►
From YouTube: City of Charleston Council Meeting - November 12, 2019
Description
City of Charleston Council Meeting - November 12, 2019
C
D
Mr.
mayor
council,
thanks
for
having
me
here
briefly
tonight,
my
name
is
Joe
Waring
with
North
Bridge,
Baptist,
Church
and
West
Ashley
love
to
have
you
all
come
you
know
who
you
are
preaching
is
OK.
Worship
is
awesome,
let's
pray
father,
we
just
give
you
glory
tonight
and
Lord.
We
would
pray
your
favor
and
your
blessing
over
this
meeting
to
come.
Lord
I
pray
specifically
for
integrity
and
unity
that
come
from
humility
and
wisdom
over
this
group
of
people.
D
B
Thank
You
Reverend
for
that
nice
prayer
and
thank
you
for
your
hospitality
of
providing
your
church
facilities
as
a
polling
place
I,
a
very
busy
one
at
that.
Thank
you,
sir.
So
I
think
everybody
knows
this,
but
in
the
very
unlikely
event
we
needed
to
exit
the
building.
These
are
our
exit.
Doors
here,
do
not
use
the
elevator
and
then
just
use
the
two
stairs
going
down
to
the
first
floor
and
there's
one
stairway
going
out
to
the
front.
I
didn't
want
to
recognize
I
just
see.
B
One
of
our
new
council
members
here
with
us
tonight,
or
he
will
be
a
new
council
member
in
January
Ross
Appel,
is
is
in
attendance
with
us.
Thank
you
for
being
here
mr.
Appel
and
next
I'd
like
to
ask
Joe
McGill
if
you're
in
the
house-
and
he
is
to
please
come
forward,
he
is
the
founder
of
the
slave
dwelling
project
and
it
works
to
engage
the
community
in
honest
conversations
about
American
history
and
raise
awareness
of
how
enslaved
ancestors
live,
and
we
have
a
proclamation.
I
think.
B
So
if
you'll
bear
with
me,
mr.
McGill
I
would
like
to
read
this
for
you,
whereas
the
city
of
Charleston
is
honored
to
recognize
the
slave
dwelling
project,
whose
vision
is
to
identify
and
assist
property
owners,
government
agencies
and
organizations
in
the
preservation
of
extent
slave
dwellings.
I,
don't
see
that
word
every
day,
extent
I
guess
that
means
they're
about
to
go
out
of
existence.
If
you
weren't
around
it
to
save
you
in
that
right.
B
B
E
Thank
You
mayor
tech,
Limburg
for
the
honor
and
the
invitation
is
over
it's
open
for
anyone
who
would
like
to
join
us
in
the
year.
2020
our
10th
year
anniversary
our
conference
this
year
will
be
at
Clemson.
University.
Excuse
me
next
year,
we'll
be
at
Clemson
University
epitome.
If
any
of
you
would
like
to
join
us,
so
please
look
out
joana,
look
at
our
website
slave
dwelling,
part
org
and
you
can
get
all
the
details.
Thank
you.
B
B
Choosing
locals
creates
diverse
job
opportunities,
therefore,
protecting
us
from
the
effects
of
economic
downturns
and
y'all
probably
know
the
multiplier
effect.
But
if
you
keep
your
dollars,
local
as
opposed
to
shopping
with
Amazon
and
sending
your
money
off
the
Seattle,
it
really
our
local
economy
there's
a
real
multiplier
effect,
whereas
by
buying
local
Charleston
residents
support
a
healthy
and
happy
community.
B
Now,
though,
therefore
I,
John,
J,
Tech
and
many
of
the
city
of
Charleston
do
hereby
proclaim
November
15th
through
December
15
as
by
local
month
in
the
city
of
Charleston,
and
so
want
everybody
to
think
about
that.
When
you
I
know
it's
real
easy
to
go
online
on
Amazon
and
buy
all
those
presents
and
have
them
come
in
by
UPS,
but
think
about
the
local
businesses
that
are
right
here
in
Charleston
that
you
can
have
fun
and
make
our
whole
community
healthier
and
happier
with
that
I'd
like
to
call
upon
you.
F
G
G
It's
the
places
where
you
can
fix
a
shoe,
find
the
perfect
dress,
buy
a
coffee
or
a
new
book
and
connect
with
your
neighbors.
We
know
that
you
must
invest
in
what
we
value
or
else
risk
losing
it,
and
that
includes
being
intentional.
With
our
holiday
spending
as
individuals,
businesses
and
leaders
in
the
community,
thank
you
again
and
if
you
are
looking
for
gifts
visit
by
local
Montcalm,
it's
where
we
highlight
all
of
our
local
businesses
and
what
they
offer
this
time
of
year.
So
thank
you
again.
B
C
B
B
H
Morgan
Thank
You
mr.
mayor
members
of
council,
so
the
screen
comes
up
here
of
this.
First
one
is
e
one
1815
beechwood
Road,
it's
a
rezoning
from
SR
six
to
diverse
residential
dr6.
It
actually
ends
up
being
almost
like
a
down
zoning,
because
the
density
and
sr6
is
eight
point:
seven
and
deep
in
dr6.
It's
six
units
an
acre
essentially
by
going
to
the
diverse
residential
dr,
they
are
allowed
to
do
multiple
unit
buildings,
as
opposed
to
single-family
only
in
SR
six,
and
that
is
what
the
applicant
wishes
to
do
on
the
property.
H
Here
you
see
it
it's
off
the
edge
of
Ashley
River
Road,
just
north
of
Magwood
Beachwood
comes
in
off
to
the
side
of
that.
There
is
a
assisted
living
facility
across
beechwood
from
this
one,
and
there
are
limited
business
and
general
business
zone
properties
along
Ashley,
River,
Road
to
the
east.
The
Planning
Commission
recommends
approval.
It
conforms
with
our
century.
Five
plan
and
staff
recommends
approval
as
well.
H
B
Right
Oh,
would
anyone
like
to
be
heard
on
this
matter?
Okay,
this
matter
will
not
be
coming
to
Council
tonight,
because
apparently
the
wrong
street
address
was
was
given
1809
in
1815.
So
we
are
going
to
wait
until
our
next
meeting
to
take
action
on
this
matter,
but
the
floor
is
open.
If
anybody
would
like
to
comment
or
ask
the
question:
councilmember
Schiele.
I
So
this
piece
property
has
been
deferred
twice
his
first
time.
We
didn't
put
the
zoning
signs
out
and
now
we've
got
the
wrong
address.
So
now
it's
gonna
be
kicked
down
the
road
a
little
bit
further,
but
I
guess
I'll
go
ahead
and
ask
some
questions.
I
do
have
some
questions
on
this.
You
know
I
had
spoken
with
mr.
warden
and
some
wanted
to
speak
with
the
owners.
It's
in
my
district
and
I
never
did
hear
from
the
owners.
I
F
I
It's
point,
six
five
I
believe
on
the
acreage.
I,
don't
see
how
you
could
fit
more
homes
on
there,
then
you
can
townhomes
and
maybe
I'm
missing
something,
but
if
you've
got
one
access
in
but
I,
don't
know
how
this
is
a
down.
Zoning
I
don't
see
how
you
could
fit
as
many
homes
as
you
could
tell
townhomes
right.
H
And
it
given
the
configuration
of
the
law,
it
could
be
that
you
can
fit
fit
more
townhouses
than
you
can
single-family
houses,
but
the
actual
categories
do
have
the
it's
a
de
facto
down
zoning
via
the
actual
categories,
but
on
the
property.
It
could
be
that
once
you
configure
it
and
I
don't
know
their
intent
as
far
as
where
they
would
put
townhouses
versus
single-family
houses.
That
thing
as
I
look
at
it,
it
could
be
that
you
would
have
fewer
single-family
houses
than
you
would
townhouses.
Okay,.
I
I
B
J
K
Chambers
I
live
at
218,
Marsh,
Oaks
Drive
I
do
on
this
property.
The
previous
zoning
is
SR
six
and
you
can
buy
zoning
put
more
single-family
residential
units
on
that
property.
The
issue
is
access.
You
can
put
a
call
to
suck
in
that
has
to
be
50
feet
wide
and
frankly,
to
do
that
you
can
cut
a
lot
of
trees
down
so
in
rezoning
it
to
dr6.
I
can
put
one
structure
on
the
back
of
the
property.
K
B
H
This
is
1220
hobart
avenue,
which
is
in
the
ashley
ville
Maryville
area.
It's
the
right
pictures.
These
are
just
some
pictures
there.
It
it
backs
up
to
properties
that
front
on
Ashley
River
Road
in
the
Ashley
lobe
Maryville
area.
The
request
from
the
applicant
was
to
go
from
SR
to
as
it's
currently
sun
to
general
business.
However,
staff
and
the
Planning
Commission
both
recommended
for
limited
business
to
less
than
the
impact
of
the
rezoning
on
the
adjoining
properties
to
the
south,
which
are
sown
for
single-family
development.
H
Those
are
the
properties
that
are
shown
in
yellow
on
this
map.
Here
you
see
in
the
comprehensive
plan
it
does
show
in
our
kind
of
highway
designation,
so
G
B
would
be
appropriate,
but
L
B
would
be
as
well
and
again.
That
was
some
of
the
thinking
at
Planning,
Commission
and
staff
is
to
help
protect
some
of
those
folks
that
are
across
the
street.
In
residential
areas.
H
You
can
see
that
there's
a
nearby
food
distribution
center
across
the
street
daycare
facility,
overflow
parking
for
some
of
the
nearby
restaurants
and
bars
and
then
to
the
right.
There
is
a
bar,
the
music
venue,
the
the
tin
roof,
so
it's
definitely
an
area
that
has
a
lot
of
more
intense
uses,
and
we
were
hopeful
that,
with
this
lb,
it
could
help
reduce
some
of
the
the
intensity
of
those
uses.
Since
LV
is
not
a
24-hour
a
day.
H
H
Now
there
you
see
it
up
close
and
then
we
have
that's
a
nearby
overflow
parking
for
the
tin
roof,
I
believe
and
then
that
it's
the
tin
roof
itself
and
then
some
houses
across
the
street
that
are
residential
that
again
they'll
be,
would
help
to
protect,
and
you
see
the
daycare
center,
that's
there
as
well
and
some
other
residences
nearby.
So
both
staff
and
Planning
Commission
recommend
for
L
beams
all.
B
L
B
I
H
This
is
sorry
1165
falling
Road.
This
is
course
covered
by
the
following
road
overlay
as
well.
It
currently
is
general
office.
It's
in
an
area
of
folly
that
does
have
residential
across
the
street
as
well
as
some
commercial
uses,
it's
just
south
of
a
church
and
just
north
of
a
small
retail
strip
center.
That
has
some
restaurants
in
it.
That
is
also
zone.
Limited
business.
We'll
show
you
some
pictures
here
again,
it's
in
the
highway
recommendations
from
the
comprehensive
plan,
so
the
LV
is
appropriate.
H
As
per
that,
and
then
here
you
see
it's
an
undeveloped
tract
one
of
the
few
remaining
undeveloped
tracks,
long
Valley,
Road
wooded.
Of
course,
all
tree
preservation
ordinances
would
have
to
be
in
effect
here
as
well.
You
can
kind
of
see
how
the
buffer
of
trees
was
left
to
the
property
to
the
west.
That
is,
the
art
to
the
south,
is
the
strip
center.
There
you
have
the
street
that
leads
in
adjacent
to
it.
That
goes
to
the
church,
and
there
is
the
adjoining
retail
strip
center.
That
has
some
of
the
trees
remaining
long.
H
There
I
would
imagine
similar
development
would
occur
on
the
property,
and
then
this
is
residential
backing
up
to
the
property
in
the
northern
end,
and
this
is
across
the
street,
some
residential
and
also
some
commercial
again
staff
and
Planning
Commission
recommend
for
the
limited
business
on
that
property.
All.
M
Thank
you.
My
name
is
William
Ford,
my
Max
Lee
st.
George
real
estate,
appraiser
I,
was
looking
to
open
a
second
office
in
Charleston,
because
I'm
gonna
retire
to
Folly
Beach
I
plan
on
putting
a
small
strip
center
there
from
my
personal
office.
I
would
like
a
limited
business
zoning.
So
when
I
rent
my
additional
space
I
can
not
only
court
office
tenants
but
more
business.
Tenants
like
myself.
That
would
be
a
good
mix.
Any
questions
thank.
B
N
And
and
my
purpose
of
going,
there
was
to
be
a
representative
for
the
rethink,
Bali
Road
steering
committee,
meaning
I
made
mine
that
was
prior
to
our
giving
first
reading
to
the
Fowler
mode
overlay
amendment
that
is
now
I'm,
going
to
ask
redevelop
as
a
property
like
and
support
to
build
out
the
12-foot
multi-use
path.
So
I
just
wanted
to
put
that
on
the
record,
I
I'm,
assuming
that
you
know
that
that's
now
part
of
your
requirements,
but
I
would
like
to
have
it
on
the
record
that
that's
why
I
would
in
favor
of
us.
B
H
This
is
six
Riker
Street
on
the
peninsula.
It's
on
the
west
side
of
meeting.
It
is
very
close
to
the
I
26
overpasses
that
go
to
the
west
of
Meeting
Street.
It
is
an
area
that
has
a
lot
of
limited
business,
zoning
fronting
on
Meeting
Street,
as
well
as
some
general
business
on
the
eastern
side
of
meeting.
This
is
part
of
a
larger
redevelopment
of
several
Lots
that
goes
to
the
north
here.
B
H
Yeah
this
is
1707
McLeod,
which
is
in
James
Island.
It
is
an
annexation
from
back
in
I.
Believe
July
is
this
all
folly:
Road
it's
across
the
street
from
some
multifamily.
It
backs
up
to
a
general
office,
zoned
Percel,
and
then
there
are
other
parcels
to
the
residential
in
Charleston
County
jurisdiction,
the
Planning
Commission
and
staff
recommend
for
the
SR
one
and
I
believe
we
have
a
couple
of
pictures
of
it.
I
believe
there
is
a
group
home
on
the
property
now
for
our
veterans.
O
B
B
H
H
B
B
Most
certainly
will
yeah
alright.
So
hearing
no
other
comments,
we're
going
to
move
on
throat.
Next
is
our
approval
of
City
Council
minutes
from
October
8.
We
have
a
motion
to
approve
any
changes
deletions
all
in
favor,
please
say
aye
and
opposed
the
units
have
it.
Next.
We
have
citizens
participation
period,
also,
council
and
and
those
attending
I
introduced
one
of
our
new
new
council
members,
but
another
one
has
arrived
so
I'm
Murray.
Would
you
please
stand
and
be
recognized?
B
A
B
P
P
We
take
care
right,
we
have
a
lease
on
it.
You
all
have
to
leave.
Somebody
else
on
this
property
got
a
statue
up
there.
We
talk
a
reparation
and
all
of
that
of
a
man
who
told
the
biggest
lie,
cause
all
the
black
and
white
to
start
fighting
and
we
release
enough
property,
taking
care
of
this
property
with
taxpayer
money,
innocent
people
money
and
we
talked
about
reparation
period,
etc.
Don't
you
be
ashamed
of
yourself
why
they
can't
take
care
of
the
property.
P
Poor
people
are
paying
to
take
care
that
property
and
we
got
the
biggest
liar
in
the
world.
Jc
Calhoun
up
there
and
y'all
taking
care
of
that,
and
you
see
you
the
mayor
of
Charleston,
South
Carolina.
I,
can't
understand
that
you
give
me
three
minutes.
You
say
your
father
and
son
me
and
somebody
said
you
could
devil.
So
you
must
be
a
devil
yourself.
P
Q
Good
evening,
my
name
is
Elijah
here
with
the
third
I
serve
as
the
chief
operating
officer
for
the
International
african-american
Museum
I
come
this
evening
to
just
offer
some
gratitude.
You
see,
you
have
boxes
in
front
of
you.
These
are
candles
from
our
groundbreaking
ceremony
and
the
candles
read
illuminating
the
african-american
journey
about
a
couple
weeks
ago
we
hosted
the
groundbreaking
for
the
museum
and
there
was
a
really
amazing
milestone,
one
that
was
about
20
years
in
the
making.
Q
We
are
very
clear
that
milestones
such
as
the
one
that
we
celebrated
would
not
be
possible
without
the
tremendous
support
of
the
city,
so
I'm
here
today
to
thank
Merritt,
Oakland,
Berg
and
City
Council
for
your
support
of
our
projects.
We
really
appreciate
everything
that
you've
done
to
allow
us
to
reach
this.
This
point
also
wanted
to
thank,
in
particular,
the
city
staff,
for
their
role
in
helping
to
support
the
groundbreaking
ceremony
and
making
it
what
it
was.
Q
B
You
kindly
what
anyone
else
like
to
be
heard,
since
we
have
the
time
all
right.
Well,
thank
you
for
participating
in
our
citizens
participation
period.
Next
we
have
petitions
and
communications.
First
up
is
a
resolution.
It
says
extending
an
invitation,
but
in
effect,
what
we're
doing
is
approving
our
sister
city
agreement
with
the
city
of
Doha,
Qatar
and
I.
I
You
but
for
mayor
I
want
I
want
to.
Let
know
that
this
particular
sister
city
agreement
is
a
little
bit
bigger.
What's
a
lot
bigger
a
lot
more
involved
than
some
of
the
other
sister
cities
that
we've
had
before
we've
got
a
real
opportunity
for
some
economic
development
out
of
Doha
for
specifically
for
Johns
Island,
maybe
West
Ashley
and
some
of
the
other
areas,
so
I
hope,
I.
Hope
I
can
pique
your
interest
in
what's
going
on
here,
because
there's
a
lot
with
education
in
USC
is
very
involved
with
this
fact
we
have.
I
We
have
cardiac
surgeons
that
are
actually
sharing
and
studying,
along
with
Doha
surgeons,
particularly
with
with
young
people
and
heart
problems.
The
University
of
South
Carolina,
Clemson
College.
The
Charleston
is
all
involved
in
this
course.
Boeing
is
very
involved
and
there's
a
lot
of
other
groups
that
are
very,
very
involved
and
interested
in
this
and
I
think
we've
got
a
we've,
got
a
real
opportunity
with
this
particular
sister
city
agreement
and
I
hope
you'll
pay
attention
to
it
and
and
support
it,
as
as
you
hear
more
about
it.
Thank.
B
You
very
thank
you
any
further
discussion.
Well,
we
have
mojo
on
floor
right.
That
was
confirmed
all
in
favor.
Please
say:
aye
any
Posey
on
its
habit.
Next,
just
to
advise
Council,
we
did
have
a
second
meeting
of
our
new
underground
utilities.
Committee
and
Tracy
McKee
is
kind
of
staffing
that,
but
she
wasn't
able
to
attend
so
if
I
could
call
him
Jacob
Lindsey,
who
was
there
to
give
us
just
a
very
brief
report
about
what
we
discussed
there.
B
R
R
They
discuss
the
matter
of
respecting
grand
trees,
which
is
often
a
conflict
when
undergrounding
utilities
researching
best
practices,
especially
when
installing
underground
utilities
and
existing
neighborhoods,
which
is
not
often
done.
Typically,
it's
on
commercial
corridors.
The
next
steps
is
that
the
group
will
be
looking
at
a
future
ordinance
and
the
planning
department
will
be
looking
at
creating
that
valuation
matrix.
So
we
can
look
at
cost-benefit
when
looking
at
undergrounding
utilities
and
the
legal
and
Parks
departments
are
going
to
work
on
a
list
of
neighborhoods
for
future
consideration
for
placing
utilities
underground
and.
B
Then,
finally,
look
for
ways
to
move
along
the
neighborhoods
that
are
already
on
the
list
of
neighborhoods
and
there's
one
that's
getting
ready
to
proceed.
That's
Country,
Club
two
they've
finally
met
all
their
requirements,
they're
getting
ready
to
go
underground,
but
we've
got
this
long-standing
list.
It's
got
about
a
dozen
neighborhoods
on
it
and
we
want
to
set
up
a
fair
way
to
either
move
them
along
or,
if
they're
not
going
to
step
up
to
the
plate
and
get
all
their
easements
and
all
in
place.
B
You
know
to
start
fire
our
ties
in
other
places
in
the
city
and
some
being
commercial
corridors
or
where
there's
really
beautiful
canopies
of
trees
that
we
want
to
protect
and
and
be
able
to
move
forward.
With
some
of
the
funding
we
have.
We
have
six
million
dollars
sitting
in
the
bank
and
we
only
put
up
thirty
five
percent
when
we
do
a
projects
and
Dominion
puts
up
fifty
fifty
percent
so
so,
in
effect,
I
mean
we
could
leverage
that
existing
six
million
dollars
for
eighteen.
Seventeen,
eighteen
million
dollars
worth
of
undergrounding
right
now.
S
R
Councilmember,
so
we
have
it
done
network
presently
our
department
hasn't,
but
that
certainly
is
going
to
be
something
that
we
do
consider
when
we
create
this
valuation
matrix
and
that
may
end
up
taking
any
number
of
different
forms.
But
we
think
that
the
commercial
areas
absolutely
need
to
have
a
similar
way
of
evaluating
how
undergrounding
happens.
So,
yes,
we
will
be
doing
that,
but.
S
B
C
I
just
wanted
to
build
on
what
councilmember
woody
was
mentioning,
because
certain
parts
of
West
Ashley
but
tickle
Hotel
Road,
would
be
a
prime
example
of
we
get
Charlestown
landing.
That
would
be
needs
attention
along
that
corridor.
I
know
the
county
is
about
to
unveil
its
plans
for
this
park
next
door
to
Charlestown
lands.
They
meet
it's
an
opportunity
to
work
with
the
state
and
the
county
to
look
at
those
opportunities
to
vary
some
of
these
lines.
J
J
B
Number
four
on
the
list
and
they
just
never
got
their
easements
all
together,
and
what
part
of
the
discussion
I'll
share
is
that
sometimes,
if
you
take
the
whole
neighborhood,
it's
it's
harder
to
get
it
done
and
we
feel
like
it'll,
be
better
to
prioritize
certain
certain
roads.
You
know
based
on
the
canopy
of
trees,
maybe
based
on
the
importance
of
the
commercial
district
rather
than
prescribing
that
a
whole
neighborhood.
B
It
has
to
be
done
at
once,
because
it
it
makes
it
difficult
apparently
to
get
get
it
to
completion
depending
on
how
big
the
neighborhood
is
great,
all
right.
So
next,
if
I
could
call
Tracy
McKee
to
finish,
establish
report
on
our
Novak
consulting
process
and
service
improvement
work,
and
we
started
at
last
meeting
and
we
talked
about
TRC,
but
there
were
many
other
things
have
been
working
on
so
she's
going
to
try
to
give
us
a
brief
update
on
the
rest
of
them.
So.
T
T
And
I'm
gonna
jump
ahead
because
you
all
have
seen
that
and
I
promise.
This
will
be
brief
because
most
of
what
I
really
wanted
to
show
you
guys
last
time
was
about
TRC.
So
thank
you
for
indulging
me
again.
Two
weeks
later,
I
think
you
know
couple
points
that
I've
failed
to
communicate
a
couple
of
weeks
ago.
Were
you
know
number
one
that
implementing
the
recommendations
made
by
Novak
has
really
had
a
very
positive
impact
on
improving
delivery
of
city
services.
T
The
recommendations
have
allowed
us
to
really
focus
on
the
most
impactful
and
the
most
important
changes
that
we
can
make
to
better
improve
services.
It's
also
really
help
departments.
They
are
really
embracing.
The
change
and
I
sense
that
they
are
feeling
much
more
empowered
than
ever
to
actually
make
additional
improvements
that
they
see
in
their
work.
So
I
think
those
are.
Those
are
really
important
things
that
to
communicate
to
Yelp,
so
we'll
dive
right
into
the
public
service
piece.
They're,
really,
two
reports
produced
related
to
public
service.
T
The
first
was
focused
on
environmental
service
and
fleet
operations,
and
then
the
second
was
the
second
was
an
assessment
of
the
department's
organizational
structure,
so
I
just
wanted
to
these
again.
These
are
just
highlights
you
have
the
report
and
I
think
you
guys
have
my
slides
now
so
I'll
run
through
these
really
quickly,
but
the
first
was
to
reassign
fleet
to
public
service.
That's
been
completed.
T
Another
great
recommendation
was
to
expand
the
technology
used
to
trash
and
street-sweeping
I
know
that
it's
been
completed
for
trash
and
I
believe
that's
being
worked
on
for
street
sweeping
as
well.
So
that's
going
really
really
well
prioritizing
acquisition
of
the
automatic
side,
loaders
or
ASLs.
That
was
a
recommendation
that
came
out
of
this
and
also
the
big
bellies.
So
we
you
know
introducing
those
high
capacity
receptacles
downtown,
we'll
talk
about
the
impact
of
those
and
actually
the
second
one.
All
of
the
all
the
recommendations
have
already
been
implemented.
T
So
the
SLS
we
introduced
the
first
ASL
into
our
garbage
collection
fleet
in
2019.
So
when
this
is
fully
implemented,
we
expect
to
see
the
number
of
routes
that
we
run
will
go
down
from
41
to
32
routes
because
of
the
efficiencies
introduced
with
the
ASL
and
when
they
are
fully
implemented,
we
can
expect
to
see
we
hope
about
1.2
million
in
savings
based
on
those
efficiencies.
T
So
I
think
that's
a
really
really
great
product
of
just
one
of
the
recommendations
from
from
the
new
about
consulting
services
or
know
that
consulting
group,
so
the
other
one
was
that
big
bellies.
As
you
all
know,
those
went
online
this
year,
so
our
our
folks
would
go
and
collect
those
old
bins,
six
to
seven
times
a
day.
T
So
now
these
receptacles
actually
send
notifications
when
they're
ready
to
be
collected
so,
which
is
really
really
great.
It's
really
allowed
that
additional
capacity
to
focus
those
staff
on
groundskeeping
duties
and
they've
been
able
to
eliminate
some
temporary
positions
so
receive
seeing
some
savings
there,
as
well
special
events,
a
lot
of
good
stuff
going
on
here.
This
team
is
really
really
going
gangbusters.
We
created
a
new
Special
Events
Manager
position
that
is
actually
all
transferring
to
the
liveability
department.
So
it'll
be
right
in
line
with
all
the
tourism
and
livability.
T
T
Lastly,
so
the
IT
governance,
one
of
the
big
recommendations,
was
to
do
an
IT
strategic
plan.
This
is
a
pretty
recent
report.
They've
already
been
working
on
the
cybersecurity
element
of
that
all
the
other
recommendations
are
expected
to
be
executed
in
2020
on
the
part,
staffing
study.
I
think
you
all
know
a
work
order.
Management
system
was
implemented
earlier
this
year,
and
so
that's
really
helped
to
parks,
become
much
more
efficient
in
their
work
and
I.
Believe
all
the
staffing
recommendations
that
were
made
were
entered
into
their
2020
budget.
T
So
if
you
guys
need
a
refresher
on
that,
please
look
at
the
report
to
prove
that
for
the
parks,
the
parks
budget
and
then
purchasing,
we
did
give
that
report
to
you
all
too,
but
those
recommendations
are
actually
still
being
vetted
by
B
FRC
so
and
like
I
said
last
time
this
was
not
a
one-person
effort.
There's
been
it's
multiple
departments
working
together
to
make
all
these
changes
to
how
we
provide
services.
So
with
that
I'll
be
happy
to
answer
any
questions.
U
T
This
is
because
the
efficiency
of
the
new
machinery-
I
am
I'm,
not
an
expert
and
they're.
So
forgive
me
if
I
might
stumble
here
a
little
bit
with
this,
but
the
these
new
trucks
only
require
one
driver.
So
right
now
we
have
one
driver.
We
have
two
people
on
all
of
our
existing
trucks.
So
now
we
can
use
these
with
just
one
driver.
U
U
About
14
hours,
one
o'clock
you
got
one
truck
at
one:
man
pick
it
up.
One
sv,
then
you
close
to
:
you've
got
about
30
houses
and
then
you've
got
another
truck
picking
them
up.
I,
don't
say
you
make
a
name
question
because
at
one
point
one
to
take
it
at
all
three,
but
now
you've
got
two
trucks
taking
it
taking
care
that
Street.
U
T
U
B
Have
two
we're
asking
for
two
more
and
as
you
mentioned,
they
really
don't
work
on
the
peninsula
or
in
really
tight,
tighter
spaces.
You
need
a
little
room
from
the
arm
to
pick
up
the
trash.
Can
they
pick
up
in
my
at
my
house
and
they
started
a
few
months
ago,
so
he's
so
much
faster.
That
they've
been
able
to
extend
the
the
length
of
his
route
and
so
by
doing
that
they
can
eventually
cut
down
a
route
or
to
take
a
route
out.
B
I
T
That's
a
great
question
and
I
know
that
that
was
talked
about
in
public
works
today,
and
you
know,
Tom
may
be
able
to
speak
more
intelligently
to
this,
but
it
was
my
understanding
that
they've
had
such
a
such
a
difficult
time,
keeping
employees
that
this
this
actually
matched
the
number
of
employees
they've
been
able
to
maintain
on
a
regular
basis
in
part
in
environmental
services,
not
really
good
answer,
but
I
mean
it
could
be
an
opportunity.
But
I
understand
that
there
is
that
challenge
for
them
as
well.
Kevin.
L
You,
mr.
mayor,
if
you
see
those
trucks
are
gnashing
and
the
suburban
area,
a
pretty
efficient
I
mean
seriously.
They
pull
up
arm
goes
out
dumps
it
puts
it
back
down,
goes
right
to
the
next
one.
Actually,
Keogh
and
Seabrook
hate
that
stuff
long
time.
So
in
the
suburban
areas
they
work
extremely
well,
but
you
right
downtown
when
people
parked
on
the
street
and
stuff,
it
wouldn't
work
at
all.
So
yeah,
that's.
T
V
V
T
We
have
talked
about
it
and
talked
about
ways
that
we
can
handle
that
some
of
the
concerns
that
have
come
up
just
just
being
completely
open
and
honest
TRC.
Doesn't
it's
not
a
voting
body
so
that
all
they're
doing
is
trying
to
ensure
that
applicants
are
following
the
city
code
and
making
sure
that
that
those
rules
are
being
met?
And
so
you
know
it's
it's
they
don't
they
don't
vote
on
anything,
but
we
are
definitely
trying
to
figure
out
how
we
can
how
we
can
integrate
that
into
the
TRC
process.
Absolutely.
V
The
second
thing
that
we
discussed
at
the
last
and
had
to
do
with
incentives,
I
think
have
you
addressed
that
and
if
so,
have
you
established
performance
standards
that
each
employee
would
be
judged
against
in
order
for
that
person
to
be
performance
to
be
assessed
as
poor,
failing,
fair
out
student
cetera?
Do
we
have
such
a
performance
standard
in
so.
T
I
know
that
there
I
missed
that
budget
ad-hoc
meeting,
but
I
believe
that
there
was
some
discussion
about
how
we
can
jump-start
that
again,
because
you
know
we're
not
doing
a
very
good
job
of
doing
performance
evaluations
in
it.
Yes,
so
we're
having
ongoing
discussions,
we
have
a
team,
that's
meeting
on
a
regular
basis
to
talk
about
what
is
the
right
way
that
we
can
introduce,
reintroduce
or
introduce,
because
20
of
in
here
20
years
never
have
mayor
okay.
So
how
do
we?
How
do
we
introduce
that
into?
T
V
B
All
right,
so
we
got
one
more
Thank,
You
Tracy,
one
more
report.
We
had
a
phone
web
meeting
of
the
hotel
task
force
that
the
main
topic
was
began
on
rooftop
Bars,
but
really
it
morphed
more
into
a
noise
discussion
because
it
really
doesn't
matter
if
it's
a
rooftop
bar
or
patio
bar
or
of
what
kind
of
lounge
if
it
seemed
that
the
main
concern
was
if
my
noise
generated
so
on.
Mr.
Lindsay
was
staffing
that
do
you
want
to
give
us
a
brief
report
on
that
as
well.
R
Yes,
sir
Thank
You
mr.
mayor
I
met
last
week,
convened
my
staff
and
follow-up
from
this
meeting,
and
we
have
assigned
specific
duty
to
the
staff
what
we're
doing
right
now,
it's
looking
further
into
this
matter
of
rooftop
Bars.
First
of
all,
we
are
going
to
produce
recommendations
for
an
or
an
ordinance
change
and
potentially
enforcement
changes
and
we're
doing
three
specific
things
at
the
moment.
R
One
is
we're,
looking
at
additional
maps
for
how
this
proposed
ordinance
might
affect
the
entire
city
and
then
includes
highway
17
or
in
Avondale
maybank
Highway,
other
parts
of
West
ashley
and
further
mapping.
That
shows
how
it
affects
the
entire
city.
We're
gonna
be
working
with
the
zoning
staff
to
provide
some
additional
info
in
Daniel
Island.
R
They
have
their
own
rules,
of
course,
and
almost
everything,
but
specifically
look
at
how
rooftop
Bars
would
work
on
Daniel
Island
in
terms
of
our
proposed
regulations
and
the
last
thing
and
the
most
important
there's
further
coordination
with
the
livability
department,
as
well
as
our
division
of
business
and
neighborhood
services
to
discuss
best
practices
on
noise
enforcement,
and
this
relates
to
how
one
enforces
against
noise
violations.
All
the
discussions
we've
had
so
far
and
continue
to
have
about
decibel
levels,
what's
what's
really
enforceable?
R
What
holds
up
in
court
we're
good
looking
into
how
we
do
this
the
best
possible
way
and
we'll
be
making
recommendations
about
that
as
well.
We're
gonna
reconvene
the
task
force
when
they
are
ready
and
when
we
are
ready
to
hear
that
I
think
staffs
is
gonna.
Have
those
ready
in
December
availability
of
the
task
force
would
determine
when
we're
able
to
get
everyone
back
together
again,
all.
W
Gonna
make
my
point
pretty
short
and
sweet
once
again.
I
think
this
is
ridiculous,
absolutely
ridiculous.
We
defer
something
as
a
council
and
it
just
gets
put
under
a
rug
and
hidden
for
several
months.
Why?
Don't
you
let
this
body
be
the
one
who
makes
a
decision
on
whether
or
not
this
becomes
an
ordinance
I.
Think
y'all
should
be
careful
about
how
much
time
you
spend
on
this,
because
when
it
comes
to
us,
it's
going
to
change.
W
N
You
mayor
I
was
just
I,
mean
I
I
haven't
set
in
on
your
task
force,
mr.
Lindsey,
so
I
don't
know
if
this
has
been
a
consideration,
but
in
thinking
about
my
district
and
James
Island
as
a
whole,
we
don't
have
rooftops
to
have
bars
on
yet,
but
we
do
have
a
lot
more
land
around
establishments,
so
literally
I
was
riding
my
bike
in
my
neighborhood
about
four
o'clock
last
Saturday
and
a
very
popular
establishment
on
fronting
on
folly,
Road.
That
has
a
parking
lot
that
it
comes
within
20
feet
of
the
street.
N
V
Agree
we
should
deal
with
noise
generally,
but
but
my
question
is
at
the
last
meeting
we
talked
about
a
hundred
and
fifty
feet
standard
and
it
occurred
to
me
that
when
someone
is
doing
a
nightclub
in
a
neighborhood,
we
used
a
500
feet,
rule
and
I'd
like
for
the
task
force
and
staff
to
be
able
to
explain
the
difference
in.
Why
not
now
is
great,
but
I
just
think
that
if
we
have
an
existing
standard,
okay
at
500
feet,
why
are
we
at
a
hundred
and
fifty
feet
for
rooftop
Bars?
What's
the
difference?
Okay,
all.
L
So
his
suggestion
was
or
their
suggestion
was.
Maybe
you
limit
it
to
music
or
something
you
know
kind
of
Pumped
in
music
like
that
versus
a
obviously
live
band,
so
I
mean
I'm
not
on
the
task
force,
but
maybe
pass
that
along
for
consideration,
because
it
is
not
the
fun
and
frolic
of
the
people.
It's
just
usually
that
loud
music
creates
a
problem
and
it's
right
in.
B
B
W
P
W
Please
just
just
to
give
I'd
like
to
get
some
background
from
them,
so
that
I
can
explain
this
to
you
what
I'm
really
looking
for,
because
this
started
off
as
sort
of
a
very
simple
inquiry
about
what
kind
of
state
law
we
might
already
have.
And
you
know,
as
we've
seen
in
this
current
election,
there's
been
a
lot
of
players
outside
of
just
the
candidates
that
were
very
involved
in
these
this
election
process
this
year.
W
So,
once
I
have
that
meeting
with
our
legal
department,
I
think
I'll
be
a
lot
more
well
informed
and
kind
of
able
to
help
kind
of
even
see
if
I
want
to
go
anywhere
with
this
other
than
the
fact
that
I
think
it's
a
good
discussion
for
us
to
have
as
a
council,
because,
as
we've
seen
over
the
last
decade,
the
amount
of
money
spent
in
the
election
cycle
has
drastically
gone
up.
The
people
that
are
donating
to
campaigns
has
drastically
changed.
W
B
B
W
Sir,
we
met
today
the
the
Committee
on
Public
Works
in
utilities
met
today
at
about
310
I
was
fashionably
late,
and
then
we
began
acceptance
and
dedications
we
approved
both
of
those
unanimously.
We
had
some
good
discussion
on
on
the
stormwater
management
department
update
and
also
he
reported
about
Carolina's
waste
and
I
would
ask
mr.
mayor
your
pleasure
if
mr.
fountain
could
come
up
and
maybe
touch
on
a
few
of
those,
especially
the
medical
district
tunnel
extension,
the
stormwater
standards
schedule
update
and
the
doo
drainage
improvements.
I
think
those
three
are
very
important.
X
The
medical
district
tunnel
extension:
this
is
the
project
reader
we
refer
to
as
the
Erhart
shaft.
This
is.
We
brought
this
up
for
discussion
as
we
had
previously
approved.
It
counsel
the
30%
design
for
that
work,
based
on
the
necessary
time
frame
to
complete
that
project
before
the
phase
for
construction
is
complete.
So
this
discussion
was
that
that
initial
30
percent
of
design
work
will
be
complete
this
early
winter
December
January
time
period,
so
we'll
need
to
bring
to
council
the
authorization
to
continue
with
the
remainder
of
that
design
work
for
next
year.
X
We
expect
to
bring
that
this
December
again
that
we
are
still
working
on
the
construction
funding,
so
it
was
brought
up
at
committee
to
make
sure
that
whatever
we
authorized,
it
only
finds
us
to
deconstruct
the
design
costs
not
into
the
construction
costs,
and
we
said
that
wouldn't
be
a
problem
with
the
way
we've
set
up
the
the
work.
We
also
talked
about
the
stormwater
design.
It's
manual.
We've
now
received
comments
from
all
of
the
engineering
firms,
the
Chamber
of
Commerce,
and
we
had
open
as
the
comment
period
for
anyone
from
the
task
force.
X
We
didn't
receive
much
other
written
comment
from
the
other
task
force.
Members
a
comes
currently
reviewing
those
comments.
We
will
have
a
follow-up
stakeholder
task
force
meeting,
probably
the
first
week
of
December,
to
go
back
and
forth
with
here's.
How
we
responded
to
those
comments.
What
we
see
is
necessary
revisions
to
manual
honey
and
then
we
would
plan
to
make
those
revisions
to
manual
after
that
meeting,
assuming
nothing
that
different
than
what
we've
seen
so
far
from
reading.
X
Through
the
comments
and
having
some
initial
discussions
with
the
members,
we
would
be
prepared
to
have
a
draft
copy
of
that
manual
in
late
December,
so
either
for
a
second
meeting
in
December
or
possibly
for
a
first
meeting
in
January,
the
DuPont
whopper
drainage
improvements
project.
We
talked
about
this.
The
mayor
had
brought
up
with
Charleston
County
councilmember
moody,
the
option
of
continuing
a
collaborative
funding
for
the
work
in
that
Basin
and
the
county
has
been
very
supportive
of
that.
We
had
some
follow-up
meetings
with
their
Finance
Group.
They
proposed
to.
X
We
follow
up
the
same
2575
cautionary
split
that
we
have
for
the
existing
study,
so
we're
going
to
go
through
an
IgA
process
to
put
that
together,
based
on
a
similar
idea
to
what
we
did
for
the
existing
work,
which
is
where
the
city
manages
the
project
and
the
county
is
based.
A
financial
contributor.
X
Absolutely
so
so
Bruns
Lane
was
an
emergency
art
repair,
that's
the
small
street,
that's
in
between
the
Yeti
store
and
the
five
guys
on
the
King
Street
side,
and
then
it
runs
past
the
Charleston
College
of
Charleston
TD
Arena.
Thank
you.
That's
recreational
center
TT
arena
in
the
back
there's
their
main
loading
docks
and
their
some
of
their
capital
project
group
access
points.
So
we
had
a
pretty
significant
failure
where
the
road
was
starting
to
cave.
In
that
area
we
had
to
go
in.
There
was
a
brick
arch
as
much
smaller
arch
than
usual.
X
We
actually
had
to
replace
the
arch
with
a
HDPE
pipe
in
that
situation,
so
we
just
had
that
discussion
point
because
it
was
a
significant
amount
of
funds
that
were
expended
in
case
for
any
questions
other
than
that.
Just
if
you
do
want
very
brief
updates,
Lorena
projects,
this
bring
fishburne
project.
X
The
tunnel
concrete
is
making
steady
progress
now,
so
we
do
expect
to
have
that
phase
completed
this
summer
phase
four,
which
is
basically
installing
the
large
hole
and
pipes
that
extend
out
into
the
river
to
let
the
water
come
from
the
tunnels
out
into
the
river.
We
do
have
the
test
piles
in
now,
which
is
what
that
structure
will
sit
on
top
of
it's
testing
to
make
sure
that
the
assumed
Powell's
design
works.
We
also
have
the
trestle
be
constructed.
V
There's
several
places
on
the
peninsula
that
well,
we
know
it's
floods,
but
we
have
not
really
been
having
any
discussions
with
regard
to
how
to
fix
it.
Like
Gordon
like
Moo
tree
and
president
Piedmont
peach
tree
mean
these
places
are
literally
rivers
and
we
have
yet
really
to
have
start
any
discussion
with
regard
to
trying
to
remedy
it.
If
it
can
I
know,
most
of
them
are
creek
beds
and
that's
a
part
of
the
problem,
but
I
mean
folks
have
been
living
with
that
now.
V
Wow
50
60
70
years,
and
has
nothing
to
do
with
any
construction.
It
just
is,
and
so
at
some
point,
I'd
like
to
just
get
some
type
of
feedback
on
how
and
if
and
and
when
we're
gonna
start
approaching,
that
issue
on
the
peninsula.
I
know
we
have
problems
all
over,
but
these
are
areas
that
traditionally
have
flooded.
You
know
I'd
like
to
see
all
that
water
pumped
into
Hampton
Park
and
make
it
reservoir
doing
the
time
or
something
I
mean
you've,
got
figure
out
something
creative
to
sort
of
pump
that
water
out
of
it.
X
If
you,
that
might
actually
be
a
good
point
to
talk
about
a
couple
of
the
projects
right,
I
didn't
get
into
great
detail
and
I'll
try
be
brief,
but
we
do
have
the
this
prioritization
system
going
into
place,
and
then
we
have
the
special
protection
area.
Mapping
was
showing
the
areas
of
known
flooding,
so
the
the
intent
is
when
we
have
that
work
complete
to
come
back
to
council
say
now
that
we
have
these
areas
of
known
flooding.
X
X
There
have
been
a
lot
of
changes
in
whydentity
for
some
of
the
peninsula.
Work
may
end
up
having
a
lot
of
the
same
similarities,
but
that
still
needs
to
be
incorporated,
I
guess
with
what
we're
spending
in
the
other
districts
as
well
in
the
into
one
plan,
instead
of
sort
of
seven,
a
special
plan
for
the
mid
Peninsula,
a
special
plan
for
what's,
they
want
to
have
a
citywide
plan
that
we
can
say.
This
is
the
approach.
Okay,.
V
I'm
just
saying
84
was
a
citywide
plan.
It
was
annexed
some
new
areas,
okay
and
the
areas
I'm
talking
about
we've
had
that
problem
in
84
and
there
were
specific,
specific
provisions
in
the
84
study,
the
tupman,
how
we
can
correct
them,
I'd
hate
to
just
continually
doing
it
and
doing
it
in
absolutely.
Nothing
is
getting
done
so
somehow
we're
gonna
have
to
be
able
to
tell
the
residents
in
that
area,
especially
wagging
terrorist
and
Hampton
Park.
What
are
we
going
to
do?
I'm
not
saying
we
haven't
done
anything.
V
X
Agree,
I
think
the
intent
is
to
have
an
updated
plan
that
this
the
capital
improvement
plan,
then
ties
directly
into
so
that
we
are
again
in
30
years.
Looking
at
a
plan
and
saying
why
did
none
of
this
get
accomplished
but
to
actually
have
a
plan?
That
is
where
we're
making
decisions
off
of
so
we
we
do
have
that
actual
addressing
of
the
issues,
not
just
identifying
the
issues
right.
O
O
Nothing
have
never
been
done,
and
this
is
now
going
into
20th
century
tired
me,
2020
we've
been
flooding
since
the
forties
that
I
know
it's
still
the
same
way,
so
we're
getting
new
things
down
and
going
here
and
fixing
flood
over
here.
So
we
say
in
doing
flying
over
here,
but
these
places
still
was
planning
and
is
still
playing
as
of
the
day.
So
I
don't
see
any
changes
being
done
with
it
all
right,
we're
doing
nothing
with
it
at
all.
O
It's
still
the
same
thing
over
and
over
and
over
again,
we
are
going
say
we're
doing
this.
We
have
to
go
over
here
and
fix,
but
when
you're
not
fixing
this
problem
and
you're
leaving
this
problem
alone,
you
fixing
this
problem.
Then
you
go
into
another
problem.
The
first
problem
still
exists
and
you're
not
accomplishing
anything
to
me.
I
feel
that
if
we
do
something
to
accomplish
it,
they
don't
have
to
come
back
to
that.
That's
the
way,
I
look
at
things
and
doing
things
and
even
its
structure
than
anything
like
that.
O
O
The
list
when
I
look
at
the
list
again,
but
they
were
first
on
the
list
to
be
rectified
and
I
can
tell
you
as
facts
in
the
city,
even
with
King
and
huger,
even
without
President,
Street
freshman
Street
actually
happen,
you
never
first
on
the
list
and
they
were
pushed
backwards,
and
then
we
went
to
someplace
else,
so
we
left
that
alone
is
still
existing
now,
so
now
we
are
going
elsewhere
and
you're
still
existing.
So
when
are
we
gonna
get
to
this?
X
Absolutely
agree:
most
most
of
the
projects
working
now
are
identified
and
funded
five
to
ten
years
ago.
So
I
agree
that
what
we
need
to
do
is
have
a
plan
that
the
funding
is
being
based
on
what's
in
the
plan,
so
that
we
all
do
have
assurance
that
we
actually
get
to
the
projects
we've
identified,
not
just
identified
the
projects
but
then
built
those
projects
to
repair
them.
I
W
B
L
Things
we
did
discuss
in
the
meeting
was
also
looking
at
bringing
off
people
back
on
board
to
do
it
already
discussions
about
our
people
being
the
best.
But
now,
when
you
put
the
automated
truck
in
there,
it
may
be
cost-effective,
they
get
the
new
trucks
in
the
suburban
area
and
can
move
through
the
routes
faster
and
obviously
these
Fairyland
and
being
pretty
close
so
hard.
L
B
N
B
O
Y
Y
M6,
which
we
laid
on
your
desk,
which
was
regarding
the
reporting
of
accidents
when
there's
damage
to
vehicles
and
last
time,
I
think
mr.
Zimmerman
asked
if
we
could
include
the
language
collisions
and
the
legal
department
asked
for
the
opportunity
to
research
that
to
see
if
there
was
any
issue
with
state
law.
We
added
that
language
we've
researched
it.
We
don't
have
any
problem
with
that.
So
we've
proposed
an
amendment
that
we've
laid
on
your
desk
for
second
and
third
reading.
That
would
just
add
the
language
collisions
to
the
reporting
of.
B
B
S
F
B
O
B
N
N
B
So
all
in
favor
of
second
reading,
please
say
aye
any
opposed
the
odds
have
an
upper
third
reading
of
one
through
six,
eight
and
nine,
with
council
member
Jackson
recusing
from
number
one
all
in
favor,
please
say
aye
and
the
opposed
Aeons
habit.
Thank
you
for
that
correction.
Next
bills.
Up
for
first
reading.
B
B
N
L
A
This
is
the
Comcast
people.
All
of
you
should
have
gotten
information
from
Comcast
that
they
are
having
a
forums
or
that
anybody
remember
receiving
them.
Okay,
so
all
right.
So
there
is
a
forum
tomorrow
and
what
we
can
pass
this
around.
If
you
haven't
seen
it
there,
numerous
things
that
begin
at
9:45
in
the
morning
with
Digital
Inclusion
rally,
diversity
and
tech,
lunch-and-learn
and
a
cybersecurity.