The
working
group
sessions-
Bar
None,
are
the
major
number
of
things.
The
major
groups
of
things
that
you're
going
to
see
here
but
you're,
also
going
to
see
birds
of
the
Feather
sessions
and
a
birds
of
a
feather
session,
is
sort
of
a
proto
working
group.
I'll
talk
a
little
bit
more
about
that
internet
research
task
force
sessions.
I
think
we've
actually
got
a
dozen
this
time.
It's
kind
of
high
you'll
have
sessions
that
are
sort
of
the
summary
of
what's
going
on
in
an
area.
A
So,
for
example,
if
you're
interested
in
security,
the
security
area
advisory
working
group
session
will
be
a
summary
of
what's
been
going
on
in
security
area
for
the
meeting.
So
it
may
be
worthwhile
for
you,
if
you're,
to
learn
a
little
bit
more
before
getting
it
to
to
wet
and
other
things
on
Wednesday
we
have
a
plenary.
Sometimes
we
have
two
of
them
right
now.
We
just
have
one
combined
plenary
and
that's
on
Wednesday.
A
It's
both
the
administrative
about
how
many
people
showed
up
how
we're
doing
on
money
things
along
those
lines
and
a
technical
plenary
which
may
include
technical
presentations
on
a
particular
topic
and
then
questions
and
answers
with
the
internet.
Internet
internet
architecture
board
and
with
the
I
internet
steering
group
internet
Engineering
steering
group.
So
if
you
want
to
ask
good
question,
so
that's
a
good
place,
there
are
tutorials
and
lunch
sessions.
The
tutorials
are
mostly
on
this
day.
A
Lunch
sessions
are
generally
hosted
by
the
post,
whoever's
paying
for
part
of
the
the
stuff
that
we're
doing
here
and
it's
an
opportunity
for
them
to
talk
about
something,
that's
near
and
dear
their
heart,
with
a
captive
audience,
social
events,
how
many
people
signed
up
for
the
social
event?
Okay,
here's
a
hint
one
of
the
old
the
things
the
old
timers
know
about
is
the
social.
Is
it's
supposed
to
get
your
ticket
because
most
cases
they
sell
off
fairly
quickly.
A
If
you
don't
want
them,
you
can
always
turn
back
in
or
create
them
off,
but
you
know
whether
but
hackathons
Co
Sprint's
and
related
actives.
Does
anybody
do
the
hackathons
or
close
friends
here
a
few
of
you?
Okay,
so
the
hackathons
are
basically
just
go
off
and
do
things
that
are
of
interest
for
a
group
of
people
the
Coase
prints
are
people
were
actually
writing
code
that
the
IETF
uses
for
its
standards
processing.
A
A
There's
no
sign
up
no
registration
for
a
working
group
session,
just
go
on
in
and
I'll
tell
you
how
to
behave
in
slide
later
disorganized
events,
possibly
the
most
important
thing
about
the
IETF
is
that
this
is
an
opportunity
for
unique
people
who
are
interest
in
the
same
things.
You
are
to
make
friends,
friendships
or
technical
contacts
that
might
last
for
30
years,
they're
still
having
lunch
with
people.
I
went
to
the
first
meeting
with
okay.
A
This
is
important.
It's
all
about
us
hearing
your
ideas
and
you
hearing
our
ideas
and
we
synthesizing
something
better.
We
really
do
want
to
hear
from
you
and
the
hallway
means
in
many
cases
are
going
to
be.
Were
you
get
quite
a
lot
of
the
benefit
from
this
meeting
bar
boss,
things
that
are
not
ready
for
real
organization?
A
People
basically
send
a
note
out
to
the
mailing
list,
saying:
hey
we're
gonna
meet
in
the
bar
someplace
and
talk
about
this
topic
anybody's
welcome
to
come
in
so
you
buy
your
own
beers,
but
you
know
it
may
be
an
opportunity
to
hear
about
it,
an
idea
that
you
thought
okay,
nobody
else
was
interested
in,
but
I
I
think
there.
You
know
we
should
talk
about
it.
A
The
editing
sessions
are
actually
something
I
want
you
to
be
careful
about
the
you
may
wander
around
here
and
you
will
see
groups
of
people
sitting
around,
usually
in
a
ring
all
with
all
typing
along
those.
Are
people
working
on
documents
usually
trying
to
get
them
done
because
they
got
people
there
to
work
through
them?
Please
don't
disturb
them
if
you're
not
involved
in
that.
In
that
particular
thing,
that's
the
only
one
I'm.
A
Not
to
involve
people
are
most
not
to
annoy
people
most
of
the
time
going
up
and
talking
to
people
is
perfectly
fine.
That's
the
about
the
only
one
now
there's
three
different
ways
to
get
a
copy:
the
agenda
to
URLs
and
the
app
I
recommend
the
app
the
these
URLs
and
the
app
allowing
you
to
get
access
to
the
list
of
working
group
sessions
and
all
the
meeting
materials
that
are
associated
with
a
particular
working
group
session.
So
you
can
click
on
it
and
you
go
okay.
What's
the
document
they're
talking
about?
Oh,
that's
it!
A
Oh,
that
stupid,
throw
it
away
and
you
move
on.
You
know
or
I
like
that
mean,
and
you
can
find
something
else.
So
you're
gonna
end
up
doing
a
lot
of
research
when
you're,
when
you're
working
with
the
IEP
yet
so
be
respectful
to
people
again.
Like
I
said
some
people
don't
know
they're
being
rude,
don't
assume
people
are
being
rude
to
you,
don't
try
and
be
rude
to
other
people
being
nice
to
each
other.
Do
introduce
yourselves
if
you're
talking
with
someone
and
and
wait
for
a
break
in
the
conversation.
A
Introduce
yourself
tell
me
what
you're
interested
in
tell
them
why
you
think
you
might
contribute
or
what
you
want
to
know
about
the
whole
thing.
Harassment
do
we
have
any
of
the
Ombudsman
here?
Can
you
stand
up
for
a
second?
The
IETF
has
the
IE
and
hold
up
your
badge,
because,
oh
okay,
is
it
now
green,
okay,
I
keep
changing
the
colors,
so
there's
three
of
these
folks.
If
you
feel
that
you
mean
you're
being
harassed
or
something
along
those
lines
go
find
one
of
those
folks.
It's
a
green.
A
It's
a
badge
with
a
green
tag
on
it
that
says
Ombudsman
the
problem
is
we
now
have
lots
of
green
tags
of.
Did
you
see
the
list
of
Oh
Naveen
brought
a
whole
bunch
of
bag
tags.
I've
got
troubles
troublemaker
in
mine.
So
if
you
can't
find
one
of
those
folks
find
somebody
with
one
of
the
dot
one
of
the
colored
dots
on
their
badges
and
ask
them
to
help
you,
okay,
we
have
a
policy
mostly
because
we
have
a
policy.
We
haven't
had
much
arrest
in
the
last
few
years.
A
Anybody
ever
see
those
nature
films
with
the
army
ants
where
they
basically
go
would
attack
the
carcass
and
then
all
is
left
is
bones:
it's
a
little
bit
like
the
ietf
at
the
socials,
where
there's
food.
So
please,
when
you
get
a
chance,
if
you're
in
there
take
some
food
move
away
from
the
line,
come
back
back
for
seconds
leave
some
for
the
other
folks,
don't
leave
your
bag
unguarded
we're
in
a
good
place
here,
but
still
you
know,
can
we
an
entire
day
if
your
if
your
bag
is
alright,
feel
free
to?
A
A
Everything
that
we
do
in
the
sessions
here
has
to
be
ratified
on
the
mailing
list
before
it
becomes
a
standard
or
before
we
move
forward
upon
that.
The
things
here
we're
focused
on
the
key
issues,
we're
generally
working
on
topics
that
have
already
been
discussed
on
the
mailing
list,
but
we
need
high
bandwidth
to
work
through
them
here.
A
They,
the
working
group,
have
low
an
agreed
word
plan
has
a
schedule
to
complete
stuff,
which
it
mostly
never
gets
to
most
of
them
last
more
a
couple
more
years
and
they
were
actually
scheduled
for,
and
they
are
sometimes
preceded
by
a
birds
of
a
feather
session.
These
are
not
tutorial
birds
of
a
feather
sessions,
maybe
a
little
bit
more
tutorial
there
about
a
new
idea,
or
some
are
trying
to
figure
out.
A
The
area
directors
are
the
guys
who
basically
figure
out
whether
or
not
the
working.
The
baath
is
going
to
happen.
If
you
want
more
details,
you
can
approach
one
of
the
working
group,
either
the
working
group
chairs
or
one
of
the
area
of
directors
and
ask
them
for
the
process
for
doing
it.
I'd
recommend
waiting
a
few
meetings,
but
you
know
it's
there.
A
If
you
want
it
so
I
talked
about
the
areas
and
I
said
it
wasn't
quite
as
straightforward
as
as
going
to
the
same
same
area
as
the
stuff
is
in,
because
the
areas
are
set
up
so
that
applications,
transport,
intern
and
routing
are
our
layering
stuff.
But
security
can
have
stuff
in
applications.
Transport,
internet
and
routing
and
operations
can
have
the
same
thing,
so
you
may
have
to
do
a
little
bit
of
playing
around
to
figure
out
which
which
area
some
topic
of
interest
is
in
for
you,
so
pointing
into
the
stick.
A
When
you
get
up
in
a
working
group
session,
this
is
probably
the
most
important
thing
from
the
slide.
It's
all
about
identifying
yourself
get
up,
identify
yourself.
Every
time
you
get
to
the
microphone.
Please
have
a
topical
conversate
topic
and
please
be
brief
about
it.
When
you
go
there,
there's
a
set
of
blue
sheets
for
some
reason.
We
never
do
them
for
this
meeting,
but
in
every
meeting
there's
a
a
blue
sheet
sign
your
name
and
your
organization.
We
keep,
we
basically
scan
them
and
discard
the
things
they're,
mainly
there.
A
Assign
the
blue
sheet
please
be
prepared,
read
the
working
group
agenda
and
drafts
before
you
going.
If
you
don't
have
the
time
to
do
that,
ideally,
don't
you
probably
don't
have
anything
to
say
on
the
topic:
listen
if
the
speaker's,
not
speaking
up
well
enough
or
you're,
having
problems,
understanding
and
feel
free
to
tell
people
you
know,
get
up
and
say
that
the
problem
and
and
make
sure
they
fix
it.
They
can't
fix
it.
They
don't
know
it.
A
If
you
read
the
draft
and
you've
got
a
Kangol
comment,
feel
free
to
to
do
the
brief,
but
please
be
brief
about
it.
Don't
have
the
microphone
being
the
other
part
of
it.
Look
around
you
most
of
you
have
your
bags
and
some
of
you
have
your
bags
on
the
seats
here.
We've
got
plenty
of
room
here.
Some
of
the
rooms
are
very
full.
So
please
be
aware
of
the
folks
standing
in
the
back.
Looking
for
a
seat,
move
your
bags
down
and
make
the
seats
available
avoid
signing
side
conversations.
A
You
may
think
you're
being
quiet,
the
best
room
may
not.
So
if
you
need,
if
you,
if
you
need
to
do
a
conversation,
go
on
outside
how's
that
and
how
many
people
here
have
used-
jabber,
okay,
that's
actually
a
good
start.
So
in
the
working
group
sessions,
every
working
group
session
has
a
jabber
channel
and
it
is
where
there's
a
jabber
scribe,
typing
and
who's
talking
and
the
topic
of
conversation
not
doing
notes
on
there.
But
for
newcomers
really
useful
to
have
access
to
the
jabber
channel.
A
It's
a
chat
application
we'll
talk
about
how
to
get
there
and
you
can
put
in
a
comment
saying
what
was
he
talking
about
or
why?
Why
is
this
important
and
the
thing
and
people
in
the
channel?
Why
answer,
especially
if
you're,
not
an
English,
speaker
and
and
de
spoke,
the
person
speaking
is
English
or
the
person's
being
is
non-english,
speaker
and
you're,
not
quite
getting
what
they're
saying
so.
A
The
ITF
has
a
weird
approach
to
dealing
with
standards.
It
we
looked
at
a
lot
of
different
things
and
we
finally
got
to
the
point
of
consensus.
Consensus
is
basically
not
everybody
has
to
agree,
but
every
comment,
or
every
ever
reasonable
opinion
has
to
be
addressed
and
done
now.
We've
got
a
couple
of
different
ways
of
doing
consensus.
A
Sometimes
it's
a
working
group
survey
of
a
mailing
list
survey
of
what
people
thought
was
going
on
another
one
is
coming,
you
might
end,
you
know
a
meeting
and
you
may
be
sending
head
down
on
your
on
your
laptop
and
also
you
know
and
you're.
You
know
feedback,
it's
not
feedback,
it's
a
way.
We
we
do
things.
So
let
me
give
you
an
example
here.
So
the
question
for
consensus
in
this
room
is:
is
this
room
too
hot,
too
cold
or
just
right?
When
I
asked
the
question?
A
A
The
consent,
the
the
the
opinion
of
the
chairs,
the
consensus
of
the
room
is
in
the
room.
Is
too
cold?
Okay
and
I
actually
tend
to
agree
with
you
and
you
and
you,
people
who
think
is
just
right.
You
know
I
I,
don't
understand
you.
Okay,
there
is
actually
a
good
RFC
on
consensus
and
humming
I've
listed
the
RFC
here.
A
So
you're
gonna
see
a
bunch
of
people
wandering
around
with
badges
on
them
and
they
may
have
no
nothing
on
them.
They
may
have
one
or
more
dots
on
them
and
they
may
also
have
this
this
dot
here
that
used
to
be
just
printed
on
the
badges.
Now
it's
now
a
separate
it's
now
a
separate
sticky
and
the
the
smiling
face
means
that
somebody
who
is
willing
to
basically
talk
to
anybody
willing
to
help
friendly
guys.
So
you
can
approach
those
you
can
approach
those
people
for
things
that
are
of
general
questions.
A
Working
group
chairs
are
probably
the
ones
with
the
most
number
of
dots
here.
By
the
way
they
told
me
that
the
they
are
now
printing.
You
know
ia
VI,
ESG
I'm
calm.
How
does
the
map
that
that,
on
there,
anyway,
they're
they're
printing,
those
on
the
they're
printing,
the
names
on
the
badges?
So
if
you
can't
remember
this,
remember
blue
for
the
working
group
shares
or
that's
the
ones
you
can
see
a
lot
of,
and
remember
this
pretty
hard
line,
the
other
one
you
may
want
to
look
at
as
localhost.
A
They
are
now
getting
the
green
tag
at
the
bottom,
unfortunately
like
the
Ombudsman,
and
they
are
the
folks
who
are
responsible
for
this
part
for
hosting
part
of
the
network,
they're
the
local
host.
They
work
with
the
networking
folks.
They
work
with
a
set
of
folks
here
and
if
you've
got
a
question
about
this
particular
area.
In
this
particular
IETF
they're,
good
people
to
go
talk
to
and
I
will
change
the
color
names
and
I
swear.
It
was
orange.
A
Fall
meeting:
I!
Guess
that's
right,
so
you
should
see.
A
number
of
these
folks
are
the
nominations
committee
us
how
the
IETF
picks
its
Pyxis
managers,
the
internet,
Engineering
steering
group
managers,
the
area
directors
are
there
and
the
internet
architecture
board
and
the
internet
advisory
Oversight
Committee.
Those
are
the
people
to
get
selected
by
the
NomCom
and
then
approved
through
a
different
process.
A
At
this
meeting
there
are
a
number
of
useful
people
that
you
should
know
about.
You
may
never
use
you
never
never
need
to
know.
You
may
never
need
to
use
them,
but
they
are
important
not
only
for
the
meeting
and
for
but
for
the
IETF
standardization
process.
The
first
group
of
the
folks
are
the
Secretariat
you'll,
see
them
wandering
on
I've
lost
track
of
what
the
color
of
their
shirts
are.
This
I
think
they're
in
the
teal
blue
shirts.
They
are
employees
of
a
contractor
that
is
responsible
for
the
Secretariat
functions
for
the
IETF.
A
That's
setting
up
the
meeting
managing
the
servers
for
the
IETF
and
everything
else
the
registration
desk
is
most
is
on
one
side
manned
by
local
people,
that
we
hire
for
the
registration
process
and
on
the
other.
People
are
the
Secretariat
folks
that
are
there.
So
if
you've
got
a
question,
you've
got
problems
with
a
hotel.
You've
got
you've
got
things
that
you
weren't
able
to
resolve.
Sometimes
they
can
help
you
with
that.
The
internet
assigned
names
and
numbers
folks,
Sabrina,
okay,
so
stand
up
for
a
second,
oh
yeah.
A
So
when
you
get
to
the
point
of
making
standards,
there
are
lots
of
assignments
between
like
which
bid
is
what,
in
a
header,
what
an
option
code
is
thing
along
those
lines,
the
the
I
Anna
is
responsible
for
managing
our
registry
of
those
things.
That's
what
four
hundred
records
use
now:
twenty
okay,
twenty-five
hundred
regice
separate
registries,
we
started
out
with
an
internet
addresses
and
the
main
names,
and
now
it's
lots
of
other
things.
So
if
you
are
writing
a
standard
that
involves
things
like
that
Union,
you
must
talk
to
them.
A
I
mention
them
because
they
have
a
booth
here
and
actually
they're
kind
of
fun
Gobbo
over
and
talked
to
many
ways.
They
have
candy
so
and
they're.
Always
there
always
basically
trying
to
compete
with
the
RFC
editor,
who
is
sitting
right
next
to
them
on
how
good
the
candy
is,
because
she
also
brings
her
stuff
in
so
the
RC
editor
is
responsible
for
turning
Internet
drafts
into
our
our
documents
are
formal,
published
documents
request
for
comment.
Okay,
sorry
I've
been
told
that
we're
no
longer
using
requests
for
comments.
A
Although
that's
what
RFC
stood
for
it's
now
like
going
from
international
business
machine
to
IBM,
you
know
it's
now,
just
IBM,
so
it's
now
our
C's,
but
way
back
when
RFC
1
was
literally
a
document
was
going
out
into
the
internet
community
for
comments
for
building
what
was
turn
going
to
turn
into
the
internet.
So
but
so
the
series
editor
is
responsible
for
the
editorial
characteristics
of
the
documents.
A
The
production
center
in
the
publication
and
the
publisher
are
responsible
for
actually
getting
the
stuff
through
the
process
and
onto
the
onto
the
servers
as
a
final
document.
So
when
you
get
to
the
point
when
you
went
later
on,
you'll
probably
end
up
interacting
with
me,
but
like
I
said:
they've
got
candy.
So
here
are
the
folks.
A
This
is
these
folks.
Here
are
the
Secretariat
Portia
is
the
brand
new
internet,
administrative
director
and
I'm
sorry
ietf,
administrative
director
and
she's
in
it
she's
here
on
an
interim
basis,
ray
just
left
us,
although
you'll
probably
see
him
wandering
around
I,
think
he
just
hang
on
me:
I
Anna
staff.
We
saw
Sabrina
Alise
is
leaving
us,
she
will
be
retiring
as
of
whenever
she
keeps
moving
her
date.
So
I
I
can't
get
rid
of
her
on
here.
A
Neville
is
the
independent
submissions
editor.
So
we
have
the
RFC
series
and
there's
a
lot
of
streams
that
go
into
that.
Some
of
the
streams
are
coming
from
the
IETF,
but
there's
actually
a
stream
that
allows
anybody
to
submit
something
inside
the
as
an
independent
submission
and
Neville
and
Neville,
and
his
folks
are
responsible,
are
Neville
primarily
is
responsible
for
figuring
out
whether
or
not
something
gets
published
in
that
stream.
A
A
Everything
I've
said
here
in
some
ways
is
represented
in
the
various
documents
that
are
available.
I
just
hopefully
made
a
little
bit
more
fun
to
listen
to
the
wiki.
The
wiki
is
actually
one
of
those
things
you
want
to
go
and
take
a
look
at.
It
is
very
helpful,
specifically
if
you're
looking
for
a
ride
to
the
airport
on
the
way
back,
but
it's
also
where
the
information
on
the
network
is
and
where
you
can
put
help
tickets
in
and
things
along
those
lines.
There's
a
whole
bunch
of
tutorials
that
we've
created
over
the
years.
A
A
The
IETF
has
lots
and
lots
and
lots
and
lots
of
mailing
lists.
There's
one
per
working
group,
there's
a
and
then
there's
a
bunch
of
others
on
there's
the
IETF
million
things
like
that,
I'm
not
going
to
go
through
them.
If
you
really
care
take
a
look,
you
can
scribe
to
email
to
your
heart
content
and
get
lots
of
information.
You
are
automatically
subscribed
to
this
mailing
list
and
you
can
always
get
off
of.
In
fact
somebody
asked
how
to
but
it's
useful,
because
this
is
an
information.
A
This
is
a
way
we
can
contact
you
directly
on
things
that
might
not
make
sense
for
a
newcomer,
but
you
know
the
rest
of
us
are
just
going
at
same
old
thing
and
the
network
information
is
here
any
given.
Network
are
getting
any
given
session.
Just
change
that
number.
We
finally
got
the
the
URLs
to
actually
stabilize
a
little
bit.
If
you
go
to
the
terminal
room,
there's
actually
a
printed
copy
of
the
current
network
information.
So
if
you
don't
want
to
go
look
online
or
you
can't
get
online
go
to
the
terminal.
A
The
terminal,
by
the
way
I
should
mention
the
term
room,
has
people
a
lot
of
local
host
people
who
can
help
you
get
on
to
the
network
and
in
be
helpful
and
the
terminal
room.
Interesting
link
has
no
terminals
just
has
printers
and
hard
hard
links.
So
if
you
want
to
plug
in
via
ethernet
instead
of
Wi-Fi,
you
can
do
that.
A
The
IR
teff
a
moment
ago,
the
the
IR
TF,
was
a
separate
task
force
under
the
Department
under
the
Department
offense
early
stuff
and
is
now
an
activity
of
the
internet
architecture
board.
So
what
ends
up
happening
is
the
IR
TF
deals
with
topics
that
the
IETF
is
not
quite
ready
for.
So
one
of
the
things
we
worked
on
was
the
late
island
networking,
which
was
literally
investigating
how
to
run
an
internet
over
the
solar
system.
So
the
crypto.
A
Crypto
forum
research
group,
CFR
G,
is
sort
of
a
halfway
group
between
the
IETF
and
the
IR
ITF
dealing
with
cryptography.
So
if
your
interest
in
things
like
that,
but
there's
a
bunch
of
them,
there's
like
12
of
them
on
here.
If
you
get
into
V
and
if
you
get
into
the
app
you
can
actually
filter
and
just
see
all
those
you
may
attend
as
an
observer,
you
may
not
be
allowed
depending
upon
how
the
working
group
is
set.
A
How
the
research
task
force
group
is
set
up
to
talk
generally
invitation
for
the
research
groups
is,
is
by
invitation
or
by
credentialing,
so
you'll
ask
to
join
and
we'll
say
what:
why
should
we
let
you
join
it's
again.
It's
not
part
the
ietf
exactly,
but
it
does
generally
meet
with
us,
but
it's
a
useful
thing.
If
you're
looking
to
hear
about
new
topics
or
topics
that
we
may
be
dealing
with
in
five
years,
newcomers
page,
ideally
everything
we
need
everything
you
might
need
is
a
new
current
sort
of
linked
off
there.
A
There's
a
bunch
of
older
briefings
from
the
guy
was
doing
the
newcomers
brief
before,
which
was
much
more
historic.
History
tutorial
things
along
those
lines.
So
if
you
want
to
spend
a
half
an
hour,
looking
you
know
hearing
about
the
history
of
the
IETF.
There
are
a
brief.
There
are
things
there.
The
tools
page
is
where
you
would
go.
If
you're
submitting
internet
drafts
lots
of
information
there
again,
I'm
just
gonna
give
you
the
URLs,
you
probably
won't
need
them
for
a
few
meetings
and
then
jabber
I'll
talk
about
in
a
second.
A
Okay,
that's
kind
of
small
if
we
end
up
having
people
come
on
weather
with
their
spouses,
significant
others,
families,
whatever
the
Companions
program
later
on
for
you,
may
be
useful
because
it
allows
all
those
people
to
meet
and
figure
out
what
they're
going
to
do
when
you're
off
nerding
or
geeking.
So
keep
in
mind
our
definition
of
newcomer
is
anybody
who's
attended,
five
meetings
or
less?
So
if
you
have
attended
five
meetings,
less,
you
are
welcome
to
go
to
the
newcomers
meet-and-greet,
and
that
is
just
before
the
Welcome
Reception.
A
The
working
group
shares
the
area.
Directors
will
be
there.
People
like
me,
will
be
there
we're
generally.
Various
tables
are
set
up
to
represent
each
of
the
area,
so
you
can
go
over
the
area
that
you're
interested
and
talk
to
somebody
and
see
what
what's?
What
if
you
got,
if
you
see
two
people
with
dots
on
their
badges
talking
to
each
other
feel
free
to
interrupt
them.
The
this
is
about
you
guys
in
this
particular
thing.
We
really
do
want
to
hear
from
you.
A
Newcomers
dinner
naveen,
who
is
one
of
the
Secretariat
folks
sets
up,
sets
up
a
dinner
for
the
newcomers.
It's
you
know,
pay
your
own
way,
but
they
figure
they
figure
out
a
restaurant
name
and
they
send
people
over
to
it.
Send
her
an
email
to
RSVP
I,
think
that's
the
date,
the
date
and
time
right
now,
but
check
with
Naveen
and
it's
opportunity
to
have
a
chance
to
talk
to
other
newcomers
and
go.
You
know
what
the
heck
did.
A
I
get
myself
into
so
now
coming
here,
her
participating
the
MIT
participate
or
signed
up
for
the
mentoring
program.
Okay,
so
the
mentoring
program
is
about
a
dozen.
The
mentoring
program
is
an
opportunity
for
you
to
get
matched
with
somebody
who
has
interests
that
are
similar
to
your
own
who's
been
dealing
with
the
ietf
for
a
while
I
recommended.
A
If
you
and-
and
you
don't
have
to
do
it
this
meeting,
you
can
do
it
the
next
meeting,
for
example,
once
you
get
a
better
idea,
what
you
want
to
do
so,
and
Nani
Elkins
runs
that
she
does
a
pretty
good
job.
So
this
slide
changes
every
IETF
and
it
depends
upon
the
particular
particular
location,
we're
in
here
it's
safe
to
wander
around.
There's
really
no
problem
with
being
out
by
yourself
at
night.
Again,
like
anything
else,
you
just
sorta,
watch
things,
drugs
and
chewing
them.
A
I'd
never
heard
the
chewing
gum,
one
before
I
knew
about
the
drugs
be
careful
of
littering,
and
this
one
was
one
that
I
wasn't
able
to
confirm,
but
I
I
was
told
that
it's
possible.
If
you
can
connect
to
an
unconsidered
Wi-Fi
same
thing,
might
consider
of
service,
so
be
a
little
bit
careful
about
where
you
go
still
watch
your
stuff
so
and.
A
Sorry
there
we
go
okay,
so
three,
more
slides,
I,
think
networking
I
by
now,
you've,
probably
all
gotten
under
the
IHF
Network.
If
you
haven't
there's
lunch
is's,
they
begin
IETF
or
IETF,
six
nat64
or
any
of
those
each
one
of
those
has
a
separate
reason.
A
separate,
/,
separate
reason
for
being
in
existence.
Most
of
them
are
secured
and
the
password
and
user
ID
are
IETF
and
IETF.
It's
pretty
much
all
you
need
to
know
in
the
hotels
we've
got
one
of
the
best
networks.
They'll
ever
see.
A
We've
been
doing
this
literally
for
thirty
years,
well,
29
years,
I
think
when
we
started
doing
the
first
network
and
we
take
over
the
hotel.
So
if
you're
in
one
of
the
conference,
hotels,
the
Fairmont
or
the
Stanford,
the
Swiss
hotel
you're
on
the
IHF
network
on
the
IETF
hotel,
SSID,
so
another
reason
for
trying
to
get
into
the
conference.
Hotels
I
talked
about
the
terminal
room
and
about
the
network
stuff.
So
so
jabber
I
can't
give
you
a
recipe
for
getting
on
to
jabber.
A
You
have
to
do
some
research
here,
but
these
are
the
two
locations
you
want
to
go
to
this
location
lists
the
clients
and
it's
reasonably
up
to
date.
I
checked
this
last
time
around
this
website
lists
where
you
can
get
free
jabber
accounts,
so
you
can
go
off
there
and
sign
up
something
once
you've
got
your
account
set
up
generally.
The
chat
rooms
are
the
working
group
name
at
jabbered
on
I-80
f10
org.
Ask
the
guy
ask
somebody
in
the
working
group
that
you're
in
and
you
can
join
their
cool.
A
Two
things
make
sure
you
take
the
survey.
Okay
and
the
other
thing
is:
there
is
a
feedback
session
at
the
end
of
the
week.
We
really
appreciate
the
newcomers
showing
up
for
the
feedback
session,
talk
about
what
you
like
to
at
the
xix,
what
you
didn't
like
about
the
IETF
and
how
we
can
improve
things
for
newcomers,
so.
A
A
Over
this
last
30
years,
something
on
the
order
of
8,000,
RFC's
or
7,000
RFC's,
and
probably
tens
of
thousands
and
Internet
graphs
have
gone
through
the
system.
That's
a
lot
of
work
for
a
lot
from
a
lot
of
people
who
aren't
getting
paid
by
the
standards
organization
to
do
that
work.
So,
please
take
out
it
put
please
taking
an
opportunity
to
make
the
most
of
your
stuff
here.
So
with
that
I'm
gonna
take
some
questions.
A
If
any
and
if
you've
got
a
question,
please
get
up
to
the
microphone
and
tell
me
your
name
at
least
somebody
give
me
an
example.
So
I
can
show
you
okay,
or
is
everybody
just
want
to
get
on
here?
Okay,
that
may
be
the
case.
So
I
got
one
last
one
for
you.
If
you
want
to
play
adventure,
there's
the
URL
for
it,
it's
an
old
text
game,
it's
still
a
classic
and
it's
still
kind
of
fun
and
I.
Dare
you
to
find
the
last
point
without
cheating?