►
Description
City of Boston Licensing Board Violations Hearing - 08/15/23
A
B
Good
morning,
this
is
a
hearing
before
the
licensing
board
for
the
city
of
Boston.
Today
is
Tuesday
August
15
2023..
Today's
hearing
is
being
held
pursuant
to
Temporary
amendments
to
the
open
meeting
law.
That
is
what
allows
us
to
meet.
Virtually
today's
hearing
is
being
recorded
and
will
be
posted
to
the
city
of
Boston's
website.
B
Thank
you
please
ensure
that
your
audio
and
visuals
are
working
properly.
If
you
plan
on
testifying
I
will
call
each
item
in
the
order
that
it
appears
on
this
morning's
agenda.
I
will
then
ask
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
Boston
Police
Department,
and
whether
there
are
any
other
individuals
with
first-hand
personal
knowledge
of
the
alleged
incident.
B
B
Again,
all
testimony
will
be
limited
only
to
those
individuals
with
first-hand
knowledge
of
the
alleged
incident
begin
with
the
first
item
on
this
morning's
agenda.
Calling
item
number
one:
Los,
arios,
Restaurant,
Inc,
doing
business
as
Los
arrieros
restaurant
located
at
13
to
15
Meridian
Street
in
East,
Boston
date
of
the
incident,
March
26
2023
assault
and
battery
Patron
on
Patron,
in
violation
of
Mass
general
laws.
B
B
B
F
F
So
yarrows
did,
while
they
were
both
being
escorted
out.
They
haven't
set
one
and
grabbed
her
by
the
hair
and
threw
her
on
the
ground.
The
woman
was
later
identified
as
cirelli
tamero,
jamilo
and
fundiosis
that
she
felt
pain
in
her
shoulder
due
to
her
falling
plus
EMS
A7
Albano
May
unit.
Four
was
requested
to
the
scene
and
salguero
declined
for
the
medical
attention.
You
have
to
observed:
Mauricio
silgaro,
to
be
intoxicated.
F
F
The
office
spoke
to
the
managers
establishing
Antonio
Espina
ospina
stated
that
marixa
soguero
informed
him
that
one
of
the
patrons
and
inappropriately
touched
her
ospina
then
spoke
to
Victor
Mejia,
who
denied
the
allegation
against
him
moments
later.
The
suspect,
Oscar
Gaines,
began
yelling
and
causing
disturbance
inside
the
establishment
security.
Then
escorted
out
of
the
out
of
the
premise.
F
He
then
intervenes
to
prevent
any
physical
altercation
lopera
observed
the
suspect
attempting
to
fight
the
victim
and
was
escorted
out
of
the
establishment.
Well,
Paris
that
the
suspect
resisted
and
was
not
a
client,
well
Paris
stated
that
he
used
Force
to
remove
the
suspect
from
Los
arios,
because
he
was
fighting
him.
The
officer
spoke
to
cirelli
Tamaro
gemarlo
to
Mario
tremelo
stated
she
observed
the
verbal
physical
altercation
at
the
bar
she's,
an
observed,
the
manager
being
pushed
while
the
others
were
escorting.
F
The
suspect
out,
Tamayo
jamarillo
attempts
to
intervene
as
he
steps
in
to
help
Maritza
salguero
raises
her
hand
as
if
she's
going
to
hit
her
acting
in
self-defense.
She
grabbed
it
by
the
hair
and
so
Garo
fell
to
the
ground.
Tomato
jamalo
stated
that
she
tried
to
help
her
get
up,
but
saguero
continued
yelling
at
her.
F
The
officer
spoke
to
the
suspect,
Oscar
yanes,
who
stated
that
he
was
escorted
out
of
the
establishment
for
no
reason
and
was
assaulted
by
security,
Sebastian
lepera
when
he
was
when
he
was
escorted
off
the
premise.
The
suspect
stated:
the
security
twisted
his
right
thumb
during
the
interaction,
the
suspect
denied
medical
attention.
F
The
suspect
stated
that
if
the
police
did
not
arrest
victim
here,
he
would
handle
the
matter
and
would
hurt
him.
The
officers
also
spoke
to
Alfredo
Gomez
Gomez
stated
he
was
present
during
the
incident
should
be
noted.
That
officer
Crespo
had
a
hard
time
understanding.
What
Gomez
was
saying
due
to
the
fact
he
was
highly
intoxicated?
F
Patrol
supervisor
Sergeant
Matera
at
the
Gold
907
was
notified,
was
unable
to
respond
to
the
location
through
to
being
another
Priority
One
Call,
detective
Samaras,
the
goal
837
and
Detective
Holder
gold
817
were
then
notified
and
conducted
a
licensed
premise:
inspection
notice,
code,
35,
citation
number
022-584,
District
detectives
into
offices,
review
video
footage
of
the
incident.
It
was
observed
that
Victor
Mejia
was
on
the
left
side
of
Maritza
salguero.
He
was
standing
and
she
was
sitting
on
the
bar
stool.
It
should
be
noted
that
both
siguero
and
Mejia
were
very
close
to
each
other.
F
It
was
observed
that
Mejia
was
resting,
his
right
arm
on
the
chair's
back
support.
While
officers
reviewed
the
video
with
where
the
incident
occurred
bar
area,
it
was
not
observed,
it
was
not
observing
the
video
that
victim,
inappropriately
or
intentionally
touched
Maritza
salguero.
Furthermore,
it
was
observed
at
Oscar
yanes
approached
victim.
He
hadn't
gotten
in
his
personal
space
and
grabbed
him
by
the
jacket
moments
later.
The
suspect
yane
struck
the
victim
on
the
shoulder
and
security
intervened
at
the
time.
F
The
officers
responded
due
to
the
fact
that
the
video
evidence
of
the
incident
did
not
corroborate
the
allegations
made
by
Maritza
soguero.
You
also
did
not
place
the
victim
under
arrest
due
to
the
fact
that
all
parties
were
intoxicated
in
the
country
concerts
and
video
evidence.
Further
investigating
further
investigation
would
be
conducted
by
District
detectives
detectives
will
seek
additional
video
footage
of
the
incident
at
a
later
date.
Sergeant
kauf
will
notify
sexual
assault
unit
spoke
to
detective
Lewis.
Detective
Lewis
of
the
incident
will
be
further
investigating
with
District
detectives
body
went
camera
activated.
F
About
11
20,
the
first
paragraph
recaptures
the
whole
other
one
I'll
start
with
the
second
paragraph.
It
should
be
noted
that
respond
detectives,
William
Samaras
and
hold
a
rise
unseen
and
performed
a
code
35
later
the
patreon
and
Patron
the
legend
employee
on
Patron
assault,
detective
responding
officers,
viewed
video
footage
of
the
incident
from
the
cell
phone,
the
manager,
Antonio
Spina,
while
on
scene,
an
interior
video
camera
gave
a
clear
and
unobstructed
view
of
the
incident.
F
The
video
showed
that
both
Mr
yanes
and
Miss
elgaro
seated
in
the
bar
drinking
in
Mr
Hugo
Mejia,
standing
to
miss
saguero's,
left
with
his
hand,
placed
on
Mr
garrow's
back
of
her
chair
rest,
Mr
Mejia
appears
to
be
engaged
in
conversation
with
unknown
males
who
was
left
and
not
focused
on
the
sargero.
Further
video
shows
Miss
elgaro,
leaning
back
and
making
contact
with
Mr
mahia's
resting
hand.
F
Miss
o'guro
has
a
very
apparent
reaction
to
this
and
to
this
contact
and
was
observed
to
be
in
this,
that
it
was
observed
to
be
indisputably
unintentional
and
accidental
Mr
Mejia
did
not
make
any
overt
motions
with
his
hand.
Miss
elgaro
was
then
observed
in
an
anime
discussion
with
Mr
yanes,
who
then
initiates
an
animated
conversation
with
Mr
Mejia.
F
He
is
observed
for
having
me
here
by
the
shirt
and
pulling
them
when
security,
Mrs
Sebastian
lopera
then
intervened
and
stood
between
the
two
men.
Video
then
clearly
shows
Mr
yanes
reaching
over
the
parents,
striking
Mr
Mejia
in
the
chest
in
fighting
staff
violently,
as
they
tried
to
escort
Mr
yanes
out
detective
Smasher
recovered
two
or
Terror
videos
in
one
video
on
the
front
sidewalk
of
13
Meridian
Street,
the
video
further
depicts
Mr
yanes,
violently
fighting
staff
and
striking
patrons
not
identified
the
exterior
video
also
shows
Miss
algero
fighting
and
striking
Mr
rally.
F
Tamaro
jamilo
Mr
mellow
did
not
bring
Mr
early
to
the
ground,
did
bring
Mr
Ellie
to
the
ground
in
the
struggle
it
did
it
and
did
appear
to
try
to
help
her
out
based
on
witness
accounts,
victim
accounts
and
all
videos
recovered
I'm,
requesting
that
here
in
East,
Boston
District
Court
for
Oscar
Gaines
for
assault
and
battery
Victor
Hugo
Mejia
on
Victor
Hugo,
Mejia,
further
I'm
requesting
a
hearing,
the
East
Boston
Court
for
Marissa
seguero
for
assault
and
battery
on
cirelli
to
mail
jamilo.
That
concludes
the
reports.
D
D
Thank
you.
No
further
questions
I'd
just
like
to
give
a
brief
overview
and
then
ask
some
questions
of
Mr.
Osvina
Los
arrieros
is
a
small
Colombian
restaurant.
It's
is
a
one-room
establishment.
It's
been
owned
and
operated
by
primarily
by
Mr
ospina
for
the
last
30
years,
and
he
is
there
almost
every
night
and
he
was
there
this
night.
D
There
are
two
allegations
here:
one
is
Patron
on
Patron
assault
and
battery
with
a
suggestion
of
inappropriate
touching
first
of
all,
Mr
ospina
wants
to
say
that
he
takes
this
quite
seriously.
He
has
an
all-female
bartender
staff
and
they
are
Vigilant
about
this
type
of
activity.
At
all
times.
That
being
said,
we
concur
with
the
police
report.
It
appears
there
was
no
inappropriate
touching.
There
was
no
assault
and
battery
and
the
video
that
we
have
provided
to
the
police
and
that
we
have
provided
to
the
board
cooperates
that.
D
D
D
H
H
D
Yes,
all
right
by
way
of
explanation
for
the
board,
this
is
not
directly
relevant
to
the
incident,
but
the
owners
have
been
concerned
about
sort
of
a
cultural
disconnect.
This
is
a
Colombian
bar.
Most
people
are
from
Colombia
and
in
that
country
you
can
buy
your
drinks
and
take
them
outside.
There's
no
rule
that
you
have
to
drink
them
inside
and
there
have
been
several
contentious
discussions
lately
with
people
saying
I
bought
this
drink,
it's
mine,
you
can't
prevent
me
from
breaking
outside
so
out
of
an
abundance
of
caution.
D
H
H
H
H
C
C
D
D
He's
a
he's:
a
dedicated
Bouncer
and
I
I
apologize
for
our
late
submission
of
the
video,
but
when
the
board
has
a
chance
to
review,
you
will
see
that
both
The,
Bouncer
and
Antonio
were
in
between
these
two
people
before
any
physical
altercation
started
they've.
Just
they
just
started
arguing
vigorously,
and
these
guys
are
in
between
them
literally.
A
B
Thank
you
we'll
see
if
we
can
get
that
video
from
Maria
and
share
it
with
the
board
as
soon
as
I
do
with
that,
the
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement.
Thank
you.
Thank
you
all
very
much
calling
item
number
two
Fuente
Cleaning
Services
Inc
doing
business
as
Bill
Yaris
Colombia,
located
at
28
Bennington
Street
in
East
Boston
to
enter
the
incident,
April,
2nd,
2023
assault
and
battery
with
a
dangerous
weapon,
a
bottle
of
mass
generalize
chapter
138,
section
64.,
265,
section
15
a
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
N
B
B
B
P
B
O
O
Do
you
want
me
to
start
over
if
you
could
please?
Okay?
Thank
you
about
1
57
a.m,
on
Sunday,
April,
2nd,
2023
officer
Velez
on
the
gold
411
Alpha,
while
conducting
a
code,
19
responded
to
a
report
of
a
fight
at
17,
Bennington,
Street,
Bajaj
bar
also
on
scene,
was
the
gold
101
Alpha
officer,
Forbes
and
Ashman,
and
the
alpha
910
Sergeant
Downey.
O
Upon
arrival,
the
officer
was
waved
down
by
a
female
stating
there
was
someone
bleeding
the
officer
then
approached
the
victim
Eduardo
Cartagena,
who
was
actively
bleeding
from
what
appeared
to
be
a
laceration
for
the
head
above
the
eyes
the
victim
stated
he
was
hit
in
the
head
with
a
glass
bottle.
The
victim
States,
while
inside
the
bar,
a
group
of
guys
were
starting
trouble
with
another
female
friend
of
the
victims.
A
fight
then
ensued
and
finished
outside
of
the
premise.
F
Mr
perennis
then
directed
detectives
to
construct
a
construction
project
going
on
in
the
rear
of
the
building
detectives,
observe
an
additional
unfinished
structure
with
electrical
wiring
that
was
exposed.
Mr
parenz
went
to
say
that
the
construction
had
compromise
the
video
System,
including
the
time
of
the
incident,
present
further.
He
was
trying
to
remedy
the
situation
with
the
surveillance
system.
Citation
number
022
585
was
issued
by
Detectives.
M
P
P
Q
Q
Q
Q
P
Q
Q
P
M
B
M
You
based
on
the
eyewitness
testimony
of
this
witness
she
was
inside
the
bar,
her
friend
started
to
cause
a
commotion.
He
was
asked
to
lead
and
escorted
outside
the
premise
by
security
outside
he
picked
a
fight
with
the
group
of
people
that
were
walking
down
the
street.
Nobody
committed
the
alleged
assault
had
anything
to
do
with
this
license
promise.
This
was
something
that
happened
out
in
the
street
and
it
was
not
foreseeable,
and
we
believe
that
in
this
particular
instance,
the
licensee
did
what
they
were
supposed
to
do.
They
de-escalated
the
situation.
M
B
M
There's
no
camera
footage,
as
noted
in
the
police
supplemental
report.
This
was
during
a
time
where
this
particular
establishment
was
undergoing
Renovations
for
sound
proofing.
A
significant
amount
of
work
was
being
done
inside
the
premise
and,
as
is
reflected
in
the
police
report,
I
believe
the
officer
confirmed
that
as
well.
C
Well,
I
did
see
that.
How
long
did
this
I'm
just
curious
I
mean?
How
long
was
the
were
the
cameras
down?
There
is
a
2019
security
plan
that
the
licensee
signed.
That
said,
they
would
always
have
cameras
available
I
understand
within
reason
that,
if
you're
having
construction,
but
when
did
the
construction
start,
how
long
did
it
last
and
why
and
is
it
directly
related
to
this
particular
incident.
P
The
construction
went
under
under
a
thing
was
for
like
four
to
five
weeks
and
the
thing
is
a
drop
ceiling,
so
all
the
wires.
This
is
an
older
building.
All
the
wires
are
connected
and
whatever
goes
to
the
cameras,
the
guy
who
was
doing
the
electrical
for
the
outside
for
the
lighting
and
everything
they
had
cut
it
down.
I
wasn't
aware
of
it.
P
I
just
knew
when
we
came
to
give
them
I
saw
that
all
the
wires
were
out
and
that's
when
I
asked
them
and
I
also
was
when
the
officer
came,
I
showed
them,
but
then
he
came
also-
and
you
can
ask
him
a
week
after
and
everything
was
working,
all
the
cameras
were
working.
Everything
was
working
perfectly
cameras.
C
A
C
You
want
to
make
that
clear.
That
is
part
of
your
security
agreement.
It's
also
part
of
our
rules
and
regulations.
You
have
to
act
reasonably
and
diligently
to
disperse
crowds
to
prevent
something
like
this.
So
your
attorney
just
said
that
that
he
was
escorted
outside.
Can
you
describe
the
scene?
Was?
He
is
just
escorted
to
the
front
door?
P
P
C
P
O
P
A
P
H
K
P
K
M
K
M
K
Okay
and
why
I'm
asking
is
because
dispersal
as
it
has
been
here
has
been
an
issue
and
it
was
re-raised
with
the
facts
from
September
of
2022.
and
I'm,
just
saying
I'm
concerned
as
I.
Think
the
chair
is
that
you
know
there's
only
one
security
guard
to
hear
that
this
aggressive
party
was
thrown
out
and
then
the
security
guard
immediately
had
to
basically
turn
his
back
and
go
back
inside
to
deal
with
the
rest
of
the
people.
It
just
seems
inadequate
to
me
and
maybe
foreseeable
that
one
security
guard
wouldn't
have
been
adequate
here.
M
L
L
So
if
you
have
any
other
Construction
in
the
future,
just
make
sure
that
you're
upfront
with
the
contractor
to
say
that
the
the
security
cameras
you
have
a
you
have
to
prioritize
them.
So
if
there's
any
time
in
which
the
the
electricity
needs
to
be
updated
or
it's
just
that
they
need
to
be
got
beat
up
as
soon
as
possible.
R
B
Thank
you
without
the
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement
calling
item
number
three,
which
concerns
the
same
licensee
point:
a
Cleaning,
Services
Inc
doing
business
as
Billiards
Columbia,
located
at
28
Bennington
Street
in
East
Boston
date
of
this
incident.
April
29
2023
assault
in
battery
employee
on
Patron,
in
violation
of
mass
generalize
chapter
138,
section
64
and
chapter
265,
section
13
a
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensing.
M
B
B
F
F
The
victim
further
stated
that
the
incident
incurred
about
1
30
a.m.
In
the
morning
the
victim
continued
and
stated
that
the
unidentified
suspect
is
a
security
guard
at
the
location
stated
above
the
victim
informed
the
officer
that
the
unidentified
males,
a
white
Hispanic
male
about
five
six
in
height
and
a
168
weight.
The
victims
further
stated
that
the
unidentified
suspect
had
stopped
the
victim
and
demanded
the
victim
pay.
His
bill
as
the
victim
was
leaving
the
establishment
to
which
the
victim
identified
suspect
he
had
paid
his
bills.
F
The
victim
also
reported
that
he's
got
to
ensued
with
the
unidentified
suspect
had
placed
the
victim
in
a
choke
hold
the
victim
refused
any
medical
attention.
At
the
time
the
victim
stated
to
the
officer
that
he
has.
He
has
a
mental
disability
and
that
he
needs
to
gather
his
thoughts
at
the
time
and
did
not
think
to
call
9-1-1.
The
victim
also
stated
that
he
had
consumed
a
few
alcoholic
beverages.
The
awesome
formed
the
victim
to
re-contact
the
police
when
he
needed
when
he
needed
and
that
the
police
report
is
going
to
be
generated.
F
I
have
a
supplement
to
read
until
the
record
Monday
5
1
20
23
1930,
detective
samaritus
detective
Williamson
went
to
28
Bennington
Street
Belarus
for
a
code
35
response
to
an
alleged
employee
on
Patron
assault.
The
sector
Samara
spoke
to
his
staff
to
staff,
who
put
the
owner
manager
Mary
Quintana,
with
a
phone
number
on
the
phone
with
detectives.
Miss
Quintana
provided
the
name
of
security,
John
Alvarez
that
was
working
that
night
and
that
he
was
from
was
familiar
with
the
incident.
F
Miss
Quintana
refused
their
victim's
accusations
and
advised
the
victim
had
not
paid
his
full
Bill
and
that
there
was
no
assault
by
the
security
guard.
Ms
Quintana
was
advised
to
produce
video
on
the
incident
and
she
advised
that
she
would
comply.
Bilaris
was
issued
a
licensed
premise:
inspection
notice,
022-585
by
detective
Samaras
staff,
member
on
site
manager,
Alexandria
biles,
signed
and
accepted
citation.
The
staff
was
cooperative
with
detectives
in
the
pyramids
were
clearly
posted.
M
S
P
P
P
A
M
A
M
You
note
from
the
police
report
that
this
individual
showed
up
at
the
police
department
at
3
30
in
the
morning
long
after
this
establishment
it
closed,
he
admitted
to
the
officers
that
he
was
suffering
from
a
mental
disability
and
that
it
was
also
had
consumed
a
number
of
alcoholic
beverages.
We
are
sad
to
hear
of
this
unfortunate
person's
mental
disability,
but
this
had
nothing
to
do
with
the
lares
Columbia.
M
P
F
C
P
A
P
B
S
Good
morning
attorney
green
Madam,
chair
members,
the
board
Dennis
quilty
attorney,
representing
the
licensee
with
me
this
morning
is
Anthony
assistant
manager,
who
is
on
duty
in
the
making
question.
Excuse
me
and
I'm
sorry
Katina
corresponds
is
the
director
of
risk
management
for
Alliance
Group
good
morning.
S
A
E
R
About
1
19
a.m,
on
Sunday
April,
9th
2023
I
saw
being
on
the
Delta
431
Alpha
responded
to
a
radio
call
for
Boston
EMS,
requesting
the
response
of
Boston
police
at
nine
lands
down
street.
Upon
arrival,
officers
were
directed
by
Lansdowne
public
security
to
meet
the
victim.
Christian
Dorian,
who
was
assaulted
inside
the
bar.
R
R
Lansdowne
public
security
was
able
to
call
police
and
EMS
to
assist.
Boston
EMS
responded
to
the
scene.
The
victim
declined
to
go
to
the
hospital
and
stated
he
would
go
on
his
own
Boston
EMS
assistant.
He
go
to
the
hospital
due
to
his
head
injury,
but
the
victim
still
declined.
The
victim
stated
he
had
a
head
and
knee
injury.
S
S
A
S
U
U
It
was
clear
that
the
guy
kind
of
told
them
no
she's
with
me.
The
guy
didn't
seem
to
like
it
kind
of
put
his
hands
on
the
guy.
They
begin
to
to
wrestle
a
little
bit.
I
ran
over
and
I
was
able
to
grab
the
guy,
who
initially
went
over
to
the
couple
and
as
I'm
walking
him
out,
I
see
a
guy
run
over
and
another
man
hits
him
so,
as
as
Christian
Doran
was
running
over
a
man
on
the
side
of
him
strikes
him
Christian
Dorian
falls
to
the
floor.
U
Hits
his
head
I'm
able
to
pass
off
the
guy
I'm
kicking
out
to
security.
I
now
call
9-1-1
immediately
requesting
EMS
and
just
kind
of
making
sure
that
Christian
Dorian
is
able
to
when
he,
when
he
wakes
up,
make
sure
that
I'm
there
to
explain
that
he's.
Okay,
that
I'll
take
care
of
him
when
he
does
wake
up.
U
I
walk
him
over
to
our
back
server
station
kind
of
just
out
of
sight
and
there's
where
we
wait
for
police
to
arrive
for
the
ambulance,
to
arrive
just
to
make
sure
I
also
told
him
you
should
get
checked
out,
but
he
refused,
as
stated
by
the
police
as
well,
and
once
once
they
did
the
license
from
his
check.
He
he
said
to
me
as
well
that
he
would
go
on
his
own
and
from
there
he
left
with
a
friend.
B
Thank
you.
The
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement
as
well.
Thank
you
calling
item
number
five
knk
Restaurant
Group
Inc
doing
business
as
Estella
located
at
49
Temple
Place
dated
the
incident
June
18th
2023,
a
salt
and
battery
on
a
police
officer
in
violation
of
Mass
General
Law
chapter
138,
section
64,
contractor
265,
section
13,
D
and
assault
and
battery
patreon
on
patreon,
in
violation
of
mass
generalize
chapter
138,
section
64
and
chapter
265,
section
13
a
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
V
Good
morning
attorney
Greene
the
chairman
Joyce
members
of
the
board.
My
name
is
Adam
barnowski
255,
State,
Street
Boston
with
me
on
behalf
of
licenses.
He
is
Hilda,
brandeo
he's
the
owner
and
manager
of
record
and
Joseph
Pina,
who
is
the
operations
manager
and
was
on
site
with
your
native
question.
B
B
B
B
E
Reading
from
a
report
authored
by
Officer
Marshawn,
who
reads
as
follows:
a
9
21
on
Sunday
June,
18,
2023
officer,
Marshall
and
Hilton
assigned
to
the
gold
I'm.
Sorry,
the
alpha
102
responded
to
a
radio
call
for
a
large
fight
at
49.
Temple
Place
Boston
police
dispatch
advise
officers
that
they
were
receiving.
Multiple
calls
for
a
large
fight
happening
on
Temple
Place,
assisting
several
assisting
units,
including
over
a
dozen
officers
from
district.
E
As
Dwayne
Hardy
immediately
looked
at
officer
Hilton
and
stated
you
all
are
at
which
point
obviously
help
them
advise
them
to
leave
the
area
after
the
statement
was
made
to
ask
to
Hilton
Mr
hardy
then
proceeded
to
work
directly
at
the
officer
stating
in
a
breast
manner.
What
what?
At
this
time
officer
Marshawn
noticed
that
he
was
in
between
the
police
cruiser
a
cement
traffic
barrier,
which
was
between
him
and
the
sidewalk.
We
realizing
that
he
had
little
chance
to
egress
or
disengage
with
the
suspect
who
was
still
approaching
him
officer.
E
Marshawn,
put
his
hands
out,
moving
the
suspect
away
from
him
upon
the
suspect,
moving
backwards
and
turning
away
from
the
office
officer
Marshawn,
the
suspect
turned
back
around
and
swung
his
right
arm
at
officer
Marshawn,
making
contact
with
the
zombie.
At
this
time,
officers
gained
control
of
both
of
Mr
Hardy's
arms
and
placed
him
under
arrest
on
a
place
in
Hardy
into
handcuffs
of
observed
party
to
be
intoxicated
in
the
smell
of
alcohol.
E
After
placing
Mr
hardy
under
arrest,
officers
requested
the
assistance
of
several
of
the
ray
one
officers
on
scene
to
clear
away
the
street
of
the
rowdy
crowd,
which
was
now
in
the
middle
of
the
street.
In
order
to
transport
Mr
hardy
to
the
station,
a
majority
of
officers
assigned
the
district
had
to
remain
unseen
for
a
significant
period
of
time
in
order
to
support
disperse
the
disorderly
and
rowdy
crowd.
E
V
E
V
V
W
V
And,
and
are
you
aware,
do
you
have
any
knowledge
of
any
facts
which
would
support
that
any
of
the
patrons
that
were
involved
either
on
the
patreon
patron
assault
or
or
be
Patron
on
on
a
police
officer
assault?
Do
you
have
any
facts
and
support
that
any
of
these
individuals
were
were
patrons
of
Estella
in
the
restaurant.
E
V
No
more
questions
for
for
the
police
department.
I
would
like
to
address
the
incident
briefly.
As
I
mentioned,
Mr
brandeo
and
Mr
Delfina
are
available
here
to
testify,
as
needed.
Mr
brandea
opened
to
Stella
in
2022.
It's
a
minority-owned
business
with
him
and
Mr
delpina
handling
the
day-to-day
Affairs
of
the
business
and
operation.
The
ownership
takes
these
incidences
all
instances
very
seriously,
including
the
matter
at
hand
the
license
he
was
operating
on
a
Sunday
function.
At
the
at
the
time
of
the
incident
which
occurred
on
Temple
Place.
V
There
is
no
contesting
the
facts
that
are
stated
within
the
police
report.
It's
clear
that
there
was
a
disturbance
in
the
area
on
Temple,
Place
I,
think
the
arrests
occurred
after
the
police
arrived.
What
the
board
will
see
is
that
there's
no
Nexus
relationship
between
what
happened
on
Temple
place
and
Estella
at
management
staff
acted
cooperatively
and
appropriately,
and
that
there
was
the
incidence
the
instances
were
not
reasonably
foreseeable
by
the
licensee.
V
There
are
numerous
license
establishments
at
this
location,
including
the
Godfrey
Hotel
Estella,
George,
Howell,
Coffee,
Boston
shops
and
Cafe
bonjour,
there's
no
record
of
any
individuals
involved
in
the
instances
being
at
Estelle.
On
the
night
of
question,
the
primary
incident
involving
Mr
hardy
occurred
after
BPD
came
to
the
area.
Nothing
occurred
at
the
licensed
premises
and
there's
also
no
record
of
Mr
hardy
being
a
Stella
on
The
Dating
question.
The
testimony
today
should
also
demonstrate
that
the
license
he
acted
appropriately
and
was
cooperative
with
the
pig
that
I
would
like
to
ask
my
client
to.
A
V
V
N
I
Was
Made
Away
by
two
two:
there
was
a
fight
the
last
the
last.
What
was
it
called?
The
Godfrey
Hotel
has
last
doing
their
around
the
base.
Part
they're
car
parking
ballet.
So
there
was
a
gentleman
there
who
eats
there.
All
the
time
came
in
and
said
that
there
was
a
fight
in
front
of
the
Godfrey
I
believe
they
were
the
ones
who
made
the
initial
call,
and
then
I
was
told
by
my
security.
There
was
two
women.
N
V
N
N
N
Is
everything
okay,
I
believe
he
was
the
sergeant.
He
was
a
taller
guy,
you
know
and
then
I
have
a
cousin
of
mine
who's,
a
police
officer
in
that
area
he
came
in.
He
told
me
he
spoke
to
my
native
language
everything's,
all
right.
He
it
was.
It
was
good.
I
actually
had
three
official
police
officers.
One
was
an
MBTA
cop
in
the
in
the
building.
I
had
Senator
Liz
in
the
building.
N
Everything
is
perfectly
fine.
One
of
the
gentlemen
actually
was
a
that's
a
hero
there,
so
yeah
they
they
came
in
and
they
they
spoke
to
us.
We
I
told
him
everything's
perfectly
fine
in
here
he's
like
do
you
need
help
clearing
the
crowd.
I
said
yeah
at
this
point
we
we're
and
then
the
party
we're
going
to
clear
them
out.
The
police
never
went
into
entire
establishment.
N
I
had
two
security
guard,
Until,
the
End,
two
security
guards,
two
security
guards
come
out
and
then
I'm
sorry
I
had
six
security
guards
inside
doing
their
job
and
then
I
two
of
them
came
out
to
kind
of
help.
The
help
the
police,
clear
the
crowd
and
then
I
was
taking
people
away
from
the
police
because
the
the
way
they
were
they
reacted.
In
my
opinion,
they
weren't
de-escalating
the
situation.
They
were
escalating.
N
The
situation,
I
was
taking
people
to
say,
hey,
look,
you're,
just
move
away,
just
go
home,
there's
no
need
to
yell.
It
comes
just
go
home,
they
do
it
because
they
were,
they
were
mad,
that
they
stopped
the
party
of
some
sort.
But
so
I
was
just
getting
people
like
hey.
Just
let's
go
home.
Let's,
let's
go
home,
there's
no
need
for
that.
I
was
taking
people
away
from
the
police
officers
and
just
telling
my
guests
to
hey
just
go
home.
N
We
want
to
just
get
home
safe,
there's
another
day
that
kind
of
stuff,
and
we
were
cooperating
with
them
everything
they
did
and
the
police
officer
was
even
a
grandkid.
Why
the
isn't
these
these?
These
people
out
of
your
building,
yet
I
have
a
2AM
license.
You
know,
as
long
as
people
are
acting
accordingly
and
they're,
you
know
they're
safe.
You
know,
there's
there's
nothing
going
on
in
my
facility.
N
V
N
C
N
There
was
no
50
people
until
the
people
the
the
police
came
in.
There
was
no
50
people
outside
until
the
police
came,
and
it
was
probably
I
would
say
when
they,
when
the
police
showed
up
I
would
say
it
was
maybe
a
handful
of
people.
You
all
have
cameras
on
that
street
I
would
highly
recommend
that
you
look
at
it.
N
C
C
C
N
N
C
N
N
B
V
S
A
B
B
B
W
W
B
X
Mr
stated
he
was
talking
to
a
girl
at
the
bar
when
a
white
male
punched
him
in
the
face.
One
time
with
a
closed
fist,
Mr
Worcester
described
the
suspect
of
the
white
male
about
six
three,
two
thirty
twin
Thirty
pounds
bald
and
no
facial,
hair,
Charles
rooster
believes
the
suspect
was
a
boyfriend
of
the
woman.
He
called
Beautiful
officers
requesting
EMS
on
channel
2
area.
X
A
officer
spoke
to
with
Ray
Decker,
who
is
the
general
manager
of
fin
Point
Oyster
Bar
and
Grill
Mr
Decker
stated
a
physical
altercation
occurred
outside
with
Mr
Wooster
and
another
individual,
which
then
led
to
a
verbal
dispute.
Inside
the
restaurant
Mr
Decker
stated
that
staff
members
separated
World
parties
and
contacted
the
police.
Mr
Decker
told
officers
that
the
person
who
had
a
confrontation
with
Mr
Wooster
did
attend
the
restaurant.
However,
the
suspect
used
a
gift
card
for
all
his
payments,
so
they
couldn't
provide
officers
with
information.
X
Ems
Ambulance
won
a
one
Martinez
and
D'amico
arrived
on
scene.
However,
Mr
Worcester
declined.
Medical
treatment
telling
EMTs
to
off
Mr
Wooster
is
a
guest
of
the
Hilton
Boston
hotel,
which
is
located
in
the
same
building
as
the
Finn
Point
Oyster
Bar
and
Grill
offices
accompanied
Mr
Wooster,
along
with
his
father
back
to
the
hotel
room
office
notified
the
Victor
923
Gallagher
and
victory
815
Hernandez,
who
stated
they
would
conduct
conducted
1235
at
a
later
date,
officers
informed
Mr
Decker
of
this.
It
should
be
noted
that
Mr
Wooster
his
father,
told
the
officers.
X
On
Sunday
January,
1st
2023,
sorry
detective,
William,
Gallagher,
detective
ready,
Hernandez
assigned
to
the
BPD
license
permission
to
conduct,
responded
to
finpoint,
located
89
Broad
Street
to
speak
to
staff
regarding
assault
and
battery
incident
that
occurred.
The
prior
evening
detectives
spoke
to
the
person
in
charge,
Miss
Daniel
O'driscoll,
who
confirmed
that
she
was
aware
of
the
incident
and
had
been
working
that
evening
special
informed
was
Drisco
was
informed
by
detectives
to
preserve
any
video
surveillance
of
the
incident.
X
B
W
A
S
W
S
W
S
W
W
W
The
blood
was
on
the
floor,
so
you
could
say
that,
but
like
I
said
I
don't
know
I,
wasn't
there
I,
wasn't
there
to
see
or
witness
it,
but
from
what
I
got
is
the
victim
indicated?
It
happened
in
the
bar
when
they
called
the
woman
beautiful
the
the
staff,
the
ministry,
that
the
altercation
happened
inside
the
physical
altercation
they
went
inside
to
have
a
verbal
disagreement
with
the
manager
was
saying:
okay,.
S
S
S
And
did
that
person
cooperate
with
you?
Yes,
sir
I.
Don't
know
whether
it's
detective
Gallagher
with
us
this
morning.
No
sorry
you
couldn't
make
it
today,
sir
okay,
as
they
just
I,
mean
Mr
simonelli
who's.
The
witness
for
the
licensee
will
will
testify
that
he
made
diligent
search
of
the
records
of
the
establishment
and
was
able
to
determine
who
the
individual
the
assaulting
individual
might
have
been,
and
he
reached
out
to
and
left
a
message
for,
detective
Gallagher,
providing
that
information.
Are
you
aware
of
that?
I.
G
G
S
I
I
You
know
given
the
tenor
of
the
holiday
and
up
until
the
point
of
the
incident,
it
was
a
very
standard
evening
from
my
experience
as
I
experienced
it
in
real
time,
I
was
walking
through
the
lounge
area
towards
the
lobby
door
of
the
Hilton,
which
connects
directly
to
our
restaurant.
When
a
gentleman
who
ended
up
being
identified
as
Mr
Wooster
came
running
in
the
door,
bleeding
flailing
and
lunging
towards
guests,
there
were
a
number
of
guests
at
the
bar
and
at
the
high
tops
so
obviously
again
being
a
normal
evening.
I
With
dinner
service,
this
stood
out.
It
was
disconcerting,
so
I
put
myself
between
him
and
the
other
guests
attempted
to
calm
him
down.
While
he
began
swinging
and
grabbing
at
me,
while
bleeding
I
directed
our
other
manager
to
call
9-1-1
call
for
police
assistance
and
just
tried
to
calm
Mr
rooster
down
and
get
him
into
the
lobby,
so
we
could
speak
with
him.
I
He
was
speaking
unintelligibly
and
screaming
and
trying
to
grab
me
and
hit
me
and
then
his
father
came
up
and
tried
to
hit
me
and
said:
he's
been
assaulted
and
I
said.
Well,
we
we
called
the
police,
we
want
to
help.
We
will
help
you
you're
bleeding.
We
got
him
into
the
lobby
and
he
stated
that
someone
in
the
bar
hit
him.
I
had
been
there
the
entire
evening
and,
as
did
my
other
two
managers,
we
were
separated
watching
all
portions
of
the
restaurant.
S
I
You
know
after
I
had
slept
a
little
bit
and
had
some
time
to
myself.
I
began
looking
up
what
I
could
on
what
I
know
about
this
person,
meaning
I,
know
kind
of
sort
of
what
industry
they
work
in
I
know
kind
of
sort
of
where
they
are
from
and
I
just
got
very
lucky
in
between
LinkedIn
Google
and
our
OpenTable
reservation
system.
I
was
able
to
find
a
name
that
I
believe
matched
I
found
a
video.
I
I
called
over
to
A1
the
I
believe
the
non-emergency
number
I
have
that
number
in
my
phone
and
I
asked
to
speak
with
the
license
premise.
Unit
and
I
got
Sergeant
detective,
Gallagher's,
voicemail
and
left
him
a
voicemail
stating
who
I
was
where
I
was
calling
from,
and
my
cell
phone
number
and
said
that
I
had
an
identity
for
the
person
in
question.
I'd
be
happy
to
provide
it
anytime.
B
L
B
I
B
X
This
mail
looked
young
and
watched
him
meet
up
with
two
females
that
were
standing
in
front
of
the
store,
detective
stopped
the
group
and
ask
them
to
produce
identification
to
confirm
their
ages.
All
three
individuals
immediately
stated
they
were
under
21
days
of
age
when
the
touch
was
asked.
Mr
Roman
Seth
how
he
obtained
the
alcohol
which
that
which
detectives
observed
him
walk
out
of
the
store
with
Mr
broman's
dad
produced
a
fraudulent
Illinois
driver's
license
sitting.
He
was
over
21
years
of
age.
X
Detectives
confirmed
that
the
driver's
license
provided
by
Mr
Bowman
sets
will
indeed
fraudulent
detectives
took
photographs
of
Mr
Broman
Roman's
heads
valid
Switzerland
driver's
license
along
with
a
fraudson
Illinois
driver's
license.
A
fraudulent
driver's
license
was
confiscated
by
detectives.
The
two
females
were
identified
as
Sarah
Kloss
and
Nina
Lambert
upon
speaking
to
the
first
female
mixed
coloss
provided
detectives
with
a
New
Jersey
with
her
New
Jersey
driver's
license
status.
She
was
under
under
21
years
of
age.
X
Detectives
were
able
to
confirm
that
Miss
Claus
did
have
a
valid
New
Jersey
driver's
license
the
second
female
Ms
Lampard
provided
detectives
with
her
Florida
driver's
license.
They
did.
She
was
also
under
21
news
of
age.
The
Titans
were
able
to
confirm
that
Ms
Lambert's
did
have
a
valid
Florida
driver's
license.
Miss
Mr,
Bowman,
Sapp,
Ms,
Claus
and
Miss
Lambert
will
be
some
corporate
persons
under
21
in
possession
of
alcohol.
Mr
Bowman
Seth
will
also
be
summoned
to
the
court
for
Forge
misuse
or
an
r
b
document.
X
As
a
result
of
what
the
type
of
Reserve
track
effective
Gallagher
issued
license.
Private
inspection
notice,
zero,
five,
nine,
nine,
eight
five
to
Walsh's
liquor
store
for
sale
of
alcohol,
the
person's
under
21
years
of
age,
a
person
in
charge,
Mr
sugary
chatri
signed
for
an
acceptance
notice.
So
thank.
Y
Incident,
thank
you
before
getting
started
with
testimony.
I
just
would
like
to
note
that
this
violation
predated
two
subsequent
violation,
notices
that
the
license
you
received
on
December,
20th
and
February
10th,
and
the
hearings,
unsaid
notices
and
thus
predated
the
updated
processes
the
licenses
has
since
put
into
place
to
address
underage
minors,
as
per
the
operational
memo
that
was
submitted,
and
that
was
later
amended
after
the
informational
hearing
that
we
all
attended.
Y
Okay,
also
as
it
relates
to
this
particular
violation,
because
no
hearing
was
scheduled,
Mr
shrether
did
believe
that
it
was
resulted
in
a
warning
that
this
notice
really
resulted
in
a
warning
and
that's
why
it
wasn't
addressed
in
the
previous
two
hearings.
So
just
briefly,
could
you
you've
been
sworn
in?
Could
you
state
your
name
for
the
record
yeah.
J
Y
J
J
J
Y
J
Y
B
S
Morning
again,
attorney
Greene
Madam
chairman
was
the
board
Dennis
quilty
attorney
representing
the
licensed
seat
with
me
this
morning,
Katina
corrupines,
the
risk
manager
who's
already
been
sworn
in.
Gabriella
Wooten,
who
signed
for
the
inspection
notice
of
the
night
in
question
in
corvington
Vermont
employees
of
the
establishment
good
morning.
X
B
X
I'll
be
reading
from
a
police
report
written
by
Sergeant
detective
Gallagher
on
Now
One
Two
of
2023,
at
about
one
16
PM
Lieutenant,
to
take
a
reader
and
Troy
sign.
Detective
William,
Gallagher,
detective
Hernandez
assigned
to
the
election
Ceramics
unit
conducted
a
licensing
department,
inspection,
the
bleacher
bar
at
82,
Lansdowne
Street,
before
the
Winter
Classic
at
Fenway
Park.
X
As
detectives
enter
the
premise
they
asked
the
doorman
as
to
the
account
the
doorman
replied
198.
The
capacity
of
the
bleacher
bar
is
198.
thinking
that
the
premise
had
exceeded
its
occupational
load.
The
Texas
conducted
a
mechanical
count
of
the
premise
which
resulted
in
220
persons.
This
was
relayed
to
the
manager
Gabby
Wooten,
who
who
stated
that
she
would
bring
the
premise
of
the
compliance
as
a
result
of
what
was
observed.
X
B
S
S
X
S
Establishments
up
and
down
the
street
and
yeah
it's
a
very
a
very
a
very
busy
day,
but-
and
this
will
lose
this
morning,
she
signed
the
inspection
notice
and
your
you
indicated.
She
was
cooperative
that
they
do
everything
they
could
once
you
brought
this
to
their
attention
to
cooperate
and
clear
the
space
and
get
into
compliance.
Yes,
sir,
they
did
okay,
I,
just
I
have
no
further
questions
of
any
Detachment.
I.
S
S
The
number
which
was
given
to
the
officers
of
198,
of
course,
is
the
capacity
of
the
establishment.
They
have
indicated
to
me
that
their
staff
were
informed
to
keep
a
lower
number
on
their
door
counts.
For
just
this
reason,
and
as
a
result,
they
now
have
these
clickers
kept
at
190
so
that
they
are
a
you
know
more
substantially
under
that
count,
so
that
they
have
some
leeway
for
just
this
kind
of
circumstance.
I,
don't
believe
that
this
establishment
has
any
such
violations.
S
It
is
a
popular
establishment,
but
I
don't
believe
they
have
any
such
violations.
They
were
Cooperative,
they
understand
that
they
have
to
stay
within
their
capacity,
and
hopefully
this
new
setting
of
a
lower
number
will
help
us
stay
in
that
in
that,
within
the
proper
capacity
and
I.
Just
would
like
to
ask
Ms
Wooten
you've
been
sworn.
Would
you
just
tell
the
board
what
your
position
is
with
the
establishment.
A
S
L
Z
S
Right
and
when
the
police
officers
came
in
and
informed
me
that
they
took
account,
that
was
over
capacity,
did
you
follow
their
lead
and
and
reduce
the
capacity
to
it
to
their
satisfaction?
Yes,
okay
and
subsequently
have
you
and
other
managers,
Mr
demand
and
his
corapons
and
others
in
the
Lions
group
spoken
to
your
staff
about
what
steps
to
take
to
try
to
keep
the
capacity
at
or
where
it's
supposed
to
be.
S
B
The
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement.
Thank
you
calling
out
of
number
nine
atg
Inc
doing
business
as
clear
he's
located
at
331
to
335
Columbus
Ave
date
of
the
incident.
March
7th
2023
service
of
more
than
two
alcohol
drinks,
one
Patron
in
violation
of
best
generalized
chapter
138,
section
64.,
an
expired
ISD
certificate
posted
with
an
expiration
date
of
September
19th
2020
in
violation
of
mass
generalize,
chapter
138,
section
64
and
Boards
rule
1.02
B,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
W
B
X
Good
morning
sir
I'll
be
reading
from
police
report
which
I
wrote
on
Tuesday
March
7
2023
shine,
detective
Long,
Island,
detective
Hernandez
assigned
to
the
BPD
license
from
student
conducted
a
license.
It's
current
inspection
of
Cleary's
located
at
331
Columbus
Avenue
in
Boston,
while
standing
in
the
bar
area
of
the
establishment
detectives
observe
they
bartender
provided
Patron
with
12
shots
of
tequila.
The
patron
then
walked
away
from
the
bar
and
went
over
to
a
table
of
patrons
then
upon
reviewing
the
licenses
certificate
of
the
Departments
of
the
establishment.
X
Detective
reserved
that
there
was
no
car
inspectional
services
department
certificate
posted
the
one
that
was
there
was
from
919
of
2020,
and
no
current
city
of
Boston
entertainment
license.
One
displayed
was
a
inspired
at
12
31
of
2022
detectives
brought
this
to
the
attention
of
the
person
in
charge.
Mr
Patrick,
Duncan,
Mr
Duncan
immediately
took
corrective
action
and
spoke
to
the
staff
member
in
question.
X
As
a
result
of
the
detectives
issued
license
department
inspection
over
zero,
six
zero
one,
seven
five
for
service
of
more
than
two
drinks
to
one
Patron
at
one
time.
This
is
a
prohibitive
practice
in
violation
of
a
mass
law,
204
cmr4
section
B
for
and
for
no
current
ISD
certificate
posted
the
new
current
city
of
Boston
entertainment
license
posted
Mr,
Duncan
sign
for
an
acceptance
device.
X
G
A
G
P
B
G
G
No,
no,
the
waitress
had
been
waiting
on
them
for
a
period
of
time,
but
the
waitresses
shift
finished.
The
party
stayed,
it
was
in
the
same
room
where
the
bartender
could
clearly,
you
know
see
you
know,
was
in
close
proximity
to
the
bar.
So
after
the
waitress
left,
they
were
coming
to
the
bar
themselves
for
service.
L
A
B
Thank
you
for
that.
If
there
are
no
further
questions
from
the
board,
the
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement
as
well.
Okay,
thank
you
includes
the
license
permits
inspection
portion
of
this
morning's
hearing.
The
board
will
take
a
quick
five-minute
recess
and
then
continue
with
the
remaining
item
for
an
informational
Hearing.
In
five
minutes
we
will
pause
the
video
and
we'll
be
back
in
five
minutes.
Thank
you.
B
We
will
now
move
on
to
the
remaining
item
of
this
morning's
agenda.
Item
number
10.
This
is
an
informational
hearing.
This
is
not
a
disciplinary
hearing.
The
purpose
of
this
informational
hearing
is
for
the
board
to
gather
necessary
information
regarding
the
operation
of
this
license
premise.
The
licensee
is
154
Maverick
LLC
doing
business
as
Maverick
House
Tavern,
located
at
154
Maverick
Street
in
East
Boston.
B
It's
a
mandatory
informational
hearing
regarding
the
potential
non-use
of
the
license
ownership
and
beneficial
interest
in
the
licensee
entity,
manager
of
record
of
the
licensee
entity
and
oversight
and
control
of
the
day-to-day
operations
of
the
licensing
entity.
Pursuant
two
Mass
general
laws:
chapter
138
sections,
12,
15a,
23,
26,
64
and
77.,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
D
Good
morning,
everyone
Andrew
Upton
for
the
licensee
and
with
me
is
John
Tyler,
the
principal
owner
of
the
licensing
entity,
the
manager
of
record
and
the
principal
owner
of
the
building.
I
would
like
to
note
for
the
record
that
Mr
Tyler
lives
in
the
apartment
above
the
restaurant
and
has
at
all
times
well.
The
license
has
been
in
action
and
he's
been
the
manager,
so
he
literally
10
feet
away
from
the
license
premises
at
all
times.
B
AB
C
Thank
you,
Danny
I
I
will
try.
We
call
this
informational
hearing
today,
because
this
is
a
restricted
license
at
this
location
and
the
licensee
has
not
been
open
and
operating
for
nearly
a
year.
The
last
time
we
formally
heard
from
the
licensee
was
last
September
when
they
asked
the
board
for
permission
to
close
temporarily
to
refresh
and
Rebrand
their
concept.
C
Since
then,
we
have
heard
anecdotes
about
other
restaurants,
potentially
planning
to
open
and
operate
here.
We
even
received
a
police
report
about
one
of
those
potential
operators
being
locked
out
and
I
see
she's
here
with
us
today,
but
we
have
heard
nothing
from
the
licensee
themselves.
We
have
been
down
this
road
before
with
this
licensee,
where
we
have
held
similar
informational
hearings
to
determine
what
is
happening
at
this
license
premise
and
who
was
in
control.
It's
still
unclear
to
me,
as
chair
of
the
board,
exactly
what's
going
on
here.
B
B
D
D
D
C
D
Yes,
Mr
Lions
okay
was
operating
the
restaurant
under
a
Consulting
contract
and
purported
purchase
agreement
initiated
by
John's
ex-wife,
who
was
here
tonight
today,
and
we
struggled
for
some
time
to
try
to
get
him
into
compliance
to
file
a
change
of
beneficial
interest
to
file
as
the
manager
to
comply
with
a
wide
variety
of
rules,
regulations
and
standard
business
practices
for
restaurant.
Those
negotiations
failed.
M
D
D
D
They
made
a
professional,
a
provisional
decision
to
move
forward
under
a
letter
of
intent,
as
negotiations
were
proceeding.
Mr
Tyler,
who
lives
upstairs,
as
we
said,
discovered
that
the
potential
tenant
had
already
taken
down
interior
walls
without
permission
or
permits,
and
that
the
work
had
damaged
the
sprinkler
pipes.
D
So
in
a
meeting
with
Claudius
year,
the
LLC
Mr
Tyler
informed
her
that
her
failure
to
make
the
payments
and
her
dispute
with
Andres
Jaramillo
was
an
impediment
to
Future
relations
and
as
a
result
of
her
incompetent
renovation,
work,
failure
to
pay
contractors,
partnership,
breakup
and
misrepresentations,
reminding
regarding
Renovations
and
financing.
The
LLC
ended
that
relationship,
so
that
takes
us
into
earlier
this
year.
D
He
has
a
good
experience
and
he
would
like
to
move
forward
himself
opening
a
restaurant
with
a
Latin
menu
appropriate
for
the
neighborhood
he's
currently
the
operator
of
Perros
piesas
in
two
locations,
as
well
as
a
food
truck,
and
he
is
a
CV
licensee
under
a
CV
issued
by
this
board.
So
we
felt
that
he
would
be
qualified
and
appropriate.
So
work
is
progressing
on
schedule
to
have
Mr
yarmio
as
a
consultant
to
open
a
restaurant
in
Early
September.
D
Finally,
it
appears
that
this
place
is
on
track.
We
have
sent
some
photographs
to
the
board
of
the
substantial
Renovations
and
which
would
demonstrate
how
near
to
completion
and
operation
it
is,
and
once
Mr
jeremio
establishes
himself
as
a
qualified
operator
Consulting
to
run
this
show.
We
may
seek
to
include
him
as
under
a
management
agreement
to
further
codify
the
relationship,
but
we
can
also
tell
you
that
Mr
Tyler
hosted
a
meeting
for
Community
leaders
and
stakeholders.
D
C
C
AB
AB
AB
It
listed
the
capacity
and
it's
it
also
directed
to
send
some
information
for
when
we
spoke
with
Mr
Tyler,
he
offered
us
a
lease
for
five
with
the
for
five
years,
with
the
option
to
extend
it
to
10
years.
At
no
point
at
the
beginning
of
the
negotiations,
Mr
Tyler
told
us
that
this
that
we
were
going
to
be
his
managers.
We
were
not
interested
in
working
for
Mr
Tyler
and
then
after
you.
C
AB
That
was
not
the
understanding.
The
understanding
was
always,
and
he
had
always
referred
to
us
as
tenants
and
as
our
payments
of
8
100
a
month,
he
always
referred
them
as
rent.
So
at
no
point
we
had
any
indications
that
we
were
going
to
be
working
for
Mr
Taylor
as
time
progressed
after
we
gave
him
a
significant
amount
of
money.
AB
He
his
attorney,
sent
us
some
documents
that
were
certainly
not
a
lease,
not
an
occupancy
agreement.
They
were
a
management
agreement
and
they
were
a
Consulting
agreement
and
constantly
Mr
Taylor
told
us.
We
don't
want
to
embarrass
the
boar.
The
boar
is
aware
that
we
are
using
these
documents
for
you
as
a
manager,
but
you
cannot
disclose
that
you
are
the
owner
of
this
restaurant
and
you
cannot
disclose
the
address.
So
we
worked
and
improved
his
restaurant
significantly.
C
D
AB
AB
AB
When
he
learned
that
John
Ortiz
and
I,
where
potentially
gonna,
be
tenants
at
this
location,
he
automatically
asked
us
to
allow
him
to
join.
Then
his
request
was
that
John
Ortiz
was
removed
or
worked
as
a
manager
and
I
told
him
that
you
know
it
was
John
and
I's.
You
know
Venture
if
he
wanted
to
come
onto
the
partnership.
That
was
fine,
but
none
of
us
were
going
to
leave
because
he
wanted
to
enter.
C
C
AB
AB
The
balance
to
be
refundable
should
the
license
process
be
not
satisfactory
to
the
city
of
Boston
or
the
abcc,
or
if
the
parties
are
unable
to
come
to
final
agreement
of
all
matters,
and
to
this
day
we
have
not
seen
a
dime
I
want
to
clarify
that
Andres
failed
to
invest
the
same
amount
of
money.
We
invested
Andres
failed
to
show
up
Andreas,
who
is
always
arguing
with
us.
AB
However,
with
meeting
secretly
with
John
Tyler,
the
first
twenty
thousand
dollars
that
he
provided
to
that
we
provided
to
Mr
Tyler
Andres
gave
them
directly
to
Mr
Tyler,
it
didn't
come
from
our
business
account.
It
came
from
andres's
business
peris
python,
which
was
given
through
excuse
me
was
given
directly
to
John
Tyler,
then
John,
Ortiz
and
I
paid
the
remainder
of
the
deposit
that
he
requested.
AB
AB
Unfortunately,
Mr
Taylor's
attorneys
caught
Adams
was
not
responsive
for
a
lot
of
the
times
that
our
attorney
contacted
him,
and
this
dragged
for
six
months,
who
was
your
attorney?
Our
attorney
was
Fred
10
News.
What's
his
name,
Fred,
okay,
t-a-n-n,
all
you
ads.
Okay,
then,
when
Andres
returned
in
January,
he
asked
us
why
we
hadn't
signed
the
agreement.
We
told
him
that
there
was
this.
This
agreement
did
not
protect
us
at
all
that
this
didn't
say
that
we
were
tenants.
In
fact,
there
was
two
agreements.
AB
AB
AB
Andreas
became
abusive
verbally,
abusive
name,
calling
stopped
showing
up,
and
then
we
had
to
get
an
independent
attorney,
Miss
Miss,
Mary
and
Cicero,
who
spoke
Spanish,
who
speaks
Spanish
and
start
with
the
three
of
us,
and
he
admitted
in
front
of
her
that
he
had
no
interest
in
being
part
of
our
partnership.
The
following
day,
Andres
sent
us
a
text
to
a
group
chat
and
said
that
he
was
voluntarily
leaving.
However,
within
the
same
week,
he
went
to
the
city
of
Boston.
AB
The
office
of
Economic,
Development
and
fi
complain
about
me,
lied
and
said
that
I
was
harassing
him
and
that
I
was
threatening
him
and
Mr
Ronald
Ellie
from
this
office,
provided
him
a
free
attorney
to
go
after
us
for
the
money
most
of
the
money.
You
know
it
was
not.
Forty
thousand,
it
was
like
thirty,
four
thousand
twenty
thousand
dollars
he
had
given
to
John.
A
C
C
To
me
that
Mr
Tyler
was
shopping
around
a
license
and
I'm
trying
to
figure
out
exactly
what
was
going
on.
I
think
you've
you've
been
riding
this
wave
to
attorney.
This
is
very
confusing.
Bear
with
us
we're
taking
time
out
today
to
try
to
figure
this
out,
Claudia
I'm,
going
to
ask
you
to
hit
to
stop
there
for
a
minute
I'm
going
to
ask
the
other
Commissioners
if
they
have
any
questions
based
upon
what
you
said
so
far.
This
is
completely
confusing,
not
straightforward.
C
D
D
T
K
T
S
K
N
T
J
T
K
C
L
AB
D
L
C
D
He
will
be
the
manager
of
record.
He
will
be
the
licensee.
The
restaurant
could
be
open
in
the
next
few
weeks
with
Andres
yaramillo.
As
the
operator
I've
sent
the
board
some
progress
photos
showing
that
it's
very
close
to
being
ready
if
Mr
Tyler
is
understandably
gun
shy
about
dealing
with
anyone
in
the
restaurant
industry.
At
this
point,
but
if
things
progress
appropriately,
he's
perfectly
happy
to
transfer
the
manager
of
record
responsibility
to
Mr
yarmio
and
to
enter
into
a
management
agreement,
so
the
flow
of
funds
can
be
compliant.
C
T
T
That
is
the
agreement
that
we're
operating
under
so
he's
not
I
mean
effectively.
He
would
be
there
to
make
sure
the
rebranding
and
everything
goes
accordingly
and
in
that
sense,
managing
the
employees
and
things
like
that,
since
he
has
the
experience
the
restaurant
experience
to
do
that,
but
he's
it
is
not
the
management
agreement
that
Andrew
Upton
is
referring
to
that
we
would
be
operating
at
this
time
when
the
restaurant
opens,
it
will
be
opened
as
an
entity
owned
by
154
LLC,
who
the
manager
of
the
LLC
is
John.
T
T
T
The
procedure
proper
procedure
would
be
for
us
to
pay
that
into
court
and
notify
the
priorities
that
the
money
is
there
and
they
can
fight
in
court
as
to
who
has
claimed
to
that
money,
because
we
are
not
going
to
decide
whether
Claudia,
Sierra
or
Mr.
Jaramillo
has
a
right
to
the
money
that
was
paid
buy
an
LLC
in
which
the
two
of
them
were
members.
R
T
T
B
B
AA
They
Superior
Court
issued
John
Tyler,
the
manager
only
in
the
our
court
orders
that
were
filed
with
you
and
it
states
clearly
that
the
probate
court
is
best
to
divide
the
assets
we
are
still
in
litigation
over
all
of
us.
Mr
Tyler
keeps
appealing
it
so
we're
still
at
a
50
50
split
as
Adam
said
that
there's
a
forensic
accountant
has
been
involved
because
of
the
money
issues
and
management
issues.
AA
AA
C
AA
I
believe
that
that's
correct,
but
I
was
operating
a
restaurant
with
Dan
Lyons.
He
and
I
were
business
partners.
Dan
Lyons
was
locked
out
with
bicycle
chains
across
the
locks
and
all
of
his
equipment,
and
the
cafe
equipment
was
locked
inside
the
premise.
At
that
time
he
was
completely
cut
out
of
his
livelihood.
He
was
not
evicted
with
a
correct
with
an
eviction
letter
to
the
best
of
my
knowledge.
AA
AA
C
C
I
would
appreciate
a
status
update
of
the
various
litigation
going
on.
Oh
I'm,
not
sure
how
it
will
all
relate
to
the
license
at
hand,
but
I
will
take
a
look
at
it.
I'm
just
concerned
I'm
looking
for
more
information
at
this
point
about
what
is
going
to
happen
at
this
location.
With
this
license
what
Mr
Tyler's
involvement
we're
going
to
be
in
what
is
a
realistic
time
frame,
I'm,
not
quite
sure,
interrupting's
time
frame
of
September
is
realistic.
AB
Thank
you,
I
just
want
to
clarify
that
Mr
Taylor
did
not
notify
us
that
we
were
going
to
be
evicted
or
terminated.
We
had
a
meeting
with
him
on
April
4th
regarding
our
concern
about
the
agreement,
the
occupancy
agreement
not
being
ready,
and
he
asked
us
to
help
him
pass
the
building
inspection
that
he
had
failed
within
that
same
week
after
we
did
and
finished
our
Renovations
Andres
is
doing
a
paint
over
what
we
did
the
bulk
of
the
work.
AB
We
did
it
and
we
were
locked
out
without
any
notice,
nine,
five
or
six
days
after
paying
the
April
rent
and
it's
been
four
months
we
had
to
file
a
police
report.
We
hadn't
had
our
belongings
return
or
our
deposits
returned
and
Mr
Taylor
said
he
was
going
to
make.
He
appointed
the
director
of
East
Boston
main
street
as
the
middle
person
for
us
to
pick
up
our
belongings
and
from
the
restaurant
specifically
when
we
got
there,
they
were
thrown
outside
of
the
restaurant
they're
damaged,
incomplete.
AB
We
Salvage
a
few
things
from
there
and
we
had
to
leave
everything
else
because
we
did
not
bring
any
of
our
stuff
in
that
and
not
State,
and
you
know
just
want
to
clarify
that.
We,
the
the
adapters
that
Mr
Adams
says,
have
been
the
companies
that
we
had
to
hire
in
order
to
run
a
restaurant,
the
payroll
company,
the
cable
company
Etc,
who
have
reached
out
to
Mr
Taylor,
who
sent
me
an
intimidated
message.
AB
C
AB
C
AB
B
B
D
D
D
You
know,
I
I,
resent
the
implication
that
I
locked
anyone
out
of
information
I
have
not
heard
from
any
lawyer
from
Alyssa
Tyler
in
several
years,
but
I
recognize.
This
is
not
about
my
feelings.
It's
about
compliance,
and
the
goal
here
is
to
use
the
license
to
involve
the
community
and
John
Tyler
has
taken
the
appropriate
steps
he
met
with
every
single
elected
official
and
the
police
last
week,
as
well
as
East
Boston
main
streets.
The
place
is
close
to
ready
to
open.
D
It
is
entirely
appropriate
for
him
to
hire
someone
as
a
consultant
to
help
him
run
the
restaurant
as
long
as
the
consultant
does
not
get
revenue
from
alcohol
service
that
Consulting
agreement
is
compliant
and
in
place
and
moving
forward.
You
know,
should
he
decide
that
this
is
a
good
fit?
We
will
talk
to
Andres
about
becoming
the
manager
obtaining
a
beneficial
interest
under
a
management
agreement,
and
those
applications
would
be
timed
would
be
filed,
timely
right
now.
D
B
AA
Concerned
because
I
was
given
paperwork
from
John
Tyler
and
his
attorneys
that
there
was
rent
paid
for
the
cafe
during
this
time
that
Ms
Sierra
was
involved.
So
I
can't
don't
know
why
they're
saying
there
was
no
rent.
It
was
reported
to
me
that
there
was
rent
again.
There
was
a
letter
of
intent
that
was
sent
to
my
attorneys
for
the
new
tenant
and
I
would
only
receive
the
signature.
Page
I
was
not
given
the
two
other
pages,
so
I
do
not
know
what
their
intentions
are.