►
From YouTube: 05 21 18 Committee Work Session
Description
No description was provided for this meeting.
If this is YOUR meeting, an easy way to fix this is to add a description to your video, wherever mtngs.io found it (probably YouTube).
A
D
G
H
G
J
F
H
A
Thank
You,
mr.
president,
tonight
with
us
making
a
presentation
will
be
our
Health
Commissioner
of
Summit
County,
Donna
Skoda
and
with
her
also
is
Corrie
Kendrick,
and
forgive
me
for
forgetting
your
title,
but
I'm
sure
that
we'll
get
to
that.
If
you
would
go
ahead
and
take
the
podium
and
stage
name.
K
My
name
is
Donna
Skoda
SK
Oda
I
am
the
health
commissioner
for
Summit,
County
and
I.
Thank
you
greatly
for
letting
us
come
here
this
evening
and
talk
to
you
about
the
issue
of
tobacco
in
our
community.
I'm
gonna
start
out
briefly
and
talk
a
little
bit
about
public
health
policy
and
then
Corey
will
get
into
the
t21
presentation.
First
of
all,
as
you
know,
and
each
of
you
should
have
a
handout
to
refer
to.
If
you
look
on
that
first
page,
there's
a
triangular-shaped
item
that
looks
at
the
health
pyramid.
K
This
is
a
tool
that
CDC
has
used
for
many
many
years
to
influence
public
health
and
lawmakers
to
try
to
really
look
at
the
health
impact.
How
much
bang
for
your
buck
are
you
getting,
and
we
know
that
individually,
it's
important
to
have
education
for
individuals,
but
you
get
much
more
if
you
change
policy
and
if
you
make
it
more
difficult
and
if
you
make
the
default
choice,
the
easier
choice.
So,
if
you
turn
the
page,
when
we
look
at
over
the
century,
public
health
policy
interventions
have
been
good
and
far-reaching.
There's
the
vaccine
issue.
K
There's
helmets
we
require
children
to
wear
bike
helmets
and
some
states
have
mandatory
motorcycle
helmets.
We've
also
done
seatbelts,
and
what
this
is
is
it's
a
way
to
protect
the
general
public?
Not
everybody
likes
it,
but
it
does
really
save
lives
and
help
keep
costs
down
for
the
public
spend.
We
know
that
tobacco
kills
more
folks
than
alcohol,
aids,
car
crashes,
illegal
drugs,
murders
and
suicides
combined.
K
K
If
you
remember
and
think
back
to
smoke
free
Ohio
in
2006,
it
was
initially
met
with
a
lot
of
opposition.
But
now
it's
difficult
to
imagine
going
to
a
restaurant
or
anywhere
in
being
exposed
to
secondhand
smoke
and
I
can
tell
you
in
my
lifetime.
I
know:
I
have
seen
the
greatest
impact
we
will
have
on
health
is
by
creating
smoke-free
Ohio.
We
at
the
Health
Department
do
all
of
the
follow
up.
Calls
for
the
state
of
Ohio
for
violators
and
I
can
tell
you
it's
just
become
like
part
of
life.
K
L
Good
evening
my
name
is
Cory
Kendrick
I'm,
the
director
of
population,
health
for
Summit,
County,
Public,
Health,
I'm,
just
gonna
talk
a
little
bit
specifically
about
tobacco
21,
and
so
this
is
a
program.
That's
been
going
on
for
some
time
now.
It's
currently
in
300
plus
cities
in
19
different
states
and
currently
five
states
have
went
tobacco
21,
so
the
whole
state
you
currently
have
to
be
21
years
of
age
to
buy
tobacco
in
Ohio,
Columbus,
Cleveland
and
recently
Akron
have
all
passed.
L
L
L
Premature
death
things
you
can
do
to
present
to
prevent,
as
well
as
the
American
Heart
Association
Lung,
Association,
Cancer,
Society
Coalition
for
tobacco-free
kids
and
countless
others
who
have
brought
on
support
for
tobacco
21.
This
is
also
evidence-based.
The
21
is
just
not
a
magic
number,
it
might
seem
like
well.
Everything
else
is
going
21.
Why?
L
Why
21
well,
there's
a
couple
good
reasons
for
this:
it
pushes
it
out
of
the
social
circle
of
high
school
kids
and
what
the
aim
of
what
this
is
really
looking
to
do
is
get
tobacco
and
recently
vaping
products
which
I'll
talk
about
in
a
minute
out
of
the
reach.
Eighth
graders,
two
seniors,
that's
the
biggest
issue,
and
if
you
don't
start
smoking
by
the
age
of
21,
you're,
95%
less
likely
to
do
so.
So
really,
two
percent
of
smokers
create
90%
of
lifelong
smokers
Ron.
L
This
is
evidence-based
so
by
pushing
that
social
circle
out
and
making
it
harder
for
teens
to
know
someone
who
might
be
21
years
of
age
or
older,
which
is
less
likely
than
knowing
an
18
year
old,
which
is
likely
a
senior
in
their
school,
it's
harder
than
for
harder
for
them
to
get
tobacco,
and
we
know
from
our
youth
risk
behavior
survey
that
we
do
that.
The
two
main
ways
that
teens
get
tobacco
are
one
from
a
peer
and
two
from
a
retail
establishment.
They're
able
to
buy
it
at
so.
L
Their
component
of
this,
which
we'll
talk
to
in
a
minute,
is
enforcement
I'm
doing
stronger
enforcement
with
the
retailers
electronic
tobacco
vaping.
This
has
become
huge.
We've
definitely
seen
a
downward
trend.
Tobacco
use,
which
is
great
Ohio,
is
still
one
of
the
worst
tobacco
states
in
the
United
States.
L
We
rank
like
48
the
49th
from
the
Health
Policy
Institute
of
Ohio
on
some
of
our
tobacco
rankings,
but
it's
definitely
declined,
but
vaping,
however,
is
is
went
up
and
you
can
see
from
the
electronic
tobacco
vaping
slide
that
36%
of
students
have
tried
vaping,
as
opposed
to
27%
of
try
traditional
cigarettes.
This
is
concerning
because
these
new
joules
I
don't
know
if
you
guys
have
seen
these
in
the
newspaper
I'm
starting
to
come
out
and
they're
becoming
really
popular.
L
It's
become
almost
a
social
media
meme
to
be
Zhu
Ling
in
school
and
I've
talked
to
some
local
high
schools
and
I've
heard
some.
Some
concerned.
Parents
stating
their
kids
really
having
an
issue
with
these
dual
devices
in
the
classroom,
there's
about
the
size
of
a
USB
device
they
actually
plug
into
a
USB
portt
charge
and
they
have
electronic
their
electronic
cigarette.
They
contain
nicotine
and
what
we're
starting
to
find
out
about
electronic
cigarettes.
L
They're
brand
new
I
mean
they've
only
been
on
the
scene
since
about
2010,
so
we
don't
have
a
lot
of
data
on
them,
but
they're
starting
to
do
more
research.
The
American
pediatric
Association
has
done
some
research
on
this
and
they
found
that
there
is
multiple
cancer-causing
ingredients
in
these
cigarettes.
Five
cancer-causing
ingredients
and
the
highest
level
of
cancer-causing
ingredients
come
from
this.
The
fruit
flavors,
which
are
most
popular
with
high
school
kids,
and
these
come
in
thousands
of
fruit
flavors
from
grape
to
apple
banana
to
all
sorts
of.
L
L
Another
study
that
was
done
by
the
American
pediatric
a
publication
is
that
these
cigarettes
are
a
one-way
street
to
traditional
tobacco
use,
so
students
who
try
a
vaping
device
are
seven
times
more
likely
to
go
to
traditional
cigarettes.
The
following
year
and
the
tobacco
industry
knows.
Tobacco
industry
is
kind
of
conceded
traditional
tobacco
and
they're,
starting
to
really
ramp
up
their
marketing
and
move
towards
cigarettes
because
they
know
they'll
still
get
the
net
gain
it's
in
the
e-cigarette
advertising.
It
increased
110
million
dollars
per
year,
one
of
the
biggest
questions
I
get
from.
L
This
is
the
military
aspect,
and
so
what's
interesting,
the
military
is
made
a
shift
in
the
recent
years
and
I
know.
You
know
talking
to
other
council
members
that
you
know
cigarettes
used
to
be
provided
in
the
you
know
to
soldiers
by
the
military.
So
it's
interesting
they're
not
flipping
there
their
stance
on
this,
but
you
know
knowing
the
data
we
know
now
about
tobacco.
L
The
military
is
very
interested
in
having
a
tobacco-free
military,
where
this
first
passed
in
Hawaii
statewide
the
base
also
complied
with
a
21
and
over
they
didn't
have
to
they
chose
to
and
each
branch.
The
military
has
launched
a
tobacco
cessation
program
and
campaigned
to
try
to
get
soldiers
to
commit
smoking
and
they're
very
supportive
of
any
method.
To
do
so.
L
So,
as
I
mentioned
before,
just
2%
tobacco
sales
helped
produce
90%
of
new
smokers
and
if
people
don't
start
by
the
age
of
21,
they're
95%
less
likely-
and
we
know
that
cessation
is
an
option.
But
if
you
remember
that
health
impact
pyramid
Donna
talked
about
that's
at
the
very
top
of
that
pyramid,
so
Shay
cessation
affects
one
person
at
time.
There's
a
90
percent
failure
rate.
It
takes
an
average
of
three
attempts,
so
it's
very
costly
to
do
so.
L
So
if
we
can
stop
teens
from
ever
starting
by
the
age
of
21,
they're,
very
less
likely
to
ever
start
so,
I'll
talk
just
briefly
about
enforcement
and
the
other
issue.
So
we
know
that
teens
get
the
cigarettes
from
either
their
friends
or
older
peers
or
from
retail
establishments.
They
get
sold
to
currently
there's
not
great
enforcement
for
tobacco
really
across
the
country.
It's
not
enforced
the
same
way
as
really
anything
else,
even
alcohol,
and
so
we
know
for
the
few
enforcement's
that
we're
done
in
Summit
County.
L
L
So
the
three
components
of
this,
the
implementation.
So
what
has
to
happen
for
this
to
work?
The
health
department,
the
model
that's
been
most
successful-
is
that
the
health
department
would
do
the
enforcement
compliance
and
inspections
of
these
retailers,
and
so
this
means
there's
no
cost
to
the
city.
The
retailers
pay
about
$150
fee
one
time
and
they'll
have
to
pay
anything
else.
L
L
This
has
to
be
done
through
a
ordinance
through
the
city
to
empower
the
health
department
to
enable
us
to
do
the
enforcement.
It
also
has
to
be
passed
to
raise
the
minimum
buying
age
of
21,
so
those
the
two
components
of
the
tobacco
21.
So
why
would
that
I?
Give
you
a
lot
of
information?
I
know
you
guys
have
lots
of
questions
so
or
may
not
have
any
questions?
I,
don't
know.
I.
H
L
H
L
There's
there's
really
not
a
whole
lot
of
funding
that
we
get
to
do
that
so
right
now
the
state
gives
us
a
very
small
grant
amount
for
very
specific
areas
to
do
enforcement
and
currently
we
have
to
contract
with
local
police
departments.
To
do
so.
So
very,
very
few
retail
establishments
are
ever
checked
for
compliance
and
that's
really
why
we
have
such
a
high
assault
rate,
and
on
top
of
that
I
mean
the
difference
between
a
17
or
18
year,
old
or
16
year
old,
18
year
old.
L
H
L
Well
again,
we
try
we'll
try
to
launch
an
education
campaign
with
all
the
retailers.
The
goal
is
to
bring
everyone
in
compliance.
We
wouldn't
want
to
penalize
anyone,
but
we
also
don't
want
them
selling
to
minors,
so
we're
gonna,
launch
education
campaign
to
the
retailer's,
provide
them.
Education,
cessation
information
for
those
18
to
20
year
olds,
that'll
be
affected
and
then
also
provide
some
signage
and
stickers
to
an
education
that
they
can
give
their
employees
to
make
sure
they're
not
selling
to
anyone
under
the
age
of
21.
L
It
may
not
have
an
immediate
impact,
but
very
shortly
over
time
it's
been
proven.
So
the
one
thing
I
forgot
to
mention
where
this
is
evidence-based.
The
first
one
of
the
first
areas
to
implement
this
in
Needham
Massachusetts
passed
this
and
they
did
a
youth
risk.
Behavior
survey,
the
next
three
years
following
and
what
was
interesting.
L
They
passed
it,
but
the
surrounding
areas
did
not,
and
so
they
had
a
50%
reduction
and
youth
initiation
rate
in
tobacco,
so
it
cut
their
teen
smoking
rates
in
half
over
the
next
three
years,
while
the
surrounding
towns
who
didn't
pass
it
didn't
and
they
didn't
drop
at
all,
so
it
had
a
significant
impact.
So
why
no
one
of
the
you
know
arguments
is
that
well,
they
could
just
go
across
the
street.
Well,
some
people
will
go
across
the
street
or
across
a
town
of
do
so,
but
it
still
has
a
significant
impact
on
that.
L
Now,
one
of
the
things
we're
trying
to
do
it
we'd
like
to
be
one
of
the
first
county,
wide
areas
to
implement
this.
So
we've
been
talking
to
many
towns
that
I
guess
the
township
associations
are
very
interested.
I
have
a
second
reading
tomorrow,
another
mystic
pala
D
in
Summit
County,
and
so
very
very
some
people
when
the
spies
are
looking
at
this.
So
if
we
can
get
the
majority
of
Summit
County
to
pass
something
like
this
can
have
a
huge
impact
for
our
youth.
Thank.
H
L
L
M
L
A
A
So,
if
we're
insane,
because
you
can
carry
a
gun
and
go
dodge
bullets
that
you
should
be
able
to
smoke,
let's
think
about
that.
Who
are
we
trying?
What
are
we
trying
to
do
we're
trying
to
save
lives
by
not
letting
them
have
free
access
to
cigarettes
and
smoking
and
apparatus
and
getting
started
when
their
influences
at
an
early
age?
A
We
can
have
alcohol
at
21
and
right
now
we're
trying
to
move
the
bar
a
little
bit
higher
on
the
smoking,
because
this
is
designed
to
prevent
disease
prevent
things
later
in
life
and
if
you
don't
start
by
the
age
of
21,
you're
much
less
apt
to
start
later
in
life.
21
you
make
you
you
make
that
decision,
but
I
think
it's
a
wise
decision
to
endorse
the
t21.
A
The
other
is
the
impact
from
California.
Now
we
have
some
data
from
other
states
that
passed
us
and
they're,
finding
that
in
the
15
and
16
year
olds
that
their
smoking
rate
has
vastly
decreased,
so
the
data
from
2009
which
were
analyzing
now
9
years
later,
it
takes
the
government
a
little
time
to
move,
as
you
all
have
found
out
since
you're
sitting
back
here.
A
A
A
The
states
since
I
know
that
we
mentioned
five
states.
Those
states
so
far
are
California,
Hawaii,
Oregon,
Maine
and
Rhode
Island,
and
just
as
an
aside
since
I
was
deep
in
tobacco
company
this
past
country
this
past
week
we
realized
we
have
a
culture
that
goes
back
deeply
in
United
States
of
smoking.
That's
how
our
country
was
funded.
A
Our
early
settlers
didn't
have
money
and
tobacco
what's
what
they
used
as
money,
that's
how
they
traded
with
the
English
or
British
as
we've
come
to
know
them
later,
and
so
it's
deeply
ingrained
in
our
society
that
smoking
is
just
part
of
our
culture.
We
need
to
rethink
that.
Are
we
going
to
endorse
the
smoking
and
let
them
actually
have
access
and
continue
doing
as
they're
doing,
because
we
know
what
we're
getting
by
doing
it.
The
way
we've
been
doing
it
I
think
it's
time
to
make
a
change
and
I.
Think
I
would
endorse
this.
A
L
Just
leading
onto
that
with
the
brain,
the
doctor,
Christopher
Norman,
Christopher
Children's
testified
at
Akron,
and
just
it
has
to
do
also
with
the
addiction
reward
center
in
the
brain
and
so
forming
those
addictions.
Young,
even
at
18,
can
change
the
way
your
brain
develops
because
it
physically
is
not
developed
yet
so
being
exposed
to
any
addictive
substance
before
your
drink,
your
brain
is
fully
matured
can
have
long-lasting
consequences.
The
earlier
you
start.
So,
even
though
it's
18,
it's
still
very
risky,
so
way
to
add
that.
H
L
Yeah,
that's
been
going
back
and
forth,
I'm,
not
sure
if
that's
going
to
go
or
not
the
biggest,
the
bigger
issue
in
my
and
in
my
mind,
really
is
not
tobacco
anymore.
It's
vaping
we're
seeing
again
a
huge
shift
from
tobacco
products
to
vaping,
especially
with
our
kids
and
it's
completely
unregulated.
So
that's
a
little
big
piece
where
this
ordinance
would
do.
It
covers
any
nicotine
product,
not
just
tobacco
but
vaping
products
and
tobacco
paraphernalia.
So
that's
the
bigger
issue
for
our
kids
and
our
future
generations.
L
We
don't
know
we're
not
going
to
know
for
thirty
years
what
these
vaping
products
are
doing
to
do,
our
our
kids
and
our
our
lungs,
because
we
don't
have
the
data
we're
just
now
finding
out
the
carcinogens
that
are
in
it
or
finding
out
that
there
is
widely
unregulated
nicotine
levels,
extremely
high
and
all
sorts
of
other
carcinogenic
products
that
are
in
here
and
so
we're
not
going
to
know
the
full
scope
of
this
until
it's
it's
likely
too
late
for
for
a
whole
generation.
I
just
saw
in
the
news.
L
The
other
day,
a
person
had
been
vaping
for
three
weeks
and
developed,
wet
lung
and
was
emitted
at
a
hospital
and
certain
condition
that
can
happen.
So
there's
a
lot
of
risks
that
come
with
this.
It's
just
not
known
yet
and
we're
not
going
to
know
the
full
consequences
for
some
time.
Unfortunately,.
A
Obviously
this
is
something
I'm
passionate
about
as
a
pharmacist
and
I
believe
I'm.
The
only
one
here
on
the
council
that
represents
medical,
but
I
was
on
the
board
of
tri-county
hospice
for
two
years.
I
did
home
visits
with
them,
occasionally
volunteering
and
if
you've
ever
seen,
someone
you
probably
know
someone
who
has
passed
away
because
of
lung
cancer
or
other
related
illnesses:
emphysema,
asthma,
that's
been
aggravated
deterioration
of
the
lung,
the
lung
tissue
changes
and
it's
a
horrible
death.
A
J
J
J
However,
government's
there
to
serve
I've
heard
several
times
that
the
two
words
used.
We
can't
let
them
that
frightens
me
that
if
I'm
just
gonna
be
honest,
it
infuriates
me
I've
got
relatives
who
have
served
through
every
war
this
country
has
ever
seen
they
served
for
me
to
have
my
freedom,
it's
my
duty
to
protect
that
again.
J
What
you're
doing
that's
great
I
applaud
that,
but
the
question
for
us
up
here
is:
are
we
here
to
decide
what
we
let
people
do
or
not,
or
are
we
here
to
serve
the
people
and
your
opinions
are
going
to
differ
from
mine,
but
I
would
like
us
to
at
least
focus
on
that
going
forward?
It's
not
at
least
for
me.
It's
not
really
about
what
a
15
year
old
gets
in
school
or
not.
J
F
If
I
might
we
should
up
here
and
tell
people
what
to
do
all
the
time
I
do
not
well,
we
have
speeding
laws,
so
we
tell
people
they
can't
speed.
We
have
laws
that
make
you
buy
a
car
insurance,
so
we
tell
people
that
they
have
to
have
car
insurance.
We
tell
people
that
they
can't
drink
before
the
age
of
21,
so
we
tell
them
that
they
can't
do
that.
We
tell
16
year
olds
that
they're
not
allowed
to
vote.
So
we
tell
them.
They
can't
do
that.
F
J
F
N
F
B
I
basically
agree
with
Paul
I
mean
this
is
just
another
step
and
it's
an
old
term,
but
Big
Brother
I,
don't
like
him
and
the
fact
of
it
is
where's.
It
gonna
stop.
Now
it's
today,
it's
cigarettes,
they're
already
already
working
at
the
looking
at
the
sugar
content.
Put
in
too
many
things
what
we
eat
drink,
yet
they
don't
make
healthier
food
to
put
out
there
for
people
mandatory.
They
just
want
to
regulate
the
people.
Also
by
your
own
admission,
you
can't
enforce
what
we
have
now.
L
B
L
A
That's
why
they
elected
says,
counsel
to
make
decisions,
and
it's
costly
for
us
to
bring
every
single
little
decision
we
make
to
the
general
populace
I'm
more
in
favor
of
counsel.
Doing
that
work
that
we
were
hired
to
do
so.
I,
don't
have
a
general
feeling
of
the
of
the
group.
Perhaps
ask
your
advice
on
that.
Mr.
president,.
H
At
this
time,
I
don't
think
that
based
off
the
information
provided
so
far,
I
don't
think
there
is
probably
enough
support
to
pass
it.
We
could
carry
it
over
to
the
next
committee
work
session.
Give
people
opportunity
to
kind
of
take
in
what
the
health
department's
given
us,
the
information
they've
given
us
tonight
weigh
it
check
with
constituents,
see
what
they
think
and
discuss
it
further.
At
the
next
committee
of
the
whole
or
committee
work
session,
okay,
yeah.
D
F
G
H
C
M
Could
I
could
personally
support
the
piece
of
legislation
that
had
an
exemption
for
military
personnel
over
18
years
old
I
will
not
support
any
any
piece
of
legislation,
no
way
shape
reform
cigarettes,
alcohol
shoes,
anything
that
that
deprives
any
military
person
of
anything,
and
that's
depriving
that
18
year
old
soldier
the
right
to
go
overseas
and
come
back.
He
smoked
over
cities,
he
comes
back
he's
sitting
in
his
own
living
room
and
he
can't
legally
smoke.
A
cigarette
I
will
not
deprive
him
of
that
I.
L
L
L
F
G
I
L
H
N
L
H
E
Is
our
semiannual
interest
payment
on
our
bonds?
The
invoice
comes
at
a
US
bank
up
in
Minnesota,
it
left
up
there,
it
was
it
was
postmarked
or
invoice
was
actually
dated
for
nine
I,
don't
know
exactly
when
it
was
mailed,
but
by
the
time
I
got
it
and
was
able
to
write
the
purchase
order.
It
wasn't
the
17th
which
was
later
so
we
created
it
then,
and
now
can.
H
H
E
H
I
prevent
it
in
the
future
if
they're
willing
to
email
it
as
well
as
a
mail,
a
hard
copy,
all
right.
Any
questions
on
this
and
I
will
move
to
add
those
to
counsels
next
agenda
and
since
you're
looking
to
get
this
paid
by
the
end
of
the
month
with
the
emergency
and
I'll.
Ask
that
we
waive
the
second
and
third
since
it's
normal
payment
that
we're
making
it
was
just
the
invoice
amen
before
the
PIO.
So
well.
Second,
motion.
Second,
any
further
discussion,
roll
call
please.
Mr.
H
H
H
H
C
The
property
either,
so
thank
you
as
the
albrecht
property
was
getting
ready
to
go
to
trial,
which
we've
just
recently
settled
was
scheduled
to
begin.
Last
week
it
was
deposition
testimony
doing
a
new
appraisal
based
on
new
information,
evaluating
the
albrecht
property
appraisal.
All
those
things
that
you
need
to
do
to
go
to
a
appropriation
trial.
They
were
doing
those
services,
so
is
the
work
leading
up
to
that.
B
C
They
they
work
for
the
city,
so
they
were
appraiser.
That
is
part
of
the
ODOT
package.
So,
as
you
know,
as
you
get
the
ODOT
money,
they
have
certain
appraisers.
They
work
with
Roger
sours
company
is
one
of
them.
Miss
Bowie
works
for
Roger
sours
company,
and
so
that
was
one
we
get
to
select
the
appraiser,
but
they
were
pretty
much
told
it's
one
of
these.
You
know
qualify
and
appraisers
that
you
can
select
from
so
he
had
performed
mr.
sours
had
performed
the
original
appraisal
for
the
property.
B
C
I
B
G
E
Possible
mr.
president,
I'd
like
to
if
we
could
waive
second
and
third
reading,
I'd
like
to
get
it
paid
by
the
end
of
the
month,
if
possible.
So
if
we
do
a
first
reading
next
Wendy
and
pass
it
I
can
get
it
paid
yet
in
the
month
of
May.
If
that's,
if,
if
counsel
would
like
to
have
more
ratings,
then
then
they
can
have
more
readings.
H
J
J
D
The
collective
bargaining
law
of
the
state
of
Ohio
provides
that,
when
it
contract
expires,
that,
when
you
sign
a
continuation
agreement,
that
any
payment
for
that
year
is
retroactive,
so,
due
to
the
fact
that
this
contract
was
settled
in
2018,
both
years
would
be
retroactive.
So,
while
technically
you
could
argue
they
their
contract
continued
during
the
term
of
the
negotiations,
so
they
always
had
a
contract
in
the
terms
within
subject
to
retroactivity
based
on
those
terms
of
the
law.
So
that's
why
there's
two
years
of
retroactivity.
J
D
C
J
C
F
D
G
D
B
B
J
J
J
B
F
C
F
C
A
H
H
M
Or
whereas
the
parks
and
cemetery
board
recommends
that
Norton
City
Council
use
money
collected
for
park,
improvement
from
the
cable
franchise
fee
to
install
locked
restrooms
with
sinks
into
pavilion,
Royal
Oak,
Park,
aka
oak
leaf
park
included
in
this
proposal
is
a
faucet
with
a
protective
cover
if
located
outside
the
pavilion
and
a
drinking
fountain.
The
board
also
recommends
the
installation
of
a
camera
inside
the
pavilion
and
a
protected
box
to
monitor
suspicious
activity.
In
addition,
the
lighting
inside
the
pavilion
also
needs
upgraded
and
improved
last.
M
We
recommend
that
at
least
one
additional
porta
John
be
added
to
Loyola
Park
during
the
soccer
season
to
accommodate
the
large
attendance
over
300
people
during
soccer
games.
Until
the
said
improvements
listed
above,
which
include
a
drilled
well
and
a
water
source,
be
completed
at
the
pavilion
since
gone
since,
since
this
was
discussed
at
parks
and
cemetery
and
since
I
drew
up
this
proposal
for
it,
I've
got
information
concerning
the
well,
which
is
the
only
water
source
in
that
area.
M
C
Mr.
Gaynor,
the
the
issue
with
drilling
a
well
for
drinking
fountains,
is
that
it
would
it
would
make
us
a
public
water
source
at
that
point,
once
you
become
a
public
water
source,
the
highway
PA
puts
a
bunch
of
requirements
on
for
water
quality
testing
we'd
have
to
treat
the
water
before
I
could
serve
through
the
drink
engine.
We
don't
have
anyone
trained
to
do
that.
C
There's
some
cost
associated
with
that
either
have
the
contract
for
it
or
train
someone
and
get
them
out
there
test
and
treat
that
water,
barring
the
fact
barring
getting
a
water
line
there.
At
some
point,
oh
we're
looking
at
a
water
line
coming
down
to
61,
but
until
that
time
I
don't
think
oh
well
to
serve
a
drinking.
Fountain
really
works.
The
issue
the
holding
tank
for
the
restrooms
is
that
the
EPA
will
allow
holding
tanks
temporarily.
If
you
have
like
a
festival
or
if
you're
doing
something,
you
know
something.
C
M
M
That
is
not
flushable
and
I'm
told
by
him,
and
he
seems
to
know
exactly
what
he's
talking
about
that.
The
EPA
will
not
approve
a
holding
tank
of
any
kind
that
has
water
going
into
it
flush,
toilets.
In
other
words,
they
will
not
approve
it,
and
also.
He
said
that
the
Metro
parks
are
trying
to
eliminate
all
of
their
wells
and
as
a
water
source
they
every
time
my
water
line
comes
close
to
them.
M
So
as
far
as
mehar,
as
even
considering
putting
the
tank
in
I,
don't
see
any
way
to
do
that,
I
don't
see
any
way
to
even
know.
There's
a
lot
of
people,
including
myself,
I
want
restrooms
in
that
Park
at
Royal,
Oak
I,
don't
see
any
way
to
have
a
flush,
toilet
or
anything
other
than
a
porta
John
at
this
time
until
the
water
and
sewage
is,
is
brand
past
there.
M
M
M
M
That
there
is
housing
there
now
the
pump
and
everything
for
the
well
the
pump
and
everything
for
the
well
the
way
I
envision
it
could
be
if
the
well
is
drilled
in
direct
vicinity
of
the
building,
just
be
a
matter
of
installing
a
pump.
The
electrics
there,
the
the
the
mayor
at
one
time
mentioned
that
he
thought
there
was
a
dirt
floor
in
there,
but
there's
not
they're
all
concrete
floors.
D
M
All
concrete,
but
anyway
I'm
just
back
to
the
well
I
I'd
like
to
see
it
looked
into
to
see
if
there
could
at
least
be
a
well
drilled
there
for
a
water
source,
not
only
for
the
fields,
but
in
the
future.
If
there
everything
goes
all
right
with
a
water
and
stuff
that
could
be
used
for
years
cheaper
than
a
city
water.
M
You
know
if
the
the
electric
to
run
that
well
to
water,
the
fields
with
could
on
positive
would
be
less
than
the
cost
for
city
water
to
pump
and
run
the
fields
paying
by
the
gallon
and
since
we're
not
any
longer
considering,
or
at
least
in
my
mind,
I,
don't
think
we
can
consider
putting
restrooms
in
there.
I
would
like
to
suggest
as
their
as
their
Parks
and
Recreation
resolution
stated
to
at
least
put
one
portage
on
more.
In
addition
to
the
one.
M
That's
there
now
add
to
the
contract
that
we
have
with
the
portage
on
company
for
the
remainder
of
this
season
and
henceforth
and
forever.
Until
we
get
restrooms
in
there
their
their
attendance
that
these
soccer
games
continued
to
increase
every
year,
they
were
down
to
I,
don't
know
a
hundred
members,
or
so
last
year
or
year
before
last
and
they've
already
up
to
around
300
can.
M
M
M
So
I
don't
see
any
reason
in
the
world
why
we
can't
have
restrooms
and
that
building
again
and
have
a
camera
setup,
it's
necessary
if
they
think
it's
necessary
because
of
vandalism
have
the
camera
set
up
at
this
building
to
guard
against
vandalism
and
it
could,
as
I
suggested
before
it
could
be
a
camera
that
is
either
wired
or
Wireless
direct
to
the
dispatch
center
I.
Don't
believe
that
would
add
a
lot
of
work
to
the
dispatchers.
H
The
only
way
that
you're
going
to
be
able
to
monitor
the
restrooms
is
if
the
baseball
associated
say
Association
is
practicing
there,
then
that
individual
whoever's
in
charge
of
the
practice
has
a
key.
He
opens
it
up
at
the
beginning.
Closes
it
at
the
end,
he's
solely
responsible
for
it
to
have
a
camera
there
tied
to
dispatch
I
mean
every
time.
Somebody
goes
to
the
restroom.
We're
not
gonna,
send
an
officer
down
the
inspect
afterwards,
so
I,
don't.
M
Know
no,
it's
not
you're
misunderstanding
what
I'm
suggesting
okay!
If
you'll,
let
me
go
into
it
and
finish
it
I'm,
not
suggesting
that
you
have
a
camera.
That's
running
24
hours
a
day,
7
days
a
week
and
everybody
that
walks
by
there
does
it
I'm,
suggesting
that
that
camera
would
be
turned
on
when
there's
no
for
nothing
going
on
in
there,
like
you
said,
if
a
coach
for
the
baseball
team
unlocks
those
restroom
doors,
the
camera
comes
on.
M
Maybe,
whatever
time
that
park
is
not
open
to
the
public
and
there
are
times
unless
we're
the
only
city
in
the
world
that
don't
close
their
parks,
there
are
times
that
parks
are
supposed
to
be
closed
to
the
public
and
I
believe
it's
probably
in
our
ordinances
9
o'clock
at
night,
and
if
it
is
that
camera
should
be
on
and
nobody
should
be
there
period,
it's
just
a
simple
event:
nobody
should
be
there,
I
mean
not
walking
your
dog,
not
not
talking
to
your
neighbors
or
whatever.
If
that
park
is
closed,
it's
closed
at
dusk,.
H
M
M
Western
star
cemetery,
please
see
attached.
That
was
a
vote
on
the
motion
was
four
against
zero
abstained,
zero
approved
on
the
back
of
it.
It
states,
whereas
the
park
cemetery
board,
recommends
that
Norton
City
Council
used
money
collected
from
the
cable
franchise
fee
to
replace
the
fencing
which
is
being
done.
So
you
can
forget
that
that
was
removed
from
Western
Star
Cemetery,
with
comparable
fencing,
which
is
happening
as
to
what
is
located
in
the
front
portion
of
the
cemetery.
M
We
also
strongly
recommend
that
city
council
approve
one
of
the
submitted
quotes
from
either
Summit
memorials
or
Midwest.
There
were
lasting
memorials
in
order
to
upgrade
and
improve
the
historical
headstones
located
at
Western.
Star
cemetery.
Both
companies
come
highly
recommended
in
the
parks
and
cemetery
board
feel
either
company
would
do
quality
work.
This
improvement
would
be
done
over
a
period
as
time
as
a
period
of
time
as
allocated
by
time
and
cost
last.
M
The
board
recommends
that
the
leaning
tree
located
inside
the
cemetery
on
the
south
side
be
either
repaired
or
removed
due
to
damage
at
the
base
of
said
tree
and
that
the
two
remaining
dead
trees
located
on
the
south
side
of
the
cemetery
be
removed,
and
there
are
two
proposal
quotes
attached
to
the
back
of
this.
One
of
them
is
from
Summit
memorials,
which
is
the
lesser
expensive
of
the
two
and
which
is
the
one
that
I
would
recommend.
M
We've
had
them
do
work
before
and
I
know
they
do
good
work
and
the
other
company
is
I,
think
a
wodsworth
company
and
they
also
I'm
told
do
excellent
work,
but
their
proposal
they're
doing
more
for
the
amount,
but
they're
also
doing
a
lot
more
detailed
work
on
the
tombstones
and
such,
but
as
far
as
the
two
proposals
and
cost
wise
and
what
we
can
afford.
I
think
if
we
were
to
approve
the
8750,
which
really
is
not
a
great
deal
of
money,
for
what
they're
going
to
do
I've
been
through.
M
M
The
the
fact
is,
like
I,
said
before
we
as
a
city
have
the
responsibility,
a
legal
responsibility
to
maintain
these
two
graveyards
at
least
Norton
Center
and
the
Western
Star,
and
in
my
opinion
we
have
not
maintained
them.
We've
depended
on
volunteers
and
they've,
went
in
and
did
an
excellent
job
of
trying
to
maintain
them.
M
There's
a
lot
of
accolades
that
could
be
handed
out
to
the
people
that
worked
throughout
the
years
on
them,
but
still
there's
just
too
much
work
for
volunteers
to
do
as
I
found
out
after
looking
at
them.
Closer
and
I
would
recommend
highly
that
this
be
done
not
next
year,
preferably
not
even
thought
about.
M
M
Maybe
some
of
the
local
businesses,
if
contacted
by
the
proper
people,
would
be
willing
to
donate
to
it,
but
even
if
we
were
to
get
a
thousand
dollars
from
eight
different
companies
that
would
almost
pay
the
bill.
I
still
think
the
city
should
do
the
work
and
pay
for
it
and
if
we
receive
these
donations,
then
apply
it
now.
M
I
mean
I'm
sure
that
the
cemetery
committee,
if
they
are
asked
to
do
that,
they'll
research,
you
know
and
look
for
donations,
I,
just
I,
just
don't
see,
setting
back
waiting
on
a
donation
to
come
in
to
do
work
that
needed
done
last
year
and
it's
still
it's
getting
worse
every
year,
and
not
only
that
cemetery,
the
minute
that
that
cemetery
is
done.
We
should
start
on
the
other.
M
H
M
Don't
know
exactly
what
they
done
from
what
Lisa
tells
me.
I
spoke
to
her
three
or
four
times
about
it
from
what
she
tells
me
she
was
under
the
impression
they
were
still
in
good
shape,
I.
Think
since
then
I
believe
she
told
me
that
she
had
been
out
there
and
the
she
feels
that
Norton
Center
is
worse
than
Western
Star
I
disagree,
a
hundred
percent
I
think
Norton
Center
looks
not
good,
but
it
looks
better
I
think
than
Western,
Star
and
and
the
method
that
they
used
to
repair.
M
M
Not
saying
Scott
I'm
not
saying
that
we
should
go
with
some
memorial
just
because
of
the
cost.
If,
if
the
council,
it
would
have
to
be
council
and
the
Board
of
Control.
Of
course,
if
we
went
with
the
other
company,
because
it's
many
more
dollars
and
and
if
council,
in
their
wisdom,
which
I
would
agree
with
a
hundred
percent,
the
the
work
that
they're
willing
to
do
the
company
from
wodsworth
would
be
far
superior
in
their
in
their
in
their
description
of
what
they'll
do
would
be
far
superior
to
what
Summit
Memorial
says.
M
H
M
Don't
either
and
and
I'm
not
saying
that's,
be
a
good
idea,
send
him
out
there
I
mean
I'm,
a
hundred
percent
behind
it.
I
was
going
to
I
was
willing
to
volunteer
to
do
it.
If
the
city
would
supply
the
materials
and
everything
I
personally
would
have
supervised
the
work
I'm
capable
of
it
believe
me,
I'm
capable
of
it.
But
but
we've
talked
about
this
since
February,
the
9th
I
believe
and
nothing's
been
done.
M
Not
one
thing
has
been
done
to
fix
those
cemetery,
headstones
and
I
personally
and
I'm,
ready
to
throw
up
my
hands
and
run
away
because
I
think
the
headstone
should
be
repaired
starting
tomorrow
morning.
So.
F
O
Denise
Mullins
2886
Wilbanks,
Drive,
Miss
Gibson,
the
chairman
of
parks
and
Cemetery
hadn't,
made
up
a
letter,
soliciting
contributions
that
was
to
go
out
recently
and
that
was
going
to
Kiwanis
Lions
Women's
Club,
twins,
Brooke,
Garden
Club,
all
the
different
local
organizations
to
see
if
they
would
be
willing
to
contribute,
and
in
addition,
from
the
few
times
that
we've
been
visiting
western
stars,
specifically,
it's
clear
that
a
number
of
the
headstones
were
fixed.
Those
that
show
signs
of
having
been
repaired
are
still
repaired,
so
it
looks
like
that's
held.
O
O
F
You
first
of
all
I
just
say
that
as
a
city,
we
do
have
an
obligation
to
maintain
the
cemeteries.
It's
our
property,
it's
something
that
we
need
to
do.
I
think
we
all
know
that
first
question
is
regardless
of
which
of
these
proposals
we
may
or
may
not
choose
I.
Don't
recall
that
this
is
something
that
was
budgeted
at
the
beginning
of
the
year,
so
this
have
to
come
from
somewhere
and
mr.
Mesner.
Do
you
have
any
idea
where
that
would
be.
E
F
What
do
we
know
that
is
normally
used
for
parks
correct,
so
we
would
have
to
authorize
it
to
be
used
for
cemetery
by
ordinance
all
right.
The
second
thing
is,
is
while
I
think
it's
always
a
good
idea
to
look
for
other,
less
expensive
options
like
help
from
the
high
school
students
and
stuff.
This
isn't
something.
F
This
is
something
that
is
I,
I
would
guess
specialized
as
far
as
how
these
repairs
are
made,
the
epoxy
all
of
those
things
so,
while
I
get
trying
to
look
into
those
things,
I'm
not
sure
that
you'd
have
a
good
outcome
or
lasting
outcome.
Maybe
you
would
I,
don't
know,
but
I'm,
not
sure
that
you
want
to
take
that
chance
with
something
that
you're
talking
about.
You
know
graveyard
memorials
and
things
of
that
nature,
so
it
needs
to
be,
in
my
estimation,
needs
to
be
done
professionally,
so
I
just.
N
G
M
F
F
I
just
may
ask
a
question,
because
I
would
assume
that
mr.
Markey's
gonna
have
to
prepare
legislation
for
us
to
look
at.
Are
we
looking
at
one
of
these
particular
bids
from
the
property
committee?
Are
we
looking
at
saying?
Okay,
let's
do
let's
do
legislation
for
some
memorials
in
the
amount
not
to
exceed
80
750.
Are
we
to
that
point?
I.
B
B
I
think
it
needs
to
be
done
and
I
agree
with
Jo
as
far
as
assessment.
I
would
not
want
to
bring
the
kids
and
not
say
that
they
couldn't
do
it,
but
I
think
we'd
be
better
off
just
paying
and
having
it
done
and
getting
take
care
of
and
as
far
as
the
trees
our
people
can.
Our
service
department
can
handle
that.
Can
it
removing
those
three
trees
I
think
it
is
they.
B
H
M
F
B
H
A
G
D
B
M
M
M
More
thing:
yes,
the
water
problem
that
I'm
pretty
sure
was
already
decided
to
take
care
of
on
fairway
across
the
street
from
Terry
mr.
Parker's
house
is
that
still
on
Larry's
agenda,
because
I
noticed
yesterday,
it
was
not
addressed.
Is
that
still
something
that
he's
planning
on
doing?
He
told
me
couple
three
weeks
ago
that
he
could
not
get
a
hold
of
the
person
who
owned
the
home
where
the
pipes
were
to
be
removed.
I
haven't
had
any
trouble
getting
ahold
of
him.
M
M
D
D
M
H
H
N
Judith
Lindley
three
to
two
seven
Creekside
Drive
Norton
Ohio
to
Mayor
azita
and
the
Council
of
City
of
northern
I
come
to
I
come
before.
You
were
concern
about
an
incident
that
happened
here
in
the
city
of
Norton.
One
of
our
residents
was
charged
with
menacing
ethnic
intimidation
and
criminal
trespass.
After
placing
a
cross
with
intimidating
messages.
Ie,
we
don't
want
you
here.
We
need,
you
need
to
move
bad
things
will
happen
to
you
and
more
on
the
property
of
his
neighbor,
who
was
african-american.
N
N
I
asked
that
the
City
Council
of
that
Ward
reach
out
to
this
young
man
and
and
as
well
as
the
residents
of
that
neighborhood
and
let
them
know
that
we
are
a
family
I,
can
only
hope
and
pray
that
we
conduct
ourselves
as
though
as
well.
I'm,
not
sure
what
I
think
that
would
be
either
be
Ward
one
or
war.
Two,
if
you
have
not
mr.