►
From YouTube: IETF106-TUTORIALNEW-20191117-1230
Description
TUTORIALNEW meeting session at IETF106
2019/11/17 1230
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/106/proceedings/
A
New
comers
overview,
this
is
a
presentation
to
get
you
started
in
your
IETF
week.
I
am
Carolyn
Donahue
and
part
of
the
education
team
here,
and
we
are
definitely
interested
in
any
feedback
that
you
have
on
this.
So
at
the
end
of
this
you'll
see
a
survey
link.
We
would
appreciate
any
comments
that
you
have
also
I
wanted
to
point
out.
A
It'll
show
up
in
the
presentation
as
well
what
we
do
also
have
a
newcomers
feedback
session
on
Thursday
morning
and
the
other
thing
that
you
will
probably
get
I,
don't
know
if
it's
gone
out
yet
or
not,
it
is
Greg
wood
who
is
the
who
works
on
the
ITF
website
is
interested
in
getting
any
newcomer
feedback
on
your
experience
with
the
website.
Did
it
provide
you,
the
information
that
was
useful
to
you?
A
What
suggestions
do
you
have,
and
so
there
will
be
an
email
going
out
to
all
the
newcomers
with
a
request,
if
you're
interested
in
and
having
a
short
sit-down
session
or
chat
with
Greg,
he
will
be
asking
for
people
to
sign
up
for
that
and
we
would.
We
would
really
appreciate
it.
One
of
the
challenges
we've
had
with
the
website
is,
you
know,
for
all
of,
for
those
of
us
who've
been
around
for
a
while.
B
Hi
good
morning,
hi
good
morning,
my
name
is
rich
Saul's
pronouns
are
he/him
I
me
mine.
Whatever
so
I'll
be
talking
that
says
the
session
lasts
about
an
hour.
It's
broken
into
three
parts,
the
first
to
some
background.
The
second
is
what
the
week
is
like
real
world
and
then
the
third
is
some
additional
resources.
B
How
many
people
four?
Is
this?
Their
first
IETF
meeting,
whoa?
Okay,
great?
How
many
people
are
already
on
some
working
group
mailing
lists?
Okay,
thanks
all
right,
so
this
will
be
hopefully
real
experience.
I
am
here
through
the
week
I'll
be
at
the
Thursday
morning.
New
members
debrief
feel
free
to
come
to
that
there
are.
B
There
are
other
people
around
who
you
can
also
talk
to.
We
have
a
number
of
activities
that
I'll
go
over
shortly,
so
first
off
welcome.
This
is
great.
We
have
a
very
large
crowd
this
time,
comparatively
and
I.
Think
it's
on
the
order
of
200
first-timers
looks
like
most
of
you
are
in
the
room
which
is
nice,
so
welcome
we're
glad
to
have
you
and
we
hope
you
will
contribute
and
continue
to
contribute.
B
Every
meeting
every
session
at
every
IETF
meeting
and
the
IETF
meets
three
times
a
year
starts
with
these
next
two
slides.
So
this
is
the
very
first
session.
Probably
this
is
the
first
time
you'll
see
it.
There
are
two
and
by
Wednesday
they
sort
of
rush
to
them
by
Friday.
Everyone
goes
okay.
You've
already
seen
this
before.
B
Let's
get
to
all
the
work,
so
this
this
this
slide
identifies
the
policies
and
when
you
sign
in
an
attendance
list,
you're
acknowledging
that
you
understand
the
note
well,
it
is
called
that
note
well
because
it
means
hey
note,
well
that
these
are
the
policies
under
which
we
operate,
and
if
this
is
a
reminder
of
what
they
are,
the
fundamental
ones
are.
If
you
say
anything,
you
should
know
that
it
is
public.
B
This
is
not
a
closed-door
industry.
Working
group
form
public
in
that
the
meetings
are
recorded,
often
streamed
live
on
the
web
and
they
are
archived
on
various
video
channels.
There's
a
YouTube
channel
personal
information.
We
try
to
respect
PII.
Oh,
it's
called
PII
personal,
identifying
information.
When
you
signed
in
you
got
one
of
two
colored
lanyards,
the
blue
says
you
can
take
my
picture,
there's
a
red
one.
That
says
please
don't
photograph
me
things
like
that.
B
These
are
the
specific
policies.
Again,
you
don't
have
to
read
to
understand,
but
the
important
part
is
the
acronym
BC
P
stands
for
best
current
practice,
and
this
is
an
indirect
layer
on
top
of
the
RFC
series
and
talk
about
the
RFC
series
for
those
who
don't
know
later,
on
BC
p,
nine
points
to
a
specific
thing,
which
is
RFC
26.
B
If
the
process
gets
changed
in
twenty-six
twelve
becomes
obsoleted
by
RFC
fifty
to
seventy
five
I'm,
just
making
these
numbers
out
of
the
air,
the
BC
p9
will
stay
the
same.
So
it's
you
know,
think
of
it
as
a
symbolic
link.
Any
problem,
computer
science
can
be
solved
by
an
extra
layer
of
indirection.
This
is
an
example.
These
are
the
main
policies
that
are
appropriate.
It's
at
some
point.
You
know
worth
skimming
if
you're
trying
to
avoid
jet
lag
or
you're
trying
to
cover
from
jet
lag.
You
know
skim
through
these
things,
newcomers
activities.
B
We
have
many
activities
planned
for
this
this
week
and
as
we
do
in
previous
weeks,
and
we
will
in
the
future
the
tutorial
you're
getting
off
to
a
good
start.
That's
here
and
now,
usually
there
are
two
presenters.
We
split
one
one,
two
three
or
one
two
and
then
the
first
speaker
again,
but
unfortunately,
this
time
you're
stuck
with
me
for
the
full
hour
45
minutes.
Quick
connections
is
also
this
afternoon.
B
That
I
believe
is
in
the
Fairmont
ballroom
Lobby
there'll
be
a
little
table,
set
up,
they'll
be
experienced,
IETF
errs
there,
myself,
Karen
I,
think
a
couple
of
many
people
and
it's
sort
of
like
speed
dating
go
to
a
table.
Talk
about
you
know,
introduce
yourself
or
get
introduced
or
we'll
introduce
ourselves.
What
are
you
looking
for?
What
kind
of
areas
are
you
interested
in?
Oh
this
person
over
there
is,
you
know,
he's
very
good
that
person
over
there
is
really
important
about.
You
know
routing
an
ipv6.
B
To
pick
an
example,
the
person
running
the
meeting
guy
named
Paul
routers.
Will
you
know
every
five
minutes
will
say
time
and
he
move
off
to
another
table
the
intent.
Is
you
get
a
brief
moment?
People
get
a
brief
moment
under
you
know,
to
meet
a
couple
of
old
hands
Greybeards
if
you
will
meet
some
peers,
who
are
also
among
the
first
timers
or
newcomers,
and
then
you
move
on
and
so
on,
and
then
that
leads
there's
a
short
break
and
that
leads
into
the
opening
reception.
B
There's
also
a
program
called
the
IETF
guides
mentoring.
We
used
to
call
it
ITF
mentors.
We
used
to
call
it
ie
TF,
guys
we
couldn't
figure
it
out.
So
now
we
call
it
guides
mentoring,
you're,
probably
next
year
we
mentoring
guides.
Who
knows
these?
Are
you
get
us?
You
can
sign
up
and
it's
off
the
newcomers
link
I
believe
on
the
website.
You
can
sign
up
and
say:
I
speak.
You
know
here's
the
languages
I
speak
I'm
interested
in
these
particular
technology
areas.
B
We
try
to
find
a
volunteer
who
is
available
to
you
for
the
whole
week.
I
don't
participate
in
that
I'm,
not
sure
of
many
more
details
other
than
that
there's
a
newcomers
dinner
Monday.
That
is
not
you
know,
that's
a
pay.
Your
own
I
believe
it's
twenty-five
dollars,
Singapore
they're
joined
and
that's
purely
newcomers
chance
to
meet
some
of
your
people
here
in
the
room
or
the
75.
So
who
aren't
here,
as
Karen
mentioned,
there's
a
feedback
session
that'll
be
Thursday
morning.
B
All
of
these
items
are
listed
on
the
agenda,
so
you
can
find
the
specifics
about
details
and
rooms.
I
mean
that's
where
you
can
tell
us
hey,
you
guys
did
really
good
I
was
or
how
I
was
totally
unprepared
by
Tuesday
I
couldn't
keep
my
eyes
open
whatever
it
takes.
Whatever
your
information,
you
have,
we
take
feedback
very
seriously
in
that
we
really
listen
to
it.
We
really
encourage
it
like
we
don't
not.
Everybody
participates
in
the
surveys
and
so
on.
B
So
if
five
people
say
you
need
to
talk
about
this,
some
more,
we
will
revise
these
slides
and
make
sure
we
talk
about
it.
Some
more
next
time
I
should
mention.
The
IETF
definition
of
a
newcomer
is
five
or
fewer
meetings
which,
basically,
since
there
are
three
meetings
a
year.
That
means
you
know
for
the
first
two
years
you
can,
if
you'd
like
consider
yourself
to
be
a
newcomer,
feel
free
to
come
to
any
of
the
kind
of
any
of
the
newcomer
events.
B
Okay,
preparing,
so
what's
a
little
more
detail
about
what
I'm
gonna
talk
about?
Can
someone
in
the
back
row
raise
their
hand
just
make
sure
I
can
I'm
being
heard?
Thank
you.
So
the
goal
here
is
to
present
information
that
is
useful
to
you,
starting
at
the
end
of
this
session
running
through
the
week
Friday
afternoon,
as
you
attend
your
first
first
ish
ITF
session.
As
you
move
from
being
involved
in
some
mailing
lists
to
day-to-day.
You
know
active
participation
in
the
in
room
this.
B
We
call
it
to
maybe
going
back
and
then
joining
some
mailing
lists
and
so
on.
We
want
to
teach
you
how
to
make
the
most
out
of
the
meeting
it's
sort
of
the
unique
the
ITF
is
a
unique
experience.
Unlike
you
know,
John
with
one
I
Triple
E
w3c
a
winner.
This
doesn't
talk
about
the
history
of
the
ITF.
We
used
to
talk
about
that
a
lot
mm-hmm.
Nobody
really
cares
right.
B
The
ITF
is
32
years
old,
I
believe
many
of
the
people
who
roam
the
halls
and
attend
the
meetings
have
been
here
for
all
thirty
years.
It's
pretty
impressive
and
talk
about
some
of
the
impacts
from
that
long-term
involvement.
There
is
a
YouTube
channel
as
I
mentioned,
okay,
so
now,
or
talk
about
the
broader
standards
ecosystem
where
the
ITF
lives.
B
The
mission
and
I'll
just
read
this
because
it's
short
and
it's
really
sort
of
the
unusual
kind
of
mission.
Our
mission,
the
IETF
mission,
is
to
make
the
internet
work
better.
That's
the
short,
very,
very
short
summary:
we
want
to
make
the
internet
work
better.
How
do
we
do
that?
We
produce
high
quality,
relevant
technical
documents
in
English.
That's
the
language
of
the
ITF
notice.
It
says
technical
documents
and
not
standards.
B
B
The
way
it's
enforced
is
we
design
doctor.
We
build
documents
that
influence
the
way
people
design,
use
and
manage
the
net
okay.
So
it's
purely
a
matter
of
well.
This
is
the
way
everybody's
doing
it.
If
you
want
to
do
it
with
everybody
else,
here's
what
you
should
do
you
know,
sometimes,
depending
on
the
working
people,
often
hear
the
phrase
we're
not
the
protocol
police.
B
If
you
do,
if
you're
writing
a
web
server-
and
you
understand
you
have
get-
and
you
spell
it
with
lowercase
nobody's
gonna
come
work
with
you.
If
you
change
get
to
take,
nobody
will
complain,
but
your
code
won't
work
with
the
browser
right.
So
that's
the
goal
you
want.
If
you
want
to
interoperate
and
work
with
the
rest
of
the
world
out
there,
you
know
follow
the
RFC
s,
they
are
written
in
English,
they
are,
which
means
the
human
language,
which
means
there
are
ambiguities.
B
We
have
an
errata
system
where
we
can
put
where
people
can
point
out
errors
Corrections,
we
revised
standards,
so
we
had
HTTP
0.9,
1.0,
1.1,
2
and
now
we're
developing
HTTP
3,
for
example,
TLS
101,
1,
1,
2,
1
3,
it's
hard
TLS
didn't
want
to
change.
The
first
number
and
HTTP
has
no
qualms
1
2
3
1
.
1
1.
B
Whatever
the
mission
of
the
IETF
is
described
in
an
RFC
39:35
as
you
attend
meetings
throughout
the
week,
you'll
hear
people
say
things
like:
oh
you
know,
that's
really
not
compliant
with
RFC,
26
12
and
the
rest
of
the
room
will
go
yeah,
that's
the
trait.
What
the
hell
is
26
12
and
you
might
have
to
look
it
up.
I'm
long
I'm
like
that
I
can't
I'm
bad
enough
with
names.
B
That
alone
are
seen
so
I'm
always
impressed
when
people
can
just
spout
off
these
four
digit
numbers
or
now
five
digit
numbers
and
everybody
instantly
knows
what
it
means.
So
what
is
the
ITF?
Where
standards,
development
organization
notice,
the
previous
slide,
didn't
say,
standards,
it
says
technical
documents,
but
we
recognize
that
what
we
do
our
develop
standards,
no
implementation
force
behind
them.
Other
people
pick
them
up
and
publish
them
as
standards.
We
no
problems
with
that.
Our
documents
are
openly
available
freely,
reusable
referenceable,
it's
self
selected
in
that
anybody
wants
to
join.
B
All
you
have
to
do
is
sign
up
to
the
mailing
lists
that
you're
interested
in
there
are
about
a
hundred
and
thirty
groups.
They're
about
a
hundred
and
fifty
mailing
lists.
Read,
participate,
write,
mail
and
so
on.
We
don't
do
formal
voting,
for
example,
many
national
standards
bodies
or
the
International
like
I,
so
each
country
gets
a
vote
or
each
company
gets
a
vote.
Each
member
in
w3c
gets
a
vote.
We
just
do
things
by
what's
rough
called
rough
consensus
and
I'll
talk
about
that.
More
detail.
B
Talk
about
humming,
which
is
kind
of
a
strange
thing
and
we'll
do
an
example
of
that.
There's,
a
formal
government
role,
the
US
government
used
to
host
what
was
the
ITF
and
host
what
was
ICANN
and
the
number
Authority.
Those
are
all
spun
off
as
separate
things.
The
IETF
is
now
a
nonprofit
organization.
B
You
can
donate
money
and
get
a
tax
benefit
if
you're
in
the
u.s.
we're
driven
by
market
adoption.
So,
unlike
some
other
organizations,
you
can't
come
in
and
make
the
IETF
standardize
what
you're
working
on
to
develop
market
some
others
are
what's
called
pay-for-play.
You
pay
the
membership
to
work
on
a
standard
for
of
whatever
you
want,
we're
focused
on
the
internet
and
we're
bottom-up.
In
other
words,
the
people
who
are
in
this
room
and
on
the
mailing
lists
are
the
people
who
determine
what
the
IETF
produces.
B
There's
no
arching.
Oh
there
are
some
general
Architecture
boards
and
technical
reviews,
pardon
me,
but
it's
the
people
working.
You
know
in
the
trenches,
as
the
phrase
goes,
who
do
that
kind
of
stuff
and
we'd
like
to
think
we're
pretty
unique.
The
ITF
is
divided
into
eight
areas.
Seven
areas
this
is
called
an
eye
chart
in
that
you
know
people
sitting
in
the
room
there
you're
not
expected
well.
This
is
kind
of
legible
you're
not
expected
to
read
and
understand
all
of
it
take
a
picture.
B
B
Internet
is
defining
the
IP
and
TCP
protocols.
Transport
is
the
congestion
control.
What
happens
when
the
receiving
side
says?
Oh
I
can't
take
all
your
packets
anymore.
You
know.
Buffer
bloat
is
a
common
thing
right
when
you
see
when
you're
trying
to
watch
a
video,
and
you
see
that
little
circle
going
round
and
round
and
round
congestion,
that's
the
kind
of
thing
that
the
transport
works
on
applications
in
real
time.
B
Art
is
things
like
HDPE
WebSockets,
so
on
for
the
most
part
you
don't
have
to
care,
you
can
think
just
look
at
the
working
groups
but
understand
it
in
the
organization.
There's
the
working
groups
feeding
up
into
the
areas
and
then
there's
the
steering
committee
on
top.
As
I
mentioned,
we
work
by
consensus.
The
ITF
loves
this
quote:
it
was
by
Dave
Clark
MIT,
professor
one
of
the
first
IETF
developers
for
a
while.
He
was
like
the
chief
protocol
scientist.
B
It
was
the
starter
project.
We
reject
Kings
presidents
in
voting.
It's
everyone,
you
know
for
themselves,
rough
consensus
and
running
code.
That's
the
important
part
rough
consensus
means
everything
has
to
be
addressed.
It
doesn't
have
to
be
accommodated.
We
can
disagree
but
and
running
code.
You
know
the
ITF
over
the
past
couple
of
years
has
added
hackathons
the
weekend
before
so
yesterday
and
today
and
that
wins.
You
know
if
someone
says
I
keep.
B
This
is
completely
unemployment,
Abul
and
three
other
people
say
it's
completely:
unemployment
alone,
it's
unlikely
to
get
evolved
as
an
IETF
standard,
spec,
humming
I've
talked
about
the
session
chair
in
this,
for
example,
I
am
the
chair
of
this
rushon
sitting
at
the
front
of
the
room,
we're
responsible
for
the
building
or
talking
about
what
content
determining
what
consensus
is.
Every
working
group
has
a
mailing
list
and
the
mailing
lists
or
where
the
official
work
is
done.
B
So
when
we
say
oh,
we
have
consensus
in
the
room,
they
will
then
say:
okay,
we'll
take
it
back
to
the
list
to
confirm
which
means
someone
one
of
the
chairs
will
post
this
a
you
know
short
description.
We
decided
that
we
need
eight
bytes
for
the
session
identifier.
Does
anybody
disagree,
so
you
know,
discuss
it
on
the
mailing
list
or
confirm
and
so
on.
B
Of
course,
there's
an
RFC
that
talks
about
consensus
and
humming
ITF
culture,
passionate
smart,
vocal
people,
which
is
to
say
you
know,
networking
nerds
people
love
t-shirts,
people
get
free
t-shirts
and
many
people
walk
around
with
previous
IETF
t-shirts
as
a
badge
of
honor.
It's
fine
just
casually
just
comfortably,
you
know
business
casual
hotel,
casual
native
dress,
whatever
is
appropriate,
I
would
not
recommend
walking.
You
know
barefoot
speedos,
topless
things
like
that.
The
key
point
is
what
we
care
about
is
technical
excellence.
We
recognize
that
many
non-native
speakers,
many
people
are
shy.
B
Many
people
have
other
concerns
or
issues
might
prevent
them
from
speaking
up.
But
as
long
as
you
can
make
a
technical
technical
contribution,
that's
good
that
advances
the
cause
of
what
the
ITF
does
I
mentioned.
Before
some
people
have
been
coming
for
the
past
thirty
years
they
meet
it's
like
family
reunions.
Right,
hey,
you
know,
hey
Mike,
how
you
doing
Bob,
you
know
whatever
I
see
Karen.
You
know
three
times
a
year
more
often
than
I
see
my
sisters.
B
The
thing
that
looks
like
a
cell
over
here
on
the
right
left,
your
right,
that's
CI,
that's
the
ietf,
what
you
think
of
as
the
ITF
each
of
the
areas
and
there's
three
bubbles
there,
there's
no
should
be
seven
or
eight
has
within
it
working
groups.
Every
working
group
is
assigned
to
an
area.
Each
area
has
two
or
three
area
directors.
Area
directors
are
responsible
for
monitoring
the
progress
of
the
working
groups,
creating
new
working
groups,
creating
birds
of
a
feather
sessions
to
determine
whether
or
not
a
group
should
be
created,
and
so
on.
B
The
area,
directors
all
collectively
form
the
steering
group
internet,
Engineering,
steering
group
iesg.
That's
the
technical
leadership
of
the
ITF.
It's
appointed
there
were
overlapping
two-year
terms.
Every
year.
New
people
about
a
third
of
the
ISD
is
reappointed.
The
black
box
is
the
nonprofit
corporate
identity,
for
example,
when
the
ITF
sets
up
arrangements
to
have
a
meeting
in
a
hotel,
somebody
has
to
put
down
the
deposit.
B
Somebody
has
to
sign
the
hotel
contracts
and
somebody
has
to
make
all
the
logistics
arrangements,
for
example,
dealing
with
the
livestream
and
video
recording
fine
folks
in
the
back
of
the
room.
You
know
you
can't
just
have
a
thousand
people
show
up
and
say
I'd
like
a
room,
please.
At
the
same
time,
oh
and
by
the
way
I
want
30
breakout
session
rooms,
it
just
doesn't
work
the
IRS
G
internet
research,
steering
group,
a
parallel
organization,
they're
trying
not
to
deliver
standards
but
to
discuss
and
promote
research.
B
There's
a
crypto
forum
group.
There
is
a
networking
protocols
group
there
is
a
privacy
impacts
of
the
ie2
internet
protocols
group.
The
IAB
is
sort
of
an
oversight
of
both
of
those
things.
The
irst
in
the
iesg,
the
RC
editor
is
a
paid
set
of
professionals
who
do
the
final
document?
Production
Ayana
internet
assigned
numbers
authority
is
also
paid.
They
do
professionals
who
do
things
like
OD
NS
goes
on
port
53,
HTTP,
port
80
and
here
are
some
extensions
defined
for
TLS.
B
B
There
are
many
things
going
on
the
IETF.
The
iesg,
among
their
over
included
in
their
oversight,
is
organizing
the
overall
meetings
we
have
about
a
hundred
and
thirty
working
groups
about
80
of
them
meet
and
any
given
meeting.
There
are
birds
of
a
feather
it's
from
the
saying
birds
of
a
feather
flock
together.
B
That's
where
we
get
people
who
have
like
interest
to
decide
do
we
want
to
proceed
with
a
formal
working
group?
There
is
a
working
group,
some
Monday
on
the
mathematical
mesh
there's
another
working
group
on
web
packaging,
which
is
sort
of
think
of
it.
As
Google's
amp
project
evolved
and
I
forget,
there
are
three
or
four
other
working
groups
as
well
offs
as
well.
Rtf
meets
at
the
same
time
may
have
open
sessions
crypto
sessions,
as
I
mentioned.
Those
are
the
ones
interest
to
me.
There
is
a
plenary
which
is
this
time.
B
It's
just
a
management
plenary
plenary
is
a
Latin
word.
That
means
all
together.
Nothing
else
is
scheduled
opposite
the
plenary.
It's
in
the
ballroom
and
it'll
be
like
an
hour
two
hours
of
here's.
What
our
budgets,
like
any
questions
for
the
iesg,
any
questions
for
the
IAB.
A
lot
of
people
sit
in
the
back
of
the
room
and
make
snide
comments
to
each
other.
B
B
What
the
other
one
is
deep,
dives
we're
not
having
one
this
year,
there's
lunchtime
sessions,
some
other
social
things
tonight
is
the
hot
RFC
hot
requests.
For
you
know,
topics
people
get
ten
minutes
to
talk
about
something,
that's
interest
and
then
it's
that's.
It
move
on
to
the
next
one
next
one.
So
you
can
see
things
that
aren't
currently
ietf
activities
that
might
be
in
the
past.
I've
picked
up
two
or
three
of
the
stalks
and
brought
them
into
Acme
the
working
group
by
chair.
So
it
can
be
a
source
of
interesting.
B
You
know
it's
the
advanced
rnd
technology.
If
you
will
side
meetings
open
time
every
morning,
this
session
this
week
is
set
aside
for
unscheduled
meetings.
Sometimes
you
sleep
late.
Sometimes
you
just
get
together
with
colleagues
for
breakfast
and
talk,
and
then
the
working
groups
actually
started
10:00.
B
There
are
other
activities
not
on
the
agenda,
hallway
meetings,
which
means
often
at
the
end
of
the
session
people
gather
outside
talk
about
something
or
capture
the
you
know
talk
to
the
working
group
chair
or
the
people
who
presented
the
tutorials
are
different
from
working
groups.
In
that
it's
usually
just
the
chair
who
talks
is
in
me.
We
have
an
app
it's
worth
getting.
If
you
go
to
the
place,
you
know
Play,
Store
or
Apple
Store
ITF
app.
It
lists
all
the
schedule
it
lets.
You
highlight
sessions
that
you're
interested
in
I.
B
Think
then
iPad
Apple
one
is
integrated
with
the
calendar.
The
Android
one
map
the
agenda
across
from
the
registration
desk.
There
are
bulletin
boards.
Where
updates
to
the
agenda.
Are
posted
that'll
also
remind
you
where
the
rooms
are,
but
you
know
get
the
app,
sometimes
I,
guess
again
this
year
we're
having
paper
handouts
of
the
sessions
working
group?
Okay,
this
is
the
main
point.
This
is
why
you
are
all
here
you
got
sponsor
for
your
employees
paid
you
to
come
here.
This
is
where
all
the
work
is
done.
B
The
rooms
look
like
this
there's
somebody
speaking
people
running
the
meeting,
the
chairs
or
sitting
here.
There's
mics,
you
see
there's
one
in
the
middle
of
the
room
there.
If
people
have
questions
you
go
to
the
mic
and
so
on,
the
sessions
are
streamed
by
the
fine
folks
of
you
know,
line
speed,
meet
echo
they're,
always
sitting
there
in
the
back
of
the
room,
often
there's
a
pink
box
around
the
mic
here
so
that,
if
you
are
presenting,
you
know
where
to
stand
so
you
can
be
beamed
out
over
the
internet
or
recorded
on
YouTube.
B
Mideco
is
for
online
remote
participation.
That's
at
the
far
the
smaller
screen
over
there
on
the
right.
When
people
want
to
talk,
you'll
see
them
come
up
to
the
mic.
The
chair
has
a
handy
red
button.
They
can
push
and
recognize
someone,
and
then
they
get
to
talk
just
as
if
it
were
somebody
local
talking
there,
birds
of
a
feather,
more
informal
precedes
a
working
group.
They'll
be
often
at
the
reception.
There
will
be
poster
boards
scattered
around
the
room
about
the
different
offs
people
running
them
have
signs,
as
they
asked
me
about.
My
bath.
B
I
gave
my
sorry
pins.
I
gave
my
pin
to
the
guys,
actually,
the
technical
lead
of
it
and
so
on
bath
meets
once
sometimes
it
meets
twice
and
then,
at
the
end
of
that,
with
the
area
directors
in
the
and
the
bath
folks
determine
if
there
is
consensus
to
do,
you
know,
create
a
working
group.
I
RTF
is
officially
part
of
the
IAB.
The
oversight
group
focused
on
research.
They
meet
at
the
same
time,
of
course,
there's
an
RFC.
B
Seventy
four
eighteen,
one
of
the
things
they
do
is
they
present
a
networking
prize,
the
one
of
the
one
or
two
I
think.
Sometimes
it's
been
three
of
the
best
papers
on
networking.
How
I
can
fool
the
router
into
sending
all
my
packets
to
you
know
India,
for
example,
they
get
sponsored
to
come
to
the
IETF
to
present
their
paper,
it's
kind
of
cool
stuff.
It's
a
way
to
get
some
academic
involvement
applied.
Networking
research
workshop
it
met
last
IETF.
It
meets
annually
in
conjunction
with
the
IETF
first
two
days.
B
It's
very
it's
part
of
the
ACM
Association
for
Computing
Machinery,
very
much
a
academic
organization,
even
more
so
than
the
IRT
F.
Think
I
RTF
is
advanced
research
and
development
in
an
engineering
organization
and
our
W
is
actually
academic,
no
cost
free
to
attend
highly
worthwhile,
presumably
it'll
be
at
the
next
one
away:
I
figure
out
what
that
is.
B
B
Hackathons,
the
hackathon
meets
Saturday
and
Sunday
no
cost
if
you
had
signed
up
or
next
time,
if
you
want
to
come
and
work
on
something
you
sign
up,
you
get,
you
know
the
t-shirt.
Free
food
I
think
about
two.
Three
hundred
people
are
the
current
one.
This
year
there
will
be
a
small
reception
with
the
best
results
of
the
hackathon.
You
know,
prizes
handed
out
and
so
on.
The
way
it
works
is
there's
a
wiki
page
where
you
sign
up
for
topics
or.
B
You
sign
up
for
topics
or
you
join,
or
you
sign
up
to
work
on
existing
projects.
There
have
been
a
lot
of
interrupts
sessions.
Otl
s13
was
at
the
hackathon
for
a
number
of
times.
Quick
is
currently
at
the
hackathon
dns
privacy
dns
over
TLS
things
like
that.
Are
there
networking
in
social
events
the
ITF
attendees
list,
106
attendees
mailing
lists
right
now
it's
about
to
switch
over
from.
B
B
This
one
was
from
Singapore
two
years
ago.
Is
the
aquarium?
I
forget
the
name
of
the
part
that
attacked
this
time.
The
picture
on
the
right,
yeah
right,
that's
from
the
ietf
sisters,
that
is
an
organization
of
people
who
identify
as
women,
Dyna
Phi
is
female.
They
have
a
social
lunch
which
anyone
you
know
who
feels
appropriate
can
sign
up.
They
also
have
activities
during
the
week
that
are
all
listed
in
the
agenda.
B
More
side
meetings
ongoing
experiments
with
the
agenda
to
find
more
unstructured
time.
Some
working
groups
don't
like
constrained
in
meeting
and
think
it's
all
waste
a
time.
It's
better
to
have
more
hallway
conversations
more
one-on-one,
more
sit
down
together
in
small
study
groups
so
and
I
mentioned
the
tutorials.
No
deep
dive
this
year.
This
meeting
and
the
hot
RFC
this
igloo
okay
meeting
adequate
etiquette
behavior
when
you're
attending
a
working
session
general.
B
You
probably
know
for
the
most
part,
what
working
groups
you're
interested
in
you
know,
while
you're
here
it
helps
to
read
the
documents
beforehand,
behave
respectfully,
tolerantly
talk,
listen
enjoy
yourself,
get
some
sleep,
that's
a
silly
thing,
but
the
meetings
you
know
the
day
starts
at
you
know:
breakfast.
Is
it
or
eight
or
nine
side
meetings
you
may
or
may
not
have
any
the
first
time
around,
and
then
the
sessions
run
until
6:00
or
7:00
at
night,
and
then
the
bob
off
start,
which
is
a
informal
gathering.
B
Let's
go
to
a
bar
in
the
past,
the
IETF
has
drained
the
hotel's
of
all
the
beer.
They
have
right-
maybe
not
here,
but
you
know,
and
that
runs
you
know
until
11
o'clock
at
night.
I
learned
this
really
great
finished
drinking
game
where
you
sing
a
song
and
say
new
everybody
drinks
and
by
the
second
or
third
round
you
stop
singing
you
just
say
new
when
everybody
drinks,
but
it's
fun
and
you
know
you're
working
with
colleagues.
So
it's
not
just
you
know
drinking
to
get
drunk.
B
But
if
there's
a
lot
of
technical
discussion
going
on
the
whole
day
is
involved
with
technology
and
protocols
and
networking
and
it
extends
through
dinner
and
through
the
night.
So
even
if
you're,
not
physically
tired
or
even
if
you're,
not
physically
jet-lagged
your
mind
is
exhausted.
I
guarantee
it
get
some
sleep
respectfully
in
tolerantly
we
try
to
all
be
adults
and
there's
some
things
about
a
code
of
conduct
that
I'll
mention
later
on
Newark.
The
IETF
is
always
looking
for
areas
where
we
can
help
make
the
internet
better.
B
If
there's
some
idea
of
some
protocol
that
makes
sense
to
evolve,
we
do
less
well
with
api's,
but
we,
but
if
their
protocols
or
work
where
you
want
to
communicate
over
the
internet,
doing
something
you
know:
videoconferencing,
multi
conferencing,
that
stuff
is
WebSocket
space.
Here's
how
to
do
it.
I'll
just
skip
over
this
one,
since
it's
unlikely
to
have
pretty
unlikely
to
have.
You
know
I
like
to
have
new
ideas
coming
forward,
the
slides
we
gave
a
tutorial
on
it
one
year
ago
in
Bangkok
session,
etiquette:
okay,
that's
yo!
Who
will
co-chair
back
me?
B
He
won't
be
here.
You
didn't
make
it
over
from
Israel
this
time,
speak
directly
into
the
mic.
You'll
often
hear
the
phrase,
especially
if
you're
not
used
to
it.
People
go
eat.
The
mic
eat
that
mic,
and
that
means
you
know
you've
got
to
get
really
close
it
mics
here
or
good
in
other.
In
other
venues,
they've
been
not
so
good,
say
your
name
every
time
you
speak
part
of
the
reason.
The
main
reason
why
that's
done
is
there
somebody
typing
it?
B
So
it's
visible
online
so
that
people
who
are
watching
remotely
say
via
medical
and
with
the
illogical,
live
streaming.
They
know
who's
talking
after
a
while,
you
can
tell
there
are
certain
people
like
and
people
will
go,
you
know
by
Tuesday
they'll
be
yeah.
Rick
sells
Akamai
and
I
want
to
say
that
you
know
it's
hard.
It's
also
to
encourage.
You
know
to
you,
have
to
acknowledge
and
take
credit
blame
or
be
associated
with
the
things
that
are
said
at
the
mic
blue
sheets,
it's
on
blue
sheet
of
paper.
B
Historically,
it
was
always
on
blue
sheets.
We
just
like
traditions
kept
it
you
sign
in
and
when
you
sign
in,
you
agree
to
follow
the
practices
of
the
note
well,
which
you
all
remember,
was
the
first
two
slides
or
slide
saying
for
technical
questions
and
comments
are
always
welcome.
Not,
and
that
means
not
like
you
know,
that's
really
a
stupid
idea,
but
have
you
considered
that
maybe
eight
bits
for
a
network
is
not
wide
enough?
B
That's
a
better
way
of
saying.
On
the
other
hand,
people
have
known
each
other
for
decades,
so
there
will
be
people
who
come
to
the
mic
and
go
because
I've
known
you
for
20
years.
That's
really
stupid.
You
should
do
it
this
way,
don't
listen
to
them,
don't
take
their.
You
know,
don't
think
that
behavior
is
the
way
to
go.
Every
working
group
has
backed
a
back
channel
side.
Channel
instant
messaging
jabber
mention
that
in
a
little
more
detail
later
on
resources,
people,
the
key
people
are
Secretariat.
B
This
is
the
paid
the
paid
staff
who
handles
all
of
the
all
of
the
logistics.
You
see
a
picture
of
them
there.
They
wear
these
blue
polo
shirts.
They
run
they're,
often
seen
at
the
registration
desk
swear
you
picked
up.
Your
bed
they'll
run
around
the
meetings.
If
you
have
any
problem
with
logistics
or
you
like
you're
completely
lost,
they
will
answer
you
on
Friday,
as
the
meeting
begins
to
wind
down,
they
all
change
into
Hawaiian
shirts,
but
they're,
very
nice
people.
B
Also,
we
have
the
RFC
editor
series
and
the
IANA
staff,
the
assigned
numbers,
those
determined.
You
know
those
keep.
The
registry
of
like
I
said
DNS
runs
on
53,
SSH
runs
on
22
mail
runs
on
25,
say:
I
got
two
digit
numbers:
I
can't
do
for
you
a
notable
thing
about
them.
In
addition
to
being
friendly
and
helpful,
they
will
have
desks
in
the
same
registration
area
and
throughout
the
week
they
have
candy.
B
So
if
you
need
a
quick
pick-me-up
grab,
a
piece
of
chocolate
or
sour
tart
or
whatever
they
have
Jay
Daly
is
our
new
executive
director.
He
is
paid
staff
runs.
You
know
the
one
who
signs
the
checks
on
the
direction.
Ward
negotiates
with
hotels.
Does
all
of
the
kind
of
stuff
you've
probably
seen
some
emails
from
him
talking
about
who
the
hosts
are
for
the
subsequent
meetings
coming
up,
I
think
with
Cisco
mentioned
to
do
Bangkok
next
year
he
comes
from
I
sock,
sorry
be
the
DNS
side
of
the
house.
B
I
can
couldn't
take
it
mister.
So
we
know
he
understands.
You
know
the
technology.
It's
a
good
day,
the
Ombuds
team.
We
try
to
be
relaxed
friendly
and
welcoming
to
everyone.
If
you
have
concerns
or
issues
or
feeling
pressured
or
uncomfortable
or
made
to
feel
or
see,
someone
else
being
made
to
feel
uncomfortable,
please
find
one
of
these
people.
If
you
can't
find
one
of
these
people
find
them
helpful,
Secretariat
staff
and
talk
to
them.
B
B
B
Ribbons
there's
a
sore
ribs
at
the
bottom.
You
know
probably
God
are
seeing
the
new
comers
attendees
there's
also
nowadays
a
jar
of
ribbons
and
markers
to
the
side,
and
people
can
write
their
own
jokes
and
paste
them
to
the
bottom
of
their
label
by
the
end
of
the
week,
and
certainly
by
the
after
your
second
and
third
IETF.
B
There
are
no
funny
jokes,
it's
just
no
same
ones
over
and
over
new
comers
resources,
the
Dow
of
the
ITF,
what
it
means
to
have
rough
consensus
and
running
code
deliberately
modeled
after
you
know
the
Buddha
philosophical
document
of
how
the
ITF
works.
This
newcomers
page
there'll,
be
a
newcomers
page
for
every
IETF.
B
More
meeting
resources,
there's
a
wiki,
the
wiki
before
the
meeting
is
usually
done,
monitored,
especially
by
local
people.
Who
will
tell
you
the
best
way
to
get
from
the
airport
to
the
hotel?
How
to
use
the
MRT
in
this
case,
there's
a
first-time
attendees
mailing
list,
if
you're
not
on
it,
consider
it
joining
it.
The
ITF
sisters,
as
I
said,
is
a
support
group
for
women.
People
who
present
as
female
women
and
there's
other
mailing
lists
the
social
lists
travel
companions.
We
have
a
slight
lightweight
program
for
spouses,
significant
others.
B
All
the
information,
so
there
are
two
websites
listed
here,
the
top
one
and
the
one
on
the
right,
the
data
tracker,
or
also
known
as
DT
IETF
org,
that's
the
site
where
you
will
find
everything
about
the
working
groups,
everything
about
the
drafts,
everything
about
the
RFC's
who's
come
now
who's
car
and
all
the
mailing
lists.
Every
mailing
list
has
a
charter
that
says
you
will.
You
know
by
the
end
of
first
quarter.
B
Will
do
this
by
the
end
of
second
quarter
will
do
that,
but
in
the
third
quarter
will
do
that
no
working
group
ever
meets
its
deadlines
milestones.
They
always
get
revised,
they're
the
phrases
it's
aspirational,
but
DT
that
IETF,
that
org
/wg
/
and
then
the
working
group
named
TLS
w
DNS
op
whatever,
and
that
will
bring
you
to
a
page
that
looks
like
the
one
you
see
here.
Multiple
tabs
talk
about
the
specific
overall
working
group,
the
stuff,
the
tab
default.
B
Startup
tab
is
all
the
documents
that
are
working
and
you
can
see
when
it
started.
How
many
pages
it
is
what
the
status
is.
If
it's
still
a
draft
of
it's
been
waiting
for.
You
know
review
and
so
on.
The
tools
page
links
at
the
bottom
page
pages
to
the
left
is
of
less
importance.
This
is
for
folks
who
want
to
know
well,
which
RFC
was
cited
the
most
by
any
other
RFC
or
where
can
I
find
tooling
on
how
to
turn
you.
B
Or
XML
into
an
RFC
document
that
stuff's
on
the
tools
page
more
and
more
people
or
users
are
more
and
more
people
are
migrating
from
using
the
tools
to
using
github
which
we're
developing
better
tooling.
For
if
you're,
if
you
know
so,
you
can
saw
often
many
groups
now
are
putting
their
documents
on
github
periodically
taking
a
snapshot
and
posting
it
to
the
data
tracker
for
official
IETF
release.
B
So
github
is
like
the
author
is
working
copies
and
people
can
make
pull
requests
and
raise
issues
on
github
they
get
addressed
or
they
get
delayed,
or
that
discussed
in
the
mail
in
the
working
room,
email
and
then
a
draft
is
posted.
You
know
periodically
to
the
data
tracker,
remote
participation,
the
fine
media
core
folks,
attended
to
the
I
face-to-face
attendance
is
not
required
only
if
you
want
to
serve
on
the
nominating
committee,
but
you
had
to
have
attended
among
three
out
of
five
meetings
to
get
to
know
people
we
support
remote
attendants
completely.
B
It
generally
works
seamlessly
these
days.
You
can
see
the
remote
stream
over
there
on
the
far
right
me.
Deco
is
a
tool
it's
browser-based,
so
on
it
works
really
well
the
network.
If
you
haven't
already,
there
are
multiple
networks.
This
you
know
encrypted
legacy,
ipv6
ipv4,
the
name
and
password
for
all
of
them
is
IETF.
B
The
only
reason
to
have
a
name
and
password
is
so
we
can
encrypt
it
to
keep
private,
keep
your
privacy.
It's
really
fast.
It's
free
in
this
hotel.
You
know
the
Swiss
hotel
on
the
Fairmont
in
general.
It's
free
in
the
main
meeting.
Hotels,
you'll,
never
find
Hotel.
Internet
is
fast
and
is
cheap
as
it
is
the
ITF
meeting
local
hosts
and
the
sponsors
you
know
bring
in
equipment
and
donated
if
you've
noticed
you
might
see.
B
For
example,
if
you
go
to
web
search
engines
right
now,
it
might
think
that
you're
in
Zurich
or
Prague,
because
the
IP
addresses
haven't
been
updated
to
geolocate
properly
it's
the
same
equipment
that
was
in
Prague
back
in
March,
there's
quiet
space
called
the
terminal
room
for
historical
reasons.
There
are
no
terminals,
this
power,
wired,
Ethernet
connectivity,
there's
a
help
desk
and
a
printer
in
the
registration
area.
B
If
you
need
to
print
off
your
boarding,
pass
right
on
Thursday,
that's
what
everybody
does
jabber
every
working
group,
so
DNS
op,
the
DNS
Operations
Group-
will
have
a
jabber
room
at
group
chat
at
DNS
off
at
Jabra,
ETF
org,
you
just
you
know,
search
for
jabber,
client,
there's
a
number
of
free
ones.
There's
a
number
of
phone
ones
available.
You
have
to
get
an
account
on
a
server
somewhere
and
then
you
can
participate.
One
of
the
things
at
every
meeting
is
a
jabber
scribe
will
write
down
in
the
room
the
name
of
who's.
B
Speaking
at
the
mic,
the
page
number
of
the
slides
that
they're
on
so
people
who
are
remote
can
follow
along.
If
somebody
remotely
says
I
want
to
say
something
at
the
mic,
they
type
it.
The
jabber
scrub,
gets
to
cut
to
the
front
of
the
line
and
say
relaying
for
holder's.
This
DNS
record
is
invalid.
Whatever
the
comment
is.
B
Above
all,
above
anything
else
enjoy
the
fireworks
we
actually
had
fireworks
in
Prague
four
years
ago,
two
years
ago,
that
was
a
really
nice
social
event.
The
one
this
year
is
supposed
to
be
pretty
nice
too
lots
of
smiling
faces
lots
of
enthusiasm.
You
can
see
the
guy
in
the
blue
t-shirt.
There
is
making
a
point
to
one
of
his
colleagues.
B
It
is
a
pretty
amazing
and
pretty
unusual
time
it's
not
like
a
regular
conference
technical
conference,
the
work
that
we
do
and
the
quality
and
the
breadth
of
the
work
we
do
will
depend
on
you
as
well
as
everybody
else.
Who's
here,
I
think,
is
about
a
thousand
people.
Eleven
hundred
those
kind
of
stats
will
be
presented
at
the
plenary.
B
Have
fun
it's
a
good
time
be
nice.
You
know,
fill
your
head
full
of
lots
of
cool
technology
and
come
away
with
wow.
I
really
want
to
do
this.
This
isn't
this
and
then
slow
down
and
figure
out.
You
know
what's
actually
manageable
questions
your
feedback,
the
link
on
the
slide
title
is
wrong.
It's
off
by
one.
It
should
be
106.
That's
what
the
survey
you
know.
The
link
in
the
main
body,
the
slide,
is
correct.
B
There
is
a
team
at
U
for
educational.
We
run
the
Karen
and
I
are
the
co-chairs.
We
run
these
tutorials,
we
have
a
chair,
we
organized
a
lunch
for
the
working
group
chairs.
We
meet
every
session
that
talked
about
what's
new
and
talked
about
other
issues,
we
help
do
the
deep
dives
and
someone
like
that.
We're
very
much
interested
in
what
feedback
you
have
to
give
one
session.
B
We
got
like
three
people
feedback,
then
I
think
the
past
now
we're
running
between
one
and
two
dozen
people
actually
fill
out
the
survey
and
it's
not
a
contest,
but
I
always
look
to
see
if
we
got
better
ratings
than
any
of
the
other
groups
in
the
ITF.
So
be
honest,
you
don't
have
to
tough
things
up,
oh
okay,
so
let
me
mention
humming,
there's
a
number
of
reasons
why
we
hum?
For
example,
you
can't
look
around
and
see
who
you
know.
B
B
We
want
a
rough
consensus
of
the
room.
We
want
to
know
how
most
of
the
people
the
room
feel,
and
it's
really
hard
to
you
can't
hum
loudly
I
mean
probably
here
at
the
mic.
I
can
hum
loudly
than
any
of
you
out
there,
but
you
know
so.
The
way
humming
works
is
we'll
say:
okay,
we're
gonna,
do
a
consensus
call,
and
so
the
chair
will
say
what
the
options
are
and
it
will
typically
be.
Did
you
find
this
session
useful
and
the
choices
are
yes
no
or
I
need
more
information?
B
B
Okay,
please
hum
now.
If
the
answer
is
no
so
and
please
hum
now,
if
you
don't
have
enough
information
to
decide,
okay,
great
so
most
people
know
so
we
we
had
a
rough
consensus.
Most
people
seem
to
think
it
was
useful.
We'll
confirm
that
on
the
mailing
list
we
won't,
but
that's
what
we
would
do
next
is
we'd
say
most
people
found
this
session
useful,
valid
reason
to
say:
I,
don't
know
yet
is
you
know,
ask
me
at
the
end
of
the
week,
but
that's
the
way.
B
D
B
Search
for
like
free
jabber
account,
you
should
be
able
to
find
some.
You
don't
have
to
register
on
the
ITF
server
a
jabber
server
anywhere.
You
can
get
you
an
account
that
will
then
let
talk
to
the
ITF
server,
so
look
for
like
free
jabber
account
and
you
should
get
like
a
dozen
sites.
You
can
sign
up
on
come
to
the
helpdesk
or
come
see
me.
I
can
help
you
with
that.
E
B
Maybe
yes,
there
are
going.
There
is
a
in
the
video
library.
There
is
a
section
on
like
the
mechanics
of
how
you
write
a
tutorial,
the
structure
of
the
XML
or
the
markdown.
There
are
some
in
the
past,
we've
had
tutorials
on
how
you
do
the
Security
section,
security
considerations
area
in
general.
The
best
way
to
learn
is
like
we
in
existing
RFC
an
area
or
you
know,
read
the
drafts.
The
progression
is.
The
working
group
has
drafts
the
drafts.
Our
editors
or
authors
are
picked
by
the
chairs.
B
B
The
simplest
way
to
find
it
is,
if
you
go
to
the
meetings
page
on
the
IETF
website.
It'll
have
a
direct
link,
I
think
to
the
naps.
There
are
two
I
know
in
the
Android
store.
There
are
two
apps
one
of
them
ends
you
install
it
and
it
says
IETF
99,
that's
the
wrong
one.
It
should
okay.
I
can
try
a
screenshot
if
you
want.