City Of Tampa Tampa City Council 2021, 28 Jan 2021

Previous Meeting Next Meeting

⏯

youtube image

►

From YouTube: Tampa City Council PM 01282021

Description

Tampa City Council PM 01282021

A

Just said, an email that uh scott dudley and brady coffee keller will appear virtually on item one.

A

We just have another screen. I don't see the other two signed on yet: okay hi there katie.

A

And uh javon's already done a sound check for you. So that's good.

A

All right, who else did you need jim um scott dudley.

A

B

Yeah, I don't see them signed in yet no.

A

C

C

A

Can you do a sound check for us brady uh yeah? I just don't need it right now, perfect.

D

It's strike city council is coming in now.

C

C

C

E

Mr crew, if you can hear me, let's start the broadcast.

A

Broadcast has started, sir, go ahead. All right.

E

Good afternoon, I'd like to go ahead and call this tampa city council meeting to.

E

Order roll call please fiera here, goods here, carlson dean, felder, stink, belter.

E

Here all right uh first is.

E

Ceremonial activity- council, member goose- I believe this is yours. Go ahead, sir.

F

Tonight we have mr brady coffee. Keller is 13 years old.

F

And an eighth grader at llt academy in temp he's a member of the national junior honor society.

F

And ray is also part of the falcon news crew at llt in his free time he enjoys.

F

Going to disney world and playing video games, apparently brady was in a contest.

F

Of an essay for what it would feel like or what it would be like to be mayor, and we want to probably.

F

Give him this accommodation, I think we have mayor castro on the line. The mayor of the city attempt.

D

Somebody's got their phone in here. That's going off.

D

We'll wait on you we'll wait on you, how you doing brady.

A

Good. Thank you. How about you all right, we're waiting for my man to get paid. My ip assistant.

D

Had their left their phone in here on audio um all right, I am so excited uh with your essay.

D

And I tell you what you can come and be mayor here in tampa uh anyway, because your ideas are.

D

Exactly what we're working on here in the city of tampa myself in the mayor's position, along with.

D

City council, looking at our park parks, are so important to us. You mentioned having after-school.

D

Programs- and we have several of those throughout our city- we also have a program that was.

D

Implemented by the previous administration called stay and play, and that allows our youth to have.

D

Constructive activity in our open parks until 10 o'clock at night- and we also- um we also provide.

D

Dinner for them so a lot of great ideas in our parks and recreation. You also brought up recycling.

D

We do have recycling bins for all of our residents. Unfortunately, people don't follow.

D

The rules- and they really don't know how to recycle appropriately, and so we spend a lot.

D

Of time on educating, we take all of our recycling products to a recycler located down in igbor city.

D

And unfortunately, we are called back to take about three quarters of that to our waste to.

D

Energy plant, so we have to make sure that people are recycling appropriately. So we.

D

Spend a great deal of time on that. You talk about our our um being eco-friendly and we are.

D

Just lit focused on the environment here in our community, we actually hired the first resilient.

D

Team sustainability officer for the city of tampa and we're focusing on you mentioned solar, we're.

D

Looking at that, putting on city-owned businesses, we just bought our first series of electric.

D

uh Vehicles we are also, I mentioned. We have we're only one of two cities in the united states that.

D

Has our own we own and operate our own waste to energy uh plant and of that energy? We're going to.

D

Use for our our trucks that we use in solid waste, so we're doing a lot of that also talked about.

D

The environment and keeping it clean we just started, beat free bay, making sure that those.

D

Gas borla beads don't end up in in in our bay. We have a tree program. We have community gardens.

D

And we're really focused on the water making sure that we are saving water for the future. Ensuring.

D

That we have clean drinking water for all of the tampa bay area. So thank you for all of those ideas.

D

And please please, please keep those coming and I thank councilman goode for bringing you on here.

D

I also thank scott dudley and uh the uh florida city mayors and I really do appreciate everybody's.

D

Emptiness, and thank you thank you. Thank you, brady for uh for giving us all of those great.

D

Ideas and keep those coming because one day you're going to be running this community.

F

Thank you madame well brady. It's that time to give you your your accolade, tampa city council.

F

Is proud to honor brady coffee keller of the lrt academy, with this accommodation for receiving.

F

The distinction of being the second place winner and the florida league of biblical mayors, florida.

F

League of cities, if our mayor essay contest this contest encourages young people to think about.

F

Public service and future community leadership, bray's essay is a great reflection on the role.

F

Of being the mayor and importance of being the highest elected official in the city,.

F

Brady currently expressed what he would do to improve the city. If you were mayor, leaders are.

F

Always planning for the future have a vision, road map and game plan which speaks to the strengths.

F

And the goals of the future brady coffee keller is currently a leader with great achievements, yet.

F

To come, it's great pleasure that attempted city council presents this accommodation on the start.

F

On the 28th 28th day of january 2021, thank you brady, and let me show you your nice. uh Thank you.

F

Accommodation here and we're gonna get that to you. Would you like to say a few words.

C

Thanks for having me here and.

A

I don't really know I'm just really surprised that I won this. It's.

A

Despite the honor, well, we we thank you. Thank you for your leadership. I see we have scott dudley.

F

On the uh virtual call, you like to say something: scott, uh yes thank you and uh council members and.

A

Mayor good to see you and brady congratulations to I'm the executive director of the florida.

A

League of mayors we have uh over 250 mayors from across the state that are members of the.

A

Florida league of mayors they get together to talk about ideas like the ones that you raise.

A

In your paper brady, they they share ideas. They think about what ways to tackle problems that are.

A

That cities are looking at all around the state, they share those ideas and.

A

They like new ideas and so we'll we shared your essay with the other mayors across the state, with.

A

The mayor's cross state and uh I'm sure I wouldn't be surprised to see some of your ideas get.

A

Implemented somewhere and so uh to be at your age and to be thinking so uh globally and looking at.

A

The bigger picture is really it's. It's good. It's it's good to see our youth doing that they're.

A

I have a lot more uh hope for the future than I did than I previously did, uh and so that's.

A

That's a really good thing. We greatly appreciate that you're. uh If you participated in the contest.

A

And that uh and congratulations for for being a winner. It was a really a good essay and, as I.

A

Said thinking ahead and I I think you're going to do great thing. Things stay focused and uh if.

A

You ever get to tallahassee, maybe you're, going to pick a great college and come to fsu and if we can.

A

Help you, when you get up here, that's where we're located uh come by and see us at elite cities and.

A

We'd be uh happy to put you at an internship or something like that. So uh come come by and see us.

A

When you get older and get into college and we'll uh keep your thought processes going so we'll work.

G

You hard but we'll uh [, __ ] but it'll be a good good experience for you so and council members.

A

Thank you for all that you all do uh great public servants, and we appreciate you very much. Thank.

A

You scott, uh I actually recently just got accepted into a collegiate program at my local high school.

A

Congratulations! That's great for my um collegiate future excellent! Well! Good luck! Good luck!.

A

You got a bright future ahead of you, man, that's great paul cameron. I turn over you [ __, ], say.

F

Something we have a, we have a gift certificate for you for 50, and then we have a plaque that.

A

We're gonna mail to you. uh It's a resolution by the league of mayors, uh just uh basically.

A

Recognizing your achievement for winning the award and uh we're really proud, and we hope that you'll.

A

Encourage your next set of uh the classmates coming behind you to participate in this and.

A

And to stay focused on important issues. Thank you, scott. Mr chairman, councilman carlson. I I just want.

H

To say, congratulations, as the mayor said, um we look forward to seeing you step up um to run for.

H

Mayor some other office in the future or helping in other ways and there's no age. That's that's too.

H

Early as you know, and I'm sure you're involved in a lot of things already, but if any of us can help.

H

Please reach out to us. My email is bill.carlson tampagov.net you're, welcome to email.

H

Also, I ran a program on friday's cafe on tampa you're welcome to come anytime. You want for free.

H

There was a guy kevin o'hare who's, a friend with lots of us who had 17 started coming.

H

Going to events like that, he would skip school from. I think he went to plant city high school.

H

Not recommending skipping school but now he's like 22. I think he just turned, but he was one.

H

Of the leaders of offer transportation getting city-wide, county-wide transportation, funding and.

H

He was just recently grassroots lead in in part of hillsborough for president biden's campaign.

H

And he's making lots of changes in lots of ways and just graduated college like a year ago, so.

H

um You know the sooner we can get uh smart interested folks like you.

H

Involved the better our community will be so let us know how we can help. Thank you.

E

Thank you very much, councilman vieira. uh Thank you very much that that is, that is awesome was.

H

Kevin skipping school to go to cafe con tampa yeah. He would go to school an hour nerd, and I said that.

H

And I'm a nerd good for him. That's awesome! um Just no one wanted to say. Congratulations! It's funny!.

H

That you say that you were surprised that you won. I was surprised when I won my first race so that.

H

Makes two of us right, but um just congratulations. I I I would encourage you to just continue to be.

H

Involved um you know when I was younger. I got involved in politics when I was 18. I interned in.

H

In washington dc in the in the capitol in the then house, minority leaders, office and uh and.

H

I've just always been involved, and I think that you know whether you're republican or a democrat.

H

Or whatever um your you know, pub public service can be a very patriotic endeavor to improve our.

H

Community and the great thing about public service is, you can take those issues that matter to you.

H

Based upon your life experiences that you can be earnest and sincere and compassionate about and.

H

Make changes on them things that you care about things that you bring a unique uh perspective to.

H

I don't mean to point at you, but but things that you bring a unique perspective to so anything that.

H

I can do to help just just let me know, I mean that god bless you and congratulations. Anybody.

E

Else: counseling, cedro brady, congratulations to you! My friend, uh you have taken the first step.

I

To achieving your goal, what I recommend to you is the moment you turn 18 get on a board.

I

Get on a commission get get on some sort of entity or body that makes important decisions.

I

For the city hone, your skills learn the process and ensure you know what you're talking about.

I

And out of due respect for you for winning this award, let me be the first one to call you, mr mayor.

E

Very good: well, congratulations! uh The kevin o'hare that they've mentioned I'm actually meeting for.

E

Coffee tomorrow morning, at 7, 30. and I've told him just like I'm going to tell you I wish I.

E

Would have gotten involved at your age or just as young. I didn't get involved in politics until.

E

I was 25 which to some people, it's young, but I wish I would have started 10 years earlier or more.

E

Because it's so important, you know the foundation that you begin building will reap you know. So many.

E

Benefits for you in the future, so congratulations, you're, doing good things. We're very proud of you.

E

And the mayor on the call is very proud of you and, like she said, you know soon, you'll be leading.

E

You'll be leading the city, so uh thank you for setting a great example. Thank you so much thank.

A

You great job brady. Congratulations! Thank you, council. Thank you very much.

E

All righty, I see uh mr schmidt on the line. Are you here for the uh the mutual aid uh walk-on.

A

uh Yes, sir, go ahead, sir, um I have a walk-on for the mutual aid agreement. It's with five agencies.

A

They are orange county sheriff's office.

J

Let's see orlando.

E

Jacksonville jacksonville right: yes, sir jacksonville um largo and sarasota.

A

Sheriff's office, so we've reached out to we've reached out to all of them. They all uh are.

J

uh Entering into the mutual aid agreements with us are all providing assistance during the super bowl.

A

And that was a reason for uh this lock-on. We needed this uh all executed.

A

Prior to the super bowl, so we're respectfully requesting that this resolution be approved.

E

Any questions or comments, mr chairman, martin shelby. Yes, I'm sorry, I just uh I would just.

A

I might have missed this comment, but uh this is moving. The substitute is that correct. It's been.

A

Filed with the clerk, mr schmidt, is that correct. That is correct. Yes, that is correct. There is a.

D

Substituted one that was submitted, um I think this morning, yeah. I have it right here, sir. Okay. Thank.

A

You so for the purposes of the clerk it could be if you can move the stuff to do. Please all right.

E

Any if there's no questions or comments can I get a motion to move the substitute.

E

Moose substitute resolution, we have emotional councilman sitro, second from councilman vieira, all.

E

Those in favor indicate by saying I I any opposed anything else, mr schmidt. Oh sorry that takes care.

A

Of it, thank you, sir. Thank you very much. We'll move on to the agenda a little bit of housekeeping.

E

Items 6, 7 and 14 are not going to be heard tonight. Let me start with item number six item.

A

If you could take those individually, please that's what I'm that's what I'm doing.

E

Item number six uh cannot be heard: there's a petition to withdraw.

E

um And that's by the applicant, mr cassidy: can I get a motion to withdraw councilman.

E

Goods with the motion secretary, councilman vieira, all in favor aye, any opposed great item number.

E

Seven is an email from mr patrick thorpe as representative, also a petition to withdrawal. We.

E

Have from councilman good second councilman sietra, all in favor, aye great and then item number 14.

E

um Applicant did not perfect notice, so we cannot hear it. Can I get a motion to remove that.

E

Motion from councilman good, second from councilman citro, all in favor.

E

Aye all right that settles the agenda for the cleanup in the housekeeping, so we start off with.

E

um Can I get a motion to open the um so move public hearings, public hearing motion from.

E

Councilman good side from the councilman, I'm sorry most councilman teacher councilman goods.

E

All those in favor aye all right item number two, mr chairman. Yes uh just for the record, uh if the.

B

Clerk could notice uh that I've I've been on for the last couple of minutes. I missed the roll call.

K

Yes, I do have it for 5 15. p.m. We have you logged in at 5, 15.

E

Thank you very good item number two. Three, two okay, mr chairman, jim cruz city, clerk's,.

A

Office we have two individuals registered to speak for the representative, david kellcoin.

A

Is uh on the meeting tony martino has not signed into the meeting.

A

E

E

All right, who's, gonna, speak on item number, two.

E

I know we have two registered individuals if you could turn on your camera and be sworn in.

A

I'm sorry it's not a don't need to be sworn in, but please turn on your camera.

E

Mr killcoin, if you could please turn on your camera.

A

Council, um are you able to hear me? I'm sorry, we hear you, but we can't see you sure. Sorry. So.

A

This is patrick perez. I I'm I'm in uh the city attorney's office, I'm an assistant city attorney.

A

Yeah um I just uh while mr killpoint is setting it up just a bit of a background.

A

This is a resolution. That's setting a public appearance for a special street light assessment.

A

um uh It would be for next month and uh mr coop coin is the uh the applicant okay.

E

Mr kilcoin and mr martino were the two applicants representatives that I see here.

E

Mr chairman, yes, if it's merely a resolution, I don't know that we need evidence, etc. Mr assistant.

B

City attorney, if not I'll, move the resolution, I was about to ask that yourself. Yesterday, council.

A

Yes, that is correct. This is just the resolution to set the hearing um it does. It will be uh noticed.

A

In the public for four consecutive weeks, so it'll be come back on february, 28th great so correct. We.

A

Do not we don't have the applicant here? It is just the resolution setting the hearing all right, 28.

E

All right, we have a motion counseling fellow who's, the second second from councilman foods,.

E

All in favor aye any opposed. Great item number three uh item number. Three. I see we have a brian.

E

Sykes, uh that's registered okay, who would like to um go ahead and begin with that? I see miss.

E

Malone on the uh line- yes jennifer planning, commission, um if I could share my screen.

E

If we can share the screen.

L

Commission can everyone see my screen, it should say tampa conferences for the math amendment 20-21.

E

Yes, go ahead, okay, so this is a plan amendment that is in the central tampa planning district as well.

L

As within the west tampa urban village, um it is just west of the university of tampa. We see north.

L

Boulevard there to the west as well south kennedy or kennedy boulevard, is the south of the subject.

L

Site, but it is not is out of frame, um as I'm sure you guys are aware. This area has changed quite a.

L

Bit in the last several years, um it is a mixture of industrial but really transitioning to that.

L

Multi-Family development pattern to the north: we also have the the river and then tampa preparatory.

L

School as well, I have some sight pictures it's a little hard to get pictures of the site.

L

But this is kind of looking into the site at west carmen street and north delaware avenue.

L

This is another view of the site facing east towards university of tampa, so we do see those.

L

Railroad tracks, and then this is north edison avenue facing south towards the subject site.

L

And towards downtown it is a privately initiated amendment. It is small scale at about 3.87 acres.

L

The subject site has three land use: designations general mixes, 24 urban mix, 260 and public school.

L

Republic, the request before you today is to be one future. Ladies designation of urban mix 260.

L

um It is kind of hard to tell on this map because of our uh the black boundary lines, but the entire.

L

Site will not change. A small portion of the site on the eastern edge will remain the public.

L

Semi-Public future land-use designation, and that is where the railroad tracks are.

L

But the remainder of the site will change to. We have three land use designations in the area.

L

And the applicant is requesting that it is taken to one land use designation of.

L

um Urban mixed 60., so urban mix 360, is already present to the east of the subject site general.

L

Makes these 24s further east regional makes use 100 is to the north. um That is the universe that.

L

Is the tampa preparatory school and then we see that public future land use designation is.

L

Representing this, the university of tampa, but just to be clear, a portion of the folio will.

L

Remain public semi-public and I will I'm sure the applicant will further elaborate on that in this.

L

Presentation so we have, um this would increase the potential from about 130 units to about 240 units.

L

It would also increase the dem intensity from about 315 000 square feet to 570 000 square feet.

L

In the proposed feature, ladies designation of urban makes you 60. The applicant. Can utilize.

L

That square footage number for residential or non-residential or a mixture essentially.

L

This is going to amend the entire site to a unified future language, designation.

L

To allow for this redevelopment to occur not associated with the public use, we do have comments.

L

In your packet from the metropolitan planning organization, city of tampa development and.

L

Growth management is also here to speak on their comments when I'm done with this presentation,.

L

The hillsborough county school board did note that a couple of the schools don't have adequate.

L

Capacity and those are all in your packets. um The planning commission did find this consistent with.

L

The comprehensive plan- I have a historical ariel on the site on the slide right now.

L

This parcel was utilized as a rail yard, which is why it was wider. um There's a lot of width.

L

To accommodate that sorting and loading and unloading and infrastructure storage.

L

Historically, but as you all are aware, this area has shifted towards multi-family and mixed use. The.

L

University of tampa has really grown, and that shift is supported by the plan which seeks to.

L

Build upon and support the university of tampa as one of the city's economic engines.

L

This is also consistent with several of our policies regarding the compact city.

L

Forum strategy, we encourage the mixed-use infield development within proximity to the.

L

Existing transit near the site and employment services, this will provide redevelopment land.

L

uh For housing to meet kansas growing population, as well as.

L

um It's consistent with our policy regarding new housing on vacant or under utilized land.

L

And again, the planning commission did find this consistent. That resolution is in your packet.

L

And I'm available for any questions, and I will pass it on to frank hall with this video.

E

Any questions no go ahead good evening. uh This is frank hall with the city of.

A

Tampa the city planning city planning has reviewed the request and we have no objections at this time.

A

Our comments have been provided in the packets, so unless you have any further questions, I will.

A

Pass this on to melanie callaway she's on the line to review comments for mobility.

E

Any questions any questions: if not, we go to melanie no go ahead. Melanie.

E

You're, muted, you're, muted, melanie callaway transportation planning good. No, I think you.

J

Can I think it's a little delayed? Yes, you're good you're good you might. It might not sync up.

J

So transportation planning um I had comments in the package, but they have changed. You are emailed.

J

The additional comments this morning from abby feeling, but I'm going to summarize my comments for.

J

You just so you have them so for at least 20 years, the city of tampa transportation, planning staff.

J

Has worked diligently to preserve the right-of-way along the csx trail corridor, specifically within.

J

The corridor from north boulevard cass to willow all the way down to the inner bay area. There are.

J

Numerous proposed right-of-way vacant applications discussed in this immediate area of this subject.

J

Application over the years and were discouraged from moving forward in order to maintain access.

J

To the csx rail corridor there were several zoning applications that were approved along.

J

This corridor, that incorporated such things as future rail pad commitment, a sidewalk on their.

J

Property line on the east side adjacent to the rail corridor to maintain that access to the csx.

J

Corridor this corridor is critical for our future rail and multimodal needs. There is a regional.

J

Planning effort that is provided by the tampa bay regional transit authority, also known as tubarda.

J

In their plan, envision 2030 the future of transit in tampa bay, tampa bay's. First.

J

Regional transit development plan, the regional transit vision network map, clearly shows this.

J

Corridor for future rail transit in context of the city's mobility and multimodal system goals.

J

The location and design of the subject property can have substantial impact on the overall system.

J

It is our intent to inform both city council and the applicant of the unique planning opportunity.

J

Which will be reviewed at the time of rezoning for the implementation and consistency with.

J

The comp plan policies that I have provided in my memo to you earlier today from abby philly.

J

And those are all my comments, I don't know if anybody has any questions.

E

We have a question from councilman goodes mentally. Was this the site that.

F

Originally did we found the narcissist and now we're changing it to consistent? Now, yes,.

J

I'm sorry I has been. Maybe I should back up.

J

My comments previously were provided on september 15th of 2020 to our staff, as well as the planning.

J

Commission I was unaware that my comments were an issue until january 19th last week,.

J

With that issue that came up, there have been long discussion in the past week about.

J

My comments and therefore the comments had changed to what I provided to you today.

F

Maybe I must be missing that.

J

Abby philly emailed them early this afternoon, we've been canceled all day.

F

She essentially she emailed this afternoon. You said.

K

E

Anybody else have questions. No all right. Let me look at it a minute ago. I remember this vaguely. I.

F

Remember it distinctly that's why, when it said it changed, I wanted to make sure yeah I'll go to I'll.

E

Go to ding filter in the meantime and then we'll come back to you. That's fine, councilman dingfelder.

B

Councilman goods uh brings up a good question.

B

Is callie uh not to put you on the spot or put your job at any risk, but, as your did, your did.

B

Your opinion change or did just the letter from the city change she's on the spot. Mr team, father.

J

Councilman good's correct: I am on the spot both of you, everybody's she's, on the spot, so.

F

I wouldn't well I'll tell you what I'm I'm going to send a message real loud and clear.

B

From now on to your supervisors: okay, if your supervisors want to have a different opinion.

B

Then they need to come down here and give it to us themselves. um They shouldn't put professional.

B

Staff on the in the position of having to change their opinion and being as uncomfortable.

B

As as this very very well qualified and fine staff person finds herself, so I don't know where.

B

I don't know where that direction came from, but it obviously came from above and that's not right.

B

Okay, I'm not saying that they don't have the right to give their own opinion and to give a different.

B

Opinion from the city, but they need to come, do it themselves. If that's what they're going to do.

B

That's that's just that's just my humble humble opinion and my humble statement is one city.

B

Council, okay, thank you. Miss miss callaway, keep up the good work just for the records michelle.

F

I'm inclined to send this back and maybe get an explanation from your superiors or what you mean.

F

What counsel this is kate wells, chief assistant city attorney, you haven't even heard from the.

M

Applicant, yet this is a privately initiated plan amendment that is properly before you this evening.

M

With respect to the change in the comments from staff, it was my understanding that abby feli and.

M

Other representatives in the transportation mobility department, the intent, was to further.

M

Clarify the city's position and comments- and I would you know, councilman goods, you indicated.

M

That this was previously found inconsistent, um just a correction. There were previously.

M

Objections by uh miss calloway, but that was not a finding of inconsistency.

M

And the memorandum filed by ms feely earlier today just further clarifies the city's position.

M

But with all due respect, we haven't even heard from the applicant yet.

F

Ms wills, I appreciate your comments and I I do take that into consideration. We.

F

Can hear from the applicants, uh but I think council still has the right to make decisions.

F

But I do appreciate your comments and I respectfully we'll hear from the applicant.

E

All right, let's hear from the applicant, we have a mr sykes on the line if you're.

E

Muted, please unmute yourself, it should be unmuted. Can anyone hear me, okay, go ahead.

N

Excellent um ryan sykes with meridian partners law- I'm here representing the applicant in this matter.

N

So just to start out with and maybe to set the table a little bit more strongly for this. So.

N

Everyone understands this property represents excess property for csx in 2018 csx formally.

N

Put the property out and started marketing it for sale. My client in 2020 approximately may of 2020.

N

Put the property under contract, my clients had a relationship with csx has done other.

N

Transactions with them and saw this as an opportunity to develop a unique.

N

Urban infill project without displacing any other types of uses. um You know staff has noted.

N

Quite correctly that this area has undergone a change, a fairly significant change.

N

Mr dingbelter and I had a conversation a few weeks ago and talking about the change.

N

Because he was around when I had the uh one of the first privately initiated small scale,.

N

Amendments in this area, which started out what was called west end project, we.

N

Took out a bunch of warehouse, uses a bunch of industrial uses and turned it into multi-family.

N

Opportunities and for poor rent product and for sale product as well, and then things continue to.

N

Grow in that area, there's been more growth as far as residential, more growth. As far as commercial.

N

And the area has turned into a a unique vibrant area. Michael and I looked at this property and saw.

N

An opportunity to do a really unique project, something that, as I said, would not displace.

N

Other types of uses, but would utilize vacant land that today is used as a dumping ground.

N

If you would walk down the the track alongside of the tracks, you would see mattresses there. You see.

N

Garbage there uh it's somewhat of an eyesore of what's happened to that area. um The project.

N

Also is unique and attractive to my client in that it is close to downtown it's close to ut.

N

It is it's going to have a high walkability score. It's going to have a high urban transportation.

N

Sport, we all see the scooters in town to be very simple and easy to be riding scooters to and from.

N

University, your work, what have you in this location, so the site is staff noted.

N

Is currently has um three different land use designations? It's got uh gmu 24, umu, 60 and.

N

Public quasi public, if the pqp designation had not encroached into the site by about seven to ten.

N

Feet we wouldn't even be here before you today we could have accomplished what we want to accomplish.

N

With the umu-16 and gmu-24, however, because of that small sliver, the pqp we needed to come through for.

N

The small scale amendment we determined- let's just go through and make everything consistent.

N

Take it to ufu 60.. The one thing I want to make very clear and want everyone to understand is that.

N

The railroad is not going away, the railroad will remain intact, the railroad will be there.

N

For future use, whether by csx, whether by a joint use agreement with the city and csx, whether by a.

N

Private initiative that decides to provide rail transportation, but the railroad will be there.

N

We are not proposing, nor has csx proposed in any manner to shut down the railroad.

N

That is an important track. It's an important track that runs down to south tampa runs through.

N

Downtown and up there's nothing! That's going to happen to it. uh The design that my client has come.

N

Up with, although we cannot go into it today, we'll be bringing it up during the rezoning process.

N

Is a very unique design it takes into consideration the urban area, the the.

N

Crux of our arguments, for this is that it is a true infill project. It's utilizing underutilized.

N

Land today, in a manner that is beneficial to the city, it will provide additional ridership for the.

N

Public transportation services and it provides some housing that will be very close to the.

N

University, where we are going to be discussing with the university plans on a prospective.

N

Crossing uh or over the railroad uh from our project site over to ut um that will be coming.

N

Up we'll be discussing that more later, um it's a unique opportunity. It's it's a.

N

Unique opportunity to do something with land- that's not being utilized currently, and we.

N

Have no intentions of doing anything that would take away the opportunity to utilize the rail.

N

I'm available for any questions should council have any do we have any questions.

E

From council members councilman dingfelder, then councilman citro.

B

Mr spike, the um generally speaking, I've been pretty vocal in favor of intensifying development.

B

Along the kennedy corridor- and I think this would pretty much qualify as the kennedy corridor so.

B

Conceptually, uh I'm I I don't have a problem with with uh with greater intensity from this planet.

B

um I know we're not in the resounding phase right this second.

B

But I did note that one of miss callaway's comments from her earlier transmission. Maybe maybe.

B

Even this one as well spoke to the importance of cross access of getting to those tracks um of the.

B

Community being able to get to those tracks so again, I know we're not in the pd phase and I know.

B

I know you don't have a cyclone in front of us, but eventually you will. I assume, um but I hope that.

B

When that day comes that that your client will be very very sensitive to the importance important.

B

Location that this property uh is at, as as related to the community's future ability to.

B

You know to to uh to get to the tracks for what whatever? That means, we don't know what it means.

B

But obviously uh our transportation folks have been trying to preserve that axis. For many many.

B

Years so uh anyway, that's my two cents, councilman steve, mr sykes, you were going to say something.

I

Because this is talking about land use and not what is going to be going there. I won't uh have.

I

Miss wells uh raise her hand in objection. However, I am going to make the same type of statement.

I

That councilman dingfelder has, since you, since this request, is based on a multimodal system.

I

I'm hoping that in the future you're going to come to us with something that is going to actually.

I

Use these railroad tracks and be able your design is going to make it.

I

So that these tracks can be readily used and available to the people which might be living.

I

Or working in this this this proposed site. Thank you, mr chair. Thank you very much. Anybody else.

E

Great, do we have anybody in the public that wishes to speak on item number three and just.

E

To clarify the record, I I know I made this motion: can I get a motion to open items three through.

E

Five show moves. We have emotion from councilman, councilman, goose, all in favor, all right. Just.

E

To keep it clear, is there anybody in the public that wishes to speak anybody in person down below.

E

Is there anybody that's in the room here to speak in person? I know there's not, but I have to ask.

A

No response, mr chairman, where we have motion clothes from councilman good morning.

E

Secretary councilman seatron in favor hi all right. We have.

E

We have an ordinance for first reading, councilman vieira, would you mind taking it? Yes, sir, mr chair.

H

I present an ordinance for first reading, consideration and ordinance amending.

H

Imagine the imagined 2040 tampa comprehensive plane, feature land use, element, future land.

H

Use map for the property located west of the university of tampa south of west cass street.

H

And east of north willow street from urban mixed use, 60 umu, 60 general mix use 24 gmu 24 in public.

H

Semi public p, slash sp to urban mix, u60 umu 60, providing repealable ordinances in conflict.

H

Providing for severability providing an effective date.

E

Councilman roll call vote vieira, yes, goods, no dean, felder, yes, maniscaco.

J

Yes and miranda motion carry with goose voter, no miranda being absent.

K

Second, reading and adoption will be held on march 4th and 9 30 a.m.

L

Staff I'm going to share my screen. Yes, we can see it.

L

Great okay: this is uh tampa comprehensive plan text. Amendment 2004.

L

This was transmitted to the department of economic opportunity by motion of counsel on october, 1st.

L

20-04 esr is the number that the department of economic opportunity gave this and the they.

L

Had no comment on this purple and my if you bear with me my um powerpoint doesn't want to advance.

L

This was publicly initiated by the planning commission staff, with the cooperation of.

L

City campus staff: it's just deleting um an objective in some associated policies.

L

And kind of updating the language and we did find it consistent.

E

All right city of tampa.

A

Let's try and call with the city of tampa the city planning city planning has reviewed the.

A

Request and we have no objections at this time- comments have been provided in your packets.

A

And I am available for any additional questions at this time. Thank you very much. Any questions.

E

And there's no applicant on this: do we have anybody in the public that wishes to speak.

K

No one has registered to speak on this item. Thank you very much and we've checked below and there's.

E

No one to speak on this item. Item number four: can I get a motion to close from councilman good.

E

Second, from councilman sietra, all in favor aye any opposed councilman sietra. Would you mind reading.

E

Item number four: yes, thank you, mr chair file, number c, a tpa 20-04 and is being presented for.

I

First reading consideration ordinance amending the imagine 2040 tampa comprehensive plan.

I

Future land use element, public safety, land use goal, 11, removing land use, objective, 11.3.

I

Renumerating the objective immediately following thereafter and modifying policy language directing.

I

The tampa police department to focus on neighborhood crime and drug activity providing for.

I

Repeal of all ordinances and conflict providing for severability providing for an effective date.

E

Wait a minute there's someone standing at the at the podium below. Are you here for public comment.

D

Growth management- there's no one here all right. Thank you very much.

E

Great uh councilman sietra made the motion. Do we have a second.

E

Senator councilman good's roll call vote miranda, sietro, yes, carlson.

K

Maniscaco, yes, ding felder, yes, goods, yes and vieira motion carry, would be arabian correction motion.

K

Care will meet on the being absent second reading and adoption will be held on march 4th at 9 30 a.m.

I

Thank you sure. Thank you very much. Next is item number five jennifer malone.

L

Jennifer planning commission item number five is a park amendment 20-12.

L

It's williams park. This was it's about 10.66 acres, it's over that 10-acre threshold. So we.

L

Must transmit it to the department of economic opportunity which this board voted to do on.

L

September 24th um 20-03 is the number that the eu gave this amendment and they had no comment.

L

um Just a refresher, this is where it is located. Just south of some schools, east of 40th street.

L

um The request is from recreational open space and light industrial to the recreational open.

L

Space and uh we found it consistent, and I thank you for your time tonight. Thank you, city of tampa.

A

Good evening, frank hall, with the city of tampa city planning, has reviewed this request and we.

A

Have no objections at this time. Our comments have been provided in your packets and I.

A

Am available for additional questions, you should need me. Thank you very much. Do you.

E

Have any questions from council members? No all right! Do we have anybody in the public.

E

That wishes to speak on item number five. No one has registered to speak on this item.

E

Wait: anybody in the public down below I, I know the answer but gotta ask.

E

Can I get a motion to close close motion for councilman good second councilman c troll in favor.

E

Aye all right, councilman goods. Would you mind? Reading item number five? Yes, chair order has.

F

Been presented for first reading, consideration in order's amending the imagine, 2040 temple comes.

F

In plan future land use element, future land use map for the property located at 4362 east.

F

Osborne avenue and otherwise known as williams park, from light industrial allied to and in.

F

Recreational slash open space to recreational open space, providing for repeal of all owners.

F

And conflict providing for sale, building providing an effective date. We have a motion.

E

For councilman goode, second from councilman c trial in favor, I'm sorry roll call vote.

K

Vieira, yes, foods, yes, dean, felder, yes, maniscaco, yes, carlson, yes, cedro, yes and miranda. Motion k.

K

Would miranda be an absent second reading and adoption will be held on march 4th at 9 30 a.m?.

E

Thank you very much. It's 5 52. We can't start the rest of the hearings until 6.. So let's go to new.

E

Business from council members is that, okay, if it's not too early, so we can get out of the way.

E

Councilman vieira, do you have anything for new business.

E

Councilman seacher: do you have anything nothing this evening, councilman coos, you have anything.

E

Councilman carlson councilman dingfelder, yes, so earlier uh this afternoon um on new business, I.

B

Made a motion that passed unanimously in regard to that division of chapter 7 and that limits us.

B

To only doing land use excuse me zoning amendments uh twice a year. A legal staff has.

B

Asked for a clarification on that, and, um and so I wanted to give them a little more clarification.

B

To come, and specifically I'm going to amend my earlier motion and restate it with more.

B

Specificity and mr shelby, you said that was um amending 27 151. Is that correct? I believe.

A

So, and and ms wells is also online, if you had anything as well that you wanted to ask.

B

I'll clarify it and then if she wants to ask a question, she can okay um specifically to.

B

Amend chapter 27 151 to provide city council with the ability to with the ability to um to.

B

Visit uh chapter 27 amendments, uh at least quarterly, or let's say, let's say uh quarterly,.

B

um If, if it's the desire of counsel and um and if staff wants to continue to do,.

B

You know uh semi-annual uh updates, that's fine. We can leave that provision alone.

B

But staff would do those those, but if, if the need be, if the, if the neighborhoods or or some other.

B

Issue comes up. The council wants to amend that. We have the ability to.

B

Do that uh on a quarterly basis, more more frequently than what we provide right now.

E

All right, that's a an official motion. That's an official amended motion from my amen for my.

B

Earlier motion this happened: do we have a second second councilman, good, all in favor aye, any.

E

Opposed anything else, sir. No, thank you, council all right. It's 5, 55.! We have to wait five minutes so.

E

We're in recess until six, I wish, I could say, we're adjourned, but you know.

C

C

C

Scan you up and down.

C

Why did it have to be.

C

C

C

How to be fair.

C

Why did I go to this party? What did it have to be? Make it harder you make it harder.

E

Welcome back roll call, please fiera foods, carlson dean, felder, citroen, here miranda and maniscaco.

E

Here all right uh just to be safe, let's open uh items number we already did it, but items number.

E

Six through uh 15., we have most councilman citro; second councilman goose, all in favor aye, all right.

E

uh Item number: eight: uh if you could please uh raise your right hand and we'll swear you in.

E

Mr crew, oh there we are we're on the second floor. Do you swear firm.

K

You would tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth. I do thank you.

E

All right, I see uh mr fernandez on the line who'd like to begin with this item. The course is back.

E

Okay good evening um this is kamaria pettis mackel from the city of city attorney's office. This item.

M

Is before you um as a petition seeking review of the architectural review commission decision.

M

Made during its meeting that occurred on october 5th of 2020., I've previously provided.

M

Legal counsel, mr shelby, a copy of sample motions and in the sample motions you will.

M

Find the hardship criteria that set forth in code, section 27-114, subsection d pursuant to section 27.

M

61 subsection, j, subsection 2 city council applies a de novo standard of review.

M

Your decision is not limited in its review to that information, documentation or evidence upon which.

M

The commission based its determination. Instead, you can take public testimony, accept new evidence.

M

And make a decision based on the application, the applicant meeting, the hardship criteria.

M

Set forth in section 27-114, subsection d, the um items, the materials that were included.

M

For this agenda items were the copy of the initial application for the variant.

M

The staff report, the architectural review commission's written decision, the petition for.

M

Review and the affidavits establishing compliance with the notice requirement the application filed.

M

With the air, the architectural review commission requested a variance for the north side yard.

M

Setback from seven feet to five feet, uh with an encroachment of two feet for eaves and gutters.

M

Section uh after reviewing section 27-61, subsection, j 2, a after considering.

M

All the evidence introduced into the record at this evening's hearing city council may affirm.

M

The architectural review decision decision to deny the variance council may overturn.

M

The architectural review commission's decision and approve the variant with.

M

Or without conditions or council may remand this item back to the architectural review commission.

M

You will now have a brief presentation by dennis fernandez, with historic preservation.

M

And I'm available for any questions if you may have any questions at this time,.

E

Nope all right next good evening. This is dennis fernandez, architecture, review and.

O

Historic preservation manager uh to give you a brief uh summary of the application.

O

uh The property is located at 613 south oregon avenue, which is in the hyde park. Local historic.

O

District and an application was submitted in on june 15th of 2020 to conduct both work on.

O

uh The principal structure and uh on an accessory structure, um the uh hearing was scheduled after.

O

The notice was perfected and occurred on august, the 3rd of 2020 for the first hearing at which the.

O

Request for the accessory structure to demolish and rebuild was granted. There were no variances.

O

Attached to that request, and that was approved by the commission uh at the end of that particular.

O

Hearing after going through a variance discussion, the applicants decided to continue.

O

Their variance request, uh it was then placed on the september 14 2020 arc public hearing agenda.

O

At which time the applicants once again presented their variance hardship. There was discussion by.

O

The commission, however, the vote to deny the variance ties with a 2-2.

O

Vote which, through the rules of procedure, entailed an automatic continuance to the next hearing.

O

That hearing occurred on october 5th of 2020.

O

uh The variance request at that particular time for a north side yard variance from 17 feet to 5.

O

Feet with an encroachment of two feet for eaves and gutters was denied by a vote of three two.

O

uh If we, I can share my screen uh for a minute, I will give you a photo overview.

B

Can you see that.

E

Yes, we can yeah go ahead. Okay uh on the uh screen, there is a map of the hyde park.

O

Local historic district, it's a little difficult to see, but just.

O

In this small green box is where the subject property is located, uh just north of swan avenue.

O

On uh oregon and uh just north of the high park, village development.

O

This is an aerial showing the property a little bit more clear. You can see it does front oregon.

O

With a commercial development on the south and residential.

O

Development, otherwise around it, there is an alley that runs along the rear.

O

There's a contributing structure, very nice, craftsman-style home.

O

In the historic district, this uh the east elevation.

O

Moving around uh this is the south elevation that, above.

O

The commercial I'll show you a photo of that just a moment.

O

Difficult to take a picture of the north elevation, but this is the area where the rear edition.

O

Necessitated the variance I'll show you a closer photo of that that was provided by the applicant.

O

In this general area, here on the side yard, this is rs-50 zoning there's a seven foot.

O

Side yard setback that's required and once again the request was to encroach into that by two feet.

O

This is a photo of this, the same area of the rear and the side yard on the south.

O

This is a photo from the alley with the accessory structure that was approved in the fire hearing.

O

This is the property that abuts to the north. uh This is uh from the alley, the property that a bus.

O

To the south, this is the rear. As I said, of the high park village.

O

This is a view looking south along oregon. You see that commercial.

O

Development there on the right and turning around and looking north another view on oregon.

O

I did include the site plan, which I'm sure the agent will go through.

O

uh You see the area in question, uh for the variance was this small bump out.

O

uh Reducing the side yard setback from seven to five and I'm available for any questions.

O

That you might have do we have any questions from council members councilman dingfield. Yes, sir! So.

B

I I guess we'll hear from mr grandma, but the the little bump out that you that you're speaking to.

B

How many square feet is that that, in terms of the the proposed encroachment, it looks pretty small.

O

I I believe it's uh 22 square feet uh I'll. Have mr grand I'll confirm that? Okay and secondly, um I.

B

Know we don't make our decisions solely on this basis and several of us having served on these.

B

Type of boards before brb etc, um but the neighbor to the north, which is the impact directly impacted.

B

Neighbor uh did they did they approve? Did they eject? Did they abstain? uh They did submit a record.

O

uh Into the uh or a letter into the arc record uh on uh july, the 18th um from elizabeth.

O

Kellny, I'm sure saying that incorrect uh who owns the budding property to the north.

O

She said she had no objection uh to the demolition of the existing garage, the new construction or the.

O

Variance that was being requested and she signed uh that letter. I I wasn't aware of the demolition.

B

So that so that garage goes away, are they replaced? Were they replacing it with a new garage or.

B

So this is really, you know somewhat of a separate request. It was on the same application, but the arc.

O

Had approved the demolition of this one-story accessory structure and approved a replacement.

O

Structure in august, so the you know the items that dealing with the um accessory.

O

Building uh were resolved. The outstanding item still was the variance and the small addition.

O

On the primary structure, thank you, mr finance. Thank you any other questions or comments.

E

Hearing none will go to the petition. Mr grandoff.

A

Good evening, mr chairman, yes, sir, um my name is john grandoff. My address is suite 3700 bank of.

A

America plaza and I'm joined this evening by jamie mayer, who's an associate in our office.

A

And she's going to make the presentation I compliment mr fernandez on this very detailed.

A

Summary to you on the essence of the uh the matter before you this evening,.

A

We respectfully request that you uh reverse and approve this variance.

A

I'm going to introduce jamie now, she'll present the appeal case to you. Thank you.

P

Good evening councilman jamie mayer for the applicant 101 east kennedy, boulevard, suite 3700.

P

And I have been sworn I'm going to use the elmo. um I guess I don't know if it automatically turns on.

E

It's automatic just place the item and we can we'll be able to see it. Okay, perfect.

P

So to councilman um dingfelder's question: actually that was.

P

My opening statement is we're asking for 47 square feet. That's the nature of this.

P

Request um the applicant missed cindy smaney. She lives in this home. She's lived here for a while.

P

She loves living in hyde park, it's our homestead, but the home was built in 1921 and, of course, the.

P

People who built it could not have foreseen what would become standard. Modern basic quality of life.

P

Elements of a single family, home and, frankly many apartments- and that is a laundry room.

P

Currently, miss mani has a washer and dryer that are stacked and crammed in a pantry in the kitchen.

P

um The floor is uneven there, so the machines shake and rattle violently when they're used.

P

And so it's not a laundry room by any stretch of the imagination and it's not particularly safe.

P

um And this is especially concerning because miss manny's 80 year old mother does live with her half.

P

The year every year and she struggles to use these machines, um so the plumbing for a washer and dryer.

P

Is already there, of course, and as you can see, from the site plan that mr fernandez showed there is.

P

Space on the exterior wall to create a bump out just big enough to unstack the washer and dryer.

P

Be able to walk in turn around fold clothes, yes, it will still be in her kitchen, but it.

P

Will be functional, safe and greatly improve her quality of life, so we asked for the variance.

P

A total difference of two feet and, as it was stated earlier, the neighbor miss mclaney betsy.

P

She is in full support of the request, but, as you'll also see, there is a significant six.

P

Foot, opaque wooden fence that separates the two properties so really miss mclaney won't see much.

P

Of the addition at all, anyway, even though she's in full request full support of it and neighbors.

P

And anybody in the surrounding area from the right-of-way won't really see much of it either.

P

Because the same six-foot, opaque wooden fence um buffers the entire backyard.

P

So the arc denied the variance on the grounds that the applicant had not shown consistency with.

P

The variance criteria and one of the criteria they specifically called out, was that the.

P

Hardship was self-created, which I will go into later. However, I just want to express how much.

P

Evidence we put forth photos, site plans, elevations narratives floor plans. We walked.

P

The commissioners, through everything, and we fully believe that we submitted evidence that.

P

Showed we do meet all of these criteria. In fact, we could have added additional evidence to this.

P

Record before you tonight, but we haven't added anything other than what we'd already shown the.

P

Arc because we think it speaks for itself um many other several of the commissioners who.

P

Denied the variance said well, surely there's somewhere else in the house that it could go.

P

But those who agreed with us saw what we were showing is there isn't? We have gone through.

P

Every possibility and I'll walk you through those alternatives that simply will not work.

P

So here's the floor plan as you can see it's the layout. The historic flow of the home is from the.

P

Entry is here, and it's straight shot through to the back here, and this is where the porch is the.

P

Washer and dryer is in a pantry, and this is the kitchen. So, as you can see, there's not a whole.

P

Lot of wiggle room in here it's pretty much set in stone and it is the way it was built. There's.

P

Really nowhere to build a new room, for example in the interior, to put a washer and dryer and plus.

P

They would have to re-plumb the house, here's the site plan again. I want to point out the grand tree.

P

Here takes up a huge portion of this corner vr, which constrains the ability to build horizontally.

P

Or vertically in that area and there's also a bump out here, you can see it more clearly here.

P

Already on the south side of the property, which itself is less than seven feet away from the.

P

South boundary line, so what we're proposing here is not, unlike that which are exists on the house.

P

You've seen these um that's coming out a little dark. Well, you'll have to take my word for it. I.

P

Guess this is miss mclaney's house. This is miss manny's house and I circled the fence between.

P

Them, um but you did see that on the aerials that mr fernandez also showed so I wanted to.

P

Walk you through some interior pictures. Again, as I explained, there's the front door here. You.

P

Walk straight through and there's the back doors, this is the pantry with the washer and dryer in it.

P

Everything's backwards, and here it is with the doors open. You can't see it too well, because.

P

Of the quality, but there is a piece of wood here- that's been shoved underneath the washer and dryer.

P

To sort of alleviate the uneven floor to somewhat mitigate the rocking and shaking of the machines.

P

And the doors can't be shut when it's operated and, of course this is not to say that washers.

P

And dryers can never be stacked, they can, if it's in a place where it's meant to happen, but this is.

P

A shallow pantry with an uneven floor. It wasn't built to be a laundry room and again cindy she's.

P

Sensitive to her mother's needs is her mother ages, especially, she wants a home that is sustainable.

P

And livable for herself and her mother, when she's visiting six months out of the year.

P

You've seen the porch earlier from staff, but some of the commissioners suggested that we build.

P

An addition protruding into the porch so that we wouldn't need a variance um that would.

P

Significantly impact the facade here, you've got this lower roof line that no matter what we would.

P

Have to take a chunk right out of the middle of it, it would disrupt the flow of the house if we.

P

Had to move these doors or, alternatively, we would have to remove one or more of the very classic.

P

Row of double hung windows, so this facade is so characteristic of the home. What we're proposing is.

P

To put it at this corner here, not too different from what's already on the other side, and it.

P

Will retain the maximum amount of the historic materials, the style, the flow and just generally.

P

The the look of the building, and also it's using part of the existing footprint of the home.

P

Plus, if we put it anywhere here, we'd have to add new plumbing once again again, here's a grand oak.

P

It's a spectacular tree. You can see how the canopy extends over the roof of the house.

P

And this radius takes up a large portion of the yard. Here's the side view that you saw earlier.

P

With the mechanical equipment here, which further constrains the ability to build on this side, but.

P

Also to build on that side, we would still need a variance and the plumbing isn't there once again.

P

So I put little arrows on here, so you could see specifically, the bump out would be in the very.

P

Back here that's the shed that was talked about earlier, but the bump out would be on the back.

P

You can see the significant fence here. This is the second floor of the neighbor's.

P

House, so this is going to be on the first floor, really not going to be so visible. This was taken.

P

By me, when I was standing in the right-of-way, so you can see the fence continues all the way.

P

To the front of the house and again not going to be extremely visible from the right-of-way, either.

P

So I want to walk you through the variance criteria. One of the first criterion is that the.

P

Difficulty has to be unique and singular well, we showed that, as I just went through for you.

P

Everything about this issue is the unique floor plan and lot configuration of the.

P

Home, it's everything from the location of plumbing to the oak that constrains you know.

P

The ability to build in that entire portion of the yard to the flow of the house and.

P

There may be different houses up and down the street in the craftsman style that have.

P

Completely different layouts, a look on the aerials of the property appraiser can immediately show you.

P

These are all different. Each house is completely separate completely unique.

P

And some people might be able to do this without a variance, but that is simply not the case here.

P

This was the criteria that was specifically noted by the um the board was that this.

P

Was a self-created variance? I immediately objected to having it characterized like that.

P

Because a practical difficulty or hardship is not self-created just because the property owner wants.

P

To change something or build something that requires a variance if that were the case, I.

P

Don't think any variance could ever be not self-created. They almost always stem from somebody.

P

Wanting to change something and not being able to do it without a variance, none of the conditions on.

P

Site were created by cindy, she didn't build the house, she didn't plant the tree, so this.

P

Meets exactly the intent of the code in that she didn't create the conditions, so this provision.

P

Was misconstrued and it was heavily relied on by the board, and it was a huge basis for the denial.

P

There will be no injury to health safety or welfare, as we have discussed, miss mclaney to the.

P

North is in full support and she's the person who would be most directly affected and she's.

P

Also got the six foot fence buffer and also this edition is going to be completely in harmony with.

P

The style of not only miss manny's, actual home, which already has that bump out on the other side,.

P

And it's in the craftsman style, but it's going to contribute to the fabric of hyde.

P

Park which is known for that crafts and style of so many of the houses.

P

Also consistent with code and comprehensive plan.

P

For the same reasons, it's in harmony with the historic character of her actual home and the area.

P

We're preserving a home, improving it extending its relevancy into the 21st century. We want.

P

People who care about the historic district to live in these homes, but we can't expect them to.

P

Live in a time capsule of the year in which it was built, um they need to be able to modernize.

P

These homes, miss manny's, put a lot of love and money into this home and she'd like to stay here.

P

There will be a public benefit from this again for all of the reasons, I've just stated.

P

We benefit from these maintained, preserved historic homes. That's the whole point of the.

P

Historic preservation, district and we want people to keep them not you know, knock them down and put.

P

Something else in its place, um so with this you know weighing her practical difficulty.

P

With the fact that this will benefit the public, uh this is a de minimis variance and we think.

P

It supports this request. Finally, our evidence was disregarded entirely that this edition is.

P

Totally consistent with the district's style, again, it's the craftsman, style and I'll show you some.

P

Pictures of houses just up and down her street as I took a scooter up and down and took photos.

P

And we're going to, of course, the materials are going to match the home.

P

I thought this was this is on her street. I thought this was a great example.

P

Because, as you can see, although the roof orientation isn't exactly how we're going to do it.

P

It's a bump out at the very rear and it's blocked by a wooden fence. So this is not unlike what we're.

P

Proposing this one's a little more difficult to see because of the significant hedges. But it's the.

P

Same thing, you can see the roof line there between the hedges. It's this little bump out more examples.

P

Very different roof orientations. It's a very eclectic style. It pretty much does what it.

P

Wants- and it lends itself very well to these bump outs on all different sides and many different.

P

Shapes and sizes, some that are even facing each other. This is also a little hard to see but again.

P

More examples, I think these are two really good examples of the craftsman style.

P

And, like I said just how well, it lends itself to these features, these differentiated side, facades.

P

And on that note here were the elevations we submitted.

P

Of course, this doesn't give you the perspective of the depth of the fact that this is going to be.

P

Back, you know in the very back of the house, but it shows you kind of how we're going to do the roof.

P

um The north facade, this is the side that would face mclaney if she could see it, but she won't.

P

Because of the fence, however, the windows are going to match the row of windows that currently exist.

P

Along that side of the house, so with the wealth of evidence, we submitted the neighbors support.

P

The person who would be most directly affected the fact that what we're asking is totally.

P

Consistent with the home, with the district, with the goals of the historic preservation district.

P

At large and the fact that we're asking for 47 square feet, some of which is in the existing.

P

Footprint of the home, and it's a two foot request. We think all of this overwhelmingly weighs in.

P

Favor of reversing the denial and granting this manny her laundry room. Thank you. Thank you very.

E

Much councilman dingfeld are you you're going to raise your hand um only after you close, oh.

E

uh No, I thought your hand was going to anybody else on council. Have any questions or comments.

E

No, do we have anybody in the public that wishes to speak on this.

E

I don't believe so. No one has registered to speak on this item. Okay, I believe that maybe some people.

A

Downstairs, no one has registered online to speak and cttv has access to the camera for.

A

The second floor to see if anyone is on the second floor, thank you is there anybody in the audience.

A

This is thailand's society of development and growth. There's no one here to speak on this item.

E

Most motion clues from councilman good secretary councilman seitur, all in favor.

E

Aye, what's the pleasure of counsel councilman ding felder? Thank you, mr chairman. um The man I I didn't.

B

Catch your name, but uh mr grandoff, your associate did a great job. um She double her salary, john.

P

Yes, listen to him as somebody who recently uh renovated a craftsman, bungalow.

B

um They are very delicate and, and- uh and you can't just plop things where you you know.

B

Where other people might think you should so, I think the um I'll move to uh reverse.

B

uh Respectfully, I know they work hard, but it looked like a close call three to two.

B

I'll move to reverse the arc's decision uh without conditions. um I believe that the the.

B

Petitioner and the applicant have met the the five prong five prongs required for the variants.

B

And I especially want to note a couple of things: um it's only a two foot variance on the side yard.

B

It's toward the rear, so, at the end of the day I think it'd be extremely challenging for anybody to.

B

Be able to even see the bump out from the street the next door neighbor to the north did not.

B

Complain obviously, to the south is commercial property, but nobody's complaining there. The two.

B

Foot bump out obviously only runs about well. I guess maybe what you say: it's about a total of 40.

B

40 square feet, so it's not running very long and it's probably a two or three foot room.

B

I believe that there's nowhere else appropriate for the.

B

Washer dryer laundry room and, for those reasons, I'll move to to reverse um the nrc decision.

B

As stated, we have a motion from councilman dean, felder council, mr shelby. Yes, mr chairman,.

A

Councilman dingfelder, I believe um uh the motion I believe, would be to overturn the arc decision.

A

And I believe, when you set forth the criteria, you were referencing section.

A

27-114 d: is that correct, sir? You say so I will agree with you. Yes, we have a motion.

E

From councilman, dinklage or second councilman vieira was that correct.

E

Yes, sir, the roll call vote vieira yes boots, yes, link belder.

K

Miranda being absent all right, thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Next is item number nine.

E

We have uh two registered speakers: the applicants there but we'll begin with the city's presentation.

D

Good afternoon, council or good evening, council, susan johnsonville senior assistant city attorney.

D

Council members, this is a review hearing for a design exception 1 pursuant to ldc section 27-60.

D

An alternative design exception allows minor deviations from the strict application of the land.

D

Development code subject to limitations described in the code criteria that staff applies when.

D

Evaluating an alternative design exception are found in section 27-60 e5 of the land development.

D

Code, this application did not meet the code criteria as determined by the zoning administrator.

D

Petitioner has the burden to prove they meet the criteria for the granting of the design exception.

D

This review hearing before you tonight is de novo, which means that you are not limited in.

D

Your review to the information, documentation or evidence upon which staff faced its decision.

D

However, you must apply the code criteria to the evidence presented. Council may impose reasonable.

D

Conditions upon the design exception to ensure that the public health, safety and general welfare.

D

Are protected and substantially justice that will turn over to eric cotton who will present.

D

The case to you, I need to be swollen, let's swear in mr cotton. Mr hudson, were you sworn in.

E

No raise your hand and we'll get it all done. Do you swear firm? You would tell the truth. The whole.

K

Truth and nothing, but the truth. Yes, thank you go ahead, sir, if you'd, like so much pain, please.

E

Mr crew, you're, muted and whoever's, not speaking, please meet yourself. I.

E

Hear a child in the background. Yes to repeat mr galati needs to be sworn in.

A

Needs to turn on his camera and be sworn in. If he will be speaking, he is the other person signed in.

A

To speak for in the meeting mr gulati, okay, yeah, please raise your hand and we'll swear you in.

K

It's all right, do you swear for me, you would tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Yes, I do very good go ahead. Mr cotton.

O

Bear with me one second, while I fix this okay.

O

There we go there, you are eric. Cotton, landed, um development, coordination.

O

um This was a this is a petition for review for a design exception, one it's de120-197.

O

For a property at 2526 cordelia street, the request was to reduce the side yard from 5 feet down to.

O

1.9 feet in the rear yard, from 20 feet down from 15 feet down to approximately one foot.

O

The output excuse me the applicant originally applied for the applicant. The entire request.

O

Was denied the applicant then came in and did another design exception at de1 21-12 presented.

O

Additional evidence and, as a result, staff approved the increase in the front yard set back from 12.

O

Feet to 18.2 feet increases as a result of the block average. That's required in west tampa.

O

And we've approved the corner yard reduction from 5 feet down to 3.4 feet for an open, porch area.

O

That's on the side which I'll show you briefly momentarily on the site plan, but again even on.

O

The second request, with additional information staff, still denied the rear and the side yard.

O

This is the uh the site plan in question. um We can tell cm a little red box. What's.

O

The request that we denied staff wise the 1.9 feet and the roughly one foot in the rear.

O

um Property is zoned, rs-50 is at the corner of campania and cordelia. It's a single-family home.

O

um Just some photos: this is a photo of the front. um It's a longer house.

O

So this is the remainder of the front yard of the front. um This is the portion that you see on.

O

This picture behind the fence that was approved administratively to reduce the corner yard that.

O

Was a condition that it never yet enclosed. That would always remain as basically as a screen room.

O

This is an aerial photo from the property creators office.

O

The part- that's um I don't know if my mouth, so you can see this area right there in the back.

O

That's the part that was denied by staff, that's the corner and the.

O

Appreciably, the side and the rear yard um request. That's what we had denied administratively.

O

And this is the sanborn map. This is what I use for justification for the um approval of.

O

The front yard the park, that's highlighted in yellow, that was the house as of 1976., so the.

O

Front yard, you can see, the front yard is more or less the way it was in 76, with the greater setback.

O

And this coronary artery again was just a smaller portion that was approved administratively to be.

O

Reduced again, the rear yard, from from the zoning administrator's perspective, that's a not a minor.

O

Reduction, that's a pretty large reduction, it's 66 percent or 60 about 60 on the side and around 90.

O

Percent in the rear, that's allura! So that's too large of a reduction to improve administratively.

O

Does council have any questions regarding the any questions or comments from council members.

E

All right, thank you very much, sir. Thank you.

E

All right next up, I believe, is the applicant.

E

uh Mr hudson go ahead or or mr galati who's going to.

E

Kick it off hey good evening, council tyler, hudson 400, north ashley drive here on behalf.

Q

Of the applicants here with me is the property owner and applicant dan gulotti. Can I share my.

Q

E

We can see it go ahead, sir, all see the powerpoint yep all right. Thank you.

Q

um Eric whenever this generally the location of the home, you can see the frontage and the.

Q

The issue with the structure: that's on the left side there, which is the.

Q

Southeast corner uh the this is in west tampa, the closest landmark is probably the west west campus.

Q

Sandwich shop just down the street from there- and this is uh that's sorry- eric already went through.

Q

The precise setback reduction we want. I want to give some history about really why we're.

Q

Here on this property, this house had a history of code enforcement issues that go back many years.

Q

There was some inappropriate rental activity of this structure in the history of unpermitted.

Q

Construction and that's that's really where things things start, the house was.

Q

Constructed in 1949- and it was 49 years after that in 1998- that the unpermitted construction.

Q

Of this southeast addition occurred, caused the setback violations that were here to confront.

Q

uh The addition has been assessed continuously for property taxes to be clear. That's not part of the.

Q

Designed exception criteria, but that's noting that and between 2011 and 2018, is when there.

Q

Was a route of code enforcement uh complaints, my client dan gulotti who's going to speak shortly.

Q

Acquired the property in 2019 there's been no unpermitted work uh by the current owner and.

Q

In a minute, dan will go in detail about some of the permitted work that has been done in.

Q

The attempt to rehabilitate the structure and then, as eric noted in september of last year,.

Q

The design exception application was partially approved and partially denied um for some historic.

Q

Context eric shared the scan board from 1976 from I believe, 1939, when this entire block was.

Q

um Was not not inhabited but you'll need it to the south into the east, a development pattern. That's.

Q

Somewhat pervasive in west tampa with very minimal side, rear setback structures being either.

Q

Connected to, as in the case of 27, 19 kathleen or in the same lot as as the primary structure.

Q

Well, I'd like to go through briefly the criteria that are applicable to this case.

Q

And that you all need to apply in overturning it, which is what we're requesting this evening.

Q

The first is: is that there's no no interference with others? I would note at the outset that the.

Q

Mcfarland park, neighborhood association, who dan's been in touch with that, does not object to this.

Q

Request- and we do not know of any neighborhood opposition, despite this.

Q

Being publicly noticed with a conspicuous sign out front, uh we don't believe there.

Q

Is interference with the rights of others and their ability to enjoy their property.

Q

As a result of this structure, that's been in place since 1998, staying and continuing in its form.

Q

The second criteria, about the exception being necessary: we we believe that it is necessary.

Q

To allow this structure again to continue and to avoid an unnecessary demolition if we.

Q

Do not get the exception, then the applicant is going to be forced to essentially demolish the.

Q

Property, that's been fairly nicely integrated into the primary portion of the structure.

Q

The cop plan, I think this is really important to the extent that the zoning code has to be in.

Q

Development orders generally need to be compliant and consistent with the comprehensive plan.

Q

There are policies in place that that encourage sorry did you guys just lose my.

Q

Q

Sorry, the comprehensive plan has policies that I think are applicable here, particularly the.

Q

Discourage of demolition of single family residences, which will be such a practical.

Q

Necessity, the design exceptions denied dan will talk about this in a moment, but there is.

Q

A demand in a lot of parts of tampa, including west tampa for multi-generational housing and.

Q

That's exactly what this structure and its current configuration does. Permit uh landings policy 9.5.1.

Q

Speaks to the point about uh having single-family areas that attracted households with children and.

Q

Other residents, we think this allows that um so part d. This exception is the minimum possible.

Q

It's actually exactly what's required to preserve the structure answer in its current configuration.

Q

um Conditions, uh e and f uh f is really not applicable because there's no specific plans.

Q

In place for this property, um but we're open to any conditions of approval, that council believes.

Q

Is appropriate um so we need this design exception to keep the property. It's concurrent configuration.

Q

That's fairly straightforward about why we're here we're proposing new construction. We want to.

Q

Maintain this, the civic association is not opposed, we're not aware of opposition, and this will only.

Q

Apply to the building footprint, not the entire lot. So with that I'd like to dan to say a few words.

Q

About why we're here go ahead, mr gelati, thank you and uh thank you tyler. um Yes, um I just wanted to.

G

Basically, just reiterate reiterate that uh you know I have every intention of doing the right.

G

Thing by this house and by the neighborhood, I'm very familiar with with west tampa and mcfarland.

G

Park- and I you know, I really appreciate the history- that's involved in the neighborhood.

G

And essentially you know, I saw a home in disrepair with a lot of deferred maintenance. Here um I was.

G

Able to determine the floor plan and see that it's it's there is enough space for an extended family.

G

And realize that you know this could satisfy the need in the community. That west tampa is very.

G

Historic, it's got a lot of um multi-generational demand in it as far as living with elders or.

G

Or you know, typically, you see three or even four generations living in one house and I I saw the.

G

Potential there, the house simply needed some tlc and attention so uh we've since improved the home.

G

With a new roof, we know with some water intrusion issues we fenced in that yard and essentially.

G

Created a beautiful, updated, safe place for a uh a multi-generational family to call home so.

G

uh Now, obviously, we're at a crossroads where we're no longer sure if we can fulfill that need.

G

And the additional costs alone to remedy this may limit the buyer's ability to purchase this home.

G

If we're forced to demo it and make right of the existing structure after the demolition, so.

G

Ultimately, I just feel it would be a shame to have to eliminate a perfectly good structure.

G

And take away that offering from a neighborhood that has shown historical demand.

G

To provide housing for larger multi-generational families, I really see potential there. I've already.

G

Received interest and exam that exact type of demographic and I'm just hoping to be able to.

G

Provide that with the existing structure, you know we believe it to be safe and quality, build and.

G

Our contractors have basically confirmed that the house is good to go and we feel confident that it.

G

Can it can serve the need of the neighborhood? Thank you very much. Councilman dean, felder.

B

Thank you, gentlemen, for your presentation. um Tyler. Can you put the aerial? Do you have an aerial photo.

B

Show in the backyard because I believe mr cotton indicated there's a rear yard setback at issue.

B

And a side yard setback, um I think eric's ariel is probably going to be the most helpful to see.

Q

Eric do you mind, sharing your screen. Okay show my screen again, you wouldn't mind. Thank you.

O

Is it is it? Is this what you're referring to counseling.

O

Yes, um yeah: can you zoom in on the um on the aerial or the rear for that rear of the.

O

I hate to say this: I honestly, I do not know how to zoom in on a powerpoint, so.

O

Is that any better? Okay, let's go back to the arrow for a second okay, mr guardi. um It appears to me.

B

That the that there's an addition, there's an addition, as you go toward the rear lot and then.

B

There's a separate roof um that even goes closer, and I guess that goes to one feet off. One foot off.

B

The rear property line, what is the, what is that addition behind the addition, so that is basically.

G

A uh four posts and like a metal, it's almost what they call a lean-to. So it's essentially.

G

Are you trying to keep that um not necessarily that's a covered patio? There is a rear door.

G

Off of the structure, and that basically is a continued covered patio off of that door.

G

To the right of the tree, I assume.

B

Oh yeah, you did zoom in okay, so eric that that structure that he's talking about.

B

uh The the I guess, the four post.

B

Four post lean to sort of thing is that what takes us very close to the rear property line.

O

The rear property line from from the site plan.

O

It looks, I don't know if this is a detached structure or an attached structure.

B

Is there was there a survey that came in with this application? Yes councilman? I can.

Q

Put that on screen and and just to be clear that without giving effect to that the the.

Q

Rear setback reduction is from 15 feet down to 13 feet two inches and I defer to my client but.

Q

I believe we could cert would be welcome to we'd, be welcome to condition that it's the.

Q

Reduction is the 13-2 and not one um there. It is right there hold on somebody's gotta worry at me.

O

This is the addition that's under question. This is the.

O

Which I thought was part of the property, but I guess it's a detached shed, correct, yeah.

Q

That's right, I don't want to jump in during your presentation. I think our de1 application package.

Q

Requested the 1 9 reduction on the side, which is correct, but I believe our rear was actually.

Q

13 feet, 2, which, which is does not give effect to what dan referred to as the lean to okay.

B

Because what I heard at the beginning of eric's presentation spoke to.

B

A reduction I think, down to one, I thought it was down to one foot that is correct like I was in, I.

O

I this had just said covered based on the survey. I assume this was part of the main structure.

O

Not a second, not a shed, so to speak right because the survey made it look like it was like a covered.

O

Area that was attached to the main structure right. The application before you councilman.

Q

Is for a reduction to 13 2 on the back, and just so, everyone is on the same page.

Q

I think that that is what we're requesting, not not a reduction to one foot on the rear.

B

But but even that covered structure, if it's within a foot um it still could be.

B

Still could be not not legal in that true eric, I thought it has to be three feet.

B

If it's a separate structure, yes, sir, if it's a detached structure that has to have a three foot.

O

Side, a three foot rear and it has to be five feet in the main structure and the application that.

O

Could remove that if it's not necessary, you can relocate it elsewhere on the property. Okay,.

B

Yeah- and I think mr gotti spoke to this a minute ago,.

B

Based upon what I've heard so far- and I know I'm only one of.

B

Five or six members tonight based upon what I've heard tonight, um you know I'm comfortable with.

B

Leaving you know this, the block, the block addition, that's in front of that which would go back to 13.

B

Feet on the rear. One point: I guess one one foot on the side uh just because it was built a long time.

B

Ago um and and to get rid of or land or move, you know the the upper lean to whatever it's called.

B

You know I I would feel comfortable with that now I do want to say one thing, mr glotti you're you're.

B

You're a knowledgeable person experienced in this type of stuff when you bought it, I'm sure you were.

B

Well aware that this wasn't necessarily legal structures: um you're, not you're, not the innocent.

B

Purchaser, so that concerns me a little bit because what's happened here is somebody built something.

B

A long time ago, they kind of took advantage of the system, for whatever reason you know, then they.

B

Sold it to you and now you're you're begging forgiveness. On that basis, so um you know I.

B

That worries me a little bit, you know we don't want people building illegal.

B

Structures and moving it and profiting it from from that et cetera, et cetera with that said,.

B

I'll get off my soapbox and leave you alone. Thank you very much. Any other council members.

E

Do we have anybody in the audience that wishes to speak on? This item? Item number: nine.

K

No one has rushed to speak on this item. Eileen. Do we have anybody to speak in person? No, we do not.

A

Have anyone here to speak on behalf of this item? We have a motion to close from councilman goodes.

E

We have a second from councilman sitro, all in favor.

E

Aye any opposed. What is the pleasure of counsel item number nine.

E

And you have sample motions in front of you to overturn or affirm the arc.

E

E

Oh, that's! That's! That's correct! I'm sorry! Let me flip this over okay.

E

The the zoning administrator's decision, whether to a firm or.

E

Would anybody like to take it.

E

I don't, I just have the arc document, I have the arc document and I have the alcoholic beverage.

H

I don't mean making emotion if, if somebody can walk me through it.

H

So I would, I would make a motion to overturn the zoning zoning administrator ruling.

H

Marty, what what else should I say.

D

So, council members- this is susan, johnson, velez senior assistant city attorney.

D

So the remaining requests before you this evening are to reduce the rear yard setback from 15 feet.

D

To 13.2 feet and reduce the side yard setback from 5 feet to 1.9 feet. So if that is if it's council's.

D

Pleasure to overturn the zoning administrator's denial, then your motion should reflect that you.

D

Are overturning the zoning administrator's denial and approving the request to reduce.

D

The rear yard setback from 15 feet to 13.2 feet and approving the request to reduce the side.

D

Yard setback from 5 feet to 1.9 feet, so thank you. If it's okay with the clerk and attorneys, I.

H

Would like to amend the motion to include the language that miss john civilez just gave us.

E

We have a motion from councilman carlson with the second from councilman vieira roll call vote. Let me answer this question.

B

Question on the motion: yes, sir: go ahead: okay, um ms johnson blitz, um do does counselor. Have the legal.

B

Ability to condition the motion uh conditioned additionally to remove or relocate the.

B

The covered structure that we were talking about, sir council, yes, susan johnsonville,.

D

um Yes, council has the ability to condition its approval of their requested um setback, variances.

B

Mr glotty has his handle. We get a motion to reopen the hearing motion, councilman.

E

Vieira second room councilman uh seatro, all in favor, aye, aye, okay, the hearing is now reopened.

E

Go ahead that for me, uh councilman dingfelder had a question. We have the hearing reopened.

B

I guess I guess I would ask the the petitioner, the applicant mr hudson or.

B

Mr golotti, if they have any objection to that additional condition, um you know removing that.

B

Structure, mr glotti, yes um thinking about it. Obviously uh no one here has been on site. I don't.

G

Believe that that lean to to be um very close to the property line. And uh after reviewing the.

G

Survey um I'm looking at a picture here. Actually I have a picture of the backyard that someone shows.

G

It but after looking at the survey, uh it doesn't seem that they've done any sort of measurement.

G

Of the size of that lean to it's just essentially uh they've they've negated it from the structure.

G

Itself and just basically shown a covered area. But if I'm able to potentially show my screen.

G

uh You might be able to see how there's more than there is more than uh thank you.

G

um I don't know what the requirement is, because we don't have a measurement, but.

G

Can you see my screen? Yes, we can just go ahead, sir. Okay, so this is this. Is the.

G

Distance here you can see this is the edge of the roof. This is the lean-to in question.

G

And uh this is not only a couple of feet, this may be 10 12 15 feet from the distance from the fence.

G

And after looking at the survey, you know they really make no measurement of it other than the.

G

Fence line to the structure itself, so I I don't know what the requirement is to keep that, but I.

G

Just want to make sure everyone is completely informed that this is not in question of being.

G

Only one foot from the property line, if you, if you look at this here and just me by experience.

G

Know that this is a substantial amount of space. If I can jump in uh briefly uh councilman keller, we.

Q

Certainly accept and appreciate the the setback production from to 13 feet, 2 inches on the rear.

Q

And we will ensure that there are no more code violations regarding setback issues. We've.

Q

Trudged a longer to get here on that, so we'll make sure that if there is anything.

Q

uh Past 13 feet two inches that it will be removed.

E

Anything else councilman dean photo. Does that that answer the question.

B

Well, it's kind of intriguing, because the survey definitely shows something different than what.

B

The photograph shows um just go back to the survey somebody here yeah if you'd.

G

Like to show my screen, I have it okay, so I'm looking at this survey and it's like.

B

A foot a foot away: that's probably what eric saw when he was looking at it. But this is eric cotton.

O

um Development coordination. I believe that this, what that's showing in the survey.

O

This is covered, if you, if you recall from the arrow from the partner figure's office, looks like.

O

That was a shed that may have been removed since the property pressure took that aerial, because the.

O

Shed looks like a metal shed that was proper. That was previously on the property that doesn't appear.

O

In the pictures at this point that mr gelati showed so that may have already been removed.

G

Yes, I can confirm a previous shed was removed. I think that's the disconnect between the survey and.

O

The pictures that the applicant just showed all right well in that case, uh then I don't have any.

B

Objection period do we have a motion to close it's a second motion closed, most close to the teachers.

E

Counseling carlson, all in favor aye aye. We had a motion on the floor from councilman carlson.

E

With a second from councilman vieira, roll call vote, veer yes, goods, yes, stinkfelder, yes,.

K

Yes, carlson, yes, sidra, yes and miranda motion care with miranda being absent. Can I say one thing.

H

Yes, sir, just quickly, I had the same concerns that councilman dingfelder had about.

H

Folks changing things and then and then expecting council to approve them later.

H

But this one is far enough away from. I think whoever did it that.

H

That I was okay with this, but just as a warning to anybody watching who's thinking about doing.

H

That in the future, please don't that's right or else. Thank you very much all right. Thank you.

E

We uh just to be safe. Can I get a no motion to open items 10 through 15.? Second, we have.

E

Emotion from councilman sitro, second from councilman goodes, all in favor, all right all.

E

Right, these are all alcoholic beverage and we have five this evening item number ten.

R

I'm a nasty development coordination chair. I think I need to be sworn in. Yes, sir. Please.

E

Swore the gentleman in do you swear affirm. You would tell the truth. The whole truth.

K

And nothing but the truth. I do thank you, mr chairman, jim cruz city cook's office. There.

A

Are two speakers that also need to be sworn in if they would turn on their cameras? Please.

E

All right, I have uh michelle knight and grace yang good evening. Yes, please turn on your.

E

Cameras- and we will swear you in all right- I see michelle. We need grace to uh turn on her camera.

E

And there's brian knox as well. You have not been sworn in. So all.

E

All three raise your hands and we'll swear you in.

K

Do you swear firm, you would tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.

K

Thank you all right, mr manassee. Go ahead, sir. Thank you chair good evening, council ryan.

R

Manassee with development coordination, if I would be able to share my screen.

R

Please go ahead. We can see it. Yes, okay, excellent.

R

So item number 10 is file number 820-05. It's for the location at 201 generally, uh north dale mabry.

R

And the proposed uh special use before you tonight is for a small venue.

R

Beer wine liquor consumption on premises and package sales for off-premises consumption.

R

Got a little ahead of myself again, the proposed use for the establishment is bar lounge and retail.

R

Sales, um the total av sales area is 6 317 square feet that consists of 5 572 square feet inside.

R

And 745 square feet outside the site plan does show access driveways on both north dale mabry.

R

And north uh b street and sterling avenue the required parking for the site as it.

R

Has multiple uses on it through an approved pd is a 260 parking spaces and and the site.

R

Plan is showing 277 being provided. uh The subject. Property is located in the west.

R

Shore, business center and the distance separation requirement is 250 feet from all residential uses.

R

Again, the site plan does state that the sales area shall not be located within a parking.

R

Or loading area or space and that all permits issued after april 1 2011 shall be kept on site.

R

Which is a copy of the adopted, ordinance and associated site plan?.

R

The hours that are being requested are consistent with chapter 14., um as you can see on the slide.

R

There is an existing active ab sales permit, it's ordinance 93-200, and it was for a for.

R

Copr, so that's reporting license for beer, wine and liquor, and uh that was only for the indoor.

R

Area is 69.01 square feet, so there's a little bit of an increase by making that outdoor area.

R

And again that is per the previously approved pd site plan and that was from 2012.. I'm sorry.

R

Ordinance 2012-107, which is file number 1228 and their hours of operation, were to city code.

R

um The waiver request before you and that's just to ensure that the pd is in compliance.

R

With today's standards, with a special use, that's in front of you is comes from section 27283.12, j.

R

And that's to allow the commercial traffic access to the local street um that those local streets.

R

Are north sterling avenue and um the north marie dr murray avenue the distance separation again is.

R

Is with it it's ashore specifically, and that is the 250 feet from residential uses, um and there.

R

Is a heart route 36, which runs regular service on north dale, mabry, highway and route 30 along.

R

Kennedy boulevard, here's the site plan and generally it's a little oriented differently.

R

Just because the shape of the site but north is over here to your right, so here's going north.

R

Dale mabry and you can see the subject pd and the property. Is this um oddly shaped lot, but this was.

R

The previously approved lot and the subject side itself is right here, which is building a.

R

Here's the floor plan that is before you and they're.

R

But their um parking calculations for the specific site are 185 seats and that's how.

R

It was calculated for the previous pd, so we were trying to keep in, in conformance with that as well.

R

And this might be a better, uh ariel, just kind of show you the outline.

R

Of the property and here's kennedy to your south and then north dale mabry.

R

Here's a picture of the two establishments that are currently there.

R

I'll, let the agent explain more about the applicant's proposal for the site and generally.

R

It's the entire structure, that's being av, zoned or re-av zoned, to include that outdoor area.

R

Here's the north end of the site and then to the right, the south end of the site. These are some of.

R

The other establishments that are on there, um the appropriate pd and located at the east of the site.

R

And then there's that parking garage, that's closer to the east side as well. Barnes noble on the north.

R

Side and then the large glass office building is on the corner of kennedy and north uh del mabori.

R

Oh, I have a little delay there, sorry about that. So with that being said, your staff report that.

R

Was presented before you does outline section, 27, 129 general standards for your review as.

R

Well, as section 27 132, which are the regulations governing these special uses um with that being.

R

Said the development review and compliance staff has reviewed the application and we do find it.

R

Consistent with the city of tampa applicable, the applicable city of tampa coded ordinances,.

R

There are some minor corrections needed for the site plan between first and second reading.

R

Should this ordinance be read and approved and those are outlined in the staff report.

R

Staff is available for any questions that you may have. Thank you very much. Do we have any questions.

E

Okay, thank you. Next.

J

Good applicant council members, my name is grace yang. I am at the gray robinson law firm at 401.

J

East jackson, street suite 2700 in tampa florida. It's my pleasure to bring this application before.

J

You today to request approval. This is a a single building with two different businesses side by.

J

Side operating right now with the hatchery restaurant and the brass tap prior to the.

J

Hatchery and the brass tap being developed here it was the old ruby, tuesday, restaurant.

J

And mr manassi mentioned that this has been a for copr restaurant zoning under ordinance, 93-200.

J

This request, we are adding an outdoor patio which you saw on the presentation.

J

The outdoor patio is currently on the side, known as the brass tap and.

J

The applicant is requesting the permission to have alcohol sales and consumption in that outdoor.

J

Patio area, in addition to the interior occupied by the brass, tap and hatchery under a common roof.

J

We are requesting that the use in addition to having the outdoor patio approved.

J

Allow for the use change uh to your wine and liquor consumption on premises and package sales.

J

Off-Premise consumption, um the brass tap has a craft beer bar and they would appreciate the.

J

Opportunity to offer package sales as well for the beer enthusiasts who visit as previously mentioned.

J

There is one waiver required to allow commercial traffic access to a local street, which is north.

J

Stirling avenue there's currently an existing access from sterling avenue. It's the rear of.

J

The building that has the office depot in it right now, I'm happy to answer any questions you may have.

J

um And with me tonight are michelle knight from the company, fsc franchise and brian knox. Do you.

I

Have any questions, mr sheriff? I'm a machine? Yes, um the uh the uh off-premise sales, the package.

I

Sales will that be confined to beer only or will it also consist of hard liquor and wine.

J

It could consist of hard liquor and wine under the license category. If this is approved.

J

It would be a quota license, the 4c photo license would be for beer, wine and spirits. The current.

J

Business at the brass tap is a craft beer bar, but they do also have a great variety of beers.

J

And their license would allow wine and spirit sales they do offer cocktails right now for but.

I

I'm talking for the package store, would they just be selling growlers or would they be selling wine.

I

And liquor to take off premise the license the license would allow sales of bottles of wine.

J

Growlers, as well as as other spirits, if they choose to do so.

J

But the emphasis currently is is on the on the craft beer business. Thank you miss shank. Thank.

I

You, mr chair, thank you very much. Anybody else all right. Do you have anybody in the.

E

Public that wishes to speak on item number 10. No one has read us to speak on this item.

E

Is there anybody in the audience this is eileen rosario development and growth? There's no one here.

A

To speak on this item, thank you. We have a motion closed from councilman goose. Do we have a second.

E

Second, from council member vieira, all in favor.

E

Aye, where did I leave off with, I believe, councilman carlson, okay, councilman vieira.

H

I present for first reading consideration and ordinance approving a special use permit s2 for.

H

Alcoholic beverage sales, small venue, consumption on premises and package sales, off-premise location.

H

And making lawful the sale of beverages regardless of alcoholic content, beer wine and liquor.

H

On that certain lot plot or track of land located at 201, north dale mabry highway.

H

Tampa florida is more particularly described in section three.

H

Providing that all ordinances or parts of ordinances and conflict are repealed.

H

Providing or strike that repealing ordinance number 93-200 providing an effective date do.

E

We have a second, we have a second from councilman goods, roll call vieira, yes, boots, link the other.

K

Yes, yes, carlson! Yes, yes, siege, no and miranda motion k with sitra voting, no miranda being absent.

K

Second, reading in adoption will be held on march 4th at 9 30 a.m. Yes, sir, mr chairman, yes.

B

Yes, yes, okay um anyway, I just want to give a shout out to ms yang. I haven't seen her in many years.

B

And- um and it's great great to see you back here again in front of council, thank you.

E

Item number eleven: thank you, chair ryan, manassee development, coordination item number, eleven's, ab2,.

R

Ab2 20-12 for the property located at 2223 nor northwest shore boulevard, specifically.

R

Unit b217 and if I could share my screen, go ahead, sir. Mr chairman, the speakers need to be sworn in.

E

All right, uh mr manasseh, been sworn in, but anne pollock needs to be uh sworn in.

E

Go ahead, do you swear firm? You would tell the truth. The whole truth and nothing but the truth.

K

I do and uh the same goes for jonathan scott and mr knox. You've already been sworn in so.

E

You're good go ahead, mr manassi. Thank you chair uh again. Just for the record item number 11 file.

R

Number 8220-12 for the property located at 2223 northwest shore boulevard, specifically unit v217.

R

This is at the international mall I'll share my screen, please let me know when you see.

R

The welcome we do go ahead, sir excellent. So again, the petition before you is requesting.

R

Special use approval to allow the sale of alcoholic beverages for a small venue, beer.

R

Wine consumption on premises and package sales, off-premises consumption, uh the total ap sales.

R

Area for the proposed petition is 3755 square feet which contains 2 868 square feet, interior.

R

And 887 square feet exterior the proposed use for the property is restaurant and retail sales.

R

The parking requirement for the entire site is 5 669 spaces approved through file number de1-19-165.

R

The petitioner, the participant's required parking for the specific area is 26 spaces.

R

And it's within that overall required parking for that international mall property. uh It is located.

R

In the west shore business center and this upper distance separation requirement is 250 feet from.

R

Other residential uses there are no residential uses within that 250 foot separation requirement.

R

The site plan states that the sales area shall not be located within the parking or loading area.

R

Or space and all permits issued after april 1st 2011 shall be kept on site with that copy of the.

R

Ordinance, as well as the approved site plan, and that comes specifically from section 27, 132.

R

As you can see, there's no active av permit on the property and the hours that they are requesting.

R

On the site, plan are consistent with chapter 14.

R

There are no rivers being requested and there are no residential uses within that 250 feet.

R

And again, the property is located in that west shore business center. It's also in the west.

R

Shore overlay, here's the site plan, as shown, and specifically this enlarged view will show you it's.

R

Zooming out, to give you more reference, the establishment that is before you tonight.

R

Our aerial obviously uh encompasses the entire property, but then we try to market a little.

R

Bit better just uh so, you know specifically where it's located at that international mall.

R

There's some pictures of the front of the subject: property and then the rear of the subject site.

R

And again, just for you in the staff report, section 27 129 for your general standards is.

R

Outlined for you, your reference as well as 27 132 for the regulations governing special uses.

R

For our staff report, the development review and compliance staff has reviewed the application.

R

We do find it consistent with the city of tampa code of ordinances. We do request some.

R

Minor modifications needed between first and second reading should this be approved.

R

I do believe um the agent for the application is going to have a minor modification to add as well.

R

um And she can discuss that with ustaff is aware of it and we are okay with it. um But.

R

At this time, this uh council have any questions for staff. Do you have any questions at this time.

E

Okay, go ahead, uh miss pollock! I may I share my screen. Please.

J

Okay, does that work.

P

Let me try this again, not yet.

J

Okay, there we go, I apologize, we don't see it yet. On our end,.

K

I don't know why this isn't working here. We go okay,.

L

Well, anyway, if you, I don't know if you can see it, but I'm gonna start. We can.

L

I am here tonight uh anne pollock 433, central avenue, st pete. I'm here representing tampa west.

L

Shore associates we're here to request a beer and wine consumption on premises.

L

And package sales for a site on bay street. If you can see my screen, I hope you can.

L

The the outlined area is where the uh the space is. It's located on bay street within.

L

The international plaza between the back of restoration hardware and the back of the.

L

Pub it's got an entrance both on one side and on the other, so you can enter it. Two different ways.

L

It's going to be 10 and 10 ineteka, which is inateck, is italian for wine, library and.

L

This is basically going to be a wine bar cafe and shop, offering quality wines and.

L

Local craft beers, consumption on premises and package sales of wine.

L

And beer for consumption off-premises also be serving light. Lunch and dinners inspired by.

L

Italian, spanish and portuguese cuisine and the chef is a of toledo, spain and.

L

Has worked with many michelin star staff chefs around the world so other than just.

L

Having dinner and drinking wine and selling wine, though, expect to have wine classes flying pair.

L

Dinners tastings and meet and greets with various wine folks that people want to meet.

L

As ryan went through, it's a 3755 square foot area with two small patios, one on either side.

L

No full kitchen hours of operation per the code and for the lease no waivers requested within.

L

The west shore business center and we do need the required parking. The one change that we are.

L

Requesting is that, for some reason, our occupancy plan that was submitted only provided parking.

L

Seating on the larger exterior patio- and we would also like to put seating on the smaller exterior.

L

Patio, so that would add an additional 10 seats or occupants and two additional parking spaces.

L

Which we have no problem needing because we have the large amounts in the mall, approximately 5900.

L

So I would just respectfully request uh your approval and uh with the addition of the extra 10.

L

Seat and the two parking spots, thank you. Do you have any questions from council members.

I

Yes, if I may miss pollock, are these uh beers made specifically by this restaurant? No, are the wines.

M

Local ones from local breweries are, are the wines made specifically for this restaurant.

L

I believe that they have some collaboration with other, uh with specific vineyards around.

L

That they are working with to bring in those wines to here, but I believe they will be selling.

L

Those wines plus other wines.

I

Thank you. Thank you. Any questions.

E

Another question: is there anybody in the public that wishes to speak on item number 11.

K

No one has registered to speak on this item. Is there anybody in the general public? I just got a.

E

uh There is no one here to speak in reference to this item. We have motion clothes from councilman.

E

Goodes, we have a second second, second from councilman carlson, all in favor aye.

I

Okay, councilman dink felder. Are you able to read item number eleven.

E

Can you read number 11., do you have it in front of you.

B

Not andy but I'll support the motion, all right, councilman. uh You want councilman goose.

F

An ordinance approving a special youth permit issue 2 for all beverage sales, small vegan.

F

Consumption on premises and package, sales for off-purpose consumption and making lawful the.

F

Sale of pier and wine at at or front or at a from that certain lot plot or track of land located at.

F

2223 northwestern boulevard unit p217 tampa florida is more particularly described in section.

F

Two, providing all ordinance or partially ordered in conflict or repeal providing effective date do.

E

We have a second second from councilman councilman dingfield. Yes, sir, just a question on the motion.

E

Yes, sir, um actually you know what I don't want to taint the record so.

B

Come back to me after the mission is done. If you would please the chairman, martin shelley,.

A

A quick question where, as to the uh addition, is that noted on a revision sheet or is that.

A

Something that needs to be just made, um mr manassee, as part of the motion ryan, asks.

R

Development coordination, if you would just include it, the revisions, are based off your staff report.

R

So they're a little different than probably what you've seen recently in the rezoning request. But.

R

On pages uh you'll see under general requirements of code staff, specifically for this petition, it.

R

Is on page two at the bottom, there are some minor corrections that are being asked for um the verbal.

R

Request that ann stated for the record would be what we want to include in the motion as well.

R

uh The per the corrections in the staff report and again specifically for the purposes of the clerk.

A

What was that with the 10? I believe it was, do you have that it's to.

R

Add the 10 occupants to the smaller exterior patio, which is not affecting any parking. So really it's.

R

Just modifying the parking calculations to um include that two extra parking spaces that are.

R

Specifically required for this set establishment and it'll show the 10 occupants on the occupancy.

R

Plan that will be presented before you with that revision on second reading. Thank you, sir.

E

We have mosh from councilman goodes. We have a second from.

E

Councilman carlson roll call vote carlson, yes, citro miranda, vieira, yes, goods, yes, ding felder,.

K

Yes in maniscaco, yes, motion carry with situa voting, no miranda being absent.

K

Second reading and adoption will be held on march 4th at 9 30 a.m. Thank you very much.

E

Yes, sir yeah, this was my follow-up question, perhaps to miss johnson velez or mr manas. um The.

B

I remember we used to have quite a few of those.

B

A b applications in from international position. I always thought they were just a huge waste of time.

B

um Just because they're they're encompassed within the mall they have no, they have no.

B

Impact on neighborhoods if the mall approves the lease, etc, etc, um but I'm pretty confident.

B

That we have no provisions with our within our code to address these types of multiple tenant.

B

um Operations, so I'm just you know, ryan, is anything anybody's ever talked about or.

B

Thought about I'm sorry, mr chairman, mr dink felder, I'm sorry to interrupt.

A

All good questions, uh perhaps um better, perhaps held for second after second reading,.

A

Or perhaps to talk with staff offline about this, and if it's something that.

A

You think is appropriate to bring it back. I'd appreciate that I'm sorry and susan johnsonville.

D

Senior assistant city attorney, uh mr dingfeld I'll, just remind you as well that we do have.

D

um An ab workshop um coming up at the end of february on your february 25th workshop agenda.

B

I did not realize that and susan you will have to remind me on that date for us to chat about.

B

This issue, thank you. Thank you to everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Mister. Mr manassi item number 12.

R

Thank you, chair, ryan manassee. I believe the agent would have to be sworn in before we continue.

E

And we have uh yes do. We have the agent on online.

E

We have mr grandoff going sir, do you, sir affirm, you would tell the truth.

K

The whole truth and nothing but the truth. I do thank you.

E

Okay, mr manassee you're all good to go. Thank you. Chair item number.

R

12 was file number 8221-01. If I could share my screen, please.

R

Please let me know when you see it, we can, we can see it, go ahead. Excellent, so again, item number 12.

R

82 21-01, it is a petition before you requesting special use approval to allow the sale of.

R

Alcoholic beverage for a small venue, beer, wine and liquor for consumption on premises only.

R

This petition is proposing a use as a private recreational facility, uh with the total av.

R

Sales sales area of 25, 251 square feet, indoor 1706 square feet outdoor for a total of 26 957 square.

R

Feet which again is first floor, only the site plan shows singular access. Driveway on east washington,.

R

Street and this property is along a mixed use, corridor village, so the distance separation.

R

Requirement is 250 feet from residential uses and 250 feet from other av sales establishments.

R

The site plan presented before you does state that sales will not be located in the parking.

R

Loading area or space and that all permits issued after april 1st 2011 shall be kept on site with.

R

The adopt the door ordinance and the approved site plan, as you can see on screen, there is no current.

R

Active av permit and the hours of operation are listed in this chart, as well as your staff.

R

Report and I'll just state them for the record. It's monday through thursday, 11 a.m to 11 p.m.

R

Friday through saturday, 11 a.m to 1 a.m and then sunday 11 a.m to 12 a.m, with the exception.

R

Of new year's eve and super bowl, I believe something got cut off there. I apologize for.

R

That, let me see super bowl, gasparilla and gasparilla, which will be 11 a.m to 1 a.m.

R

And that should reflect appropriately in the staff report, but I think it got cut off. But I stated for.

R

The record um the waiver requested there are none, the distance separation waivers there's.

R

None there as well and again, the property has a future land use designation of the cmu 35, which.

R

Is a mixed-use land use which is a mixed-use land use which qualifies the parcel to be in.

R

That mixed-use corridor village, which is where we determine that distance separation requirement.

R

The site plan, as shown here, is that singular access on washington street and you can see.

R

The large parking area- this is a two-story structure and the first floor being where.

R

The alcohol petition is being requested before you there's some elevations of this. uh The structure.

R

And then the ariel, which shows the outline property in red.

R

And then, as you can see, it's a newer construction in the subject site right here.

R

There's some physical pictures from the site. This is uh looking on washington street viewing south.

R

And then north side, which is viewed across crosstown and sunday area,.

R

And the north side, which is more overgrown vacant area,.

R

West side vacant- and then you can see this other uh the gas station over here. That's on the corner.

R

You're looking east on washington street and then the west view of washington street.

R

Again, section 27 129 is um presented before you and your staff report for.

R

Reference general sanders, as well as 27 132 132, for regulations governing.

R

Special uses, and with that being said, the development review and client staff has.

R

Reviewed the application we find it consistent with the city of tampa applicable code of.

R

Ordinances, minor corrections are requested to the site plan between first and second reading.

R

As outlined in your staff report, and if you would please include that in your motion, if approved.

R

Staff is available for any questions that you may have do you have any questions for staff.

F

Right ryan is that a new place south of adama? Let me scroll back up.

F

Washington yep 618 and then here's 50th street here. So I believe this is where adamo jimmy.

R

Cookies, always correct me on that is that a new construction building, I'm sorry, sir, is that a.

F

New construction building, like that, I believe, I believe it is, but um I'd probably refer to.

R

The agent he could probably better explain the um the process that they're at the only thing I can.

F

Remember used to be on washington boulevard and it was the old wtmp uh building down at that place.

R

Yeah, as you can see, there's a lot of vacant land I mean these aerials are probably as new as we can get and um you can see there is a lot of vacancy um around the area yeah. Yes, sir.

E

Thank you very much anything else: okay, applicant, mr grandoff. Yes, good evening, mr chairman members,.

A

Of the city council, my office is at 3700 bank of america plaza. My name is john grandoff.

A

And I have the pleasure of representing the egypt temple shriners, who are very.

A

Good citizens and a jolly group of gentlemen, by the way they have built their new clubhouse here.

A

Just east of 50th street on the outskirts of town, as mr goods recognized mr manassee, has.

A

Very well detailed, his staff report and the findings. We agree with the findings and the.

A

Brief revision to the site plan, I direct you to page five where he finds the project in compliance.

A

We have no objections from any other city staff nor neighbors. I respectfully request.

A

Your approval, on behalf of the shriners, thank you very much. Did you say a jolly group very, very.

E

Jolly group, thank you very much. We have anybody in the public that wishes to speak on this item.

K

No one has registered to speak on this item and do we have anybody in the audience.

E

Second, councilman dean: federer! Wait! Do you have a question, sir?.

E

Yeah, I just wanted to ask mr grant, I know he's a member of.

B

Of the crew, I don't know if he's a shriner or not, but if we, if we vote yes, we get the little hats.

B

Because lord knows, I need to come. No, no! No, not for you! Sorry councilman dean feldman, not for you.

I

Wow there's a process, no, you got, you got to go through and no you don't have to convert. I do not.

A

um I'm not a member of the shriners, I don't have a fez, I don't think they would have me, but I I think.

A

They do good works and they're very excited about their new clubhouse. Mr mr grandoff you're you're.

I

You're, a notable man put in your application I'll be a top line. Signer I'll have to wear a fez.

A

Mr chairman, mr chairman, I didn't hear whether there was somebody on the second floor.

A

I didn't hear if there was anything there was nobody, sir. Okay, thank you.

E

All right can I get a motion to close motion from councilman goode. Second, from councilman.

E

Citroe, all in favor all right, hi all right any opposed.

E

Councilman citro, would you mind reading on number 12? Yes, thank you very much file number ab2-21-01.

I

Ordnance being presented first, would you consider it consideration an ordinance approving exposure.

I

Use permit s 2 for alcohol beverage sales, small venue, consumption on premises only.

I

And making waffles with sale beverages regardless, regardless of alcohol content, beer want and.

I

Liquor. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Forgive me. I'm sorry interrupt my mistake. I I apologize my mistake.

I

At or from certain lot plot tractor land located at 50-17 east washington street tampa florida is.

I

More particularly described in section two that all ordinance or parts of ordinance and conflict.

I

Be repealed providing an effective date with minor modifications between first and second rating.

I

And with the hours of operation that have been noted, we have a motion from councilman seacher.

E

With a second from councilman vieira roll call vote, carlson, yes, sietra, yes, miranda vieira, yes,.

K

Yes, ting felder and maniscaco, yes, motion care with miranda being absent. Second reading in.

K

Adoption will be held on march 4th and 9 30 a.m. Thank you, mr manassian. Thank you.

A

Gentlemen, yes, yes, sir and mr manasseh, you are pronouncing it correctly. It is adamo.

A

Thank you, sir yeah yeah yeah. It is good yeah you're right that was very good. He's retired.

E

Item number uh item number 13.. I I see we have one registered person to speak. I don't know if.

E

They're in the audience or if they're online, mr crew, uh mr chairman james cruz city, clerk's,.

A

Office there is one person registered to speak. They have not signed into the meeting okay. If, if.

E

And if and when they sign in we'll swear them in, um do we have an applicant here for item number 13.

R

It should be dixie liberty for the record ryan manassee. That's the agent for the application.

E

Okay and that's the person that I think is registered, um is it dixie liberty, sir mr crew,.

E

I believe it is go ahead, mr manasseh, that is the only person uh registered for the meeting. They did.

A

Not indicated that they were the applicant just says that they are registered. Okay, go ahead, mr.

E

Manassi, may I ask, is there somebody who's going to be testifying or representing the applicant.

A

Mr chairman, I saw somebody sitting down in the corner of the second floor, but I don't.

E

Know if they were here for this item, can we make inquiry to see if the applicant is do.

E

We have anybody in the audience there. Yes, we do. We have one applicant okay, there. You are okay,.

E

Ma'am, if you could just come to the screen, raise your right hand we're going to swear you in.

K

Do you swear from you would tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.

K

I do thank you very good. All right, mr manassi go ahead.

R

Thank you, chair brian manassee development coordination again item 13 is file number 82.

R

21-02 it's for the property located at 4808 east broadway avenue. If I could share my screen, please.

A

Where's, we can see it go ahead. Sir excellent, thank you. So the petition before used requesting special.

R

Use approval to allow the sale of alcoholic beverages for a small venue, beer wine, liquor.

R

Package sales, off-premises consumption: only this petition is proposing a use, as retail.

R

Sales shoppers goods with an a b sales area of 2 000 square feet, which is indoor only.

R

The site plan does indicate that the proposed hours for operation will be monday through.

R

I'm sorry monday through saturday, 7 a.m to 3 a.m and then sunday 11 a.m to 3 a.m.

R

The site plan shows dual access: driveways on east broadway avenue and north 40th street.

R

The subject property in reference to the distance separation requirement is 1 000.

R

I'm sorry 1000 feet residential uses, institutional uses and other av sales establishments. The cycling.

R

Does state that sales will not be located within the parking loading area or space and that all.

R

Permits issued after april 1st 2011 will be kept on site with the copy of the adopted ordinance.

R

As well as the approved site plan, and that comes directly from section 27 132 of our code.

R

As you see on screen, there is an active ordinance from 2010-19 it's for 2 aps, which is for beer and.

R

Wine package sales off-premises consumption only and that was approved for 2 000 square feet.

R

So that is the existing um package store, as it is right now, um their hours of operation work.

R

Per city code and again, the request before you is over here to the right on the screen.

R

Which I've already detailed? They are requesting three waivers and those come from the distance.

R

Separation requirements all from section 27 132 and that's to reduce the required minimum distance.

R

Separation from a thousand feet to 189 feet for other ap sales establishments, the second being the.

R

Distance separation requirement from a thousand feet to 88 for residential uses and then the last.

R

Is that this separation requirement 1000 feet to 312 feet for institutional uses.

R

And those uses are outlined here in the next block down the residential uses at 2002 north.

R

49Th street they're, zoned arm 16 and again 88 feet institutional uses is that the baptist church at.

R

4901 east 10th avenue and then the closest av sales is 4911 east broadway avenue. There are.

R

No heart routes along this subject property the site plan. As you can see, this is like an existing.

R

Strip center there's an amstot building here and then the existing av sales area right here.

R

Outlined in red again, the petition before you is trying to increase that from beer wine to beer.

R

Wine and liquor for the package sales only there are some minor modifications that are required.

R

That are outlined in the staff report if this is approved first reading before second reading and.

R

Then you can see the outline of the subject property here, just north of broadway avenue.

R

There's some photos: food, seven, that's the subject, property and then the amp scott over here.

R

And this is the north end of the site. Looking from north 49th street.

R

This is north of the site and then the picture to the right is south of the site.

R

Looking west on 7th avenue to your left and then west of the site itself left picture east of the.

R

Site and that's from the parking lot looking east and then the east side, east of the site,.

R

Again got that delay. Section 27 129 is outlined in your staff report for general standards as well as.

R

Section 27 132 for your regulations governing special uses, um the development review and.

R

Compliance staff has reviewed the application we do find it inconsistent with applicable city.

R

Of tampa code of ordinances, again, minor corrections to the side plan are needed.

R

Between first and second reading should this be approved on first reading, and if you would.

R

Include that in your motion and then staff is available for any questions that you may have.

E

Do any questions for mr manassee hearing none? Yes, this message put that map back up the.

F

Location, please be that m scott plasma. Yes, sir, put up the amp scott photo for him.

C

Thank you, sir. Yes, sir.

E

Thank you, sir. Thank you. We have the petitioner, um please say your name go ahead. Hi! Yes, my name.

J

Is dixie liberty, I'm from riverview florida I'm here on behalf of kaley enterprises, inc at 4808.

J

East broadway avenue he's already in business for a 2 aps and he's asking to go to am 3ps package.

J

Store with beer, wine and liquor on premises only on 2 000 square feet, he has 19 spaces.

J

Provided only has to have 16 and I have not heard anything from anybody. No one has contacted me.

J

Let's see, I did zone him back in 2008 and he was approved then, and I.

J

Also have to have three waivers, which mr massey on already mentioned, that.

E

Any questions for the petitioner.

E

Hearing none do we have anybody in the public that wishes to speak on item number 13.

K

No one has registered to speak on this item. Council member ding felder. I see your hand up, sir.

B

Is this a quick question that to ryan ryan? I was having a little bit of trouble seeing.

B

The relationship between the I guess it's an existing building that they wanted to.

B

Put that use in and the church the church, that's close ryan monastic development coordination.

R

It comes from the the survey has to outline institutional uses, uh residential uses and.

R

Other av sales establishments within that thousand foot radius. That's what.

R

That waiver request is identifying it's it's within that thousand feet um specifically.

R

It was at 312 feet and because the distance separation requirement.

R

Is a thousand feet? They have to present that before you as a waiver.

B

I understand that, but can you show graphically photo anything in terms of where the church is.

B

I just want to see if there's any you know real impact um from the potential wet use to the church.

A

One second, a question, mr chairman:.

A

The petitioner, I believe, is still present but not on screen and I think maybe perhaps it.

A

Would be best to have the petitioner on screen? Can we keep the petitioner on the screen? Please.

A

R

So what I can um and I'll try to answer both questions, um the school, sir. I'm not aware of.

R

So per our application requirement, they have to identify this per a surveyor and then the.

R

Surveyor identifies the closest uses, um as you can see, here is number one oak park baptist church and.

R

The subject sites outlined in red that's easier to see if I zoom in sir one sec, there we go and then.

R

It's it's located over here: councilman, dean, felder and then uh councilman goods, I'm not sure um the.

R

Again, the serve area has to identify the closest use. That's within there to identify for the.

R

The waiver there may be more of those uses within that thousand feet, but, as you can imagine, some.

R

Of those uses can get quite those lists can get extensive if it is the pleasure of city council.

R

I believe you can request that from the agent if their server can provide additional listing.

R

Between first and second reading, if that would help, show all the uses within a thousand feet, but.

R

As you can imagine, it can get extensive and for waiver purposes. We have to identify the closest.

B

My next question is: does if you're within the thousand feet I mean typically, our notice is.

B

Only what 250 feet for the wet zoning um is the church within the notice area for the 250.

R

It would not be so. You can see this outline. This 250 ring that the surveyor has provided from the.

R

Subject, site and then they're identifying one outside of that 250 feet. But again this is in.

R

Relation this exhibit that's before you as part of the application packet and that's in relation.

R

To the distance separation requirement, not the public notice radius, that's required by code.

B

Ma'am, have you had any contact with the church? No, I tried calling them. They never returned. My call.

J

I drove by also- and they were not open.

B

Brian, can you go back to the picture and tell me where I guess the front of this building and.

B

Tell me where the church is as related to it is it down down, it looks like it might be down.

B

And around the corner to the rear and the the bent the best I can show you, sir, was that.

R

Let me pull back up is the exhibit from the server, because again, these are identified by the surveyor.

R

As part of the application requirement on that, but I can't see this- I can't see the street layouts.

R

I can google it. Let me do a little math view.

B

I want to make sure that I mean it's a little bit close and I just want to make sure that.

B

That it doesn't have any practical impact on the church.

R

So here's the uh subject site right here off of broadway and then here's the 4901 east 10th avenue.

R

So north on 49th street, on 10th avenue where's the subject sign again right here, sir.

B

And then the red dot is the church correct? So I guess it's a good two blocks behind.

R

For the survey documents outside of that 250-foot radius that they're identifying.

R

And they're identifying again for the record at 312 feet and the way that's measured.

R

Councilman is from the point of the alcohol, the closest point of the alcohol establishment.

R

To the property boundary so that 312 feet would be to the property boundary.

R

Any other questions, any other questions.

E

Do we have anybody in the public that wishes to speak on this item? Item number 13.

K

No one has read us to speak on this item. I'm sorry! Anybody I linked to there's no one here to.

A

Speak on this item, we have motion clothes from councilman goode secretary councilman, citroe.

E

All in favor aye any opposed councilman carlson. Would you like to read item 13.

H

Sure I'd like to move file number ab2-21-02 ordinance being presented for first reading, consideration.

H

An ordinance approving a special use permit s2 for alcoholic beverage sales, small.

H

Venue package sales off-premise consumption only in making lawful the sale of beverages.

H

Regardless of alcoholic content, beer, wine or and liquor at or from that certain lot plot or tract.

H

Of land located at 4808, east broadway avenue tampa florida as more particularly described.

H

In section three, that all ordinances or parts of ordinances and conflict are repealed.

H

Repealing ordinance number uh 2010-19 providing effective date, we have a motion from councilman.

E

uh Carlson was it a second from vieira roll call vote goods no vieira? Yes, ding felder.

E

K

My name is kaku yes, carlson, yes, sidro and miranda motion k with goods and dink builder voting, the.

K

No an absence second reading and adoption will be held on march 4th to 9 30 a.m. Thank you very much.

E

Last item of the night- and it's not even 8.

E

Item number 15 and we have to swear in mr jim porter. I believe.

E

Mr porter, if you're on, please turn your camera on I'm trying. Is it not working.

G

Hold on there we go.

E

That worked there. We are go ahead. Sir, do you swear firm? You would.

K

Tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing, but the truth. I do thank you.

E

Okay, mr manassee, go ahead, sir. Thank you. Chair ryan manassee item number, 15 file, number ab2.

R

21-05 it's for the property located at 2205, west kennedy boulevard and if I could share my screen.

R

If you would please let me know, when you see the welcome, we do go ahead, excellent, so the petition.

R

Before you is requesting um alcohol approval for a small venue, beer wine and liquor consumption.

R

On premises, only the proposed use is a bar with a total ap sales area of 4485 square feet. 2615.

R

Of that being indoor and then 1870 square feet being outdoor according to the floor,.

R

Plan there's a total of 151 occupants that that floor plan was attached to the site plan that.

R

Was previously sent over and the site plan does indicate that the proposed hours operation will be.

R

Compliant with chapter 14 of our code, the site plan shows an access driveway on west kennedy.

R

Boulevard as well as an alley access off south westland avenue the required parking for the.

R

Proposed use for bar is the occupancy multiplied by 0.25, which comes to that. Well, the occupancy.

R

Being 151 people times, 0.25 requiring 38 parking spaces and there are 21 spaces being provided.

R

The subject property is along a mixed-use quarter, village and the distance separation requirement.

R

Is 250 feet from residential uses and then 250 feet from other av sales establishments.

R

um This the site plan does uh state that there are no sales. uh No sales area shall be located.

R

Within the parking loading area or space and then all permits issued or I'm sorry all permits issued.

R

After april, 1st 2011 shall be kept on site the copy of the approved ordinance, as well as the site.

R

Plan and that comes from 27 132 of our code, as you can see on the screen, there is an active ordnance.

R

That's 2007-25 or file number 07-14, that was for a 4copr, which is a consumption on-premise in.

R

Connection with a restaurant, the total area being 3895 square feet that are existing and approved.

R

With 24 parking spaces provided and the sales hours being per city code,.

R

And then the request right next to it before you that I've already outlined.

R

There are three waivers being requested: um the first coming from 27 to 83.7 and that's to.

R

Reduce the required uh parking from 38 required to 21 being provided. That's a 45.

R

Reduction and then the last two being the distance separation requirements from 27 132.

R

um The requirement to 250 to residential use as being 30 feet and then 250 feet required to.

R

Other ap sales establishments to 48 feet and then those two closest uses listed below the.

R

Closest residential use being the 100, I'm sorry 103 south westland avenue it's own.

R

Arm 16 and it's 30 feet again and the abc sale, I'm sorry, the ad sales area being the circle k.

R

At 2220 west kennedy boulevard it's own cg. They help with 2 aps, which is beer and wine.

R

Package sales only at 48 feet again, the property is in the future. Landis designation, umu 60, which.

R

Is a mixed use, land use which qualifies parcel to be along that mixed use, corridor, village and.

R

That's where we get that distance separation requirement again that property is located.

R

In the kennedy, boulevard, porter overlay and the site plan shows the existing structure.

R

Here is south of kennedy, boulevard, the access here and then there's also the access through.

R

That alley on westlawn avenue this is a outdoor av sales area which is outlined here that be.

R

On the north side of the property and then the existing interior area, this is first floor. Only.

R

And then the floor plan is where we get the occupancy calculations for the required parking.

R

Here's the aerial of the site, so you can see south howard here.

R

And then west kennedy and then the subject site outlined in red. This is.

R

A circle k and then the closest on westland, the residential use, is directly to the south.

R

Across the alley, there's some photos of the site on kennedy and then the west west side of the site.

R

This is the view looking east on kennedy, boulevard and then there's two pictures.

R

To the right or east uh east of the site on kennedy and then east of the site on westland.

R

Those are commercial um north north side of the street is uh commercial as well.

R

That's north kennedy and then the south side, which should be that closest residential use.

R

The staff report does outline again section 27 129 general standards for your reference.

R

As well as 27 132 for the regulations governing the special uses, the development review and.

R

Compliance theft has reviewed the application we do find it inconsistent with the applicity.

R

Of tampa code of ordinances, if approved, there are minor corrections needed to the site plan.

R

Between first and second reading, as outlined in the staff report, and if you would please make.

R

That part of your motion, if approved staff, is available for any questions that you may have.

E

Any questions councilman dingfelder, yes, sir.

B

Well, mr manas or maybe mr porter, so it's called pups pub. So the question is: if the four-legged.

B

Occupants are they counted for two and does that impact parking space? You took my job. You took my.

B

Job the agent to answer that- and I hope mr court didn't didn't pick out the sign out front that.

B

Just flashed by that spoke about chasing tail. That's really distasteful, mr porter, carrying.

G

Fair enough, um thank you. Aaron jim porter, I'm with acreman 401 east kennedy right across the street.

G

Watching you on my window, um I am the agent or the representative for the applicant. I'm.

G

Excited to bring this petition for you, it's sort of a relatively new concept in a relatively old.

G

Building um it is called pups pub and the idea is that it's a place for pet owners, uh people.

G

Who own dogs take their dogs and have a drink? uh This is the site of the old bungalow restaurant.

G

That you'll recall- and there was an active av license on it and they had attended when the.

G

Owners bought this, they had intended to just use it as a restaurant and a a place where the dogs.

G

Would go because of state regulations with the animals. They can't have a food operation so even.

G

Though there's a brand new kitchen in the bungalow they're not able to use that so we worked with.

G

Mr manassee, to identify the appropriate process that we needed to go through in order to secure.

G

A dap license- and this is a small venue that we're seeking there are waivers associated with this, but.

G

I'll note that nothing has really changed in the operation. It was bungalow before the.

G

Residents across the alley has always been there. The circle k has been different things.

G

At that corner, but there's always been sales there. The parking again is.

G

A waiver we played around with trying to get more spaces, but it seemed to make sense to.

G

Keep the existing configuration as it is and ask for the waiver we're not aware of any opposition.

G

They've been sort of operating under the current license, but this will clean everything up and.

G

Allow them to work with the operation as it's intended again. It's a new concept and they're very.

G

Excited about, I think there might be one other one in the city, but it's definitely something new for.

G

The city um and with that I'm happy to answer any questions and you respectfully ask for your.

G

uh Approval councilman c. Thank you very much, mr chair, mr porter, uh and the outside portion will.

I

It be amplified music, I'm not that I'm aware of now. So that is a no no thank you. I can't if I, if I.

A

Can yes for mr councilman sitro just a reminder that that's just a representation that has no.

A

Weight one way or the other, because it's not uh enforceable it's worth a try. Thank you. Well, okay,.

A

Well, well, the question: I'm sorry, I'm asking the development coordination um just for the record.

R

There it's not stating on the site plan, it's not a requirement of 27132 for that, but again um just.

R

Having the output of the agent state that, for the record, is not going to be enforceable like.

R

Mr shelby did state so if there is something that I needed to put on the site plane, I'd need.

R

That clear in the motion, as well as added between first and second reading, all right anything else.

E

Yes, I mean, if that's something, I'm trying to think of what what neighbors.

B

Might be nearby, but mr porter do your clients have any objection to adding that to themselves? I don't.

B

Remember I I'm not aware of the and the intent to have amplified music. I don't they're not with.

G

Me tonight I could confirm that between first and second reading the front is facing kennedy um and.

G

There's there's a wall there, so I I will ask them and I can confirm that between first and second.

G

Reading, that's something council's interested in exploring councilman wait. It used to be.

E

It used to be a patio on the kennedy side. Did they did they make it solid subsequently make it solid.

G

There's um there's still a patio but there's a wall there now. So I don't know if you could go.

G

Back to the um brian, if you could go back and show the photos, I just need them. Let.

R

Me share my screen again. So that's the only outdoor area is on the kennedy side. Yes, yes,.

B

I'm not overly concerned about music on kennedy. um I think there is some residential.

B

Further up that yeah, there's no residential uh near on the kennedy side, the residential.

G

That we identified was on the westland side and it's in the alley and yeah it'd be to the south.

R

Here, right, nasty record: if this helps out so here's the subject side again outlined.

R

In red, so you have commercial along kennedy and then going south. You have residential.

R

Yeah, um just for the record sense uh we're talking about it um again between first and second reading,.

R

Any kind of corrections would have to be made in order to be heard at second reading and get the.

R

Zoning administrator to sign off on the site plan so again for any motions. I would.

R

Just need to make sure I know the agent has specified he'd have to speak to the client, but.

R

I would not be able to add that at second reading presentation, because we would be.

R

Presenting you with a certified site plan from the zoning administrator from tonight's hearing.

I

Mr chair, if I may yes, sir, mr porter, yes, I I am concerned with encroachment into the neighborhood.

I

uh If that can be done, and you can ask your well no, I would have to ask that now, if it, if you're.

I

Sure that there could be no amplified out uh music outside can we put that into the record for now.

A

Mr, mr chairman, I'm sorry, mr sito. The reason I'm going to say no is because remember that whatever.

A

Representations are made here, it does not run with the land, whereas, when it's on the site plan, it.

A

Runs with the land and it's enforceable, so what may be true today could change tomorrow unless.

A

It's on the site plan again, I'm martin shelby city council attorney. Thank you any uh other questions.

B

Now I just wanted to point out to mr porter a couple of months back. We did approve a similar.

B

Doggy establishment in drew park- yes, um the first one I think yeah I've driven by it, looks like it's.

B

Doing? Okay, it's a great concept. Do we have anybody in the public that wishes to speak on this item.

K

No one has registered to speak on this item. Is there anybody uh uh down below? On the second floor.

E

We have a motion club, councilman, good secretary councilman sea troll in favor.

E

Any opposed councilman vieira. Would you mind reading this item I sure will mr chair, I move.

H

An ordinance being presented for first reading consideration an ordinance approving a special.

H

Use permit s u2 for alcoholic beverage sales, small venue, consumption on premises only.

H

And making lawful the sale of beverages, regardless of alcoholic content, beer, wine and liquor on.

H

That certain lot plot or track of land located at 2202 west kennedy boulevard tampa florida is more.

H

Particularly described in section three, providing that all ordinances or parts of ordinances and.

H

Conflict are repealed, repealing ordinance, number 2007-25, providing an effective date.

E

Do we have a second who's? The second second for councilman carlson,.

E

Roll call miranda cedro, no carlson, yes, yes, ding felder,.

K

And vieira yes, motion k would meet under being absent, citra voting, no second reading.

K

And adoption will be held on march 4th at 9 30 a.m. Thank you, council. I appreciate it.

E

Thanks, can I get a motion to receive follow-up documents so move second.

E

From councilman vera secretary council teacher all in favor, we are adjourned. Sorry.