►
From YouTube: IETF105-TUTORIALNEW-20190721-1230
Description
TUTORIALNEW meeting session at IETF105
2019/07/21 1230
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/105/proceedings/
A
So
I
want
to
introduce
I'm,
I'm
Carol
Donahue
I'm
from
the
education
team
here
at
the
IETF
is
rich
sells.
He
and
I
are
currently
Co
chairing
the
edgy
team
and
we
offer
a
series
of
tutorials.
We
also
do
the
newcomers
overview
the
newcomers
feedback
session
on
Thursday
morning,
and
we
do
a
number
of
other
things
as
well.
So
there's
two
things
I'd
like
to
ask
you
at
the
end
of
this
there's
gonna
be
a
link
to
a
survey.
A
We
really
are
interested
in
your
feedback
on
this
particular
tutorial
itself
and
then
towards
the
end
of
the
week,
we're
interested
in
any
feedback.
You
have
on
things
that
we
can
do
to
make
your
experience
here
at
the
IETF
better.
There
is
a
mailing
list,
edge.you
team
at
IETF,
Torg,
it's
in
one
of
the
slides,
you'll,
see
it
as
it
comes
through.
So
we
welcome
your
feedback
there
as
well,
and
with
that
I'd
like
to
introduce
our
two
speakers
for
today
providing
the
newcomers
area.
A
We
have
Angela
Maharshi
from
Boston
University
I'm
fairly,
certain
I
mispronounced,
her
last
name
because
she's
always
been
just
on
child
to
me,
but
as
I
turned
to
her
I
was
like
oh
I.
Just
realized
I,
don't
know
how
to
pronounce
your
last
name,
but
you
can
fix
it
and
rich
cells
from
Akamai,
so
I
hope
you
all
enjoy
this
and
I'll
talk
to.
C
C
C
C
F
Hello,
everyone
I'm
Anton
Malhotra
from
Boston
University
I'm,
a
PhD
student
there
and
my
research
basically
focuses
on
the
security
of
internet
protocols,
and
here
at
ITF,
I
am
involved
with
several
working
groups,
primarily
with
the
NTP
working
group
and
other
security
groups.
This
is
I,
guess
my
10
IETF,
now
10th
or
12th
well,
I've
enjoyed
every
single
bit
of
it
and
I
hope
that
you
guys
too.
So,
let's
get
you
all
started.
First
of
all,
I
have
question:
can
I
see
a
show
of
hands
for
those
who
are
newcomers
here
and
by
newcomers?
F
I
mean
those
who
have
attended
up
to
5
meetings,
ok,
most
of
you
and
who
are
the
first-timers
like
the
very
first
ok
that
should
have
been.
My
first
question
is
great.
So
most
of
you
have
not
attended
this
in-person
newcomers,
tutorials,
and
maybe
some
of
you
have
attended
any
of
you
have
attended
the
webinars
that
happened
before
great,
ok
cool.
So
today
we
are
going
to
keep
equip
you
with
a
lot
of
information
so
that
you
can
have
a
better
week
here.
F
First
of
all,
welcome
to
Montreal
it's
a
beautiful
city.
Do
you
explore
it?
I
would
like
to
thank
Brad
and
Mike
for
drafting
this
presentation.
A
lot
of
other
people
have
after
works,
work,
Donna,
so
I'm
sure
I
haven't
met
them
personally,
but
I'm
sure
there
are
great
people,
they
have
done
a
great
job,
you'll
see
so,
first
of
all
this
and
the
following
slide.
These
are
the
ietf
note
well
slide,
as
the
name
suggests.
It's
a
note
well
slide.
F
So
you
better
note:
it
well
you're
going
to
see
the
slide
a
lot
of
times
during
this
entire
week,
specifically
before
every
working
group
session
and
we'll
talk
about
what
working
groups
are
and
what
working
group
sessions
are.
But
you
are
going
to
see
this
slide
the
sliders.
Basically
it
applies
to
all
the
ietf
participation,
whether
you
are
participating
in
person
or
remotely.
It
basically
reminds
you
that
all
the
participants
of
the
IETF
agrees
to
abide
by
the
IETF
policies
on
various
topics.
F
I,
don't
expect
you
to
read
this
whole
thing
right
now,
but
it's
important
that
you
read
it
before
any
sort
of
participation
at
ITF.
This
is
again
the
continuation
of
the
IETF.
Note
note
well
slide.
These
are
different
BCPs,
that
is
best
contract,
current
practices,
documents
which
are
the
RFC's,
and
they
have
like
details
on
several
topics
that
ITF
IETF
has
policies
on
and
that
you,
as
an
ITF
participant,
would
agree
to
abide
by.
F
There
is
BC
p4
standards
processes
working
group
processes
where
the
most
of
the
work
of
IETF
happens.
Then
there
are
policies
for
anti-harassment
code
of
conduct,
patents
and
copyright,
and
then,
most
recently
there
is
a
BCP
on
privacy
policy.
That
is
about
the
interim
that
how
ITF
handles
all
the
information
that
you
provide
to
ITF.
So,
if
you
guys
are
interested
in
that
kind
of
thing,
you
should
go
through
all
these
BCPs
okay.
F
So
here
at
IDF,
we
try
to
provide
you
with
all
the
necessary
information
and
resources
that
are
necessary
for
you
to
get
started
for
this
week
and
get
integrated
into
the
community.
So
there
are
a
lot
of
newcomers
activities
that
are
organized
at
every
ITF
meeting.
So
before
this
newcomers
tutorial,
there
were
webinars
for
the
newcomers,
and
today
this
is
the
newcomers
tutorial,
your
hair,
it's
from
12:30
to
1:30.
F
The
next
newcomers
event
is
the
IETF
quick
connections.
That's
also
today,
at
4:00
p.m.
it
requires
a
pre-registration
there's,
a
newcomers,
I.t
I.t
of
newcomers,
page
there's
a
link
there.
You
can
go
there
and
register
yourself,
it's
a
limited
space
event,
so
it's
better
that
you
register
early.
This
event
is
basically
here:
you'll
meet
the
IETF
leadership,
so
you
can
have
it's
a
very
efficient
way
to
meet
the
working
group,
chairs,
area,
directors,
mentors
and
other
leaders,
other
weddings
at
the
IETF
and
I
mean
yes.
F
E
F
So
yeah,
you
can
have
short
one-to-one
conversations
with
the
experience
right
here.
First
there
it
will
be
a
good
start
of
the
week.
You
can
ask
queries.
If
you
are
interested
in
certain
specific
topic,
you
can
go,
ask
them
yeah.
It
will
give
you
a
good
kickoff
for
the
for
surviving
the
rest
of
the
week
and
also
it's
not
a
forum.
Even
there
will
be
no
speeches
or
presentations.
It's
a
very
laid-back
and
informal
event.
F
There
will
be
beer,
there
will
be
wine,
there
will
be
soda
there,
some
snacks,
so
I
suggest
you
should
go
there.
Okay,
so
this
is
in
the
evening
today.
Then
there
is
this:
IETF
guides
mentoring
program
it.
It
was
known
as
IETF
mentoring
program
earlier,
but
now
it's
in
so
basically
you're
assigned
a
guide.
I
may
I
know
who
how
many
people
have
a
mentor
assigned
already?
F
Ok,
very
few
people
actually
I
would
suggest
highly
suggest
that
you
should
go
ask
for
a
mentor
that
will
help
like
it's
super
easy
to
ask
questions
any
specific
questions.
They
will
also
guide
you
and
guide
you
through.
Like
tell
you
all
about
ITF
and
guide
you
to
how
to
meet
new
people,
how
to
approach
different
working
groups
working
group
sessions,
how
or
like
which
working
group
session
is
happening
when
there
are
several
parallel
tracks
going
on
at
the
same
time,
and
then
they
can.
F
Then
there
is
this
newcomers
dinner,
it's
not
an
official,
even
it
is
organized
by
a
secretariat
and
you
have
to
pay
I
guess
25
dollars
for
this
dinner.
So
if
you're
interested,
you
can
register
yourself
and
pay
for
this
dinner,
it's
new
comers
only
dinner.
It's
also
a
mingling
event.
Networking
event
you
can
meet
with
IT,
Affairs
and
other
newcomers.
Here
then,
towards
the
end
of
the
week
that
is
on
Thursday,
we
have
an
early
morning
newcomers
feedback
session.
F
We
are
really
interested
in
knowing
what
you
feel
about
all
these
initiatives
and
all
these
activities
that
we
have
organized
and
how
did
it
help
or
did
not
help
you
get
through
the
week?
How
do
you
feel
about
it
and
what
are
the
other
things
that
you
would
like
to
include,
and
that
would
help
newcomers,
so
this
is
important
and
then,
as
Karen
mentioned,
there
is
a
survey
form
that
we
would
like
you
to
fill
up
to
get
the
feedback
all
right.
So
this
is
almost
about
newcomers
activities.
F
F
So
this
presentation
does
not
really
include
I'm
not
going
to
talk
about
the
history
of
the
IETF
or
how
to
write
standards,
documents
and
the
process
of
standardization,
and
there
are
several
other
things,
but
we
will,
but
there
is
this
link
to
the
YouTube
channel,
where
you
can
find
more
information
about
all
this.
All
these
topics,
okay,
in
the
Nick,
any
any
questions
so
far.
F
Ok,
so
in
this
section
now
I'm
going
to
talk
about
a
little
bit
about
what
IETF
is,
and
it's
related
organizations
and
processes.
So,
first
off
what
is
the
mission
of
IETF?
The
mission
of
the
IETF
is
to
make
the
internet
work
better
by
producing
high-quality,
relevant
technical
documents
that
influence
the
way
people,
design,
use
and
managed
the
Internet.
So
basically,
what
we
are
trying
to
do
here
is
to
develop
and
maintain
the
standard
technologies
to
provide
service
and
the
internet.
F
So
we
want
to
make
sure
we
want
to
ensure
that
the
technology
that
we
provide
here
at
IETF
provides
the
necessary
functionality.
We
also
want
to
make
sure
that
the
technology
is
easily
and
efficiently
deployable.
We
also
want
this
technology.
We
want
to
make
sure
that
the
technology
is
scaleable
at
both
deployment,
as
well
as
the
usage
level,
and
you
also
want
to
make
sure
that
the
technology
that
we
deploy
is
secure
in
itself,
as
well
as
the
at
the
operational
level.
F
F
So
IETF
it's
a
standards,
development
organization.
There
are
several
other
stos,
but
IETF
is
different
from
these
as
dioz
in
in
a
lot
of
aspects.
So
IETF
is
basically
of
voluntary,
based
organizations,
it
organization,
it's
us,
it's
a
self-selected,
individual
participation.
There
is
no
formal
membership,
unlike
other
st
o--'s,
anybody
can
come
willingly
and
join
and
anybody
can
go
whenever
they
wish
to
another
important
and
very
unique
feature
of
IETF.
Is
that
to
reach
a
consensus?
We
do
not
follow
a
formal
voting
procedure.
F
F
Another
important
and
unique
factor
is
that
the
standards
that
we
develop
or
write
here
are
not
mandated.
We
don't
mandate
standards
on
people,
it's
mostly
the
standardization
is
mostly
driven
by
market-based
adoption.
So
if
people
think
that
a
standard
technology
is
useful,
they
would
read
it,
they
would
deploy
it
and
see
if
it
works
and
that's
how
a
specification
becomes
a
standard
when
people
actually
think
that
it
is
useful
and
it
is
deployed.
So
that's
how
it's
kind
of
a
Bottoms
Up
approach,
as
opposed
to
going
from
standardization
to
adoption.
F
We
believe
in
going
from
adoption
to
standardization.
So
it's
a
very
market
adoption
based
process
at
ITF.
We
are
primarily
focused
on
improving
the
internet
working
on
internet
technologies.
That
is
where
the
focuses-
and
that
is
where
we
think
our
expertise
is
as
opposed
to
other
organisations
where,
where
they
are
involved
with
several
other
things
like
other
processes
and
parts
of
Internet,
are
improving
the
internet.
F
All
right,
so
this
is
really
interesting.
If
you're
in
here
for
technology,
then
you
should
definitely
look
at
these
the
slide
and
dig
deeper
into
all
these
areas.
So
the
work
of
IETF
is
organized
into
working
groups.
The
those
are
the
workhorse
of
IETF,
you
can
say,
and
ITF
groups
these
working
groups
into
these
groups
all
right.
So
there
are
currently
seven
areas,
broad
areas
and
the
working
groups
fall
under
one
of
these
areas.
These
areas
are
mostly
dynamic.
F
F
So
how
do
we
achieve
rough
consensus?
As
I
said?
Voting
is
one
option,
but
that
doesn't
really
resonate
well
with
the
idea
of
the
mantra
of
IETF
and
the
people
here.
So
whenever
I'm
in
a
working
group
session,
the
working
group
chair
wants
to
know
the
temperature
of
the
room
on
a
certain
topic
or
how
many
people
agree
to
something
or
disagree.
What
they
usually
do
is
instead
of
a
show
of
hands
or
on
a
voting
process.
F
They
ask
people
in
the
room
to
hum
like
for
or
against
a
topic
and
when
people
do
that,
the
working
group
chair
is
responsible
for
judging
basically
the
the
weight
of
yes
or
no.
It
doesn't
tell
anything
unequivocally
like
what
is
the
real
decision,
but
it
just
gives
an
idea
of
where,
on
the
spectrum
of
completely
acceptable,
completely
unacceptable
people
in
the
room.
Are
it's
really
interesting?
F
So
then
yeah
so
then
the
working
group
chair
is
responsible
for
deciding
whether
we
are
going
for
or
against,
and
it's
not
decided
on
the
spot
like
this
decision
is
then
taking
this
issue
or
topic
is
then
taken
over
to
the
mailing
list
and
it
has
continued
there.
This
is
this
is
basically
to
accommodate
those
people
who
could
not
attend
the
who
were
not
present
there
in
person
and
then
the
whole
process,
not
the
humming,
but
the
entire
discussion
is
taken
to
the
mailing
list
and
then
we
reach
on
judgement.
F
So
that's
that's
the
way
how
we
reach
rough
consensus
and
there's
this
really
interesting.
If
you're
interested,
we
should
go,
read
RFC,
seven,
eight
that
describes
whole
history
of
why
we
follow
and
how
it
all
started
the
humming
process.
Another
important
thing
is
that
about
rough
consensus
is
that
everybody's
voice
is
heard
and
addressed,
but
not
necessarily
accommodated.
So
not
one
person's
dissenting
opinion
can
control
reaching
us
a
judgement.
It's
a
rough
consensus.
F
Okay:
let's
talk
a
little
bit
about
IETF
culture.
As
I
said,
it's
a
very
it's
an
individual
voluntary
based
participation,
so
the
people
who
are
here
are
very,
very
passionate
and
they
are
motivated
and
self
driven
they're
smart
people.
They
are
very
vocal
about
their
opinions.
So
if
you
hear
people
in
the
hallway
yelling
at
each
other,
don't
get
scared.
It's
just
the
way
they
are.
They
are
trying
to
reach
reach
a
good
solution
trying
to
hear
each
other.
F
Also
I
should
keep
in
mind
that
these
people,
some
of
these
people,
have
been
coming
to
these
ideas
for
like
last
20
years.
They
know
each
other
really
well.
They
know
how
to
talk
to
each
other.
They
know
their
ways,
so
don't
get
scared
of.
If
you
are,
if
you
want
to,
if
you're
interested
in
talking
to
someone
just
go
there,
introduce
yourself
talk
to
them,
it'll
be
all
fine
you'll
be
accommodated,
don't
worry
about
it.
F
Another
thing
is
technically
technical
excellence
and
topical
knowledge
is
highly
valued,
so
I
would
suggest
if
you
are
attending
some
working
group
sessions,
make
sure
that
you
have
read
the
relevant
documents
and
if
you
say
something
smart
and
technical
people
would
you
know
you
you'll,
be
accommodated.
You'll
be
you'll,
be
heard,
and
that
says
a
lot
about
ITF
culture.
We
are
very
it's
it's.
It's
pretty
informal
like
it's
very
friendly,
just
like
ITF
culture.
F
The
dress
code
is
also
very
informal
people
mostly
here,
like
to
wear
t-shirts,
though
I'm
in
a
little
bit
of
formal
attire
here
today.
That's
not
how
I
am
normally,
but
if
that's
your
way
go
for
it
whatever
you
want
to
do
you
wanna,
wear
informal,
formal,
it's
it's
all
acceptable
there,
yeah
and,
as
I
said,
people
have
been
coming
here
for
a
very
long
time.
They
have
closed
working
relationships
with
each
other,
and
people
know
each
other
very
well
at
both
personal
as
well
as
professional
level.
So
it's
it's
a
very,
very
friendly
environment.
F
Yes,
okay!
This
is
yes.
This
is
interesting.
So,
as
a
newcomer
here
in
this
week,
you
are
going
to
get
a
lot
of
acronyms
I
would
suggest,
do
not
pay
attention
too
much
attention
to
all
of
them.
A
little
bit
is
fine.
If
you
are
working.
If
you
are
interested
in
the
mostly
interested
in
the
technical
thing,
the
slide
previous
slide
on
the
technical
areas,
you
should
dig
deeper
into
it,
and
these
these
will
we'll
get
these
different,
working
and
moving
parts
of
IETF.
F
That
makes
this
entire
organization
work
gradually,
as
you
start
attending
more
meetings
and
getting
more
involved
in
the
administrative
stuff,
but
just
to
give
you
an
overview
about
different
different
moving
parts
of
ITF.
There
are
several
groups.
The
first
one
here
is
iesg
internet
Engineering
steering
group.
F
F
Then
there
is
IRT
F
internet
research
task
force.
This
organization
is.
This
group
is
basically
focused
on
longer-term
research
areas,
research
topics
in
the
Internet,
as
opposed
to
its
parallel
organization,
IETF,
which
is
focused
more
on
the
immediate
engineering
and
standardization
processes.
So
I
RTF
is
more
research,
long-term
research
focus
groups,
for
instance,
there
is
CFR
G
group,
that
is
the
crypto
forum
research
group
that
provides
guidelines
on
the
adoption
of
emerging
crypto
technologies.
Then
there
is
really
interesting
HPRC,
which
is
the
HR
PC.
F
That's
human
rights
protocol
consideration
group,
which
considers
how
standards
and
protocols
that
we
develop
here
could
could
enable
strengthen
or
weaken
human
rights.
If
you
are
interested
in
that
kind
of
stuff,
you
should
go
attend
I
think
the
meeting
is
on
Friday.
It's
really
interesting,
and
apart
from
these,
there
are
several
other
research
groups
that
are
not
all
of
the
research
group
meetings
happen
every
IETF,
but
a
few
of
subset
of
them
sure
happen
at
different
IETF
meetings
throughout
the
year.
F
Then
there
is
this
internet
architecture
board
that
provides
an
oversight
for
the
technical,
technical
requirements
of
the
end
of
the
internet,
so
they're
also
involved
in
writing
RFC's
and
standards.
The
internet
architecture
board.
Recently
there
was
a
workshop
organized
by
I'm,
not
sure
if
it
was
organized
by
Ivy
via
web
packaging.
Yes,
so.
C
F
F
F
E
E
Sometimes
they
have
little
printouts
and
fan-fold
paper
that
are
worth
doing.
They're
about
a
hundred
and
thirty
working
groups
in
the
IETF
is
on
Tom
mentioned.
They
are
the
unit
of
work
within
the
ITF.
The
people
that
do
things
about
eighty
of
them
are
meeting
this
week,
there's
also
what's
called
birds
of
a
feather
from
the
English
American
phrase.
Birds
of
a
feather
flock
together,
meeting
like-minded
individuals,
and
these
this
is
the
step
of
before
an
actual
working
group
is
formed.
E
So
there'll
be
announcements
and
there
are
announcements
and
things
are
in
the
agenda
about
offs
for
various
topics.
They
may
be.
It's
called
working
group
forming,
meaning
meaning
the
intent
is.
We
want
to
end
up
with
a
working
group
that
then
has
to
get
approved
by
the
area
directors,
or
we
just
want
to
get
together
and
see
if
there's
interest
they
both
might
meet
once
or
twice,
for
example,
and
our
W
o
the
IRT
F
is
meeting
also
on
there's
about
fifteen
sessions.
E
It's
actually
you
can
consider
it
to
be
part
of
the
IETF
meetings
there
in
the
agenda.
You
can
just
go
and
show
up
there.
A
lot
of
the
terminology
and
workflow
is
very
similar.
Instead
of
talking
about
a
working
group,
there's
a
research
group
instead
of
talking
about
an
internet
draft
or
an
RFC,
there's
research
documents,
there's
actual
mentions.
Some
of
them
are
very
focused
on
sort
of
being
the
advanced
R&D
group
of
the
IETF
and
some
are
focused
on
being
more
social
oriented,
there's
one,
for
example,
the
largest-scale.
E
E
There's
the
applied
networking
research
group.
This
is
an
eighth
ACM,
affiliated
organization.
It's
meeting
all
day
tomorrow.
I
think
registration
is
still
open
for
that.
It
obviously
conflicts
with
working
group
meetings
that
are
tomorrow
like
to
that
I'm
chairing,
so
I
can't
go.
Unfortunately,
there
is
also
plenary
x'
to
this
year,
one
right
after
the
other,
a
technical
one
and
the
administrative
one.
The
paper-pushing
there's
an
invited
lunch
talks.
E
There's
the
tutorial
program,
which
you're
part
of
here
there's
a
follow
on
another
tutorial
about
how
to
write
security
considerations
about
thirty
minutes
after
this
one
there's
a
social
event.
There's
a
mailing
list
for
IETF
105,
attendees,
you're,
probably
registered
you
may
have
signed
up
or
not
signed
up
for
that
list.
One
of
the
most
common
uses
of
the
mailing
list
is
hey.
Does
anybody
have
a
spare
social
ticket,
especially.
E
A
hot
RFC
which
is
requests
for
comments
or
rest
requests
for
conversation.
This
people
say
well,
I,
don't
even
know
if
this
is
a
working
group
idea.
But
here
is
you
know
some
research
that
I've
been
working
on
or
something
I've
been
thinking
about.
They
talk
for
10
minutes
and
see.
Maybe
there's
interest
I've
had
a
number
of
people,
I
volunteered
them
from
the
hot
RFC
to
come.
Talk
it's
a
acne
or
other
working
groups.
E
We're
trying
an
experiment
with
this
meeting.
The
first
hour
of
every
day
is
set
aside
for
side
meetings.
One
of
those
I
guess
is
the
newcomers
debriefing,
although
that's
before
the
side
meeting,
just
to
get
together
and
talk
with
people
that
you've
met
during
the
week
and
so
on.
Oh
yes,
yeah
comes
later.
There's
also
Tuesday
Monday
Monday
morning
is
the
ITF
sisters
breakfast
you
can
see
at
8.
You
can
see
I'm
told
to
sign
up
for
that.
If
you
want
anybody
who
identifies
as
female
is
welcome
to
come
to
that.
E
Working
group
sessions
are
the
main
point
that
sort
of
the
justification.
Why
most
of
us
are
here?
Not
everybody
about
most
of
us
work
is
officially
the
ITF
work
is
officially
done
on
mailing
lists.
The
meetings
face-to-face
are
to
talk
about.
What's
happened
since
the
last
face-to-face
meeting.
What
the
open
issues
are,
the
quick,
no,
the
h2
one
of
those
two
working
groups,
for
example,
is
only
about
issues.
There's
no
new
work
being
discussed.
That's
what
their
agenda
says.
E
The
sessions
are
all
streamed
and
recorded.
This
session
is
being
streamed
and
recorded
as
well,
fine
folks
in
the
back
of
the
room.
So
you
can
always
it's
often
worthwhile.
This
usually
unavoidable
conflicts
I
really
wanted
to
go
to
this
and
that
but
they're
meeting.
At
the
same
time,
shortly
after
the
ITF
meeting
go
to
the
IETF
YouTube
channel
on
YouTube
and
watch,
the
meeting
that
you
didn't
see.
E
Birds
of
a
feather
I
mentioned
here
is
opposed
to
session,
summon
presenting
at
the
reception
for
their
birds
of
a
feather
acme
the
certificate.
Let's
encrypt
certificate
protocol
now
does
10
million
certificates
a
year
and
it
started.
You
know
it
started
up,
and
then
there
was
a
buff
and
then
it
was
a
working
group
and
the
RFC
was
published
six
months
ago,
so
they
can
be
very
successful.
I
RTF
it's
officially
part
of
one
of
these
alphabet
soup
organizations
at
Chantal
pointed
to
that's
not.
E
Oh
sorry,
I'm
child
pointed
to
I
got
up
very
early
this
morning.
Sorry,
sorry,
there's
a
RFC
primer
on
the
difference
between
the
IETF
and
the
IRT
F,
as
I
said,
they
share
on
purpose
a
lot
of
similar
terminology
and
they're
hosted
by
the
same
parent
organization,
applied
networking
research,
it's
a
forum,
for
you
know,
academics.
This
is
how
we
bring
are
starting
to
bring
more
academic
involvement
and
participation
in
the
eye
into
the
IETF.
There
is
also
the
I
applied
networking
research
prize.
E
E
So
this
is
what
the
plenary
looks
like
it'll
be
held
and
the
group
or
me
held
in
the
grand
ballroom
the
same
one
that
the
reception
is
in
is
that
they
assess
the
front
and
the
various
leadership
teams
will
cycle
through
that
I'm
on
the
IAB.
You
got
any
questions
with
the
IAB.
Ok
next
I'm
in
the
iesg
any
questions:
ok,
next
I'm,
the
executive
director.
E
Here's
what
our
budget
looks
like
next,
its
nitty-gritty
details
about
how
the
organization
works
this
year,
there's
also
a
separate
co-located
just
before
technical
plenary
and
I,
don't
recall
what
the
topic
is,
but
worthwhile.
Nothing
else
is
scheduled
against
the
plenaries
invited
lunch
to
talk
the
sponsor,
in
this
case
nbc/universal
comcast,
comcast
nbc/universal.
Whatever
their
thing
is,
they
will
have
a
speaker,
I
think
on
Thursday
hackathons
and
code
sprints.
So
the
first
time
you
haven't
missed
it,
you
sort
of
missed
it
now.
E
The
code
sprint
is
we're
on
Saturdays
we're
smaller
group
of
people
develop
the
website
that
powers
all
of
the
workflow
for
generating
RFC's
hackathons
are
for
people
just
want
to
get
together
and
discuss.
You
know
and
work
on
their
implementation
make
sure
they
interoperate
notable
successes
have
been
quick,
TLS
one
three
right
now
we're
doing
teep
and
some
DNS
work
at
later
on
in
the
week
there'll
be
a
hackathon
happy
hour.
Will
they'll
be
a
presentation
from
some
of
the
more
successful
things
in
the
future.
E
E
So
the
picture
on
the
left
is
from
the
social
in
Singapore,
the
National
Aquarium
a
really
big
tank,
a
very
big
tank,
and
then,
when
I
picture
on
the
right
is
a
picture
from
the
sisters
breakfast
from
London,
okay,
so
five
a
number
of
sessions
ago,
there
are
also
many
many
informal
sessions
the
ITF
starts
in
the
morning.
We
serve
a
continental
breakfast.
Many
people
get
the
hotel
breakfast
there's
the
side
meetings,
informal,
chats
planning
for
the
day
skimming
over
the
doctor.
E
You
know
the
drafts
that
you
want
for
the
meetings
you
want
to
attend
all
the
way
through.
You
know,
lunk,
there's
a
break.
There's
lunch,
there's
dinner,
sometimes
there's
a
session
after
dinner.
That's
often
the
plenary
for
example,
and
then
you
get
together
often
not
quite
get
together
with
friends.
Colleagues,
people
you
just
met
earlier
in
the
day
to
have
after-dinner
beer,
drink
go
out
and
socialize
or
more
likely
go
out
and
work.
It
is
a
long
day
there
are
lots
of
things
going
on
and
which
brings
me
to
the
last
bullet
on
this
slide.
E
Remember
sleep!
It's
tiring
by
the
end
of
the
week
as
tired
as
people
are
seeing
that
note
well
slide
that
on
shell
started
with
you'll,
see
it
at
every
single
session.
As
a
reminder,
don't
talk
about
private
patents,
don't
harass
anybody
be
kind
to
your
neighbor.
The
note
well
stuff,
they'll
be
even
more
tired.
Just
you
know,
ready
to
crash
out
on
the
flights
or
driving
on
the
way
home.
How
are
you
at
home
a
few
key
points
about
etiquette.
We
want
to
be
respectful
and
tolerant
towards
everybody.
The
ITF
started
as
a
u.s.
E
contracted
kind
of
thing
it
has
since
grown
to
be
global.
We
are
deliberately,
for
example,
we
need
once
in
the
US
hemisphere,
once
in
Europe
in
March,
we
were
in
Prague
last
March
and
then
once
in
Asia,
so
it's
1,
1
1
to
get
global
participation.
We
try
to
make
sure
that
people
who
can't
attend
in
person
are
able
to
participate
such
as
streaming
and
YouTube
videos.
Also,
we
have
something
called
Medeco,
which
is
a
great
service
where
people
can
participate
remotely
or
just
listening
remotely.
So
we've
had
remote
presenters.
E
We
will
present
on
often
on
a
topic
they
just
can't
make
it
to
wherever
the
meeting
happens,
to
be
talked
and
listen.
Listening
is
obviously
more
important
than
talking
bringing
new
work
to
the
ITF.
We're
trying
to
encourage
this,
except
maybe
watching.
That's
a
joke
find
the
way
to
do
it.
If
you
have
an
idea
that
you
think
might
be
useful
to
help
the
internet
work
better,
that's
a
very
broad
umbrella
on
purpose
find
some
collaborators
good
ways.
You
know
this
is
kind
of
related
working
group.
E
So
let
me
go
specialize
that
when
you
talk
to
the
working
group
chair
see
if
they
think
it's
interesting,
let
me
put
a
note
near
the
schedules
paper
schedules
that
are
printed
in
the
registration
area.
I,
guess
down
that
way.
Just
get
a
bunch
of
people
together,
post
on
the
IETF
105
attendees
list,
hey
I,
want
to
talk
about.
You
know
ways
to
use
DNS
to
find
my
phone.
Whatever
it's
gonna,
be
you
hold
it.
You
propose
a
bath,
that's
you're,
starting
to
get
into
more
formal
structure.
E
E
E
E
The
speaker's
stand
here
in
this
case,
there's
a
pink
X
to
make
sure
that
the
video
cameras
are,
you
know,
can
record
you
if
you
step
off
camera,
it's
uncomfortable
to
the
people
remote
and
to
the
video
there's
a
microphone.
This
is
a
smaller
room,
so
there's
one
with
the
plenary.
There
are
six
or
eight
a
bigger
meeting,
such
as
TLS
or
DNS.
We'll
have
two
mics,
and
you
know
the
rooms
will
be
almost
half
again
or
twice
this
size.
E
If
you
want
to
say
something
you
say
you
come
up
to
the
mic
and
there's
a
line
and
the
chair
will
say
you
know.
Next
to
the
line
you
say
your
name,
Rick
Saul's
for
identification.
You
say
your
company,
your
affiliation,
rich,
Saul's,
Akamai
and
I.
Think,
and
then
you
say
what
your
point
is.
If
it's
directly
addressing
a
presenter,
you
know
I
think
that
the
extension
you
wrote
there
could
be
better
improved
by
doing
this
and
that's
it.
E
There
are
blue
sheets
which
will
go
around
on
those
done
at
the
beginning
of
the
meeting
collected
at
the
end
of
the
meeting,
you
write
your
name,
your
affiliation,
those
are
scanned
and
posted
and
put
online.
So
we
have
a
record
of
all
the
attendees
again,
that's
to
ensure
compliance
with,
you
know,
make
sure
there's
no
submarine
patent
work
going
on.
We've
been
pretty
good
about
that
and
also
to
help
plan
in
the
future
meeting.
Well,
you
know
the
chairs
they
go.
E
Oh
well,
I've
got
75
people
and
want
to
come
to
my
next
meeting
and
we
can
look
at
the
blue
sheets
and
go
really.
You
only
have
20
the
last
three,
so
maybe
we'll
give
you
a
smaller
room,
any
kind
of
technical
comment
and
questions
are
discussed.
Well,
somebody
is
presenting
someone
can
come
up
to
a
mic
and
say
I.
Have
a
clarifying
question.
I
didn't
understand
what
you
just
said
that
that
and
then
details
about
what
your
confusion
was.
There
is
a
jabber
when
we
talk
about
the
resources.
E
I'm
cha
will
mention
that
instant
messaging
protocol
there's
always
a
jabber
room
available,
always
a
jab
room
open
for
people
put
in
questions
and
comments,
and
also
to
keep
track
of
what
the
slides
are
with
that
I'll
turn
it
back
over
to
Chantal
Melissa.
Someone
has
a
question
on
what
I
just
talked
about
for
this
week.
E
E
Ok,
I'll
try
to
bring
it
on
time,
which
means
I
will
talk
even
faster
there's.
A
person
associated
with
the
ITF
called
Eric
named
Eric
Rescorla,
he's
often
called
by
his
initials
ecker
ekr
and
his
speaking
style
is
the
unit
of
speed
for
speaking
so
people
say:
oh
I
speak
at
half
a
Necker
or
I
can
speak
it.
You
know
a
point-9
of
a
Necker
and
he
speaks
really
really
quickly
and
he's
very
technical,
and
it's
really
hard
sometimes
to
understand
him.
E
Don't
worry,
you're,
not
alone,
but
anyhow
I
will
speak
a
little
quicker
to
try
to
get
us
to
finish
close
to
time.
The
Secretariat
are
the
key
resources
for
this
week.
The
lovely
people
in
shirts
I
think
they're
all
women.
They
are
the
ones
who
handle
the
logistics.
When
we
couldn't
figure
out
how
to
get
the
slides
projected
here
right.
Somebody
in
the
blue
shirt
who
came
up
they
handle
the
registration.
They
handle
all
the
paperwork,
the
coordination
of
everything
they
collect.
The
blue
sheets
scan
them.
E
You
know
after
the
meeting
and
so
on,
lovely
people
we
couldn't
do
this
week
without
them.
Also
noticeable
on
Friday
is
we're
starting
to
take
down
everything
or
they're
starting
to
take
down
everything.
They
changed
the
Hawaiian
shirts
RFC
editor.
There
are
two
tables
out
by
the
up
either
in
the
registration
area.
One
is
for
the
RFC
editor.
Those
are
the
people
who
copy
edit
and
actually
Publishing
of
the
documents
once
they've
been
approved
by
the
isg.
E
Having
left
the
working
group
having
been
written
by
the
working
group
authors,
so
that's
the
workflow,
the
RSC
editor
and
then
there's
I
Anna,
the
internet
assigned
numbers
Authority.
That
ensures,
for
example,
that
DNS
uses
port
53
and
nobody
else
does
then
HTTP
uses
port
443
and
nobody
else
does
there's
a
whole
bunch
of
number
spaces
that
have
to
be
managed
and
assigned.
Some
of
the
numbers
have
names,
so
I
Anna
handles
all
of
that.
E
Other
notable
thing
about
these
two
organizations
outside
of
their
being
friendly
and
some
are
paid,
and
some
are
volunteers.
They
always
have
candy
out.
So
if
you
need
a
quick
pick-me-up,
hi
know,
I
love
the
job
you're
doing
Portia
Irwin
Stanley
is
our
interim
executive
director.
The
IETF
recently
went
through
a
slight
reorganization
for
legal
purposes
to
form
a
legal
entity
as
opposed
to
being
this
sort
of
amorphous
thing
guiding
through
that
is
Ben
Portia.
Who
is
the
executive
director?
You.
E
The
checks
keeps
the
lights
on
the
Ombuds
team.
The
IETF
has
a
very
strict,
no
harassment
policy.
Nobody
should
feel
harassed
bothered
constrained
from
talking
constrained
from
giving
their
technical
opinion.
Similarly,
you
should
feel
constrained
from
insulting
the
way
somebody
looks
or
commenting
on
them
or
saying
you
know,
I
think
you're
really
stupid.
No,
you
can
say
that
idea
isn't
good
and
here's.
Why,
but
don't
you
know?
Obviously
we
know
how
to
act
like
mature
adults
towards
each
other.
A
hard
part
of
this
is
as
I
mentioned.
E
Many
of
these
people
have
known
each
other
for
years
or
decades.
So
somebody
will
stand
up.
You
know
Barry
Lebowitz,
tanned
up
and
go.
You
know.
That's
really
dumb
of
you,
Mike
or
Mike
will
say,
that's
a
really
stupid
conclusion.
You
have
to
separate
sometimes
from
the
people.
If
they
look
middle-aged
us
beards
they've
been
around
for
a
long
time,
I'm
not
middle-aged.
E
We
have
a
team
of
Ombudsman
there's
a
policy
about
it,
but
the
Ombuds
team.
There
is
anti
harassment
policy.
There's
pictures
of
the
people
involved.
All
three
of
them
are
very
long
time.
Itf
participants,
if
you
see
anything
and
they
have
a
particular
sticker
on
its
a
green
tag
at
the
bottom
of
there's,
no
neon
green,
go
up
and,
and
the
think
will
handle
things
appropriately
and
so
on.
E
On
mailing
lists,
we
have
a
organization
called
the
sergeant
of
arms,
who
has
occasionally
stepped
in
recently
to
try
to
make
sure
that
this
course
is
civil,
mature
and
respectful
who's.
Who
working
group
chairs
those
are
the
people,
as
I
said,
who
will
sit
at
the
front
and
handle
all
things
a
blue
button
like
that
on
their
badge.
Sometimes
the
other
important
thing
is
the
smiley
face.
E
That's
a
sticker
anybody
can
put
on
and
it
means
I
am
willing
to
answer
questions
about
the
ITF,
obviously,
on
trial
and
I
are
up
here
to
help
introduce
you
and
we're
willing
to
answer
questions
about
the
ITF
so
later
this
evening,
when
there
is
the
Welcome
Reception
for
everyone,
as
you're
wandering
around
with
you
know,
plate
of
hors
d'oeuvres
and
stacks
or
whatever
it
is,
and
you
have
a
question:
look
you
can
look
for
somebody
or
you
might
recognize
a
familiar
face,
do
ask
questions.
We
want
people
to
come,
learn,
contribute
and
not
leave.
E
E
Iso
ITU
has
one
vote
per
country
and
the
national
standards
organization,
ANSI
psi
dot,
forget
what
you
know
and
so
on
they
pick
who
their
representatives
are
gonna,
be
anybody.
You
can
join
the
mailing
list,
anybody
gets
an
equal
say,
there's
a
specific
newcomers
page
for
this
IETF
and
they
were
also
the
tutorials
are
all
available,
not
just
the
newcomers,
but
going
back
in
time
as
we
said
how
to
write,
how
to
bring
new
work
in
how
to
write
an
RFC
and
so
on
get
more
meeting
resources.
E
All
of
these
are
available
in
slides,
which
are
on
the
data
tracker
next
slide:
data
tracker
that
IETF,
Torg
or
or
DTI
ETS
org.
This
is
the
website
that
is
manages
all
of
the
document.
Workflow
everything
we
do
goes
through
the
data
tracker,
so
every
working
group,
every
team,
which
isn't
quite
a
working
group,
as
Karen
mentioned
at
the
beginning,
the
AG
team
that
people
who
do
this
there's
an
RFC
team
who
handle
the
defining
that
the
content,
not
the
content
but
defining
the
style
and
markup
of
the
RFC's.
E
They
all
have
pages
on
here.
The
most
common
thing,
I
type,
is
DT
that
I
80
after
Doric
/wg
for
a
working
group,
slash
and
then
what
the
working
groups
abbreviation
is.
The
IETF
is
fond,
perhaps
overly
fond
of
having
coming
up
with
pronounceable
English
kind
of
pseudo
words
right
lurk,
t
DNS
up
about
that,
Tia,
quick
and
so
on.
So
but
that's
a
way
to
find
and
from
there,
as
you
see
on
the
right-hand
that
works,
so
you
see
on
the
right-hand
side
over
there.
E
That
is
a
working
group
page.
It
shows
all
of
the
doc
all
of
the
drafts
that
are
currently
in
progress.
What
their
state
is
sometimes
they're
waiting
for
the
area
director
and
the
isg
to
move
them
forward
tabs
across
the
top
overview.
The
of
the
working
group
that
documents
the
mailing
lists
from
the
website
you
can
join
any
number
of
the
I
call.
The
ITF
mailing
lists
are
on
data
tracker,
dot
IETF
that
org
the
tools
is
once
you
start
to
get
involved
in
writing.
Rfc's.
E
Then
you
may
care
about
the
tools,
but
for
now
don't
bother
the
data
tracker.
Is
your
friend
or
the
bane
of
your
existence?
Remote
participation
attendance
is
not
required.
The
only
time
attendance
is
required
is
if
you
want
to
participate
in
the
nominating
committee
or
be
selected
for
the
nominating
committee.
We
support
remote
attendance
for
at
all
of
the
working
group
sessions.
Many
of
the
other
sessions,
like
I,
said
that
this
tutorial,
the
these
side
meetings
are
not
remotely
they'll
available
and
we
have
a
team
medic.
E
Oh
those
are
the
people
we'll
find
folks
on
the
Medeco
team
very
friendly
and
helpful.
There's
always
a
video
AV
person
in
the
back
of
the
room,
handling
the
screaming
the
mics
and
so
on
the
network,
if
you
haven't
logged
into
the
ITF
network,
yet
it
is
a
thing
of
wonder:
people
arrive
about
a
week
early,
they
bring
in
all
sorts
of
you
know,
working
with
the
local
telecom
company
they
bring
in
all
sorts
of
extra
capacity.
E
The
purpose
of
that
is
not
to
be
prevent
people
from
getting
access
to
the
network.
It's
to
make
sure
that
we
can
do
encryption
right,
you
log
into
the
network,
and
then
you
get
keys
and
so
on.
We
try
to
avoid.
You
know
there
was
a
big
RFC
published
shortly
after
Edward
Snowden
that
says,
surveillance
is
a
threat
that
we
need
to
mitigate.
So
we
try
to
move
everyone
towards
encryption,
funny
story.
When
I
was
walking
around
I
guess
down
the
underground
shopping
center
things.
E
E
There's
a
quiet
space
there's
a
terminal
room,
it
doesn't
have
terminals
anymore.
It
just
has
wired
power,
cords
and
wired
Ethernet
there's
a
printer.
If
you
need
to
print
your
boarding
pass
or
a
last-minute
document,
it's
now
out
by
the
registration
area,
so
that
you
can
just
there's
a
little
sticky
note
on
the
printer
that
says
how
to
access
it.
E
The
help
desk
is
also
out
in
the
registration
area.
Jabber
we
use
XMPP,
it's
not
eff
protocol.
There's
a
bunch
of
clients
available
here.
I
strongly
encourage
everyone
to
get
jabber
set
up.
If
they
can,
you
can
there's
a
number
of
free
and
open
jabber
services,
there's
a
list
of
them
there
and
then
every
working
group
has
a
chat,
room
working
group
name
at
jabbered,
IFL
org
ask
questions.
That's
where
somebody
still
be.
Somebody
called
a
jabber
scribe
who
will
post?
Ok,
literally
this
the
the
bulk
of
the
slides,
the
bulk
of
the
jabber
room.
E
E
E
There
is
a
survey
we'd
like
everyone
to
participate
and
click
on
the
survey
in
particular.
If
you
have
suggestions,
if
you
know
next
time,
Richard
wear
long
pants,
whatever
we'll
take
any
kind
of
feedback,
there
is
a
it
helps
us
improve.
We've
gave
a
lot.
We
take
a
lot
of
that
feedback
and
bring
it
back
in
to
constantly
evolve
the
slides
every
single
time.
E
E
E
Hey
I
forgot
one
thing:
let's
do
a
practice
home
just
you
know
what
it's
like:
here's
the
way
it
works.
The
chairs
will
say:
okay,
here's
what
the
question
is,
and
they
will
always
be
the
possible.
It's
always
multiple
choice,
the
possible
answers
and
then
the
the
last
part
of
the
question
is
always
don't
know
enough
can't
decide
yet.
So
the
question
is
the
question
will
be:
did
you
find
this
useful
and
the
choices
are
yes
no
or
can't
decide
so
how
many
people
found
this
useful?