►
From YouTube: Project Catalyst - Weekly Town Hall
Description
Join Dor Garbash (Product Manager), Daniel Ribar (Community Manager) and the rest of the community for our weekly Catalyst update.
Tune in to live zoom event to participate in the call: https://bit.ly/3rCicSR
More info below.
👇👇👇
Too busy to watch it all?
📝 Skip over presentation slides: https://bit.ly/3ko01Nq
What's Project Catalyst? The largest decentralized innovation fund in the world now totalling almost 30,000 participants working together. You can join them today!
ℹ️ Need help? Want to help? 🤝
📣 Announcements only: https://t.me/cardanocatalyst
🎥 Rewatch past town-halls: https://www.crowdcast.io/iohk
💡 Browse insights, ideas, and proposals: http://cardano.ideascale.com
💬 Join main Telegram group: https://t.me/ProjectCatalystChat
🏟 Go deeper with Catalyst Discord: https://discord.gg/2RnUtK8
🤓 Become Community Advisor/Mentor: https://t.me/CatalystCommunityAdvisors
👩🔬 Join Proposal Owners: https://t.me/catalystproposers
🐛 Help find bugs & test: https://t.me/catalystdryruns
⚙️ Get lost in data: https://bit.ly/ProjectCatalystDashboard
Timestamps:
00:00:00 Welcome to Project Catalyst Fund 6 Town Hall #3
00:04:25 Final call for proposal submission
00:09:01 Cohort update by Ashish Prajapati, Cardanoscan.io
00:14:58 Cohort update by Sebastien Guillemot, dcSpark - Cardano Message Signing
00:21:45 Catalyst Coordinator
00:25:21 Welcome Fund6 Proposers!
00:27:19 Challenge Setting
00:31:15 Fund6 innovation phase
00:32:45 Proposer checklist & The self-assessment checklist
00:34:46 How to refine proposals
00:38:32 Merge efforts when sensible
00:40:15 Giving feedback
00:47:35 Catalyst circle update
00:53:49 We’re hiring!
00:56:25 Useful links
00:58:20 Open Space with Swarm
B
B
B
C
C
B
B
So
congratulations
on
being
a
pioneer
and
you're
the
first
of
many,
but
later
today,
you're
gonna,
you're
gonna.
You
know
kind
of
like
do
the
official
wrap-up
of
your
proposal
and
I'm
really
looking
forward.
That's
gonna
happen
in
a
few
minutes
and
in
the
meantime,
it's
like
having
some
logistical
problems
right
now
with
my
screen
share.
One
second.
B
A
B
A
B
How
about
now
perfect,
yep,
okay,
so
now's
the
time
there's
like
a
few
more
hours
before
we
reach
the
deadline
to
submit
draft
proposals,
and
I
really
want
to
I
mean
they're.
Probably
a
few
people
are
listening
to
this
right
now,
who
are
you
know,
really
fought
hard
to
to
to
submit
and
maybe
for
some
reason
they
didn't
submit.
Yet
you
know
maybe
you're
not
sure
if
that's
the
right
idea,
maybe
there's
some
things
that
you're
still
not
certain
about.
B
B
The
purpose
of
of
this
whole
catalyst
process
is
is
not
to
it's,
not
what
you
usually
think
about
for
like
when
you
think
about
like
something
like
a
submitting
grants
or
rfps
or
any
sort
of
anything
you've
known
in
the
past.
It's
not
it's
an
ever
continuing
system,
a
giant
incubator
that
helps
that
basically
catalyzes
you,
it
helps
you
grow.
B
It
helps
you
take
a
deeper
dive
into
the
process,
get
to
know
the
community
polish,
your
ideas,
get
feedback,
refine
them
and
the
single
best
thing
to
do
is
to
take
the
leap
of
faith
and
get
started,
and
we
love
it
and
we
appreciate
it
when
people
come
with
kind
of
an
early
idea
and
and
they're
open
to
to
change
it
and
modify
it.
That's
what
we
celebrate.
B
B
You
will
still
have,
after
the
submission
two
weeks
of
interactions
with
your
with
the
community,
to
refine
it
and
adjust
it.
So
if,
if
in
any,
if,
if
you're
sitting
on
the
fence-
and
I
really
want
to
encourage
you
to
actually
you
know
potentially
even
like
stop-
stop
leave
the
town
hall
and
go
submit
a
proposal.
B
B
B
C
Yeah
I
mean
it
was
the
it
was
the
greatest
thing
that
that
actually
came
to
my
life.
Actually,
that's
that's
really.
It
is
because
not
not
just
because
of
this
one
particular
proposal,
but
I
also
had
had
a
proposal
in
front
four
and
before
that
had
a
proposal
in
front
of
which
failed
miserably,
but
I
tried
again
it
worked
out.
I
tried
again
in
point
five.
B
C
C
The
name
is
strika
and
I'm
managing
with
my
all
the
friends-
and
this
is
a
this.
This
particular
proposal
was
for
a
test
net
version
of
the
cardano
skin,
explorer
that
we
got
funded
in
point
five
and
we
have
successfully
delivered
it
because
it
took
us
like
two
weeks
to
work
on
it,
and
I
think
we
got
enough
time
after
the
announcement
of
the
results.
C
We
thought
of
a
requirement
for
the
test
net
version
of
katana
scan
because
it
has
a
lot
of
unique
features
for
developers,
especially
because
of
that
there
are
a
lot
of
things
that
go
into
cadance
into
cardano
in
terms
of
certificates
in
terms
of
proposals,
protocol
parameter
changes,
I
mean
and
searching
by
metadata,
and
things
like
that,
there's
so
many
things
that
are
actually
not
available
in
other
explorers.
So
this
was
this
was
a
requirement
that
we
were
actually
getting
from
a
lot
of
developers,
and
I
thought
this.
C
B
Okay,
cool
all
right
anything
else.
You
want
to
tell
us,
it
was
like
you
know
like
shortened
to
the
point.
I
think.
Thank
you
maybe
just
like
you
know,
everybody
can
look
at
the
actually
go,
go
to
test
net
cardano
scanio
and
check
it
out
for
yourselves,
I'm
almost
like
I'm
holding
it
back
from
actually
clicking
it.
I'm
feeling
when
I
click
it,
I'm
gonna
see
what
happens.
B
C
I
don't
know
you:
can
you
can
click
on
the
filters
to
to
search
a
lot,
a
lot
of
different
different
things
that
that
are
available
for
searches
and
you
can
go
to
certificates
also
on
the
top
bar
to
see
all
different
kinds
of
certificates?
That
cardano
has
that
you
know
that
most
of
the
people
actually
do
not
know
what
goes
behind
the
scene,
but
this
is
something
that
that
the
developers
will
will
thank
a
lot
to
to
be
able
to
see
all
those
transactions.
B
D
D
So
if
you
look
at
the
proposals
here,
fun
five
proposals,
those
were
all
dc
smart
proposals,
because
I
started
this
spark
back
in
april
this
year,
fund
two
was
back
when
I
was
at
emergo,
so
let's
kind
of
go
to
the
next
slide
and
I
can
kind
of
introduce
you
this
proposal.
So
what
is
the
cardinal
message?
Science
expects.
The
chronometer
signing
spec
is
a
way
to
sign
messages
with
your
cardano
account,
so
this
allows
features
like
login
with
cardano.
D
It
allows
features
like
proving
ownership
of
assets,
and
you
know
anything
where
you
want
to
basically
prove
something
is
true
in
the
state
of
your
wallet.
This
spec
allows
you
to
do
it
so
the
product,
the
history
of
this
project
was
basically.
I
was
really
passionate
about
this
idea
because
I
thought
state
pools.
So
I
started
this
project
back
in
august
2019.
This
is
before
we
had
state
pools
before
we
had
tokens,
but
I
said:
hey
look:
we'll
have
stake
posts
in
the
future,
we'll
have
tokens
in
the
future.
D
So
I
talked
to
myself
to
write
the
first
measure
science
specification,
so
I
wrote
the
whole
specification
for
how
this
should
work,
but
unfortunately
I
wasn't
able
to
actually
convince
virgo
management
to
put
funding
towards
getting
this
developed,
but
I
thought
this
really
deserves
attention,
because
this
is
going
to
be
hugely
important,
so
in
october
2020
you
know
over
a
year
later
I
told
miracle
management
like
hey,
look
we
can
submit
this.
This
is
a
fun
two
proposal
get
part
of
the
cost
covered
and
we
can
use
this.
D
As
a
you
know,
good
reason
to
get
virgo
introduced
to
the
calais
ecosystem
get
the
experience
of
submitting
a
proposal,
and
after
we
got
the
funding
back
in,
I
think
december
was
when
the
rewards
are
hanging
out
for
fun
too.
I
took
us
until
april
to
release
the
first
version
of
the
message:
sonic
specs,
so
it's
on
github
and
I'll
say
this
is
under
the
american
repository,
because
this
proposal
was
from
emergo.
D
And
then
so,
since
we've
released
this
proposal,
it's
actually
been
integrated
by
real
people.
For
the
reasons
I
mentioned
so
there's
a
wallet
that
implements
this.
That's
not
me
that
you
can
see
right
here
and
people
are
actually
using
this
production,
so
you
can
see,
for
example,
somebody
wanted
discord
channel
where
you
can
only
join
the
discord
channel
if
you've
actually
participated
in
in
their
process.
D
D
D
I
want
to
sell
this
nft
for
500
ada
and
here's
a
proof
that
I
own
this
nft
and
somebody
created
a
discord
bot
that
basically,
if
it
selects
this,
so
you
say
like
prove
within
the
assets,
the
discord
bot
will
send
you
a
dm
saying,
like
hey,
sign
this
message
and
then
once
you
sign
the
message
and
you
send
to
this
corporate
support
can
verify
that
you
really
do
own
this
and
then
so
you
have
the
permission
to
put
up
this
nft
for
auction.
So
this
really
streamlines
the
process.
D
B
Great
I
loved
it.
I
loved,
I
mean
first
of
all,
congratulations
so
I
think
actually
sebastian
had.
Then
he
told
me
you
might
be
the
first
one
who
completed
the
actually
a
proposal
in
catalyst,
so
I
think
both
of
you
can,
because
you
know,
can
hel
hold
this
trophy
together
and
and
yeah
I
don't
know.
Can
you
tell
us
I'm
kind
of
curious?
If
this
is
park
and
catalyst
and
governance
like
do
you
have
any
any
anything
you
can.
D
Yeah,
I
I
can
go
over
that
real
quick,
so
our
company
is
hugely
focused
on
garments.
This
is
like
the
main
pillar
of
our
company.
So
that's
why
we
made
three
proposals
on
fund
five.
We
have
more
proposals
in
fund
six.
We
have
four
proposals
we
will
be
submitting
and
we
are
also
applying
for
grants
and
some
other
projects
as
well,
and
you
know
we're
applying
for
grants
from
iosk
and
other.
You
know
people
in
the
cardinal
ecosystem.
D
So
this
is,
you
know,
kind
of
a
core
pillar
of
our
ecosystem,
and
you
know
we
want
to
be
a
governance
focused
company
and
we
also
want
to
contribute
back
to
government.
So
we
have
some
long-term
plans
for
how
we
want
to.
You
know
start
building
tools
to
contribute
to
the
government
ecosystems
itself
to
kind
of
start
our
wallet
you
know
in
five
fives
for
people
don't
know.
D
That's
our
engineers.
We
wrote
the
message
signing
spec.
That
was,
you
know
us
as
well.
We
have
experience
writing
udoi.
You
know
that
was
us
as
well,
and
we
just
really
suddenly
announced
earlier
today
a
new
project
called
melgomeda,
which
is
our
sidechain
for
cardano,
so
you
can
deploy
slated
style,
smart
contracts
on
the
cardinal
blockchain
and
so
we're
in
a
really
good
position
to
develop
a
wallet
that
only
implements
all
this
technology
we've
developed
so
far,
but
also
be
a
really
competitive
like
this
with
as
well.
D
No,
will
you
be
able
to
use
please
smart
contracts,
but
also
you'll
be
able
to
call
fully
style
smart
contracts
as
well,
and
this
will
be
a
unique
offering
to
our
wallet.
So
I'm
really
happy
with
with
the
direction
our
company's
going
I'll
see
we're
building
so
many
things
in
parallel.
So
our
start
companies
start
in
april
we're
now
up
to
20
employees
and
we
have
over
10
open
positions
right
now.
D
B
B
All
right
so
moving
on
to
the
next
next
part
of
the
presentation.
So
let's
talk
about
the
catalyst
coordinator,
so
we
we
launched,
you
know
our
goal
and
I'm
sure
we're
gonna
accomplish
this
over
the
next
quarter
is
is
to
have
a
a
really
great
public
dashboard,
where
everybody
in
the
community
has
basically
a
very
transparent,
easy
to
read
a
window.
Okay
into
everything,
that's
happening
in
the
funded
proposals.
You
know
we're
growing
in
exponential
pace
and
fund
five.
B
We
funded
the,
I
believe
around
150
proposals,
0.6
no
reason
to
to
say
that
it
will
be
like
it
could
be
something
like
300,
I
think
easy.
So
we
need
to
start
to
have
more
like
data
analytics
and
dashboards
and
interfaces
to
do
that.
So
we're
upgrading-
and
this
is
the
first-
this
is
introducing
the
first
step,
so
everybody
can
access
this
link
and
let
me
give
you
a
quick
preview,
how
it
looks
like
okay,
so
and
the
very
first
thing
where
we're
monitoring
is
just
the
reporting
of
proposals.
B
Basically
every
funded
proposal.
Every
two
weeks
we
ask
them
to
submit
a
report
about
their
progress,
the
key
kpis
so
so
key.
You
know
like
how
they
are
actually
solving
the
challenge,
with
like
basically
observable
outcomes
that
they
report
back
and
this
table
here
basically
tracks
whether
they
submitted
the
report
or
not,
and
so
everything
in
green
means
support
report
submitted.
B
If
there's
like
a
n
a
it
means
that
for
some
justified
reason
it
wasn't
submitted.
So,
for
example,
you
can
see
in
week
28
like
the
catalyst
system
had
had
a
issue
and
and
nobody
submitted.
So
everybody
got
this
like
that
kind
of
signal,
and
when
you
see
a
red,
it
means
that
people
did
not
submit
a
report.
Okay,
so
everybody
can
see
who's,
communicating
and
who's
not,
and
you
can
already
see
you
know
so
so
this
is
fun
too.
You
can
look
at
funds3
the
big
picture.
B
B
So
that's
that's
really,
that's
really
great,
because,
because
with
decentralized
funding,
it
was
actually
a
big
question.
You
know:
are
people
gonna
just
like
disappear
with
funds,
or
are
they
gonna
be
reporting
and
transparent
and
keeping
track?
So
I'm
really
happy
to
see
that
so
far
so
good,
and
that
and
and
under
this
I
want
to-
I
want
to
thank
fun-
six
proposers
we
still
have
about.
I
believe
something
like
12
hours
before
we
we
finish
the
deadline
and
but
we
all
almost
got
to
500
active
proposals.
B
B
Apologies
for
everybody
and
thanks
for
those
who
brought
this
to
our
attention
and
on
another
note
you
know
when
you
look
at
it,
you
can
also
see
there's
a
few
challenges
that
are
a
bit.
You
know
not
not
so
super
competitive
like
the
cardano
emerging
threat,
alarm
and
define
microlending
for
africa,
a
disaster
when
all
it's
at
stake.
B
So
you
know
I
really
want
to
call
everybody.
You
know
we
have
a
few
more
hours
and
this
is
a
so
if
you
think
you
can
actually
make
a
meaningful
contribution
for
any
of
these.
These
challenges
go
ahead
and
submit.
This
is
a
great
opportunity
for
you
to
get
to
to
get
your
leg
into
the
system
and
start
your
start.
Your
journey.
B
Another
thing
we
noticed
we
looked
this
morning
at
under
challenge
setting
proposals.
As
you
know,
this
fund
is
unique
in
that,
instead
of
all
fans
before,
like
most
most,
challenges
were
actually
were
determined
top
down
by
I
o,
and
you
know,
and
basically
like
we
ran
with
it.
It
was
kind
of
like
a
reference
implementation
and
this
time,
there's
like
the
big
reset
is
happening.
B
Basically,
challenges
are
not
just
like
going
to
move
from
fan
six
to
fan,
seven
automatically
like
like
he
did
like
they
did
in
previous
times,
and
also
the
community
is
deciding
which
challenges
are
in
so
having
like
diverse
and
high
quality
challenge.
Setting
proposals
is
really
critical
to
to
the
success
of
fund
7..
B
B
You
can
see
you
can
see
the
list
here
and
those
in
bold
were
actually
proposals
that
were
made
by
the
community
okay,
so
we
we
took
the
initiatives
and
and
are
basically
going
to
resubmit
them.
What
we
want
to,
what
we
want
to
emphasize
is
that
we're
not
trying
to
steal
anybody's
challenge
or
something
like
that.
All
we
want
to
do
is
to
assure
the
continuity
of
the
challenges
so
that,
basically,
you
know
proposals
that
winning
in
fund
six
at
the
atala
prism.
B
You
can
click
on
the
form
and
you
can
and
you
can
apply,
to
join
and
to
be
a
member
of
the
challenge
team
and
there's
it's
basically
a
few
questions.
We
ask
you
there
mostly
about
what
kind
of
value
you
can
bring
to
the
table
and
basically,
if
you're,
if
you're
selected,
you're
going
to
be
the
owner
of
the
challenge,
you're
going
to
be
eligible
for
the
challenge.
Team
rewards.
Okay,
so
that's
like
25
100
in
ada
per
team,
and
it's
also
an
incredible
way
to
really
you
know.
B
Imagine
you're,
like
part
of
the
challenge
team
for
developer,
ecosystem,
okay
and
you
actually
tracking
and
leading
and
inspiring
and
defining
like
the
future
of
the
ecosystem.
You
know
it's
like
it's
like
a
huge
opportunity
right
here
to
have
a
lot
of
influence
over
the
future
of
cardano,
and
I
hope
many
of
you
take
this
opportunity.
B
So
not
only
that,
but
next
week
we
will.
We
will
have
a
a
workshop.
It
might
be.
We
haven't
determined
exactly
the
exact
time
yet,
but
everybody
who's
registered
as
a
proposer
in
the
challenge
setting,
will
receive
an
invite
and
we
will
all
work
together
as
a
group
to
to
basically
learn
best
practices
about
how
to
write
good
good,
engaging
challenges,
receive
support,
help
each
other
so
expect
an
email,
an
invitation,
and
I
hope
you
will
join
all
right
so
now
we're
moving
into
the
innovation
phase.
B
So
it's
kind
of
quiet
week
and
just
take
take
all
that
feedback
in
and
now
this
this
refinement
stage
it
has.
It
has
one
purpose:
okay,
it's
to
evolve
proposals
to
better
address
the
challenge,
and
this
is
not
a
dance
just
that
just
the
proposers
are
doing.
It's
it's
everybody:
all
of
us:
community
advisors,
spos,
er,
er,
toolmakers,
champions
of
the
community,
lurkers
everybody.
B
B
It's
a
little
checklist
okay,
so
this
checklist
came
from
basically
our
experience
in
the
past
year
running
catalyst,
and
we
noticed
that
there's
proposals
that
are
more
successful
than
others,
and
so
we
wanted
to
provide
people
with
a
few
tips
about
some
stuff
that
should
be
included
in
proposals
and
that's
really
important
information.
Okay,
especially
for
the
reviewers,
the
community
advisors
that
come
and
look
at
it.
B
Okay,
so
in
your
in
your
in
your
submission
form,
you
will
see
the
ability
to
look
at
the
self-assessment
checklist
and
there's
gonna
be
a
few
items
there
that
you
can.
You
can
track
and
see
if
your
proposal
contains
them
and
it's
not
a
mandatory
thing,
you
don't
have
to
sub.
You
know
check
all
the
items
to
be
eligible.
It's
more
like
a
guideline,
it's
a
tool
to
help
you
and
I
really
hope,
you'll
take
advantage
of
it.
B
So
examples
of
some
of
the
items
in
the
checklist.
So
you
know
there's
an
explanation:
how
my
proposal
meets
the
challenge
objectives
and
you
know
making
sure
that
you
didn't
submit
a
similar
proposal
in
other
categories
challenges
in
parallel.
So
you
know
you
need
to
pick
a
challenge
and
not
like
submit
to
multiple
ones,
the
same
proposal
that
you
have
an
enough
budget
to
to
execute
what
you
see
on
the
proposal,
etc,
etc.
B
B
B
Maybe
you
can
just
advise
them
make
you
know
the
it's
up
to
you,
but
it's
a
big
part
of
the
process.
These
are
these
proposals
are
not
static.
It's
the
whole
idea
that
it's
a
draft
and
we
evolve
them
to
evolve
them
together,
not
just
the
content,
but
also
the
team
members
and
and
the
skills
and
capacities
the
team
is
bringing
to
the
table
when
they
try
to
implement
so
use
this
as
an
opportunity
this
week
to
really
review
proposals
and
ask
yourself:
should
I
join?
B
Maybe
we
should
join
forces,
you
know,
maybe
I
can
help
them
in
some
way
and
second
thing
is
to
give
constructive
actionable
feedback.
Okay,
proposers
really
really
need
that,
and
this
is
the
critical
time
you
know
we
just
have
this
week
for
them
to
for
them
to
be
able
to
refine
it
and
and
learn
from
you.
B
You
know
if,
if
your
perspective
and
how
things
can
can
improve
and
they're
really
looking
forward
to
it,
okay,
so
this
is
like
a
big
deal,
so
we're
going
to
give
you
a
few,
a
few
tips
how
to
achieve
these
two
things.
So,
first
of
all,
proposers.
Okay,
so
you
can
add
tags
to
your
proposal
if
you're
looking
for
specific
people-
okay,
so
you
can
add
a
tag
in
any
scale
like
sick
accounting.
B
A
second
tool
is
in
the
in,
in
the
community
discord
channel
the
catalyst
discord
channel,
there's
a
whole
challenge
of
pitching
to
devs,
so
whether
you're,
a
dev
looking
for
a
project
to
participate
in
or
you're
someone
looking
for
devs
join
the
discord
channel
and
and
pitch
it
good
luck
and
also
another
thing.
I'm
gonna,
I'm
gonna
leave
the
in
the
after
town
hall,
a
room
called
the
proposer
diving
lessons
where
basically,
I'm
inviting
everybody
who
is
starting
their
journey
or
even
if
they
don't
have
to
start
a
journey.
B
Even
if
they're
they're,
just
submitting
to
fund
six
and
they're
already
been
been
around
to
share
a
bit
about
what
they
want
to
get
as
a
proposer
and
things
that
are
blocking
them.
Okay,
and
we
will
work
together
in
the
in
that
room
to
help
you
out
and
offer
you
advice
and
guidance
and
maybe
form
some
connections.
B
Another
tip
is
to
merge
efforts
when
sensible,
okay,
so
it
is
often
it
is
often
that
that
great
minds,
think
alike,
and
you
actually
find
that
the
several
teams
that
are
heading
in
their
in
this
in
a
similar
direction
and,
unlike
you
know,
competitive
zero-sum
games-
that
we
were
brought
up
in
catalyst,
is
a
fully
collaborative
environment
and
we
actually
want
people
to
join
forces.
Work
together,
see
where
see
where.
Maybe,
instead
of
like
five
different
teams
doing
the
same
thing,
they
can
form
one.
B
It
could
be
also
that
there's
like
a
mergers,
happen
and,
and
they
did
happen,
and
we
know
that
they
little
a
lot
of
success-
usually
merge
proposals
win
big
in
in
funding,
so
take
that
into
account
and
like
if
you
want
to
contact
anyone,
you
know
whether
you
want
to
join
their
team
or
you
want
to
merge
with
them
or
you
want
to
send
them
some
feedback
here.
Privately.
Okay,
the
name
of
the
of
the
proposals
are
right.
There
united
scale
just
click
it
and
you
can
message
them.
B
B
And
lastly,
I
want
to
talk
about
giving
feedback.
This
is
really
important.
It's
one
of
the
easiest
thing
to
do.
You
know
you
just
need
a
few
minutes
of
your
time
and
attention
and
it
can
make
pivotal
changes
right
to
the
proposal.
Trajectory
like
people
need
to
hear
from
you
and
and
learn.
This
is
also
everybody
is
thinking
about
becoming
a
ca.
B
It's
a
good
practice.
It
can
help
you
learn
if
you,
if
you
want
to
you,
know,
take
take
the
deeper
dive
into
ca
or
not,
and-
and
it's
also
a
great
way
to
familiarize
yourself
with
the
ecosystem
and
what's
going
on
and
get
a
bit
more
in
the
weeds,
it's
it's
really.
You
can
really
gain
a
lot
by
giving
feedback
like
for
yourself,
not
just
not
just
for
the
not
just
of
the
proposer
or
for
the
mission
and.
B
So
the
best
way
to
when
you
want
to
give
a
feedback
to
a
proposal.
The
best
way
to
do
this
is
to
ask
yourself,
as
I'm
reading
this
proposal,
what
needs
to
happen
and
that
this
proposal
will
will
receive
five
stars
in
these
three
criteria.
Okay,
and-
and
these
are
the
three
criteria,
one
clarity,
so
what
information
needs
to
be
added
for
this
proposal
to
be
accurately
reviewed?
B
Okay,
so
where
are
gaps?
Second,
one
is
impact.
So
looking
at
the
challenge
and
the
objectives,
for
example
in
the
the
in
the
developer
ecosystem,
this
is
like
an
old
challenge
for
fun
too,
but
in
in
the
fanta.
This
phantom
challenge
is
like:
how
can
we
encourage
developers
and
entrepreneurs
to
build
apps
and
businesses
on
top
of
cardano
like
in
this?
B
Is
there
ways
that
the
proposal
can
modify
itself
to
better
address
that
challenge
and,
and
then
the
third
one
is,
is
feasibility,
so
how?
How
can
the
proposer
communicate
or
maybe
even
just
bring
more
or
maybe
make
changes
in
the
scope
or
the
resourcing
of
the
proposal
in
order
to
increase
the
chances
of
success?
B
To
sum
it
up,
you
know,
you
see
a
proposal,
you
look
at
the
challenge
and
you
and
you
look
at
the
three
criteria
and
you
try
to
lift
it
up.
Okay
and-
and
it's
really
important-
that
we're
trying
to
lift
everybody
up
in
race
quality
and
help
people
grow
and
learn
and
evolve.
And
you
know
not,
everybody
can
win
funding
every
round,
but
as
we
as
as
we
learned
from
from
ashish,
you
know.
Sometimes
the
third
time
is
the
the
time.
Okay.
So
you
need
to
do.
B
B
You
have
no
idea
how
meaningful
it
is
for
the
proposers
that
sit
on
the
other
other
end
of
this
of
the
feedback
and
receive
it,
and-
and
they
know
that
you
know
they're
not
just
holding
this
proposal
by
themselves
that
other
people
who
care
and
help
them
and
support
them.
So
I
really,
I
really
hope
you
will.
You
will
show
up
in
this
fund
even
more
than
you
showed
up
before,
although
before
you
also
showed
up
in
an
amazing
way,.
B
A
B
B
Thanks
victor,
I
think
there's
there's
an
apply
here.
I
don't
know
if
it's
it's
a
link
yeah,
it
is
a
link
oops,
I
open
it
even,
but
so
you
can
apply
directly
here
and
submit
your
applications.
You
know
we
would
love
to
trial
a
few
people.
I
think
next
next
fund,
what
we
try
to
do
that.
That's
what
we're
discussing
you
know.
B
We're
gonna,
create
a
proposal
for
the
community
to
to
actually
provide
some
funding
for
the
circle,
so
we
can
have
more,
just
become
more
efficient
and
deliver
more
and
part
of
it
would
be
would
be
paying
for
a
facilitator
right
because
it's
a
job.
It's
you
need
dedication
and
commitment
to
do
this.
So
it's
not
a
volunteer
thing,
but
temporarily
now
in
our
proto
in
our
first
iteration
of
the
circle,
we
we
do
need
a
volunteer.
B
So
it's
like,
I
think
it's
a
good
chance
for
someone
who
wants
to
have
be
be
really
influential.
I
think
the
situation
is
like
probably
one
of
the
most
influential
things
a
person
can
do
so
I
really
I
you
know
so
initially,
volunteering
later
on
again
depends
if
the
community
agrees
with
this
with
our
proposal,
but
if
they
will
agree
there
will
be
a.
B
B
Okay,
so
so
just
give
you
an
example,
the
number
one
thing
that
people
gave
us
as
feedback
in
front
three
was
that
there
was
no
vote,
a
voting
history
in
the
voting
app
once
we're
gonna
launch
fund
six.
You
will
see
in
the
voting
app
it's
going
to
have
voting
history
in
it,
okay
and
and
some
they're
actually
going
to
be
a
few
exciting
features,
but
but
but
once
we
got
that
feedback,
that
was,
that
became
our
first
priority.
B
Okay
and-
and
we
built
it
and
and
now
because
of
because
of
the
work
people
did
in
front
three
in
fund
six,
they
will
have
voting
history,
and
so
so
that
so
this
kind
of
stuff
is
our
bread
and
butter.
So
do
give
us
your
feedback,
next
town
hall
and
next
week,
regular
time
and
the
regular
link,
here's
the
registration
link,
use
it
put
it
in
put
it
in
your
calendar,
and
you
know
you
know
what
to
do.
B
B
B
B
If
you
are
this
white
person
or
you
know
someone
who
thinks
it
fits
the
bill
with
with
love
with
love,
if
you
you
will
apply,
this
is
this
is
the
time
for
this
role
and,
of
course,
all
the
other
roles
are
also
extremely
important.
I
just
wanted
to
focus
on
this
this
one
particular
one,
because
I
think
it's
extra
important,
all
right
so
general
links
so
for
all
of
you,
a
bunch
of
really
cool
resources
to
get
deeper
in
and
the
announcements
the
mailing
list.
B
This
is
just
the
essential
information
to
keep
track
of.
What's
going
on
past
town
halls,
the
id
scale,
the
main
telegram
group
there's
also
all
these
sub
sub
channels.
Like
the
catalyst
discord,
I
can't
oh
yeah,
we
have
the
catalyst
swarm
and
sessions,
so
these
are
really
great
resources
for
someone
who
really
want
to
get
take
a
deep
dive,
and
you
know
talk
about
not
just
composers
themselves,
but
also
like
the
process
and
like
like
governance
in
even
a
higher
level
of
obstruction.
B
We
also
have
a
group
for
finding
bugs
and
testing.
We
have
at
a
dashboard,
it's
full
of
useful
information
so
like.
If
you
want
to
look
at
previous
funded
proposals
and
see
any
trends,
you
know
like
how
much
funding
people
received
or
asked
for
and
all
sorts
of
that
kind
of
insights
and
the
dashboard
is
your
friend
and
yeah,
and
there's
also
like
a
cool
mapping
of
all
the
fun
funded
proposals
at
the
glance.
So
you
know
if
you
want
to
see
that
you're
not
doing
something
that
someone
is
already
doing.
E
So
first
up,
there's
going
to
be
an
event
by
wada,
so
the
west
african
decentralized
alliance,
the
catalyst
conference
2021
it's
going
to
be
this
week,
the
28th
and
29th
from
2pm
to
6pm,
and
it's
about
blockchain
and
cardano
in
africa,
and
it's
about
get
funding
and
resources
for
your
software
ideas.
So
there
will
be
ada
prices
for
attendance
to
be
one
really
really
cool,
so
use
the
link
in
the
slides
and
register
now
and
because
this
event
is
going
to
be
held
on
on
saturday.
E
So
but
let's
start
with
the
after
town
hall,
as
I
said
by
catalyst
swamp
here,
you
can
see
also
all
the
links
if
you're
interested
in
swarm
sessions
as
well.
But
what
is
the
after
town
hall
about
it's
about
now,
connecting
with
other
catalyst,
community
members,
it's
about
participating,
having
meaningful
conversations
and
collaborations,
and
it's
about
catalyzing,
new
ideas
and
improving
these
processes
together.
E
A
A
B
Oh
yes,
I
haven't.
I
haven't
spoken
in
a
long
time,
so
two
minutes
everybody
is
a
proposer
and
wants
to.
He
feels
like
he
wants
to
take
a
deeper
dive.
Okay,
there's
something
blocking
him
or
or
or
some
hesitation
or
some
doubt
or
something
like
this-
we're
gonna
dive
together.
So
each
participant
gets
two
minutes
to
to
talk
a
bit
about
it
and
receive
help
from
others
in
the
room.
A
A
Yeah
hello,
so
the
cafe
is
our
give
us
a
room
to
to
hang
out
with
spanish
speakers
and
talk
about
catalyst.
But
today
we
are
gonna,
have
a
very
different
and
special,
really
special
session
by
showing
what
the
game
changer
wallet
that
our
fellow
adriano
has
built
is
from
the
hispanic
community.
So
I
will
be
covering
that
on
the
salad
cafe
in
spanish
and
he
will
have
his
own
breakup
room
to
to
present
the
wallet
to
the
english
speaking
community.
E
A
E
A
Yes
correct
today
we
are
going
to
do
it
a
bit
differently,
not
going
directly
into
workshop
and
create
a
new
proposal,
but
science,
the
the
proposals
are
now
submitted
and
we
want
to
to
like
entire
proposal.
So
in
this
workshop,
I'm
going
through
entire
process
taking
an
one
example
of
a
proposal
and
briefly
introduced
to
all
the
the
caps
pb
you
might
want
to
have
in
the
proposal
itself.
E
A
It's
the
rapid
funding
mechanism
challenge
team,
which
is
supported
by
the
catalyst
circle
and
last
week
we
we
announced
the
recruitment
and
we
had
a
bunch
of
nice
people
signing
up
and
today
we're
gonna,
meet
them
and
set
up
a
team.
So
those
who
signed
up
and
in
the
room
that's
the
room
where
we
will
meet.
E
A
Thanks
for
this
amazing
opportunity,
it's
incredible
so,
yes,
this
is,
for
everybody,
all
the
builders,
all
the
entrepreneurs
please
pass
by
to
salah
cafe
or
game
changer
wallet
room,
because
this
wallet
is
for
you.
So
let
let
us
all
take
a
bit
with
dive
into
it
and
and
check
what
it
can
do
for
you.
A
E
Really,
really
cool
and
last
but
not
least,
we
have
open
rooms
as
well.
So
if
you
have
a
topic
that
is
really
burning
and
you
really
want
to
talk
about
it
and
have
other
people,
then
you
can
just
go
into
these
rooms
and
continue
the
discussion
there,
and
so
now
is
the
time.
Oh,
I
see
a
hand
that
is
being
written,
phil.
A
E
A
E
A
E
Rules
there
will
pop
up
a
list
where
you
can
just
select
the
different
rooms
you
want
to
go
to
there.
You
can
just
click
join
room
and
then
you
will
be
directly
transferred
to
that
room.
If
you
got
a
question
or
don't
find
the
option,
you
can
just
afterwards
write
us
or
just
raise
your
hand,
and
then
we
will
navigate
you
to
that
room
and
there
will
be
posted
a
link
with
a
my
report
into
the
chat
that
is
being
used
by
some
of
the
breakout
rooms
and
all
the
hosts
will
share
their
screen.