►
From YouTube: JUN 22, 2022 | Planning Commission
Description
City of San José, California
Planning Commission meeting of June 22, 2022.
This public meeting will be conducted via Zoom Webinar. For information on public participation via Zoom, please refer to the linked meeting agenda below.
Agenda https://sanjose.granicus.com/AgendaViewer.php?view_id=51&event_id=4576Agenda
A
A
C
B
All
right,
thank
you
so
much
robert
all
right
good
evening.
My
name
is
rolando
bonilla
and
I
am
the
chair
of
the
san
jose
planning
commission.
Welcome
to
the
planning
commission
meeting.
This
meeting
is
being
held
via
zoom
conference
call
due
to
the
covet
19
crisis.
Members
of
the
public
may
participate
by
following
the
instructions
listed
on
the
agenda.
You
may
also
view
and
listen
to
the
meeting
on
live
stream,
cable,
tv,
granicus
and
youtube
following
roll
call.
During
the
summary
of
hearing
procedure,
we
will
review
how
the
public
may
provide
comment
during
tonight's
session.
B
Young
here
the
record
reflected
as
of
this
moment:
caballero,
garcia,
oliveira
and
ornella's
wives
are
absent,
summary
of
hearing
procedures.
The
procedure
for
this
hearing
is
as
follows.
After
the
staff
report,
applicants
and
appellants
may
make
a
five-minute
presentation.
City
staff
will
call
out
names
of
the
public
who
identify
the
items
they
want
to
speak
on.
Excuse
me,
excuse
me,
city
staff
will
call
out
names
of
the
public
who
identified
the
items
they
want
to
speak
on.
B
You
may
identify
yourself
by
the
raise
hand,
feature
on
zoom
click,
star
9
on
your
phone
or
you
may
call
408,
535,
3505
or
email
planning,
support
staff
at
san
jose
ca.gov
and
identify
your
name
phone
number
and
what
item
or
items
you'd
like
to
speak
on,
as
your
name
is
called
city
staff?
Will
unmute
you
to
speak
after
we
confirm
your
audio
is
working.
Your
allotted
time
will
begin.
Each
speaker
will
have
two
minutes.
B
Speakers
using
a
translator
will
have
four
minutes
after
the
public
testimony
the
applicant
and
appellant
may
make
closing
remarks
for
an
additional
five
minutes.
Planning.
Commissioners
may
ask
questions
of
the
speakers
response
to
commissioner
questions
will
not
reduce
the
speaker's
time
allowance
staff
will
unmute
the
speaker
to
respond
to
the
commissioner.
B
The
public
hearing
will
then
be
closed
and
the
planning
commission
will
take
action
on
the
item.
The
planning
commission
may
request
staff
to
respond
to
the
public
testimony
ask
staff
questions
and
discuss
the
item.
If
you
challenge
these
land
use
decisions
in
court,
you
may
be
limited
to
raising
only
those
issues
you
or
someone
else
raised
at
this
public
hearing
or
in
written
correspondence
delivered
to
the
city
at
or
prior
to
the
public
hearing.
The
planning
commission's
action
on
rezonings
pre-zonings
general
plan
amendments
and
cone
amendments
is
only
advisory
to
the
city
council.
B
B
The
planning
commission's
action
on
conditional
use
permits
is
appealable
to
the
city
council
in
accordance
with
section
20.100.220
of
the
municipal
code,
but
that
will
now
go
on
to
item
one
call
to
order
orders
of
the
day
now.
Item
two
public
comments:
is
there
any
public
comment
on
items
that
are
not
on
our
agenda
staff?
Do
we
have
any
public
comment.
E
B
A
B
Yeah,
that
is,
that
item
is
on
the
agenda,
so
this
is
not
the
appropriate
time
for
that.
Thank
you.
Thank
you
all
right
with
that.
Public
comment
is
now
closed
item
three
deferrals
and
removals
from
calendar
staff.
It
doesn't
look
like
we
have
anything
to
remove
or
defer.
Is
that
still
still
the
position.
B
B
G
F
F
G
Well,
if
the,
if
everyone's
in
agreement
with
the
changes
that
were
made
by
the
commissioner,
if
that
reflects
everybody's
reflection
of
what
occurred,
we
can
go
ahead
and
make
that
change
today
or
we
can
put
it
over
additional
research
to
go
back
and
look
at
the
record
and
confirm
what
happened.
But
then
we
should
put
it
on
for
another.
E
B
B
B
H
B
E
Go
ahead
sure
so
mark.
Regarding
item
four
e,
I
believe.
Let
me
double
check
the
agenda,
make
sure
that's
the
correct
one
that
I'm
referring
to
yeah
so
for
for
e,
we
got
an
email
from
remember
the
public,
raising
legal
issues
with
us.
I
just
wanted
to
clarify
with
you
if
there
was
anything
raised
there
that
we
need
to
be
mindful
of
not
this
particular.
B
E
B
A
H
A
I
I
This
site
development
plan
was
approved
at
the
march
9th
director's
hearing.
The
appeal
of
planning
director's
decision
approving
this
permit
was
submitted
on
march
21st
by
the
owner
of
the
property
to
the
south
of
the
project
site
and
the
appeal
form
cites
hazardous
operations
and
criminal
business.
I
As
the
reasons
for
the
appeal,
the
appellant
is
not
appealing
the
sql
clearance
for
the
project.
The
appellant
has
expressed
to
staff
and
stated
at
the
director's
hearing
that
the
existing
gas
station
and
the
auto
repair
service
have
created
a
nuisance
in
the
neighborhood,
and
there
have
been
illegal
activities
such
as
outdoor
vehicle
storage
and
repaired
and
24-hour
operation
of
the
gas
station.
I
I
I
The
code
enforcement
inspectors
have
been
to
the
site
multiple
times,
and
they
have
confirmed
that
the
currently
the
only
pending
conversation
case
is
the
unpermitted
parking
lot,
which
will
be
legalized
with
the
approval
of
this
site
development
permit
when
the
project
is
consistent
with
the
neighborhood
community,
commercial,
general
planning,
news,
designation
and
council
policies
and
complies
with
the
development
standards
for
the
commercial
general
zoning
district.
As
discussed
in
staff
report,
therefore,
staff
recommends
the
planning
commission
to
deny
the
appeal
and
approve
this
society
development
permit.
B
Angela,
thank
you
and
before
we
go
on,
if
we
can
all
turn
off
our
mics,
I
keep
hearing
voices
in
the
back
and
I
know
it's
not.
I
don't
think
it's
you.
I
think
someone
else
has
our
mic
on,
so
we
can
make
sure
our
mics
are
off
that'd,
be
great.
Okay,
with
that,
let's
go
ahead
and
provide
the
applicant
five
minutes
for
their
presentation
and
staff.
If
we
can
monitor
that
five
minutes,
that'd
be
great.
Thank
you.
E
J
With
indy
consulting
awesome
great,
thank
you
angela
for
that
rundown
of
everything
I'm
like
she
said
this
already
been
approved
and
most
of
the
the
issues
that
are
being
raised,
we're
we're
making
every
attempt
to
make
the
sites
you
know
better
for
the
neighboring
property
owner.
So
I
hope
that
kind
of
comes
in
and
be
the
plan
we've
put
forward
here.
So
we're
doing
we're
doing
what
we
can
and
I
don't
want
to
take
up
too
much
of
your
time.
J
G
Hey
everyone.
We
really
appreciate
this
opportunity
to
speak
with
you.
I'm
mike
stratta,
I'm
with
first
element
fuel
I've
been
with
the
company
for
about
six
years.
We
currently
operate
36
gas
stations
throughout
the
state
of
california,
as
well
as,
I
believe,
there's
two
of
them
currently
operating
in
the
san
jose
area
with
a
fourth
one
that
we'll
be
looking
to
possibly
get
permitted
in
the
next
year
or
so
with
you
guys
as
well.
B
D
B
A
H
G
K
B
C
A
C
Okay,
for
you
is
item
5b.
This
is
the
sikh
gudwara
expansion
appeal.
So
this
project
is
located
at
3636,
gudwara
avenue
it's
an
existing
sikh
gurdwara
temple
located
in
district
8.
The
project
would
allow
for
a
second
story.
Addition
to
two
existing
religious
assembly
function,
halls
they're
located
in
from
the
building.
This
would
be
two-story
additions,
approximately
35
feet
in
height.
C
In
addition,
the
project
would
include
some
minor
site
improvements,
including
landscaping,
gate,
repaving
and
restriping,
and
then,
lastly,
they
would
have
eight
new
non-occupiable
architectural
features.
There
are
the
traditional
domes
that
you
see
existing
on
top
of
the
guidoir
already
they
would
be
adding
eight
new
domes
with
regards
to
the
appeal,
so
this
project
was
approved
at
directors
hearing
on
april
13th
2022,
and
it
was
appealed
by
a
neighbor
within
a
thousand
feet
of
the
site
on
april
25th.
C
2022,
specifically,
the
appellant
is
not
appealing
the
sql
clearance,
but
the
plan
development
permit
and
within
that
it's
the
plan
development,
permit
conditions
of
the
original
plan,
development
firm
for
the
site.
So
without
going
too
long
on
this,
essentially
this
plan
development.
Permit
amendment
includes
a
condition.
It's
condition.
Number
eight
on
the
attached
draft
resolution
that
requires
that
this
amendment
conform
with
all
the
previous
conditions
of
the
original
development
of
the
site.
This
is
common
for
most
amendments
to
include
these
types
of
conditions,
but
specifically,
the
appellant
has
appealed.
C
This
permit
on
the
grounds
of
the
applicant
has
repeatedly
violated
condition.
Number
34,
which
includes
hours
of
operation,
requirement
that
all
in
indoor
activity
be
in
all
activity
occur
indoors,
as
well
as
no
amplified
sound,
and
while
staff
is
sensitive
to
these
issues,
we
just
want
to
be
clear
that
the
planning
commission
is
not
the
forum
for
code
enforcement,
and
so
staff
has
directed
the
applicant
to
submit
a
code
enforcement
case
in
order
to
resolve
any
of
these
past
concerns
that
were
mentioned
in
the
appeal
application
that
you
all
received.
C
One
last
thing
I
would
like
to
point
out
that
this
plan
development
permit
does
actually
rectify
an
existing
code
enforcement
case,
and
that
is
for
the
illegal
installation
of
a
gate
along
quimby
road.
So,
as
part
of
this
plan
development
permanent
amendment,
the
applicant
is,
you
know,
replacing
the
gate
with
a
manual
swing
gate
as
opposed
to
what
was
illegally
installed
and.
D
B
C
B
B
C
C
B
C
C
B
C
H
L
L
L
L
L
We
have
got
relation
with
with
the
neighbors
and
promote
the
partnership
concept
with
the
neighbors
and
inviting
them
on
the
main
events,
such
as
july
4th,
socializing,
ice
cream,
socializing
second
grade
5k
rate,
5k
run
and
allah
and
other
communities
are
also
using
our
city
to
like,
such
as
yoga
classes,
children,
playground
and
other
sports
activities
and
the
epi
appellant
has
no
objection
for
this
project.
But
he
has
some
concern
about
the
code
and
performance
code,
installment
enforcement
violation.
L
We
just
want
to
let
you
know
that
we
are
complying
with
all
the
all
the
original
permit,
condition,
pdepartment
conditions,
and
we
will
continue
comply
on
that
one,
and
there
was
only
one
violation
which
eric
has
mentioned
and
we
are.
We
are
doing
this
in
this
project
and
there
is
no
other
pending
violations
to
briefly
answer
his
concern.
L
We
sent
him
the
message
and
called
him
number
of
times
to
meet
us
at
the
common
place
to
go
over
his
concern,
but
he
was
insisting
to
meet
us
at
a
temple
with
the
code
and
supportment
inspector
and
we
we
said,
let's
meet
at
a
coffee
place
and
go
over
these
issues
and
we
can
always
meet
at
the
temple
at
later
date.
But
no
luck
on
that
one,
his
his
com,
his
his
appeal
is
costing
us
thousands
of
dollars
and
playing
the
project.
L
B
You
thank
you,
sir,
for
your
time.
I
think
we've
exceeded
the
five
minutes
and
stuff.
Can
we
stay
tight
on
that
time
and
if
we're
not,
then
I'll
go
ahead
and
keep
time,
but
thank
you
thank
you
for
that.
I
will
now
go
ahead
and
allow
for
the
appellant
to
make
a
five
minute
presentation
and
sir
you're
gonna
get
another
five
minutes
after
public
comment.
So
keep
that
in
mind.
M
I've
been
in
that
position
before
eight
years
on
the
millennium
commission,
so
ending
is
bittersweet.
Thank
you
esteem,
commissioners,
and
thank
you
for
hearing
this.
I
want
to
thank
the
staff
for
following
up
and
for
providing
some
excellent
customer
service,
as
was
stated
by
the
staff
member
alec.
M
My
concern
isn't
necessarily
with
the
expansion
of
the
project,
except
from
the
perspective
of
enforcement,
of
the
conditions
that
are
in
the
original
permit.
In
the
original
permit
under
number
34,
there
was
a
a
significant
number
of
items
that
dealt
with
everything
from
occupancy
peak
hour,
trips,
hours
of
operation
and
so
on,
and
the
ones
that
I
specifically
had
an
issue
with
was
the
times
of
of
operation,
outdoor
noise
and
outdoor
services.
M
Excuse
me,
there
was
a
specific
item,
34e
which
says
all
worship,
activities
or
other
organized
social
activities
shall
be
conducted
indoors
and
for
the
last
I'll
just
be
kind
and
say
five
years
they
have
been
conducting
outdoor
services.
I
have
been
in
contact
with
mr
dillon
a
number
of
times
he
was
supposedly
the
coordinator,
and
I
have
some
some
responses
here
from
him
regarding
texts
that
I
sent
him
and
he
would
respond
with
things
like
learn
to
enjoy
the
sounds
from
your
neighborhood
and
don't
be
like
trump
right.
M
So
his
responses
to
me
were
quite
dismissive
and
he
acknowledged
the
fact
that
the
noise
was
coming.
That
sound
was
emanating
quite
clearly
beyond
the
the
the
boundaries
of
the
facility.
Also
code
enforcement
was
out
there
after
I
did
make
a
code
enforcement
complaint.
It
took
seven
weeks
for
them
to
get
somebody
to
go
out
there
after
hours
and
on
the
weekends
because
of
staffing
issues.
My
understanding
is
at
the
weekend
and
and
after
hours
person
aren't
there
anymore,
so
they
had
to
grant
overtime.
M
Okay,
I've
got
recordings
that
I
can
send
you
if
you,
if,
if
that,
helps
at
all,
I
decided
not
to
to
kill
your
emails
with
very
long
mp4s,
but
you
know
that
they
clearly
depict
the
the
let's
just
say
that
the
sound
coming
from
the
site
to
my
bedroom
window,
okay,
which
is
over
a
thousand
feet
from
the
site
of
where
the
the
service
is
actually
being
held,
because
there's
a
whole
bunch
of
of
parking
between
my
house
and
the
site.
My
site
is
about
300
feet
from
the
corner
of
the
site.
M
Okay,
so
my
my
issue
isn't
so
much
what
they
want
to
expand,
except
to
ensure
that
they're
using
it
specifically
for
what
was
intended
and
not
as
a
catering
hall.
Okay,
they
want
to
do
weddings
and
they
want
it
and
they
specifically
state
in
the
permit
here
that
they
want
to
have
receptions
afterwards.
M
Now
a
pqp
does
not
allow
for
commercial
uses
and
a
catering
hole
is
a
commercial
use
if
they
have
weddings
and
they
allow
there
to
be
receptions
that
are
paid
for
it
is
a
catering
hall.
So
my
concern
is
that
we
put
in
place
the
conditions
and
the
appropriate
ways
to
abate
any
code
violations
right
and
that's
really
what
it
comes
down
to.
M
When
I
sat
in
those
seats
also
many
years
ago,
my
concern
has
always
been:
will
the
city
be
able
to
enforce
its
cup
when
a
site
is
granted
a
permit,
and
I'm
finding
that?
Unfortunately,
the
city
has
staffing
issues
and
I
would
just
like
there
to
be
safeguards
in
place.
He
may
have
a
thousand
emails
from
from
people
who
attend
the
the
goodwire
saying
that
everything's,
wonderful
and
for
the
most
part
they
are.
I
can't
argue
with
that.
M
B
N
Please
submit
yourself
hi.
My
name
is
patrick
mcgarrity,
and
I'm
calling
in
on
behalf
of
council
member
sylvia
arenas,
who
represents
the
district
for
this
project,
is
being
considered
and
council
of
arenas
strongly
supports
the
seek
guidance,
application
and
urges
you
to
approve
the
permit
amendment
and
reject
the
appeal
councilman
councilmember
anderson's
support
is
consistent
with
widespread
support
in
our
district
8
community
for
the
guidewa.
I
have
served
district
8
for
over
five
years
and
have
had.
N
I
also
have.
We
also
have
serious
concerns
about
the
the
first
amendment
rights
and
the
ability
to
have
religious
practices
not
be
infringed,
and
the
concerns
just
expressed
by
the
appellant
regarding
wedding
ceremonies,
I
think,
is
a
particularly
important
thing
for
the
commission
to
note.
Just
to
summarize,
council
miranda
strongly
encourages
the
commission
to
follow
staff
direction
and
lead
leave
questions
of
code
enforcement
code
enforcement
to
the
code
enforcement
process.
Thank
you.
B
F
F
F
We
have
never
had
a
call
from
the
city
that
your
instruments
are
loud.
I've
spoken
to
mr
ziro.
Via
text.
He
had
complained
that
there
was
a
function
going
on
and
I
was
there
at
the
temple.
There
was
absolutely
no
function
going
on
regardless.
These
are
all
baseless
claims
by
mr
zito
and
we
urge
you
to
prove
our
prod
project,
so
we
can
move
forward
with
building
it
as
it's
becoming
a
necessity
for
our
congregation,
and
we
thank
you
for
your
time.
A
A
I
really
would
like
to
ask
him
as
a
member
of
saint
francis
of
assisi,
where
he's
also
a
member,
why
we're
allowed
to
have
church
weddings
and
outdoor
events
and
speakers,
and
yet
he
wants
the
guaduara
not
to
have
those
things
if
he
wants
to
complain
about
loud
speakers.
What
about
the
evergreen
high
school
football
games?
A
My
house
is
several
a
thousand
feet
away
from
the
evergreen
high
school,
but
I
can
hear
those
football
games
being
broadcast.
Why
is
that
not
an
issue?
It
seems
to
me
that
mr
zito's,
real
issue
is
not
with
the
noise
complaint
or
any
other
things.
Mr
zito's
issue
is
that
he
doesn't
like
the
temple.
Thank
you.
K
Thank
you
good
evening
planning
commissioners.
My
name
is
patricia
andrade
patty
and
I'm
here
to
speak
on
item
5b
in
support
of
the
gurdwara's
plan
project,
and
I
ask
that
you
reject
mr
zito's
appeal.
I
am
a
neighbor
of
the
secret
dwara
and
have
lived
on
sheboya
court
since
2003.,
there's
only
one
road
that
leads
to
our
home
chiboya
road
and
we
drive
by
the
gurdwara
multiple
times
a
day,
sometimes
every
day
of
the
week
as
a
direct
neighbor
of
the
gurdwara.
K
K
We
sometimes
sleep
with
our
windows
open
throughout
the
year
and
not
once
have
we
heard
noise
in
the
early
hours
of
the
morning.
We
can
hear
the
sound
of
the
high
school
during
evening
games
and
that
is
a
little
short
of
a
mile
further
down
the
road
from
the
gurdwara.
So
if
the
gurdwara
was
hosting
events
at
5am,
we
would
hear
it.
The
gerdwara
has
hosted
events
that
have
supported
not
only
the
evergreen
community
but
the
city
of
san
jose.
K
Last
year
they
hosted
a
coven
19
vaccination
clinic
they
host
4th
of
july
community
events,
they've
held
ice
cream
parties
for
the
community
and
they
welcome
anyone
who
wants
to
visit
and
invites
us
to
break
bread
with
them
too,
from
our
home.
We
can
sit
outside
and
enjoy
the
view
san
jose
peacefully
and
quietly.
K
We
appreciate
having
the
gurdwara
as
a
neighbor.
We
appreciate
the
work
that
they
do
for
our
community,
although
we
are
not
members
of
the
guadwara,
we
feel
part
of
their
community
because
of
the
effort
they
put
into
building
relationship
with
the
neighbors.
I
can
also
tell
you
that
when
I
did
raise
a
traffic
safety
concern
a
few
years
back,
they
were
happy
to
discuss
the
solution
and
we
resolved
it.
We
are
fortunate
to
live
what
we
do,
and
we
know
that
the
best
way
to
enjoy
living
here
is
to
communicate,
celebrate
diversity
and
come
together.
B
O
O
Not
only
are
they
a
wonderful
neighbor
and
and
I've
known
them
for
many
many
years,
but
also
when
I
was
on
the
city
council
worked
with
them
during
the
years
of
2009
through
2016.,
I'm
just
very
impressed
with
all
the
things
they
not
only
do
for
their
own
community
for
the
general
community.
I
think
it's
already
been
brought
out,
but
feeding
and
clothing
the
homeless
each
month
providing
packaged
foods
and
drinks
to
all
in
the
schools,
parks
and
police
stations
during
the
coveted
pandemic.
O
They've
had
vigils
there
when
needed,
to
bring
the
community
together.
They've
had
financial
and
food
help
to
help
fire
victims
local
and
abroad.
They
partnered
with
the
local
schools
churches
in
moss,
they've,
had
emergency
shelter
center
in
case
of
natural
disasters,
they've
had
state
of
the
art,
children's
playground
open
all
members
and
non-members
seek
awareness
annual
month
in
november,
the
annual
4th
of
july
open
to
everybody
free
kitchen
for
all
feeding
people
free
tutoring
medical
attention.
O
They
have
a
free
medical
clinic,
they
participated
when
we
put
together
the
lighting
installation
and
down
down
in
the
evergreen
village
square.
They
contributed
ten
thousand
dollars
to
that
effort.
They
provide
free
transportation
to
all
seniors.
They.
They
have
environmentally
friendly
projects.
The
solar
project
they've
done
on
the
ev
charging
situation
to
all
members
and
non-members,
so
the
the
goodwata
has
done
a
lot
for
for
its
own
community
for
the
community
at
large.
Their
project
is
not.
I've
read
what
they
were
promoting
to
do
on
their
project.
O
P
It's
mr
larson,
here,
okay,
I've
been
living
here,
I'm
a
parent
and
I've
been
living
here
for
over
40
years
and
I
got
involved
with
the
secret
door
about
10
years
ago.
As
a
volunteer,
I
wanted
to
just
say
that
I've
been
up
there.
I've
been
up
there
as
a
volunteer
and
we've
helped
people
in
the
creeks.
P
P
I
would
like
to
call
your
attention,
dear
planning,
commissioner
members,
that
I
did
submit
a
letter
to
you
it's
in
your
written
area,
and
I
did
a
test
myself
where
I
happened
to
see
a
wedding
going
on,
so
I
decided
to
document
it
and
there
was
no
noise.
There
was
absolutely
no
noise
and
inside
maybe
but
outside
nothing.
P
B
L
B
L
So
so
this
one
I
mean
like
like.
We
have
also
have
the
reading
of
the
unvoice
and
they
are
within
the
limit,
and
we
we
have
send
you
that
information
from
our
sound
engineer
that
at
certain
time
he
has
taken
those
those
readings
and
we
are
within
those
limits,
and
we
speak
to
people
who
are
only
like
few
hundred
feet.
Like
he's
a
thousand
feet
away
and
we
talked
to
them
and
they
said
they
never
hear
any
noise
and
they
have
no
complaint
on
this
one
and
also.
L
Furthermore,
we
just
want
to
add
that
we
are
doing
a
lot
of
future
projects,
that
there
will
be
like
a
heritage
garden
up
on
the
hills
which
we
have
a
lot
of
space
and
that
and
we
will
have
a
heritage
garden
and
the
trails,
and
that
is
for
not
only
for
our
community
and
all
the
other
communities
can
use
it,
and
this
is
this
is
this
will
be.
So
we
welcome
everyone
to
use
that
one
and
also
children's
program.
L
L
F
Just
wanted
to
add
that
we
currently
have
no
code
enforcement
violations
on
record
for
sound
or
only
violation
that
we
had
as
we're
correcting.
It
already
is,
from
the
electrical
gate
to
a
manual
gate
which
is
on
side
of
the
road
which
most
people
don't
even
know.
There
was
a
gate
there
that
existed
we'll
take
any
questions
from
the
panel.
B
All
right
so
that
that
concludes
you're,
yielding
the
remaining
balance
of
your
time
here.
You're
done!
Yes,
sir.
All
right
perfect!
Thank
you
for
that.
So
I
will
leave
the
public
hearing
open
in
the
event
that
we
have
questions
and
just
so
we're
on
the
same
page.
I
think
the
staff
had
made
a
statement
earlier.
I
think
it
was
staff
about
noise
being
a
code
enforcement
issue.
Not
a
planning
issue
for
purposes
of
this
decision
tonight.
Council
is
that
is
that
accurate.
B
B
H
B
B
D
B
B
B
D
H
I'm
usually
short
with
words
so
I'll
keep
it
short.
You
know
I
just
want
to
say
thank
you
to
all
of
you
to
all
the
commissioners.
It
was
a
very
good
last
year.
I
wish
I
could
stay
on
longer,
but
you
know
there's
there's
life
that
comes
into
play
and
I'm
also
looking
at
you
know.
We
bought
a
cabin
last
december,
there's
renovations
that
we're
doing
out
in
idaho,
and
I
just
can't
give
that
much
attention
to
the
commission
that
I
would
really
like
to
give.
H
I
mean,
I
just
don't
think
it's
fair
to
the
commission
of
the
commissioners
and
the
city
of
san
jose
to
have
a
commissioner
on
a
commission
and
that's
not
willing
to
give
you
know
101
percent
of
their
time.
So
I
wanted
to
respectfully
step
away,
and
you
know
just
kind
of
put
my
focus
on
my
family
and
my
little
tiny
cabin
and
but
it
has
been
I
it
has
been
a
great
year
and
you're
doing
great
work
cherbonia.
H
You
know
thank
you
for
leading
us
this
last
year
through
you
know,
through
everything
I
think,
there's
a
lot
of
great
changes.
I
think
this
commission,
you
know
just
keep
moving
forward,
keep
presenting
your
ideas.
You
know
be,
you
know,
stand
you
know
I
I
think
be
creative
and
innovative.
You
know
there
are
issues
before
you
tonight.
H
You
know
I
I
sit
back
and
I
think,
and
I'm
glad
the
the
the
speakers
made
some
of
the
comments
that
they
made
because
sometimes
through
land
use,
we
do
see
that
there
are
issues
of
equity
that
we
are
not
necessarily
addressing,
and
I
think
tonight
there's
some
of
that.
That's
there
and
you
have
an
opportunity
to
really
you
know
make
make
make
good
decisions
that
are
equitable
to
communities.
H
I
think
tonight
we
did
that,
especially
with
the
last
vote,
so
I
just
want
to
say
that
all
of
you
thank
you
so
much.
I
know
we
never
got
to
see
each
other
in
person.
The
only
one
that
I
met
in
person
is
cerebral
mia,
but
thank
you
so
much.
Thank
you
for
the
fun
ride
and
I
keep
doing
the
great
do
that
you
work
and
to
staff
this
the
great
work
that
you
do
and
staff
the
same
thing.
Thank
you
for
everything.
I
really
appreciated
being
on
the
commission
this
last
year.
B
Thank
you
for
your
service
commission.
Yes,
yes,
applause
applause
and
I
I
remember
fondly
when
you
did
reach
out
to
me.
I
remember
that
meeting
and
remember
the
energy
and
the
excitement,
and
I
remember
I
think,
sharing
with
you
how
happy
I
was
that
you
were
on
board
and
how
you
were
part
of
a
new
cohort
of
this
11
member
body
that
I
think
is
showing
the
rest
of
the
city.
How
we
can
all
come
together,
agree,
disagree,
but
always
respect
our
respect
each
other
and
this
city.
B
So
thank
you
for
that.
Commissioner.
One
thing:
yes,
all
right
with
that,
we
will
have
this
one's
kind
of
awkward,
but
that
will
go
to
7e
recognition
of
rolando,
I'm
gonna.
Let
you
in
a
little
secret
arturo,
my
middle
name,
bonilla
service
to
the
city
of
san
jose
and
planning
commission.
So
I'm
ready
for
it.
D
D
B
You
the
only
time
in
my
life,
where
are
unanimously
in
support
of
me
in
an
election,
so
I'll
take
it,
but
I
I
I'll
I'll
keep
it
short.
I
I
just
want
to
say
thank
you
all
for
being
you
and
commission
oliver.
I
remember
in
the
very
beginning
in
I
think
19
when
we
were
talking
about
diversity
of
opinions
and
perspectives,
and
I
know
you've
heard
me
say
this
along
the
way
that
I
couldn't
have
asked
for
a
better
group.
B
In
fact,
when
I
was
asked
by
reporter
yesterday
about
you
know
my
transition,
one
of
the
things
that
I
said
was
I'm
the
beneficiary
of
being
able
to
serve
with
some
highly
committed
and
passionate
individuals
who
have
succeeded
and
have
lived
lives
and
who
simply
just
want
to
serve.
Remember
this
feeling
tonight
remember
the
fact
that
we
all
do
have
differences
of
opinion.
We
all
come
from
different
walks
of
life,
but
we
always
have
put
this
city
first
and
we've
always
respected
each
other.
B
Remember
that
as
we
move
forward
as
you
move
forward,
as
perhaps
outside
forces
and
positions,
try
to
divide,
you
remember
that
at
the
end
of
the
day,
we're
all
here,
because
we
care-
and
that
should
be
the
only
thing
governing
anyone
serving
in
either
appointed
an
elected
office.
It
has
truly
been
one
of
the
highest
honors
of
my
professional
life
and
that
honor
is
made
even
more
special
by
the
fact
that
I
have
gotten
to
know
a
lot
of
you
behind
the
scenes
privately.
B
Thank
you
all
for
everything
you
do.
Thank
you
for
putting
up
with
me.
I
know
there
were
times.
I
think
I
shared
this
with
commissioner
olivario,
where
I
I
may
have
been
a
little
too
wound
up,
but
I
also
knew
I
had
to
bring
my
a
game
when
I
was
working
with
the
best
and
the
brightest
in
my
mind
in
the
city
of
san
jose
and
my
colleagues
and
all
of
you.
So
thank
you
for
that.
Thank
you
for
your
support.
B
B
F
I
I
just
actually
want
to
take
a
moment
to
say
thank
you
not
just
for
your
service,
but
for
your
friendship
and
your
camaraderie
and
your
support.
It
really
has
truly
been
a
pleasure
to
serve
with
you.
You've
been
an
honorable
person
throughout
this
and
this
this
small
period.
I've
worked
with
you
and
I'm
I'm
grateful
to
have
had
the
experience
of
working
with
you.
Just
thank
you.
H
H
You
will
be
missed
so
much
your
warmth,
your
your
humor,
your
wisdom
that
you've
shared
the
only
bone
I
have
to
pick
with
you
is.
I
once
got
inspired
to
maybe
have
music
at
the
beginning
of
our
meetings
and
that
hasn't
happened
yet.
So
I'm
going
to
pass
that
to
commissioner
olivario
to
consider
maybe
some
fun
music
instead
of
silence
at
the
beginning.
But
beyond
that
you
are
just
an
amazing
human
and
I
will
keep
in
touch
and
thank
you
for
everything.
E
Yeah,
I
I
just
want
to
say
thank
you
so
much
to
you
chairman,
I
am
to
commissioner
montias.
It's
been
an
honor
to
serve
with
both
you
and
you
know,
particularly
it's
been
a
big
challenge
on
this
commission,
the
past
two
years
operating
over
zoom
and
dealing
with
some
very
contentious
issues
that
have
come
before
us
and
I
I
really
have
been
grateful
to
have
the
both
of
you
along
for
that.
G
Thank
you
chair.
I
just
wanted
to
pass
on
congratulations
and
thanks
to
both
commissioners,
commissioner
montenez.
I
hope
you
enjoyed
the
ride
of
land
use
and
that,
when
you're
all
throughout
the
balance,
your
life,
whether
it's
here
or
idaho,
that
you
look
at
things
through
that
unique
lens
that
you
get
from
the
planning
commission.
So
thank
you
very
much,
chair
bonilla.
G
Thank
you
for
your
leadership,
your
advocacy
and
your
energy
and
passion
for
your
community
of
both
san
jose
and
specifically
your
neighborhood,
which
you
finally
call
the
east
side,
and
I
think
you've
brought
a
lens
of
clarity
to
many
issues
and
really
appreciate
it,
and
I
think
the
words
you're
hearing
from
your
fellow
commissioners
are
very
sincere
and
certainly
wish
you
the
best,
and
I
know
you
will
continue
to
be
a
force
for
betterment
of
san
jose.
Thank
you.
B
B
Commissioner
casey,
thank
you.
Thank
you
for
being
an
awesome
vice
chair.
Thank
you
for
always
being
receptive
to
some
of
my
ideas
and
and
thank
you
for
your
support
throughout
and
with
that.
I
leave
you
all
with
this.
San
jose
you've
got
an
11
member
planning
commission
that
has
devoted
itself
and
will
continue
to
devote
itself
to
serving
you.