►
From YouTube: Электронные повестки - практика. Пожизненное за госизмену. Дискуссия о смертной казни. Статус S06E34
Description
🇮🇱 Помощь в получении израильского гражданства: https://clck.ru/34B3xm
https://t.me/nimrod_israel
👩🎓Онлайн-курс Стань дизайнером презентаций от Bonnie&Slide ➡️https://bit.ly/3KNg6cC
🔥Получи скидку 40% по промокоду СВОБОДА и зарабатывай 200К+ на удалёнке
НАСТОЯЩИЙ МАТЕРИАЛ (ИНФОРМАЦИЯ) ПРОИЗВЕДЕН, РАСПРОСТРАНЕН И (ИЛИ) НАПРАВЛЕН ИНОСТРАННЫМ АГЕНТОМ ШУЛЬМАН ЕКАТЕРИНОЙ МИХАЙЛОВНОЙ, ЛИБО КАСАЕТСЯ ДЕЯТЕЛЬНОСТИ ИНОСТРАННОГО АГЕНТА ШУЛЬМАН ЕКАТЕРИНЫ МИХАЙЛОВНЫ
Тайм-коды:
0:00 – Интро
1:02 – Не новости, но события
2:00 – Электронные повестки
9:30 – Паника вокруг электронных повестках. Цифровизация и Госуслуги.
18:26 – О мобилизации
23:40 – Реестр военнообязанных
24:52 – Пожизненное за госизмену
27:50 – 25 лет заключения для Владимира Кара-Мурзы
30:41 – О смертной казни
34:12 – Поправки в закон о референдуме
36:12 – Возвращение "Гаранта" в публичное поле
37:49 – Никаких праздников. 1/9 мая и бессмертный полк
42:28 – Дело ростовских судей
50:00 – Вопросы от слушателей: В 2024 году в России может появиться своя Тихановская?
56:06 – Вопросы от слушателей: Как в идеале должны строиться отношения между государством и научном сообществом?
58:09 – Вопросы от слушателей: В Финляндии существует обязательный призыв для мужчин. Не явная ли это демонстрация нормализации неравенства даже на официальном гос. уровне?
1:00:07 – Хорошая новость
Мы снимаем этот выпуск в студии канала Bild: https://youtube.com/channel/UCy1xqjMJExef6EtEXfAULcg
Для сотрудничества - respublicanec77@gmail.com
Подписывайтесь на канал: https://youtube.com/channel/UCL1rJ0ROIw9V1qFeIN0ZTZQ
Другие соцсети Екатерины Шульман:
Telegram: https://t.me/eschulmann
Twitter: https://twitter.com/eschulmann
D
For
questions,
of
course,,
we
had
to
sacrifice
the
rest
of
the
columns,.
Ask
forgiveness
from
dear
listeners
that
for
the
second
week
in
a
row,
We
are
in
this.
We
are
going
out
in
a
somewhat
extraordinary
format,,
but
something
is
rustling
in
our
kingdom
of
Denmark
and
we
are
trying
to
track
this
rustle,.
It
seems
important
to
us
to
talk
about.
D
D
A
week,
the
special
operation
achieved
its
result,
too,.
Everything
happened
extremely
quickly.
So,
the
very
next
day,
on
April
12,.
It
was
on
Wednesday
that
the
law
was
approved
by
the
Federation
Council
sent
by
the
president,.
The
president
signed
it
14,
2
and
14
step
was
published,
and,
accordingly,
came
into
effect.
D
He
is
actually
the
president,.
This
is
a
separate
issue,
today,
and,
in
my
opinion,
even
yesterday,
there
was
a
lot
of
talk
on
this
topic
when
his
Easter
comes
according
to
which
calendar
exactly
where
he
will
start
located
where
he
is
present
at
the
service
where,
on
the
contrary,.
Some
troops
visit
It
is
rather
mysterious
We.
We
will
not
delve
into
this
matter,.
We
are
concerned
about
clearer
things,,
namely
the
law-making
process,
here,.
As
you
understand,.
There
is
no
place
for
ambiguity,
because,,
as
is
known
in
the
joke
about
the
anthem,
And.
D
You
will
drink
the
sixth
again,
you
will
have
to
stand
up
and
ignorance
of
the
laws
does
not
exempt
from
responsibility.
So
signed,
published,
entered
into
action,
Since
then,.
We
have
managed
to
read
it
and
you
once
again
and
form
some
opinion
about
it,.
So
last
time
we
talked
about
its
legislative
fate,,
about
its
legal
content
and
about
the
political
framework
within
which
the
law
arose.
Today,,
we
will
try
to
talk.
If
we
talk
after
all,
about
its
application,,
which
since
then
we
have
added.
In
addition
to
the
fact
that,
again,
we
read
it,.
D
Other
people
read
it
and
tried
to
understand
the
meaning
of
what
is
happening.
In
general,.
A
large
number
of
explanations
came
from
officials
here,,
some
are
interesting.,
departmental
disagreement
said
in
these
explanations.
So.
We
have
speaker
number
one,
so
to
speak,.
This
is
the
deputy
committee
on
defense;.
He
says
different
things,
every
day,,
but
equally
persistently
expressive
and
loud,.
So
we
also
listen
to
him
and
try
to
merge
him
both
with
himself
three
days
ago
and
with
others.
Officials
sometimes.
D
This
is
the
same
deputy
who,
on
the
31st,
said
that
the
distribution
of
electronic
bandages
is
impossible,
and,
accordingly,
on
the
11th.
He
already
led
the
adoption
of
these
same
electronic
trips
in
the
conduct
of
their
legislation
in
the
second
and
third
readings,.
There
is
one
more
public
commentator
we
have
is
the
Minister
of
Digital
Development
of
Informatization
Maksut
Shadayev.
He
explains
this
matter
not
about
and
where
A
on
a
rather
unusual
site,
Yes,,
you
don’t
know:
For
example,
I
plunged
there,
it’s
interesting,.
D
It
means
there
is
a
Telegram
chat
for
the
it
sphere
for
IT
specialists
for
workers
in
this
industry,
and
the
minister
himself
appears
there
and
explains
directly
in
the
chat
I
signed
up
on
telegram,
there.
I,
hope,
I
won’t
cover
him
up
after
that,,
but
because
it’s
really
interesting,
there,
and
the
other
day
he
made
such
a
serial
statement,.
D
That
is,
right
here
is
a
series
of
posts
Well,
or
how
in
a
chat
it’s,
not
just
such
remarks,
in
which
he
says
the
following
asks
himself
a
question:
he
answers
himself
like
a
famakin
is
whether
the
amendments
to
the
legislation
on
conscription
are
connected
with
plans
to
resume
mobilization.
The
first
question,
but
in
general
the
most
urgent
that
the
minister
tells
us,
the
minister
says
that
there
is
nothing
of
the
kind
and
even,
on
the
contrary,
he
is
pursuing
the
line
that
he
had
to.
D
We
hear
in
the
state
media,,
namely
that
this
is
all
the
successful
adoption
is
a
reaction
to
the
shortcomings
identified
during
the
mobilization
in
the
fall,
in
the
fall.
There
was
a
mess,.
They
sent
subpoenas
to
anyone
without
hitting
it,
as
it
turned
out,.
It
suddenly
turned
out
that
there
was
a
single
accounting
base,
here
we
are
this
single
base
and
and
we
create,,
which
means
that
it’s
still
interesting,
that
it.
D
Was
and
that
those
people
who
are
not
subject
to
either
conscription
or
mobilization
and,
in
general,
would
not
be
subjected
to
anything
of
this,,
which
is
interesting,.
He
says
about
the
register
because
he
cannot
be
responsible
for
the
military
unit,
so
to
speak,,
but
he
can
for
just
informational,.
He
says
the
development
of
the
registry,.
This
is
the
registry
of
conscripts
involved
in
min
numbers
on
the
instructions
of
the
Ministry
of
Defense,.
D
The
exact
timing
of
the
launch
of
the
registry,
I
quote,
will
be
determined
after
the
adoption
of
the
law,,
but
most
likely
it
will
not
be
possible
to
launch
it
in
full
until
the
start
of
the
next
autumn.
Conscription
for
military
service
Why
am
I.
I
draw
your
attention
to
these
details,
firstly,.
Such
a
characteristic
ambiguity
is
that
some
state
speakers
say
that
the
spring
draft
will
already
be
held.
According
to
the
new
procedure,
that
is,
the
sent
electronic
subpoenas
are
considered,
delivered.
And,
accordingly,
sanctions
come
If.
D
D
Was
to
occur
before
the
end
of
the
twenty-second
year,,
but
a
unified
electronic
register
of
all
those
liable
for
military
service
should
appear
by
April
1,,
the
twenty-fourth
year,
that
is,
the
next
autumn
conscription
And.
This
will
be
an
autumn
conscription
for
23,
years,
it’s,
not
how
to
get
out.
The
deadline
does
not
fall,
that
is,
it’s
not
very
clear
how
they
are
among
themselves.
Er
agree.
B
C
We
are
ready
to
argue
that
there
is
no
person
among
you
who
would
not
recognize
the
intro
to
the
great
song
that
the
brilliant
sang,
Louis
Armstrong
Surprisingly,.
Its
plot
is
understandable
without
translation;
it
is
the
Old
Testament
stories
of
the
Exodus
of
the
Jews
from
Egypt,,
led
by
Moses.
The
prophet,
set
to
music.
C
This
song,
according
to
legend,,
was
created
by
the
Baptists,,
but
it
was
especially
popular
among
the
black
population
of
the
southern
states,
who
were
in
a
slave
position,
in
general,
this
such
Uncle
Tom's
Cabin
only
in
music
and
even
from
the
south
to
the
slave-free
North.
There
was
an
underground
path.
C
There
were
kind
people
who
agreed
to
accompany
runaway
slaves
to
the
line
of
Freedom,
that
is,
to
the
border
with
the
state
where
slavery
was
already
prohibited,
and
it
is
known
for
certain
that
the
lines
from
this
song
are
password
and
recall
that
worked
on
the
same
underground
road,
so
guides
and
Runaways
recognized
each
other.
And
if
you
are
looking
for
a
guide
to
Israel,,
we
recommend
that
you
contact
your
good
friend
from
the
Israeli
Nimrot
Agency
Our
partners
are
ready
to
help.
You
get
rid
of
restrictions
and
obtain
Israeli
citizenship.
C
C
D
Electronic
registers,
electronic
agendas
for
coordination
between
ministries,
So.
We
are
quoting
the
minister
of
our
digitalization
who
claims
that
the
register
will
be,,
but
it
is
never
known
when
what
is
happening
has
nothing
to
do
with
mobilization,
and
users
of
public
services
can,
if
they
mistakenly,
those
documents
will
receive
a
subpoena.
That
testify
in
favor
of
the
fact
that
they
have
the
right
to
a
deferral,,
also
through
public
services,,
and
it
will
also
be
possible
to
apply
to
be
removed
from
military
registration
without
personal
presence
in
general,.
D
A
citizen
personally
is
no
longer
obliged
to
actually
appear
anywhere
Comfort
and
what
is
the
name
of
the
state
providing
services
in
in
general,?
The
intention
is
understandable,
of
course,,
with
this
panic
with
electronic
agendas
and,
most
importantly,,
with
restrictive
measures
that
immediately
come
upon
their
receipt,
and
our
state
somewhat
stepped,
with
a
heavy
boot
on
this
fragile
dream
of
a
comfortable
public
service
and
on
the
little
that
caused
citizens
to
trust
in
in
the
entire
register
and
state
activity,.
We
have
institutional
trust
in
general,
low
in
Russia,,
constantly
low,
chronic
state
institution,.
D
Of
course,
a
heavy
blow,,
as
we
said
some
time,
ago,
the
right
turned
out
to
be
those
people
who
said
that
the
TIN
is
the
demonic
number
666,
that
it
is
the
seal
of
the
Antichrist
that
you
don’t
need
to
get
passports
at
all,,
don’t
open
the
door
in
the
mailbox,
don’t
climb
in
and
somehow,
in
general,
don’t
communicate
with
outside
world
and
being
Agafya
Lykova
it’s
clear
that
it’s
difficult
for
a
modern
city
dweller
to
be
Agafya
Lykova,.
But
now
you
remember
many
arguments.
B
D
D
Why
the
citizens
of
the
free
world
are
so
protective
of
their
data
and
are
so
distrustful
of,
for
example,
cameras
in
public
places,,
let's
say
in
London:
it
is
better
to
Continental.
Europe
is
very
good
here,,
so
you
can’t
just
hang
a
camera
somewhere
so
that
it
shoots
all
sorts
of
passers-by
or
even
potential
intruders.
So.
What
else
has
become
more
or
less
clear
to
us?
This
week?.
D
D
It
is
not
better
for
you
to
recommend
urgently
deleting
public
services
to
know
what
is
happening
than
not
to
know
Moreover,.
The
new
legislation
relieved
you
of
any
responsibility
for
the
fact
that
you
carelessly
opened
the
letter,.
You
understand
this
is
not
a
phishing
message
that
you
opened
Clicked
on
the
link
and
the
virus
jumped
to
you,
the
virus
already
jumped
to
you.
When.
You
received
the
passport
of
the
Russian
Federation
Now,
you
can’t,
pronounce
it
from
your
body,
anymore.
D
Therefore,
it’s,
better
to
remain
in
the
know
than
in
the
dark,
it’s
better
to
go
into
your
account,.
You
will
know
that
you
have
been
sent
some
kind
of
rubbish,.
You
can
really
send
some
documents,
proving
you
are
right
through
public
services,
it’s,
better
than
walking
in
military
registration
and
enlistment
office,
because
from
there
you
may
not
return
in
the
same
form,,
but
through
public
services.
D
For
those
citizens,
for
example,
students,
Well,
in
general,
young
people
of
military
age,
who,
for
obvious
reasons,,
do
not
want
to
appear
at
the
military
registration
and
enlistment
office
themselves,.
There
is
an
intermediate
option
to
send
mom
with
documents,
mom
Maybe.
They
won’t
mobilize
So
far.
There
have
been
no
such
cases,
at
least
don’t
go
yourself,
but
enter
into
an
explanation.
In
general,
you
can,
if
it’s,
not
if
it’s,
not
accompanied
by
your
physical
resource,,
but.
B
D
Contact
Well,
it’s
already
good,
that
the
main
thing
is
Take
care
of
yourself
physically.
With
all
the
talk
about
the
Great
Digitalization,,
everything
is
still,,
they
will
send
you
to
fight
as
a
body
and
not
your
digital,
Avatar
Until.
It
has
come
to
this
Although
But.
Maybe
we
are
moving
towards
this,.
It
means
that
it
is
still
useful
to
remember
this
legislation,
for
all
its
revolutionary
nature,
let’s.
Say,
does
not
change
the
order
of
conscription,
that
is,.
What
I
mean
is
not.
D
B
D
We
actually
fix
the
situation
until
and
there
the
term
of
service
has
not
changed
age
changes,
it
changes
differently,
That
is,,
everything
that
is
called
as
it
was
and
remains
in
the
essential
sense,
the
order
of
notification
has
changed
and
there
are
now
restrictions
that
are
imposed
on
you,
If.
You
are
not,
and
of
course,
these
restrictions
are
such
that
they
make
your
citizenship
all
your
life,
almost
impossible,
though
there
is
not
one
item
among
them.
D
D
Sale
for
the
sale
of
disposal
of
her
property,
she
is
driving
a
car
of
registering
cars
for
registration
as
an
individual
entrepreneur
in
general
for
registering
enterprises
and
what
attracted
the
most
attention
is,
the
temporary
restriction,
as
they
call
it.
We
have
everything
to
leave.
Naturally,
for
the
time
being,.
This
concerns
those
who
are
called
up
as
part
of
the
spring
draft,,
but
it
could
potentially
affect
the
mobilized
too.
And.
This
clever
idea,
removes,
of
course,
any
need
to
announce
some
new
waves
of
mobilization.
D
It
went
on
and
on,,
and
the
decree
has
not
been
canceled,
among
other
things..
This
means
that
contractors
who
enter
into
a
contract
for
the
service
cannot
quit,.
This
is
important..
That
is
why,
in
the
same
law,
adopted
by
those
who
entered
into
force,,
there
is
one
more
provision
that
at
first
slipped
low
from
the
readers,
because
everyone
was
busy
agendas
and
restrictions
associated
with
them,,
and
this
law
simplifies
the
procedure
for
signing
a
contract,
in
other
words,.
D
D
Or
higher
serve
at
least
three
months,
by
the
way,.
The
term
was
reduced
at
first,,
but
it
was
six
months,.
Then
they
made
3
months,,
which
means
that
now
all
these
qualification
signs
have
disappeared
from
the
law.
So.
You
are
18
years
old,.
You
are
liable
for
military
service
and
can
do
military.
Service.
You
can
sign
a
contract.
B
D
D
Anywhere
What
kind
of
money-
yes
When,
you
can
earn
money
and
it’s
much
easier.
How
poor
it
seems
to
them,,
then
keep
in
mind.
Dear
listeners,
I
understand
that
among
our
listeners,
Few
people
need
to
be
convinced
that
18
years
old
is
not
worth
signing
a
contract,.
But
so
far
the
decree
on
mobilization
is
unilateral.
Termination
of
the
contract
is
impossible.
If
you
signed
it,
you
can’t,
quit
it’s
a
one-way
ticket.
D
What
is
called
to
all
the
other
delights
of
the
contract.
Service,
they
are
added,
and
this
is
returning
to
the
New
wave
of
mobilization,,
which
is
no
longer
necessary.
What
is
called
declaring,
it
can
go
on
constantly
and
it
can
What
is
called,
intensify,
weaken,
As
necessary,
in
general,,
this
organizational
nervousness
Apparently,,
let's
say,
again,.
We
go
alone
beyond
our
sphere
of
competence,,
apparently
due
to
the
impending
aggravation
of
the
situation
on
the
fronts,.
Otherwise,
it
is
not
very
clear
why
everything
is
like
this.
D
D
B
D
2010
China
is
planning
for
2150,,
which
means
they
have
big
plans,
and
it
is
believed
that
this
is
being
done,
so
to
speak,,
based
on
the
results
of
observations
of
the
Russian
case,,
in
which
the
war
begins
first
and
then,
actually,
someone
will
think
about
who
we
are
going
to
fight.
China
apparently
believes
that
it
is
not
necessary
to
act
in.
B
C
Dad
and
who
built
this
road,
Count,
Petr,
Andreevich,
Klin,
Mikhel
darling,
exactly
This,
is
how
the
epigraph
to
the
famous
Nekrasov
poem
sounds
railroad
that
we
all
learned
at
school,
Meet,
Count,
Petr,
Andreevich,
Klin,
Mikhel,
nothing
about
him,
it’s
impossible
to
say
good
things,.
Everything
that
you
know
is
bad.
Russian
officials
had
all
this
with
Mikhel’s
glue,,
but
as
you
know,,
there
are
periods
in
our
history
when
exactly
such
people
occupy
an
important
state
position,
and
under
Emperor
Nikolai
Pavlovich
Klein
Mikhel
was
such
a
head
of
the
main
construction
projects
of
the
country.
C
Klein
Mikhel
was
in
love
with
his
position
because
he
is
the
inventor
of
this
famous
scheme
of
ours
when
you
give
contracts
to
relatives
and
they
return
50
percent
to
you,
and
so
One
day
at
breakfast,,
Count,
Klin
Mikhel
reads
in
the
newspaper
that
Lord
Wellington
is
the
prime
minister
of
Britain,
who
was
an
opponent
of
the
iron.
Such
roads
allowed
a
signal
for
its
construction,
a
gigantic
amount,
when
he
saw
this
wonderful,
figure,
Pyotr
Andreevich
immediately
realized
that
the
construction
of
a
railway
in
Russia
was
the
work
of
his
whole
life.
C
He
completely
forgot
that
Nikolai
Pavlovich
the
martinet
that
he
adores,
the
husband
of
the
military,
teachings
and
parades,
the
emperor
said
something,,
but
suddenly
Klin
Mikhel
interrupted
him
Your
Majesty
Your
Majesty
Thank
you
for
that.
They
told
me
with
their
appearance
but
also
by
rail.
You
can
quickly
transport
a
soldier,
Nikolai
Pavlovich
thought
about
Klin
Mikhel
realized
that
he
is
fabulously
rich
presentation.
Skills
are
needed
for
absolutely
everyone
and
to
make
beautiful,
slides.
C
C
Online
course
Become
a
presentation
designer
at
the
academy
of
Nikolai
and
Svetlana.
A
company
training
course
takes
4
months,
learn
a
new
profession
and
start
earning
from
200
thousand
rubles
a
month
remotely
from
anywhere
in
the
world
with
Bonnie.
You
immediately
learn
to
develop
a
design
from
scratch
and
receive
feedback
from
professional
after
each
task.
Completed,,
the
Academy
has
already
trained
50,000
students,,
including
employees
of
Sber,
Tinkoff
and
Gazprom..
An
important
point
is
that
Bonen
Slide
is
guaranteed
to
help
graduates
with
their
first
clients.
The
vacancy
for
slide.
C
Designers
is
also
relevant
on
the
international
market,.
According
to
the
App
Ford
service,,
a
presentation
designer
with
knowledge
of
English
earns
on
average
2000
rubles
per
hour,
and
top
specialists
have
a
price
tag
twice
as
high
to
start.
Your
journey
in
slide
design
take
useful
gifts
from
Ekaterina
Mikhailovna
Academy
with
the
promo
code,
freedom.
You
have
a
40
percent
discount
on
the
online
course
Become
a
presentation
designer
learn
to
make
beautiful,
slides
with
a
bonin
slide
and
change
your
life
for
the
better
And.
If
the.
D
At
least
the
register
agenda
that
should
be
somehow
public
Neither
one
nor
the
other
is
there,,
but
the
responsible
departments
promise
us
that
someday
they
will
nevertheless
arise,.
So
while
they
are
not
there
Once
again,
we
repeat
our
recommendation.
The
account
is
not
remove
the
physical
recruiting
office
if
possible,
do
not
go
if
there
is
a
chance
to
enter
into
a
long
bureaucratic
communication
by
mail
enter
into
a
long
bureaucratic
communication
by
mail.
D
Do
not
make
a
decision
from
a
point
of
panic,
but
do
not
force
the
disturbing
information
out
of
your
mind
under
the
pretext
that
today
nothing
seems
to
have
happened.
Yet
they
didn’t,
kill
me,,
it’s,
probably
going
to
carry
me
through,,
so
it
won’t
carry
someone
who
didn’t
bother
with
the
plan,
it’s
okay
to
take
care
of
it
by
all
means,
and
useful
links,.
D
As
always,.
We
give
the
most
useful
link.
Will
the
military
be
hotter
or
not,
according
to
the
rights
of
conscripts,,
the
military
duties
of
everyone
else
And
there
you
need
to
write
e
outside
depending
on
whether
the
military
is
obliged
or
the
relatives
of
the
military
are
obliged
to
ask
their
questions,
to
be
warned
means
armed,.
Then
we
talked
about
during
immobilization,.
We
will
talk
about
other,
no
less
cheerful
continents,,
namely
the
death
penalty
and
life
imprisonment,.
We
have
such
topics
today
that
how
it
is
Where
do
we
start
Maxim
Vladimirovich,
Let’s,.
D
D
D
The
sentence
cannot
exceed
two-thirds
of
the
maximum
term,,
so
if
you
let's
say
20
years
is
the
maximum
term,,
then
2/3
is
13
years
with
a
penny,.
So
yes,,
you
understand
how
wonderful
this
argument
will
sound
at
the
very
beginning
of
the
investigation,,
or
do
you
want
to
leave
for
life,
or
you
can
only
track
13
years
as
far
as
state
treason
is
concerned,,
we
understand
everything
wider
and
wider
and
wider
with
each
new
change
to
the
Criminal.
D
Helping
this
Yes,
it’s
better
not
to
help
this
You
know
how
it
is.
In
a
bad
deed,.
No
help
will
help.
But
that
there
can
be
no
government
transfers,,
because
money
transfers
can
also
be,
as
you
understand,
with
treason,.
This
is
assistance
in
activities
in
the
direction
against
the
security
of
the
Russian
Federation.
D
payment
for
services,
assistance
in
treatment
and
humanitarian
aid.
With
the
latter,
it
is
unclear
that
the
investigator
will
consider
humanitarian
aid
about
aid
directly
to
enemy
troops,.
You
will
find
out
when
this
knowledge
will
no
longer
help
you,,
then
these
forty
huge
new
ones,
so
to
speak,,
which
we
now
award
for
treason,
espionage,
A
in
the
case
of
sofro,
and
quite
recently,,
Vladimir
Kara-Murza,
In
general,.
What
is
called
is
in
line
with
these
legislative
changes.
Regarding
25
years
that
have
struck
the
imagination
both
inside
and
outside
the
country,.
I
can
only
say
one
thing.
Well,.
D
The
obvious
has
already
been
said
to
everyone
here.
A
year
ago,
Vladimir
was
here
not
here,
I
mean
In
this
studio,
but
here
I
mean
in
Berlin,
I
returned
of
my
own
free
will
and
a
day
after
the
verdict
was
passed
on
both
sides
at
the
same
time
immediately
started
talking
about
the
exchange
from
the
Russian
side.
It
looked
a
little
parodic
because
it
happened
through
Margarita
Sumanin,
the
famous
public.
D
She
was
something
like
that
said
that
they
say:
Let’s
go
there,
these
Evan
Yushkovichs,,
and
that
means
another
American
citizen
and
we’ll
have
to
give
it
up,.
We’Ll
get
Julian
Asaja
in
exchange,,
but
it
also
turns
out
a
column
in
the
Wall
Street
Journal,,
which
says
that
Vladimir
Murza
means
he
lived
in.
America
had
I
don’t
know,
citizenship
or
American
of.
D
In
America,
therefore,
it
can
be
what
is
called
a
legitimate
object
for
exchange.
I
am
not
telling
you
this
in
order
to
some
kind
of
illusory
hope,,
so
to
speak,
to
calm
down
a
little
the
heavy
feelings
or
development
of
it
that
has
gripped
us
all,,
but
Evan
Deshkovich
also
appeared
today
in
in
court,
his
preventive
measure
was
extended,
there.
And.
D
It
is
clear
that
there
will
also
be
some
kind
of
expressive
verdict,
and
in
his
case
it
is
obvious
that
this
is
material
for
exchange
in
the
case
of
Karamurza.,
These
are
more
cases
of
political
revenge,,
so
it
is
more
difficult
to
imagine
the
exchange
here,
but
not
impossible.,
The
Russian
Federation
tried
recently
to
exchange
people
Yes,
with
a
boot.
It
turned
out
very
well
from
her
point
of
view,.
Therefore
Why
not
try
to
arrange
this
again,.
D
There
is
a
candidate
there,
I
will
not
delve
into
the
complex
complex
topic
of
the
abundance
of
Russian
agents,
who
are
caught
from
time
to
time,
And
in
different
European
and
European
countries,,
but
Believe
me,
osansha
is
so
for
Twitter.
And.
There
are
people
who
are
much
more
closely
interested
in
the
Russian
Federation
and
whom
she
would
like
to
get
back
much.
B
D
D
Last
time
we
talked
about
a
very,,
very
old
bill,
signed
by
a
group
of
initiators,
most
of
whom
are
no
longer
alive,,
which
was
to
be
clarified
from
consideration
returned
by
the
author,
because
that
the
provision
of
this
draft
law
of
this
legislative
proposal
is
addressed
to
already
outdated
legislative
norms,.
This
draft
law
seemed
to
be
an
exception
in
general
to
the
concept
of
the
death
penalty
from
the
Russian
Criminal
Code
And.
D
D
Has
changed.
Yes,
Deputy
Yarovaya
was
the
initiator,,
but
she
withdrew
her
signature
in
the
fourteenth
year
in
advance,
and
so,.
A
similar
event
happened
the
other
day
and
now
it
seems
to
me
that
this
is
not
only
a
cute
detail
of
m-m
regulatory
procedures
means
he
has
been
in
the
house
since
1999
and
the
draft
law
introduced
by
President
Yeltsin
at
that
time.
On
the
ratification
of
protocol
number
six
The
Convention
for
the
Protection
of
Human
Rights
and
Fundamental
Freedoms
is
a
very
short
bill
to
ratify
protocol
number
six.
D
Regarding
the
abolition
of
the
death
penalty,
signed
in
the
city
of
Strasbourg
on
April
16,,
ninety-seven
years,,
almost
anniversaries,
that
is,
look
what
happened
with
us
and
there
is
a
Convention
on
the
Protection
of
Human
Rights
83
years
old,,
the
Russian
Federation
signed
it
In,
the
ninety-seventh
year,.
This
convention
has
protocol
number
six
that
abolishes
the
death
penalty
in
the
ninety-.
Ninth
year,
President
Yeltsin
makes
the
appropriate
ratification
of
the
State
Duma
and
he
brings
it
in,
you
know,
when
on
August.
B
D
D
So,
some
time
after
that,,
as
you
understand,
to
the
president,,
we
change
the
bill
lies
in
the
Duma,.
Nothing
happens
to
it.
Every
new
Convocation
What
is
called
rediscovers
its
existence
But,
it
does
not
move
it
anywhere.
It
is
interesting
that
the
new
president
almost
immediately
slows
down
the
progress
of
tariffing
And
now,
literally
the
other
day,.
The
Council
of
the
Duma
proposes
to
return
this
very
bill
to
the
initiator,
that
is,.
D
The
only
address
that
dear
colleagues
And
besides
nostalgic,
memories,
I
see
something
bad
in
this
lying.
He
was
lying
to
you.
No
one
touched
him.
If
we
already
had
two
in
a
row,
Yes
one
deer,
Accidentally
shot,
not
a
trend.
We
have
two
deer
removed
from
consideration:
long-
standing
abolitionist
bills.
This
might
look
like
some
kind
of
preparation
for
something
like
that.
Besides,
what
else
worries
me
a
little
though
it
would
seem
somehow
mister
teacher.
I
would
have
your
problems
a
lot
to
worry
about,
but
everyone
worry
about.
D
Some
strange
amendments
to
the
referendum
law
were
introduced
to
the
Duma
groups
of
deputies
of
senators,
headed
by
a
cliché,
that
is,
how
important
people
seem
to
be
talking
about
how
a
special
procedure
for
which
referendums
can
be
held
in
the
so-called
new
territories
realized
a
referendum.
They
have
already
spent
there
since
then,
the
territories
have
changed
beyond
recognition,.
They
have
decreased
territorially,
but
nevertheless,
at
the
same
time,.
D
D
D
Military
means
there
was
some
kind
of
territory
with
clear
borders
with
a
clear
population
that
did
not
run
back
and
forth
here
and
there
everything
is
much
more
vague.
I
am
now
not
new
territories.
I
am
worried
about
the
old
territories.
I
am
worried
about
whether
there
is
any
idea
to
hold
a
constitutional
referendum
or
another,
a
wave
of
constitutional
amendments
or
a
new
Constitution
in
general,.
You
will
become
one
of
our
beauties
from
them
and
now
you
can
already
enter
everything
else
and
the
death
penalty.
D
There,
I
understand
that
I
am
not
acting
in
my
role
now,,
but
these
noises
seem
suspicious
to
me,.
So
I
share
my
suspicions
with
you.
It
means
further,,
but
about
the
emergency
and
regular.
It
means
that
we
have
such
stability
and
such
a
rise
from
our
knees.
That,.
As
we
said
last
year,
repeating
rituals
that
form
institutions,
as
our
listeners,
know,
are
being
canceled
or
at
least
postponed,,
which
means
in
last
year.
You
and
I
didn’t
have
any
presidential
appearances
at
all,
except
for
congratulations
on
the
New
Year
Maybe.
D
It
would
be
better
if
we
didn’t
have
him
this
year.
We
have
a
little
so
to
speak.
The
president
is
trying
to
restore
his
public
presence
here
with
a
message
he
addressed.
Nothing
special
did
not
say
let’s
say
retrospectively
and
a
informs
us
about
Rostelecom
that
on
June
8
there
will
be
a
direct
line
in
Gostiny
Dvor.
Remember
we
have
such
a
procedure.
Direct
line
is
the
answers
to
questions
from
citizens'
complaints.
Distribution
of
puppies
means
Christmas
trees,
but
in
June
it
may
already
be
a
bit
late,
but
nevertheless,
last
year
now
it
will.
B
D
Is
already
going
to
deal
with
Yes,,
we
have
such
a
small
but
such
initiative.
Nonetheless,
and
at
first
there
were
rumors
that
in
Gostiny
Dvor,
somehow
all
the
tenants
were
told
to
get
out,,
but
because
there
would
be
preparation
for
something
for
something
And
in
general.
It
is
temporarily
closed.
But
sources
in
Rostelecom
say
that
And
this
organization
began.
The
organization
began
preparation
for
the
broadcast,.
D
This
is
what
is
called
good
about
what
is
still
happening,,
but
other
things
are
much
more
significant
for
our
citizens
than
the
Direct
Line,
with
the
President
With,
all
due
respect
to
it,.
They
are
canceled
So.
We
have
the
Federation
of
Independent
Trade
Unions,,
which
is
officially
the
organizer
of
the
May
Day
marches,
calls
on
citizens
all
over
the
country
not
to
go
out
to
the
procession
on
May
1,
Why
Because.
It
is
called
so
because
of
the
terrorist
danger,.
The.
D
Thanksgiving
procession,,
they
say,
look
how
everything
is
fine
with
us,,
which
means
there
will
be
no
May
Day
demonstration.
It
is
unlikely
that
anyone
will
shed
tears,,
we
more
or
less
understand
all
this,.
In
fact,,
the
only
people
who,
in
recent
years,
went
somewhere
on
May
Day
were
the
Communists
of
the
Communist
Party
of
the
Russian
Federation
organized
a
procession
and,.
D
D
D
An
interesting
idea
here
again
We
all
suggest
we
suggest
So
yes,.
If
we
are
afraid
to
walk
during
the
day,,
maybe
at
night
you
can
walking,,
maybe
it's
better.
Somehow
it
will
work.
Out.
So,,
who
announces
this
to
us,.
It
doesn't
come
out
regional
authorities
and
they
say
that
we
shouldn't
come
out,
for
example,
representatives
of
law
enforcement
agencies
and
say
that
it's
dangerous.
D
We
remind
you
that
it
was
born
as
a
public
initiative
in
the
city
of
Tomsk,.
Then
it
was
in
the
best
traditions
of
our
postmodern
photograph,,
so
to
speak,
intercepted,
made
quite
official
Well,.
It
seems
like
the
public,
still
bears
responsibility
for
it,
as
such,.
This
is
not
a
state
event,,
so
these
very
public
activists
are
gathering
a
press
conference
in
interfax
and
they
say
that
it’s
not
so
easy
for
us
to
get
out
of
the
vending
machines
of
one
street.
We
urge
all
day
long
to
commemorate
our
heroic
ancestors,
in
particular,
for
example,.
D
Such
an
action
is
proposed
to
replace
the
avatar.
With
a
portrait
of
some
of
our
older
relatives
who
fought,
and
that
is,,
it
does
not
say
directly
What
you
know,,
we
are
afraid,
firstly,.
There
are
sabotage
of
terrorist
attacks,
and
secondly,.
We
are
afraid
that
people
will
come
With
portraits,
for
example,
of
their
not
so
distant
ancestors
And
those
who
have
died
now,.
Maybe
this
may
be,
in
general,
some
dissatisfied
may
gather,.
D
We
do
not
need
this
time
of
national
unity
and
extraordinary
support
for
everything
that
happens,
we
don’t
need
people
on
the
streets,
Let
them
drink
at
home,,
then
there
will
be
no
public
events
on
May
9,.
This
does
not
yet
apply
to
the
entire
Russian
Federation,.
This
concerns
the
Kursk
Belgorod
regions,,
the
most
unfortunate
and,,
as
it
is
customary
to
say,
now,
the
occupied
Crimea,,
which
means,
in
general,,
no
matter
whose
parade
it
is
on
May
9,.
It
will
not
be
there,.
D
This
is
already
explained
by
the
fact
that,,
like
the
fact
that
we
fear
here,
security
motives
are
declared
in
general,
quite
openly.
Enough.
The,
Belgorod,
governor,,
courageously
taking
responsibility
for
this,
is
not
hiding
with
any
what
kind
of
public
figures
or
veterans
union.
How
could
he
say
there
will
be
no
parade
so
as
not
to
provoke
the
enemy
with
a
large
accumulation
of
equipment
of
military
personnel
in
the
center
of
Belgorod
Indeed,?
Why
provoke
the
enemy
with
military
equipment?
D
Let's
not
provoke
him,
not
in
the
center
of
Belgorod
in
any
other
places,
then
the
enemy
No
it
won’t
be,,
but
it’s
okay,.
This
is
how
it
serves.
Reasoning,
let’s
say
in
general.
And
you
and
I
somehow
quoted
the
result
of
sociological
studies,
according
to
which
a
lot
unites.
The
citizens
of
the
Russian
Federation
in
the
sense
that
we
have
very
few
generally
accepted
symbols
or
some
practices
and
phenomena
which
the
majority
equally
approves
or
disapproves
of,.
We
are
such
a
rather
fragmented
political
nation,,
so
to
speak,.
D
It
really
is..
This
is
when
these
practices
crumble,
of
course,
well,,
let's
say,
it
makes
it
clear
to
people
in
the
most
direct
way
that
life
does
not
continue
as
they
are
used
to
seeing
it,.
This
is
the
destruction
of
the
regularity
that
was
in
covid,,
which
in
22
came
already
on
a
new,
so
to
speak,
socio-political
level,.
It
continues,
that
is,
to
pretend
that
everything
is
happening
as
it
was,
it
becomes
more
and
more
difficult,.
D
Then
further
We
still
have
one
story
that
we
wanted
to
talk
about
last
time,,
but
we’ll
talk
about
it
in
this,,
all
the
more
there
was
added
so
to
speak.
Details
this
so-called
the
case
of
the
Rostov
judges.
This
is
no
longer
the
case
of
the
judges,.
This
is
apparently
a
very
large-scale
operation
that
is
taking
place
in
the
city
of
Rostov-on-Don
and
in
the
Rostov
region.
We.
Remember
that
we
are
monitoring
inside
the
elite
repressions.
D
D
In
general,,
this
is
such
a
high-level
event,
that
is,,
not
every
operative,,
not
every
investigator
can
come
here
and
what
investigative
actions
against
a
judge
to
take
here
means
the
immediately
detained
chairman
of
the
council
of
judges
of
the
Rostov
region,,
the
head
of
the
department
of
the
judicial
department
and
the
chairman
of
the
Rostov
regional
court
still
tell
us
sources
of
at
least
14
judges
are
being
developed
and
travel
to
Moscow
in
order
to
participate
in
investigative
actions.
Those
who
have
already
been
detained
are
under
house
arrest.
Everything
here
is
humane.
D
B
D
So
then
maybe
something
will
be
added,
but
for
now
So
it
means
that
a
brigade
of
employees
of
the
Ministry
of
Internal
Affairs
has
been
working
in
Rostov-on-Don
since
April
3,
The
FSB
and
the
investigative
committee
seem
to
be
the
head
structure,
so
to
speak,.
Here
it
is
the
investigative
committee.
If
you
remember.
Last
year,
in
my
opinion,
there
was
a
big
raid
on
the
traffic
police
in
a
number
of
regions
in
autumn,.
Remember
then,
in
particular,.
D
D
The
traffic
police
is
not
on
a
territorial
basis,,
but
on
a
professional
basis,.
What
is
happening
here
clearly
relates
to
the
Rostov
region,
whether
these
two
cases
are
two
round-ups
connected
to
each
other
or
not
Well,.
What
is
called,,
the
future
will
show
further.
We
have
detained
the
prosecutor
of
one
of
the
districts
of
the
city
of
Rostov,.
D
He
was
caught,
red-handed
informs
us
e
FSB
when
receiving
a
bribe
in
the
amount
of
a
million
300,000
rubles
What
is
strange
with
this,,
so
to
speak,
is
not
the
amount
of
the
country,,
not
that
the
prosecutor
takes
bribes.
It
is
strange
that
he
takes
the
money
in
his
hands
at
the
moment
when
this
group
is
already
working
in
Rostov,.
D
And
brought
from
Moscow
to
Rostov
A
large
gang
has
already
taken
several
judges,.
Someone
is
wandering
to
Moscow,.
You
can
imagine
what
it
is
for
the
city
or
this
law
enforcement
environment.
That
is
very
closely
connected,
always
with
each
other
and
relationships
of
kinship
and
actually
see
some
kind
of
commercial
relationship
And.
So
he
goes
to
someone
and
takes
a
million
300,000
rubles
in
his
hands.
Well,
again,
the
prosecutor
is
different,.
Maybe
it
seems
to
them
that
this
will
never
affect
them,,
which
means
that
it
can
be
on
what
it
is
at.
D
D
Bloomed
such
a
beautiful
flower,
it
may
be
necessary
to
make
room
for
others
who
want
to
sit
on
these
wonderful
places.
The
region
is
super
rich
super,
corrupt,
Krasnodar,
Judge
or
Krasnodar.
Judge
This
is
already
a
meme,
but
believe
Rostov
is
in
no
way
inferior,
And
besides,.
The
region
is
bordering.
D
What
does
this
mean
It
means
not
only
an
increase
the
number
of
crimes
with
the
use
of
weapons
of
explosives,
and
this
means
unprecedented
opportunities
for
trafficking
in
these
weapons.
Explosives
for
human
trafficking
in
various
forms
for
trading
in
general,
everything
that
moves
In,
this
gray
zone,
in
general,.
What
is
called
the
sources
of
places?
Tell
us
I
understand
how
it
sounds:
source
people
who.
B
D
The
Russian
Federation
they
are
related
to
law
enforcement
agencies,.
They
say
that
even
the
persecution
of
dissidents,
so
to
speak,
somehow
cannot
turn
to
the
proper
level,,
because
all
law
enforcement
officers
are
busy
redistributing
property,.
They
are
busy
redistributing
property
with
enthusiasm
reminiscent
of
the
90s,,
but
with
much
greater
freedom
of
hands,
because
that
in
the
90s
Well,,
let's
just
say
there
were
bandits
and
there
were
some
conditional
Rubovites
who
somehow
chased
these
bandits
now.
Interest
groups
fighting
for
property,
for
assets,
for
flows
for
markets
consist
of
the
security
forces
themselves,.
D
D
Interests
consisting
of
security
officials
from
representatives
of
this
law
enforcement
law
enforcement
community
are
fighting
among
themselves.
Their
methods
are
known,
they
are
not
controlled
by
anyone,
how
they
will
agree
or
not
agree
among
themselves,
so
to
speak.
It
is
difficult
to
understand.
This
may
be
more
like
a
war
of
annihilation,
what
else
to
do,
but
not
to
kill
or
transplant
each
other,
completely
And
than
any
famous
gang
wars,
thirty
years
ago,
so
to
speak,.
This
is
what
is
called
one
version,.
There
may
be
another
version,.
Even
the
fight
against
corruption
may
be
a
version,.
D
D
D
B
B
B
Ask
questions
from
all
these
sources:
So,
let's
start
with
the
YouTube
channel
belt
in
Russian,
Ekaterina
Mikhailovna
Is
it
worth
hoping
that
in
2024
Russia
may
have
its
own
Svetlana
Tikhanovskaya
asks
you
Sonya.
If
this
happens,,
what
will
it
give,
provided
that
the
incumbent
president
wins
in
electronic
voting,
after
all,
on
In
practice,
Belarusians
are
now
no
easier
than
Russians,,
despite
the
presence
of
a
legitimate
leader,.
D
And
Belarusians
are
easier
than
Russians
due
to
the
presence
of
a
legitimate
leader
because
they
have
a
person
and,
accordingly,,
an
office
structure
with
which
European
governments
are
ready
to
talk.
When
we
are
unfortunate,
Citizens
of
the
Russian
Federation
of
such
we
will
live.
Our
situation
will
be
much
easier
than
it
is
now,,
so
the
Belarusians
are
better
off
in
this
respect.
For
those
who
are
naturally
outside
And.
Now
we
are
talking
about
them
with
Belarusians,,
look
really
When
in
the
twentieth
year.
These
events
took
place
in
Belarus,.
D
The
thought
arose
that
this
was
a
scenario
for
Russia
for
24
years,,
that
is
so
to
speak,.
The
authoritarian
Leader
comes
to
the
polls
in
the
usual
way,
wins
them,,
but
this
result
is
no
longer
accepted
by
society,,
something
that
was
swallowed
up,
willingly,
so
to
speak,,
but
already
causes
indignation
and
a
really
massive
wave
of
protest.
Begins.
D
If
it
wasn’t
for
Russia,,
if
Russia
simply
looked
the
other
way
at
that
time,
of
course,,
the
Belarusians
would
have
demolished
their
handsome
man,.
Then
we
said
that
if
this
happened
in
Russia,,
there
is
no
second
Russia
in
Russia
that
she
can
turn
to,
unless
China
said.
We
would
then
want
to
maintain
stability
Well,.
How
much
China
would
want
to
support
that
leader
who
would
support
himself.
This
was
not
a
question.
But
indeed,
in
Russia
there
is
such
a
problem.
We
still
have
to
live
for
24
years.
Although.
It
is
not
very
long,.
D
We
don’t
know
what
will
happen
in
the
next
few
months.
we
see,
so
to
speak,.
If
you
want
rather
fussy,,
if
you
want,,
energetic
action
of
the
Russian
authorities
that
it
is
worried
about
military
failures,,
let's
say
neatly,,
or
at
least
the
lack
of
military
successes,
do
not
have
a
very
good
effect
on
the
popularity
of
a
personal
autocrat;.
It
is.
D
Somehow
difficult
for
the
citizens
of
Victory
not
to
claim
victory
in
general,,
it
is
somehow
difficult
to
maintain
the
previous
level
of
legitimacy,.
All
this
talk
about
what
they
will
draw
electronically
will
count
everything
remarkably,
good
The
question
is
not
to
draw
the
result,.
The
question
is
to
sell
it
to
citizens,.
Citizens
may
not
come
out
so
to
speak,
imagine
actively
because
they
are
quite
intimidated
in
Belarus
For,
all
its
repressiveness,,
the
repressiveness
of
their
political
regime,
nevertheless,
in
the
twentieth
year
of
the
war,
Russia,
is
in
a
practically
semi-military
position,,
so
to
speak,
therefore,.
D
D
Anyway.
If
we
have
elections
in
24,.
There
is
more
than
one
name
on
the
ballot,
and
there
is
some
candidate
who
there
will
never
be
Prigozhin,
speaking
conditionally
about
no
such
candidates,.
No
one
will
be
allowed
on
the
ballot,.
Do
not
doubt
it
will
again
be
the
scheme
of
Snow
White
and
the
seven
dwarfs,
the
candidate
and
many,
many
freaks
around
him,.
This
is
again
the
scheme
of
the
old
proven.
D
D
Yes,
she
didn’t
go,
nevertheless,
it
wasn’t
even
possible
to
allow
that,.
You
see
that
they
didn’t
even
let
him
become
a
deputy
of
the
State
Duma,
it’s,
still
dangerous
once
again,
I,
repeat,
authoritarian
regimes,
hate
and
are
afraid
of
elections,
Even
those
that
organize
themselves
control
themselves.
All
the
rules
will
write
all
the
same.
They
are
afraid
the
sacred
spirit
of
popular
representation
hovers
there.
He
does
not
strive
for
the
chosen
procedure
invented
civilizations
that
are
much
Older
than
us
who
are
older
than
the
letters
of
our
alphabet.
You
understand,
therefore,
not
for
our
rascals.
D
Her
completely
break
So
So.
We
will
have
a
candidate
as
funny
as
possible.
Comical
old
leaky,
thin
faded.
As
you
know,
the
poem
is
just
worthless,
however,.
If
one
of
them
is
at
least
approximately
similar
to
a
person,,
I
will
have
to
repeat
it.
Again,
I
will
have
to
concentrate
around
him
just
to
show
to
support
his
wonderful
And
to
show
that
some
people
exist,
this
is
a
very
difficult
to
implement
company,.
It
is
extremely
difficult
to
implement
because
it’s,
not
even
a
smart
vote
for
anyone
except.
D
D
B
D
That
this
is
the
foundation
of
his
main
activity.
You
why
you
are
a
society.
Why
you
support
him?
Why
do
you
pay
us
money
for
what
we
said
that
any
propagandist
can
say?
Scientists
contain
the
Society
in
order
for
them
to
think
Regardless,.
Maybe
as
a
result
of
this
thinking,
they
will
discover
something
useful
things
may
not
be
opened
But.
Maybe
they
won’t
open
But.
If
they
don’t
open
it,,
then
no
one
will
open
it,.
Then
a
dependent
scientist
is
not
a
scientist
at
all,.
D
Instead
of
him,
you
can
put
cardboard
images
and
saving
money
means
how
relations
between
the
state
and
science
should
ideally
be
built,.
I
won’t
tell
you
about.
First
I
don’t
have
such
a
short
version
of
how
this
should
happen.
But
in
this
area,,
as
in
any
other,
monopolization
is
death;.
Diversity
is
development;.
If
your
state
is
the
only
employer,,
the
only
founder
of
all
universities
and
the
only
payer
of
all
salaries,,
then
your
science
will
not
flourish.
D
In
spite
of
ideas
that
this
very
enlightened
autocracy
is
now
pumping
a
lot
of
money
into
science
and
science
will
give
an
outstanding
result.
No
So,
it
doesn’t
work
for
us
people
of
intellectual
labor
who
earn
their
living
by
reading
and
writing.
We
need
a
competitive
environment,
free
communication
with
colleagues.
Our
community
is
international
by
nature.
We
we
can’t
close
ourselves
within
state
national
borders,,
it’s
impossible.
What
was
called
in
the
17th
century,
Public
of
letters,
a
republic
of
letters,,
that’s
it,,
so
to
speak,
our
Motherland,.
D
B
Any
use
Katya
Kovalchuk
on
Twitter
Echo
asks
you
And.
It
actually
accumulates
a
lot
of
similar
questions
But
here
it
is,
using
the
example
of
Finland
and
Finland.
There
is
a
mandatory
conscription
for
men,
it’s
clear
why
it
can
exist
in
principle,.
But
how
is
the
argument
built
as
to
why
it
is
obligatory
only
for
men,?
Isn’T
this
a
clear
demonstration
of
the
normalization
of
inequality,
even
at
the
official
state
level,.
D
Men,,
but
for
women
there
is
the
possibility
of
military
service.
You
know,.
These
conversations
do
not
seem
very
productive
to
me,,
because
I
would
like
that
without
presenting
the
army,
there
would
be
no
contract,
so
that
humanity
would
somehow
learn
to
solve
its
security
problems
in
a
different
way.
Without
such
a
number
of
people
of
productive
age,
taking
a
completely
unproductive
occupation.
These
people
could
do
something
more
useful,,
it
always
seems
to
me,,
but
for
now,
the
prospect
of
this,
so
to
speak,
therefore,.
Let's
say
so,
digressing
from
our
current
sad
circumstances,.
D
The
conscription
army
as
an
army
is
ineffective,,
but
as
an
army
that
should
fight
effectively,,
a
professional
army,,
but
conscription
for
a
small.
The
term
really
contributes
to
the
formation
of
a
single
civil
nation,
educates
people
in
the
feeling
of
not
this
unity
Well,.
This
is
the
notorious
military
duty,.
So
to
speak,
they
pay
and
feel
part
of
some
single
whole.
It
works.
Yes,
it
works
If.
There
is
no
beating,,
no
rape,,
no
starvation,,
then
again.
Look
at
Israel
and
possibly
Finland,
too,.
Just
with
this
experience.
D
I’m
less
familiar
with
people
who
come
from
there
completely
with
bright
memories,
and,
as
it
were,,
they
feel
that
they
have
done
something
for
their
country,
and
you
can
include
women
there,
you
can
Israeli.
Experience
suggests
a
step.
This
is
in
towards
equality.
A
step
towards
equality
will
be
a
decrease
in
this
kind
of
duty
of
a
person
in
relation
to
the
state
in
general,.
I
would
like
to
think
more
in
this.
D
We
have
a
bill
introduced
by
the
government
that
is
conducting
an
experiment,
postulates
an
experiment
in
Moscow
and
the
Moscow
region
on
the
sale
of
alcohol
by
mail
of
wine
products.
Domestic
wine
products
through
the
mail
of
Russia
is
not
good
in
itself,.
This
news,
in
my
opinion,
is
absolutely
not
good
with
us,
and
so
the
level
of
alcoholization
of
the
population,
which
had
been
declining
for
so
long,,
began
to
grow
again,.
Our
alcohol
trade
has
been
liberalized
to
the
limit
in
residential
buildings.
B
D
Just
not
around
the
clock,
no
state
monopoly,
even
close,
can
be
located
anywhere
Well,.
They
don’t
have
them
in
kindergartens
yet,,
but
again,
in
living
houses,,
please
drive
down
the
street
of
any
Russian
city.
You,
see
Red
and
White
and
other
similar
networks,,
and
so
our
beloved
department,,
one
of
our
favorite
clients
of
the
Ministry
of
Internal
Affairs,,
suddenly
woke
up
and
opposed
this
very
of
the
bill.
So
they
write
that
the
bill
does
not
take
into
account.
D
The
existing
ban
on
the
sale
of
products
to
minors
and
the
purchase
via
the
Internet
is
not
public,,
which
means
that
a
minor
can
also
sell
it
Yes,.
It
does
not
take
into
account
regional
restrictions
on
the
place
of
sale
in
general,
against
They,
of
course,
would
like
them
to
be
against.
Then,
when
this
bill
passed
through
the
government
commission
on
legislative
activity,,
because
it
is
government,,
it
means
it
went
through
a
general
procedure
Well,
then
they
apparently
overslept
it,,
but
at
least
now
they
woke
up
and
object
to.