►
From YouTube: IETF104-TUTORIALNEW-20190324-1230
Description
TUTORIALNEW meeting session at IETF104
2019/03/24 1230
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/104/proceedings/
A
Some
have
already
joined
the
webinars
and
we
offered
before
so
I
hope,
not
everything
all
the
200
will
show
up,
because
there
won't
be
enough
space.
So
we
are
feel
free
to
ask
questions.
Also.
There
are
three
parts
to
this
and
we
will
do
a
bit
of
a
back
and
forth
I'll
start
and
which
will
take
over
and
then
I'll
do
the
the
end,
and
so
maybe
in
between
these
three
part
after
each
part.
A
A
Okay,
well,
maybe
you
should
have
shown
me.
This
is
the
PowerPoint
version
interesting,
but
I
got
a
little
sneak
preview
of
the
next
slide
already
down
here.
So
this
you
don't
have
to
be
able
to
read
this
I
mean
I
understand.
This
is
a
lot
of
takes
on
one
slide,
but
you
will
see
this
a
lot
in
the
working
groups.
A
Also,
this
is
the
M
denote
well,
and
it
lists
a
lot
of
kind
of
legalese
the
intellectual
property
rights
and
make
sure
that
you
understand
that
you
make
contributions
to
the
ITF
what
the
rights
are
for
the
ITF
and
for
you.
It
will
also
list
some
privacy
considerations
on
the
next
slide.
Then
you
can.
A
A
There
is
another
tutorial
in
parallel
with
this
and
there's
another
a
third
tutorial
after
this
that
talks
about
github
tools.
That
might
be
interesting
if
you're
interested
to
go
to
that.
It's
not
particularly
for
newcomers.
It's
open
to
anybody.
Actually,
everything
at
the
ITF
pretty
much
is
open
for
anybody.
Unless
it's
marked
differently,
then
at
three
o'clock
there
is
something
we
call
the
ITF
quick
connections
which
allows
you
to
quickly
get
to
meet
a
lot
of
people
that
are
a
bit
more
familiar
with
the
ITF
already.
A
So
it's
like
it's
like
a
big
room
with
lots
of
tables
and
numbers,
and
you
have
like
a
few
minutes
to
walk
from
one
table
to
the
other
and
talk
to
people
and
maybe
find
those
people
who
are
involved
in
the
area
that
you're
also
interested
in,
and
so
that's
usually
a
good
way
to
get.
You
know
see
the
new
faces,
and
then
you
have
people
to
go
to
during
the
rest
of
the
week,
then
after
that,
there's
also
a
meet
and
greet
session
specifically
for
newcomers
were
a
lot
of
the
working
group
chairs.
A
Both
chairs
area
directors
will
be
there
and
they
have
little
areas.
You
can
find
the
area
that
you're
working
with
or
that
you're
interested
in
or
the
working
with
chairs
that
you
would
like
to
meet.
So
please
don't
be
shy.
This
is
really
for
you
there
to
meet
the
people
that
you
know
are
sharing
the
working
groups
that
you
are
maybe
going
to
a
late
in
the
week
or
you
know
the
area
directors
that
are
responsible
for
the
topics
that
you're
involved
with.
So
please
go.
Make
yourself
known
to
them.
A
Also,
you
know
make
maybe
ask
them
questions
if
you
come
here
with
specific
topics,
so
that's
a
usually
a
good
session
to
go
to
and
then
after
that
is
a
regular
ITF
welcoming
reception.
But
the
newcomers,
of
course,
are
also
welcome
and
then
I
don't
know
how
many
of
you
have
registered
or
have
subscribed
to
the
guides
or
mentoring
program.
Are
there
any
you
who
have
subscribed
to
that?
No,
oh
one,
two,
oh
three:
okay,
a
few
hands
and
so
yeah.
That's
it
yeah
I
believe
you
can
still
sign
up
for
that.
A
A
It's
a
bit
more
familiar
with
the
ITF,
ideally
in
the
same
field
that
you're
interested
in
and
then
you
have
one
contact
person
that
you
know
you
can
go
to
June
the
week
if
you're
kind
of
you
lost-
and
that
can
happen
you
despite
a
big
event,
so
I'm
recommend
you
to
if
you,
if
you
don't
have
any
colleagues
or
if
you
can
appear
on
your
own,
maybe
sign
up
to
the
guide.
So
a
mentoring
program
to
have
a
contact
person
there
and
then
there's
a
more
informal
thing
on
Monday
evening.
A
It's
a
newcomers
dinner,
it's
not
at
all
mandatory
or
it's
just
if
you
feel
like
you
know,
I,
don't
know
how
are
they
going
to
organize
at
this
time
if
you
have
200
newcomers
and
a
few
more
people
to
join
how
that's
going
to
work
but
you're
welcome
to
attend
it,
but
it's
like
pay.
You
pay
yourself
your
own
dinner,
but
you
didn't
you
at
least
get
to
meet
all
the
other
newcomers
as
well,
and
then
I
would
like
to
ask
you
also
later
in
the
week
on
Thursday
morning
against
the
feedback
session.
A
It's
also
on
the
agenda.
You
can
see
it
and
then
there
we
would
like
you
to
give
us
feedback
about
all
these
programs
all
these
activities
and
see
what
works.
What
didn't
work
in
our
later
in
the
week
here,
I've
already
have
an
idea
like
how
you
you
know
felt
after
a
few
days
peaking
at
the
ITF
and
then
you
would
like
to
learn
from
that
for
next
time.
A
So
yeah
and
this
presentation,
as
I
said
every
three
parts
and
you
really
want
to
focus
on
unbe
near
at
the
ITF
meeting.
So
it's
really
hard
to
how
you
survive
this
week
with,
like
hundreds
and
hundreds
of
people
and
I
hunted
and
30
working
groups
in
seven
areas
and
there's
a
lot
of
information
and
a
lot
of
meetings,
and
so
we
focus
on
how
you
make
the
most
out
of
it
this
week.
A
There
is
a
lot
more
to
the
ITF,
the
whole
history,
the
overall
structure,
which
we
don't
really
not
gonna,
focus
on
in
this
presentation
and
there
as
a
lot
more
information
on
the
website,
and
we
list
one
link
here
to
youtube
this
life
by
the
way
they're
also
available
on
the
agenda.
So
you
can
download
them
and
look
at
the
links,
and
there
are
some
nice
short
videos
about
various
aspects
of
the
of
the
idea.
A
A
The
mission
of
the
ITF
is
to
make
the
internet
work
better
by
producing
high
quality,
relevant
technical
documents
that
influence
the
way
people,
design,
use
and
manage
the
internet,
and
that's
pretty
generic,
but
but
it
boils
down
to
is
really
that
that
the
ITF
develops
protocols
that
should
be
secure,
stable,
sustainable
and
they
are
deployable
easy
to
deploy
implementable
together
as
a
group
together
here
at
the
ITF.
So
that's
basically
what
we
do
here
during
the
week
and,
of
course,
also
in
between
the
ITF
meetings.
So
the
work
doesn't
stop
here
on
Friday.
A
Yeah,
so
if
you
put
that
in
here,
because
you
might
be
familiar
also
that
other
standards
organizations
so
the
IETF
is
a
standards,
development
organization
and
SDO,
but
it's
quite
different
from
others
that
you
might
have
attended
in
the
past
like
the
ITU
or
Etsy
w3c.
There
are
some
other
standards
bodies
out
there.
First
of
all,
the
ITF
kind
of
focuses
on,
or
internet
protocols,
and/or
the
Internet
itself
and
there's
of
course,
sometimes
some
overlap
and
there's
long
liaison
going
on
also
between
the
different
standards,
development
organizations.
A
But
the
ITF
is
kind
of
different
and
such
that
it
really
is
a
group
of
individuals.
So
you
participate
all
here
as
individuals
I
mean.
Obviously
a
lot
of
us
have
our
employer
or
university,
however,
as
backing
and
maybe
paying
the
bills
but
and
in
principle
other
opinions
and
comments
and
and
drafts
and
everything
are
contributed
as
in
as
by
individuals.
A
So
there's
no
there's
no
official.
You
know
role
of
the
governments
or
organizations
that
endorse
the
standards.
In
the
end
it
really
is
market
driven
and
that
every
standard
is
suspended
once
it's
used
widely
on
in
the
in
the
industry.
On
the
internet-
and
so
that's
very
important
and
also
what's
important-
is
there's
no
formal
voting,
so
you
might
have
seen
in
other
events.
You
know
people
you
know
raise
their
hands
say
how
many
are
of
you
are
for
solution,
a
we're
the
solution
be
now
here.
We
don't
do
that.
We
don't
do
voting.
A
You
do
humming
I'll
get
to
that
later.
That
gets
a
little
getting
used
to
I'm
at
first
and
it's
yeah.
As
I
said,
it's
quite
unique.
So
it's
bottom-up.
It's
really
people
in
the
working
groups,
most
of
the
work
and
then
a
kind
of
trickles
up,
gets
reviewed
and
and
in
the
end
kind
of
goes
through
this
whole
internet
and
so
RC
standards
process.
A
Yes,
at
the
moment,
we
have
seven
areas,
so
there
are
these
areas
that
the
working
groups
are
clustered
within,
and
this
can
change
over
time.
Some
areas
merged
over
time
and
some
were
closed
and
new
ones
were
created.
So
at
the
moment
we
have
these
seven
I'm
not
going
to
go
through
all
of
them.
You
will
see
on
the
agenda
every
working
group,
it's
linked
to
one
of
these
areas.
A
Right
so,
let's
get
back
to
the
humming
and
the
main
mantra
of
the
ITF.
So
the
main
mantra
really
isn't
it's
one
of
the
very
early
quotes
from
one
of
the
early.
My
dear
participants
says
we
reject
Kings
presidents
and
voting
people,
even
rough
consensus
and
running
code.
So
now
what
does
that
mean
like
running
cold?
A
They've
been
discussed
and
in
the
end
the
solution
is
something
we
can
all
live
with
and
and
it's
it's
it's
the
task
of
the
working
group
chair
or
the
session
chair,
to
drive
this
process
and
to
ensure
there's
consensus
in
the
end,
and
it
doesn't
stop
at
the
working
group
meetings
here.
It
also
often
gets
carried
into
the
the
mailing
list.
A
A
lot
of
work
gets
done
on
the
working
group
mailing
list,
of
course,
and
that's
how
it's
done,
but
with
this
humming
I
wanted
to
say
a
few
words
about
the
humming,
because
it's
kind
of
special
I,
don't
know
if
you
have
already
experienced
with
this.
So
sometimes
the
working
group
chair
would
ask
in
our
who.
Do
you
really
who
believes
solution
a
is
the
best
solution.
A
Any
people
would
go
and
then,
in
order
to
go
like
who's
who
things
solution,
D
is
the
best
solution,
and
then
maybe
more
people
go
home
and
then
and
it's
kind
of
it
or
quitting
like.
Why
would
you
want
to
do
that?
You
know
it's.
It's
really
clear.
You
don't
know
how
many
people
are
humming
or
not
actually
get
a
pretty
good
idea
of
the
temperature
of
the
room
of
the
sense
of
the
of
the
room
and
who's.
A
You
know
which
solution
might
be
carrying
more
more
weight
and
another
important
aspect
of
that
is
that
it's
anonymous,
so
you
don't
raise
your
hand
and
I
can
see
how
this
person
is
for
the
other
solution.
You
know
so
I'm
not
going
to
talk
to
him
later
on
where
I
do
wanna
talk
to
so
it's
really
more
anonymous
and
it
gives
a
a
good
overview
of
the
actual
working
group
as
a
whole
and
not
as
individuals
in
networking
group.
A
Another
interesting
aspect
is
the
M,
the
actual
culture
and
the
ITF,
and
maybe
that's
also
different
from
other
organizations.
You
already
notice
and
I
see
also
on
how
you're
sitting
here
that
is
quite
an
informal
gathering
and
also
the
dress
code
is
quite
informal
and
there's
no.
As
I
said
no
official
like
you
know,
government
role
or
organizational
role,
or
so
it's
quite
an
informal
people,
love
t-shirts.
You
know
your
first
thing
you
get
when
you
register
you
get
new
t-shirt
and
people
are
very
proud
of
the
old
t-shirts.
A
Also
that
they've
been
attending
like
ten
years
ago.
The
idea
is
still
wearing
them,
and
people
are
quite
quite
knowledgeable
and
passionate,
and
you
will
sometimes
feel
in
the
room
or
at
the
microphone,
but
like,
oh,
my
god,
these
guys
are
fighting.
You
know,
that's
not
really
fighting
they're,
just
really
trying
to
get
the
best
solution
out
of
it
and
they're
passionate
about
what
they
think
is
the
best
way
forward.
A
Yes,
so
technical
excellence
is
highly
valued,
so
you're
always
welcome
to
ask
a
question
or
make
a
comment,
but
make
sure
you
know
what
you're
talking
about.
So
you
have
read
through
the
documents-
and
you
know
the
topic,
and
otherwise
somebody
might
have
a
bit
of
a
rude
comment
to
you,
but
you
shouldn't
accept
that
either
you
know
you
just
don't
feel
hesitant
I,
don't
feel
shy
to
really
come
to
the
mic
and
say
this
is
my
first
idea:
I
read
this
document
and
I
have
a
question
about
this
or
I.
A
Think
I
have
a
different
opinion
about
it
and
I
think
that
will
be
very
valuable
and
you
also
noticed
a
people
know
each
other
a
lot
of
clicks
or
groupings
and
people
like
to
see
each
other
again
and
hang
out
and
so
don't
feel
excluded
there.
You
know
if
people
are
usually
very
open
and
and
happy
to
introduce
themselves
so
go
up
to
people
and
say
I'm
this
person
I'm
new
here
you
know
and
I
learned
from
New
York
and
we
hang
out.
A
Yeah
I
said
I'm
not
gonna,
go
into
a
lot
of
detail
about
the
structure
of
the
idea,
but
there-
and
you
probably
won't
be
able
to
read
this-
and
this
is
currently
a
bit
in
flux.
Also
but
what's
important
is
tasty.
Ietf
change,
the
coloring
now
I'm
gonna
produce
the
ietf
with
all
the
working
groups
and
then
there's
also
the
IRT
F,
the
internet
research
task
force,
which
has
the
research
sister
organization
of
the
internet,
Engineering
Task
Force.
It
has
research
groups,
so
you
will
see
on
the
agenda.
A
Sometimes
it
says
I
RTF
or
it
says,
like
an
acronym
and
then
RG,
which
means
research
group.
It's
not
a
working
group,
but
it's
a
research
group.
So
the
IRT
F
is
more
looking
into
researching
more
future
looking
solutions
to
the
internet
architecture,
and
then
it
has
the
internet
architecture
board
the
IAB
and
then
there's
a
new
over
arching
kind
of
legal
organization,
the
IETF
LLC
and
their
other
part,
so
that
RC
and
it.
So
there
are
a
lot
of
acronyms
that
you
will
see
during
the
week,
but
I
mean
I.
A
Yeah,
you
just
said:
I
mean
you
can
retail
later,
and
it
just
has
a
few
of
the
of
the
groupings
that
you
will
hear
more
during
the
week.
The
internet
Engineering
steering
group
is
actually
the
combination
of
all
the
area
directors
together
they
make
the
it's
almost
like
a
bit
of
a
management
layer.
They
kind
of
have
a
final
say
about
the
you
know.
The
working
group
documents
that
they've
moved
through
the
process
and
there's
also
a
plenary
session
on
Wednesday
evening
afternoon,
I
believe
we're.
A
The
iesg
will
sit
there
and
you
can
ask
questions,
and
there
are
some
discussions:
I
RTF
our
dimensions,
IAB
and
it's
the
separate
groupings
they
were
grouping.
They
will
also
do
they
kind
of
have
more
they
over
arching
over
side
of
the
developments
of
the
of
the
standards
and
the
IETF
as
a
whole.
And
yet
the
the
administrative
organization,
ITF
LLC.
B
Okay,
so
I'm
here
to
talk
about
the
IE
tip
Oh
crystal
with
any
questions
on
the
first
part:
oh
yeah,
okay,
so
shrinking
okay.
So
the
eye
tip
meeting
ly
I'm
here
to
talk
about
what
this
upcoming
week
will
be
like
the
week
is
nominally
Monday
through
Friday,
and
then
we
are
adding
more
and
more
activities
on
the
weekend
before
so,
for
example,
we
have
many
of
the
tutorials
and
the
opening
reception-
or
today
yesterday
was
a
hackathon
mentioned
later
on
and
also
okay
closer
to
the
mic.
B
Yeah,
oh
wow,
much
better:
okay,
cool,
okay.
So
the
the
key
point
of
this
week
are
the
working
group
meetings.
As
Mirim
said,
there's
about
130
working
groups,
I
think
about
80
of
them
were
meeting
this
week.
There
are
also
called
birds
of
a
feather
session
and
it
comes
from
the
English
American
phrase:
birds
of
a
feather
flock
together,
the
idea
being
that
we
informally
will
get
together.
People
who
have
a
particular
interest
and
see
if
there
is
enough
interest.
B
There
is
enough
interest
and
enough
possibility
of
doing
something
that
eventually
a
boss
may
meet
once
or
twice
and
then
look
to
form
a
working
group
IRT
F
sessions,
the
internet
research
task
force.
This
covers
areas
including
say
a
cryptography
working
group
which
is
focused.
You
know
hardcore
math
Human
Rights
protocol.
How
does
things
like
the
DNS
affect
Human
Rights
around
the
world
to
also
there's
a
new
group
serving
on
quantum
cryptography?
B
This
first
meeting
is
a
tutorial
each
of
the
areas
that
Miriam
mentioned
our
meeting,
so
security
group
will
meet
one
day
during
the
week.
The
routing
group
meets
another
area,
and
this
is
where
they
talk
about
things
that
are
related
overall
often
there's
a
guest
speaker
involved
to
come
talk
about
you
know,
Cisco
will
come
and
present
routing
in
the
latest.
You
know
architecture
of
the
the
current
router
or
something
like
that.
There's
the
IETF
wide
plenary
plenary
is
a
Latin
word.
That
means
everybody
which
I
just
looked
up
yesterday.
It
runs
Wednesday
evening.
B
It
covers
a
wide
variety
of
things
from
the
really
mundane
like
here's.
What
our
budget
is.
Here's
what
the
bylaws
we
approved
are
too
often
again
often
again,
a
guest
speaker
to
question-and-answer
period
in
the
March
meeting
is
when
we
change
over
from
the
previous
boards
of
the
IAB
and
the
area
directors
to
the
new
boards.
So
everybody
comes
up,
gets
thanked
and
then
they
all
stream
off
and
then
the
new
folks
come
in
there's
often
a
lot
of
overlap.
There
there's
often
a
lot
of
drinking
in
the
audience
there,
the
hackathons
and
code
sprints.
B
Those
are
conventionally
the
weekend
before
the
hackathon
is
where
people
get
together.
There's
a
wiki
page
to
sign
up
it's
sort
of
too
late.
Obviously,
for
this
IETF
and
people
say
oh
I'm
interested
in
doing
quick
interoperability,
I'll
bring
my
implementation,
you'll
bring
yours
and
we
try
to
you,
know
bash
them
and
make
them
work
together.
Often
heard
that
the
thing
is:
oh
I
got
a
segfault,
hey
so
did
I,
we
interoperate
yeah,
there's
tutorials
mode.
Many
of
them
are
scheduled
for
the
Sunday
before
this
one
there's
a
follow-up
afterwards
about
using
github.
B
It's
a
chance
to
you
know,
meet
friends,
re
meet
friends
if
you
haven't
already
seen
them
in
the
areas
and
and
ketchup
or
other
people
here,
and
normally
there
are
lunch
sessions.
There's
one
on
router
architecture
Wednesday
afternoon
this
time
it
was
being
reserved
for
unstructured
activities.
So
some
of
the
informal
lunch
activities
been
blown
away
hot
are
see
it's
a
hot
request
for
comments.
This
is
a
short-term
thing
where
you
you
stand
up
and
you
talk
about
10
minutes.
Guy
named
Aaron.
B
Fox
is
coordinating
that
if
you
have
something
that
you
want
to
talk
about
and
present
to
the
technical
audience
for
literally
10
minutes
find
him.
The
hot
RFC's
often
lead
to
drafts
or
documents
being
adopted
by
working
groups.
Two
hours
two
meetings
ago,
we
had
two
people
come
and
then
actually
present
at
the
Acne
working
group
of
track
coach
at
social
events.
Not
this
time,
but
typically
there
is
a
social
event.
Wednesday
night
go
out
to
a
local
tourist
kind
of
a
yeah.
B
Next,
the
agenda
is
only
partial.
There
are
many
things
that
are
not
there.
What's
called
hallway
meetings,
literally
people
will
gather
in
the
hallways
outside
of
the
meeting
rooms,
or
you
know
in
the
bar
hotel
bar
this
or
you
know,
in
the
breakfast
area
or
in
the
the
snack
bar
area.
Here
there
are
many,
what's
called
barbed
offs:
let's
go
out
for
beer
and
talk
about
how
NTP
needs
to
be
fixed.
The
time
protocol.
Let's
go
out,
let's
meet
in
the
hallway.
B
You
know,
I
heard
someone
talk
at
a
DNS
meeting
and
I
cornered
them
and
they
said
oh
well.
The
next
meeting
is
starting.
Let's
go
out
in
the
hallway
and
talk
that
kind
of
thing
happens.
All
the
time
don't
be
shy.
As
Miriam
said,
people
are
passionate
and
respect
technical
knowledge.
Those
are
kind
of
nice
ways
that
saying
they
come
sometimes
can
be
rude
or
brusque
right,
don't
be
put
off
by
it
just
say:
no
wait
a
minute
you're,
not
explaining
yourself
or
no
I.
B
Have
you
really
consider
this
point
and
people
will
you
know
everyone
will
eat
with
everybody
marathon
editing
sessions?
People
working
on
a
document
will
often
go
off
to
a
room
Wednesday
afternoon.
This,
as
I
said,
is
set
aside
for
a
lot
of
that
stuff.
There's
an
online
app.
Our
chair
and
Miriam
managed
to
crash
the
app
yesterday
by
uploading,
but
but
they
fixed
it,
they
took
the
they
took
yeah
it
works.
Now
you
can
find
it
on
the
meeting
page.
B
B
About
some
of
the
etiquette
later
on,
it's
the
biggest
part,
it
is
for
the
most
part,
the
month
late
Monday
through
Friday,
meet
of
those
those
day
meetings.
It's
a
chance
for
people
who
are
working
on
documents
called
internet
drafts
to
come,
explain
to
the
crowd.
What's
happened
since
the
last
time
question
and
answer
and
resolve
open
issues,
and
the
resolutions
are
done.
As
we
have
said
by
humming
humming
is
cool.
We
could
we
could
do
a
sample
palm,
which
is
how
many
people
are
here
for
a
particular
working
group
meeting.
B
Okay,
all
of
the
sessions,
all
of
the
this
tutorial
and
all
the
working
group
meetings
are
streamed
online.
We
are
friends
at
need
echo
over
there,
it's
important
when
you
speak
or
you
either.
You
stand.
You
know
on
the
square
or
in
the
box.
If
you're
asking
a
question,
you
have
to
stand
at
the
mic,
so
they
can
be
heard
remotely
yeah,
it's
good
accent,
a
buff,
as
I
mentioned
an
informal
session,
the
gathering
of
people
who
want
to
do
something.
B
It
often
proceeds
a
working
group,
although
sometimes
there
will
be
a
need
where
people,
the
area
directors
will
say.
No,
we
really,
you
know,
there's
obviously
a
lot
of
interest
in
doing
this.
So
let's,
let's
go
right
to
the
working
group.
Most
of
the
time
it's
consumed
by
what
the
Charter
is.
The
Charter
says
these
are
the
specific
things
we
want
to
work
on,
and
these
are
rough
milestones.
The
milestones
are
always
what's
called
aspirational.
Oh
we'll
get
the
next
version
of
quick
out
in
six
months.
B
Now
we
really
meant
a
year
in
six
months,
but
so
it
goes.
Sometimes
it
can
be
one
top
one-time
meeting.
Sometimes
it
can
be
Oh
a
bath
met
to
discuss,
should
we
standardize
the
protocols
for
network
drives
things
like
Dropbox
and
Google
Drive
and
so
on.
Everybody
people
showed
up,
it
was
very,
very
well
attended
and
the
final
decision
was
nope.
It's
too
early
nobody's
going
to
do
it
again.
Next.
B
B
Previously
the
IAB
was
the
people
who
signed
the
contracts
with
the
hotels
and
things
like
that.
If
you're
having
a
thousand
people
come
to
a
hotel,
you
need
to
have
contracts
and
agreements
and
all
of
that
kind
of
stuff
the
RIT
adjusts
often
meet
at
working
group
meetings.
They
can
also
meet
coincident
with
ACM
meetings
or
other
organizations.
B
They
are
open
to
everyone,
they
sponsor
a
networking
prize
and
the
prize
is
they
find
two
papers
in
the
networking
area,
everyone
is
encouraged
to
submit
papers
or
references
to
papers
and
those
two
people
get
picked
to
come
to
the
next
IET
meeting
expenses
paid
and
present
their
paper.
So
it's
a
really
good
way
to
encourage
academia
flow
into
the
IETF
area-wide
sessions.
So
the
leftmost
picture
there
you
can
see
is
the
open
mic.
The
the
plenary
is
held
in
the
grand
ballroom.
B
Eight
nine
hundred
people
show
up
a
couple.
Dozen
will
get
to
go
to
the
mic
and
ask
questions
of
the
the
technical
leadership.
If
you
will
seated
there
up
at
the
front
of
the
dais
there
may
be
a
talk
is
shown
in
the
middle
slide.
Then
this
one,
you
know
I
think
is
it
was
invited
lunchtime,
talk
from
what
the
Cisco
fella
but
I'm,
not
sure,
and
this
more
so
the
hackathons
and
code
sprints
again
too
late.
B
Cisco
in
the
past
is
funded
it
free
lunch
and
snacks
and
so
on,
but
you
can
see
in
the
bottom
middle
one
there
that's
sort
of
what
it
looks
like
now.
If
you
went
into
the
room,
fifteen
tables
of
people
sitting
around
and
either
working
on
their
own
implementation,
talking
to
other
people
or
sharing
code
and
repositories
on
github,
get
lab
whatever.
B
Next
networking
social
events
so
on
the
left
was
the
social
event
from
Singapore.
We
went
to
the
National
Aquarium
and
there
were
you
know:
stacked
tables
order
tables
in
front
of
this
giant
glass.
They
should
have
taken
a
picture
of
the
octopus,
but
no
on
the
right
hand,
side
is
the
idea
of
sisters,
sys
ter
s,
anyone
who
presents
as
female
as
welcome
to
come
this
typically
at
lunch,
I
think
sponsoring
this,
and
it's
a
pretty
isn't
large
group.
B
You
know,
as
I
said
open
it
all
who
present
this
female
next
general
meeting
etiquette,
okay,
so
the
most
important
useful.
The
most
useful
thing
is:
if
you're
planning
on
attending
a
working
group
session
be
familiar
with
the
documents
otherwise
will
be
lost,
because
what
happens
at
these
meetings,
as
I
said,
is
the
presenters
talked
about?
What's
changed
since
the
last
time?
If
this
is
the
first
time
a
document
is
being
reviewed,
then
obviously,
what's
changed
is
everything
so
it's
an
overview
of
the
document.
B
But
if
you
come
to
a
working
session,
thinking
you'll
get
a
tutorial
of
what's
going
on.
It's
not
gonna
work,
you'll
be
lost,
they'll
be
bored
and
you
won't
get
as
much
out
of
it.
We're
working
really
hard.
The
second
bullet
to
behave.
You
know
respectfully
in
tolerantly,
we
have,
you
know,
we're
all
computer
nerds,
so
we
tend
not
to
be
the
most
socially
Pleasant
people
all
the
time
us
accepted.
B
That's
why
we're
here,
but
you
know
we
have
what's
called
an
Ombuds
team
and
we'll
be
a
slide
with
the
people
there
and
the
resources
section
if
you
are
being
harassed
or
made
to
feel
uncomfortable
by
all
means
reach
out
and
contact.
One
of
these
people
talk
to
people
enjoy
yourself
remember
to
sleep.
The
meetings
start.
You
know
breakfast
is
typically
you
know
at
8:00,
someone
will
say:
hey,
let's
meet
together
at
breakfast
and
talk
about
things
and
the
session
start
at
9:00.
It
goes
through
lunchtime.
B
My
younger
days
yeah
used
to
go
from
7:00
to
11:00
p.m.
whatever
that
is
7
to
2300
and
I
pop
back
on
the
phone
and
call
back
to
the
states.
My
wife
would
go,
oh
you're,
tired
and
drunk
again.
Aren't
you?
No?
No,
it's
fun.
It's
also
a
lot
of
work
just
being
technically
aware
and
on
all
the
time
session
etiquette.
This
is
how
to
behave
at
almost
any
session,
but
in
particular
the
working
groups
speak
directly
into
the
microphone.
B
B
Yes
and
oh
yeah
Eric
Kaler
score
what
got
it
yeah?
They
tend
to
slur.
It
people
often
also
say
their
employer.
It
doesn't
count
for
anything
other
than
just
help.
You
understand
what
biases
they
might
bring.
Hi
I'm
rich
Sol's
for
Akamai,
Technologies
and
I.
Don't
think
you
know
everything
should
be
on
a
CDN
yeah,
the
blue
sheets.
We
don't
have
them
here
or
at
the
tutorials.
They
will
be
passed
around.
B
B
It
also
I,
don't
think
it
happened,
but
it
also
is
a
way
if
you
say
I
know
what's
happening
here
and
by
participating.
I
agree
to
abide
by
the
no
well,
so
you
won't
accidentally
disclose
some
patent
to
get
involved
in
patent
discussions.
That
kind
of
stuff
technical
comments,
questions
always
welcome.
B
The
working
group
tears
sit
at
the
front
like
Miriam
and
I
are
well
at
one
point,
say:
okay,
I'm
going
to
cut
the
line
because
they're
trying
to
follow
an
agenda,
and
that
means,
if
you
know,
if
you
haven't
already
come
to
the
mic,
then
don't
bother
coming
up.
If
you
have
a
last-minute
question,
come
up
after
the
session
and
talk,
there's
a
jabber
channel,
every
working
group
has
an
instant
messaging
XMPP
protocol.
B
It's
almost
always
working
group
Nate,
it
is
always
working
group
name,
dot,
jabber
working
group
name
is
the
group
at
jabbered
IETF,
dot
org
that
can
be
dissin
the
back-channel.
You
can
make
snide
comments
about
people
who
aren't
here,
but,
more
importantly,
it's
a
way
for
us
to
communicate
who
to
remote
people
who's
talking
what
slides
they're
on
next
before
Mirim
comes
back.
Are
there
any
questions
about
how
the
meeting
runs?
B
A
A
You
see
a
picture
of
the
IGF
Secretariat
and
they
are
really
the
people
who
make
all
this
work
and
they're
the
people
who
gave
you
the
badges,
there's
a
registration
desk,
and
you
write
when
you
pick
up
your
badge
and
your
meeting
material,
but
also,
if
you
have
any
questions
or
if
you're
looking
for
a
room
or
or
if
there's
anything
wrong
when
need,
please
feel
free
to
go
and
find
in
these
people
the
world
purple
shirts,
no,
no
I'm
confused.
They
blue
okay.
A
They
were
a
blue
shirt,
see
except
for
Alexa,
who
is
them
incognito
here
so
yeah,
please
feel
free
to
find
any
of
these
friendly.
Ladies
and
blue
shirts
they'll
be
able
to
help
you
they've
been
around
a
long
time.
There's
also
am
next
to
the
registration
desk.
There
will
be
some
other
desks
with
people.
A
One
is
from
the
our
RFC
editor,
so
there's
the
staff
that
really
works
on
the
internet
drafts
and
the
RFC's
and
makes
them
bring
some
in
the
right
format
and
ultimately
publishes
and
as
RFC
in
the
in
the
RFC
series,
they
have
a
desk,
usually
that
you
can
go
and
ask
some
questions,
maybe
about
some
draft
that
you
have
submitted
or
any
of
the
processes
you
know,
Bihar
CSR,
published
and
I'm
sure
they'll
be
happy
to
help
you.
There
I.
B
A
Ask
Andy
no
tariff
CAF
candies.
Well,
no,
all
right!
Yeah!
Okay,
can
you
say
they're
competing
with
each
other
for
most
candies
on
their
tables.
So
there's
the
I
Anna
di
got
the
internet,
assigned
names,
numbers
and
authority
names
and
numbers
anyway.
They
hand
out
numbers,
addresses
and
protocol
numbers,
so
IP
addresses
domain
names
and
protocol
numbers
in
this
event
in
this
forum.
Obviously
the
protocol
numbers
are
the
main
focus,
but
so
they
also
have
a
desk
there
and
they
have
office
hours
there.
A
You
can
find
them
and
ask
you
know
questions
of
what
they
do
and
how
these
protocol
numbers
are
assigned,
and
then
there
is
an
ITF
executive
director,
Portia
and
she's
probably
be
rent
at
that
area
as
well.
If
you
are
interested
to
find
out
more
of
that
role,
yeah
the
Amity,
my
rich
already
mentioned
them.
That's
important
and
these
three
people
are
the
Ombuds
team
and
if
you
experience
anything
unpleasant
any
rudeness
or
any
unpleasant
behavior,
please
feel
free
to
contact
them.
A
There
is
the
link
to
their
document
and
there's
also
contact
information,
but
we
put
the
pictures
here,
so
you
can
get
familiar
with
them.
That's
Alison,
Rankin
and
she's
also
still
I.
Think
the
I
RTF
chair
right
until
exactly
until
this
meeting
so
she's
chairing
the
IRT
app.
So
you
might
see
her
later
today
in
the
IRT.
No
tomorrow
in
the
IRT
F
open
and
session,
then
there's
Pete
Resnick
in
the
middle
there.
He
has
been
around
for
a
long
time.
A
So
you
can
see
if
somebody
has
a
blue
dot.
That's
the
working
group
chair
and
you
will
also
see
them
later
on
today
at
the
newcomers
meet-and-greet
session,
I
tend
to
say
that
I
guess
you
don't
have
them
I
tend
to
say
that
the
most
important
one
is
the
one
with
a
smiley,
but
we
don't
have
to
smile.
Is
there
any
more
I,
don't
know
what
happened
to
the
Smiley's
we
used
to
have
Smiley's
on
our
badges.
A
A
Actually
it's
still
up
there
in
the
in
the
on
the
badge
up
there
anyway,
so
I'm
not
gonna,
go
through
all
these
colors
I
mean
you
can
ask
people
if
there
are
people
with
multiple
color
badges,
because
they're
involved
in
different
groupings,
but
yet
the
Ombuds
team,
maybe
it's
a
good
one
to
spot
and
and
also
I
believe
the
technical
team.
Where
is
it
I?
Don't
see
it
right
now,
I
thought
they
had
a
another
color
batch,
but
yeah
doesn't
matter
you'll
find
you'll,
find
them.
A
Okay,
move
on
just
some
links
and
some
more
information
that
at
the
end,
there
yeah
there's
a
link
to
all
the
tutorials,
all
the
slides,
the
recordings
it's
all
there.
They
are
submitting
wiki
about
each
and
every
ITF
you'll
find
a
lot
of
information.
They
also
people
share
some
logistical
informations
if
they
wanna
share
a
taxi
to
the
O'hare
Airport
or
you
know
interesting
restaurants,
they
find
you
can
find
all
that
on
the
wiki
and
I
believe.
A
There
is
a
newcomers
mailing
list.
Are
you
all
on
that
list,
I
believe
in
your
register?
You
could
choose
to
be
on
their
list
and
you,
you
know,
be
subscribed
to
that
list.
So
you
have
received
all
this
information.
I
guess!
That's
why
you're
also
here
there
is
the
list
of
the
ietf
sisters
which
mentioned
so.
If
you,
the
ladies
of
you,
are
in
the
room
interested
to
participate
in
that
in
that
lunch
there
is
a
some
information
about
it,
but
you
can
also
come.
A
Ask
me,
or
you
know
any
of
the
other
women
here
we
meet
on
Thursday
lunch
time,
but
it's
also
on
the
agenda
just
feel
free
to
come,
and
there
are
some
other
mailing
lists
there
about
various
groupings.
I,
don't
know
if
you're
on
the
meeting
participants
mailing
list,
it
can
be
quite
a
lot
of
traffic
on
that.
A
There's
usually
a
lot
of
very
helpful
people
on
there
that
you
know
send
a
lot
of
information
about
specific
meeting
venue
and,
what's
around
here
and
where
to
find
the
drugstore
and
the
cleaner
and
all
that,
yes,
you
can
subscribe,
also
unsubscribe,
if
it's
too
much
yes
and
then
there
is
a
lot
that
maybe
that's
one
of
the
most
important
parts
of
the
ITF
from
materials
and
it's
a
data
tracker.
It's
for
all
the
materials
are
our
stores.
All
the
internet.
A
Drafts
agendas
milestones
the
scope
of
the
working
groups,
it's
all
on
the
data
tracker
and
you
often
won't
even
notice
if
you
go
from
the
agenda,
for
instance
to
some
of
the
specific
materials
of
the
working
groups.
You'll
end
up
in
the
data
tracker
and
that's
a
page,
that's
been
developed
by
the
IETF
tools
team,
which
is
mostly
voluntary,
I'm
team
and
they've
been
working
for
many
many
years
on
them
on
useful
tools
for
the
IETF
participants
and
there's
also
a
page
that
lists
all
the
available
tools
right
and
while
you're
here.
A
So
you
don't
need
remote
participation,
information,
but
I
find
it
over
the
last
year.
Actually,
the
remote
participation
facilities
of
the
ITF
have
increased
improved
significantly,
and
it's
thanks
to
a
lot
of
the
meet
echo.
The
work
to
meet
echo
team
has
put
in
so
I,
don't
know.
If
any
of
you
participated
in
the
webinar
last
week,
we
also
had
them
in
the
background
helping-
and
maybe,
if
you
next
time
you
might
won't
be
able
to
come
I
would
encourage
you
to
really
try
that
out.
It
works
quite
well.
A
Obviously
there
is
a
network
you
can
use.
That
would
be
weird
if
yeah,
otherwise
you
have
to
be
relying
on
the
hotel
network
yeah.
Now
some
hotels
still
think
like
yeah.
We
have
one
network
here,
it's
just
done
and
just
use
that,
but
that's
not
going
to
work.
We
have
so
many
people
here
with
so
many
different
devices
and
have
such
a
high
demand.
There's
it
there's
another
tool
of
a
team
of
volunteers,
the
network
opera,
the
NOC
team
network,
operation
center
team
knock-knock,
and
they
are
set
up
there.
A
Well,
they
already
here
for
a
whole
week,
setting
up
the
network
and
all
the
vices
in
the
hotel,
and
there
are
no
more
pesticides
you
can
use.
There
is
one
that
list
here,
specifically
that's
the
ITF
legacy
that
we
don't
encourage
you
to
use
because
that's
not
encrypted,
and
there
are
others
in
Oregon
over
v6
and
the
so
don't
go
over
meeseeks,
and
so
there
there
are
a
number
of
exercises
you
can.
A
A
Yeah,
that's
right
that
so
there's
you
used
to
say
there
are
people
in
there
that
can
help,
but
they're,
not
there
now
at
the
registration
desk.
So
you
can
find
if
you
have
a
technical
problem,
you'll
find
them
at
the
registration
and
this,
but
you
can
still
use
their
room
also
to
see
their
work
and
yeah
and
then
last
but
not
least,
which
already
mentioned
that
the
jabber
room.
A
If
you
see
us,
if
you
have
any
questions
or
people
at
the
registration
desk
and
there's
a
link
here
on
this
slide,
I
would
like
you
to
fill
that
in
it's
a
survey
this
one
here.
We
would
like
to
get
your
feedback
about
the
newcomers
tutorial
and
also
maybe
later
in
the
week
as
I
said
earlier
after,
if
you
come
to
the
Thursday
morning
feedback
session,
it
would
be
great
to
hear
from
you
maybe
some
suggestions
or
improvements
you
have
for
us,
as
the
education
team
right.