►
Description
City of Boston Licensing Board Violations Hearing 09/26/23
A
A
Good
morning,
this
is
a
hearing
before
the
licensing
board
for
the
city
of
Boston.
Today
is
Tuesday
September
26
2023..
Today's
hearing
is
being
held
pursuant
to
Temporary
amendments
to
the
open
meeting
law.
That
is
what
allows
us
to
meet.
Virtually
today's
hearing
is
being
recorded
and
will
be
posted
to
the
city
of
Boston's
website.
B
C
A
Ensure
that
your
audio
and
visuals
are
working
properly,
I
will
call
each
item
in
the
order
that
it
appears
on
this
morning's
agenda.
I
will
then
ask
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
Boston
Police
Department,
and
whether
there
are
any
other
individuals
with
first-hand
knowledge
of
the
alleged
incident.
A
A
Again,
all
testimony
will
be
limited
only
to
those
individuals
with
first-hand
personal
knowledge
of
the
alleged
incident,
beginning
with
the
first
item
on
this
morning's
agenda.
Calling
item
number
one:
Old,
Trafford
Inc
doing
business
as
Paradise
located
at
967
Commonwealth
Ave
dated
the
incident
March
23rd
2023
and
over
served
intoxicated
Patron
in
violation
of
that
general
laws.
Chapter
138,
section
64.,
who
is
present
on
behalf
of
the
licensee
good.
D
Morning
attorney
Greene
Madam,
chairman
of
the
board
Dennis
quilty
attorney
representing
the
licensee
with
us
this
morning,
Patrick
Declan,
Meegan
who's,
the
manager
of
record
Joseph
Dunn,
also
in
the
ownership
structure
of
this
licensee
and
Bill
Guerra.
Who
was
the
manager
on
record
and
who
signed
the
inspection
notice
of
the
night
in
question
good
morning.
A
E
A
F
A
E
Yes,
about
909
pm
on
Thursday
March,
23,
2023
officer
Burke
in
the
kilo
414
Frank
unit
responded
to
a
radio
call
for
an
unconscious
female
in
the
bathroom
at
the
paradise
Rock
Club
967
Commonwealth
Ave
in
Brighton,
the
kilo
980
start
to
detect
the
Fitzgerald
myself
and
Keel
908
Sergeant
Murphy
also
responded.
Staff
had
called
9-1-1
when
they
discovered
a
female
unresponsive.
Excuse
me
on
the
floor.
E
In
the
bathroom
staff
stated,
they
were
eventually
able
to
get
the
female
victim
later
identified
as
Gabriella
Sanchez
date
of
birth
of
7-2
2003
up
and
she
was
able
to
walk
outside
to
a
bench.
Outside
The
Establishment,
which
was
met
by
offices,
Boston,
EMS
and
Boston.
Fire
were
also
on
on
scene
Sanchez,
who
was
responsible
and
able
to
sit
up
with
assistance,
was
unable
to
keep
her
eyes
open
and
was
very
sluggish.
E
A
Alpha
09
transported
Sanchez
to
Beth
Israel
Hospital
for
further
evaluation.
A
friend
who
was
with
Sanchez,
stated
that
someone
was
passing
around
a
blunt
in
in
the
pit
of
the
dance
floor
and
Sanchez
had
smoked
too
much
of
it.
The
kilo
908
and
kilo
980
conducted
at
code
35
on
the
establishment
and
issued
citation
number
zero
zero.
Eight
five:
oh
two.
D
E
D
E
D
G
D
I
H
Business
is
exactly
as
a
as
a
stated
in
the
police
report.
I
was
called
Down
by
security
notified
that
there
was
a
female
discovered
in
the
bathroom
unconscious
by
the
time
I
got
downstairs,
staff
had
already
called
EMS,
I
called
9-1-1,
and
they
were
on
the
way
and
by
this
part
of
the
the
young
woman
was
being
escorted
out
onto
the
sidewalk
and
seated
bench
outside
the
venue.
The
EMS
and
police
arrived.
H
D
D
J
D
She
was
seeing
smoking
it's
It's,
oddly
enough
and
we've
seen
this
before
the
entire
level
that
this
person
was
on
is
open,
standing
room.
It's
there.
There
are
no
seats
or
the
establishment,
except
for
special
special
events,
which
might
be
seated
for
a
smaller
show.
So
there
is
no
pit
as
such.
The
entire
floor
is
open
and
people
stand
so.
H
Sure
yeah,
normally
on
nights
like
this,
we
have
one
security
guard
standard
on
the
sort
of
a
landing
for
the
staircase,
that's
keeping
the
stairs
clear
and
also
keeping
an
eye
on
the
floor.
We
also
have
guards
positioned
as
sort
of
bookends
on
either
end
of
the
stage,
keeping
an
eye
on
that
the
center
dance
floor,
and
then
we
have
the
roamers
as
well,
so
usually
two
two
to
three
roamers
at
a
time
walking
through
the
area
trying
to
keep
an
eye
on
things.
H
We
did
we,
we
do
had
shows
of
this
nature.
We
do
observe
smoking
and
we
do
our
best
to
contain
it.
But
it's
difficult
and
the
crowd
is,
a
lot
of
people
are
lighting
up
and
you
know
we
we
always
try
to.
You,
know,
police
it
and
tell
them
to
put
it
out
as
often
as
we
can,
but
sometimes
it's
a
little
tricky.
G
B
G
B
H
Essentially,
anytime,
someone
in
either
a
rumor
or
someone
on
the
stairs
or
someone
in
our
barricade
area.
If
we,
if
we
have
a
barricade
up,
you
know
anytime,
we
see
someone
lighting
up
anything
whether
it's
you
know
whether
it's
a
blunt
or
if
it
could
be.
You
know
some
people
try
to
be
inside
the
menu
and
anytime
it
that's
observed.
We
always
tell
them.
You
know,
please
put
that
out
or
we're
gonna
have
to
ask
you
to
leave.
B
A
Matter
under
advisement.
Thank
you.
Thank
you.
Item
number.
Two
has
been
continued
to
the
next
available
hearing
date.
Calling
item
number
three
jajaj
Inc
doing
business
as
Tavern
in
the
Square
Austin,
located
at
161
to
165
Brighton
Ave
in
Austin,
go
to
the
incident.
March
24th
2023
Patron
injured
on
premise,
in
violation
of
mass
generalize,
chapter
138,
section
64.
who's
present
on
behalf
of.
M
A
A
N
A
P
She
was
conscious
at
the
time
of
interacting
with
all
medical
personnel
and
was
able
to
speak
coherently
victim,
had
a
cut
and
was
bleeding
from
her
forehead
on
the
right
side.
Officero
was
told
by
friends
that
she
had
tripped
on
one
of
her
friend's
legs,
but
this
one
of
the
security
staff
stated
that
she
had
fell
down.
P
A
short
flight
of
stairs
victim
was
given
pressure
dressing
and
walked
upstairs
to
a
stretch
and
taken
to
both
his
little
Deaconess
Hospital
Sergeant
McLaughlin
responded
and
conducted
a
code,
35
initial
violations
and
there's
a
supplemental
report
here
from
Sergeant
McLaughlin
who
reads
his
followers
officers,
who
responded
to
a
9-1-1
call
for
a
purchase.
Some
personal
unconscious,
a
Tavern
in
the
Square
on
arrival
officers
observed
the
victim
Megan
Michael,
the
Boston
University
student,
being
assisted
onto
a
structure
by
EMS
officers.
P
Not
not
able
to
get
a
straight
story
is
how
she'd
receives
a
cut.
The
first
story
she
had
tripped
and
another
story.
She
had
fallen
down.
The
stairs
Miss
Mike
was
having
trouble
speaking
while
she
was
in
the
ambulance.
Sergeant
McLaughlin
was
able
to
was
unable
to
tell
for
sure
if
she
was.
This
was
due
to
alcohol
consumption
or
the
the
blow
and
gas
that
she'd
received
to
her
head.
P
As
a
result,
a
licensed
premise
violation
was
issued
by
for
patreon
being
injured
on
the
I'm,
sorry
Patron
being
injured
on
the
premises,
a
violation
was
issued
by
Sergeant
McLaughlin
Chris
McGee,
the
general
manager
on
scene
signed,
acknowledged
and
receipt
of
the
citation.
That's
the
extent
of
the
police
reports.
M
I
would
I
don't
have
any
questions
for
the
officer's
attorney.
Greene
Madam,
chair
members
of
the
board,
I
provided
attorney
green
earlier
today
with
an
email
with
incident
reports
that
that
we
do
as
a
matter
of
course,
I
suggest
to
you
that
what
was
what
what
happened
on
this
particular
night
is
exactly
the
way
you
want
bar
owners
to
to
address
this
issue
immediately.
They
called
9-1-1
as
soon
as
they
found
the
person
was
injured,
EMS
and
the
police
showed
up.
M
They
immediately
did
an
incident
report
which
I've
provided
to
this
to
to
this
board
the
the
woman
herself
she
was.
She
did
not
provide
any
statements.
However,
she
was
with
provided
a
statement
which
says
and
I
provided
to
you.
We
had
a
drink
each
and
while
headed
to
the
toilet,
my
friend
tripped
over
my
leg
and
missed
a
step
and
fell
I
suggest
to
you
that
what
had
happened
is
she
missed
the
steps
she
tripped
over
a
friend's
eye.
M
She
had
high-heeled
shoes
on
that
was
observed
by
our
security
guard
and
she
just
tripped
going
down
to
to
make
sure
that
we
that
this
was
consistent.
We
went.
We
found
that
there
was
a
recording
of
a
sale
of
two
drinks
to
her
and
her
friend
on
this
particular
night.
So
not
only
is
the
is
the
statement
from
the
witness
consistent
but
the,
but
the
backup
showing
that
she
they
did
only
have
one
drink
is
consistent.
M
I
suggest
you
that
this
is
just
an
accident
that
happened,
there's
no
violation
of
of
138,
and
you
know
it
was
handled
the
way
you
want
these
bar
owners
to
handle
it
call
the
police
and
let
them
come
in
and
do
an
incident
report
to
make
sure
that
you've
done
everything
on
your
end,
so
I'm
not
sure,
there's
much
more.
That
I
can
talk
about,
but
I
certainly
have
Max
here.
Unfortunately,
Mr
McGee
is
out
of
state
on
vacation,
something
he
didn't
take
all
summer.
M
B
M
B
C
M
A
N
A
A
N
P
As
officers
parked
across
the
street
and
approached
the
establishment
officer,
Diaz
activated
his
body
Walling
camera,
as
they're
approaching
they
observed
a
line
to
enter,
had
been
formed
to
the
right
of
the
front
door.
On
the
left.
There
were
a
number
of
people
congregating,
one
of
the
staff
was
speaking
loudly
to
a
patron
whom
they
appear
to
have
just
removed
from
inside
the
bar,
as
the
officers
approached
the
front
door,
Sergeant
McLaughlin
toward
told
the
doorman
that
he
was
there
to
check
the
licenses.
He
asked
the
doorman
to
see
a
clicker
to
check.
P
The
number
of
people
inside
did
not
show
clicker.
Nor
did
he
look
at
one,
but
he
said
that
they
had
175
people
inside
the
sergeant
knew
from
past
visits
to
the
bar's
maximum
occupancy
is
exactly
100.
175
Dr,
McLaughlin
McLaughlin
entered
the
establishment
with
officer
Diaz
and
immediately
began
to
inspect
and
record
the
license
numbers
when
he
finished
writing
the
license.
Premise
form
from
the
inside
the
inside
doorman
come
over.
Sergeant
McLaughlin
asked
him
to
see
a
clicker
said,
and
he
said
that
there
was
195
persons
in
there.
P
P
The
place
was
clearly
over
122
because
it
was
wall-to-wall
people,
Sergeant
McLaughlin,
from
the
drama
that
he
had
to
have
an
accurate
count
on
the
clicker.
At
all
times,
a
licensed
premise:
violation
was
issued
for
being
overcrowded,
based
on
a
sub
on
the
Sergeant's
observations,
combined
with
multiple
numbers
that
he
were
told
by
two
different
dormant.
It
was
also
it
was
also
noted
on
the
violation.
There
was
not
a
clicker
present
at
the
door
and
the
one
they
finally
produced
was
clearly
incorrect.
P
Sergeant
McLaughlin
asked
to
speak
to
Mike
and
Judy
was
identified
as
Kristin
who
was
directed
me
outside,
where
I
met
where
Sergeant
question
Sergeant
McLaughlin
explained
that
they
were
indeed
needed
to
have
an
accurate
account
and
a
person
with
a
clicker
at
the
door.
At
all
times,
he
told
Kristen
that
he
was
issuing
a
violation
for
being
overcrowded
based
on
the
answers
that
he
had
been
given
and
the
observations
he
had
made.
P
P
He
again
explained
to
her
that
it
was
a
responsibility
for
that
person
at
the
door
to
have
an
accurate
account
with
the
plugger
question,
told
Sergeant
McLaughlin
that
she
want.
She
wanted
it
written
down,
but
he
refused
to
go
through
and
do
account
Sergeant
McLaughlin
founder
that
it
was
all
recorded
on
officer,
Diaz's
body
camera
Kristen
signed
for
the
violation
she
informed,
Sergeant
McLaughlin
that
you
she
was
going
to
Fireball
to
the
doorman.
P
Sergeant
McLaughlin
explained
again
that
the
bar
had
a
responsibility
to
keep
an
accurate
count,
so
the
officers
can
check
when
they
show
up
for
an
inspection,
Serge
McLaughlin
now
subsidious
in
his
opinion,
the
size
of
crowd,
and
he
thought
it
was
well
over
the
allowed
amount
of
175.
That's
the
extent
of
the
police
report.
Thank.
N
Q
You
very
much
as
the
board
will
know.
This
was
at
the
end
of
the.
If
you
will
the
college
season
last
year
and
admittedly,
Thursday
night
is
our
and
we
we
got
a
little
bit
overwhelmed
them
that
night.
Actually
the
person
who
was
had
the
clicker
was
ins
had
to
help
inside
the
license
premises
because
of
a
scuffle
that
had
happened.
Q
So
when
the
police
came
the
person
the
person
who
had
the
clicker
was
not
there
and
the
doorman
tried
to
compensate
in
some
way,
we're
not
quite
sure
but
I'm
sure
the
board
that
they
have
been.
Let
go
since
the
start
of
the
new
school
year
and
as
looking
at
it
over
the
summer,
we
have
new
procedures
in
place.
The
first
procedure
is
is
that
we
now
have
three
door
men
on
the
door
as
soon
as
the
doorman
go
on
the
door.
Q
They
go
through
the
license
premises,
they
take
their
clickers
out
and
they
take
an
accurate
count
of
the
people
already
in
there.
That's
usually
a
very
low
number,
but
we
make
sure
that
the
doorman
all
have
the
same
number
on
their
clickers
and
they're
all
doing
it.
In
addition,
we
have
gotten
headsets
for
each
of
the
door,
men
so
that
they
can
talk
to
each
other
and
that
they
know
exactly
what's
going
on
and
there
is
designated
a
head
door
man
so
that
all
the
doorman
know
who
they
are
reporting
to.
Q
We
also
keep
a
doorman
on
the
rear
exit
of
the
license
premises.
Who
also
has
a
headset.
Nobody
is
allowed
to
enter
with
that
rear
exit,
but
that
doorman
is
on
the
headset
and
is
also
being
constantly
told
how
much
the
the
capacity
is
and
when
it's
met,
we've
instituted
a
new
program
to
make
sure
that
the
aisles
are
always
clear
and
that
we
are
able
to
get
people
in
and
out
of
the
license
premises
at
all
time.
Q
Since
we've
put
in
this
new
procedures,
we've
had
we've
really
had
no
problem
and
it
seems
to
be
working
pretty
well
since,
since
the
students
are
back,
the
president's
at
the
door
seems
to
be
working.
The
headsets
have
totally
upped
our
communication
skills
and
we
believe
that
that
we've
we've
gotten
a
much
better
handle
on
on
this.
A
D
Of
the
licensee
good
morning,
again
attorney
green
Madam,
chair
members
aboard
Dennis
quilty
attorney,
representing
the
licensee
with
us.
This
morning
is
Henry,
Wong,
the
owner
and
manager
of
record
and,
if
I'm
pronouncing
it
correctly
in
who's,
the
individual
who
signed
for
the
violation,
illness,
Gloria.
A
P
Yes,
happily,
thank
you
oops.
This
is
a
video
okay,
two
separate
reports
here,
the
first
one
officer,
John
Flaherty
and
reads
as
follows:
at
10,
21
pm
on
Saturday
April,
29,
2023
officer
Flaherty
responded
to
a
radio
call
for
an
unconscious
person
at
1
38
bright
enough
on
arrival.
At
stage
karaoke
officer
spoke
with
EMS,
who
are
transporting
victim.
Corey
Boudreau,
who
was
intoxicated
breathing,
but
not
awake
officer,
spoke
to
Mr
boudreau's
friend
John
Keith,
who
stated
that
he
believed
Boudreaux
may
be
allergic
to
fish.
P
Second
report
written
by
Sergeant
McLaughlin,
reads
as
follows:
at
about
12
30
a.m:
Sergeant
McLaughlin,
assisted
kilof,
498
officer
Colleen,
with
the
stage
karaoke
at
138
Bright
Now
for
the
purpose
of
issuing
a
license
premise:
violation
for
over
serving
a
patron
and
Corey
Woodrow
is
detailed.
In
the
original
report
on
arrival
officer,
Conley
activated
his
body,
worn
camera
Sergeant
McLaughlin
filled
out
the
violation
form
for
over
serving
a
patron,
the
manager
on
duty,
Patrick
Sweeney,
the
general
manager
on
duty
identified
himself
as
Mr
nulen
Mr.
P
No
one
stated
that
he
was
the
person
who
would
call
the
ambulance
for
the
victim.
As
noted
in
the
original
report,
the
victim
Boudreau
had
been
transported
from
stage
karaoke
Saint
Elizabeth
Hospital
for
passing,
passing
out
performing
a
second
song
on
stage
well.
At
district
14,
the
victim's
friend,
who
identified
himself
as
John
Keith,
came
into
district
14
and
sparked
spoke
to
Sergeant
McLaughlin.
P
P
He
said
he
thinks
Boudreau
had
a
number
of
drinks
before
arriving
at
stage.
Karaoke
Keith
said
that
when
he
got
to
Stage
karaoke
about
8
30
PM,
the
bar
gave
them
a
round
of
shots
for
Keith's
birthday.
Keith
said
that
they
also
ordered
another
round
of
shots
after
the
first
one,
according
to
Keith
Boudreau
had
an
amazing
voice
and
that
he
was
performing
a
second
song
on
stage
when
he
passed
out.
He
described
him
as
amazing
virtuoso.
P
He
said
the
Boudreaux
looked
like
he
stumbled
a
bit
and
that
one
of
the
bartender
said
something.
May
I
get
Boudreau
some
water
before
he
passed
out
well,
Sergeant,
McLaughlin
officer,
Conley
would
stage
karaoke
the
general
manager,
Mr
nawang
said
that
Boudreau
only
had
a
few
drinks
while
he
was
there.
Serge
McLaughlin
explained
that
he
would
have
the
opportunity
to
explain
his
side
before
the
board
of
the
hearing.
Sergeant
McLaughlin
also
suggests
that
he
preserve
any
video
to
back
up
the
story.
It's
also
a
lot
of
the
stage.
Karaoke
was
very
cooperative.
D
D
N
D
G
N
D
You
and
I
do
want
to
know
Madam
chair
just
so
you
have
it.
There
is
a
video
which
will
provide
to
you
of
this
individual,
basically
taking
the
stage.
If
you
will
to
sing
ing
in
the
literally
in
the
middle
of
a
song.
He
literally
just
backs
up
against
the
wall
and
appears
to
just
phase
out
with
no
forewarning
Etc.
D
B
B
R
B
D
R
R
R
D
R
R
B
R
D
R
K
K
L
G
L
A
T
A
A
A
A
U
U
About
306
a.m,
on
Sunday
May,
28,
2023
officer,
Feeney
and
LaRosa,
and
the
Delta
103
Alpha
respond
to
a
radio
call
for
shots.
Spotter
activation
at
280
Huntington
Ave
Boston
officers
were
assisted
by
the
Delta
912
Sergeant
Sullivan
Delta
101
Alpha
grachowski
and
Galvin
Delta
105
Enriquez
and
Jenner
Delta
Gold,
one
McDonald
and
Doherty
Delta
421
assigned
on
the
499
Delta
441
Mahoney
Channel
5
operations
advised
officers
that,
after
the
shot
spotter
activation,
several
911
calls
were
received.
U
He
stated
he
was
in
El
jefe's
Taqueria,
located
at
269
Huntington
Ave.
When
he
observed
two
groups
of
females
fighting
outside
Johnson
stated.
He
then
heard
a
noise
consistent
with
six
firecrackers
Johnson
stated
he
exited
the
establishment
and
observed
ballistic
damage
to
his
vehicle
Johnson
stated
to
officers
that
he
was
not
involved
in
the
incident,
but
that
he
was
equipped
with
a
firearm
and
has
an
LTC
officer.
Jenner,
seized
and
secured
the
firearm
nine
millimeter
Glock
in
Boston
police,
Mark,
Cruiser
1526.
While
officers
were
on
scene
officer,
McDonough
obtained
Johnson's
LTC
licensed
number
one.
U
Three
one
one:
five:
seven:
six,
nine
Alpha
a
sieges
inquiry
confirmed
the
license
status
and
Firearm
ownership
information
officers,
observe
ballistic
damage
to
multiple
areas
of
mass
Ridge,
Mike's,
Sierra,
Tango,
alfax
or
x-ray.
Ballistic
damage
was
observed
on
the
passenger
side
front
door,
the
passenger
side
front
dashboard
and
Ballistic
damage
to
the
passenger
side
rear
panel
and
gas
cap
cover.
A
fragment
of
a
casing
was
found
on
the
passenger
floorboard.
The
passenger
side
window
was
spider.
Webbed
and
shattered
officers
secured
the
area
with
crime
team
tape.
U
The
Delta
912
Sergeant
Sullivan
arrived
on
scene
Sergeant,
Sullivan
photographed
photographed
the
scene
in
8.357
cases
were
recovered
in
the
area.
Additionally,
one
bullet
fragment
was
recovered
from
the
front
passenger
side
of
the
vehicle
officer
folk,
with
witness
to
Brendan
Donovan,
who
stated
he
was
with
Johnson
at
El
jefe's.
When
a
group
of
females
started
fighting
outside
Donovan
stated,
he
heard
what
he
believed
to
be
shots
fired.
U
Vasquez
stated
he
went
outside
when
he
observed
a
black
male
with
black
dreads
wearing
a
black
T-shirt
fire.
Multiple
gunshots
Vasquez
was
able
to
obtain
a
video
of
the
incident
via
phone
from
an
Uber
driver
who
was
on
scene
Vasquez
visually
identified,
the
suspect
to
officer
Enriquez,
stating
that
the
black
male
with
the
black
shirt
and
dreads
featured
in
the
video
was
responsible
for
the
shots
fired.
U
The
unknown
female,
accompanied
by
her
friends.
Confronted
a
omarovic
and
stated
I'll,
see
you
outside
a
omirovic
stated.
She
did
not
think
anything
of
the
comment
and
eventually
exited
the
establishment.
Aomorovic
stated
when
she
exited
El
jefe's,
multiple,
unidentified
black
females,
started
to
punch
her
and
throw
her
to
the
ground.
A
omorovic
stated
when
she
was
on
the
ground,
the
unknown
female
started
to
kick
her,
which
caused
her
to
lose
consciousness.
U
Awoked
the
unknown
female
still
kicking
her
on
the
ground.
Officers
observed
a
omarovic
to
have
swelling
on
her
face
with
bruising
under
her
left
eye.
Multiple
scratches
were
observed,
along
with
a
cut
on
her
elbow
omarovic
stated.
She
had
pain
along
the
right
side
of
her
body
from
being
kicked
while
on
the
ground.
Almorovic
was
able
to
recover
her
bag
that
she
had
lost
on
scene,
but
stated
that
she
believed
the
unknown
females
took
her
wallet.
U
Hey
omarovic
stated
her
cousin
Susana
omarovic
was
on
her
way
back
to
speak
with
officers
D
over
omick
confirm
the
details
of
the
incident
described
by
aomarovic
Boston
EMS
aimland
6
arrived
on
scene
to
evaluate
aomorovic
aolic
was
transported
to
Mass
General
Hospital
for
further
evaluation.
Ballistic
evidence
was
collected
by
Sergeant
Sullivan
and
security,
District
4
in
the
Gun
Locker,
okay,
and
that's
the
end
of
the
report.
V
2023-232041
687
the
Texas
spoke
to
the
person
in
charge,
Mr
friendly
ubrey,
who
confirmed
that
he
was
aware
of
the
incident.
The
story
set
of
the
D4
detective
was
already
contacted
them
and
the
establishment
would
be
providing
surveillance
video
to
the
investigators
as
a
result
of
the
incident
trying
to
take
the
calibration
license.
Department,
inspection
notice,
zero,
four,
zero,
three
three
two
for
assault
dat,
repeating
on
patreon
and
sell
by
mean
to
a
dangerous
weapon
firearm
the
super
signed
for
an
acceptable
notice.
So
thank.
S
A
S
S
S
It
it
was
a
it,
it
wasn't,
a
major
incident.
I
mean
it
was
a.
It
was
a
busy
night
there,
the
incident
inside
the
restaurant.
We
we
didn't
really
observe
it
until
we
went
and
looked
out
at
security
there.
It
wasn't
a
very
it
wasn't
a
big
issue
inside
the
restaurant.
We
didn't
realize
something
was
happening
until
after
they
had
got
outside
the
restaurant.
S
We
did
not,
we
we
did,
we,
we
haven't
had
security,
we've
we've
been
opening
the
four
restaurants
in
the
Boston
area
until
three
or
four
a.m
in
the
in
the
and
the
Boston
Common
store
until
2
A.M
and
we've
just
never
had
incidents
we've.
Never
it
didn't.
It
never
seemed
like
it
was
something
we
don't
serve.
Alcohol
there's
not,
but
this
incident
I
guess
scared
us
to
be.
To
be
honest
and
it's
why
we've
secured
a
security
for
for
this
store.
S
S
A
Thank
you.
Anything
further
from
the
board
will
take
this
matter
under
advisement
as
well.
Thank
you
found
item
number
seven
Concord
entertainment,
Inc,
doing
business
as
Bill's
Bar,
the
Lansdowne
Pub,
located
at
nine
Lansdowne
Street
date
of
the
incident.
May
13
2023,
illegal
drug
use
on
premise:
a
reported
roofie
incident
in
violation
of
Mass
general
laws;
chapter
138,
section
64.,
who
was
president
on
behalf
of
the
licensee.
D
Good
morning
again
attorney
green
Madam,
chair
members
of
the
board
Dennis
quilty
attorney
representing
the
licensee
with
us
this
morning,
Katina
Alliance,
Group,
Nelson
Burns
was
the
general
manager
at
the
time
of
the
incident.
Anthony
chuga
one
of
the
managers
as
well
and
Wayne
Miller,
who
at
the
time
of
the
incident
was
security,
is
now
in
management
at
the
Alliance
Group
good
morning.
G
W
W
Good
morning,
I'll
be
reading
a
police
report
that
was
written
by
Officer
Ryan
Milliken
at
about
3
48
p.m.
On
May
15
2023
law
office
of
Milliken
assigned
to
the
front
desk
officer
received
report
at
650,
Harrison
Avenue
officer
Milliken,
received
the
report
the
victim
later
identified
as
John
Cosgrove
date
of
birth,
3
19
1989
and
his
girlfriend
identified
as
Jessica
Murphy
data
5-1
1990.
W
Murphy
reported
that
he
witnessed
an
unknown
suspect
open
a
pill,
capsule
important,
unknown
white
pottery
substance
into
buzzgrove
spear,
while
that
nine
Lansdowne
Street
on
May
13
2023
at
about
11
30
P.M,
where,
if
you
reported
that
standing
at
the
curved
by
table
area
in
the
middle
of
the
bar
on
the
end
closest
to
the
entrance
Murphy
reported,
the
white
powdery
substance
dissolved
Murphy
reported
that
the
unknown
suspect
who
poured
the
unknown
Pottery
substance
into
cause.
Gross
beer
was
a
20
to
30
year
old,
Hispanic
female,
approximately
five
foot,
two
dark
brunette
shoulder
length.
W
The
suspect
was
wearing
a
black
blouse
jeans
with
a
purse.
America
reported,
the
female
suspect
was
accompanied
by
a
20
to
30
year
old
Hispanic
male,
approximately
five
foot
ten
Murphy
in
Glasgow
did
not
have
any
further
details
about
the
mail
Murphy
reported.
Both
female
and
male
suspects
was
standing
directly
across
Murphy
in
Cosgrove
at
the
end
of
the
curved
by
table.
At
the
time
of
the
incident
applying
Murphy
witnessing
the
female
suspect
or
the
white
part
of
the
substance
in
beer,
she
informed
Cosgrove
of
what
had
just
occurred.
W
Carswell
never
took
a
sip
of
the
beer
after
the
substance
was
placed
in
a
drink.
Cosgrove
reported
that
he
was
originally
confused
and
confronted
the
male
suspect
about
what
happened.
Thinking
that
the
male
suspect
was
the
one
who
poured
the
unknown
substance
into
a
streak.
Cosgrove
reported
that
Lansdowne
security
was
notified,
but
ended
up.
Kicking
Murphy
in
Cosgrove
out
of
the
bar
Murphy,
reported
that
there
was
only
a
verbal
dispute
between
all
parties
after
the
incident
and
did
not
escalate
into
a
fight.
District
or
detectives
were
notified.
W
1
5
30
2023
Sarge,
detective
William
Gallagher,
detective
Eddie
Hernandez
signed
the
license
premise
unit
conducted
a
licensed
premise:
inspection
of
the
Lansdowne
Pub
located
at
9
Lansdowne
Street.
This
inspection
came
about
hot
because
of
an
incident
that
occurred
on
5
13
2023
at
11
30
PM.
The
incidents
recorded
on
Boston
police
instrument,
port
number,
two,
three:
two:
zero
three:
seven,
eight
nine
two
victim
Jessica
Murphy
and
her
boyfriend
stayed
in
the
report
filed
at
District
4.
She
observed
an
unknown
female,
plays
a
substance
into
her
boyfriend's
drink
at
Lansdowne,
Pub,
11,
30
p.m.
G
W
Then
informed
staff
in
the
incident
miss
American
woman
to
report
that
she
was
asked
to
leave
the
pub
along
with
her
boyfriend.
Sergeant
Gallagher
made
contact
with
Murphy,
who
was
very
upset,
Lansdowne
Pub.
That
did
nothing
to
investigate
her
claims
and
went
one
step
further
to
remove
her
and
her
boyfriend
from
the
premise
on
the
night
of
the
20th
Sergey
Gallagher
spoke
to
the
manager
Scott
miles
Mr
miles
was
given
a
picture
of
Miss
Murphy
and
her
boyfriend,
as
they
appeared
that
evening
by
Sergeant
Galaga,
so
as
to
assist
in
video
search.
W
The
incident
as
a
result
of
this
report,
size
and
technicality
issue
license
premise:
inspection
office,
number,
040-328,
Lansdowne,
public
for
illegal
drug
use
on
premise:
a
possible
roofie
incident,
Mr
Scott
miles,
signed
for
and
accepted
the
notice,
closing
size
and
Gallagher
stress
the
importance
of
investigating
these
claims
and
promptly,
alerting
police
and
smiles
I'm.
Sorry
Mr
miles
stated
he
would
speak
to
all
staff
members
of
a
guy
in
this
incident
and
that's
essentially
it
my
reports.
W
W
W
They
did
they
did
some
investigation
and
I
believe
that
I
don't
want
to
take
their
words.
They
said
that
they
might
have
come
from
Alabama
earlier
in
the
evening
and
they
would
they
might
have
been
watching
them,
but
that
that
all
the
statement-
I
don't
know
where
that
came
from
that's
not
something
I
would
say.
Okay,.
D
W
D
D
D
W
D
F
D
Y
Me
and
the
person
I
was
working
with
that
night
Jonathan
price
who
no
longer
works
with
us.
We
followed
the
two
people
in.
We
told
them
to
point
out
the
people
and
the
first
they
pointed
at
a
group
of
Hispanic
people.
Then
they
pointed
out
a
group
of
older
Asian
American
looking
people
and
then
they
we
started
asking
them
to
pretty
much
produce
the
drink
and
we
was
with
them
for
about
a
half
hour
and
no
drink
was
produced.
Y
Y
Y
My
first
encounter
with
Miss
mercy
and
Mr
Cosgrove
in
the
night
it
was
at
earlier
in
the
day.
I
was
working
a
door
I
built
at
the
time
and
I
believe
that
they
were
looking
for
a
lighter
and
the
mail
said.
If
any
of
you
guys
got
a
lighter,
my
girl
will
show
you
her
breasts
and
before
anyone
can
even
get
out
of
lighter
her
breasts
were
out,
so
I
ended
up,
throwing
him
a
lighter
and
just
letting
him
know
like
you.
Y
Y
Y
D
Y
Y
D
D
Z
Z
Yes,
I
asked
him
what
what
had
occurred
and
they
had
told
me
the
whole
sequence
of
events
from
the
beginning
of
the
day.
Earlier.
In
the
day
to
then
we
talked
to
someone
from
the
House
of
Blues
and
yeah.
I
got
the
whole
story
of
what
had
happened
and
I
really
didn't
think
much
of
it.
They
left
and
then
I
got
the
summons.
A
few
days
later,.
Z
Z
Y
D
D
AA
D
A
O
So
on
that
night
we
did
tell
the
staff
and
he
did
come
with
us.
We
went
over.
We
went
to
the
same
group
of
people,
the
woman
who
poured
that
my
wife
said
she
poured
into
the
substance,
was
still
there.
She
was
like
a
deer
in
headlights.
She
was
very
shook.
The
guy
disappeared
from
the
group.
We
never
pointed
out
two
different
groups.
It
was
just
one
group,
one
group,
and
then
we
were
asked
Olivia.
We
were
not
with
the
security
staff
for
half
an
hour.
AB
AB
But
there
was
no
discrepancy
in
the
group
of
people.
They
asked
me
to
describe
what
they
looked
like
race,
wise
and
I.
Couldn't
tell
them
definitively
what
their
race
was
and
I
think.
That
may
be
why
they
got
confused
about
multiple
groups,
but
I
can
identify
the
girl
that
did
it
and
we
did
identify
the
girl
in
the
bar
with
the
security.
O
AB
AB
And
now,
when
we
email
to
follow
up
about
the
investigation
of
the
video
footage,
they
said
that
it
was
inconclusive,
but
our
understanding,
though,
was
that
the
sergeant
was
going
to
be
reviewing
it,
not
that
manager
yeah,
so
that
just
seems
like
King's
biased,
biased,
because
why
would
they
produce
it?
You
know,
of
course
it
will
be
gone.
A
Z
Z
D
A
week
later,
it
was
a
week
later
before
they
were
notified.
They
simply
escorted
these
two
people
out.
It
was
no
incident,
no
incident
whatsoever,
no
complaint
made
on
the
night
in
question.
Complaint
made
48
hours
later
at
a
police
station,
which
we
don't
learn
until
a
week
later,
so
there
there's
kind
of
very
little
that
that
they
could
do.
Given
that
the
passage
of
time
and
I'm,
you
know
the
concerns
about
who,
who
reviewed
the
tape?
D
I
mean
I,
Sergeant,
Gallagher,
I
presume,
you
know,
would
have
asked
for
it
if
he
desired
to
see
it
or
I
I,
don't
know
that,
but
as
to
what
we
did
I
mean
I
think
it
was
totally
appropriate.
In
the
circumstances
I
mean
the
reports
indicate
that
they
pointed
out.
Multiple
people
couldn't
identify.
Anyone,
in
particular
didn't
have
anything
to
show
in
terms
of
the
drink.
Okay,.
B
K
D
Well,
I
mean
I.
Think
the
answer
is
the
staff
I
think
you
heard
them
this
morning.
They
were
with.
These.
People
walked
around
the
entire
place,
with
them
to
find
out
what
had
happened
and
they
were,
it
was.
Nothing
was
indicated
to
the
staff.
That
would
say
that's
the
person
who
did
it.
There
was
no
way
to
back
up
what
these
individuals
said.
There
was
no
Powder,
there
was
no
drink
and
it
was
an
inability
to
identify
anybody
who
had.
K
K
Z
K
D
F
B
D
B
D
B
L
Yeah
I
mean
I
I.
Think
along
the
lines
of
what
the
other
Commissioners
have
been
saying.
Once
there
has
been
an
accusation,
you
know
if
there
is
any
camera
footage,
it
is
not
up
to
the
the
bar
owners
or
the
managers.
That
is
a
quality.
It
is
up
to
the
police
and
is
up
to
the
the
licensing
board
to
review
so
going
forward.
If
there's
any
even
a
question,
even
as
like
scintilla
of
of
Suspicion
preserve
the
video.
A
AC
A
V
Good
morning
I'll
be
reading
it
from
a
police
report
which
two
types
of
Galaga
wrote
on
5
29,
2023,
Sean,
detective,
William,
Gallagher
and
detective
Eddie.
Her
hand
is
assigned
to
the
licensed
pharmaceutical
company
by
BPD.
A1
detectives
sign,
detective
salute
she
detective
Walsh
kneely
conducted
a
license
permission
inspection
of
Blakes
at
208,
French
Street
inside
the
premises,
detectives
Reserve
at
the
bar
to
be
quite
crowded
with
it
difficult
to
move
about
thinking
that
the
premise
had
exceeded
its
occupant
load.
Science.
Detective
Gallery
conducted
a
mechanical
count
which
resulted
in
102
persons
being
counted.
V
The
premises
capacity
listed
on
the
common
Victory
license
is
set
at
44.
detectors,
made
contact
with
the
manager
George
final
and
informed
him
in
their
findings.
The
final
stated
that
he
was
overwhelmed
by
the
numbers
of
people
who
showed
up
for
the
Celtics
Heat
game,
protect
himself
to
see
submitting
patrons
until
he
reached
his
posted
capacity
as
a
result
of
what.
V
AC
V
AC
AC
AC
AC
Okay,
yeah,
Madam,
Channel,
One
members
of
the
board,
I
think
what
happened
that
night
was
Mr
vinyl
and
his
staff
underestimated
not
only
the
crowd
surge,
but
also
the
time
that
there
would
be
a
need
for
additional
staff.
Mr
vinyl
had
called
staff
in
that
evening
and
later
that
evening
in
post
game,
not
recognizing
that
pregame,
he
would
have
that
issue.
AC
Obviously
he
made
a
mistake:
I've
spoken
to
licensee,
to
let
him
know
that
a
licensed
venue
that
is
so
close
to
a
sporting,
Event
Center
as
well
as
a
concert
venue.
You
needs
to
be
extremely
knowledgeable
about
the
type
of
crowd
the
different
games
and
different.
You
know
concerts
actually
bring
to
the
area
so
I'm
trying
to
work
with
the
staff
to
understand
how
that
works.
Mr
vinyl
has
put
in
several
procedures.
AC
F
Thanks
Jerry
Malone,
just
as
was
said,
we
did
adapt
in
a
moment
called
extra
staff
on
we
shut
a
second
door
down
so
that
there
would
be
no
entrance.
In
that
moment,
it
was
an
at
typical
crowd.
Typically,
we
see
a
bit
of
a
push
before
the
game
and
it
kind
of
clears
out
and
then
after
the
game,
we
were
always
prepared
for
that.
F
We
are
alert
to
having
presents
at
both
doors,
as
we
have
one
from
the
side
street
and
one
from
the
hotel
and
in
the
in
the
event
that
there
is
going
to
be
anticipated
higher
volume
of
foot
track.
You
shut
the
second
door
down
and
all
staff
is
trained
to
keep
monitoring
flow
of
traffic.
Also
supervisors
have
been
getting
the
crop
after
safety
course
as
well,
just
as
a
refresher
to
to
be
alert
to
the
needs
that
we
have
yeah.
F
F
It's
not
an
excuse
and
we're
ready
for
it
moving
forward,
but
this
was
where
people
were
coming
not
to
go
to
the
Garden,
which
is
what
we
usually
get
as
a
best
game
space,
but
it
was
to
come
and
participate
watch
the
game.
So
that's
really
what
the
crowd
was.
So
we
dapped
it
in
the
moment
we
got
to
a
good
level
and
then
we
were
able
to
control
the
flow
of
traffic
for
the
post
game
and
our
kitchen
is
open
until
1am.
F
F
Typically,
it's
we
have
one
doorman
on
for
the
post
game
for
the
late
night
evening
portion
to
make
sure
that
as
the
the
venue
lets
out,
we
can
keep
track
of
that
in
that
moment
because
of
the
surge
of
people
that
we
had
I
called
one
doorstep
on
early
and
then
a
second
to
arrive
for
the
post
game
as
well.
So
they
can
monitor
both.
K
A
A
W
Good
morning
on
5
29
2023
at
7,
30
P.M,
checked
William
Gallagher
to
check
if
any
Hernandez
assigned
a
licensed
premise.
Student,
along
with
detectives,
signed
the
area
A1
massage
detectives,
salucci,
Canali,
Walsh
and
McDonald
conducted
a
licensed
premise,
inspection
of
being
his
Kitchen
and
Tap
at
80
Causeway
Street
detective's
attention
was
drawn
to
the
premise
because
a
loud
Amplified,
DJ
music
observed
operating
through
the
open
window
of
the
first
floor
inside
the
premise
detectives
observe
the
DJ
to
be
set
up
with
the
speaking
facing
toward
the
street.
Out
to
the
open
window.
W
In
addition
to
Sarge
detective
Gallagher
issued
a
licensed
premise:
inspection
notice
number
zero,
four
zero
three
three
five:
the
band
is
Kitchen
and
Tap
the
service
of
more
than
two
alcoholic
drinks
to
a
patron
at
a
time
which
is
under
the
mass
prohibitive
practices,
Mr
Nick
Munoz
signed
to
pull
and
accepted
the
notice.
Those
are
the
facts
of
that
evening.
A
W
I,
don't
have
that
sir,
there
was
no.
There
was
no
violation
issue
that
was
that
was
us
delivering
the
notice.
We
found
a
manager
that
did
not
sign
for
it
and
we
had
some
correspondence
one
of
the
bartenders
which
was
kind
of
concerning,
because
it
made
it
appear
that
as
if
a
patron
walked
up
to
the
bar
with
another
person's
ID
that
they
could
purchase
four
drinks
with
only
one
person
there
and
we
we
had
questioned
that
practice
and
I
think
it's
been
addressed.
There
was
no
violation
issued.
AD
AD
W
AD
Thank
you,
Sergeant
Smith,
Gallagher,
Madam,
chair
first,
to
address
the
issue
that
precipitated
the
hearing
at
the
time
of
the
incident,
the
licensee
was
using
the
same
cups
at
that
time
for
large
busy
days.
As
for
alcoholic
and
non-alcoholic
drinks,
when
the
management
on
staff
Mr
Burns
and
the
detectives
observed
those
person
carrying
the
four
cups
they
weren't
able
to
easily
identify
what
was
in
those
cups.
At
that
time
they
may
have
been
alcoholic.
They
may
not
have
the
fact
that
this
was
game.
AD
Since
that
time
and
since
the
the
second
incident,
they
have
again
reiterated
staff
that
you
can
only
serve
two
alcoholic
beverages
to
one
person
at
any
one
time.
If
someone
is
ordering
more
than
two
beverages,
there
must
be
the
appropriate
amount
of
people.
If
they're
ordering
six
drinks,
three
people
need
to
be
there.
If
they're
ordering
four
drinks,
two
people
need
to
be
there.
They
are
they've
reiterated
that
service.
AD
Additionally,
they
have
also
brought
in
different
beverage
cups
for
alcoholics
versus
non-alcoholic
drinks,
so
it
is
easily
identifiable
for
all
patrons
staff.
Anybody
to
determine
what
is
and
what
is
an
alcoholic
to
address
the
the
second
issue
we
can
only
you
know
apologize
again
to
the
board
for
that
incident.
The
manager,
the
supervisor
on
staff
that
night,
more
or
less
didn't
fully
understand
what
was
happening.
He
thought
he
was
possibly
receiving
a
citation
for
a
night.
He
wasn't
there.
AD
B
B
X
A
A
W
Good
morning
I'll
be
reading
from
three
I'm.
Sorry,
three
instant
reports.
The
first
one
is
a
Massachusetts
state
police
report.
The
premise
does
sit
on
mass
put
property
and
primary
police
force,
for
this
is
Mass
state
police,
so
I'll
be
reading
a
report
from
Trooper
Ryan
campanny
on
Saturday
May,
13,
2023.,
I,
Trooper,
Ryan,
Fanning,
assigned
to
true
path.
W
Logan
Airport
was
on
patrol
in
sector
e
at
approximately
2100
hours,
while
on
patrol
at
the
tall
ship,
I
was
informed
to
security
that
a
fight
had
broken
out
I,
followed
security
for
tall
ship
and
found
the
victim
Benjamin
Felipe,
with
the
laceration
towards
right,
eyebrow
in
a
chipped
tooth
and
a
bloody
and
blood
on
his
face.
Multiple
descriptions
were
given
who
the
aggressor
was
but
not
fully
matched.
W
W
The
next
Boston
instant
report
would
be
myself
and
detective.
Hernandez
were
on
scene
shortly
thereafter
on
an
unrelated
matter.
My
report
means
going
5
13
20
23
at
about
9
45
pm,
sign
detective
William,
Gallagher,
detective
Eddie
Hernandez
assigned
the
licensed
premise
unit,
we're
responding
to
a
past
complaint
of
loud
music
at
the
tallest
ship
and
I
bought
our
head
called
mayor's
office
over
the
weekend
at
five.
Six
and
five
seven
to
complain
about
live,
live
performance
that
had
taken
place
as
detectives
were,
making
their
way
of
creative
ship.
W
They
observed
the
contingent
of
Mass
state
police
officers
involved
in
a
conversation
themselves
attack
those
approach
to
Troopers
in
and
quiet
as
if
anything
was
going
on.
Msp
Sergeant
Stephen
Lopes
reported
to
BPD
detectives
that
had
dispatched
the
tallest
ship
for
the
report
of
a
fight
tall
ship
sits
on
mass
or
property
Sergeant
Lopes,
then
it
scored
inside
detective
Galaga
detective
Hernandez
over
the
trooper
Ryan
Banning,
who
was
initially
flagged
down
by
tall
ship
security
that
he
would
be
carrying
the
report
and
provide
them
with
a
copy.
W
Once
completed,
Blossom
Police
Department
received
a
copy
of
the
report
on
5
30
2023
fire
detectives
completing
their
inspection
of
13th.
They
spoke
to
tall
ship
manager,
Paul
golowski,
who
stated
that
he
was
aware
of
the
fight
and
he
would
save
any
and
all
video
evidence
that
was
recovered.
Ep
detectives
will
be
following
up
with
a
licensed
premise:
inspection
notice,
detailing
Mass,
State
Trooper
banning's
report,
name
B
Patron
on
Patron.
These
last
reports
is
mine.
W
It's
for
the
lpv
and
it
reads
as
follows:
on
531
2023
at
9,
47
PM,
massage
detectively
in
Gallagher
detected
89
Hernandez
assigned
a
licensed
premise.
Unit
respond
to
the
tallest
ship.
One
East
Pier
drive
to
conduct
a
licensed
premise.
Inspection
inspection
came
about
because
of
her
assault
and
battery
patreon
Patron
that
took
place
in
the
tallest
ship
at
about
9
00
pm
on
5
13
2023
detectives
have
been
there
just
after
the
incident
has
taken
place.
Primary
responding
police
Agency
for
the
assault
was
a
mass
State.
W
W
531
detectives
licensed
Union
spoke
with
the
manager
Herman
mat
solbe,
who
stated
that
he
was
aware
of
the
incident
and
will
contact
security
company
that
oversees
the
cameras
as
a
result,
but
taking
place
in
the
13th
Sasha
Gallagher
issue
license
premise:
inspection
list
number,
zero,
four,
zero
337
to
the
tallest
ship
for
assault
and
battery
Patron
on
Patron
on
premise:
Mr
Herman
masove
signed
for
an
acceptable
notice.
Those
are
willing
Choice.
Thank
you.
K
X
No
because
we
do
not
have
any
personal
knowledge
knowing
and
when
we
were
present
was
the
licensing
Cooperative,
yes
ma'am
and
when
you
returned
to
a
general
license
department
to
notice
with
the
license
in
Florida.
Yes,
ma'am.
Thank
you
very
much.
Sorry
to
get
back
there,
no
additional
questions.
If
I
may
miss
Derek
carvala
and
then
ask
you
anything
about
several
questions.
I
Yes,
I
was
radio
over
the
phone
that
if
I
was
broken
down
on
the
main
bar
I
was
two
guys
watching
the
video,
a
boxing
video
and
then
a
third
party
showed
up
and
then
was
bothering,
and
so
if
I
started,
arguing
very
well
arguing
and
then
next
thing
you
know
the
first
people
that
are
watching
the
video
turn
around
and
this
trip
a
couple
punches
after
that
security
was
flagged
down.
We
broke
down
to
five
and
we
escorted
all
the
police
out
and
they
called
establish.
X
X
J
J
Unfortunately,
it
was
the
start
of
the
season
and
we
had
a
camera
issue
going
from
when
the
vessel,
when
the
tall
ship
was
closed
down
for
the
winter.
So
we
had
camera
issues,
so
there
was
not
camera
footage
of
this
fight,
even
though
we
have
cameras-
and
we
should
have
recordings
for
everything
we
do
not
have
a
recording
from
this
from
this
line
and.
J
X
Medicare,
commissioner,
one
we
apologize
for
the
security
footage
not
being
available
that
was
immediately
rectified.
We
do
believe
that
this
was
an
incident
that
was
not
foreseeable.
It
began
as
a
verbal
exchange
over
mixed,
martial
arts
or
boxing.
Whatever
these
gentlemen
were
watching
and
very
quickly
escalated,
these
security
staff
immediately
the
black
separated
the
patrons
flagged
down
the
state
trooper
was
there
on
detail.
We
always
have
a
detail
at
the
tall
ship
and
then
calls
EMS
to
to
request
an
ambulance
again.