►
From YouTube: Montgomery Architectural Review Board (2/22/22)
Description
Old Business
1. PRESENTED BY: Cameron Bell
SUBJECT: Request for approval of a rear addition, covered deck, and alterations to the existing shed for the property located at 3333 Lexington Road (Cloverdale Idlewild).
New Business
2. PRESENTED BY: John Aspinwall
SUBJECT: Request for approval of a parking area and approval after the fact for using red on the front door for the property located at 825 Park Avenue (Cloverdale). PARTIAL VIOLATION
3. PRESENTED BY: Robert Mullins
SUBJECT: Request for approval of a front yard fence for the property located at 1435 Watson Avenue (Cloverdale).
4. PRESENTED BY: Rick Harris
SUBJECT: Request for approval of a driveway gate replacement for the property located at 925 E. Fairview Avenue (Cloverdale).
5. PRESENTED BY: Stephanie Nard
SUBJECT: Request for approval of driveway alterations and gate for the property located at 321 Felder Avenue (Garden District).
6. PRESENTED BY: James Ross Gunnells
SUBJECT: Request for approval of tree removal and replacement for the property located at 1595 Gilmer Avenue (Garden District).
7. PRESENTED BY: Shelby & Lindsay Stringfellow
SUBJECT: Request for approval of tree removals after the fact for the property located at 3357 LeBron Road (Cloverdale Idlewild).
A
A
If
you
hear
the
gavel,
you
are
out
of
order
and
if
you
persist,
you
will
be
removed
from
the
meeting
once
your
request
is
heard,
the
board's
decision
is
rendered
and
you
may
leave
the
meeting.
However,
if
you
have
questions
for
staff,
please
wait
until
after
the
meeting
is
over
to
talk
with
them
or
you
may
contact
steph
the
following
day
at
the
office
once
public
testimony
and
discussion
for
a
particular
item
are
concluded,
the
members
of
the
board
will
deliberate
and
render
a
decision.
A
Members
with
a
personal
or
financial
interest
in
any
request
are
required
to
recuse
themselves
from
voting.
All
decisions
by
the
architecture
review
board
are
final.
Any
person
having
a
request
for
a
certificate
of
appropriateness
denied
by
the
board
may
appeal
such
denial
to
the
montgomery
county
circuit
court.
Any
appeal
may
be
filed
with
the
circuit
court
within
30
days
of
the
receipt
of
the
notice
of
the
final
decision
of
the
board.
A
A
B
Yes,
ma'am
sure
am
yeah,
so
cameron
bell
3333
lexington
road,
and
I
am
just
here
requesting
approval
of
a
few
projects
I
have
going
on
two
of
them,
or
one
of
them
is
more
significant.
Two
of
them
are
smaller,
remodel
kind
of
some
fixes.
I'm
doing
the
large
project
is
basically
an
addition
to
the
back
of
the
house
so
they're
within
the
last
probably
20
years.
B
There
has
been
a
what
they
call
when
we
bought
the
house
was
a
sun
room
that
was
added
to
the
back
of
the
house,
and
we
would
like
to
extend
that
sun
room
out,
basically
doubling
the
size
of
it,
so
that
it
would
extend
out
to
the
exterior
wall,
that's
already
present
and
then
add
a
covered
back
deck
to
the
back
of
both
what
is
existing
and
what
is
the
proposed
new
edition?
Yeah?
You
can
see
the
the
picture
right
there.
I
will
say
one
thing
about
this
proposal
is
recently.
B
B
I
would
probably
go
ahead
and
change
out
the
siding.
The
siding
is
kind
of
rotting.
It's
a
just
a
manufactured
vertical
siding
and
I
would
like
to
change
it
out
to
a
lap
hardy
plank
sighting.
Everything
would
be
painted
white.
As
far
as
the
deck
is
concerned,
the
deck
boards,
I
would
probably
paint
gray
everything
else-
would
be
painted
white.
So
that's
basically
the
first
project,
the
second
project.
B
I
can't
remember
what
order
they're
in
it's
basically
on
the
side
of
the
house
going
into
where
our
kitchen
is.
There
is
some
once
again
some
rotting
vertical
siding
paneling,
and
I
would
like
to
remove
that
and
replace
it
with
once
again
hearty
plank
siding
paint.
It
white
so
very,
very
small
project
there
and
then
the
last
one
would
be
the
shed
that
is
on
our
property
or
carport.
Whatever
it
was
built
for
was
never
the
front
of
it
was
never
enclosed.
B
Yes,
there's
project
two
right
there,
the
the
front
of
it
was
never
enclosed.
You
can
see
a
picture
of
it
right.
There
just
has
a
chain
link
gate
at
the
front
of
it.
So
I
would
like
to
enclose
the
front
match
the
the
siding,
that's
around
the
rest
of
it
and
then
put
in
a
door
just
a
door
similar
to
that
one
right
there.
B
My
original
plan
was
just
to
take
the
one
off
the
back
door
of
the
house
and
use
that,
so
it
would
be
basically
the
the
same
thing
for
that
and
then
re-roof.
It
needs
a
new
roof
repair,
some
of
the
rotting
siding
on
the
shed,
but
not
really
changing
anything
to
the
main
structure
of
it.
That's
pretty
much.
It.
C
D
Mr
bail,
yes
in
option
two
of
the
sun
room.
You
said
you're
thinking
about
maybe
doing
it
in
phases.
If,
if
you
do
decide
to
do
it
in
phases,
phase
one
or
you're
going
to
leave
the
existing
door
like
it
is,
and
do
the
french
doors
at
a
later
date
correct,
so
the
door
you
would
put
on
the
storage
shed
would
be
one
you
just
get.
B
B
D
B
E
Real
quick,
mr
bell,
you
said
you
want
because
of
course,
do
the
backs
in
two
phases.
At
the
end
of
the
second
phase,
is
it
going
to
look
like
you've
presented?
Just
we
all
understand,
I
live
in
the
neighborhood
old
houses,
they're
all
they're,
always
a
little
more
expensive
to
upkeep
than
you
think
they
will
be.
Yes,
I
think,
once
you
get
permission
has
a
year
to
complete
the
project.
Is
that.
E
B
E
Well-
and
I
guess
the
reason
I
was
asking
about
the
timing,
is
you
know
how
you
do
it?
I
don't
guess
really
matters
as
long
as
what
you
say,
you're
going
to
do
is
what
you
do,
because
we've
had
occasion
where
people
get
halfway
through
a
project
inside
without
coming
back
and
asking
change
it
yeah.
So
and
sometimes
you
run
into
trouble,
you
may
have
to
come
back,
hopefully
not,
but
that
was
my
concern,
which
is,
I
don't
guess,
really
a
concern
anymore.
B
A
A
H
H
I
H
E
F
H
G
D
So,
basically,
they're
going
to
take
up
the
width
of
the
front
yard
from
the
right
of
way
to
the
corner
of
the
house,
which
the
survey
shows
is
25
feet,
25.8
feet
or
something
like
that.
They're
gonna
take
up
that
full
width
and
then
go
from
the
existing
driveway
to
the
corner
of
the
house
as
well,
which
ms
anderson
thinks
is
more
like
23
feet.
G
H
A
I
D
A
G
A
C
A
I
E
E
E
F
D
H
All
the
brick
work
and
everything
else
is
the
bright
red.
The
old
you
know
the
common
bright
red,
brick
and
such
and
it's
similar
to
it
is
what
the
path
coming
up
and
the
steps
everything
to
it.
Is
that
and
then
it's
a
kind
of
a
say.
Whatever
the
approved
color,
it's
kind
of
a
sagey
green
is
what
the
house
is.
G
E
E
E
H
F
H
E
H
E
E
E
G
Good
evening
my
name
is
robert
mullins,
we're
asking
for
permission
to
put
a
three-foot
picket
fence
in
the
front
yard
of
the
house
extending
from
the
southeast
corner
or
excuse
me
southwest
corner
westward
to
the
coming
toward
the
front.
That's
the
design
of
the
fence.
Very
traditional
picket
fence
go
across
maintaining
the
right-of-way
and
then
back
up
to
the
southeast
corner
of
the
house.
A
D
G
H
E
G
J
G
A
I
I
E
I
K
K
K
There
is
a
tremendous
amount
of
rain
water
washing
off
of
both
my
house
and
my
neighbor's
house,
all
onto
my
driveway,
so
the
paver
or
concrete
work
would
be
to
try
and
slow
down
the
flow
of
the
the
water
and
give
it
an
area
to
drain
there's
no
direct
access
from
my
side
door
or
my
kitchen
to
my
back
deck.
So
I'm
proposing
kind
of
a
courtyard
area
on
the
back
side
of
that
gate.
K
Behind
my
kitchen
door
and
there's
also
no
direct
access
for
myself
or
my
neighbors
at
327
felder
avenue
to
get
to
either
of
our
backyards
with
you
know,
if
we
have
to
have
a
work
truck
or
anything,
I
have
a
small
unsightly
six
foot
chain
link
gate
currently
back
there.
My
neighbors
have
no
access
on
either
side
of
their
house
unless
I
do
something
where
they
have
access
through
my
driveway
and
obviously
improved
curb
appeal.
K
I
feel
I'm
embarrassed
of
my
driveway
in
that
back
area
when
my
car
is
not
in
my
driveway,
covering
it
up.
So
as
far
as
the
gates,
I've
spoken
with
someone
gotten
quote
for
a
gate
similar
to
what
you
see
in
the
picture
just
flat
on
the
top:
nothing
drawing
attention
really
to
it.
If
you
would
prefer,
I
have
an
arched
gate
I
could,
but
that
was
not
the
direction
I
was
going
to
take.
K
K
K
My
driveway
I
want
to.
I
have
currently
this
gray
slag.
That
was
there
when
I
bought
the
house,
and
I
spend
every
week,
probably
after
the
rain,
sweeping
the
rock
out
of
the
road
and
up
my
driveway
back
into
my
driveway.
So
I
would
like
to
I
can't
afford
to
currently
concrete
or
do
anything
to
my
entire
driveway,
but
I
would
like
to
extend
up
past
the
sidewalk
going
north
toward
the
back
of
my
house
at
least
a
foot
or
two
with
a
slight
incline
just
enough
to
hold
that
slag
from
washing.
K
I
will
also
would
like
to,
I
guess,
start
off
with
maybe
tire
track.
I
don't
know
what
you
call
those
strips
that
would
have
likely
been
a
driveway
at
the
period
in
which
the
house
was
built
start
off
with
that
and
I'm
I
would
either
propose
concrete
or
the
antique
paver
look,
brick
or
I'll
go
cobblestone
if
you
would
prefer
in
the
courtyard
area.
I
was
one
of
the
people
who
was
out
collecting
the
bricks,
the
pavers
that
were
in
the
pile
when
trinity
presbyterian
church
did
their
work.
K
F
E
A
I
would
like
to
caution
you
about
about
thinking
that
the
antique
paper
is
just
going
to
improve
your
water
situation,
because,
right
now
some
of
the
water
at
least
is
absorbed
by
the
gravel
stuff.
That's
back
there
and
once
it's
it's
paved
that
water
is
going
to
stand
somewhere.
So
you
need
to
be
careful
about
sloping
things
away
from
your
house
so
that
you
don't
end
up
with
a
wet
basement
and
things
like
that.
K
I
forgot
to
mention
that
and
yes,
currently,
the
driveway
slope
is
higher
in
the
middle
and
pushing
it
toward
both
of
our
houses,
and
I
sit
in
my
kitchen
looking
out
in
this
storm
yesterday
and
my
neighbors,
I
mean
it's
just
standing
water
against
their
foundation,
so
hopefully
I
can
make
it
that's.
My
goal
is
to
make
it
so
it
will
slope
toward
the
middle
and
I
don't
care
if
the
water
stands
there.
K
L
I
A
J
Yes,
shelby
string,
fellow
3357
lebron
road
we
are
requesting.
After
the
fact
approval
for
removal
of
it
was
initially
was
two
trees,
but
actually
was
only
one
tree
which
was
actually
subject
to
the
requirement
that
was
removed
that
tree
in
question
right.
There
is
actually
still
there.
It's
just
been
trimmed
back
all
the
limbs
that
were
actually
hanging
over
the
driveway
and
touching
the
house
have
been
trimmed
off,
not
all
of
them.
It
still
looks
like
a
healthy
tree.
J
However,
it's
still
there,
so
I
think
the
previous
tree
that
was
showing
the
previous
slide
is
actually
the
one
that
was
actually
removed.
Well,
I
apologize
yeah
that
that
tree,
I
think,
a
better
picture,
maybe
further
on
into
the
presentation.
However,
it
was
removed
due
to
a
significant
lien
and
some
limbs
were
actually
hanging
on
the
house.
J
J
J
E
We
don't
like
popcorn
trees
at
all,
kill
them
all.
I've
had
to
remove
got
one
out
of
my
house,
my
yard.
I
understand
birch
another
story
so
but
yes
any
tree
over
12
inches
in
diameter.
Right,
that's
that's
where
we
occasionally
have
to
step
in
okay,
so
the
tree
is
gone.
You've,
trimmed
back
and
you're,
keeping
the
birch
correct.
Okay,.
J
G
E
C
E
E
E
L
L
L
Yes,
it
was
don't
worry
about
it.
Don't
worry
about
the
photograph
same
thing
same
thing
same
roots,
I
don't
know
if
it
looked
like
two
and
then
it
wasn't
I'll
be
happy
to
put
whatever
you
like
there.
I
have
put
a
japanese
maple
in
the
front
yard.
That's
now
about
four
years
old.
I
think
maybe
five
but
I'll
be
happy
to
put
whatever
there.
I
E
G
A
F
In
at
the
december
meeting,
you
all
moved
to
table
a
decision
on
mapco's
submission
asking
them
to
go
back
to
the
drawing
board,
with
the
comments
that
you
all
made
and
the
neighborhood
made
in
hand
and
resubmit
for
the
february
deadline.
They
requested
a
delay,
and
I
told
them
since,
since
you
actually
stipulated
a
time
frame
that
we
could
do
it
once.
F
F
Last
tuesday,
someone
made
a
submission
requesting
removal
of
property
from
the
cottage
hill,
historic
district
that
is
in
the
legal
department
under
review.
I
do
not
expect
mapco
is
going
to
make
a
submission
for
march,
so
the
question
is,
since
you
did
stipulate
a
time
frame
on
tabling
that
decision.
E
E
F
F
E
F
It's
being
rev
it's
under
review
by
the
legal
department
to
determine
whether
they
think
that
can
be
done.
We
have
a
process
in
the
code.
I
got
a
written
opinion
from
the
alabama.
Historical
commission
last
fall
in
anticipation
that
something
like
this
might
happen
and
we
do
not
have
an
opt-out
provision.
F
You
know
you
can't
just
say
I'm
not
happy
with
the
board.
I
don't
want
to
play
anymore
or
we
wouldn't
have
districts.
I
mean
that
completely
defeats
the
purpose,
so
I
have
been
told
our
clg
funding
would
be
withheld
if
something
like
this
doesn't
go
through
the
process,
which
would
be
an
hpc
recommendation
to
council
to
undesignate
property,
but
it
needs
to
be
cottage
hill
as
a
whole.
E
F
That
when
we
updated
the
code
last
spring
and
basically
it's
to
run
the
process
in
reverse
that,
and
we
did
that
with
the
powder
magazine
neighborhood,
which
ended
up
with
so
many
vacant
lots
it
no
longer
met
the
criteria
that
got
it
designated
in
the
first
place.
So
cottage
hill
on
the
whole
would
have
to
be
surveyed
and
found
to
not
meet
the
criteria
that
got
it
designated
in
the
first
place,
which
isn't
going
to
happen.
F
F
So
do
we
just
let
the
the
table
ride
and
see?
What
happens?
Do
you
all?
If,
if
you
deny
it,
that
would
mean
two
things
if,
if
they
have
to,
if
they
don't
get
cut
out
of
the
district,
and
they
have
to
come
back
to
you
and
their
original
submission
was
denied,
they
could
appeal
that
decision
in
circuit
court
or
they
could
resubmit,
but
they
could
not
resubmit
the
same
plan
that
was
submitted
initially,
it
would
have
to
be
modified
to
be
resubmitted.
F
E
I
can
guarantee
you
on
the
on
the
list
of
priorities
of
this,
considering
that
I
don't
remember
how
many
homicides
and
other
violent,
offenses
and
whatnots
are
pending
in
the
circuit
courts.
This
is
not
going
to
get
a
lot
of
attention
anytime
soon,
again,
I'm
not
going
to
be
here.
I
don't,
if
you
don't
want
to
let
it
ride
until
april.
I
can
be
here.
I
feel
certain
I
will
be
here
to
participate
and
make
whatever
motion
is
necessary
to
con
nothing,
I'm
prejudging
anything
but.
F
E
E
G
G
E
F
F
Yeah,
it's
not
a
good
traffic
flow
and
I
would
add
that
there
there
I
got
a
conceptual
submission
for
the
next
vacant
corner,
which
also
doesn't
fit,
and
you
know
if
it's
it's.
You
know
we
talked
about
it
before.
That's
the
first
domino.
We
got
one
chance
to
get
this
right
and
whether
it's
y'all
making
the
right
decision
or
hopefully,
the
powers
that
be
having
some
wherewithal
and
saying
you
know
we're
going
to
do
this
for
our
residents.
But
if,
if
that
happens,
you
all
will
never
see
this.
E
E
A
F
And
I
know
there's
been
resistance
and
I'm
sure
cruz
probably
has
seen
this.
You
know
with
with
gas
stations
adjacent
to
some
of
our
neighborhoods.
I
know
it's
an
issue
in
capitol
heights.
It's
been
there's
that
sort
of
marathon
or
chevron
on
carter
hill
road,
where
someone's
decided
they
wanted
to
start
selling
liquor.
You
know
you
know
getting
the
beer
and
liquor
licenses
that
go
with
it,
which
don't
get
me
wrong.
F
E
I
was
still
going
to
do
something
I
I
agree
and
again
I'm
not
going
to
be
here
next
month,
but
my
thinking
was
there's
no
reason
to
let
this
thing
float
for
ever,
and
so
you
know
if
they
make
the
modifications,
hey
look
at
them.
If
you
know,
if
they're,
not
if
they're
just
going
to
hey,
we
presented
what
we
presented
y'all,
please
make
a
decision.
Okay,
we
can.