►
From YouTube: Montgomery Architectural Review Board (3/22/22)
Description
1. PRESENTED BY: Denton Hawk
SUBJECT: Request for approval of roof replacement for the property located at 635 Martha Street (Cottage Hill).
2. PRESENTED BY: Tracey Campbell
SUBJECT: Request for approval of a driveway gate for the property located at 3308 Montezuma Road (Cloverdale Idlewild).
3. PRESENTED BY: Janet Allen
SUBJECT: Request for approval of a front yard fence for the property located at 3010 Cloverdale Road (Cloverdale Idlewild).
4. PRESENTED BY: Rennie Vainstein
SUBJECT: Request for approval of sanctuary window replacement for the property located at 1728 S. Hull Street (Trinity Presbyterian Church, Garden District).
5. PRESENTED BY: Rennie Vainstein
SUBJECT: Request for approval of alterations to an existing vestibule/connector for the property located at 1728 S. Hull Street (Trinity Presbyterian Church, Garden District).
6. PRESENTED BY: James Rolen
SUBJECT: Request for approval after the fact of door replacements for the property located at 1103 Magnolia Curve (Cloverdale) VIOLATION
The next Architectural Review Board meeting will be April 26, 2022 @ 5:30 p.m.
A
Without
compensation,
our
procedure
for
conducting
business
is
that
the
petitioner
for
each
item
will
be
asked
to
come
forward
state
your
name
and
present
his
or
her
request.
Please
come
to
that
podium
and
adjust
the
microphone
so
that
it
picks
up
your
voice
so
that
we
will
have
a
record
of
it
for
the
minutes.
A
Our
procedure
for
conducting
business
is
this.
The
board
will
ask
any
questions.
They
may
have
that
anyone
wishing
to
speak
the
proposal
will
be
asked
to
come
forward
and
voice
their
opinion.
Each
side
will
have
10
minutes
to
speak.
If
there
are
two
sides
to
the
issue,
all
comments
should
be
about
the
project
being
presented.
This
is
not
a
venue
to
air
personal
grievances.
A
If
you
hear
the
gavel,
you
are
out
of
order
and
if
you
persist,
you
will
be
removed
from
the
meeting
once
your
request
is
heard
and
the
board's
decision
is
rendered.
You
may
leave
the
meeting.
However,
if
you
have
questions
for
staff,
please
wait
until
after
the
meeting
is
over
to
ask
them
or
you
may
contact
them
at
the
office
the
next
day.
A
Members
with
a
personal
or
financial
interest
in
any
request
are
required
to
recuse
themselves
from
voting
all
decisions
by
the
architectural
review
border
final,
a
person
having
a
request
for
a
certificate
of
appropriateness
denied
by
the
board
may
appeal,
such
now
to
the
montgomery
county
circuit
court.
Any
such
appeal
shall
be
filed
with
the
circuit
court
within
30
days
of
the
receipt
of
the
final
notice
of
the
board.
A
A
Let
me
introduce
the
the
members
of
the
board
who
are
here
tonight.
I'm
elizabeth
brown
and
j
barry
robinson.
Thank
you,
john
foshee,
hillary
morgan
and
khalia
bell.
Oh
katie,
I'm
sorry.
I
skipped
right
over
you,
katie
katie
williams,
all
right
land
use
staff,
christy
anderson,
paula
wade,
russell
stringer
and
ethan
fowler
all
right.
The
first.
A
B
B
A
B
A
One
of
my
favorite
architecture,
professors
at
auburn,
said
that
it
was
never
wrong
to
do
the
dumb
thing
and
by
dumb
he
meant
ordinary,
and
so
I
think
that
a
shingle
roof
in
this
case
is
probably
a
good
idea
and
one
that
anybody
can
fix
and
you
should
be
able
to
get
better
service
out
of
it.
Is
there
any
comments
from
the
audience.
D
D
A
D
F
D
F
G
E
H
H
The
church
was
rebuilt
in
1952
after
a
fire
had
burnt
everything
except
the
masonry
walls,
and
since
then,
we've
had
an
organ
installation
in
the
mid-80s
and
a
coat
of
paint
and
some
new
carpet.
But
no
real
maintenance
has
been
done
on
the
building
and
we're
in
a
project
right
now
to
upgrade
all
of
the
systems.
H
H
H
But
the
monument
series
was
specifically
designed
to
be
compatible
with
historic
renovations.
They
they
can
match
the
scale
and
the
sizing
the
the
profiles
of
all
the
check,
rails
and
and
the
rails
and
styles
and
and
and
the
putty
glazing
that
kind
of
thing.
So
obviously
we're
going
to
match
exactly
what's
up
there,
daylight
openings
will
remain
exactly
the
same.
The
glazing
will
match.
We
currently
have
a
slightly
obscure
glass
on
the
single
glazed
windows
and
the
interior
glazing
will
be
the
slightly
obscure
glass
again.
H
H
The
window
bottoms
are
about
12
and
a
half
feet
above
your
head,
and
then
we've
got
about
a
30
30-foot
planter,
so
you're
you're,
really
very
far
away
from
the
windows
and
on
the
on
the
west
side
of
the
building.
There's
only
one
exposed
window,
the
rest
of
the
windows
are
obscured
by
a
covered
walkway,
which
was
built
in
front
of
them,
but
anyway
this
would
go
a
long
way
towards
helping
the
envelope
of
the
building.
G
H
H
Okay,
so
my
second
item
on
the
list
is
also
part
of
the
work
that
we're
doing
to
upgrade
the
campus,
and
it
involves
a
small
portion
of
the
building
that
was
originally
an
open
porch
years
and
years
ago,
and
over
the
years
has
been
filled
in
sometimes
successfully.
Sometimes
not
so
much
with
various
things
to
you
know,
connect
the
education
building
and
and
the
main
sanctuary,
and
it
was
not
the
1984
edition.
H
We
would
like
to
remove
the
storefront
all
together
and
we'll
actually
remove
a
good
portion,
the
porch,
the
columns,
everything
will
come
down
and
they
are
going
to
either
replace
or
they
might
clean
the
columns
and
put
them
back
up
depending
on
the
state
of
the
columns
when
they
get
them
down.
But
they'll
have
to
rebuild
all
the
rotting
trim
and
everything
and
then
on
the
stucco
part
of
the
wall,
which
is
above
the
little
porch
we'd
like
to
go
in
with
the
thin
bricks.
H
We
found
a
brick
that
matches
the
building
and
we
think
we
can
get
them
cut
into
the
thin
bricks
and
go
back.
Take
the
stucco
off,
put
the
put
the
scratch
coat
and
apply
the
thin
bricks
to
match
the
building
so
that
there
will
no
longer
be
a
a
clear-cut
connector.
That's
a
different
material
from
everything
else.
The
brick
will
be
continuous
they'll
have
the
brick
wall
below
where
the
storefront
was
removed,
we're
replacing
the
door
which
we
need
to
replace
anyway,
because
it
needs
to
be
an
a
a
panic
hardware
exit
door.
H
That
door
will
go
from
the
6-8
door
now
to
an
eight-foot
door,
which
is
more
compatible
with
all
of
the
other
doors
and
openings
on
the
building
campus.
The
design
of
the
door
matches
the
other
building
the
other
doors
that
are
on
the
campus
and
then
we'd
like
to
instead
of
storefront,
obviously
put
some
windows
that
match
the
existing
windows
on
the
building,
and
they
too
would
be
the
monument
series
just
like
what
would
go
in
the
sanctuary
with
the
same
detailing
and
color
matched,
and
everything
like
that
will
match.
H
D
I
Trying
to
do
some
remodeling
or
some
improvements
to
this
property
that
I
bought
approximately
two
years
ago,
some
of
the
renters
had
mentioned
that
they
were
concerned
about
the
glass
doors
on
the
back
of
the
on
the
back
doors.
Their
concerns
were
the
exposure
back
there
that
somebody
could
break
through
the
glass
so
actually
upon
their
suggestions.
I
Door
at
the
top
is
a
common
door
when
you
step
through
that
door,
there's
two
additional
doors
that
are,
you
know
secure
doors,
and
you
know
I
may
eventually
replace
it
as
well,
but
right
now
it
doesn't
have
to
be
replaced
as
money
allows.
I'm
trying
to
do
some
improvements
such
as
this
and
replaced
some
rotted
windows
and
things
of
that
nature.
I
J
We
had
our
meeting
last
night
and
we
agree
with
christie,
anderson
or
whoever
came
up
with
the
recommendation
that
the
demalone
door,
not
doors,
not
be
approved
and
that
the
front
door
be
either
the
suggestion
here
with
the
four
rectangular
lights
or
a
sort
of
standard
colonial
crossing
bible
door
like
is
currently
there
and
since
that
is
about
the
most
popular
door.
There
is
at
places
like
lowe's,
even
though
it's
an
18th
century
style,
you
could
find
multiple
types.
J
A
Well,
I
can
understand
your
desire
to
improve
the
security
situation,
but
this
door
with
the
half
rounded
light
is
not
a
good
match
for
what
was
there.
If
you've
got
a
good
carpenter,
he
can
probably
take
these
doors
and
cut
up
even
with
a
steel
door,
cut
a
larger
thing
and
put
a
square
window
a
rectangular
window
in
there,
like
that,
one
yeah,
like
the
one
that
christy
put
the
window
and
a
door
like
the
one
that
christy
put
the
picture
on,
did
you
get
a
copy
of
that?
G
D
G
K
K
I
D
I
K
E
E
G
G
G
E
Due
to
the
character,
not
keeping
with
the
character
of
the
property,
if
you
want
me
to
resale
that
or
do
we
have
it
and
the
square
windows
would
be
and
the
square
windows
would
be
approved
so
trying
one
more
time
we're
just
making
sure
it's
worked
right.
Okay,
we
move
to
approve
the
front
door
as
presented
with
the
square
windows
at
the
top,
and
we
move
to
deny
the
backdoor
s
submitted,
with
the
exception
that
we
would
approve
the
doors
if
they
are
retrofitted
to
have
the
square
lights
as
at
the
top
like
the
front.