►
From YouTube: Board of Health - September 23, 2019 - Part 1 of 2
Description
Board of Health, meeting 9, September 23, 2019 - Part 1 of 2
Agenda and background materials:
http://app.toronto.ca/tmmis/decisionBodyProfile.do?function=doPrepare&meetingId=15399
Part 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KsA858vF8e4
A
A
B
Welcome
to
meeting
nine
of
the
Board
of
Health,
two
members
of
the
board,
two
other
members
of
council
and
two
members
of
the
public.
You
can
follow
the
agenda
on
your
computer,
your
tablet
or
your
smartphone
at
wwr
on
Tozier
/
council.
The
Board
of
Health
acknowledges
the
land
we
are
meeting
on
is
the
traditional
territory
of
many
nations,
including
the
Mississauga's
of
the
credit,
be
honest,
nabhi,
the
Chippewa,
the
whole
nashoni
and
the
wind
at
people's
and
is
now
home
to
many
diverse
First,
Nations,
Inuit
and
maytee
peoples.
B
B
There
is
an
overflow
room
in
the
rotunda
of
City
Hall,
so
for
people
who
can't
get
in
here,
there
is
seating
and
the
ability
to
watch
under
the
Rotunda
I
and
for
those
who
haven't
been
here
before
just
a
note
at
the
outset.
This
is
a
safe
space,
we're
here
to
hear
everybody's
perspective,
and
we
ask
for
members
of
the
public
who
are
here.
There
is
no
as
much
as
people
like
to
cheering
or
clapping
or
waving
and
all
the
rest.
B
I'm
gonna
begin
by
seeing
if
there
are
any
declarations
of
interest
under
the
municipal
conflict
of
interest
Act
to
the
board
any
declarations
of
interest,
seeing
none
can
I
have
a
confirmation
of
the
minutes
from
the
July
8th
meeting
of
2019
moved
by
director
lie
all
those
in
favor
opposed.
If
any
that
is
carried.
B
We
at
this
point
are
now
going
to
move
through
the
agenda
to
see
which
items
are
held
and
I'll
begin
item
9.1
tío
health
check
and
overview
of
Toronto's
population
health
status,
we're
going
to
hold
that
for
a
presentation
and
speaker
item
HL
9.2,
moving
to
acceptance,
Toronto
public
health
strategy
to
address
vaccine
hesitancy
I
understand
that
to
unanimous
I'll
take
his
character,
I'm
kidding
there.
We
have
a
few
deputies
on
that.
Just
making
sure
people
are
paying
attention
item
HL,
9.3,
Canada's,
new
Food,
Guide
implications
and
opportunities
for
action.
B
Would
anybody
like
to
hold
that
seeing
none
director
Donaldson?
Would
you
like
to
move
the
recommendations
moved
by
director
Donaldson,
all
those
in
favor
opposed
if
any,
that
carried
item
HL
9.4
establishment
of
Toronto
urban
health
fund
indigenous
review
panel,
that
is
being
held
for
a
speaker
item
HL
9.5,
Toronto,
Public,
Health
operating
budget
variance
for
the
six
months
ended
June,
30th
2019?
B
Would
anybody
like
to
hold
that
seeing
none
director
McKelvey
with?
Are
you
comfortable
moving
that
moved
by
director
McKelvey
all
those
in
favor
opposed?
If
any
that
is
carried
item,
HL
9.6,
Toronto,
Public,
Health
capital
budget
variance
for
the
six
months
ended
June
30th
2019
again?
Would
anybody
like
to
hold
that
seeing
none
I'm
happy
to
move
the
recommendations,
all
those
in
favor
opposed
if
any
carried?
Thank
you
item,
HL
9.7
enhancement
to
Toronto's
Public,
Health's,
2019
operating
budget
for
the
Ontario
seniors
dental
care
program?
B
B
Okay,
seeing
none
I'm
happy
to
move
the
recommendations,
all
those
in
favor
opposed
if
any
carried
item,
H
L,
9.9,
Toronto,
Public,
Health,
2020
operating
budget
request,
there's
a
confidential
attachment
that
is
being
circulated,
I'd
like
to
hold
that
and
then
to
the
clerk's.
Do
we
have
a
new
business
item
to
be
introduced
here
we
have
two
new
business
items
to
introduce.
The
first
is
health
concerns
associated
with
vapor
products.
This
has
been
circulated.
There
will
be
a
presentation
from
the
medical
officer
of
health.
B
I
need
a
motion
to
add
that
to
the
agenda
moved
by
director
Johnson,
all
those
in
favor
opposed
if
any
carried
and
then
also
a
new
business
item
submitted
from
staff
by
the
medical
officer
of
Health,
Canadian
Institutes
of
Health
Research
healthy
cities,
research
initiative
planning
grant
for
implementing
healthy
urban
policy
can
I
have
a
motion
to
introduce
that
move
by
director
Donaldson
all
those
in
favor
opposed
if
any
Carrie.
Okay,
we're
now
going
to
move
into
the
meat
of
the
agenda
before
we
begin
I
have
a
motion.
B
We
have
more
than
30
decadents
registered
from
one
item
on
its
own
and
we
have
other
speakers
on
others.
So
in
order
to
accommodate
everybody
and
to
ensure
we
don't
lose
quorum
for
this
tight
addenda,
I
will
be
moving
at
motion,
as
we
often
move
with
this
many
deputes
that
speakers
who
have
not
pre
registered
be
allowed
to
register
until
10:00
a.m.
so
people
who
have
not
yet
registered.
You
can
still
register
in
10:00
until
10:00,
after
which
we
will
close
registration
and
that
the
length
of
public
presentations
be
limited
to
three
minutes.
B
That
will
also
be
limited
for
us.
As
members
of
the
board
I've
moved
that
all
those
in
favor
opposed
if
any
seeing
none.
Thank
you
Carrie.
Okay.
We
will
now
begin
with
the
agenda.
Our
first
item
is
HL
9.1
tal
health
check
an
overview
of
Toronto's
population
health
status
and
we
have
a
registered
speaker.
That's
Andy,
PRNDL,
chair
of
the
Toronto
Police
Services
Board
Andy.
Please
come
on
up.
Oh.
B
C
Thank
You
mr.
chair,
we,
while
we're
getting
the
appropriate
presentation
up
on
the
screen
for
you,
I'll
just
offer
some
words
of
introduction.
You
have
before
you
in
this
report.
Teo
health
check
an
overview
of
the
health
of
Toronto's
population
and
I'm
just
making
there
we
go
this.
The
presentation
is
up
there
high
level.
C
So,
with
that
in
mind,
I'm
going
to
turn
it
over
to
my
colleagues,
we
have
Liz
Corson
and
Sarah
Collier
at
the
back
of
the
room
there
Sarah
Collier,
acting
manager
in
our
surveillance
and
epidemiology
section
at
Toronto,
Public,
Health,
they're
gonna.
Take
you
to
a
quick
presentation
of
this
report.
D
D
Good
health
is
a
key
contributor
to
quality
of
life
in
order
to
meet
the
vision
of
the
city
and
a
Toronto
Public
Health,
a
clear
and
comprehensive
picture
of
the
health
of
Torontonians
is
needed.
One
role
of
Public
Health
epidemiologists
is
to
assess
and
report
on
the
health
status
of
the
local
population,
similar
to
how
a
clinician
uses
a
diagnosis
to
develop
a
treatment
plan.
D
A
health
status
assessment
contributes
to
a
body
of
information
that
Toronto
Public
Health
uses
to
develop
strategic
goals
that
support
its
mandate
to
improve
the
health
of
our
community
and
reduce
health
disparities.
Geo
health
check
provides
an
overview
of
the
key
population
health
issues
currently
facing
Toronto.
The
report
is
intended
to
guide
discussion
on
emerging
health
issues
and
priorities
to
run
for
Toronto
Public
Health,
as
well
as
stakeholders
who
have
the
potential
to
impact
the
health
of
the
city.
D
To
tell
the
story
of
the
health
status
of
Torontonians
selected
indicators
have
been
grouped
into
11
sections.
The
suite
of
indicators
presented
together
in
this
report
provide
a
point-in-time
picture
of
our
populations,
health
and
the
context
in
which
people
live
that
directly
and
indirectly
affected
the
following
slides
present,
a
small
selection
of
the
many
indicators
presented
in
the
report.
D
In
order
to
give
you
an
idea
of
the
range
of
topics
covered
to
orient
you
to
the
types
of
analysis
that
were
completed
and
to
give
examples
of
some
of
the
more
pressing
health
issues
facing
Torontonians
today,
collectively
Toronto
is
doing
relatively
well
in
terms
of
health
and
wellness
over
half
of
Toronto
adults
rate.
Their
health
as
excellent
are
very
good,
and
life
expectancy
has
improved.
However,
living
longer
does
not
mean
that
everyone
has
optimal
health.
It
is
becoming
more
common
for
people
to
live
with
some
chronic
diseases.
D
Diabetes,
heart
disease
and
dementia
are
increasing
in
part
due
to
the
aging
population,
while
chronic
diseases
such
as
cancer
and
cardiovascular
disease
are
the
leading
contributors
to
death
and
disability.
Toronto
is
in
the
throes
of
an
emerging
type
of
health
issue,
some
refer
to
as
the
diseases
of
despair.
D
These
health
concerns
include
problematic
alcohol
and
other
drug
use.
Mental
health
issues
and
self-harm
rates
of
emergency
department,
visits
for
self-harm
have
increased
and
suicide
is
the
leading
cause
of
death
for
people
18
to
39.
Toronto
adults
are
more
likely
to
be
hospitalized
for
conditions
entirely
caused
by
alcohol
than
for
heart
attacks,
and
the
opioid
poisoning
crisis
has
become
a
critical
public
health
issue
for
Toronto
and
continues
to
have
devastating
impacts
on
our
community.
D
Health
is
also
not
the
same
for
everyone.
Health
and
inequities
are
the
systematic,
unjust
and
avoidable
differences
in
the
distribution
of
health
status
between
different
populations.
Tío
health
check
reports
on
inequities
by
income,
immigrant
status,
sexual
orientation
and
in
identity,
for
example,
in
Toronto
people
with
lower
incomes
are
at
greater
risk
for
chronic
diseases.
Have
higher
rates
of
unfavorable
health
outcomes
for
a
number
of
reproductive
indicators
and
have
higher
rates
of
premature
mortality?
D
Toronto
Public
Health
has
a
mandate
to
reduce
health
inequities,
and
these
findings
play
a
key
role
in
informing
priority
areas
for
action
and
intervention
going
forward.
We
have
only
begun
our
analysis
on
these
differences.
Using
the
health
status
report
as
a
springboard,
more
advanced
analytics
should
be
used
to
explore,
explore
more
complex
interactions.
However,
to
do
this
requires
access
to
robust
data.
D
Throughout
the
report,
a
number
of
data
gaps
are
identified,
for
example,
data
on
many
health
outcomes
and
risk
factors
cannot
be
broken
down
by
some
important
determinants
of
health
like
ethno
racial
identity,
immigrant
status
and
sexual
orientation.
There
are
topics
and
issues
that
have
limited
data,
such
as
children's
health.
D
There
are
instances
where
the
data
we
do
have
is
not
consistently
collected
or
consistently
available,
for
example
for
youth,
we
conducted
our
own
student
survey,
but
these
data
are
becoming
old
and
cannot
be
compared
over
time
or
across
jurisdictions.
And
finally,
age
or
timeliness
of
data
continues
to
be
a
concern.
For
example,
mortality
data
available
to
Toronto,
Public
Health
is
from
2015,
and
yet
there
are
other
sources
reporting
on
life
expectancy
in
2017
in
other
areas
of
Canada.
D
D
The
teo
health
check
report
provides
a
broad
array
of
population
health
indicators
that
reflect
health
determinants,
risk
factors
and
outcomes
for
the
three
million
residents
of
Toronto.
However,
we
recognize
that,
even
during
the
time
of
writing,
the
health
status
has
changed
in
the
city.
This
report
is
intended
to
complement
ongoing
population
health
assessment
reporting.
Additional
demographic
and
health
status.
Information
is
available
on
the
city
of
Toronto
and
Toronto
Public
Health
web
sites,
including
the
population
health
status
indicators,
dashboard
we're
ongoing
routine
reporting
for
key
population.
Health
indicators
are
updated,
as
data
becomes
available.
B
B
E
You,
mr.
chairman
and
good
morning,
I
have
sent
you
an
electronic
copy
of
the
report,
so
I
will
try
to
briefly
hi
to
do
some
of
the
highlights
on
behalf
of
the
Toronto
Police
Services
Board
I
want
to
thank
you
for
the
opportunity
to
be
here
today
as
part
of
your
discussion
of
the
Toronto
health
status
report.
E
I
cannot
emphasize
enough
the
importance
of
the
Toronto
Police
Service
and
our
board
collaborating
with
Toronto
Public,
Health
and
other
stakeholders,
so
that
we
can
more
effectively
deal
with
the
challenges
that
we're
all
facing,
including
individuals
experiencing
mental
health
and
addictions
issues
and
challenges
specific
to
indigenous
community.
Amongst
many
others.
We
understand
that
in
many
of
these
areas
the
problems
are
complex
and
multifaceted.
There
is
no
simple
solution
or
quick
fix.
There
are
resource
shortages,
systemic
barriers
and
long-standing
cultural
and
social
stereotypes
and
assumptions,
all
of
which
make
overcoming
these
challenges
all
the
more
difficult.
E
But
it's
not
always
about
doing
better
with
more
it's
about
being
more
innovative,
more
collaborative
and
more
creative,
and
it's
about
building
new
and
stronger
strategic
partnerships
to
more
effectively
utilize.
What
we
have
in
smarter
and
more
resourceful
ways
it's
about
joining
forces
at
the
start
of
our
problem-solving
process,
rather
than
at
the
end,
making
partnership
a
regularized
and
critical
component
of
all
that
we
do.
The
services
dynamic
community,
centered,
neighborhood
officer
program,
is
an
outstanding
illustration
of
how
collaboration
can
prevent
the
ups
issues
from
ending
up
with
downstream
challenges.
E
These
officers
work
collaboratively
to
mobilize
community
members
to
deal
with
issues
before
they
become
crises
in
February
2019.
The
board
approved
the
establishment
of
a
new
mental
health
and
addictions
advisory
panel
or
M
happen,
and
the
purpose
of
M
happy
is
to
review,
provide
advice
and
make
recommendations
to
the
board,
on
an
ongoing
basis,
related
to
monitoring
and
evaluate
the
implementation
of
a
new
forthcoming
organizational
Mental,
Health
and
Addiction
strategy
and
other
matters
related
to
policy
involving
mental
health
and
addictions
issues.
E
As
you
report
notes,
the
number
of
opioid
poisonings
has
increased
dramatically
over
the
past
five
years
in
the
emplacing.
We
have
most
certainly
seen
the
effects
of
this
dramatic
increase,
recognizing
the
need
to
confront
the
opioid
crisis
collaboratively
and
within
the
context
of
our
broader
approach
to
mental
health
and
addictions.
The
board
approved
a
motion
to
invite
a
dr.
Davila
to
be
a
member
of
M
Happ,
as
well
as
to
invite
her
to
present
quarterly
public
quarterly
public
report
to
the
Toronto
Police
Services
Board
on
relevant
public
health
issues,
including
the
opioid
overdose
crisis.
E
E
B
F
F
When
I
was
chair
of
the
Drug
Strategy
several
years
ago,
we
had
tremendous
participation
from
the
fellow
who
was
then
the
head
of
the
drug
squad,
randy
franks,
and
it
actually
helped
us
to
design
the
safe
injection
services.
We
have
in
place
now
I
see
that
in
your
written
remarks,
you've
recommitted
to
participating
in
that
in
that
process
and
I'm
glad
to
hear
I
just
wanted
to
give
you
a
chance
to
expand
on
that
in
any
way
or
well.
F
Thank
you
for
that
I
guess.
I
was
looking
at
something
a
little
different,
which
is
there's
a
formal
table
that
includes
representatives
from
the
Toronto
Public
Service,
some
of
the
community
organizations
you've
spoken
about
and
I'm,
hoping
that
what
I'm
hearing
today
is
that
Toronto
Police
Service
is
committing
to
participating
in
the
Toronto
drug
strategy
implementation
table.
Yes,
thank
you.
G
Thank
you
again,
your
short
presentation.
This
morning
you
focus
on
mental
health,
opiate
crisis
and
you
indicated
to
the
or
you'd
be
inviting
to
medical
off
somehow
to
toronto
police
services.
What,
but,
in
this
report,
there's
significant
concerns
with
the
aging
population.
You
have
not
touch
on
I,
haven't
seen
your
written
submission,
yet
it's
the
Toronto,
Police
Services,
Board,
Toronto
Police
is
going
to
be
tackling
the
issue
of
an
elder
abuse
because
I'm,
seeing
here
on
page
32
of
the
report
talking
about
elder
abuse,
intimate
partners,
violence.
G
E
First
of
all,
I
think
that's
a
very
good
point.
Even
the
longer
written
presentation,
I
think
only
makes
very
brief
reference
to
elderly,
but
I
think
it's
fair
to
say
that
it's
always
an
ongoing
issue
for
Toronto
police
any
time
there
is
violence
against
the
elderly
and
we
recognize
it's
a
problem
and
often
a
silent
problem
and
again
I
I.
E
Think
that's
why
the
Toronto
that
the
neighbourhood
community
officers
and
the
engagement
and
focused
tables
are
so
important,
because
otherwise
we
are
just
responding
to
an
issue,
as
reported
where
the
neighbourhood
officer
should
be
in
the
communities
and
therefore
part
of
those
community
solutions
and
discussions.
So
that
I
think
is
really
the
number
one
way
in
which
we
would
look
to
deal
with
it.
But
it's
certainly
one
that
we're
very
strongly
aware
of.
E
G
H
Thank
you
very
much,
mr.
Pringle.
Thank
you
very
much
for
your
deputation
I
recognize
that
it
was.
It
was
brief
and
I
wanted
to
just
ask
you
to
expand
on
the
mobile
crisis
intervention
team,
which,
which
is
a
highly
effective
strategy
deployed
by
Toronto
Police,
often
in
conjunction
with
mental
health
nurses.
In
your
letter,
it
states
that
that
the
coverage
is
now
available
throughout
the
city.
Is
it
adequately
coverage
throughout
the
city
and
are
there
some
neighborhoods
that
are
experiencing
higher
volumes
of
calls
and
are
you?
E
Think
the
answer
is
that
there's
always
more
that
can
be
done
counselor.
This
has
been
a
highly
effective
program
over
a
number
of
years.
As
you
know,
the
constraints
to
it
I
think,
are
really
on
the
health
medical
health
side.
In
that
we
could
provide
more
officers
if
there
were
more
health
officers
are
available
and,
yes,
there
are
areas
such
as
51
division,
which
obviously
you
know
very
well,
but
I
think
you
know
we
can
identify
where
the
challenges
areas
are
and
those
are
adequately
covered.
E
I.
You
know
there
is
an
issue
around.
How
do
you
deal
with
it
24/7,
as
opposed
to
during
the
hours
which
the
mental
health
officers
work?
So,
yes,
there's
much
more
to
be
done
and
it's
an
issue
on
our
agenda
going
forward
as
to
how
we
expand
that
program.
We
know
it's
highly
effective,
but
we
know
we
could
do
more.
If
we
had
more
impediments
are
less
the
police
than
they
are
the
health
of
society
and.
H
So,
recognizing
that
you
would
like
to
have
more
research
resources
and
I
understand
in
51
division,
which
is
the
division
of
Carver's
Toronto
Centre,
big
part
of
all
of
downtown
East.
Really,
what
I
hear
is
the
biggest
concern
is
that
there
is
not
adequate
mental
health
nurses
to
go
out.
So
my
question
is
how,
with
your
request
going
to
the
province
for
funding
adequate
funding
for
these
mental
health
nurses,
how
how
how?
How
short
are
you
with
respect
to
what
you've
asked
the
province
for
on
what
they've
actually
provided
funding
for
the.
E
Crisis
is
the
issues
around
mental
health,
and
particularly
in
some
of
those,
some
more
challenged.
Downtown
areas
is
growing,
I
mean
I.
Think
last
year,
Toronto
Police
had
twenty
nine
thousand
five
hundred
calls
for
people
in
mental
distress
about
ten
thousand
of
those
we
handle
on
the
phone,
which
means
we
have
to
attend
the
balance
of
them.
It's
a
it's
a
real
draw
and
to
the
degree
we
can
have
more
resources
in
terms
of
n
CIT
units,
the
better.
E
G
H
H
Page
two
of
your
speech:
you
mentioned
something
about
the
dynamic
community
based
a
centered,
neighborhood
officer
program,
and
you
know
this
program
will
be
dealing
with
issues
before
they
become
crisis.
I,
just
wonder
whether
you
can
just
give
us
an
update
of
this
program
has
been
around
for
a
few
years
and
a
little
bit
of
a
quick
update,
and
what
are
you
planning
to
do
with
the
new
funding
that
I
think
we've
got
some
funding,
whether
there's
being
invested
in
this
program.
Well,.
I
E
Roll
out
the
program
properly
across
the
city
now
last
two
weeks
ago,
the
chief
recently
announced
an
increase
in
the
number
of
officers
committed
to
the
program.
So
this
will
get
us
further
down
the
line,
but
again
it's
not
in
all
communities
and
it's
not
as
broadly
used
as
we
would
like.
Part
of
that
is
a
timing
issue
and
that
it
takes
time
to
train
up
the
officers
specifically
as
community
officers,
but
part
of
it
is
that
resource
issue.
H
E
B
G
Very
much
mr.
chair,
so
through
you
to
their
medical
office
of
Health
on
page
I'm
just
reading
the
report,
page
21
of
the
report,
I,
was
totally
shocked
mr.
chair,
to
read
the
data
that
I'm
going
to
quote
here.
According
to
the
report,
racialized
people
were
more
likely
to
have
not
completed
high
school,
but
what
was
more
astonishing
in
this
report?
Mr.
chair,
that
this
is
coming
before
this
board
that,
for
example,
Southeast
Asian
students
were
four
times
more
likely.
G
C
So
through
you,
mr.
chair,
this
is
the
first
public
for
a.
If
you
will
for
this
health
status
report,
we
have
been
having
some
preliminary
conversations
with
other
partners
in
the
city
and
I
do
meet
regularly
with
our
colleagues
at
the
school
boards.
This
certainly
will
be
part
of
that
agenda
and
I
suspect
will
be
part
of
our
ongoing
conversation
for
quite
some
time
to
come.
I'm
going
to
turn
it
over
to
my
colleagues
over
at
the
back
desk
to
see
if
they
have
anything
further
to
add
I.
G
G
What
are
we
doing
more,
because
this
is
what
the
board's
mandate
is,
because
this
is
absolutely
unacceptable.
When
I
heard
from
the
community
saying
they
saw
this
man
chasing
this
woman
with
a
machete,
they
didn't
call
the
police
until
after
the
fact.
Well
wait
a
minute
here.
What
do
we
need
to
do
more
and
what
sources
do
we
need
to
get
to
so.
C
Through
the
chair,
I
think
there
are
many
actions
that
need
to
be
taken,
some
of
which
are
within
the
purview
and
responsibilities
of
Toronto
Public
Health,
many
of
which
are
also
going
to
be
actions
that
have
to
be
taken
in
partnership
with
with
other
city
divisions
and
certainly
with
external
partners,
of
which
the
Toronto
Police
Services
would
be.
One
I
can
tell
you
that
what
we
have
here
at
the
city
is
a
pretty
coordinated
effort
in
respect
of
intimate
partner
violence.
C
We've
participated
along
with
our
colleagues,
most
notably
at
Social,
Development,
Finance
and
Administration
on
a
program
in
and
around
interpersonal
violence,
and
we
have
public
campaigns
actively
engaging
with
members
of
our
public
to
suggest
that
they
do
have
a
role
so
that
we
don't
see
the
kind
of
thing
that
you
just
described
happen
over
and
over
again,
is
there
more
work
to
do
absolutely?
Are
we
continuing?
Yes,
we
are
and
I
think
it
is
not
exclusively
in
the
purview
of
Toronto
Public
Health.
C
We
are
taking
on
our
role
in
that
regard,
both
on
education
fronts
and
we're
also
trying
to
figure
out
what
are
the
evidence
informed
interventions
that
actually
prevent.
We
rely
on
our
police
partners,
as
you
heard
mr.
Pringle,
say,
to
manage
the
downstream
consequences,
but
from
a
public
health
perspective,
we'd
like
to
keep
it
as
upstream
as
possible,
and
look
for
those
public
health
interventions
that
actually
prevent
those
situations
from
arising
in
the
first
place.
C
H
D
Thank
you
for
the
question,
so
in
this
report
we
do,
we
don't
do
any
mapping,
but
in
the
dashboard
that
we
displayed
at
the
last
slide,
the
population
health
status
indicator
dashboard.
We
do
do
mapping
where
the
data
is
available,
we'll
look
at
it
by
neighborhood.
We,
a
Toronto,
Public
Health,
operates
within
service
delivery
areas
as
well.
So
we'll
look
at
the
information
by
service
delivery
area
oftentimes.
The
data
is
not
robust
enough.
There's
not
enough
of
a
sample
size
for
us
to
got
it
by
neighborhood,
but
where
possible,
we
do
try
to
map
and.
C
So
through
the
chair,
that's
exactly
where
we
need
to
go.
I
should
advise
you
that
this
is
this
kind
of
overall
health
status
report
is
actually
relatively
new
to
us.
It
hasn't
been
done
in
the
last
twenty
years,
in
fact,
so
this
is
precisely
the
reason
why
we
wanted
to
put
this
report
together
and
and
I
think
you
can
appreciate
as
an
audience
here,
both
as
a
board
and
those
of
you
that
are
gathered
around
the
room.
C
What
is
driving
disparities
in
health
status
amongst
our
residents,
and
how
do
we
then
use
our
resources
to
the
greatest
effect
for
the
greatest
number
of
people
so
that
we
can
improve
health
status
while
reducing
disparities
simultaneously,
I
think
striking
the
balance
between
that
which
the
provincial
government
prescribes
for
us
and
understanding
what
is
pressing
on
health
status
and
what
drives
disparities
is
exactly
the
challenge.
That's
before
us,
and
you
will
hear
us
bring
that
many
times
more
in
the
future.
To
this
table
for
conversation
and.
H
What
our
next
steps
in
terms
of
like
data
mining,
because,
right
now,
your
variables
are
all
kind
of
siloed,
but
not
really
looked
at
in
a
kind
of
interrelated
basis.
So
is
that
something
that
would
going
forward
start
to
be
brought
out
more
through
future
reporting?
Recognizing
that
this
is
new
and
fantastic
report.
Mm-Hmm.
D
H
D
So
so
we
are
partnering
with
different
data
holders,
I
guess
to
say
to
look
at
where
we
can
improve
that
type
of
thing.
We're
also
looking
at
opportunities
for
data
collection.
So
can
we
advocate
to
different
organizations
who
do
major
data
collection
to
ask
them
to
include
certain
variables,
especially
socio
demographic
type
of
information?
So
we
continue
to
explore
those
opportunities,
but
it
does
take
time
and
it
does
often
take
chances
in
policies
and
procedures.
But
in
order
for
that
to
happen
and.
B
E
L
A
C
So
through
the
chair,
I,
don't
know
that
I
have
the
specific
data
for
other
jurisdictions,
but
suffice
it
to
say
that
there
has
been
noted
a
trend
over
the
last
thirty
years,
for
example,
reduced
use
of
active
transportation
to
school.
That
is
not
unique
to
Toronto
that
has
occurred
throughout
Ontario
and
indeed
throughout
Canada.
C
Unfortunately,
I
think
whether
it's
with
children
or
with
adults,
physical
activity
has
been
largely
engineered
out
of
our
daily
lives.
We're
happy
to
come
back
with
you
and
provide
you
with
specific
results
from
other
jurisdictions.
I'm,
not
sure
if
my
colleagues
have
that
with
them
right
now.
Yes,.
D
So
that
information
actually
comes
from
the
Student
Survey,
which
I
mentioned
in
the
presentation,
was
something
that
your
honor
Public
Health
took
on
ourselves
and
so
that
specific
data
point
can
actually
not
be
measured
across
different
jurisdictions.
There
are
different
surveys
that
look
at
youth
physical
activity
in
Ontario
or
across
Canada,
and
we
would
see
similar
as
as
dr.
Davila
mentioned,
similar
trends
declining
physical
activity,
but
that
is
a
major
data
gap
that
we
actually
can't
compare
that
Student
Survey
that
we
did
to
other
jurisdictions,
which.
A
D
D
We
have
some
information
from
the
early
development
instrument,
which
is
done
in
kindergarten
students.
Looking
at
developmental
milestones
in
sk
students,
we
have
bits
and
pieces
from
other
places
with
children,
but
it
is
very
limited.
We
have
addressed
that
gap.
Statistics
Canada
is
doing
a
Child
and
Youth
Survey.
That's
happening
there
in
the
field
right
now
that
data
should
be
available
in
2021,
but
I
should
note
that,
in
order
to
get
a
robust
sample
size,
we
are
required
to
purchase
an
over
sample
of
that.
In
terms
of
youth
data.
D
There
is
the
Ontario
student,
drug
use
and
health
survey
auste
s--,
which
collects
has
been
ongoing
since
the
70s,
and
that
looks
at
Ontario
students
and
again
we
have
looked
at
purchasing
a
larger
sample
so
that
we
can
look
at
Toronto
students
that
data
should
be
available
in
early
2020.
Thanks
and
sorry.
H
You
very
much
mr.
chair
and
through
you
to
the
medical
officer
of
Health
in
the
report,
if
there's
a
specific
section
of
page
79
that
talks
about
mental
health
and
the
addiction
in
the
relationship
to
to
those
living
with
addictions,
it
also
states
that
you
don't
have
enough
information,
but
you've
Jeff
there
to
draw
the
conclusions
that
you
have.
What
is
it?
Do
you
need
in
order
for
you
to
make
that
a
much
clearer
distinction.
C
H
D
H
This
is
probably
not
a
new
area
of
research.
Some
are
the
largest
mental
health
hospital
in
Ontario
is
situated
right
in
the
City
of
Toronto.
They
get
hundreds
of
millions
of
dollars
in
researches
and
there
are
enough
money
out
there
to
do
this
research
and
to
collect
this
data
like.
Why
are
we
still
short
on
information
here?
Well,.
C
Through
the
chair,
perhaps
I
can
speak
to
that.
There
is
still
stigma
surrounding
mental
health
and
coming
forward
with
respect
to
seeking
help
and
attention
for
what
may
be
mental
health
conditions.
I
also
think
that,
as
part
of
that
stigma,
you
get
people
misunderstanding
or
not,
actually
even
recognizing
that
the
symptoms
that
they
experienced
may
be
related
to
mental
health
conditions,
and
they
may
not
seek
any
kind
of
attention
whatsoever.
So
it's
a.
H
Matter
of
the
fact
that
people
are
not
necessarily
knowing
that
they
are
living
with
some
type
of
one
form
of
mental
health
or
another,
not
necessarily
because
there
isn't
enough
money
out
there
in
the
research
world
that
everyone's
circling
that
that
particular
pot
of
cash
and
still
not
producing
the
data.
So.
C
H
Then,
finally,
just
because
I
know
we
don't
have
a
lot
of
time.
The
City
of
Toronto
has
adopted
the
vision,
zero
strategy
trying
to
get
to
zero
collisions
and
deaths
through
enhanced
Road
Safety.
In
the
report,
it
specifically
talks
about
the
fact
that
we've
seen
an
alarming
trend
going
the
other
way
more
collisions
more
incidents
in
the
road
for
road
violence.
H
This
report
was
obviously
generated
before
the
city's
enhanced
road
safety
policy,
and
there
have
been
those
who've
called
the
the
crisis
on
the
city
streets
around
Road
violence,
one
that
needs
to
have
a
public
health
lens.
Do
you
think
that
we've
done
enough
through
the
city's
vision,
zero
strategy?
Have
we
deployed
that
public
health
lens?
Was
your
last
question?
Thank
you.
So.
C
B
H
That's
fine,
I
can
actually
say
it
by
speaking
I
think
as
well
I,
if
you
can't
measure
it,
if
you
can't
measure
it,
you
can't
manage
it.
So
this
is
a
huge
staff
in
in
the
right
direction.
Looking
at
all
the
publicly
available
sources
of
information
out
there
and
I
can
only
assume
that
it
was
a
huge
undertaking
that
involved
a
lot
of
work.
So
staff
are
to
be
highly
commended
in
that.
H
A
A
B
B
A
So
I
would
like
to
see
a
more
fulsome
conversation
at
a
future
board
meeting
about
these
in
the
interim,
given
that
we've
been
having
some
very
important
conversations
about
anti
racism
and
anti
oppression
over
the
last
few
days
and
few
weeks-
and
you
know,
given
the
work
that's
been
undertaken
by
the
Toronto
Police
Service,
for
example,
I
think
this
is
very
important.
The
Ontario
Health
teams
and
the
health
systems
transformation
that's
underway
in
Ontario.
A
Right
now
mentioned
some
components
of
equity,
but
doesn't
set
out
Pacific
accountabilities
for
the
collection
and
use
of
these
data
and
I
think
it's
something
that
is
quite
achievable
for
parties
in
those
teams
and
I
think
it
would
show
leadership
on
the
behalf
of
this
board
to
recommend
that
you
know
the
kinds
of
strategies
that
are
being
undertaken
here
in
Toronto
should
be
taken
throughout
the
healthcare
system.
In
addition
to
the
public
health
system,
where
we
are
thank
you.
G
To
this
table,
we
cannot
let
this
I've
been
around
long
enough
to
know
on
this
board
at
the
province
that
we
cannot
allow
data
to
sit
gather
nother
desk
come
back
this
these
day.
That
information
that's
been
shared
with
us
this
morning
should
be
the
backbone
mr.
chair
for
this
board,
but
more
important
to
Council,
because
at
the
end
of
the
day
we
are
supposed
to
driven
by
data
evidence
right
evidence.
G
So
how
do
we
ensure
the
2020
budget
lens
is
based
on
this
health
check,
because
at
the
end
of
the
day,
it's
means
nothing
to
my
community
to
every
citizen
in
this
great,
proper
City,
because
at
the
end
of
the
day,
mr.
chair
I
am
very
very
concerned
what
councillor
Christian
want
and
just
talked
about
that
vision,
zero.
These
are
preventable
deaths
that
we
just
experienced
in
this
city
and
the
fact
the
matter
here
is
how
do
we
ensure,
through
the
motion
that
Cage's
present
to
the
board,
not
just
about
Ontario
healthcare
team?
G
This
council
has
to
take
some
responsibility
because
we
cannot
allow
another
death
of
a
young
woman
on
our
streets.
That
is
preventable.
So
how
do
we
ensure
that
when
we
pass
a
2020
budget,
we
aren't
starting
that
conversation,
but,
more
importantly,
how
do
we
push
out
to
educate
all
the
communities
we
have?
Such
a
diverse,
City
and
I
want
to
make
sure
the
staff
not
sharing
with
Detroit
police
services,
but
other
agency.
That
is
not
so
prominent
as
fringo
before
us
this
morning,
but
there's
so
many
small
little
community.
G
That
can
be
a
partner
with
us,
whether
it's
eternal
district
school
board
on
a
Catholic
District
School
Board.
But
how
do
we
make
down
to
the
smallest
community
that
they
learn
about
this
piece
because
it
may
not
be
involving
money
because,
often
time
we
talk
about
money?
How
do
we
educate
people
that
we
are
more
aware
right?
So
thank
you.
Thank.
H
H
Make
sure
that
we
are
being
proactive
in
doing
things
that
we
are
doing
in
Toronto
I
just
wanted
to
actually
I
don't
have
a
motion
but
I'm,
hoping
that
these
reports
are
being
shared
with
some
of
these
more
important
agencies,
and
so
that
we
can
go
to
the
next
steps.
I
just
wanted
to
sue
mean
one
lens
about
the
seniors.
I
think
we
do
really
need
to
do
a
lot
of
everybody
else.
You
know
everybody
has
mentioned
something
about
different.
Maybe
the
children
and
I
think
I
like
to
zoom
into
the
senior
population.
H
B
Thank
you
very
much
any
other
speakers.
Okay,
I,
have
a
few
remarks.
First
of
all,
I
want
to
thank
staff
in
Toronto
Public
Health,
for
pulling
this
together.
This
is,
as
dr.
Davila
mentioned,
the
first
comprehensive
report
that
has
been
undertaken
on
a
complete
overview
of
health
status
in
the
City
of
Toronto.
That's
the
first
one.
That's
been
done
since
amalgamation
and
I
think
at
an
overarching
level.
It
demonstrates
that
old,
saying
that
in
Toronto,
an
individuals
postal
code
is
a
better
predictor
of
their
health
than
their
genetic
code.
It's
the
postal
code.
B
It
is
the
social
determinants
of
how
more
than
anything
else,
your
access
to
housing
and
affordable
housing,
the
safety
of
your
streets,
your
access
to
services
and
opportunities,
that
is
the
biggest
driver
of
health
status,
and,
as
this
report
has
demonstrated
in
our
city,
there
are
two
cities
that
have
emerged.
You
have
one
a
city
that
is
the
most
livable
in
the
world.
B
According
to
the
Economist,
a
city
that
is,
has
the
most
construction
with
towers
in
the
screen
of
any
other
city,
with
towers
in
the
sky
of
any
other
city
in
North,
America,
a
city
that
has
become
one
of
the
tech
capitals
of
the
world,
and
then
you
have
another
city
where
we
are
the
inequality
capital
of
Canada,
where
we
are
the
child
poverty,
capital
of
Canada
we're.
Twenty
nine
percent
of
kids
in
this
city
are
living
in
poverty
and,
as
this
report
demonstrated,
where
those
children
are
concentrated
in
neighborhoods
and
racialized
neighborhoods.
B
And
so
if
the
postal
code
is
a
bigger
driver
than
the
genetic
code
of
health
status,
then
we
can
tackle
it
and
I.
Think
that's
when
we
talk
about
prevention
and
upstream
interventions
being
at
the
crux
of
this,
it
demonstrates
the
importance
not
only
of
services
we
deliver
as
public
health,
but
of
policy.
B
And
so
this
is
a
critical
report
that
cannot
be
buried
on
a
shelf
or
lost
on
a
shelf,
I
think
the
being
able
to
track
and
measure
where
we're
succeeding
and
where
we're
failing
has
to
guide
us
going
forward
and
I
want
to
thank
director
Mulligan
for
moving
her
recommendation,
which
I'll
be
supporting
her
amendment,
because
I
think
that
it's
critical
that
we
also
share
this
with
our
partners
at
the
other
levels
of
government.
With
that
we
have
an
amendment,
that's
on
the
screen
from
director
Mulligan,
all
those
in
favor
opposed.
B
If
any
that
has
been
carried.
Thank
you
and
we
do
not
need
to
move
anything
else
on
this
item.I
we're
now
moving
to
item
HL,
9.2,
moving
to
acceptance,
Toronto
public's
health
strategy
to
address
vaccine
hesitancy,
we're
gonna
begin
like
the
last
item
with
a
staff
presentation.
We're
then
going
to
move
to
deputations.
We
have
many
before
taking
it
back
in
committee,
so
I'm
going
to
turn
it
over
to
dr.
B
But
in
order
to
do
that,
I
under
our
procedures,
bylaw,
nobody
is
allowed
to
make
noise
and
when
you
know,
run
around
with
placards
and
all
the
rest
rather
we're
gonna,
listen
and
respect
everybody,
as
we
ask
members
of
the
public
to
do
so
as
well
with
that
I'm
going
to
turn
it
over
to
you,
dr.
Davila,
Thank.
C
You
mr.
chair
I
believe
we're
just
trying
to
call
up
the
presentation
on
the
screen
and
in
fact
that
presentation
will
be
delivered
by
one
of
my
colleagues,
our
associate
medical
officer,
pal
dr.
Vinita,
Dube,
so
I
think
we've
just
found
the
presentation,
we're
just
managing
a
few
technical
issues
and
we'll
be
able
to
take
you
through
this
presentation.
M
Thank
you
to
the
board
for
allowing
this
presentation.
My
name
is
dr.
veena
Dube
and
for
I
do
want
to
start
by
saying:
I
have
no
conflicts
of
interest
to
report;
I
get
no
payment
by
any
pharmaceutical
industries.
I
am
an
employee
of
the
City
of
Toronto,
so
I
think
that's
important
to
the
state
for
this.
For
this
talk
next
slide,
please,
so
just
to
reiterate
what
vaccine
hesitancy
is.
M
It
is
the
reluctance
or
refusal
to
vaccinate
despite
the
availability
of
vaccines,
and
it
is
identified
as
one
of
the
top
10
global
health
threats
by
the
World
Health
Organization
for
2019
in
Canada.
We
estimate
about
20
percent
of
Canadian.
Parents
are
hesitant,
meaning
that
they're
unsure
about
the
safety
and
effectiveness
of
vaccines.
I
want
to
reiterate
that
this
is
distinct
from
those
who
are
truly
opposed
to
and
against
vaccinations
which
make
up
less
than
5%
of
the
population
and
right
now
our
vaccination
rates
in
Toronto
schools
are
good.
M
But
if
our
vaccination
rates
decrease,
it
will
result
in
pockets
of
unpacked
vaccinated
individuals
in
our
city
and
that
can
result
in
outbreaks,
and
so
what
we're
going
to
present
in
this
report
is
a
comprehensive
multi-pronged
strategy
to
address
this
next
slide.
Please.
So
there
are
many
activities
that
we
propose
to
address
vaccine
hesitancy
at
the
local
level.
We
first
want
to
empower
all
of
the
stakeholders,
so
this
includes
healthcare
providers,
parents
and
adults,
students
and
educators
and
the
public
at
large.
M
We've
also
addressed
restricting
advertising
and
false
messages
and
addressing
the
misinformation
on
social
media
and
through
search
engines
in
the
report,
we've
also
made
recommendations
to
enhance
electronic
record-keeping
and
digital
health
solutions.
This
is
to
work
with
our
ministry
partners
so
that
we
can
one
day
achieve
an
electronic
immunization
registry.
M
We
would
also
recommend
including
vaccine
coverage
rates
as
an
accountability
measure
for
healthcare
providers
in
the
newly
established
Ontario
health
teams.
Again
working
with
our
ministry
colleagues
to
the
Ministry
of
Health,
we've
also
made
a
recommendation
to
consider
removing
philosophical
and
religious
exemptions.
The
reason
for
this
is
that
in
2006
we
know
that
our
philosophical
and
religious
exemption
rate
in
Toronto
was
0.8%
and
it
currently
is
1.7
percent.
There
has
been
a
slow
but
steady
increase
in
non-medical
exemptions
in
Toronto,
and
this
has
been
observed
in
Ontario
as
well.
M
M
Another
recommendation
is
for
a
provincial
or
National
Vaccine
injury
compensation
program,
and
so,
while
vaccines
are
safe
in
rare
instances,
serious
reactions
can
occur
and
a
vaccine
injury
compensation
program
is
a
no-fault
compensation
program
funded
by
government
that
compensate
individuals
who
are
potentially
harmed
by
vaccines.
It
would
compensate
for
services
such
as
rehab
for
known
side-effects
of
vaccines
and
not
for
unfounded
claims
of
vaccine
injury.
And,
finally,
the
last
recommendation
I'll
touch
on
is
about
increasing
federal
transparency
regarding
the
safety
of
vaccines.
M
We
know
that
vaccines
continue
to
go
ongoing,
testing
and
scrutiny
through
surveillance,
to
ensure
that
vaccines
continue
to
remain
safe.
All
serious
adverse
events
following
immunization
are
investigated
locally
by
Toronto
Public
Health.
We
then
report
these
provincially
and
then
they're
reported
nationally.
If
a
safety
signal
is
I
did
about
a
vaccine,
a
vaccine
is
taken
off
the
market,
and
this
has
happened.
Making
these
events
more
transparent
will
further
show
that
vaccines
continue
to
be
safe
next
slide,
please.
So.
M
In
conclusion,
a
multi-pronged
strategy
to
address
concerns
from
local
and
international
bodies
is
required
to
address
vaccine
hesitancy.
We
need
to
address
the
misinformation
of
that
about
vaccines
that
are
spread
on
multiple
flat
platforms.
We
also
need
to
enhance
scientific
and
evidence-based
facts
about
vaccines
and
through
health
care
providers.
We
need,
we
need
to
work
together
to
support
the
public
parents,
teachers,
students
to
make
choices
to
promote
the
health
of
themselves
and
their
community.
Thank
you.
B
Thank
you
very
much.
We're
gonna
move
to
deputations
and
then
we'll
bring
it
back
into
committee
for
questions.
We
have
30
debutantes
and
the
first
is
Christine
Colbeck,
it's
Christine
here,
Christine,
please
come
on
up.
You
can
take
a
seat
there
when
you're,
ready,
you'll
have
three
minutes.
There's
a
clock.
You'll
see
on
my
right
and
I'll.
Give
you
a
heads
up
if
you,
if
you're
just
passing.
L
My
name
is
Christine
Colbeck
I
am
the
mother
of
six
children.
My
first
child
Laura
died
a
few
hours
after
an
adverse
reaction
to
her
vaccine.
My
fifth
child
Carter
also
suffered
a
severe
adverse
reaction
to
a
vaccine
that
resulted
in
life-altering
neurological
impairment.
I
stand
here
before
you
today,
as
a
mother,
and
also
a
former
nurse
to
tell
you
that
serious
vaccine
reactions
are
not
just
one
in
a
million,
as
many
people
are
led
to
believe.
There
are
thousands
of
other
families
in
Ontario
who
are
equally
devastated,
living
experiences
as
mine.
L
Our
stories
are
not
convenient,
but
they
are
real
and
they
are
true
and
they
must
be
heard.
I
took
my
daughter
Laura
for
her
first
vaccine
appointment
at
the
age
of
three
months
and
she
was
after
she
was
injected.
Her
leg
became
very
swollen.
She
developed
a
fever
and
had
an
inconsolable
high-pitched
scream
that
we
were
later
told
was
an
encephalitis
cry
less
than
24
hours
after
receiving
her
vaccines.
My
life
was
shattered
when
my
perfectly
healthy
daughter
suddenly
died.
L
The
cause
of
Laura's
death
was
undetermined
and
no
adverse
reaction
report
was
ever
filed
after
Laura's
death.
We
were
very
concerned.
Vaccines
were
not
safe
for
our
family,
but
we
followed
our
doctor's
advice
and
gave
my
next
four
children
a
few
vaccines
at
an
older
age.
Then
at
three
and
a
half,
my
son
Carter
also
suffered
a
similar
adverse
reaction.
Carter
screamed
in
pain
for
hours
and
his
leg
became
extremely
swollen.
He
suffered
neurological
impairment
that
impeded
his
ability
to
live.
A
normal
life.
L
Carter
suddenly
died
just
a
few
months
ago
at
the
age
of
23.
We
do
not
yet
have
any
official
cause
of
death.
After
two
of
my
children
have
been
severely
adverse.
We
had
adverse
reactions
within
hours
of
their
vaccines.
I
completely
stopped
vaccinating
my
children
I'm
a
conscientious
mother
and
was
obviously
Pro
vaccine
and
pro
science
as
I
was
also
a
nurse.
Despite
this
I
am
now
labeled
the
derogatory
term
anti-vaxxer.
My
youngest
child
is
a
wonderful,
healthy
15
year
old
boy
who
is
completely
unvaccinated.
My
son
speaks
to
be
like
she
excels
in
sports.
L
L
If
conscience
and
religious
exemptions
are
removed,
I
will
be
forced
to
decide
if
I
should
risk
losing
yet
another
child,
or
if
my
son
will
lose
his
right
to
education.
This
is
a
decision.
No
parent
should
ever
have
to
make
it's
unacceptable.
It's
unconstitutional
and
immoral
to
force
families
to
choose
between
their
children's
education
and
a
medical
product
that
carries
the
risk
of
permanent
disability
and
death.
I
will
appeal
to
every
parent
in
Ontario
and
every
level
of
government
to
support
me
in
defeating
any
attempt
to
make
vaccines
mandatory
for
school
attendance.
I
will
fight.
B
B
L
N
I
would
like
to
address
my
concern
and
disappointment,
and
the
changes
proposed
to
tackle
a
vaccine
hesitancy
I
feel
that,
in
order
to
speak
about
vaccine
hesitancy,
one
must
have
an
honest
conversation,
but
why
person
will
be
vaccine,
hesitant
one
that
does
not
assume
they're,
ignorant
and
gullible
enough
to
base
their
information
on
the
opinions
of
celebrities
and
fake
news
on
social
media?
Some
of
us
have
either
been
harmed
by
a
vaccine
or
have
taken
the
initiative
to
make
an
informed
decision
after
having
thoroughly
researched
the
subject
and
weighing
both
the
pros
and
the
cons.
N
As
far
as
I
have
seen
an
experience,
there
are
no
pros
and
only
cons.
Let
me
explain
with
my
own
personal
experience
as
a
baby.
My
parents
took
me
the
doctor
and
had
me
vaccinated
at
two
four
and
six
months,
I
suffered
seizures
after
each
dose
and
had
full
body
muscle
spasms
that
would
last
for
hours
after
my
six-month
appointment,
the
spasms
never
left
they
would
present
when
I
was
excited,
happy
or
scared.
I
was
never
vaccinated.
N
Beyond
six
months
when
I
entered
school
with
the
philosophical
exemption,
I
was
delayed,
I
couldn't
focus
and
I
was
always
spaced
out.
At
the
same
time
as
these
developmental
issues
were
happening,
other
physical
issues
were
also
occurring.
I
was
having
what
can
be
described
as
arthritic
symptoms
in
my
hands,
when
I
was
only
7
years.
Old
I
got
my
hand
stuck
in
a
pair
of
scissors
because
they
froze
and
I
was
unable
to
move
my
stiff
fingers.
N
Our
doctor
was
of
no
help
and
we
discovered
a
private
medical
facility
where
I
had
a
number
of
tests
done.
Aluminum
from
aldehyde
in
diphtheria
were
detected
in
the
soft
tissue
joints
of
my
hands.
The
rest
of
my
body
was
stand
for
these
particular
substances
and
they
were
also
in
my
reflex
arc,
which
is
a
processing
center
of
the
brain,
my
thyroid
and
my
liver.
All
of
these
substances
are
in
the
DPT
vaccine,
which
I
had
received
six
and
a
half
years
earlier.
I
know
what
vaccines
did
to
me.
I
have
lasting
debilitating
side
effects.
N
35
years
later,
I
understand.
There
are
people
that
have
experienced
lasting
effects
from
contracting
certain
illnesses
and
I'm,
not
here
to
say
that
their
pain
isn't
worth
hearing.
However,
why
is
there
life
and,
while
being
valued
more
than
those
of
us
who
have
experienced
injury
or
death
from
a
vaccine?
Why
is
my
right
to
choose
for
myself
and
my
family
being
sacrificed
for
someone
else's?
In
fact,
if
someone
else
wants
to
get
vaccinated
and
they
should
have
that,
but
so
should
I
and
every
person
that
doesn't
want
to
I
know
not.
N
Everyone
has
a
noticeable
reaction,
but
I
believe
they
are
far
more
common
they're,
just
not
reported
or
acknowledged,
I.
Consider
myself
lucky
to
have
only
had
seizures
neurological
and
nervous
system
damage.
Knowing
my
history,
I
still
wasn't
afforded
a
medical
exemption
as
a
child.
This
is
because
my
injury
to
the
time
when
it
was
recognized
there
was
too
large
of
a
gap.
N
My
family
doctor
knows
my
medical
history
and
he
knows
that
my
son
is
at
a
high
risk
of
having
a
reaction
like
mine,
but
he
will
not
write
him
a
medical
exemption
because
he's
afraid
of
persecution
that
he
would
receive
from
doing
so
am
I
supposed
to
roll
the
dice
with
his
life
and
just
be
careless,
I'm,
not
willing
to
do
that.
I
will
read
quickly
what
is
on
the
new
$10
bill.
Every
individual
is
equal
before
and
under
the
law
and
has
the
right
to
equal
protection
and
equal
benefit
of
that
law
without
discrimination.
B
O
O
Have
not
begun
to
speak
in
the
clock
as
a
tenth.
Thank
you
for
resetting
the
clock.
Sir
I
am
here
to
defend
our
right
to
inform
consent,
a
parent's
right
to
make
medical
decisions
for
our
children
and
bodily
sovereignty.
My
wife,
Margaret
and
I
do
this.
In
the
name
of
our
vaccine,
injured,
son
Mark,
who
received
three
hepatitis
B
vaccines
in
grade
seven,
his
normal
brain
function
was
compromised,
shattering
all
our
lives
forever.
O
A
policy
of
denial
in
1984,
the
Federal
Register,
the
Official
Journal
of
the
US
government
containing
agency
rules
and
public
notices
stated
the
following
about
the
polio
vaccine.
Any
possible
doubts
whether
or
not
well-founded
cannot
be
allowed
to
exist.
Here's
a
quote:
it
has
become
increasingly
clear
that
medical
revisionism
is
at
the
root
of
this
hysteria.
O
This
I
mean
the
manipulation
of
historical
and
epidemiological
facts.
In
order
to
drive
a
specific
agenda,
the
agenda
is
about
inflating
the
fear
of
ordinary
beneficial
childhood
diseases,
while
denying
vaccine
risks
and
failure.
Suppress
is
the
facts
that
vaccine
derived
immunity
wanes
over
time,
leaving
swathes
of
people
susceptible
to
measles.
It's
about
demonizing
the
disease
in
order
to
erase
a
seidel
memory
of
the
long-term
benefit
of
natural
herd.
Immunity
previously
enjoyed
by
the
vast
majority
of
people
now
decimated
by
mass
vaccination
at
a
West
president
vaccine
choice.
O
Canada
this
Statistics
Canada
mortality
table
I'm
holding
up
the
takeaway
from
this
table
is
for
the
20-year
period
between
1990
and
2009.
The
annual
number
of
deaths
from
measles
in
Canada
has
either
been
zero
or
one.
This
means
the
chance
of
death
by
measles,
for
any
Canadian
is
either
zero
or
one
in
three
hundred
one
in
333
million.
The
risk
is
infinitesimal
and
is
actually
much
lower
than
the
risk
of
serious
damage
from
MMR
vaccines.
A
summary
of
this
agenda
items
stated
vaccine
hesitancy.
O
The
reluctance
or
refusal
to
vaccinate
despite
the
availability
of
vaccines
is
growing
in
Canada.
To
that
I
say
you
never
speak
to
the
question
of
safety
of
vaccines,
which
is
what
causes
the
reluctance
and
hesitation
and
refusal
to
vaccinate
in
the
first
place.
You
then
state
it
stems
in
large
part
from
misinformation
about
vaccines
that
spreads
on
social
media
platforms
and
the
Internet
in
April
I
addressed
this
committee.
Everything
I
said
was
scientifically
verifiable
information.
It
was
not
misinformation,
it
was
missed.
O
Information
that
you
so
routinely
censor
and
desperately
wish
would
never
see
the
light
of
day
Toronto's
chief
medical
officer
of
Health,
dr.
Eileen
Davila
in
the
summary
of
her
list
of
recommendations,
stated
to
respond
to
this
growing
threat.
Dr.
Davila,
there
is
no
threat
unless
you
wish
to
claim
that
the
Statistics
Canada
mortality
table
I,
just
held
up
and
quoted
from,
is
also
misinformation.
O
Vaccination
is
not
evidence-based
medicine,
it
is
ideology
and
effectively
a
religion.
We
insist
on
science
being
done
as
the
basis
for
our
medicine.
Let's
be
clear,
the
work
of
science
has
nothing
to
do
with
consensus.
Consensus
is
the
business
of
politics.
My
family
and
I
will
not
consent
to
the
loss
of
our
rights
and
freedoms
which
are
guaranteed
by
the
Canadian
Charter
of
Rights
and
Freedoms.
Thank
you
thank.
B
B
A
Morning,
I'm
here
representing
vaccine
choice,
Canada
we
advocate
for
informed
consent
and
voluntary
vaccination
decisions.
We
represent
thousands
of
families
across
Canada.
My
name
is
Giselle
Baraboo
I'm,
one
of
seven
directors
of
vaccine
choice.
Canada,
we
all
vaccinated
our
children,
but
I
am
the
only
one
who
does
not
have
a
vaccine
injured
child
and
two
of
my
colleagues
lost
their
children
as
a
result
of
their
vaccine
injuries.
There
is
much
to
discussion
in
your
recommendations,
but
I
will
just
address
the
issue
of
mandating
vaccines
or
the
removal
of
exemptions
on
this
issue.
A
The
science
is
a
mile
high
a
mile
wide
and
a
mile
deep,
and
it's
hardly
settled.
I
have
four
quick
points.
Mandates
are
not
necessary.
There's
no
health
emergency.
Here
we
have
we've
had
a
hundred
and
eleven
measles
cases
reported
to
date
in
this
country
of
37
million
people.
Pun
intended
that
it's
measly
no
one
died.
Measles
is
generally
a
benign
short-term,
violent
viral
infection
and
99.99%
of
measles
cases
fully
recovered
the
real
healthcare
crisis.
You
just
heard
it
in
your
first
agenda
item
focus
your
time
and
your
money
on
that.
A
Second,
point:
mandates
won't
work.
Artificial
herd
immunity
is
a
failed
theory
explaining
this
is
much
more
complicated
than
one
can
communicate
in
sound
bites
or
in
mere
minutes.
Read
the
science
third
point:
the
vaccine
schedule
has
not
been
proven
safe
and
pay
attention
here,
because
some
of
you
may
not
know
this
vaccines
are
classified
as
biologics
and
are
exempt
from
the
strict
and
extensive
safety
testing
required
of
all
other
drugs.
The
result
is
that
no
childhood
vaccine
product
licensed
for
use
in
Canada
has
been
safety
tested
using
the
same
standards
required
of
other
medical
products.
A
The
medical
industry
uses
the
monitoring
of
adverse
events
following
vaccination
as
a
primary
method
to
evaluate
safety.
Our
passive
injury
reporting
system
for
collate
collecting
data
is
utterly
inadequate.
The
u.s.
system
is
somewhat
better
and
their
own
Commission
study
concluded.
Fewer
than
1%
of
adverse
events
are
reported.
Jennifer
left
I
will
quote
her.
If
you
can't
measure
it,
you
can't
manage
it
point
number
4
mandates
are
a
violation
of
fundamental
human
rights.
A
We
don't
need
exceptions
because
mandates
themselves
are
unconstitutional
if
we
don't
have
the
most
basic
of
Rights,
those
of
self
autonomy
and
bodily
integrity
and
the
right
to
protect
our
children
from
known
harm.
What
meaningful
rights
do
we
have?
A
few
of
you
are
even
looking
me
in
the
eye.
In
summary,
my
challenge
to
you
is
threefold:
think
long
and
hard
about
bringing
on
government
enforce
medical
mandates,
medical
treatments,
because
this
will
come
back
on
you
personally
on
your
children
and
on
your
grandchildren.
A
Second,
if
you
want
to
truly
reduce
vaccine
hesitancy,
talk
to
us,
we
have
produced
a
16-point
brochure
on
what
will
and
won't
work.
It's
right
up
there
and
I
will
leave
copies
for
you
third
point
be
careful
what
you
wish
for
Mandy
its
connection:
fuel,
more
vaccine
hesitancy,
witness
what
you
see
here.
There
is
a
reason
that
this
is
the
fastest
growing
movement
internationally.
Thank
you
for
your
time.
Thank
you.
B
P
Would
be
nice
if
the
counselors
on
their
cell
phones
would
pay
attention?
Give
us
the
respect
that
we've
gave
you
the
main
motivation
behind
compulsory
vaccine
initiatives
is
herd
immunity.
The
idea
is
that
the
more
people
that
are
vaccinated
the
more
protection
there
will
be
for
the
whole,
the
public
health
establishment
borrowed
the
herd,
immunity
concept
from
the
pre
vexing
observations
of
natural
disease
outbreaks.
Then,
without
any
apparent
supporting
science
officials
applied
the
concept
to
vaccinations
using
it
not
only
to
justify
mass
vaccinations
but
to
guilt-trip
anyone
objecting
to
the
nation's
increasingly
onerous
vaccine
mandates.
P
However,
herd
immunity
is
undermined
by
high
rates
of
vaccine
failures.
Hence
the
growing
call
for
more
and
more
booster
shots
vaccine
immunity
does
not
equal
lifelong
immunity,
which
is
acquired
after
natural
exposure.
The
Quebec
measles
outbreak
demonstrates
that
even
a
vaccination
rate
over
95%
didn't
prevent
an
outbreak
herd.
Immunity
rates
are
based
on
statistical
modeling
and
our
only
projections.
The
reason
that
50%
of
measles
cases
occurred
in
vaccinated
children
is
primary
or
secondary
vaccine
failure,
which
means
the
vaccine
never
produced
immunity
or
the
immunity
was
lost
over
time
for
most
vaccines.
P
Primary
and
secondary
failures
go
unnoticed
because
children
are
not
being
exposed
to
most
of
these
infectious
infections
anymore,
the
infections
children
do
get
exposed
to
our
whooping
cough
and
influenza,
and
then
vaccine
failure
is
obvious
because
most
cases
of
whooping
cough
and
many
of
influenza
occur
in
fully
vaccinated
children.
In
fact,
health
compromised
children
are
at
more
risk
from
the
shedding
of
live
viruses
in
vaccines
by
other
children
who
were
recently
vaccinated.
P
Studies
show
that
the
fully
vaccinated
majority
are
as
likely
to
be
infected
with
and
can
transmit
diseases,
as
the
unvaccinated
minority
chickenpox
cannot
be
eradicated
both
because
the
vaccine
is
not
optimal
and
waning
occurs
and
because
the
virus
stays
in
your
body
permanently
after
vaccination
or
infection.
By
the
way,
the
UK
does
not
vaccinate
children
for
chickenpox
because
it
is
a
mild
childhood
illness
and
they
don't
want
a
shingles
epidemic.
A
peer-reviewed
research
paper,
titled
herd,
immunity,
history
theory
practice
concludes
that
the
science
behind
the
herd,
immunity
theory
is
not
settled
to
us.
P
Legal
scholars
have
shown
that
60
years
of
compulsory
vaccine
policies
have
not
attained
herd
immunity
for
any
childhood
disease.
It
is
time
to
cast
aside
coercion
in
favor
of
voluntary
choice.
Perhaps
Toronto
Public
Health
would
be
wiser
to
spend
more
time
energy
and
money
on
proven
health
outcomes
like
ensuring
children
have
access
to
nutritious
food,
helping
families
understand
the
disease
prevention
benefits
of
breastfeeding,
helping
families
reduce
their
exposure
in
environmental
toxins
and
so
on.
B
B
B
I
Please
don't
give
me
a
warning
because
at
that
time
this
so
carefully
you'll.
Just
distract
me.
If
you
give
me
a
warning
ahead,
that
I
spoke
to
you
in
April
about
some
things.
I've
learned
about
vaccines
since
becoming
a
grandmother
today,
I
want
to
discuss
censorship.
The
Board
of
Health
is
being
encouraged
to
join
and
amplify.
What's
become
a
major
movement
towards
severe
restrictions
on
access
to
information,
about
possible
downsides
to
vaccinations,
actual
risks
and
side
effects.
Google
is
restricting
searches
for
this
information.
The
censorship
pace
has
really
picked
up
this
year.
I
I
It's
pretty
surprising
how
deeply
vaccine
orthodoxy
continues
to
be
accepted
among
us
when
you
consider
that
the
very
industry
that
brought
us
the
lid,
amide
Vioxx,
the
opioid
crisis
and
many
other
drug
scandals
is
the
exact
one
we
put
our
trust
in
to
make
vaccines
and
that
they
were
released
by
US
Congress
in
1986
for
liability
for
any
harms
their
vaccines
cause.
It
seems
like
some
pretty
serious
cognitive
dissonance
as
it
work
here.
You
do
know.
The
Toronto
library
system
is
already
deliberately
restricting
books
about
vaccines
available
to
its
reading
public.
I
Earlier
this
year,
I
and
others
asked
the
library
to
buy
some
informative
books
about
vaccines,
one
of
them,
a
best-seller
from
the
day
of
its
publication,
I
was
told
books
by
md's
would
be
favored
which
doesn't
really
make
sense,
given
that
anyone
can
do
deep
research
and
publish
a
compelling
book,
I
put
in
a
request
for
five
books,
two
of
them
by
M
DS,
no
dice,
not
one,
has
been
added
to
the
library
collection.
I
can
read
mine
camp
at
the
Toronto
library,
but
not
dr.
I
I
About
a
week
later,
I
put
in
a
request
for
a
book
about
the
1986
Chernobyl
nuclear
accident
that
one
came
in
lickety-split
our
library
system
here
in
Toronto
practicing
active
censorship
and
restriction
of
information.
Are
you
really?
Okay
with
that
seems
to
me
like
a
pretty
slippery
slope,
those
of
us
who've
done
our
research
know.
There
is
plentiful,
scientific
evidence
about
risks
and
harms
associated
with
vaccines.
Hey
just
read
a
vaccine
insert
before
they
start
trimming
information
out
of
them.
I
That
is
when
you
follow
the
money
regarding
the
role
of
the
pharmaceutical
industry
and
vaccines
in
modern
health
care.
What
do
you
find?
A
hugely
profitable
industry
profits,
skyrocketing
measles
scares
are
very
good
for
Merck
and
no
incentive
to
make
vaccines
safer
and
more
effective.
Given
that
1986
released
from
liability,
please
do
some
research
into
the
pharmaceutical
industry.
Lobbying
that
took
place
in
New
Brunswick
this
year,
I
provided
a
link
in
my
letter
of
20
questions
sent
to
you
last
week,
I'd.
I
Are
all
entitled
to
bodily
integrity
and
the
right
to
refuse
medical
procedures?
We
have
reason
to
fear,
may
cause
us
or
our
children
harm.
This
must
never
interfere
with
our
children's
right
to
receive
a
public
education.
We
are
also
entitled
to
the
free
and
open
circulation
of
information.
These
are
our
rights
in
a
free
and
democratic
society.
Thank
you
very
much.
B
B
Q
Injury,
okay,
I
began
my
vaccine
research.
36
years
ago.
I
went
to
hear
dr.
Robert,
Mendelsohn
and
pediatrician
speak
on
MMR
after
30
years
of
giving
shots.
He
noticed
the
same
number
of
kids
got
measles,
whether
vaccinated
or
not,
and
the
vaccinated
kids
were
sicker.
He
said
there
were
no
benefits,
only
risks
we
were
injecting
latent
retroviruses
and
our
children
to
emerge
later,
as
autoimmune
diseases
like
cancer
I
determined.
Never
to
give
the
MMR
shot
to
my
baby.
Q
I
bought
his
book
how
to
raise
a
healthy
child
in
spite
of
your
doctor,
but
didn't
read
it
right
away
because
he
didn't
mention
DBT
in
his
lecture.
My
daughter
got
those
shots.
She
screamed
for
four
hours
straight
staring
with
dilated
eyes.
Everyone
said
that's
normal,
so
I
took
her
back
for
two
more
assaults
on
her
body.
She
developed
many
seizures
where
a
whole
body
vibrated
when
I
finally
read
dr.
Mendelssohn's
book
I
learned
the
DPT
shot
was
as
bad
as
the
MMR.
Q
The
screaming
and
seizures
were
caused
by
the
vaccine,
affecting
her
nervous
system
resulting
in
learning
and
physical
disabilities.
My
next
child
did
not
get
DBT
shots.
He
did
catch
whooping
cough
from
two
vaccinated
children
who
came
to
her
house,
but
he
recovered
quickly
and
their
their
coughs
lasted
for
four
months.
Not
knowing
dr.
M
had
changed.
His
stance
on
tetanus
I
took
my
son
Jonathan
to
get
a
tetanus
shot
at
four
years
old.
He
went
out
to
play
and
within
an
hour
neighbor's
carried
him
home
because
he
couldn't
walk.
Q
He
literally
had
locked
me
and
couldn't
bend
one
leg.
He
looked
at
me
with
reproach
and
said
mummy.
Why
did
you
let
that
man
do
this
to
me?
For
a
week
he
dragged
his
leg
trying
to
bend
it
the
effect
gradually
wore
off,
but
he
recently
told
me
he
thought
he
would
never
run
again.
That
was
his
one
and
only
shot
and
he's
a
healthy
33
year
old,
new
scenario.
My
daughter,
Shannon
7th
birthday,
kids
eating
and
painting
faces
next
day.
Q
Patsy's
party
same
thing
third
day
vaccinated,
Pat's,
yep,
measles,
I'm,
back
Shannon
doesn't,
but
she
gets
sent
home
from
school
for
a
week.
Patsy
was
contagious
at
our
house,
so
Shannon
she
had
got
them
back
to
school
for
a
day
in
one
more
measles
case.
Another
week
off
and
then
2
more
later
on,
I
thought
she
might
miss
the
whole
year.
So
iPhone,
Queens,
Park
and
I
got
a
hearing
I
lectured
for
two
hours
and
gave
out
16
pages
on
vaccine
injury.
The
court
reporters
thanked
me.
Q
She
had
never
heard
any
of
this
and
had
a
new
baby
as
Tonto
Star
reporter
was
there.
In
the
next
day,
CBC
interviewed
me
I'm
a
phone
ringing
off
the
hook.
Parents
asking
for
help
I
called
Etta
who
had
lobbied
for
the
exemption
in
1984
and
a
support
group
was
started.
The
grassroots
beginning
of
vaccine
choice,
Canada
a
website
where
science-based
facts
are
presented
along
with
heartbreaking
stories
of
vaccine
injuries.
I
met
a
lady
whose
baby
died
the
day
he
received
his
six-week
shot,
but
the
coroner
puts
SIDS
on
the
death
certificate.
Q
Q
B
H
Morning,
I
have
three
unvaccinated
children.
I
am
here
to
defend
our
right
to
inform
consent
in
a
parent's
right
to
not
have
their
child
drugged
in
order
to
go
to
school.
I
have
read
manufacturer
inserts.
The
MMR
has
listed
under
adverse
reactions,
type
1,
diabetes,
anaphylaxis,
the
PDS
L,
insert
states,
sudden
infant
death
syndrome
or
SIDS
has
occurred
in
infants
following
administration
of
dtap
vaccines.
Worst
of
all,
of
course,
is
section
thirteen
point,
one
that
states
this
product
has
not
been
evaluated
for
the
potential
to
cause
Carson,
carcinogenicity,
genotoxicity
or
impairment
of
fertility.
H
I
am
not
willing
to
subject
this
type
of
harm
over
benign
childhood
illnesses.
With
these
adverse
reactions
be
better
than
the
chickenpox,
my
kids
so
easily
lived
through
I.
Think
not
all
three
of
my
daughters
were
competitive
swimmers
in
our
competitive
canoe,
kayakers
they've
competed
in
high
school
sports,
getting
gold
at
offs,
I
headed
yearbook
committee
student
councils.
They
went
academic
awards
athletic
awards
scholarships
that
I
look
forward
to
a
very,
very
bright
future.
They
are
productive,
healthy,
happy
people
that
give
more
than
they
take
their
teachers.
H
Tell
me
constantly
how
blessed
I
am
to
have
them
some,
even
asking
me
what
makes
them.
So,
what
is
my
parenting
secret
I
tell
you
this
today,
not
because
I
want
to
brag
trust
me,
although
I
do,
but
because
these
are
the
very
students
trying
a
Board
of
Health
is
wanting
to
remove
from
our
schools.
My
freedoms
were
endowed
to
me
by
my
Creator,
the
Charter
of
Rights
and
Freedoms.
Is
there
to
remind
elected
and
non-elected
officials
of
that?
H
Should
you
breach
that
scope,
but
you
already
have
by
requiring
written
and
notarized
exemptions,
coupled
with
your
zero
conversion
propaganda
clauses,
you
have
already
overstepped
your
boundaries
as
per
the
Esper,
the
Nuremberg
code.
The
voluntary
consent
of
the
human
subject
is
absolutely
essential.
I
applaud
you
wanting
to
remove
the
philosophical
and
religious
exemptions
and
I.
Ask
that
you
remove
the
medical
ones
as
well.
Vaccination
is
voluntary
in
Canada
and
as
simple
No
thank
you
is
all
that
is
required.
H
I
always
tell
my
kids
to
say
no
to
drugs,
because
we
all
have
the
freedom
to
refuse
to
have
our
skin
broken.
Our
bodies
assaulted,
with
an
injection
against
our
will.
We
do
not
want
MRC
v
or
wi
38
derived
from
aborted
fetuses
aluminum
neomycin
formaldehyde
thimerosal
polysorbate
80
glyphosate
in
super
into
our
bodies
in
2017
Robert,
DeNiro
and
Robert
F
Kennedy
jr.
offered
a
hundred
thousand
to
anyone
who
could
provide
proof.
Vaccines
are
safe.
The
prize
went
unclaimed,
currently
dr.
H
Shiva
ayyadurai,
a
four-time
MIT
graduate
has
offered
his
10
million
dollar
building
in
Cambridge
Massachusetts
to
anyone
who
can
show
him
a
risk
assessment
model
for
vaccine
safety,
allowing
any
parent
to
decide
based
on
their
kids,
particular
biology,
the
risk
of
giving
the
current
mandated
schedule
of
vaccines.
Will
you
accept
that
challenge?
Removing
vaccine
information,
then
I
do
not
consent
to
having
myself
don't
write
children
for
vaccinated
drugged
and
medically
medically
induced
in
order
to
attend
public
schools.
Thank.
B
N
Am
here
today
I'm
a
registered
nurse
and
I'm
here
as
a
Canadian
citizen
who
believes
and
supports
bodily
autonomy
and
the
right
to
informed
consent?
I
am
here
to
speak
to
the
removal
of
the
exemptions
and
the
issue
of
vaccine
safety.
Vaccination
is
an
invasive
medical
procedure
which
carries
risks.
Any
effort
to
make
vaccinations
mandatory
contravenes
the
Canadian
Charter
of
Rights
and
Freedoms.
We
are
permitted
to
question
or
opt
out
out
of
any
medical
procedure
that
a
healthcare
provider
recommends.
N
So
why
should
the
choice
to
not
vaccinate
be
any
different
on
April
8
2019,
our
associate
medical
of
office
of
health
presented
that
70%
of
parents
are
concerned
about
the
side
effects
of
vaccines.
20%
are
vaccine,
hesitant,
so
I
have
to
ask
you.
Where
are
the
studies
to
quell
the
concerns
that
the
vaccine
hesitant
parents
have?
Where
are
the
studies
that
show
that
vaccines
are
safe
and
effective?
N
Many
parents
have
written
to
Health
Canada,
requesting
evidence
of
these
studies,
and
we
have
been
repeatedly
given
standard
responses
that
do
not
disclose
any
safety
studies.
The
only
safety
studies
that
seem
to
exist
are
those
who
are
fully
funded
by
the
pharmaceutical
companies.
How
is
that
not
considered
a
conflict
of
interest?
How
can
the
issue
of
addressing
vaccine
hesitancy
possibly
be
taken
seriously
when
you
are
recommending
financial
incentives
to
be
offered
to
healthcare
providers?
N
You
cannot
continue
to
repeat
the
slogan
safe
and
effective
when
there
are
thousands
of
studies
within
the
medical
literature
done
by
independent
researchers
that
demonstrates
there
are
serious
detrimental
side
effects
that
result
directly
from
vaccines,
one
of
which
includes
stuff.
As
for
the
question
pertaining
to
where
vaccine
hesitant
parents
obtain
their
information,
I
know
that
I
as
well
as
many
other
parents
refer
to
studies
that
are
published
in
peer-reviewed
medical
journals.
We
do
not
refer
to
dr.
Google,
as
people
like
to
keep
perpetuating.
N
The
many
parents
I
have
met,
who
choose
to
opt
out
of
vaccinating
their
children
are
highly
educated.
Many
of
them
are
also
healthcare
professionals
and
I'm
just
curious.
How
many
of
you
here
are
aware
of
the
fact
that
the
MMR
DTaP,
hip
and
Hep
B
vaccines
have
not
been
tested
for
carcinogenicity
toxicity
or
for
long-term
adverse
reactions,
and
that
information
is
not
misinformation.
It
is
found
right
in
the
vaccine.
Manufacturers
inserts
the
safety
of
the
CDC's
childhood
vaccination
schedule
has
never
been
affirmed
in
any
critical
studies
to
be
safe.
N
B
N
I'm,
saying
is
that
if
vaccines
become
in
a
compensation
program
is
imposed,
then
the
manufacturer
will
have
zero
product
liability
and
they
will
have
no
incentive
to
improve
product
safety
and
I
just
want
to
close
with
stating
that
the
Canadian
public,
through
our
Constitution,
has
the
right
to
inform
consent,
and
that
includes
the
right
of
refusal
to
any
medical
procedures
of
any
kind,
including
vaccinations.
Thank.
B
J
My
five-year-old
son
Grayson
is
Siviglia
neurologically,
injured
from
vaccines
and
today,
I'll
be
talking
as
a
mother
of
a
vaccine,
injured,
child
and
one
that
would
give
the
world
who
have
been
vaccine
hesitant
five
years
ago,
as
you
speak
of
misinformation
in
April
I
attended
the
open
caucus
for
Canadian
vaccine
hesitancy
in
Ottawa
I
was
flawed
at
the
inaccurate
information
the
panel
used
to
reassure
parents
on
vaccines
after
emailing
Canada
chief
medical
officer.
She
responded
agreeing
the
information
was
incorrect,
but
failed
to
publicly
correct
the
misinformation
given
that
day
and
in
public
health
pamphlets.
J
My
son's
doctor
said:
if
Grayson
gets
another
vaccine,
it
will
be
like
lighting
a
match
inside
his
brain.
However,
due
to
the
immense
pressure
doctors
receive,
he
is
scared
to
write
the
medical
exemption.
This
leads
only
the
personal
belief
exemption
which
he
has,
but
if
taken
away,
the
vaccines
will
not
have
only
stripped
away
his
opportunity
to
thrive
in
life,
but
also
his
ability
to
attend
school
after
a
night
here
that
children
of
exemptions
are
putting
immune
compromised.
J
Children
at
risk
I
have
yet
to
hear
of
a
single
case
in
Canada,
where
an
immune
compromised
child
got
an
infectious
disease
directly
from
a
child
with
an
exemption.
However,
the
personal
stories
and
vaccine
injury
databases
are
examples
of
thousands
of
children
being
injured
by
vaccines
earlier
so
essentially
you're
trading,
one
vulnerable
group
of
children.
That
sava
have
very
little
to
no
proof
that
removing
these
exemptions
will
help
them
for
another
group
of
vulnerable
children.
Where
many
already
have
the
proven
injury
and
a
strong
likelihood
of
reoccurrence
I
am
here
to
tell
you.
J
You've
got
this
wrong
by
taking
away
exemptions,
you're
not
protecting
our
babies.
You
are
killing
and
injuring
them
and
for
what
purpose?
Do
you
think
infectious
disease
stops
at
the
school
gates?
You
stopped
in
vaccinated
children
going
to
school
that
they
won't
go
out
in
public
again
I'd
love
to
see
the
studies
at
state
measles
only
infects
children
on
school
property,
and
if
that
study
doesn't
exist,
and
this
whole
theory
of
yours
is
flawed
and
useless,
it's
come
barren.
J
It's
comparable
to
locking
up
a
prison
for
only
half
of
the
day
and
expecting
no
one
to
escape
when
it
comes
to
hurt
immunity.
The
only
part
of
that
term
I
agree
with
is
heard.
It's
really
quite
genius
of
the
vaccine.
Companies
take
our
product
that
has
zero
liability,
but
just
not
it
will
only
work
for
you
if
everybody
else
buys
it
too.
J
So
then
the
heard
sleep
walk
themselves
to
all
line
up
for
that
shot
of
norm
poisons
and
neurotoxins
and
when
they
still
get
sick,
they
blame
it
on
the
people
that
didn't
do
the
exact
same
thing
as
them.
Everybody's
thinking
the
same
thing.
Yet
no
one
is
thinking
at
all.
Parents
do
this
because
everybody
else
is
doing
it.
Have
you
seen
everybody
else's
children?
Nineteen.
Eighty
six
twelve
point:
eight
percent
of
children
had
a
chronic
disease
2019.
J
That
was
naive
of
me
of
us,
but
if
you
think
you
can
do
it
all
again
in
front
of
our
faces
now
we
know
the
truth,
then
it
is
no
longer,
as
that
have
been
the
naive
ones,
our
favor.
What
happened
to
our
children
is
unshakable,
and
it
would
be
a
mistake
to
think
that
we
won't
protect
that
part
of
our
children
with
the
vaccines
didn't
take
with
everything
we
have.
Every
steps
always
get.
J
B
N
Hi
everyone,
my
name,
is
Jill
primo
Lee
I
live
in
Mississauga
now
and
previously
lived
in
Toronto.
All
three
of
our
children
were
born
at
Sunnybrook
Hospital.
Three
years
ago
we
lost
our
son
Jude
following
a
flu
outbreak
at
our
school
on
Monday
May,
2nd
2016
I,
received
a
call
from
my
daughter's
kindergarten
teacher
telling
me
that
she'd
suddenly
developed
a
fever.
It
was
at
that
point
that
I
learned
that
there
had
been
a
nasty
bug
going
through
the
class
for
several
weeks
and
it
had
already
affected
most
of
the
kids.
N
Some
fairly
seriously
I
loved
was
better
in
less
than
24
hours
and
we
kept
her
home
until
Thursday
to
make
sure
we
wouldn't
further
spread
infection
on
Friday
May
6
Jude,
one
of
my
two
year
old
twins
woke
up
with
a
low-grade
fever
but
showed
no
other
symptoms.
He
died
that
afternoon
during
his
nap
three
feet
away
from
his
brother.
The
cause
of
death
later
confirmed
as
influenza
B
causing
cardiac
arrest,
Jude
had
otherwise
been
perfectly
healthy.
Never
giving
us
cause
for
concern.
We've
always
vaccinated
on
schedule,
including
the
annual
flu
shot.
N
Jude
had
received
his
flu
shot.
Six
months
earlier:
well,
we
know
vaccination
is
our
best
first
offense
against
preventable
illnesses.
We
also
know
that
a
certain
percentage
of
people
will
fail
to
develop
immunity
from
their
own
vaccinations.
We
can't
predict
who
those
people
will
be
three
years
ago.
N
When
we
make
a
decision
about
whether
or
not
to
vaccinate
our
children,
we
aren't
only
deciding
whether
we're
willing
to
risk
our
own
kids
contracting,
a
preventable
disease,
we're
also
making
a
decision
for
other
families
that
will
either
increase
or
decrease
the
level
of
risk
we're
posing
on
them.
Vaccination
isn't
simply
a
personal
choice,
but
a
public
one,
because
it's
a
choice
that
impacts
every
single
person
we
come
in
contact
with.
We
aren't
vaccinating
children
against
these
diseases
because
they're
inconvenient,
but
because,
when
we
don't
people
die
vaccine
hesitancy
is
a
growing
problem.
N
Today,
there's
a
great
deal
of
misinformation
about
vaccinations
and
often
the
loudest
voices
in
the
conversation
or
the
most
extreme.
We
all
want,
what's
best
for
our
kids
and
with
so
much
doubt
planted
many
parents
feel
unsure
about
what
that
is.
We
can't
be
complacent
in
the
face
of
this
trend
with
increasing
numbers
of
people
choosing
not
to
vaccinate
either
fully
or
in
part,
seeing
larger
holes
in
the
vaccine
safety
net
that
prevents
diseases
from
spreading
throughout
our
population.
We
all
know
the
kids
are
wonderful
but,
let's
be
honest,
sometimes
they're
disgusting.
N
They
wipe
their
noses
with
their
hands.
They'd
lick
things
they
touch
each
other.
They
often
forget
to
cover
their
coughs
and
sneezes
and
a
classroom
full
of
young
ones.
Doing
this.
That's
an
environment
where
disease
can
spread
easily
and
that's
why
we
need
to
do
a
better
job
together
of
vaccinating
as
a
first
defense
against
illness.
N
B
N
So
thank
you
for
the
opportunity
to
come
and
speak
with
you
today.
The
topic
of
vaccines
and
vaccine
hesitancy
has
been
getting
a
lot
of
media
attention.
Unfortunately,
unfortunately,
by
careful
manipulation
of
media,
they
are
trying
to
successfully
divide
a
population
against
itself
and
fear
through
misinformation
I'm
here
to
defend
our
right
to
inform
consent.
N
A
parent's
right
to
make
medical
decisions
for
their
children
embody
sovereignty
in
2009
I
was
pregnant,
with
my
first
child
being
fully
vaccinated
according
to
government
standards
being
fully
vaccinated
at
that
time,
I
never
questioned
vaccines
or
vaccine
safety
and
I
blindly
trusted.
So
when
I
was
told,
I
needed
the
flu
shot
to
protect
my
own
poor
child
I
trusted
and
took
that
shot.
My
health
began
to
changed
after
the
flu
shot.
I
was
assassin,
fibromyalgia,
rheumatoid
arthritis,
things
got
worse.
N
Food
intolerance
has
developed
facial
paralysis,
projectile
vomiting
beef
and
egg
I
developed
allergy
to
penicillin,
and
then
I
had
adverse
reinvents
to
all
antibiotics,
so
I
can't
use
them
anymore.
I
was
informed
by
Canadian
medical
doctor
that
neomycin
egg
and
bull
fine
are
actually
in
that
flu
vaccine.
What
he
did
not
know
was
this
vaccine
was
not
approved.
For
us,
it
was
not
pre
proved
for
use
during
pregnancy,
myself
and
other
women
were
the
test
subjects.
N
I
was
not
and
provided
at
all
informed
consent
fast
forward
to
this
year
in
Washington,
DC
February,
11th
2019
in
response
to
the
Freedom
of
Information
Act
lawsuit,
the
FDA
has
admitted
for
the
first
time.
The
government
agency
is
including
the
CDC
are
recommending
vaccines
for
pregnant
women
and
have
neither
been
licensed
for
pregnant
mothers
by
the
FDA
nor
tested
for
clinical
nor
tested
for
safety
and
clinical
trials.
The
manufacturers
of
the
flu
and
the
D
top
vaccines
warned
against
their
use
for
pregnant
women.
Mothers
sensor
safety
has
not
been
established.
N
Package
insert
state
that
this
is
not
known
whether
the
vaccines
will
harm
the
unborn
baby,
and
there
are
significant
data
onto
the
use
of
using
this
within
for
pregnant
women
to
inform
to
inform
vaccine
associated
risks.
Long-Term
safety
studies
have
not
been
designed
to
detect
vaccine
related
fetal
injuries,
but
a
2017
Fraser
study
of
over
45
thousand
women
published
in
the
JAMA
Pediatrics,
showed
us
elevated
risk,
live
birth
defects
and
a
20%
higher
risk
of
autism
and
children,
whose
mothers
received
a
first
semester
flu
shot.
N
When
did
I
get
mine
first
semester
so
now
I
will
dress
the
Toronto
Board
of
Health
each
one
of
you
have
a
platform.
Here.
You
are
to
support
new
people
new
to
Canada,
Canada,
support
and
fight
for
quality
children,
the
environment,
they
marginalised,
the
same
rates
for
all.
You
want
that
for
everybody.
What
are
we
doing
here,
trying
to
remove
exemptions
for
those
who
actually
did
what
was
required
of
us
and
then
had
an
adverse
event
to
that
vaccine?
So
no
one
in
this
office,
no
one
right
now
is
actually
up
to
date.
N
Not
one
of
you.
We
are
all
not
up
to
our
children's
schedule.
Do
you
understand
what
that
means?
You're
asking
for
our
children
to
have
more
vaccines
given
to
them
than
we
ourselves
were
ever
given.
So
my
question
to
you
is
a
doctor
needs
consent.
Nurses
in
East
consent
mrs.
nice
consent.
We
do
not
need
consent
to
say
no.
Who
is
going
to
write
your
exemptions?
Who
is
legally
allowed
to
insure
us?
We
all
need
permission
to
say
no
or.
N
B
R
Morning
my
name
is
Tamara.
You
galini
and
I
am
here
to
defend
our
right
to
informed
consent,
a
parent's
right
to
make
medical
choices
for
their
children
and
bodily
sovereignty.
For
several
years,
public
health
has
been
unlawfully.
Suspending
children
under
the
is
PA
in
Ontario.
Legally,
only
a
principal
can
suspend
a
child
under
the
Education
Act
and
nowhere
under
this
act
is
it
noted
that
an
entirely
separate
munis
ministry
has
the
ability
to
do
this.
R
When
the
minister,
the
medical
officer
of
Health
Authority,
is
in
question,
we
have
seen
public
health
across
Ontario
pressure
principals
into
calling
C
is
withholding
busing
and
ostracizing
completely
healthy
children
by
restricting
them
to
the
office
and
withholding
their
recess.
This
is
bullying
and
coercion,
and
it
is
wrong.
We
don't
send
our
children
to
public
health
to
learn
their
ABCs
or
one
two
threes,
just
as
we
don't
send
our
children
to
public
school,
so
they
can
receive
medical
procedures
or
have
one
sided
vaccine
data
pushed
on
them.
As
a
Canadian
citizen.
R
It
is
my
fundamental
right
to
exercise
freedom
of
medical
choice.
It
is
an
infringement
on
said
right
that
I
require
an
affidavit
to
opt
out
of
a
questionable
medical
procedure
with
horribly
inadequate
safety
data.
The
exemption
process
violates
our
chartered
rights,
Newfoundland
and
Labrador,
for
instance,
have
no
exemption
process
in
place,
and
yet
they
have
the
highest
vaccine
uptake
in
the
country.
R
Public
Health's
agenda
today
provides
no
research
into
why
parents
may
be
hesitant.
It
makes
no
attempt
to
answer
any
of
the
questions
requested
of
Theresa
tam
in
November
of
2018
to
provide
concerned
parents
with
vaccine
safety
data,
including
the
safety
of
injected
aluminum,
long-term
clinical
trials
and
the
true
lack
of
true
saline
placebos.
This
is
not
about
misinformation.
This
is
about
missing
information.
For
instance,
grade
7
consent
forms
were
sent
out
these
last
few
weeks
by
public
health
to
schools
across
Ontario.
R
Nowhere
in
these
consent
forms
do
they
mention
informed
consent,
provides
any
monographs
or
that
there's
an
exemption
process
in
place.
They
use
words
like
required
and
mandatory
to
coerce
compliance.
Then
strategy,
section
II,
you
know
clearly
the
Canadian
code
of
advertising
standard
responsible
for
prohibiting
inaccurate
and
misleading
advertisements,
and
yet
here
you
are
making
statements
like
vaccines
are
required
and
mandatory.
Who
holds
you
accountable
for
these
misleading
statements,
an
inaccurate
verbage.
R
Furthermore,
public
health
has
the
audacity
to
propose
censorship
of
social
media
pages
and
search
engines,
remove
vaccine
monographs
stating
that
they're
confusing
and
required
they're
not
required
for
informed
consent.
The
first
element
of
informed
consent
is
that
it
is
voluntary
and
the
third
is
to
properly
inform
the
patient.
And
yet
here
you
are
attempting
to
censor
that
and
I
have
to
just
continue
on.
R
Is
it
any
wonder
there
is
mounting
distrust
of
public
health
and
ministry
that
expects
you
to
give
them
all
of
your
information
and
then
utilize
it
on
their
various
platforms
and
yet
simultaneously
removes
freedom
of
speech
in
fringes
on
your
fundamental
rights
and
intentionally
censors
informed
consent.
So
in
teresa
tam.
N
R
B
A
My
name
is
Sandra
Huang
and
I'm
a
concerned
parent,
but
today
I
am
here
to
share
a
letter
written
by
an
Ontario
lawyer
and
mother
dear
board
members.
Twenty-Five
years
ago
my
husband
and
I
watched
helplessly
as
our
four
month
old
baby
suffered
a
severe
vaccine
injury.
He
had
seizures
following
his
DPT
vaccine.
Before
the
shots
were
administered.
We
were
not
given
information
about
adverse
events
and
how
to
identify
or
report
them.
My
son
suffers
from
neurological
and
other
problems.
His
special
care
costs
tens
of
thousands
of
dollars
every
year.
A
He
is
25
lives
at
home,
needs
support,
workers
and
24/7
provision.
He
cannot
cross
the
road
on
his
own.
He
has
taken
to
parks
or
the
library
where
he
reads:
Thomas
the
Tank
Engine
books.
He
is
very
sensitive
to
sounds
sometimes
hearing
running
tap
water
is
painful.
He
has
obsessions
and
listens
to
the
same
song
over
and
over
and
over
again,
this
should
have
been
the
prime
of
his
life
college
work
friendships.
Instead,
he
sits
alone
blowing
soap
bubbles
like
a
three-year-old
and
eternal
child.
A
In
an
adult's
body,
we
spent
hours
researching
therapies,
travelled
across
North
America
to
specialists.
Left
careers
behind
we
are
the
full-time
caregivers
of
a
severely
disabled
son.
Ours
is
not
a
one
in
a
million
story.
Vaccine
injuries
are
rarely
reported.
Are
you
aware
that
Ontario
and
Toronto
Public
Health
have
a
history
of
underreporting
vaccine
adverse
events?
A
According
to
the
2014
Auditor
General's
report,
Ontario's
2012
adverse
event
rate
was
half
the
national
average
rate
and
how
is
it
that
in
2013,
Toronto
Public
Health,
with
21
percent
of
Ontario's
population,
reported
only
9
percent
of
Ontario's
adverse
events
in
the
US
four
billion
dollars
have
been
paid
to
thousands
injured
by
the
vaccines
that
you
want
to
mandate.
You
will
not
win
parents
trust
by
pushing
for
compulsory
vaccines.
You
will
not
win
trust
by
pretending
that
vaccines
have
no
safety
and
efficacy
problems.
You
will
not
win
trust
by
censoring
social
media
and
search
engines.
A
You
will
not
win
trust
by
saying
that
reports
of
vaccine
injury
are
miss-information.
It
is
unconscionable
to
censor
the
speech
of
someone
injured
by
a
pharmaceutical
product.
It
is
unconscionable
to
silence
the
victims.
What
is
before,
you
is
not
a
public
health
policy.
It
is
a
travesty,
as
a
lawyer,
I,
believe
the
recommendations
before
you
directly
or
indirectly
violate
rights
protected
by
federal,
provincial
and
international
legislation,
including
the
Charter
of
Rights
and
Freedoms,
and
the
Ontario
healthcare
consent
Act.
It
is
reminiscent
of
dark
regimes
that
had
no
respect
for
individual
freedoms
as
per
your
agenda.
B
P
Good
morning,
members
of
the
board-
my
name-
is
Safi
ibrahim
and
as
a
polio,
survivor,
UNICEF,
Canada,
special
representative
on
magazines,
a
support
of
immunize
Canada
and
a
mother
of
three
children
who
live
in
the
city.
I
strongly
support
access,
access
to
vaccinations,
I,
know
and
live
with
the
impacts
of
that
rights
being
taken
away
through
my
support
of
UNICEF
I
see
the
multiplier
effect
of
this
basic,
yet
crucial,
Public,
Health
intervention
and
the
lives
our
children
are
saved
each
year,
and
this
is
why
vaccine
hesitancy
risk
all
children's
health
and
lives.
P
Hesitancy
risked
my
life.
It
is
concerning
to
me
to
hear
that
there
are
five
times
the
measles
cases
in
Canada
than
this
time.
Last
year,
when
we
had
vaccine
when
we
have
a
vaccine
to
prevent
this
unnecessary
illness
vaccines,
don't
just
protect
people
getting
vaccinated,
they
protect
everyone
else
as
well.
P
The
more
people
in
the
community
who
are
vaccinated
the
harder
it
is
for
our
disease
to
spread
if
a
person
is
infected
with
a
disease
comes
in
contact
with
only
people
who
are
I
mean
the
disease
will
have
little
opportunity
to
spread
hurt
and
the
type
of
protection
created
when
most
people
are
immunized
is
called
herd
immunity.
It
means
that
many
of
us
are
protected
each
other,
especially
the
most
vulnerable
among
us.
Knowing
this
fact
that
is
based
on
science
and
research,
I
can't
help
but
worry
when
I
receive
a
notice.
P
In
the
first
one,
I
received
a
notice
in
the
first
week
of
school
regarding
the
child
was
to
sit
with
the
Sarah's
illness
and
second
grade
class.
It
read
dear
parents
of
the
second
grade
class.
I
would
like
to
inform
you
that
there's
a
student
in
the
class
who
has
a
serious
illness
in
order
to
protect
it
at
best.
P
It
is
our
expectation
that
if
your
child
gets
chickenpox
or
measles,
you
will
and
should
report
it
immediately
to
the
school
like
it,
likewise
any
other
cold
or
any
cold,
or
any
flu
that
should
also
be
reported
to
the
teachers.
I
think
that
you
understand
the
importance
of
this
message
and
I
know
you
could
come
I
could
count
on
your
cooperation
on
this
I
wish
you
a
beautiful
weekend.
P
The
principal
I
am
NOT
winning
concern
for
this
child,
but
their
parents,
as
well
as
a
mother
I,
could
only
imagine
the
fear
they
experience
whenever
their
child
goes
out
into
the
community,
whether
it's
to
school
or
to
the
playground.
Vaccines
have
saved
more
lives
in
Canada
than
any
other
medical
intervention.
In
the
past
50
years
before
vaccines
were
available,
many
Canadians
died
from
diseases
that
we
can
now
prevent.
P
Vaccines
also
prevent
diseases
that
are
deadly,
but
can
cause
pain
and
permanent
disability
like
polio,
I
understand
pants
of
today
haven't
seen
how
full
you
can
destroy
a
family
and
alter
a
child's
life.
So
the
urgency
to
vaccinate
is
a
man,
but
when
immunizations
drop
in
a
community,
it's
easier
for
diseases.
Disease
to
spread
from
person
to
person
and
cause
an
outbreak
by
the
way
the
polio
virus
is
still
found
in
other
parts
of
the
world
and
can
be
reintroduced
to
trial
through
travel
and
migrations.
B
P
B
H
I'm
amanda
moses
and
I
left
at
3
o'clock
in
the
morning
to
drive
five
hours
to
come
and
speak
here
with
you
guys
today
when
I
first
became
a
parent
I,
never
questioned
the
safety
or
efficacy
of
vaccines,
so
I
vaccinated
my
first
three
children
after
each
set
of
vaccines
within
a
day
or
two,
each
of
my
children
would
become
ill
and
would
be
hospitalized.
My
oldest
started
having
several
developmental
delays
and
was
constantly
sick
and
has
allergies
and
asthma.
H
My
second
oldest
child
went
from
talking
and
developing
perfectly
to
losing
all
speech
and
eye
contact
directly
after
a
set
of
vaccines.
As
seventeen
months
old.
This
sudden
and
extreme
change
was
seen
by
her
family
doctor
and
has
been
documented
in
family
videos
and
pictures
she
has
been
diagnosed
with
autism,
worsens
68%
of
children
on
the
spectrum
and
will
never
live
independently.
I
delayed
my
third
child's
vaccines
to
see
if
it
would
lessen
his
chance
of
a
reaction
after
his
vaccines
within
hours.
H
He
had
a
seizure
and
after
the
seizure
half
of
his
face
was
partially
and
permanently
paralyzed.
He
talks
at
the
side
of
his
mouth.
He
went
from
never
being
sick
to
being
chronically
ill.
This
is
why
70%
of
parents
are
concerned
about
side
effects
and
20%
are
vaccine,
hesitant.
It
has
nothing
to
do
with
what
is
being
shared
on
social
media.
The
majority
of
us
are
not
anti-vaxxers.
H
We
are
X
vac
sirs
when
you
hold
your
seizing
child
in
your
hands,
or
you
find
your
baby's
lifeless
body
in
their
crib
a
few
hours
after
their
vaccines.
There
is
no
20
minute
video
that
can
scare
us
into
wanting
to
risk
another
reaction
in
all
hopes
of
possibly
preventing
a
week's
of
the
Meisel
or
chickenpox,
which
many
of
our
parents
and
grandparents
all
had
and
survived
unscathed.
H
Infectious
diseases
are
treatable,
brain
damage
and
death
are
not.
It
is
clear
to
me
now
that
my
family
has
a
genetic
disposition,
making
us
more
successful
to
being
injured
from
vaccine,
so
I
chose
not
to
vaccinate.
My
last
to
these
children
are
now
six
and
seven
and
have
zero
developmental
delays.
They
are
the
perfect
picture
of
health.
They
have
no
asthma,
allergies
or
physical
or
mental
disabilities
of
any
kind.
There
are
risks
with
vaccinating
any
doctor.
H
Who
is
read
a
vaccine
insert
will
tell
you
this,
they
will
say
the
risk
is
rare,
but
there
is
a
risk
and
it
is
not
rare.
My
kids
are
living
proof
of
that.
No
one
has
the
right
to
force
somebody
to
do
something
that
carries
along
with
it
risks.
Vaccination
is
not
a
social
issue,
it
is
a
personal
choice
and
must
remain
as
such
in
a
free
country.
H
What
is
the
reason
and
need
for
this
rash
and
disgraceful
decision
to
try
to
directly
defy
our
human
and
constitutional
rights?
Where
are
these
supposed
epidemics
of
children
dying
from
infectious
diseases
here
in
Canada?
If
the
number
of
people
choosing
to
opt
out
on
vaccinations
is
growing
shouldn't,
we
be
seeing
epidemics
Amanda.
H
Just
have
a
question
real
quick,
so
since
this
community
is
a
committee,
is
bringing
this
motion
forward,
I'm
assuming
you
all
happily
comply
and
make
public
your
updated.
This
vaccination
status,
like
we
have
to,
can
I
get
a
commitment
from
all
of
you
today
that
you
will
do
this
within
the
next
two
weeks
to
prove
that
you
really
are
an
integrity
with
what
you
are
proposing
to
families
across
the
city.
I'm
just.
B
S
Thank
You
mr.
chairman
members,
vote
of
health.
Ladies
and
gentlemen,
my
name
is
Alison
mogera
and
I'm:
an
infectious
disease
physician,
the
Sinai
Health
System
and
a
member
of
the
newly
formed
Center
for
vaccine
preventable
disease
at
the
University
of
Toronto
declare
my
conflict
of
interest.
My
institution
has
funding
for
the
vaccine
research
studies
from
a
number
of
the
companies
that
make
vaccines.
What
Serena
can.
B
S
Thank
you
this
morning
for
the
opportunity
to
support
the
recommendations
of
this
Toronto
Public
Health
on
a
strategy
to
address
vaccine
hesitancy.
As
you'd
likely
know,
vaccines
are
second
only
to
safe
food
and
water
in
their
contribution
to
the
doubling
of
life
expectancy
over
the
last
century.
Give
you
a
sense
of
the
benefit
primarily
of
vaccines
for
every
one
year
that
your
parents
delayed
getting
pregnant
with
you.
S
Your
life
expectancy
increased
by
three
months,
World
Health
Organization
estimates
that
between
two
and
three
million
lives
of
children
are
saved
every
year
by
vaccination,
but
vaccines
have
risks
and
vaccine
hesitancy
is
a
new
and
growing
problem.
The
extent
that
the
World
Health
Organization
declared
in
2019
that
it
was
one
of
the
top
ten
public
health
threats.
It's
arisen
for
complex
reasons,
including,
paradoxically,
the
success
of
our
current
vaccination
programs,
the
erosion
of
trust
in
our
public
systems,
evolutional
social
media
and
the
consolidation
of
vaccine
production
by
the
pharmaceutical
industry.
S
We
want
to
commend
the
Toronto
Public
Health
and
the
Board
of
Health
today
for
taking
a
leadership
role
in
adjusting
the
challenge
of
vaccine
hesitancy.
I
strongly
support
all
of
the
items
of
the
action
plan
put
forward.
Recommendations
are
based
on
solid
evidence
and
each
one
of
them
will
contribute
to
the
effectiveness
and
safety
of
our
public
vaccination
programs.
S
However,
it's
also
important
to
recognize
that
many
of
these
recommendations
have
been
made
by
many
different
public
health
bodies
over
the
last
20
years.
Their
success
to
date
and
making
change
limited
I
would
that's,
encourage
the
board
and
Toronto
Public
Health
to
consider
how
they
can
effectively
support
these
recommendations
going
forward.
S
This
is
particularly
important
today
in
the
light
of
the
recent
loss
of
the
applied
immunization
research
and
evaluation
program,
the
senior
immunization
scientist
and
the
chief
science
officer
at
public
health,
Ontario
leadership
and
coordination
and
innovation
in
vaccination
programs
from
our
local
public
health
units
in
Ontario
is
going
to
be
critical
to
our
progress
in
maintaining
safe
vaccination
programs
in
the
next
few
years.
In
the
body
of
the
report,
Toronto
Public
Health
lists
a
number
of
projects.
They
are
undertaking
to
support
immunization
knowledge
and
practice.
S
These
programs
are
all
commendable
and
they
need
to
be
both
continued
and
evaluated.
It
encouraged
the
board
to
support
continued
Toronto
public
health
planning
to
meet
the
challenge
of
vaccine
hesitancy,
an
ongoing
reporting
of
both
goals
and
progress
over
the
coming
years.
I
would
also
request
that
Toronto
Public
Health
and
the
board
consider
how
they
might
continue
emotion,
I'm
afraid.
S
F
S
Evaluation
of
programs
is
one
critical
area.
So
if
you
look
at
the
written
submissions
to
this
board,
there's
a
submission
from
the
Simcoe
Muskoka
Public
Health,
looking
at
vaccine
compensation
and
which
they
took
advantage
of
the
University
of
Toronto's
public
health
students
to
do
the
research
for
those
reports,
so
I
think
there
is
a
possibility
of
working
a
variety
of
different
universities
to
to
build
the
evidence
case
for
making
changes.
S
I
think
it's
probably
not
enough
to
make
a
single
recommendation
to
a
number
of
groups
about
what
to
do,
but
to
try
to
make
sure
that
there's
ongoing
recommendations
and
that
you
start
a
discussion
going
forward
with
the
province
and
the
federal
government
about
what
can
be
done.
I
think
it's
helpful
to
ask
Toronto
Public
Health
what
they
would
like
to
do,
that
they
don't
have
the
budget
for
and
and
on
their
vaccine
hesitancy
programs.
You
know
what
their
priorities
are.
S
B
B
B
I
Journalist
I
was
in
masters
of
molecular
biology
from
the
Faculty
of
Medicine
University
of
Calgary.
It's
a
medical,
freelance,
medical
journalist
for
22
years
and
I
wanted
to
point
out
to
you
the
dozens
of
people
here
who
have
come
to
speak
about
the
clear
and
present
dangers
of
vaccines.
Can
you
anybody
who's
had
had
vaccine
injury
or
had
a
vaccine,
your
child?
Can
you
please
raise
your
hand
so?
But
yet
we
all
know
well.
I
know
we're
gonna
be
ignored.
I
Nothing
we
say,
will
make
a
difference
you,
but
not
going
to
ask
us
a
single
question.
Just
like
last
time
we
came,
you
didn't
ask
a
single
question
to
us
and
you
compare
this
drug
counselor
crusty.
You
compared
us
basically
to
flat-earthers,
and
you
said,
vaccines
are
safe
and
effective,
and
other
people
in
this
community
made
fun
of
us.
Counselor
McKelvey
read
out
a
product
monograph
through
water,
saying
well,
water
can
be
unsafe,
so
just
like
a
product
monograph
of
vaccines
that
you
know
that
anything
has
been
safe.
I
You're
ridiculing
people
who
are
just
trying
to
say
maybe
do
your
job
and
don't
just
be
trained
seals.
The
vaccine
companies
maybe
actually
say,
let's
look
at
the
evidence,
but
that's
not
happening
today
here
today.
I,
don't
expect
it,
even
though
it
should
happen.
It's
a
it's
just
unbelievable,
what's
happening
so
first,
it's
travesty
and
by
the
way,
in
the
press
conference
before
it
started
on
the
press
conference,
and
you
had
several
speakers
that
we're
all
saying
vaccines
are
great.
We
have
two
men
make
the
mandatory.
I
You
know
all
this,
but
you
know
there
are
dozens
of
people
here
who
could
have
spoken
to
some
of
the
problems
vaccines.
Where
was
any
voice
from
that,
which
is
that
a
little
bit
of
censoring
of
information
and,
for
example,
Safiya,
spoke
about
how
we're
going
to
have
a
vaccine
compensation
program,
and
that
should
be
done,
and
she
said
well
that
way
that
pharma
companies
will
have
skin
in
the
game
because
off
to
pay.
I
But
as
he
heard
in
the
presentation
from
the
officer
from
the
medical
people
from
the
Department
of
Health
know,
we
as
taxpayers
pay
pharma.
Companies
are
off
the
hook.
I
mean
the
misinformation,
is
so
deep
and
thick.
This
information
that
your
the
resolutions
you're
talking
about
are
about
a
misinformation
I'm.
I
Now
an
activist
and
investigative
journalist,
I've,
looked
into
vaccines
and
indeed
I've
discovered,
had
ton
of
in
misinformation
about
vaccines,
and
almost
all
of
that
misinformation
comes
from
public
health
officials,
politicians
and
the
government
with
a
hidden
hand
of
Big
Pharma
behind
it
to
whitewash
vaccine.
Just
look
at
the
lobbyists
register.
You
see
Ontario
province
or
other
places
depressing
hard,
because
we
as
taxpayers,
pay
for
those
vaccines.
Also,
so
it's
just
in
the
formularies.
So
it's
great
huge
moneymaker
and
you
in
the
media
censor
I've.
I
We
just
read
last
week
this
book
stonewalled
by
a
former
investigative
journalist
at
CBS
News
when
she
did
a
piece
a
few
years
ago,
but
autism
and
vaccines
there
pushback
was
immediate.
She
got
the
first
murk
back
group
that
promotes
childhood
vaccines
was
protesting,
then
hard
guns
from
pharmaceutical
companies
just
flooded,
CBS,
etc.
So
this
is
what
we
see
now,
that's
never
the
debate
now.
Media
will
not
speak
out
about
vaccines
because.
I
I
B
A
B
A
You
vaccines,
work,
vaccines
are
safe
and
vaccines
are
vital
to
our
community's
well-being.
People
should
not
be
swayed
by
the
misinformation
they
hear
to
the
contrary:
vaccines
work.
Vaccination
is
one
of
the
most
successful
public
health
interventions
in
the
history
of
mankind.
It's
led
to
the
elimination
and
control
of
dangerous
infectious
diseases
such
as
smallpox,
polio,
diphtheria
and
measles.
Not
so
long
ago,
Canadian
children
were
becoming
severely
ill
and
dying
from
these
diseases.
Measles,
for
example,
can
cause
severe
pneumonia
brain
swelling
and
serious
problems.
A
Even
years
after
the
initial
infection,
children
are
more
vulnerable
and
can
become
very
sick.
Very
quickly
comes
within
hours,
vaccines
are
safe,
fall.
Vaccines
used
in
Canada
are
rigorously
tested
through
multiple
phases
of
trial
once
approved
for
use.
They
are
carefully
monitored
to
ensure
their
safety
and
effectiveness.
In
fact,
it's
more
likely
that
an
individual
will
get
sick
from
a
vaccine
preventable
disease
than
from
the
vaccine
itself.
A
Vaccines
are
vital
in
Canada,
childhood
immunization
rates
are
generally
high,
however,
vaccine
coverage
for
millions
below
the
herd,
immunity
target
of
95%
for
many
diseases,
and
this
has
led
to
the
recent
outbreaks
of
measles,
mumps,
rubella
and
pertussis.
There's
a
lot
of
misinformation
circulating
online
because
of
this
doctors
have
been
hearing
more
from
patients,
questioning
the
need
to
get
their
kids
vaccinated
and
some
are
opting
out.
A
We
know
that
parents
want
to
make
the
best
decisions
for
their
children,
63%
of
parents
admit
to
looking
for
immunization
information
on
the
Internet.
That's
concerning
because
information
circulating
about
vaccinations
on
websites
and
social
networks
is
mostly
inaccurate
when
it
comes
to
the
safety
of
our
children,
decisions
should
be
made
based
on
science,
on
evidence
and
on
advice
from
our
family
doctors,
not
the
size
of
someone's
fan
base
or
a
Google
search.
A
Ontario's
doctors
are
invested
in
your
health
and
in
the
health
of
our
communities.
That's
why,
beginning
this
week,
the
Ontario
Medical
Association
is
launching
a
multi-channel
social
media
campaign
to
help
target
the
spread
of
the
anti
vaccine.
Myths
I
encourage
you
to
look
for
the
hashtag
ask
Ontario
Doc's
thank.
B
K
Good
morning
my
name
is
Mike
Jackson
I
work
as
an
English
language
instructor,
two
new
immigrants
and
every
day,
I
proudly
sing
our
national
anthem.
With
my
students,
our
anthem,
o
Canada,
it
expresses
what
we
stand
for
as
a
nation.
It
expresses
who
we
are.
The
True
North
strong
and
free
I
am
deeply
concerned,
because
if
this
proposal
is
made,
law,
I
feel
the
very
heart
and
soul
of
our
great
nation
will
be
tarnished.
We
will
become
the
to
North.
K
No
longer
free
Canadians
will
be
oppressed
because
we
will
have
lost
the
right
to
inform
consent
to
medical
treatments,
and
we
won't
need
any
outsider
to
oppress
us
anymore,
I
believe
in
God
and
I
believe
that
all
human
beings
have
sacred
inalienable
rights.
One
of
those
inhalable
rights
is
the
right
to
inform
consent
regarding
all
associated
risks
with
any
medical
procedure
to
violate
this
right
is
to
violate
the
most
important
part
of
the
Nuremberg
code
formed
after
World
War
two
atrocities.
K
Atrocities
I
submit
that
this
recommendation
to
abolish
the
religious
and
philosophical
exemptions
and
forced
mandatory
vaccinations
upon
our
children
as
a
condition
of
receiving
education
is
a
direct
assault
on
our
fundamental
freedoms,
guaranteed
in
the
car
Charter
of
Rights
and
Freedoms
under
Section
2,
a
B
section,
7
section
15,
1,
section
7,
the
Charter
states
and
I
quote
everyone,
not
the
majority.
Everyone
has
the
right
to
life,
liberty
and
security
of
the
person
and
the
right
not
to
be
deprived
thereof,
except
in
accordance
with
the
principles
of
fundamental
justice.
K
As
such,
the
right
to
make
choices
concerning
one's
body
is
a
human
right,
a
charter
protected
right
and
a
Supreme
Court
recognized
right
and
the
right
that
shall
not
be
deprived,
except
in
accordance
with
the
principles
of
fundamental
justice.
So
what
are
those
principles
now?
The
vaccine,
Lobby
and
their
supporters?
Will
say
that
these
recommendations
are
an
example
of
fundamental
justice:
they're,
100%,
safe
and
effective.
The
unvaccinated
are
gonna
jeopardize
the
lives
of
all
of
us.
If
this
is
in
fact,
true,
do
these
statements
really
withstand
real
scientific
scrutiny?
K
K
No,
when
I
sit
down
and
read
the
Venge
amount
vaccine
manufacturers
project
inserts,
like
most
of
the
people
here
have
done,
and
on
that
basis
I
refuse
to
vaccinate
my
child.
Is
that
now
hallway
medicine?
No,
what
I
find
really
astonishing
and
really
disturbing
is
that
this
misinformation
or
hallway
medicine-
that's
supposed
to
be
censored
by
this
strategy-
is
in
fact
any
scientific
evidence
that
actually
confirms
the
litany
of
side
effects
already
printed
on
the
vaccine.
Manufacturers
insert
mr.
K
Jackson
I'm
gonna
have
to
get
you
to
sum
up,
just
in
one
sentence:
please
you're
about
time.
This
is
not
hallway
medicine.
I
ask
you
very
very
clearly
keep
the
True,
North,
strong
and
free
do
not
accept
this
recommendation.
If
you
do,
we
will
stand
on
guard
for
thee.
Thank
you.
Thank
you
very
much.
Are
there
any
questions
of
the
deputed,
seeing
none
we'll
invite
up
the
next
one,
Tania
Roca.
G
K
L
Name
is
Tania
raka
I
am
a
lawyer,
a
wife
and
a
mother
of
two
young
boys
aged
three
and
five.
My
older
son
has
an
extremely
rare
sorter
and
is
being
treated
and
monitored
at
SickKids
by
the
head
of
oncology.
When
miss
Ibrahim
stated
that
she
could
only
imagine
what
a
mother
of
an
immune
compromised
child
feels
like
worrying
about
their
child's
health
I
am
that
mother
and
I
would
never
ask
or
expect
another
mother
or
father
to
put
their
child
at
risk.
L
For
my
son's
benefit,
it
is
my
job
to
protect
him
and
nobody
else's.
As
a
parent
and
a
lawyer,
I
am
strongly
opposed
a
recommendation
set
forth
in
the
report.
You
have
my
complete
submissions
in
heart
and
electronic
copies
and
I.
Ask
you
to
rely
on
them
and
please
read
them.
The
staff
report
is
supposed
to
recommend
a
strategy
to
address
vaccine
hesitancy
and
it
completely
misses
the
mark.
The
recommendation
to
provide
financial
incentives
to
health
care
providers
for
promoting
vaccines
will
increase
vaccine
hesitancy.
L
Financial
incentives
create
an
obvious
and
serious
conflict
of
interest
that
will
only
erode
trust
between
doctors
and
their
patients.
This
board
should
be
promoting
the
exact
opposite
recommendation
that
health
care
providers
should
be
absolutely
prevented
from
receiving
financial
incentives
for
promoting
or
administering
vaccines
or
any
other
drug.
That
would
give
people
confidence
that
their
medical
advice
given
to
them
by
doctors
is
what
is
in
their
best
interest,
not
for
the
doctor's
personal
financial
gain.
Removing
non-medical
exemptions
under
the
immunization
of
school
pupils
Act
also
does
not
address
vaccine
hesitancy.
L
Forcing
vaccines
is
a
direct
violation
of
our
section
7
charter
right
to
life,
liberty
and
the
security
of
the
person
that
cannot
be
saved
under
section
1.
There
is
no
urgent
or
important
objective
that
can
be
achieved
by
this
immunization
to
justify
the
infringement
on
bodily
autonomy.
Herd
immunity
won't
be
achieved
by
Forest.
Vaccinating
only
children
kids
make
up
only
a
small
part
of
the
herd
that
should
be
obvious
to
everyone.
I
turn
you
to
my
written
materials
where
pro
vaccine
dr.
L
Gregory
Poland
studies,
immuno
Jetix,
a
vaccine
response
and
calls
on
public
health
to
accept
that
the
measles
vaccine
has
so
many
drawbacks.
It
is
unworkable.
Consent
to
medical
treatment,
including
a
vaccine,
must
be
voluntary
to
be
valid
under
the
health
care
consent.
Act
removal
of
a
non-medical
exemption
is
a
violation
of
law
and
disproportionately
targets
parents
of
lower
socioeconomic
status
because
they
are
less
likely
to
be
able
to
home-school.
L
You
have
a
mandate
to
produce
health
inequities,
yet
your
recommendations
would
increase
them
rather
than
strip
Ontarians
of
their
freedoms
and
attempts
to
force
the
vaccine
hesitant
into
compliance.
I
encourage
this
board
to
engage
in
the
discourse
strike
a
standing
committee
that
includes
the
vaccine,
hesitant
talk
with
us
and
hear
our
concerns.
I
am
here
and
I'm
willing
to
answer
questions.
I
expect
that
you
will
have
none
of
me,
as
has
been
the
case
for
my
predecessors.
L
A
B
A
A
A
B
A
B
J
Vaccine
is
a
pharmaceutical
product
and,
like
the
majority
of
pharmaceutical
products,
it
comes
with
side
effects,
some
very
debilitating
and
even
deadly,
as
you
just
heard,
as
everyone
is
unique.
Genetically
and
physiologically
this
product
affects
us
all
differently.
We
know
that
certain
children
are
more
susceptible
to
vaccine
induced
damage
than
others,
but
we
currently
have
no
clear
way
to
determine
which
children
these
are,
and
so
the
VAX
vaccination
procedure
is
a
little
bit
like
playing
Russian
roulette
with
our
children,
something
that
truly
saves
lives
and
causes.
J
No
harm
does
not
need
to
be
mandated,
but
this
is
simply
not
the
case
with
vaccines
we
are
told
the
science
is
settled
and
the
slogan
vaccines
are
safe
to
and
effective
is
repeated
over
and
over
again.
But
if
this
is
true,
then
why
is
there
so
much
evidence
to
the
contrary?
Why
is
there
an
overwhelming
number
of
peer-reviewed
studies
on
the
toxic
ingredients
in
vaccines
and
how
they
damage
the
body
in
particular
the
aluminum
adjuvant?
It
doesn't
sound
like
the
science
is
settled
at
all.
J
It
is
often
stated
that
vaccination
rarely
leads
to
serious
adverse
events,
but
this
statement
is
false.
A
recent
study
done
in
Ontario
established
that
vaccination
actually
leads
to
an
emergency
room
visit
for
one
in
168
children
following
their
12-month
vaccination
appointment
and
for
one
in
730
children
following
their
18-month
vaccination
appointment
when
risk
of
an
adverse
event
requiring
an
ER
visit
is
high.
J
Vaccination
must
remain
a
choice
for
parents
if
an
individual
or
parent
wishes
to
prevent
illness
by
strengthening
the
immune
system
by
adequate
nutrition,
regular
consumption
of
clean
water
and
good
hygiene
practices,
then
they
have
every
right
to
do
so.
I
was
under
the
impression
that
we
lived
in
a
free
country,
but
there's
nothing
free
about
forcing
medicine
on
those
who
do
not
want
it,
especially
one
that
contains
toxic
ingredients
such
as
aluminum
MSG,
formaldehyde,
polysorbate,
80
and
foreign
DNA
particulate.
J
If
we
do
not
have
the
freedom
to
choose
what
goes
into
our
bodies
and
in
the
bodies
of
our
children's,
then
we
are
not
free
and
any
useful
or
meaningful
sense.
This
is
not
moral
and
fascism
has
no
place
here.
This
network
of
parents
of
vaccine
damaged
children
will
never
be
silenced.
There
are
rallies
all
over
the
world
and
their
numbers
continue
to
grow
every
day.
Legislation
can
never
stop
this
movement.
Please
open
your
eyes
in
your
hearts
and
do
it
as
right.
J
B
K
If
vaccines
are
so
safe
and
why
does
his
US
Supreme
Court
classify
vaccines
as
unavoidably
unsafe
if
vaccines
are
so
safe?
Why
are
pharmaceutical
companies
exempt
from
liability?
Why
did
this
CDC
vaccine
schedule
triple
immediately
following
the
granting
of
the
liability
exemption?
Why
did
the
childhood
chronic
illness
rate
increase
through
12%
of
54
percent,
not
for
the
scheduled
triple
a
vaccine,
injury
and
death,
or
so
where?
K
Why
has
over
four
billion
dollars
been
paid
out
to
victims
and
their
families
through
the
National
Vaccine
injury
compensation
program
in
the
United
States,
with
only
1%
of
births,
reactions
even
being
reported?
There
has
never
been
a
proper
study,
proving
vaccines
safe.
The
mainstream
studies
are
terribly
misleading
to
the
general
public
and
are
funded
by
one
of
the
most
corrupt
industries
in
the
world.
Respond
for
most
deaths
annually.
It
wasn't
long
ago
that
the
pharmaceutical
industry
created
the
opioid
epidemic,
which
claimed
hundreds
of
thousands
of
lies
to
deaths
from
overdoses.
K
It
wasn't
all
that
long
ago,
doctors
were
convinced
to
promote
cigarettes,
a
safe
and
healthy,
which
kills
more
than
four
hundred
eighty
thousand
people
in
the
year
in
just
the
u.s..
The
pharmaceutical
industry
has
been
charged
with
bribery,
criminal,
off-label
promotion,
fairly
disclosed
safety
data,
paying
kickbacks
the
physicians,
extortion
and
murder
over
and
over
again
with
the
lawsuits
exceeding
tens
of
billions
of
dollars.
Why
would
I
trust
them
with
my
health,
when
all
they
care
about
is
wealth?
K
I
can
name
out
thirty
five
drugs
that
were
pulled
from
the
shelves,
the
FDA
they
caused
death
and
extreme
adverse
reactions.
These
death,
these
drugs
were
tests
on
four
point,
four
average
of
four
point:
five
years
before
licensing,
not
four
point.
Five
days
like
vaccines,
we
are
being
persuade
by
the
members
of
public
health
to
vaccinate
rather
than
informed.
Being
told
by
Authority
is
the
worst
case
of
evidence
to
vaccinate
I
have
a
friend's
brother
who
died
following
a
vaccination.
It
wasn't
SIDS.
It
was
the
vaccine
that
killed
him.
K
Vaccines
are
not
are
linked
to
autoimmune
disease.
They
are
linked
to
neurological
disease,
allergies,
asthma
and
many
other
illnesses.
I
myself
am
lucky
to
be
alive.
After
almost
dying
from
a
doctor's
prescription,
there
is
no
biological
free
lunch
and
these
drugs
come
with
consequences.
So
when
does
medicine
kill
people
it's
supposed
to
heal
and
revive
us?
No
one
has
a
higher
claim
over
our
bodies
and
our
children's
bodies
and
ourselves.
This
is
fascism
and
will
not
comply.
K
Many
of
us
are
sick
in
the
lies
and
manipulation
the
mainstream
media
funded
by
special
interest
in
Carmen
pharmaceutical
companies.
There
are
experts
in
Facebook,
every
field
of
medical
expertise
and
even
faxing
scientists,
claiming
they
don't
vaccinate
or
even
have
their
kids
vaccinated,
because
the
negative
risks
are
much
too
great.
B
N
My
name
is
Amanda
Doyle,
a
previous
health
care,
professional
and
a
concerned.
Mother
I
applaud
the
recommendation
to
consider
developing
a
national
vaccine
injury
compensation
program
to
support
those
individuals.
Who've
had
an
injury
from
vaccine
I
have
a
family
and
a
friend
who
have
been
seriously
vaccine
injured
without
going
into
personal
details.
Oh
I
know,
others
are
more
effective
at
sharing
their
personal
stories
than
I
am
I
will
state
that
I
truly
value
the
freedom
to
believe
in
the
God
of
the
Bible
and
live
out
my
faith
in
this
country.
N
What
is
the
sudden
emergency
that
makes
you
even
consider
removing
these
fundamental
rights
to
religious
freedom
and
philosophical
exemptions?
These
are
our
human
rights
to
think
and
act
upon
those
thoughts
to
express
what
we
deeply
believe
in
these
mandates
without
exemptions
will
certainly
change
our
nation
for
the
worse.
N
In
this
report,
there
are
many
recommendations
for
action
to
address
vaccine
hesitancy
stated.
The
vaccine
hesitancy
stems
in
large
part
from
misinformation
about
vaccines
spreading
on
the
social
media
platforms
in
the
internet.
Here's
where
you're
mistaken
this
vaccine
has
urgency
movement
as
you
call
it.
It
was
basically
founded
because
the
fact
that
information
has
not
been
transparent
but
hidden
from
the
public
I
was
surprised
when
I
learned
that
ingredients
such
as
aborted
fetal
cells
and
formaldehyde
in
vaccines
just
to
name
a
couple.
N
Many
serious
side
effects
such
as
death,
different
autoimmune
diseases,
serious
injury,
the
fact
that
true
scientific
studies
are
not
done
on
vaccines
without
a
proper
interplay
SIBO.
These
are
just
a
few
of
the
things
that
are
concealed
from
the
people.
The
public
is
demanding
more
transparency,
not
less.
Instead
of
streamlining
information
and
limiting
the
safety
data,
as
recommended
in
item
5b,
why
not
give
full
disclosure
to
the
people
to
decide
for
themselves?
You
yourself
gather
all
sorts
of
information
and
data
can
be
limited
in
the
out-of-date
vaccines.
Failed
vaccines
are
not
safe.
N
There
are
other
ways
to
boost
the
health
of
our
community
other
than
vaccines
that
don't
carry
serious
risk
of
death
or
injury.
It's
2019
and
time
for
public
to
start
promoting
other
solutions
to
promote
real
health
care
recommendations.
I'm,
sorry,
I'd,
ask
I
know
we
can
all
agree
on
this.
Our
children
are
the
future
and
deserve
this
consideration
and
dedicated
time.
N
I'm
praying
for
you
to
maintain
our
freedoms
in
Ontario
freedom
to
follow
our
conscience
is,
and
religion,
freedom
to
parents
to
choose
what
goes
into
our
children's
bodies:
freedom
to
protect
our
children
from
possible
harm
and
freedom
to
give
our
children
an
education.
Please
do
not
remove
choice.
Thank
you.
Thank.
B
J
J
I
heard
compassion
right
here
from
the
members
of
this
committee
about
a
woman
who
was
murdered
recently,
I
heard
compassion
about
elderly
being
mistreated,
I
heard
compassion
about
children
in
substandard
conditions,
and
so
I'm
asking
you
if
you
can
find
that
same
compassion
for
the
stories
you've
heard
today,
there's
moms
and
dads
here
who
have
lost
children
just
like
the
woman
that
died.
There
are
moms
and
dads
here
whose
children's
have
been
abused.
J
If
you
will,
by
taking
on
this
injection
that
they
didn't
know,
could
harm
their
child
because
everybody
said
to
them:
vaccines
are
safe
and
effective.
It
won't
happen
to
your
child.
I'm
asking
you
I
know
you
have
that
compassion
in
you.
I'm
asked
you
to
bring
it
to
the
people
here
and
hear
our
stories
today.
J
I've
told
her
not
to
vaccinate
my
children
because
I
kept
reading
and
kept
reading
I
was
waiting
until
I
came
across
the
document.
That
would
convince
me
100%
that
my
children
would
not
be
harmed,
and
that
has
not
happened
to
me
yet
and
I
will
not
do
it
until
I
know
with
100%
certainty
if
I
consent,
my
child,
will
not
be
injured
in
any
way.
J
There's
a
lot
of
them
and
I'll
I'll
just
share
some
quotations
from
a
few
of
them.
Vaccines
are
profitable,
but
neither
safe
nor
effective.
That's
dr.
Vernon,
Coleman
vaccines
are
highly
dangerous,
have
never
been
adequately
studied
or
proven
to
be
effective.
That's
dr.
alan
greenberg
md
only
after
realizing
immunizations
were
dangerous,
did
I
achieve
a
drop
in
infant
death
rates,
dr.
or
cavities
Calo
kirino's
md
without
exception.
The
vaccine
program
for
each
of
the
childhood
diseases
was
begun.
After
that
disease
had
begun
to
disappear.
J
Many
believe
that
the
Sulkin
saben
polio
vaccines
made
from
monkey
kidney
tissue
have
been
responsible
for
the
increase
in
leukemia,
dr.
F
Klenner
MD
in
my
medical
career,
I've
treated,
vaccinated
and
unvaccinated
children
and
the
unvaccinated
children
are
far
healthier.
Dr.
Philip
and
KO
MD
and
I
would
like
to
conclude
by
a
quote
from
dr.
J
Anthony
Morris.
He
was
formerly
chief
vaccine
control
officer
at
the
FDA.
There
is
evidence
to
prove
that
immunization
of
children
does
more
harm
than
good.
Thank
you.
Thank.
B
R
Good
morning,
I
am
one
of
the
unvaccinated
students
you
are
looking
to
bully
discriminate
and
remove
from
Toronto
schools.
I'm,
not
sick,
I'm,
not
ill
and
I
am
not
contagious.
I
am,
however,
an
athlete,
a
member
of
my
school's
student
council,
an
honorable
recipient
and
one
of
the
most
healthy,
motivated
and
dedicated
students
at
my
school
I.
Don't
have
the
time
or
space
to
get
sick,
because
there's
so
much
that
I
do
and
I'm
involved
in.
R
In
fact,
the
only
time
I
ever
take
off
school
is
to
go
to
different
athletic
and
academic
competitions,
school
trips,
training
camps
and
now
things
to
you,
when
I
have
to
defend
my
god-given
freedoms
to
an
overstepping
board
of
health,
how
could
I
possibly
be
a
danger
to
my
friends
at
school?
How
am
I
considered
one
of
the
top
ten
health
threats,
as
stated
by
the
World
Health
Organization
last
year,
a
girl
at
my
school
took
her
own
life.
R
Wouldn't
it
be
better
if
Toronto
Board
of
Health
worked
at
taking
my
peers
off
antidepressants
and
anxiety
medication,
wouldn't
it
be
better
to
stop
the
suicides
that
are
plaguing
my
generation?
The
overwhelming
majority
of
my
generation
is
sick
and
tired
of
being
sick
and
tired,
and
you
want
to
medicate
all
of
us
so
that
we
all
have
to
experience
the
same
debilitating
drug-induced
diseases.
If
heart
drugs
list
heart
attacks
as
a
side
effect
and
anti
depression,
drugs
list
suicide
as
a
side
effect.
R
Why
do
you
think
I
should
trust
anyone
that
says
vaccines
are
safe
and
effective.
Your
decisions
regarding
the
immunization
school
pupils
act
affect
me.
Profoundly
I.
Do
not
consent
to
having
my
medical
choices
on
an
electronic
registry.
I
do
not
consent
to
being
forced
to
have
an
exemption
filed,
stating
my
opposition
to
being
drugged.
I
do
not
consent
to
anyone
taking
my
freedoms
of
conscience
or
religion
and,
above
all,
I
do
not
consent.
Do
you
mandating
decisions
about
my
body
autonomy?
This
is
my
body,
and
it
is
my
choice.
B
B
L
My
name
is
Christian
I'm,
an
education
worker
and
I
have
a
few
concerns
about
the
First
Amendment's.
First
of
all,
I
believe
that
they
are
unconstitutional.
You've
heard
a
lot
of
quotes
around
the
Constitution
which
sections
of
the
Constitution
around
religion,
creed
right
to
bodily
integrity,
also
the
Nuremberg
code
and
the
medical
consent
laws.
Next.
I
also
believe
that
the
amendments
are
based
on
fear
rather
than
investigation.
I
do
not
worry
about.
Students
were
unvaccinated.
L
There
is
no
risk
because
there's
far
more
risk
from
people,
who've
just
had
a
live
attenuated
vaccine,
such
as
the
current
nasals
vaccine,
the
the
nasal
spray,
the
flu
nasal
spray
vaccine
and
also
the
whooping
cough
vaccine,
and
there
are
others
that
have
got
live
attention
advices
in
them
some
blame
recently.
The
recent
outbreaks
on
children
who've
not
been
vaccinated,
however
NBC
the
majority
of
cases
are
creating
vaccinated
people
in
New
Brunswick.
L
The
number
of
cases
who
were
vaccinated
and
not
been
vaccinated
have
not
been
released,
so
one
can
only
assume
that
those
people
are
fully
vaccinated
because,
if
they
weren't
vaccinated,
everyone
would
know
about
it.
What
happens
when
vaccinations
are
mandated
in
places
where
students
have
been
mandated
to
go
to
that?
Oh
sorry,
in
places
where
students
have
been
mandated
to
have
vaccinations,
the
enrollment
numbers
go
down.
L
California
saw
the
largest
decline
in
enrollment
last
year,
34,000
135
students,
New
York,
just
mandated
vaccinations
earlier
this
year,
New
York
politicians
as
well
as
Trump
Lane,
with
the
measles
outbreak
on
Orthodox
Jews.
It
came
as
no
surprise
that
there
was
an
attack
on
a
synagogue
that
Passover
now.
Why
did
it
was
it
on
Passover,
because
that's
when
most
people
would
be
there?
L
Why
would
why
was
it
in
California
because
there's
been
a
vaccination
crusade
there
since
2015,
where
they
first
mandated
the
education
sessions
or
re-education
sessions
and
then,
since
then,
they've
removed
all
exemptions,
so
Ontario
has
followed
the
same
model
with
similar
outcomes.
It's
a
reeducation
camps,
no
one!
No
one
has
been
converted
now.
Are
we
going
to
follow
the
same
same
model
where
we
start
to
look
at
an
a
religious
group
and
ostracize
them
and
wait
for
whatever
hate
crime
is
going
to
happen?
Would
there
be
a
hate
crime
in
North
York?
L
L
L
If,
if
they
were
mandated
in
TDSB,
three
percent
of
the
students
would
go.
That's
seven
hundred
and
five
seven
thousand
five
hundred
students
that
would
be
nine
hundred
and
thirty
education
workers
who
would
be
out
of
a
job
for
its
cuts,
have
only
been
less
that
have
been
285.
This
is
far
worse
than
four.
Thank
you.
B
B
B
B
And
this
is
that
the
Board
of
Health
extend
its
meeting
past
the
12:30
lunch
brace
to
allow
the
board
to
complete
this
item,
at
which
point
we'll
take
a
lunch
break
all
those
in
favor
opposed
if
any
carried.
If
people
do
need
to
step
out
either
to
make
a
call
or
use
the
washroom
or
anything
you're
more
than
welcome.
Of
course,
okay,
our
next
speaker
is
Natalie.
Crumber
is
Natalie
here.
T
Can
you
hear
me?
Okay,
I'm
gonna
go
a
little
bit
off
script
as
well.
Just
in
the
beginning,
my
name
is
Natalie
crumber
I
am
a
mother
I'm,
a
business
owner
I'm,
also
a
mother
of
a
vaccine,
injured
child
I.
Also
I'm
here,
to
put
my
heart
out
like
it's,
it
was
not.
It
was
hard
for
me
to
go.
I
came
from
Kitchener,
which
is
not
as
far
as
some
other
people
came
here.
A
lot
of
people
took
off
work
to
come
here.
That's
how
important
this
is.
T
No
one
here
is
getting
any
sort
of
incentives
to
be
here.
No
one
is
getting
any
sort
of
you
know
if
anything,
we're
losing
money
losing
stuff
from
our
business
to
be
here.
It's
I
want
to
talk
about.
As
far
as
you
know,
I'm
not
going
to
sit
here
and
say
a
slogan
over
and
over
again
about
vaccines
are
safe.
T
You
know
it's
really
unfortunate
to
hear
that
we
it's
not
even
making
it
open
for
discussion
when
you
hear
all
these
families
and
their
stories,
and
then
someone
comes
up
here,
they're,
safe,
they're,
safe
they're,
safe,
say.
That's
all
the
other
stories
that
came
before
like
let's
have
a
conversation
about
this.
It's
really
unfortunate
that
we
can't
even
have
this
open
conversation.
It's
also
it's
2009.
T
There's
access
to
information.
There
is
no
study
that
a
doctor
has
access
to
that
I,
don't
also
have
access
to
so
to
be
like,
oh,
you
know
your
Google
research,
it's
2019,
there's
no
secret
studies.
There's
no!
Like
there's
everything's
peer-reviewed.
We
have
access
to
all
of
this
information.
So
it's
that's
really
unfortunate
to
try
to
be
like.
Oh,
you
know,
because
you
found
that
on
Google
yeah
because
we
don't
walk
around
with
like
10,000
books
in
our
trunks
anymore.
That's
where
it's
a
PDF
version
of
a
book.
That's
what's
frustrating
like.
T
Let's
have
these
conversations,
let's
not
just
say:
oh
that's
misinformation!
Cuz!
You
got
it
off
Google!
So
did
you
that's?
What's
frustrating
so
I'm
gonna
talk
about
I.
Thank
you
very
much
for
the
person
that
talked
about
their
experience
of
having
polio
as
a
young
child
in
regards
to
polio.
I'm
gonna
be
talking
about
some
information
from
dr.
Susan
Humphreys
book
as
well
as
JP
Hanley's
book
I'm.
Not
a
doctor,
but
I'm
able
to
do
research,
I
can
read.
T
I
can
decipher
like
we
I'm
a
competent
person,
so
there's
no
polio
in
Canada
the
last
wild
natural
polio
case
in
Canada
occurred
in
1977.
There
have
been
three
reported
cases
in
the
US
since
2005
all
from
vaccine
strains
of
polio
worldwide.
There
are
more
new
polio
cases
due
to
vaccine
strains
that
become
viral,
and
then
there
are
due
to
wild
polio
viruses.
T
Last
year,
vaccine
derived
viruses,
paralyzed
105
children
worldwide,
the
wild
virus
affected
just
33
children
and
more
shockingly
and
little
known
as
the
fact
that
between
2000
and
2017
in
India,
four
hundred
and
ninety
thousand
cases
of
paralysis
were
a
direct
result
of
the
vaccine,
a
short
history.
The
polio
scare
occurred
during
the
1940s
1950s
polio
was
a
summer
disease
occurring
during
pesticide
spraying
season
and
has
been
linked
to
DDT,
especially
around
apple
orchards,
fruit
and
vegetable
farms.
The
use
of
DDT
in
North
America
began
in
1945
polio,
infected
clusters
of
Natalee.
T
I'm
just
gonna
say
the
one
of
the
biggest
problems
that
we
face
is
the
exaggerated,
one-sided
fault
free
history
of
vaccines
in
1956,
the
Medical
Association
should
instructed
doctors
to
change
the
polio
delay.
Thank
you
almost
done.
I'm
polio,
diagnosis
to
an
acute
flaccid,
parallel
assist
diagnosis.
So
by
changing
the
character
of
polio,
you're.
B
C
My
late
husband,
John
spall,
spent
his
career
with
Toronto
EMS.
He
managed
Toronto's
ambulance,
Control
Center
and
then,
since
the
system's
performance
analysis
division
during
the
SARS
epidemic,
his
team
generated
the
stats
that
Toronto
and
Ontario
used
to
stret
the
tract
track,
the
spread
of
the
virus.
He
was
a
statistician,
an
advocate
for
a
well-designed
statistical
report,
basing
inquiry
on
the
evidence,
not
what
was
assumed
a
report
that
considered
all
pertinent
data
was
his
ultimate
resource.
Knowing
his
reports
informed
policy
decisions
in
the
city,
he
served,
he
took
pride
in
being
a
civil
servant.
C
Let
us
follow
his
example
and
consider
all
available
information
in
making
our
decisions
humbly.
Consider
that
you
may
not
have
all
the
data
discussions
in
1981
when
our
first
child
was
born
on
the
safety
and
efficacy
of
vaccines
on
all
mainstream
media
was
considered
acceptable.
Consumers
demanded
full
informed
consent
on
medical
procedures.
Answers
were
sought
about
the
DTP
vaccine,
which,
which
was
with
Ron,
because
it
had
so
many
adverse
reactions.
It
prompted
so
many
lawsuits
in
the
u.s.
that
the
National
Vaccine
injury
compensation
program
was
established.
C
Vaccines
were
made
liability
free
and
the
number
of
recommended
vaccines
rose
exponentially.
My
husband
handled
the
mail
for
the
midwifery
taskforce,
helping
the
movement
to
legalize
midwifery
in
Ontario,
quietly
behind
the
scenes,
as
was
his
way.
That
was
the
kind
of
man
he
was.
He
cared
about
the
environment,
about
social
justice,
about
better
birthing
options
about
the
public
good.
He
cried
when
Robert
Tchaikovsky
was
killed
by
a
Taser
in
the
Vancouver
Airport.
He
cried
when
he
watched
vast.
C
We
weren't
supposed
to
hear
about
the
top
CDC
scientist,
who
confessed
to
his
role
in
the
destruction
of
statistical
evidence
linking
the
age
of
administration,
of
the
MMR
vaccine
to
a
significant
increase
in
the
incidence
of
autism
in
african-american
boys.
He
began
to
speak
openly
about
vaccine
safety
issues
because
he
cared
he
wanted
better,
as
should
we
all
I'm.
Now
a
retired
educational
assistant
I
saw
the
increasing
number
of
health,
behavioral
and
learning
issues
and
the
dramatic
increase
in
autism
the
anxious
non
verbal
stimming
kicking
screaming
head
banging
children.
Schools
have
become
dangerous
places.
C
More
and
more
special-needs
children
appear
every
year
as
a
neurotypical.
Children
are
becoming
more
scarce,
a
tsunami.
The
demands
answers
to
questions
we
are
not
allowed
to
ask
I
have
seen
the
carnage
firsthand.
It
was
my
job
to
care
for
these
children.
Some
don't
want
to
acknowledge
this
crisis.
I
believe
my
fellow
citizens,
when
they
tell
me
their
children,
are
fine
before
vaccinations.
Remember
nothing
else,
we're
saying
but
remember
this.
They
vaccinated
their
children
as
recommended,
and
things
went
terribly
wrong
in
some
cases.
C
Within
minutes
hours
and
days
after
vaccinations,
the
motion
to
establish
a
compensation
system
speaks
to
this
reality.
Most
adverse
reactions
are
ignored
and
discounted
crucial
data
points
eliminated,
and
so
we
dismiss
parents
reports.
We
know
as
few
as
1%
of
adverse
reactions
are
ever
reported.
These
numbers
are
estimated
to
be
at
least
10
times
higher.
These
accounts
will
not
change.
Voices
will
no
longer
be
silent.
C
Will
be
heard,
we
will
be
heard,
we
all
stand
together.
We
believe
sexual
assault,
survivors,
mothers
are
saying
their
children
were
harmed.
Believe
women,
please
ask
yourself
before
you
dismiss
disrespect
and
discredit
all
of
us,
your
fellow
citizens,
brave
ordinary
people,
from
every
ethnicity,
every
income
and
education
level
as
deluded
ill-informed,
an
easily
swayed
Norman.
C
B
G
So
I
have
a
question
through
you
to
the
medical
office
of
Health.
There
was
a
recommendation
dealing
with
the
College
of
Physicians
and
Surgeons.
So
can
you
elaborate
a
little
bit
further
because
I'm
not
clear
in
that
particular
I?
Don't
have
there
was
a
section
there
to
talked
about
the
sharing
of
the
email
address?
This
is
the
first
time
I
heard
about
this.
So
am
I
clear
when
I
read
your
your
recommendation,
dr.
G
C
M
Getting
email
addresses
for
physicians
will
enable
us
to
give
timely
information
to
physicians.
We
do
currently
get
lists
of
physicians,
FAQs
and
address
information,
but
we
don't
currently
have
access
to
email
addresses
and
we
want
to
be
able
to
have
a
way
to
communicate
with
physicians
in
an
efficient
and
timely
manner.
So.
G
My
follow-up
question
mr.
chair:
what's
the
rationale
because
this
issue
here
is
that
the
college
see
this
as
a
privacy
issue,
because
at
the
end
of
the
day,
this
is
Public
Safety
right,
so
I'm,
just
not
clear,
because
if
this
is
good
for
the
City
of
Toronto,
let's
call
it
by
our
colleagues
across
the
because
this
is
not
just
a
City
of
Toronto
issue.
This
is
the
province
issue.
So
my
question:
is
you
three
that
mr.
chair
to
the
Medicus
of
health?
M
Thank
you
for
the
question,
so
panorama
is
our
the
provincial
system
that
we
use
electronically
to
house
immunization
data
and
it's
a
step
up
from
where
we
were
previously,
but
it
still
has
limitations
and
its
functions.
So,
for
example,
right
now
we
cannot
run
coverage
reports
by,
for
example,
postal
code
or
by,
for
example,
certain
socio-demographic
or
social
determinants
of
health
to
be
able
to
determine
where
we
may
have
pockets
of
under
vaccinated
individuals
in
the
city
who
may
require
more
resources,
for
example.
M
So
that's
one
of
the
ways
of
which
we
want
to
increase
the
functionality.
Another
way
which
we
have
continued
to
be
vocal
on
is
right.
Now
it's
parents
who
are
required
to
report
AXA
Nations
directly
to
public
health
in
accordance
with
the
immunization
school
people's
act
and
it's
the
parents
responsibility.
M
Currently
there
is
legislation
that
is
on
hold,
requiring
physicians
and
other
health
care
providers
to
report
directly
to
the
public
health,
and
so
that's
another
one
of
the
recommendations
that
if
we
got
the
immunization
implement
information
shortly
after
the
immunization
was
provided
in
the
office
directly
to
public
health.
Well,
then,
it
would
take
the
burden
off
parents
and
it
would
also
allow
us
for
more.
Real-Time
data
and
analysis
of
immunization
rates.
M
The
World
Health
Organization
has
recognized
the
role
of
the
internet
and
social
media
sites
on
influencing
some
of
the
information.
That's
available,
some
of
the
false
information
that's
available.
We
included
the
recommendation
from
the
Salzburg
Report
group
because
it
was
a
comprehensive,
comprehensive
recommendations
made
up
of
a
number
of
different
health
specialists
and
consistent
with
the
information
or
recommendations
that
the
Royal
Health
Organization
is
also
making
and
seem
to
play
to
specific
interventions
that
these
social
media
platforms
and
search
engines
can
actually
do
to
improve
the
public's
health.
So.
H
M
H
M
K
K
Yes,
thank
you
very
much
and
continuing
on
that
that
line
of
questions
from
director
McKelvey
the
report
on
page
nine
demonstrates
a
doubling
in
the
exemptions
rates
over
the
last
decade.
But
then
it
says
where
we
haven't
quite
hit
the
rate
of
dangerous
levels
of
exemptions.
Is
there
any
idea
of
what
that
rate
is
we.
M
Know
for
different
diseases
different
what
we
call
herd.
Immunity
rates
are
required,
so,
for
example,
for
something
like
measles.
Typically
95%
of
the
population
needs
to
be
considered
immune,
so
either
vaccinated
or
protected
because
they
previously
had
measles
and
so
right.
Now
our
rates
and
schools
are
94%
of
among
vaccinated
individuals.
So
for
something
like
measles,
you
know
having
5%
medical
exemption
rate
might
be
too
high
and
could
result
in
outbreaks
in
places
like
California.
There
were
instances
where
medical
exemption
rates
were,
for
example,
10%
and
definitely
resulted
in
outbreaks.
M
M
K
M
K
M
C
B
C
B
H
M
That
was
something
that
was
included
in
the
ending
hallway
medicine
report.
And
so,
if
the
ministry
is
considering
providing
financial
incentives
for
physicians,
for
example,
who
have
high
rates
of
XYZ,
this
would
be
one
area
in
which
they
could
also
consider
providing
financial
incentives.
So
it
was
in
that
context
that
this
recommendation
was
made.
Okay,.
B
C
Through
your
mr.
chair
I,
don't
think
I
can
say
it
any
better
than
it
stated
in
the
report.
Vaccines
are
safe,
they're
effective
and
they
are
truly
one
of
the
most
important
contributors
to
improving
health
worldwide.
You
will
see
also
in
the
report
that
there
are
rare
instances
where
serious
reactions
can
occur,
but
that
doesn't
take
away
from
the
fact
that
they
are
one
of
the
most
significant
life-saving
interventions
that
has
occurred
in
medical
history.
My.
B
C
B
F
You
very
much
mr.
chair,
as
as
some
of
you
may
know,
for
about
20
years
before
entering
elected
office.
I
worked
in
the
environmental
movement,
particularly
in
the
area
of
human
health
and
the
environment.
I
taught
that
subject
at
the
University
of
Toronto
I
studied
it
as
an
undergraduate
student
and
in
doing
that,
work.
I
learned
to
think
about
topics
like
this
requires
great
care.
F
One
of
the
things
that
I've
heard
today
several
times
is
this
notion
of
body
autonomy
and
I.
Think
it's
very
important
that
we
interrogate
that
and
understand
that,
first
of
all,
biologically
speaking,
there
is
no
such
thing:
every
human
being
trades
bacteria
viruses,
genetic
information
with
other
human
beings
all
the
time
if
you
live
in
a
society.
That's
a
fact.
F
Another
piece,
though,
that
isn't
thought
about
as
carefully
is
that
the
results
of
human
action
are
constantly
interfering
with
our
health
from
the
moment
of
conception,
we're
all
exposed
to
persistent
organic
pollutants
that
are
the
result
of
the
chemical
industry.
Every
breath
that
we
take
contains
emissions
from
the
fossil
fuel
industry.
F
Every
moment
of
every
day,
from
your
first
breath
to
your
last
human
action
is
affecting
your
health.
The
idea
that
there's
some
state
you
can
achieve
a
bodily
autonomy
where
human
actions
don't
impact
your
health
is
a
false
dream.
It's
something
that
if
you
allow
to
lead
your
thinking
about
how
you
look
at
issues
like
vaccination,
you
will
be
led
to
a
wrong
conclusion.
F
The
problem
we
have,
in
my
view,
is
that
we
don't
make
enough
intentional
interventions
in
human
impact
on
human
health
prior
to
the
rise
of
Public
Health.
40
percent
of
all
children
born
did
not
make
it
to
adulthood,
40
percent,
some
say
40
some
say
50,
but
I'll
take
40,
it's
the
lower
number
we
are.
We
are
sitting
here
in
a
moment
of
extraordinary
luck
and
privilege
that
we
don't
have
epidemic
of
childhood
and
mortality
that
everybody
prior
to
the
rise
of
public
health
and
interventions
experienced
throughout
the
globe.
Every
family
lost
a
child.
F
Many
families
lost
all
of
their
children,
but
interventions
like
treating
drinking
water
and
vaccinations
thinking
about
nutritious
food,
educating
young
girls
and
sexual
health.
These
public
health
interventions
are
the
reason
that
we
have
the
civilization
where
we
can
sit
and
argue
about
vaccinations.
F
If
anything,
we
need
to
be
more
aggressive
about
having
public
discussions
of
what
we
can
do
collectively
to
protect
health,
not
fewer.
If
anything,
we
must
do
more
to
dispel
the
myth
that
it
is
possible
to
live
with
some
kind
of
bodily
autonomy.
It's
not
biologically
practical
or
possible.
There
is
no
human
being
alive
whose
health
hasn't
been
impacted
by
human
intervention,
and
there
never
will
be.
We
have
to
do
it
with
intention.
F
Instead
of
simply
wishing
we
could
live
in
some
pristine
state
which
none
of
us
ever
has
lived
in,
and
none
of
us
ever
will
live
in
I
salute
the
courage
of
the
medical
officer
of
Health
and
the
health
professionals
that
we've
heard
today
for
standing
up
for
this
important
principle.
Despite
the
concerns
that
many
have
raised
today,
it's
hard
to
do,
but
it's
necessary
if
we
want
to
have
a
healthy
population,
so
I
will
be
supporting
the
recommendations
in
front
of
us
Thank.
G
So
this
issue
is
very
personal.
For
me,
as
some
of
you
know,
I
was
a
former
public
health.
Nurse
I
was
also
that
immigrant
kid
who
experienced
much
many
racism
in
the
city
and
I
still
experienced
that
before
I
came
here
as
your
colleague
on
this
board
I'm
voting
for
these
recommendation.
Mr.
chair,
because
of
that
little
girl
whose
classmate
in
Hong
Kong
was
suffer
from
polio,
I,
remember
this
little
girl
couldn't
climb
in
the
playground.
G
This
issue
was
also
the
similar
issue
when
we
I
was
so
here
on
this
board,
when
we
debate
on
flooring
right
council
perk.
Remember
that,
so,
if
the
intent
of
this
board
are
legislative
responsibilities,
education,
awareness
and
Prevention,
we
have
to
do
the
right
thing.
This
is
no
different
that
we
did
and
this
board
led
when
it
comes
to
tobacco
strategy.
This
board
led
on
the
on
that
issue,
because
I
was
around
back
in
the
80s
as
a
young
public
health
nurse.
G
B
Any
other
speakers-
okay,
I'll,
speak
then,
and
first
of
all,
you
know,
I
will
be
moving.
The
staff
recommendations
and
I
have
an
amendment
as
well.
If
we
can
be
placed
on
the
screen,
which
is
to
request
Health
Canada,
to
introduce
legislation
to
restrict
inaccurate
and
misleading
anti
vaccine
messaging,
that
is
targeted
to
the
public.
B
Let
me
begin,
first
of
all
and
I
have
moved
the
staff
recommendations
by
thanking
our
staff
for
their
tremendous
hard
work
and
for
their
proactive
work
as
well
to
the
deputies,
all
the
deputies
for
being
here
and
for
talking
and
coming
to
speak
to
us.
But
if
anybody
had
any
question
as
to
whether
tackling
vaccine
hesitancy
was
an
urgent
issue
and
one
that
the
w-h-o
has
said,
it's
one
of
the
top
ten
issues
facing
the
globe
this
morning
demonstrated
that
we
have
work
to
do.
B
Let
me
be
very
clear,
as
our
medical
officer
of
Health
has
stated,
vaccines
work
full
stop.
There
is
an
abundance
of
scientifically
proven
evidence,
demonstrating
just
that.
In
fact,
vaccines
have
saved
more
children's
lives
than
any
other
health
care
intervention
in
human
history,
and
they
have
indeed
eliminated
once
deadly
diseases
and
drastically
reduced
the
risk
of
others.
So
why
are
we
here?
B
We
are
here
because
in
2019
in
the
21st
century,
vaccine
hesitancy
is
on
the
rise
where
we
have
across
the
United
States
and
in
Europe
measles
outbreaks
leading
to
deaths
and
in
Canada,
where
we
have
20%
20%
in
this
city
of
parent,
who
are
vaccine
hesitant,
and
we
also
have
a
rise
in
false
and
misleading
advertising,
and
the
risk
is
clear.
The
risk
is
clear
for
herd
immunity,
but
the
risk
is
also
clear
today
for
kids
for
pregnant
women
and
for
people
who
are
immunocompromised
and
so
at
the
Toronto
Board
of
Health
in
this
society.
B
As
the
chair
of
the
board,
I'm
not
prepared
to
wait
for
an
outbreak
I'm
not
prepared
to
wait
to
act
rather
based
on
the
research
and
the
evidence
and
the
trends
we
are
seeking
to
proactively
work
to
prevent
that
outbreak.
That's
what
this
report
is
in
April,
when
we
asked
our
our
staff
to
come
forward
with
proposals
for
a
comprehensive
approach.
We
did
this
because
we've
already
seen
in
California
in
Washington
in
New
York
states
have
been
forced
to
respond
after
the
fact
what
public
health
is
fundamentally
about
is
prevention.
B
This
is
an
upstream
action,
that's
required,
and
it
requires
all
levels
of
government
at
the
city
for
us
to
engage
in
more
public
education,
with
healthcare
professionals
and
students
in
the
public,
with
the
province
to
improving
and
implement
an
improved
online
data
system
and
to
consider
removing
the
non-medical
exemptions
and
for
the
federal
government
to
look
at
the
risk
around
advertising
and
for
the
private
sector
and
the
social
media
companies
to
treat
these
the
same.
They
do
with
other
misleading
advertisements.
Now
some
have
said
that
vaccinations
are
an
infringement
on
individual
rights.
B
Well,
people
have
the
fundamental
right
to
believe
what
they
want,
but
they
do
not
have
the
right
to
endanger
others
at
Toronto,
Public
Health.
We
will
expedite
our
work
to
promote
and
defend
vaccinations
and
in
2019
in
the
21st
century,
we
will
once
again
work
to
not
only
defend
science
but
to
protect
the
health
and
well-being
of
our
society.
I'd,
like
our
people,
comfortable
taking
the
vote
on
the
package,
or
do
you
want
to
separate
them
out.
B
No,
no,
we
can
do
the
one
separate
if
you
would
like
that
it's
a
school
board
related
one
number,
four,
okay,
so
for
the
clerk's,
so
where
there
is
a
1,
a
4
1,
a
4
provide
financial
incentives
to
promote
vaccinations
for
local
healthcare
providers.
You
want
to
vote
on
that
one
separately.
Okay,
so
we're
gonna
vote
on
that
and
then
we're
gonna
take
the
rest
as
a
package,
if
that's
all
right,
okay,
so
on
recommendations,
1a
for
all
right,
all
those
in
favor
opposed.
If
any.