►
Description
Internet Society Board Open Forum on Structures of Consultation
Session 2
25 May 2022 (Spanish)
A
A
We
ask
that
you
respect
the
code
of
conduct
for
individual
members
of
the
internet,
sos
air.
I
think
the
time
to
sign
up
for
this
session
remember
to
do
it.
We
have
simultaneous
interpretation
available
in
English,
French
and
Spanish,
and
we
have
subtitles
available
in
English.
You
can
select
these
options
on
your
zoom
panel
and
we
will
show
you
how
do
it
on
the
next
slide.
Keep
your
microphone
muted
at
all
times.
A
Unless
you
are
asking
a
question
If,
you
want
to
ask
a
question:
you
can
raise
your
hand
with
the
zoom
tool
and
we
will
see
your
name
in
the
participant
list.
If
you
want
to
use
the
chat
for
your
questions
can
write
it
r
in
your
preferred
language,
in
English,
Spanish
or
French,
and
then
we
read
it
if
it
is
in
French
or
Spanish,
we
will
translate
it
and
when
you
ask
your
questions,
please
say
a
name
and
your
country
For
example
I-
would
be
in
Portugal
again.
A
A
B
B
A
The
charter
for
the
working
group
on
governance
reform
was
put
together.
There
were
certain
limitations
among
those
limitations.
The
proposals
considered
by
the
group
could
not
include
proposals
to
lessen
the
ability
of
stakeholders
to
select
candidates
for
be
part
of
the
board
of
trustees
or
proposals
that
require
the
rehabilitation
or
solution
to
the
internet,
susari
as
it
is
currently
constituted
in
the
United
States.
A
This
working
group
would
not
consider
proposals
that
violate
in
one
of
the
current
legal
agreement,
relations
on
the
International
and
the
aikan,
and
this
is
important
for
the
internet
next
slide,
please
well.
That
was
all
on
the
administrative
side.
Now
we
open
the
session
for
conversation,
Hans
Peter.
You
want
to
go
over
the
working
group
on
governance
reform
to
start
off.
A
A
C
C
C
C
A
A
C
A
The
last
structure
that
already
lasted
13
years,
30
years
Rather
in
the
first
20
years,
communication
was
based
on
individual
meetings
as
well
as
ican,
itf
meetings
of
other
divisions
where
members
and
chapter
leaders
could
meet
with
members
of
the
Council
meet
someone.
The
staff
meet
with
them
receive
information
and
also
give
your
own
comments.
Well,
we
increased
the
membership
I
think
now,
We
are
at
86
thousand
members.
B
A
C
A
The
time
that
I
was
on
the
council,
these
sessions
were
not
very
successful.
Most
of
the
time
we
had
like
two
or
three
people
signing
up,
so
that
did
n't
work
very
well.
About
10
years
ago,
the
advisory
committee
The
chapter
advisory
committee
was
created
to
facilitate
interchapter
communication
between
staff
and
council.
C
A
I
think
the
chapter
advisory
committee
is
based
more
on
administrative
tasks
and
you
have
not
focused
much
on
free
communication
and
at
least
I
did
not
feel
that
we
had
this
free
communication
with
the
chapter
leaders
through
the
chapter
advisory
committee.
There
are
any
new
ideas
or
new
comments
as
to
how
we
can
improve
communication
and
participation.
Thank.
D
B
A
Council
would
be
happy
to
consider
that
I
would
be
happy
to
consider
that
myself.
It
would
also
be
helpful
if
people
could
suggest
different
communication
methods
that
see
that
they
work
well
in
other
organizations
of
similar
size,
particularly
if
they
do
n't
require
structural
changes.
In
the
last
session
we
talked
about
the
issue
that
Hans
better
brought
up
from
the
chapter
advisory
committee.
We
thought
maybe
that
organization
needed
to
do
more
work
as
they
weren't
acting
as
free
communication
broker.
A
We
don't
want
to
change
the
current
structures
until
experiments
have
allowed
us
to
see
what
needs
to
be
changed
or
added.
So
if
people
have
experiments,
it
would
be
great
to
hear
them,
and
it
would
also
be
helpful
if
we
can
run
those
experiments
without
first
doing
a
structural
change.
Ctural
thanks.
C
C
A
You
I'm,
sheeran,
Australia
I,
think
experiments
would
be
worthwhile,
maybe
we'll
see
different
good
practices
emerge
depending
on
the
communities.
Maybe
some
communication
methods
will
be
more
effective
in
some
geographic
areas
or
some
economic
areas
compared
to
others
me
well
representing
the
perspective
of
the
internet,
australia.
We
have
seen
a
lack
of
connection.
B
A
Specifically
refers
to
the
ability
for
us
to
see
what
is
communicating
well
or
not.
This
is
our
perspective
from
the
chapter
we
feel
like.
We
can't
really
take
a
proper
pulse
of
what's
being
received
or
what
members
are
reacting
to
I.
Don't
know
how
this
could
be
corrected,
but
maybe
we
could
look
at
them
if
the
information
were
available.
So,
that's
another
problem
that
we
have
to
figure
out
what
we
have
I,
don't
know
that
communication
bubble,
but
I
suspect,
maybe
say
a
podcast
would
work
well
in
one
area.
A
Maybe
a
webinar
would
work
in
another
area
and
a
more
traditional
text
would
work
well
in
another
area,
but
we
need
to
find
a
good
point
that
works
in
modalities.
For
example,
if
I'm
going
to
ask
you
a
follow
up
question
before
We
talked
about
one
question
was
specifically
How:
do
you
measure
success?
You
are
seeing
a
similar
topic
on
the
internet
Australia
when
interacting
with
your
members
and
the
chapter.
How
are
you
measuring
that.
D
E
We
look
at
what
we
consider
most
important
to
us,
the
peach
in
this
Division,
and
we
also
have
a
lot
of
lists
and
we
organize
policy
dialogues
and
that
kind
of
thing.
But
that's
really
just
one
topic.
There
are
a
lot
of
people
who
are
feel
very
passionate
about
some
topic
or
another.
We
don't
know
what
is
really
successful,
p
to
communicate
with
them
or
not
As
for
the
communication
or
the
general
communication
that
is
being
sent
or
not.
It
is
being
sent
on
time.
E
If
we
receive
something
we
think
Well
that
was
just
to
the
members
or
to
the
board
members.
So
we
have
to
go
back
and
look
Like
this
that
there
is
still
a
lot
to
improve
Thank
you
And,
thank
you
for
the
suggestion
of
forming
different
types
of
communications
in
the
chat
right
now,
and
it
says,
different
modes
of
communication
must
be
used
in
different
areas
or
age
groups,
so
that
it
says
I
think
success
can
be
measured
by
the
impact
tracking
the
interns
and
seeing
how
they
are
impacting
society.
B
E
So
I
would
also
like
to
point
out
that,
even
during
the
covid
pandemic,
I
I
got
very
involved
in
deploying
the
infrastructure,
with
a
strong
base
of
support
for
the
interaction
and
its
programs,
and
that
is
why
I
think
that,
if
that
continues
to
be
strong
and
present
in
the
local
communities,,
I
think
that
we
simply
have
to
document
more
of
the
activities
that
we
are
carrying
out
in
society
regionally
AND
locally.
Thank
you.
Thank
you.
E
E
If
those
effects
are
impacting
the
world
as
we
want
it
to
and
many
times
in
those
cases,
we
look
at
how
the
work
that
the
staff
and
the
The
internet
in
general
involves
the
wider
community
and
if
it
really
has
a
positive
impact
on
the
internet,
and
if
those
properties
of
the
internet
are
growing
AND
if
they
are
healthy,
Over,
the
last
12
months,
we
have
been
doing
additional
work
to
develop
some
measures
regarding
this
topic.
I
hope
that
in
the
coming
years,
the
impact
report
will
also
have
a
system
of
e
metrics.
E
So
we
can
see
the
health
of
the
internet
etcetera.
So
that's
what
we've
been
focusing
on,
but
generally
it
has
to
do
with
these
metrics
so
that
they
reflect
what's
going
on
in
the
world
and
capture
the
stories
that
illustrate
how
those
things
work,
I,
hope
that
have
answered
the
question.
Thank
you
very
much
and
I
think
that
if
I
can
reflect
on
what
Barak
was
saying,
there
are
many
individual
stories
regarding
the
impact
As.
He
said.
A
E
E
E
Sometimes,
what
is
reflected
back
to
us
as
a
community
and
then
to
the
community
are
not
always
perfect,
because
people
who
are
interested
in
the
company
and
have
very
different
interests
than
people
who
are
just
starting
to
get
interested
in
interference
needed
So.
Maybe
we
need
a
different
report
for
this,
but
What
I
want
to
say
is
that
you
have
to
be
careful
so
that
the
impact
is
clear
to
the
different
countries..
E
It's
fascinating
that
so
many
people
are
interested
in
what
is
necessary,,
but
I
would
also
like
it
to
be
more
widespread,
because
I
think
there
are
many
people
in
the
world
who
could
be
interested
if
they
are
not
participating
and
it
could
be
an
opportunity
for
us
Thank
you
and
if
the
proposal
to
have
two
separate
reports
makes
sense
and
as
I
was
saying
before,
maybe
it
has
to
do
with
How.
These
groups
are
spoken
to
depending
on
age
and
region,
but
also,
depending
on
the
current
participation.
E
B
E
E
B
E
E
B
C
E
A
B
E
E
E
E
To
talk
about
that
topic,
So
maybe
develop
more
communication
material
is
using
the
same
tools
and
resources,
so
there
is
more
variety
as
far
as
what
is
happening
from
ni
way
between
many
and
many
instead
of
many
and
a
single
person,
I
think
that
this
is
the
design
that
interests
me,
especially
and
I
would
also
be
interested
to
know.
If
we
are
talking
about
how
we
communicate
at
this
moment
many
times
we
communicate
about
what
we
have
done.
Instead
of
talking
more
in
depth
about
the
policies.
E
F
F
F
A
A
Sometimes,
when
there
are
calls.
I,
don't
know
if
the
invitation
is
sent
to
all
the
members
of
the
chapter,,
only
the
leaders,
because
sometimes
we
don't
know
very
well
how
to
they
send
the
invitations
As
has
already
been
mentioned.
There
are
new
people
on
the
internet,
you
are
air
and
they
do
not
have
the
same
level
of
family,
arity
or
understanding
of
the
organization
So.
The
consultations
should
consider
that
we
should
consider
that
when
we
do,
the
consultations
and
It
should
be
more
of
a
process
of
listening
or
planning
and
asking
certain
people
to
speak.
A
Maybe
we
should
think
about
ourselves.
Other
aspects
that
are
important
for
that
specific
issue
and
clear
We
will
have
to
share
ideas
on
policy
development
many
times
the
chapters
cannot
comment
when
certain
policies
are
made.
I
am
going
to
give
you
an
example.
In
India
there
is
a
directive
that
has
come
out
of
the
research.
A
Is
being
prepared
by
Access
Now,
the
chapters
are
so
sponsoring
this
document.
Many
of
the
chapters
may
agree
with
many
of
these
points
in
the
document
But.
Maybe
there
are
some
points
they
disagree
with.
So
My
question
is
whether
to
the
chapters
they
are
asked
if
they
agree
with
the
document
or
if
there
is
ci
There
are
some
changes
that
need
to
be
made,
or
maybe,
for
example,
India
has
six
chapters
we
have.
A
good
number
of
members
is
that
members
have
been
asked
about
their
perspectives.
A
A
Android
says
that
maybe
what
you
were
waiting
for
was
more
discussion
or
dialogue
during
the
policy
development
process.
As
I
understand
it.
That
process
was
done
before
I
came
to
this
job
and
the
purpose
is
to
have
long
consultation
periods
to
allow
chapters
to
talk
about
the
policy
on
the
pdp
thing
is
a
process
that
controls
the
internet
suzari
in
other
cases,,
for
example,
when
Access
Now.
Another
group
of
inter
rnet
formulates
a
position
and
asks
us
or
the
chapters
If
we
want
to
support
them.
That
process
is
not
controlled
by
the
internet
society.
A
Maybe
we
will
say
yes
and
then
we
make
the
request,
but
we
will
not
be
able
to
control
the
consultation
in
this
case,
so
we
have
to
distinguish
between
those
two
cases.
Yes,
but
for
example,
when
we
say
that
the
toolbox
is
being
developed,
we
think
of
that
process.
So
perhaps,
when
the
tool
house
is
being
wasted,
the
chapters
can
help
if
it
is
with.
Another
association
that
is
done
is
different
when
it
comes
to
from
a
country.
I
understand
that
the
sosaeri
internet
works
with
many
chapters,
other
partner
organizations,
etc.
A
B
A
For
including
the
comments
from
the
chats
Android
says,
he
would
be
happy
to
review
the
to
review
Rather
the
necessary
changes
for
pcp
and
says
q
ue.
Signing
the
open
letter
is
not
something
that
governs
the
PDF
and
Rita
responded
that
the
toolbox
for
the
working
effort.
If
you
have
undergone
the
pdp
process
in
the
last
two
years,.
D
A
Level
of
consultation
for
the
pdp
process
may
be
appropriate
for
certain
processes,
but
for
other
things
when
they
have
to
advance
at
a
certain
pace
because
they
are
initiatives
of
other
organizations
or
other
entities.
Perhaps
if
we
have
to
talk
with
a
government
or
another
entity,
we
have
other
pending
issues
And.
These
are
not
going
to
evolve
at
the
same
pace.
We
will
have
to
consider
all
this,
but
if
we
have
to
think
that
there
are
consultations,
but
that
they
are
different.
B
A
Would
like
to
return
to
a
question
that
I
asked
before
to
see.
If
you
have
any
reflections
on
organizations
of
similar
size,
you
see
successful
consultations
that
could
be
used
as
the
model.
There
are
stories
that
They
will
be
able
to
share
with
the
group
where
this
model
works
with
other
groups
that
we
can.
We
would
adopt.
A
B
F
A
A
When
we
look
at
the
level
of
consultation
and
interaction
that
they
have
with
the
chapter
advisory
committee,
We
would
like
see
more
participation,
At.
The
time
of
voting
We
would
like
to
see
more
opportunities
to
present
our
perspectives,
and
since
I
am
speaking
for
the
accessibility
group,
I
would
like
to
see.
Other
groups
could
express
themselves
as
well.
A
B
A
A
Some
success
At
the
time
of
attracting
actors
from
different
sectors
And.
This
is
in
the
general
space
of
the
sector.
In
recent
years
we
have
been
arguing
about
the
definitions,
for
example,
of
different
terms.
Then
all
people
are
talking
about
these
issues
and
we
have
been
able
to
promote.
A
positive
change
is
how
the
situation
has
changed.
We
no
longer
say
he
said
she
said
they
said.
But
now
we
say
like
that:
I
understand
that
perspective,
I
understand
it
and
the
sector
is
taking
the
lead.
Very
interesting
solutions
are
emerging.
A
We
have
had
a
lot
of
conversation
and
all
this
arises
around
a
theme
we
commit
to
this
theme
and
we
make
people
start
thinking
More
on
this
Regarding.
The
mechanisms
And
that
should
have
been
part
of
the
process
for
them
to
be
effective,
It
stopped
bothering
us,
and
then
we
said.
Yes,
we
are
going
to
make
it
possible
And
again,
it
was
not
overnight.
E
I.
Think
one
of
the
keys
would
be
to
have
a
real
witness,
that
is,
based
on
the
public.
That
was
showing
those
disagreements
and
that
we
could
develop
an
understanding.
There
were
a
lot
of
panels
and
it's
a
very
broad
topic,
but
really
exposing
that
topic
to
enough
people
so
that
more
people
embraced
that
thinking
and
that's
when
I
think
that
change
happened
and
it
was
accepted
as
a
problem
and
that
as
a
solution
In
my
opinion,.
E
E
If
it
was
still,
let's
say
a
little
broader
in
terms
of
the
spectrum
of
polarization,
it
was
a
fear
of
change.
It
was
a
strategy
of
how
it
will
benefit
me.
Then
In,
the
end,
instead
of
public
interest,,
they
thought
that
there
could
be
a
benefit
for
me
too,.
So
there
was
a
commercial
interest
and
in
the
end,
it
was
driven
by
thoughts
that
went
beyond
the
fact
that
there
was
more
benefit,.
However,
I
did
not
want
to
focus
on
that
especially,,
but
it
is
what
was
happening
simultaneously.
Thank
you
for
the
additional
comment.
E
You
I
had
previously
raised
his
hand,.
It
was
not
recent.
Oh,,
it
was
not
because,,
since
we
did
not
understand
it
very
well.
Before,
due
to
the
connectivity,
I
wanted
to
invite
him
to
try
to
give
his
comment
again
and
the
question
of
Wanted's
blood,
I
think
that,
as
part
of
the
question
he
wanted
to
ask,,
he
already
asked
cheryl,
and
the
second
part
of
that
question
is
that
the
social
interest
to
you
concerns
many
chapters
and
members,
including
the
annual
action
plan.
E
E
Thanks
for
the
question
How
it
develops.
The
action
plan
is
a
plan
for
the
staff
is
a
plan
that
the
staff
with
which
the
per
staff
must
comply.
So.
It
cannot
be
developed
as
a
community
effort,.
However,
we
can
change
that.
We
can
change
the
nature
of
the
necessary
reading
and
to
avoid
having
to
depend
on
professional
staff,
but
currently
the
plan
works
that
way.
What
we
do
have
is
a
very
important
effort
to
check
with
multiple
people
if
they're
interested
in
a
particular
project,
etcetera
and
the
projects
that
are
included.
E
Very
significant
feedback,
so,
for
me,
I
see
that
it
is
difficult
to
evaluate
this
topic,
I
see
that
the
chapters
are
interested
in
it,,
but
in
any
case,
we
receive
very
positive
responses
from
the
chapters
that
participate,
for
example,
positive
reactions
this
year.
Regarding
the
effort
on
digital
sovereignty,
those
in
fact
were
one
of
the
reasons
why
it
ended
up
as
one
of
the
projects,
because
it
is
obvious
that
many
people
are
interested
in
that
topic.
We
have
also
received
interest
in
the
area
of
community
networks.
E
There
are
other
topics
that
people
are
less
interested
in
But.
There
has
been
a
lot
of
participation,
For
example,.
The
communication
network
was
difficult
to
explain
to
people
what
we
were
doing.
So.
That's
why
we
didn't
receive
many
reactions
when
we
started
it
several
years
ago,,
but
when
we
began
to
develop
the
material,,
people
began
to
get
excited
because
they
realized
that
this
can
be
done.
use
as
a
tool
for
many
other
things.
So
there
is
a
combination
of
two
pieces.
First,
the
formal
mechanisms
that
we
use
and
consult
with
people
about
this
to
see.