VMware Cartographer Community Meetings, 23 Mar 2022

Previous Meeting Next Meeting

⏯

youtube image

►

From YouTube: Cartographer Community Meeting - March 23, 2022

Description

00:00 Intro
01:31 TL;DR, what's new in the project this week?
03:45 Request for RFC: resource status

A

Got it welcome to the cryptographer community meeting a place to share updates on the current status of the project and also to bring your questions, demos, ideas, etc.

A

um I will share the agenda link here in case you don't have it handy.

A

Right there in chat, right and chain screen real, quick.

A

Okay, well again feel free to add yourself to the app in the list, so we can connect back to words.

A

Thank you. All right new faces well montessori you're joining the team and I believe it's the first time. I see you in the uh community meeting so welcome and thanks.

B

A

Taylor as well, and then yeah taylor, welcome here um great great great, to have you here.

A

Okay, all right um well tldr is a bit of a section where we share real, quick, what's new in the project this week and what he is working on. It basically comes basically comes from the uh development board right there in the on the ripple. Let me share that.

A

Right: okay, uh yeah: the board should give you a fair idea. What the team is doing right.

B

A

And what happened in the last meeting a little bit uh summary of what we, what team is working on has to do with tutorials and uh documentation work and then others, uh but uh besides the the code itself, I just wanted to say thank you to everyone who joined yesterday to the cncf webinar recording is already up, and um this is all part of the efforts of keeping you know spreading the word about the project and refining the message we find in our demos refining the way we tell the story.

A

um So thanks thanks, everyone joined and also will be well. I will be in the devil's toronto meetup on april. The 5th this is going to be virtual um registration is open, so yeah feel free to to hang out there to come and and share with this awesome community. This is a meetup with more than 7 000 members, it's a huge community and well that's that's great. So it's great space to keep spreading the love for for the project, great uh okay.

A

So what team is working on a request for rfc, which is a new thing? I believe uh this one. I guess this comes from muddy or enemies. Is that correct, yep, we're.

B

Currently, working on writing this rfc.

A

Great, hopefully,.

B

You have it today, I don't know we'll we'll post it in the community channel when it's ready to for review awesome.

A

Okay, yeah. Thank you once it's live, the the goal is for everyone to provide their comments, observations, etc and and to yeah completely established rsv process. Discussing a a new idea is great: okay, any comments around the request for rfc. We usually introduce this in the office hours meeting, but if someone wants to drop something about this, otherwise we can move on.

A

All right, great, um okay, anything else regarding updates on the project, what team is working on besides, during a new release,.

A

Nope, okay, great so yeah. Next, in the open, my discussions, which again it's open, feel free to add anything. You want to discuss ask in this section.

A

um I was thinking on proposing you and then running a poll in the community channel um changing the cadence for this particular meeting to every other week um because uh yeah in order to to gather enough updates uh for for the first single meeting- and you know every two weeks thumbs up thumbs down on this idea.

A

What do you think.

A

Reactions here to give your thumbs up or down.

B

Yeah, I think david, you probably know the best out of any one. If we've been cutting this meeting short every week, and it would just.

A

B

To go to every other week.

A

Yeah, thank you cool all right. uh Next, up, breaking change.

B

So uh I don't actually know, let me pull up who, who or who opened this issue, there's an issue attached to it, but essentially.

B

They had in the workload name had a period and the workload name gets translated into many different resources, and I think it was in a service or something that the workload name was used and it failed because the period is not a dns label, 1035 some very specific character that some subset of characters that is allowed, and so there is a proposal to limit the. What characters can be used on the workload uh name, and this would be a breaking change because we would be limiting the character set.

B

um And so I guess we just wanted to get some community opinions on this change.

A

Yes cut, please.

C

Yeah so, while I agree, this is definitely a potential breaking change for some class of users, I wonder how many actual cases in the wild this will affect like, because currently, if you use these special characters, certainly it depends on the particulars of your supply chain, uh but, like you're, probably already broken. So this is really just a matter of validating sooner or providing a better error message.

B

Yeah, it's kind of in the same same thought as that.

B

Do what do we have to do.

B

For this, like as it's a breaking change just post about it, we don't have to do. We need to bump any versions of anything like or we just say this was. Is this just a bug and we're fixing it? I mean that's kind of where I was at.

C

I mean I would tend to consider this a bug that's being fixed.

C

Just because, like the the current behavior wasn't functional in many in almost all cases um but like it is possible that someone had a supply chain where all the resources they were stamping out, didn't have that restriction.

C

So then this would then affect them.

C

So the other option is to make the the change how the behavior of how resources are named when they're stamped out and not to base it on the workload name or to do it on the safe version, the workload name whatever. That means.

C

That's probably a lot more work.

B

If anyone else has any comments want to throw anything on the issue or the pr, I'm happy to take a look at those. Otherwise, I think we will move forward with this change and make the change on deliverable also.

A

Thank you any comment around this or wise, please feel free to add it yeah to the issue or the vr.

A

Okay, um okay, anything else you like to discuss to share the media here.

A

Okay, um thank you all for your time hope to see you well in the next meeting. Thanks.