►
From YouTube: Administrative Appeals Board | August 23 2023
Description
Regular Meeting of the City of Palm Springs Administrative Appeals Board, held August 23rd, 2023
C
B
C
D
D
B
D
D
The
next
item
is
probably
a
comment.
This
time
has
been
set
aside
for
members
of
the
public
to
address
the
board
on
items
of
general
interest
within
the
subject
matter.
Jurisdiction
of
the
board
30
minutes
will
be
assigned
to
each
speaker.
Although
the
board
values
or
comments
pursuant
to
the
brand
act,
the
board
generally
cannot
take
any
action
on
items
not
listed
in
the
posted
agenda.
D
B
C
This
evening
my
name
is
Patrick.
Whatever
the
department
of
study
program
compliance
and
we
will
receive
the
vacation
Revenue
program
and
see
this
afternoon-
is
the
staff
report
for
the
property
book.
One
two
seasons
on
the
road
number
20.
it
was
found
at
his
property
was
operating
as
a
vacation.
Rentals
21
degree
in
your
staff
report
is
elements
that
led
to
the
insurance
consultation.
I
didn't
want
the
code,
compliance
officer
that
investigated
the
property
found
the
elements
of
the
agency
here
and
I'll
be
going
to
introduce
and
invite
the
road
officer
to
provide.
C
While
reviewing
the
advertisement
and
stated
that
the
entire
two-bedroom
condo
was
being
offered
for
eight
guests,
I
wasn't
able
to
find
a
city
ID
number
on
the
advertisement
as
required
for
a
registered
vacation
rental
property.
So
I
reviewed
the
photos
contained
within
the
ad
and
I
positively
identified
the
property
address
as
1268
East
Ramon
Road
Unit
number
20.
upon
review
of
the
city's
vacation
rental
registration
records.
C
G
C
Which
can
be
found
in
attachment
number
six
about
a
pretense
day,
arriving
Friday
May,
19
2023
and
departing
on
May
Monday,
May
22nd
2023.,
my
message:
shaded
hi,
there
cute
place
we're
looking
to
vote
for
a
friend's
birthday
weekend
from
May
19th
through
May
22nd
2023
I
just
wanted
to
see
if
the
check-in
time
is
flexible,
that
it
will
be
driving
from
Santa
Barbara
if
not
not
a
deal.
Breaker
the
host
manipoletta
responded
to
my
inquiry
with
the
following
unique
response.
Good
afternoon
I
most
definitely
I
most
definitely
can
be
flexible.
C
What
time
are
you
thinking
of
checking
in
before
I
can
send
a
reply.
I
received
the
following
two
additional
messages
from
The
Host.
Thanks
for
your
inquiry
about
my
vacation
rental,
the
property
is
available
from
May
19th
through
May
23rd,
2023
and
I'd
like
to
invite
you
to
stay
your
pre-approved
to
book.
So
you
automatically
be
confirmed.
If
you
make
a.
G
C
The
property
will
then
be
booked
for
you
for
your
requested
dates.
If
you
have
any
further
questions,
just
let
me
know
thank
you.
Nicoletta
Smith,
following
that
message,
I
then
received
the
following
from
the
host
again
by
every
I
have
updated
your
original
quote.
If
you
wish
to
continue
with
the
reservation,
you
may
now
make
a
payment
to
confirm
your
booking.
C
C
F
D
D
G
G
Last
year,
I
also
decided
to
place
my
rental
or
place
it
for
rental,
because
I
live
in
Los
Angeles.
My
children
are
under
at
the
age
of
18
and
I
have
to
take
care
of
their
medical
stuff
and
they
have
court
cases.
And
what
have
you
so
I
cannot
move
to
Palm
Springs
currently,
but
it's
more
for
a
future,
but
I
got
a
loan
on
this
property,
so
somehow
I
have
to
figure
out.
How
can
you
hear
me
yeah?
We
can
hear
you.
G
Oh
okay,
I'm
sorry
I
was
seeing
some
motion,
so
I
was
wondering
if
you're
hearing
me
anyways
last
year,
I
wanted
to
have
it
rented
in
a
long
term,
because
I'm
not
sure
if
it's
like
going
to
be
five
years
or
whatever
amount
of
time
until
my
children
are
able
to.
You
know,
take
responsibility
and
or
move
there,
but
I
had
a
very
bad
luck
with
that.
G
Eventually
she
can
pay
me,
but
it
was
all
a
lie
and
I
ended
up
having
to
evict
her
and
I
lost
more
than
twenty
thousand
dollars,
and
that's
a
lot
for
a
single
mom
like
me.
So
after
that
happened,
I
heard
that
I
can
put
the
place
on
rental
and
I'm
really
honestly
afraid
to
move
somebody
in
because
this
lady
stayed
there
and
destroyed
my
property
and
didn't
pay
rent
for
like
eight
plus
months
and
destroyed
my
property.
She
took
my
my
refrigerator
apart.
G
She
left
garbage
all
over
and
no
I
had
no
idea
how
there
was
nobody
to
help
me
and
I
did
all
the
filings.
She
did
file
to
get
rental
assistance,
but
apparently
she
didn't
file
all
the
paperwork
and
nobody
released
me
any
fund,
and
so
I
was
kind
of
desperate
to
have
this
covered
because
I
don't
know
what
to
do,
and
so
somebody
suggested
verbal,
so
I
listed
it
on
verbal
I
had
no
idea
that
I
have
to
have
some
registration,
or
this
would
be
some
short-term
rental,
I'm
terribly
sorry
I.
G
You
know
I,
of
course,
I
am
kind
of
desperate
to
have
some
money.
Some
income
coming
in
because
not
only
did
she
not
pay
the
rent
and
I
had
to
pay
out
of
pocket
for
all
the
expenses
like
the
association
fee
and
my
mortgage
and-
and
you
know,
electrical
bill
because
part
of
that
she
also
did
not
pay
any
anything.
G
So
I
I
listed
my
property
there.
I
did
not
know
that
I
have
to
have
some
registration.
I
did
pay
my
taxes,
I
paid.
My
taxes
to
you
know
yearly.
I
didn't
know
that
there's
other
taxes
I
did
see.
There's
some
taxes
on
verbo
and
I
added
that
too,
but
I
I
don't
understand
all
those
things
that
are
listed
there.
G
You
know
trying
to
break
the
law.
I
I
never
tried
to
break
the
law.
I
don't
have
any
infractions
anywhere
I.
Don't
have
anything
against
me
anywhere
for
anything
and
I.
Try
to
be
respectful
and
take
care
of.
You
know
the
society
and
you
know
not,
even
my
you
know,
not
biological
children,
I'm
taking
care
of
other
people,
I
respectfully.
G
Ask
that
you
don't
borrow,
because
my
understanding
is
that
you're
trying
to
borrow
my
name
from
Forever
renting
or
something
like
that
and
the
five
thousand
dollar
fine
is
a
lot
of
money.
I've
already
lost
a
lot
of
money
last
year
on
this
even
trying
to
get
this.
This
appeal.
It
was
very
a
lot
of
money
for
me
to
come
up
with
so
that
I
can
be
heard,
but
I
think
that
it's
important
that
you
guys
know
all
the
facts
and
circumstances
and
I
feel
like
I
was
deceived.
G
I
was
deceived.
Last
year
by
the
lady
who
came
in
and
gave
me
some
story
and
I
guess,
I
was
deceived
by
getting
this
request
to
rent
my
unit
online
I,
I,
just
I
feel
it
feels
that
it's
not
fair
and
I.
Don't
want
my
name
forever
barred
from
Palm
Springs,
I
I
haven't
done
anything,
you
know
any
other
thing,
but
this
so
I
I
did
not
know
I'm
breaking
the
law.
G
F
G
F
G
G
H
B
G
G
Actually
it's
more
multiple
bills,
it's
kind
of
confusing
in
the
city
of
Palm
Springs,
because
in
Los,
Angeles
I
don't
get
two
tax
bills,
but
in
the
city
of
Palm
Springs
I
got
the
different
tax
bills.
I
guess
there's
a
tax
bill
for
if
you
have
a
property
on
land
lease
and
another
tax
bill
for
your
property,
it
was
very
confusing.
F
G
F
D
F
C
F
D
C
No,
let's
just
this
is
an
unfortunate
situation.
Unfortunately,
we've
seen
it
before
and
unfortunately
you
know
people
we're
not
doing
research
before
putting
a
property
on
the
market
doesn't
excuse
the
responsibility,
and
so
again
this
is
a
situation
that
we've
seen
many
times
over
and
there's
really
nothing.
We
can
do
without.
F
Okay,
Mr
facilities
facility-
thank
you
so
I
would
tend
to
agree.
You
know
I.
We
have
been
through
this
many
many
times
and
you
know
to
to
research
afterwards.
I
think
you
put
yourself
in
a
precarious
position
that
simple
step
beforehand
could
have
saved.
All
of
this
she's
clearly
admitted
that
she's
rented
it.
You
know
when
we
see
from
the
report.
F
E
D
You
just
for
the
Appellate,
so
there's
a
please
understand
under
this.
Under
the
ordinance,
we're
only
allowed
to
either
say
yes
or
no
we're
not
allowed
to
give
warnings
or
to
change
anything
about
the
fine
or
the
failure
to
be
able
to
rent
in
the
future.
May
I
have
a
emotion
from
someone
please.
Okay,.
E
Sake
make
it
clear
to
the
palette
based
on
what
I
heard.
This
is
not
bad
you
as
a
human
from
Palm
Springs.
This
just
says
you
cannot
do
short-term
rentals
in
this
city.
That's
what
that
means.
So
you
can,
if
you
are
game,
rent
for
29
days
or
more
and
that's
up
to
you
and
you
are
certainly
not
banned
from
this
city,
so
that
this
just
applies
to
Vacation
Rentals,
and
this
ordinance
that
we
have
is
extremely
strict.
So
you
just
won't
have
to
mess
with
it.
D
D
A
F
F
D
F
Thank
you
as
he
walks
out
of
the
room
and
there's
an
appeal
of
a
five
thousand
dollar
fine,
an
administrative
decision
that
light
speed.
Investments
is
permanently
ineligible
to
operate
a
vacation
rental
in
the
city
of
Palm
Springs
board
secretary.
Can
you
please
ensure
that
the
city
staff
and
the
appellant
understand
that
their
testimony
is
under
oath?
We.
B
Do
have
Saint
affidavits
from
City
staff
NFL
and
if
in
person,
anyone
on
Zoom
who
desires
to
testify
under
this
appeal
hearing
under
the
laws
of
perjury.
If
you
choose
to
speak,
you
hereby
accept
and
acknowledge
that
your
testimony
shall
be
the
truth,
the
whole
truth
and
nothing
but
the
truth
to
begin.
C
All
right,
good
evening,
members
of
the
board,
my
fellow
City
staff,
members
of
the
public
present
for
tonight's
hearing.
My
name
is
Jason
Whitaker
and
I'm,
a
co-compliance
officer
with
the
city
of
Palm
Springs
on
Thursday
April,
27
2023.
While
conducting
a
review
of
available
rental
listings
on
the
web-based
booking
platform.
Airbnb.Com
I
came
across
an
advertisement
in
the
Gene
Autry
neighborhood
of
Palm
Springs
title
Coachella
retreat
with
private
pool,
which
can
be
found
as
attachment
number
five
in
the
staff
report.
C
While
reviewing
the
advertisement,
it
stated
that
the
entire
three-bedroom
home
was
being
offered
for
up
to
eight
guests.
I,
wasn't
able
to
find
a
city
ID
number
on
the
advertisement
as
required
for
a
registered
vacation
rental
property,
so
I
reviewed
the
photos
containing
within
the
ad
and
I
was
able
to
positively
Identify
the
property
address
as
2811
East
San
Diego
Road
upon
review
of
The
City,
the
Eastern
rental
registration
records
I
confirm
that
the
property
identify
did
not
hold
a
vacation
rental
registration
certificate.
C
C
C
C
The
host
Mark
responded
to
my
inquiry
with
the
following
unique
response:
hi
Wayne,
thank
you
for
your
inquiry.
Our
home
is
available
over
the
ditch
requested
and
we
would
love
to
host
you.
The
availability
of
an
early
check-in
depends
on
the
day
you
arrive.
If
another
guest
is
checking
out
on
the
same
day,
you
arrive
housekeeping
will
need
time
to
clean
the
home.
Before
you
can
check
in,
we
will
do
our
best
to
accommodate
you.
We
will
send
you
a
special
offer
to
include
the
Spring
discount
after.
C
C
As
a
result
of
my
findings
contained
within
the
advertisement,
the
unique
response
to
my
inquiry,
as
well
as
the
host
invitation
to
book
the
property
for
a
fortnight
stay
I
found
the
property
located
at
2811
East
Sandia
Road
was
in
violation
of
5.25.0408
operating
education
rental
without
a
vacation
rental,
Administration
certificating
and
I
issued
administrative
citation
number
av0513
to
the
property
owner
on
title
white,
State
Investments.
That
will
include
what
I
have
to
present
and
I
will
hand
it
over
to
Patrick
I'm
available
to
answer
any
questions.
C
F
C
E
A
B
F
F
Thank
you
all
right.
At
this
time,
I'd
like
to
open
the
appeal
hearing,
the
appellant
is
invited
to
speak
for
up
to
10
minutes.
Any
member
of
the
public
who
desires
to
speak
on
this
appeal
hearing
shall
have
up
to
three
minutes
to
speak.
If
a
member
of
the
public
testifies,
the
appellant
will
be
invited
to
provide
a
rebuttal
for
up
to
two
additional
minutes.
Court
secretary,
could
you
please
begin
the
public
testimony
period.
B
F
E
F
C
Okay,
so
now
I
I
can't
respond.
Okay,
I'm,
sorry
about
that.
Thank
you
yeah.
This
is
this,
is
you
know
contradicting
I
mean
I
can
understand.
Maybe
why,
if
you're
not
on
on
the
call,
because
they
pretty
much,
they
emit
it
even
in
their
own
ad,
that
they're
violating
the
ordinance.
So
this
is
pretty
easy
to
to
discuss
and
also
make
a
decision
on.
E
F
F
I
agree
with
Ms
Kane
that
you
know
when
you
take
the
time
to
put
us
through
this
pay.
For
this,
that's
not
showing
up
is
unfortunate
because
you're
not
offering
any
explanation
or
defense,
but
it
seems
pretty
clear
that
they
were
renting
or
were
intending
to
rent
short
term
without
yet
having
obtained
a
permit
whether
they
were
intending
to
ever
get
a
permit.
We
don't
know
because
they're
not
here,
but
they
were
clearly
offering
it
for
rent
without
a
permit.
F
C
D
Around
six,
yes,
next
item
is
agenda.
Number
six
concerning
the
property
located
at
806,
East,
Racquet
Club.
It's
an
appeal
of
a
twenty
five
hundred
dollar
fine
and
administrative
decision
of
a
six-month
suspension
of
a
vacation
rental
registration
certificate
board
secretary.
Would
you
please
ensure
that
the
city
staff
can
appellate
understand
that
their
testimony
is
under
Earth?
We.
B
C
Yes,
thank
you,
chair,
Vice,
chair
and
board
members
residents
on
zoom
and
joining
us
at
the
meeting
this
evening.
My
name
is
we
oversee
the
vacation
of
our
program
here
at
the
City
Glass
Springs,
but
before
you
this
evening,
as
a
staff
report
for
the
property
located
at
806,
East
correctly
Road
some
background
about
this
property
as
a
regular
vacation
rental
with
the
start
date
and
February
7th
2013.
C
The
code
officer
that
investigated
this
property
is
here
to
provide
further
information
regarding
the
investigation
of
the
legis
against
the
citation.
Additionally,
on
attention
to
that
report
is
reviewed.
The
contract
suddenly
submitted
that
would
be
found
that
working
summaries
have
been
filed.
As
of
August
16
2023,
with
the
first
submission.
As
of
June
15
20
1930.,
there
was
also
an
email
sent
to
the
property
owners
on
February
7th
2023.
C
that
community
and
getting
the
requirement
to
provide
contract
summaries
and
additionally
provided
a
link
to
the
right
to
access
our
web-based
contract
summary
Additionally.
The
code
compliance
officer
can
transient
idg
tests,
documents
supporting
short-term
cities
between
the
months
of
March
and
April
2013,
and
that's
included
his
attack
and
seven
and
additionally,
we're.
Comparing
that
information.
C
The
resulting
observation
led
to
the
officers
contacting
the
off
defense
at
the
front
door,
confirming
their
vacation
rental
stay
and
issuing
a
citation
to
the
responsible
renter
for
vehicles
exceed
I
mean
limit
while
conducting
follow-up
back
his
workstation
officer,
Whitaker
search
the
city's
applicable
record-keeping
database
and
could
not
locate
any
contract.
Summary
submissions
for
806
speaks
City
ID
number
5372
at.
C
Whitaker
contacted
me
with
his
initial
findings:
I
conducted
a
secondary
search
for
contract
selling
submissions
for
this
property,
confirmed
that
none
were
on
file
an
instructed
officer
Whitaker
to
request
additional
records
from
the
vacationing
owners
officer.
Whitaker
then
contacted
the
property
owners
Josh
and
Maria
to
follow
up
regarding
complaint
received
in
the
observe
violation.
C
It's
important
to
note
that
completing
the
statement
of
rules
and
regulations
is
a
separate
requirement
in
addition
to,
and
not
in
lieu
of
submitting
a
contract
summary
and
is
generally
done
during
the
check-in
process
between
the
property
owner
or
their
agent
and
their
guests.
Copies
of
this
form
are
only
provided
to
the
city
with
requested.
In
this
case
they
were
requested
so
that
we
can
determine
the
property's
utilization
as
a
vacation
rental
and
ensure
compliance
with
the
limits
of
contracts
for
vacation
release.
B
C
C
During
the
course
of
our
investigation,
we
found
a
corresponding
advertisement
for
the
property
on
Airbnb,
which
can
also
be
found
in
the
test
and
seven
which
had
reviews
dating
back
to
April
of
2023,
which
is
consistent
with
when
this
property
was
issued.
Its
initial
registration
certificate.
There
are
approximately.
A
C
To
the
vocational
owners,
Scott
Barker
and
Marie
Granberg
and
was
sent
me
a
certified
in
the
LTD
address
on
file,
and
it
should
be
noted
in
a
Patrick
mentioned
in
as
part
of
the
attachments
at
the
bottom
of
attachment.
Seven
there's
a
screen
capture
that
was
taken
on
June
22nd,
which
showed
all
the
submitted
contract
summaries
up
to
that
point.
The
furthest
left
column
has
the
the
date
stamp
and
that's
the
the
time
of
submission.
C
So
the
first
submission
of
a
contract
summary
from
for
this
property
was
on
June
15th,
which
was
after
we
had
conversations
with
the
property
owners
and
not
before,
and
then
since
I
think
when
Patrick
ran
his
reports,
which
was
just
recently,
they
had
some
additional
ones
that
were
added
and
that
will
conclude
what
I
have
to
present
but
I'm
available
for
any
questions
the
board
may
have
officer.
Whitaker
is
also
available.
If
there's
any
questions
that
I'm
unable
to
answer,
you
can
provide
Clarity.
If
he's,
obviously
in
the
room.
D
E
C
C
C
E
Okay,
because
that
to
be
clear,
they
were
given
a
permanent
February,
correct
and
in
the
initial
email
is
conversations
or
there's
instruction
on
contract
summaries
right
right,
then
I
couldn't
find
anything
in
the
contract,
something
until
June,
but
we
do
have
evidence
lots
of
evidence
that
they
have
had
renters
and
and
the
purpose
of
content.
Summaries
is
clear,
I
think
to
all
of
us,
certainly
and
yeah.
This
is
Matt.
This
is
a
mess.
Okay,.
F
So
I
have
a
question:
did
I
glean
for
all
of
this
that
there
were
actually
two
issues?
Is
it
what
started?
It
is
a
complaint
that
there
were
too
many
cars,
so
that
would
have
been
a
citation.
But
on
top
of
that,
you
found
that
there
was
no
contract
summaries
and
and
researching
so
like
when
you
went
to
research
after
a
complaint.
You
say
well
because
you
I
think
you
frequently
tell
us
one
of
your
first
steps.
Is
there
a
contract?
C
F
E
D
At
this
time,
I
would
like
to
open
your
public
hearing.
The
opponent
is
invited
to
speak
for
up
to
10
minutes.
Any
members
of
the
public
who
wish
to
speak
in
disappearing
shall
have
up
to
three
minutes
to
speak.
If
any
member
of
the
public
testifies,
the
appellant
will
be
invited
to
provide
a
rebuttal
about
the
two
additional
minutes
board
secretary.
Please
begin
the
public
testimony
period
as.
J
Hey,
can
you
guys
hear
me?
Okay,
yes,
hi
I'm
Josh,
my
wife
was
just
with
me,
but
she's
wrangling,
our
three-year-old
right
now,
I
just
wanted
to
thank
you
guys
for
taking
the
time
to
hear
our
appeal,
we're
very
appreciative,
the
city
of
Palm
Springs,
and
very
grateful
to
own
a
property
there.
So,
first
and
foremost,
I
just
want
to
acknowledge
that.
Yes,
it
was
our
responsibility
to
submit
the
contract
Summers
and
we
we
do
acknowledge
our
failure
to
do
so
between
March
and
June.
J
Please
know
this
was
absolutely
unintentional,
as
expressed
in
the
email
that
was,
you
know
referred
to
on
612
to
Jason
and
Mitchell
and
arwell
and
Chantal.
It
wasn't
until
after
one
of
our
attendance
was
issued
that
citation
on
the
11th
that
it
was
even
brought
to
our
attention
that
the
contract
summaries
weren't
being
submitted
when
we
spoke
with
Jason
I,
think
it
was
on
that
Sunday
morning
and
he
notified
us
about
the
tenant
having
the
car.
J
We
did
ask
them
about
you,
know
in
that
email.
It
talks
about
the
contract
summaries
and
they
told
Maria
that
they
take
care
of
that.
Obviously,
there
was
a
big
misunderstanding:
I
think
they
were
probably
referring
to
the
contracts
on
airbnbs
and
not
necessarily
submitting
the
contract
summaries
to
the
city.
I
just
want
to
make
it
clear
by
no
means
were
we
trying
to
rent
the
short-term
rental
without
the
knowledge
this
is
Maria
of
the
city
of
Palm
Springs.
J
We
just
let
them
know,
obviously
that
we
were
sorry
that
moving
forward
you
know,
the
a
certain
protocol
would
obviously
be
adhered
to.
I.E
the.
When
the
booking
is
made,
we
will
submit
the
contract
summaries
immediately
and
I
think
as
evidence
by
the
submissions
after
June
15th.
We
have
done
so.
Of
course,
we
also
once
we
received
the
administrative
citation
about
the
suspension
we
reached
out
to
evolve
and
said
you
know.
J
By
no
means
can
you
guys
continue
to
advertise
the
property
until
we
know
what
the
resolution
of
this
appeal
is
going
to
be,
but
we
did
have
bookings
a
handful
of
bookings
between
the
15th
of
June
and
in
August
and
of
course,
we've
submitted
the
contract
summaries
for
all
of
them.
Maria
has
received
signed
statements
of
rules
and
regulations
and
the
Good
Neighbor
documents
from
all
the
attendants
since
then,
and
has
had
you
know
a
FaceTime
resume
meeting
with
them
to
review
the
procedures
and
ensure
that
they're
adhered
to.
J
So
you
know,
I
I,
don't
really
know
what
to
say
other
than
that.
We
love
this
Palm
Springs
area
we're
hoping
to
retire
there.
Honestly,
the
six-month
suspension
would
create
a
financial
hardship
for
us,
so
we
are
requesting.
We
need
to
see
given
the
circumstances
and
just
want
to
thank
you
for
your
consideration.
Much
appreciated.
C
F
J
F
A
F
J
C
F
We
were
probably
caught
up
in
that
that
Hiatus
of
no
permits-
okay,
so
I,
guess
and
the
reason
I
asked
that
was,
if
you
did
the
permanent
application,
ostensibly
that
checklist
page,
you
would
have
initialed
next
to
the
or
the
point
that
contract
summaries
are
required.
That
was
also
listed
on
the
letter
you
got
with
the
permit.
J
Correct,
yes,
and
as
stated
you
know,
the
only
thing
we
said
is
that
after
we
had
forwarded
the
permit
and
that
letter
to
our
management
company,
the
conversation
that
was
had
with
them
gave
us
the
assumption
that
they
handled
all
of
that
you
know.
As
and
that's
you
know,
it
wasn't
our
intention
to
not
submit
them.
We
were
just
we
assumed
that
that
was
part
of
evolve's
scope
as
a
management
company.
F
F
C
There
is
a
penalty
for
not
submitting
these
reports
and
the
homeowners
sign
off
on
these
reports,
saying
that
they'll
make
sure
that
they
get
they
get
submitted
and
they
hire
a
company
that
doesn't
do
it
and
ultimately,
it's
the
homeownership,
that's
responsible.
So
this
is
another
example
of
a
case
that
we've
seen
many
times.
D
E
C
C
So,
under
the
suspension,
we
usually
have
it
as
a
wind
down
period.
We
send
the
suspension
letter
as
specific
Deeds.
We
haven't
worked
with
a
policy
board
to
you
know,
try
to
mitigate
any
kind
of
last
minute
reservations
that
need
to
be
canceled.
So
that's
something
we
can
work
with
to
the
power
to
see.
You
know
it's
an
appropriate
date
within
reason.
C
C
C
G
C
C
The
last
thing
we
want
to
do
is
disrupt
their
state,
but
so
the
effect
of
short
terms,
the
the
effective
date
for
the
suspension
is
August,
28,
24
degrees
and
February,
28th
and
23..
If
August
28th
seems
to
might
have
impact
stays,
we
can
definitely
work
with
the
pellet
to
see
make
sure
that
any
guests
they
coming
in
it'll
be.
B
D
Fine
and
suspension
of
NFL,
the
ordinance
I
would
penalty
of
balance
is
very
strict.
We
have
no
leeway
to
give
leniency
or
do
anything
other
than
an
up
or
down
vote
on
this.
Obviously,
as
you've
probably
just
heard,
the
city
will
work
with
you
in
these
dates
and
on
the
payment
of
fine
with
that.
This
includes
the
hearing
and
we
thank
you,
everybody
for
their
time.
The
next
hearing
is
item
number
seven
concerning
the
property
at
28,
28,
North,
Arcadia,
Court,
number
b-206,.
D
It's
a
set:
the
Martin
castrillo
is
permanently
ineligible
to
operate
a
vacation
rental
in
the
city
of
Palm
Springs
and
he
administrative
fine
of
five
thousand
dollars
for
operating
the
unregistered
vacation
rental
property
board
secretary.
Please
ensure
the
city
staff
and
appellate
understand
that
their
testimony
is
under
oath.
C
C
C
C
Good
evening,
members
of
the
board,
my
fellow
City
staff
members,
president
of
both
all
the
money
management
in
person
for
tonight's
hearing.
My
name
is
Jason
Whitaker
and
I'm,
a
co-compliance
officer
for
the
city
of
Palm
Springs
on
Saturday
June,
17
2023.
While
conducting
a
review
of
available
rental
listings
on
the
web
Facebooking
platform,
airbnb.com
I
came
across
an
advertisement
in
the
Palm
Springs
Village
two
neighborhood
of
Palm
Springs,
titled,
Palm,
Springs,
cozy,
condo
and
pool
which
can
be
found
as
attachment
number
five
in
the
staff
report.
C
While
reviewing
the
advertisement,
it
stated
that
the
entire
one-bedroom
condo
was
being
offered
for
up
to
three
guests.
I
wasn't
able
to
find
a
city
ID
number
that's
required
for
a
registered
vacation
rental
property,
so
I
reviewed
the
photos
contained
within
the
ad
and
I
was
able
to
positively
identify
property
address
as
230
sorry
running
the
wrong
thing:
2820
North,
Arcadian,
Accord
unit
b206
on
review
of
the
city's
vacation
rental
registration
records,
a
confirmed
of
the
property
did
not
hold
a
vacation
and
Rental
registration
certificate.
C
I
then
sent
a
message
via
the
airbnb.com
contact
host
feature
which
can
be
found
in
attraction.
Number
six
inquiring
about
a
five
night
stay
around
on
Friday
June,
30th,
2023
and
departing
on
Wednesday
July,
5th
2023..
My
message:
shaded
hi
there
cute
condo,
we're
looking
to
book
for
Fourth
of
July
weekend
and
I,
wanted
to
see
a
check-in
time
as
possible,
not
a
deal
breaker.
If
not
thanks.
C
C
C
B
C
E
C
Believe
is
kind
of
meaning
to
wander,
allows
short-term
rails,
there's
two
communities
that
is
the
fostering,
because
there's
one
that's
the
Gated
Community,
the
Gated
one
of
those
ones
nominated
the
Gated
Community
and
then
the
non-needed
one
just
recently
in
the
big
stop
allowing
short-term
rails.
So
yeah
I'm,
saying
both
those
complexes.
A
F
D
No
questions
here
at
this
time,
I
would
like
to
open
the
appeal
hearing.
If
God
has
invited
to
speak
for
up
to
10
minutes,
any
members
of
the
public
who
wish
to
speak
on
this
appeal
hearing
shall
have
up
to
three
minutes
to
speak.
If
any
member
of
the
public
testifies,
your
account
will
be
invited
to
provide
an
additional
rebuttal
of
up
to
two
minutes
report
secretary.
Please
begin
the
public
testimony
period.
B
H
H
D
H
I
H
H
According
to
him,
this
property,
he
he
was
trying
to
sublease
it
so
sub,
rented
and
rented.
While
he
was
renting
it
from
you
and
he
doesn't
Martine
doesn't
understand
exactly
what
happened.
He
is
pleading
that,
to
please
understand
him.
This
is
the
only
time
he
never
collected
anything
as
soon
as
he
got
the
notification
he
stopped
and
he
promised
he
will
never
be
a
problem
for
you.
I
I
had
a
conversation
with
him.
He
by
the
way
is
my
brother.
H
D
H
F
F
E
Yeah
I,
don't
I,
don't
think
I
mean
this
is
really
a
frightening
thing
that
can
happen
to
people
and
what
we're
the
thing
I
just
want
to
make
clear
to
you,
as
the
accounts
is
that
what
we're
talking
about
here
is
a
vacation
rental
like
a
short-term
rental
certificate,
not
that
he
will
never
be
allowed
to
rent
it
again.
Clearly,
it's
a
risk,
if
you,
if
you
rent
right
things,
can
happen,
but
what
we're
deciding
today
here
shouldn't
make
him
think
that
he
like
has
to
leave
I
mean
it's.
E
I
H
He
he
bought
it
originally
for
him,
but
he
had
this
problem
with
his
family
and
he
had
to
leave,
but
just
he
doesn't
want
any
problems
with
nobody.
He
never
had
any
problems
before
and
he
respectfully
wants
to
just
avoid
problems
and
decided.
100
percent
sell
it
and
he
terminated
Julio
immediately.
Just
so,
you
know.
Thank
you.
D
Mr
visilian
any
of
this
question.
No,
nothing!
No!
We've
done
this
number
of
months
in
a
row,
but
Council
I'm
going
to
ask
you
and
our
translator
the
law
surrounding
the
fact
that
he
didn't
know
is,
as
I
said,
this
law
is
very
strict
and
I
want
Council
to
explain
to
you
so
that
you
understand
why
the
fact
that
he
didn't
know
about
it
is
not
helpful
in
this
case,
so
Council.
C
Yes,
so,
as
you
know,
as
the
board
is
heard
previously
in
terms
of
the
relevant
Municipal
Code
sections
in
chapter
5.25,
what
essentially
will
be
what
they
say
is
that
operating
in
a
vacation
rental
without
a
dedication.
Mental
registration
certificate
is
a
violation
of
of
the
municipal
code
and
section
c
subdivision
C
in
Section,
5
125.090
provides
that
any
per
sample
operating
vacation
rental
without
any
insurance
certificate,
job
reliable
to
the
city
for
the
pain
management
occupancy
tax.
D
What
you
can
say
with
all
that
lawyers
box
adjustment
on
is
the
law
requires
the
vacation
rental
and
it
it
does
not.
The
owner
does
not
have
to
have
knowledge
that
this
was
rented
in
order
for
there
to
be
a
violation.
So
you
can
pass
on
what
you
think
is
relevant
at
this
point
to
your
to
your
to
the
ability
so.
H
D
Haven't
voted
yet,
but
we
have
not
voted,
but
he
will
not
be
banned
from
long-term
rentals
if
he
ever
wants.
If
that's
the
outcome
of
this
of
this
appeal,
but
I
think
it's
important
for
everybody
to
understand
that
the
law
requires.
We've
had
many
cases
like
this,
where
the
tenant
rented
without
knowledge
of
the
owner
and
that
doesn't
matter
under
the
law
and
that's
I,
think
an
important
point
for
everybody
to
understand.
H
H
D
F
D
F
I
think,
like
you
had
said,
the
we've
been
down
this
road
a
number
of
times
where
somebody
without
the
owner's
knowledge,
but
the
ordinance
is
pretty
clear.
The
penalty,
knowledge
or
not
the
penalty
calls
on
the
owner,
and
you
know
the
unfortunate
that's
unfortunate,
but
but
the
owners
ultimately
responsible-
and
you
know
I-
would
hope
that
this
owner
goes
after
Julio
for
putting
him
in
this
position.
H
He
already
did
he
cancel
and
suspended
and
quit
him
immediately.
So
the
bottom
line-
I
I'm
gonna-
translate
to
him
and
it
is
so
the
appeal
today.
It
is
just
to
remind
everyone
that
there's
a
law
and
everybody
is
still
with
the
find
and
what
Martin
Martin
will
never
be
able
to
rent
again
or
apply
for
a
permit
to
ever
rent
or
like
a
rental
property
I.
C
D
F
C
D
F
D
B
We
do
have
assigned
after
David
from
City
staff,
and
the
appellant
is
also
in
person.
Anyone
on
Zoom
who
does
desire
to
testify
under
this
appeal
hearing
under
the
laws
of
perjury,
if
you
choose
to
speak
either
by
Etc
and
acknowledge
at
your
testimony,
shall
be
the
truth,
the
whole
truth
and
nothing
but
the
truth.
Thank.
D
A
C
H
E
C
It
thank
you,
members,
City
staff,
president
of
all
this
evening
and
joining
us
in
the
room
this
evening.
My
name
is
Patrick,
whatever
the
department
of
special
program
compliance
and
we
oversee
the
vacation
rental
program
here
in
City
class
Springs.
But
before
you
see
me
as
a
staff
report
for
the
property
located
at
3230,
North,
Santa,
Springs,
Drive
and
this
property.
So
the
background
this
is
vacation
registered
vacation
rental
with
the
start
date
of
June
1st
2012.
C
C
C
Lead
from
our
office
of
special
program
Advent,
while
they
were
processing
the
renewal
application
for
this
property,
and
you
can
see
that
as
part
of
attachment,
five
I
believe
it's
a
patient
advice
upon
receiving
that
information.
I
searched
the
city's
applicable
record
keeping
database
and
confirmed
that
the
city
had
not
received
any
contract.
Summary
submissions
for
3230
North,
Sand,
Springs,
Drive,
City,
ID
number
5021.
C
C
Knowing
there
were
no
recorded
contract,
summary
submissions,
I
instructed
officer
Whitaker
to
make
a
request
for
copies
of
the
sign
and
completed
city
of
Palm,
Springs,
vacation
rental
State,
and
the
rules
and
regulations
forms
for
All,
Guest
studies
and
vacation
rental
bookings
from
October
2022
to
June
2023.
A
six
month
period
is
important
to
note
that
completing
the
statement
of
rules
and
regulations
form
is
a
separate
requirement.
In
addition
to,
and
not
in
one
of
committing
a
contract
summary
and.
C
F
F
C
C
I,
don't
believe
that
we've
issued
any
citations
for
exceeding
the
contract
limits,
but
as
far
as
doing
investigations,
both
reactively
and
proactively,
as
we've
started
doing
in
the
last
five
months,
I,
don't
know
that
we've
done
that's
been
very
robust
and
since
it
came
into
as
a
regulation
in
2018.
yeah,
that's
where
I've
done
most
of
the
finance
of
the
client
is
just
you
should
say
no
contact
where
you
know
we're
starting
to
look
at,
and
it's
probably
easier
to
get
towards
closer
to
the
end
of
the
Carolina
year.
C
Well,
we
can
probably
start
seeing
more
evidence
of
the
contract
salaries
that
are
exceeding
the
annual,
but
usually
we
start
looking
at
those
in
a
spring.
It's
still
so
so
early
in
the
year
that
most
people
probably
have
not
even
guts
out
of
me
yeah.
So
a
lot
of
that
investigation
would
be
pushed
more
towards.
F
C
We
reviewed
the
records
going
back
for
the
entire
year
from
when
they
were
issued
there
and
registration
certificate,
and
there
was
gross
receipts
that
were
submitted,
I
believe
for
the
month
of
July,
August
and
September,
and
then
they
submitted
zero
dollar
businesses
for
October
and
November,
and
then
at
that
point
the
the
system
changed,
and
so
we
had
less
visibility
as
far
as
like
what
they
actually
submitted,
but
we
had
no
reason
to
believe
that
they
are
not
up
to
date
with
their
cheats
for
events.
Okay,
thank.
C
D
All
right,
thank
you
all
for
your
testimony.
At
this
time,
I
would
like
to
open
the
in
the
appeal
hearing.
If
Colin
isn't
invited
to
speak
up
to
10
minutes
any
members
of
the
public
who
wish
to
speak
and
disappeared
after
three
months,
if
any
member
of
the
public
has
to
say,
if
Ellen
will
be
invited
to
provide
a
rebuttal
thought
to
two
minutes
board
secretary,
please
begin
the
public
testimony
period.
We.
A
And
I
won
Mr
Jason
Officer
Jason
called
me:
I
noticed
that
I
had
to
send
that
to
Steve,
and
then
this
is
my.
Only
income
I
wanted
to
take
everything
like
seriously,
because
before
I
bought
this
house
I
did
all
the
searches.
I
didn't
quite
have
to
get
an
apartment
from
the
city
and
I
after
that.
I
bought
this
house
and
then
I
didn't
want
to.
You
know,
get
any
violation:
I
wanted
to
be
like
good
owner
for
the
you
know
for
short-term
rental,
but
I.
This
is
the
mistake.
A
A
F
E
C
E
E
D
F
So
it
seems
like
there's
confusion
between
two
issues.
One
is
that
rules
form
whoops.
Sorry,
here
the
there's
confusion
between
two
issues:
one
is
the
city's
Good
Neighbor
form
the
rules
that
you
have.
The
renters
sign,
that's
separate
from
and
you're
doing
that
that's
separate
than
the
contract
summaries.
Those
are
done
online
and
so
that
step
wasn't
completed.
I
guess
my
question:
is
you
manage
the
property
yourself?
F
D
D
A
F
F
Those
contract
summaries,
as
we
have
seen
over
and
over
again,
are
an
important
part
for
the
city.
That's
how
the
only
way
the
city
knows
how
many
times
it's
rented
to
kind
of
keep
it
under
control
and,
unfortunately
not
noticing
that
when
it's
kind
of
you
initial
next
to
it
and
then
it's
it's
reminded
when
you
actually
get
the
permit,
isn't
an
excuse
for
that.
So
that's
my
two
cents.
Other.
D
C
D
E
D
F
E
B
D
You
speak
English,
remember
Moses.
One
thing:
that's
bothered
me
on
the
years
I've
been
on
this
commission.
Is
people
leave
obviously,
as
Steven
has
he
made
great
contributions
and
I?
Think
when
that
happens,
we
should
have
a
a
resolution
passed
by
this
Lord
thanking
him
for
his
time
and
commending
him
for
his
service.