►
Description
Internet Society Board Open Forum on Structures of Consultation
Session 1
24 May 2022 (Spanish)
A
Join
today,
Sorry,
we
are
starting
the
session
a
bit
late.
Here
are
the
logistical
rules
for
today's
session.
Please
respect
the
code
of
conduct.
We
also
have
simultaneous
interpretation
in
English,
Spanish
and
French,
and
We
also
have
subtitles
available
in
English.
You
will
have
the
possibility
to
choose
it
at
the
bottom
of
the
zoom
screen.
Please
keep
your
microphone
muted
and
use
the
chat
for
all
questions
or
raise
your
hand
virtually
if
you
want
to
do
an
audio
intervention.
A
If
you
can,
please
ask
your
questions
with
your
name
and
country,
for
example,
Ted
Portugal
and
with
pleasure.
You
can
also
write
your
comments
in
the
chat
in
English,
Spanish
or
French,
and
they
will
be
translated
in
the
chat.
Now
the
session
is
being
recorded
and
a
link
to
the
recording
will
be
shared
later
next
slide.
Please.
B
A
C
A
A
A
very
important
position,
Please
know
that
there
were
some
restrictions
and
included
proposals,
including
reducing
the
capacity
of
communities
in
the
United
States
or
proposals
requiring
their
relocation
or
dissolution
from
the
United
States
internet
forgiveness,
and
lay
especially
for
the
elections
in
terms
of
Well.
We
would
also
like
to
add
that
there
would
not
be
any
restrictions,
but
since
it
is
not
today's
topic,
we
are
going
to
move
on
to
the
next
slide.
C
A
A
A
A
D
D
D
A
Let's
say
a
reprosmante
between
the
two
now
the
question
is:
is
it
something
important
or
is
it
not
about
trust?
One
I
don't
know,
but
we
would
like
to
hear
the
comments
of
those
who
have
met
today.
If.
They
have
not
heard
or
seen
the
report
it's
out
now.
I
hope.
If
you've
read
it,
you
have
some
thought
about
the
report.
Thank
you
very
much
Richard.
A
Yes,
thank
you.
I
totally
agree
with
George's
summary
I
would
just
like
to
add
that
one
of
the
reasons
this
happened
between
the
board
was
that
the
board
couldn't
disclose
certain
items,
because
the
board
had
entered
into
an
agreement
not
to
share
this
information
with
the
people
who
had
proposed
to
buy
the
find
I
think
several
board
members
have
shared
the
restriction
and
in
some
circumstances
it
was
necessary
for
them
to
agree
because
it
was
in
the
best
interest
of
the
internet.
A
A
A
B
A
Now
we
are
formally
acting
as
a
board.
There
are
some
conversations
that
are
held
in
executive
sessions
and
are
then
held
under
the
advice
that
advises
us.
If
Some
particular
topic
needs
an
executive,
session.
I
think
that
we
cannot
exercise
responsibility
from
the
board
and
never
have
executive
sessions..
It
is
certainly
the
case
that
we
would
have
to
know
what
the
proposal
is
to
know
if
we
can
comply
with
the
transparency
clause
and
the
trustee
responsibilities.
A
We
could
take
those
issues
to
the
head
of
the
council
But,
especially
since
Gonzalo
started,
pushing
the
issues
to
YouTube.
The
idea
that
the
community
would
want
us
to
be
As,
transparent
as
possible
is
very
important.
Now
it
is
about
whether
there
is
a
difference
of
opinion
as
to
what
is
possible
Steven.
A
A
A
E
Tell
me
what
that
experiment
would
look
like
good.
It
could
be
services,
maybe
it
could
be
work
on
governance
So.
Maybe
the
mechanisms
that
were
brought
up
in
the
conversation
is
once
to
analyze
the
surveys
and
the
other
benefits.
I
understand
the
difficulties
with
the
questions
from
members,
but
I
think
it
would
be
something
that
is
based
on
experimentation
at
this
time.
E
E
B
E
E
When
we
look
at
the
established
methods
of
communication
between
members
and
councils,
we
have
the
chapters
and
the
advisory
committee
and
there
is
a
process
to
raise
a
matter
before
the
advisory
committee
and
for
the
advisory
committee
to
propose
it
to
you.
The
council
already
seems
somewhat
slow
and
complicated
to
me
Maybe.
That
is
not
your
opinion.
But.
There
is
some
other
mechanism.
There
were
opinions
in
various
ways.
Some
thought
they
were
useful,
others
that
The
process
could
not
be
improved.
Others
said
that
we
could
have
more
openness,
Any
opinion
regarding
that.
D
C
E
Which
is
how
we
can
guarantee
representation
of
marginalized
sections
of
society,
such
as
people
with
disabilities
in
the
councils
and
chapters
good.
In
terms
of
the
consultations
that
we
normally
do,
these
consultations
with
the
society
with
cesarity,
we
have
people
with
different
interests
in
the
areas
that
would
be
included,
Beyond
that
I
don't
know
what
specific
segments
you
are
considering.
You
can
take
the
floor.
If.
You
want
to
comment
a
little
more.
D
E
E
You
can
send
the
message
in
English
and
in
other
languages.,
but
you
could
Translate.
We
could
have
sign
language
interpretation
of
different
videos.
That
would
also
be
useful.
We
could
also
include
descriptions
of
any
images
that
are
sent
in
the
message
that
would
be
Useful
for
people
with
disabilities
So.
E
These
are
some
of
the
suggestions
to
start
and,
of
course,
we
can
guarantee
that
the
messages
are
acceptable
for
people
with
disabilities
in
social
networks
and
other
areas
we
on
the
internet,
and
we
can
benefit
from
those
tips
that
are
already
available
and
that
have
been
created
by
different
organizations.
That
was
a
point
that
I
wanted
emphasize
Of
course.
If
there
are
other
marginalized
groups
in
the
internet
society,
in
addition
to
people
with
disabilities,
we
could
use
other
tips.
Other
strategies
to
receive
feedback
from
those
groups.
I
would
also
encourage
them
to
take
those
strategies.
E
Thank
you
very
much,
sir
dealer
Yes
good.
Regarding
the
advisory
committee
chapter
many
years
ago,
25
years
ago,
most
communication
between
members
staff
council
happened
with
I
can
and
ytf
meetings.
Normally,
you
would
meet
someone
and
you
could
take
them
aside
and
talk
to
that
person
During
the
years
ago.
That
is
no
longer
possible,
I,
think
10
or
11
years
ago.
Now,
I,
don't
know
for
sure
I
don't
know
very
well,
but
John
Moore
perhaps
remembers
better.
We
sat
down
in
Washington
and
decided
that
we
had
to
change
something.
E
C
E
E
E
E
B
E
Luis
then
said
that
the
ISO
processes
that
are
open
to
any
member
or
local
chapter
can
provide
more
information
Steven.
He
said
he
doesn't
have
a
local
chapter,
but
that's
a
separate
thing
andrew,
provided
the
mechanism
to
join
the
governance
reform
working
group.
If
you
are
not
already
a
member
and
silhard
goes
to
me,
asked
a
question.
He
said
the
topic
was
consultation
structures,
these
consultations,
Are
they
from
council
meetings
or
are
they
other
queries
regarding
the
internet
and
policies
in
general,
she
made
it,.
It
is
a
501
C3
organization,.
E
How
can
this
be
done
with
other
companies?
Well,
in
general,?
The
topic
is
the
different
methodologies
for
queries
and
Hans,
Peter
and
John,
with
their
comments
concluded
that
this
issue
is
how
we
can
guarantee
bilateral
information
between
the
council,
members.,
bros
and
other
parts
of
the
membership.
Flavio
said
that
the
council
is
not
being
used
to
consult
with
the
chapters
on
more
strategic
issues
or
political
issues
that
could
be
more
effective
and
could
have
also
interacted,
as
the
council
with
the
council
decides.
E
Commissioners
sagarica
said
that
a
more
accessible
format
for
web
pages
would
be
a
conclusion.
This
has
to
do
with
the
topic
to
which
he
responded.
Mohamed
Luis
commented
to
Flavio
that
Jack
or
any
Isa
entity
provides
reports
to
the
board
of
trustees.
Sagarica
said
they
should
have
policies
to
create
web
pages.
Affordable
Android
provided
a
method
to
connect
with
the
list.
C
E
O
Excuse
me
Flavia
asked
Luis
And.
These
reports
could
be
shared
with
the
chapters
and
Luis
said
that
the
reports
are
part
of
the
open
sessions
of
the
Council
of
Commissioners
Therefore.
If
they
go
to
the
website,
you
can
review
all
the
materials,
Jordi
I,
think
it's
your
turn
and
I
see
your
hand
raised
n
I,
don't
know
if
that
was
from
the
last
time.
B
E
D
E
E
They
think
that
this
is
an
issue
that
we
need
to
address.
I
would
also
say
the
way
in
which
the
advisory
committee
representatives
are
actually
elected.
This
does
not
allow
the
operation
can
go
ahead.
For
example,
every
year
we
have
elections,
maybe
from
one
year
to
the
next.
All
the
members
are
brand
new.
D
E
Representatives
In
my
opinion.
They
should
also
try
harder
to
participate
in
all
the
meetings
Or.
Maybe
we
should
think
about
increase
the
size
of
the
advisory
committee
to
have
a
minimum
number
of
participants
And.
This
is
an
idea.
Maybe
members
should
be
able
to
renew
their
membership
every
year.
But,
maybe
not
all
members,
but
we
want
continuity.
This
is
my
own
experience.
I
joined
the
council
and
Well,
all
year,
I
was
trying
to
understand
the
issues.
E
C
A
A
Maybe
this
way
we
could
address
certain
topics
and
focus
only
on
those.
There
are
some
topics
that
were
also
included
in
the
chat
Steven
asked.
If
there
is
a
link
to
the
reports,
I
imagine
you
can
see
it
from
the
platform.
Kevin
shared
a
link
to
the
Steven
comedy
report,
and
then
Flavio
says
that
I
was
referring
to
the.
A
C
D
A
C
A
Comment
from
Sarita
to
make
the
meeting
truly
inclusive,,
then
the
partici
IPation
of
people
with
disabilities
and
gender
and
sexual
minorities
It
should
be
ensured
Well.
That
was
the
topic
of
the
previous
consultation.
I,
encourage
you
to
review
the
minutes
or
the
recording
of
this
meeting.
I
think
you
are
the
first
person
first
person
to
suggest
gender
inclusion
and
sexual,
but
we
have
already
talked
about
this
topic
and
I,
encourage
you
to
review
the
session
that
we
already
had
on
this
topic.
A
B
A
Well,
I
I,
wonder,,
Andrew
says,
does
the
interaction
between
the
divisions
and
the
board
need
a
statement
about
what
it
is?
the
objective
of
what
it
is
to
interact
with
the
board?
I,
don't
know
if
this
is
what
the
board
wants,
and
he
asked
me
if
this
topic
has
to
do
with
what
people
think
is
the
purpose
of
the
board.
A
Yes
I
think
it
has
a
lot
to
see
the
chapters
they
should
not
continue
with
more
information.
They
should
have
more
transparency
what
the
divisions
want.
In
that
case,
it
is
very
clear
and
I
think
it
is
just
an
example
of
generic
transparency
as
I
mentioned,
and
it
shows
us
that
transparency
is
not
always
possible,
but
it
is
that
the
divisions
are
requesting
is
very
clear..
Well,
just
to
clarify,.
I
did
not
say
that
the
transfer
of
transparency,
well,
is
not
possible,.
A
Simply
that
we
have
to
look
at
the
transparency
proposal
to
make
sure
that
we
can
deliver
or
fulfill
the
responsibilities
of
life
and
commissions.
And.
That
has
to
do
with
talking
to
the
councils
to
see
what
they
want.
In
some
cases
we
cannot
achieve
this,
and
in
some
sessions
that
the
board
has
it
is
esc,
It
seems
like
we
can't
make
this
available
to
everyone.
There
are
some
sessions
with
chirping,
where
the
responsibility
and
commissioner
is
to
catch.
You.
A
Sharing
information
with
the
public,
there
are
some
cases
where
the
board
must
operate,
and
you
can't
have
full
transparency.
I
think
you
will
continue
to
do
the
case.
The
question
is
Is
there
any
aspect
of
transparency
that
we
can
achieve
where
we
can
increase
it
without
sacrificing
any
trustworthiness
and,
commissioner,
if
Richard
still
has
a
bad
hand,
wants
to
Add
something.
I
would
just
like
to
clarify
something
that
was
said
at
the
beginning.
There
are
maybe
a
few
things.
A
example
would
be
that
some
things
are
not
totally
transparent
But.
What
is
transparency?
A
Does
not
seem
fair
to
me
to
say:
let's
come
back
to
you
and
ask
what
you
want.
It
is
not
about
what
we
can
get
you
to
see
what
can
be
achieved
in
the
law.
I,
don't
know
I'm,
not
a
lawyer,
but
it
is
something
that
can
be
explored,.
You
cannot
ask
us
to
develop
a
proposal
that
complies
with
the
laws
And
as
you
said,.
Some
things
will
always
be
more
closed,,
but
that
is
not
what
it
is
about,.
What
could
be
opened
a
little
more
and
at
the
same
time
comply
with
the
laws.
A
I,
don't
know,
I,
don't
know
what
it
could
be,
but
that's
what
it's
about.
Thank
you
thank
you,
and
it
seems
to
me
that,
let's
say
the
heart
of
the
question
is
one
is
an
issue
that
we
continue
to
consider
what
started
this.
That
dialogue
was
the
worst
that
was
not
part
of
the
board
in
that
moment,,
but
the
responsibility
decides
and
the
commissioner
that
they
had
to
do
with
the
aspects
that
required
confidentiality
and
that
did
not,
and
that
focus
on
making
sure
that
they
met
that
goal,.
A
A
Apart
from
this,
there
was
a
time
when
we
could
I
will
review
this
information
and
now
I
access
that
in
the
regional
ones.
It
seems
like
a
one-way
street
Carlos
Vives
says:
I
am
an
enthusiast
of
local
internet
governance
and
he
focused
me
on
the
use
of
the
internet
and
documents
and
I
focus
on
defending
human
rights
from
the
local
communities
of
cara
moja
in
uganda.
A
B
A
Board
would
be
interested
to
hear
from
the
leaders
of
the
members
of
the
members
leaders.
Luis
says
that
there
is
no
Good
what
The
Simpsons
is
similar
to
to
divisions.
However,
there
is
no
division
exclusively
equivalent
to
6.
If
this
answers
the
question,
Benny
says
By
the
way.
Speaking
of
dividers,
we
received
a
request
today
to
sign
a
letter
new
from
the
airsoft
agreement,
where
the
purpose
of
the
divisions
is
defined
as
the
purpose
of
the
div
Mission
should
support
the
vision,
Mission
and
the
operating
principles
of
the
necessary
industry
in
the
territory.
A
They
may
have
lost
the
conversation
about
this
topic.
There
could
be
some
notes,
then
another
comments
that
what
the
board
could
be
is
to
have
a
board
of
a
board
newsletter
inside
the
board
room
visible
to
the
people,
sir,,
then
I
will
continue
in
February,.
He
says:
I
think
that
this
interpretation
of
the
responsibility
and
commissioner
of
the
board
is
something
that
could
be
discussed,.
There
are
reasonable
arguments
on
both
sides
and
then
many
to
me
he
says
it
could
be
just
a
simple
poster
to
talk
about
some
issues.
A
A
A
C
A
Come
says
this
letter
is
replacing
the
2018
one,
so
I'm
not
sure
if
there
are
differences.
I
haven't
had
a
chance
to
compare
and
there
is
no
note
to
tell
us
what
the
changes
are
very
good.
There
are
a
lot
of
comments,
so
what
we
have
been
talking
about
is
the
scaling
issue.
How.
Do
we
get
86,000
people
in
a
society
to
interact
in
some
way
so
that
when
issues
arise,
we
understand
how
important.
A
E
D
E
There
are
opinions
that
are
below
the
threshold
so
that
it
is
not
among
the
main
elements
or
so
that
the
community
can
see
it.
The
way
that
this
is
usually
solved
in
situations
is
that
we
have
different
communities,.
If
we
have
something
that
is
very
important
for
a
specific
community,
yes,,
we
see
that
it
is
separated
from
other
chapters
and.
B
E
B
E
E
We
want
the
internet
to
be
available
to
everyone
to
be
more
solid,
more
successful,
m,
more
extensive,
and
we
must
know
what
is
happening
with
our
communication
to
really
allow
us
to
fulfill
our
mission.
There
are
administrative
issues.
There
are
other
issues
that
are
for
a
small
group
of
people
for
a
certain
time
to
fulfill
that
mission,
but
I
really
think
we
don't
need
that
that
communicates
horizontally
as
advice
I
could
spend
all
my
time
talking
to
the
members
in
the
society,
but
since
there
are
86
thousand
members,
it
would
never
end
really.
E
I
will
never
know
that
I
am
also
getting
the
message
of
air
ties.
Because
I
could
have
a
conversation
of
five
minutes
with
each
member
But.
That
would
be
impossible
So.
We
must
know
how
we
can
continue
to
fulfill
our
community
before
we
have
been
able
to
communicate
using
chapters
using
omak,
for
example,.
B
E
C
E
The
session,
then,
we
will
probably
have
less
than
250
And.
That
is
a
small
group
of
those
of
our
society
in
a
larger
group
that
is
larger
than
the
groups
that
we
usually
have
to
it's
useful,
but
we're
not
all
of
us
So
to
come
back
to
another
point,
which
is
what
we're
trying
to
do
with
our
communications.
We
want
to
create
these
new
structures
so
that
they
can
escalate
appropriately.
E
They
should
be
structured
throughout
the
sahari
throughout
society,
so
that
everyone
can
contribute
equally
or
members
can
communicate
with
each
other,
or
these
structures
are
for
councils
to
make
decisions
or
certain
segments
can
collaborate
on
specific
projects.
We
need
to
understand
that
better,
then,
that
It
will
allow
us
to
guarantee
that
the
structures
that
we
create
truly
fulfill
the
mission
M
ohamed
I,
see
you
ahead.
D
E
D
D
D
D
D
E
E
There
are
many
reasons,
but
chapter
members
and
their
representatives
at
these
meetings
have
had
very
low
participation
rates.
So.
We
need
to
improve
those
structures.
We
need
to
find
a
way
to
share
our
feedback.
When
I
say
our
feedback.
I
mean
the
community.
We
want.
The
advice
is
a
reflection
of
the
entire
community.
D
E
C
B
E
Going
to
leave
comments
between
participants,
aside.
Flavio
says
that
consulting
with
80,000
members
could
be
complex,,
but
many
of
those
members
are
also
from
specific
chapters
and
groups,
and
it
would
be
easier
to
interact
with
them
in
the
chapters
or
the
centuries.
Well
I
think
that
is
appropriate
when
it
is
done
through
the
Council.
We
have
to
see
if
it
is
appropriate
that
it
has
to
transmit
that
message
through
the
chapters
or
the
centuries,
the
chapters
should
represent
the
perspectives
of
their
members.
I
I
think
we
are
not
questioning
that,.
E
B
E
And
Ask
how
many
commissioners
are
on
the
call
and
well?
We
have
not
counted
when
they
were
on
the
previous
call.
We
can
see
if
they
are
interested
or
if
they
have
ideas
regarding
the
lack
of
communication
or
participation
in
the
organization,
including
the
council,
Fred
and
Android
are
talking
Come
on
and
it's
talking.
B
E
B
E
We
have
a
question
where
we'll
be
looking
for
feedback
from
the
community
if
we're
experimenting
with
those
structures,
I
think
it
would
be
successful
if
we
have
experiments
where
we
don't
require
changes
in
the
structures
immediately.
Maybe
these
experiments
could
guide
us
to
change
these
structures
in
the
future.
E
What
could
be
valuable
for
us
is:
if
you
have
ideas
about
specific
experiments
for
different
types
of
queries,
we
might
see
what
experiments
could
be
useful
and
what
is
the
goal
is
communication
with
the
board
with
different
parts
of
the
organization,
and
how
are
we
going
to
measure
success?
I
think
it
is
useful
to
experiment
in
different
ways
and
I
think
these
public
forums
have
been
put
in
place
by
It's
been
a
while
so
the
first
time
we
used
it
here
at
the
council
to
see
how
we
can
help.
C
E
E
B
E
E
I
want
to
remind
you
that
this
will
be
an
ongoing
process.
We
will
be
thinking
about
how
we
can
do
different
experiments,
o
How.
We
can
make
certain
changes
to
improve
communication
in
different
parts
of
the
implementation,
particularly
in
relation
to
the
advice
and
During
this
process,.
We
hope
that
you
can.
Let
us
know
how
different
experiments
work,,
how.