►
From YouTube: Tool House Rock #6 | Tally
Description
MakerDAO Forum Post: https://forum.makerdao.com/t/tool-house-rock-6-tally-tuesday-april-11th-15-00-utc/20495
Description
Tool House Rock is a structured community call to give projects a way to showcase their tools and solutions to the growing MakerDAO Ecosystem. Tool House Rock will follow a consistent call agenda, focused on giving Ecosystem Actors a foundation for reviewing and assessing tools.
This Session's Guest: https://www.tally.xyz/
Tally is a front-end platform that empowers users to manage and engage with on-chain DAOs effectively. With Tally, users can gain insights into their DAOs, delegate voting power, and create or pass proposals for various DAO activities, such as managing funds, protocol changes, or smart contract upgrades. Tally is designed for:
* Operators: Build a homepage for your DAO, manage proposals, and streamline DAO governance.
* Voters: Create and share profiles, understand governance processes, delegate voting power, and participate in votes.
* Delegates: Campaign for voting power, build a profile showcasing DAO participation, and create or vote on proposals.
Disclaimer
This communication is provided for information purposes only. The views and opinions expressed in this meeting are those of people involved and do not reflect the official policy or position of MakerDAO or any of its contributors, Core Units, or affiliates. This communication makes no representations about the enduring accuracy of the information or its appropriateness for a given situation. This content is provided for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as legal, business, investment, financial, or tax advice. You should consult your own advisers as to those matters. References to any digital assets and the use of finance-related terminology are for illustrative purposes only and do not constitute any recommendation for any action or an offer to provide investment, financial, or other advisory services.
MakerDAO Links:
https://makerendgame.com
https://mips.makerdao.com
https://forum.makerdao.com
https://chat.makerdao.com
A
Welcome
maker
doubt
Community
to
toolhouse
rock
episode,
six
I'm
retro,
the
interim
facilitator
or
current
co-facilitator
of
the
ecosystem
cluster
and
today
we're
hosting
tally
a
governance
solution
targeted
towards
the
subdials
and
potentially
even
cbc's
as
a
way
to
coordinate
on
chain.
Before
we
get
started,
though
quick
30
seconds
on
toolhouse
rock
and
an
even
faster
disclaimer,
these
views
are
our
own.
Inaccuracies
are
possible.
A
This
is
definitely
not
Financial
advice
and
definitely
not
legal
advice
from
the
ecosystem
cluster
today,
but
as
a
quick
preview
on
telly,
before
handing
it
over
to
frisen
and
ref.
A
couple
team
members
from
town
who
are
joining
us
today,
taking
a
look
at
the
impact
areas
that
this
solution
supports
the
ecosystem,
infrastructure
and
governance
security.
Scopes
look
to
be
in
play
for
this
solution,
due
to
the
way
that
it
provides
coordination,
tools
on
chain
and
is
a
way
to
power.
B
A
C
B
Cool
I
will
go
into
slideshow
mode,
all
right,
good,
stuff,
cool,
so
yeah
and
feel
free
to,
of
course,
jump
in
with
questions
anytime
and
RAF
obviously
feel
free
to
jump
in
as
well
yeah,
so
I'm
I'm
fishing,
I'm
kind
of
like
the
the
non-engineer
at
tally.
So
I
do
you
know
I,
do
all
the
least
important
things
just
kidding,
but
I
do
like
community
and
beauty
and
comms
and
stuff
like
that
and
Raph
is
our
technical,
co-founder
and
CEO.
B
B
Just
a
quick.
You
know
overview
of
what
problems
tally
solves
for
Dows.
So
on
the
left,
you
can
kind
of
see
like
our
main
use
cases
and
then
or
like
value
propositions
for
Dallas
and
on
the
right.
It's
just
a
screenshot
of
our
interface
on
the
right
is
a
screenshot
of
the
like
very
controversial.
You
know
recent
unit
swap
proposal
in
q1
to
deploy
unit
spot
V3
on
BNB
chain,
and
so
you
can
kind
of
see
like
how
we
represent
that
proposal.
B
B
You
know,
there's
a
lot
of
kind
of
other
on-chain
governance
systems,
where
it's
quite
technical
to
create
a
proposal
like
there's,
really
not
like
a
a
no
code
or
a
user-friendly
way
to
create
an
Unchained
proposal.
You
have
to
you
know,
create
it
in
the
terminal.
It
needs
to
be
created
by
a
Dev,
whereas
tally
anyone
can
use
kind
of
our
like
intuitive
UI
to
to
create
a
proposal,
and
we
we
also
have
you
know
various
like
pre-built
actions
that
you
can
use.
B
So
if
you
want
to
do
like
a
simple
transfer
from
an
from
an
on-chain
treasury,
you
know
you
can
we
have
like
a
an
action
Builder.
You
know
to
to
create
that
transaction
and
you
can
choose
from
a
token
that's
in
the
treasury
and
you
can
choose
the
destination
and
create
the
proposal
as
like
a
non-technical
or
less
technical
user.
B
So
we
opened
up
on
chain
governance.
We
also
provide
Unchained
decentralization.
So
another
thing
that
makes
us
maybe
a
little
different
from
like
some
parts
of
the
Dow
tooling
ecosystem
is
when
you
create
a
proposal
on
tally
it
it
contains.
You
know
executable
code
right,
so
I'll
just
use
another
example
like
you
know,
if
you're
sending
funds
from
the
treasury
right
and
you
create
a
proposal
on
tally
it
it,
you
know,
contains
that
actual
transaction
of
sending
from
your
Dow
treasury
to
to
the
recipient.
B
In
the
case
of
this
unit
swap
proposal
to
display
Uno
swap
V3
and
BNB
chain,
you
know
when
this
proposal
passed,
which
It
ultimately
did
it.
Actually,
you
know
executed
deploying
uniswot
V3
on
BNB
chain.
So
it's
not
just
you
know:
treasury
transfers.
It's
like
arbitrary,
you
can
sort
of
you
know,
have
an
arbitrary
training
transaction
that
you
know,
calls
arbitrary
functions,
and
that
means
that
the
dial
can
actually
control
anything
that's
on
chain,
including
protocol.
B
So
we
have
a
ton
of
tools,
not
all
of
which
are
captured
in
this
particular
screenshot
on
the
right
that
are
really
designed
for
Community
engagement
with
on-chain
governance.
So
we
have
a
suite
of
tools
that
power
delegation.
We
enable
delegate
tracking
like
a
UI
for
delegate
tracking.
So
it's
not
just
like
the
delegate
in
there
in
the
Forum
being
like
and
then
I
did
the
following
right.
It's
like
you
can
actually
go
on
tally
and
see
like
everything
the
delegate
has
and
has
it
done
in
the
Dow
that's
on
chain.
B
So
I
won't
spend
this
much
time
on
every
slide.
But
this
is
just
kind
of
like
the
the
kind
of
high
level
like
what
Tally
does.
You
know
infinite
respective
maker
for
like
basically
inventing
a
lot.
A
lot
of
this.
Our
architecture
is,
is
a
little
bit
different,
we'll
talk
about
this
more,
but
we
support
the
the
governor
kind
of
smart
contract,
primitive
and,
and
we
we
can
kind
of
support
like
a
variety
of
different
kind
of
dial
designs
around
around
Governor.
B
So
you
know
we
do
provide
like
some
features
that
that
you
know
that
that
aren't
available
in
some
Legacy
on-chained
governance
systems
and
we
support
A
Primitive,
that's
kind
of
like
emerging
as
really
the
standard
for
for
entry
governance
we've
talked
about,
but
just
wanted
to
like
recognize
maker
for,
like
you
know,
blazing
the
path
forward
on
on
chain
governance.
Definitely
definitely
an
inspiration
to
us
at
tally.
So
anything
to
add
there
ref.
D
B
B
Cool
so
yeah.
This
is
just
some
quick
background
on
us.
We
are
highly
adopted,
we'll
we'll
talk
about
Governor
in
a
second
which
is
like
the
the
the
smart
contract
framework,
slash
primitive,
we
support,
but
it's
really
becoming
the
standard
for
for
on-chang
governments,
and
so
you
can
see
like
we
power,
arbitrum
ens
get
coin.
You
swap
compound
Ave
and
kind
of
a
long
tail
of
you
know,
100,
plus
more
mainnet,
Dows
and
yeah.
We
talked
about
a
lot
of
this
on
the
last
side,
so
keep
going.
B
B
So
yeah
I
want
to
talk
a
little
bit
about
Governor.
So
one
thing
I'm
kind
of
trying
to
highlight
some
of
the
things
that
make
tally
different
from
you
know.
Other
on-chain
governance
Solutions,
which
are
also
awesome,
but
just
like
the
kind
of
unique
things
about
tally,
so
tally
is
just
the
interface
right.
So
like
the
company
tally
and
tally
the
product,
we're
really
focused
on
the
front
end
slash
UI
AI
for
on
chain
governance,
but
we
support
a
specific
set
of
smart
contracts
called
Governor.
B
So
we're
we
kind
of
like
made
a
bet
of
you
know
a
couple
years
ago
with
founding
tally.
That
Governor
would
become
the
standard
for
for
online
governance
and
that's
really
played
out
and
and
there's
kind
of
a
few
reasons
for
that.
It's
very
simple
right,
like
I
mean
you
know,
it's
easy
to
kind
of
understand
and
Intuit
how
Governor
works.
It's
also
easy
to
deploy.
B
You
know
a
basic
governor
and
also
customize
some
important
pieces
of
it.
So
it
only
includes
three
contracts:
the
token
contract,
the
governor
contract
and
the
time
lock.
It's
supported
by
open
zaplin.
So
you
know
you
can
use
their
libraries
and
documentation
to
to
you
know
to
to
get
started,
and
then
it's
completely
modular.
So
any
part
of
Governor
you
can
you
know.
Basically,
you
know
make
a
a
Lego
block
with
any
other
part.
You
know
primitive
in
the
in
the
ethereum
ecosystem.
B
It's
compatible
with
both
erc20s
and
erc721,
so
like
when
Gary
you'll,
see
on
tally,
is
Downs
right
and
then
all
of
the
kind
of
like
derivatives
of
nouns
or
like
copy
pastas
of
of
nouns
afterwards
are
are,
you
know,
compatible
with
governor
and
support
it
on
tally
and
it
scales
really
well.
So
one
of
the
things
that,
like
we
see,
often
is
kind
of
early
Dows
or
smaller
Dows
or
projects
that
are
in
the
earlier
stages
of
decentralization.
B
They
will
start
with
basically
like
a
some
kind
of
social
signaling
tool,
like
usually
snapshot
right
and
then
they'll
use
the
notes
to
save
for
execution
and
there's
a
few
challenges
with
that,
but
perhaps
the
biggest
one
is
it
really
doesn't
scale
very
well.
You
know
you,
don't
you
can't
really
have
too
big
of
of
a
multi-sig
before
Things
become
like
a
little
bit
of
a
nightmare
and
also
there
isn't
really
an
ability
for
like
the
the
entire
Community
to
participate
as
it
grows.
B
So
you
know
when
you
look
at
a
Dao
like
arbitrum,
which
recently
launched
you
know,
there's
over
80
000.
There
were
over
six
hundred
thousand
addresses
eligible
for
the
airdrop
and
there's
now
over
80
000
unique
addresses
that
have
voting
power
delegated
to
them
and,
like
you
know
any
you
know
those
80
000
folks
right
anytime,
there's
a
dow
vote.
They
can
participate,
which
is
just
like
not
something
that's
possible,
with
certainly
with
like
snapshot
plus
Nosa
safe,
but
really
with
like
a
lot
of
other
Unchained
down
Frameworks,
either.
B
Also
governor,
very
secure,
like
very
battle
tested,
it's
been
around
for
a
while,
formally
verified,
heavily
audited
and
also
like
you
know,
just
has
had
effectively
a
massive
bug
bounty
on
it
for
several
years
now.
So
this
is
more
rap
is,
is
more
of
an
expert
here
than
I
am
but
anything
you
want
to
add
to
my
my
overview
or
like
pitch
for
for
governor.
D
Maybe
this
is
on
the
next
slide,
but
I
would
also
emphasize
that
Governor
is
an
ecosystem
right,
Governor,
isn't
a
tally.
Product
Governor
is
a
standard
that
compound
built,
a
bunch
of
people.
Forked
it
opened
Zeppelin
made
a
sort
of
canonical
implementation,
but
it's
not
the
only
implementation
and
friends
like
tally,
support
it,
but
so
do
lots
of
other
front
ends
so
I
think
the
the
why
I
think
the
governor
is
a
good
bet
is
because
you're
not
betting
on
one
company
or
betting
on
having
an
in-house
team.
D
That's
going
to
maintain
this
Tech,
but
you're
betting
on,
like
a
whole
ecosystem
of
tooling
providers
and
people,
building,
cool
extensions
and
upgrades
to
it
and
I
think
it's
a
a
great
example
of
kind
of
composability
and
open
source
and
modularity,
because
it
kind
of
is
this
new
primitive
for
running
controlling
an
account
at
scale
with
a
bunch
of
people
right
there.
You
could
draw
a
Continuum
of
an
eoa
that
controls
one
person,
one
account
a
multi-sigware,
several
people,
control
One
account
and
a
governor
where
many
people
control,
One
account
and
I.
B
A
lot
of
times
you
might
have
to
like
you
know,
wrap
the
token
or
do
other
things
that
are
like
very
painful
for
the
community
and
so
by
making
a
bet
on
Governor.
You
know
you're
you're,
sort
of
betting
on
something
that's
like
maximally
composable
and
also
not
dependent
necessarily
on
like,
like
anyone
group,
so
I'll
just
make
that
concrete
like.
If
you
take
a
look
at
how
uniswap
governance
operates.
So
there's
actually
many
different
front
ends
right
unit
swap
maintains
their
own
front
end
for
governor.
B
B
Yeah,
that's
just
an
example
of
kind
of
like
how
that
can
play
out
and
why
it's
sort
of
like
maximally
robust
from
the
perspective
or
it's
sort
of
like
future
proof
from
the
perspective
of
it
now
cool,
so
yeah
we're
just
gonna
dig
into
these
things
in
a
little
more
detail
and
I'm
gonna
go
through
these
quickly.
So
awesome,
tooling,
I,
as
I've
mentioned,
not
very
smart,
not
a
solidity
Dev,
but
I
have
deployed
it
out.
B
Pretty
sweet,
I'm,
not
chained
out
right,
and
that's
because
there's
this
really
cool
tool
called
the
open
Zeppelin
contracts.
Wizard,
where
you
can
like
go
over
and
be
like
I
want
to
create
an
nft
down
with
a
quorum
of
100
and
then
deploy
myself
all
the
tokens.
So
I
can,
just
you
know:
I
can
be
in
control.
You
know,
I,
just
I
just
want
to
feel
important,
okay
and
so
all
right
yeah.
B
This
contracts,
lizard,
is,
is
pretty
sweet
very
easy
to
use
very
easy
to
understand,
which
is
very
important
for
maximizing
Community
participation,
like
sometimes
it's
cool
in
doubt,
to
have
all
sorts
of
like
crazy
steps
and
processes
in
lingo.
Because
then,
you
like
actually
have
to
commit
it
commit
to
understanding
it,
but
sometimes
it
can
also
be
like
a
little
bit
not
ideal,
especially
in
the
on-chain
part.
Right,
like
a
big
part
of
the
value
proposition
of
volunteering
governance
is
that
anyone
can
like
audit
a
proposal
and
be
like.
B
Oh,
do
I
actually
want
this.
No
I,
don't
even
want
this,
and
so,
and
so
the
on-chained
part
here
is
sort
of
like
very
easy
to
use
and
understand,
yeah,
and
because
it's
modular,
like
people
so
like
there's
a
lot
of
talk
out
there.
Obviously
about,
like
you,
know,
areas
for
improvement
in
governance
right,
and
so
these
are
some
of
the.
Like
things.
People
talk
about
right.
Liquid
delegation,
quadratic
voting,
multi-chain
multi-governor
multi-token
necessary
Governor's
signatures.
B
These
are
all
things
that,
like
people
want
to
try
experiments
in
on-chain
governance
and,
like
you
what's
cool
about
Governor
is
you
can
be
like
all
right,
I'm,
gonna
use,
governor
and
I.
Don't
have
to
commit
to
any
of
these
experiments
in
particular
working
because
the
underlying
framework
is
modular,
but
then
you
can
like
try
any
of
them
with
the
base.
B
Here's
other
other
teams
in
the
ecosystem,
so
other
tools
that
are
kind
of
like
tally,
boardroom,
there's
a
bunch
of
tools
in
the
nouns
ecosystem,
civil
downlines
and
more
and
then
then
these
there
are
teams
that
are
like
building
more
like
smart
contracts
and
trying
to
like
innovate
on
top
of
Governor
primitive
scope,
lift
gfx
labs,
open,
Zeppelin,
Agora,
gnosis
and
more,
and
this
these
these
num.
These
teams,
like
there's
like
more.
This,
is
one
of
the
like
the
fastest
growing
like
highest
product
Market,
fit
kind
of
areas
of
crypto
right
now.
A
D
Happy
to
talk
about
that,
so
the
voting
delay
in
the
governor
contract
is
the
amount
of
time
between
when
a
proposal
is
proposed
and
when
voting
begins
and
most
I
think
Governor
dazontali
had
that
set
to
zero,
but
a
good
fraction
of
them
have
it
set
to
something
larger
than
zero
and
the
reason
they
want
to
do
that
set
a
number
to
larger
than
zero
is
because
they
want
to
give
voters
time
to
get
their
votes
ready,
because
when
the
vote
begins,
there's
a
snapshot.
You
know.
D
Is
just
to
give
people
time?
Oh
I
forgot
to
delegate.
Oh
I:
don't
want
this
person
to
control
my
votes
for
this
proposal,
I'm
going
to
delegate
to
someone
else
or
until
I
get
to
myself,
and
some
Dows
like
nouns,
also
use
that
voting
delay
as
a
kind
of
a
social
period
for
people
to
evaluate
the
proposal
and
talk
about
it
and.
E
D
C
D
D
C
D
Yeah
yeah
they're,
both
they're
all
kind
of
an
experimentation
face,
so
the
nouns
zero
and
all
of
the
nouns
private
voting
proof
of
concept.
Some
of
the
submissions
are
using
ZK
proofs.
Some
are
using
two,
you
know
NPC
or
different
kind
of
cryptography,
and
it's
very
much
proof
of
concept
that
we're
like
10
teams
that
made
pitches.
D
There
was
a
poll
to
pick
the
top
three
teams
and
those
three
teams
are
building
proof
of
Concepts
right
now
for
private
voting
for
the
Nam
style
and
I
expect
that
those
kinds
of
proof
of
Concepts
will,
you
know,
get
shipped
to
Sierra
and
maybe
get
productionized
later
this
year
or
early
next
year,
but
there's
definitely
a
path
to
deploying
a
governor.
Today
is
sort
of
future
proof
in
that
it
there's
a
a
place
to
plug
in
the
ZK
voting
when
it's
ready
in
the
future.
D
Actually
one
more
question
from
bonnet
publica,
and
can
you
explain
the
role
of
the
cast
vote
function
of
the
open,
supplement,
Governor
contract,
so
Cass
vote
very
important
function,
cast
vote
and
then
there's
a
few
variations
on
it
like
cast
vote
with
reason
and
cast
out
by
signature.
But
the
purpose
of
all
of
these
votes
is
that's
the
function
that
a
voter
calls
on
the
governor
contract
to
cast
a
vote
on
that
proposal.
D
So
the
core
Loop
of
a
governor
contract
is
people
create
proposals
to
do
in
the
on-chain
action
you
know
most
commonly
like
spend
money
or
change
the
parameters
of
a
defy
protocol
or
upgrade
a
smart
contract,
and
then
that
proposal
is
a
transaction
that
is
intended
to
be
executed
but
can't
be
executed
yet
because
it
has
to
pass
a
vote.
This
is
I,
think
pretty
similar
to
maker
votes,
but
anyone
with
voting
power
in
that
Governor
Dow
can
call
the
cast
vote,
function
and
vote
Yes
or
no
or
abstain
on
each
proposal.
D
B
May
all
of
your
favorite
proposals
be
passed
and
executed.
Okay,
so
I'm
gonna
show
off
three
different,
like
use
cases
or
jobs
to
be
done
of
tally.
First
ones
focus
on
delegation,
so
we've
really
seen
like
delegation
emerge
as
a
standard.
You
know
in
on-chain
governance
a
lot
of
the
most
thoughtful
Dows
that
launch
are
launching
with
delegation
at
the
Forefront
and
really
requiring
the
user
to
delegate
in
the
airdrop
claim
flow
if
they're,
if
they're
doing
an
airdrop.
Of
course,
you
can
delegate
to
yourself.
B
You
know
if,
if
you
want
to,
you
know,
represent
yourself
in
governance
or
even
represent
others,
but
you
can
also
delegate
to
others,
and
so
this
is
the
current
state
of
Delegation
in
the
arbitrum.
Now
this
is
called
the
Explorer
delegates
page
on
tally.
So,
as
you
can
see,
it's
a
really
handy
way
to
see
like
who
has
voting
power
in
the
Dow
and
so
another
thing,
a
thing
that's
cool
about.
Our
return
is
that
two
of
the
top
three
delegates
are
Dows.
B
Look
at
that
more
delegates.
Oh
look!
It's
my
favorite
delegate
myself
shout
out
to
you,
know
freshen.
He
voted
yes
on
AIP,
1.1
and
1.2.
So
if
you
support
the
entity
that
manages
the
Arbitron
sequencer
and
having
funding,
you
know
you
and
you
want
to
delegate
your
arm
tokens
to
someone
I
I
vote,
for
you
know
things
that
are
healthy
for
the
Dow
going
forward
and
and
what's
cool
is
you
can
actually
see
that?
B
B
B
Slash
Forum
stage
hasn't
made
it
to
the
like
actually
happening
on
chain
yet,
but
I
think
that
will
happen
soon,
and
these
are
actually
some
spam
proposals
in
in
arbitrum
that
have
come
through
on
on
the
on-chain
side,
and
so
you
know
the
the
the
the
the
I
guess
just
between
us
friends
and
anyone
who's
watching
this.
The
the
Unchained
threshold
for
submitting
proposals
on
Arboretum
accidentally
got
set
a
little
bit
lower
than
they
originally
intended
with
the
design.
B
So
is
allowing
some
spam
through
and
we
we
represent
the
state
of
the
chain
accurately
on
tally.
So
here
are
these
proposals
are,
but
they
don't
have
any
executable
code
in
them.
So
it's
like
not
really
a
security
risk,
but
I
also
did
not
vote
in
them
because
they're
spam
so
and
they
lost,
which
is
kind
of
funny,
but
anyway
yeah.
So
this
is
and
then
you
can
like
see
what
else
I
do
right.
Here's
some
other
on-chain
dials,
where
I
am
a
participant,
see
maybe
I.
C
B
Go
there
from
here
and
keep
digging
so
this
is
cool
because,
like
it
really
helps,
you
understand
like
if
you
want
to
understand
like
where
voting
power
is
in
the
Dow
on,
if
the
Dow
to
decide
where
to
delegate
your
votes,
see
who's
performing
well,
see
who's
not
performing
well
and
then
try
to
cross-reference
that
with
behavior
and
other
dials
you
can
kind
of
do
all
that
on
a
tally
which
is
pretty
sweet.
This
is
content
kill.
B
This
is
like
a
service
now
for
creating
content
about
douse
that
we
kind
of
like
launched
out
of
tally
and
are
like
progressively
decentralizing
into
its
own
entity.
So
if
you
want
content
about
Dallas,
you
know
hit
me
up.
We
can.
We
can
provide
that
as
well,
but
yeah
here,
I
am
I'm
very
active
in
in
content,
Guild
and
so
oh
interesting.
This
is
because
I
changed.
My
I
have
shift
my
voting
power
to
a
new
address,
so
so
yeah
you
can
see
how
I've
performed
in
contact
Guild
all
right.
B
B
B
So,
like
you
know,
if
you're
you
got
to
make
sure
when
these
proposals
go
live
that
you
make
sure
you
have
your
voting
power
delegated
before
the
voting
period
starts
we're
in
the
live
voting
period
era.
It
looks
like
they
have
us
stay
I.
Guess
it's
like
I,
don't
know
what
this
would
count
as
in
terms
of
blocks,
but
roughly
five
day,
I
guess
voting
period
for
their
proposals.
B
It
ends
on
Saturday,
April
15th,
so
this
Saturday
and
then,
if
it
passes,
it'll,
be
in
this
like
Q
proposal,
where
anyone
can
execute
it,
we
got
the
voting
timeline,
so
you
can
see
how
it's
progressing
all
the
details
of
the
proposal.
We
got.
The
X,
which
is
this,
is
just
like
the
written
description.
Obviously
somebody
did
a
really
good
job
of
explaining
it
very
thoroughly,
and
then
we
got
the
executable
code
too.
So
you
can
go
check
out
and
see
what's
actually
going
to
be
happening
on
chain.
B
If
this
passes
oh-
and
we
got
comments,
0x
zero,
three
four
six
feels
this
is
right,
that's
good
and
so
yeah
and
then
yeah
and
then
I
can
participate
right.
So
I'm
not
gonna,
actually
vote
right
now,
because
I
don't
think
I
have
Unity
tokens
delegated
in
this
wallet
and
stuff,
but
I
can
vote
on
this
proposal
with
it.
You
know
I
again,
I
have
to
have
Unity
tokens
delegated
to
this.
This
address
to
vote,
which
I
do
not
currently
with
the
wallet
I'm
signed
in
on.
B
But,
yes,
anyone
can
vote
all
right
cool,
so
that's
voting
and
then
finally,
I
am
going
to
talk
about
creating
proposals.
So
another
example:
this
is
a
hopped
out
they're
a
multi-chain
bridge,
so
anyone
can
create
a
proposal,
but
there
is
a
caveat
there.
I
kind
of
like
touched
on
this
with
the
with
the
which
I
need
to
actually
like.
C
B
C
B
B
B
C
C
B
Look
I
did
it,
let's
go
all
right:
I
am
signed
in
I.
Think
I
like
tried
to
sign
in
too
many
times,
but
anyway,
Okay
cool,
so
I'm.
Sorry,
I'll
I'll.
Do
this
real,
quick,
so
I'm
signed
into
content
Guild
with
my
wallet
that
has
one
voting
power,
which
is
above
the
proposal.
Threshold
I'm
gonna
continue
I'm
gonna
title.
My
proposal
maker
is
awesome.
B
Let's
freaking
go
so
we
have
a
cool
like
markdown
editor
where
you
can
be
like
you
know.
End
game
is
dope
and
I
can,
like
you
know,
make
that
bold
and
I
can
look
at
oh
boom
I
preview,
the
march
on
editor.
It's
bold!
Let's
go,
you
can
add
a
preview
image
and
then
yeah.
This
is
where
you
actually
do
the
on-chain
stuff,
so
I'm
gonna
transfer
tokens
to
myself
about
to
just
you
know:
drain
the
treasury.
Let's
go
so
I
put
my
wall
address
in
there.
B
B
It
tells
you
what's
about
to
happen
here
with
some
sweet
media
and
then
yeah
you
can
submit
on
chain
which
I'm
not
going
to
do
because
I
don't
want
my
fellow
members
of
content
Guild
to
think
that
I
am
bragging
the
treasury,
but
but
yeah.
Then
it
kind
of
goes
into
that
flow
where,
like
there's
proposal
status
and
everyone
can
vote
so
there
you
go.
This
is
just
like
the
you
know.
B
The
most
basic
action
I
would
say
for
unchain
down
is
like
moving
fans
out
of
Treasury,
but
you
know
you
can
also
do
all
of
the
other
things
such
as
you
know,
custom
action
that
targets
a
smart
contract
and
calls
functions
and
does
things
like
change
parameters
or
deploy
to
a
new
chain
or
or
or
or
or
anything
so
there
you
go
okay,
I'll!
Stop
there.
A
Oh
awesome,
oh
appreciate
the
tenacity
with
the
demo
and
call
out
of
a
possible
rug
again
highlighting
the
disclaimer.
This
is
not
Financial
advice,
but
all
jokes
aside,
the
one
question
I
had
was
regarding
the
tokens
that
you
said
were
accepted
by
the
system,
both
ERC
20s
and
721s.
Do
you
also
integrate
with
the
1155s
or
is
that
outside
compatibility.
B
I'll
take
that
opportunity
to
like
show
the
tally
team
so
like
we,
we
are
alike
in
the
mix
like
we
try
not
to
be.
You
know
like
in
our
Ivory
Tower
being
like
I,
think
you
know,
there's
a
temptation
as
like
a
VC
backed
out
tooling
company
to
be
like
you
know,
like
we
built
a
tooling
make
dials
for
it.
Now,
please
please,
but
we
try
to
like.
Actually,
you
know
be
in
the
mix
so
like
we
built
the
service
style
content.
B
So,
like
you
know,
if
there's
something
that
you're
thinking
about,
and
you
just
want,
like
our
opinion,
which
is
not
like
the
be-all
end
all,
but
just
like
in
opinion
from
people
who
have
been
full-time
building
in
Dallas
for
several
years
and
also
have
like
observed
successes
and
failures
across
many
large
towns.
We're
always
happy
to
provide
it
and
just
be
like
friends
if
you
want
more,
like
tactical
help,
actually
building
your
dial,
like
you
know,
or
like
figuring
out
Dal
launch
strategy.
B
A
No
I
appreciate
you
highlighting
that
we've
had
a
couple
other
teams
on
this
call
talking
about
badging
and
permission
based
Solutions,
so
seeing
how
that
could
potentially
integrate
with
this
one
as
well
was
the
source
of
the
question,
but
Republica
also
asks
in
the
chat
something
similar
to
what
I
was
also
going
to
ask.
You
talked
about
how
tall
is
basically
through
contracts,
the
one
of
them
being
the
token
contract
maker
core
does
have
the
intent
to
release
subdo
tokens
themselves.
A
D
Sure
so
the
the
the
first,
the
first
question
that
Rector
asked
about
Can
tally,
integrate
a
token
generally.
Yes,
the
one
thing
that
a
token
the
main
thing
that
a
token
needs,
an
erc20
or
ERC
12721
token
needs
to
be
compatible
with
Governor,
is
a
couple
of
methods
that
keep
track
of
voting
power
and
those
are
called
I.
D
Think
the
best
implementations
are
in
open
Zeppelin,
it's
a
standard
Library
there's
one
called
ERC
20
votes
and
one
called
ERC
721
votes
for
you
know:
5020
nprc,
721
tokens
and
there's
also
an
EIP
standard
that
they
just
finalized.
Last
late
last
year,
called
EIP
5805
that
talks
about
what
methods
a
token
contract
needs
to
be
compatible
with
the
governor,
because,
as
we
talked
about
with
these
these
three
contracts,
token
governor
and
the
time
lock,
they
need
to
be
able
to
talk
to
each
other.
D
So
there
is
a
pretty
well
defined
interface
that,
like
in
tally
stocks
and
opens
up
on
stocks.
That
says
what
needs
to
happen
for
them
to
talk
to
each
other,
so
I
think
the
Takeover
here
is,
if
you
are
deploying
tokens
for
a
maker
subdial.
Even
if
you
don't
have
a
governor
yet
and
aren't
sure
if
you
want
a
governor
I
would
say
consider
making
those
tokens
compatible
with
the
governor
standard.
D
So
you
can
deploy
a
governor
in
the
future
if
you
decide
to
and
happy
to
send
more
documentation
on
what
that
standard
is
after
the
call,
but
the
the
thing
to
search
for
is
either
eip5805
or
the
the
contracts
themselves
that
Implement
EAP
505
in
openstep
on
standard
Library,
the
the
extensions
are
erc20
votes
and
ERC
721
votes
and
then
to
one
republica's
question:
why
does
the
token
contract
need
to
implement
name
symbol
and
decimal
functions
for
Tally's
on-chain
governance
system?
The
I
guess
specific
answer
is
tally.
D
Calls
those
functions
on
a
token
contract
when
we
are
indexing
it
to
put
it
in
our
UI.
We
want
to
show
you,
you
know
you
user.
You
have
this
many
tokens
or
this
much
holding
power
of
these
tokens.
Then
this
is
the
name
of
the
token,
and
this
is
the
symbol
of
the
token
but
I
think
there's
a
another
question
that
maybe
you're
asking
because
it
sounds
like
you're
reading.
Tally's
talks
about
compatibility.
D
So
if
you
go
look
at
Tally's
talks
about
compatibility,
we
have
a
couple
pages
about
what
we
expect
from
each
of
the
contracts.
The
token
the
governor
and
the
time
lock
to
be
compatible
with
Tally,
and
this
gets
at
the
an
implicit
standard
right
like
Tally's
a
front
end,
and
we
want
tally
to
just
work
with
these
Governor
Dow
contracts
so
that
people
can
build
out
contracts.
D
They
might
need
to
customize
them
for
their
own
needs,
but
they
might
also
just
want
them
to
work
with
Tally
as
a
front
end
and
other
Finance
and
the
hour
talks
write
down
exactly
what
things
tallies
front
end
expects.
So
maybe
you
want
to
customize
Governor,
because
you
have
particular
requirements.
We've
seen
lots
of
cool
customizations
around
to
changes
to
tokens
changes.
The
way
voting
power
is
calculated.
Quadratic
voting
liquid
delegation,
there's
all
these
interesting
customizations
that
we
alluded
to
a
couple
slides
ago.
D
B
Any
other
questions,
I
didn't
I,
didn't
comment
on
the
Harbison
Channel
like
if
you
want
so
I,
think
we'll
want
to
ask
that,
like
basically
be
during
the
Dow
launch,
arbitrary
didn't
disclose
that
there
is
a
set
like
seven
roughly
seven
percent
allocation
to
the
arbitrim
foundation,
which,
like
is
totally
fine
like
in
my
opinion.
This
is
my
opinion.
B
Is
a
delegate
right,
not
in
a
play
of
tally,
but,
like
you
know,
if
you
look
at
other
guys,
like
the
dial
actually
had
quite
a
very,
very
solid
Community
allocation
and
like
all
these
chains
have
foundations,
they
need
foundations.
The
original
Foundation
is
pretty
dope
because
it
actually
manages
the
sequencer
and
takes
all
the
net
profit
from
the
sequencer
and
puts
it
in
the
Dow
treasury
God.
Damn
that's
a
lot
of
eat.
That's
pretty
dope!
So
Foundation
good,
not
disclosing
the
foundation
allocation
in
the
Dow
launch.
B
If
you
look
at
like
the
current
state
of
origin
forums,
there's
kind
of
like
a
few
competing
proposals
to
how
how
to
move
forward
and
the
ones
that
are
winning
are
1.1
and
1.2,
which
I
think
are
like
a
very
healthy
path
forward
and
the
doubt
will
be
in
a
good
spot.
But
that's
the
tldr
on
the
on
the
art
between
drama.
A
Appreciate
the
the
insights
there,
yeah
I
think
one
was
being
a
little
facetious
talking
about
drama
in
the
Dow,
but
moving
on
from
that
I,
it
doesn't
look
like.
We
have
a
ton
of
questions
and
we
are
coming
up
to
the
top
of
the
hour.
We'll
make
one
more
call
for
any
questions,
but
while
we're
waiting,
it
looks
like
Tim
has
one.
If
you
want
to
hop
on
the
mic.
E
I,
don't
know
if
you
guys
didn't
hear
me:
oh
yeah
yeah,
so
we
spent
quite
a
bit
of
time
talking
about
Governor
and
yeah.
We
that's
that's
great
I'm,
more
curious
about
what
other
Frameworks
you
guys
are
thinking
of
sort
of
as
the
Market's
changing.
Where,
where
do
you
think
the
puck
is
going
and
what
is
tally,
doing
to
kind
of
adapt
to
that.
D
D
It
can
also
control
the
assets
in
the
Pod
and
I.
Think
there's
some
great
implementations
of
that
from
the
hats
team,
the
Metropolis
team
and
the
Nosa
zodiac
team
they've
all
built
some
ways
to
connect
a
governor
to
a
pod,
so
that
I
think
already
works
today.
We
see
several
doves
doing
it
and
we
have
a
feature
on
tally
that
prison.
If
you
go
to
like
the
ens
homepage,
you
can
see
all
of
the
ens
pods
on
tally.
D
D
D
Are
transparency,
help
make
those
transparent
and
accountable
and
also
easy
and
safe,
and
we
think
this
this
feature
helps
go
a
long
way
in
that
direction,
but
then
I
think
the
the
general
question
of
where's
the
market
going.
We
see
a
lot
of
stuff
being
built
on
top
of
this
building
block,
who
talks
about
ZK
voting
private
voting.
We
also
are
seeing
cross-chain
governance
like
uniswap
on
mainnet,
governs
the
unit
swap
implementations
of
the
protocol
on
probably
a
dozen
different
chains.
B
A
C
D
Probably,
on
the
other
desktop
you
have
to
scroll
to
the
brave
browser,
yeah
control
and
right
arrow,
but
on
that
side
there
is
a
fission
at
tele.xyz
is
an
email.
You
can
also
email
me
RAF
tally.xyz.
We
are
also
on
Twitter.
If
we
answer
our
DMS
and
telegram,
my
name
is
rafso
r-a-f-s-o
on
the
telegram.
You
can
just
shoot
me
a
message
there
as
well.
A
Awesome
we'll
make
sure
all
the
handles
are
updated
in
the
show
notes.
Thank
you
guys
so
much
for
making
time
and
conducting
an
awesome
demo
I
think
the
audience
here
got
a
lot
out
of
it
and
we'll
make
sure
to
host
this
with
the
other
Tool
Time
calls
tool
house
calls
to
make
sure
that,
as
ecosystems
are
growing
around
maker,
they
have
the
tools
needed
to
be
successful.
But
thank
you,
gentlemen,
again
and
hope
to
talk
to
you
guys
in
the
future.
Here.