►
Description
No description was provided for this meeting.
If this is YOUR meeting, an easy way to fix this is to add a description to your video, wherever mtngs.io found it (probably YouTube).
A
Let's
see
do
we
have
any
public
comment?
A
Okay,
any
anybody
else
on
there
Kevin
do
you
have
anything.
A
Nothing
to
report
okay,
Louise
indicates
she'd,
be
about
15
minutes
late.
Getting
on
so
we
will
go
two
chairs
update,
which
I
think
here
we
did
send
the
cyber
security
recommendations
letter
to
the
County
Board,
the
one
that
we
adopted
at
the
last
meeting.
So
that's
been.
C
A
Okay,
that
would
be
that's
on
the.
We
do
need
a
volunteer
to
take
the
minutes.
D
Mr
Smith
since
you're
a
few
minutes
late.
That
means
you
get
to
volunteer
to
take
the
minutes.
Are
you?
Okay,
with
that
foreign.
A
C
A
A
All
right
all
right,
Jim
you're
at
the
airport,
Jim,
are
you
at.
A
All
right
all
right,
we've
got
a
volunteer.
Thank
you,
Jack
appreciate
that,
and
we
will
deal
with
minutes
later
on
many
of
them.
Let's
see
so
yeah
no
feedback
or
response
from
the
board.
Yet
on
our
recommendation
letter
I,
don't
know
if
you've
heard
anything.
B
E
A
At
all,
all
right,
my
left
here
is
Prescott
Burton
who
attended
our
last
meeting
and
he
applied
to
join
our
commission
and
John
and
I
talked
with
them.
He
met
with
Libby
Garvey
and
he
was
on
the
recessed
session
of
the
board.
We
hope
that
he
was
appointed
by
got
an
official
word,
so
we're
gonna
take
the
position
that
you're
a
guest
tonight,
but
hopefully
you
will
be
a
member
by
our
next
meeting.
G
B
A
H
A
And
and
John
and
I
have
recommended
that
he'd
be
appointed,
he
met
with
Libby
and
Libby
Garvey,
our
liaison,
and
he
was
apparently.
A
Appointed
well,
we
have
not
seen
we
didn't
say
so,
and
it
doesn't
say
so
assuming,
but
all
right,
John
and
I
spoke
with
Julia
Berg
manager
of
programs
with
Arlington
Public,
Library
and
Brittany
beeland,
who
works
with
Julia
about
a
tech
commission
co-hosted
book
club,
possibly
with
an
author
sometime
in
the
future
and
they're
going
to
look
into
it.
We've
made
a
couple
of
suggestions
of
possible
authors
or
books,
and
they
I
thought
it
would
sound
like
a
good
idea.
A
This
is
something
that
Tech
commission
did
a
few
years
a
few
years
back
at
the
Central
Library.
We
thought
it
would
be
a
good
opportunity
for
us
to
reach
out
to
the
community
and
basically
do
a
book
book
club.
I
A
A
Let's
see
Miranda
Miranda
Willis
had
a
conflict
tonight.
Jonathan
adelstein,
Jim
surprisingly
made
it
from.
Are
you
in
at
the
airport,
in
San
Diego.
F
F
So
that's
I
I
embark
at
What,
12,
30,
Eastern,
12
30
a.m.
Eastern
time
I'm,
looking
forward
to
it.
Okay,.
A
Because
we
need
to
reflect
where
you're
attending
the
meeting
from
so.
D
Yeah
I'm
participating
from
home
via
medical
exemption,
as
approved
by
the
chair.
Okay,
yes,.
I
I
A
All
right
all
right
now,
that's
good!
Let's
see
I
think
that's
our
our
housekeeping
I
think
we're
taking
care
of
that.
So
that
brings
us
to
item
number
four
on
our
gen
agenda:
the
Broadband
resource
evaluation
and
needs
assessment
report,
presentation:
Jennifer
Scott!
Is
it
Scout?
Let's
go
okay,
strategic
projects,
planner
research
and
strategic
initiatives;
group
Hartman
of
community
planning,
Housing
and
Development
Holly
hartel
who's,
no
stranger
to
us,
assistant,
CIO
or
strategic
initiative,
Arlington
County.
J
G
J
J
G
J
Study
and
I'm
going
to
be
using
the
Consultants
slide
deck
to
give
the
presentation.
J
J
J
G
J
J
A
huge
all
of
these
really
big
questions,
weren't
really
clear
to
us,
and
we
felt
like
we
were
missing
data
to
really
answer
that
and
information.
There
was
still
somewhat
of
a
question
even.
J
Felt
like
we
had
more
of
an
affordable
issue
and
a
digital
literacy
issue.
We
weren't
sure
we
didn't
know
if
there
was
also
an
infrastructure
issue,
and
so,
while
we
knew
a
lot,
we
had
a
lot
of
information
gaps
and
that
we
felt
like
that
was
that
was
a
lot
of
unanswered
policy
questions
decision
making.
So
we
embarked
on
this
study
and.
J
G
J
H
J
There
were
a
lot
of
different
things
that
fed
into
this
needs
assessment
report.
A
lot
of
data
points
the
Consultants
had
used
local
data
Federal
data
data
we
had
ever
used
were
some
that
we
had
like
the
Census
Data.
They
had
sent
out
an
online
survey
that
helped
get
some
information
that
was
difficult
to
census
data,
and
then
they
interviewed
about
70
stakeholders
from
a
variety
of
different
groups
across
all
of
this
combined
layered
on
to
each
other.
J
Is
a
big
resource
out
there
that
that
we
had
them
look
at
for
anyone
who's,
not
familiar.
It's
a
70
mile,
Network
County
owned.
It's
a
maintained,
dark.
B
G
J
Municipal
uses
like
Public
Safety
and
traffic
traffic
lights
and,
as
you
can
see
from
the
map,
it
really
doesn't
go
into
the
neighborhoods.
It
really
is
more
in
the
commercial
corridors
and
that's
because
of
what
it's
serving
and
where
it
you
see
that
it
it
is
going
into
neighborhoods.
J
But
then
jbg
Smith
came
with
the
with
everything
going
on
in
National
landing
and
they
signed
an
agreement
with
us
to
utilize
that
for
their
work
in
National
Landing
next
slide
over
the
next
couple
of
slides
I'll
be
just
presenting
some
highlights
from
the
FCC
data
that
we
we
actually
had
to
get
special
permission
to
receive
it
and
to
publish
it.
J
And
so
this
is
property
level
data
which
we
had
and
we
wanted
to
evaluate
I
guess
we
want
to
use
speed
benchmarks
as
proxy
for
for
quality,
and
we
looked
at
two
different
benchmarks
that
are
out
there:
100
megabits
per
second
down
20
megabits
per
second
upload.
This
is
the
Federal
gift
for
being
so
anything
less
than
that
you're.
Considering
an.
J
G
G
J
A
hundred
symmetrical
or
better
or
better,
so
we
looked
at
both
and
virtually
all
of
Arlington
like.
J
G
J
Hold
Arlington
to
that
higher
standard
of
100
symmetrical
or
higher
only
five
percent
of
our
locations
don't
need
that
Target
next
slide,
no
real
Geographic
concentration
of
of
those
areas.
So
hey
it's
five
percent!
It's
that
geographically
concentrated
anywhere.
We
couldn't
find
anything
that
says
so,
and
all
planing
corridors
are
sort
of.
You
know
they're
at
the
same
level
of
service.
J
And
I
think
the
situation
is
improving
as
we
speak,
because
Comcast
is
undergoing
a
rather
public
upgrade
to
their
Xfinity
Service
this
year
to
be
able
to
achieve
over
200
megabits
per
second
upload.
So
once
that
takes
place,
only
83
locations
will
actually
not
achieve
100
symmetrical
or
high.
So
it's
pretty
pretty
minimal
next
slide.
J
We
also
have
competition
here
in
Arlington
how
we're
defining
competition,
where
you
have
two
providers
or
more
so
when
looking
at
that,
only
five
percent
of
the
serviceable
addresses
don't
have
more
than
one
provider
and
then
again,
once
Comcast
makes
their
upgrade.
That's
going
to
be.
You
know,
95
of
our
locations
will
two.
G
J
G
J
J
Yeah,
and
also
in
talking
with
the
consultant
like,
we
had
a
lot
of
discussion
around
this
because
technically
all
of
Arlington
has
choice
because
of
T-Mobile,
because
T-Mobile
is
is
everywhere
and
you
can
access
that.
But
we
asked.
J
But
to
your
point
about
looking
at
various
I
guess:
property
owner
caused
issues.
They
did
look
at
that
they,
and
that
was
an
issue
going
into
the
study
we
wanted.
G
J
Signed
a
contract
for
one,
and
so
that's
there's
a
whole
section
that
you
can
reference,
but.
G
D
And
just
to
clarify
here
when
we're
talking
about
the
number
of
services
that
are
available,
we're
talking
about
that,
the
service
provider
could
connect
their
Network
to
that
address
or
that
location,
not
that
that
it
actually
is
connected
right.
D
And
then
another
thing
I
think
is
important
to
note
here
is
that
the
location
means
building
not
like
housing
unit
right,
so
one
location
could
be
a
multi-unit
building
with
hundreds
of
apartments
or
it
could
be
a
single
family
home
or
could
be
a
commercial
building
with
businesses
right.
J
J
Next
slide,
and
so
I
mean
generally,
we
have
good
infrastructure
I
think
we
knew
that
and
this
study
and
having
this
new
data
confirmed
that
for
us,
affordability,.
C
C
J
G
G
B
J
J
Available
for
those
who
struggle
to
afford,
most,
notably
the
federal,
affordable
connectivity
program,
which
it
will
it
offers
low
and
or
low-cost
packages
from
internet
providers.
And
then,
when
paired
with
the
federal
subsidy
that's
available,
you
can
essentially
zero
out
your
internet,
but
I
will
say
that
you
have
to
income
qualify.
J
G
C
J
A
much
lower
income
standard
so
while
it's
important
definitely
it's
underutilized
in
Arlington,
it
doesn't
address
the
full
name.
Next
slide.
The
next
couple
of
slides
these
focus
on
our
digital
inclusion
activities.
What
we're
doing
here,
what
we're
doing
right
and
what
so
in
additional.
In
addition
to
the
household
subsidies
I
mentioned
from
the
federal
government,
there's.
J
Partners
have
that
are
focused
on
this
topic.
A
lot
of
them
are
providing
digital
literacy
activities
a
lesser
extent,
offering
an
Engaged
in
an
affordable
internet
activities
and
then,
on
an
even
lesser
extent.
There
are
some
who
are
focused
on
device
next
slide:
some
of
the
affordable
housing
providers
they're
starting
to
offer
in-unit
Wi-Fi,
free
and
unit
Wi-Fi
or
discounted
Wi-Fi
for
residents
and.
J
J
J
J
Yeah
yeah
and
yeah
and
second,
we
've
we've
done
a
lot
and
we
continue
to
do
a
lot.
But
it's
all
in
sort
of
a
pilot
says
and
it's
or
it's
on
a
smaller
scale
than
what
is
needed.
And
then
lastly,
County
departments
and
externalities.
J
J
I
K
J
Right
I
think
I
think
on
some
level
for
certain
pilot
projects
we've
implemented.
It's
I,
don't
know
that
we
fully
understood
what
to
do
and
I
think
we're
just
trying
to
do
something
to
move
the
needle
forward
and
I.
Think
that's
part
of
what
the
study
is
about
is
to
hone
those
efforts
in
to
really
figure
out
what
it
is
we
should
be
doing
and
where
we
should
be
focusing
our
efforts.
That's
most
meaningful.
So
that's
one
thing,
but.
G
J
J
J
J
The
first
is
underway:
it's
this
model
evaluation,
that's
kind
of
Technical
and
it's
going
to
analyze,
four
different
internet.
Three
models
offer
up
implementation
considerations,
costing
strengths,
benefits,
risks
and,
and
then,
following
this
evaluation,
we
share
a
final
report.
It's
going
to
have
strategic
recommendations
that
the
county
could
consider
and
I
just
want
to
point
out
that
this
is
not
like
the
comprehensive
plan.
That's
put
forward
to
the
board
and
they're
acting
on
it.
They're.
J
Be
acting
on
any
for
us,
the
county
has
never
actually
put
together
anything
like
this.
Yes,
comprehensive
report
of
kind
of
what
is
broadband
in
Arlington
and
what
should
we
do
with
all
these
all
the
different
things
that
are
feeding
into
it?
J
It
could
I
think
I
think
there's
a
conversation
to
be
with
the
county
board
with
County
leadership,
but
it
could
they
could
recommend
exploring
one
of
the
Consultants
recommendations
further
or
they
could
recommend
that
staff
who
maybe
put
together
an
implementation
like
framework
that
staff
LED.
That
would
have
more
more.
A
J
Yeah,
so
we're
tracking
that
this
process
would
end
in
the
fall.
Hopefully
the
model
evaluation
will
conclude
end
of
summer
and
then
the
final
report
would
complete
the
ball
and
that
would
lead
into
possible
conversations
about
what.
I
I
That
digital
literacy
is
a
huge
Factor
and
again
the
Outreach,
and
how
to
get
people
that
digital
literacy
is
as
it
is,
with
any
of
these
issues
like
public
health
as
an
example
where
we
have
similar,
you
know
10-year
mortality
rate
differences
in
one
ZIP
code,
but
it's
not
just
you
can't
just
say:
that's,
let's
just
cure
these
three
diseases
yeah,
it's
like
how
do
you
is
that
I
mean
because
that
seems
to
me
like
what
really
boils
down
to
is
all
is
not
technology
per
se,
but
Outreach
and
intervention
strategy.
J
Mean
that
their
recommendations
could
include
things
policy
things
we
could.
K
J
K
And
you
have
a
scale
of
how
the
model
is
going
to
be
applied
and
we're
based
on
what
their
related
consultant
saying.
Is
this?
What
we
want
to
do?
This
is
what
the
policy
for,
where
do
we
want
to
Target,
and
what
does
it
mean
you
can
spend
the
store
you
can
spend
money
on
an
infrastructure
to
distribute
potentially
solve
some
of
the
problems?
I
I
And
literacy
so
seems
like
it
is
much
more,
although
there
might
one
of
the
things
you
might
find
when
you're
doing.
That
is
that
you
find
some
technical
gaps,
but
not
necessarily
access,
maybe
other
kinds
of
technical
people,
but
it
so
that
would
mean
I
would
think
that,
depending
on
different
identification
of
different
populations,
either
in
location
or
demographics,
that
our
partnership
might
then
be
with
some
commission.
That
is
not.
Technology
focused,
but
demographic.
A
D
John
thanks
I
was
curious
to
follow
up
on
the
statistic
that
only
18
of
eligible
County
households
that
are
that
are
eligible.
Take
advantage
of
the
subsidy.
The
federal
subsidy
and
I
was
wondering
if
we
had
looked
into
why
that
is
because
I
think
to
Jackie's
point.
The
infrastructure
is
maybe
not
the
impediment,
but
it
does
seem
that
cost
is
an
impediment,
and
we've
heard
that
also
from
our
friends
at
Arlington.
The
affordable
housing
theme
that
ran
the
one
of
the
digital
Pilots.
D
That
cost
is
really
the
main
barrier
to
getting
their
their
residents
connected
and
so
the
availability
of
the
subsidy,
but
people
not
taking
advantage
of
it
I'm
curious
as
to
why,
if
we
unders
think
we
understand
why
people
aren't
taking
advantage
of
that,
I
didn't.
C
A
H
C
Oh
okay,
great
so
I,
don't
know
that
this
will
answer.
John's
question
or
Northern
I
think
was
directed
to
me,
but
the
18
18
ACP,
take
rate.
I
mean
we're
seeing
that
kind
of
across
the
board.
Is
that
it's
not
as
high
as
we'd
like
it
to
be?
Obviously
we
do
a
ton
of
Outreach
and
I
always
be
for
Comcast.
By
the
way
we
do
a
ton
of
Outreach
to
community
organizations
that
that
reach
low-income
residents.
That
would
be,
you
know,
eligible
for
the
program,
but
also
one.
C
This
is
just
a
hypothesis,
but
Arlington
has
a
really
awesome
partnership
that
they
created
with
the
EPS
that
that
Holly
was
involved
with
I
worked
on
very
closely
with
Holly
and
her
team,
and
we
connected
well
over
a
thousand
students
to
our
Internet
Essentials
program,
because
APS
decided
to
continue
with
that.
All
of
those
people
could
have
transitioned
to
the
ACP
a
lot
of
school
districts
elected
to
do
that
APS
decided
to
keep
it
the
way
it
is
which
is
which
is
fine
by
us.
C
So
that
means
that
they're
not
getting
the
ACP
because
there's
no
need
for
because
the
school
district
is
already
paying
for
it.
That
could
be
what's
contributing
to
the
I
guess
the
slightly
lower
ACP
take
rate
in
Arlington.
That's
just
one
hypothesis,
but
I
did
want
to
point
out
the
partnership
that
we
have
with
the
school
district.
At
the
time
connected
all
the
students
that
needed
internet
service,
whether
it
was
through
Internet
Essentials
that
we
offer
or
the
the
modified
devices
that
the
wireless
companies
provided
to.
A
A
G
C
They
wanted
it
for
free;
they
won't
have
to
pay
anything
more
exactly,
but
if
they
want
a
gig
speed,
service
they'd
certainly
have
access
to
that
as
well.
But
if
they
didn't
want,
if
they
wanted
to
keep
it
for
free,
they
could
keep
it
at
the
internet.
Socialist
price
and
I
would
point
out.
I.
Think
someone
commented
that
just
because
you
live
in
public
housing
doesn't
automatically
mean
you're
eligible
for
the
ACP.
C
That
does
mean
you
are
eligible
for
our
Internet
Essentials
program,
so
they
typically
go
hand
in
hand,
but
if
you
do
live
in
public
housing
or
go
to
a
title
one
school,
even
if
your
student
isn't
necessarily
eligible
for
a
free
reduced
school
lunch
program,
all
they
have
to
do
is
go
to
a
title.
One
school
they'd
be
eligible
for
for
ACP,
for
our
Internet
Essentials
program.
G
K
That
can
address
affordability,
so
there's
options
that
we're
looking
at
in
the
model.
One
of
them
is
subsidies
and
what
that
looks
like
and
how
we're
meeting
those
who
don't
either
qualify
for
ACP
and,
in
addition
to
those
who
don't
to
understand
what
would
be
the
total
cost,
should
the
county
as
well
fitting
in
vesting
ACP
to
the
point.
Also
there
have
there
has
to
be
more,
you
know,
communication
and
that
I
think
it's
probably
going
to
come
as
part
of
the
recommendation
and.
G
C
G
C
To
that
point,
Holly
too,
the
state
of
Maryland
has
an
additional
15
per
month
for
emergency
Broadband
benefits.
So
if
you
lived
in
Maryland,
you
could
get
45
off
of
your
bill.
Albemarle
County
has
one
as
well
I
think
theirs
is
20
a
month,
so
Albemarle
is
right
outside
of
Charlottesville.
So
there
are
some
communities
that
are
doing
additional
benefits
beyond
the
ACP
yeah.
D
So
I
think
my
question
might
have
got
lost
there.
I
was
the
the
specific
question
was:
do
we
think
we
understand
why
the
take
rate,
the
the
sign
up
break
for
that
subsidy
program
is
so
low,
or
is
that
something
we
we
still
need
to
investigate.
J
So
there's
been
some
kind
of
uncovering
of
maybe
why
I
guess
definitely
say,
but
it's
it's
sort
of
this
two-step
process.
You
first
have
to
verify
your
eligibility
with
the
Federal
government.
Then
you
go
to
the
internet
provider
of
your
choice
and.
G
J
The
package
that
you
and
so
I
think
that
there's
a
lot
for
someone
to
kind
of
manage
and
deal
with
and
I
think
that's
that's
one
possible
explanation
and
what
we,
what
we
know
and
I
know
that
they've
improved
things
federal
government
has
to
improve
improve
since
the.
J
Program
was
just
put
in
place
during
covet,
but
Holly
had
a
lot
of
experience,
helping
with
Outreach
there
and
actually
received
a
lot
of
calls.
I.
Think
there's
a
lot
of
confusion
as
to
how
to
how
so
I
think
like
there
needs
to
be
a
lot
of
hand.
Holding
and
I
think
that
there
are
and
that's
why
one
of
the
things
eligible
expenses
for
the
Outreach
grants
that
are
that
out.
There
is
hosting
sign.
J
Is
what
is
needed?
It's
hand-holding
people,
but
that's
really
time
consuming
so
I
mean
we
haven't
really
done
that
there's
been
Partners
who
have
done
that
and
they
partnered
with
Comcast
I
know
the
Aging
Alliance
a
lot
of
that,
and
so
that's
I,
think
just
digital
literacy
and
awareness
and
understanding
of
the
process.
J
J
J
J
C
J
G
A
Okay,
I
think
that
might
might
be
something
to
be
interested
in
sure.
Thanks
for
watching.
Okay,
all
right
thanks,
Louise
keep
it.
H
C
J
Outreach,
it
is
expensive
to
host
those
kinds
of
contact
resource
intensive,
because
you
have
to
have
a
person
there
walking
someone
through
and
it
takes
a
lot
of
time
and
there's
only
so
much
that
one
person
how
many
there's.
G
G
G
K
J
Have
a
data
available
that
touch
on
demographics,
legible,
households
and
the
use
of
ACP?
But
in
terms
of
the
like,
the
census
data
that
that's
presented
in
the
report
of
being
subscription
used
in
computer
use.
That.
G
I
H
A
G
I
I
Organizations
so
I'm
thinking
of
like
the
counties
complete
vaccine
committee,
which
has
now
become
the
same
model,
is
being
used
for
the
preparedness
and
the
new
preparedness
advisory
committee
is
built
on
that
same
model.
G
C
Yeah-
and
this
is
Kevin
if
I
can
just
chime
in
and
we're
kind
of
talking
about,
the
D
for
digital
Navigator,
so
people
to
kind
of
help,
others
that
don't
have
the
digital
literacy
skills
kind
of
get
connected
and
how
to
how
to
use
a
computer
how
to
use
the
internet.
So
that's
kind
of
what
we're
talking
about
here,
but
I
do
want
to
kind
of
point
out
the
alliance
for
Arlington
seniors,
which
I
didn't
call
you.
C
You
brought
up
a
they're,
really
probably
my
favorite
partner
that
we
work
with
across
the
region
because
of
just
how
successful
their
kind
of
Outreach
programs
have
been
granted.
It's
a
small
scale.
They've
done
numerous
sign
up.
Events
where
we
and
Verizon
have
been
there
to
kind
of
help.
People
get
connected
to
the
internet
through
the
ACP.
But
what
they're
doing
is
really
incredible.
C
Work
I
mean
they'd,
have
Vans
pick
people
up
from
their
affordable
housing
complexes,
bring
them
to
the
Walter
Reed
Community
Center,
where
a
team
of
volunteers
are
helping
them,
navigate
the
ACP
process
to
the
FCC,
and
they
send
them
over
to
the
the
Verizon's
of
the
Comcast
to
get
signed
up
and
and
that
kind
of
model.
If
it
can
be
scaled,
I
think
it
could
be
be
very
successful.
Montgomery
County
has
gotten
a
lot
of
money
to
provide
computers
to
low-income
people
and
Montgomery.
County
is
obviously
much
bigger
than
Arlington,
but
I've
attended.
C
Numerous
events
where
you
know
three
400
people
are
coming
through
there
to
pick
up
computers
and
then
they're
being
sent
over
to
the
various
isps
to
Comcast,
Verizon
I.
Think
RCN
is
up
there
as
well,
and
then
even
wireless
companies
is
too
so.
Those
kind
of
sign
of
events
they're
time
consuming
and
they
cost
money
but
I,
but
I
have
seen
them
work.
A
C
G
K
I
C
Yes
and
I'm
only
talking
about
Comcast
people
too,
there's
plenty
of
other
companies
that
are
participant
in
that
that
could
even
make
that
number
bigger.
D
Yeah
I
was
curious,
I
know
in
the
report
that
spends
a
lot
of
time
on
on
housing
units
and
households.
It
talks
a
little
bit
about
businesses.
D
J
J
G
J
J
Based
on
the
mcpc
data,
actually
at
a
slightly
lower
rate
than
others,
it
was
a
pretty
minimal
number,
so
I
didn't
really
mention
it,
but
they're
actually
at
a
slower
rate,
100
service.
J
J
J
G
D
And
then
Frank,
if
you
would
let
me
of
my
last
question,
my
favorite
question
is
I
noticed
that
you
touch
in
the
towards
the
end
of
the
report
on
the
lack
of
addressing
Broadband
infrastructure
in
the
comprehensive
plan
and
the
fact
that
Virginia
legislature
has
made
that
a
requirement
for
municipal,
comprehensive
plans
and
I
would
say
that.
We've
noticed
that
as
well
and
made
that
recommendation
on
several
occasions.
So
I
look
forward
to
more
kind
of
recommendations
on
how
this
issue
can
be
addressed.
G
G
J
A
A
H
J
County
I
would
say
the
wireless
service
Authority
is
one
of
them.
It's
the
most
extreme.
Okay,
we've
been
identified,
the
scale
of
the
need,
we're
looking
at
you
know,
50
Ami,
households
or
who
are
cost
proven
we're.
J
G
J
Looking
at
it
with
and
without
since
it's
somewhat
underutilized,
we
don't
know
if
it'll
extend
beyond
few
years
from
now
and
then
looking
at
it
100
leveraging
leveraging,
knowing
that
we
should
probably
be
doing
more
Outreach
and
getting
more
and
so
there's
a
couple
of
in
between.
We
could
send
our
own
infrastructure,
but
then
have
someone
else
kind
of
do
the
service
and
then
there's
a
partnership
opportunity
where
more
of
the
onus
is
on
the
internet
provider
and
less
assistance
and
so
they're.
J
J
To
making
sure
it's
easily
understandable
but
looking
kind
of
cross-cutting
and
it's
not
total
Apples
to
Apples,
because
they're
all
very
different.
But.
G
G
J
Didn't
know
where
to
hone
our
Focus,
so
we
want
to
look
at
that
higher
level.
Rough
order,
magnitude
costs
some
of
the
a
lot
of
the
you
know
the
risks
that
are
associated
with
each
each
one
of
them.
What
are
the
benefits?
How
well
would
they
address
the
need
that
we've
identified
and
then
yeah
and
then
and
then
they'll
make
a
recommendation
as
to
which
one
one
they
would
recommend
or
multiple
ones
which.
J
G
G
K
A
J
Link
as
well
yeah,
it's
called
the
model
evaluation
framework,
which
is
essentially
just
kind
of
tells
you
what's
the
scale
of
the
issue.
What
are
we,
you
know?
What
are
we
doing
are
and
how
we're
going
to
do
it
and
again
to
Holly's
point:
it's
it'll
flag
risks,
it'll
flag
benefits,
not
gonna
solve
for
those
risks.
J
To
model,
then
that
one
in
particular
would
need
more
now
if
we
couldn't
just
go
into
implementation,
so
I
need
to
do
research
to
kind
of
hone
in
with
that
mirror
and
then,
like
an
engineering
analysis,
more
business
model,
but
before
we
kind
of
paid
for
that,
we
wanted
to
kind
of
take
a
step
back.
Look
at
things
kind
of
at
the
30
000
foot,
View
and
kind
of
hone,
our
Direction
a
little
bit
with
that.
So.
B
B
A
A
Very
dynamic
situations
constantly
right
right.
H
J
H
A
Thank
you
very
much.
That's
huge
100,
but
30
some
odd
pages.
So
it's
you
know
very
comprehensive.
Taking
an
Innovations
final
report,
Holly
yeah.
K
We
can
just
ask
questions.
I
know
it's
been
a
long
time
coming
to
get
this
information
up
there.
Some
things
I
want
to
highlight
about
the
work
that
we
had
done
is
that
it
was
a
pilot.
G
K
K
So
we
partnered
with
us
ignite
Comcast
as
well
as
Virginia
Tech
and
George
Mason
University,
to
test
out
some
technology
and
and
also
test
out
our
privacy,
all
our
our
pledgling
privacy
principles,
which
hopefully
will
be
coming
privacy
policy
at
some
point
and
to
try
to
do
it
in
a
safe
environment,
the
the
information
we
had
several
different
reports
that
we've
been
working
on
internally.
So
what
you
see
in
the
final
report?
That's
supposed
to
do
this
summary.
There's
three
components
to
that.
One
is
a
internal
assessment
working
with
all
the
partners.
K
What
did
we
learn?
What
were
the
lessons
learned
from
it?
The
third
part
was
a
privacy
panel
assessment
report,
support
summarizing
kind
of
what
some
privacy
recommendations
and
the
third
part
was
George,
Mason
University
really
dug
into
the
technology
and
the
data
itself
and
what
they
were
able
to
see
and
what
they
were
able
to
find
spoiler.
Some
of
the
there
wasn't
really
data
that
we
could
use
for
anything
because
a
lot
of
that
ended
up
being
making
children.
G
K
We
know
it's
accurate,
that's
so
that
was
where
most
of
the
effort
was
spent.
Nothing
was
ever
operationalized
and
at
the
very
beginning,
that
was
a
conversation
that
we
were
focusing
on.
What
it
did
do
for
us
is
understand
the
level
of
maturity
of
where
this
type
of
sensor
information
is
and
to
ask
questions
about
for
Public
Safety.
What's
missing,
what
do
we
need?
So
the
contextualization
one
of
the
things
that
you're
focusing
on
originally
was
fall.
K
Detection
be
able
to
do
fall,
detection
without
a
camera
with
a
data
if
it's
not
there
yet
another's,
not
coming,
but
it's
not
there.
Yet,
in
addition
to
that,
what
type
of
information
in
order
to
prompt
a
public
safety
response,
contextual
information-
isn't
there
yet,
but
it's
coming.
So
what
are
the
types
of
things
that
Public
Safety
needs
to
be
thinking
about,
so
that
they're.
K
G
K
Presentation,
I
hadn't,
prepared,
prepared,
I
think
the
partnership
in
working
with
the
public
safety,
as
well
as
with
Comcast,
because
I
George
Mason
I
mean
was
it
a.
K
Experience
for
all
of
us
in
a
good
our
resources,
one
of
the
things
I
think
it's
important
to
highlight
is
you
know
the
sensor
data
and
the
volume
of
data
that
is.
K
Making
sure
it's
accurate
and
we
didn't
do
that
and
so
partnering
with
George
Mason
was
so
helpful
for
us
thanks.
My
last
thing
is
on
the
Privacy
side.
We
were
very
cautious.
We
had
a
set
of
documents
have
been
created
internally.
Let's
try
this,
let's
see
if
this
Works,
let's
see
if
our
privacy
impact
assessment
is
actually
meaningful,
let's
see
what
it
means
to
you
know.
Where
are
our
risks,
and
we
learned
from
that
so
you've
got
that
information
back
through
County
channels
and
we'll
see
what
comes
out
of
the
other
end.
K
So
I
think
for
us
I
think
was
very
valuable,
I,
don't
know
if
there
I
said
everything
I
don't
know
looked
at
what's
online
and
if
you
have
any
questions,
I'm
happy
to.
I
I
I
had
a
couple
questions:
the
Navy
of
interest
for
this
group.
First,
what
might
be
of
interest
for
follow-up
is
the
nist
framework
was
used
and,
secondly,
that
one
of
the
things
noted
this
was
from
the
slides,
so
it
was
pulled
out
was
getting
the
difficulty
of
dealing
with
privacy
at
a
project
level
as
opposed
to
an
enterprising
and
one
of
our
recommendations.
K
I
K
I
E
G
A
I
I
D
I
Connecting
those
dots
with
the
comprehensive
play
are
going
to
be
in
your
next
iteration
broadband.
I
We
now
have
two
elements
of
common
principles
under
the
digital
Equity,
but
also
under
privacy.
It
could
be
key
elements
in
the
kind
of
plan
and
that
this
group
might
might
continue
to
follow
up
on
so.
I
K
Slides
that
should
be
the
same
thing
within
the
summer
deck,
but
that's
supposed
to
make
sure
it's
clear.
Your
the
Privacy
panel
report
is
not
out
there,
but
these
some.
It
should
be.
The
couple
of
bullets
that
were
selected
from
the
Privacy
panel
reporting
yeah
should
be
reflective
of
what
was
most
important
so.
I
The
other
thing
that
was
absent
was
any
reference.
The
fact
that
the
panels
that
this
item
two
privacy
panel
included
participation
by
two
conditions
and
I
did
think.
Even
though
we
had
some
issues
about
what
happened
to
the
report,
we
did
but
considerable
amount
of
time
and
energy,
as
as
commissions,
get
into
providing
that
some
guidance
that
I
think
were
I.
Think
we
all
thought
is
a
very
good
collaboration,
so
I
think
we
appropriate
to
at
least
reference
that
you're
that
you're
part
of
that
all
the
other
partners
have
mentioned,
but
not
us.
K
G
A
Right,
I
think
our
one
of
our
concerns
back
then,
was
that
there
really
wasn't
a
specific
framework
that
put
those
various
factors
into
account
again.
John.
D
Yeah
I
was
just
I,
didn't
see
it
in
the
in
the
report.
I
know
the
fiscal
impact
of
this
was
pretty
limited
because
the
equipment
was
donated
or
it
was
it
was
lent
to
us
by
the
by
the
owner,
but
was
there
ever
an
assessment
of
the
amount
of
staff,
time
involved,
I
think
and
I
asked,
because
I
think
we
are
and
and
included
in
our
recommendations,
encouragement
to
do
more
of
these
types
of
projects.
D
But
the
concern,
of
course,
is
that
there's,
even
if
there's
not
you
know
significant
fiscal
impact,
it
does
take
staff
time
and
staff
time
is
valuable,
and
so
we
want
to
be
have
it
be.
You
know,
managed
appropriately
and
focused
on
the
most
important
stuff.
So
was
there
ever
kind
of
an
assessment
of
of
Staff
time
that
was
invested
in
this.
K
K
D
Yeah
we
heard
from
from.
D
Miss
McMahon
last
week
or
last
month
on
the
on
the
performance
parking
pilot.
One
of
the
comments
she
made
was
that
it
it's
very
hard
for
her
team
to
find
the
time
to
do
Innovative
stuff,
like
the
performance
parking
pilot
without
like
a
driver
without
the
funding
behind
it,
and
so
I
was
just
curious
like
it's
interesting
to
hear
your
characterization
as
being
it
was
workable.
It
sounds
like
maybe
you
took
on
a
lot
of
the
load
but
I
think
finding
ways
to
to
create
space
for
staff.
D
To
do
things
like
that,
I
think
would
be
good
and
I
think
the
way
to
do
that
is
if
we're
focused
on
things
that
are
are
really
high
priorities,
because
then
everyone
can
get
behind
carving
out
a
little
time
to
do
it
on
the
side.
So
to
speak.
I
K
Had
reached
out
to
two
different
everybody.
G
I
I
K
G
A
All
right,
I,
don't
think
we
have
any
more
action
items.
I
No
I
think
John.
Probably
your
expert
on
that.
D
No
I
I
think
you
know
we
made
our
recommendations
and
nothing
in
the
the
summary
I
think
changes
that
it's
all
still
good,
I
think
the
Privacy
aspects
of
that
project
were
the
best
parts
and
I
think
those
and
the
idea
of
working
with
industry
to
do
pilots
and
demonstration
projects
and
learn,
is
really
good
and
should
be
carried
forward
and
policy
should
enable
that
to
move
faster
so
long
as
the
risks
are
managed
and
it's
focused
on
community
priorities.
D
I
mean
it
was
kind
of
part
of
the
inspiration
for
the
idea
of.
Could
we
could
we
develop
this
into
a
more
this
type
of
project
into
a
more
regularly
scheduled
programming
in
partnership
with
industry
as
an
as
another
toolkit
as
another
tool
in
Economic
Development
toolkit?
A
All
right
now
other
questions,
we'll
move
on
to
item
number,
six
July
Broadband
session
planning,
I.
Think,
given
the
report
or
presentation,
we
had
tonight
I'm,
not
sure
that
it's
really
right
yet
for
us
to
I
think
what
we
discussed
was
doing
sort
of
a
public
forum
on
the
Broadband
Authority
option
of
the
model.
I
don't
know
John.
Do
you
think
we
should
still
go
forward
with
that
at
the
July
meeting.
D
Think
I
think
we
should.
You
know
if,
if
folks
wanna
after
hearing
this
presentation
and
having
access
to
the
report,
want
to
show
up
and
make
public
comment,
I
think
we
should
encourage
that
to
inform
kind
of
the
reaction
in
in
characterization
of
the
report,
but
I
agree
that
any
sort
of
I
don't
think
we're
ready
to
make
any
sort
of
recommendations
or
or
actions
as
a
commission.
Until
we
hear
phase
two
and
three
of
the
the
needs
assessment,
yeah.
I
A
G
A
The
various
viewpoints
I
think
we're
not
there
yet
yeah.
We
gotta
wait
and
see
what
the
recommendations
right.
I
A
G
D
A
K
F
A
Right
I
mean
they're
right.
There
is
I,
think
a
place
there
on
the
web
page.
To
do
that,
yes,
I
mean.
Do
you
see
any
benefit
in
US,
although
based
based
on
our
stable
franchise
renewal
hearing
I
would
say
if
a
tree
falls
in
the
forest
and
nobody
hears
it.
A
A
Yes,
oh
yeah
anxiously
awaited
all
right
that
I
think
John
and
I
will
confer
on
July,
which
brings
anything.
A
Which
does
I
guess
add
I,
guess
hey
have
some
impact
on
how
what
we
want
to
do
for
that
real
hot
old
John
to
try
to
figure
that
one
out
and.
A
Maybe
we
want
to
flip
flop
and
go
go
to
the
August
meetings,
Spike
July
and.
I
A
A
A
Stick
with
the
plan:
okay,
we're
sticking
with.
We
took
a
boat.
B
A
A
All
right
Virginia
is
going
to
receive
what
nearly
1.5
billion
dollars
in
Broadband
funding
through
the
Broadband
Equity
access
and
deployment.
The
deed
program,
whose
goal
is
to
connect
all
Americans
to
high-speed
Broadband,
probably
that
hundred
hundreds
by
2030.
A
at
the
announcement
of
the
big
funding.
President
Biden
noted
that
the
White
House
is
working
with
Congress
to
extend
the
affordable
connectivity
program
ACP.
That
means,
but
it
did
receive
bipartum
or
bipartisan
support
in
the
past.
But
there
actually
has
been
some
discussion
or
concerns
about
fraud,
and
so
there
so
there
may
be
some
additional
strings
or.
A
K
K
G
K
G
G
A
And
there
are
actually
excuse
me
to
my
next
item.
Fcc
sure
there
are
many
buckets
of
money
here.
Fcc
chairwoman,
Rosen
Warsaw,
announced
a
learn:
Without
Limits
initiative,
urging
her
telecommissions.
G
A
Vote
to
allow
e-rate
to
to
allow
e-rate
funding
to
be
used
for
Wi-Fi
and
school
buses
and
to
support
Wi-Fi
hotspots
so
that
libraries,
School
libraries
and
schools
can
check
my
math
to
patrons.
Today
again,
this
is
using
EV
rate
in
the
past.
Hadn't
been
authorized
for
those
types
of
uses
and
they're
really
trying
to
to
stretch,
stretch
it
and
push
that
earlier.
A
A
G
E
A
A
Privacy
infringements,
Starry
effects,
wireless
internet
provider
here
in
Arlington,
will
be
exiting
from
chapter
11
bankruptcy
with
a
new
CEO.
It's
Starry
grew
its
networking
customers,
nearly
60
from
the
2020
2020
to
2022
and
Starry
is
offered
here
and
I
think
their
largest
Focus
has
been
on
the
multi-dwelling
units.
Yes,
and
they
use
actually
interesting
bunch
of
frequencies.
They
use
the
former
lmds
frequencies,
which
I
think
are
in
the
23
gigahertz
band,
so
it's
fairly
high
up
there,
but
it
apparently
where
I
I
know
somebody
who
has
it
it
works.
A
A
F
E
A
Facilitate
that
transition
through
rule
making
U.S
Conference
of
mayors
has
objected
to
portions
of
legislation
that
would
set
a
60
to
90
day
shot
clock
for
how
long
localities
can.
H
A
Law
Firm
that
the
county
uses
was
involved
with
the
working
with
the
conference
of
Mayors
and
objecting
to
that
legislation.
The
FCC
announced
details
for
additional
Outreach
grant
opportunities
to
promote
the
affordable
connectivity
program.
Yeah
Outreach
grants
seek
to
enlist
target
targeted
trusted,
Community
Messengers
to
develop
Innovative
Innovative
Outreach
strategies,
reach
unserved
and
underserved
running
over
a
little
bit,
but
that's
all
I
have
this
one
and
I
can
actually
exactly
I
can
actually
send
you.
My
list.
H
Good
I
I
do
have
a
question.
Okay,
I
was
asked
to
request
feedback
from
the
folks
in
teams
land
out
there
have
you
noticed
any
audio
issues,
Broadcasting.
A
All
right,
one
item
for
you:
I
saw
the
videos
for
all
our
meetings
are
on
the
web
page,
but
the
one
set
of
minutes
that
were
approved
weren't
up
yet
I
think
March
was
approved.
Okay
I
think
I
sent
you
a
copy.
I'll
go,
look
all
right,
which
brings
us
to
approval
and
meeting
that
we've
actually
had
a
flurry
of
minutes.
Yours
were
the
only
one
approved
so
far,
so
you're
the
winner
so
far,
but
we
have
circulated
John
circulated.
February
did
anything
anybody
have
any
changes
for
John's
February
minutes.
A
G
A
A
Anything
else
for
the
April
minutes
or
eight
or
no
that
was
may
actually
I'm.
Sorry
I'm
talking
about
the
name
and
it's
real
to
April
next,
but
may
minutes
the
main
minutes.
That's
what
they
were
good,
all
right,
that
yours,
I,
think,
okay,
so.
H
A
H
A
H
A
I
I'm
learning
the
twos
here
so
conflating
the
two
minutes
so
all
right.
Well,
anything
more
from
Moran
I
actually
put
some
additional
edits
there
as
far
as
people
who
were
attending
or
not
attending,
and
she
did
actually
make
the
change
that
I
had
changed.
The
spelling
of
my
name
from
zazzo
to
Jazz
outside.
A
So,
okay,
why
don't
we
take
April
minutes?
We
have
a
motion
to
adopt
the
April
minutes.
A
All
right,
hi,
okay,
I,
think
that
one
carries
eight,
eight,
nothing.
Okay,
maybe
minutes!
That's
one,
okay,
any
additional
edits
for
the
made
other
than
yours,
April.
Okay,
it's
clear:
okay,
hey,
okay,.
A
I
A
So
I
think
we
only
actually
I
went
back
to
the
videotape
on
January
and
it
looked
actually
looked
like
John,
you
and
I
think,
because
somebody
off
just
off
the
camera
but
I
think
it
might
have
been.
You
said
you
were
taking
notes
and
you
might
get
together
on
January.
A
A
A
A
H
How
do
you
get
the
transcript,
not
the
video,
but
the
set
of
special
request
thing
Richard
can
provide
I.
Think.