►
Description
City of Boston Licensing Board Licensed Premise Inspection Hearings 4/27/21
A
Good
afternoon,
this
is
the
hearing
before
the
licensing
board
for
the
city
of
boston.
Today
is
tuesday
april
27th.
Today's
hearing
is
being
conducted
pursuant
to
certain
temporary
amendments
to
the
open
meeting
lot.
That
is
what
allows
us
to
meet.
Virtually
this
hearing
will
be
recorded
and
will
be
posted
to
the
city's
website.
Before
we
review
some
procedural
matters,
I
will
introduce
chairwoman
kathleen
joyce.
B
A
Thank
you
as
a
reminder.
Please
mute
yourself
unless
you
are
testifying
before
the
board.
Please
ensure
that
your
audio
and
your
video
is
functioning.
When
you
are
called
you
will
need
to
be
sworn
in.
So
again,
please
make
sure
you
can
turn
on
your
video.
I
will
call
each
item
in
the
order
it
appears
on
the
agenda.
I
will
read
the
item
into
the
record.
I
will
then
ask
who
is
president
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
A
A
A
Calling
ghira
and
tambora
llc
doing
business
as
guira
and
tambora
located
at
4014
washington
street.
The
date
of
the
incident
was
july:
26
2020
patron
on
patreon
assault
and
violation
of
mass
general
law;
chapter
138,
section
64
chapter
265,
section:
13;
a
failure
to
notify
police
in
violation
of
mass
general
law;
chapter
138,
section
64
in
boardroom,
1.14
b,
who
is
president
on
behalf
of
the
licensing.
A
Are
there
any
other
individuals
with
personal
knowledge,
of
the
alleged
goodbye,
seeing
no
one
if
all
parties
could
please
raise
your
right
hand,
you
swear
to
tell
the
truth
the
whole
truth
and
nothing.
But
mr
durant,
can
you
raise
your
right
hand?
Do
you
swear
to
tell
the
truth
the
whole
truth
and
nothing,
but
the
truth.
A
G
Okay,
about
10
10
p.m.
On
sunday
july,
26,
2020
I'll,
say,
anderson
assigned
to
the
front
desk
of
district
18
took
a
walk-in
report
for
assault
dangerous
weapon.
Two
at
night
at
4014,
washington,
street
guerrero
white
tambourine,
jamaica,
dominican,
restaurant,
jamaica,
plain
mass,
miss
bostibal,
santiago,
dated
birth,
913
1982
opposed
to
front
desk
asking
for
officer
that
speaks
spanish.
I'm
saying
there
are
fresh
scratches
on
miss
santiago's,
forehead
and
arm
area.
G
Lima,
800,
detective,
cardoza,
assisted
with
the
translation,
miss
santiago
was
crying
and
stated
through
the
translation
of
detective
cardoza
that
she
had
been
having
ongoing
issues
with
the
female
identified
at
miss
selena
selena
ruiz
for
three
years.
Because
of
the
way
she
looks,
other
girls
are
jealous
of
her
and
every
time
miss
ruiz
sees
her.
She
blows
her.
Ms
santiago
said
that
she
see
miss
ruiz
different
places.
G
All
the
time
and
mr
ruiz
does
not,
like
her
miss
santiago,
said
that
she
recently
had
problems
with
miss
ruiz
when
she
saw
her
in
the
hair
salon,
selling
stolen
merchandise.
She
stated
to
her
that
she
didn't
like
her
stolen
products
and
it
wasn't
right
missing.
Miss
santiago
stated
tonight
at
approximately
9
30
pm,
while
she
was
inside
the
above.
She
went
to
the
bathroom
and
miss
rory's
follow
her
in
the
bathroom
stating
to
her.
G
I
don't
like
the
way
you
are
miss
santiago
stated
after
she
left
the
bathroom
to
go,
sit
at
her
table,
miss
ruiz
was
laughing
and
talking
about
her
to
another
girl,
miss
santiago
stated
she
approached
miss
ruiz,
mr
ruiz
started
laughing
at
her.
She
she
threw
a
drink
at
her
and
then
miss
ruiz
grabbed
her
by
the
hair
and
started
punching
and
scratching.
Her
miss
santiago
stated
after
the
fight
miss
rory
stated
to
her.
G
When
I
see
you
I'm
going
to
kill
you
miss
santiago
stated
when
they
went
outside
miss
ruiz,
held
a
knife
by
her
side
and
stated
come
near
me
and
I'm
going
to
slice
your
face
while
pointing
the
knife
at
her,
so
she
ran
and
security
had
to
walk
her
to
her
car.
Miss
santiago
stated
she
was
scared
to
go
home
because
miss
ruiz
is
bigger
and
stronger
than
her,
so
she
drove
to
a
police
station
and
feels
she
has
to
move
away
from
here.
G
Officers
deserve
scratches
on
miss
santiago's
forehead
near
her
right
eye,
right,
breast
area,
right
upper
arm,
chest
area,
lower
back
area
and
right
hand.
Ms
santiago
complained
the
pattern
bumps
on
the
top
of
her
head
neck
pain
and
a
headache.
Officers
requested
an
ambulance
to
district
18
for
evaluation,
ambulance,
817,
mckinnon
rossi
responded
to
the
station
evaluated,
miss
santiago
and
she
declined
any
further
medical
treatment.
At
this
time.
Miss
santiago
described
mr
ruiz
as
a
white
hispanic,
female
5,
8,
5,
9,
170
pounds,
black
hair
black
eyes
wearing
a
black
polo
shirt
and
blue
jeans.
G
G
Okay,
the
supplement
report
says
on
monday
july
27
2020
sergeant
detective
carl
schroeder,
echo
983,
and
the
sector
for
rita
echo.
807
responded
to
4014
washington
street
roslindale
mass
zero,
two
one:
three
one,
their
hambury
dominican
restaurant
detectives,
met
and
spoke
with
the
owner.
Felipe
durian
violation
was
issued,
patreon
patron
assault
and
fiat
and
notified
police
citation
number
zero.
Six.
Three
four:
two:
nine
thousand.
D
Good
afternoon,
thank
you
very
much,
so
I
just
like
to
make
this
incident
report
was
made
by
miss
santiago
to
the
police.
After
the
actual
incident
had
happened,
no
officers
were
actually
there
that
witnessed
this
incident
when
the
officers
did
go
to
the
restaurant.
The
next
day
to
acquire
mr
duran
fully
cooperated
with.
D
Them
so
I
have
mr
duran
here
that
will
also
be
able
to
speak
on
the
behalf.
The
report
that
has
actually
been
filed
is
based
on
just
miss
santiago's
report
and
it's
actually
inaccurate,
there's
two
witnesses.
There
should
be
another.
Mrs
garcia,
the
manager
that
should
also
be
logged
in
that
is
on
the
zoom
call
to
a
test,
including
mr
duran.
D
Miss
santiago
was
actually
not
the
victim,
but
she
was
the
one
that
assaulted,
miss
ruiz
as
miss
ruiz
was
leaving.
Miss
santiago
was
at
the
table
right
near
the
exit,
and
she
is
the
one
that
actually
threw
a
drink
at
miss
ruiz.
There
was
a
quick
scuffle
where
she
ended
up
on
the
floor.
It
lasted
seconds.
D
They
were
immediately
split
up
by
mr
duran
and
some
others.
Mr
durian
escorted
miss
santiago
to
her
car
to
ensure
no
further
issues
and
miss
ruiz
left
immediately
as
well.
Mr
duran
mentioned
calling
the
police.
He
fully
acknowledges
that
he
should
have,
but
both
parties
left
immediately
and
the
incident
happened
within
seconds.
It
was
extremely
quick.
D
D
D
I
know
that
in
the
letter
for
the
violation
you
are
requesting
video
surveillance.
I
had
submitted
a
letter
last
week
in
anticipation
of
this.
Mr
duran
has
a
company
that
does
all
of
his
video
surveillance
and
even
after
the
officers
had
come,
he
contacted
the
surveillance
company
to
get
all
the
footage.
D
Mr
duran
takes
the
safety
of
his
patrons
and
his
employees
as
top
priority.
He's
his
he
has
had
this
compa
this
restaurant
and
he's
been
in
here
for
decades
now
he
has
not
had
any
other
violations
and
which
shows
his
dedication
to
the
safety
for
his
patrons
and
the
community.
He
works
diligently
with
the
community
he's
also
in
this
community
and
works
with
the
officers
around
and
just
keeping
everybody,
including
the
patrons
and
all
of
his
employees.
Safe
he'd,
be
more
than
happy
to
also
answer
any
other
questions
that
you
have.
I
Dr
pitch,
can
I
speak
for
a
moment.
Please
I'm
sorry.
I
do
apologize,
I'm
having
some
technical
issues
here,
but
can
I
speak?
Can
you
hear
me?
Yes,
detective,
pitts?
Yes,
so
I
I
just
wanted
to
speak
briefly
on
that
monday,
when
my
self-insulting
detective
struggles
had
gone
in
to
speak
with
mr
durant.
Regarding
the
incident
you
know
initially,
he
stated
that
he
didn't
know
anything.
You
know
about
it.
I
And
so,
when
I
returned
on
august
1st,
let's
see
he
told
me
that
he
was
having
trouble
with
the
hard
drive
and
that
he
had
provided
me
with
the
name
of
an
individual
that
handles
his
surveillances
of
a
gentleman
by
the
name
of
junior.
I
called
in
contact
several
times,
never
got
a
contact
back,
so
we
did
issue
the
violation.
This
junior
person
never
responded,
and
so
mr
durant
said
that
he
was
his
security
systems
specialist.
So
we
don't
have
any
video
of
the
incident.
I
C
C
Basically,
we
were
at
the
patio
I
mean
mr
santiago
was
sitting
on
me
near
the
exit.
Next
to
the
parking
lot
I
mean
mr
reed
just
was
walking
out
on
her
way
out
the
little
restaurant
and
it
would
happen
so
so
fast.
I
mean
she
just
threw
a
drink
on
her
and
she
just
quickly
heard
about
the
hair
and
put
it
in
the
floor
because
we
were
so
close
because
they
were
sitting
there.
I
mean
near
the
exit,
we
were
there.
I
mean
in
the
way
we
can.
C
We
don't
know
how
how
hard
we've
been
working
with
our
business
and
I
go
escort
her
to
her
car.
I
didn't
see
any
knife.
I
was
surprised
the
next
day
when
the
police
stopped
by,
because
I
thought
it
was
something
that
it
was.
It
wasn't
even
necessary
to
call
the
police,
because
I
mean
we
took
care
of
the
situation
after
that
the
tax
explained
to
me.
Even
though
nothing
happened,
you
got
to
call
the
police,
I
say
yeah.
C
That
was
my
only
mistake
and
I
I
think
the
responsibility
that
I
said
to
her,
but
I
was
so
mad
that
morning
because
we
were
in
in
a
bad
situation
and
there
after
I
mean
this,
this
incident
happened
and
I
just
asked
her.
I
mean
this
is
gonna,
be
happened
to
us
right
now.
I
mean
we're
just
trying
to
get
back
in
track,
and
these
two,
ladies,
I
mean
you'll,
go
into
a
business,
get
some
travel
put
all
my
customers
in
danger.
You
know
that
and
I
was
so
mad.
B
C
C
C
I
always
been
cooperating
with
anything
happening
around
this
area
and
even
with
the
police,
even
though
I
can
get
in
trouble
for
that,
but
I
always
be
incorporated
with
that
and
I
say
yeah
I
will
get
the
burger
when
I
when
I
come
down
to
the
office
and
I
try
to
check.
I
have
some
issues
because
I
don't
see
any,
I
don't
see
any
any
video
anything.
I
call
the
guy
who
usually
take
care
of
all
this
such
system
and
say
hey.
I
don't
have
any
video
how
I
can
get
the
video.
C
A
B
D
A
I
do
not
thanks.
Thank
you.
The
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement.
Thank
you
calling
west
end
dining
llc
doing
business
as
causeway
located
at
65-71
causeway
street.
The
date
of
the
incident
is
march.
1St
2021
over
served
patreon
started
disturbance
verbally
accosted
customers
in
violation
of
mass
general
law,
chapter
138,
section
64.,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of.
K
A
A
L
H
About
8
pm
on
monday
march,
1st
2021
offices,
again
in
daddy
echo,
alpha
k1
frank,
responded
to
a
radio
call
for
an
assault
and
battery
at
the
causeway
bar
located
at
65.
Causeway
street
in
boston
prior
to
arrival,
officers
were
informed
via
bpd
dispatch
that
the
911
caller
stated
that
there
was
a
drunk
man
outside
the
restaurant
who
was
harassing
customers.
H
The
911
caller
stated
that
the
man
was
a
white
male
5'4
in
height
medium,
build
in
his
late
20s
wearing
glasses,
a
grey
sweatshirt,
blue,
pants
and
white
shoes.
The
9-1-1
call
stated
that
the
male
was
in
the
window
staring
at
customers.
Upon
arrival.
Officers
briefly
spoke
with
a
white
male
identified
as
paul
fitzpatrick.
H
H
Officers
initially
were
under
the
impression
that
fitzpatrick
was
security
for
the
bar,
but
officers
later
found
out
that
fitzpatrick
was
not
an
employee
of
the
bar
fitzpatrick
stated
that,
while
inside
the
bar,
a
short
white
male
later
identified
as
david
bellevue
began,
arguing
and
swearing
at
a
male
and
female
couple,
while
sitting
at
the
bar
fitzpatrick
then
said
that
bellevue
was
in
the
bar
for
about
an
hour
eating
and
drinking,
and
he
seemed
fine.
But
then,
without
any
reason
he
began.
H
The
n-word
fitzpatrick
stated
that
he
attempted
to
de-escalate
the
situation,
but
bellevue
was
operated,
took
a
swing
if
it's
patrick
and
had
to
be
physically
escorted
out
of
the
bar
dispatch
said
that
while
bellevue
was
outside
the
bar,
he
kicked
the
front
door.
He
punched
one
of
the
bar
glassed
windows
and
then
fell
on
the
sidewalk
multiple
times.
H
Patrick
stated
that
bellevue
left
the
area
on
fort
sports
canal
street,
while
officers
were
searching
the
air
area
for
bellevue,
another
9-1-1
call
is
generated
by
bellevue
bellevue
stated
to
the
9-1-1
call
ticket
that
the
restaurant
owner
kicked
him
out
and
physically
removed.
My
wrist
bellevue
stated
that
I
stated
to
the
9-1-1
call
ticket
that
he
wanted
a
medical
evaluation
officers
located
bellevue
matching
the
above
physical
description
who
was
lying
on
the
sidewalk
outside
the
santander
bank.
H
At
the
corner
of
canal
street
and
causeway
street
bellevue
was
holding
his
left
wrist
in
an
awkward
position
and
stated
to
officers
that
he
thinks
his
risk
was
broken.
Bellevue
admitted
to
being
inside
the
causeway
bob,
but
stated
that
everything
was
peaceful
officers
asked
bellevue
how
a
peaceful
atmosphere
produced
a
broken
risk
for
himself.
W
then
admitted
that
he
is
forcibly
removed
from
the
bob,
but
he
denied
being
intoxicated
officers
requested
boston,
ems,
soliciting
for
a
medical
evaluation
of
bellevue
boston.
H
Ems
arrived
on
scene
to
transport
bellevue
to
the
nearest
hospital,
but
bellevue
began,
giving
the
emts
a
rude
and
unnecessarily
negative
attitude.
The
emts
gave
bellevue
the
opportunity
to
to
enter
the
ambulance,
but
they
advised
him
that
he
was
to
cooperate
and
behave
himself
after
a
very
brief
time.
Inside
the
ambulance
it
appeared
as
though
bellevue
was
unable
to
follow
the
emt's
directive
to
behave
himself.
As
a
result,
bellevue
was
asked
to
exit
the
ambulance.
H
Bellevue
had
mentioned
to
the
officers
that
he
left
this
great
bag
inside
the
causeway
bar.
The
obvious
stated
that
he
was
in
the
area
because
you're
staying
the
night
at
the
onyx
hotel
located
at
155
portland
street
offices,
then
requested
return
to
the
calls
we
bought
to
retrieve
bellevue's
bag
officer.
Mcginn
again
interviewed
and
asked
fitzpatrick
questions
regarding
the
incident
officer.
Mcginn
also
spoke
with
the
bartender
identified
as
maryland.
H
Israel,
who
confirmed
the
story
given
by
patrick,
emphasizing
bellevue's,
poor
and
assaultive
behavior,
while
both
inside
and
outside
the
bar
israel
also
alerted
office
to
the
fact
that
beverly
had
not
paid
his
bar
tab,
which
consisted
of
food
in
nine
adult
malt
beverages,
each
consisting
of
16
ounces
of
beer.
The
grand
total
of
the
bar
tab
was
132
dollars
and
42
cents
officers
were
able
to
retrieve
the
gray
bag,
which
belonged
to
bellevue
sergeant
king.
H
The
alpha
915
arrived
on
scene
to
conduct
a
licensed
premise
inspection,
while
our
officers
and
sergeant
king
were
inside
the
causeway.
Speaking
with
the
bar
patrons
boston
police,
channel
dispatch
alerted
the
officers
that
bellevue
was
again
calling
9-1-1
concerning
his
injured.
Wrist
officers
brought
the
great
bag
to
the
onyx
hotel
in
hopes
of
meeting
up
with
bellevue
to
hand
the
bag
over
to
him.
H
The
hotel
front
desk
clerk
advised
officers
that
bellevue
did
have
a
reservation
at
the
hotel,
but
he
had
not
yet
checked
in
officers
contacted
bellevue
via
his
cell
phone
number
in
order
to
track
him
down
to
give
him
his
gray
bag
back.
W
stated
to
office
that
that
he
was
outside
the
cvs
tool
located
at
the
corner
of
causeway
and
canal
street
officers,
along
with
sergeant
king
drove
over
to
the
cvs
to
relocate
bellevue
officers
observed
bellevue
inside
the
cbs
walking
around.
H
All
of
you
exited
to
the
cvs
to
nasa
offices
and
officers,
asked
about
you
if
you
needed
any
more
services.
Beverly
continued
to
complain
about
his
injured
risks.
Sergeant
king
requested
boston,
ems
to
the
scenes
to
treat
bellevue
for
a
second
time.
Ems
unit
a15
arrived
on
scene
in
identifies
bellevue
that
the
same
rules
apply
in
that
they
would
need
his
cooperation
if
he
were
to
enter
the
ambulance.
W
agreed
to
cooperate
and
enter
the
ambulance
where
he
was
transported
to
massachusetts.
H
General
hospital
for
further
medical
treatment
and
evaluation
officers
advised
bellevue
to
not
return
to
the
cause
we
bought
tonight.
Officers
advised
bellevue
that
he
did
not
pay
his
vote
and
you
should
contact
the
bar
tomorrow
morning
to
pay
his
tab
officers
informed
bellevue
that
if
you
do
not
pay
his
bartender,
that
this
may
result
in
a
criminal
charge,
officers
left
a
copy
of
the
buyer's
seat.
In
the
side,
mesh
pocket
of
bellevue's
great
bag
body,
worn
cameras
were
activated
during
this
incident
upon
further
review.
H
It
appears
as
though
this
is
not
the
first
time
bellevue
has
been
in
the
west
end
area
of
boston,
generating
a
disturbance,
in
fact,
on
january
15
2021.
During
this
prior
incident.
Bellevue's
misconduct
was
also
on
display
at
the
indigo
hotel
located
at
280
front
street,
and
that's
the
end
of
the
report.
M
Yes,
ma'am,
I
wrote
a
supplemental
report
that
states
about
3
18
p.m.
On
tuesday
march
9th
2021's,
the
alpha
915
unit
created
a
supplemental
report.
Relative
incident
that
occur
first
2021
bar
65
causeway
street
sergeant
king
reported
that
when
he
responded
to
the
original
incident
he
did
issue
premise:
violation
number
459
through
the
causeway
bar
for
certain
bartender.
M
K
Yes,
good
afternoon
again,
there
are
several
things.
First
off
we
apologize,
miss
israel
is
on
vacation
out
of
the
country
and
could
not
make
it,
but
we
did
do
a
an
investigation
and
we
can
report
to
the
board.
That
of
even
though
the
the
tab
had
nine
alcoholic
beverages
on
it,
five
of
which
the
perpetrator,
here,
whatever
we're
going
to
call
them,
bought
five
drinks
for
another
table.
They
were
not
served
to
him.
K
Miss
israel
reports
to
us
that
she
was
serving
this
gentleman
and
he
had
three
beers
and
had
ordered
a
fourth
at
which
time
she
told
him
that
his
90
minutes
were
up
and
that
he
would
be.
He
would
be
getting
his
check
at
the
as
soon
as
he
finished
this
and
his
his
food,
and
it's
been
described
to
us
like
switching
on
a
light
this.
This
man
just
went
crazy.
I
mean
he
started
to
yell
at
other
people
in
the
bar.
He
eventually
threw
food
at
the
coven
barrier.
K
K
K
A
K
N
N
K
K
K
J
K
N
N
A
All
right,
thank
you
very
much.
The
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement.
Thank
you.
Thank
you.
Calling
makuma
latina
inc
doing
business
as
macumba
latina
located
at
477
river
street.
The
date
of
the
incident
is
february.
22Nd
2021,
two
drug
overdoses,
in
violation
of
mass
general
lodge
138,
section
64.,
who
was
president
on
behalf
of
the.
O
O
E
A
E
E
E
Second
individual
was
administered
narcan
and
both
individuals
were
deemed
viable
and
then
transported
to
a
fortner
hospital.
And
that
concludes
the
first
incident
report.
The
second
incident
report
is
from
march
30
2021
reads
about
2
30
a.m:
officer
mcduck,
I'm
sorry
sergeant,
mcdonough
various
officers
from
area
b3
responded
to
a
radio
call
for
loud
music
at
477
river
street
macomb
bar
and
grill.
E
E
Mr
lopez
stated
that
he
remembered
the
overdoses
and
stated
that
he
was
there
on
the
on
the
evening
of
february
21st,
saying
that
the
two
males
who
overdosed
on
drugs
had
locked
themselves
into
a
compass
bathroom
that
night
sergeant
mcdonald
vanishing
that
the
citation
and
that's
that's
concludes.
The
second
incident
report.
O
E
O
Thank
you.
I
have
no
further
questions
of
the
officer,
mr
mr
fernandez
and
mr
lopes
were
there
that
night
and
and
they
would
like
to
testify,
but
before
they
do,
I
would
just
simply
like
to
add
the
following.
First,
this
is
the
only
incident
of
drug
overdose
at
makuma
there
have
been
no
other
reports
or
incidents
of
drug
overdose
at
makuma
latina,
since
this
incident
happened
in
february.
O
O
I
do
have
photos
of
those
signs.
I
don't
know
whether
the
board
I
could
easily
email
them
to
the
board
subsequent
to
this
hearing.
But
the
fact
is
that
there
are
numerous
signs
posted
right
now
at
the
establishment.
For
that,
as
I
said
mr
lopes
and
mr
and
lopez
and
mr
fernandez
were
there
that
night
and
I
would
like
to
give
them
the
opportunity
under
oath
to
tell
the
board
exactly
what
they
observed
on
that
night
and
I'll.
Ask
mr
fernandez
to
first
testify.
Q
Good
afternoon,
member
of
the
board,
my
name
is
max
fernandez
owner
fire
owner
of
my
cumberland.
On
monday,
the
22nd
me
and
john
both
presents
I'm
doing
my
1
45
workout.
I
was
going
to
walk
in
check
out,
make
sure
that
everything
is
okay
and
security.
Is
it
posted
where
it's
supposed
to
be
posted?
I
observe
a
male
that
I
know.
One
of
my
customers
is
a
is.
Is
he
been
to
the
place
like?
I
know
personally,
because
he
visited
me
pushing
me
a
lot
of
times.
Q
I
observed
that
he
was,
he
came
out
from
the
bathroom
and
he
was
passed
out.
He
was
laying
down
so
me
and
my
security
try
to
get
my
try
to
give
him
some
water
try
to
give
him
some
juice.
Some
people
try
to
give
him
some
cherry
something
sweet.
We
didn't
know
what
was
going
on.
We
didn't
know
if
he
passed
out
because
yeah
I'd
be
sick
or
something
after
five
minutes
that
he
didn't
come
back
to
him.
Q
I
decided
to
carry
him
out
to
put
him
from
the
door
just
in
case
ems
come.
It
was
fast
work.
When
I
was
walking
out.
I
called
I
was
calling
the
police
when
I
opened
the
door
when
I'm
out
in
front
the
door,
the
police
was
only
there
a
lot
of
other
people's.
I
called
I
observed
outside
another
gentleman
that
was
on
the
ground
and
mr
john
was
watching
over
him,
and
I
had
one
of
my
witches
and
that
night
got
four
witches.
Q
One
of
my
watchers
would
give
him
cpr
to
that
gentleman.
That
I
believe
was
his
name
was
anyway.
It
was
not
john
carlos
I
was
I
was
taking.
Mr
juan
carlos
and
john
was
taking
care
of
the
other
gentleman
I
hold.
I
hold
the
gentleman
in
his
head
until
the
ms
came
after
like
two
three
minutes
later,
when
they
came
in,
they
told
me
to
release
the
guy
to
let
him
put
his
head
on,
let
his
hand
on
the
ground
I
did
so.
Q
There
was
still
people
coming
from
the
from
makumba
from
the
club
exit
from
that
door.
I
stopped
them,
so
ms
can
do
their
work
and
I
would
put
it
back,
make
them
to
use
the
back
door
to
exit
back
door.
There
was
a
there
was
a
sergeant.
There
was
a
sergeant
police
officer
sergeant
that
was
in
front
of,
though
that
helped
me
do
really
right
the
re-eject
we
had
to
erect
the
patrons,
so
they
will
go
to
the
back
door,
so
be
the
ms
can
do
their
work.
Q
Q
What
I
did
is,
I
asked
all
my
staff,
maybe
train,
that
we
have
training
with
our
cpr.
All
the
skype
here
learn
how
to
do
cpr
because
it
seems
like
this
is
not
going
to
be.
The
last
thing
we
want
to
see.
This
is
like
this.
Young
people
are
looking
for
some
kind
of
well.
I
I
said
everything
and
mr
john
got
something
to
maybe
go.
O
And
with
that,
mr
fernandez,
we'll
turn
it
over
to
to
mr
lopes,
who
has
just
a
few
words.
He
wants
that
he
was
there
again
that
night
and
can
testify
firsthand
as
to
what
happened
that
particular
night
mr
lopes,
if
you
just
direct
yourself
up
a
little
bit,
so
they
can
see
you
on
on
the
screen.
Yes,.
P
P
P
A
A
Calling
myn
corp
doing
business
as
dublin
pub
located
at
709
stoughton
street.
The
date
of
the
incident
was
april
3rd
assault
and
battery
with
a
deadly
weapon
in
front
of
paid
out
from
the
premise
patron
shot
in
violation
of
mass
general
law.
Chapter
138,
section
64
chapter
265,
section
13
a
who
was
president
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
F
Good
afternoon,
william
gardner,
representing
the
licensee
president
with
me,
is
yaza
mohammed,
who
was
the
manager
of
the
licensee
and
was
also
present
on
the
premises
on
the
night
of
the
incident.
We
also
have
with
us
joseph
paul
and
william
dunn,
who
are
members
of
the
private
security
firm
who
were
on
site
that
night
as
well.
A
R
Sure
so
the
report
says
about
1
22
a.m.
On
saturday,
4,
3,
20,
21
officer,
kerrigan,
australia,
side
to
the
bravo
101
alpha
on
sighted,
multiple
shots
fired,
resulting
in
a
person
shot
in
the
area
of
7
stoughton
street
dorchester
officer,
o'leary
and
officer
kerrigan
were
traveling
on
columbia,
road
in
the
area
of
hamlet
street
heading
towards
stoughton
street
in
mark's
boston,
police,
cruiser
7523
officers
had
their
windows
partially
open.
At
the
time
officer
officers
heard
what
sounded
like
multiple
gunshots
coming
from
the
area
of
stoughton
street.
R
As
officers
approached
stoughton
street,
they
observed
a
large
crowd
of
people
running
off
of
stoughton
street
towards
columbia.
Road
officers
notified
boston
operations,
channel
3
that
they
had
just
heard
shots
fired
in
the
area
of
the
dublin
house.
7
stoughton
street
officers
turned
the
corner
onto
stoughton
street
and
continued
to
the
area
where
they
believed
the
gunshots
had
been
coming
from.
As
officers
approached
the
area,
they
observed
a
male
party
who
was
being
held
up
by
two
people
walking
across
stoughton
street.
R
The
male
party
later
identified
as
tyrone
shepard,
was
being
assisted
in
walking
and
appeared
to
be
injured.
The
party's
assisting
shepard
were
walking
him
towards
new
jersey,
registration,
c76
lhp,
a
white
toyota
4runner
that
was
parked
on
sultan
street.
Upon
closer
examination,
officers
deserved
shepherd
to
have
a
significant
amount
of
blood
seeping
through
his
clothing
officers,
exited
their
cruiser
and
assisted
shepherd
to
the
side
of
their
cruiser,
so
they
could
attend
the
shepherd's
injuries.
R
At
this
time,
officers
heard
what
sounded
like
multiple
additional
gunshots
coming
from
the
area
of
the
intersection
of
columbia,
road
and
stoughton
street
officers
to
updated
boston
operations
that
they
had
heard
additional
constructs
and
had
a
person
shot.
Officers
requested
boston
ems
to
respond
to
the
scene.
R
Upon
closer
examination
of
shepherd
officers
observed
multiple
gunshot
wounds
to
shepherd.
Officers
could
observe
one
gunshot
wound
to
shepherd's
left
upper
arm,
which
was
produced
in
a
significant
amount
of
blood
due
to
the
amount
of
blood
coming
from
shepherd's
upper
arm
officer
o'leary
applied
his
boston
police
issued
you
tourniquet
to
shepherd's
upper
left
arm.
R
L
Good
afternoon
I'm
going
to
be
reading
from
police
report,
which
I
wrote
on
monday
april
5th
2021
shy,
detective,
william
gallagher
and
detective
eddie
hernandez,
signed
to
the
bpp
license.
Permission
responded
to
the
dublin
house
located
at
7
stoughton
street
to
speak
to
staff
regarding
an
assault
and
battery
with
a
dangerous
weapon
incident
that
occurred
on
april
3rd
2021
detectives
spoke
their
owner,
yazar
muhammad,
who
confirmed
that
he
was
over
the
incident,
mr
muhammad
informed
detectives
that
the
b-2
detectives
had
already
contacted
him
and
the
establishment
would
be
providing
video
to
the
investigators.
L
F
Yes,
if
I
may,
the
security
of
the
dublin
house
has
private
security
on
the
night
of
this
incident.
The
security
folks
heard
the
gunshots
the
same
time,
apparently
that
officer,
kerrigan
and
officer
o'leary
did
they
heard
the
gunshots
in
the
sand
in
the
area
of
the
santander
bank
coming
closer
to
the
dublin
house
what
they
did
at
that
point
in
time.
F
Everybody
who
comes
into
the
place
is
is
frisk
for
weapons
or
any
type
of
contraband.
There
is
a
well-staffed
private
security
firm.
They
have
no
indication
that
anybody
involved
in
this
incident
was
on
the
premises
that
night
and,
as
I
indicated,
they
heard
it
coming
from
sandy
santander
bank
towards
the
dublin
house.
At
seven
stoughton
street,
once
the
police
officers,
the
police's
officers
were
on
scene
instantly
and,
and
once
things
settled
down,
they
did
come
into
the
premises.
F
Mr
mohammed
also
cooperated
with
detectives
that
night
and
provided
evidence
provided
access
to
the
video
surveillance
footage
right
away.
That
particular
evening
he's
got
a
fairly
extensive
system,
16
different
cameras,
so
that
they
didn't
have
enough
time
to
go
through
all
the
footage.
At
that
point
in
time,
as
detective
fernandez
indicated,
they
did
come
back
on
monday.
This
happened
friday
night
into
saturday
morning.
They
came
back
in
on
monday,
and
mr
mohamed
again
cooperated
with
the
detectives
and
has
provided
access
to
all
of
the
video
footage.
F
F
A
A
S
N
L
Good
afternoon
I'll
be
reading
a
police
report
with
the
authored
thin
march,
4th
2021
at
about
10
30
p.m,
starting
detective
gallagher
and
detective
eddie
hernandez
assigned
to
the
licensed
permission,
we're
performing
checks,
bars
and
restaurants.
During
the
cover
19
emergency,
we're
walking
into
bodega
canal,
located
in
canal
street
detectives,
observe
a
table
of
four
female
patrons
drinking,
an
alcoholic
beverages,
a
margarita
pitcher
and
four
tequila
shots
detectives
noticed
that
these
females
looked
young
detectives,
asked
them
to
produce
identification
to
confirm
their
ages.
L
Three
out
of
the
four
individuals
stated
they
were
under
21
years
of
age
and
produced
various
forms
of
identification,
confirming
that
they
were
all
under
21
years
of
age.
Detectives
were
able
to
confirm
the
identity
of
patrons
alexander,
rich
amy.
Bocos
sydney
bear
and
lucy
stone
detectives
asked
the
group
how
they
obtained
the
beverages
they
had
in
front
of
them.
The
underage
females
produced
fraudulent
new
york
from
stone
and
bear
and
new
jersey
for
a
bogus
driver's
license
that
contained
the
individuals
name
but
displayed
a
date.
L
Birth
inmate
appears
they
were
all
over
21
years
of
age,
detectives
used
a
license.
Verification
program
which
confirmed
that
the
driver's
licenses
were
indeed
fraudulent.
The
fraudulent
driver's
license
were
confiscated
by
detectives
staff
at
the
bodega
canal,
confirmed
that
they
used
a
license
verification
program
to
scan
the
licenses
and
were
aware
that
the
three
patrons
had
produced
fraudulent
licenses
to
the
staff.
The
staff
say
that
they
let
the
patrons
sit
at
the
table
with
the
one
person
who
was
over
21
years
of
age,
miss
rich.
L
It
should
be
noted
that
another
individual
who
was
confirmed
to
be
over
21
years
of
age,
miss
samoa
arbutu,
along
with
ms
alexander
rich,
will
be
summoned
into
court
for
procuring
alcohol
persons
under
21
years
of
age.
These
patrons
ordered
the
drinks
that
were
brought
to
the
table.
The
three
underage
individuals
we
summoned
the
court
for
persons
under
21
possession
of
alcohol
and
possessed
in
a
fraudulent
identification
detectives
brought
the
situation
to
the
attention
of
the
person
in
charge.
Michael
wyatt,
as
a
result
of
detectives
deserved
shine.
L
S
L
F
U
U
U
S
U
U
S
U
U
U
S
U
U
right
now.
We
only
serve,
for
example,
this
table
with
someone
under
21,
we'll
deny
them
service
of
large
format.
Pictures
prints
meant
more
than
one
person
or
shocked,
so
nothing
can
be
passed
around.
So
if
you're
21
plus
you
just
get
one
drink
for
yourself
and
are
not
able
to
pour
off
for
another
person.
S
S
U
L
U
L
U
Correct
I
mean
it's
it's
hard
for
us.
You
know
from
a
business
standpoint
to
I
mean
also
just
like
customer
service
standpoint
too.
So
if
there's
one
person
under
21
say
hey,
no
one
potable
can
drink.
You
know
we
don't
have
that
policy
but,
like
I
said
we
do
now
have
that
policy.
If
there's
721
that
we
don't
serve
any
large
format
or
shots
or
anything
like
that,
but
you
know
at
the
time
if
someone's
under
21
at
the
table,
we
can't
say
you
know
everyone
over
21
can
drink
anyone's
excuse.
A
U
Like
I
said
they
were,
they
were
at
one
table,
the
ones
they
walked
in
that
where
they
said
there
was
121
plus
and
three
underage
at
the
time
ordering
two
of
the
patrons
at
that
table
were
21
plus,
so
the
two
that
were
21
plus
ordered
a
picture.
The
others
with
the
fraudulent
ids
attempted
to
order.
They
were
denied
service.
So
the
two
with
21
plus
they're,
very
well
able
to
split
one
picture,
because
it's
just
two
drinks
each
so
they
did
that
shot
wise.
It
was
just
kind
of
like
you
know.
U
They
ordered
two,
then
another
two
and
another
two
after
so
it
wasn't
like.
I
said
it.
Wasn't
the
server
directly
serving
the
underage
patrons.
It
was
the
21
plus
patrons
ordering
drinks
themselves
at
both
tables
and
kind
of
passing
them
off
and
being
a
little
bit
deceptive,
and
again
too.
I
just
want
to
reiterate
to
this
kind
of
a
new
server,
not.
U
About
our
training
or
anything
like
that,
but
this
is
probably
her
first
time
kind
of
being
deceived
by
you
know
underage
patrons
trying
to
pass
off
drinks
and
whatnot
we're
not
it's
not
our
policy,
just
let
anyone
in
that's
under
reach
and
serve
the
whole
table
type
of
thing.
It's
more!
So
a
couple
of
the
patrons
being
a
little
bit
deceptive
and
trying
to
get
around
that
taking
advantage
of
a
younger
server.
L
U
U
L
S
S
Did
not
in
fact,
have
proper
id
if
who
were
underage
as
a
result
of
which
they
were
able
to
get
drinks
from
the
other
patrons.
As
we're
saying
when
the
picture
was
served,
it
was
served
with
two
margarita
glasses.
What
they
were
doing
was
they
were
pouring
some
of
the
margarita
into
water
glasses
and
passing
them
around
the
same
with
the
shots.
S
They
went
on
the
shots
themselves
and
then
you
know,
as
the
waitress
left,
they
would
pass
the
shot
over
to
one
of
the
other
age
people.
We
understand
that
we're
trying
to
implement
additional
policies,
as
mentioned
about
not
serving
either
pictures
or
shots
on
tables
where
anyone
of
the
party
is
under
21.
S
A
Thank
you
attorney
frulo.
The
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement.
Thank
you.
Calling
cng
10
p.o
square
llc,
doing
business
as
marielle
located
at
10
coast
office
square.
The
date
of
the
incident
is
march.
20Th,
2021
failure
to
abide
by
governor's,
covert,
19
guidelines,
tables
of
greater
than
six
patrons
at
three
tables
who's
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
A
A
T
Yes,
good
afternoon,
massage
detective,
william
gallagher,
boston
police,
currently
assigned
licensed
premise
unit
of
your
meeting
boston
police,
against
a
report
that
I
wrote
on:
3
20,
20
21
at
12
30
a.m.
Detective
gallagher
of
the
licensed
premise
unit
in
po
sandport,
the
alpha
435
bpd
area
a1
conducted
a
licensed
premise:
inspection
of
marielle
at
10
post
office
square.
T
This
inspection
came
about
because
of
complaints
received
at
city
hall
of
the
premise
not
following
the
covert
19
guidelines.
This
complaint
stated
the
premise
was
being
run
like
a
nightclub
with
the
dj
and
patrons
staying
over
the
90-minute
time.
Allotment
aside,
the
premise
on
the
lower
level
officers
observed
three
separate
tables
that
had
more
than
the
six
maximum
patrons
allowed
officers
brought
this
to
the
attention
of
the
manager,
john
o'connor,
who
stated
that
he
would
take
corrective
action.
W
X
Yeah,
so
I
do
I
I
don't
the
you
know
the
facts
here
aren't
in
dispute.
We
have
a
strict
policy
of
booking
no
more
than
six
people
per
table.
When
we
do
book
the
restaurant,
the
night
that
the
the
detective
gallagher
came
in
was,
there
was
basically
a
situation
where
a
few
of
the
guests
were
friends
with
guests
at
another
table
had
gotten
up
and
walked
over
and
had
sat
down
to
chat.
We
didn't
see
it.
X
You
know
we
missed
it
and
so
at
the
moment
time
that
the
gentleman
walked
in
three
of
the
tables
did
in
fact
have
seven
people
instead
of
six
at
them
each
individually.
So
you
know
they
checked
the
pos
and
you
know
reviewed
how
long
the
tables
have
been
there.
We're
satisfied
with
everything
else.
You
know
coveted
wise,
but
you
know
we
didn't.
We
didn't
see
those
three
people
sitting
at
the
other
table,
so
those
are
the
facts
from
where
we
stand
and
happy
to
answer
any
other
questions.
A
A
Thank
you
very
much.
The
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement
calling
j
and
k
blasey
inc,
doing
business
as
blasey
cafe,
located
at
762
adam
street,
the
date
of
the
incident.
The
date
of
the
notice
of
the
hearing
is
march,
9,
2021
informational
hearing
regarding
non-use
of
license
and
violation
of
mass
general
law,
chapter
138,
section
64.,
and
for
the
record
this
is
the
second
hearing
for
non-use
with
this
licensing
who's
present.
On
behalf
of
the.
K
But
it's
clicked
back
in
so
I've
been
brought
on
in
the
last
couple
of
weeks
to
do
we
we're
going
to
have
a
little
bit
of
a
change
of
a
floor
plan.
We'll
probably
have
some
change
of
beneficial
interest.
We've
been
to
isd
with
the
plans
and
it
looks
like
we're
going
to
move
forward
and
hopefully
be
and
hopefully
be
open
very
very
shortly
or
within
a
few.
You
know
as
soon
as
possible.
Sorry,
that's!
Actually
your
office
calling
me.
A
A
Absolutely
so
under
massachusetts,
general
law,
the
failure
to
utilize
your
license
is
not
appropriate.
It's
considered
what
is
commonly
referred
to
as
a
pocket
license.
Once
a
licensee
is
put
on
notice
of
a
non-use
issue.
They
have
a
six-month
period
under
massachusetts,
general
law
to
cure
that
non-use
curing
the
non-use
means
either
transferring
the
license
or
reopening
the
establishment
with
that
license
in
use.
If
they
have
not
cured
within
that
six
month
period,
the
board
can
schedule
a
cancellation
hearing
at
which
it
may
put
the
licensee
on
notice
and
cancel
the
license
throughout
kovat.
A
The
board
has
not
been
enforcing
non-use
for
the
vast
majority
of
our
licensees
because
of
the
impact
of
the
pandemic
on
licensees.
However,
with
this
particular
licensee
and
a
number
of
others
who
are
also
being
scheduled,
there
is
a
long
history
of
non-us
significantly
pre-dating
covet,
and
this
licensee
has
been
on
notice
for
approximately
two
years,
if
not
longer
that
this
non-use
must
be
cured.
K
B
V
You
know
the
property
and
wonder
what's
going
on
and
then
they
can
assume
their
own.
You
know
opinions
on
what
we're
doing
so
we're
a
partnership
myself
and
my
brother,
and
we
waited
a
year
for
insurance
to
go
through
unaware
on
how
to
handle.
You
know
a
fire
and
a
loss
of
business
and
a
complete
shutter
of
the
building.
We
lost
five
tenants
along
with
the
restaurant,
so
for
three
and
a
half
years
I've
been
unemployed.
V
I've
been
trying
to
get
this
going.
My
brother,
joe
after
the
insurance
proceeds,
were
released.
The
bank
took
the
money
and
paid
the
mortgage.
We
had
from
doing
the
the
build
out
in
an
opening.
We
had
done
pre,
you
know
18
years
previous
and
we
ended
up.
We
owned
the
building,
so
that
was
you
know.
That
was
the
best
thing
that
came
out
of
it.
So
we're
lucky
to
you
know
have
that
he
decided
to
get
out
because
he
didn't
want
to
go
through
the
he
just
was
done.
V
V
We
came
to
an
agreement
a
year
ago
february
and
when
I
submitted
all
my
plans
and
the
whole
project
with
an
sba
504
loan
approved
for
half
of
the
amount
I
submitted
submitted
it
to
mansfield
bank
and
within
the
two
weeks
they
had
shut
down
because
of
coving
and
so
for
a
whole
year
up
until
right.
It's
over
a
year
now
I've
gone
through
20
banks.
V
I've
been
struggling
through
this,
the
building's
empty
there's
beard,
there's
one
temporary
electricity.
You
know
one
box
in
the
building,
keeping
a
pump
running
in
the
building
and
so
now.
Finally,
a
bank
I
had
dealt
with
last
august
is
ready
to
re.
Re
is
re-entering
it's
it's
in
underwriting
right
now,
only
because
of
the
vaccines
that
are
out
and
that
the
restaurants
came
back
to
you
know
100
seeding,
but
not
you
know,
without
you
know,
they're
still
skeptical,
but
they're
moving
forward.
V
So
no
banks
wanted
to
make
any
move
with
a
restaurant
involved,
because
the
whole
project
was
wrapped
around
the
restaurant
because
I'm
the
owner
occupied
and
the
sba
loan
was
approved.
So
it
held
me
up
from
I.
Just
that's
that's
that's
it.
I
really
don't
know
how
else
to
explain
it's
awful
that
that
building
has
my
my
dad's
name
on
it.
We've
been
after
80
years
as
a
family
we
had
given
to
the
neighborhood
all
these
years.
20
is
a
restaurant,
almost
50
as
a
hardware
store.
B
V
K
Yes,
we're
we're
actively
looking.
We
have
somebody
who
is
in
the
real
estate
business,
a
real
estate
broker
and
we've
we're
trading
a
letter
of
intent,
so
we're
actively
marketing
the
building,
and
we
believe
that
we
will
be
entering
into
this
lease
of
with
the
real
estate
broker.
We're
looking
for
other
tenants
as
well.
V
I've
had
a
I've
had
a
contractor
who's
been
involved
with
me
since,
since
the
plans
have
been
approved,
tom
babin,
he
he's
we've
been
in
contact
every
once
a
week
at
least
he's
still
on
board
to
move
forward
as
soon
as
the
financing
comes
through.
So
I'm
just
I'm
shopping
at
the
bed.
I
don't
know
what
to
say.
B
A
V
More,
I'm
sorry,
just
in
the
process
with
the
bank
is
similar
to
what
we're
going
through
here,
they're
in
once
or
twice
a
week.
They
connect
once
or
twice
a
week,
they're
completely
overloaded
with
the
ppe.
You
know
everything
involved
with
the
federal
government
loans
and
so
everything's
just
been
obviously
everyone's
aware
of
it's
a
slog
yeah.
So.