►
From YouTube: Heritage Preservation Board May 1, 2017
Description
Heritage Preservation Board Regular Meeting 5-1-2017
A
A
A
And
will
public
comments
if
there's
anybody
that
has
any
public
comments
you
can
step
forward
state
your
name
and
address
for
the
record
and
you'd
have
two
minutes,
and
this
would
be
four
items
not
on
our
agenda
and
seeing
you
none
will
go
on
with
our
quasi-judicial
announcement
in
swearing-in
of
speakers.
Please.
C
This
is
a
quasi-judicial
proceeding
where
the
Heritage
Preservation
Board
acts
in
a
quasi-judicial,
rather
than
a
legislative
capacity
at
a
quasi-judicial
hearing.
It
is
not
the
board's
function
to
make
law,
but
rather
to
apply
law
that
has
already
been
established
in
a
quasi-judicial
hearing.
The
board
is
required
by
law
to
make
findings
of
fact,
based
upon
the
events
presented
at
the
hearings
and
apply
those
findings
of
fact,
the
previously
established
criteria
contained
in
the
Code
of
Ordinances
in
order
to
make
a
legal
decision
regarding
the
application
before
it.
E
Okay,
this
is
case
17:41.
The
property
is
located
at
111,
East,
torqueman,
Avenue
and
the
applicant
is
requesting
to
allow
for
the
replacement
of
the
front
windows
and
doors
on
the
structure
and
replace
the
existing
metal
buildings
located
behind
the
structure.
The
owner
is
bear
Haven,
land
company
and
the
applicant
is
Leyland
Johansson,
be
contributing
historic
structures,
a
two-story
masonry
vernacular
commercial
building,
which
once
was
one
of
Tarpon,
Springs
earliest
general
stores.
E
The
store
was
operated
by
brothers,
James
and
LB
Benson
until
the
1920s
Aldi
Vinson
also
became
an
undertaker
and
started
a
funeral
parlor,
which
was
originally
located
behind
this
building
on
our
street,
the
Vincennes
funeral
home.
We
located
the
456
feet
orphan
Avenue
and
is
still
in
operation
constructed
a
rusticated,
concrete
block.
The
building
still
has
early
intact
storefronts
with
cast-iron
columns
at
the
first
floor
level.
The
second
floor
level
has
been
stuccoed
over,
but
the
original
fenestration
is
still
evident.
E
The
two-story
covered
deck
seen
in
earlier
photos
of
the
building
has
been
removed
from
the
building.
However,
in
1980
the
second
floor
was
stuccoed
and
windows
on
the
first
or
most
likely
covered
up
and
replaced
the
roof
is
a
built-up,
shed
type
roof
and
exterior
the
structure
is
rusticated
concrete
block
in
stock
up.
There
are
two
angled
recess
entries
which
are
proposed
to
be
retained.
E
The
applicant
is
proposing
to
replace
two
metal
storage
buildings
which
currently
exist
behind
the
main
building
and
which
have
become
extremely
weathered
and
dilapidated.
The
applicant
would
like
to
remove
the
two
decomposing
sheds
and
replace
them
with
two
new
steel
metals
buildings
that
meet
the
same
size,
shape
and
mass
of
the
older
structures
and
locate
them
on
the
existing
concrete
slabs.
The
new
metal
buildings
will
have
an
exterior
that
may
be
its
elapsed.
A
lap,
siding
metal,
material
and
forced
rock
material
is
proposed
for
the
area
between
the
two
structures.
E
The
applicant
is
also
proposing
to
replace
a
single
pane
existing
front
with
front
doors
and
windows.
On
the
first
floor
with
clear
glass,
transom
style,
one
over
one,
panes,
adding
lattice
style
trim
on
the
upper
windows,
the
window
and
door
replacements
are
proposed
to
meet
the
ADA,
a
and
hurricane.
E
In
fact,
so,
both
new
bronze
windows
separators
will
be
added
on
the
window
that
approved
two
items:
the
upper
and
lower
storey
awnings,
which
are
planned
to
be
replaced
and
the
lighting
on
the
Front's
of
facade,
which
is
will
be
replaced
under
the
awning,
the
review
criteria
in
Regina
and
application
for
certificate
approval.
The
board
shall
consider
the
following
design
guideline
criteria
for
tuning
to
this
application
that
accessory
structures
such
as
a
shed
shall
be
located
within
the
rear
or
side
yard,
and
closest
to
the
rear
yard.
E
C
E
Architectural
design
of
accessory
structures
is
important
if
they
are
owned
within
the
public
view.
Original
and/or
new
windows
should
be
should
not
be
highly
attended
and
replacement
to
worship
match
the
design
and
opening
of
their
original
Dewar
in
reviewing
an
application
for
certificate
approval,
the
board
shall
consider
the
following
criteria:
number
one,
the
height
and
width
of
any
proposed
alteration
or
new
construction
shall
be
consistent
without
of
the
adjacent
contributing
structures
and
with
those
of
similar
character
and
architectural
style
found
throughout
the
immediate
neighbourhood
or
the
district.
E
Staffs
analysis
found
that
the
proposed
metal
accessory
structures
will
have
the
same
dimensions
massing
in
height
of
the
original
structures
and
will
not
impact
the
main
structure.
The
guidelines
recognize
the
commercial
uses
mean,
may
need
accessory
structures
for
storage
purposes
and
requires
that
they
are
located
within
the
rear
yard,
as
proposed.
The
existing
storage
structures
were
not
recognized
on
the
Florida
master
site
file
as
being
historic,
and
the
city
has
already
officially
recognized
and
listed
these
two
structures
as
being
condemned
requiring
their
removal.
E
The
proposed
front,
doors
and
windows
are
very
similar
to
what
is
present
with
exception
to
the
lattice
trim.
Being
proposed,
however,
this
same
pattern
was
approved
recently
on
a
neighboring
structure
and
is
not
anticipated
that
the
added
design
will
detract
from
historical
significance
or
fianc
of
the
structure
number
two,
that
the
width
and
height
of
windows,
doors
and
entries
shall
be
consistent
with
the
character.
E
Number
3,
the
relationship
of
the
structure
within
an
historical
cultural
preservation,
district
to
the
open
space
between
it
and
the
street
and
to
other
buildings
or
scenic
views,
vistas
or
streetscape
characterizing.
The
area
shall
be
protected
through
a
site
plan,
review
process,
addressing
setbacks
with
lines,
garage
placement,
parking
and
access
analysis
in
the
use
of
landscaping.
Jazz
findings
are
that
all
the
improvements
proposed
have
been
reviewed
for
the
city's
technical
review
committee
to
ensure
compliance
with
the
city's
land
development.
E
So
the
committee
recommended
approval
of
the
improvements
number
for
the
shape
and
texture
of
the
roof
shall
replicate
the
shape,
texture
and
type
of
roof,
distinguishing
the
building's
original
architecture
and
on
structures
of
similar
style
and
age,
with
an
historic
and
cultural
preservation.
District
snaps
findings
are
that
the
shape
and
type
of
the
roost
for
the
new
accessory
structures
replicate
the
roofs
of
the
existing
metal
structures,
the
new
structures
fit
into
the
same
footprint
and
have
the
same
dimensions
as
the
existing
structures
and
are
obviously
more
aesthetic
and
appearance
than
the
existing
structure.
E
Number
5
besides
a
mass
or
shape
of
the
building
after
alteration,
shall
be
reflective
of
the
building's
original
architectural
style.
The
size
of
mass
stands
for
shape
of
a
proposed
structure
should
reflect
the
character
of
contributing
buildings
within
the
district,
as
well
as
those
immediately
surrounding
the
subject.
Property
and
shall
include
review
of
the
architectural
elements
such
as
roof
lines,
fenestration
and
other
components
of
facade
design.
E
Staffs
analysis
is
that
staff
is
of
the
opinion
that
the
proposed
facade
modifications
will
enhance
the
downtown
town
area
and
reflect
the
character
of
other
contributing
structures
within
the
neighborhood
and
district
number.
6
landscaping
shall
be
utilized,
as
means
to
enhance
the
architectural
character.
We
do
not
find
this
particular
one
livable
number
7,
distinctive
architectural
features
shall
be
repaired
rather
than
replaced
wherever
possible
architectural
details,
including
color
materials,
fixture
and
site
lighting,
shall
be
treated
so
as
to
make
the
building
structure
or
traditional
cultural
property
consistent
with
the
property's
original
architectural
style
and
character.
E
New
materials
should
replicate
the
materials
being
placed
and
composition,
design,
color,
texture
and
other
visual
qualities.
Staffs
findings
are
that
the
materials
proposed
replicate
the
existing
features
being
replaced
in
composition,
design,
color
and
texture,
and
other
visual
qualities,
number
8,
all
building
structures,
sites
and
traditional
cultural.
They
shall
be
recognized
as
products
of
their
own
time
and
alterations.
Modifications
or
other
changes
to
a
structure
shall
not
attempt
to
create
an
earlier
appearance
in
the
original
date
of
construction.
E
Sass
findings
are
that
the
addition,
the
additions
are
not
expected
to
create
an
earlier
appearance,
number
9,
the
renovation
of
contributing
structures
and
a
historic
cultural
district
or
designated
site
shall
meet
the
Secretary
of
Interior
standards
for
rehabilitation
and
guidelines
for
rehabilitating
historic
buildings.
Staffs
findings
are
that
replacement
of
the
front
windows
and
doors
meet
the
Secretary
of
Interior
standards
for
rehabilitation
and
guidelines
for
rehabilitating
historic
buildings,
number
10.
E
Therefore,
staffs
recommendations
are
for
approval
of
the
applicants.
Certificate
of
approval,
requests
for
number-one
demolition
of
existing
metal
storage
structures
in
the
reorder
property
number
2,
replacement
of
the
storage
doctors
with
two
new
steel
storage,
accessory
structures
with
horizontal
off-site
and
facade
of
clearance.
Number
three:
the
dimensions
of
square
footage
of
the
replacement,
metal
storage
structures
shall
not
exceed
the
dimensions
and
square
footage
of
the
original
structures
and
shall
be
placed
within
the
same
footprint
of
the
original
structure.
A
Thanks
so
at
this
time
this
would
be
best
to
ask
any
questions
that
we
have
in
the
city
in
question.
I
have
one
the
size
of
the
accessory
buildings.
Is
there
a
reason
that
they
can't
if
they
had
wanted
to
exceed
the
current
size,
that's
being
demolished?
In
other
words,
if
there
weren't
any
accessory
structures
there
now,
but
it
was
just
vacant
and
the
code
or
guidelines
allow
for
accessory
structures,
and
they
wanted
to
put
something
there
that's
bigger
than
what's
there
now.
Would
that
be
acceptable?
A
E
Not
recommend
it
because
of
leaves
number
five.
Besides,
a
massive
shape
of
the
building
after
alteration
shall
be
reflected
at
buildings
original
now.
These
weren't
cited
in
the
florida
master
file
but
I
think
anything
larger
than
what
they.
What
they're
proposing
we've
got
to
kind
of
be
careful
with
the
roof,
tiles
and
the
heights
of
those
as
compared
to
the
original
stuff.
Okay,.
A
D
C
A
A
C
C
D
E
Actually
I
haven't
spoken
to
Heather
about
that
and
wise
because
she
has
her
intern
working
on.
Those
did
I
mentioned
that
to
you
before
so
I,
don't
know
how
far
they
have
gotten
on
it.
The
intern
has
done
quite
a
bit
of
research
on
other
communities
and
she's
actually
picked
out
before
the
interim
came
on
there.
There
were
few
that
I
had
picked
out,
she's,
actually
picking
out
two
same
ones
when
I
think
that
which
is
a
good
sign,
but
we
can
ask
I
can
ask
her
tomorrow.
Can.
A
We
add
to
that
to
the
agenda
for
every
meeting
from
here
on
out,
since
that's
a
working
item.
That
is
something
we're
all
have
a
interest
in
and
it's
important
to
the
citizens
of
Tarpon
Springs
to
know
how
that's
moving
forward
and
then
every
month
that
we
meet
be
prepared
with
a
update
on
that
thanks.
A
And
then
number
two
I
would
ask
our
our
bylaws
our
rule
state
in
rule
2
to
an
attendance
member
shall
notify
the
city
staff
person
assigned
to
the
board
of
his
or
her
designee
if
they
are
not
going
to
attend
a
meeting.
If
a
member
misses
two
out
of
three
consecutive
meetings
without
cause
and
without
prior
approval
of
the
chairperson,
the
member
shall
forfeit
is
her
appointment.
A
Can
we
reach
out
to
mr.
Tunstall
and
find
out
if
these
do
we
have
their
prior
knowledge
of
him
not
attending,
or
is
there
a
way
we
can
ask
him
if
he
wants
to
maintain
I,
don't
want
to
just
say
this:
is
the
rule
notified
the
commissioners
that
we
have
an
opening?
That's
not
very
gracious,
so
can
we
find
out
if
he
has
an
interest
of
and.
C
C
I
think
the
Board
of
Commissioners,
from
my
understanding,
is
working
on
filling
all
of
these
voids
in
a
lot
of
the
boards
and
also
working
on
a
possible
ordinance
to
make
sure
that
that
that
specific
rule
is
modified
and
gained
for
the
board,
so
that
we
make
sure
that
we
keep
our
boards
filled
with
people
and
have
a
smooth
removal
process
of
some
of
the
EP
removes.
Because
of
the
pendants.
C
C
C
A
Going
to
defer
to
you
for
meetings
that
don't
feel
like
you
have
to
read
that
full
paragraph
we've
all
heard
it
a
million
times
before.
Okay,
if
there's
something
pertinent
in
it
that
you
really
want
to
highlight
that
you
feel
that
we
should
hear
then
I
think
that
would
be
okay,
but
don't
feel
you
know,
especially
if
there's
not
an
application.
You
just
say
six,
like
you:
did
the
landscaping
you've
read
these
said
kind
of
in
general
about
landscaping,
those
nothing
so
just
save.